Episode 55

Web3 Gaming

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In today's episode of the Untangling Web 3 podcast, we dive into the transformative world of Web3 gaming. With the gaming market projected to reach nearly half a trillion dollars in 2024, it's clear that this industry is booming.

Web3 gaming introduces revolutionary concepts like player empowerment, true ownership of digital assets, and immersive, decentralized virtual economies. Join us as we explore how Web3 is reshaping the gaming landscape.

Key highlights

  • Evolution from Web1 to Web3 Gaming. We begin by exploring the history of gaming from the early days of Web1, through the dynamic, multiplayer experiences of Web2, to the current innovations in Web3. This includes discussions on user-generated content, in-game economies, and the integration of blockchain technologies.
  • Web3 Technologies in Gaming. We delve into how blockchain, digital identity, and NFTs are revolutionizing the gaming industry. These technologies enhance privacy, security, and transparency, while enabling true ownership and interoperability of in-game assets.
  • Immersive Experiences and AI Integration. We discuss the potential of VR, AR, and AI in creating more immersive and personalized gaming experiences. From dynamic NPC behaviors to procedurally generated environments, AI is set to transform how we interact with games.

Web3 gaming is poised to redefine the gaming industry by fostering stronger communities, enhancing player engagement, and enabling true ownership of digital assets.

As we move forward, technologies like blockchain and AI will continue to drive innovation, making gaming more immersive and interconnected.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

gaming as an industry has typically been ahead of the curve so a lot of the innovations that you see in lots of different Technologies and lot different cultural things they often come from things like gaming first cryptocurrency or in-game tokens that are spendable elsewhere and you can actually use those tokens to vote so the people that Mo make the most content are rewarded for the most content the most popular creators then have say the most say how the game is actually played the decisions going forward the whole Community actually engaged in that can decide on the future of that game the idea of the generative AI being able to build a story that's unique to you based on how you interact with it and it be genuinely unique and as an experience to you is going to improve replay value for people where we say blockchain is a solution looking for a problem that will apply to gaming as well where the blockchain element is just hidden beneath it provides additional trust say more features

for users for Content Generation all this kind of stuff you don't talk about it so much welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today's topic is web 3 gaming something that's very close to my heart as Jack and hopefully some of the listeners out there know the gaming Market worldwide is forecasted to reach about half a trillion in 2024 which puts it at Double the music and movie Industries combined this is big money we're talking about and at its core web 3 gaming introduces a new paradigm of player empowerment where individuals have hopefully unprecedented control over their digital assets and the direction of virtual economies but also you know more immersive and empowering technology as well for their experience which is you know quite exciting so anyway let's kick this one off Jack how you feeling today yeah pretty good I think it's a really fun topic I know everyone who's listened to the podcast for a long time will know you are a big gamer I think much bigger than I

am and I I would describe myself as a gamer overall I I think I played a lot more when I was younger when I had a bit more spare time but I still love gaming right and I think it's very interesting because of the traditional media types I think gaming is the one that is consistently growing consistently profitable there's a big decline in Hollywood right now I've been following people aren't going to the cinemas anymore everything gets released to Netflix within two weeks but gaming is still going from strength to strength if you ask me and then web 3 is is adding a new dimension to how successful it's been so yeah there I'm sure there's lots we can talk about so why don't we just get straight into this one yeah I think it always surprises people when you say you're not like an avid gamer I think people tend to ask you know rather than do game it's like what games do you play they're always surprised you just got the vibe of

a gamer but yeah let's kick this one off because this is an exciting one for both of us I think so as we tend to do with these things let's go back to the early days but rather than the ENT entire history I think we segment this via web 1 web two and web 3 gaming so the early days of web 1 gaming were as you could imagine quite basic so just to give a little bit of context for those people that haven't been following us throughout the podcast web one refers to the first generation of the internet which is primarily characterized by Static website so read only with very little user interaction which as you can imagine for gaming is very limied the early games were super straightforward usually quite text based and sometimes they had simple 2D environments that supported multiplayer capabilities really yeah I think the web One gaming predates us just a little bit but as we were growing up or certainly as I was growing up I remember seeing some

of those early games things like your pong right something very simple 2D Graphics very simple game solitire as well I think is one that everyone would have played at some point or another again so mostly single player simplistic games that are easy to run on the older Hardware they're not necessarily internet compatible either right that they tend to be single player in an application or maybe a little bit later web based as well and when we're talking about web one obviously you do have some console games but again they're also not interconnected necessarily might play multiplayer in your front room with some friends but you wouldn't be playing kind of peer-to-peer online basically yeah that's really true I think it is just slightly before I mean one of the games that I know about and I've actually played because it's kind of one of these iconic games have you heard of it it's called zorc and it was basically D and D St and as you know I'm very much into Dungeons and Dragons and

it's basically a text Bas version of that which predated like the the guey graphic user interface era and effectively you'd get like this kind of text based prompts in like command line style which would describe scenarios and locations and give descriptions for that and you would interact by giving like commands like go north take Lantern attack roll all very Dungeons and Dragons style and this interaction was handled by servers and it was mostly played over the web reflecting you know the basic capabilities that that web one actually allowed at that time I think that would be one of the ones that are probably more advanced for the time as well that's kind of probably on the cusp of also things like multiplayer right so again I've not played D and D full disclosure it's as a nerd shocking I do feel bad saying it but I've actually not played D and D it never kind of appealed to me that's one of the things about gaming there's a million different types of games for for

