Episode 56
Video Game Monetization with Timothy Tello
About this episode
Welcome to another episode of the Untangling Web3 podcast, where today we're diving deep into the realms of gaming and blockchain with none other than Timothy Tello.
Timothy, a seasoned blockchain evangelist and gaming aficionado, has been at the forefront of integrating these technologies. As CEO of 3thix, Timothy is revolutionizing how gamers and developers monetize and interact within digital landscapes, making significant strides in blockchain applications in gaming.
Key Highlights
- Timothy discusses his transition from traditional gaming into the pioneering space of Web3, reflecting on his extensive career and the evolution of monetization models in the gaming industry.
- The episode delves into the challenges and opportunities presented by blockchain technologies in gaming, including player retention, in-game economies, and the potential for cross-game interoperability.
- Timothy shares insights into the significance of user-generated content (UGC) and digital rights management in Web3, highlighting how blockchain can enhance player ownership and profit-sharing.
Timothy's journey and insights illustrate a transformative phase in gaming, underscored by the shift to Web3 technologies that prioritize player agency and economic models that benefit creators and players alike.
The future of gaming seems geared towards a more interconnected and user-centric industry where blockchain plays a pivotal role in shaping new experiences and opportunities. Tune in to grasp how these technologies are not just changing the game but setting the stage for the next generation of gaming.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
half of the world at this point considers themselves Gamers four billion people play video games on a regular basis and as the person who claims the the invention of Ling gaming I've had a very big issue with what we've seen in web3 gaming today digital right management is definitely on the floor front of what the blockchain can provide right ownership of ugc content right that's a big thing we're in a world where content matters right the the currency of a player is content and the more content you have the more likely you are to retain them and you look at Netflix or what Tik Tok does they're designed to make you keep going as long as they can keep you there and that way they can monetize you over and over again while you're there so their value is not so much that you're a user their value is how long they can keep you in the app video games do this by far better than anybody else welcome to another episode of the untangling
web 3 podcast today we're delighted to be joined by Timothy T Timothy is a blockchain evangelist and gaming expert whose work includes pioneering the world's first SEC approved blockchain token and co-authoring patent on blockchain and gaming as the CEO with ethics Tim is driving the revolution of monetization for the gaming industry by redefining tools and processes utilizing blockchain Technologies welcome to the show Tim yeah thank you for having me hey Tim how you doing today I'm doing well how you guys doing yeah not too bad thanks not too bad glad to finally get you on the show we've been looking forward to this one a while and before we get on to all the web 3 gaming stuff can you just tell us a bit about you and maybe your career background how your early career was in the web 2 Gaming world before all this kind of came around yeah so funny how I got into video games my wife as an influencer social media marketing person Webby Award winner but she wanted to
move from Texas or from Los Angeles and at the time I was in like oil Consulting as an upstream process expert so nothing to do with video games nothing to do with blockchain at all and so I didn't really know what I was going to do in uh the Video Game World or what I was going to do in LA to be honest with you I had no idea you know as a sales person I started applying to sales jobs and got very fortunate to be hired by the former BP of Warner Brothers who had just broke off and started his own entrepreneurial Journey if you will and so I started working with him and him and I did a bunch of things and the model that you find within oils is the rollup model right you have one company owning a bunch of different companies but for some reason he owned the localization company he had a development Studio he had a Publishing Company none of it really made sense to me in my
mind so I helped him reorganized helped him with rollups and really became like his right hand in doing so it gave me the ability to meet basically every executive in video games I was on a person name basis with everybody going to meet with people like Frank gabo the CEO of Zinga and guys like John Rella who at the time was the CEO of EA then was the CEO of unity and so I got to really co-mingle with the top Executives of the industry and gaming is very very small it's a very insular industry maybe like 300 people actually run all of gaming from an executive level and so you kind of get to know everybody you know so I I get on the first basis I I help him with his thing I get a little bit of cash from that and I decid you know this is pretty easy I could do my own entrepreneurial thing I met these guys and we started a language learning game the first of its kind we
did pretty well had a couple million dollars of the sales on Steam built another game that game went on to win a bunch of awards and we focused on box is Game Pass like early on Game Pass is so we were number one game on ID at Xbox was IND developer at Xbox two years in a row and then went on to do something with influencers because I really understood marketing was very expensive so before Justin really qu created twitch me and my friend Chris Cross who in my opinion is like one of the most prolific developers of all time created Medal of Honor was headed next on DreamWorks THQ Etc him and I decided to to build a studio together so we built a company called sugar glazed and it was the first ever influencer gaming company and what we did was with marketing costing so much money we were like what if we just put an influencer in the game so that's what kind of led into me moving into the web 3
world I was at E3 and I was hanging out with some friends and Cliffy B if you know who that is he's the creator of unreal so he's like this Prodigy he created unreal when he was 13 his wife is also an influencer my wife's an influencer and we were like hanging out wives were talking going back and forth at the time they were introducing a e3 game called Gunslingers Gunslingers evolved into fortnite and became fortnite and he was telling me how and you got to understand where we were in the industry this is like 2015 2016 free-to-play gaming was not very well liked in the industry people did not want to give away their games for free at all what was that is it just they couldn't understand the revenue models early on or what was the to that do you think from a de developer perspective you got to understand the gaming industry is a very Monkey C Monkey Do industry and when one person does well they'll all do it but until
they do well it's it's all skepticism do you think they're quite risk averse as an industry maybe or extremely risk averse I would say you don't leave the Golden Goose to touch the dragon the dragon it's hiding the massive amount of loot behind it but you already have a Golden Goose so you can't risk the Golden Goose to touch a dragon and yeah that's how the nature of video games are and that's why we're where we're at in web three right when those people go and they touch the dragon and they do very well and have a lot of success that's what other people that's what drives adoption and so freet to play was this thing where why would I give it away for free I spent millions of dollars to make it da there was if you go back and look at the news back then there's people talking about how Apple's going to have to to cancel free to play and make it and block it from the Apple App Store it's a
problem and like web 3 it took shape because southeast Asia latched on to it and it really drove the growth of the freet to-play game going back to my conversation with Cliff he was explaining to me how fortnite would be the first freeto playay game on console and I was like you can't do that that doesn't make ask you what was your opinion on that when he told you that initially yeah immediately was like you can't do that going from mobile games that are like a couple million dollars to make at most right you can make a solid mobile game like two 300 Grand but a console game at that time was probably 30 to100 million now we have games like Call of Duty are more than movies right $300 million to make call of Dy especially in that kind of AAA category the budgets have just kind of blown up haven't they in the last they're they're obscene what they cost but it's because of like how much you have to build now because
here you got to understand like human psychology right once once players realize that console games could be free all games had to be free and I understood that the moment he told me I was like look you can't do that that's not possible you can't get away something for free that cost you that much money if it tanks it's going to be bad it's G to be really bad and his thought process is what I was saying before marketing costs a lot of money it it's very expensive in a video game industry it cost $32 for user acquisition and then the to retain that player is almost impossible the average retention in a mobile game is less than seven days it it's it's it's crazy so you paid $32 and now you have to retain them in order to get them to monetize within the game and you have seven days to do so or you've lost money right it's this very high stakes betting right you're basically playing the roulette and you're praying well
that's why we have this like whale hunting mentality in the video game industry let me find these guys who are going to pump a th 2,000 $10,000 into this game and I'm just going to sit there and I'm gonna hit him over and over again and I'm gonna I'm gonna pray on these people that's really interesting as well Tim because while you're on that point I think we've obviously seen a big shift in how game developers monetize players as well right going back 10 15 years it was basically just a buy the game one time purchase that's the only time you're extracting value from the user now you've got all of the the downloadable content DLC you've got all the pre-order kind of culture and then obviously the the in-game currency and collectibles loot boxes and things like that so the landscape of how you actually extract value from your players is totally different right now yeah but what's crazy is it's not designed to to be focused on people that only want the game
right it's designed for whale hunting it's designed to keep like almost like for collectors right like you you have this like this desire to own everything and those are the people that are paying for the entire industry then you got to understand out of the $32 right 3% of all players are paying players that's it wow so when you think about that half of the world at this point considers themselves Gamers four billion people play video games on a regular basis there's 8 billion people in the world and predictions say that by 2030 with the elderly passing on and the the younger generation growing in by 2030 it'll be closer to 8 billion people will be consider themselves gamers in 80% of the world my God at that time at the rate of growth will be at 10 billion people in the world 8 billion of which will be playing video games and it makes sense right every baby every toddle now walks around with an i parents literally hand him an iPad say hey
here you go so going back to my story he's telling me about this freet to playay stuff I'm like that doesn't make sense you can't give it away your investors are going to be so mad like how like if this tanks like you're screw buddy this is bad and he's like we're doing it I don't care we're doing it Tim Sweeny said we got this epic is a private company it doesn't matter we're doing it I said okay you do you and we all know that Tim when he does not care what his investors say right he took on Apple and was like I'll I'll go down with the ship I don't care I'll do it if that's what it takes to get it get it done I'll go down with the ship so was that one of your first interactions then with the idea of free to play obviously but then did that introduce you to the concept of web 3 initially or was that like a gradual Journey from there no so I
was already doing free to play right because the games that we were doing were mobile games right sugar gles where we put an influencer into the game that was a freeo playay game so we did like the mama channel was our first test they had like 4 million YouTube followers and we were able to get hundreds of thousands of downloads and so we we were able to monetize these people through ads and we were able to get money so that's how freeo play worked it was all because if you had enough users coming in advertisement would cover the cost you don't have toar just like social media right how how we have it in all the big platforms now yeah but that's not a thing on Console you don't have when last time you play a console game and an ad popped up it's never happened so how do you take a free-to-play game on console that cost you 50100 million and you're going to turn around and say hey I'm gonna do this I'm
gonna put I'm gonna give it away your investors are going to freak out like how you can't do that and so they did it but at the same time the European Union was doing the Euro they were consolidating because Greece was about to become bankrupt and I had already been investing in blockchain since like 2010 2011 and I'm kind of a nerd so I've been paying attention and watching things and I bought Bitcoin at $100 I bought ethereum at like $9 so your character Arc makes sense to me you had an understanding of Bitcoin you're an early adopter then you had this illustrious career in gaming and it kind of brings the two together and that's why you're here today to talk about web 3 gaming and like what the opportunities are and what how IT addresses some of the challenges in web two gaming yeah yeah going to the story right so European Union is coming together Greece is coming out of bankruptcy CR the Euro and I'm like wait if free to play
games are on Console right that he's going to do it that means all games have to be free to play and if all games have to be free to play there could be a consolidation of video game tokens and there could be the only thing that I know that could do that is cryptocurrency and this is really early so this is like ethereum had just like really kicked off at this point like it just started and so I'm like I think you could do it and so we invented blockchain gaming so that patent that you refer to I don't go after anyone for building blockchain games but it's my declaration that I invented blockchain games that I was the first will never do it I wrote the patent for the use of blockchain and the video game via custodial wallets in that patent talks about like data agregation based on decentralized versions that get around Copa compliance get around European data law that get around American data laws California Privacy Law and how we can
Target People based on their wallet address rather than their personal information so all that's in my patent then as you alluded I went on to get the only SEC no ation letter ever given so I worked with DLX law and LS Cohen to had the first ever erc20 token approved by the secd um with the model that would never be uh attacked by the SEC and so we we built the in-game currency model um that basically had no power value it's a blockchain token that replaces in-game currencies but it's only has value than it's economy so yeah let's say you play Madden or you play FIFA or you play whatever EA Sports could have one token right for all those games an EA Sports token and that would reduce the user acquisition cost that would reduce the need for retention metrics I reduce the need for a bunch of different things and so because of that it really would would push so you look at roadblocks right roadblocks has a singal currency and when they
introduced that was also the same time 2015 following the eura they they dropped from a two token model to a single token model and their revenue doubled every year for seven years their retention remember I told you retention in a video game is up to seven days their retention was three years now wow the average retention of Roblox is three years the average LTV so the LTV standing for the value of a player lifetime value of a player in a regular game is about three bucks and Roblox it's $300 wow the you know user acquisition doesn't change it's still about $32 but if you're retaining them that long and you they cost $32 but you're making $300 on them that's a a really solid return I just want to nail down right the in-game currency aspect right because you know for many people in-game currency has existed since as long as games have you know you've had Mario you pick up your coins that's kind of what comes to mind for many people when they
think of that but the model has really changed as you're alluding to you can have currency that is interoperable between games and I think for me that's one of the big elements of web 3 gaming that's exciting so for you what actually defines web3 gaming as opposed to what we've had in the old world of gaming online and mobile is it just about these new currency tokens or is there something more profound or am I missing anything in what makes web 3 gaming special and distinct from all that well I think there's a lot of different things and I want to be completely transparent so I don't want to hide I think that blockchain gaming isn't where it needs to be on mainstream gaming yet we're not we don't have the finality the TPS we don't have the security layers that are strong enough yet to really handle like Call of Duty or fortnite and the transactions in the user base those games can produce right we also don't have a really solid version of
a subnet or layer twos that can that can offer their own zks or their own side chain that are strong enough that don't have issues with scalability that's a big problem right if could you imagine a world where Call of Duty goes down for five hours it'd be like the world was ending for a lot of people we're we're not there yet and so we're at a point where I think the the real value of blockchain and I as the person who claims the the invention of it of bling gaming I've had a very big issue with what we've seen in web3 gaming today I I don't like the speculation I don't like how nfts have these massive barriers of Entry right I don't understand how you can sell your nft for $200 to your pame that's in my opinion not even a game what makes your game that much better than Call of Duty Call of Duty is 60 bucks why are you saying that you're $200 game is is better of these aren't
even games or staking protocols with animations they're not games there's nothing gaming about it and so we're getting to the point where true games are coming like strap gunzilla these games are are are coming out and they're actually AAA quality titles now we also have a lot of people that are looking at these interoperable tokens and I think that's the the first step into web three like I always say no one cares how the internet works they just care that it works and with that in mind the blockchain should be invisible there there's no reason that we we sit and talk about oh I'm on madic or I'm on optimism or I'm on ZK or I'm doing this like it doesn't matter no one should care because the last time you went to a website or you know us using this app right now the streamyard to host this podcast what server is it sitting on you have no idea nor do you care right but somewhere this is being stored on the internet somewhere
it's being hosted on the internet but it doesn't matter and it shouldn't as long as it works and it makes life easier that's where things matter and so we've had the wrong view in web 3 for a long time it's been about holistic gains it's been about speculation and it's been about Ponzi schemes and not about technology we've had a lot of Bad actors I like that a lot and it's something that has resonated with Jack and I throughout the show we've kind of always said especially in blockchain and web 3 and cryptocurrency CES there's been a focus on the tech right and that's typically to the detriment of the user experience and why build anything unless the user benefits in some way or unless maybe the developer saves money or something like this in some way and I think one of the things I think as a an avid gamer myself you say half the people in the world Define themselves as Avid Gamers I think a big thing is the collect Collectibles market
right if I'm in World of Warcraft I want mounts if I've got a skin in a certain game I want to display that it's not just about the functionality and the utility it's also to an extent about the social Flex I've seen someone numbers being thrown around the nft market for specifically for gaming by 2030 will be around half a trillion like I get what you mean completely agree there's so much BS speculation around this stuff but there's some real utility in Social kind of um currency I guess that can be derived from this for for users and Gamers as well right yeah digit Ro management is definitely on the Forefront of what the blockchain can provide right ownership of ugc content right that's a big thing I think as we get into video games further and further we're in a world where content matters right the the currency of a player is content and the more content you have the more likely you are to retain them and you look at like games like
Roblox or Netflix or what Tik Tok does it's all about how much content one person can consume at any given moment and they' proven this right Amazon does the same thing right why does everyone use Amazon Prime because it has all the items you could ever possibly want it's all about content right I don't know how many times I don't even use Facebook the only reason I have it is because of Facebook Marketplace and I don't buy anything I just scroll I just want to see what people are selling right that content is valuable so ugc content now let's take that a step further right now you don't own the rights to any of the content you create within Roo within fortnite within Unity like you don't own this as a Creator like when you guys post this on the internet you don't own it and that's a problem in my mind right with digital Rights Management you could own it you could create an item that makes gaming easier or makes making a game
easier or makes some kind of artistry or something that people can add and you can get a revenue share off of that item for the purchase of whatever all through the smart contract right we can create tokens that create interoperability right that make the value of playing within a publishers Community much better right we can look at ways to create advertisement and so this is what uh ethics is doing we're redefining how in-game advertisement Works how in-game monetization works by handling in a decentralized manner people like me don't want to opt in I don't want you to have my personal information I want to be anonymous and I feel like a lot of the blockchain world wants that and a lot of millennial and Chin Z want that they don't want you to track them they don't want you to know when you set up your computer I guarantee you everyone turns off every bit of the location all the things that you just don't want that and so there's been a big misconception from
Web Two to web 3 and it's with all these apps like you were saying social media makes money from advertisement right but what people don't realize is you are the product you are the what they're selling Facebook is and Tik Tok and Twitter these are our pieces that are psychological drivers that attach you to them that keep you there they're designed to make you keep going as long as they can keep you there and that way they can monetize you over and over again while you're there so their value is not so much that you're a user their value is how long they can keep you in the app video games do this by far better than anybody else yeah that's why we're using the term gamification right and you you touched on something really important there that I hadn't considered so we've emphasized the value of like web three gaming for players is around ownership of assets ownership of skins nfts whatever you want to call it and I think most Gamers understand the
value of that but there's also the Privacy aspect like I can start to do privacy preserving identity verification and all this kind of stuff which is super important to players as well but something you mentioned there is also about the benefits to developers is because you have players who are more incentivized to create community-driven content because you can you know use things like smart contracts to incentivize monetization back to the developer and all also the Creator Inay of Roblox like they're going to get these games that are just glowing past anything they'd originally developed because the communities has an incentive to develop it themselves and that gets people in really quickly right there's nothing better than someone developing a game who loves the game as much as any player does yeah yeah and we have like mods and I'm a big like old school game player like Final Fantasy and like with the new Final Fantasy coming out it's kind of had a Resurgence of these Final Fantasy 7 mods and so there's people who
aren't making any money at all to build that are building mods that you can download onto your computer and you can have a full rendering of Final Fantasy 7 from 1999 that looks like a modern day title these people are making they're just doing it because they love it and they they could be making money from that they could be selling this they could be creating a revenue share model they could like square unit is really big on web 3 they're doing a lot of stuff on web 3 they could make Gil Universal from all games Revitalize every single Final Fantasy to ever ever exists right they could automatically start monetizing them all this kind of comes back to your relationship with like the influencer and understanding influencers and their relationship with social media like they have these weird kind of symbiotic relationships but there's no the say the Instagrams or the Facebooks of the world don't have to give them monetization even though they're bringing in so much fan base to watch their content
it's a similar kind of Paradigm with these people that are creating Maps creating mods for Gam games that are bringing in the user base but they're not necessarily being incentivized in a transparent kind of defined way by the game but they should right yeah it should be a part of it the games like I said going back to the Facebook analogy Facebook and Tik Tok and all these guys they're trying to get you to stay there as long as they can think of the last time you turn on a video game I guarantee you you played it for more than 30 minutes you played it more than an hour right on average the average game time of a of a console game is three to five hours that's great that's that's nothing I've five times that I think on an average but the average is three to five now yeah I also look at blockchain and I look at like what is us from the Privacy standpoint and what can we actually really do so
again going back why do they want you to stay in Facebook and Tik Tok it's because they want to monetize you as many times as possible through ads and so they're selling your information into these data pools we've lost a thing called idfa idfa is identifier for advertisement right and apple is what it's what made Apple a trillion dollar company make no mistake apple does not make any money selling you this they make zero dollar selling you this they make zero selling you a Macbook that's not what they're trying to do apple is a credit card processing and video game third-party publisher that is their business 30% of all the revenue that is sold to the App Store goes to Apple all yeah exactly it goes back to the exact same problem you're describing with these games and how they monetize you and also with the social media platforms they're trying to create wall Gardens that capture you that keep you in there that are very sticky and hard to move in and out of
and you know apple is another example of that it's you know very arguable how much is it worth it for a lot of people you've seen people starting to make decisions adversely and actually maybe I don't need my app on Apple anymore especially with the rise of things like steam I think is really interesting right because that is also in a way democratized how games are sold because you all have this whole idea of pre-ordering more openly and transparently and launching games on there I'm also really interested in we I think we've hinted at this idea of uh play to earn right I think that's part of what is in the web three gaming space this idea of the more you play the more activity you do the better you are at a game you might earn more money for it I've even seen examples of like leaderboards and if you're at the top of a leaderboard you earn money and micro payments from other people which I think is really cool what do you
think about the flip side of that as well and how important do you think it is if we don't want to have this social kind of advertising world where you monetized for being in a platform what do you think about the idea of almost like streaming payments while you play so paying per second or per region of the map you unlock do you think there's a role for that in web 3 as well I'll be honest with you no and I also don't think play earns in a sticker I think that's more on the speculation side and I think that's more on valuing the economy in itself right let me ask you this if you were to go outside and go to a park and I said all right I'm going to turn on the timer and for every second you you're out in this park you have to pay me x amount of dollars right you probably would no longer go to park right even if your kid really wanted to go you're probably
not going to go there's a reason like when you go to Disneyland or to Six Flags there's a one time fee stay as long as you want then you can leave that's how games work that's how everything in life works you would literally instead of having fun you'd be doing this you'd be watching the clock the entire time get out of it you're it's costing you money your mind would be there why do you think when you walk into an arcade and you don't use real money anymore in the 80s you did why did it die because we we started getting inhouse consoles right we started that became more prevalent why is it that it has switched so when you walk into an arcade they make you take your 20 $ and convert it into David Busters into their token into whatever do you know why they do that the psychological thing you are less likely to spend the cash in your pocket than you are to spend the money that you've transferred into the
car you you've disconnected that this is real money this no longer a thing you've now connected to the fact that you have all this funny money and you want to spend yeah and I think that's that's why I brought up play to earn is that that was the craze maybe one two three years ago and everyone saying this is the the big future and it's kind of died to death if you look at something like axi Infinity they don't have a huge number of daily users and they were one of the biggest proponents of that model and it seems as a trend that's really tailed off so I'm glad you you also have the contrarian or maybe not contrarian anymore view that is not necessarily where the value proposition is for web 3 gaming it's probably more in digital Rights Management as you said it's in a lot of things right it's not just digital rights right so again going back to the ad stuff let me talk about what ethics does so ethics in
America I know you guys aren't in the United States in America everyone has a social security number I'm not sure if there's something similar in the UK I'm sure there's some kind of way they track you but essentially your social security number is a custodial wallet that that's what it is so when you're born you're assigned a social security number your birth certificate is attached to it when you go to school you your parents write down your social security number it's attached to you so now they're they're collecting all this information about you right it's all going back because there's 365 million people in America how many of them are named Tim it's a lot right there's no way they could track me by that they can't do it and so when I get a driver's license when I get a credit card when I do all these things it's all Associated to my Social Security member that is the tracking identifier that the government uses to identify who I am the same thing happens
in blockchain we all have a unique wallet address every single one of us no matter what chain it's on it doesn't matter you have a unique walled dress that is is a 100% you it's all about who you are what you're doing and so ethics what we are doing is we're taking that wallet address and we're looking at the games you're playing we're looking at when you monetize in those games and if you do opt in great we're looking at what things you're doing on the internet now let's say Jack he's one to opt in he wants to to earn higher rewards but Alec you don't you're like me and you say I don't want to do this then we say okay Jack is doing all these things this is what we know about Jack he likes this stuff he likes he constantly is looking at bicycles on on Instagram we can see that he's doing this he's doing that all Assassin's Creed for me okay he's playing a lot of Ubisoft stuff and he's
he's going that down that route and then we look at Alex and we compare Alex's wallet to Jack wallet now Alec we don't know his his name we don't know his personal information we have his IP address that's not personal so we know about where you're located we know what games you've been playing we know when you've monetized in those games now Alec and Jack are both playing Assassin's Creed they both come from a very similar IP address they both have very consistent things that they're doing within the video games that they play and that we can track and they have very consistent transactions on chain that are completely public we say these people are are an 80% match and we put them in the same data lake so we're create we're recreating that idfa we're recreating identifier for advertisement in a decentralized manner and so what we're saying is we're taking the in-game consumption of a player and we're comparing it to known players with similar licenses and then we're putting them into Data
L well a data lake is what an Advertiser uses to advertise so let's say now let's say like Coca-Cola comes to us and says Tim we want to advertise to to men from the UK between the ages of 20 and 40 that love Assassin's Creed okay now Jack because he opted in will probably get a higher return now how the system works and think of like Brave browser was the first version of this they were saying you should get paid for the data that you consume on the internet that data you should not only be the the user that we sell to Facebook you should be you should have a revenue share it's your data you consumed it you should get paid for that I think the same for video games I think the same for the whole internet and so Jack opted in Alec didn't so Jack is going to get maybe eight cents for th000 and Alex's going to get four cents for thousand so half the value so what happens is Coca-Cola
comes to us and say we have $100,000 to to advertise this network great over the next two weeks cool they give us 100 grand we put that and mint it into ethics tokens ethics tokens are then dropped into your wallets for the advertisement you see for the the pieces that you look at the for the games that you play however the developer wants to give it to you those tokens are dropped into your wallet like a leaky faucet almost like an airdrop right you are getting paid for the advertisements you watch now ethics acts as a medium of exchange token and what that means is it's very much built to be similar to oil is for the US dollar the reason the US dollar has been the Beast spoke currency of the world is because if you buy oil you buy it with US Dollars no other currency in the world can buy oil I don't know why but that's just how it is to oil you buy with US Dollars I'm I'm I'm the
UK I buy I had to hold US dollars in my treasury to buy oil I then take this oil that I bought and I turn around and I sell it to the people of the UK to and they're paying me in British pounds right yeah now that's the conversion so think of it very much the same way so ethics tokens are are minted when an Advertiser comes to the network the money is held in escrow right then we turn around and we dropped those tokens to you so now we have the lock up value of The Advertiser you have the money sitting in your custodia wallet and now we have a backend Dex which is a decentralized exchange that you don't ever see but let's say you want to go play an EA game right we will swap our tokens for EA's game $ doll match to your token or if it's a a token that's already a cryptocurrency you could just swap it directly and now if you want to move the ethics token
to your own noncustodial wallet you could do that we'll give you a temporary wallet address and we'll send it out so the idea around ethics is that you should own your own data that you should have a medium exchange token that developers whether they're ready for web 3 or not can have access to web 3 metrics so nfts we got to understand there's a distinction here digital rights and nfts are not considered cryptocurrencies by the government and by Publishers they they can put nfts in their games today epic games could have nfts across the entire thing does not it does not hurt them they can have that but cryptocurrencies they can't really have them on their balance sheet they're especially if they're publicly trade it's a big deal so instead we do is we have our own sponsor bank so we offer on Ranch we could sell cryptocurrencies we could sell nfts credit cards debit cards Apple pay Etc but we also then can turn around and say hey EA we just like you sell
your tokens gift cards at Best Buy we want to do the same we want to buy them at wholesale so we'll buy your tokens 80 cents on the dollar and then we'll sell we'll give these users these ethics tokens and then they can convert them into yours so you don't ever have to touch crypto all you we became we almost act like a market maker right so let's go let's say EA gives us a million dollars worth of their tokens to give out we we give them out whether that through a gift card or a number or we have access directly in their wallet um and I'll get a little bit further into that in a second but we can we swap your token so what happens ethics token burns the money stays in the esro so you spent a dollar we burn a dollar worth of the ethics tokens that you sent then EA sends us an invoice for the dollar that you spent we pay them that dollar through our banking partner they
never touch the crypto at all they get cash and the whole system becomes a full fledge Market making piece interesting Tim is it fair to say this is somewhere please shoot me down I'm just trying to get a piece of this because sounds really interesting are you somewhere between let's say a kind of almost an fx provider between different tokens that are in the gaming world the web 3 gaming world and also like the way of stable coin I'm clinking acts as an easy way to on ramp and offboard between different currencies but you're doing that for the gaming space is that a fair description somewhat we're not a stable Tok ethics is not stable so the lock up you got to understand how where a cryptocurrency gets its value a lot of people there's two ways of the cryptocurrency gets back off off of psychology of speculation right so people thinking it's going to go up that's been the the whole thing with xrp there's been a lot of people that'll say it's going
up and that's kept that price where it's at right whether they have actual fundamentals or not or real true utility that's arguable but the second thing is what is the total lockup the the lockup of any token and you can go look on on any anywhere in the world the lock up usually is equivalent to about 4X so if you have $100 locked up your token market cap is about $400 it's always about four so if you have you can take ethereum and I think the last time I check ethereum there was like 65 billion lockup with a 265 billion market cap and you look at polygon two billion lockup eight billion Mar okay right it's always roughly about three 3 to 4X is what that lock up is so the more we have locked up in the escro the higher the value of the ethics tokens which gives you the holder of the tokens whether you know they're being held or not more value for the data that you're consuming that's really interesting it's
going Way Beyond what you have typically with the medium exchange token where you're actually reflecting how much value is being provided right in terms of the data and the kind of replacement rtiz side I think that's really interesting I want to get on to kind of what is in the future then let's take where you are today with ethics what are you most excited about tackling in the future because I've seen obviously with the recent news with Disney putting 1.3 billion into epic games creator of fortnite and they're looking at this whole idea around inability for gaming and web3 gaming and that being a big challenge is that something that you're very passionate about helping to tackle or are there other challenges on the horizon for you with ethics yeah no so like the first step I do things in iteration so the first step is consolidating web three giving everyone the on ramps they need to be able to sell their tokens in the games that they're playing now there's no reason to had
to go to an exchange to a wallet back to the game to sign you're losing $10 before you even play the game that's a problem so we we have that now the second step is to recreate idfa right Unity went from a $55 billion company to A10 billion company in less than a year because they lost Unity ads it completely devastated the entire like people don't realize mobile games are 200 billion up to $300 billion total gaming economy 2third of all video games are monetized through mobile 65% of mobile advertisement or mobile games monetization comes through mobile advertisement so Unity ads idfa that's a massive T that's now been destroyed we need to fix that so idfa in a decentralized manner that's step two step three is exactly what you were just talking about with epic we are going to take that SEC no action letter that I got my Pat on custodial wallets and we're going to start building out economies of scales for for all these Publishers so you play Assassin's Creed I
play Assassin's Creed it'd be great if I was going from one Assassin's Creed to the next without having to buy more tokens I could just move my islands and tokens or if there was a secondary Market where I could sell the things that I'm not using right instead of selling them in game I could sell them to someone else get tokens to put over in end game A or B right the beauty of Assassin's Creed is you probably play one or two over and over again yeah like for me I yeah I constantly go back and it's not even that old but I I play the um Greek one all the time oh but I'm a huge Greek mythology fan right so I like to go back and play it over and over and I really like how they did the pre Colt to the Colts of the past Odyssey is my favorite too I love that yeah yeah aesty yeah but it' be great because they had the new Witcher witch one coming out
right ofum witch TRS I would love to be able to sell my stuff in Odyssey on the secondary market now because we have Smart contracts Ubisoft gets a cut of that secondary sale and we can turn around and move our stuff into the next game and they're doubling up they're not having to pay to re-engage me it's a solid win for them so what we're looking to do and one of the things I didn't touch on is I also helped create the first layer twos I helped create the first zks all based on video games right so jany kunani the founder of polygon actually worked for me when I created the first blockchain gaming company and he created polygon because I got mad that ethereum gas fees were 99 Cents at the time and if you think about it like right now I think the average gas be on ethereum is about 99 Cents but if you were to remove Avalanche and polygon and all these other chain all these other layer twos if you
remove them what would the gas field on ethereum be because of the the network clogging it'd be imense right but even those like polygon and Avalanche they're not quite at the point where they need to be that's we're seeing things like subnets being introduced that's why we're seeing them cloning chains all on edge right like they're doing that because they understand that they are on a limited path they only have so much longer they can run and so instead of continuing to run on polygon's Main net they're like we'll just clone it for you that's what we did with ethereum we forked it we cloned it we made it scalable we'll just give you this until you run out of bandwidth well that doesn't work for video games so we're looking at how we can create what I call a family tree and that's where this this whole scalable economies work if I can create a family tree where we had a consensus layer the security layer on the first layer and we have a
second layer where it's me on the main net layer where I'm handling all the transactions and data I'm handling the the credit card processing and then we have a third layer that is actually the branch itself that's handling all of what's going on within the Publishers economy that they've set up now we can really start to look at security privacy consolidations finality like those things start to actually get solved and you look at like layer ones like out there likeu right s has 400,000 TPS but there's not a layer two on it's only Built for daps well 400,000 PPS is what it would take to run Call of Duty so if we scale that and we we we pivoted to a privacy sector and we we look at zks how they could be introduced to to site we look at how a layer two could be introduced to S we look at how a layer three could be introduced to S then now we're talking about a truly operable system that can compete with servers
that can compete with AWS very exciting right these layers that provide interoperability between different platforms but also preserve privacy that's so fundamental going forward I'm really excited for that so we're coming to the end of the show and this has been great I'm so glad we got to talk about web 3 gaming finally one of the questions I like to ask just before Jack jumps in with two questions that he loves to ask is what's your take on the Vision Pro I see it everywhere right now do you think it's going to affect the gaming space in a big way not yet I think we're close to BR um and might have some full AR stuff and but I always everything in the world revolves around the mom test and what the mom test is imagine your mom doing something right imagine you sit down next to your mom say mom put on this VR headset if your mom tells you no it does not pass the mom test and everything that's ever been successful
ever has to pass the mom test why does Roblox pass the mom test because they don't know what game you're playing but it it looks childish enough even though it's not there's definitely some bad stuff on Roblox it looks tallish enough that they're willing to buy you a gift card because they can't be wrong it passes the Montage right they can give you a $10 gift card and you can play any game you want now if you can't imagine your mom wearing a Google headset or an Apple headset it doesn't pass the mom test now we're getting to the point where our generation is is becoming moms these 30y olds these 40y old within the next five to 10 years absolutely going to be a thing because you will be able to picture moms wearing those heads yeah but until you can imagine your mom doing it it doesn't pass the mom test that's a really interesting way of thinking about it because yeah there's obviously lots of talk about it at the minute and
whether this is the kind of drinking milk on your iPhone age of Apple Vision Pro headset and I think you're right that's exactly where we are and that didn't become really consumer wide accepted for a long time wouldn't have passed the mom test for a little bit further so Tim we're coming to the end now what every episode we like to ask two very specific questions because we like to see the different answers people give and also how they change over time so if you're ready I'm going to fire the first one at you now in one sentence what is web 3 to you web 3 is the aggregation and consolidation of payments transaction and ownership on internet nice that was really good and very concise because we don't always get that so that I really think that's powerful awesome and then the second question and normally when I ask this question I say if you could choose anybody around on the planet today or from any time throughout history I would also throw in
anyone from an Assassin's Creed game as well if you want to add aler in there go for it we've mentioned him so much but if you could choose anyone ever to sit down and discuss web 3 with who would that be and why there is a good question um I'm G I'm going to go way off track I'm going to say like something like Nicola Tesla and the reason I say that is because I think he was a Visionary of his time I think he understood really what ownership should be right he wanted to give away electricity he didn't think that one company should have the right to conserve the energy and then sell it to others and I look at the at web 3 very much like that right it's the the ownership layer of the internet what you truly are who you are your perspectives and I think he would have a really refined thought process you know I kind of feel like like a lot of us who have been around for
a long time are like version like we're all fractional versions of of Nicola Tesla trying to give the the internet back and we're getting fought by Banks we're getting fought by Facebook we're getting fought by all these traditional web twos who don't want you to have it they don't want you to get away from them because they're all middlemen right middlemen make their money in the middle if you cut out the middle who's really making the money well it's between you and the the actual servicers and so I think Nicola Tesla would would be an amazing person to really look at the fundamentals of what we're doing and why we're doing it and why that path means so much to the greater world and he failed at getting electricity for free he tried very hard and they shot him down but now there's a lot more of us fighting to give back what true ownership is to people I like that that's a really powerful answer yeah we emphasize the importance of the peer-to-peer economy
and real value added and not just facilitating exchange but that's powerful thanks Tim this has been a really great episode I've been so excited to have an episode on web 3 gaming from an actual expert in the space so thank you for coming on and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we untangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we Express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto