Episode 46

Web 2.5 with Luke Mulks

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this edition of Untangling Web3, Jack and Alec speak to Luke Mulks from Brave Software, exploring the concept of Web 2.5 as a transitionary phase towards a fully integrated Web3 future.

Luke shares his journey into the Web3 space, emphasizing Brave's initiatives in marrying traditional internet infrastructures with emerging Web3 technologies. The discussion delves into Brave's innovative approach to user-first web browsing, the importance of privacy, and the implementation of blockchain technology to reimagine web advertising.

This episode illuminates the challenges and opportunities of navigating the current digital landscape, providing insights into the evolution of the internet and the potential of Web3 technologies to create a more transparent, user-centric online experience.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

we've gone through this journey ourselves here you're dealing with challenges and how the technology has to improve in order for those things to become a reality right we definitely had to take these 2.5 approaches and we thought okay if we can make it two to three clicks you're on and you're a part of the system that's a win and so we did that right and we got over 10 million users to opt into Brave rewards and start to be a player in the system you have to figure out ways to reduce that cognitive load for users because the reality is is you're not just making something new with web 3 you're making something that has to compete with big Tech on incumbent web 2 spaces welcome to another episode of the entangling web3 podcast today we're thrilled to have Luke MKS joining us on the show Luke is Vice President of business operations at Brave software where he Champions Braves mission to build a user first web in this episode we'll be talking to Luke

about the idea of web 2.5 the transition phase between the old internet and the new as well as some of the practical ways that the team behind the brave browser are looking to integrate web 3 Technologies into existing internet infrastructure Luke it's a huge pleasure to welcome you to the show thanks for having me on been looking forward to this hey Luke how are you doing today doing well doing well great to hear so Jack gave a little bit of an introduction there to you and I am really excited for this episode find out more about Brave we use the term web 2.5 a lot so it' be good to get your insight into what that actually means for the space but you know before we get there could you tell us a little bit about your early career and background before we go into what led you into web 3 and web 2.5 and all these things yeah sure so I kind of started off in the media production side of things I work

for publishing companies and then founded some startups and crashed and burned some startups and wound up like after about an eight-year journey of bringing when I was in publishing we were bringing everything digital so this was back in 2003 to 2011 roughly and so everything had been on film and transparencies and the whole even the printing process was all done very analog and so I was there at that stage when they were cutting that over into digital which was like super interesting too especially Ai and things like that where is kind of like the next phase of that but anyway crash and burned some stuff there and then I ended up in adte where I worked really in the middle of everything so we work for this company oao we were we had clients that were like NBC Google we were a Google reseller for Google ads and then for all their publisher stuff too as well and then and then we work with like NBC NFL a lot of the major media companies Warner

Brothers Etc and so what we did there was basically like hooked up all the ad products and advertising for them to monetize because these developers they they love developing their apps they don't really care about the money even though it's what kind of powers everything so our company came in and we're like cool we know how all this stuff works and so we plugged it all together but it gave me a really interesting vantage point because we were a small company so we could be really agile but you were really in the mix of everything and it was right when advertising was used to be like at the site level so you go buy ads on a property then whoever's there sees them and they quasa personalize them but I got into advertising as Google and Facebook started to like really drill down into programmatic advertising and take more and more market share and so you saw this whole like consolidation of the advertising space and then that Focus went away from targeting websites and

people that visit websit to just targeting big herds of people then targeting very specific people right and then that's where I was okay I'm not really like I did that for several like six years and then I was like okay what's the next thing that I want to do because I wasn't really happy with how like being a part of that whole apparatus and there really wasn't any alternative but I told myself if there was a startup I wanted to go back into I wanted to make sure it was something I really cared about with a team and that I really cared about and For A Cause I was really cared about and so I stumbled into Brave at that point where I saw what they were doing this was back in early sh 2016 so like January February and I saw they had this really interesting like proof of concept that they were working on that involved paying creators Bitcoin in the browser and that they were really trying to do a bunch of

advertising related things but the challenge with them was that they blocked all the ads and tracking that were part of like web to right so there's good reasons for that right but like the problems with doing that is that's Al so how they account for everything is through the tracking right so I reached out to them back then in March of 2016 I started working with brave I think there maybe like 10 or 11 people at the company at the time and then yeah like we came on full-time and then started working on the white paper for bat with the team and then we brought that to Market but that's the Genesis of the journey there was really nobody these problems that Bray we've been trying to solve especially back then like 2016 there weren't anybody people like other companies trying to solve them because everything was like so plug inpl and when you're plugging and playing into like kind of the user or hostile defaults like there's not a lot of incentive to do

something else especially back then because like things like gdpr and like privacy regulations weren't really they didn't have any traction back then and so people looked at me kind of weird when I said hey yeah we're going to go try and make advertising work without tracking I mean that's really exciting to know and we're definitely going to go into Brave and everything you're doing there later in the show but it's really good to know that you were kind of in and around web one web two with all these problems especially in the ad space right the ad space for the internet has been both the fuel for the industry but also some of the problems that I'd like to go into right now you're very familiar with web 2 and the web two challenges that exist today but what do you see as some of the major challenges with the internet right now yeah I think there's still a lot of challenges around this whole the advertising model and user tracking and privacy like those

are still big challenges but there's actually been progress there which is interesting too because this year Google finally said we're going to kill third party cookies and chrome which is like a long time coming like that was like they've been kicking the can down the road on that for years and so this is where it's exciting for us is because with everything that's happened on the regulation side too like with the gdpr and driving everybody crazy with cookie consent notices which you're probably like there's a lot of like mixed bags with these you know types of regulations because in some respects like the great thing about having something like gdpr is that you actually have a definition for what you user data means because in the US you're basically like privacy is basically whatever either lawmakers decide which they are really slow and don't move quickly on or it's what companies dictate privacy means right because that's where a lot of the conversation happens and so in Europe when you have a standard there like

with what the regulation says no this is actually user data this really black and white thing it helps to set the tone enforce has of forcing function everywhere else and so those challenges are still big I think that a mix of things are happening right now where you have marketers that don't really know exactly what the world looks like when you get rid of third party cookies because they're such a huge part of like programmatic advertising and tracking and audience segmentation and all those things work but then on the other end of the spectrum too like web 3 is still not at a place where you can go get your neighbor to use it your relatives to use it super easily and that's where we're trying to help out with things too being folks that really care about this like it's in our DNA here at Brave like all this web 3 technology but also just the usability of things and so I think those are the big challenges like especially in the web 3