for different people but I'm aware that they as it developed you then did end up having some kind of multiplayer I think they were called things like multi-user Dungeons which sounds a bit scary sounds a bit weird yeah I'll cut that out but yeah these are things that use some of those early components of the internet some of those early interaction things bulletin board systems and just using the internet itself to connect to those servers right so it's using the basic infrastructure but not really leveraging it to a a significant extent another one I actually did play was habo hotel which is a good example of one of the early kind of multiplayer games it's probably straddles web 1 and web two as well right but this is where you would have like an online environment where you have multiple people can potentially interact with one another and you even talk to each other and there's Myriad issues that come with that as well but yeah I was a big h a hotel player as

well and you're kind of right like when I was doing like some of the research around this stuff I was like okay how do you actually Define what's web one Web Two because obviously you need some interaction for it to be a game rather than a book right and then it's like okay where is the boundary and it's always even like with any kind of definition of web one and web two it's always quite gray and there's no black and white end but Hab Hotel was great like it was even for like how simple it looks now it was less about the game itself more about the ability to connect and interact with other people I remember like setting up a little gang back in the early days and just like it basically was a 12y old I imagine just like chilling in some hotel room and you'd all wear the same clothes and then you'd all just be like should we go to a different room and just like spam them with loads of

w bir like the original spammer tap on Hotel was like that alive yeah I think back then I was busy Outdoors Alec enjoying the enjoying sport yeah but again each to their own yeah I think that one of the things to highlight as you said with Hab hotel is that you see this element of community building these are some of the earliest kind of online gaming communities and d and d is important to mention because that a lot of the games in web one they had an existing community of players because they were often B based on board games or existing kind of intellectual property that there was a fan base around and then you would have the kind of online mirroring of that community and it wasn't necessarily until a bit later on in web 2 and Beyond where you started seeing new games being web native or Internet native that built and spawned their own communities from online play basically yeah I don't know what it is but the fan base around gaming

is just so hardcore and dedicated to whatever their game is right I think it's like when you think of movies it's too hours maybe once every two years that you get invested into a movie apart from Lord of the Rings obviously that's like a whole culture around it but with games you're logging like hundred hundreds if not thousands of hours so it becomes like part of your kind of DNA in a way and I think that's why the online communities are so strong and have such strong bonds and like they're supported in loads of ways as well because you have like Collectibles which is super huge which is all about the social flex and obviously there's a lot of kind of there's a lot of web three characteristics around that and I think one of the big things that we started to see with h hotel and that era of games and D D generally is the idea of like user generated content it was very simplistic back in like especially in the web web

one era but you still had like Clans and like boards and you can have custom competitions and that idea of user generated content is so powerful and it's going to be a reoccurring theme that we talk about in each of the versions of the web with gaming especially yeah that's a really interesting point that you mentioned user generated content because we're still talking about web 1 and I think normally we say us generated content is a feature of web two but I think that speaks to the fact that gaming as an industry has typically been a bit ahead of the curve I think so a lot of the innovations that you see in lots of different Technologies in lots of different ways of communicating different cultural things they often come from things like gaming first and we'll see that as we come later to to you know what we're seeing in web 3 but I think it's important to highlight that gaming has kind of led the way even if early on there were lots

of the technological limitations right you had kind of low connectivity speed a lot of these would been dial up internet based if they were online so the scope of them was quite small and obviously you had much lower powered Hardware worse graphics and processing capability so they had to be quite simplistic quite buggy low Fidelity graphics and things but the ideas like you generated content as you said were were already there even though the technology hadn't necessarily caught up to make that a big thing yeah and the last thing I want to mention about the web one era is that they did have in-game currency it's the way in which a lot of people describe Bitcoin is it just game money or something like that or online money e money magic internet money magic internet money exactly that and you started to kind of have this in like the habo hotel era where you could buy things in like games as it was verging on the web too this is the first kind of real

place we started to see like digital currency should we describe it but not in like the way that we tend to actually think of it in how me and Jack describe it and most of this podcast is based around yeah I think that's a good summary of web one right yeah exactly and the ingame currency pieces is good because it straddles into web too right because one of the the games from that era is probably RuneScape that I think lots of people will be familiar with and that's that's probably my first experience of in-game currency because it was so important and you could uh you could easily lose it by being killed in that game and that kind of stuff so moving on to web two then as we say this is where the technology has advanced and the models for doing things online have advanced so you have Dynamic websites that can update content based on user input you have this movement towards true user generated content so not just the demand for it

coming from gaming but then across all aspects of internet use you then you start having uh the growth of user generated content primarily through social media where actually lots of the new gamings evolved from right on social media platforms yeah this era saw like the explosion of online gaming right the advanced Graphics like complex game mechanics and really importantly the idea of having massively multiplayer online role playing games like RuneScape was the perfect example of that like I was very into that space I think I logged like thousands of hours into that game to the detriment of most of my studies when I was a Youngster but also because you had so many players in one game and the US experience was so addictive you also started to have this as we tend to have in web two models this centralization of companies and games towards fewer games fewer game developers mostly because of like Network effects like a lot of these kind of community- based games are very good because there's so much community

so many people actually involved in the game and obviously because of that that you can't have millions of games with millions of views in all of them and this kind of created a stickiness which is kind of lasted to today in most of the gaming companies right yeah and this is the era that I definitely grew up in for gaming where lots of your let's say your Call of Duties or your fifas and things like that there's a huge social element to all of them the way people play games I think changed as well so people weren't just playing s individually as they were previously now you're as you were previously maybe as I was now you're playing FIFA online against a friend somewhere else right that you couldn't do before and these as you said the network effects the large communities that you start getting supported you have this kind of almost live service element that has become much more popular recently but basically you have these much larger persistent worlds that people can

play in right these multiplayer worlds like your Call of Duty maps for example these are digital spaces and again this sounds talking of gaming leading the charge for things this to me sounds a lot like where the metaverse is now and is promising to head is large digital online worlds that you can play in with lots of other people simultaneously right so it's all synchronized online which is a big technical Challenge and it's kind of amazing to me that they have been supported for so long really and obviously that came with the development of much more powerful consoles you know your PlayStations Xboxes or came around in the web 2 era which were way more powerful anyone who's owned one will know how heavy they used to be in the early days and the sheer size of the games themselves right like sometimes you have an update for a game that's like 50 60 gigabytes to download which is pretty painful but shows you the level of complexity and detail you get in in that

in that era yeah that's a massive point is the idea of this advancements in Hardware so anyone could start to game at a high level in their homes basically and that was also supported with improved connectivity like Wi-Fi was basically everywhere so people could start to connect more easily and then kind of like on the other side of that everyone started to get mobile mob like Mobile gaming really kicked off I'm not saying that that this is necessarily the best example of mobile gaming but Angry Birds is probably the best example of mobile gaming but one thing that kind of takes a step back from like the Call of Duties and all this kind of stuff is actually maybe more on the level of a web one style Graphics game but in a web two kind of context is Farmville right that's such like a a parent and grandparent version of a web two game but this kind of was quite an interesting project because it was a really simplistic game but what they did

really well was obviously bridge to face Facebook and had that kind of network effect where you connecting to your friends asking them for points all time I remember getting pinged like hundred times a day by my mom on Facebook saying can you give me whatever it is more crop or more seed and all this kind of stuff and you see like it's the really good thing about was Facebook had a billion users or something like that at the time and everyone was pinging everyone and you find out like what the hell is fville actually might be a way to connect with my friends actually ping them all the time and actually start a conversation with them yeah Farmville bit died to death now I imagine I can't imagine there's many farms still going yeah there was a PR previous episode Alec where you claimed that Bara doesn't exist but I think Farmville is is the place where we might have all experienced it at one point or another yeah Farmville was huge I remember sinking

way too many school hours into that game growing my crops fairly unsuccessfully but yeah it's the perfect example of the huge Community aspect combined with in-game currency Collectibles the social Flex elements of those Collectibles wanting to show you had the best farm the most crops all these kind of metrics you have against your game because it was integrated into Facebook it just became absolutely massive and and this in-game currency was something that we we ended up using all the time without really thinking about it now obviously at that time why this is again characterized as web 2 is that in-game currency is very much purely for use in that game and it's one of the things that we're moving away from in web 3 as we'll come on to later is how you can use that externally yeah kind of mentioned in web one there was an ability to do user generated content but it wasn't so much in the kind of the sense we think about in there where users were creating environments Maps

it was more that they were in a fixed environment and they were creating things socially like let's all go to this place let's go to that place that kind of stuff but web 2 we really saw a boom in user generated content because you can have these Dynamic environments that would update and change like one of the perfect examples of this for me was Halo like Halo 3 where you could build in forge mode and actually have these maps and game types that you could design yourself and then get the ENT entire Community to play it was perfect like it was so addictive no one builds content like the fans of the content like the best Builders of the Halo was the Halo fans the Halo buyers the people that were in there and I think this had such a huge ripple effect that it made these games so much more immersive because people were building for things they loved when you're on a project that's all about passion you're not being paid for it

like you really are addicted to it and I think that was the rise of user generated content in web two gaming was huge and so important it's going something we talk about when we go to the web three side as well about how we can improve that yeah for me it was FIFA Ultimate teams right because you're building your own team you're living this power fantasy of building your favorite players into a team and then playing with them online right but yeah for me that that gets back to this characterization in the web 2 Gaming world of now there was the technology available to service that demand there was for as you said creating things that you love so in that time probably one of the best examples is Minecraft right that game is literally all about creation there's there's basically nothing there to start with you build everything yourself and you play with other people online it's it's amazing for showing the power of that concept specifically so yeah user generated content is a

huge feature of the web 2 Gaming era I mean some of the things they build in Minecraft like I've seen someone create an entire replica of Lord of the Rings of Middle Earth like Minister down to individual buildings and characters and you like they've invested like years and years into this stuff and it's unbelievable they're not expecting anything from it it's just because they love it so much yeah and and another one I really like is mods as well we saw the rise of mods which is basically the game engines themselves basically became a bit more transparent so this is probably a a case again where the gaming world was one phase ahead of the rest of the world because there was this element of interoperability there was this element of transparency of the back end of a lot of these games so you could actually if you're you know skilled enough you could go and build new skins for characters in games you could take the engine that powers the game and tweak it

and and do fun things with it almost like jailbreaking a game and it's not for everyone but there's millions of hours of content on YouTube where you can go and watch people again loving that content people just love to tweak and and play with the the existing world that's been built so I think mods are another good example of how culturally there was that shift in web too and this is a really nice inroad into something else that became quite big because of this it was the idea of like gaming as a mainstream entertainment like the rise of YouTube no longer just like playing games yourself but also watching people play games like when I first found out that this was like a big thing kind of blew my mind I was like why would you watch people play games when you can play games yourself it's like well they play it from their own personal angle like they had commentary and all this kind of stuff I was like oh that sounds a bit

weird and then I watched a couple I was like oh God this is quite addictive like I can't it's one of those things where I don't want to buy the game itself cuz I know it will ruin my life and it won't do anything else but if I just like watch watch them for a little minute rather than play 100 hours myself then you end up watching 100 hours of content anyway it's so addictive yeah I definitely did that a lot right I mean there's there there's something to be said for that actually lowering the barrier to entry because by this point a lot of these games were like 5060 pounds for the the triaa titles and you could instead go and watch on YouTube your favorite streamer or your favorite Creator playing for free so I actually remember watching I think it was dead space right I never actually played dead space but I watched all of ksi's play through of Dead Space because it was amazing and this is back when KSI was

very small but yeah it's a huge thing I still do it to this day you know I'm a big Assassin's Creed fan I don't buy all the games anymore because they're ludicrously expensive and we'll get on to the kind of cultural issues surrounding that but yeah it's something that I think brings a lot of people joy and is a characterization of web to now yeah one of the things that I started to see around this space which a bit of an issue was the idea of like loot boxes like I remember playing FIFA like you did and loot boxes were such a thing right whenever you wanted to create a new team and all kind of a FIFA Ultimate Team right you would do that by paying for loot boxes and hoping you'd get the best player and I remember putting so much money into that there like a 16y old kid like begging my mom to give me the money to play like how are you putting like 20 pound into this game and

even at the time she was thinking like how is this legal that these kids can just put money into it there's very little verification on this kind of stuff and this become very controversial right because what they've started to see this as now is a way of gambling in a way it's effectively like I'm spinning the dice or I'm putting going on roulette putting some money and seeing what comes out of it and that a lot of kind of class actions are coming out a lot of regulations like to pick up on the idea of loot boxes being quite bad and encouraging gambling in mostly teenagers yeah and this is part of some of the cultural shifts we saw during the web 2 Gaming phase more broadly this idea of microtransactions so in web one you would just buy the game or even play it for free and that's it there's one monetization event for you as the end user right that the company making the game they get money off you once in web

2 they decided we have the rise of subscription models for the internet generally and they realized oh hang on we can do a very similar thing here we can charge people not once for buying the game we can charge them five six seven times for DLC right downloadable content to expand the experience so now you have games that coming out a lot of the time half finish right I mentioned Assassin's Creed and a lot of people call this a Ubisoft problem because there's been a few big uh controversies I think it was Assassin's Creed Unity that came out basically completely under finished and there's been so many of the games since then that have been in the similar problem where they come out unfinished and people have often paid to pre-order these games right sometimes without even seeing footage because the model has totally changed in web 2 people are willing to sell you a pre-release version of the game before it's even ready promising the world and then you know you might not get

it on release day and then even if the game you know even if they patch it with one of those 100 gigabyte updates and it gets fixed they'll then sell you via these what we call called microtransactions and again these microtransactions are not what we talk about in web 3 where we're talking tiny amounts of money these are just transactions that are smaller than the 6070 you paid for the game and they to sell you these loot boxes so a chance to win new skins maybe just to buy things directly in the game so that the whole Revenue models associated with gaming have completely changed over the last 10 15 years I think and I think this kind of sets the stage you know kind of highlighted some of the problems that Eric and web 2 Gaming for the opportunities of web 3 gaming so let's jump on to that 25 minutes let's start talking about web 3 gaming so like at a really introductory high level like I think the philosophies of web 3

and gaming really align like both of them the principles are to bring people together and build community and I think they go hand inand in achieving that and what's the the thing that Robert Rice said the two areas that really push technology especially in this space of web 3 is porn and gaming I think he's right on that yeah to be fair when you when we're talking about trying to Define web through gaming it is as ever quite hard to pin down exactly what it means because it's emerging it's evolving all the time but yeah I think it for me it means two things primarily one is like what you said the alignment of incentives between people in these gaming communities allowing that sense of you know that that greater deeper sense of community and how that is often operating in what what I described earlier as almost like a pseudo metaverse that's always been there in gaming but now in web 3 where the metaverse is its own thing I think we're seeing that

convergence again to stay on the Assassin's Creed uh di tribe here they've released a VR version of assassin creed which is the kind of thing that when I was 12 years old I would have absolutely loved to play and that's merging the the VR AR side of web 3 that we talked about a lot with the traditional gaming sense the other piece of web 3 that I think is really interesting is then all about the digital asset ownership piece right how you own these assets like your in-game skins your in-game currency and how that becomes more meaningful I think those are two separate things but often they they come packaged together now yeah I think that's a really good way to define it like there's the community piece that you talked about at the end there and that's compared with maybe the traditional web three still to we blockchain digital identity all that kind of thing Collectibles nfts all that kind of ownership verifiability and then I think the other piece is gameplay itself and

that's the immersive Tech like the metaverse of VR AR Mr really excitingly AI obviously AI is just a buzz word thrown at every single area right now but we've seen some real practical examples of how AI can really make this really immersive on the fly as well which is exciting so yeah should we go more specific and start talking about some of the areas in which we see web 3 really impacting the gaming space yeah sure so why don't we go through these kind of one by one right the major areas of web 3 is is impacting gaming so firstly is is probably one of the more generic ones is on this idea of privacy and data security that we always talk about in web 3 right we always talk about this idea of moving personal data to the edges and not having lots of personal data stored potentially insecurely by large companies a really good example of this that I always like to go back to for a number of reasons is Playstation hack

do you remember this it was in 2010 Alec yeah I remember this being like example 101 of like how to do cryptography and how to do it wrong and it was all about not replacing the ephemeral key between different things Yeah so basically the signing key and this is why I like talking about it because it's using the same technology as blockchain right and talk about blockchain as being a solution but essentially the signing key they were using to sign certificates for PlayStation was implemented really terribly as you said reusing a key and this basically allowed hackers to to steal the key to sign their own certificates and then basically they could install any software they liked on everyone's PlayStation 3 it was a huge issue and it just shows that everyone gaming and doing everything through centralized consoles centralized companies I mean there's only really been for most people there's like two or three players there's Nintendo Microsoft Xbox and Playstation those are the three kind of ways you'd game for a lot of

people in web 2 and there are obviously some security issues there that the typical Tools in blockchain and web 3 can help address I think yeah I think there's a privacy is kind of the bread and butter of this stuff the idea of like also verifying someone verifying their allowed to play a game age verification without revealing too much information necessarily like I think digital identity fees into this piece quite well selective disclosure like another thing when we talk talk about how blockchain can enable this space Also transparency for gaming from their side right like we talked about loot boxes and how do you determine like the odds of winning a loot box who is verifying that this one in 10 chance of getting the mess is actually happening without showing who got the Messi for example and we can get more extreme versions of that but you do want transparency in how a lot of these things occur and it can only really happen in a privacy preserving way I imagine so that's another

good example of how blockchain can actually help in creating that kind of trust between the big Central company and the users of the experience yeah and there are so many interesting things you can do with just blockchain as is right you can use it for generating random numbers there are lots of things like in chain link they have verifiable random number generation which sounds kind of boring but it can be used as you said to make these things like loot boxes Much More Much more trustworthy I think and on that point you mentioned selective disclosure that is a really interesting one for authenticating logging into multiple different games or different services but persisting a single kind of pseudonymous identity so we talk about taking your reputation across different places I think that's one of the areas where it will help a lot in the future yeah the next one which has obviously been a reoccurring theme throughout this is the community support aspect and right now I feel that even in web 2 Gaming there

is isn't that Community Support like I say the best content comes from the community itself but these players aren't really directly compensated for their effort and the actual engagement they create like I said the Halo is the Minecraft of the world people have the tools to build things but are they actually being rewarded directly in the games themselves not necessarily I think web 3 and actually you know play to earn style models where you can tokenize the assets that they're actually building and guarantee that those assets when they're used you'll be rewarded in the person who actually created those assets in cryptocurrencies or actually tokenized them as an nft through gameplay I think that has a really powerful potential to incentivize the people to keep building this content and reward them when they do like I think that is one of the biggest things that has to come out of web 3 gaming yeah I think this is linked heavily with the digital asset ownership piece I mentioned right you're essentially creating your own digital

assets when you're creating new things in games they're in a sense your own intellectual property right there that came out of your brain it's natural that you'd want a way to monetize that and also I think really interesting things like just being able to as soon as you tokenize a lot of the things that are being made in games or even just the basic Collectibles themselves you can then build this history of ownership which is really interesting because then you might be owner of a skin that was owned by one of the most legendary gamers in the community right that that that kind of stuff is really interesting and then you get very different market dynamics for maybe there are secondary markets where you can go and sell those assets and prove who owned them in the past you can have this lineage to them which I think a lot of people would quite like yeah you love talking about secondary markets but I do agree like you could start to get programmability around assets

which is quite exciting and related to that point you can start to have your community governments Dows as people keep saying where the people are actually contributing to the game are rewarded in maybe some kind of cryptocurrency or in-game tokens that are spendable elsewhere and you can actually use those tokens to vote so the people that Mo make the most content are rewarded for the most content the most popular creators then have say the most saying how the game is actually played the decisions going forward it's not just this centralized player who hasn't created all the content going forward but the whole Community actually engaged in that can decide on the future of that game which I think is really important as well yeah and when I mentioned DLC and patches to games that's often been a kind of it is a two-way process the community is outraged at something being wrong and a lot of the time the developers of the game will listen but now I think web 3 does offer you a

different model for actually directly incentivizing that you could have people you know staking money towards certain features and they're the most popular features the best funded features that gives the developers the proper incentive then to to go and build it so I think that's a really interesting one another one I think we talk about inability a lot as a basic benefit of web3 and blockchain systems in general and I think this is as we've mentioned with in-game assets with in-game currency at the minute they're totally siloed you can't really take the points you earn in FIFA to a game like like fortnite right and even though you may have paid 10 pound of real fiat currency to buy one in another and you could there is a way of valuing them against each other you still can't P that value across especially as games get deprecated over time right things I put into Ultimate Team when I was 15 years old that's lost right I can't take that out and use that somewhere else now

so I think just making your assets more portable is a huge benefit of tokenizing in general and using them in web 3 one thing like I agree with this stuff I think that's very good for the user I think the hard one on that is you know what's the benefit for the company FIFA says I've got absolute Monopoly on all sports games why would they want to then open up say the FIFA points to be spendable in you know a competitor for example I'm not sure what a competitor is at FIFA because they don't think any of them exist anymore but you know what's the incentive for EA to actually enable that interoperability of currency but I think a good one is the idea of inter interoperability and portability of like reputation like taking your profile from place to place even like then like it's obvious for EA Sports if you can go into World of Warcraft and show that you're FIFA top 5% or something like that it's a bit of branding for them

a bit of marketing and I think that's a really easy kind of one to do you obviously need to tie in some verifiability and digital identity stuff potentially with that but yeah I think that's a big one but you need the kind of companies to actually sign up to this stuff and sometimes you know they want that stickiness right and it has to come from the users potentially pushing that on the company itself yeah I I agree it's it always this is something we always come up in web 3 right is there's an enine of incentives to make between the users and and the companies behind whatever products we're talking about I think there's an obvious case for you know making assets portable even within an ecosystem right so it doesn't solve the whole platform lock in but making it portable between new versions of a game there's a new FIFA out every year or I think it's called EA Sports now because the rights change but we'll ignore that but I'm sure there's a

huge demand and it would would likely keep players playing if they can take things from one game to the next or to different sports game under the same umbrella again that doesn't solve for the the platform lock in for the user but it does give them something whilst retaining benefit for the the game platform so I think that there are different models to consider there that are interesting so you can prove that you've been playing FIFA for like 20 years when you're destroying those 10y olds online yeah exactly again I'm just think but I'd love to be playing with some of the players I used in my Ultimate Team 10 years ago I'd love to play alongside moala or something now which would be good but yeah I think another thing we obviously have to talk about when we talk about web 3 here is the impact of AI right because AI has kind of been involved in gaming for a long time actually just under the hood but now it's obviously exploding and has

potential to change even further right oh God I hate to just bang on about this stuff but the impact of AI and W and gaming is going to be huge like there's so many different areas so it's we're going to have to like maybe just throw these out quite quickly one is non-player character behaviors I told you I played dungeons dragons and the best thing about that is you know some a character can react in any way on the Fly because someone is basically pretending to be that character the idea of like non-player characters in role playing games like Witcher whatever it is say RuneScape World of Warcraft being a to just react on the fight to whatever you say in any instance being El to walk around you ask them something you give them some pointers and they create an entire Universe game on the Fly it's going to be so powerful it's going to be super immersive I've seen that Ubisoft have already got models for this and they were showing like you're

in a canteen basically and you throw any information at the guy you tell him your name your age all stuff and he creates the entire universe basically on the fly around you that is going to create whole new levels of immersion yeah and the bit that I get excited about there is your kind of your RPG games or even something like Fallout right where there's a lot of text based gameplay and a lot of it is in in the law the idea of the generative AI being able to build a story that's unique to you I think is really interesting and based on how you interact with it the the inputs you and it be genuinely unique and as an experience to you I think is going to improve replay value for people I think the potential there is massive right yeah even like game environments and stuff like being out like for the games the characters like the actual map itself to be able to update to whatever you're doing wherever you're looking like

being able to create your own characters that look exactly like you like you know darly style or mid Journey Style just be able to create any content your own base like anything the possibilities are really Limitless in this kind of stuff and that is extremely exciting there's of stuff around like voice and facial recognition as well how you can start to have higher accessibility for people that can't necessarily game with like in the way that traditional gaming support with your hands potentially and I think that's Obviously good like lowering the barrier to entry for anyone to be involved but also to have like better feedback and response and stuff like that's it's really exciting yeah I can imagine maybe even I don't know if this has happened yet but you being able to have your character speak in your voice as well right because if you've got the lines repaired there are lots of incredible AI tools for just generating voices now I'm sure we'll see a game where your character can take on your

entire Persona almost which is pretty scary equal parts scary anal Parts exciting I think we' never get you away from the console You' just be talking to yourself all the time yeah you lit up about the idea of been able to hear your voice for a thousand hours I'm just thinking if Etso Ador da with my voice that would be amazing okay so before yeah maybe before I mention Assassin's Creed again there are obviously lots of things I think we don't need to harp too much again on the AR VR Mr Right or XR as Robert would say all these kind of ways to augment the experience with mixed reality and things like that there are so many things I mean you showed me a video Alec of I think that in Disney Labs they've got this moving floor which you could walk on and you could be wearing VR headset and basically be literally walking around but on the spot right so the kind of ground moves underneath you you stay static but you

can explore real world physically right which is you know there's the potential there is huge you could have games which keep you fit you get your step count in while playing RuneScape in the I don't know or playing uh what's a better example yeah like where you could get your step step goal in for the day while playing Skyrim or something like that must be I think that's going to be on the cards too this sounds so tragic like I obviously super key for it when you're like rather than go outside you could just step inside do get your step count while on a trackpad yeah you're right like when you watch like the really player ones of the world like the headsets are there the games are getting there the graphics are improving constantly the thing that I've always found like really difficult to get my head around is how do you stay in the same place and they have like really complex Contraptions that kind of hold you up in this movie by

wires and stuff yeah I saw this Disney trackpad style and it looks so freaking cool like it was just a tiny little Dome that's around you could run on it you could like crouch on it do all these things I'm like that is the next level of VR game being able to run around and immerse with the headsets that we have right now but yeah the AR Mr stuff is just it's quite obvious how people actually get it's the interface right it's the interface for all these games the idea of having 360 degree expiration is human and intuitive we have really good depth perception really good spatial awareness like a screen is not what we've evolved to understand and I think even like the most basic games like really basic models in these VR worlds are so much more immersive purely because they add that spatial perception that we really require for everyday life yeah and I think one of my favorite examples if you're kind of a skeptic on this and you think oh

well how can this improve immersion that much just look at what happened with the Nintendo Wii right all jokes aside it was literally a really low quality in terms of Graphics game playing Wii tennis or something like that but everyone on the planet pretty much did it everyone who bought one of these consoles loved playing these games because you were so much more immersed because there was a physical element you're using your SP personal kind of spatial awareness to play these games and that was like at least 15 years ago now right and that just proves that that experiential side of gaming and bringing that into the physical world is a huge thing that people there's a lot of demand for I think I completely agree and on the AR version of that like any naysayers like look at Pokémon go if you said it was fad or whatever it is like there was millions of people using that basically overnight and it's really powerful the idea of being able to take your game with

your smartphone wherever you go smartphones are just getting more powerful and more powerful every year and the capabilities are improving constantly like they're just going to support like really high-end games soon I've seen like concepts of like them having hologram games we can project it into whatever environment you're in but I quite like AR games based on phones like the idea of being to take gaming anywhere I quite like the idea of having a murder mystery app where you could go on the Fly be on holiday and just have an entire experience kind of set up for you in the home that you determine but yeah all this stuff is really exciting and quite obvious the potential that's going to Happ happen with web three gaming yeah and maybe just as a final note on these elements is the kind of wearables tech as well and Biometrics I think that's just another aspect of emerging technology that is going to deepen that experience further so like games tailoring experiences to individuals based on your wearables

uh getting data about you as you're playing right you think of like horror levels sensing your heart rate and things like that there's a lot that you can do there so I think it's just worth mentioning and everything spoken about so far I think is we're talking about web 3 gaming but this is really web 3 Technologies being mostly applied to traditional gaming right what we would call Web Two gaming we should also mention something that is pretty much web 3 specific and something completely net new in web 3 which is the play to earn model now there are lots of detractors of this model but we should just mention it so essentially this is the idea of you're playing a game and you're earning some kind of real world or financial value from playing the game just you're playing it is earning you something now whether that has much value is another question but that's been a characterization of what people generally call Web three gaming right yeah so when you're talking about that

I think about the II in the Ready Player One film and have their whole goal is how many ads can we put on the screen at any one time without giving someone a seizure so that's what I'm thinking I think play to earn star people just running around like decentral land and having like adverts everywhere and just being paid to stare at them getting micro incentives for them but you know some people will do do that if it lowers the barrier to entry for the game like gaming is so damn expensive now even us as like fully formed adults like we're saying it's too expensive to get into it I don't know how the kids are getting into it so the idea you log an hour of like walking around ENT land to top yourself up and then play a game because of that well all power to you if that's what you want to do yeah and I think it's I think the early iterations of the play to earn model are probably you

know not the way it will end up but there are things that are useful with it right it also lowers the barrier to entry for game developers because it's a way of funding game play it's a way of funding feature development as we said you can start off with a basic game and the more people play you know the more money there is slotting around that ecosystem that they can pay it's a little bit akin to the Ico model potentially as well and a lot of games will tend to launch their own token for the purposes of playing the game and then a lot of the time that will die off eventually but I think there will be some element of the play to a model in some of the games of the future so I think it's just worth touching on it there yeah and you know we've gone through all the many exciting areas let's touch on some of the challenges that happening right now so I think the kind of we talk

about web 3 gaming I think most people maybe in the early days were talking about blockchainbased gaming and obviously blockchainbased gaming is not very good because I don't even know exactly what that would look like committing every action and transaction to a transaction on the blockchain that idea glows my mind like why would any want to do that but there's not many big companies moving into blockchain gaming specifically right it's too slow too costly a lot of people have said there's no real USP for that I think it was Jack O Hollin the CEO of scale which is an ethereum scaling Network believes that the term web 3 gaming itself will actually disappear within five years as like the integration of blockchain into games will just be ubiquitous and assumed and like you said there's been a lot of problems where we say blockchain is a solution looking for a problem and I imagine that will apply to gaming as well where the blockchain element is just hidden beneath it provides additional trust say more

features for users for Content Generation all this kind of stuff you don't talk about it so much yeah I I tend to agree as we've said it feels like gaming has been so far ahead of the curve it's it's almost been integrating the concepts of web 3 for the last 10 years or something like that and I think the technology of web 3 now will just become embedded as you say and it will just work to deliver what the gamers want basically I think that's how it will eventually work and yeah blockchain native games or games that are built around the blockchain themsel and doing everything on chain I think there have been some interesting examples like obviously crypto kitties is the one that people point to and then more recently the one that you point to number one fan of crypto kitties well I never played it right I I never played it it was way before my life lifetime in in web 3 it was more like a proof of concept and then

things like axi infinity have come since then and again proved very popular in certain place in the world for a while but the token behind that as I said that has also dropped by like 95% from its peak right so there is it seems like there's almost an expiry time for lots of these games even if they have initial success so I agree I think lots of the blockchain Native blockchain based games probably won't necessarily survive but the infrastructure that we've talked about throughout the episode I think definitely will be embedded in let's call it traditional gaming going forward yeah I think like decentraland is another good example of this where it's like the kind of elements of blockchain in there like decentraland has a lot of kind of nfts nfts I really do think will be a part of the gaming Universe you're not going to have the entire game based on blockchain but nft ownership the idea of verifiable ownership and trading on blockchain to guarantee that and see the entire history of

that collectible you have I think that's how it's going to become emergent in the space you have these small elements in the game itself and you won't even know it's blockchain you'll say this is an nft that guarantees your ownership and you can see the entire history of that the D centr land is a very good example of that they do a lot of community governance as well which is the Dow stuff that we've been talking about but even they've had their challenges right they've saying that it's very complex to actually get users on board and navigating the whole wallet ownership and key control and all this kind of stuff has actually been really tricky which is always the barrier to entry with a lot of the stuff yeah and for every good example like a decentraland or a Sandbox I think where you're having let's say that's like a more like a web three native game you've also had some really bad examples some potentially Bad actors right so the bate Yacht Club that

was promising game and metaverses for a long time its first entry I think it was called dooky Dash right it was just a very simple endless Runner game that disappointed everyone but it cost you $2 and a half thousand nearly to play right you needed to buy a sewer pass to play that right so it's there's been a lots of disappointments in this space I know that bourette yach club has basically just released a metaverse MMO RPG as well right so they are trying to move in this space but I think the the appetite for it is probably pulled off a lot and then you have I don't know if you saw did you see Logan Paul's entry into the web 3 gaming World a few years ago know tell me a little bit about it yeah this is It's really well covered on YouTube by people like coffeezilla but basically he he was selling an nft collection for an exciting web three game supposedly called crypto zooo which is basically the same idea as

crypto kitties naxi Infiniti kind of nft based so you sell the nfts you merge them to make new characters and basically the whole thing got canned a couple of years later after everyone bought their nfts he'd used his influence to sell them and now that's ended up in a class action lawsuit that was filed against him he's promised to pay back million dollars to investors so there's been a lot of bad examples as well of of these web three games and that's why I think you have people like Jack saying this whole web 3 native gaming industry could well disappear I think nice yeah it's good to know that I mean as all this kind of space there's always Bad actors right he the classic Ponzi scheme so be careful out there not Financial advice or gaming advice shall we wrap this up then maybe give some predictions for what we think the future of this space is going to be I think we kind of touched on it it' be nice to know what

some of your highlights are yeah I think for me the digital asset ownership piece will be the leading component of gaming web three elements in in the near term because it's the infrastructure is there now right even though there are some scalability challenges and some blockchains you're seeing really big Partnerships come out all the time to you know token in-game assets there something I really like that I saw from mutable so they basically they've launched this thing called the immutable passport which lets people sign in and take their digital identity their gaming reputation between games and they take their digital assets between games but without having to manage like multiple wallets it was a really cool gaming passport and I think that's the kind of innovation that is going to lead the next kind of four five years and then maybe further down the line we'll get the kind of high futin metaverse World version but as we've said that's potentially a little bit p in the sky right now yeah you're totally right Gamers

understand Collectibles they understand the importance of ownerships and like nfts that really fit that bill and yeah that's going to be most people experience like a blockchain interface basically in web 3 gaming in my mind I think we've covered the arvr immersive experience angle that's going to be the norm I imagine in like five to 10 years AI completely makes sense for personalized on the Fly customized experiences I also think something we didn't touch on is the idea of AI being used for cheaper game development potentially allowing people to actually create a beach head in the space and have more Indie Games popping up left right and Center we don't need an entire development team you just need a couple of AI agents that can build the game on the Fly for you if you've got a really cool concept so if we want to go really finger in the air Super Future predictions I've got two one is the idea of neural interfaces so you no longer need any VR headset any actual console

you just have a little program in there a little chip in there that plays the game as you go walking around Elon Musk will love that imagine that idea Elon and the other one is maybe Quantum Computing imagine like a personalized quantum computer in like 60 years where you could just have a game that's like can run everything instantly like a hundred different AI agents they're all running persistently consistently at the same time but let's see if that's possible yeah I think the neural interfaces one is pretty scary for me I'm not sure I'd be lining up as a customer for it but definitely on the quantum Computing even if we don't get fully-fledged practical Quantum Computing we're still likely to have this kind of exponential increase in the power available from computers and the storage improvements all this stuff that that allows much higher quality experiences to be packed into smaller and smaller devices and one thing that's maybe not as far in the future but it's almost basically here today is this whole

idea of the kind of live service game and and basically everything being always online and you being able to play I mean I think it's been shelv was it Amazon or Google basically came out with a project to say there's going to be this full gaming platform that you can access on your phone anywhere in the world and play like full quality AAA 4K titles right proper games but on your phone and it's all streaming based and I think that was maybe ahead of its time they announced that like four or five years ago now but I do think that is what we'll eventually see these super high fidelity games basically available in your pocket and then if you combine that with a digital asset ownership piece I think that's quite an exciting future for gaming you've got there yeah I I'm incredibly excited I think that there's going to be a time where it's difficult to distinguish between reality and potentially the games like even now it's on a 4K TV across the wall

I still think damn this looks completely real and maybe I can't tell the difference anymore so imagine as soon as that becomes 3D like it's gonna be really difficult to tell a difference but that's like the 50y year Horizon anyway so don't worry we're still safe you're still just using a PS5 in the distance but maybe one day it'll be a bit more real than that yeah no I think that's that's a nice place to end I think so yeah this has been a fun one I think we've given away our gaming preferences in this you're a D and D fan I'm a big Assassin's Creed head so yeah I think solit Solita solo no I got I grew I grew past solitire a long time ago but yeah I think that's a good place to end thanks for listening wherever you may be join us next time to entangle a little more web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and

comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Business & Society

Related episodes

All episodes