Episode 69

Web3 x Deck-building with Justin Gary

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this week's episode of Untangling Web3, we're joined by Justin Gary, the visionary behind the innovative trading card game, Solforge Fusion.

With decades of experience in game design and a passion for blending physical and digital gaming experiences, Justin dives into how Web3 is revolutionizing trading card games through blockchain technology.

Key Highlights

  • Transition to Web3. Justin shares his journey from traditional game design to embracing Web3, highlighting the unique opportunities and challenges this technology presents for trading card games.
  • Solforge Fusion's Unique Mechanics. The game combines trading and deck-building mechanics with unique digital assets, making each player's deck a one-of-a-kind collection that can be traded on the blockchain.
  • Economic and Community Impact. Discussion on the economic models within Web3 games and how Solforge Fusion fosters a community-driven approach, allowing players to influence game development and future content.

This episode sheds light on the transformative impact of Web3 on traditional gaming, particularly in the deck-building and wider trading card game space.

Justin's insights into the integration of blockchain technology highlight significant advancements in gameplay innovation and community engagement. His vision for Solforge Fusion not only enhances player ownership but also sets a new standard for interactive and immersive gaming experiences in the Web3 era.

Learn more about Solforge here: https://solforgefusion.com/how-to-play

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of the entangling web 3 podcast today we're incredibly excited to be joined by Justin Gary a truly distinguished figure in the gaming industry and CEO stoneblade entertainment if you don't know him already Justin is the design Guru behind both the World of Warcraft Miniatures and the Marvel vs DC Trading Card Games along with many many more with 20 years of game industry experience behind him Justin is now forging A New Path into web 3 with his new game Soul Forge fusion co-created with Richard Garfield the legendary designer of Magic the Gathering Soul Forge is pioneering a new approach to unique deck building card games backed by the salana blockchain so without further Ado let's find out more from the man himself welcome to the show Justin really excited to be here thanks for having me the pleasure is all ours Justin we've uh we've been really looking forward to this for a long time how are you though first and foremost I'm doing great I'm doing great I'm actually down here

in medine Columbia I've been uh doing the digital Nomad thing for a while um only got another couple days here but it's been it's been wonderful the weather's been great and uh get to launch really cool projects so it's been fun yeah you're really rubbing it in there Jack and I based in London so we look at a window and it's not so fun um let's kick it off like so we typically don't go into people's backgrounds because I I don't know people tend to just want the meat of the episode they want to learn things they want to find out you know what the topic at hand is but I've got an interest in gaming like I used to be a huge Yu-Gi-Oh fan Collectibles fan used to be very into World of Warcraft so when I was looking at your background doing my research listen to the Tim Ferris episode I was like God we have to really go into this guy's like origin story effectively and you've got the classic story philosophy

major you you know Magic the Gathering world champion you went to law school and then eventually you got into the world design you know it's the cat classic kind of Orthodox character Arc but before we get into all this stuff could you talk a little bit about that like I really want to know like how that happened what motivated you to move into the world of game design yeah yeah so you know you kind of hit some of the highlights but really for me uh you know I was always passionate about games my my family would get together and you know we play Cutthroat games of Monopoly around the kitchen table uh all the way up till you know discovering Dungeons and Dragons and playing that with my friends when I was in my early 13 14 years old and then discovering magic when I was 16 and I just took to it right away I mean it was something that I was just so amazed that there was this this game that you could

play but also that you could kind of create and design as you played right every single new pack you opened was this magical Discovery moment and then you could build and craft deck that fit your personality and then discover new things when you played against other people and I basically eat slept dreamt in Magic and within a year of discovering it I became the youngest ever US national champion um and so it became a all of a sudden this is like a real thing and I started traveling around the world and playing tournaments in Rome and Tokyo and I mean I'm still in high school while this is happening right and so now all of a sudden I make enough money to pay my way through college I stopped you know flipping burgers and working at the little local Deli I it was really really was very transformative um and so it was this thing I'm so grateful for I get to make friendships that I still have to this day and uh but you

know for whatever reason I still did not see it as as a career right I still did not see it as something that was like a life's forever thing it was just I was playing games and I was having fun uh and that's where the law school part comes in right and this is my parents were both lawyers it was always like okay yeah go play your silly games that's fine but you know you're you're a lawyer you're going to be a lawyer and uh it took me a year of law school at NYU Law where the weather was not as nice as is here in uh in medine and I remember and you know I S that Not only was I just like miserable but I was so unhealthy my body was rebelling against me I I've just told the story before where I literally threw my back out from Reading like literally just in the library get up throw my back out I'm out of commission for two weeks and thank God at

some point that summer because of my magic career I got the opportunity that some friends who had I had known from that time invited me to come when we were working on the original versus trading card game that Marvel and DC Trading Card Game that summer so instead of working in a law firm I went to San Diego and got to go work on games and just really came alive again and really felt that passion for design and it was something that by the way I had to like learn the hard way because designing games is very very different than being good at playing games being good at playing games is one certain kind of skill figuring out how you design games and how you craft and experience people totally different skills so I was thrown into the deep end but I really loved it I spent all of the time I could studying asking question questions of designers people I knew eventually I was able to learn enough and launch projects there I turned

that into my book called think like a game designer and launched my own company um about five years later we launched our deck building game Ascension and then there's another part of the story which is how Soul Forge gets started but I'll pause there it feel like I've been rambling a little bit but it's definitely been it's been an interesting Journey for sure no don't worry we're gonna get on Soul Forge and everything that came after all this stuff but I think yeah on all my kind of like you know the the little bit of research I've done on you the big decision point was seemed like you when you were in law school and that was going to be the future right the stable future and all of a sudden you were thrown into the game design world as an intern and you didn't have the experience classic kind of impostor syndrome imagine became apparent but you had the passion for it and I think that is so important even though you didn't have

the expertise and what's already coming through and I imagine will continue to come through this episode is the passion for the thing you're doing and passion is more important in my mind than almost anything else and yeah that I think that's something that's going to become apparent in the rest of the episode hopefully yeah that's right you know like my passion drives me you know it's it's it's my the sort of my values in life it's love wisdom and courage right and this love is is represent being L with what you do being really passionate about what's going on this wisdom in saying look I'm trying to get better right I've made a lot of stupid mistakes and I'm sure I will make many more and I'm trying but I'm trying to learn from those things as I iterate and then the courage part is the thing that really I think a lot of people misunderstand because that fear that I felt when I left law school I mean remember this is is the kind

of thing that like I've destined to do since I was born I didn't know what the path was like on the other side I knew that my family was going to be disappointed I was leaving this like safe steady path but in reality what I was afraid of was all elcer right in if I wanted to I could have gone back to law school the next year right I would have lost at most a year of my progress and and and that's all that was really at stake maybe a little bit of embarrassment but on the other side there's a different kind of fear and that fear is never taking your shot never trying to follow your dreams never trying to live your passion and if I went through and 50 years from now I was looking back and saying oh well this is it I never even got to see if I could have succeeded I never got to see if I could do that that's what you should really be afraid of and

so learning to really Channel your fear in the right way is a really important part of why I'm here where I am and willing to take the risks that I do because each piece of it is like okay well what would I how would I feel if I didn't do that thing how would I feel if I didn't push that boundary whether that be with you know leaving law school or quitting my dream job as a game designer to start my own company or jumping feet first into web 3 or all the different pieces of it right each one of them is something where I'm like all right I'm going to face the fears of of potential failure of embarrassment of whatever because if what's more important to me is that I I push those boundaries and and do what's what I'm excited about and passionate about yeah that's really inspiring and what's What's the phrase that comes to mind you know like you miss 100% of the shots you don't take right so I

think if if there's an industry where you have the the shot takers it's probably web 3 and and you know people who are actually putting themselves out there um but before we do jump into all the web 3 side of things I want to take a moment to pause and just kind of lay the groundwork for what what are these deck building games exactly because we've talked a lot about gaming on the show in the past we've talked about you know mostly in the video game sphere and I think this is really interesting so when you say deck building I think of something like Yu-Gi-Oh as Alec mentioned I remember going and buying packs at the local Corner Shop every week and and begging and begging to buy a new pack and that's that's what comes to mind but for the uninitiated people who don't know what these games are what they're all about can you just give us a really brief 101 you know what are these kind of games and why people love

them yeah yeah I'd love to so so we distinguish a couple different terms here um because deck building is part of it but there's one that's that speaks to a specific genre of games so there's trading card games and collectible card games those terms are used interchangeably and then deck building games which are slightly different and I'll explain what both are so a trading card game is a game where all of the cards are not the same for each player so typically speaking you will buy random packs of cards you will like you buy baseball cards or any other collectible right and you open up those packs of cards and based on the cards that you have versus the cards your opponent has you'll build a deck of cards that you construct you will build a deck and then you'll play that against other people and different rules about which cards you're allowed to use or play with that's kind of you know can vary from game to game but the basic idea is my

collection of cards is different than your collection of cards and I build a deck out of my collection and you build a deck out of your collection Magic the Gathering was the very first of those games and that was it started the whole genre and other games like Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokemon and others kind of followed suit with the same formula slightly different rules but the basic idea is that the whole game is not contained in one box and not everybody has the exact same collection and so there's this fun of collecting and Rarity and chasing after this cool card you want there's the fun of the creativity and the building part of like how do you what kind of deck do I want and then there's just the core of the game experience the fun that you have of just playing a strategic game what I like to describe it for those that are uninitiated is imagine if you had a game that was like crossed between chess and poker but you got to decide

what your starting cards and starting pieces were and that would give you a close approximation of what a trading card game is now a deck building game is slightly different a deck building game is actually the game I'm probably most well known for called Ascension is a deck building game and the you literally the whole game is the process of building a deck so imagine if instead of like a game like magic or Yu-Gi-Oh where I'll collect cards from buying packs and you'll collect cards from buying packs we'll build our decks before we start playing and then we'll start playing a deck building game is we all start with the exact same deck of cards and we actually acquire cards during a game so instead of having to buy packs and packs of cards I would just buy one box of things so ension you can download for free and play for free or you buy one $40 box if you want the tabletop version and the the game itself is a game of building

your deck and so that's kind of a genre that evolved out of the trading card Game World it appeals to the same sort of audience but it's not exactly the same um and you'll see when we get to it why Soul Force Fusion Richard Garfield the Creator magic and me the Creator Ascension have created what we call a hybrid deck game which sort of takes the best of both worlds in ways that we can talk about later I mean that's really exciting like I'm already starting to see the overlap between these style of games moving into the digital world and and how nfts can start to empower that but like said with Jack before we get on to web 3 blockchain all this kind of stuff what can you kind of highlight from traditional gaming both physical and digital when it comes to these deck building games what kind of issues do we see in the traditional sense of these games yeah so so at its core right fun you know your there's a there's

a phrase I really love uh it's a you know your greatest strength is also your greatest weakness um and that's true in a lot of these game categories you have to understand your business model and the the system that you build around it dictates the fun of the game and it also dictates a lot of the problems that you're going to have so for example in a game like magic the Gathering it's really fun and cool to be opening up packs of cards and collecting super rare cards and having an opponent that sees a card that you've never seen before or plays a card you've never seen before um but on the flip side the problem some of the problems are like okay well if the cards are super rare and hard to chase then it could be very expensive to play if you played Yu-Gi-Oh at all you maybe you had to chase after some of those expensive cards I mean now a day some of the old the most expensive magic cards are

worth millions of dollars it's kind of wild right and that's that's so that's one kind of you know cool thing because they can be cool Collectibles but also can be a problem if people want to kind of play and compete and get into it in addition there's been an interesting phenomenon over the years when I started playing to date myself a little bit here uh the it was the early days of the internet right so you could actually still open up packs of cards and never have seen that card before in your life nowadays the spoilers are out before the sets are even released everybody knows everybody else's cards and in fact the generally speaking the strategies are all broken down beforehand like people the best players will have the best decks and you'll basically consolidate around maybe three or four decks if the environment's healthy like that the Everybody Plays the same strategy with a few variations and so everybody's just copying everybody else whereas in my day I mean when I won my

US national championships I just had my home brew deck it was my custom deck that I just brought to the tournament and won but nobody had ever seen it before cu that's very very rare nowadays um so so that's kind of the one of the challenges is finding that balance between collectibility and Innovation and Discovery and the kind of hive mind and making the game accessible and helping to support players who don't necessarily want to spend tons of money making it fun for everybody at each level of the process and deck building games were an attempt one of the attempts to solve that because it's a complete box game everybody's on the same equal footing but you you know once play it a few times you already know everything that's in the box so you don't have that same sense of Discovery and openness and so there's some you know positives and negatives to both um so that kind of just lays the groundwork a little bit about what do I as a designer I

think about when I'm working on these kinds of games yeah that's super interesting that you know essentially the information age right the web web one and web two whatever you want to call it kind of changed the nature of these games and how you approach them right you're saying that being able to know what the best cards are there's no spoilers anymore people can analyze decks you know even people I know people watch uh videos of tournaments of these kind of things as well to kind of learn about the strategies and things so there was obviously a shift when the internet itself started so we're we're now talking about the next phase of that Evolution right so what is the impact of web 3 for these things now there's one trivial link that we should at least acknowledge right because with with the link with magic the Gathering so people may have heard of Mount GA The Exchange that's uh that's the exchange that went bust and the guy originally had built it to trade

uh M Magic Gathering trading cards right so that was that's one kind of trivial link that's and for some people that'll be all they know about where the Two Worlds intersect so where for you do you see them intersecting in a meaningful way right from a technology perspective why do you think they can complement each other all right so there's a lot of layers to this answer but I'm going to give you the basic one right which is at its core there is no better game system in the world to cross over and show the value of web 3 than a trading card game and its variations because in a traditional game you own like I have a box of Monopoly at home right trying to turn the car or the you know the top hat into an nft is ridiculous like who why are we doing this like it's just a game I play the game it's not collectible it's its own thing but for a trading card game I'm already used to the

idea that I own cards you don't that I could sell those cards to you trade those cards to you that we would have collections matter and the process of collecting and the process of ownership is an important part of the fun of the game it's intrinsic to it and so I can hand you a card that you can play or I can let lend you a deck to play play and you might let trade cards with me and that's part of the fun to be able to do that digitally makes perfect sense and what's in happened over time and again this evolved as the internet evolved is that the big players right magic Arena and uh Hearthstone and other games they force you to play in a w Garden they don't let you trade they don't let you get things out of your account like they are they are controlling everything and keeping it in and that has prevented players from doing what's Perfectly Natural for these games which is to be able to trade

and sell and collect and really own your your collection so that's that's like at the Baseline level it's one of the reasons why web 3 was an obvious next step for trading card games and an obvious value out because my collection has value I should be able as a player to unlock and control that value not the creator of the game it should be you know there's a lot more layers but that's the fundamental one I think everybody can follow that that's like a key part of the process yeah I definitely get the trading card games and having basically these unique nfts right to represent uniqueness in the digital space like I remember in the early Yu-Gi-Oh days going to nerd out a little bit here collecting the god cards and having like these versions of the god cards and having no real way to know that they were authentic and having no real way to prove to anyone else that they were authentic when actually use them I think one of them was fake

in the end it's been at50 pound when I was like 16 years old which is a lot of money right and then being able to translate that you that authenticity and now I have no idea where those cards are and I couldn't get them back obviously they were just printed and they're there for some reason so that's a really obvious use case in relation to trading card games can you like I don't really understand the connection right now to deck building games so how can web 3 empower the deck building game side as well yeah so in this world I think uh the pure box deck building game I don't think right now has a lot of value for web 3 at a baseline but what now we got to start talking a little bit about Soul Forge Fusion because Soul Forge Fusion is trying to find somewhere in between right and so to give now a little bit of the history and the backstory so we can understand why we're here and why I

think this is so important um when I I mentioned I started my company I launched the deck building game Ascension right and then uh I got a chance to go to a developer conference called pdev and Richard Garfield Creator M of the Gathering was giving a talk so of course I'm going to go to see the talk from the master right this is this is this is I'm gonna learn from the master here and at the end of the talk somebody asks a question says what's your favorite game right now and Richard says Ascension my game and I just lose I mean I literally jump up like a kid and just like woohoo in the back of the audience and like the whole room laughs right but it gives me that opportunity to start talking to Richard and we end up chatting after his talk and we go for about three hours of talking about what we want to design next now this is back in 2011 and that was the original what we created

then was the original version of Soul Forge which was a perfect combination of trading card games and deck building games and the basics are you build your deck of cards and then you every time you play a card you level up that card that level up card goes to your discard pile and then you shuffle your deck every couple of turns and now you get access to your higher level card so you're actually building your deck as you play but you've got some pre-building done like you would a trading card game You're Building deck as you play like a deck building game and that became the original version of Soul Forge then that was the first game to come a trading card game ever designed for mobile designed for web like built from the ground up to be a digital trading card game we took the best of what we knew from the physical world and brought it into the digital world now Soul Forge Fusion I wanted to do the exact same thing with

web three designs and so what we've done is we've created what I I pr mentioned called a hybrid deck game where we actually algorithmically generate each deck of cards so they are 100% unique no two people ever have the same deck right so when I talked about the problems of a trading card game the problems of design it one of them is okay you've seen every card because you've seen the spoiler right and generally speaking you're just going to copy whatever strategy other people have well that's not possible in Soul Force Fusion because every deck is one of a kind you can Shuffle any two different decks together to play so you still customize but you can't copy and so now each deck is its own nft each deck is its own oneof one collectible that you can now trade sell buy you can follow its progress as that deck wins tournaments it gets leveled up it gets extra status when you compete in our storyline tournaments you can actually influence the lore of the

world and that story will get custom t tagged to that deck so the deck evolves the nft of it evolves and you can now trade sell and collect that and so we've taken what I felt like was some of the coolest parts of the deck building game genre and the coolest parts of the trading card game genre and now created this hybrid model that now of course benefits we have our own token which allows you to Min the nfts the nfts themselves are all unique and track this data and so now we've been able to really evolve the genre and take the best of the tabletop gaming world and bring it to web 3 and kind of cross-pollinate that's epic so you effectively creating like a digital passport of these decks as they're kind of upgrading progressing all this kind of stuff to create like the entire history that's authenticated verifiable that is so epic one of the things that I saw when I looked into Soul Forge as well was the concept of decentralized

governance you know there's a lot of buzzwordy stuff around Dows how Dows can be implemented like are they actually decentralized is the single point of failure could you talk a little bit about like how it works basically in Soul Forge right now the decentralized governance aspect yeah yeah absolutely so we have a a kind of white paper gbook that's up that describes all the stuff which hopefully we can link to for those I want to go deeper into this right but we're we're we're rolling this thing out in faces and in my mind there is a great place for Community government governance and there's a great place for expert you know kind of expertise leadership right and so I believe that we have the largest portion of our token pool I think it's like 33% or something of our token pool is community controlled and what that means is that the community will be able to vote and make decisions about how what kinds of tournaments do we create how do we F out rewards

what kinds of streamers and partner rewards do we want to do right that's the kind of thing that absolutely should be Community controlled and I'll give you an example right so in uh match at the Gathering right there's a the most popular format right now is called commander and it's a format that was actually invented by fans and played by fans and Wizards of the Coast the main company that makes magic was resistant to it forever they stopped they wouldn't run tournaments for it they wouldn't design cards for it they wouldn't reward it and it took like a years and years of groundwell of support and forcing the issue before wizard was finally like oh okay yeah I guess we'll have those kinds of tournaments I guess we will support those that large community and what should happen is the community should get to decide those things and so that's where the community governance should live and that's what we want to be transferring Community governance over um over the course of the next year

year and a half to be able to have that fully controlled by our players and have Representatives who are token holders have Representatives who are tournament Players have Representatives who are the Casual players and streamers and make sure that each piece has a voice in the way that the future of the game evolves now I differentiate that from things like game design decisions because I've been doing this a long time and Richard's been doing it even longer than me and the truth is that most people think they know what they want from a game design and if you gave them exactly what they want the game would be terrible right people want uh they want to be able to not ever run out of Mana in Magic and get have a perfect uh set of cards you want to be able to always draw the best you have you want to remove variance people say this stuff all the time but that variance and those uh frustrations are in fact some of the best parts

of the game because you have to overcome the challenges and and play with it so the game design portion I believe should still be controlled by professional designers who are trained to do that but the community growth and how the future development of that is done should be controlled by the players and that's the intent is that we will use the web3 technology to help hand that off and allow for a global governments from our player base it kind of um brings to mind what Plato said about democracy and if you give like the every vote to every person in the exact same way like they're going to vote for unlimited food and all food will be gone in like a day basically so I do understand that but I also want to double click on the point around you know feeding the community the community is what is the driving force like communitybased content and user based content is so good because like we said earlier it's all about love and passion they have

love and passion absolute droves so to empower them and give them you know the tools to basically grow that individually in this decentralized way is such a powerful aspect of I imagine you're doing one thing I want to just ask about there is so I know you're based on salana blockchain but you were talking about token issuance and like growth within the network and all this kind of stuff so do you have like a native token that's specifically for soul Forge that's based on salana is it separate like a colored token type thing could you that's correct yeah we have a soul Forge token that we have aird dropped uh to our community and in fact most salana holders uh I think I forget what the number is but there's a massive number of Salon holders are eligible for the airdrop a massive number of players of other three games um like axi infinity and parallels and a bunch of others are all eligible for the airdrop so if you go to soulforge fusion.com uh

you can click on the claim airdrop link there and see if you're eligible for it and our goal is that everyone you know we're not selling these tokens we're not like trying to monetize that proc we're just trying to get people to come and participate in the economy come and participate in the game the game is totally free to play and available now this is another big distinction between us and most games in web 3 let's be honest uh we are not vaporware you can play us right now on Mac and PC on Steam totally for free uh we have everything that's there and it and you know great gameplay was first right so we just launched it in Early Access back in April we are now launched our web 3 token you know if really at the beginning of September and the nft functionality and trading functionality but we had to make sure that the game was great and then we just distribute the web three to get web three people excited and participating

and then we believe very much that that will be the kind of key to not just our growth in because again this game exists as a physical table top game it exists as a web 2 game for people that don't want to pay attention to web 3 and as of just now it is now available as a web 3 game and all of those things connect together I think that's that's so important you know just touching on the fact that you said you know it's not Vape web because yeah in in web three games we see that so often people put the cart before the horse they say I want to make a web 3 game because I want to do something with tokens I want to do something with nfts I like the web three side and then they completely forget to design a fun game around this we've seen this time and time again with kind of both games coming out whether or not they mean to or you know it's actually intentional

that's a big problem right and then if you're bringing because I wanted to touch on the community cross-pollination aspect because I think you mentioned s Forge was a game in its own right before it became s Forge Fusion right so you had a community of players in in the existing game so what's it been like that process taking a player base from the web 2 or the the physical world into web 3 and then cross poting further across other parts of web 3 you know you have people following salana people might be coming in from different chains that kind of thing like what's that been like yeah so it's a it's a it's been very interesting I certainly did not choose the easiest path uh for My Career here um so to give the backstory we had the original version of Soul Forge was the first ever native purely digital web 2 kind of game experience that ran for about five years and then we kind of had to Sunset it we brought Soul Forge

Fusion back in in we just launched the physical version of the game so it was a physically algorithmically digitally printed cards that you could play in October of 2022 and so that we sold you know we had massive Global launch we had people playing all over the world We've Ended up selling about a million decks and every single one of those decks had a QR code that could scan into your online account which at the time didn't do much of anything but once we launched the web 2 account the web 2 game in April now all of those decks can be played in web 2 and now as of September we launched the web 3 aspects now all those decks can be transformed into nfts and played as nfts and un traded sold and you know done all the things you do with true ownership now that process has led to many great upsides and some downsides the upsides of we were able to bring those players over and and access a wide community of

players who have never even been aware of web 3 or were just leery of it for the exactly the reasons we talked about right a lot of rug poles a lot of not real games a lot of you know challenges with trust in this supposedly trustless environment but we got a chance to bring them along for the ride right so when we announced that we were going to web 3 as you might expect we got a lot of hate we got a lot of people that like review bombed our game a lot of people that were very upset and you know felt were very concerned and I made it a point to be very much direct and out in front of it right so I did amas I did spaces I went we have a very active Discord anybody's welcome to join in I'm very active there my team's very active there um you know thousands of people are there talking about soul for fusion and our other games and I answered every question right

there were some that were completely misinformed like oh my God you're going to destroy the planet with the energy usage of this stuff which is crazy it's you know a salon transaction is part of the reason we told Salon is the salon transactions like doing a Google Search right it's the same very very economic economical for the player and economical for the planet energy usage but then there were other concerns that were legitimate right like okay well what happens if my stuff gets stolen right in a classic web 2 economy it's protected and the you know the sort of the the developer can just reimburse you or fix everything in a web 3 world not as much and so we had to add in extra security measures and you know had two-factor Authentication and some other security measures to help protect people and so that discussion really helped to bring the community forward and make them ready for web three and I think that we not only that but also again I've been doing this

for 20 plus years it's not like you know I'm GNA run away and trying to grab a quick fck here right this is this is my career this is my livelihood this is not you know so it helps to build trust and it's a it's a lifetime of building trust not just somebody showing up and saying hey I'm going to make a game trust me uh and uh and so that that has helped as well and then the last piece of this is we made sure that everybody knows this is fully optional all the way through right if you want to play the tabletop game and never want to touch a computer cool you can do that you want to play the web two game and you never want to touch tabletop that's cool too you want to trade web 3 and get involved with that right every piece connects and supports each other but you're not required to be in anyone so I think that's going to what we'll do is just show the

value and that's the best way to bring Web Two audiences over and that's what I think is going to be key to us allowing us to grow uh you know it's great game first to help people actually care and want to be there great Community second is the is the key to helping people stay there and then you know just clear communication um from the developers showing that we are listening showing that we care and showing that that's it's a thing that we're going to grow together that's that's really fascinating as a journey because I think you know not many people will have probably gone through what you've described I think but it is it is almost certainly the right way to do it and you you've probably done a service to web 3 generally into salana by you know doing this the right way having that level of transparency and being highly Hands-On with your your community I think it's a it's a really good way of approaching this kind of project um and

you mentioned the kind of choice to use salana there and and it being related to the energy and things like that I'm kind of curious to step take a step back from okay you've chosen salana but why do you think it's important that maybe blockchain had come along at this point like all when you were talking with Richard about you know the design of the ideal uh card game Trading Card Game debt building game this hybrid model did you at the time you know we're talking 2011 bitcoin's only been around for a couple of years at that point do you think that game realizing this this new hybrid model would have been possible without blockchain or do you think there are some kind of unique properties of what we have in web 3 that really change the game to to use a you know for one of a better phrase for what you wanted to achieve is that really important to you well there's no there were multiple technologies that had to evolve in order

for this to come to fruition right so the the algorithmic printing technology and digital deck creation we couldn't have done that 10 years ago you know let alone in 2011 that that technology didn't exist back then either and blockchain was in such a nent phase in fact I I mean I've I've been a True Believer for a while um probably not since 2016 I'd say for me I really got into to blockchain and I built a blockchain game in 2018 just for fun called block Brawlers um but the technology was so new and it was so expensive I had to build a game where you just had you know minimize number of transactions on the on on the exchange and you know on on the Chain I mean and being able to like it was just a very restricted world and the technology wasn't there and so when I was you know it was not a foregone conclusion that sufor Fusion was going to be for sure on the blockchain it was something I researched

because you know in reality as a game developer you can offer most of the services that blockchain provides you know using traditional web two technologies you can allow people to trade things on a server you can manage it but it's very expensive both in terms of building in terms of the legal and Regulatory infrastructure and it doesn't you know it does require everybody to trust you not to just turn off your servers at some point and so when we researched it and we did a lot you know we talked with all of the you know major chains we had a lot of layer tws we spoke with um salana proved to be both the most cost- effective and the most supportive with the most robust Community uh for us to launch on now we do want to support multiple chains over time in fact we've also done an airdrop to a bunch of ethereum accounts on games that are on ethereum so we are you know we plan to be multi-chain but salana was as

a you know we're a small developer right we I've been doing this a long time but we're not a we're not a huge team uh salana proved to be the best for us to build on their team full disclosure they also invested in our in our project um and so they believed in us from the beginning and we believed in them and that's been a great uh what we call ourselves soulmates uh uh throughout the process what was it you talked said in 2018 you developed a simple like blockchain based game I think that the term blockchain based games are kind of dying out cuz everyone's kind of I don't know they haven't really done so well right as soon as you advertise yourself as a blockchain based game everyone's like oh God this is not going to be fun to play right um what was it initially you talked a bit about the advantages of like supporting Community transparency you know trustless all this kind of stuff was there a certain thing was there

a moment where the kind of the penny dropped you like we really need to push this technology into gaming I think there's a real value add to it was there a certain moment you can recall well for me um you know I I like to live on the edge of where technology can unlock new and better forms of gameplay that's just like I've realized that over time I've always been looking for the crossover between digital and physical I have you know again Ascension was the first deck building game to come to mobile Soul Forge Fusion was the first training card game to to be designed for mobile and for and and and and digital as mentioned was also the first virtual reality deck building game I wanted to be push I saw what was possible with web 3 and again I believe in the long you know we could go deep down the travit hole but I'm a like I'm a True Believer that like what web 3 means is it allows us to unlock

new ways of building communities and growing our Collective action that have never been possible before and so my first foray into games in web 3 and a blockchainbased game was more about me getting to understand the technology and and learn what's possible and I think games are the perfect kind of you know lead in this space because you know games build virtual communities and virtual economies and in interactive systems and get people to collaborate and work together whether that's you know World of Warcraft raid or you know trying to build your farm in Farmville or whatever right like people work together and collaborate to do things and so you it's a it's a low consquences way to be able to try what is it like if we wanted to build you know in disconnected nation states or corporations that are you know Dows and everything that Dow wasn't even a term back then but that concept uh was was very front of mind and so you know I basically at that time I was like

all right let's see what I can do here I understand the concept of a trading card game and love the idea of having cool colle collectibles in this one what if I baked a lot more into those Collectibles they were little block Brawlers they were little like Fighter characters that had different stats you built a team of them you matched them up against another team and it was you know a somewhat more complicated rock paper scissors battle uh to find out what happened with them where your stats mattered and your types of Team synergies you had mattered um and so it was partially for fun partially because I saw the value of a digital collectible object the same way I saw the value of a physical collectible card and partially to be able to learn and grow in that space because I do think it's the future of not just gaming but like society and finance and the things that are really going to matter in the long term well I mean you're totally right

like Gamers they're Pioneers right they're kind of like the Misfits the retr baates who like to push the bound and are willing to take risks on this stuff and the community aspect is so important like and it's it's an obvious kind of target market for this kind of tech stuff which I find so exciting it's why we try and get as many gaming people on this podcast as possible and it's really I love that you like to be at the bleeding edge of technology and work it you know what's the value ad for the game at the end of the day like kind of you've talked about say the nft the idea of this like product kind of passport style for the decks and like starting to integrate the aspects of there and community-driven content and all this kind of stuff what's the future of a soul Forge like outside it can be blockchain based as well or even outside of blockchain to other technology kind of talked about digital physical blending those two kind

of realities what does the future of Soul Forge look like what are some of the big things that you want to incorporate into the game the community yeah so I mean we've we've got a lot of this stuff up on our road map right the most important part for games like this is continued content so we have we just did our most recent release called the last winter back in June we have another release that'll be coming out um in October uh we have a variety of new new cards new content new varieties we're moving to New platforms so as I mentioned we want to be multi-chain so not just to salana but also be able to move to ethereum and to other chains and be cross- compatible we're also looking to move to mobile and be available on Apple and Android devices and so like you know broadening the base uh continuing to create great content is part of it and then the other thing that one of the things I I personally love

uh about the game is the fact that you kind of mentioned this briefly earlier but we have what we call like storyline events and storyline tournaments where players by playing the game can influence the world and the lore of the world and which of the forgeborn which are kind of like our Jedi Commander characters that you play as that which of them becomes more dominant and which uh what types of effects will will appear in future sets so different cards will show up and you get a storyline element that gets we have writers will write and tag it to your deck and I think that's just so cool and to be able to like grow the lore of the world and get people more immersed in it and feel like you really are engaged because again no other game has this ability to say no no no this one-of-a-kind deck has the story attached to it has the lore has the connection and is able to influence what's going on in the future like it's

just a really cool space that I want to continue to build on and there's a lot of other little features and stuff that which is this is exactly where I think the community can help us prioritize you know we want to do you know in-game more in-game tournament features and have more variety of different ways to play I didn't even mention that you can actually take we have also uh a single player algorithmically generated campaign inside the game you could play totally for free so you take your unique decks you play in this campaign you battle monsters you gain XP you get unique powers all that stuff generated unique for you every single time you play uh being able to expand that and add more encounters and more variety and More Story uh is all stuff I'm super excited about because you know it's just super fun and you know it's exact I'm basically making the game that I want to play uh and hopefully there's enough people out there that want to do the

yeah it really sounds it in terms of you know how how exciting and the possibilities that you're opening up with that right I think those are two really powerful concept the idea of user generated content whether that be law whether that be kind of More Design we've seen that a lot in in video games as well with engines being opened up we spoken a lot about that but also that uniqueness of experience not just of the items you're using in in in the decks and having unique decks and cards but having a unique experience I think this is something that is going to be huge in in video games generally going forward the way AI is Advanced to be able to generate Things based on your user input and and become much more intelligent as you play I think is super interesting so you know on that note taking a step back from from what you're doing with soul Forge do you see this movement in web 3 you know you say you're you're kind

of a full believer in web 3 now like us I think um do you see this as part of a bigger shift in in gaming because I think when we've spoken about it before I think we see Gamers as Alex said the Pioneers they're probably more used to the concepts and the the philosophy of web 3 than almost any other demographic so do you think these kind of this is part of that shift and is and is it being kind of Taken and run with by these these Gamers or is something kind of not unique to them well there's there's there's multiple facets to this right so I agree with you that Gamers tend to be on the Forefront um but I also think that Gamers also can turn turn on you very fast uh and they love to hate uh so for if you look at the history of gaming and as different business models became more dominant uh there was always a massive hatred that came with it right so when you move

from a classic I bought this game in the store or I bought a CD or whatever to again to age myself or floppy disc for really age myself uh I buy my game and then it's the whole game to things like subscription models right like World of Warcraft people were like oh my God they're they're raking the money away from us they're doing a terrible thing whereas in fact that allowed them to create a much more immersive world than anybody before and then when premium games became a huge model right for free-to-play games and all of that people were screaming in the streets because oh that's all try to take money from us they're you know it's pay to win like and people got very upset and then that became the dominant model and I think web 3 is another version of this right where there have been some you know both Bad actors as well as people who were totally innocent but you know didn't deliver on their promises and a lot of people

who just tried to shorn web 3 into games where it didn't fit and I think there's been a massive backlash and in part justifiable from the classic web2 Gaming Community and the key to making the shift which I do believe is going to happen is you've got to have the killer products that really show the value and create a good user experience and in my opinion the best way to do this is an optional on- ramping like we're doing with s fusion and that will allow people to kind of come into the space and start to see the value of it because there's no real um you know you can't explain it as much as you want but it's it's really about showing people why this is better for them and they'll start to see that as they say okay no cool I do have real ownership of this stuff or okay cool I can you know earn and my you know I get I get value out of growing this community or I have

the ability to have control over the direction of this game and feel a sense of ownership that is deeper than I could get in another gaming experience and I think as people start to see that come to life then they will be converting over but I think it's been a rocky road because of a lot of those hiccups along the way so you're testing this out right now where you have the option right it's optional to get on boarded with all this web 3 stuff do you think like based on a pure prediction I know it's completely speculative do you think it will be de facto do you think it will be the default in say five to 10 years something like this yeah I think that I think that in five to 10 years for sure most players who play our game will be using the web three elements because again it's just free value for you it's just better for you all right and so I think the fears will go away and

it will become more common in place will it be the case that all games are web 3 games in 5 to 10 years I don't think so I think that it requires the specific kind of game right if I'm G to play a single purchase play RPG game like a balers Gate 3 or you know I'm gonna play something that's a coherent complete experience I don't think I need web 3 for that I don't know whe that web 3 adds value for that but if I'm gon to play a game that does have more growth and collectible objects and things that allow more ownership of land and territory within the virtual world and expanding that and like a second life kinds of things like those kinds of games are very natural and I believe they'll all move to web 3 because that will be better for it and as the the technology gets better again when I made a game in 2018 it was very cost prohibitive to do anything on chain now in 2024

I still can't run the whole game on chain right it's still like incredibly cross behav to do that we're just doing the the exchanges and elements on chain I think once you have the technology get to the point where okay no it actually is economical and cost effective and by default the one thing I love about web 3 is so much of it is open source by default right so you can just build on what's available in a way that was never possible I can't access Blizzard's code for what they're doing I can't access a lot of the different elements in the player bases here that's going to be something that that I think comes by default and so people can build on top of what already exists and access communities that already exist and so that's going to become a natural flow for people to continue to grow and continue to move forward so I think that we will see that Trend and many games will default to web 3 where it makes sense

sense but not all I I mean I love that the kind of the the concept of us generated content built on top of Open Source Code and that's kind of publicly available well sometimes immutable at least there anyway in perpetuity one of the things I remember seeing in the early days of blockchainbased gaming is the idea that every single action was a transaction on chain so every single shot every single movement and some of the people like kind of doing these run throughs of like a single movement takes 10 seconds to get confirmed on J that kind of concept is slowly dying out thank God and people are starting to understand that it's a lot more kind of nuanced than that and actually under the hood typically which I think it should be more and more so we we definitely have some game designers who listen to this podcast and you've kind of gone through this now you talked about some of the potential risks but for those game designers that are trying to integrate

web 3 into their games or build games based on web 3 what are the potential risks that they should be thinking about when doing this yeah so I mean at a Top Line you know most game designers who have play played and if you know if you never built in-game economies before right they can take they takes a lot of attention a lot of time and there's a lot at stake right even when you're just having a a box you know closed system what are your inputs what are your syncs how do you how are people getting access to your in-game currencies what are they being spent for how do those translate into you know player enjoyment in terms of or player power level and how are those things balanced and how do you manage each tier of player like we talked about earlier the kind of you know new player the the minnows versus the whales versus the Sharks right and how do you balance all those things that's really critical and that takes

a lot of experience when you move to web 3 it's like 100x more complicated right because now the tokens and the nfts and everything you're doing are open systems and so certain players this is where you can get you know kind of farming happening in you know the Philippines where they're going to just spend hours doing certain things or nowadays Bots and AI that you have to protect against and you know one mistake can crash your entire economy um and so the the realities of building um I think you need safety valves because nobody's figured this out yet in my opinion I done a lot of research on it nobody has like the answer and so you need to be able to have some safety valves as you're moving through be very thoughtful about how you build your economies and then making sure that your game really does that web 3 really does add value to your game and you're not just tacking it on because you think it's going to be a quick Buck

or you think it's going to be better right what is it that you couldn't do before or that would be worse without web 3 that you could do better with web 3 and then making sure you have some protections when it comes to how are you regulating that economy and then from a player perspective I think you want to make sure that you're also protecting your players because people are not used to especially if you're not a web3 native you're not used to protecting your keys and making sure that your account is locked and secured and making sure that you know once people take ownership you know when I I've had my magic card collection stolen back when I was a kid too and that was that sucked they smashed it in the back of my car took my backpack which was thousands of dollars worth the cars and that was rough but I had insurance and and my insurance paid out for that so that sort of thing doesn't really exist in web 3

right now there's there's not the same level of protection so so you you know people people need to be educated on the protections you as a you know kind of developer need to decide what levels of support and protection you're going to offer or enforce U for your player base to make sure that they're safe and educated about what needs to happen um so those are two major elements to it and then I think uh there's a lot more nuances as as you have to just follow the tech as it evolves because it's a very fast moving space right so which platform and which chain is the right one to move on which tools are available that make things easier and again I think the biggest lesson for me is continually focusing on the user like uiux like the user experience making it like I don't know how many people that have played with you know when you first come into web 3 it's it's pretty intimidating and pretty awful uh it's I hav just

you know there's clearly like a lot of like hardcore developers who went down this road and not a lot of uiux designers but that's gonna get better over time but I think as a as a game designer you need to think about that too like what is the experience of a player who's coming in not as deep into this as you are uh and making sure that that on-ramp is is smooth it's funny I was in the pub yesterday um and I was literally talking about this we were like a room of people and we're were talking about our jobs and all this kind of stuff and there was a couple of ux people couple of developers couple of like crypto people and we were talking about okay how many ux people do you have in like a typical crypto firm it's like not many it's all developers pretty much typically and they're saying where what industry should we pitching to as a new ux developers new UI I was like crypto because everyone knows

that crypto needs more ux and more UI people and I think the maturity is coming but you're totally right like You' hit the nail on the head there we're saying it was always just backend developers just stuck there just developing things that they would assume people wanted and very little engagement with the real world but it is changing I think yeah I definitely see the trends moving in the right direction again we're trying to be part of the solution here right and and I think it's just uh it just takes a while to catch up and it takes a while and I think you you got to talk to the actual customers and actual players right like that at the end of the day people who are deep into web 3 just assuming that gamers are going to want web 3 because web 3 is awesome is a mistake I think you need to be able to show them the value actually show them the value and and have a smooth way for them I

understand when I buy something with a credit card I understand when something's in my account but when I have a wallet and it's different and I can you know have that be stolen or have a different you know what does it mean to work on it have to go to an exchange to get the token all that stuff is stuff we're dealing with very directly right because I mean again we aird dropped our s Forge token to you know our our communities and to other communities that are interested but if you want to get it than that you've got to go find it on an exchange somewhere and there's a whole other process so we're trying to make it clear you know uh how that works and uh it's it's not easy to educate people right now and as the tools get better as the interfaces get better all that's going to become easier so I'm not worried about it in the long term but as a developer who's making games and launching them right

now it's a big deal yeah I think it's really great advice you know for any of those game developers out there and even just for anyone thinking about web 3 in any sphere really you can of hit the nail on the head when you say when you add in web three it can make things 10 hundred thousand times more difficult in some ways and then you ask yourself why are we doing that well it's because there are some really cool benefits to be had from this like all the cool things that you described you know for most of this episode I think they are really exciting and provided that you have designed the game in in a careful thoughtful way such that the you know the players will realize that value they will get something better out of it than just the the traditional web 2 games and I think that's really important but I also love you know bringing it back to how you have this kind of optional uh system right now I

think that's really important right making sure you're never forcing people down that path you want them to kind of Discover It organically so I think yeah that's a really nice way to kind of maybe close the book on on gaming itself and just as we come to the close I really want to ask you you know completely you know throwing gaming out the window just for the ending here and looking more to the future is is there anything that you're really excited about in web 3 that isn't in gaming right just it could be anything could be in any sphere at all any application uh you know any use case or maybe you're just kind of a Bitcoin Maxi under the hood I don't know what is it that gets you out of bed when you think about web 3 other than your game no to me to me like like you know governance in a broader sense is what I'm very excited about right I believe that there is you know that we've sort

of joked about you know just like you know Le how you lead lead a society and I think that democracy is you know is a terrible form of government but it's the best we found so far I think that the ability to have you know variations of some people call like liquid democracy where there's abilities to have people have access to the rights to vote and have access to the ability to you know throw extra currency towards things that you want I could imagine I can have weighted vote systems based on you know every citizen gets a 100 tokens per quarter to be able to assign to projects that they care about and the collective will can now actually be assigned in ways that are way deeper and way more empowering than before right there's a there's a million different ways to do this but right now we have centralized systems that are inefficient many of which were designed hundreds of years ago that require that make it so that most people in America don't

vote at all right and that and and people that the ability to people's voices be heard the ability to have a more efficient way to distribute resources and to be able to kind of call the best of what people are interested in and the client of collective will just like we try to do in things like you know the stock market and how we aot resources in venture capital I think being able to a lot Collective will and a lot governance in ways that are not possible or have not been possible before is something that web 3 can really unlock in a way that's again where trust is critically important right I mean at gaming in one sense trust is yeah it's helpful but like most people didn't have a problem trusting game companies because our interests are all aligned right the game companies just want you to pay them money and give you a good time and you want to pay the money and have a good time right but when you're talking about

governments and like a distributor of resources globally like that's a big deal and there's a lot of reason for people to be bad actors and we've had to have a lot of inefficiencies so to me there's this ability to create collaborative communities that are deeper and richer and uh more uh decentralized is something I'm very passionate about and I think can really change the world for the better I love that I think um a lot of the narrative has kind of been dominated by ai's role in gaming going forward and I'm really glad that you think it's maybe as much if not more decentralized governance and impairing individuals to participate in the community could I get you a really short take on ai's impact on gaming at large yeah so if you want a slightly longer impact uh I have an episode of my podcast called think like a game designer where I talked to Ethan mik who's one of the foremost experts on AI I've just wrote a book called co-intelligence and we go

deep into all of this stuff U but I'll give you my short version is I think it is a we are currently in what I would call a golden age which is AI if you're good at your job it is a way to empower you in ways that were never possible before I can do so much more now uh without you know requiring other resources than I ever could I believe in the long term how much that plays out and how that value is distributed and what happens when AI if it does gets better than all of us at everything that we do um then what I'll tell you is my I'm an optimist by default so there there are nightmare scenarios here but I will tell you my optimistic scenario is that actually gaming becomes more important than ever because in a world where our economic value cannot be we don't we can't really contribute economic value to the world right imagining AI is better than us at everything what we do is we're

going to have in theory a world of Plenty but we're still going to want ways to challenge ourselves and to compete and compare because that's just built into our nature and the best way to do that is games right sports like we just had the Olympics recently and you can run way faster if you have like a motor vehicle but that's not the game the game is we're going to put you in a box and play that game the same way I'm going to play a game like fortnite I'm going to play a game like Soul Forge fusion and so I think a the best case scenario future world of AI is where we have a world of abundance because AI can provide those resources for us and we create games and spaces of play for us to to compete and connect and find Value in ways that were you know previously considered frivolous but will now become the center of our existence as we uh figure out what it means to have value and

be human I love that will that definitely end on that now so we're coming to the closing section now I've learned a lot like I've had a lot of fun during this episode so thank you very much for that um in the the closing section we tend to ask two questions across all our guests this SE like how answers vary and things like this across time and across Industries and all this kind of stuff typically we ask um what is web 3 to you in one sentence but earlier you actually did do a perfect one- sentence answer so I'm not going to repeat that question and we'll probably just copy and paste it here because it was so good and I was like we need to you know save that little clip bite um so the second question I want to come to is if you could choose anyone on the planet you know throughout history or even fictional to sit down and discuss web 3 with who would it be and why and I

thought you might go with Richard Garfield but you've already done that so maybe someone else yeah that's not fair I get that one for free so I wouldn't I wouldn't pick that I wouldn't pick that um I got my first answer I feels like it might be a cliche answer but uh I'm going to go with it because it's my first answer so I think uh Elon Musk would be at the top of my list um I think he has pushed an enormous amount of innovation across a variety of fields I think he is has been he's danced as very Pro crypto and danced back from the edge some and I would really want to know with where he's taking you know the xplatform with how he's building communic he obviously built PayPal or was part of the team that built PayPal how I think he would have the deepest insights in terms of like how it can currently Empower communication and financial technology and uh I think several things that maybe we might disagree

with about him and some of his trolling nature I do think he wants to do good for the world uh at at his core and I would love to sort of see how he feels about it today and how it integrates with the kind of Frontier of technology so that's my that's my answer yeah I think that's a really good one because he does seem to be you know sometimes the darling sometimes the devil of of web throughing crypto and but yeah there are elements that do seem like you know he really gets a lot of the philosophy you know when you're talking about uh micro payments for articles and things on X I think yeah that's a really great choice and by the way it's so just so ironic you know the one time someone gives us a a perfect one sentence answer to that question we didn't even ask for it you just offered it up straight away so maybe that's the key we don't ask that one in the future listen just

it's been such a a great episode I've really really enjoyed this and learned a whole lot from it um Freddy would wants to learn more about Justin and soul Forge will definitely link his profile and the giit book that you mentioned in the show notes and all remains to say is to every listening at home thank you very much for listening and you can join us next time on un tangling web three thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes