Episode 27
TradFi
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
I think FTX is the is the really interesting one there because it kind of it was the first time that that the tradire world really properly accepted and bought into the the defi world and the web 3 world and it ended pretty badly obviously and it shows the same problems of of traditional Finance can creep in the information asymmetry the the kind of underhanded operations of the companies in web 3 and some cases so but it also shows that the demand was welcome to another episode of the entangling web 3 podcast Alec how you doing today mate I am very good I'm very good it's very dark these days so I've got nothing better to do than be recording podcasts with you jack how are you yeah not not too bad thanks mate I'm I'm all good yeah so today we are we we're kind of going on an interesting journey I think because you and I have both for quite a while been excited to talk about this concept of defi or decentralized finance
and then we started planning an episode for this to talk about it and we realized actually we might have to spend some time talking about trafi first right traditional Finance or CI centralized Finance whatever you want to call it just the old Financial world because so much of what defi is doing is building on or modifying Concepts from in finance so yeah I think we're going to be on a kind of multi-episode Arc here right we talk about trafi to build us up to uh to understanding defi a little bit more well yeah I mean I think for context I just want to say this is a very complicated topic right it's like we planned to do this a while ago we're like you know what we'll just record it next week that'll be fine and then you start looking into it you start looking into all all the different episodes out there all the different books out there all the different articles and newsletters and it is complicated there are so many different angles
to this you kind of just think of traditional finances just being Banks and loans and super simple and bitcoin's going to replace everything and all this kind of stuff but there it's so multifaceted it's so complex and I think it's really important for us to Deep dive like you said into traditional Finance specifically to understand what's going on right now because it's so much more than just Banking and removing some intermediaries right we talk about the opportunities of defi there just yeah it's really really monolithic in a lot of ways and I think this is going to be quite interesting I learned a lot in the research for this and I'm sure we're both going to learn a lot more as we kind of go into this episode yeah I don't know about you Alec I feel like I've done the learning in Reverse here I feel like I knew a lot more about defi than I did the traditional Financial world and then in preparation for this I've actually understood a lot more about
the old world so yeah why don't we why don't we start from the beginning then and try and basically give a very quick overview of traditional finance and also of decentralized Finance as a starting point and then maybe let's just drill down some specific Concepts after that yeah I mean that makes sense when most people think of traditional Financial institutes and players and actors they think of banks right you know retail Banks whatever it is you know Sant andere HSBC that's how most people I'd say most normal people like you or I interact with the trafi world and your Banks a big business obviously worth something like five trillion is and then not to be um kind of misunderstood as central banks here we're talking about um I guess private Banks normal banks at the day today commercial banks that that we speaking of we had a a whole episode on central banks which are different yeah exactly and not not just Banks as well but obviously we touched on in in the Black Rock
episode we talked a lot about Black Rock as another player in traditional Finance your kind of investment management firms and the other players involved in traditional Finance but kind of my understanding at a very high level is you know traditional Finance is about anything you need to do with money whether that's saving it or investing it growing it I mean the vast majority of Finance tends to be about growing your money you know beyond the basic case of securing and storing and saving your money in whatever form it is most of Finance is really geared towards you know making profit and how do you how do you make your Capital work for you that's basically what how people tend to describe it and capital obviously meaning just basically the money you have as as an individual or a company you want to grow it using uh the range of different asset classes different Financial products which we get into that for me is just what the traditional Finance world is yeah and completely agree and
when most people think of traditional Finance they think of like fat lazy monopolies right and we said that this you know the point of this is to gear ourselves up to to Define what the the opportunities are there and when people think of tradire they think of high fees slow transactions limited accessibility all these kind of lack of transparency things Financial crashes all this stuff and this is the opportunity that is presented to Defi and like you said we are going to dial into it a lot more but the philosophy of defi in relation to Trad FY is Shifting the kind of the emphasis or the focus the need from centralized entities like Banks like one you just mentioned to technology and technologically driven Solutions um and the foundation of that is all the technology we're going to speak about blockchain technology you know smart contracts crowdfunding all this stuff and this is big business I think um it's really important to understand like setting the tone here that defi is worth around 80 billion
right now and it's forecasted to be absolutely huge over the next five to 10 years but yeah back to Banks like you said banks at the absolute basic level the idea is to take in funds I think they call it deposits um which is effectively people's money and pull them together and lend that money to people who need funds so banks are the definition of an intermediary between depositors and borrowers and that's one of the primary kind of I guess um I guess defining characteristics of of banks yeah exactly and when you when kind of when you AR as as a kind of normal uh retail consumer of banking products or banking services that's our relationship with them you tend to deposit money and you you you might typically have an interest rate on the on the money you store there well how do they generate that interest rate that's by going and reinvesting your money in in other you know Enterprises that's when they there's kind of the front office where they're dealing with
you as a customer and they they take in your money um effectively as as a service to give you returns but then how they generate those returns is a whole other world right and that's where you get into them more kind of complex um parts of the financial World which involve the other institutions you know in the background like I said your investment funds your exchanges for exchanging assets that kind of thing but yeah the banks are basically I would say our interface for most people into into finance and let's not like you know throw too much crap at Banks like everyone we're kind of describing them as these lazy monolithic super slow sluggish players but they are shifting towards you know digitalization technology all this kind of stuff I think one of the stats I saw was that 3.6 billion people would be using some form of digital banking by 2024 and this is um yeah I think that's like a a big opportunity and more and more we're seeing Banks partnering with fintech
and don't even get me started on what fintech is I thought fintech was some crazy advanced technology until one of my friends who works in fintech was like oh no I just do uh you know online banking apps I'm like oh okay that's what fintech is yeah so the stat is that 81% of traditional Banks and they're partnering with fintech companies to actually push this you know digitalization digital transformation agenda yeah exactly and and you know Banks as you said are starting to look more like tech companies or fin tech companies you know they were called Challenger Banks I don't think they are so much anymore like you're Starling the monzo in the UK I think starling's been voted the best British bank for the last kind of few years so these banks are becoming more modernized and how they offer their products to Consumers is looking a little bit more like the web 3 world to be honest and the line is blurring you have Banks also offering web 3 products which will kind
of come on to but yeah that they're the kind of major player for consumers kind of you know storing their money and hoping for a return and that kind of thing then the other major player as you said was kind of your you know your stock markets and exchanges right so that's where maybe you want to kind of do something more more interesting you want to be more active in your how you get returns and you don't want to be kind of passively generating income on top of your savings through a bank then go to a stock market you'd start trying to you know make these bets on on on company stocks and things right yeah exactly that's the big number two kind of actor in the ecosystem here we've got that I mean stock market exchanges they're just like public marketplaces you know like Facebook marketplaces if you will where companies can raise money by selling shares investors can buy and sell those shares and I guess that the stock markets and exchanges helping
setting the prices for these shares based on you know demand and Supply I guess we're going to say the terms demand and Supply over and over again during this um they provide a way for investors to easily convert their shares into cash and they're weirdly quite a good indicator of the economy's health apparently um and additionally that I guess they ensure the companies um the companies follow certain rules and standards you know promoting fair play and transparency and this is a big thing around you know traditional versus defi is the idea of you know standards rules how you ensure that assets or you know companies on these exchanges actually do play ball properly and actually aren't you know doing illegal illicit things and this is very relevant with a lot of the things that's been happening lately with you know FDX binance I think we'll talk about this a bit later but that's a very important aspect of these as well yeah I think that's the key is you said as you said access to
Consumers you know whether that be retail consumers like u i or or companies wanting to you know diversify on on their balance sheet what other companies they hold they hold stocks in your stock markets and stock exchanges are the kind of the access point for you and they are generally heavily regulated so you know the big examples of stock exchanges you've got New York Stock Exchange London Stock Exchange the NASDAQ Shanghai stock exchange these are all kind of very well known even if you if you've never invested you know directly on a stock exchange you'll still know those names there are whole news channels dedicated to the movements on them and they're all subject to heavy regulation and not just the exchanges themselves but as you said companies who want to be listed as a as we call it as a public company if you can be bought and sold have your shares bought and sold by the public there are very stringent listing requirements and I just want to call out one kind of
nice little segue into the web three world is is with something like coinbase you know the detail they had to go through because that was probably the biggest Market listing we've had so far of of a web 3 company on on a traditional Stock Exchange to get listed they had to put in all sorts of declarations and risks and things and one of the risks they are you aware of this one Al like the the RIS risk they put in which is really kind of funny to me what what is it so they put in as one of the big disclosures a huge risk would be if if the identity of Satoshi Nakamoto is revealed right really yeah yeah if Satoshi comes back then they that's one of the things they identified as their their major risk so even they had to had to put put that in the listing I mean there's like there's layers to that I mean it's like Inception kind of complexity it's like coinbase is an exchange is it a
web two or a web three exchange debatable it's kind of like this web 2.5 where it gives you access to web 3 assets but it does it in a very centralized web two way and that that exchange is listed on an exchange it's like to to be listed you have to hit all these regulatory standards that coinbase itself doesn't really Implement and it just like blows my mind a little bit yeah it's interesting world and you also have kind of lots of other different types of exchange as you said um coinbase itself is I think we'll get onto the types of asset but that's more of like an alternative asset exchange right because they deal primarily in crypto assets like we've covered in in the past like Bitcoin and tokens on top you also then have so stock stock exchanges alternative exchanges like web 3 and then derivatives exchanges so you know trading contracts about to go one level deeper into the Inception analogy you know trading contracts about assets and that's the kind of
thing that you know uh the Chicago Mercantile Exchange CM CME would deal in for example so yeah it's it's as soon as you go Bel below the service level you start thinking oh my god there are all these different strange variations on on trading I it's ridiculous like having debts and then betting on debts and then debts betting on debts like it's ridiculous it's like just terminology for the sake of terminology and complexity for the sake of complexity um I think yeah one of the interesting things about the stock market generally in like say the last decade or so is that it's experienced growth like much more I mean it's always growth right but the economy's always growth that's the point of capitalism but it's much more growth than it has been previously and and much more volatility because they've opened it up to standard retail participation which is you know normal everyday users like you or I who may be a bit more kind of fickle with our investments or a bit more risk
averse potentially you know I see something in the news saying Donald Trump's been elected or something like this I'm like well get all my stocks out quickly because I'm scared the economy is going to tankle whatever it is so that's an interesting thing is there's more volatility in stock markets generally and another one is all these IPOs we seeing like lots of tech IPOs like they the the biggest news all the time like obviously coinbase's IPO was an absolute Fiasco like big money everywhere and exchanges are facing bigger and bigger regulations for new listings because of you know Market manipulation all these things it's not just say the defi sectors that are coming under say more regulatory scrutiny but it's also trafi because of all these probably mostly because of all these tech companies that are listing yeah and maybe we should just say IPO we've both used the term now means kind of initial public offering to the first time your stocks have floated on a public Stock Exchange I actually heard the term
Ico before I ever heard IPO which is the kind of web 3 equivalent and and much more malign the initial coin offering where uh I don't know if you I don't want to spoil I won't spoil it actually there's a TV show about technology that used this in quite a funny way but essentially companies in the past and still to to an extent do now have tried to raise funds against tokens of of a new blockchain for example that they're issuing and and they actually instead of issuing shares in the company they're issuing a share of or a number of tokens right and that's a whole another world that's very much alternative assets that's not as nowhere near as heavily regulated right now but yeah it's just worth mentioning you still have these analoges already creeping in between uh Trad fine and and Define yeah so that's the the first two big um actors that we've spoken about Banks and stock markets SL exchanges and the third one which is another really big one is
investment and asset management firms and I mean these are companies that effectively handle money from for individuals and organizations probably using stock markets and exchanges as we've just spoken about but these in my mind are the definition of middlemen in a lot of ways like the the aim of them is to you know grow people's money by investing it in in stocks and real estate so they tend to do it on behalf of their clients tend to be experts in the field and you know I give1 pound to whoever it is a JP Morgan of the world or something like this and they promise to give me 1% return and they make a long margin on that but these These are big big players that handle it's not like you know small companies they are trillion dollar companies or multi-billion dollar companies a lot of the time yeah and it's very big business obviously it's way you make the most money if you've got a maths degree or a science degree that's where you want
to end up because that's where all the money is right because you have these huge teams of people and and this is what you'll often see much maligned in uh in in media and films and stuff as you have these people at these trading desks and and and building trading strategies right so how do I best they call it I think they call it Alpha is how do you Alpha is your improvement on the General market how do you get more returns than the average person who puts their money into the S&P 500 right and it's a highly specialized thing and it's also becoming much more automated and and actually much more AI Le now we mentioned in a previous episode somewhat who Moved their entire investment management firm to using artificial intelligence and algorithmically trading assets so it's a huge business and you know you will have heard of a lot of the names like you as we said black rock is the biggest asset management firm in the world you also have like
your Vanguard you see them advertising all the time on TV as like a consumer focused asset management firm and then you also have things like your Pension funds so wherever your pension is going every month say something like an Aviva they're effectively managing those funds for you until you retire um trying to in reinvest those funds as well as possible to make sure you have more when you retire than you put in yeah and I think like you say it's big business this kind of stuff like I kind of have maybe thrown them off as as middlemen and they don't add much value but it will be really interesting to see like you said what happens to these businesses when AI becomes the norm and there's like open source models that are just like the optimum way to get Returns on investment like because is it like a a net zero net sum game like zero sum game type thing where it's like if everyone's doing the optimum strategy all the time how can anyone
make money on this like will it just defeat the idea of these investment firms if there's just an open source protocol that is the optimum investment strategy you no longer have people competing at people this will I mean this is an interesting kind of topic but maybe one that's slightly outside the remit of this this talk yeah well I think it's important though as well because you're saying open source but these companies the strategies they build are highly secretive they're obviously like a huge they're the main IP arguably that these these Investment Management firms have is the strategies they're using they don't make them public for obvious reasons and there's kind of a difference there between in the web 3 world where we have more transparent open protocols but you still do have people trying to make a buck you have traditional Investment Management firms trying to make a buck of uh alternative assets like web 3 digital assets so yeah there is a different there's a bit of a blur there between the two
worlds um speaking of asset classes I think we've thrown around a couple of them so far we should probably Define them a bit better before we go any deeper right so there's kind of four or five that we we should probably cover there there are like hundreds of asset classes but I think there if we just hold in our few that that should give us a decent grounding I think now we're going the real meat of the episode this is the really exciting stuff for everyone at home um yeah sure let's jump into this so I think the big one well one of the big ones I guess probably one of the more complicated ones as well is Securities um so Securities are financial investments like stocks and bonds where you're essentially buying a small piece of a company or lending money to someone in exchange for interest and really importantly they're not physical things they just represent a financial agreement like to kind of keep it lay and which always helps with me is
that they're like tickets that you buy that can either represent you know a tiny piece of a company or a small loan that you would give to someone yeah exactly and it is quite an abstract definition I always find myself bumbling around when I think of you know what is security but it it is very Broad and there's lots of different subdivisions of it which we won't kind of go into too much detail but again one of the important things is that Securities are highly regulated so you know because they're so abstract and as you said that they're talking about taking a small piece of a company or taking a loan from in a Government Bond or something they are very very heavily regulated we've mentioned the Securities and Exchange Commission of America and there is a very very broad definition they use which is another link back to web 3 that I I'll bring in but the way you classify security normally is something called the har test right and they basically say if
this asset or or contract or whatever the financial thing is the financial product if it if it is an investment of money well that's you know basically all of them in a common Enterprise so something that has a common goal like a company for example with an expectation of return well as we've said you're always expecting a return When you put money in these things and then there's actions on a third party to generate those returns then it's classified as a security and there's been a lot of debate playing out as we've seen recently in the media with the SEC and uh coinbase and you know other other crypto projects like Ripple about the definition of assets and web three assets you know are they Securities or not because it looks like a lot of them could be satisfying those four criteria but it's not completely clear and I guess the important thing around like why actually people care about this is mostly because of the regulation you come under if you are a security
it's a bit more stringent like you just said but also the tax around that right if something's classified as a security then you're more heavily taxed versus other asset classes and I think I think one of the main arguments from my understanding was around you know whether things like ethereum are securities and it all came down to was it due to the actions of a third party SL the common Enterprise on it's like are there people that can manipulate this asset class for example and they said ethereum that that actually is the case like people do control the agenda and how it works and things like this whereas Bitcoin it seemed to be that they they inferred the SEC inferred that it's much more open than that and it's really difficult There's No One Market manipulator it's very hard for them to do that so it actually doesn't classify as security is that correct uh I believe so so far but who knows what will in the future if the if the definitions will shift
and actually that's one of the reasons I mentioned the icos before as well because that's one of the reasons lots of companies that did offer these icos actually ended up violating these Securities laws because they were selling uh tokens in expectation of profit of that company or that blockchain protocol uh working to make them a return right so they effectively were unregistered Securities because they didn't register with the the SEC so we've seen lots of examples of people falling a foul of that of that definition already but yeah we could talk it for an hour about Securities but that's the kind of the high level please don't please don't talk for an hour about Securities um so say that's Securities done and dusted to an extent the next one much more easy to understand the one that I get personally Commodities these are just physical Goods like oil gold wheat you know when you invest in Commodities you're investing in actual products that have a a tangible presence right they can be bought or sold
in markets for example and I think they're often used by you know who's invested in wheek for example ex that's the question I asked they're often invested or used by investors to protect against inflation or or Market fluctuations right as their value isn't really as kind of um moves differently to say stocks and bonds for example you know you always need wheat it's pretty stable yeah and uh you're right I think especially in the precious metals or things like gold silver Platinum uranium I've also heard yeah you know as an example of what kind of these Commodities that are potentially highly lucrative but also you know the gold Platinum silver very stable in value seen as a good hedge against inflation and things like that and one interesting thing about Commodities is that you know you think of them as physical assets but even they can be traded in kind of nonstandard ways so you can either buy them directly you know OTC they call it overthe counter so you basically have actual marketplaces for
this you know go go go into a physical Market to buy them or and is I think it's more commonly done now by lots of these financial management companies is you bu what's called Futures contracts or derivatives and derivatives will come on to but kind of these are these are these are contracts based on that underlying value right of of the asset that's been in in motion and we mentioned the CME Chicago M to exchange that's the kind of place you can go to buy and sell through these contracts but I've heard you know people doing this with like the price of oil barrels while they're in transit from the source to the destination place right people this is crazy to me people buy and sell contracts for the oil barrels while they're in transit because you have all these different risks Associated and the price can change a lot while they're while they're on the boat so it's it's fascinating but a little bit scary to me it's ridiculous can nothing be simple like
you trying toine a commodity as something you can use and then people are betting on the future value versus the debt associated with it like why is financial services why is trafi so complex I think unfortunately it's kind of important for us to understand because these are the opportunities that defi presents in reducing that complexity remove well adding to the transparency in preventing you know some of the is we'll talk about a bit later that have come about because of the complexity that's involved in this kind of stuff yeah exactly and I think we there also will come on to some kind of issues with defi as well because whenever you're talking about things like Commodities you have physical tangible goods then you have the question how do you actually connect those to the digital world and things get a lot more complex one thing I want to say on this this kind of gets my um grinds my gears is around gold and like you know the intrinsic value that people say you know
oh yeah well you know what's it called bitcoin's never gone replace the gold standard because gold has an intrinsic value and Bitcoin doesn't have an intrinsic value and they like yeah gold is some uses a precious metal like semiconductors sometimes and engines and all this kind of stuff but really it's like a cultural kind of um Association and prioritization of gold that's just come about over thousands of years and this intrinsic value is actually kind of I guess quite cultural it's kind of been put on it and really the intrinsic value is actually kind of maybe more metaphorical eeral and all this kind of stuff I was going to say that's a good point from the Peter Griffin School of economics exactly and I think my point here is that it's actually not too and I'm not sure that Bitcoin should replace the gold standard that's not really what it was intended for right it was this peer-to-peer digital Cash System but I I don't think it's too big a leap for Bitcoin to actually
you know be this potential hold of value that would replace gold for a lot of the reasons we've spoken about previously and this kind of intrinsic value that people hold gold up because of is really just something that's been around for thousands of years that people trust in it and think it's never going to change right yeah exactly and you know there's a famous kind of joke but it's true you know if an a meteorite crashed to Earth that was full of gold then our our our trust in in the value of gold and would completely dissip dissipate overnight so it's not completely faultless and I I agree with your your kind of idea right that Bitcoin could fulfill a lot of these properties and that is also why as we said black rock is is looking at the ETF because it's it's being starting to be treated like all these other kind of traditional Financial products as well okay so big number three Cash we've done a whole episode on cash and digital cash
so if you don't know what cash is I recommend go listening to that episode yeah nice yeah exactly and you know you have different forms of cash you have things like cash equivalents essentially just liquid assets you can convert into cash but I think a very uninteresting thing for us to talk about so maybe we'll just skip over that one yeah exactly so I think number four is a bit more well not more interesting but kind of it's easier maybe easy to understand initially real estate like real estate investment is simple to understand you know when it's direct ownership I own my house that's an investment that's an asset right I think actually one of the things I did want to talk about on this is the financialization is that's a word of real estate you know particularly through mortgage backed Securities and now we're starting to have overlap between the different asset classes and some of the complexities you mentioned earlier and this you know mortgage back Securities introduced layers of complexity and risk
and for anyone that um was around for the financial crash in 2008 as depicted in the big sh which I would highly recommend they'll explain it much better than I ever could I mean this is one of the the complexity and the risks that I'm about to talk about is actually one of the reasons that led to the financial crash of 2008 and um you know effectively what happened was home mortgages were bundled together and sold as Securities Financial products to and the problem was that the lack of transparency and really understanding of these bundles and actually the risk of the bundles being much higher and the quality being much lower of the debt that was associated with these these bundles um created a lot of Confusion And um you know owning a security like these mortgage bundles is like it's kind of owning a financial paper that represents um a mortgage payment and it was actually really far removed from the realities of the housing market and this you know complex Financial engineering really
led to a disconnect between reality and the financial State and the lack of transparency really played like a massive role in the financial crash of 2008 and the the reason I I talk about this is because again this is another huge opportunity for defi generally to create you know more transparency more understanding and hopefully remove some of the complexity that's involved in these crazy things like mortgage back Securities that I hate the idea of yeah I think I I would also recommend going to watch um the big sh because yeah it shows you how the complexity of building assets on assets and derivatives of derivatives is can be quite dangerous especially when you have this kind of information asymmetry you have these private asset managers all trying to make that Alpha on on the underlying assets um and and I think yeah that shows part of what we're striving towards in the defi world is to have more transparency over these protocols there's a kind of analog of this called composer in web 3 where
you you build things on top of each other but you actually can see the underlying protocols for all of them at the same time so we'll definitely come back to that one but the other part I'd like to mention there is with the big sh and what happened in the big Financial Crow of 2008 is that you you saw some of these big players like the leand brothers you know going under which were trusted effectively financial advisers asset managers so it shows that things can go wrong and when they go wrong in in the tradire world they tend to go very very wrong and it ends up being the consumers holding the bag and I don't think that's completely solved by any means in the D5 World especially not now maybe in the future but yeah it shows that there are problems to be solved there is a good motivation for moving to to the defi model of things I think yeah I'm glad you mentioned that the information asymmetry because in you know the
big short specifically they really highlight that big players like Goldman Sachs knew that it was coming and they knew the financial crash was about to happen and what they did was they put it off to Everyday consumers like you or I to say okay we actually know this is going to happen mostly because we've caused it to happen but now we see it we're going to give it to other people give it to Everyday users and let them pay the burden of the financial crash that we have in part caused and I think you know I'm not saying blockchain's the answer but I think the principles and philosophy of defi actually should really combat that in a in a lot of cases hopefully yeah exactly it it definitely shows that the system can be improved right um and that kind of does bring us on to the last major classification I mentioned men earlier as well alternative Investments this is a lot of these things are um there are traditional alternative Investments so like things
like what hedge funds do and private Equity firms taking a large majority stake in a company improving it that kind of thing but also things like are Collectibles anything that's not a standard kind of form of investment along the lines of the other categories you mentioned comes under this alternative investment and they have a very different risk reward profile you know they're very different risk associated with the requiring a company trying to improve it or owning owning art and collectibles but this also encompasses you know your crypto assets which again as we know have a very different risk reward profile to traditional assets um which are you know we had the high volatility you have existential risk you know you don't know if this this blockchain will be here in 10 years for example um and you also have your digital art your digital Collectibles now with your nfts so they're all kind of bundled into this new asset class yeah and like you say much less regulated which means means the the risk return
profile is very different to traditional assets um probably less accessible like you say normal people like it tends to be rich investors that buy Collectibles and art and I think we're already seeing the opportunities here with defi as well with the nft craze of board apes and all this kind of stuff that we've talked about many times on uh on this podcast but Collectibles is no laughing matter at like Collectibles generally the market is huge we had Sean come on um a couple of weeks ago now and talking about access rights and management of assets and it is huge the colle Collectibles market like I was shocked to hear how big it is and how important it is and how it's like kind of so intrinsic to humans to really want to own things and collect as many as possible I don't know what it is it's like the inner grock in me the inner ug in me wanting to just have a collection of berries or whatever it is but people love this stuff
and it's a huge Market it's a huge opportunity and I think nfts I know we give them a lot of crap but there is there is value to be had there for for Collectibles especially with some of the utility things that we've talked about I think previously like in episode number three yeah I don't know about you I still got my some my very rare Yu-Gi-Oh cards in a shoe box you never know yeah but I think it's important you mention that you know so I think alternative Investments are things that have traditionally been much less accessible to the masses but that as you said part of the defi movement and part of what we see where web 3 is actually making these much more accessible making things whether these alternative ass assets were illiquid or whether the market Market places for them were a bit more opaque in the past they're becoming more transparent I mean I I was going to touch on later but maybe it makes sense to now you know the
Constitution da is a great example uh one of these decentralized autonomous organizations they they they formed this to try and buy an original copy of the of the of the US Constitution right which seems crazy but they very nearly did it right they they raised I think it was around 47 48 million dollars in ethereum and they they very nearly managed to buy it so it shows that that there was no way for an average person to get anywhere near having only a piece of the of the Constitution before that and with with with these new protocols with this kind of way of collecting money together using web 3 they very nearly managed it so it's very interesting I think what I'm taking a back by that you can sell the they're selling the Constitution I don't understand that's actually you must you must have been living under your grock rock yeah this happened um at least a couple maybe a couple of years ago now but there was an original copy of the Constitution
because I think maybe there were a few copies made being sold in a sbe's auction and they created this Dow with the sole purpose to buy that with this collection and yeah 47 million dollars in eth were raised and they were just outbid by by someone else but it's incredible to think that much money could be raised you know with any individual person just putting in that their five pence basically God I imagine like America would be like in outrage if the constitution been bought by this Dow um okay so the next stage back to um the podcast I guess Financial products here I think these are things that most people will understand you know an easy One banking products that's a kind of quite everyday one that we all interact with you know we have savings accounts pretty low risk low return everyone kind of has done this you get a small interest rate potentially which is you know determined by the government and it's actually a me well it's actually not s by
the government necessarily it's it's a means for governments and Banks to regulate things like inflation right if I up the interest rate encourages people to save spend less maybe I can decrease inflation by doing that and the other way around also works where if I have a low interest rate encourages people to invest in stocks trades all this kind of stuff um the other one that I think people are quite familiar with is check-ins accounts these are day-to-day transactions typically like pretty well understood I think yeah exactly so you you're you're kind of the first trunch of banking or financial products is what we would as we said we interact with with banks right and whenever I hear the term Financial products I kind of think oh that sounds weird like what what is a financial product it's just money right but you know we we do use them in in our day-to-day lives a savings account with with a even if it's a low rate of return it's still a product you're still putting
in your money with expectation of return as we kind of said that kind of thing then if you move away to the kind of more complex things and now we're kind of talking about again not just what the institutions are but what do they do then you have your investment products this is anywh you'd invest in one of those asset classes that we mentioned whether that be stocks and shares so like a consumer typically you might know of something like Robin Hood right as as as a classic trading for what there's lots of these small mobile apps you can now just very easily surprisingly easily uh just just sign up and start buying stocks in you might also have your your isers as well your iser accounts so something like help to buy Isa in in the UK where you're putting in money again some government influence there because you get a little bit more money from the government if you put it in to buy a house that kind of thing so it's the
kind of thing that most people even if you don't think of yourself as an investor you may well have been involved in an investment product like that as well and then obviously as you mentioned your hedge funds private Equity all these other firms will have different types of investment products they are using or we offering as well yeah and the big sexy one that we spoke about a few weeks ago was the Black Rock ETF which is going to be an investment product for people to you know put their feat in and black rock will invest in Bitcoin potentially assuming that gets to Pro let's see what happens um so that's another example of that and that's kind of another um way in which defi is moving into Trad find and this kind of this um combination or integration of the two which is quite exciting um we got insurance products doesn't everyone love talking about insurance products like life insurance health insurance property um but this is big business as well there's like so
much value to be derived from that insurance makes so much money I can't remember I had a fact somewhere it's like hundreds of billions a year um through Insurance just premiums and things like this it's absolutely mental yeah it's a I don't want to spend long talking about it because it BS me to death but it it is huge business right and you have again you have Structured Products in insurance as well you have things like reinsurance on top of insurance that kind of stuff so again very big business and in some cases obviously it's also mandated right so most of us if you if you're driving a car in the UK you will have had to buy an insurance product your car insurance or typically you'll buy a travel insurance if you go abroad as well obviously not mandatory in that case but you know it's something that you will have touched that as a financial product in your life as as well um yeah and then kind of the one of the the
other bigger more interesting but much SC scarier again types of product is then your derivatives right and this is effectively anywhere you have a product that is not itself the underlying asset but deres value from an underlying asset so this is you know effectively betting on future price or movements of an asset without holding it directly yeah it's like how did I he describe once it's like um they're like bets like you say on how the price of something will change in the future like imagine guessing like the score of a football game and placing it bet on it but you relaying that to underlying assets um quite a complicated thing and it's a bit abstract yeah but also I I've seen you know quite common in the UK is this something called the share save scheme whereby if you're a company that's publicly traded then you can effectively as an employee you can put your money into this scheme you take away a certain percentage of your your salary each month and it gives
you an option so they again an option is one of these these futures um contracts these derivative contracts it gives you the option to buy the company shares so the company you work for at a big discount in the future so it says okay it's going to be up to 20% discount on the price you put in your money now for i' say two or three years and then at that date in two or three years time then you have the option to buy the company stock at the originally agreed price so this is what it means by giving you the option to buy at a certain price and again you know you're hoping that the company's stock has gone up because you've been a productive worker in that time and and and that's kind of a nice example because it's it shows where Financial products can have a I think a strong benefit not just for the company because it incentivizes people to stay at the company right to get to see that two
or three year period through but it also incentivizes you as an employee to have skin in the game right because you think well you know my my investment in this product is going to be worth much more if we are successful in two or three years time so it's kind of it's a nice example I think that is is less demeaning of the financial industry okay and some other big Concepts that we really need to talk about because these become extremely relevant when we're going to talk about defi in the next episode um the first one is Market making and as the kind of the name suggests this is how you make a market and it inv involves like continuously buying and selling all these wonderful financial instruments that we've been speaking about for the last half an hour to provide liquidity to the market typically done by you know big Institutes like Goldman Sachs JP Morgan New York Stock Exchange all these kind of things and you kind of like I said you can
kind of think of this um as like a store that always has what you want to buy and is willing to always buy what you want to sell and they make sure there's always a product available for customers so you have this kind of guarantee of service that is offered and that promotes a healthy economy right yeah exactly and and you know part of why there are so many finan of products is you know because there is a market for them and then also an incentive to make the market and you know and one way I think about this is when you fire up your Robin Hood app and you go click I want to buy shares of apple right because you think it's going to keep going up or Tesla or something then you need someone to sell you a share right that's the market how you make that market how you make that happen a lot of it is typically based on S golden order book where people are willing to sell people
are willing to buy and then your Market maker is effectively you know matching you up if it's an exchange or is acting as your counterparty so is willing to to sell it directly to you so again you need some kind of whether peer-to-peer is possible and that's what we said with the OTC but typically you have some intermediary in the middle who's there to make that market for you yeah and I think this is like when I kind of think of how this is actually beneficial it's like with your Yu-Gi cards for example you try and sell uh an alternative collectible it's hard right you put it up on eBay you kind of post on forums you have no one to sell it that's a big issue but that was also the case with Bitcoin in the early days when you trying to buy Bitcoin like it took so long to actually get it from someone who was willing to to sell it and now it's like instance which is what I guess exciting right
and kind of it bodess well for the future and shows how much importance there are on all these kind of defi applications yeah exactly and then kind of Highly related to Market making is this idea of liquidity and we we touched on this before but one of the big features of Any Given Market is how liquid it is so how easily can you buy and sell how much is there how much availability is there of the asset that you want to buy or sell in the market because if no one's willing to sell you have a highly liquid asset or if no one is able to sell I should probably say then you have a highly liquid asset so they're intrinsically related to Market making and having more market makers better funded market makers will typically make your asset more liquid but it's a huge Topic in defi right and and and web three Assets in general because sometimes they're not liquid but as we'll come on to I guess in the next episode how
you make that market is becoming much more automated right and you have these very clever new ways of doing it in the web 3 world yes liquidity is how easily you can turn something into cash right if you can sell it quickly without the price dropping much then it's considered very liquid and that's very important for businesses and all this kind of stuff right yeah but I would say not just cash right because when we talk about I think that's like the the very traditional interpretation of liquidity yet is how how how can I liquidate my asset into something that I can pay my debts into to the government pay my taxes in but in general now we talk about liquidity as how easily can I swap one asset for another right that that's kind of typically what it means because as we'll see in in web 3 liquidity is often referring to how do I swap crypto x with crypto y you know that's that's a good big big aspect yeah I think that
makes sense to me actually um and then the next thing that we have is counterparty risk um and counterparty risk is like the chance that a person or a company you're doing like a financial deal with might not be able to hold up their end of the bargain right like an example of this is not paying back the money that they owe you or not delivering good product you bought and I think this is really important to understand because you know you typically have when you're interacting with big Enterprises in traditional ways you have a way of recourse you know if I assign a contract if you don't pay back your mortgage then the bank will take back your house and things like that and recourse is very important but this has been a bit of an issue maybe with say things like Bitcoin you know because of like the things we talk about immutability um once bitcoin's there how do you get it back and like how do you actually do that on the
blockchain you tend to do it at the exchange level and I think this is a very important thing because quite complicated to instill this in say smart contracts that we'll talk about in The Next Episode because like the reasons that you maybe don't pay back a loan can be very convoluted it's not just I didn't pay my loan on this day so then you take all the asset back there could be like very actual reasonable reasons why you didn't pay it back like say the server went down or the blockchain had a delay or you put in the hospital with an accident so it's not as black and white as as maybe people tend to think it isn't maybe we always need will need some human element or some trusted intermediary to actually oversee and control these things in a certain way but this is something I think we'll speak about in a lot more detail when we talk about smart contracts in in the next episode yeah and I only add to that I
kind of your counterparty risk can take many different forms right because it can your counterparty for any given Financial product might be a different one uh the the risk associated might be as you said for a different reason it might be reasonable in some cases um it's why you're willing to to to give your money to the bank and let the reinvest it in on your behalf you have this idea of fractional Reserve banking they don't keep all the assets there all the time and then in bad cases you can have a run on the bank but um you know one good example even for the most basic Financial product which is your checking account like you said right as a banking product recently on on Black Friday if you're an HSBC customer you couldn't really access and transfer your funds because the app was down right during Black Friday so that's an example of your counterparty effectively your bank as as the person providing the service of using your money failing you in that
case it was only for a few hours but it does go to show that this can apply in very very different different circumstances with varying degrees of impact yeah so yeah Jack Davis the biggest whale of Bitcoin couldn't actually sell any of his assets when you needed to it's painful painful to see um Okay so we've talked a lot about trafi and the question is why are we talking about trafy this is a web three podcast right and I think we we've hinted at it throughout but all the challenges the complexities and elements that we're speaking about here are opportunities for web 3 and opportunities for you know the defi companies that were going to speak about in in the next episode or even next two episodes like we kind of said that it's um there's a lot of inefficiencies there's a lot of intermediaries probably because of the complexities and the information asymmetry that they want and like I said this is a real opportunity for defi application and the real fundamental philosophy of
defi is to sh shift the trust Paradigm from centralized entities and unnecessary intermediaries more and more towards technology and it's not to remove all intermediaries I think that that that's ridiculous and I think there always always will be some need for an intermediary in in some form even if it's just a low Reliance on them but it's to create more transparency and more trust and more efficiency by moving that trust and dependency from those intermediaries to technology and in a lot of cases to blockchain and smart contracts and all these wonderful and weird technologies that we'll talk about yeah I think that's that's very exactly the um the philosophy of defi is minimizing the amount of intermediaries you have the trust involved mitigating counterparty risk wherever possible and it's like a very it's a very alluring proposition I think in some cases you could be arguing that it's amplifying some of these risks and we'll get into the detail I think in in the next episode there have been some some significant failings in defi
but there's also some real Innovation as well that we we'll talk about and go into the specifics of of defi but yeah it was definitely I think necessary to to lay out the foundations of trafi what is the problem what is what is the aim or the perceived problem that defi is trying to solve you know with how you provide these Financial products how you create new types of asset classes how you let them interact and things and which parties provide those those services and products for you I think like what I would say is it's you know people kind of think about it and the conversations I've seen is that it's defi is going to replace Trad fins this binary thing where there'll be no Trad fine there'll just be Define it's like that's ridiculous like that's never going to be the case like we're already seeing the terminology and we're using ourselves like web 2.5 and seeing how these kind of these big trafi entities who have a monopoly in a lot of
ways on the financial sector are moving more and more into defi it's not going to be like you know overnight HSBC is going to move to a completely decentralized platform or you know currencies will overnight move to cbdc or Bitcoin or whatever it is but we're seeing the slow transition for you know and kind of little cases little prototypes little test cases being developed around the world like a lot of central banks looking into cbdcs that's an initial kind of move into the defi space in a lot of ways but I mean there's a lot of benefits to that and it's great to see that say people like Black Rock and companies like Black Rock are seeing the value for investors even if it's just value for them they're seeing there's an investment opportunity there and there's opportunity that's what I want to emphasize big opportunity but there's also a lot of friction right we already mentioned like some throughout this like the American sec versus Bitcoin versus ethereum like what what is security what
is commodity like it's these technologies that are coming into these you know tradire ecosystems and people don't have a clue how to define them or how they fit into traditional kind of um definitions even we've said it's like very abstract and difficult to actually Define but people need this like people need this kind of this trust this confidence and this regulatory kind of um certainty to move strongly into into these spaces and then we've also seen a lot of like um lawsuits you know binance have recently been really screwed over in America FDX obviously and I think this friction is also a really interesting interesting kind of um point or area to comment on as well yeah I think FTX is the is the really interesting one there because it kind of it was the first time that that the tradire world really properly accepted and bought into the the defi world and the web 3 world and it ended pretty badly obviously and it shows the same problems of of judicial Finance can creep
in the information asymmetry the the kind of underhanded operations of the companies in web 3 in some cases so but it also shows that the demand was there right it shows that you know if all these big traditional finance companies could see the value in the proposition of defi in general you know if if FTX had operated as a good company really we'd all be huny do right now it was very much a human failing by the looks of things and not necessarily a technology fail but yeah I think I think it's encapsulates the fact that there is demand for what defi is offering and we can learn from its mistakes as you said all these different things that happened and we we'll cover some of these ex kind of explicit examples of of those failings in in the coming episodes but yeah I think maybe for now it's we should leave it there and and say you know that is that is a crash course a 101 into the in the Trad by world
and hopefully should arm us with you you know what we need to to talk about Defi and and specifics of it in the next few episodes so yeah next time we should take a closer look at some of the defi protocols specifically and some of the projects we've mentioned you know things like Unis swap as well we kind of very briefly touched on um to understand how they work also some of the risks and and concerns associated with them but for now Alec I think we'll say thank you for listening wherever you may be join us next time to untangle a little more of thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of
our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto