Episode 3
Tokens
About this episode
Web3 is on the cusp of a revolution, with tokenization primed to transform the landscape of asset representation. With predictions showing that global asset tokenization might skyrocket to a staggering $16 trillion by 2030, it's crucial to get a grasp on what this means for our future.
In this episode, Alec and Jack dive headfirst into the swirling vortex of tokens. They unravel the myriad types and classes of tokens, their unique properties, and their role in powering the electrifying peer-to-peer value exchange within the Web3 ecosystem.
Our hosts guide listeners through the storm, touching on everything from native blockchain tokens and fiat currency to the stability of stablecoins, and exploring intriguing utility applications, including supply chain tracking, in-game virtual assets, and revolutionary ticketing systems.
Prepare for the whirlwind as Alec and Jack delve into the intriguing distinction between 'fungible' and 'non-fungible' tokens (NFTs), unmasking the key differentiators that make some token types stand out in the complex landscape of tokenization.
Got a question or topic suggestion? Send us an email at theuntanglingweb3podcast@gmail.com
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
thank you welcome to the untangling web3 podcast you'll go to hope to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep uncovering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web3 welcome to another episode of untangling web3 podcast so Jack how you doing hey Alex yeah very well thanks how are you yeah not too bad not too bad uh the last episode was very fun uh quite exciting so I'm looking forward to talking about another topic yeah we've made a good start I think and now uh on to the next chapter on to the next uh thing we can try and demystify a little bit in web3 yeah so last week we covered blockchain like the
general history what it is how it can be used in some of the Core Concepts and this week we're tackling the big topic of tokens I guess and you know there's a lot of kind of hype around tokens right in there so this this should be quite an interesting one yeah this is uh this is one of the first things that comes up as a question uh tokens and this concept of tokenization that kind of really go hand in hand with any any discussion you get into about web3 so this is a good one friends test to tackle next I think yeah like my mom's a regular touch point for these podcasts now and nfts is everywhere like in the even in the news like it's pretty mainstream talking about nfts which is a specific type of token that will obviously go into a lot of detail later and you try to explain the concept of an nft and it's quite difficult to explain the concept and even like understand like tangibly what that means
like an everyday person who maybe isn't in like the digital world yeah and and it's also another one of those quite broad topics with lots of different subcategories of tokens and we've already started talking about nfts as one of those um so yeah maybe we can we can we we'll start by giving a broad brush Strokes understanding and then uh going to dig into some of the details about those different kinds of tokens Maybe yeah well you gave me um some stick last week for the Layman definition so why don't you start with the Layman's definition this week okay I'll I'll try and actually reconcise um this week so um tokenization that's the word we tend to use when talking about tokens tokenization generally refers to taking some kind of asset something of valued and there could be any kind of value whether that's already physical or digital and representing that in a digital form so that can be easily tracked transferred um and efficiently used by whatever other systems you want so yeah it
can apply to virtually anything um but it's just about digital representation of some kind of asset wow that was incredibly concise so yeah I think that's a that's a great definition of what a token is and I think obviously well we're a web three podcast so probably what we're going to be talking about is blockchain based tokens and as Jack kind of said that a token is a physical or digital asset representing value or specific attributes so a blockchain based token is just representation of those assets using blockchain technology where blockchain is the medium for representing ownership and also the medium for exchanging that ownership and you know like like Jack mentioned it can make facilitate trade easier record transactions you know streamline payments and all these kind of things and that's the primary use case as to why you'd use blockchain as a medium to represent tokens yeah I think um well can we talk about it's a digital representation of either physical or digital assets and really blockchain came around you know with
starting with Bitcoin and then later ethereum and other other blockchains they kind of they brought a new way of tokenizing digital assets but more broadly they also help us to tokenize physical assets as well so they're kind of an all-purpose tool for this site this idea of tokenization in general um and maybe it's worth you know to capture some of that discussion around the physical versus digital assets maybe we can talk a little bit around the the history of tokenization and money in general and I know you have a you have some some interesting insights on this Alec if you want to maybe talk us through that yeah I'm a historian at heart so I love this stuff but you're totally right I mean the concept of tokens is not a new one even if it has got like a lot of publicity recently because of like blockchain based tokens and nfts and all this hype that's coming out of the Woodworks um but can you guess when some of the earliest tokens um were
around Jack or have been discovered by archaeologists so that should give you a rough kind of order of okay archaeologists or maybe let's say a few thousand years or something is that sound the right ball yeah no I mean yeah that's not that's not far off so 9000 BC was some of the earliest tokens that that we've found and kind of discovered it was in Mesopotamia you know everything is always Mesopotamia when it goes to that those orders of magnitude of ancient history and you know they basically use small clay Idols to represent cereals grains cattle and the this this Societies or these civilizations use this for like 5 000 years basically consistently and I mean the the use case is kind of obvious well I think this is why it's quite important to go back to where tokens kind of derive from originally it's not convenient to take cattle and you know tons of grain to Market to potentially sell or exchange them it's far easier if you have like a trusted kind of
mechanism for doing so to have a small clay Idol that people trust in and know you know represents the ownership of that grain to take that to Market and and then exchange ownership you know and get payment for something and that person can then claim the grain from like a a central repository or something like this so that is the primary idea that you're using it as a almost a medium of exchange something more efficient uh that can be users in the medium exchange as opposed to the things that you're you're actually trying to buy right as opposed to just straight at barter barter for different goods and services yeah exactly like it's a more efficient way of representing and exchanging value no one wants to be looking around you know tons of grain with them when they can just have a token that represents it and store it somewhere off chain and I think that analogy is going to make a lot of sense when we start to talk about assets that are represented
on blockchains as well um can you guess why something called the Roman token was invented as a kind of an alternative to Roman currency the Roman token was it something to do with oh I don't trying to tokenize local currencies of places that uh the Roman Empire conquered or something well maybe I'm completely off there uh so I mean yeah kind of off so like basically Roman currency had the empress face on and you couldn't use the emperor's face for nefarious activities however you want to Define that and so they created a Roman token there was an alternative to currency that could be used for all these nefarious activities which is quite interesting because this is like some of the applications where Bitcoin kind of historically all kind of I guess publicly people think tend to think this is how Bitcoin is used which is you know as we're now seeing not the case with more and more utility kind of coming into these spaces but it's so funny to see the history kind of
repeats itself in certain ways yeah that is interesting I mean hopefully we don't have the same kind of fall of the Roman Empire for Bitcoin and blockchain but hopefully history doesn't repeat itself completely in that sense yeah everyone will become a History Podcast rather than a web 3 podcast well I mean maybe to add a bit more to that as well so the ones the ones I'm familiar with the kind of early um monetary assets let's call them um what all these kind of they were essentially Commodities and things or um either Commodities or other maybe even more inefficient things so the one I I you hear quite often referred to as the I think they're called rye Stones which were on one of these kind of Pacific Islands and there were these huge heavy Limestone kind of discs which were used um very infrequently I think to um as a medium exchange for large transfers of value like things like um how you'd uh how you claim ownership of a new house or something
um in these communities and then you also have things like calorie shells are using another physical commodity in shells and then you have other examples in more recent history I think to do with using metals and obviously gold um being kind of even more recent than that you know in in the 20th century as something that was obviously used as a medium of exchange so I guess these are all these are kind of primarily physical things that are in some sense tokens but not quite in the way that we were describing tokenization for blockchain and web3 right because we're talking about digital representations and obviously carry shells and rhystones when digital in any sense really yeah I think and it kind of blows my mind to think of the Alternatives before that you know the barter Society before standardized currency came out and like how do you change a chicken to cows if I'm a chicken farmer and you're you're a care farmer like a hair does that work I just can't even imagine but
all of this kind of taking all the cow is that the question you asking chicken farmer but yeah how do you kind of easily facilitate to facilitate trade in a barter Society so you kind of have that's where currency kind of came came about like to kind of I guess make the exchange of goods and services more efficient by creating what standard units of value that was universally accepted but it's really important that you have a central um kind of point of trust that determines that and everyone kind of you know trust in that that central point of value which I how would you implement that like imagine being the first person to implement the idea of coinage I mean to be a nerd it was back in Lydia like a long time ago but crazy yeah and I think that's an interesting point right that you're relying on this being recognized by some Central um to be used effectively as currency or or an exchange of value I think to kind of bring it
to closer to the modern day so and the discussion of digital tokens so to my knowledge the earliest example or kind of mainstream example of digital tokenization was used in in the stock exchange in in kind of the 1970s where um and you'll hear this this phrase also dematerialization where they were initially you know trading using physical stock and bond certificates so you had to be you had to you know physically have one of these certificates to um that showed a claim of ownership over over your stocks or bonds or whatever assets were being traded and then they moved it to a digital system where you could put these into digital order books you could represent these physical certificates in a digital form in the stock exchange and that kind of as you were talking about increased the efficiency with which you could exchange them because no longer do you have to make sure the right papers in the right in the right people's hands you can use these these digital systems to much more
effectively and efficiently execute the trade so I think that that is as far as I'm aware that's kind of where digital tokenization first became kind of a mainstream idea yeah and I think to tie this back into the web three that is obviously the the primary goal of this podcast is the tokens the concept of tokens is not new the whole point is to to represent goods and services and maybe even access and rights in a more efficient way a kind of a more efficient to exchange way as well and blockchain was the kind of the Natural Evolution of that because it's the most efficient way to exchange peer-to-peer for example and it's the gold standard for auditability and ownership so I think that's how all of this relates to web3 and yeah yeah I think kind of tokens are in one sense the the fundamental unit or the medium of exchange for web3 and as we said starting with Bitcoin it has its own kind of native let's say token the Bitcoins themselves which
are used to um you know for payment um or for or or to make transactions in Bitcoin and then you you know there were actually very early examples of of token systems built on top of Bitcoin so they're actually called colored coins I think was one of the first examples where you take one of these native tokens and you add a little bit of extra meaning to them you kind of color them um so they can represent another form of value which doesn't necessarily have to be digital because obviously Bitcoin is an example of a digitally native token but it can be then used to represent any kind of asset on top and then you'll you kind of seen from say 2015 16 onwards other platforms like ethereum have really popularized the idea of using blockchains as a base layer to build um uh new token systems on top that can represent anything on and that's where we that's where the conversation leads to nfts and things I think um so yeah I think if
I was to relate this these kind of this this blockchain based tokens to web3 there's there's two key principles for me one is ownership like how do I probably say that I own something and when I talk about ownership I think traditionally that's a bit about like um you know Goods Headway how do I prove that I own this physical good but more and more with seeing things like credentials who am I like specifically do I own this degree like is this profile for me and I think as we kind of move more and more into web3 this is going to become a big area for for blockchain based tokens is is kind of credentialing people less around like the kind of the the tangible things that you can physically own in real life and more around social currency who are you like what you know to take it back to a kind of gaming you game quite a bit have you ever bought skins in games yeah I have I have for sure yeah
I think that's one of the best ways to talk about nfts a bit later it's like if you've bought skin you understand the value of owning an nft basically maybe I'll go into a bit more detail on that I think the second principle is around the peer-to-peer economy it's going to create like new exchange models having blockchain based tokens more efficient mechanisms for for exchanging those things that you can own yeah and I think we've exactly right we've seen that principle play out in many different things you know um one good example is kind of tokenization of real estate things or of um you know corporate shares in a similar way to might have been done on the on the stock exchange but now web 3 is allowing people to do that with a little bit less friction outside um some of the you know in some sense trading tokens was a kind of gated Paradigm before you you had to be you know on the floor of the stock exchange to be doing some
of these things now web 3 is is enabling a much more peer-to-peer version of that where you know you have fewer intermediate intermediaries required to um to facilitate that kind of interaction it's all you can build be transparently um and mediated via the blockchain and then we have as we discussed kind of last up last time the blockchain has its own secure infrastructure behind it that helps people trust the token systems you build then on top of the blockchain so it's kind of just impro in many ways it's just improving on um the digital tokens that we had prior to 2009 really yeah exactly and I think when we're talking about physical tokens you talk about like monarchs that were kind of the central point of trust and everyone trusted in in the currency and they bought into that and eventually created social trust whereas in in these kind of blockchain based tokens now you to an extent you trust in the technology and I think you do need that social kind of adoption of
it obviously that's where a lot of the value comes from it's not just in the technology it's also in the kind of the social trust in that and the confidence in that system you know Bitcoin at first obviously wasn't adopted super heavily but as it kind of progressed the technology didn't change too much well it it shouldn't have changed too much but it's the fact that socially we tended to trust more and more and kind of proved how stable it was it proved how kind of um resistant it was to attacks and all these kind of things it's the social confidence in that that's kind of built up the value over time yeah I mean what it's also maybe worth thinking about like what are the what are the concrete benefits because we've talked a little bit about like improving on Stock Exchange trading but that's not really the domain of most people in general you know people aren't necessarily that worried about how efficiently you can trade things on on the stock exchange so
you know what other kind of tangible benefits for tokenizing other forms of value in your opinion like what what other forms of value do you think that uh you know offer the most kind of potential for tokenization as well I think a good tangible example is any kind of item in which you care about provenance so like you could talk about kind of high-end Goods like a watch or something like that you want to know how many owners um has that watch had in this lifetime is it can you actually like trace it all the way back to the um kind of the original kind of creation of that watch from like I don't know Omega and that's that's what you mean by provenance right I think is the the tracing back yeah something originated or something so yeah I should have explained that to him so I think Providence is kind of just the history of an item it's been one of the best ways I say so like what we tend to say
is like um sourced to product or something something like that and that's the term that we tend to use so yeah one good example of how we can use tokenization is that how you actually know you can kind of um comfortably know the entire history of products ownership for example but also if we think kind of in terms of like I don't know you can even talk about like tokenizing meals and things like that something we'll talk about why you don't tokenize meals uh later you can think of like the entire supply chain of all the different items of that food all the data being included immutably in that food that you then own that you can then redeem and use for utility and I've got a good use case I want to talk about later that will kind of uses that a little bit well I like that because I think what you're talking about is what people will often refer to as almost like a digital twin so that the token in this
sense is is a digital twin a digital representation of some physical asset in the supply chain like your um like your your watch or maybe uh your your packet of salmon that you pick up in the supermarket and then blockchain is allowing you not only to to easily verify the the history but um also you know have some more accountability between the parties that are involved in creating that the Providence of that product right yeah and it's interesting it kind of comes back to the um what data is stored on chain because like the digital twin itself the raw data everything that say is that packet of salmon as you just said isn't going to be on chain there might be off-chain data that's a more efficient way of storing it but you reference all that data on chain to kind of immusively prove that that data is you know has the the kind of the problems that we said it has for example yeah and I think like for me there's a real tangible
benefit in that because going to some extreme cases you know you um you can have big failures in Supply chains that cause massive Downstream problems um you know when a building collapses or um when you know there's all the kind of scandals around the use of sweatshops in the production of fast fashion and things like that and they cause significant harm being able to tokenize the products um is something that is helping to combat some of those issues am I right yeah yeah I mean consumers care as a consumers that I mean us too like we care more and more about what who kind of who the actors involved in making the products that we're buying now this is like something that we really do care about but the information isn't always transparent it's not always easy to attain and even when you do attain it say if I buy you know a can of Coke and Coke says that all of this is great and everything's fine hair do I trust that you know
Coke isn't just gonna lie because they obviously have a reason to lie they want me to think that it's all fine and I think yeah there's a lot of applications for blockchain based tokens to kind of you know improve improve the Trust In in consumer relationship a big example is this plastic packaging taxes recently come in as part of the UK Crackdown on like making new virgin Plastics they've said that you get a tax kind of redemption if you reuse plastic from you have to prove the provenance of that plastic you can't just say yeah this bottle that I've recently made has 30 plastic in it you have to prove the entire history of the previous plastic that goes into that and I think a lot of people are looking at blockchain to kind of provide that long-term problems are you think about like I think about long term these these kind of potential Solutions as well plastic has like a a lifespan of like 50 to 100 years or something like that and you
know blockchain hopefully has the potential to kind of facilitate that long-term yeah that's an interesting example of plastic because I think that that's an example of plastic bottles of where you have maybe even more benefits of web3 potentially can can be combined with the basic provenance so once you have your digital twin or tokenized version of your bottle not only did you get to track it until it's used but then you might introduce something like micropayments to incentivize it being recycled I know there's um there's a deposit return scheme in Scotland I think it's either just been implemented or is about to be implemented where you can get something like 20p back as a consumer for every uh plastic bottle you recycle so that's an example of a kind of micro incentive to to improve the um uh the kind of carbon footprint of these Plastics um which could also be mediated by blockchain you know blockchain is a great platform for micro payments so maybe that's a huge Avenue to kind of tie up
some of these benefits in web 3 as well I mean I love that yeah like being able to say like the entire history of the product you're buying know how it's been recycled who's been involved in that what incentives you know if someone's kind of reclaimed it and reused it like as a consumer I would love to have that knowledge and I think when you're talking about all these different data sources and data inputs as blockchain makes a lot of sense there you have all these various actors who don't necessarily trust one another come in together you can use the blockchain as a means to kind of facilitate those interactions and a kind of trusted basis and yeah I think we've covered a lot there and I think we realize there's a lot more we can't go but it's really exciting that even the first half of this we've talked about so many different use cases already but that might be a good time to take a break Okay so we've talked a little bit
about what tokens are and what tokenization is in generally about how we can create these digital versions of physical and and digital assets um I think maybe it's worth we turn to our our friend chat gbt to see if if it has any other opinions or if we've kind of covered the key points well what do you think please stop referring to chatgpt as our friend it's creepy and if we don't refer to as our friend what we're going to do when it takes over that's why that's what I want to know okay fine I mean this is the bit that my mom likes the most she says she finds this bit the most digestible which is like a bit of a put then it's a bit of a put down so I think this is mostly for her um but yeah so I asked Chachi PT to um explain tokenization to my mom and actually came with quite a big definition so we're gonna have to break this down a little bit so it
said a crypto token is like a digital version of a coin or ticket that exists on the internet it represents something of value or has a particular purpose like using it to buy Goods services or even having a say in how a digital Community is run so I I think we covered that pretty well I think we spent 20 minutes like saying that but yeah I think it's interesting it mentions tickets we didn't mention tickets so much but that's a nice example of a a physical real world thing that we might be used to that we're now more used to in the last kind of 20 um having a digital version of like our plane ticket right that's a good example of that I think when we speak about use cases a bit later let's talk about tickets because I see a lot of applications to have tickets to blockchains you know especially on the kind of the um the scalping aspect and all this kind of um okay so I think we covered that
part pretty well so the second part of the definition it says these tokens live on a special digital networks called blockchains which makes sure they are secure transparent and can be easily tracked just like you keep your money in a wallet you keep these tokens in a digital wallet which lets you store send or receive them safely yeah I mean we've talked a little bit about blockchain right and from not previous episodes I think it's clear how blockchains make these things a little bit more secure right having a transparent model of the underlying infrastructure that we base these tokens on rather than just them just existing in uh Central repository in one company let's say um so I think I think that's that's something we've definitely covered but maybe this idea of um of wallets and how you how you actually use these in practice is maybe another another new topic that chat gpt's introduced here yeah I was gonna say the exact same thing I think we covered most of that apart from the
digital wallets it's quite complicated to imagine how you actually own something that is referenced on the blockchain and this is we are 100 I hate doing this we do this all the time we're 100 gonna have an entire episode about digital wallets and how they work but I am doing that we're going to go into more detail on that but I think their digital Wallace is effectively how you prove ownership of something that's referenced on a blockchain so you know I think when we talk about nfts you say that you own some art that is on the blockchain a token that represents ownership of that art and in your digital wallet which is just an application on your phone it will show like the jpeg the actual image of that digital art but really I mean what the wallet is the kind of primary purpose of the wallet in my mind is it it proves ownership typically through um actually owning the keys that correspond to to the the the token that's referenced on the
blockchain I think that's quite a simple way of putting it which you know I'm very good at Jeff yeah no I think that's a good a good way of describing it I think one way you can think about digital wallets is yeah I'll show I'll show my uh my allegiance to Apple here as a fanboy but if you you if you've used something like an apple apple wallet or I think Google have a similar thing in the Android phones um you have your your credit and debit cards in there you might have your plane ticket in there your Club Card memberships for a supermarket for example that's an example of a digital wallet but everything you own and and have represented in that wallet is very much in some kind of Walled Garden where each individual issuer of your your bank card your ticket um is still very much in control of the data and you can't do very much with it it's other than just Redeeming the ticket or spending um or using the
card to spend in in the shops you don't have too many controls about what you can do you can't for example directly uh give your plane ticket to someone else on a secondary market for example whereas digital wallets in the blockchain crypto web 3 world are essentially just giving you a bit more control over what you can um with those assets and with that comes this idea that you said of being able to prove independently of those those third parties that you actually do own and control those assets yeah that's a great summary and like I said we'll go into more detail on that at a later date so the final part of this long-winded definition of tokenization by Jack's friend chat GPT crypto tokens are managed by something called smart contracts which are like digital rule books that automatically ensure the tokens are used correctly securely and according to their intended purposes making it easier for people to trust and use them in various online transactions we didn't even think to talk about smart
contracts so I think we should no yeah 100 so I mean why don't you why don't you give us your kind of overview of what smart contracts are I'll give you the tough job this week for that you love put me in this um smart contracts really simply I'd say uh digital forms of traditional pen and paper contracts that are stored and typically executed on blockchains and this has the added value of you know immutability and transparency I think I don't know how big a problem it is but you know I've always struggled to understand how if I get a contract I make a contract and say you know Jack is paper-based contract say Jack you sign there and you know five years down the line I sue you because obviously you've pretended that contract doesn't exist or you've changed the terms of that contract because that's who you are Jack and how do we prove at the how do we prove you know five years before that the terms on this paper-based copy of
what I own so hold somewhere is the same terms that you saw in sign like I have no idea how that's proved in the court of laws it's crazy to me well tell me what you really think of me I like I um yeah I think I think kind of generally it's smart contracts are a way of just encoding some kind of logic some business logic um or some some rules to do with the transfer or management of these tokenized assets and um in many cases these blockchain platforms allow you to to kind of execute that logic to maintain things and I think I'd actually I might push back on chat GPT a little bit here because it's kind of assuming that um you need this this smart contract Paradigm for tokens to exist and I don't think that's necessarily true I mean one thing we've admitted to talk about a little bit is that whenever you have tokens you tend to have an issue or you want a credible issuer okay because you don't
want well I don't want you uh for example I like to issue my um my my season ticket right because because you have no authority to as far as I can um you have no Authority Jackie Weaver well I I actually did not expect to ever have Jackie Weaver no that's another friend of the podcast Jackie Weaver they will get her on one day shout out to Jackie Weaver uh maybe we should see what Jackie thinks of uh web3 but yeah um I think I think the ish the role of the issuer in tokens is is crucial and smart contracts are a great way to allow an issuer to codify these this rule set um what these tokens may be and how they're allowed to be used but it's probably I would call it more programmability that is the interesting thing because it's just ways of allowing more functionality that the issuer may or may not have to be directly involved in every time so rather than having to go to the issuer to do
every single piece of the of the logic it might allow them for instance to let you sell on directly and not be involved in that process um but they're still involved in the issuance and making and and again back to your point about provenance you always want to to check the history of that that token to make sure it was issued by a credible um uh you know Authority essentially yeah I can yeah I think um it's all about the trust Paradigm who are you trusting and if you've got an issuer with fairly simple you know tokens that you know a good example is Cash you don't need cash is considered a token and you can have digital forms of cash you don't need a smart contract necessarily every time to kind of run that you can just have a central issuer and they kind of yeah it's quite simple but there are a lot of applications in my mind particularly exciting applications that come from Smart contracts as well I think a really cool
way of understanding how a smart contract individually could be used is a good example is Kickstarter you know Kickstarter just brings lots of people together to fund crowdfund projects so I set up a fund say I don't know I want Jack to meet Jackie Weaver and I'm going to sponsor Jack's trip to find Jackie Weaver but it costs a lot of money Jacob he was very far away because she's living the high life right now in the Bahamas are riding that high and she has a high appearance fee I hear as well I mean you're a big fan so you would know these things so I start a Kickstarter project and I get loads of people on that platform to you know all put in but Kickstarter charges a fee for that and they don't really do that much apart from kind of connecting people and facilitating the transfers and stuff so it'd be fairly easy for me to set up a smart contract put it on the blockchain specify that you know I need
100 pound total and for that 100 pound if I get 10 investors that each give me 10 pounds and they all put in I'll promise them you know I don't know Returns on that investment so for some reason you meeting Jackie Weaver gets them returned on their investment no idea why and in the smart contract I specify those terms if in one year they haven't received um 10 pound plus the 10 that they've been promised on top of that then something happens or maybe I have to put an asset up against it like my house because I'm so desperate for you to meet um and a smart contract facilitates that are very easy everyone can trust in the technology trust in smart contract I could Implement systems like have all of the investors take a vote after one year to if they're happy and everything goes ahead as normal or if they can take my house and things like that and I think that's a good example of removing unnecessary intermediate is using smart that
sounds great Alec but I mean the floor in your plan is that you're you're a millennial so how can you you know stake your house you clearly don't own a house um yeah but I think one interesting thing you actually mentioned there right sorry you know just uh self-deprecate as well um I you you kind of mentioned this idea you know maybe inadvertently of investment with her expectation of returns and that kind of brings in you know that sounds a little bit like what we call this a security potentially under under different uh legal regulations and one thing we haven't touched on today because I think it will take many episodes to cover each individually but there are lots of different types of tokens we've talked about it broadly but you know this covers uh traditional types of token like Securities um cryptocurrencies or blockchain native tokens like Bitcoin it can cover um those non uh kind of non-monetary assets like the the things in the supply um and it can also you know be
all sorts of things like things just used for exchange or things all utility tokens so there are lots of different categories that I think it's not worth trying to drill down into all of them right now but maybe one area we should can I touch on is the distinction between what we call fungible and non-fungible tokens because you've already mentioned non-fungible so I feel like we owe it to the audience to describe a bit about what we mean there yeah we also owe it to Emma who's in the background saying stop talking about these things I think get us some more content yeah that's too interesting and we're having too much fun I feel like we're making this podcast for um yeah so fungibility I think that is probably one of the defining characteristics that that's maybe well I guess defines tokens in the blockchain space so fungibility complicated word is in is defined as the uniqueness or interchangeability with other tokens of the same type uh equal value and identical properties so I think
in my mind the easiest example to talk about this is cash so if I have you know a one pound coin I know that that is set the same as the identical value and properties to your one pound coin Jack so we Define that as a fungible token because you know I can have five thousand pounds and all those five thousand individual pound coins are tokens but the fungible tokens because you know for all intents and purposes they are the same basically and I guess because because they're dematerialized into paper and um and coins or even you know in the case of cash or just a digital form in in a bank account money then yeah that's that's part of the the fungibility of them is that they're all effectively equal um in how you can use them um and I think maybe I would just add to that that fungibility is I'm as I'm aware is is very much a legal concept um because you can have money your money could be in different
states where maybe it isn't as exchangeable right if if funds are seized as the as proceeds of illegal activity then in a sense those those funds aren't as uh have the same value at that point in time as the money in our bank accounts but as a property of the system as a as a whole you would still say that Fiat money and currency is fungible for the properties you yeah and I think I was kind of when I was reading about this I was trying to contending with different sources and some sources argued that you know that the cash note that I have the 20 pound well that has a a unique serial number so is that truly unique like someone could be oh I don't know like the FBI could use that to trace you know illicit activity or something like that so in a way it's Unique and I think at a high level and I don't know about the legal aspects you were talking about Joe but I think at a
high level it's for like all intents and purposes they have the same value and properties they might be like you know the serial number is slightly different but my 20 pound equals your 20 and that is quite convenient because we can trust that you know we have this um the standard kind of representation that we can use for you know exchanging Commerce yeah 100 agree that that for all intents and purposes is the the best way to put it it's um you know on average will your 10 pounds be worth the same in a shop as my 10 pounds that's what we mean by fungibility and that can apply to many of these other tokens types so we we just kind of uh name dropped very briefly there and obviously other examples would be Bitcoin ethereum um loyalty points might be a good one these are all kind of examples of you know fungible tokens that are blockchain um and then we have the other one the the big one the kind of the thing
that's got a lot of a hype and sensation going for it right now non-fungible tokens or yeah and you know you've done the hard work in defining fungible tokens so uh non-fungible is essentially the opposite where you know every token is very much unique in some sense so they're distinguishable from one another and they will have some their value will can can fluctuate um wildly depending on you know uh the mysterious forces of the market and and how much one person is willing to Value one token um over the other so you know non-fungible tokens are one of the things that ironically in my opinion because everything they're quite as interesting as some of the fungible tokens um you can get but they're one of the things that popularized blockchain and web3 in the minds of um the mainstream I think it kind of caught the attention because you had some of these uh digital artworks being minted we say as as these non-fungible tokens and then sold for eye watering amounts of money not
necessarily you know sold on again for the same amounts uh a few years later but they're one of the first things that kind of captured the imagination and that's kind of I think digital artwork is a great way to understand what nfts are because all art is subjective and you know each piece might be valued by the you know in the eye of the beholder and that's how where where it gets its value and they're very much not interchangeable um with one another you know two pieces even from the same artist are typically valued widely differently in traditional parts so yeah I think I think that's a good way to understand it even though if if it's not the most interesting use of nfts you know what this is what I was going to say so you're an nft naysayer you think the fungible tokens are the way is this going to be a big division between us I'm an nft naysayer in the context of what's made them popular in this kind of digital
artwork world 100 okay we're on the same page then because I find entities extremely exciting because of what I think they can and will be used for like you say all the board apes and all this kind of stuff as sensationalized and popularized them but I think what we're seeing more and more is the utility that nfts and uniqueness that it's so important to the blockchain the blockchain is one of the best ways to prove uniqueness that's what I find so exciting about it but to come back to the example earlier you've bought gaming skins before in game right I have yeah yeah but that was that's gonna be my question so are they in what sense are they fungible or non-fungible would you say oh no no no that's I'm not coming to the point of fungibility and non-fungibility yet I think that nfts in that particular I mean I think that the value of say gaming skins in in that context defines what the value of nfts will bring in the coming years
there's there's two aspects in my mind there's one there's the the social currency deflects to say you know I look good in this skin I don't know what game you're playing maybe it's some like armor that is um kind of uh that's particularly shiny or something like that and the social currency to that there's also the utility you get benefits in game for that and I really do think that that is going to expand to real-day life like it's you know how are you you know how I Define you how to find out about you so go on your social media profile and you have like details on there I honestly think in the future I will go to your web3 wallet to understand who you are and you will own an ft you'll own nfts that relate to albums of artists that relate to art that you're interested in that related to tickets you've been to and that is how you will Define yourself and how I will Define you I really think this
idea of social currency in the future is extremely important and I think it's gonna be one of the reasons the nfts you know really do become big I think they're expected the nft markets expect to reach 220 billion by 2030 and it's not just going to be this bored ape nfcs it's going to be more and more about the utility they can provide like the credentialing the identity yeah I think I think that's a 100 I agree with that's that's the way things are going to go um but you talked a lot about kind of the gaming use case decks I know you're excited as an avid gamer but you know what is is that the most interesting use case to you or is there any are there any others that you think are particularly interesting and then have more potential than that maybe I think like I think crowdsourcing is going to be a big one I think like maybe we can put into context of in the context of this podcast so you
know we want to imagine that you know me Jack and Emma we want to go big and we want some liquidity typically it's quite hard to get they have to go to investors it's like very hard to kind of get to the market engage properly so imagine that we were to create an nft for you know this episode episode three of the untangling web3 podcast I create 10 10 nfts and we sell them I mean the only people that probably gonna buy it and my mom maybe Jack's mom maybe Emma's mom they'll be the three people that buy it but in the smart contract within the nft it says that you'll get one percent royalties for anything that this episode generates in the future and forever and you also get you know early access to events future episodes you can speak with me and Jack and then my mum would love that um so we get at you know the liquidity but we also get the social engagement you know for them to take those
nfts and go out there and say look you know I own this nft it's like kind of self-perpetuating marketing that they do for us and they gain you know the social currency to say I'm investing in this small style of investing in my son and so it's a social currency that I've talked about but also the utility the access the other early events of the royalties the episodes and I think you know that can be applied in a lot of instances to benefit you know both the kind of the person or the individuals that want to Kickstart projects but also the investors and the people that care about investing in these projects yeah that I think royalty sharing is a massive uh a massive kind of benefit beneficial use case of of tokens in general right because you have all these problems around how to creators monetize more effectively and you know people who use other people's work under the the kind of the the creative licenses but there aren't particularly good ways to um
or or for the original creators to make a lot of money out of that so I think that's a really good one yeah and it applies to like any kind of artists albums things like that I mean if who's your favorite band Jack oh uh Kings of Leon let's say really wow that's surprising um so Kings of Leon say they're going to nft one of the first ever albums and you can be an owner of that and you know that you get to meet the in the contract to find the nft you get to meet them once a year go to their albums get early access to this and if you don't think about the royalties aspect would you be interested in that even just to say prove that you're a Kings of Leon fan well like I'm going to shock you and I thought this was right and I've just double checked the Kings alone actually done an aft of one of their albums really once yeah yeah so that was that was lucky
actually that I said them nice I wonder what I wonder what they put into the the actual credit property of the nft so yeah I I'm kind of imagining that it's quite basic it just proves you know you own so many of teens about the social currency but if they added all the utility we're talking about this kind of voting rights haven't even spoken about voting rights but imagine being out to like distribute the the voting rights of some kind of art amongst the owners and kind of implement that within the token like that opens up a whole new Avenue for tokens I think you're you're you you're clearly good at predicting the future or the past actually in this case but I think so it looks like they have you know included different levels of uh of of rights that these entities confer on you I think they have said you get access to specific content for some of these nfts and backstage um kind of privileges so yeah I think looks like you're
on the money unless you knew about it already but yeah I know Kings of Leon so yeah you're you got off it's called reading I really knew that you're a Kings of Leon fan straight away I did all the background research anything like this kind of applies also I saw something about um house splitting you know you own a house and if so you know I own I don't as Jack has kindly pointed out I do not own a house but hypothetically imagine I do own a house that's worth a hundred grand for every reason and that's not a good price for a house but whatever it might be in Wales um looking on the housing market recently clearly and suddenly I come into debt and I can't pay my mortgage you know most people have to sell the house but that's obviously not ideal you no longer have a house that live in it's very tedious what if you could you know nft your house sell 10 of the house to pay off your
debt and continue living in 90 of the house and I mean again it creates liquidity it lets people to invest and you don't have to go through the whole process of selling the entire house which is tedious yeah I think I think you're just going to hit on the other head there with like it's a good way of making very illiquid assets liquid and get and gaining access to the market what providing access to those assets to The Wider market and then also releasing equity for yourself I think is a great use case for that yeah well I've talked a lot about my ideal use cases um when you give us yours Jack okay so I'll have to think of a different one so that people don't think our opinions are fungible you can't laugh it you've just lost my joke then sorry so um I'll be very I'll be very brief but this this is one that's personal to me and we've mentioned ticketing already so I think I think it's a great is
a um industry that can be disrupted by digital tokenization so when I was younger much younger um I'm a Liverpool fan unfortunately at the minute and for the 2006 FA Cup Final one of the most famous games ever uh you know Gerard scored two late screamers so that was an incredible game and I only found out years later that my parents had bought me a ticket to go to the game um so I should have been there watching but I don't know if you remember recall this but there was uh there was a theft of of a postal van right about back at the time I think it was I don't know where exactly the van was but someone stole you know hijacked a van stole the content and on that van was my ticket and thousands of other tickets to the uh oh my good game you're not joking about this no not not even joking this is true so it's traumatic yeah and and they didn't tell me two years later because it
was such an amazing game and I should have been there but this this kind of shows the vulnerability of ticketing and other other systems to you know the just bite into them being physical that they are at risk from you know various things as basil was just as a theft by by someone so obviously you can improve on that by by digitizing and tokenizing tickets because then you wouldn't rely on on the physical counterpart you could you could you know you could you could have a you could just rely on the digital version and back in 2006 this wasn't really a possibility it's much better now with normal digital token systems or normal ticketing systems that we're used to but what blockchain can add kind of on top of that is then a more secure secondary market for those so as I mentioned if I have a ticket and I can't go anymore I still rely on going back through the ticketing platform and hoping that they can resell it for me whereas I might
prefer just to sell it uh myself independently so they don't take a big cut of what of the resale fee um as they might often do and and for the person buying the secondary tickets you know they have to they have to go through the the central ticketing service to be to trust that it is the correct ticket whereas you can do this in a much more peer-to-peer way if you're using the blockchain to trace that provenance back to the original issuer and you don't you know involve that original um uh that issue in every step of the resale process so I think tickets are a a really exciting use case so maybe you can save other people from the same heartache I had uh when I when I was a kid that's such a sob story I think yeah I guess you know to you could use Smart contracts as well to implement royalties on scalping fees so that as people if people you know what's the classic scalper they come in they buy
super low instantly and then they really sell for a lot I mean the artists could Implement a resale fee on top of that so if someone does resell the tickets they get five percent back and you know actually monetize scalpers to an extent definitely yeah for sure that's a good one I like that use case so yeah I think we've covered a lot I think maybe just as a very final thought on tokens you know we've been very positive about them but um there are there are kind of some concerns and I by the very nature of tokenization being a broad a broad topic there being so many different types of digital assets and and different classes of digital tokens that you can have I think one of the big um issues at the minute is the lack of regulatory Clarity on a lot of blockchain based tokens so I don't know if you've seen recently in the news but this is even affecting companies as large as coinbase right I think coinbase and the
the SEC um Securities and Exchange Commission in are kind of having almost a public battle that they're waging over the definitions of these assets so it's very much not a a clear clear-cut issue at the minute there are big companies who are still struggling to understand what regulations even apply to digital tokens so you know do you have any thoughts on that and it can have other issues around I mean yeah I've seen some of the I've seen them um kind of yeah in in the US government in the Senate speaking about these things and there is just no Clarity like it's very confusing I don't know who's more confused at the SEC or coinbase but I've watched some of those um some of those I don't know the debates or hearings probably the correct term and I just come out of it having no idea what's going like I think I understand it before and like they asked the same question like is this a security for example or is it this and they
just give such you kind of um ill-defined answers or kind of vague answers but I don't know I think my opinion is that that I assume there's a lot of existing law that defines how these wealth defines how these things should be defined and I don't know if we necessarily need to retrofit that law to that or we can just reuse it yeah I agree I think it does seem like lots of existing laws should apply in theory and then Europe we were also seeing other regulations passed like in the EU I think the the it's called the um regulations um that they've either passed very recently or gonna got through to a late um uh in in the EU voting process so yeah I think it's just it's just something to be uh conscious of that it's it's still an emerging topic and there's not complete Clarity in any one jurisdiction really but you know it's certainly not across jurisdictions on what each of these token types mean so I think it's uh it's
worth bearing that in mind whenever you're looking into the concept of tokenization generally well thanks for the Doom and Gloom on my um my happy nft predictions and hope for the future healthy dose of realism from someone who lost their tickets in a postal uh robbery so and then the show would come full circle if we found out that I was the one that robbed that van but yeah we're gonna carry on with this podcast ever so yeah to kind of to caveat Jack's Doom and Gloom I think that the key message from this episode is that tokens generally offer a lot of you utility and it's all about representing value in a more seamless and efficient way for going also for exchanging that value So blockchain based tokens was the Natural Evolution of that because it represents one of the most efficient ways to exchange and represent value and I think yeah that's a good place to maybe end end this episode thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced
by Emma camilleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto