Episode 16
Digital Identity (part 2)
About this episode
Join hosts Alec and Jack in the Untangling Web3 podcast as they delve deeper into the world of digital identity in their enlightening second installment.
They kick off with the concept of Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI), highlighting its crucial role in redefining data ownership and advocating for enhanced privacy and selective disclosure. Transitioning to Provenance, the duo underscores the importance of authenticity in our digital age, contrasting the familiar terrains of Web2 against the emerging Web3 landscape.
A closer look at the Peer2Peer structure reveals its promise: unparalleled privacy and empowered user control in the digital realm. As they traverse through the seven pillars of digital identity benefits, Alec and Jack illuminate the wonders and challenges, drawing attention to the pivotal W3C standard.
But it's not all smooth sailing. The hosts tackle the inherent challenges in digital identity, from UX dilemmas to the quest for inclusivity. Providing a touch of practicality, they spotlight Microsoft Sidetree, showcasing how these concepts take shape in the real world.
The episode concludes with a peek into the future: the expansive Metaverse where digital identities span across avatars and the intersection of AI with Digital IDs. Informative and thought-provoking, this episode is a must-listen for those intrigued by the future of identity in the Web3 era.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast your goto Hub to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web 3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web 3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep on covering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast this is the second part of our TARTA on digital identities so last time we covered the history of identity from paper based to Biometrics to digital IDs and then the ambitious goal of a fully self- Sovereign identity we spoke about the basic setup and the ecosystem which is issuers holders and verifiers and how the blockchain fits into that to make the process more efficient compared with traditional identity systems and we also spoke about the overlap with web3
and the shared goals which are you know things like ownership the user experience obviously which is always a problem that we're identifying with some web three projects uh privacy and how digital identity can actually alleviate some of the privacy concerns compared with traditional identity systems and finally we gave some use cases Jack spoke about employment and how to make employment and recruitment uh more efficient and I spoke about um transportation specifically about Airlines and airports and how we can kind of bring all those separate isolated individual systems to one unified solution to make the process more efficient um so with all that said this is the second part and let's kick off yeah why not and I think last time we said we would kind of cover some more of the crossover between web 3 and and digital identity and and dids and all all the concepts we' spoke about with self- Sant identity last week so I mean why don't we start digging into what those actually are so I wanted to kind of
start maybe with the this data ownership crossover right so we talk a lot on the on the show about um web 3 being almost all about data ownership putting data back in the hands of of people rather than the big corporations and it's strikes me that web 3 in that sense is very much aligned with the ideas of digital identity where you're trying to actually help people take custody of their own identity their own identity information their documents um but in a way that's still secure for them and you know there's lots of benefits to that but for me that's we can get onto those but I think that's at the core of where the crossover actually is between the two what do what do you think about that have I missed anything on that on that point no definitely like we said before it's a Continuum and obviously this term in itself self- Sovereign means control and it's about ownership not just ownership of the data but also the processes and everything dictating where
that data goes and how that data is being used and I think like everything's kind of a trickle down effect from there like um this also relates to the Privacy you know if I'm controlling where my data is being used and how my data is being used that also has an effect on the privacy because I can ensure that there's no middlemen that are actually being used in the communication and that in itself also aligns with the peer-to-peer element there's just so many different areas that we kind of continually speaking about within the web three and kind of framework that overlaps with identity like another big one is obviously Provence there's like so we've talked so much in the AI the nfts about why and how blockchain is so important for Providence of not just people when we're talking about identity but also you know objects art NF Etc like the authenticity of these things is so Paramount and we see that there's a big push in the web three space right now to just
kind of put art quite simply on blockchain to enable that authenticity that individualism to guarantee that something is unique and cannot be duplicated and I think there's a lot of overlap between that and identity because individuals aren't in themselves individual and I think that kind of makes it quite easy to understand yeah exactly and something that people get wrong quite a lot actually in the early days of web 3 even um is is how how you link identity to your digital assets that you might own in in web 3 like your your nfts your your actual kind of crypto and funds as well um you see time and time again people kind of using really poor privacy practices with with their with their digital assets um and because of the the traceable nature of the blockchain then they they end up causing themselves problems in some cases it's good for for us in society when when a scammer or something gets caught um I've seen many times scammers you know um or not even scammers
like people who are celebrities in fact like uh pumping the price of an nft right before they they go and sell it and because of the LAX identity protocols they used you know they're just using a one wallet address or something then they end up getting caught for it I don't know if have you seen coffeezilla Alec ever I I'm aware coffeezilla maybe not as um kind of closely aware as you are but I'm sure you're both to enlighten me well shout out to him because he's got a really good Channel where he basically does a lot of the leg work and you see lots of um his kind of it's It's almost like a new brand of web three investigative journalism where he actively goes along and ties real world identities to um of of people who may be scamming or maybe um Pro promoting and pumping the price of some some asset and I the reason I mentioned it is because it's so easy if you don't Implement proper digital identity to then
then be linked to to your web three interaction so that's kind of another maybe tangential link they're not just similar but they kind of go hand inand and you need good digital identity systems for you to use web3 you know in a private manner that pres preserves your privacy well online and I think we're a long way off people actually uh using best practices at the minute right as as you'll see coffeezilla channel it's very easy to expose people at the minute yeah and I think like maybe there's more people that are familiar with how nfts will work in the kind of the web three agenda you know I will have this wallet that controls or owns or stores the keys that relate to the nfts the items the objects that are important to me be that art be that PO Apes potentially whatever it is and then I can use that web three wallet to then show those things and provably say that I own those things and potentially exchange them or maybe just
show off and we kind of said before that in a way like nfts in the future could represent you know credentials that relate to me like who I am I'm the top 1% of fans of of this artist or I have listened to this artist a 100 million times or I've donated loads to this charity and that you kind of seeing the relation there more and more between nfts in the form of objects that I own and nfts that then relate to who I am the characteristics my online characteristics like say being the one top 1% of listeners and then more and more to verifiable credentials like the link there is is quite an obvious one it's not just those things the nfts relate it's also you know who I am actually am as a person I'm Alec Burns I have a driving license I have this degree and I think in the future we'll just have one platform hopefully I imagine that just defines all these they're all my web in my web 3
wallet and I can just share them how I like and just Define you know what I do what I like who I am everything about me I think that's quite exciting yeah exactly it's the it's it's a really good point right because it's the authenticity of the credential it's doesn't it's not just important that you can you can create the credentials or you know to use the web three term to Mint a credential maybe it's not important that you can do that because that might be very easy but actually proving that it's authentic and linking it to maybe the identity of the issuer or having some some public information about the issuer that you can access and use the check it against is is crucial um but yeah and I think uh that that's that's that's an example of like nfts are digital property in the same way that your verifyable credentials you should treat as digital property as well going forward I think um and that's also you know you're mentioning just being able
to prove things to whoever is asking and and the Privacy element that's why we also talk a lot about things like selective disclosure because you don't need to you don't want to have to show all that information every time you're verifying a single Claim about you as we said I think we talked about previously like when you show your driving license to go into a bar you end up exposing your your house address your full name your your your driving license details when all you need to do is prove the claim I'm over 18 so the authenticity of that claim if you don't if you're not going to show the full driving license because that's the what we're replacing right normally you say well this is an authentic claim because I I know what a driving license is I know that's a government issuer if the claim then goes down to just an age thing and it's like are you above 18 then you need to have a new way of checking the authenticity of
that claim basically yeah and I think that's a big concern for people like you who go to these dodgy bars I assume but um no that's the yeah that's the one angle with the Privacy only needing to reveal the data that is actually relevant to the verifier but the other angle as well is the peer-to-peer thing that we keep emphasizing and this is like the term that I know me and you use regularly I prefer the term that you know web 3 is all about the peer-to-peer internet rather than the de centralized internet because decentralized has all these kind of associations with you know anarchism and all this kind of stuff whereas peerto peer is more about the fundamental underlying technology and the efficiencies gained from that but I think the overlap between the peer-to-peer in web 3 that we've kind of emphasized a lot and digit identity cannot be Str strongly cannot be emphasized enough like it's so important and this peer-to-peer aspect is fundamental in the kind of the success of digital identity
because like we said it really gives you the control to say I know who this is being sent to I know who has access to it I know how they're using it why are they using it and also all the Privacy that comes to that if I'm not sending you know my digital Identity or the verification of some cred evental through a middleman I'm just sending it to the verifier in that instance for something that I know is relevant I have a certain degree ofert certainty that that is not being used misappropriate for example and I think now I want to come to like you know the overall benefits we kind of laid the foundations there with some of the Technologies like I said the the Providence the peer-to-peer the the data own ship but the main benefits of digital identity I think we can kind of categorize into to seven key areas we've kind of hinted that throughout this so far in the previous episode um do you want to kick us off yeah
so I think that and it's a nice way to start from what we've just been talking about is this idea of you know portability so being able to take your credential from one place or one domain to another basically so as we you know we're on the the driving license example your your driving license is from the domain of uh the dvla in the UK or whoever whoever's the authorizer of you know who's allowed to drive a car in your country and you're taking that into another domain you're taking it to the domain of a a commercial setting with a with a bar or something where it's actually about you know buying alcohol or something like that so you that's an example worried you well no it's just it's it's I think it's just an instructive example you know don't read anything into it ale like um but yeah that that's you know and that's why we tend to I would say we tend to use I mean I have friends in the past who
who've used their passport when they go out and things which I think is it's funny but it's why we use our driving license so often especially in the UK is because it's more portable it's smaller it fits in your wallet it's it's like a it's a it's a physical example of a portable credential but when you go to the digital realm that goes you know through the roof because we always have our phones with us and you can put whatever you like in there you know your wallet's going to fill up with too many ID cards if if you have a credential for every single thing but your your your your digital wallet that we all use in our our smartphones now can carry a you know virtually boundless amount of information and credentials so it's it's really powerful going from physical to digital you just you almost inherently get that portability and then in the web 3 world you know that portability is also applied in my mind to the actual proof as well
right so it's like a you're not just taking the information that says you know oh here's a nice looking card in the uh in the digital wallet you actually have cryptographic proof backing the authenticity of that when you take it to that other domain basically yeah I mean the beauty of the digital landscape is the convenience right it means that I can flip between you know a hundred different services in one day if I really want to the issue with that is that I need to prove my identity in each of those 100 different services and this you know requires you know duplicated kyc checks duplicated passports not passports but duplicated passwords and username combinations so I think yeah one of the most important things around digital identity is the portability aspect taking one credential and moving between things seamlessly a good example might be you know taking your your FIFA top 1% uh score and using it to prove that you're a team player in LinkedIn that kind of thing shows maybe how web
3 could be used in the future and I think when you think about how this applies that the metaverse as well being able to jump between different domains and take who you are your credentials what you've achieved from place to place and I have to restart every single time because that's not seamless that's not efficient that's not what people want and I think maybe we'll talk about it in a bit more detail but one of the issues with this kind of stuff is why would a company want you to be able to leave you know if I set up the digital identity in my ecosystem in my environment why do I want it to be particularly portable which means you can easily leave and go to my competitor and this is maybe one of the resistances to to to digital identity especially on the portability aspect yeah exactly we've talked about this idea of you know sticky platforms and and people you know actually not wanting to support portability and interoperable kind of Standards um
and yeah I don't think there's an easy answer for that it's probably one of the reasons that it's it's taking its time to to to be adopted and widely used I mean I do think there will be potential business models and and advantages for companies to open that up and that's just talking about the private sector like it it's for me it's very obvious for governments to want to adopt this model because you know they have an incentive to increase efficiency as we keep talking about so for them and again you're not exactly the portability isn't necessarily changing I'm not going to move my citizenship you know because I can can use my credentials more easily abroad it's about making Services easier government services easier to access especially if you are abroad in a in whatever context um being able to to interoperate more easily with whatever is back in your home country but yeah the private sector one is is a bigger challenge I mean I think one interesting maybe resolution around that is
um you this market for verifications and the fact that when you when you need to get verified on a for a certain credential or someone needs to do a check say you're going for a loan application or something you normally have to go through these these kind of Brokers of information you need to that that check will potentially get repeated many many times over the course of a year or something whereas there might be a market for people providing this this different web three proof standard where they can then say okay well to another company I know you have to verify my customer um it'll cost you X to go and do that separately or I'll give you you know x minus um some some small percentage and you can do it more cheaply with me basically I think there is a way around that but it's not it's not completely obvious I don't think yeah I mean that's very web three as well right like sharing profits like proving authenticity proving who's checking what
what time and I think that makes a lot of sense to actually share those profits and like we said in the previous episode I think in the UK it was estimated that GDP would increase by approximately 10% if we had a digital identity system in place and I think this is one of the main ways in which that happens is the portability enables better customer experience better purchasing all this kind of stuff and you're completely right like the private sector right now might be missing the kind of missing the trick of this but I think maybe the UK government will push that or governments generally need to be the people that push the digital identity space because it's probably going to be a commodity in the future potentially um okay so I think the next one is authenticity and like we've said before we can't um emphasize this enough like this is blockchain fundamentals 101 it's you know the provence of items the provence of people prove proving that data is authentic proving that say
in the instance of digital identity that you are what your credential says you are um for example you know if you have a passport is to prove very efficiently and securely that you not only are you the owner of that passport but also that data uh is accurate and authentic and in date and comes from the UK passport office and proving all these things extremely efficiently and with a high degree of certainty and I think it's also yeah like I said theic IC is the one part but also the security and the authenticity is is the other part it's like one perfect package that cryptographic tools and cryptographic um security kind of enables right yeah 100% and uh you know why is this such a web three aspect as well you know is we've spoken about previously cryptography is is not inherently web 3 it's existed for long before much much longer if you go back to Cesar and and the Caesar Cipher back in uh you know how many thousands of years ago but
web 3 is very much the the movement or the vehicle that's taking a lot of these cryptography schemes mainstream and it's offering lots of new different proof systems with different properties so you know we'll come on to the other property of like privacy but the range of proof systems we're having now with we you know zero knowledge proofs which I'm sure we'll cover in detail in a future episode but these are kind of really amazing Cutting Edge type proofs that allow you to prove a claim without giving away any about the claim itself you just say oh this is true whatever that is so it's really it's um web 3 is kind of the best vehicle to deliver on that authenticity right even though we use cryptography in our daily lives for other things in the background I think web 3 is is where it's kind of the new things are being tested and the more exciting things are we're getting now I think yeah um so number three on the pillars is composability and
this is a less obvious one I think this is something that I think would be very difficult to achieve with traditional identity systems and this is basically selected disclosure that we've kind of talked about before it's if I show my driving license like Jack says all I want to prove there is that I am over 18 I don't want them to know my address and how many points I've got on my license and all this kind of stuff so composability is all around you know extracting one or two fields from the credential that is important and ensuring that those you know those two Fields still relate to an overall approved document but only showing the verifier of those one or two fields that relate to them and this is so important because it's all about privacy again right like I don't want to give them all the data I just want to give them a little bit of data and this also relates to another element of this is being able to combine different identities
and Fields from different identities and match them together I might want to say that you know I'm over 18 from my driving license I might want to say that I don't know I have a degree from X University or another one and just take those two fields and compose them together and that's what the verifier sees and they can instantly say that um and I think yeah this is another maybe less obvious one but very important characteristic of digital identity yeah I I really like this potentially applications for this composability thing in you know less serious ID context where things like reputation systems where you're trying to build up a reputation maybe in a game or you know as a fan of a certain football team and and you can go and make claims about um how many maybe how many away games you've been to by getting credentials from another football club that said you bought a ticket from us you know I'm just thinking um on the Fly about that one but you
know there are all sorts of things uh in the gaming world where you could say I got this many points in this game and this many points in this game and therefore I'm a legend of um you know open world games for example as as a not not that I am obviously but you know I just think there's lots of interesting combinations of credentials you can think of when it's not just the um the basic like human identifier stuff I can definitely see a onep person market for that it's obviously you there's a one person Market if there's a one person market then you've got to build it I'm sorry so good yeah so on that point and and maybe saving my own gaming privacy um you know brings us back to this idea right the kind of the fourth big uh property in benefit you know it's one of these ones we're hammering home and surprise surprise we do it a lot in the in the web 3 podcasting we talk about privacy a
lot um but it relates to that you know Continuum you mentioned and there's there's overlaps between a lot of these properties right A lot of them don't exist without another right they kind of they work together but this idea as you mentioned selective disclosure only sharing exactly what's needed and the P you mentioned peer-to-peer earlier which I kind of wanted to touch on in the Privacy aspect um it's the peer-to-peer typically we think about in like payments or you know sharing data and things where it's you and I as two consumer level actors basically just sharing things with each other but in this context I think the peer-to-peer takes on a slightly different meaning where one Pier is um you as the user and the one controlling your identity the holder the other Pier is actually more like a company entity where they're actually trying to verify your credential without going through another intermediate so you're actually almost saving them the task of going through someone else which which is kind of a slightly backwards
way of of doing PTP and and similarly with issuing credentials that you know they want to be able to do that directly with you um because it's more efficient than than having to rely on other data sources and things so yeah I think privacy is an obvious benefit right yeah definitely and you Kind Of You' mentioned two very important ones there that the idea of I only need to reveal the information that's super relevant be it one field out of many but also the idea of peer-to-peer so I don't need to involve unnecessary intermediaries who then have access to the data the other thing that we've kind of mentioned around dids and spinning up these decentralized identifiers as many as you want potentially is then the ability to have nonc correlation between you know you and all your various characteristics I might have a decentralized identifier or a did for my gaming account and I you know I have loads of verifiable credentials that say you know Alec did is I'm a legend is all
these things he's you know great at this game top 1% unbelievable kill to death ratio all these kind of things but then I don't really want nchain to know how much of a legend I am on Call of Duty so then I have my my work profile my LinkedIn profile it's like Alex got all these certificates you know he flunked all his cast glasses all these kind of things all the all the the lies that are on my CV potentially and then I have a third one that's my private account with all the nfts I own all the board Apes I own that I really do not want anyone else to know about apart from that World um and I think this is quite important as well as well so there kind of these three big areas that all relate to privacy within the digital identity space and all of them are super important with all them together you do get a really really nice um kind of combined privacy benefit from digital identities and
I think again that's really really exciting I know we keep hammering at home but privacy is one of the the kind of the key core characteristics of web three and clearly of of digital identity as well and and and the next one related to what you said Jack on the peerto peer that we keep hammering home is also control with kind of mentioned it briefly but if obviously if you're controlling the interaction and also controlling the the person or the entity that you're interacting with you obviously control and consent to the interaction with no middle people so exactly what data you want is usually exactly who you want to send it to as user when you want to use it when you want to send it how you want to send it and I think control is obviously a very very important part and that is the next pillar that it kind of relates to to digital identity yeah and I think kind of for me the control aspect is subtly different from uh the
authenticity and portability kind of aspects because it's about you as a user actually being the decision maker in the the verification process and you're you're actively choosing what you share rather than passively giving away too much data I think that's the the key difference but again that that's that's wrapped up in the the peer-to-peer Point as as you mentioned um and this also relates to kind of the next one as well which is as you can see they all they all kind of build on one another but all of this arrives at the the kind of sixth pillar which is security and I think this is a really this is obviously a really fundamental because as we've talked about the security of your identity data relies on who's holding it and how much of a Target they are and moving to this SSI model where you distribute the holding of information you only provide proof not data necessarily to verify credential then you're you're you're reducing that attack surface right so you don't have these
big Crown jeel data sets stored in big companies where people can go oh that's a big Target for me to go and attack and and hack and and expose on the dark web it becomes oh well now I I need to hack everyone individually for their data and maybe it might still be a big problem for very very high net worth individuals but for people like you and me Alec it's a it's going to be much much much less of a problem and think this kind of relates to one of the D sides of all this stuff as well right it's also puts a lot more responsibility on the user like you're no longer kind of dependent on Facebook to control all your data and your credentials and all this kind of stuff but also you know Facebook they have an obligation to the user to give them the best customer experience so you know if you forget your password which I do every other week Facebook will help me get back in and make
sure that I can continue using the service in the digital identity space where we're saying all that responsibility is pushed to the user for the benefit of security control privacy all these things that we've mentioned then there's also the liability there if I lose you know my phone or access to my my web 3 wallet with my digital identity credentials on there how do I get it back and this is a kind of a big not a big issue I'm going to say but it's something to consider when you considering these kind of implementations and a lot of like kind of solutions will get around this by saying okay you actually do have a backup that's on say a centrally hosted system like AWS but only you can access that centrally hosted system using cryptographic tools using all these kind of things and that's one way that a lot of solutions get around this it's not to kind of say that it's impossible it's just to say these are things to consider um around the
kind of the benefit that is security and the last one that we've hinted at and it comes all the way back to the start which is composability is interoperability how all of these different solutions can work together like right now we have so many different credential so many different kind of issuers of credentials passports UK like don't get me started on crossborder stuff and how to prove that you're you know you have this credential from the UK to America one of the main goals and also one of the main challenges of digital identity is around interoperability how we can have all these different credentials pertaining to one person many people Cross organization cross border working together to make verification really efficient and really easy and good for the user and the verifier and the entire ecosystem and not going to lie this is probably one of the the biggest limitations of the space right now right we have so many different identity providers trying to develop these incredible Solutions but as we kind of often
see these companies aren't working together so well and you know we've mentioned before the w3c standards that are emerging and probably are the leading standards but they're not complete like I I've read through them and they're a good hint at how things should be done but they're not fully fledged it's not to say that anyone's fully implementing them and using them it's just yeah that's the goal right it's something that we need to Aspire to yeah exactly like in the theory of it and why we like to say it's a web 3 concept is that it should be intable in theory and it can be the technology exists but it's a it's a human and a a coordination issue that we we have to get through and this is a you know it's the case with all standardizations it's the case with web one and the early days of web to we've we've had and to to be fair we've had credential standards emerge in the past you know passwords and usernames are a very
widely used credentialing standard and now getting a link sent to your email is arguably uh credential standard is kind of maybe not an unspoken one but it's become one de facto um and you have things like API tokens uh Json web tokens as well for kind of program level authentication and yeah as you say the w3c standard is only just I think in 2022 gone kind of progressed to the um the recommendation stage so it's taken a long time to even get there and it takes even longer for it to get widely implemented but you know as we'll come on to um a little bit later there are there are examples of web 3 based did systems being built using this standard but you know how long it'll take to be adopted is is a is another question but you know at least we can say in theory that um interoperability is is one of these core qualities that we expect from a a good SSI system you know yeah and I think a quick
point that I want to make is we've mentioned these Seven Pillars of potential benefits and kind of aspirations of SSI and digital identity it's quite important to say that I haven't seen any solution or kind of proposed solution that really embodies all seven of the pillars and that's fine you know like a lot of them are kind of bespoke for certain applications it's not like you need all seven pillars in some applications you know maybe if it's an internal system privacy might not be the big of the Paramount concern for you there might be some applications where you know you don't exactly care about security so I'm not sure why but the point is like it's not that when you're designing an identity solution you need to say okay I need to have all seven of these pillars to the absolute maximum for all of my users always like that that's not always the case it's something to aspire to it's a continue and maybe in a hundred years we'll see everything perfected to the
end degree but right now it's not to say we need all of them perfected exactly and we don't know exactly what the market demand is for all these features and benefits as well as I've proven live on the show maybe there's not so much demand for certain composability ideas but I think the demand will be definitely is very high for things like privacy and security especially in places like the EU now I mean I was listening to a podcast recently talking about the difference between um uh you know different countries and and how how different countries view privacy and obviously in Europe we've got such high standards at the minute um so yeah it's it's one of these things I think it will be quite Market determined what people actually want in and will determine which features we see in widely adopted SSI things but you know on on that point then given that adoption is quite a challenge what are the specific kind of downsides and concerns because we've hinted at the ux you
know user experience challenges and just the sheer complexity of of um of using things like web 3 and and web 3 based identity systems even worse to be honest at the minute so yeah what do you think about the the downsides of all this yeah like it's we've painted a nice picture of the potential and you know we've been talking about digital identity for many years now um why hasn't been adopted well there are a lot of pitfalls like the first one you've mentioned is is probably one of the most most um extreme maybe is the user experience and the complexity and this is like I I'd say it's so maybe one of the biggest problems with web 3 based apps or decentralized apps generally right is that when people think of like crypto that's the problem right now is that whenever someone thinks about web 3 they think about crypto is that they think about like Keys you know uh seed phrases how to get into your wallet remembering 15 words to you know
get my password back and all this kind of stuff and I think like that has become less of a concern maybe um now but this is like incumbent in most a lot of the applications I see is the user experience is not up to the same level as what we see from web 2 based applications and I think this is one of the big Inhibitors that we're seeing and we need to get around this that we talked about the killer application of chat GPT the technology maybe wasn't so much more advanced than previous Technologies it was the user centricity and the user experience the reduction of complexity that made chat GPT The Unbelievable success it is today and this is one of the most important things that people need to consider when they're thinking about decentralized apps and you know digital identity is how to make the user experience as seamless as possible and right now we're not seeing that I don't think yeah exactly I mean you kind of hinted at all these issues
you have in in the web 3 world and I mentioned the Privacy problems you have if you if you don't have best practices and if you just reuse wallet addresses for example these are people are really struggling with the ux challenge in in web 3 and it just is it's almost um the the consequences are a little bit more severe I would argue in identity because if you get something wrong there it's not just your doge coins that will will be sacrificed it's your it's it's your identity and your your and your your your personhood almost so yeah on the ux side is is very it's very challenging at the minute and also things like you know backup and and and recovery so this might actually be a good point to mention the the implementation I was going to talk about so one example of uh a did protocol that's kind of been developed and is being implemented is is called the side tree protocol was developed this as I mentioned in the last episode
by some researchers of Microsoft and it's been kind of put into formalization with the decentralized identifiers Foundation the diff foundation and this is really it's a really interesting system because they are trying to account for lots of these things the complexity the backup so they have functions and operations defined for each did in a crud model so the classic Computing kind of create update recover um delete now it's not quite the same as the classic one because you have slightly different acronym but they're covering all the options and and especially I thought it was interesting that they have this recover and deactivate so if you need to recover your details if you lose one of these cryptographic Keys like you like when you lose your your your crypto wallet keys you might lose the key that's tied to your identity right in some way so they're building in recovery protocols and backups directly into these standards into these implementations um and you know they're taking these things very very seriously but it's still a massively
complex thing right and it does it doesn't completely solve all the backup challenges necessarily I think yeah it's an interesting one like recovery you know when you talking about blockchain and things being immutable and when you talk about like the attestation authenticity meaning that only you can possi have access to these Keys like that becomes a bit of a concern when you're talking about recovery because obviously the processes are involved are a lot more intricate let's say and lot more difficult to do but it's good that companies are fin sign to get their heads around it and hopefully like the user experience won't come at at the cost of you know the security and vice versa the security won't come at the cost of the user experience and and I think one of the the next issues that I kind of want to talk about which I think it's really important is the inclusivity aspect like this is um you know in the UK specifically for the first time we had vot we have voter
ID being implemented right and it's really interesting to see that there was a lot of kind of um concerns and theories that this would be a problem for inclusivity and the voter ID so far in the UK which can kind of there's a lot of relation to how digital ID potentially would be implemented um it actually affected um disproportionately disabled and minority groups and this is something I think we really need to be quite careful with that we want you know a dig well the digital age and the digital economy is it's everywhere right it's completely Universal almost everyone in society is using it and active on it but not everyone and I think that is quite important we don't want to create solutions that are so focused on the majority that it starts to negatively impact the minority and we do need to think about say peoples that don't have phones people that are visually impaired people that can't easily use digital identity solutions they can't just be left behind and we need to
maybe start to you know think of Sol solutions that you know ensure that it has the most widespread adoptions possible and you know benefits and doesn't leave these people behind yeah I think that's a really important point for sure and I also see this playing into the idea of optionality and you know web 3 we don't want to throw the baby out with the bath water we don't think I certainly don't think that we're going to replace all physical cash with digital cash in the future necessarily I don't think we're going to replace all intermediaries with uh with with nothing make everything purely peer-to-peer there's a role to play for them I think it's more about giving the option for this better version of identity and more efficient management of identity but it should definitely be backwards compatible and and still allow anyone kind of in the in the analog physical world who can't on board into into this system to still interoperate with it and there's lots of you know there's lots of um
the technology hurdles I don't think are that huge I think we see the integration of smart s all the time which are very low cost to produce where you can you could um maybe integrate certain parts of this but it the barrier between the physical and digital is not is not an easy one to overcome I don't think no you're definitely right um yeah I mean the the next big issue we talked about but we don't spend too long on it is interoperability companies you know spending lots of money developing these digital identity Solutions potentially for internal purposes they don't then want to let you take that digital identity and gain the benefits to competitors like companies want stickiness they want you to go into their ecosystem and stay in their ecosystem um this is something that we I mean I don't know if it comes from regulation comes from you know governments pushing it through or how we get around this um there has to be like a way of like enforcing shared profit
I think that what will happen is if big companies like the Facebooks of the world that already have unbelievable footfall won't develop interoperable solutions for say digital identity then eventually a competitor will come along say a much smaller player who will offer that as a USP and say you know you can jump between as many different providers as you want if you use my digital identity solution they will become the dominant player with that kind of offering and I think that is how it's going to play out I hope yeah for sure I think that it's going to take a long time to resolve the that problem but I agree with your your thesis on on how it's going to go I think so um yeah thinking of the future maybe it's a good good place to kind of round off the conversation we've had on on digital ID by talking about you know where this is going what are the exciting future elements like what what's the really out there things apart from my
my Legend status in World of Warcraft or something but I think I think metaverse is you know we've talked about it at length but I think it's a really good application as you said this many to one identity that you can have in web 3 and and self- soverign identity has a real role to play in in the metaverse because you're going to have lots of avatars multiple different identities with different aspects and you know that's also where you know where everyone's using some Avatar that doesn't necessarily look that much like them you might want to still have things like age restrictions in there so you have age restricted spaces where you need all this um you need selective disclosure and selective proof of of these different claims to use the metaverse because at the minute you know if you go into one you don't know who you're talking to you don't know how old they are you don't know what's going on right it's kind of scary it's a scary place to be I've
only been there for about five minutes sometimes but um yeah I'm thinking like um Oasis style you know when we're talking about like ready player one in the Oasis like if I'm going into the kind of the universal single metaverse of the future there is like the Oasis in Ready Player one I'm not going to be me I'm not going to be you know 5 foot 10 just about Alec I'm G to be a Tyrannosaurus Rex and how are you like offering 18 plus kind of services to a Tyrannosaurus Rex like you're completely right you want to have the I mean the metaverse is is the perfect example of how you can imagine like a digal identity that is usable across multiple experiences and it's it's unlikely that we're going to have a James holiday of the world that creates a single platform and everything falls into that single platform where they can control the rules and make sure everything's monitored give you one digital ID and that use Works across Services what's probably going
to happen is we have different kind of Worlds potentially different metaverses if that is actually appropriate I can't remember if it was or not and you'll move between these services and can take your credentials from one your experiences from one who you are from one to the other and to the other and to the other there and no one's going to want to do that and have to log in every single time no one's going to have to do want to do that and kyc between every different service like the idea of the metaverse is something that is seamless and something that feels as like the real world as possible and I think yeah that is super important the metaverse is is a perfect example of why digital identity is completely crucial yeah and also that the point we mentioned earlier about kind of digital wallets for holding your credentials and your assets that's a great example where you know in one of these metaverse world you might end up earning digital currency or or
you know utility type nfts that you can go and redeem in the real world so you want to have your identity linked to that so that you can use them in the the metaverse platform you're using or you can take your mobile phone and redeem them a physical store right if you want to if you want to buy something with them in the real world that's the interoperability that you want not just between digital Realms but also in the physical world I think is is really interesting so finally I think another really cool application and where this this will be really relevant in the future is in kind of AI and and tying digital identity to AI agents and even iot to a degree but yeah I think the AI point is being so hot as it is um we've mentioned before you know personhood for AIS as well in the future and maybe maybe that's going a bit far but being able to know which which Persona which AI is being used and tying
that to different context is going to be is going to be important especially when you talked about the kind of payment rail stuff right you want to know which AI is executing which trades or something um it it's gonna be it's gonna become a relevant point I think yeah this stuff as you know excites me so much the idea of like AI right now just being like tools where they do the leg work and you make the decisions like so so soon we're going to see AI that has agency but not just AI that has agency Internet of Things devices that have agency we've done those two topics talked about how these things are going to be interacting in the real world autonomously and independently without human intervention and you're going to need identity for that like if you have drones flying around in the future dropping off you know packages here and there and recharging and having their own agency they're going to need to have some identity so they can interact safely with
say charging stations or Tesla cars or autonomous vehicles whatever it is we're going to need to see these autonomous agents which is AI in some cases or iot devices in other cases having identities that allow them to interact with the world having like you know verifiable credentials that say they're allowed to do this thing or they're allowed to be in this space or allowed to interact in this way and that is something that really excites me and I think if we don't have you know digital identity Solutions but even like Provence Solutions and authenticity Solutions then the AI of the future and the iot of the future is going to be quite a scary place in which there's you know very little kind of transparency and auditability in how things are done and I think yeah completely completely essential for those systems to kind of work in an open world environment yeah I think that that that credentialing point you mentioned is is is the key one for me right because it's about how do
you hold them to account and and and orchestrate what different machines at the end of day we're talking about machines here are allowed to do um you know you want to make sure that that you only issue the valid credentials for you know a given time they're allowed to uh maybe an autonomous vehicle is allowed to drive in this country for the next week and that's it that kind of thing um and even even online I think there are good use cases for Bots I know we've talked I know we've talked down about bots so far but um in the podcast but there are good use cases for having automated systems like interacting with social media so you want to give them some kind of persona whereby people don't just speculate oh this might be a bot pretending to be a human or something you can actually have you know oh no be transparent about it and this is an accountable agent that's doing a service and you can check what credentials I have so
you can check the limits on me as an AI agent I think that's that's going to be very relevant I mean Colin who we had on about the generative AI episode talked about you know people already getting married to AI peoples or Ai personas and that happened like a couple of years ago and now I'm seeing like advertisements not for me specifically but for friends I don't know what they're searching around like AI girlfriends that you can now pay for and have like a a fully autonomous AI girlfriend that you could do whatever you want with I have no idea you do just talk to them probably and you probably if you want to get married to these AI girlfriends or boyfriends sorry as well a persons you want them to have a digal identity right I it would not surprise me if in like five years time we'll have legal identities for AI peoples that you can then get officially married to and you know give half your wealth to and all this kind
of stuff that is probably the future and speaking of you know the market demanding things I actually think that's where there will be Market demand for that kind of stuff right because you've already seen people creating AI versions of themselves to talk to people I'm not not saying I'm interested in this but I think I think I think there will be demand for it out there so yeah okay so I think we've covered a good amount there to to kind of wrap up the whole story about digital identity and self- Sovereign ID so yeah we've covered the key pillars of good self- Sovereign identity systems we've covered some of the drawbacks and some of the concerns especially around the adoption and what's potentially going to limit that in the future and then we've had a little bit of a peer into the crystal ball of of the future and what what the future might hold so yeah I think that's a that's a good place to to end this episode so thank you for listening
wherever you may be and we'll see you next time to untangle a little more of thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Digital Identity