Episode 20
The Future of IoT with David Palmer
About this episode
In the latest episode of Untangling Web3, hosts Alec Burns and Jack Davies, accompanied by David Palmer from Vodafone, delve into the intricate universe of Web 3 technologies, blockchain, and IoT devices.
David shares insights into how the Digital Asset Broker platform leverages a permissioned blockchain to foster trustworthy, automated transactions between IoT devices, addressing industry challenges like monetization and interoperability, and managing substantial data.
The conversation ventures into the dynamics of AI, discussing the trials of connecting data from numerous devices to large language models that power AI. The episode explores critical considerations about trust, authentication, and data credentialing using Web 3, discussing the strategic move from private to public chains in blockchain adoption and highlighting the instrumental role of digital asset brokers across various sectors.
Navigating through the complexities of data ownership, especially in Web 3 platforms, the discussion emphasizes the necessity for consent and monetization incentives and pivots towards machine-to-machine payments, account abstraction, and the integration of Web 3 into established businesses.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
I think it's monetization um so so so there has been a lot of investment in iot um and a lot of um a lot of effort in connecting devices um but not a lot of results in terms of business benefit or or monetary benefit because 75% of the data collected isn't used so there's a lot of money connecting the device in storing the data but it's not used and part of the reason it's not used I think it's welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we're delighted to be joined by David Palmer as the chief product officer and co-founder of vodafone's digital asset broker platform David is a recognized thought leader in blockchain and Enterprise grade web 3 applications focusing on the convergence of digital Technologies and new business models David is currently exploring the opportunities associated with iot blockchain defi digital identity and the metaverse so without further Ado David welcome to the show nice to be here guys finally um real pleasure to be on this platform uh discussing
uh my favorite topic uh web three uh with you today um really really looking forward to this competition and uh and learning as well thank you for being here David how are you doing today okay yeah I think it's good um I'm I'm I'm talking to you from Paddington or HQ in Paddington London um weather is surprisingly wonderful for for this time of year um and yeah and then there's just a buzz in London you could almost feel web three and Ai and uh you know moving through the year so yeah London London London gives me energy so I'm I'm feeling good you are right there it does feel like there's something about London where there's just all of these different disparate f Fields all kind of coalescing at the same time and it's a very exciting time I mean your introduction you've talked about so many different fields and the overlap between them I am extremely excited to go a bit deeper into this but before we get ahead of ourselves David could you
just give us a little bit of an introduction to you know your early career and your please uh yeah so so so those of you looking at me on the on the camera I'm not that young uh so I've got quite a bit of background to to go through um but but my ground has been in Telecom um so so so I have been involved uh through my career uh in um you know Broadband as we called it back then so DSL uh Broadband satellite Broadband uh also fiber uh so uh fiber to the premises um satellite Broadband uh internet of things or machine to machine um but I also had always been looking for technology in the latest technology so as well as being a gamer um I started looking at Bitcoin uh you know introduced by a friend uh 10 years ago or so um and uh you know tried to to mine uh mine Bitcoin I think I managed to mine one which I still got um and then and then became
absolutely fascinated with ethereum at smart contract absolutely fascinated um with the possibility of having this business logic and and contracts automated um and how this could could work with a sort of decentralized Ledger and peer-to-peer and and and payments and the possibilities of this and um and yeah I started looking at um the technology and and start googling okay you know what's happening with blockchain and TCO there's about four Lin there about four lines at the time and I said okay could you know how could this work in my world so so what are the US cases where you know decentralized Ledger blockchain could could actually work for Telco and you know how how more specifically could it work for iot or machine to machine where I work and that's where uh the digital AET broker platform came from uh which was originally just looking at okay you know how if if we had devices dynamically transacting with each other um how could we automate the Contracting the onboarding how could you know two devices
trust each other automatically and uh and and then we started looking at how they could transact and then we started looking at uh you know what role the slim card could play in that so could we link the SIM card to blockchain could we link the SIM card blockchain and the cryptography I the public private keys that we have in the SIM card uh to to being able to sign on chain and triggered smart contracts but that's where it came from and now I'm pleased to say that uh you know we've graduated from uh you know a um you know and talking about use cases to actually having a live platform uh so so the digital asset broker which incorporates Edge technology stim cards devices with blockchain is now live uh it's not only live uh but it's a a subsidiary of vform on the digital broker and pairpoint um and and we have live customers uh on there and we are using web3 and smart contract devic so yeah really really excited about it
well congratulations because that's always I feel like that's been a meme of blockchain for a long time is that everything's a proove of concept phase and never gets to production and you you've successfully gone over that hurdle and I definitely want to dig into the specifics of the digital asset broker platform but you know I I kind of want to bring it back for a moment you talked about iot already and me and Alec have done you know our best to Define iot and and what it is and why it's important but it'd be nice to hear you know from yourself as an industry expert what is iot what are what are these iot devices and why are we actually talking about them why is it such a buzz word like what are what are the applications of them yeah so so so formerly known as machine to machine um The Internet of Things uh is about devices being connected and some of those devices you'd be surprised about um you you have connected cars
so pretty much most cars now um come connected uh and uh you know and they come with um with data right which can be uh sent back to the auto Manu manfacturers or can be linked to the customers uh you have drones uh which are connected I think by law now um you have connected cabinets you have sensors uh you have um you know if you look at the consumer angle you have wearables uh so I don't I I personally now don't leave home without my my my watch right my connected uh watch because uh yeah I don't exist right so you I want to know how many steps I've done how my hard was performing uh you know the calories I've lost and that is a wearable and that is a thing um so you have a lot of things um which are connected and I suppose The Internet of Things is about how those things which are connected can come together to for perform common pools of data how they can be findable
how the data can be used um and and uh and and the economy of things which is where the disc that broker said is about how you can monetize them how can uh you know device how can my watch data uh be sold to a drone how can a drone sell sell uh data to a car um and and you know you sort of go in this circle of uh of economy and transactions which is um you know connected by the internet of things but um is monetized by the economy of things and please go ahead you've um you've you've introduced so many different angles there I think when people think of iot the numbers that are related to iot devices is huge right I think it was previously estimated to be 30 billion active iot devices by 2030 that's been brought forward significantly to 2025 I think we actually might hit it in the next two years is now is what they're saying and you've given a couple of like futuristic examples the idea
of drones and you know paying for data from drones all this kind of stuff my background is actually in drone Tech so I'm very very into that um before we yeah I know there's a lot of things we can talk about even the gaming Stu an avid gam no before we n out before we N Out like before we get to the solution as well what are some of the issues that are facing the iot industry right now I think it's monetization um so so so there has been a lot of investment in iot um and a lot of um a lot of effort in connecting devices um but not a lot of results in terms of business benefit or or monetary benefit because 75% of the data isn't used so there's a lot of money connecting the device and storing the data but it's not used and part of the reason it's not used I think is twofold one of one of the reasons is that a lot of the data has a value
near real type right so so so so in my location uh is important to um you know where you know a retail outlet once to position a discount or whatever then that that's near real time information which which which has a value near real time but doesn't have a value post near real time um I think the other reason is that iot silos so the business model is that if I own a device then that device will send data to me and if I can use it find in my business model but if I can't uh then then then then it's just thought but you could use it Al or you could use it Jack but but but but we don't trust each other our devices don't trust each other and there's no dynamic where um where they can find each other and transact that data or or or a service near real type and uh and and that is a I think a big problem for monetizing um The Internet of Things I think
some of the other um challenges are what type of connectivity you have so obviously we provide cellular uh connectivity but you've got um you know you've got other other ways that devices can be uh connected and then you've got standards which areal iated with that uh so so so so those are some of the challenges uh you have as well as the share amount of data so I think um I think uh you know 90% of the data has been created in The Last Five Years or or so um and The Internet of Things is only adding adding to that there's more and more devices um I always use the the the 70 billion uh by 2025 I don't know if it will be 70 billion but suddenly the next five to 10 years we're likely to hit the 70 billion Mark which means you have you know 10 times the amount of devices as human and then the sort of estimates that that we will have many devices um coming I think a lot
of us will start to have uh uh AR or Mr mixed reality headset now which will be another device on top of our airpod top of our phone and our iPods and our wearables um and and and the key well sorry the challenge has been how do you make that interoperable how do you make these devices speak to each other and speak to other devices and then the the second thing is how do you monetize it um yeah and investment needs returns and I don't think we seen the return so far I I I like that I mean when we did our episode in iot which again was very surface level we spoke mostly about the sheer amount of data I think the number is 175 zettabytes I don't even know what a zetabyte is but it sounds huge right and we talked about the interoperability and like how to communicate peer-to-peer and all this kind of stuff but a big thing that we did didn't talk about that actually so obvious now you say
is Real Time data how important it has is to have the data real time so that's another challenge that me and Jack didn't even consider what we talked about this previously so now you've kind of highlighted all the problems how does blockchain and web 3 how does it help um well I think the block blockchain and web 3 um helps in in a number of ways uh I I could speak from the digital act broker angle so we looked at it very simply on the vone platform iot platform we we we currently have uh 160 million connected devices uh so these are customers that have our connected Sim on our iot platform and and we were simply looking at okay if we put all of those devices on a blockchain and if the owners of those devices the big customers hosted nodes on on on our permission chain so we started with permission chain uh then could we issue an identity standard uh you know and attributes uh or or credentials within those identities that
would allow these devices to trust each other and and if one of the credentials was the payment credentials which which which linked to Smart contracts in some circumstances or you know where the preconditions the parameters were known we have automated transactions right and and and so so so the blockchain is providing um the ecosystem it's connecting that ecosystem and it's providing um the trust and the and the link to automated smart contracts to to to to have that so so that's where web3 is helping obviously we started off looking at tokens uh so iot you know we you're looking at a high volume of transactions uh very low value so it could be your bu of data which which you're selling which is very low value and obviously the the the original atttention was to use uh peer-to-peer transactions and tokens to do that because we thought at the time there would be a lower transaction cost and then ethereum the price of ethereum went up with the other tokens and the gas fees went
up and uh this was before you had the layer twos really doing the job and and yeah the the the microtransactions disappeared and we started to to to to look at ways of doing it with uh with with with real currencies and real payments and postpay settlements but um that that's what we were looking at now there's another Dynamic that's entered and I'm I'm you're going to quit me on this but it's Ai and the story of of of the year so far has been open Ai and chat GPT um and where that's gone and it's developing really quickly but it's got a great use case and um yeah there's a headline I think over the last few weeks that chat GPT yeah which used to be uh dependent limited to 2021 data or two-y old data I suddenly learned to Ser the internet and it can now pull in real data uh but I think what it's done is it's got people very hungry for data and if you look at what the Internet
of Things does it's all about data right it's data from billions of devices uh so part of the other Dynamic that we're looking at now is how do you connect the data from billions of devices with large language models that P okay that's a that's a fascinating problem and it's something very interesting to work on I think right yeah and how do you TR that data so how do you trust how can you trace um the data you're getting to a device how can you authenticate the owner how can you authenticate the data and and if it's authenticated how do you turn that into a credential and that's where web 3 comes in as the bridge and the trust between the data being generated uh and the AI That's going to use it and providing traceability so there's there's some Dynamics there where you've got iot web3 and AI working together in an endtoend model got that is that is so fastc there's so many things I want to dig into I don't know what
to ask first um maybe one thing would be I because I heard you kind of mention it and I want to just you know Peak by interest you I think you mentioned you started on a private chain right and this is something I've seen I've seen this pattern with Enterprise adoption of of blockchain and web through over time they they tend to have to start with private I just wanted to ask you about that that process right and how what was the decision to to start with it why did you move to public and what was the value proposition there because I'm sure I'm sure you'll provide some insight right having gone through this process yourself um yeah so so so so we started five years ago uh so the digital AET broker started with that use case of um you how can we not take six months to on board you know a vendor that one of our devices are going to do business with um and it started there and we started you
we programmed it for parking it can uh it's been on a long journey but back five years ago um people didn't trust public blockchains right so there was a a lot of issues uh with privacy there was a lot of issues about the you know these fake news things about the energy being used and uh and and transparency and uh you know and security um so the only way we could start you know to even look at this was to go on a permission to um so so so that was a lot of thinking behind making it for permission and and it wasn't just us it was our customers right that that's what they wanted and we also had the uncertainty in in terms of the gasby um which which made public blockchains at at the time you know not Enterprise grade um and and there was also um you know with public blockchains a lot of issues around um you know the the energy side and yeah and the security and the amount of
public blockchains and the transactions per second and and they couldn't integrate with Legacy Etc now obviously things have changed a lot um and now you're having the very real situation where um you know I I I believe thoroughly that everything will move to public CH just like internet and internet I believe it will move there but the halfway house is where you have like we do a permission team uh which you know provides some security and provide some control points but where we can link that to evm chains or public chains uh and then you have the idea of public chains which can have permissions um layers within it uh you know so you've got public permission the permission public and I I believe that's a halfway house I believe we will move to public chain I I believe that they will become infrastructure just like electricity uh connectivity uh and and other forms of infrastructure I believe that blockchain will become infrastructure I I believe there'll be a lot of convergence but we're not
quite there yet and and I don't believe that we would have gotten as far as we have in terms of going live had we gone straight to public but um as you can see with the ethereum merge I think it's EIP 1559 um and and some of the other developments the public chains are are really moving forward I think that would layer to optimistic rollup EK uh zero knowledge proofs um you know so some of the things that are happening there that we're starting to see a lot more efficiency um and I going forward so so I believe that we will end up on public teams and I believe it will be infrastructure just like the mobile network is an infrastructure but we're just not there yet so we've got to go on the J this um this resonates with me and Jack you can see we're nodded along quite a lot because we completely agree we imagine like you know blockchain in this future final implementation will be protocol or the piping that allows
a lot of these things that we're talking about and for that to happen it's got to be open right um so this the the digital asset broker you've kind of touched on it a little bit I just want to go a bit deeper so the the premise of it early doors was effectively to kind of get high quality data from iot devices and be able to sell that and obviously we had issues around transaction fees so we're now trying to sell that based on fiat currency can you give you know this has moved from PC to product now with paying customers I assume could you tell what are they paying for what is it the solution how do you sell this to people what is it doing right now um so so so very very good question um and and you're absolutely right it's you know it started with data and services um and and it's about you know we had this dream of being the Google of devices uh so not only could devices
become searchable uh but dynamically um you know autonomously the devices could transact with each other and or with services um as well now obviously there are some challenges uh so some of challenges are around the intelligence of devices or the processing power of devices some of the challenges are with the majority of the uh business areas business sectors of the devices operating um so so and the other one is just availability of devices so Bon currently have 40 million Sims in C uh so so seven out of 10 of the Sims that are are actually shipped in cars and I think 70% of the data is actually trans transacted over our Network so opportunistically um you know given the car fact that cars have these embedded Sims the majority of them are vone um and the cars are very intelligent meaning that there's a lot of processing power in there you made a lot of things to to start with with Automotive use cases um on top of that if you look at um the
automotive sectors one of the the biggest challenges that they're going through uh is electronic vehicle charging the shift the EV charging where by 2030 I think it's now 2035 it sure will move to 2040 uh a lot of the manufacturers will will not be uh will not be making ice fuel cars anymore and everything will be electric let's see how it plays out but there's a a massive transition there and we saw an immediate uh use for the digital asset broker because remember the digital asset broker is a platform stroke protocol uh which is about the device to device right device to device communication device to device trust device to device transactions so then we're say okay well we've got connected cars which we can enable with da and we've also got a lot of the charges which we can enable with da so we've got daab cars and daab charges uh and they're both daab enabled can we have automatic transactions from from car to charging station using daab um and uh so that
was the use case that that we looked at and we started with which is live so so you can go and download our our Da app um and you can you for if you're a fleet you can you you can provide a you can get a dab identity for your free vehicle uh you can associate multiple drivers uh to that vehicle you can associate multiple drivers to use the one payment credential in that vehicle uh and you can have a a a peer-to-peer or direct settlement over payment rail transactions between the car which has an identity and a payment credential and the charger so that that's something we've looked at we've extended that to parking and tolls and other subscriptions and other other incar Payment Solutions we're also looking at Supply chains so that's another news case where blockchain clearly has a role um but but also with iot has a role and uh we're also looking at Health Care um and and and of other areas but we we are live now um you
know in production uh with uh the incar payments uh and need be charging I like that I mean my background is kind of like autonomous vehicles and I was talking about this a few years ago it's like in a world in which we have autonomous vehicles in the future people aren't going to own cars there's going to be like like kind of these autonomous taxi services and to have an autonomous taxi service you probably want an autonomous charging stations as well so I see the application like I was thinking about this a couple of years ago I was like this this makes so much sense to me um one of the questions I've got a kind of product background is you know whenever you design a product like this like where is the data being held so that you talking say in these autonomous cars just let's say Tesla for example say it's a Tesla vehicle a user of the vehicle and then you've also got Voda phone who owns the data in that instance
that must be quite complicated around here gdpr that's the buzz word right yeah so I you know that's a loaded question right because uh that's a lot of question so if I say that daab owns the data then we're a web two platform if if I say that we don't own the data then uh then who owns it I mean the bottom line is that the digital active broker is a is a broker um so so what we what and I think one of the killer applications of uh of web3 is digital Identity or self- Sovereign digital identity of verifiable credential and that's what we apply to devices so in this case who owns the they they very complicated uh but but what we are doing is um you know for stakeholders in the data we are developing smart contracts uh and when we are developing um you know the ability for owners of the data to agree to Smart contracts to to agree splits of the data and to um and to agree for
that data to be used uh dynamically so so in that case we we don't actually hold the data uh what what we are what we but we will broker the data uh but what we are looking at going forward is obviously developing a learning language model for for for for dab where the owners of the data can opt in for that data to be part of the large language model and they can share in the profit uh from that I like that so I think that's where I think that's where we're going to go but at the moment we just broke the data yeah goad yeah so so we are more web three alike right that yeah I think it's really interesting that you describe it and characterize it as a broker right because you know this reflects I think I don't want to speak for Alec but what what our view on web 3 is not that we should you know go throwing the baby out with a bath water we don't necessarily think
web 3 is about replacing all intermediaries it's just about you know where you can replacing inefficient ones things that don't need to be there especially in payments but I think there's definitely a case to be made for new types of third parties right because we we've talked a lot about this whole concept of data sovereignty and we talk quite disparagingly of of data brokers in web 2 because data Brokers are typically kind of um Shady you know underhanded ways of selling your data without your consent whereas it sounds much more like what you're doing is a more transparent much more Equitable model because there is a market for this data there is also therefore a market for Brokers of it but it's as you said it's the opin aspect that really differentiates you right and means it's a transparent model I think is that fair I I think that's s on remember 75% of the data is not used uh it's not being monetized it is a currency uh it can be used definitely near
real time there's a massive market for for data from billions of devices to feed into large language models uh but but it's about getting agreement it's it's about you know number one providing the opportunity and then getting consent consent being the key thing The self- Sovereign uh identity self- Sovereign models um making data a credential and giving people the chance to opt into the smart contract and modify it I think that's impossible that that's important um I think the problem at the moment is that you know everybody in the web 2 well wants to own the data they can't right because some of the data belongs to the driver in this case in the EV charging some will belong to us some will belong to the car manufacturer but remember the manufacturer not the driver they may not be the owner right so there's so many parties there know the way for it is to get consent right and to provide incentive through monitization no I love that and it's also quite important to remember
that different people different actors might want different parts of the data and we tend to think of data as a whole and when you sort talk about identity a big into self- soverign identity we've done episodes on it there's a ways to selectively disclose the relevant information to certain parties depending on what's relevant to them and the Privacy preservation security of that is so important so I really love it and obviously I picked up on the word data broker but I'm glad you answered in that way because I'm completely on Bo I love this so yeah and I think um yeah this is you're almost like making a new market right you're providing this service of bringing together devices connected devices for people to monetize them and kind on that point one thing I wanted to dig into you've already mentioned this term machine to machine payments right and it's something that I think Jack Alec and I have bandied around a little bit as well but I'm I'm curious to know how they work
and also what is the interface with the humans as well right because it's not like a machine necessarily has its own wallet autonomously to start with you someone has to give it some money so where do the humans fit into the machine to machine payments piece and why why would someone set something up right like who who stands the benefit in one of these interactions if you have a good example yeah so so so great questions um so so I think the first the first thing is that we you know we major in providing machine or device identity right interoperable device identity passort but of course a device can't exist autonomously it must be owned by a person or an organization right um so so so so first of all the person or the organization must register the device on the platform that's the key thing and and it must be a delegated identity of a person or or an organization uh in terms of how um you set the parameters obviously there's smart contracts
which relate to certain use cases like charging or supply chain or energy or not Med it um and then you link to a payment credential right so you have uh you have tariffs you have uh payment credentials which are part of the identity and you have limits right which are are in the smart contract but and then you have triggers uh which are you know for example the car goes to a charger or the Drone gets the the S the delivery point and then you have a trigger and that's the power of iot and and and and sort of web3 and smart contract is that iot can provide the trigger and then web3 can provide the Authentication of the identity and the and the uh payments in in terms of payments so so so our technology does provide an identity it does provide a wallet app or the ability to have a wallet app which is linked to a secure element in the SIM card uh which is linked to public private Keys which we
can generate in the SIM card or we have something called Sim trust which is a symmetric key that that can be generated in SIM card which links to public private key key pairs which are on um in terms of the wallet we are looking or we have implemented wallet connect so I'm big fan of wallet connect and the ability to to to to um to to link to different wallets um you know with one wallet we call it the wallet of wallet uh I very very very excited about account extraction I can tell you all the smart I think account extraction is another lay layer that that that can potentially Bridge it can make the user experience better but I think it's also the key to bridge between token payment and uh real well payment can you explain what that is that concept because I think that's one we haven't actually covered on the podcast before and I think it'd be good to get your take on it yeah so you have externally own accounts
right and then you have uh you know and uh account abstraction is basically allowing you to have accounts that can be related onchain with uh account that are not onchain they can take the the ownership of accounts uh uh rather than being limited on chain to be limited to to to to to to um not be not not be restricted to being onch so so that that is where account of stratching comes in and and from a user experience it just means that you have so much more that you can play with and there's so much more um integration you can do with conventional applications or conventional accounts or conventional um conventional payment means and it means that you can start to merge these two well together blockchain based accounts and PB or or traditional banking accounts um and you you you can play the uh with the interation a lot more but also you can have more interoperability so I think vitalic spoke on this a lot it is the potential is really big
I think we're only beginning to take the first steps to it where I think it will go uh is uh I had this this I said this years ago that we're moving to was the world of wallet so so no longer will our accounts be uh our bank accounts be that relevant and sore codes uh no longer will our credit card accounts be relevant but but but uh and no longer will our driver's license be that relevant what will happen is you will have an identity or you have an identity wallet and in that wallet will will be all of your credentials your driving credentials your travel credential cral your payment credentials and and basically you move towards the world especially where you get into the metas and we get more Dynamic and we get more real time uh where you know you will be asked you know to authenticate your age in which case you have an issued credential well you know this and and uh you know you can say Okay Jack's over
18 or David's over whatever you know does Jack have the ability yeah does Jack have the ability to does he have a traval credential which allows him to enter the US does he have it and you move into this new automated World um and and and you move to to wallet I believe the account extraction is the beginning of that move I I think it's the beginning of a move to the world of wallet but those wallets in the beginning we thought those wallets would be crypto wallets and they would only be used on chain now we're realizing that those wallets need to interact and interoperate uh with uh uh the 4.5 billion digital wallets that we have in the real world right they need to work with Apple pay and Google pay and other types of wallets and I think I think account abstraction is the beginning of being able to have that match and that is where you get the big boom because essentially what it does it will make crypto and tokens
more accessible to real world real world transactions but it will also uh uh make real world payments yeah more accessible to crypto and blockchain users and that is when you start getting into math adoption yeah I mean the idea of having like credentials separated and sad across the board you know the best kind of use case of this for everyday users is going to the airport like the idea of having my covid passport here my Visa here like my travel documents here it's just ridiculous how many different checks do I need to do everything should be on one wallet like you say and I really love that use case and you kind of see how that extends to iot devices in a way as well and I I really like that one of the things passport or the perbal one of the the things that you mentioned there David was around the integration with traditional systems and and interoperability and a big thing I think especially for for you know web3 philosophies and companies based
on web 3 is how they kind of go to establish companies and establish systems and obviously you're part of a big establish established company I want to know what your experience has been exploring web 3 as part of that uh yeah I I think this is um a key point so so so a lot of the web tree at the moment um I think there's two types of web three so there's the self-sufficient web three so these are the sort of layer one layer two protocols B nfts where you you're creating your own business in web3 and you're not in fact you're you're probably against Enterprises and big systems they represent everything or against and then you've got the other side of web3 which is looking at how it can be implemented in big business and the two don't necessarily go together because there is a school which wants to replace big business and what they do with with a with with decentralized methods and then you've got some which are looking at how you
can make the um I think we're getting closer to a sort of Middle Ground um where um I mean even if you look at Dy 2.0 is looking at how defy can work with some of the established Trad by companies um if you look at the identity now you've got the the European guys coming with the identity wallet on one side you've got self- sover identity from from web3 you've got tokens now and and real real world tokenization which is tokenization which is being pushed by Banks interestingly you've got cbdcs you've got more recently we work with uh companies on tokenized deposits which is where you can tokenize currency in your bank account and and and then exchange that for onchain token like etherium or or whatever um so I think you're starting to meet them um there has been a lot of Suspicion I think there's been a big mistake on the web fre site uh in that the the approach yeah you had an idealistic approach which is that we're going to get
a rid of all intermediaries everything will be decentralized and even in that world when you actually get down to it you know even the most decentralized platform ends up going to a centralized middle right it's still there right there's very very little pure de centralite like you're in the for example in ethereum right exactly um and yeah so so you've got that and I think the mistake they made was that when they designed the app it's like okay you're going to everyone's going to come and get an ethereum wallet or everyone's going to come and get a blockchain wallet and you're all going to buy our tokens and that's how it's going to work right and they didn't really think about as a service uh you know trust as a service or blockchain as a service or tokens as a service you know which can integrate with with the establish it was it was more about everybody's going to come to work and I think that was a mistake I think that's reflected in the
fact that you only have 300 just over 300,000 crypto wallets in operation despite all the brilliant things we've done with nfts and Defi and and AFF tokenization and then on the other hand you've got the established World which are people of this and and they're never going to give up all their EIP syst Erp systems and take that approach right because they they they they lose some control um I think some of the things I'm seeing now is as a service so so a lot of people are looking at trust as a service or nfts as a service or whatever way it can be built into existing business models I think that that that's helpful um but I also don't want web three to lose that that that revolutionary aspect where it's challenging how Finance is done it's challenging how identity's done it's challenging how how tokens challenging how Money's been raised because that has really helped to get us where we are so I'm kind of torn between the two on the one hand
I you know I believe that web tree should make itself more integratable with uh with with established business and I think that is happening um but on the other hand I do really respect and I'm excited about the Revolutionary aspect of web threee and I think it's shown us I mean who would have thought that an organization could be run by and governed by a smart contract the D who who would have thought that who would have thought that Finance could be completely automated with smart contract who would have thought that so so some of the things that that web stre has done is absolutely remarkable and I think it's only the beginning um but we do need to see more of the middle ground where we bring the established into web3 and vice versa yeah you're totally right I mean I think the term that I'm seeing more and more is web 2.5 and I have the exact same mindset as you of you is like we need to bring these big Enterprises on
a journey right and the journey is not change everything all of a sudden drop what you're doing and move to this web three that's revolutionary because they're all obviously so risky us no one wants to do that but more and more you're seeing people I mean it's like the the user experience right like I talk about CPT all the time but chpt the technology wasn't that crazy like it was the user experience that really nailed it people could easily adopt it and see the value straight away and I think the idea of this web 2.5 that takes people on a journey and shows efficiencies and shows tangible benefits real time without changing too much is the best way to get there as long as like you said we don't lose sight of the end goal which is this maybe web three Paradigm that a lot of and that doesn't mean anarchism there's always going to be trusted authorities that have to you know manage and set up the protocols peer-to-peer but it does mean efficiency
and I'm really excited for that no I agree totally I agree told me and I I think it's funny because you know you you even mentioned like the the the kind of Grassroots crypto web three people I think web 2.5 is still something that is an Asma to them but I think a lot of people you know as you say right say there's a mistake being made in this assumption that Enterprise adoption is bad you know a lot of the people who just think Bitcoin huddle to the Moon Etc I think they they miss the point that the more Enterprise adoption you have of the underlying as you call the self-sufficient web 3 which I really like as a term I've not heard that one before the more Enterprise adoption of that you get the more valuable the underlying change should be in theory right the more it anchors in a real world that should that should indirectly have a consequence on them they should it secure the network it should attract more miners it
should attract more Capital to securing the network so I think they they're really missing that point right I I think if I think that was the that's that's the biggest shortcoming we've got so far but there's been so much positive um you I think we're just starting to see the the beginning of it um I was having some conversations earlier today and and they were saying well how do you see you know web3 working with uh iot and uh and uh Ai and uh metaverse and all of these things and I said well what's actually happening if we take a step back is we're we're actually seeing the emergence of a new infrastructure infrastructure used to be electricity and and hard phone M and there then you know we start to see infrastructure as fiber you know carrying data and then we start seeing infrastructure as the mobile or cellular network and and actually that that that's fine but now there's a new type of infrastructure coming and that new type of infrastructure will be
blocking layer ones which will start moving with mobile and it will start becoming part of the core infrastructure um you know that that could be used by businesses and people uh and then the metav US um you becomes in my view an operating system uh that that allows applications to build on that uh on that infrastructure and um I think that's where we're going right we've got a new infrastructure uh and these layer one protocols and Layer Two protocols will be part of that infrastructure uh going forward uh so I see that as very um exciting um and and and and and I I believe we're seeing the evolution I keep on saying you know I was on I was saw the posting this week um you we can look back on on this day in 2023 uh that the last 25 years um have been maybe the technologically um Advanced or Technologic it's been the biggest technological change in the last 25 um you know we've seen Cloud we've seen web 3 we've seen
web 2 we've seen uh so many Technologies mobile um you know Edge comput yeah I'm missing for big ones but we've seen some massive yeah uh Technologies we've seen some massive changes in the way we do things I me who would have thought 20 years ago that you could Bank on your app buy cars on your app travel on your app do every I mean there's an app for everything you that you do that's a massive Revolution if you showed that to your grandfather or your great-grandfather they they would think we're crazy right and that's been a massive Revolution but I think it's only the beginning because now you start adding blockchain you start adding a new Dynamic of interoperability when you start adding AI you start adding a new um Dynamic of intelligence uh which is 24/7 and you start adding metab you start a new adding a new dimension of experience or part of the infrastructure and you're you're you're you're saying to yourself okay where is this going to go um you
know what is the next layer of uh you know of of change and I believe that that that next layer of change uh is going to be um Ai and the metav uh you know uh brought together by web Tre and I believe honestly that um that the metas you very negative headlines this year it was top of the hype cycle 18 months ago now it's the bottom of the hype cycle but it's not going anywhere because essentally the the the metaverse in my view will become the new web browser it's going to become the new uh interaction point for humans uh businesses to interact with uh with content and Ai and I believe that uh that the metabat will also be AI on Earth uh so uh when you think about AI replacing millions of jobs or becoming the new tool for millions of people um they need an interaction point they need a means to to interact with ai ai needs a body it needs an environment and that's where the metaverse comes
in but we also need to trust the beta we need to trust the the the AI actors in in our universe we need to yeah the Deep bait the chance for deep bait becomes uh a lot higher and security becomes more important and it needs to be dynamic and and we need trust and that's where blockchain comes in and we also need a currency um you know that can go across boundaries and I believe that's where blockchain comes in so it's an exciting New World we're heading into I I believe the digital asset broker brings the machine part um to that so it brings the machines uh that generate data uh and can buy and sell services to this new um and I believe uh you know the digital asset broker will you know it provides identities and security for devices that I also would like to extend that to AI going forward as well when you um when you told me you were a gamer and you started talking about metaverse and AI I
thought you were going to be talking about fully immersive MPCs you know custom dialogue all this kind of stuff but no um as my question was actually going to be so what are you most excited for in the future with all of these things coalescing is there one use case you're like wow that is going to be killer that's a really good question so so so I think I think my excitement relates to my frustration I think we touched on it earlier I see a world where you've got two two streams I think this is paid out even when you watch the news you've got the stream of of sort of digital native people uh who who believe you can do everything with your mobile phone we don't print uh yeah we don't might paper document we believe that everything could be done digitally and we're actually right because when you look at it everything is done digitally there's some code behind everything we do uh but we also coexist with this Victorian age paper
system where somehow you still need to show a document to rent a car you still need to show a paper uh Drive uh passport to get Street border control you still need to have a copy of a paper utility bill uh to get Finance and and all the rest and you're thinking well this doesn't make sense because behind all of those paper documents is a digital you know a digital system which which needs to be informed and and and and what I'm most excited about is eliminating the paper eliminating the document uh eliminating the the remnants or the leftovers of the file based document system and going to a truly digital world uh where essentially I can move seamlessly uh between physical environments you know with just my identity and and having that authenticated automatically but also vially I can go across platforms without passport or without password uh because my digital identity yeah and my credentials are issued and they can be verified automatically I believe when we move to that that is going
to be the single most transform formative technology we have decentralized V identity and verify the credentials because it will change it will change the world from a trustless world where everything is about proving who you are proving where you are proving how much money you've got proving you you haven't defaulted on payments proving that you've got a a travel credential proving you've got a driving credential to actually processes where actually it's not they trust less weal but it's they trusted weal because I can trust the verify your credentials easier I don't have all these people checking stuff right all of that's done automatically uh with the identity protocol and and and that will then give R to a completely new experience which is fit for the digital world and fit for the metab and fit for me to be able to go from a a gaming platform uh to a social media platform carrying my identity carrying my credentials uh carrying my digital uh my my my digital assets uh and being able to have
consistency uh in my identity and and and possibility of those assets across all of them yeah that excites me yeah that's really interesting you say it and you pitch it like that right because we've been talking about iot machine to machine the whole time but what you're describing there is a fundamentally human problem that you're you're looking to solve with this right and I I completely agree and I'm sure Alex does as well because we talked at length about digital ID on the show we see that as you know very much also infrastructure fundamental to the Future digital economy right and then after that once we've got that because I can see why that's the what you're most excited for because this needs to be underpinning lots of other things um and I have to ask you right because a previous episode we talked about device payments and things I I mentioned a kind of crazy futuristic theory about what kind of world we could live in and I want to hear it from you
based on what you're doing is this crazy so I was thinking about uh world where you have drones flying around and instead of having kind of big stock orders coming into shops you have just these drones buzzing around with stock all the time and then you have the the machines in the shops talking to drones telling them oh I need a new pint of milk in my in my fridge cabinet or something is that a crazy world or is that the kind of thing that you think device to device real time iot data can possible I I believe that that that is precisely why uh the digital a broker was designed um I believe AI has now made that even more possible because uh we we we I call them um what did I call uh well I I think I call them economy of things algorithms right uh but but uh know I believe in the future there'll be different algorithms for different use cases and different sectors um and those algorithms will will
basically be um the the the things that I use to to send a drone to a specific uh supplier or a specific buyer using realtime data right uh oh yeah I call them monetizable event right so so so these algorithms will will basically detect monetizable events so this this data has a Val value now because this person needs it right uh you know this location is important to this insurance company or this retailer or this uh yeah this drone company uh and and uh and and I believe that AI will be the glue or the Middle where uh where these uh monetizable event algorithms can start to to to link these devices together dynamically as you so so so um clearly outline Jack so I I believe that that is the future um but there's one thing we haven't discussed which is regulation uh and uh insurance and uh and uh all of these compliancy things that uh gdpr you know which are are you are in some ways barriers to these things happening you
know I think the technology is there I think the technolog is there for a lot of things now um I think some of the barriers are getting the regulatory environment and the legal environment and the finance environment and the uh you know and the insurance environment to to buy into and I think that's starting to happen uh because they can save money there's business opportunities there and I think that's the last piece of the jigsaw we need to to to you know make make some of this a reality yeah and as techies we tend to ignore the regulation stuff right we find it a bit boring but it's so important like you look at autonomous vehicles how long's the tech been there how long's the data been there to prove that it's much safer but there's a regulatory barrier I think a lot of it is kind of fundamental human psychology of not wanting to trust a machine and if you know one Tesla car crashes into a person or all Tesla car is dangerous
there an accountability thing there but we could jump into the regulation all that kind of stuff for quite a while I just want to thank you for helping you know justify Jack's dream of being delivered milk by a drone has been pestering me for a while now asking if I can design him a drone that delivers milk to his door say like that it is weird thank you maybe he'll be a bit patient there and not ask me to to to create one of those but yeah David this would be incredible that we're coming to the the closing sections of uh of the show now and we have some two standard questions that we like to ask our guests to kind of compare and contrast as we kind of progress through the uh through the podcast so the first one is in one sentence what is web 3 to you trust and opportunity that is the most concise answer we've ever had and I like that very much thank you the second one is if
you could choose anyone Dead or Alive to sit down and discuss web 3 with who would it be and why Steve Job oh nice you just want to listen though you just listen and let him talk he's the master I like that one a lot yeah I I feel like if Steve Jobs was still with us he would be winning the web three the web 3 race right now so and I can't believe we haven't had that one yet that's crazy yeah he's uh St Steve Jobs always but Sora he could imagine a future that others couldn't be and I think um with the input and the ingredients that we've got now you I'd be really excited to see what future he imagine definitely well with that thought I think that's a really good place to end David it's been an absolute pleasure to talk to you and thank you for validating my dreams as Alex said So yeah thank you for joining us David and thank you to those listening wherever you may be
join us next time to untangle a little bit more of web three my my pleasure thank thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Infrastructure & IoT · Business & Society