Space 2 we've been I've been in the space for like eight years and there's an obsession sometimes with complexity and with the doodads and the airdrops and all these oh it's like a infinite amount of chains and it's okay can I just get one where it's easy for folks to get on and start making the economics work and and so there's a lot of competition in that space right now but also in some specs it's looking like that onramp might take longer than folks anticipated which is kind of frustrating that said there's a lot of things happening in that front that are interesting too and ways for these two things to converge too which you're super interested in because if you have this really nice like symbiosis of okay we have to get rid of third party cookies but like things like nfts or or other types of crypto technology are becoming more and more popular or actually like usable and and people can relate to them then you can start to look at things

that like can we search a segment based on like holders and communities and then work it to Brands because everything can be scaled up into a different context like with a bigger brand yeah I I really like how you've articulated that and to be honest I think you're touching on problems in web two and then also web 3 because I think the problems in web 2 are quite concrete and especially when when I try and talk to somebody about why do we need web 3 people say this is just this term what does it actually mean I often start with the problems of web 2 and say advertising is one of the top ones I talk about the fact that as you say we have these cookies which effectively track our history when you visit a site you might log in there's this cookie that follows you and then links Behavior or your your browsing activity across different websites and I think a lot of people understand that problem people know when they're being advertised

to even you know there's all the conspiracies around is my iPhone recording me and every time you have a conversation about a pair of new Nikes then you'll get advertised them immediately so people are quite conscious of this problem around advertising and I personally think web 3 is quite well placed to kind of alter that model and provide a different way but before we get on to the web3 side of this and the new problems that you know trying to use web3 Solutions might bring in as you're alluding to are there any other problems outside of just advertising in the web 2 world that you think are important to be addressed and then could be addressed by web 3 yeah I think that there's a couple things the advertising problem too is like deeper than than just cookies at at this point because there have been companies that have specialized in linking offline and online data too and some of them have been operating for like decade at this point and so that part gets

even scarier down the rabbit hole the more you go and that there's companies that people have never even heard of that are doing these things like on a regular basis but outside of that too I think we're starting to see things manifest too like a couple of Cycles ago in crypto like people would talk about Bitcoin and and about web 3 in the abstract of like well if something were to happen with one of these big Tech companies then I would be locked out of their system or I would be I don't have control over my Identity or I don't have control over my content or I don't have control over this or that and I think the past two years especially we've seen a manifestation of situations that kind of lived in the abstract or scenarios that used to live in the abstract actually like playing out in the real world where it didn't matter too initially it seemed okay it went from these companies could do this if they wanted to to like

no now YouTube's actively demonetizing everybody says these magic words and then it's like okay well one side of the spectrum seems to be getting hit now it's like everybody I mean if you think about every podcast or YouTube channel you go to where you hear these hosts have to self-censor themselves because the they might say something that's not that's going to get flagged and then demonetize them I think that these things are kind of manifesting now the rubbber meeting the road even things like with the trucker protest in Canada where you start to see things that were like used for like terrorism law being used against like protesters to freeze accounts like with funding that protesting I mean regardless of the politics of it the point is that these things are going from the abstract into like the everyday world where it is starting to affect people at that level that kind of I think exactly you've hit the nail on the head is this wall Gardens type issue right and for many years people

are saying these big tech companies they are wall Gardens they can lock you out they can stop things and everyone's like well that's not a problem but it's not a problem until it becomes a problem I mean even things like as you mentioned YouTube I've seen a lot of cre creators struggling with things like copyright striking now right where they're getting you know the one that comes to mind I'm a rugby fan and during the Rugby World Cup lots of independent creators were having you know completely fair use videos where they've taken you know footage from rugy World Cup and they've done something with it and they've transformed that content it should be protected under fair use but YouTube is still allowing these copyright strikes to go through because they're beholden to the interest of the larger companies right that's one of the big issues I think you're getting out here oh I have a wild anecdote that's on that line too so we have a partner of ours this this a company called karate

combat they do like UFC types of mixed martial arts and they had they were doing a live stream and I was at the event in Las Vegas in December they had a live stream and for their app and then they also had one on YouTube and somehow like within seconds there was a a fighter music that was coming on when they do the walk-on appearance and and somehow YouTube knew within 10 seconds of it going on that it was copyrighted and they flagged and turned off the live stream on YouTube it was like so quick and we were in there and I was standing next to the CTO at the event and his phone was just blowing up because all these people are like we have all these streamers that are that are live streaming it from YouTube and now it's all YouTube seats down you know it was like I was just impressed though by the fact that like how did they know how did they it was a live event we were there

like how do they know it that quickly there's got to be something in there that's checking these things like really rapidly as are happening but it was it was the next level like that one opened my eyes a bit and that is usually a struggle for me to get surprised like that at this age in my life but I think I definitely touch on the problem you mentioning too around the copyright side that's incredible and I think another thing that you were talking about there is the role of these big say World Garden Web two players in terms of I guess Free Speech right and I'd be really interested to get your opinion on what do you think their role is what do you think the role of an ex or a Facebook of the world is when it comes to free speech hate speech should they be filtering content or should they just be a service provider that doesn't touch that kind of stuff it's such a messy thing too and this is the

other part like a web two problems manifesting too is like you've got these W Gardens and then you've got these wal Gardens that have like very established monetization and then the the forces that are behind those are very Consolidated too so what you're starting to see happening more and more I mean not starting to it's been happening for a while now but are like a loose Confederation of of companies that are all part of these lobbying groups that typically go after politician but what they're doing is putting pressure on platforms right when they see somebody they don't like or or somebody talking about something they don't want they'll get people Brigade the platform or whatever right like and I think it's a messy it's a messy situation right now because from my point of view like in what Brave tries to do everywhere is have like credible neutrality so you want to be able to let as as long as it's not promoting violence or something that's going to directly harm somebody you want to

use that first amendment as a Northstar to like model after where as much as you can and so you're seeing different platforms use different approaches at this like Facebook made a council that tries to approach these things from the industry side x has taken a very different approach which I kind of align a lot more on I think that there's another part of the Free Speech element too that really really applies to web 3 too because what you're seeing with crypto regulation is a lot of these issues start to boil down with like how do the reg how's the us trying to regulate crypto a lot of it turns into okay in a situation where you have a bunch of hosted daps and things like that that are hosted on servers you it breaks down into like a First Amendment issue because of the way that software is published and like a lot of lawyers I actually had got Preston burn on my pod last week we were talking about this where if you have

something that's locally on your browser on your client on your device that runs on your device just how it needs to run doesn't rely on like a hosted server to do it Things fall into Free Speech territory with with as far as the software is concerned right so there's this element of like the content creation around free speech and users around Free Speech but then there's also this element of like development around free speech and and so what folks are trying to do is say okay like how much of your D or how much of your software can you have run locally on the client versus having to run it there because if you're running it on a server there's a chance you might get flagged as like an unregistered broker dealer or something like that based on the other towns like 1930s Securities regulation which is just very hard to work in you end up with like having a startup in this space is like really wild because we've had companies have to have

so many law firms on tap for different areas and then it's cheap not cheap at all it's really expensive and you see where the barriers of Entry are all playing out too on that side so I mean I think that plays into usability big time too yeah it's so interesting like we started this as a technology first podcast but so often the web three dilemma and debate and philosophy well gets into philosophy right it's such a philosophical point to all this stuff and it borders into legality and it's not just about the tech anymore it's also about how it affects individuals how it affects rights and how governments are starting to regulate and understand that and I think on that point we've talked so much we've talked a little bit so far about the challenges in web 2 and I guess then they present the opportunities for web 3 so tell us about Brave tell us about what it's what the journey is what problem it's trying to solve and how it's solving it yeah

sure so I think um it this this leads in very well um from what you were just talking about around I think if this technology wasn't important it wouldn't boil down to the philosophy so often right because this is where it's like super powerful technology because when you break it down like what we're really trying to do here at Brave is take we say user first a lot and what that really means is you're building software and tools that prioritize the interest of the user first right so that means that the user's privacy is protected by default that means that the user can give data to whoever they want they they just have to be the one to do it and you have to like prompt them to do it and this isn't like cookie consent knowled notices or things like that are super annoying it's more about just like building to fundamentally respect people and our thesis on this initially and what really got me over to Brave initially back in 2016 was the

fact that they were the only people I was seeing that were saying like look you don't have to subvert users decision because there were these companies out there that were starting to say okay for Publishers we can actually bypass the ad blocker and serve an ad to the user and it's pennies but at least you're monetizing something because it was a big problem that you only had a big hammer to solve and that hammer was adding an ad blocking extension for the user right that that just takes the monetization away and then you had these ad blockers that were like okay we can put acceptable ads or whatever in the mix but that doesn't solve the Privacy problem at all because then they just end up whitelisting tracking so Google ends up tracking people anyway right and so brave was like let's just start from zero let's start with those conditions where the user is respected and and users are put first and so that means we're going to block any third party ad and

tracking um by default in the browser and users can still go and and turn them on if they want that's up to them but you're giving the choice back to the user and then it started there with the Privacy side and with and then we started implementing policies internally all of our stuff's open source too but basically any time we have new code or updates to the code that ship in the browser we have a really pretty intense like security and privacy review process because if you want things to be user first you have to make sure that what you're doing is like living up to a really high security standard you have to make sure that it's transparent that it could be audited by the outside and so we check off all these boxes on the ethos side but really if you can put the user first respect their privacy there's no reason why business can't live in that environment I think that people naturally hope that's how things are happening but then it's

not right so what we're doing is starting from zer zero building business on top of that that works and then trying to get the accounting right and everything right with okay well there's no reason why you can't account for things right like you should be able to track things you just have to do it in a way that doesn't identify a single user and then broadcast their information everywhere on every website that they go to right and so that's kind of where these approaches and it ties into what we were talking about around First Amendment earlier where okay like Brave what we did with the ad model initially was say okay look not only can we try to fix the Privacy problem and change the way the ads are served but we also want to give users the option to where they could actually earn a revenue share on the advertising that they do because they're part of the attention economy like without them you have nothing and so like users have been giving us

stuff away without even knowing it and giving it away is a generous term right like they've really been getting fleeced uh and tracked without really even knowing it for a really long time but if we can fix the model the way that it it works with privacy and then we can also give users an opportunity to earn that want it that's a better model that we we positioned that the the internet could start adopt at a bigger scale and so you get a bunch of like awesome benefits when you start to care about privacy too from a software perspective because you you realize how much of the internet web pages are just clogged with Just Junk right like you you go to some I used to do these Benchmark tests where we go to different websites like CNN or other news websites and you would see like if you let it just open up and run without any protection going like thousands of requests are going out over a matter of minutes and all of

them almost all of them have your information in them and so the weight that puts on your system is pretty severe the amount of bandwidth that consumes is heavy and if you start looking outside the US these things are really important to people especially bandwidth and and device size because there's only so many resources on a couple year old device or whatever and so we started to build these models at work we changed the way that advertising would work in a browser and this is something I work pretty closely on because it was really inefficient when you look at how ads were served especially programmatically you go to a web page all these things are happening from the page that go back to the cloud where all these servers live a decision is made up there about what ad to show you and then an ad has showed you it's all done based off of like a ton of data that's leaked but it's all like different profiles of you that are never complete really

and so what we said is look like the browser knows everything about the user locally on the device the browser knows your browsing history the browser knows where you're at browser knows all these things what if we just put the way to match advertising directly in the browser instead of having it work on the cloud with all these other companies trying to do it for you like we we actually use that whole Corpus of data locally on the client to match the ad so it's like putting a really smart ad server directly in the browser and then serve ads and then don't leak the user information to anybody and then use ways like with zero knowledge proofs and and reporting to like actually get an accurate accounting to The Advertiser so that they know that they're getting Roi like on their investment for spending money on the platform and so that's what we that's what we did right we changed the way that um ads work from the browser and then we started implementing reporting

systems that like actually could give you an accurate read without without compromising user that's fascinating there's so many little things that I want to pick up on there one I mean add Revenue sharing we have to talk about that in more detail but before we get there it's the idea of cookie so most people we talk about it at a shallow level see cookies is a bad thing right people are tracking your information you go into a web page and there's cookies everywhere and that slows everything down it means they're tracking everything you do everywhere and that's bad generally that's what the kind of consensus is but you get things like remembering login information personalization shopping cart session management all this kind of stuff so I imagine what you're saying is we're turning cookies off completely do you lose all these features but what you've just inferred from what you said was that actually it's managed locally in the browser so you still have all those features the user doesn't see much of a difference

we just don't have this connection between the local browser being connected to something on a server and having that ping back is that correct it's correct there's a lot of different contexts with this too there are types of cookies that are used that are like first party cookies like when you go to a website and it tries to save your login information and things like that like functional cookies right that that you need to be able to like do the thing that you're going to the website to do and what's the challenge there for us has been over the years it's been a huge challenge to the point where we've actually brought new technology to Market to help to break the web as little as possible while still giving really good privacy protection because brute forcing these things sometimes makes it really hard to like what advertising technology started to do as ad blockers got more popular was they started to tie the marketing technology together with the functional technology so that if you couldn't

if you block this thing that the ad needed it would then block the functional thing on the website and so what you end up happening is like all these cases where the ad blockers had to like whitelist stuff or whatever and what we said is okay what our our research team this guy piece in our super big brain on this stuff like brought some research papers out where okay we can put these techniques in that will allow for the user to have their privacy preserved and then not break the web as fundamentally so like that's been the ongoing challenge too is that like you've got a Brute Force approach that people have been using for a long time that works decently well to block a lot of the stuff but then also as the technology gets more and more because ad blocking and and advertising is an adversarial game it's a cat and mouse game it's very tomon Jerry where okay anybody that goes to Twitch a lot like will see this cat and ass

game play out where it's like oh I'm not seeing ads I am seeing ads now like we hear about it all the time and so a lot of effort goes into making sure that like users are getting what they expect but also like you're not breaking important things because that if you can't use something that you need to use you're going to change your browser like we see that happening uh pretty quickly too so it's been a balancing act that it took us a long time like our retention has gotten so much better because we put the time into making these things work over time but it it's a challenge right because the the industry like they don't want to lose money and and yeah how business works too so I think you're balancing these two things which kind of collide often but there's ways you can do with technology that makes both of them still work yeah I I like that you describing it as that Journey right and this is why I wanted

to talk about this theme of web 2.5 in this episode because you're as I understand it and I I'm also a brave user so my understanding of Brave has always been it was this privacy focused browser first super fast privacy preserving the new way of blocking and handling ads basically your data in the browser and then over time it's developed more and more of these what we will call Web 3 features it was gone from just zero to one on improving the web 2 experience and saying here's the better advertising here's the better priv preserving properties you get in a browser and then you've added the basic attention token for you know being rewarded for watching advert and then you also have the kind of the the Creator rewards system right so can you go into a little bit more about those two things firstly what the role of the basic attention token is the bat token and then also what the kind of more modern Creator royalties and and rewards programs are for brave

yeah sure so we initially started with Bitcoin in the browser back in 2016 with a proof of concept and it was really an interesting time because um people were looking for different kinds of use cases for it but at the same time like we it was when all these big things were happening in Bitcoin around like block sizing and transaction fees you really started to see okay on its own Bitcoin cannot scale to do what we needed to do here both like with okay you're only making a block every 10 minutes and the fact that we have something in production now where if somebody wants to contribute $5 to content creators as they browse they have to put $10 in the machine in order to do it because the fees were expensive when there were a lot more people using it and so at the time we were looking at options and like I mentioned in the beginning we hit this one of the things when I I was really interested in helping on when

I came on board was the fact that there's a tricky problem here of blocking the accounting in the process of advertising right and so when we saw what ethereum was doing with the ability to tokenize different use cases we saw there being a great one with the attention economy and we really in order to make things from the original work that Brendan Ike our creator had it was basically or the co-founder and and president of Brave found it was you got to fix the web right and you got to make it commercially viable and so what we started was like okay let's make this use case with advertising because that's the biggest lowest hanging case that we can do especially with that and so we can lean in on on getting the Privacy right first and then building the business lines in first because even back then in 2017 2016 like nobody had really solved the problem of how you do these things at scale but what we were seeing is ethereum was the place

where people were actually like really addressing it seriously and so we started to say okay cool let's make let's make a token that we can use and over time like initially we'll prove out that users can get a REV share and that creators can get rewarded from users in this platform but also like over time as the technology improves and and gets uh more scalable let's put the reporting for the system on chain so that advertisers and and creators and and the the public at large can see an accurate accounting of what we're saying because if you think about how advertising Works outside of our system you've got five different companies in a lot of cases all tracking one impression because nobody trusts anybody and they're all kind of tracking each other and so if you can have a public blockchain that you could verify campaign data from you don't need to have all those different intermediaries that are all collecting data on the user so that's kind of where it started is let's use

this smart contract model as a way to initially put a token value out there that users can earn from and creators can earn from and you can have more transparency and clearer reporting on that's publicly verifiable because that fits really well with the open source codebase that we have that model that ethos of you know having transparency and nobody else was really even thinking about this at the time and so that was the initial thesis that's what we put in the white paper and it was initially for advertising but it really was something where we put this in the white paper too where there are lots of other attention based use cases that we can use this token for and um that's been interesting thing about actually having this in Market is because it's a erc20 token we started seeing bat get picked up by other projects and protocols for use cases we didn't even think about like that that time that we made the white paper so like dii came on in 2019 2020

this is like two years roughly after uh the white paper had come out where you start seeing people because they're holding bat like they want to put it to work on these different things so maker Dow and compound and a bunch of the D5 protocols early on started to add bat and started to play with it in the in production which was cool we're all sitting back with popcorn saying this is great let's see hopefully this thing doesn't blow up over here and then and then and then compound was a big one where I think they did like you know tens of millions of dollars in in in defi testing basically like in production with their community and then they ended up upgrading the protocol from what they learned from that and having bat involved those things is cool but we saw this in like web 3 gaming too and in other areas with nfts Etc but back to what you're saying though initially the original question right like the earliest cases with this stuff

like bringing people in for ad blocking right like when you're growing a product like you have to find fit and you have to find fit at the stage that you're in and for us like having these web three ethos in the product has always been what we've wanted even before people were even using web 3 as a term we had Bitcoin in and and it was all very much of having a better model and the thing that people lose sight of is that there's so much noise around scams and garbage in this space that people try to think approach it especially uh politicians or political leaning people that do are feel threatened or or whatever they they'll approach us as like a negative thing when in reality like this is a publicly transparent blockchain that works with math and is actually an upgrade to to the system if you have to deal with advertising you're dealing with different reporting systems for one event that all are 10 to 15% off there's a discrepancy between all

of them that's all money that you're losing right like if you can have this stuff from a single uh Ledger where you can verify it and it's verified in by a consensus model in the beginning like that solved a huge problem and so so yeah like getting that ad blocking piece initially worked while we built the platform up and then once we started to launch we integrated the token into the browser six months after we created on the blockchain because we had Bitcoin already there and so we transitioned from Bitcoin into bat and that was where you could actually like contribute if you wanted to put it in the system and what we did was we set aside a pool of tokens when we did the launch basically for user growth where we could tap into that and basically say okay like we can use this to bootstrap the platform so we would give people grants a bat to to test out and show creators that hey look you could start to make some income

off of this and if you work with us and grow with us like we can turn this into a really a good business line for you that's so interesting it's a really interesting story as well I didn't realize that you'd originally been trying to use Bitcoin that's really interesting to hear because yeah I think a lot of people when you look back at the origins of Bitcoin and it's talked about doing these small casual payments like micro payments to Me Brave has has been one of the Pioneers in actually putting that model forward and I'm glad you man mentioned Brandon Nike right one of the co-founders also for anyone listening co-founder of Milla creator of JavaScript so this is an idea that is being backed by some of the biggest people in Tech effectively some of the greatest Minds in Tech this whole idea of a Creator economy attention economy as you put it that is based on this kind of micro payment system or partial revenues right so if you watch an advert maybe

a small piece of it goes to Brave and that helps you to stay in the business as a platform and a small part can go to the Advertiser and the small part can go to the person watching it it's a much more Equitable model right so the next thing I want to ask you then we've mentioned web 2.5 this term I want to ask you what do what do you think about that as a piece of terminology because I as I said I would probably put Brave on that Spectrum it's very much doing web three things but it's plugging it into existing Web Two infrastructure into a familiar setting like a browser to to help people on that Journey so would you also characterize it as part of web 2.5 2.5 or something else entirely yeah no I think the way the way that you guys are framing it I what I was super excited to do this interview too because we've gone through this journey ourselves here like when you've got the first principles

that you want with these things and then you're dealing with challenges and how the technology has to improve in order for those things to become a reality right and it required us to to very much have a 2.5 approach because when we first launched this like I said earlier like the technology wasn't scalable to do this on chain fully but also so we did our token launch in May of 2017 like the end of May Regulators hadn't really talked about any of this stuff in a serious way until a few months later like in July of 2017 and that's where it was like okay there was the DOW one of these Dow guidelines that they put out there and a bunch of opinions Etc around crypto and using it was still very unclear right but from our perspective like we have always started by saying look we don't want to part of the things that makes Brave different from other companies is like companies typically want to start collecting data right away about their users

so they can learn Etc like we don't want to collect any data from our users we want to collect the minimum amount of anything possible in order for the service to run because if something happens like a government confiscates your servers or you get breached by hackers or whatever if you have user data on those servers especially if it's not encrypted you're putting those users at risk right and we want to make sure that we have a situ like a position of like maximum deniability so if something does happen even Brave doesn't use it we treat ourselves as the adversary when we're threat modeling a lot of these problems because we just want to make sure that this is what sets us apart from a lot of the other players in the space especially when you see companies like Google and others that start to talk about privacy where it's like you guys the first thing I do is get prompted to sync everything to your guys' servers on all my devices this is not

privacy it's a different type of privacy you're talking about from our perspective we haven't wanted to handle that user's data but the the regulatory situation was so unclear that we decided okay let's work with partners that are like exchanges or custodians that so if users want to take their earnings and take them off like we can offload to a compliant partner so in our system you can opt in view ads and basically like in a couple of clicks be a contributing person in the ecosystem with that if you want but then if you want to withdraw it you have to go through a process of of part linking with a custodian like a uphold or gemini or bit flyer in Japan or Zay in India like so there there's different we offloaded things at certain points kind of as a 2.5 step basically because at the time then too I mean go back to 2017 users were using like Mist as a wallet on ethereum or they were using like what my ether wallet metamask

started to kind of become popular but like the the tooling was like really crude and hard to learn around self- custody back then and so basically there were all these different types of problems that needed addressing and so we put in some pragmatic steps that were like 2.5 is steps to get them there plus like a really interesting thing here and this really applies to Brave I think more than others in the space because it's not just about the users like we have to be able to make a Creator come and use our platform easily and so when I since we worked with these creators and Publishers in the past I know that okay they can the process for them adding an ad tag to a page is like not terribly complicated and it's something that they're familiar with can we make a process that works it's about as easy as that is to get into our system and then get them hooked up to a custodian so then they can get paid right as

the second part of that and so we had to approach these things from these different angles so like creators we figured that out got like two million creators to to on board over the the course of time and then the other challenge we had too was on the advertising side where this platform uses crypto right especially back in 2019 when we launched the ad platform this stuff was way over advertisers mainstream businesses heads they didn't want to hear about it they don't they they hear crypto and they think lawyers and and accountants and more and more annoying things that nobody has time for especially when you're a startup and you don't have a ton of scale yet because I think when we launched our ad platform we had about five million monthly active users at the time and so like it was the numbers were were moving up but they weren't that's not moving anybody that has to manage time on their calendar during a day that's not going to get people excited and so

we had to make a system that worked for the advertisers too so what we did for them was model that similar to like how they buy media elsewhere and then abstract away a lot of the crypto but make it there if they want so if you want toay with that you can pay with that or you can pay with other cryptocurrency too but we don't require it up front because we wouldn't scale the business if we had to right so these we definitely had to take these 2.5 approaches and we thought okay if we can do this and make it super easy if we can make it two to three clicks you're on and you're a part of the system that's a win and so we did that right and we got over 10 million users to basically opt into Brave rewards and start to be a player the system and it was one of those things that really stood out too when in the last bull run with crypto where my neighbors I don't

know if this happens to you guys either but like each of these Cycles picks up and then I become like this kind of crypto consiliary with everybody in my friends and family and neighborhood that I talk to and they're all like okay at the first one 2017 18 they were like okay this is a scam you guys are going to get banned or whatever and I don't believe in this and then the next cycle 2020 2021 everyone was like oh how do I buy can you show me how to buy cryp and I'm like okay but what you started hearing from people there was like I don't understand all these weird use cases but I totally understand that I use your browser and then I can earn while I'm using your browser because that fits a lot of like loyalty reward types of programs that are out there and and so they got to be on board but the other cool thing that started happening is that we' had users that had been earning in

the browser for a long time before the last bll run and then when things started to move with markets and the values of the token went up and people had been accumulating a lot of bad throughout they started to see oh my gosh like I've earned hundreds of dollarss of value in crypto just from using a browser which is cool because we do another thing in Brave on our new tab page like in the browser we show you how many ads you blocked how much time you've saved estimated and then how much data you've saved but then there's this other M element where it's like this is how much I've earned like over time too where these are all great growth hacks by the way like if people are trying to look for product Market fit this is kind of how you can do it without having to do an airdrop is you think of ways to reward retained use of your product because that's what you really care about there a vanity metrics out

there like oh I got this many downloads or or this many users or whatever but what I look at that stuff sure but like when I'm looking at the health of a product I want to know what the daily returning users are because those are the people that use me every day right and those are the people where if I can figure out ways to connect with those people we can build product that other people will use for sure that's a powerful sentence I really like that um I think you touched on a lot of the the challenges to adopting web 3 and I think these are pretty constant across the board and it's you know one of the reasons why the web 2.5 term is becoming so popular it's the things that you know me and Jack say all the time like you touched on regulatory uncertainty that's always one of the top ones right the biggest one is always user experience so I've got two questions here one is do you think that

users are becoming more ready for the full web 3 Model because of this you know web 2.5 transition and the increased knowledge and understanding of you know crypto assets for example and all this kind of stuff and are there any other challenges you see to the full adoption of a full web 3 Paradigm right now outside of regulatory certainty and user experience that's a really good question I mean because we saw these things manifest a bit in the last bll run where Jimmy Fallon and all these big names started to promote nft projects basically I don't know if they would like me saying promote but you guys get it right uh or like Eminem or Snoop Dog or whatever with board apes and things like that but I think that it was great to see a lot more people show interest at that time but I think that what we saw were the cracks too big time right like I used to deal with a lot of Frontline support when this was happening where the

because you had all these people flocking to the the blockchains it led to more congestion in the middle of a bull run which is going to see defi all these other use cases are congesting the network too and one of the most painful things of it was sitting there getting feedback from people like look I didn't know about gas fees like I didn't know like it's costing me more to make the transaction than it is for the thing I'm transacting for which is a huge problem right and the thing that's been really difficult as somebody that's been in this space for a long time is seeing how low a priority that's been or how much it's been handwaved I guess I would say because people will come and say things like oh we're going to abstract all of that we'll make all these l2s but then we're going to abstract it away with a account abstraction it's going to be great you're not even going to know you're on there that's like talk like that's

those are hard things to do and I think that's the thing that the space totally ignores is just how hard it is the mortality rate for startup is like 90% right over over the first five years you have a 90% chance of failing a startup right that's before you throw web3 into it we throw web 3 into it the barriers are even higher right like you have to figure out ways to reduce that cognitive load for users because the reality is you're not just making something new with web 3 you're making something that has to compete with big Tech on incumbent web two spaces where they're figuring out ways for you to do to a checkout line at Whole Foods and pay with your palm at the register they're trying to think about things of like how do I remove the need to even take a wallet out of my purse to buy groceries which is like a level of convenience that you have to compete against which if you take that to web 3

developers they just they're they just don't know how to handle they could lose their mind like they don't which is fine they don't need to figure those problems out but my point is that if there isn't a big effort around this and this is why the 2.5 stuff I think is useful if there isn't a big effort around Bridging the Gap here and making things competitive like against commercially web two things then this is never going to get Beyond uh a science experiment or or a science project where maybe we got like tens or 20,000 daily active users that are all web three people but we never were able to get those bigger players on that can get us that breakthrough into bigger mainstream audiences and so I think that's a big usability it's like such a huge thing that we're finally now at this phase able to start to put things together for broader adoption which the timing of this interview is really interesting because last week we announced something pretty big around this

but but I think that from our perspective at Brave too getting the problems we were trying to solve with the token initially were big enough that we could really focus on the Privacy side and then work in the web three pieces as long as we're driving the principles of those things where it's like users getting rewarded creators having an alternative build those pieces in with 2.5 and then get to where we are now where okay now there are options for with the technology where we can start to do things on chain and now we can actually start to take it to that next level on the web 3 side that's where we're at now it's taking eight years to get here and it's not even clean or or pretty right now like it's really ugly right now right like there's stuff that you're having to do to really try to make this work that aren't great but I think that'll come with time too and I think that AI coming hitting the scene now and

the ways that crypto can help address some of the concerns around AI with identity and proofs of authentication and authenticity and all these types of things like it's just going to help to make that adoption more more more easy for developers and software creators and kind of creators and everybody right but but yeah you have to have the 2.5 and from us what we've done is we've figured out okay here's a really great way to get millions of of users millions of creators and to get mainstream advertisers to buy into a web 3 based system here's what the next phase of this if we're being serious and what really I mentioned earlier how we started having these abstract scenarios come into manifesting themselves in reality with with big Tech and Regulators Etc when we saw things happen we introduced like a self custodial wallet into the browser because like self custody is one of those user first things that you need to if you're building for users like self custody is a critical part of

that um because you know you own you're controlling your own destiny basically by having self- custody um and so if we had a model that we could get millions of users to use that was with our token if we can apply the learnings that we have from getting those millions of users to do that system into something like self- custody 90% of browser users are making e-commerce purchases in a browser so if we can start to build those things out that's where we see ourselves as being a real player here in bridging that Gap it's not going to be to a billion users overnight but it needs to be Millions to tens of millions to hundreds of millions right and so I think that we're at that phase now where okay cool like I can go we can plug salana in and we have a multi-chain wallet so we're not saying one blockchain over another it's like making these things accessible is key because there's Regional things like some blockchains are used in different parts

of the world compared to others and it's also nent it's like acting like there's only one size fits all for anything is stupid there's no technology that's really like that and so we built in multi-chain self- custody while it into every single braid browser and it's in the core browser code so it's not turned on by default but users have it there if they want it and it's being in the core browser code it's basically sandbox from the outside to so you get a lot of like security protection that wouldn't get from an extension where there's still cases now where there's a fake extension gets on an extension store and you start talking about people's funds it's the Privacy is a good primer for dealing with user funds right like from a software perspective because you are not going to hear a lot of the issues a lot of times because of the nature of Finance like people don't really feel comfortable airing their financial laundry in public so you have to really figure out

ways to like solve some addressable problems when you're building these things out we're not there yet right I mean self- custodies in every Brave browser but like the process needs to be cleaner and it needs to be easier but what we started to do was look at things like a video conferencing piece of software that's kind of a zoom competitor it's called Brave talk it's in the browser so we've added in web 3 functionality into that so if you have nft uh on salana or on ethereum we can basically like token gate conversations you can pass off moderator access you can sign in we added to sign in with ethereum we've support in like crypto browser domains too so like doou or or ensam addresses or Unstoppable domains and we've also integrated ipfs into the browser as well so we've got all these pieces like we really see web 3 as part of the bigger web in general right and the other interesting thing about last cycle is like metaverse as a meme blew up

but like really the metaverse is the web right and the user's agent is the browser like technically browsers are called a user agent right and so that's the last line like between you and the internet really is that browser and so us building these things out and progressing them as pragmatically as we can on the Practical business side but also as radical as we can on the Innovation side that's a lot to balance but like that's where we've been at with these things and we think we can do it because just because the last run we had neighbors saying huh yeah I could do this the other thing was super interesting too so the I used to default to saying okay go to coinbase to buy your crypto and I'll walk you through that process the last run because coinbase got so much bigger and their anti fraud and other things like the regulatory burden came on them it actually became a lot harder like I walked through with an retired aunt and uncle-in-law that

wanted to buy it took me two and a half hours to get them from starting to actually buying something on coinbase and they could only buy $50 a week and they were tired they have money they're established it was really difficult and then I ended up getting them I was like they're like don't you guys I saw an ad in Brave for your wallet can I just buy it through your wallet and I was like oh yeah like I had just been mental modeled this out to where I'm like self custody so hard I'm not going to have them I have them trying 20 minutes they had bought from the browser directly and they have they're types that are writing notes when they're next to their computer and and have safes and things like that they they get it right so I think that the technology has been making progress It's not three yet it but 2.5 is a good kind of way to approach it to get because even getting fit in the markets

hard with with Market participants like and by Framing it with 2.5 is something people understand yeah I really glad you agree then and I think one thing I've Tak from the conversation is you've really nicely articulated this dichotomy from the huge value proposition of web 3 but also the misalignment of incentives of the web 2 world to getting it adopted right and I think the way youve described Brave is actually it's very well positioned to realign the incentives and to actually put put the the companies and the creators as well and the individuals in the position where they actually can benefit from this technology much more easily so I'm really you know excited by that I also really love the idea Brave talk that sounds amazing and I think there's all sorts of applications I could think of there for you know micro payments joining a Twitter space where you get someone to pay large micro payments maybe to speak would be interesting but you know I feel like we could talk about some of

these kind of more wacky use cases all day we're coming to the end of the conversation though Luke so I want to ask you I have to give you a word on the future so what are you most excited about to see the space in five 10 years time yeah I think where I'd love to see it is where and this is an area where we're trying to be a player in too is like right now this crypto space is often its own Silo in a lot of ways compared to other types of payment methods and other even things like we're talking about token gating right or accessing things like these are still siloed out like a wallet is a crypto wallet and you have a separate thing for all of your passwords and key phrases and all this stuff and then you have a separate thing for all your payment methods that are traditional right like I think that getting those things together in the same SP Bas in a wallet makes a lot

of sense because like it should be where this all lives and being in proximity of those things removes a lot of that it demystifies it and that's what you need to do for these things to get the scale that they need because you're going to see people naturally will gravitate in a certain direction and and if they know where to go they can get there and so where I'm excited is to see like how that part of the process gets to see scale and then I think if you look at things like the AI right a year ago this stuff really exploded with Chachi BT and a year later you're seeing an interesting scenario where you have a lot of startups building tooling that need to start to show growth for their investors but also you're starting to see use cases hitting the wild with Taylor Swift was a great example where okay deep fakes are very political season like all these things where you know if these web three things over here can help

to authenticate whether something's real or not or start to approach an ID landscape responsibly it can be the one thing that might be able to actually crack the on making these things easier to like tell the difference of whether something's real or not and so where that's going is going to be huge I think that the other piece that's really been awesome to see too and purists will hate me for saying this but I think like seeing ETF adoption with crypto and what that does for the space for visibility even with Bitcoin being what the etf's on but now you're seeing other things hopping up I think that these are ways where you can start to get those second order effects of what has this done to my Investment Portfolio for my retirement like where without even having to touch any of it right like it's going to do a bunch of things around okay if the markets are set up to speculate based on retail investors which is what the original early stages of

the crypto markets were like you could see it every time they buy the rumor sell the news and and all the bad players and stuff like that but if you're in a situation now where ETFs are a thing and you got institutional buyers making regular purchases whether the Market's up or down it doesn't matter it's on a more of an automated schedule these things are how you get more ility in the markets too over time and more scale and then how you like those people that are using the old methods of of making money in crypto or moving the markets in certain ways are less important than they were which is what badly needs to happen right like I think it's it is depressing how many scams are out there those aren't going to go away but like the reason why they work is because somebody can make a lot and the market move that move things in a certain direction without too much effort to make it in their favor right and I think

that these bigger things happening with institutions and then the bigger potential around adoption and with AI there there's so much investment in the AI space right now and these problems do not have a clear answer that doesn't involve mentioning crypto somewhere along the lines like it's going to be really exciting to see these things come together but there and if people are going to look for that tool and the political arguments around this stuff fall apart like on any type of inspection right to the point where it's just blatantly like you've got us politicians that are FR holding up news articles that have been clearly debunked by other major players in the space and you've actually got judges that are challenging Regulators at the agency level that are being overzealous and all of this stuff where I'm glad there are these checks and balances in place I didn't expect it to come down to like old judges that are making these calls but I'm really glad they're there but but I think that what this

is doing institutionalsales all this stuff being more freely open to use and to adopt and I'm super excited about that plus it's like Banks and other other institutions are also seeing the benefits of upgrading the technology too and so you've seen there's like a ton of these cbdc Pilots I hate the notion of a cbdc personally but but the fact that these things are actually being taken seriously by these players is an indicator that like the technology itself is like what's the important thing is here and these other things are just noise and we've always even to our own detriment at Brave like we've always been heads down and building on this stuff because we've always seen the technology as what's going to deliver the value as opposed to like any short-term whatever and that's to our own detriment like the space does not reward projects that are serious about anything really and it's not just us either look at what partners that chain link has gotten right like it was insane and they're finally

seeing some Tailwinds but it on the market side but these markets are ridiculous right like you can't let them run you or you're they're going to run you right yeah so I think like longer term I think like getting this to become more widely adopted just like how streaming is for media delivery it went VCRs to DVDs to to streaming I think that's a huge it's a leap like that where like um I don't need a bunch of peripheral things I have it all working for my phone I I looking forward to that being what what we start to see rolling out over the next couple years I love that I really resonate with well two of the anwers you gave there one I think there's been maybe some downsides and some naysay about the ETFs and kind of the focus on you know speculation over utility but I think investment in this space generally does tend to feed into all the other projects right that do provide utility and yet the regulatory Clarity that's

going to come by these big institutional players moving into space is going to be a boon for web 3 and specifically for utility projects based in web 3 and the other one you mentioned is obvious a new you touch on it is AI going forward and the need for provence of content account accountability of Bad actors spam deep fakes all this kind of stuff it's just going to be an absolute kind of perfect scenario for web 3 public blockchains and a lot of the things that it seems you're doing it Brave and I'm really excited that you are already starting to thinking about addressing these problems because like you say upcoming ux election it's going to be a boon for deep fakes and Ai and misinformation and we're going to need to have solutions by the next election and yeah it's going to be really exciting to see what projects capitalize on that so we are coming to the closing section now of this super informative and exciting episode I've got two questions Luke that

I like to we like to ask across each episodes to see how the answers vary between different Industries people across time the first one is in one sentence what is web 3 to you web 3 is about uh user first about bringing control back to users basically bringing control back to us succinct I liked it that's really good and the second one is a bit more open if you could choose anyone Dead Alive or fictitious to discuss web 3 with who would it be and why who would it be let me think about that oh gosh that's a good one what I who would I who would I talk about web 3 with I don't know I'd like to talk to Ron Paul about it to be honest he's not dead but the conversation we make that happen we'll hit him up for you that's a tough one because there's so many that come to mind that I could say but yeah cool thanks so much Luke it's been as as Alex said such an

interesting episode I think this will be really valuable one for everyone listening so yeah thanks again Luke for joining us I hope it won't be the last time we have you on the podcast and thanks to those listening wherever you may be join us next time to untangle a little more of 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma CER don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes