Episode 15

Digital Identity (part 1)

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode, hosts Alec and Jack dive deep into the evolution of digital identity and its significance in Web3.

The conversation kicks off with a historical overview of identity, from its simplicity within ancient tribes to the emergence of coats of arms, badges during wars, and eventually, technological methods like fingerprints, DNA testing, and social security systems.

The hosts then delve into the development of digital identity, highlighting the role of physical and digital systems, such as ID cards and computer databases, and Estonia's pioneering efforts in digital identity systems. They discuss the rise of the internet and web 2.0, and the challenges that came with it, like managing multiple usernames, passwords, and phishing scams. Alec and Jack also explore potential solutions like password managers, single sign-on services, multifactor authentication, and biometric identification.

The core of the episode revolves around digital identity in Web3 and the concept of self-sovereign identity (SSI), which empowers users to have control over their own data rather than relying on big corporations. Alec and Jack discuss the role of blockchain technology in decentralized digital identities, the key actors in an SSI system (issuers, holders, verifiers), and important terms like decentralized identifiers (DIDs) and verifiable credentials (VCs).

The hosts discuss the potential of SSI in Web3 as part of a continuum towards decentralization and user empowerment. They mention companies like Microsoft, which are already using blockchain for SSI solutions. The episode wraps up with Jack and Alec sharing exciting use cases for SSI, such as verifiable credentials in the job market and streamlining travel processes. They agree on the significant potential of SSI for various applications and express their eagerness to explore more in future episodes.

Tune in to this episode to understand the past, present, and future of digital identity and how self-sovereign identity is reshaping our digital world in the era of Web3.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast your goto Hub to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web 3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web 3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep on covering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast Alec how you doing mate I'm good thank you I'm very good as you can see I've got a change of setup I'm actually back home in Birmingham some people thought that my mom would be on the show this episode but no not this week no nice yeah it's good to see you good to see you in your in your natural habitat for once thank you sir so importantly who are you jack who am I

is that is that your accent creeping in no no no don't be so don't be so K this is this week's episode we're talking about digital identity and that's the that's the element we want to cover right who are you how do you prove who you are yeah exactly um slightly cheesy inroad but it's an important way to start I think because yeah today we are talking about digital identity which is you know a big big Topic in in web 3 and also slightly philosophical I know we got philosophical for AI maybe we won't go that far today but it does invoke the question about you know what is identity at its core so yeah who am I and how do I prove it that's that's kind of the central question we're going to be thinking about today right exactly I mean we' kind of referenced identity a lot in previous episodes like proving who you are we kind of mentioned in the AI episode how do you prove that someone is real how do

you prove you know the Providence of a deep fake all these kind of things but I think it's it's it's huge topic digital identity we'll kind of see a bit later that a lot of the aims of digital identity kind of align with the aims of web three and you kind of need both to have like a successful implementation of either and but yeah should we kick off in the way that we always kick off by going back to ancient o times yeah why not I think it's good to Let's recap overall the the concepts and history of identity itself and then we can move on a little bit to digital identity and what what that means in web 3 so yeah what do you know about ancient history and identity have you got any have you got any thoughts identity early on in like I suppose in most things that we spoke we go back to ancient times was super simple you know you had really small communities small tribes of like less than

150 people and identity was just what you could remember about someone right it's really hard to to fraud an identity when I I know jack on a personal level I know all of his negative traits and he can't he can't lie about those because I'll hold him to account so identity early on was super simple you didn't have to worry about you know kind of identity moving from place to place which because you know it was just the the people in your tribe and they knew and they had a history of you and there was rumors and gossip at the person so it's quite simple in the ancient times I assume yeah and and the problem of verifying identity kind of maybe didn't exist to such an extent because you you you kind of already know you already prever verifying People based on who you know um and to yeah as you say to forge someone's identity is much more related to you know uh wearing a mask or or changing your hair color or

or whatever you know trying to phys physically impersonate someone right which is kind of important this is way way pre- digital so the only way you could impersonate someone was with some some physical changes you could make yeah well I'm not going to go down the route of philosophy but if You' read the book sapiens you know that there a hard limit on the amount of people we had in the tribe about 150 people because that is the maximum number of people that we could actually remember characteristics and qualities on and which is super interesting but as societies grew and became more complex we actually needed forms of identification um they kind of came into play like seals and badges um and letters of introduction that kind of attested to something you know you could say like this person is a good person this person has a criminal record this person is very good and making metal and things like that so as Society grew more complicated and we had to move from say tribe

to tribe for example we actually needed to prove our identity and maybe more importantly our credentials what we could actually do from this one tribe to the next tribe we could think about this as like portability it's probably the web three ter that we probably Ed to describe this right yeah and as as you get to kind of like you know the Middle Ages and things you start seeing these uh these heraldry and Coats of Arms you get to to describe different tribes or different factions of people and I wonder how much of that is a consequence of things like the need to go to war right because you need to identify which side you're on by what color you're wearing and what flag you're you're marching under I mean I think in Game of Thrones uh you know that that's a good ex that's a good example of that kind of early um group identity system you might might have yeah yeah when we bring this back to like you the Web Two web

3 Model I imagine like the lord of the area whose coat of arms you wore that's like the central Authority right and you've been kind of bestowed this this uh with the coat of arms that actually on be by on behalf of that on behalf of that Central Authority I imagine that's how I think about it yeah yeah and also that's I think you you definitely have a clear example coming in there as as we have more tribal or um or International Wars throughout history the need to verify someone's identity as part of those Clans became much more important you know to be able to to to root out if someone was infiltrating you know Behind Enemy Lines for example you needed some some way of trying to identify them and obviously that would be something like a code word or something but it it doesn't get to the heart of individual identity right it's still just a tribe based thing yeah well I I don't know why you're so focused on war like it's

like going to be like your use caser it's all about war Through the Ages yeah I I didn't I didn't plan this I mean I just it just kind of came to mind I was like well if we're talking about codes of arms then Game of Thrones makes me think of of War too much but yeah I mean I guess that covers the kind of very early the Early systems and the first few hundred thousand years or or something of um of human civilization and then by kind of the 19th century you then start getting more formal versions of identity issued and you and you get this concept of ident identification issuance right by governments you have state issued identities passports and things that form as your kind of centralized form of identification coming from a central party like your state um rather than in identity just being this um uh this kind of local concept you have um amongst people yeah yeah so I guess that happened in like the the 19th century right

and then kind of advancing from that we had more kind of well I guess better attestation to Identity wasn't just like you know talk before about ownership saying I have this piece of paper so that means that it's mine and it kind of it means something for me specifically but then we kind of moved into the realm with more technology is technological advancements kind of increase of fingerprints and photographs and actually having some way to attest that that document is actually for you so it's not just holding it personally in your your kind of your possession which we kind of get into the reals like data and all the kind of stuff we mentioned in the data sovereignty episode it's also provably saying this actually means something for me and I can I can prove that by you showing the picture on this on this document is actually a picture that is for me the same with fingerprints so this is when it started to get a bit more interesting and a bit more maybe

easy to verify yeah and it's it's clear that you know technology was the driver for improving identification having more solid attestation of of of the characteristics the unique characteristics of people that you mentioned fingerprinting there as one example and you know as you go later you get to things like DNA and and blood testing and things and it's it's it's it's crazy how recent that is there's a development in technology I mean you I don't know if you've seen some of the like True Crime dramas and things um documentary sorry uh it's incredible how much ambiguity there was in in uh in evidence for for criminal proceedings before the technology became Advanced enough to say definitively okay this this evidence is attributed to this person that's only a recent thing I saw like whenever I watch those crime dramas it was always like oh we've got um his genetics everywhere it's always like how many crimes do you imagine there's like seen samples everywhere and you've got a backlog of all all the seen like

all the people in the country it's like so ridiculous but they always use it somehere they like we genetically match the SE here to the person over here it's just ridiculous that's just not how it works is it no no exactly I mean is it's unbelievable the kind of um to my mind how frail the legal system would have been in absence of what we have now I'm just quite glad we live in this age where where you know the criminals will be identified and things like that yeah yeah what we talking about like atation as well I don't want to jump the gun we've already talked about fingerprints and you kind of see like I mean most people will will recognize that they have Biometrics to kind of scan in you know with their fingerprint to get into their phone or even I scan and face scans and all this kind of stuff but like I saw someone the other day who did a post about like having like blood scans and genetic scans

have like the purest form and the best form of attestation they're kind of quite scary is that kind of stuff going that far to have like you know blood storage and all this kind of stuff to to attest to who you are yeah exactly and I think it's also it um speaks to the number of different ways you can be identified as a human being I mean it be it kind of explodes or we get to the the modern day but even even back then the number of distinct characteristics you have as a human that you can measure is is actually quite uh significant so when you move on then you know just we've kind of talked a little bit about biological markers and things but you also then have um kind of in the 19th century the big the Advent of things like social security system systems where you then tie your identity to social benefits to state state issued benefits and things um and access to like government services for example we start

seeing that I think yeah and then you have like I suppose this kind of relat it later you'd have like unique identifying codes that represented you and what were personally for you in some way and I saw there were lots of issues around like the first social security systems where it was like it's like 400,000 people or something like that shared like one Social Security number and like got the benefits from it or something like this like yeah it was quite interesting in America I think in like the in the late 19th century or the yeah something like this or the mid 20th century whenever it was bought in but yeah some of the earliest acts and like obviously this was just them trialing it out in the early days and there was a lot of issues around that yeah exactly so you know we've kind of stayed in the realm of physical ident identity almost and physical uh markers of identity physical systems based around identity then we kind of get the what we

call maybe the birth of digital ID in the late 20th century when you start getting you know things like driving licenses and ID cards that are linked to digital systems and using kind of computer databases and things um what is there anything else I've missed there I think yeah it's a good one like it's interesting that a lot of the the kind of the need for this or the necessity for this came from say automobiles for example like the widespread adoption of automobiles meant that there needed to be like um kind of an efficient way to attest to someone's ability for a driving license right and also to to verify it quite efficiently and I think this like led to kind of an emphasis or a drive in the area of digital ID and like this was kind of enabled through you know computer databases in the late 20th century that we've kind of spoken about in previous episode so these databases allowed it the easy management of like large scale identification systems and also

like made it more efficient right yeah exactly um and I think you know we're not we're not quite talking yet about the um the kind of full-blown digital identity systems that you kind of are looking at today but there are some there are some examples where countries really did Embrace this change quite early I mean I know Estonia for example has had a forms of digital identity in place you know in all kind of government systems from I think it was as early as the early 2000s so like 2002 I think they've had this in place for which is which is remarkable considering that we don't you still don't have it in in all countries in the world and in some in lots of places it's not particularly advanced yet well it's interesting like for some reason I mean maybe this Prejudice when I thought about Estonia previously I was like ah you know okay probably not as advanced to say the UK and then like I met a friend from Estonia who became very

close and I went to Estonia visited a couple of times and realized like how technologically advanced it was like it's crazy they like invented Skype like they have Wi-Fi absolutely everywhere they had like publicly accessible Wi-Fi in Estonia and in Thailand specifically for like 10 years or something crazy like for some reason Estonia is really leading the game in a lot of these kind of Technologies like and like you mentioned like the the national identification system they've had like decentralized their D like for a bit now I think um it's just really interesting there's like a little Hub there of kind of technological innovation in the space yeah and it kind of came you know talking about 2002 that also aligns with the Advent of the internet as we've spoken about you know the early days of web 1 and moving into web to uh that's when we start getting new forms of communication in particular you know mobile phones become popular email as well as as a way to identify someone I mean I

know by by now there are lots of countries that will have government IDs I think Italy is is a good example in the EU where you have a a government system that will push out notifications you send documents to Citizens via uh email and so email you know coming from the early days of the internet became a really really popular source of identity and a way of verifying identity I mean it's it's pretty much the most common way I think my identity is verified now right you know those emails you get to say go and click your verification link every time or you get the magic sign on links I mean some people just don't bother with some some companies don't even use passwords now you just get a sign on link that from your email yeah it's crazy well your um your you email address is like incredible bad kit Jack at 95 it's just it's you know I wouldn't I wouldn't want to lose that either it's a good attestation to who you

are as a person but yeah I think um like you say like the there in the late 90s we saw this the massive rise of like digital identity the different form you being able to create usernames and passwords to access systems and then there's also like the the the kind of the mass um adoption of e-commerce where you know digital identity became really crucial for transactions like online banking and shopping that required you know a reliable way to prove digital identity when someone was making a purchase and verification systems and this kind of pushed the the kind of the area the ecosystem even further technologically yeah and and as you said the rise of the internet I mean even as you come into the early 2000s and in the 2010s kind of early 21st century that shift even from web 1 to web to as we've talked about where social media becomes much more dominant brings with it a number of different ways you can be identified so you know in particular you get the

rise of internet personas or pseudonyms and I know we've had pseudonyms for a very long time you know they would have been applicable um in the 19th century and way way further back you know people writing under studs but now they're so common on the internet people have their their handles on Twitter on uh on YouTube on on Instagram whatever which don't need to be tied to your real world identity other than through maybe an email but there's this kind of many toone relationship now with your online identity and your actual inperson physical identity let's say yeah I think that's it's particularly important when we're going to talk about you know the F final form maybe of digital identity which is which is self- Sovereign identity which is is definitely coming um spoiler Al this spoiler alert this many to one relationship is very important because it kind of in a way it enables privacy so it's like I can have a pseudonym that I use for say my banking account and I can have

a pseudonym that they use for maybe buying tickets to football matches and I don't need to use the same pseudonym for both and if say things are publicly viewable or there's transparency there like transactions happen on happen on a public blockchain it makes it more difficult to associate the two maybe on the public blockchain but also it means that say if I'm directly transacting with one using that pseudonym they don't know them directly transacting with the other as well and I think this is quite important right yeah and I think it's there are many cases where you do want your pseudonyms to be separate and separate also from your maybe your public um physical Identity or government identity as well um but there are there are other use cases which aren't really served well by the web 2 world where you might actually want to have them linked together so I'm thinking bringing your reputation between two different social media platforms right so you changed platform you wanted to add a new one it's quite

important to be able to link what you've done on one to another which is not always an easy problem this is the kind of interoperability challenge you have with with digital identity as it is today you know up to up to kind of 2020 yeah yeah and I've seen ones with like gambling say someone's like a reckless Gambler and there been there have been restrictions placed on them and they have like markers of harm that that Gamble company has to monitor to make sure that they're not say danger to themselves they don't spend money they don't have for example well you know you have a kyc where you register with you know gambling company a and they monitor those marketart to make sure you don't overspend and you're safe and all healthy and all this kind of stuff if I have all of a sudden then go to gambling company B and start to use them as a service provider as well and then split the amount of spending between the two and then not

communicating because of these student that's an issue right yeah massive issue um and another issue kind of haven't we've mentioned usernames but we haven't mentioned the the other counterpart which is the passwords so with all these online identities and usernames and accounts with different um you know web two companies we also have the rise of the use of passwords and as we've spoken about in in the other previous episodes you that brings all these other challenges to do with you know fishing scams um uh password leaks data breaches that kind of thing like there's this whole plethora of problems and the fact that these are linked to your identity now makes the now makes it so much worse because what you can lose potentially if you lose your credentials if someone takes your password or gains access to one of these accounts they can potentially impersonate you quite easily yeah I mean the only thing worse than fishing scams is my company's tests for fishing scams and security tests like I get caught with those

all the time like fishing scams now are so Advanced like it's actually crazy like we had that ra Rafaela talking about them she got called I there's quite a few people that I know that been calling these like teex people so yeah identity theft and fishing scams are a massive problem that's kind of become apparent because of this and actually another just a point to add to that you know um because we're talking about identity and if you are if you are the victim of one of these scams your your identity details like your your um your email address your phone number your your your address your your house address what anything anything like that your name will then get shared around others right so basically VI of scams yeah this is a a lot of scam scamming companies become essentially data Brokers to other scam companies I've been watching a few videos on it recently that are really fascin I don't know if you've seen there was a documentary around taking down a a

call center scam agency but you know this is the thing right if if you if you fall victim to one of these you're your D your your identity data is going to start hurtling around and you become much more wonderful God that's that's absolutely crazy and then what's the solution is the solution to have like is it to keep it more distributed is single sign on stuff a solution to this where everything's managed by like Apple or Google or something like this or is it safer to have distributed accounts and distrib distributing users names and passwords for each of them because it's crazy like how many accounts and passwords I have like to store right now I probably have like 40 or different 50 different username and password combinations for all the 40 or 50 different Services they use and like the user experience on that is not good at all that's like a really tricky for me to remember to like have all these things at the same time yeah exactly I don't think

there's a there's one easy solution to all this right because as you say if you you introduce things like password managers and you know single use passwords that brings this user experience challenge but it still doesn't completely solve the problem and uh you know as you mentioned single sign on you get your sign in with Google sign in with Apple sign in with Facebook and I'm I'm guilty of using those you know being quite often and they they introduce these Central points of failure so if you then uh if you then lose your someone hacks your password and gains access to your one of these accounts then they can start very easily logging into all these other services which are effectively connected to it so yeah I don't think I don't know if there's a single particular solution and what as we're going to get on to talking about self- Sovereign identity and identity systems in web 3 I think there is still a big challenge Alles there but a lot of the a lot

of the problems in the web 2 world are coming from what we spoke about in the data sovereignty episode the fact that you are giving away far too much information to access services and that's what I mean by you know if a if a company gets hacked then that's when your data goes around the the scamming world right because they they should have been they should have been holding the data in the first place ideally you should have been able to prove your identity without giving all that over letting them and and having the company keep the data yeah yeah I think like I suppose some of the the technological kind of solutions we have to to this like identity death stuff to mitigate that is around one multiactor authentication right which I personally hate like I hate so much but I see that it's quite it's it's useful I understand why we need it and it's better than the alternative of me remembering all my passwords constantly um the other one that I really

do like is biometric you know fingerprint scans attesting to my identity like it's obviously quite tricky to do that with say mobile devices web apps kind of stuff that's pushing more and more to say mobile device I think I said mobile devices twice there pushing more to mobile devices rather than laptops and and computers and I think that directly aligns with the the kind of The self- Sovereign identity stuff that we're going to talk about as kind of maybe the final evolution of digital identity potentially yeah yeah exactly I think I I agree these These are quite important even if they they might be cumbersome or introduce new problems I mean we're getting more used to things like biometric identification like if you sign up for kind of a Challenger bank or something these days your kyc will often involve you um having to take a photo and and having yeah say ascendence or something which is a kind of form of biometric ID I think I've recently got changed on my banking login now

they have login with your voice have you have you come across that uh yeah I have what do you ever pass the human check for the voice test or not yeah I can't access my my bank at all now unfortunately no but yeah they all kind of do partially solve the problem but I agree you know kind of bring us on to this this concept of of where we are now and with um digital identity in web three and self sof identity which we'll kind of Define in a moment I think that that is potentially the end state where you're combining a lot of these Web Two security features with a different Paradigm for du identity in the first place yeah so like you talking well previously about them kind of housing all the identities and all the data on there and and where we're at today is around using you know blockchain technology for decentralized digital identities where you know you shift some of the control of the user data to the users themselves

that are actually controlling that data and away from like the big corporations and there's a lot of benefits that that we' spoken about previously I think like a lot of this stuff directly aligns with the data sovereignty episode that we did you know having smaller attack surfaces you know if all say a m what's Facebook now two billion people's worth of identity information is stored in a central server in Facebook that's a bigger attack surface you know you want to invest a lot of money to get that get that data but if we start to you know push that to users and um have two billion separate devices each with one say identity piece of data underpinned quite importantly with blockchain technology um then we have you know a more say kind of powerful security solution yeah exactly so maybe it's worth us now trying to put a bit of a definition on self- Sovereign Identity or SSI as we'll kind of refer to it so I mean I'm happy to have a go first

although it's going to be pretty handwavy because I think uh I think it's quite a general term so kind of to me self- soverign identity is the umbrella term that captures this concept of moving away from the the types of Web Two Digital identity systems we've just talked about you know all these uh account based things where you you have to hand over too much information passwords get stored and leaked and essentially moving as you said moving um the verification and storage of identity data to the users instead of holding it in big corporations SSI essentially describes the overarching goal and ambition of of digital identity in in the web 3 world I think I mean I have anything to add to that no like it that's that's perfect like I think the the Nuance between like decentralized identity and SSI is kind of hard to Define but I thing like SSI like you said there is is the end goal and the end goal is a solution where individuals have full control over their

their identity the data that's in that identity and I think a lot of people say there's like no Reliance on you know trusted third parties or Central authorities and all this kind of stuff I don't think that's true you're always going to have to have some point of trust right like we can't just have I produce my own identity Jack produces his own identity then we can interact no I still need to know that Jack is Jack and we still need say the government of the UK to say You Know Jack is actually Jack and Alec is actually Ali it the point is that we reduce that Reliance we don't need the government to say every single time me and you have a conversation Jack the UK government says yeah yeah this is Jack and this is Ali we just say they produce a credential say this is Jack and they sign off it sign off on it using cryptographic proofs and then we can interact based on that kind of trusted ecosystem that's been

provided by the UK government signing off on that and yeah you want to jump in there yeah no I just wanted to kind of because you're resonating with what I've heard people some people describe as the definition of identity is kind of your identity is the aggregate of what people around you will say right and attest to to um characteristics of you as well because you have them you know you do have innate characteristics but a big part of it is what other people will recognize and and be able to attest to so I think this model of you know you can claim to be something but then a lot of the time you need that claim to be verified or authenticated by a third party that's the kind of just the reality of it and I think like the way I think of it you always have a root kind of trust and it's all ways that you know the UK government and gives Jack his equivalent of a driving license in the digital

space that says he is Jack and he lives here and he's a real person and then you can have like kind of different trust points that are built from that anchor say you know if you're in a gaming environment and you want to build up a reputation that you're really good at Call of Duty or something like that like the degree of trust there is it's less serious right we don't need like full cryptographic proofs like a trusted peer-to-peer interaction all this kind of stuff but you can build up your own kind of your own kind of persona based on what you're actually doing in game rather than needing like a full cryptographic secure proof over the top of it but if it say something like you need to spend like 20,000 uh on a transaction buying a new BMW or something like this then it the kind of the trust there is a bit needs to be a bit stronger right and we probably need more checks and a bit more kind of security

there so like there's different points around this right this kind of all ties back into the the many toone relationship we're talking about pseudonyms it's not like I need that central point of trust for everything I need to reveal all my core information every single time we can selectively choose what what's applicable where yeah different claims about you and your identity will require different levels of proof and different levels of uh attestation from others I'm I'm conscious that we're we're still being relatively abstract about like what SSI is and decentralized identity but I know that there are some quite concrete Concepts around it like a lot of a lot of the ideas have been standardized Now by organizations like w3c so I don't know can you explain because I know you you're quite familiar with the terms around how you establish a a digital identity system what the kind of entities are involved and how they kind of relate to each other yeah you're right like I think um the maybe the actors in the

ecosystem at a high level are are quite defined and they lend themselves a lot from like traditional identity systems so the kind of the key actors the kind that we're talking about are we have issuers holders and verifiers at quite a high level so it's like the issuer could be I keep saying it but the UK government they give you your passport Jack they give you your driving license and maybe a university would be another good example they issue you your degree certificate okay so they're like the certificate Authority and they're the ones that can credential you and say Jack has a driving license Jack has this degree all this kind of stuff so they're they're the The Trusted party there and like I say we all we'll always need that trusted party everyone will always kind of rely on a trusted parties just maybe reducing the Reliance so the other party is the holders so in that case Jack it's you the the kind of the subject it's often referred to as well so

it's the the the credentials we talked about previously the information pertains to you it's given by the issuer but it pertains to you it says that you can drive it says that you have this degree and then the final party is the verifier they're the people that are actually interested in proving that this information is true and that it actually relates to you so it could be a police officer that's pulled you over for a DUI or something like that and they want to prove that your license is real for example experience there Al no no no never never never no points at my license U probably because they mostly don't drive um and or could be a recruiter or a company that wants to prove that you actually have a degree and it's actually a real degree that applies to you so they're the three parties um so the issuer they issue credentials to the holder and the verifier verifies those credentials of the holder so there's a relationship there and that's quite a

standard relationship in digital identity before blockchain was introduced so the interesting thing about SSI and decentralized identity is that when we're signing credentials now we're actually using cryptographic signatures that intrinsically link the the credential itself to the information contained in the driving license to the person as well to say that it relates to this holder specifically and from the issuer so we've got a way to easily verify all that information in one go and we kind of underpin that using the blockchain so we can put that information on the blockchain to get all the benefits that was previously spoken about like the immutability the ability to have transparency provably say that this information's up to date and things like this and when we're saying like a lot of people want to remove the need for trusted parties what they're actually saying is we have the trusted party that instigates the initial credentialing and giving the credential and then after that rather than the verify need to go to that issuing party every time they want

to check that Jack actually has a degree they can actually rely to an extent on the blockchain and say do I check that this is still valid for example and that becomes a much more efficient process like if you've ever tried to to verify a University degree it's a long task like universities aren't open you know 24/7 it takes them weeks to get back to emails say is this real imagine if I could just put a certificate on the blockchain know that that it's from the the university Itself by knowing what their public Keys basically or the signing tool they use and then instantly verify it I mean that's such a really efficient system and I've seen like some of the stats around I think McKenzie did a massive report on if there was a fully instigate SSI model in some like Western countries it would lead to an increase in GDP of 6 to 13% just from efficiency convenience fluidity ability to just jump into different services and goods constantly it's it's a hugely

gamechanging SSI yeah I think that's that's why I definitely see it as such a web three concept is that it's a much much more efficient way as you say of of doing and verifying identity you know it just makes more sense and the kind of two components you were mentioning on like why is that the case yeah you have you have the blockchain as as a persistent uh reliable source of data for lots of these things and we'll come on to some other kind of terms like dids in a but the blockchain is fundamentally a great platform to build a a digital identity system on decentralized identity system on and then the cryptography itself as well is is almost this tool that's allowing for verification like the Advent I mean cryptog isn't that modern cryptography is the kind of things we're actually talking about here are only kind of 30 40 years old like public key infrastructure systems they are quite new and these are what allow lots of the credentials to be stored with

the individual because you can publicly verify something without knowing the actual information that's kind of the the key principle yeah and I think something I didn't say is that like the information is held by the user still and like a perfect SSI environment like they still own say that their driving license and all the data within it on their device so it doesn't necessarily have to be stored in like a central server that everyone can potentially hack into and it's just like when I reveal the data on my mobile device to say so a verifier who's interested in it they can verify the integrity and authenticity of that data using public key infrastructure that you've already mentioned cryptographic proofs yeah it's kind of simple way maybe way to talk about is like the data is private and then the proof proof is public or it's something that can be made public that kind of yeah exactly and the proof itself doesn't reveal that much information the thing that's actually on the blockchain doesn't reveal any

information particularly about that data yeah so I think maybe just before we move on about from our kind of Base definitions it's worth defining two quite popular terms so one of them is and it doesn't help that we've got decentralized identity and also um decentralized identifiers but in general we just refer to them as dids and you also have verifiable credentials which is kind of a lot of what you've been talking about already with credentials that you'd issue and they're referred to as VC um so maybe I'll tackle the the dids first so my understanding is that a a decentralized identifier is is is similar to what you've been describing but it it refers to the actual thing that uniquely identifies you in the digital ecosystem so it has to be something that is globally unique there's like a there is like a onetoone mapping between you as human entity and this digital world so this is what what gives you the Anchor Point into the identity system so as as as a user of

uh self- Sovereign identity system you would have a did you would have a a a unique digital uh decentralized identifier and the other component of that is often linked to something what's called a did document which contains kind of the basic information about how that information relates to to you and it it won't necessarily include any personal information normally it will just include some kind of cryptographic information as you were saying some certificate on some public key that means you can prove statements or statements can be proven yeah about you right yeah and I think the the re that's really great like summary and I think the really interesting things about dids is that on this like W3 standard that's kind of emerging as like the standard for for SSI is that the individual fully controls that right that's not shouldn't really be given by like a central Authority they should be able to spin up however many they want could it be thousands hundreds Millions but it also doesn't necessarily mean anything right it's

just say a string that is unique and could pertain to me but say if I want to go on you know I want to buy something online to prove I'm over 18 my did doesn't mean anything I still need verifiable credentials that relate to that did to actually get some usefulness from it and I think if we if we move on to the verifiable credentials that kind of hinted to awards they're like digital statements that are made by issuers like governments or you know universities and things like this about the subject which can be you know cryptographically verified by a third party okay but it's like really there the you need dids plus the verifiable credentials to start to get the usability and the actual kind of use cases that we'll move on to a bit later yeah and I think maybe one thing to add there to distinguish dids and and verifiable credentials correct me if I'm wrong but in my mind it's like dids are something which can be self-issued if you want

you could you could establish your own unique digital identifier and the corresponding did document but then the verifiable credentials are the things that would be issued by other people on that did right so you could issue your did but then the government would issue the verifiable credential the uh University would issue the verifiable credential on you essentially exactly and I think this is kind of like the misunderstanding that emerges sometimes people say there'll be no need for Central trusted parties and all this kind of stuff is yeah to an extent that might be true people can spin up dids self- allocate dids whatever they want and maybe for some interactions like you just want a game on something like that that's fine you can just use that did to interact in the metaverse whatever but for a lot of interactions where you need to prove you're a person prove that you're 18 all this kind of stuff it's the verifiable credentials that given by a trusted third party basically that will actually enable a lot

of use cases and applications to prove who you are who your identity and what your characteristics are yeah exactly and as you were saying you still need these trusted third parties but they're on the issuance of the credentials not the actual issuance of the identity basically yeah exactly and I think a really interesting thing about the w3c standard as well is that it on the verification side it's actually one of the the objectives that the issuing third party like the government who gives you a driving license shouldn't know when there's a verification that takes place so like the UK government shouldn't know if you go to an off license and use your passport digitally to say you're above 18 for example and that's quite an interesting kind of objective of SSI from the w3c standards okay well why don't we consult our our friend as I always call him chat GPT to just double check on on the definitions and make sure we've kind of covered everything so far so chat GPT says in the

context of web 3 digital identity refers to a set of verifiable self- sovereign and decentralized digital attributes or credentials associated with a specific entity such as an individual organization device or application these credentials can be used to present verify and manage the ident the identity of the entity on the internet without the need for centralized authorities or intermediaries the control and management of this identity data rests with the entity itself enhancing privacy security and user agency so yeah not bad I think um maybe I would take a little bit of issue there with how it's saying you know without the need for centralized authorities because we've kind of established you still need that for the verifiable credential side but maybe not on the management of the actual identity itself yeah definitely like we're always going to need a trusted entity like be it the government be it the university like we do need someone to credential as them in most use cases say most use cases maybe not all use cases especially for the the

kind of the low trust or um ones like gaming and things like that where you actually don't really care who you're interacting with so much and the identity doesn't matter too much but at that stage like the identity doesn't matter either right you could just use an IP address or something like that so maybe it is it actually need them in actuality for for most um applications where we need identity I think an interesting thing about that chaty PT definition was that it also said it's not just an individual how we've kind of contextualized it it's also organizations devices applications I really like that because I I think we've kind of well we we've put out the iot episode right and we've talked about iot devices and AI as well having more agency and being like entities in their own right and when we we think about identity we're obviously all humanized think about people but I think more and more in like hopefully utopian and not distopian future we are going to see the

need to identify devices and they're going to be able to do things and need to prove their identity as well I think that's a really interesting use case for this stuff yeah I mean you're already hearing people talking about uh civil rights for for AI systems so you'll definitely be having a identity for AI if that if that goes any further but maybe to not stray too much again into philosophy and I think there's definitely lots to talk about in a future episode on that kind of stuff but what why don't we kind of bring it back to you know what's the actual relationship with web 3 because we have thrown in lots of these terms from web 3 we've explained a little bit about why we think web 3 is is is related but I think we can make it a bit more concrete so I know you have some thoughts on you know how uh we're moving from I normal digital ID to SSI so I don't know if you have a way

of kind of contextualizing that in web 3 I think like I see a lot of parallels between SSI and web 3 and I think if we think of both as like the end points on a Continuum so the one Continuum is you know centralized identity to decentralized Identity to SSI which is the final goal and you know the kind of the end goal of that is around decentralization user empowerment right and I think this that's the same goals that apply to web one to web two to web three it's moving more and more was moving more towards decentralization and user empowerment and I think what they are they're kind of the successes I think in a way are related you know if we think of web 3 as providing like the infrastructure for for peer-to-peer and then the self- Sovereign identity enables user ownership and control without the complete Reliance continuously on on a central Authority so I think there's a mutual kind of dependence for Success there like we thinking about interaction in the

me verse and moving from application to application you need like a a real portable identity solution um for that yeah I 100% agree um maybe also just to specifically pick up on the infrastructure piece right I think as we've said with other things as well but you know I think blockchain in particular and a lot of the tools like the cryptography and the proof systems like Z knowledge proof we're seeing uh in web 3 they are just a natural infrastructure the natural tools that you'd use to implement an SSI system to achieve these things on the end goal that you're talking about I mean blockchain has pretty much made the term decentralization uh one one that everyone knows about now from being something that would have been pretty obscure 10 years ago and now it seems to be something that people will slap onto everything and I think you can go way too far with that but at the same time as you say it is getting away from holding everything in one Central system

to holding it in a more distributed system and crucially again putting the data back in the the hands of the user and you know we're already seeing blockchains in particular being used for that reason people it's it's the obvious choice so if you look at something like the um the side tree protocol this is something that was developed by by some researchers um at Microsoft and they they basically developed this did protocol so you know how decentralized identifier looks how it operates how you manage it how you add verifiable credentials they built a system to do all this and they actually anchored it in the Bitcoin blockchain and it's it's it's it's something that is designed to be portable between blockchains it is compliant with the w3c standards we mentioned but you know it's it's mad that that this has been taken seriously by companies like Microsoft and they're using public blockchain infrastructure to to achieve those goals that's very exciting and I know that we're talking about some of like there are like key

pillars in SSI and you've mentioned it there like portability is a big one we've mentioned privacy and security and I think as with a lot of things we're realizing this is a big topic that warrants you know two or maybe even three episodes to really unpacked properly and I think we'll come on to those those pillars in in the next episode and also the challenges and concerns that are associated with that but I think for this episode we should really maybe jump into some use cases that make it tangible and exciting and practical for everyday users to understand why SSI is important check what is the kind of leading exciting use case in your mind for an SSI solution so I think the one I'm really excited about is basically the in the job market in employment because it brings together like two or three of these different topics we've been talking about into one place so I think the verifiable credentials for your basically everything that's on your CV is going to be really

big in the future you know be for Employers in particular to be able to trust that what is the content of your your CV is actually accurate and true right I know people people it's it's a common thing about people it's it's people always say don't lie on your CV but many many people do lie on their CVS and for the employers and and you know recruiters who who recommend candidates they want to be able to check that the authenticity of of your degree of your professional qualifications and we're already seeing it happen loads and I think this will become the go this will become the standard they'll have a blockchainbased did system with verifiable credentials issued by uh by higher education institutions by professional certifiers it's just going to become the standard so that that's one aspect of how I think it'll play a role the other spoken like a true good citizen by the way who has a an accurate CV with no BS in there exactly exactly I'm one of the good

guys so the other aspect which is because that's all from I'd say that's more from the employer perspective I mean it's good for people who are honest because it'll bring the standard up for everyone else but uh but it it will also really benefit the people who are looking the job Seekers right people who are giving the CVS out because I know there's a there's this kind of culture I think of bit like what I said with the data Brokers and scams your ID your details circulated you how do you know where your CV is going when you when you pass it over if it if you get asked by a recruiter you know they say can can I see your CV you have no rights and well you have no way of um enforcing your rights you have no way of making sure they're not going to circulate that with hundred different companies they're going to see your your details you just don't know where it's going right and imagine recruit is just looking

at my CB and laughing in the back office yeah exactly it's it's GNA get embarrassing it was only meant to embarrass one person but um a lot of the web three tools and techniques like selective disclosures zero knowledge proofs and just general kind of slightly more boring but Access Control Management and certificates that we've we talked about previously so when you give your CV over to a recruiter you'll give it over with permissions it won't just be a PDF that you send on LinkedIn it'll be it'll be a blockchainbased system where you know you say you have access to this and only the person who has uh control of this public private keyek and read it so you might encrypt it before you send it for example um to to a particular key pair that is tied to someone um I think that's going to become really important in the future to make it much more honest from the perspective of of if you're seeking a job basically I think that and that I think

that's just a very cool way to tie up both sides of the of the equation oh yeah it's all about the job market baby like that yeah it's really cool super excited I think like on that stuff like we talk about like read access and access one time like a lot of it is application specific though right like it's really you have to have an application that would enforce that with the I mean with the kind of the blockchain underpinning that they would actually allow you know a one time spend access to actually read the PDF once and then revoke access following that and I think that's something that needs to come right it's quite not easy but it's somewhat simple to implement that on a blockchain a spending of a token all this kind of stuff but we're actually not really seeing the the kind of the applications on the mobile end and the user end that actually enforce that kind of stuff right now and I think yeah it would be really powerful

if we could do yeah for sure so what about you Alec is there any what's what's most I know you love digital identity so you must have an application you're really excited about for it I love I love everything I love every topic we've done so far um so I think mine is something that everyone understands it's like you know have you been to an airport Jack I have yes surprisingly I know you wouldn't get it guess it from my lack of tan but yeah how many checks were there when you went through the airport oh yeah this this is something I I can see where you're going with this because I it depends wildly like uh International you go into let's say you go to America let's say let's say three but what I will say is sometimes I've noticed that you get double checked right you go go through one barrier and then you walk a 100 yards and they check you again it's like nothing's changed you know I I hope you

don't get called out in like a comedy show you'd be the worst audience participant ever expected a simple answer you're making this about youor you just you just you just gr you you picked up on a a pet peeve of mine sorry so yeah you know you go to an airport there are lots of checks you have ticket checks you have passport checks you have boarding checks Visa checks destination Hotel checks in some countries obviously coid Tech checks as well you have you know records checks it's Carnage it's absolute chaos like it's there are like you know eight to nine checks sometimes per international flight on you know going out landing and getting there and all this kind of stuff and imagine like when you're doing it on behalf of your kids as well like it it's absolutely crazy having to imagine like all of these different documents some can be digitalize some cannot be digital they're just all over the place and you have to find the right one make sure it's like attesting

to you and you'll see that like you know for say a Visa check they'll also have to check your identity as well these are two separate documents in some cases which is crazy now you know the solution for SSI is so obvious there imagine all of these like different checks and documents in one app that allow you know automatic verification of all of them amongst all of the others as well like the benefits are so obvious there you have like streamlined travel data minimization and no centralized database potentially they're prone to beach breaches but you also you know control and maintain the privacy and like the efficiency of checking with just one app on your phone and not having to handle all these different documents and get different apps up and all this kind of stuff it's just so obvious there and I think when earlier when I was talking about you know the GDP increase for ssis Solutions being like adopted widely in like a an economy of like 8 to 14% I think

it was like it's things like that like the lack of paperwork and the efficiency of being a to sign up and not duplicating kyc checks and all this kind of stuff that's where you're going to see the real benefits to the economy I think that kind of stuff really excites me yeah no I didn't realize it would excite me until you said it like that because yeah the last the last flight I did go on I both remember getting checked two or three times without changing location essentially so it's like why do I need to check my passport three times to get on and also it was in an unbelievable queue and I nearly missed my flight because it's such an inefficient process now there you go see this is a real pain point I think a lot of people actually understand it um but yeah that's why I find like such an exciting use case awesome well yeah I think I think both of those are interesting and there's going to be loads more

that I think we'll have to do another episode on as you as you said but I think yeah we've we've covered some pretty good ground I think we we've laid the foundations of what digital identity is what this overarching concept of SSI is the web three kind of end goal and then some of the components in that of of dids and VC and uh yeah we'll maybe talk about some of the principles of a good uh digital identity system in the future maybe yeah definitely I think in the next episode we'll cover some of the the fundamental pillars of SSI what the aims are we've kind of alluded to some of them there but also what some of the challenges and concerns are and hopefully we'll also go into some of the technologies that underpin them in a bit more detail and you know maybe the most exciting is what the future looks like how we tie all of this digital ID density stuff into you know some of the other buzzword that are coming

out like Ai and all this kind of stuff so yeah I think that wraps up this first part thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we entangle a little more of we thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Digital Identity

Related episodes

All episodes