Episode 105

Worldcoin

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of the Untangling Web3 podcast, we dive headfirst into the controversial, ambitious, and wildly futuristic project known as Worldcoin.

Created by Tools for Humanity and co-founded by OpenAI’s Sam Altman, Worldcoin combines digital identity, blockchain, and biometric scanning via the infamous “Orb” to tackle one of the most urgent problems of our AI age: proving you’re human in a world overrun by bots, agents, and deepfakes.

But is this visionary solution as revolutionary as it sounds—or just dystopian science fiction?

Key highlights

  • Worldcoin’s Vision for Digital Identity in a Post-AI World. With AI-generated content dominating the web, Worldcoin sets out to answer a crucial question—how do we prove someone online is a real human? At its core, the project offers a blockchain-based digital identity called World ID, anchored in biometric iris scans captured via the sci-fi-looking Orb. This proof-of-personhood system aims to separate bots from people while ensuring privacy through zero-knowledge proofs and decentralized protocols.
  • The Role of the Orb and the Tokenomics Behind It. The Orb is the hardware gateway into Worldcoin's ecosystem. It scans users' irises to confirm uniqueness, creating a one-to-one digital credential tied to a real person. Once verified, users receive a World ID and are rewarded in the project’s native token, WORLD. This token not only incentivizes adoption but is positioned as a future vehicle for distributing universal basic income (UBI) in a world where AI displaces jobs. The podcast also covers the cryptographic privacy mechanisms involved, and the ethical dilemmas of onboarding users in developing countries through financial incentives.
  • Criticism, Controversies, and the Future of Identity Systems. Worldcoin’s bold approach hasn’t come without backlash. The episode unpacks controversies including accusations of “bio-data colonialism,” the lack of hardware audit transparency, and compliance concerns with GDPR and consent revocation. Alec and Jack also explore alternative decentralized identity models from the Web3 space, such as Proof of Humanity and Gitcoin Passport, questioning whether Worldcoin’s centralized rollout aligns with Web3 ideals or undermines them.

Worldcoin presents a radical approach to solving the digital identity problem in the age of AI. With its Orb, crypto incentives, and biometric-backed Web3 identity, it’s undeniably innovative—but also deeply polarizing.

As the line between humans and AI blurs, projects like Worldcoin may shape the future of how we verify identity, distribute value, and govern online interactions. Whether it becomes the "login with Google" of Web3 or fades under regulatory pressure, it's a project worth watching.

This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

Welcome to the Untangling Web 3 podcast. With the rapid rise of Genai, how can you be sure you're interacting with a real person online? How can you prove to somebody else that you are a real human? That's the question at the heart of today's episode as we're finally covering Worldcoin, also known as World Network. WorldCoin is Silicon Valley's boldest attempt yet to create a universal identity system fit for the challenges of a post AI world. But what on earth does all this mean? That's what Alec and I are here to unpack today.

Alec, are you excited for this one? I know. I know I am. I'm very excited. I'm surprised you recommended this because I was kind of thinking as you were talking, you know, how do you know someone is human? And obviously this makes you quite nervous, Jack, as a robot that people are going to find out through this project that, you know, one of us isn't actually human. But yeah, you've been wanting to do this for a while. I'm excited. I was reading some of your research just before.

I didn't realize how interesting, exciting, and slightly out there this project actually is. Yeah, it's an interesting one because like it's one that I think I and probably a lot of people have dismissed in the past as this slightly scary dystopian uh project that's come out, but actually there's some really interesting technology at play and we'll get to kind of the details later, but it's I'm kind of conflicted about it because yeah, the technology being used is really really interesting and it covers a range of kind of web 3 and crypto stuff to hardware, all this all this kind of fun things that we talk about.

But then there's also the the kind of the vision and theory behind it and the potential avenues this could go down that aren't quite as as rosy. So yeah, it's it's a very interesting mix of things. But yeah, I think we should uh we should have a go unpacking it all today. Yeah. And I kind of I think one of the interesting things around this is it obviously bridges digital identity and crypto and we'll talk about that in more detail but the motivating factor and like the man maybe the middle of this is Sam Alman and it's kind of like starting to think about what does society look like in 10 to 20 years time when AI inevitably comes kind of the displacer the disruptor that we all know it's going to become now what are some of the impacts that's going to create and then what are some of the solutions we can have to that it's really forward thinking and yeah it's quite exciting exciting actually.

Yeah, exactly. So, let's get into it. I mean, just to kind of set the scene then like at a base level, what what are we talking about? So, Worldcoin is I think it's it's a number of things, but fundamentally it's a digital identity protocol, right? As you mentioned, and the goal is providing a universal digital identity for the internet, for inerson interactions as well, but specifically for, you know, what's the best way of doing this in the post AI age. So the the kind of main problem that is espoused here is how do you verify someone on online when the quality of deep fakes is so good right the way the way of simulating most human markers online is actually really good now it's hard to distinguish so this project aims to provide digital identity without uh you know they won't fall into a trap of deep fakes basically and can be can be can be completely kind of trusted and yeah as you said it's kind of funny because it's been f co-founded by

Sam Alman. So he's kind of like owning the supply and the demand here. He's like built the problem with OpenAI and now is supposedly solving the identity solution. Um yeah, they raised a ton of money. They raised like I think around 250 million in total now from the kind of usual suspects like A16Z Anderson Horowitz and things like that. So he Alex Blanier, Max Noven, they set this up. You know, we're a bit late to the party. This is around two years ago that it's been going now.

Um but yeah, it's it's interesting that it came from them, isn't it? Yeah, I think you're right to highlight the problem that, you know, we're going into a world where agents is the new sexy term and we can't really tell the difference between a person and, you know, an AI robot or an AI agent online anymore. And it's interesting that we kind of use this term digital identity because, you know, what we're seeing is the really successful digital identity systems always need some kind of anchor to the real world.

And like you know your case in practice here what we're seeing is they're creating this digital identity system that basically stores information in a digital way. So it's accessible in a digital way. But again they're strongly linking that digital proof to some physical trait that is very difficult to you know fake basically and very difficult for a nonhuman to create. And I think that's really interesting. But the need for this is so obvious. We're seeing spam online. You know we've talked about review systems. the kind of there's a pressing need for real digital identity systems not to remove AI in you know the kind of the digital sphere but just to highlight who who is human and know that when you're interacting with someone you are interacting with a human or interacting with an AI and that's fine but you need to be able to tell the difference and distinguish between the two yeah there are definitely there's so many cases where you you want to be able to be sure you know when you

think of things like online banking there's potential I think in the future for social media to also pop up where you have you know you want to know you're talking to a human, all that kind of stuff. I mean, so the problem is actually very concrete and compelling. I think this part of my kind of conflicted view on this whole project is, yeah, I completely buy the problem. I think is something that needs solving. Um, there's an interesting kind of data point here. There's a Harvard professor, Latia Sweeney, the kind of company behind uh, Worldcoin.

They point to this data point as well is that they're predicting kind of 90 plus% of content online is going to be not generated by humans in the future. So the distinction is going to become even less clear as we go on. So yeah, I think it's a compelling problem. Um, and they are pitching this solution as essentially humanness and that's a phrase they really like in the age of AI, right? So that that's kind of how they're pitching it. And as of 2025, they've had, you know, kind of mixed level of success.

We'll get into kind of some of the controversies around it later, but as it stands, they've had over 5 million people actually uh on boarded onto the system, right? they've gone and scanned their eyeballs at these uh these orbs and they've got kind of millions of active users already. So, it's it's a bit weird that it's it's already been taken up that much. But yeah, what do you think? That is the first and the last time I want to hear you say eyeballs on this program.

I don't know why that word reallys me out, but we're going to get into the how this is actually done and the different components of this system a bit later. I think it it's quite interesting that more and more we're seeing, you know, it used to just be digital identity. How do we get digital identity? How do we prove that a human has credentials that can you know a human can do these certain things is say of this community or is of this you know technical standard whatever but now more and more we're seeing kind of these digital identity schemes be pushed to the idea of proof of personhood because of the kind of the mass adoption of AI agents in in the world so I kind of understand why they're kind of pushing the idea of personness and proof of personhood to the the kind of the forefront of this project but it kind of it's it's a lot bigger than that I think it's quite interesting to understand, take a step back, that

the internet didn't really ever have like a native concept of identity, which is really interesting. And we've always kind of relied on these kind of modular systems like email logs or platform spec specific accounts. And obviously, they've become more and more centralized and widespread where you might may not be able to tell the difference between the two way because Google's basically accepted everywhere now. But Worldcoin, they're they're saying they're trying to fix that by tying identity to biology and thus creating like a native concept of identity that could be widely adopted across the world.

We'll go to some of the scope and some of the kind of the applications of this a bit later because this isn't just an identity system as a kind of an academic like project to discern between humans and non-humans. got real applications in mind and they are tying this to things like crypto to basically give out money across the globe and you know serve the unbanked population which I think is quite a powerful use case a huge use case obviously. Yeah. And if you look at kind of the rhetoric around it from uh the world coin foundation and things they are they're talking very much about inclusivity and kind of financial inclusion of the world right which is why they actually talk about they looked at approaching this problem from a few different uh you know standpoints like different ways of verifying identity and they ultimately settled on having to use biometrics and it makes sense because we I I think biometrics are obviously the kind of gold standard for ident identification We're used to

using Face ID on our iPhones, right? That's just completely industry standard now. That kind of thing. But the difference here is that they are introducing this kind of protocol aspect. So, it's not just uh an a kind of localized individual verification on your iPhone that's run by Apple, etc. using kind of standards for your phone. But it's it's a protocol that's bigger than that that establishes a network of humanity because they're kind of they're trying to onboard everyone into this single kind of canonical network saying this is the set of human beings on Earth.

And obviously at the minute it's not just five five million people on Earth, right? It doesn't represent uh the the the totality of humanity right now, but that's the goal is that once everyone's on, you have a provable set of of human beings based on this biometric marker, which is yeah, very interesting. And again, they they talk a lot about like, you know, trying to fix the the the fact that lots of people are unbanked, right? Like they're kind of said like 1.4 1.5 billion adults are still unbanked according to World Bank, right?

So that that's an interesting aspect, too. Yeah. And I think it's maybe we're starting to get to one of the primary use cases here is that Sam Alman's kind of obviously his main thing is AI and what the world looks like in 10 20 50 years where AI is kind of like the dominant technology and he's kind of and a lot of people are saying this as well. not just Sam Alman but a lot of people are envisioning this world in which AI does a lot of the jobs that we have today and rather than creating you know new jobs as most technologies have tended to do there will just be a complete disrupt disruption there will be less jobs for humans and it's saying when we get to that state like it's not a thing that can be solved necessarily politically or shifting the economy we need complete revamp of how we kind of actually structure the economy so it'll be things like he really wants thinks that we need to implement this universal

basic income right for people that have been disrupted by a AI. AI is now replacing your job. You don't necessarily have to upskill anymore and change things. We just need universal basic income. And it kind of ties into the idea of like there will be an abundance of resources, an abundance of, you know, food, houses, energy, absolutely everything in this, you know, utopian world that's going to be created with AI. And he's assuming that UBI, university basic income will be needed and will be a standard across the world.

And then you start to think, okay, well, how do we give UBI out to individuals? So, it's kind, this is why he's tying this idea of humanity to crypto payments. You've got the efficiency of crypto where you can distribute it to individuals, but also you need to prove that an individual is an individual. And if I, as an AI agent or even as an individual, can spam up 10,000 accounts, I can really start to manipulate these UBI systems. And so, it's kind of like that's the pain point he seems to be primarily trying to tackle with this.

Yeah, exactly. I think and and actually when when I see them talking about the world coin and world network now they don't seem to talk so much about UBI at the minute but that was that's very closely tied in with the inception of the network and I think it is still philosophically very much tied to it but yeah it's about you know how when we have this final what is it not latest stage capitalism post post late stage capitalism whatever that whatever that becomes when if we are going to be receiving these universal or basic income UBI payments then what's the most efficient way to distribute that in a fair way um and the other aspect is also in that kind of post post capitalism world uh the governance of the system as well like h who should control and own this they're trying to set this up so this will be in theory acting like a public good right in the future but yeah maybe we're getting ahead of ourselves with the with the

with the future stuff should we should we try and tackle exactly how it works because I'm conscious at the minute it's still a little bit abstract yeah I think it'd be good like you definitely you know more about this maybe you can define the individual components that that fit into this. Yeah. So um basically I I I see it as a two or three different things. So the first one being the identity system that I you know we said at the start but Alex core worldcoin is built around an identity system which they call world ID.

Now the idea here is that you know we talk about digital identity plenty of times on on the podcast. There are hundreds of different digital identity systems that exist already. blockchain and non-blockchain. Um, and this is one of the blockchain flavor ones and it's based on a bunch of open protocols for issuing identities. It uses zero knowledge proofs like we've talked about a lot. So you can uh essentially present credentials and prove that you're part of this uh this human human set that's been uh defined by worldcoin.

Um so basically getting digital credentials that are privacy preserving with zero knowledge proof. So that's the identity system and and we can go into more details. The second component is the orbs that we already alluded to themselves. This is where we go from the digital to the physical digital hardware part of the the story. So these orbs and again this is like the most I guess well-known part of the project. These are the things that actually do the scanning of the eyeballs. Sorry, I like to say the word again, but this is the these are the things that actually scan your eyeballs and issue or or basically verify uniqueness.

That's kind of that's what in my research I was actually distilling it down. It's all about uniqueness these these orbs because they're basically allowing you to issue one identity per pair of eyeballs that have been scanned. Right? So again to use the word too many times but that's that's at the core of how it works. Uh and then finally so once you've scanned at one of these orbs you get one of those digital identities issued in a private manner on a blockchain on Ethereum. Um the last stage of that is then the the app itself.

So you have like a digital wallet app again very similar to what we've discussed in the past with digital identity systems that allow you to manage the credentials to add and connect other forms of identity to your world ID. Uh, and then on top of all that, if that wasn't enough crypto jargon, they also have, of course, there's a token, right, which is all part of how the, you know, when we're talking about UBI, that might be the the currency that is issued in in the future in that, you know, world that they're envvisaging.

But it's also primarily used right now as like the incentive and feedback mechanism to incentivize people to go and get scanned by the orbs and also to incentivize people to uh you know work as uh they call them operators to go and you know take the take these orbs out into the public and scam people. So it's kind of the incentive piece behind that. Man, this this just sounds so weird and dystopian. Like I don't know how like even just I'm looking at the pictures of these orbs right now and it looks culty as hell.

Like it's really weird. I think like they are trying to I think they've maybe gone for that angle as well. This is so futuristic and they've kind of set their ambition obviously 20 30 50 years in the future that I imagine they are gearing up in every way to kind of think about like how do we make this as futuristic as possible maybe like just to get the pioneers who are kind of into that stuff on board now and eventually it'll be normal in 30 years time.

But yeah, you I think you you've broken it down quite a clear way. You have these giant eyeball type things. You got me saying it. I hate it. They're like bowling ball size cylinders, right? And they, you know, you have an individual that has them for whatever reason because they're one of these creepy sci-fi people and they will take scans of people's eyes. Can we just say eyes? Like let's say eyes. Eyes is easier than eyeballs and they like you say obviously eyes have a very distinct pattern.

So that uniqueness then using the scanner cor is hashed and like you create kind of a unique representation of that that doesn't reveal has no privacy preservation like you can't sorry there is privacy preservation involved where you can't then work out what the I is based on that hash currently obviously maybe in the future that might change um and that keeps it anonymous as well so I can use it I can link my distinct eye to that if I need to but I have a degree of anonymity if I want to so someone can't work out my eyeball pattern based on the hash on chain.

I've seen like some criticisms around these giant orb things like they're not open source. The firmware hasn't been audited. They're saying that you know it's all privacy preserving and we're not storing your eyes in the orb or something like this. But I don't think anyone's actually third party come along and said, "Yeah, that's true." Imagine Sam Alman's got like a giant catalog somewhere of everyone's eyes and just stares at them in a room or something like this. But I it's TBD. Yeah, it's it's it's a real it feels like a gray area and it's again it's not something I've personally verified because it's way beyond my technical expertise, but they did they did take a few steps originally when this all came out to kind of open source aspects of it and like I think they've open source some of the designs and plans for the hardware itself.

So you could in theory kind of you know build them elsewhere, right? Which is again not sure if that's a good thing as well. I I don't know if I'd rather trust the World Coin Foundation to build these themselves or if I, you know, if we're going to start letting anyone build them, then you're going to have this issue at the point of the orb itself, right? It's like, well, how do how do I know the person presenting me with this orb is actually uh a good faith honest actor and it's not someone else trying to spoof it.

And I think there's already been some kind of worries about that. But yeah, just to kind of double click on the identity piece from a like a tech perspective, there is actually a really interesting thing going on here whereby the actual digital identity itself. So when we talk about like did the actual kind of identification information um the kind of unique identifier for you as a as a human as part of this network that's something that actually is not generated by these orbs themselves. So the kind of flow is you'll go up to go and get scanned but before that you'll download one of these apps like the world app and on device is where the keys actually get uh generated right so you're like your public key that's going to be tied to your identity is generated on your your phone let's say on this app then when you go to get your iris scanned at one of these orbs the purpose of the orb is literally just to make sure that no one

else has scanned their iris against this before. So it'll check all the all the all these hash codes they call them right that unique identification that represents this scan of the iris and it will basically say well has this pair of eyes been scanned before if no then okay that's fine I will issue uh this identity that's tied to the credential on your phone so they are actually firewall this thing that's being scanned on the device with your with your actual app but yeah and and they supposedly comes with a guarantee that nothing is also retained on the devices.

So, the scans themselves are supposedly deleted, scans of URIs, but yeah, there there have been people worrying about it nonetheless, and there have been some kind of conflicting reports about that, too. Today's episode is sponsored by the Vchain Foundation. Now, we often talk about how emerging technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability, and Vchain is at the forefront of this green movement with initiatives like Vet Dao. Let's take a closer look. Imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost, making them valuable assets.

These verified records build a massive collective impact, benefiting people through their own actions. Sound a bit complex, but Vchain made it fun. Explore our apps at vb better.com. Vchain's goal is to power a new era of sustainable solutions. So, if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small, sustainable actions every day, go check out vetero.com to find out more. And now back to the show. Okay. Oh, that's interesting. So, like the the eye scan with the orb is just for setup and it's just to prove uniqueness initially and prove humanity initially.

I thought it was cuz like obviously there's um there's two angles to proof here. one is like the proving of the credential and then like say in this instance it would be the orb saying this is a person and then the other one is the proving to a verifier that this credential corresponds to me specifically. So I thought that you know once I have the credential on my phone that I am a human or whatever I then go to the supermarket say look I'm a human let me buy this human grapes or something like this human grapes.

Yeah exactly human grapes and they're like put them in robot prison ASAP. Um, and then I thought that you'd have to somehow correspond that proof to you again and you do another eye scan. But you're saying it's just for the initial setup and everything after that is like what linked to my fingerprint or something like this. Yeah, it's it's actually so yeah, you're right to point out like the the onboarding phase and how you get the identity is a slightly different to how you verify, but the orbs would just be because I had the same assumption.

I was like, am I going to have to scan my my eyes every time I, you know, make a purchase, right? Am I going to have to have one in my house to log on to Google? That kind of thing. But no, it's it's it's literally for that uniqueness point. Um I I believe the the kind of unique representation that gets generated of the Irish stays, but all of the rest of it like you basically keep the end piece as a unique identifier to say, okay, this is a some eyeballs that correspond to this hash have been scanned and they're in the set.

And that all kind of goes uh I believe kind of gets managed on the blockchain as well on a smart contract. And then yeah what once you're on boarded it's the public key that is the important thing for the identity but then when you go to the verification side and say I want to authenticate with a website to prove I'm a human I think Reddit actually was one of the the the companies supporting this I saw um potentially but yeah if you want to authenticate once then using your your world ID what's actually happening is they've gone because they are very very you know privacy conscious or they they at least say they are and the protocols themselves are all open source for how this happens is quite interesting, but essentially you're then wrapping your credential, your public key in additional zero knowledge proofs.

So you're the analogy is you're basically having a single use disposable identity every time you authenticate, but it's all tied back to a kind of main proof. And the main proof is what I was alluding to earlier is that your the when we talk about zero knowledge proofs, again, just to recap, it's like saying I have a claim about something and I can prove it to you without revealing anything about the claim. Um the only thing that gets effectively revealed in this is the claim that I am a part of the set of humans in the system.

That's it. It's like a set membership thing. So all I'm proving is my public key is part of the global set of people who have been scanned. Uh and then that gets wrapped up in a in a zero knowledge proof each and every time you get used. And they did that intentionally so that you can't you know correlate if you log into this website and this website people can't see it's the same person logging in that kind of stuff. So, it's meant to kind of firewall privacy at that level, too.

I'm just imagining a futuristic scenario, you know, in this AI Terminator dystopian world where they're trying to get these human world coin proofs and obviously the eyeball scans are the really difficult thing to basically create. But all of a sudden, you know, Jack Davis has an eyeball scan and they can't recreate that. But Jack Davis died a hundred years ago and they're pretending he's still alive and they can quite easily get into his system and you know he's only got you know password one 123 style password to prove that it's his credential or something like this and then they can get around it.

Maybe I'm being a bit of a pessimist here but like I thought it was that was the secure line that would be used to link credentials to you every single time but obviously that's not practical. Yeah. And that's a really interesting point, right? Because I think, you know, from a marketing perspective, the orb, this big chrome bowling ball that you're going to get scanned at. That's the thing that is like the that's what people have a perception of. They think, oh, worldcoin, they think of that orb.

Um, but actually that's not necessarily the main point of security for the whole system. And actually, the weak points are going to be everywhere else. They're going to be the people who are operating them. These operators who, you know, are standing in the street with these orbs and getting people to scan. They're going to be on clothed hoods in like dark capes and stuff. Yeah. Sacrificing lambs and stuff in front of uh and it's going to be on the devices themselves, the apps that are using it, you know, all that kind of stuff.

you know, will it the way you are compromising the system will probably be most likely the way you normally are. It's like someone has got your phone and is forcing you to do something on it, right? It's like it's like any technology. It's not going to solve all those problems. So, that's why I highlighted the uniqueness part. I think that's that's like the the bit they're solving for. And again, they they chose that because it's there's a a level of universality to it because it should work everywhere.

And they are, you know, Irish scans are highly highly unique even though some people are now speculating that you could uh, you know, manufacture them with the tools today and you could create effectively synthetic eyeballs, sorry, or irises to, you know, create multiple personalities, right? So that that's one thing. And then all you'd have to do is get a sympathetic operator to scan you in four or five times. So that's another issue. But um yeah, it's definitely like there's definitely problems that people have pointed out and and are a little bit worried about.

But yeah, nothing's ever foolproof, right? This is going to get weirder and weirder, isn't it? Like it's always like technologies catching up with the proofs, right? So it's like eyeballs were the thing that couldn't be, you know, faked and then we're saying we can and then eventually it's going to be like, okay, I need to take your blood and that's going to be the thing that goes on chain. It's going to get more and more pervasive every time. I think that one element I want to talk about is the crypto aspect as well because it's not immediately obvious like what role it plays there.

I see that you have this wallet obviously where you can store your credentials which makes sense but then they have their own cryptocoin um what's it called world wd and you can they're giving lots of airdrops to users initially and you could convert it to local fiat and you know connected to daps and all this kind of stuff like it wasn't immediately obvious what the crypto use case was there if it was just another project that probably needs to make money and crypto is the way to make a big number and you know get lots of investment and whatnot.

Yeah. Um so again like it's easy to be cynical here and I I will be but I think it's like there are there are two main purposes from what I can see. One is ownership of the the network itself or ownership in the the future governance and I will you know pas on future because right now it is all being operated by the world coin foundation and even when you think about things like the blockchain stuff right how does this scale like blockchains aren't handling that many transactions per second right now and they are also introducing kind of central points of failure or central points of trust in how you use the blockchain in this right like there are there are elements of that too um but It's it's about this future vision where the world coin foundation which apparently also is not owned by the same you know Sam Olman is like separated from that as well but they're thinking about this future where essentially it's this public good and decisions in governance are

made by holders of the of the coin right which again I can just imagine has a whole bunch of other issues like how are we going to globally govern this identity system like it it sounds kind of impossible to me but that's one that's one function of it the Second and more cynical one is obviously it's an incentive to sign up. So I think you know in London when this was u I think in 2023 or 2024 when people were standing around with these orbs they were offering something like 25 world coins or WLDs for getting scanned, right?

Which is I think it was worth something like $25 at the minute. Um so it's clearly just like a like any crypto scheme, right? It's an incentive to get on boarded. There are airdrops, that kind of stuff. I also thought it was being used to incentivize the uh the operators, the people holding the the orbs for people, but I actually saw a report that they're being paid in Tether instead. So, I'm I'm not entirely sure about that anymore, but yeah, it's it's it's crypto doing crypto stuff basically.

Yeah, I saw lots of some of the controversies that we talked about earlier were related to a lot of these obviously like they're kind of pitching this towards the egalitarian angle of there's 1.4 4 billion unbanked. We've got to help these people, you know, give them universal income and all this kind of stuff. So they these kind of the projects have done very well in places like Kenya, Argentina, Indonesia. And again, like one of the controversies is they're offering $20, which is quite a large sum of money relative out there.

But many of the people that were going to these, you know, hooded figures with these giant silver eyeballs, didn't know that what they were doing or signing up to. They didn't know it was an Irish scan. They didn't know how it would be used. I saw some someone use the term um biodata colonialism which is quite powerful and they've obviously come under like a lot of stick for targeting this maybe uneducated or not giving them the information they need to actually make the decisions and obviously just waving some money around and saying you know don't worry too much yeah it's it's notable that um the world coin itself the token is not currently available in the US right so because because of all the the scrutiny around this and the potential issues around data Um while you know not to say there is or isn't but like that people are worried about it and people are uncertain and they've clearly made inroads in other countries where things might be more lax from a regulatory perspective

or they think you know frankly they can get away with uh you know what is it um ask for forgiveness and not permission basically right so they're going out there and you know in many cases they are now running into trouble like I think in Portugal uh last year they had to kind of temporarily halt everything because of an issue around being able to withdraw consent. They're like, "Well, how once it's in this big global identity system on the blockchain, how do you withdraw your consent to be part of the system?" It doesn't seem like that's been baked in very much.

And there's been various suspensions in various countries. There's been, I think one in Indonesia around uh questions over the operators and how they were working uh you know, so maybe like they would there were some dodgy dealings going on basically with these people on the ground. There have been reports of uh black markets popping up. I think it was in China there was a report from I think your eyeballs here real humans. Well, yeah, there was there was a black market for the data and I don't know if it was data that's you know in theory they're not stored on the orbs, right?

But back to that question of the hardware, how difficult is it to create or take one of these orbs and modify it slightly to to keep the data right? That kind of stuff is all going to be in question. So yeah, there's been a lot of controversy around this beyond just the the bad taste for some of the concept as well. And we talked about the Snowden um kind of leak and scandal and all this kind of stuff. Like if you get into someone's supply chain for whatever reason and you just plant a little chip in there that's recording everything, offloading it.

Like how hard is it really to do this? Especially when you think this is going to be deployed worldwide and they want to support 8 billion people. Like obviously they're going to need hundreds of thousands of orbs. There's no way they can properly vet and verify. And even if you know a government tells them to do that, they're going to have to comply. So yeah, do you trust it? You know, don't trust verify that kind of thing. But it's hard to verify these closed systems and like these little black boxes.

Well, I guess we call them silver cylinders now is the equivalent of a black box where you don't really know what's going on in there. Yeah, there's so many things that I want to like double click on. Like whenever we talk about putting data on chain, European GDPR always comes up, right? The right to deletion is paramount in all things internet right now. And that's just not possible with blockchain. Like a lot of people argue that okay, that you're not putting real data on there like you're putting hashes of data which isn't the data.

But we don't really know if there will be a time in the future at which point that data which is you know immutable always there can be reverse engineered back to the original data. So there's always kind of been a bit of a gray zone of is hash data like should it be GDPR compliant if it's on a blockchain and I think there's a lot of reluctance from governments to go down that route because of that GDPR compliance specifically in Europe I guess more than anything.

I think the big thing is like you said it they claim to be a decentralized network and you know technically they are but like you say these orbs the models the infrastructure they're all managed by this tools for humanity. So it right now like technically you might look at that but when everything's you know all the power really lies in tools for humanity and they're pulling all the strings and paying all the people like there really is a single point of failure and how much do you want to buy into that system right now.

Yeah, and I think that even, you know, coming back to the like scalability question as well. I mean, there's like tons of scalability questions here in general, like how do you scale this to getting everyone on boarded? Who's paying for that, right? Like, are we going to do these airdrops of world coin forever to everyone? How's that going to work? Like that's going to be, you know, extra trillions of of dollars to to do that. But also from just purely on the, you know, from we're we're a techie blockchain podcast as well.

So I just think of you know you you're relying on these they call them like centralized sequences and batches to do this. They've also come out with like a so originally all of this was happening on Ethereum. Um so the identities themselves that's where the they're making commitments like hash zero knowledge proved commitments to these identities on the blockchain but Ethereum can only handle so much. So they actually developed a I think it's called world network or something as a layer two. So now they have a layer 2 that's built in the same way as things like base or optimism using that stack.

But for that they still have this centralized model right where they have a world coin foundation essentially entity in the mix right so you have to ask questions like what if they run out of money what if they just stop operating these things right that the system can die just because of apathy in the end right they've got they've been funded they've got 250 million fund in funds to play with that will run out one day right and will they keep it going so it's like once you've on boarded hundreds of millions of people is it then at risk and that's where I think also the token probably comes into it.

Maybe there's a bet on the token value going up to sustain these operations, that kind of stuff. But it's a bit of a guessing game, I think, as well. I get why we're kind of in this multicoin world where it's like everyone thinks they can make a quick book by spinning out their own coin and trying to like, you know, inflate the value and if they're an initial investor, they make loads of money and lots of leverage and 100x and all this kind of stuff. But increasingly you are reliant on promises and the promise that the number will go up and like a lot of these systems don't necessarily have inherent kind of confirmed value being given to users and like you say if one party disappears that's funding everything in tether for example like how does the system self-maintain?

It doesn't a lot of the time whereas like things like Bitcoin and even Ethereum now and like other major chains they've been going on for so long now that the system is kind of like self-fulfilling in that it does self-reward and it's unlikely that that's going to disappear overnight. Like a lot of things of these things aren't battle tested and like Bitcoin was fine. It wasn't being battle or it wasn't battle tested for the first three years, but there wasn't enough people and money in the system for it to matter.

But now whatever it is 20 years later, like well less than that, but you know, it's well battle tested and people can buy into that system and trust in that system. It's probably why there's been so much reluctance to invest in, you know, other coins that aren't Bitcoin necessarily. I kind of I think with this whole project, I get the problem. I really do understand the problem. I think even to look at like really futuristic use cases like the UBI stuff looking at the underbanked population there's a lot of immediate kind of near-term problems that this could solve as well like replacing recaptures and captures like as they you know these AI systems getting smarter those things are becoming less relevant and you know less useful we obviously in in Dow systems in a lot of crypto projects we have a lot of unknown and fake users civil use attacks and all this kind of stuff and obviously that all relates to airdrops where you want value to be going to individ iduals rather than

a few manipulative malicious parties. So I think there's a lot of milestones they can tick off in the meantime. But is this the right way to do it? It seems like such a kind of like finger in the air futuristic overspec solution to a real problem and I don't know if I buy into it to be honest. Yeah, I I I'm in a similar place like beyond finding the tech very interesting and they are using cutting edge stuff to do all this. I yeah it does feel like they are sol I think they're solving the problem in a sense right they're solving the problem of proof of personhood in the digital age the problem is that it introduces a bunch of other issues right and that that's really where we would I would take issue with it personally is like are we are we just hitting the limits of what's possible when you're trying to prove humanity but you're putting a digital interface in between things right like maybe there's a fundamental law here where

as soon as you put a screen or the computer between human beings, then you can you can only do so much and you can solve it if you have a centralized party and you accept all these security issues or you accept, you know, potential privacy issues, all that kind of stuff. And and again, they they say it's very private and the technology would say that too, but there's always going to be issues. There's always going to be malicious humans involved that are are going to game the system as well.

So yeah, that that side of it just from a purely technical perspective. I feel like this is not a solution that is going to be appealing to everyone, right? Like the reception to it was very poor from most people. People don't want to go and get scanned by these orbs. They think, you know, your average person on the street is going to see this, I think, quite clearly as, you know, some weird dystopian thing, as you said, and I don't want to be involved with that.

Right. like to only have 5 million users with the kind of network effects they have and you see how fast chat GBT grew by comparison it's clearly not as compelling and then you have the whole like like you mentioned the the the feeling that there's some taking advantage of different cultures involved here right like all the adoption has happened in certain places it's been a lot slower in the west in the US in Europe right you know partly for regulation partly because maybe they haven't been targeted as much as well so yeah It's one that despite all the technological interest of this, it does feel uh a little bit unnerving to me.

Definitely. Yeah. I think I kind of like see this is I imagine because this is like a very web 3 blockchain cryptosavvy project, right? And that's probably what they're pitching towards initially as a lot of these projects tend to do. And I think I can imagine a lot of resistance from that community purely because it offers quite a centralized web two style model and yeah we got all the ZKP and the blockchain token stuff whatever but at the end of the day there you are still verified by a centralized service the orb whatever you want to call it and you know when you've got so many projects that are trying to solve this in maybe much more open trusted or trustless ways using web 3 like proof humanity doing reputation based gitcoin passport doing signalbased scoring where it's much more about you know you can verify these things in multiple ways from say a collection of reputation from a thousand people and then someone offers you this giant orb solution where it's like worldcoin gives

you the stamp of approval on your eyeball to say you are a person I can see why there's reluctance in the crypto web3 community to adopt this as well and I do think there's a there always will have to be a place for both both there will always have to be the big centralized institutions that have a big fat waiting and say Jack is Jack Alec is Alec give me your eyeball and here's your big score. But there will also always be that there will need to be more community-based voting on okay, this is my history.

This is my transaction history. These are the social connections I have. These are the things I do on a day-to-day basis. And I imagine like the future paradigm that's needed to do this kind of stuff and solve these kind of huge problems is a combination of both. Yeah, I'm glad you mentioned that because we we should also, you know, just very briefly touch on some of the competing things out there, right? They're not the only Yeah. and not the only game in town when it comes to digital identity and and having these big networks of them.

And there are lots of other companies. You've got Proof of Humanity. You've got uh what's now the Holland Foundation. They acquired Gitcoin Passport, which was another one of these big projects. And those are they're they're they're taking some of the initial thinking I think that Worldcoin had around like peer validation, attestation from your peer group like we've talked about in digital identity, right? getting your identity being the sum of what your community says about you almost. They're taking that approach which is much more kind of web 3 native and doesn't put these big centralized parties in in the way or this weird orb scanning biometric system in there as well.

Right. It's purely cryptographic, purely digital, which I think yeah, to your point, a lot of the people in the crypto world would argue private money has been solved already. And that what world coin and world world network are doing here is they're conflating a global currency, a global private currency with this d this AI deep fake problem, right? Because they're kind of do they're trying to do something that solves everything at once. People will probably argue that Bitcoin or X whatever blockchain solves the money part of it and maybe I'll just put up with the fact that I know the internet's full of deep fakes and stuff anyway, right?

Like maybe that's an acceptable thing for them. I think that's the maybe the pitfall of this or maybe will be the downfall of this is that they're maybe trying to do too much and I get why they've had to do that. Why they've gone beyond just the like identity system and to the money system as well. And I I get that a lot of it funding, a lot of it so they don't have to like, you know, buy lots of Bitcoin, buy lots of Ethereum to fund this and run this and all that kind of stuff.

And maybe they want to have a degree of centralization when they're testing things out initially to, you know, have higher transactions, not have to, you know, worry about Ethereum's throughput and all this kind of stuff. But again, like you say, other projects have already solved for that element. So I think maybe they've done too much and they should have just concentrated on the digital identity system with the orbs and maybe it would have been easier then. But let's see. Like, you know, who knows? This might be the login with Google of web 3 in 20 years and we'll look back and be like, damn, I wish I'd scammed my eyeball earlier and got $20 that's now 100 million or something like this.

Yeah. Or we'll all be kind of part of this cybernet system and we will have no choice anymore. But yeah, it's uh it's at least at least we've got a better understanding now, I think, of how it works. And I'm glad we glad we covered it even though we're about two years late. But yeah, definitely one to keep an eye on for the future. Um and yeah, I guess that's a good place to end things. And if you've been listening the whole way through, thank you for

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Digital Identity

Related episodes

All episodes