Episode 60

Web3 for Supply Chains with Nikhil Varma

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

Welcome back to Untangling Web3, where today's guest, Nikhil Varma, delves into the revolutionary impact of Web3 and blockchain technology on supply chain management.

As an expert in operations and blockchain applications, Nikhil shares his unique insights into how these technologies are reshaping traditional supply chains into more transparent, efficient, and sustainable systems.

Key takeaways

  • Blockchain and Transparency. Nikhil discusses how blockchain introduces unmatched transparency and traceability in supply chains, which can significantly reduce fraud and errors.
  • Improving Efficiency through Decentralization. Exploration of how decentralized networks can streamline operations by removing intermediaries and reducing delays.
  • Sustainability and Ethical Sourcing. Emphasis on how Web3 technologies facilitate better tracking and verification of ethical practices along the supply chain, promoting environmental responsibility and sustainability.

This episode underscores the transformative potential of blockchain and Web3 technologies in modernizing supply chains. Nikhil Varma advocates for the integration of these technologies as a means to enhance operational efficiency, ensure product authenticity, and support sustainable practices.

As we look to the future, the adoption of Web3 in supply chains holds promising prospects for creating more resilient and responsive business ecosystems.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

that is the fundamental problem in most of the supply chains that we see in the current times we don't have trust with one another so I will just not share information blockchain in my opinion solves a lot of problems how it will solve that is for us to figure out go back to this food trust example one of the reasons they failed is because they did not use a blockchain they used a private blockchain which is not exactly a blockchain I feel that the solution for this should be a public blockchain and that is why I always emphasize to be able to get things going in a public blockchain identity is one crucial piece welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we are thrilled to have nikel V with us to talk about Supply chains in web3 nikil is an associate professor at rampo College in New Jersey and a technology lead for the algr foundation in India in both roles he specializes in operations and supply chain blockchain and sustainability

with over 20 years of experience he Bridges the gap between technology and business making him a leading Authority in these areas in today's episode we'll dive into how web 3 Technologies are revolutionizing Supply chains enhancing efficiency and promoting sustainability nille welcome to the show thank you Alec thank you Jack for giving me the opportunity of course this is a very interesting area and looking forward to this conversation that we're going to have today yeah left definitely likewise nil something we've talked about a lot on the show Supply chains we want to kind of dig into those but how are you today first of all I'm doing good I'm just on the road I've been traveling for the last almost two weeks out of home living in hotels going from one place to the other enjoying myself communicating the message of web3 to different communities different types of communities all across India so it's been fun yeah it sounds like you're a true kind of missionary for the the visions of web 3 so and I

want to get into your role in alaran Foundation a bit later but first of all I want to just start by digging into the main topic right supply chain so to use case that we've talked about a lot on the show in our end of year kind of highlights look back episode we saw a clip of Alec talking in depth about supply chain use cases of blockchain but we want to get the view of an expert here right so in your you can you explain what is a supply chain in kind of layman's terms and why are they so important sure I mean one of the things that people do when they not do the nomenclature of things is they think a lot and and give a nice name which is suggestive however in the classroom I never call it a supply chain and even in Industry now people have started calling it the value chain so a supply chain sometimes is very misleading it's like oh my list of suppliers is what supply chain

is all about about but when you know we actually have studying supply chain even from a technological or a managerial or even uh you know to be able to optimize things we actually have to look at the whole value proposition what is the value chain over here so in you know if I had to Define supply chain in one word you know or kind of clarify what supply chain is I would say it's the nomenclature is wrong we should call it value chain okay then okay so we've already have to change the time episode I think from Supply chains to Value chains but that's already an interesting Insight from you okay so what is a value chain then and why are value chains important for us so the whole idea of supply chain is to facilitate Commerce right uh there is a flow of goods from Upstream to Downstream and that flow of goods from Upstream to down Downstream is nothing but a value exchange at each step right and that value exchange at each

step has has its own Salient features and that's essentially what we are trying to optimize study and have all those you know social and economic aspects around it and now even environmental uh to be able to make it more sustainable so that value exchange process if we study it from a value exchange perspective is much more easy to study and that's why we use the word value chain to be able to make sure people understand it very clear that you know if you are producing something and you're selling it to the next person you you are exchanging the value of what you have with you know for money or whatever of course money most of the times uh so that exchange of value between two people has to be uh defined within certain sets of regulations it has to have the government Norms you can't do a trade with a country that you can't you know which the government does not allow you to do things with uh you have to make sure that the

trade is fair you have to make sure that the trade does not have a huge carbon footprint now that being important uh you have to make sure that whatever is the exchange of money is reported correctly you have to make sure that it is efficient you have to make sure a lot of other things which you know the more Dimensions we study the more better we make it essentially now this value exchange often is studied from a Duo poly perspective which means basically I am going to just know the person on my upstream or my Downstream and this is often happens because we don't have trust right and that is the fundamental problem in most of the supply chains that we see in the current times we don't have trust with one another so I will just not share information and if I share information then maybe my Downstream person might directly start working with my Upstream person who knows there could be something called called a vertical integration and vertical integration takes away all

the exchange of values because there's one player who holds the Monopoly right so these are some initial problems that we see in the supply chain okay that's really useful to know and we're already starting to get onto some of the concepts of you know why trust is is important in these things and we maybe starting to see some of the opportunities that web 3 Technologies present like I know a little about Supply chains like very shallow as like Jack said they're vast they're everywhere I think everything that's more complicated in a pencil probably has some value or supply chain underpinning that but you're the expert in this Bas just to make it a bit more concrete because a lot of these terms like you say are very abstract could you give us an example of endtoend supply chain or value chain and who the actors are involved in that just so we can understand what this is sure so uh I mean whenever we are talking about a value exchange we will you know as

you mentioned end to end this whole definition of end to end is again since we don't have a holistic view right of the whole value chain it'll be difficult but when we are studying the value chain then we'll probably every person is a customer of the other right one person is the seller other person is the customer now let's take an example of a commonly use item which is coffee yeah now coffee in the supply chain of coffee what are the different players who come into play yeah you have the coffee plantations the coffee plantation is going to have people working in those plantations working day and night to be able to raise to get the coffee now then in those plantations somebody is going to get take those the coffee pods out then that there is some kind of an integrator in between after that so that integrator is the next part of the supply chain or the value chain uh just to be able to be consistent with the term that I'm going

to be using uh then in the next player in that is going to be that integrator is going to be sending it to an exporter the exporter is going to be then sending it to a roster the roster is then going to be sending it to different kinds of companies retailers maybe or different brands then it goes to the retailer and then it goes all the way to the customer yeah so this is the whole supply chain of coffee yeah that ways if we look at and I'm giving you o overly simplified supply chain over here there are no components there there no other players who come in there no people who are doing any kind of integration there is some kind of a value addition that each people bring into this picture and there is no suggestion that they should not be a part of this picture however this supply chain works with power center is over here there is not a fair distribution of power when we look at a supply chain like

this we see that the person who's closest to the customer tends to you know create that demand then that demand flows backwards there are some kind of mechanisms either there are international markets if that coffee is a commodity or different brands of coffee is a commodity then that's that demand goes back that demand based on that demand there are different people who do different kind of procurement and then that procurement leads to uh you know the purchasing or the import of coffee from various places looking at one single product which just passes through various hands of course there are people who do some value addition like the roster uh is much more easier to understand a supply chain complex Supply chains could be just look at the phone that they have in your hand right it's overly complex because there are like over 100 different components coming in from 25 different countries yeah and you don't even know you just know where the where your phone was integrated at the very end yeah so imagine

the kind of complexities that we have here and the kind of power centers that we have to deal with and the kind of uh risks and uh disruptions uh one small disruption in chipsets manufacturing during the co time impacted the whole car distribution industry yeah I mean it's just mindboggling how this whole supply chain value chain works because now we are talking about a global economy very few Supply chains are very local and in fact they are overly simplified which is basically local local production local consumption kind of a model but most of the things that we consume either these are items or food or anything that we have uh go through International boundaries and the complexities that admits I I love that kind of the segue you've given there it's the one that I was going to actually use as well it's that globalization has kind of been the reason why economies have expanded so quickly technologies have been able to advance so so quickly like it's a good thing right it's a really

good thing and but it does on the other hand make Supply chains really complex and a lot of people don't understand how cross border so many things like their devices are but this was really highlighted with covid when all of a sudden it was really hard to pass from place to place from country to Country because there was a covid spike in you didn't know if there's going to be covid on your phone device and all this kind of stuff and it really highlighted the fragility of a lot of these Supply chains right so you know on that kind of note what are some of the problems that we're actually experiencing right now in modern Supply chains so one of the key things when we look at supply chain is uh we call it resilience of the supply chain okay how resilient is your supply chain and when we look at resilient models that we build in into the supply chain there are different kinds of contingencies that are planned okay however a contingency for

covid absolutely was not there because this was complete you know the whole World kind of froze for a certain period of time and we didn't know which was stuck where right and the impacts are so far reaching that even in 2024 we are still facing disruptions here and there which we were not able to predict so resilience in supply chain is one of the things the other thing in supply chain is the disruption aspect res I mean we studied how resident a supply chain is to disruption but there could be disruptions with global activi is like War right you have two countries which are in fact four countries five countries fighting with one another having you know there are suddenly there comes a regulation we'll not stop doing business with this country or any company who is based out of this country we're going to ban them yeah but the impacts are so far reaching that we don't even know how long it will take us to see the effects of that decision yeah you

know on a on a political basis yes you have to do what you have to do but on a supply chain basis there is no mechanism at this point of time ideally like you know in this day and age when we have analytics right you have a GPS and you say you know what I want to take a stop and then from go from here to there it'll tell you oh if you take that it'll take you five minutes more which is called prescriptive analytics tells you that you know if you change things what's going to happen but we don't have anything like a prescriptive analytics for supply chain at this point of time which would mean like what happens if the energy cost increase how is my supply chain going to be impacted there is no mechanism there's no dashboard that any compan is going to get to know about what happens if we our relationship with China you know gets worse suppose you know we don't know what's going to happen I mean

of course we know something is going to happen but we are not able to do the impact analysis of that what happens if the Ukraine war continues for another two years I hope not but suppose it continues for another two years what is the impact on the economy what is the global economy so what all that we do is historical analysis we can't do a predictive anal analysis and if we can't do a predictive analysis the biggest problem that happens is all these people who are a part of the supply chain they don't even know what their how their lives are going to be impacted so all we can do is speculate and say we are going to have a Slowdown in economy but we don't know when the Slowdown is coming we waiting for the Slowdown right so these are some problems of globalization however we I mean we cannot do away with globalization that's not what I'm suggesting some economists started suggesting that oh we should produce local consume local yeah that's good

for simple supply chain you know if you're growing local Tomatoes you can have it there if you're having fish yes you can have it locally but what about your smartphone what about your Computing device what about your routers if you want to do if you want to produce local it's like boiling the ocean it's impossible to do it right there be something or the other that you need from another location so these are I feel challenges opportunities for resource researchers I mean I've been trying to look at this Avenue of doing a prescriptive analytics for a decision making process in any kind of a supply chain like you know study the supply chain and see the impact finding the levers which are the levers which is going to impact me in what way thanks for giving us that that overview of the challenges I think you've highlighted some really important ones there and I hadn't thought about this prescriptive analytics piece yet which is really interesting you mentioned this idea of well one solution potentially

being going local but actually that's not practical in a lot of cases we're in the UK we know very well that this is not a particularly practical situation because we're so heavily relying on Imports and you know speaking of Supply chains not only do we have the impact of covid on Supply chains we also have brexit right we have imposed a new trust boundary basically between us and the European Union and I've seen recently they've had to put in something like 4.7 billion pounds worth of investment to facilitate this new trust barrier between the two jurisdictions and it's going to cost businesses themselves something like 330 million pounds per year to go through these new checks right so that just shows the value extraction or value loss you get when you have these trust boundaries creating inefficiencies in Supply chains I think that's it's one of the it's one of the examples that's really struck me so moving on to then you know blockchain and three is that do you see that as a Magic

Bullet I mean typically we think not and we've seen lots of different initiatives in supply chain to do with blockchain so maybe first why do you think blockchain is being considered as a solution what part of the the problems you outlined is blockchain and web 3 Poise to actually address and people are excited about you think sure so one of the things that I had in mind when I was answering about all these issues and problems that we Face uh in the current times with supply chain was based on the fact that there is very little or no web three blockchain implementations in supply chain as yet okay you know I started off by calling it a value exchange process your you know your value chain where we exchange value uh and Trust being a key construct of all supply chain so when we study supply chain one of the things we talk about supply chain is that we need to have a relational relational supply chain to be able to make sure that it

is resilient yeah now we all know that the whole construct of relational is always has some kind of interference with the brand value right so if you are going to engage in any kind of a Commerce any kind of a trade with anyone you would first want to make sure that person is valid correct that person or that entity has some kind of credibility you know you want to make sure they are to show demonstrate that they you know you can sue them or do whatever if they don't deliver the things that as they have promised or they have the ability to deliver yeah and now with sustainability it even becomes more complex you want to make sure that you know your supply chain does not have any kind of child labor you any kind of Workforce exploitation they don't have a huge carbon footprint so on and so forth right but when we look at things like this what does it come to our mind this can only be afforded by a big organization

correct you can have only limited organizations in the current times who are able to engage in actually face Toof face com they might be integrated in the back end but in the front end these are bigger organization who can engage in any kind of a Commerce right now the moment you have an integration of organizations then you have these smaller players who have the ability to do things but there is an entry barrier for them yeah what does three do for us what does blockchain do for us blockchain brings in this decentralized trust this technology mediated trust and the moment you getting this technology mediated trust is all we have to make sure is we write those smart contracts carefully yeah and we have the right kind of oracles right and we can create a decentralized marketplace now I'm not saying decentralization is the answer to everything in fact I believe decentralization is a state n is not state zero if you start with decentralization you're only going to create a lot of commotion yeah

however in bits and pieces if we are able to decentralize things in our supply chain with the decentralized which with a blockchain based system which creates which preserves privacy then we will have a supply chain which is more connected with one another rather than just a dual pulley happening in each of these places yeah so block chain in my opinion solves a lot of problems how it will solve that is for us to figure out yeah it will bring in efficiencies it will open the doors for smaller players it will make sure we will be able to make sure that if we are claiming that these are the raw materials or this product that we are eating is actually you know comes in from organic is actually organic yeah and not that you know somebody Big Brand is claiming it to be or organic and hence it is organic or whether this product was transported in the right temperature how do we get to know because nobody is going to share the data after the

do yeah so I'm going to share it with my Downstream but then my Downstream what they do with that I don't know because it's a database system anybody can alter things blockchain can help us with those kind of things and I feel you know it'll take a bit of a time to for us to start imagining structures that would be a pure decentralized framework but in bits and pieces if we are able to start like the first thing which I always tell people is before we jump into blockchain the most important thing that we need to crack is identity yeah if we are not cracking identity we will not be able to solve the blockchain puzzle or the supply chain puzzle or the value chain puzzle with blockchain because identity has to be trans incidental if you go in and open a wallet in the current times in any kind of a public blockchain you know of course I know both of you are great guys but then when we are doing a trade I

need to make sure that you are who you are in some form right even if it is a zero knowledge proof but I need to make sure you are who you are unless until we make those mechanisms because you know blockchain came in from a very libertarian view we don't want to give our name we don't don't want to do this we don't want to do that we have to find some kind of a convergence between a country identity a regulatory identity and the decentralized identity to be able to make sure that we are able to crack this puzzle yeah that's a a lot to unack there it really resonates with me the idea of the decentralized trust you're talking about right because as I said these trust borders we have or when when you have two entities in any in any value chain that you know and you have many of these pairs in maybe the production and and distribution of one good you have so many of these relationships where you have trust

boundaries I think absolutely blockchain can play a role in in mediating that right we have this whole idea of peer-to-peer well these are all peer-to-peer interactions in some sense that you have between the initial production of something and then it getting in the hands of the End customer so I think that's a really nice way of thinking about it now you also kind of touched on the fact that this is an evolving living Beast right and it's not necessarily A solved problem even if we have some of the the components so if you look back at like 2016 17 18 IBM more or less came out looking like this was a solved problem right saying blockchain was a Magic Bullet they came out with IBM food trust to tackle the food supply chain traceability they came out with trade lens right to tackle the shipping industry with MK and all of that kind of seems to have died off it was using a more private model so I want to ask you what kind of

specific use cases or specific projects or directions because again you seems like you think this isn't necessarily A solved issue but what do you think are the most promising avenues that people are exploring with web 3 and supply chain right now sure and before I kind of talk about what is the problem now let me just go back to this food trust example and uh the shipping example that you came up with I feel one of the reasons they failed is because they did not use a blockchain they used a private blockchain which is not exactly a blockchain a private blockchain is controlled by an organization they they might aspire to be a blockchain but when the governance is under your control the nodes are what you're running I I think it's very difficult to scale something like that it's going to be one player who's going to be a monopoly which means I'm going and telling you suppose I set up a private blockchain and say oh trust me the whole world is going

to trust me but then what if I go Rogue and start sharing information with one another or start changing information because governance is under my control I feel that the solution soltion for this should be a public blockchain and that is why I always emphasize to be able to get things going in a public blockchain identity is one crucial piece and coming to the things that are being currently solved or currently which appear to be solved in a a blockchain base solution I feel is primarily to do with supply traceability I think traceability is one key aspect around which we are able to build a lot of things in supp traceability also carries the trust right from the source to the end consumer so TR traceability has different facets to it uh there could be a traceability which has to do with the production traceability whether this product was produced the weight supposed to be produced that's one of the things that we are seeing which is more based iot integration where you know a

product goes through a whole production pipeline each of these pipelines you have an iot system which is monitoring that so essentially when it goes through that iot system and it complies to the contract which it is supposed to comply with only then the product would be tokenized suppose yeah so you know I won't let you tokenize unless each of these so if I go through step one step two step three step four step five only then I'll let you tokenize otherwise it's not a product you get me and each of these steps have an iot encoding process so this would work wonders in pharmaceutical manufacturing for example where you know we hear we hear all the time that pharmaceutical manufacturers not that they want to make counterfeit Goods but when you go for contract manufacturing sometimes they are only regulated or tested by a sampling kind of a model you can't test every single drug otherwise you'll have to eat that drug or you know destroy the drug so to be able to do away

with that sampling testing you are able to have an iot device which will monitor that yeah of course the point of failure is the iot device I do agree but if the iot device is configured right it's like your taxi meter right I mean somebody just Alters the taximeter what can we do but then you know that that can be somehow secured and we know that I iot devices are getting smarter and smarter by the day so if we are able to break down those production processes and that is an iot based traceability then you will be able to make sure that the product is what it is supposed to be that's one form of traceability the other form of traceability is that if I am saying that this product came from Place X yeah and it traveled to me at 7° Centigrade frozen food yeah most of the times we go to the store and we buy frozen food do we even know whether it was transported the right temperature no we just trust

that brand that they are going to give us food which is not because if it did not get transported the right temperature which means that the expiration date on that food is not correct right so we could have an iot based traceability I mean imagine having that overhead of having somebody to actually observe each one of them that would not be possible but the iot based system could verify the authen authenticity of this particular thing the other thing is another kind of traceability is a mass-based traceability this is coming uh big way in organic food biofuel green hydrogen and we seeing lots of use cases emerge in that area uh I give you an example the amount of organic food that we consume in various parts of the world I give you example of United States the amount of organic food that we that is sold in the market is way more than the organic food that is produced okay so what happens in the intermediary and we all know organic food has a shelf

life now if you see if we are able to car this to a mathematical routine so if it goes from the main producer and the producer has 100 different intermediaries whom they sell to in their you know in the in their in the downstream the producer is gives a certificate that this is an organic food now the certificate is going to be a lot of overhead if you have a web to system now imagine you have million tokens for which would represent each of those items of say Tomatoes here yeah so I'm going to give you a certificate that this tomato like you know out of the million you bought 100,000 from me I'll give you 100,000 certificates then that 100,000 this guy goes and sells another 50,000 to one 20,000 to another 30,000 the other one so then you have these certificates which are generated by the system so essentially my system will not generate an organic certificate uh Downstream if I don't H if I don't have a proof that I receive certificates

that ways you don't need to know who's at the Upstream but that certificate would maintain the Integrity of the product that's called a a mass balance model this works for a lot of things like if you sell green hydrogen we hydrogen is hydrogen right whether it is green or not how do we assertain that so you get certificates at the very beginning certificates would maintain the Integrity of that so essentially there would be no people and it's much more complicated than that you could have value additions in the middle of what but these are some use cases that we are seeing now okay there is another use case if I may say which is very close to me my heart and I feel that at some time should be at a global scale and that has to do with finance and supply chain tied together and this is a token launched out of Argentina and Brazil this they're called AGR token they launched on algorand and this AGR token uses a very interesting mechanism to

be able to create some kind of liquidity for Farmers from the time they planted their seeds so one of the biggest problems that farmers faces that they have to you know get their crop go to the market sell it only then they are able to get that money yeah and for that time period usually in developing countries we have seen the farmers go and take loans from loan sharks and you know this is this whole vicious circle of poverty that they keep going by the time they get the money theyve they already all all the crop that they've grown the money is already going to be going back to that loan shark and these people have been you know controlling these people for centuries here now interesting thing over here is based on satellite data weather data all kinds of risk model International future market price of the crop there is a a a valuation done again you have ID of the farmer you have a token which creates which actually has what is the

land that they have know that they own or where they growing their crop based on that what is also the the type of crop that they're growing based on that there is a value future value of the crop that is determined and they get liquidity on a Visa card so essentially their future crop is tokenized to give them liquidity and that liquidity is with which they are able to run till they raise the crop and when they crop is ready to be sold they bur those tokens by paying the money and essentially then it's trade as Commerce as usual so some beautiful use cases are coming which was not possible with webo thank you niik I mean you've given us such a good oversight of so many different things in kind of like a quick fire round on all the possibilities that web 3 and blockchain bring to this space and it's I completely agree and there's so many things that as Jack would say I want to double click on there but you're like

the kind of the overview of you know know trus in data is so important right and that's what blockchains provide in many ways but I think like you said relating that trusted data to someone is so important as well and that's the next stage right and there's such a kind of pressing need for decentralized or digital identity in this space to actually aggregate the data and relate it to an individual or business or whatever it is and I think like a kind of a segue there for both those things is iot right because you know you say as soon as the data is on the blockchain I can trust it but what about the actual collection of that data and I think iot is so important for that to actually set you know the classic garbage in garbage out it doesn't matter if the data is like immutable and tamper proof and all this stuff if it wasn't collected properly and iot in a way helps reduce the likelihood of data being collected in the

wrong way or if it is collected in the wrong way you can actually get some analytics that are actually part of the data to say this is how it was collected this is some of the error messag that came with it potentially but you're reducing the human error there but I think iot also relates to the idea of digital identities when you're talking about iot operating in these kind of open trustless potentially spaces then you might need to start thinking about how you can have digital identity for your iot devices so they can say have a history that relates to them or they can actually start to exchange goods on themselves they can start to commit you know have some more agency start to commit payments as soon as they've hit decision Gates and I think iot in supply chain is going to be such an interesting kind of I guess Center Point for a lot of these different Technologies to emerge towards I think we're going to see obvious as well AI is going

to be in there well there'll be lots of data analytics occurring with the vast amounts of data that's taking this iot data and making it useful for a human to make an End decision there's so many things that we could talk about even the fact you're talking about the certificates there and the carbon credit is obviously a big booming area but like you say there's more spent than there actually are produced because you've got this double spending problem in a way where they're actually you know everyone's exchanging carbon credits but not that many are being generated so you're like okay where are they all coming from like you actually need a way to actually say okay this is authentic this is the only one and if you're not spending it from here with this signature across it then it's probably not real and we're not going to count it for example but like you say there's so many different examples that you could go into one of the questions I had for you because you've

been in this space for some time now is that people have been talking about blockchainbased Supply chains for I think like 10 plus years now and like you say it's like there have been some it's not really mainstream like you said what is taking so long to get this technology adopted in the mainstream yeah okay so one of the things when I can of somebody asked me about why blockchain is not in the mainstream even in supply chain or anywhere you know I want to kind of I always take people through this whole journey of how blockchain has evolved over the years yeah uh how did we actually got into this whole blockchain discussion was 20072 2008 with the launch of Bitcoin yeah and then Bitcoin as we all know was very libertarian because people lost trust in institutions and all kinds of things happened and then Bitcoin earned a very bad name because of the silk root and so on and so forth the people started saying oh this is only for evil people

here yeah until something very amazing happened with the ethereum launch which actually created a different kind of a perspective which is where blockchains moved away from that libertarian view to a more decentralized organization perspective yeah where you know you have Smart contracts you have automation you have so on and so forth yeah so there is transition in the view of how blockchain has happened from libertarian to decentralization now that was generation two then we had another set of problems with icos coming in people launching tokens creating all that white paper and then suddenly disappearing with whatever money was there that created another set of issues so crypto took Center strage and blockchain took as somewhere got lost yeah it was not until generation platforms that have come in which might support building tokens it's not that Generation 3 is not about but then they started looking at more Enterprise gr solution let's talk about transaction speed let's talk about no uh transaction finality which is a very big problem mind you I mean if you

see the in the grand scheme of things if somebody tells you hey you can continue doing transaction but you know what we could possibly Fork at some point people would freak out on you what are you talking about right so transaction finality is important transaction cost is very important if is you know I I used to do some kind of modeling for people and they said okay what could be my transaction cost if I like that depends on network band and network congestion and they were like I need to make sure that this doesn't inflate too much otherwise it would be not a sustainable business for me so yes good thing happened with Layer Two in generation two but then that layer two is still as good as the as the as the as the substrate layer you know which is good of course ethereum is still has the biggest ecosystem but why I like the generation three is that they are cutting that crypto noise and focusing on blockchain Revolution so I feel that

unless and until we start thinking Enterprise with public blockchain we will not be able to achieve and that's why it's taking us a lot of time because we have got into this generation three platforms who have a different kind of mindset only very recently these are three four year old back and of course that was the time when we were all you know locked in and introspecting whe whether we will be able to make it for the next five years or not right and good for us as a as as a as all of us moved out of that but the main thing that blockchain has not taken Center Stage is because of this whole transition that is happening in the blockchain space even now I come across many people who think very much in a in a very like you know that no government no institution nothing and then I go and tell them okay fine let's do a supply chain problem with your mindset do you think people are going to join your

network without having an identity do you think they will be able to engage in a legal Commerce in a in a country without having an identity and they're like no this if we are going to be very close to government and we are breaking this whole thing so I think one of the things which I would always ask people to introspect when they're building applications in blockchain is that we have to give we have to give away a bit of decentralization to be compliant but we can smartly give away that part of decentralization there is a cycle of centralization and decentralization that we are going all the time at some point these blockchains would be centralized I hate to say that but that's the fact okay and eventually find another technology to make us decentralized the only thing is what part of the business can be decentralized and what part you know we have to centralize to be able to make sure we have the Regulatory Compliance not that we are trying to kind of

make the government's happy but at the same time you are operating within the Norms of a government and if you say I don't care for the government I'm not reporting anything to the government then you're always going to be on the periphery you're not going to come into the mainstream that's the problem I I love that assessment I think you know it's so apt like we've said seen so much of the kind of the mainstream media and maybe even like the investment as well has just been focused on the crypto side right and there's a lot of negative connotations around that how much energy is it using for the amount of utility it's actually providing like what problem is it trying to solve and even outside of that like you say like Consulting 101 is you take people on a journey of like phases to get somewhere and if they're like in a super centralized model right now and you're saying the next stage is fully decentralized get rid of all the intermediaries everyone's going

to be like crap we don't want to do this do we and that sounds horrible and like I think this why this term that we've started to use in the podcast more and more is this web 2.5 model where you decentralize the aspects you can for now and probably have the trusted intermediary still in there but more and more you try and decentralize what you can with the end goal probably being as decentralized as possible but you'd always need an intermediary somewhere like when we talk about digital identity systems for example You' always need a government to say this is your passport and you are who you say you are but you can decentralize more aspects of that maybe the verification maybe the ownership and all this kind of stuff but I completely agree with you so we're coming to the end of the show here n and this has been really insightful and I have learned a lot but you know when I first saw you online this say all count out I saw

that you cover a lot of topics and you digest them so well and I was like okay we need to get this guy on he's going to be great but I have no idea what topic he's going to cover because he speaks about so many things so well online and what I want to get from you is what are you most excited for in terms of what areas what use cases most excite you for the future of web 3 and blockchain and this can be outside of supply chain if you want I mean supply chain is anyways the value chain is where we all live in I mean you know uh we can't be living in a box anyways but one of the things which I feel is this whole area of sustainability and we are doing a lot of things in India around that and you did mention about carbon crits I think carbon crit is just a piece of it there are many more sustainable initiative like water credits plastic credits so on

and so forth these are very difficult things because as we know carbon credits as much as they were you know the Kyoto protoc the Kyoto agreement was meant to create an economic model around it but we've abused that system left right and center and there are power centers power Brokers everywhere with all due respect to people who do work honestly there I don't mean to say be saying everybody's dishonest but the point point over here is that when we have any kind of an human intervention to be able to come in and look at a sample of how much carbon credits I'm going to be getting for this this is subject to error in this day and age this has to be automated and we talked about you did talk about iot so we are looking at data backed actual datab backed carbon credits of course I'm I in grand scheme of things I would bring in artificial intelligence over there also to be able to make sure those iot devices on not manipulated at

some point of time that could be another integration with a but as of now in a very grounded scheme of things we are looking at data backed and there are few other things that comes out of this which I'm really excited about so data backed carbon credits which are fair in nature okay as of now carbon credits is an integrators game if you actually have to certify yourself or your project with gold standard the amount of money that's required ired is not something which a small farmer who is doing sustainable farming can afford right and when as we all know if you have power Brokers over there these power Brokers are going to control everything they'll invest okay fine the farmer becomes sustainable what is the incentive to the farmer who's making ends made to be able to continuously do things in a sustainable manner if I create another Avenue Revenue source for this Farmer for doing sustainable agriculture that is when the magic is going to happen and that is what I'm ex extremely

excited about that is what I'm extremely motivated to continue working on and I feel a smart contract Fair smart contract based model where these intermediaries are value addition people I'm not even suggesting that they they don't add value to this if this system becomes a smart contract based system data back system a tokenized carbon credits then it's going to be very beautiful and the other thing which again is a hope I I I don't think it's going to be happening pretty soon is a decentralized system altogether why do I need an exchange if I follow a methodology right and if I am able to measure the kind of footprint or that I'm reducing on different things carbon beat water whatever be the case and also on top of that the sustainable development goals that I'm able to achieve not just on paper but on by some kind of a databased uh system which is able to contract that that would be an ideal thing and that's what I Aspire that's what is my you know

I'm very passionate about that's what I'm working on at this point of time to be able to build more robust systems around these processes I love it and you can really hear the passion coming through there I think it's a really interesting area it's one that we've talked about a lot as well sustainability and specifically carbon credits also carbon emissions reporting that kind of thing I think it's so ripe for disruption and it there's so many ways you could improve it as you said but I love that you highlighted the need for fairness right the fact that it is so much harder to do these things if you are a small Enterprise if you're a small organization or an individual entity to try and contribute to the process that allows accurate carbon emissions reporting and carbon credits allocation it is very difficult there's a misalignment of incentives there so I really like that you see the incentive game that you can play in web 3 and the fact that you can design design these incentives

tokenomics and smart contracts and things like that I think that is absolutely a great way to apply these Technologies So yeah thank you so much for for sharing that insight and I hope it's hope it's a successful project for you in the future so n it's been as Alex said it's been such a great show we always end with a couple of kind of open questions that we ask all our guests we like to see you know what the distribution of answers is here so I'll ask you the first one if you're ready in one sentence what is web 3 to you so in one sent web3 for me is not changing the frontend interfaces that we have in the current times and having a backend system which enables fairness democratization and privacy there's a very new approach I think to answering that question it's I like that it's more specific it's a bit more techy than we usually get than the kind of very Grand Vision so I really like that okay and then

our second and final question then is if you could choose anybody in the world from throughout history they could even be you know fictional character or something like that to sit down and discuss web 3 with who would you pick and why I think the only person who comes to my mind when I talk about the web three aspirations or the web three projects that we are doing or that we should be working on is Mahatma Gandhi one of the things that Gandhi always talked about Gandhi g I should say talked about is swaraj the idea of swaraj is to be able to have self-governance and self governance as we all know is very difficult to achieve because everybody has different feels web3 gives us that to be able to self-govern and self-govern really well so Gandhi G's view was that we should not punish people who are make mistakes right one of the things that has come in the current Society is or if you have bad behavior we'll kick you out and we'll

celebrate you know the rich people only I mean they're supposed to be the best people in the world anyways uh but his view was that you know recognizing acknowledging good behavior is the best thing that we can do but we should not punish people who do not want to contribute to the society there should be enough incentives for good behavior only when I read this the first time about blockchain blockchain enables incentives for good beer are like oh this is what Mahatma Gandhi mentioned all the time we should have incentives in the society for good behavior altruism doesn't is not a sustainable strategy anyways right greediness is not a sustainable strategy because there is no limit to greediness but if as a society we do not get recognize we do not get incentives to be able to do good behavior like I talked about this farmer yeah if the farmer has to do sustainable farming this farmer has to get some benefit from that sustainable farming maybe some T some are tangible some are intangible

but to the the farmer as we all can tell is making ends meet is difficult if there is nothing tangible that comes into them we'll not be able to sell them on the int intangible benefits rather this is something which I feel resonates very closely with the thoughts of Mahatma Gandhi and I would I would have loved to have sit down and discuss BB 3 with him I I love that answer I think that would be such an interesting dinner and such a good insightful dinner I think another thing that saw was around the idea of SAA that was one of the things that Gandhi promoted right the idea of Truth being the foundation of all virtues so I imagine like the idea of trusted data and a way to prove authenticity and Truth as well would probably align so yeah that would be an incredible conversation n this has been great I've learned so much and I think there's so much more we can and will learn by getting you on in again in

the future so all that's left to say is thank you for joining us and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time to untangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Infrastructure & IoT

Related episodes

All episodes