Episode 94

Decentralized Personhood with Kyle Weiss Shady El Damaty

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

This week on Untangling Web3, Kyle Weiss and Shady El Damaty join us from ETH Denver to explore the future of digital identity, decentralized personhood, and blockchain-based verification systems.

As the digital landscape evolves, ensuring secure, verifiable, and privacy-preserving digital identities has become a critical challenge. This conversation delves into how Web3 is reshaping identity management and what it means for online trust, governance, and digital interactions.

Key highlights

  • Decentralized Digital Identity in Web3. Traditional identity systems rely on centralized institutions that store and manage personal data, creating vulnerabilities in security and privacy. Decentralized identity systems use blockchain and cryptographic proofs to enable individuals to control their own identity without relying on third parties. This approach enhances security and reduces risks related to data breaches and identity theft.
  • Proof of Personhood and Sybil Resistance. Online communities and governance systems require methods to distinguish real human users from bots or duplicate accounts. Proof of personhood mechanisms verify that an identity belongs to a unique human, ensuring fair participation in airdrop distributions, decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs), and financial transactions. These verification methods prevent Sybil attacks, where single entities create multiple fake accounts to manipulate systems.
  • AI and Identity in a Web3 World. As artificial intelligence and AI agents become more prevalent, the ability to distinguish between human and machine interactions is crucial. Decentralized identity solutions ensure that human participants can verify their authenticity while interacting with AI-driven systems, maintaining transparency and trust in financial transactions, governance, and digital communities.

Decentralized digital identity is shaping the future of online trust, governance, and security in Web3. By enabling users to own and control their identity, blockchain-based identity solutions enhance privacy, prevent fraud, and create fairer digital ecosystems.

As digital interactions become more automated, the ability to verify real humans in a decentralized, privacy-preserving way will be a cornerstone of the next evolution of the internet.

Learn more about Kyle and Shady's work here

  • Holonym → https://human.tech/ - Human Passport → https://passport.human.tech/

00:00:00 - Intro: Kyle & Shady 00:03:40 – Digital Identity Challenges 00:16:17 – Use Cases & UX 00:20:23 – AI in Digital Identity 00:27:59 – Decentralized Personhood 00:34:44 – Risk & Security 00:41:07 – Sovereignty & Community

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast we're at eth Denver as you can see from everything behind Kyle over there today we're diving into one of web 3's biggest challenges secure and private decentralized identity as our digital lives expand how do we prove who we are without compromising privacy joining me are two experts well I hope they're experts who are shaping the future of decentralized identity so we have shady aldatti is the CEO and co-founder of holim foundation the leading web 3 IDE identity platform by ZK credentials uh a former cognitive neuroscientist wow and a Pioneer in decentralized science love that and we also have to my left here Kyle Weiss head of strategy at the holim foundation a five-time startup founder and former co-founder of gitcoin and passport XYZ so some recent news is holim acquired gitcoin passport now called human passport and has already distributed nearly $400 million to verified users all without a token yet so let's dive in jedy how are you doing I'm good I'm good uh the altitude's getting

to me a little bit I got oh no I forgot my Chapstick so uh okay I'm unfortunately I used to live in Denver so this is almost like the homecoming event for me whenever I get to come back um and I'm always dried out I'm like oh this is why I left a few years ago the Denver's the weather's been fantastic we've been super forun this week the merch here is crazy but I have seen loads of people giving away free ChapStick and they are the most popular stands by far yeah yeah this is we're in the middle of the conference right now it's incredible there's so much going on Kyle how are you finding eth Denver itself um it's been good it's been good it's it's much more commercialized than it used to be so like years in the past it's really been focused on Cor of community core Builders this seems to have been much more just commercialized like these venues of the the sort of boo seter setup are beautiful but things

that I would expect to see almost like a Salesforce conference it's it's been a little bit of an adjustment for me personally yeah I've noticed that as well like a lot the I've seen like there's been much more kind of content topics emerging technology some of the side events but say the main stuff is like you say mostly sales pitch marketing style which is a bit new novel I think there was an intention to shift it away from being an ethereum Community Conference uh I think it's one of the first ones with along with ECC to becoming more of an innovation Festival I started seeing that language more and more and more now we're at this big venue you know there's all sorts of crazy stuff video games and like all sorts of gimmicks and that's great but that also invites a lot of uh I think auxiliary in tensions that divert us from maybe the main reason why this got started right yep which to me is like all about the community I think

I've seen more interest in the robots that are walking around sort of like oh yeah these these competitors to Tesla's new robot as well and it's like hey like are you actually doing anything in this space one of them actually stepped on my shoe I I felt like it was intentional like it did one of those Stomps you know oh sorry about that that's how they get you in that's how they get you in yeah you are so right I've seen about 10 of them my background is robotics I go up to them be like what's the relation of this robot to what you're doing there's none it's just to pull people in but that's marketing right it's funnel that's what the point of this is right so we're not here to talk about eth Denver we're here to talk about decentralized identity let's start off nice and slow who wants to start with this one let's go with Shady why is proving identity so important in the digital age that's a great question so

if we think about um identity it's something that means different things to different people um especially I think in web 3 there's this Association of identity being the next big killer use case because people saw Bitcoin it fundamentally transformed something that we all interacted with which is money and so what's next after money we associate money with the government we associate it with our uh social contracts Etc and so identity seems to be that next thing uh that next thing that's going to be that's going to change and make things more decentralized and private and secure and trustless and Etc now the interesting thing is identity it's it's kind of um a natural reaction but identity it's something that's people don't go after people need money but they don't necessarily need a driver's license unless they want to drive mhm so there's been this I think um jumping the gun over the past 5 to eight years of people trying to make identity happen the same way Bitcoin happen um but in the end it

all comes down to what do you really need identity for now back to the question right So today we're really seeing I think uh a shift of Commerce of social functions of communities of culture into digital spaces and when that happens we're kind of bringing all of these attributes of ourselves into these spaces but perhaps we're not also bringing all of the other uh things that need to come along with it for safe and responsible use so for example personhood how do you know who's actually a person right whether and I'm talking about like not only are they a living breathing human being but also you know are they a legal person that's entered into a social contract right and so these ideas and concepts are fundamentally different when you start thinking about what social contracts look like in digital spaces versus a uh uh a constitutional republic um and some of that is so much like building trust in these ecosystems as well right like identity gives you not only reputation um but it

gives you the sense of like who you are and who you want to represent yourself as that reputation can hang off of but ultimately like Trust Systems in financial networks and social settings whatever that might be so finding ways to figure out who can participate in what capacity I think is another space that like identity has been super super valuable um sort of emerging in web 3 at least yeah I'd like that you mentioned the idea of like it was payment rails first like blockchain technology made sense immediately for all the value proposition of it is trust in data mutability all these things that are constantly touted and that makes sense currency for payments for this kind of stuff where you're just moving you know data around on a ledger but you know taking it one step further data out there is one thing how do we apply it to useful things like people I want to attach that data to an individual so you see there's an immediate alignment between web 3 of currency

and web three of identity but then on the other side like Bitcoin all these things are often touted as being kind of very good for anonymity and you think actually is there some kind of is there some kind of mismatch there is there a direct alignment with web 3 for identity or is there not and Kyle you want to answer that question yeah sure so I suspect a lot of us don't want to support those that are doing evil like whether it's sanction Nations whether you believe in those sanctions ultimately we want to make sure the funds are going to places that um are being used appropriately perhaps not to kill other people so there's there's a lot of Concepts I think that we can start to explore in the web 3 space around um you know proof of Clean Hands has this person some sort of criminal background where they wouldn't be able to get a bank account pre obviously now one thing that's lovely about a lot of the space just like blockchain

in general is it does offer payment rails for things that are in the gray area as well so we can go through and sort of prove that someone is not on a block list like they are passing like anti-money laundering all without doing kyc checks and in that particular environment it also enables a lot of onchain uh interactions where previously they might have gotten debanked okay so in this in this environment like I think the payment rails that Bitcoin has afforded has been fantastic everything's on chain and so as soon as an identity is linked to that sort of wallet address it's very very difficult to ever back away from that you have to kind of just start over but finding ways to include those inside of your ecosystem can you know we at least real humans and perhaps real humans who have good intention um unlocks a lot more sort of trust coordination interactions that I think is what a lot of folks are still working to solve in the blockchain space yeah and

you no since that this is like a big say is it a big reason that institutions have taken their time getting into say the Bitcoin space is because of the anonymity and the lack of kyc involved is that something you guys have both noticed yeah it's interesting so you know when you coming back to payment rails when we really look at crypto it's an excellent tool for Capital flow and capital flow I think in the current world we live in today it's the difference between um a good idea in theory and something put into practice Capital will help ideas Thrive they'll help them grow um and accomplish things now in the institutional setting people are looking at crypto rails and they're like wow this is an incredible way to get uh value into as many hands as possible to deploy Capital to grow the economy to bring more people uh into the marketplace but they're also looking at it with suspicion they're saying okay wait I can circulate Capital to anyone anywhere and with capital

comes power so identity is one of those things that's an actual requirement for any large scale uh distribution of capital and this is something we see with air drops projects want to be able to say get their mimetics get their tokenized value of whatever abstract idea they're selling with their token and they want to get it into as many hands as possible well I mean ultimately a lot of that started with governance right it's like we want to turn over power of this thing to the people that are using it themselves and so airdrops started you know early on days as like governance tokens in this approach that not only are we rewarding you for the efforts of participating in our ecosystem but we actually want you to help make decisions with us as well and so I think once once we've had the chance to sort of go through and say you know a how many people do you actually want to distribute and push that too and B how do you make sure

that there's real humans that you're allocating that to so that those decisions are getting made in a way that actually benefits the community and not just a couple whale actors that are perhaps acting on behalf of their own self set of the community's interest yeah and this is a challenge that's may be quite unique to you know proving identity in the digital age like when you go to a Traditional Bank you go there I prove who I am so there's no real problem with people spamming up a 100 versions of me overnight pretending to be 100 different people but when we're talking the digital age proving that the convenience comes at a lack of trust and security potentially and I guess we're going to talk about a bit later but like you say air drop is a great example the convenience of being able to send money anywhere very quickly also means there a downside of who you sending that money to like they those 100 people could be the same same person all getting

the money very efficiently and that's not ideal especially when you're talking about the governance are is the are these airdrops going to the right people are they real people which matters more than you know the convenience in some cases so we kind of talked about the problem a little bit can you explain Hy and where it fits into all this how does it fix this web three identity problem we're having yeah absolutely I can I can give a a stab at that so yes so Hollen builds Keys wallets and identity uh at the very base Foundation we have something called the Network which uh props up this whole human Tech or human aligned technology ecosystem that we're creating the human Network lets you take human data like what you have what you know what you are and create a human key with it it's a key that's very difficult to lose because it's tied to attributes or combination of attributes so for example you could uh we have like a little fun demo where you

can do a bimetric face scan and uh authenticate and create a wallet with that which is kind of cool and uh there's some very specific use cases for that we have in mind but once you have this key I mean that's the big challenge in crypto self custody is how do you actually allow people to be in control of their own assets Property Data identity Etc well you need to give them self- custody you need to give it to them in a way where that uh key is persistent so this network exists kind of as a a persistent key availability system or protocol where you can just pull your key from this decentralized network at any point and then interact with crypto you can you know interact with Bitcoin you can even perhaps uh send end to-end encrypted messages uh if that's if that's what you're doing with that so that's our foundation we've built a couple demonstrations or applied use cases to solve other problems one of them is the human passport uh which

allows you to prove personhood uh we like to call it sometimes modular personhood there's many ways to prove who you are very low barrier uh to entry and then we also have an embeddable wallet uh evm wallet that has some pretty cool features that's called the human wallet okay so I think that is really interesting the idea of you know how to create a private key from something everyone's in the crypto space anyway is familiar with pneumonics which has probably been one of the BG Bears of getting you know giant web to adoption and whatnot and the idea of linking your intrinsic attributes to your key so you don't have potentially that pneumonic problem but as soon as you say something like oh Biometrics going on chain all this kind of stuff what is the feedback there is it is it something where you know there's someone who's actually understand in my very private face scan or my blood potentially all this kind of stuff is it something you get questioned on a lot I

haven't actually this is this is like my my one liner it's like oh what do you guys do oh we make wallets from Biometrics like oh that's that's pretty cool pretty cool stuff and maybe people are just being polite I don't know yeah I think a lot of the approach that we've taken um perhaps on the passport side and why we've combined a lot of passport with holim um is because there's no one right way to prove that you're a unique human there's a gentleman named Brian Ford who's done a bunch of research in the US on uh digital identity systems and voting systems and some of that research has shown that there's kind of four key ways to prove that you're a unique human the easiest is obviously showing up in person for verification yeah um the second is usually Biometrics so we have others that are scanning Palms scanning faces scanning Ires the third is like a social or web a trust like if shotty says that someone's human and I trust shoty

then I can believe that they're they're real um and so stepping through each of those particular areas we built passport in a way that we want to make sure that we have an aggregator of those different methods so now in this particular case oh the fourth is kyc obviously so if you trust a government agency that's issuing the credential you can go through and Trust if there's a real human behind that as well so the ability to create a wallet on a face scan I think is one way that we're approaching the ability to prove unique Humanity simply bu onchain interactions or perhaps through verification of other mechanisms like um we want to make sure that we're reaching out and getting people where they are um and giving them the ability to prove their unique Humanity that is both non doxing doesn't cost them anything potentially as well um and just offers that that proof that they can take that forward into the rest of the ecosystem um and leverage across a lot of other

places that you know in this case human passports been integrated with that's strong I understand that then like that's kind of another web three principle is not being tied into say one way of doing something having options being able to distribute across multiple paths so you talked there about how to link an individual to this key the private key right and then the next step is you know anyone can link anything to a key how do I actually link that to humanity how do I link that to a verifiable credential what's the step there do you have like again many different providers many different issuers could you talk a little bit to that yeah yeah so um for those little creating Keys you can acquire a human passport either with the wallet um human wallet that we have or any other wallet in this case um and whenever you go through and sort of your unique Community we still use very basic like dids verifiable credentials VCS that are set up um one of the

reasons why we're so excited about the combination with holim is because of the addition of zero knowledge proofs and sort of ZK nullifiers on those credentials themselves which helps encrypt and protect that credential information that much more um in this particular case um we have 35 million roughly credentials that have been assigned one thing that's fantastic about this is these are all user generated themselves so we're not going out and just creating these users are actually showing up to create them themselves but it's it's through this model that they're able to go through and pick the ways that they want to self-identify to sort of prove unique humanity and take that forward using a scoring mechanism to whatever ecosystem it is that has sort of integrated passport so on the scoring system what kind of use cases are you seeing say 35 million verifiable credentials where is it being applied to mostly when I think of digital identity I typically think of the issuer the holder and then the verifier what kind of verifiers do

you see in in the set up yeah yeah um a lot of this are other ecosystems in communities the most common use cases are airdrops okay so there's there's a whole business around sort of helping understand who's a real human on an airdrop list and participating in a community there's like Cil resistance basically is that the the killer use case for this yep that's that's one of the easiest and it's the most common I think we have others that have been uh really creative and are starting to explore just onchain interactions as well so um you have the ability to hit an API restful API super performant you can understand you know a score of a wallet address one thing that's that's rather novel though is using the ethereum at testation service or EAS users can go through and publish a score and that brings smart contract to Smart contract interactions to fruition so there's a layer to that we're working with who are making all gas fees free for real humans on their Network

um we're still testing it with them on their test net right now but the expectation is is like let's let some of the automated arbit Bots go through and drive fees on that sequencer fees while we enable a space for real humans to transact and interact where it doesn't actually cost them anything um similarly there's uh prototype we were doing with shapeshift which is a defi exchange as well they're looking at subsidizing Swap fees for those that are real humans once again all provable with just onchain interactions and so there's no intermediary as soon as that's live you can take advantage of that because it's something that happens at the actual decks like the liquidity pool level itself you I mean it I'm very glad you like specifically called out Bots fake users it's something that's prevalent in crypto I think some networks are actually quite Pro to it as well it boost their transaction volume it looks good exactly right yeah it's Bonkers right it is Bonkers right I mean they're looking for transaction

throughput because then investors get excited they're looking for tvl and so like just washing tvl through the thing there's there's been a number of jokes about like one Dev that sort of builds up five dexas that all just Arbitrage against each other but because it's a single person like there's not a lot of money they're actually losing per se um and these investors don't they don't know that do they they don't they don't understand this stuff they're like oh the transactions look good that's all I care about right now I mean this whole topic is a constant it seems like a constant pull between ux and security SL performance something like this so like are you noticing that when you've deployed these is there any like kind of resistance to the ux like say barriers to entry are people like actually I don't want additional kind of steps to get involved in these air drops is that something you've noticed or not I would say for sure yeah I mean Kyle yeah please there's um

anytime we engage with an ecosystem um we're very fortunate we got to help story with their airdrop um the story team is absolutely fantastic if you hav't had a chance to check out their Network and sort of the IP that they're trying to give like democra and ownership back to certainly do that um but the IP or excuse me the story team was very much in tune with like okay we have x million of wallet users we kind of expect like maybe single digit very very low double digit these are real humans like they just they got it like they've been in the space and I was like oh Hallelujah versus these other people that's like well we have 35 million wallet addresses we're thinking we need to airdrop to 30 million of those and it's like how many people are in crypto like how many do you actually think are doing this but it's a dilution of value right because there are some real users who aren't Bots and if you're saying putting 30

million air drops out like if you're the normal person who just want individual is getting a percentage of that and that is it's not good for the network and they should see that sure short term it looks great to have these massive transaction vs but long term you're not going to get real adoption and eventually these Bots are going to just disappear yeah that's that's exactly it there's there's a sense of like okay I have maybe five or less wallets and I've been sort of farming exploring doing my best to take a part in this ecosystem that's very different from someone who has 20 plus 100 plus 500 plus that's sort of just automating scripting running some guide over and over again today's episode is sponsored by the vchain foundation now we often talk about how emerging Technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and vchain is at the Forefront of this green movement with initiatives like V better Dow let's take a closer look imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low

cost making them valuable assets these verified records build a massive Collective impact benefiting people through their own actions sound a bit complex but vchain made it fun explore our apps at v better.com v Chain's goal is to power a new era of Sustainable Solutions so if you've got an app idea or just just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day go check out vb.com to find out more and now back to the show so there's this ability to go through and sort of prove you need Humanity on those wallets even with human passport most people are able to do that if they are in the space quite regularly across maybe a couple different wallets and that's healthy because we each have different personas or ecosystems we interact with I have my regen wallet that I do a bunch of Grants and things like that with I've got my DJ wallet my nft w and like these are things that like I'm I am anon on a couple of these wallets and I

do enough in the ecosystem where I can prove youi Humanity across them but I'm I'm clearly not out there just like attacking these things to extract value for very minimal effort I like that you how you defined it that I think when most people think of digital identity they think okay every single thing I do is going to be on chain for the world to see and I think like we're seeing like W3 standards that are slowly becoming more and more concrete is that the idea of different profiles I can have a gaming profile and that you can only see that and then I can have an educational profile my DJ profile whatever it is and there's a like very specific Hub that and I can choose who sees that data when I want them to see it's very specific it's like the example they always compare it to is Cash like it's private but not Anonymous is that the right term I think so like you you know they only people involved in that

transaction know what I'm sharing and that's it which is quite an important thing especially in like the digital age um I I like that you keep mentioning Humanity we're at e Denver every other store I see has got AI in some form or format is it something you guys are asked about a fair bit the idea of AI agents like CU you've got very specifically gone down the humanity kind of protocol that's the naming convention are you thinking about know your agent in this kind of stuff that's a term I've seen more and more yeah that's that's a really interesting uh point I think like yeah there's definitely this uh overwhelm overwhelming tsunami of AI this AI that we have like people saying you know we need to we need to build for the AI future and you know how do you do AI uh so so so that's interesting I mean like AI whatever that means right like everyone calls you know it's like is it an llm or is it an whatever that

is but um I think what's going to be really interesting is the actual proliferation of agents and how they interact with people and specifically how you might have um I kind of think it it as like a Napoleonic uh organization where you might have a core of Agents you'll have uh a trading agent a translation agent uh uh say like um uh an order your food agent Etc and there's going to be some free market for these types of services and we'll see what happens right whether it consolidates into one uh service or whether there'll be specialization now if we want to be able to interact with a free market of Agents a decentralized system would probably be preferable if the consumer is going to win out in the end otherwise we'll end up with like an Amazon type situation and you have to funnel these services is through one provider and that might be less than ideal especially when we're putting the entire world economy on these rails right we don't want a singular

economy that's that's very bad um so if that happens right uh one thing that'll be I think very important is uh one privacy and shared State across agents so how do you have private private shared State well actually uh MPC networks plus blockchain are really great for that you can have agents that are posting perhaps like something called zero knowledge proofs on chain that they've accomplished some action or computed some some task and they can prove Providence of you know passing data from one provider to the other it's eventually submitting your GrubHub order or something you know after like predicting what you wanted to eat and when you wanted it um so okay so if that happens if that actually scales up what are we going to see in terms of block space well block space become a premium are we just going to see block space filled up by a bunch of requests from AI agents and you're just a human now are you are you actually going to interact with blockchains are you

actually going to submit a transaction on an L1 or is it you just interact with an agent and and and and transacts with you I think that's a big open question um if we still expect humans to need blockchains for coordination and maybe like we don't want to always have to interact through intermediaries when like like human a human is still valuable perhaps not human agent a human um then human Centric blockchains I think are going to be very valuable in proof of humanity being able to access uh block space as a commodity that's prioritized towards humans I think might be very interesting very valuable in the future I've seen more and more people arguing that you know web 3 everyone always says web 3 has this problem with ux and people you unboarding the next billion users and whatnot and I've actually seen it a few times there people saying AI is going to solve that problem you don't need to have a ux anymore it's like the LMS will solve it you just

interact with the agent the agent handles all the stuff underneath it's like the killer use case of blockchain technology is a AI I think is fascinating I do think that as a gentic AI kind of takes off they are going to need strong payment rails like there's no way they're going to be transacting in fiat currency that's just impossible and when you're talking about these open worlds you described there decentralized identity is key is it something on your road map you're thinking about like how you link AI attributes potentially to private keys and give them you know the ability to interact in open world is something that's being thought about yeah yeah so um many years ago I was at this company called Twitter which has now been rebranded and and taken over by uh someone else and whenever I was there um we were experimenting with this concept of like labeling Bots like having people know who was a bot on platform and who wasn't and what that did was is that actually built

more trust like you started to understand like oh this is a bot like I'm totally okay with interacting with this because I know it's a bot as opposed to like oh like is this a real human is this not a real human I could imagine we start to see a lot of that with his agentic future as well not only is is there now a rush to build you know AI l2s so that all these AIS can start to interact with one another and sort of transact in the way that you're talking about because doing that on on like Current financial rails is just going to be a disaster like the time it takes for things to process and whatever that might be yeah um I think one of the things that sort of I would Circle back to is like how do you continue to build trust through those interactions though so uh yes we've been asked like hey in addition to Cil can you help us label like these AI Bots versus real

humans and it's like well we likely could but like each of the transaction history is thing that you have to sort of do the analysis on and so as each of these agents take action if it's in repeatable ways that's very very easy to classify after the fact okay but I think some of the real value is going to come from like the self-labeling like trying to give wallets this this sort of uh domain space the ens like whatever it is that you want to do that sort of says like hey this is an agent and I actually trust that more as a result than like me wondering whether or not there's an aent behind it I get you one one thing I want to uh definitely kind of uh just add to this topic I think it's very important is let's let's go back to social like I think social was the very kind of a big paradigm shift in culture and society and how we communicate information it's like the future of the

of democracy right you know it's like how we interact and and decide things together now what's interesting is you know a lot of social protocols just built out what people wanted they built out ways for people to connect uh for for advertisers to access audiences uh for messages to propagate through networks and that's great that sounds like you know amazing when you're building that you know you're just like a you know in your dorm room and you're making Facebook right like yeah let's do this we're going to save the world um but what's interesting is that this is uh social is a complex it's a complex system and you have all of these emergent phenomenon that come out of it and adversarial kind of game theoretic equilibria that emerge with stakeholders you never design the system for like the Cambridge analytica of the world so one thing about social and you know we still have this issue out I feel like you know sometimes I see my feed and I'm like somebody listening to me

why am I getting these things or uh why is this information being why am I feeling this way I feel less in control of my life because I'm being prompted with certain types of information so there's this kind of like latent structure that's emerged from the game theory that's surrounding social now enter AI agent right so this is much more it's has the same information propagation uh properties of social but with the effect of direct causality where an agent can actually affect something in the world by measuring and measuring and respon you know measuring something in the world you know reasoning about it and then responding to it you're actually putting causality at least in the digital sphere uh and it's it's much structured so how can you and if you're aware of that that's like oh holy holy holy crap that's it's like really bad that's really dangerous um so you might ask okay well how can I audit this agent or how can I trust this agent how do I know it's actually

doing what it's supposed to be doing things like Global private shared State and blockchains and ZK and ZK compute and all these things are are are are really useful um but if people are going to be interacting with agents uh that are going to do things on their behalf I think it's really important to Anchor that agent's uh capacity your responsibility in that human where we have accountability that Roots back to the human so this idea of delegating your personhood of allowing an agent to represent you and uh maybe delegate attributes of yourself or rights that come with your personhood in whatever social contract you enter whether it's with the US government or with a DA and so if that's happening right an AI agent is going to start like using your uh your your your likeness to transact and do stuff like that you know that's where I think key infrastructure becomes really important and something we're thinking a little bit about is uh how the architecture of the human wallet and actually it

already has AI embedded within it for transaction simulation where you split the key so you create the human key from your human attribute you can prove person you can do all these things and then you split the key into two pieces one you keep for yourself the other you hand over to the agent and then the agent has these kind of like hardcoded very difficult to you know almost immutable policies or parameters um and there's like a whole like decentralized Network that's Computing those parameters coming to consensus that those parameters are being reached and then the agent has these guardrails it goes off you know you give it the other piece of the key it runs off it like you know transacts within the limits that you set for those policies um but as soon as it comes into a point where it starts deviating from those policies like don't spend more than $1,000 dollar per day uh don't interact with high-risk contracts don't send money to the Lazarus group in North Korea please don't

do that um once that occurs then the network will actually uh require user consent right so you're like okay well I should pay attention to this I'm going to flag this transaction and I'm not just going to put this on autopilot and just let this do whatever it needs to do so this idea of uh kind of using AI to give people situational awareness uh so you understand what each trans action means but also to automate the kinds of things that you want to do online but without without uh giving complete power to this agent that's taking your delegated personhood to do things with I like that I've actually not heard that I've actually not heard that point before I've heard the idea of you know billions of Agents just completely on their own independently doing whatever they want and you're like well what do you how do you do how do you interact with that and I think yeah decentral ENT sh you can start to have like people reviewing them rating them whatever

and maybe that can help to a degree but linking them back to a human always so there's a degree of accountability if something goes wrong then that person is held accountable for that I think it's quite powerful I've actually not heard that point before so you heard it here for first nice one um I'm I'm glad you talked about trust and the Lazareth groups it's something that everyone's constantly talking about is the you know what happened with bit and all this kind of stuff but to bring it back to what you guys are doing could you kind of talk me through how Hy's identity system could have you know improveed wallet security generally maybe how it could have helped with that situation if it could have just to bring it back to the users so they understand the value of got what you guys are doing yeah yeah sure so um the bybit hack was um like almost admirably sophisticated in the way the approach um I don't know that our systems would have done

anything um other than perhaps helped them with some of the blind signing and like the ways that that interaction through safe um safe transactions are often very large depending on the amount of signers and the types of things you're trying to transfer so um blind signing is one of the pieces that I think was um at play there and so some of the types of wallet stuff we're doing I think will help with that in the future um much of that particular approach I think on like from our perspective in the identity space we are helping make sure that like the Lazarus group has a hard time offboarding that funding okay right so in this in this case like because all of the transactions on blockchains are visible like you can track a lot of that funding after the fact it's okay where's this going how's this being spent what's happening with it um and there's all sorts of rumors already flying about like oh they're like bridging over here and they're buying nfts over

here and they're swapping this and they're doing that and it's like maybe um but I don't think it's happening because of just the quantities that was hacked like at any sort of uh clip that they can offboard that particular funding right now um some of where we've been focused so is on this concept of proof of Clean Hands So making sure that the people you're interacting with have clean hands or are not a part of North Korea some other sanctioned Nation um and so this is a thing that we're doing on I bridging I think is one of the first so working with different networks to make sure that those that are bringing funds onto their Network are not actually from the Lazarus group um and that there's proof of their sort of like clean hands like their good citizenship inside of the world is coming on that doesn't require them to always dox themselves as well so is that mostly asset tracking on chain you like create like a risk score type for per

address is that how it works roughly or yeah yeah yeah yeah so so it's interesting um I really wish our co-founder nanak was here here because he was at The Ledger offices uh I think like 3 weeks ago uh and did a podcast I think with one of the Stark uh Community folks and in it he's like hey guys uh you know I'm I'm here like you know I have this platform I really want to just say like uh I'm like paraphrasing him right but you know he's like I really want to say that hey like there's a huge uh vulnerability in the safe front end right now and our company doesn't you know we're we're not using our safe except in a in an air gap system with like a Chromebook with like minimal surface attack area for uh for for boss like there's a huge huge attack Vector um but we're working on something that could potentially uh mitigate this this this attack Factor um especially when it's combined with a ledger for

blind signing so he was like saying that three weeks ago uh and uh interestingly enough uh Morana Ventures who is a spin you know it's propped up by bybit Founders uh they were looking at this uh about a year ago we were developing this we were trying to tell them about it and so you know we're like oh no guys no one email told you so yeah yeah we're like okay so uh we might be fundraising soon uh getting no it sucks what happened um it's crazy wow so the way the way it works actually it's very similar to the 2pc it's called 2pc MPC it's um uh how I was describing the AI agent key splitting except what we do uh so we have that one sharded the key and then the other key is put in uh right now it's a trusted execution environment uh but uh sorry I have a phone call my phone really quick do a hard pause that's the beauty of not doing it live like all this is

fine and your question might have been closer to like passport scores and how we're keeping track of scores as well it is definely yeah yeah yeah so like the the going into that side I think is good but making the delineation between Humanity versus proofer Clean Hands Like Prolean hands doesn't require this score a score yeah that's what I was going to get to eventually um so so like so for example what proof of Clean Hands does is it allows you and this is really important in the case of the Aztec Bridge um it lets you bridge say ethereum from you know eth from ethereum onto Aztec unlock privacy but you have to do uh zero knowledge identity proof first so this means going through ZK kyc you know you tap your your passport on your phone if you're a privacy maxi then you do like you know client side liveness detection and then you can mint that proof uh or you just do the traditional like you know spin up with verif and then

they're blinded to who you are so once you process you know uh complete that um you then do something called a verifiable proof of encryption so then that data is then encrypted to a node or a network uh and there's proof within the zero knowledge proof of that you've completed kyc that you've encrypted that data so it's proof of um data availab now how do you no that's the first part so the second part is how do you actually know when to decrypt that data so say for example there's a hack that occurs and people want to uh law enforcement comes to your Bridge or comes to your protocol or your dap or whoever and they say hey we need the information because this might be funding nuclear weapons development like oh okay well I didn't consider that um but if you're using proof of Clean Hands what you can can do is actually have uh conditions that are either onchain right so you could say uh like for example you could have a rate

limit as to how many times somebody decrypts data or you could have uh for example we could use a service like predicate which is a an oracle service that has like this embedded logic in it and can sign can uh produce signatures if conditions are met so you could say okay well if uh an address appears in two out of the five black list that's operated by independent agencies that can act as a trigger condition to then request the decryption from from from whatever node or network that's storing that data so that's one way that we can maintain what we call transparent accountability for these edge cases uh but once you produce this proof you can then mint on Aztec uh clean eth or clean BTC and that's a a token standard that's only possible to create if you've passed the sanctions check improv in that now there's tons of problems with what happens once you're an AA cuz you can mint clean eth and then uh pass it to somebody else who hasn't done

it and then what happens then does it all of a sudden the standard drops and it's no longer potentially clean eth or how does it work that's the that's the1 billion doll question yeah so we're trying to figure that out uh yeah I really wish our girlfriend Anan is here but he's working on like how you can have Aztec has a very different architecture where you do a lot you can do a lot of client side computation on transac actions referencing onchain history so the validators or the node doesn't actually need to like do the computation for you so you can do this thing where you like unroll your past transaction history and then produce ZK proofs that you've like interacted with this in the past but it's very complicated Tri right like it was a utxo base it'd be fine because you just track the utxo forever but because it's address base everything kind of gets mixed at every single transaction so it's a bit Messier I can understand there why that's a complicated

question to ask super hard yeah um so air drops air drops is the big thing right now but you know digital identity and strong digital idenity standards being like used in the normal world has so many use cases I've seen some of the stats are it could save like 5 to 15% of GDP even in the Western World what are some of the killer use cases you guys are hoping for maybe even outside of crypto ter normal that normal everyday users will understand yeah on the identity side um I think there's there's a lot of experimentation that we still happening one of the things that I am personally uh get excited about is sort of digital like Financial sovereignty in digital spaces so that's just means being able to own your own money some aspects of it are libertarian you don't have to believe in being a Libertarian so much from the spect of like I only worry about myself but I think we do want to see more and more people are empowered like

financially where they can't get debanked or assets can't sort of be withheld from them if they want to boycott something um in this particular space this is where I think digital identity proving that someone's a unique human giving them sort of power to interact in these ecosystems where we can't actually censor the type of monetary actions they can take is really really valuable so there was this concept called operation choke point which is somewhat popular inside the US where they're trying to like debank a bunch of people a lot of crypto Founders I know have also been kicked off of banks like Chase and Wells Fargo and others and those I have a funny anecdote with that too as well yeah uh so when we closed our seed round uh we have a we we diversify our banks you know while before the Silicon Valley Bank imp plosion uh wouldn't have affected us we divers fire our banks and one of them is a traditional brick and mortar bank called pien Seattle Pittsburgh so somehow

I guess they got on the presswire they're like oh like one of our Banking Company you know one companies that's banking with us uh raised around and they didn't really look much into it so then they reached out they were like hey you know we're super excited to help you guys you know make sure you put that those funds that you've raised into the PNC bank account and let's you know we have all sorts of great financial products for you guys and all sorts of services we can help you out with automated bills blah blah blah and I was like oh thank you so much yeah we're super excited you know you know as a you know a identity company and you know we're really excited to bring crypto to the masses and they're like wait you're a crypto company and they're like oh sorry we we we can't we can't service you and then I I responded to them I was like wait so does this mean you're closing our account and then they

just never responded yeah which is like uh I'm like all right let's just see how long this keeps going then I mean uh the transition we've seen of the last few years eight months ago eight months ago that was wow that is unbelievable so on the future and stuff is there any announcement you guys want to make about the road map coming out I know I mentioned earlier on that you didn't have a coin and now follow on yeah yeah uh well we still don't have a coin um not we haven't launched anything in the last 40 minutes of the discussion here um one of the things that I think is really important to us is we are starting to build a bit more of our community focused around just human flourishing this idea that like we want humans to sort of take over and be the ones that are front and center on a lot of these ecosystems um blockchains Crypt networks that are out there so um nothing quite to announce yet uh

as far as what that means but I think there's a lot that we have now with human protocol like human Network going live ways that we want to include the community inside of governance for that um and one of the first is part of what our manifestation campaign is I feel like sha you might be the best suited to talk a little bit about that this is what I'm absolutely just like uh obsessed with and excited about right now so um we're performing this campaign for human alignment around technology so how do we uh build humanistic technology and uh basically like a nucleate a core group of invested community members that are going to uh take some of these Primitives that we've built and allow and apply them to other use cases right so the way that we're thinking about it is we're going to initialize this community with a covenant uh so a covenant is an agreement it's uh basically like a a commitment that you're going to all do something together together now

what blockchains are really good for is actually enforcing commitments and our challenge with this campaign actually is taking very lowlevel commitments that nodes are committing to do something that they said they're going to do to create a key for example and then bubbling that up all the way up to what digital rights look like in on the internet so some of these things are obvious for example right like um nodes could be running under cryptoeconomic incentives uh to have commitments to provide personhood proofs for people and because these nodes have these embedded incentives within them they're very difficult to shut down to you know take over to uh revoke the service so if you can get a proof of personhood from this network what you've effectively done is taking a natural right you know from like John Lock Thomas Hobs uh these guys of personhood and putting that into actual commitments of code that are very difficult to just you know censor so starting from that and starting from Key custody and how key custody

might be a modernday I think like uh natural right that underpins or underscores really like all societies that might be operating in the digital world under a code of ethics so we're inviting uh folks to build this co-p participatory framework and the idea is this Covenant is going to be a web app that will release and you can actually commit to these highlevel values by by creating a human Wallets on the Fly perfect onboarding you don't even know it cryptographically signing this and then now you're part of the community now you can like signal these values and we're thinking of ways as well to solicit types of contributions that allow us to build a cultural uh critical mass around human alignment around technology wow that's incredibly exciting using this technology for good which is not typically done in this space right right yeah the casinos are often sometimes hard but it's unfortunately sometimes what's popular so um we're always happy to help the digital Casino if you're a project that's looking for help as you're

uh rolling through the digital Casino let us know anti-le is often helpful um but no we we definitely appreciate sort of the manifestation campaign and trying to make sure that we're catering more towards real humans in this approach guys thanks it's been an absolute pleasure having you on the show I really appreciate it we'll put all the links to the projects on the channel on the episode So yeah thank you for joining us I guess enjoy the rest of e Denver and thank you to listening those wherever you may be and join us next time to entangle a little more of web 3

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Digital Identity

Related episodes

All episodes