Episode 33

Tokenized Securities with Julian Kwan

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of Untangling Web3, hosts Alec Burns and Jack Davis welcome Julian Kwan, CEO of InvestaX and IXSwap, a notable figure in real estate, prop tech, and blockchain.

Julian shares his entrepreneurial journey from Sydney to Shanghai, leading to the founding of InvestaX, a tokenization SaaS platform in Asia. He details how InvestaX was born out of the need to modernize the initial low-tech approach of equity crowdfunding and P2P lending platforms. His venture into the ICO boom further spurred the integration of digital currencies with digital securities, aiming to transform the investment landscape.

The discussion then shifts to the specifics of tokenization and the role of automated market makers (AMMs) in security tokens. Julian elaborates on how IXSwap, inspired by Uniswap, provides a platform for trading tokenized assets. This platform merges the efficiency of DeFi with the regulatory framework of traditional finance, representing what Julian calls Web 2.5 – a blend of traditional systems and blockchain innovation. He emphasizes the importance of creating user-friendly experiences in web3 technologies, arguing that ease of use and familiarity are essential for wider adoption.

Concluding the episode, Julian envisions a future where all types of assets, including carbon credits and real estate, will be tokenized on public protocols. He advocates for the shift from paper-based systems to digital ones, underscoring the potential of this transformation to unlock new investment opportunities and fundamentally change our interaction with financial assets. This comprehensive discussion provides insights into the evolving tokenization landscape, highlighting the necessity for compliance, user experience, and the integration of traditional finance with DeFi.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

and then so there's this huge misconception that security tokens were illegal you do not need new regulations for security tokens why because Securities regulations exist and securities regulations do not reference paper right they don't say when you sell real estate to someone written on a piece of paper it just says when you sell real estate to someone or when you customize real estate or when you trade real estate it never says on welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we're honored to have Julian Quan co-founder of eight companies across social media real estate prop Tech and blockchain he is focused on building key infrastructure connecting Defi and trafi Julian is the co-founder and CEO of investor X the leading tokenization SAS platform in Asia and I ex swap which is the first automated Market maker for real world asset and security token offerings Julian is also the host of The Infinity and Beyond podcast welcome to the show Julian thanks guys I appreciate you having me on and getting up early

yeah thanks Julian it's great to have you on I'm really excited for this episode so first things first can you give us a real quick intro to yourself and your background your career and really what led you into the world of tokenization and web 3 now sure and thanks for joining everyone here in untangling web web 3 podcast we kind of did the same thing on on my own one which is just trying to break it all down explain it um clarify what's what's interesting what's the opportunity what's the challenges there's a lot going on um so yeah quick background I'm Sydney born and raised and then Beijing in Shanghai for 13 years I I went to study some Chinese and then went back to Sydney and got bored in a week and went one way back to to Shanghai and started a company that week uh it ended up um becoming very successful it it ended up it started as alternative advertising we did the very first sms's in the world when they were

like text message like um buy a pizza with like you know maximum 10 characters or something so right before smartphones and ended up it's called mailman and ended up um representing all the MBA and EPL um social media channels in China because it's a different world right can't use Facebook and I sold out of that and we moved to into real estate and did a did the first carbon neutral Boutique Hotel development in Asia and a bunch of co-working and then real estate funds but really wanted to get in the online space so about eight or nine years ago moved to Singapore because I wanted to stay in Asia and developed one of the first online investment platforms and the first that was the first iteration I guess of of investor X which began as investor crowd and it was modeled off the very first US real estate crowdfunding platforms uh so we we set that up and we put money into about 30 different private Equity Real Estate deals and had a got a

license of one of the first online investment LIC Singapore is very Pro fintech and Hong Kong was very anti so that was kind of the choice for regulation um and so during that Journey you realized that behind that first generation of platforms is quite low Tech so if you think about Equity crowdfunding PP lending those platforms um the first Generations were very very much a marketing machine yes there were some great things you'd look at deals you could invest all over line that was on you know was online you invest all over the world you could assess deals but you actually signed a piece of paper like once you wanted to do it and typically at least real estate you know sit on it and do nothing for seven years and we might get back to you so we hadn't solved liquidity issues we hadn't we we we we left a lot on the table so 20178 with the Ico boom it was like okay this is this makes a lot of sense to me

we should use this throughout real world assets uh in a world of digital currencies we should have a world of digital Securities and if they come together we're going to have a whole new world of investment products and that's going to be the biggest opportunity in finance so what does that mean um we kind of embarked over the last four and a half five years to stitch all the necessary infrastructure together to make kind of a One-Stop shop where any investment firm could push a button and legally compliantly issue trade ciz any type of security token real world asset token it's important to and that's being the mission at invest and it's important as well that now we're using rwa real world assets that's like the seventh term that the industry's used since 2018 icos that were then becoming stos then tokenized securi and then um security token offerings and then we had you know asset back tokens and um you know now we're we're back to RW we're now at rwa which is essentially

the same thing um MH so but what what's really different now is that we used to get laughed out of all the crypto events because you know if you're going to go build security tokens you think you know you need to go on you need to go to blockchain eventss and no one was talking about that everyone said you know bestos are stupid and made no sense but anyway that's actually what literally what happened and now like this week I just saw the CEO of Franklin Templeton saying bitcoin's a fantastic distraction from the biggest opportunity in finance which is tokenizing securities and it was like Yay Larry think from Black Rock says the same thing just he's on our newsletter actually he subscribed by himself so um we've been Shilling his name around because you know one of the biggest firms out there but for me it was just very obvious so and then the next thing we did was we thought okay if in a world if you believe in a world of tokenized

assets and and you know there's a whole bucket here right like there's the Bitcoins the ethereums the alternative coins nfts and and then there's security tokens real world asset tokens and if they're all issit on the same protocols they're all living in the same Universe which is the the the point of doing this but when we thought about it we said okay actually if you go back to 2018 everyone used to be saying like what's the what's the point of this what's why tokenize any asset it was like all liquidity for liquid assets that was pretty much the only thing people said the problem was is there was no infrastructure to issue and trade them and there was no Market making so therefore there was no liquidity so that issue that problem was kicked down the road and so by early 21 and it took us four years to get our security token exchange license in Singapore so before we even had it um we were like we got to try to solve this problem

ourselves because the crypto market makers are not licensed to Market make security tokens and the security market makers are trying to work out what blockchain is they're all coming for the space but that was the Crux of the problem one of the problems that was cross One problems so any if you think about like World tokenizer assets it's like all the real estate all the VCS all the starts think about millions of assets which there will be um because we're going to be done with paper that that is the digital versus paper value proper position is the 101 of this whole thing and in that world then you think well most of these assets want trading but they're not exchange traded products so your $20,000 startup stos you know my whatever $100 million real estate fund there there's going to be too many assets the top 1% will probably sit in security token exchanges with traditional market makers just like the biggest startups gets going to NASDAQ and everyone else's phone calls on paper but

so if you think about that then you start thinking all right that is actually a bigger problem like multiple times hundred times bigger than the same problem that crypto had in 2017 in 2017 I like I just give an extreme example because easier for people understand if you're a top 10 coin you're on coinbase in binance and you you had lots of money and you paid a million dollars to list the market makers life was amazing if you were 10,000 altcoins um you sat on the decks the decentral which actually is just a swap platform and nothing was for sale which is better than a paper version which is impossible with faos but you know the point was is that there wasn't any liquidity so 2018 the launch of what I still consider to be probably the best innovation in centralized financials Unis swap where they said okay smart contracts to crypto anyone with the crypto again I'm simplifying it can start a liquidity call and and then when someone comes to the front of

the decks we don't have an aut book and matching engine because it's not nutritional Market maker it's pool of value of coins and algorithmically driven by just going to give them a price right ABC token to usdc okay and anyone who has those coins can join the liquidity pool share in the market making fees and then but but essentially anyone who has a coin can start liquidity pool that was The Innovation and then Zero to Hero on on on liquidity um and so we we said okay well you know could we build the Unis swap for security tokens and and what would that mean you know could anyone with a security token start a liquidity pool and and fast and cheap low cost and what would that mean you know and and so what it meant was we' for UN code we'd start with version one and by this stage they on version three um because it started you know two three years before yeah and behind so essentially what it does how operates it's

just like Unis swap but behind the smart contracts there's a security token broker and a security token custodian so there's a legal pool and a legal trade so that's difference Unis swap can't do security tokens because don't have any licenses so then we sort of stitched all that kind of infrastructure together and that's how we got to today really yeah that's that's a fascinating story thanks for the history because it sounds like you've been you know in the weeds for a very very long time yeah I'm curious about how you're saying the the difference between Define Unis Swap and then what you guys are doing is that you said you've had this infrastructure that sits below the the smart contract is that like a centralized infrastructure that's run by you guys and that's the requirement for the the kind of regulatory side yeah so what we do is essentially very much you know our industry they come up with new terms every day and it's conf it's confusing the audience but essentially we are more

web 2.5 because you do need call it Web Two Securities you know kyc whatever it is real estate funds fund managers like all that stuff is still there but then we three technology you know blockchains and protocols so we're issuing these assets on these protocols which is why it sticks together and you need to pass these Securities through licensed entities that also have the technology so so that's why I say we're kind of 2.5 because we connect the dots and you know what what I swap is it's essentially you know operates like a decentralized exchange but there are certain parts of the transactions that need to go through you know these these license entities but we built it to have exactly in Brackets as close to the uxui that Unis swap has and the crypto has um okay so that that's kind of how how it operates and as you guys know there's now so this been convergence as well because you know the one thing that's I think is is really exciting and I've

been we've been saying this for a long time um I think we did the first security token event in 2018 in Asia and there was like five old guys turn up for free spring rolls and they like this sounds great you know I was like all right uh so let me break break it down to why I think tokenization is so valuable and what what's the real proposition here because most people are sitting here saying digital versus paper and blockchain's immutable and it's great blah that's like 101 right the second second most important thing is that we're going to be if you issue security tokens on public protocols then you you can plug into the power of decentralized finance and automated Market making models we buil ex swap to even prove that that's happened so you can take take your little startup share or whatever it is and you can start a liquidity pool never happened before in the history of the universe this is powerful and and it's G to it's it's powerful and

it's magic it's great but there's then there's like if you if you issue tokenized Securities versus PID Securities you have the ability to lend borrow and state those assets that's also something that's coming down the pipeline is just beginning this will be much bigger than the trading volume of security tokens because if I could take my VC fund token and go and lend it to you and get a yield on it or vice versa however it wants to work versus I'm gonna wait 18 years to get my exit from the BC fund that's really really powerful and that's actually why J Morgan's Onyx platforms tokenizing publicly traded assets not because they don't trade but because they're very hard to use in a lending and borrowing environment so that's really powerful and then you have new investment products so the best analogy I like to give everyone is the ETF structure so 1989 the first ETF uh actually considered a failure is a 6 million do and now the ETF industry somewhere between 6 and8 trillion

do like it's massive right so in 25 30 years it's it's grown from nothing again Zero to Hero but that was a new technology Maring with the marketplace so now what they're saying is here's the new technology token security tokens real world assets blockchain marrying with the existing private markets eight you know the trillions and trillions of dollars of of that then we're going to see an explosion of value we're going to see new so you can create new investment products so a new version of re real VC 2.0 I call it or real estate 2.0 or tokenizing your esops which we've done so our team can trade new investment structures will give us a whole new world of assets and a whole new way of investing into real estate private Equity everything that's massive just on its own and then the last one I've got I'm not going to try and think of anymore because it's these things to the last one is new distribution channels so if you try to sell a a

startup share even a VC fund um which is probably more relevant to this world into you know a private bank or wealth manager or money manager like there's no one's ever going to do it those worlds only invest buy and sell assets for their captive investor base that are basically public traded right right digital liquid Marketplace compliance they can get paid they can screw a lot of their clients over by by keeping them inside this Loop right but anyway the point is that um they all started selling Bitcoin ethereum and the next Evolutions real world asset tokens which is actually something they should understand a lot better because we're not coming in saying bitco better than the US dollar we're coming in and saying here's this huge assets that you guys never sell because you can't get paid in the same format that you used to using and these guys pay way bigger margins because it's private assets give you an example of that what can a private Banker charge a client to trade a

stock these days nothing or maybe one basis point or five basis points you can do it we all do it ourselves on our phones like well what's the stock broker good well if I can go I can go to a private bank and say if you raise money for the for Jack's tokenized startup he'll pay 500 basis points because that's what pay right so now High private Banks 500 times the margins from a product that's pretty exciting but that's just that size that's the trafi side on the other side you have the defi side so if FTX binance bitfinex someone else a year and a half ago or longer they started launching security tokens in the form of tokenized stocks they didn't do it properly because they didn't have license and they're doing all the stuff that we're doing so they pull them all down but essentially this is what platforms do that's what banks do right they get a huge audit to start selling as many things as they can so the the coin

bases of this world now and coinbase is one of our investors and we' just integrated with coinbase wallet and Coin and Bas protocol the 15,000 institutions are asking for real world Asset Services and we're going to be preferred partner in Asia um but the point is that you know coinbase has 110 million retail wallets in 15,000 institutions like and they're selling crypto already so they get it and now what's next the next evolution is trillions of dollars of asset and it's the same for I you guys might not use this but out here the Southeast Asian version there's one last example on this top the Southeast Asian version of uber is called grab grab and grab won B between DD in China and Uber in Southeast Asia anyway grab's got something like 280 million wallets right and they first did grab Finance which was basically put the change from your you know your cab Fair into a interest you know some kind of deposit thing now it's crypto they're adding and then then they add

security tokens and then you start start seeing grab Finance selling security tokens to 280 million people so the distribution channels for this are dramatically like dramatically change like worlds and worlds and worlds apart and then standard charted and DBS all launch crypto exchanges and then the crypto guys are coming for so the trafi and the defi guys are going to start competing much more closely and that's that's great for security tokens essentially yeah thanks that is extremely exciting I really like how when when you kind of gave credit to the idea of web 2.5 and especially with these traditional kind of large entities the idea of web 3 might seem quite revolutionary and probably sometimes maybe a step too far and you have to take these companies a longer Journey but kind of on that note I want to ask that how would you distinguish between say traditional token systems and you know web three tokenization and how do you kind of put that across to say the Layman which I imagine you have to

interact with a lot in this kind of area maybe you know I think so what we've to we spend all day trying to simplify right and it's like okay what what's different now why we're having this conversation is because in in in well give I give the short history of the space because I think it paints a better picture so in 2017 we had the first stos I think the the SEC in America was partly responsible for coining the term St because they were like hey those Ico things are securities they're not initial coin offerings they're security coin offerings but sounds better you know and then people went oh stos are illegal the SEC is finding people and they were like no no no the Ico the initial coin offering was considered a security by all its features and we're going to fine you because you didn't follow the rules like everyone else has to do and then so there's this huge misconception that security tokens were illegal you do not need new regulations for

security tokens why because Securities regulations exist and securities regulations do not reference paper right anywhere they don't say when you sell real estate to someone written on a piece of paper it just says when you sell real estate to someone or when you customize real estate or when you trade real estate it never says on paper so that was mad confusion and at the same time of course you had you know actual cryptocurrency so not security tokens like you know growing across the world and also mad confusion in every single country what is it and what's the regulation how it works so in 2018 we had kind of the birth of these stos and I St I don't use rwa it's harder to say but it's the same thing real world asset tokens security tokens then you have the first infrastructure companies that could help people tokenize assets and what did they do they were just tech companies they left they they promoted all the value of what we're talking about here but they couldn't

do any of it because except the token issuance part because raising money trading custody amm Etc that's all regulated activities it has Securities licenses around them but that's where it began because that was the easiest thing to do all the vent Capital guys piled in thinking this is going to be the next crypto whatever they thought and then the actual volume went down in 2019 because more and more of the issuers realized that okay so you know pay this money in token so where's the exchange and where's the trading and where's and it's like oh yeah we don't really do any of that so it used to frustrate the hell out of me but anyway that's what happened and then in 201920 you had the first security token exchanges so that was t0 in the US the Singapore Long Count adx then necessary infrastructure for the greater good of the industry but they also very limited on value proposition because they didn't help on the primary issuance so they're waiting for fully funded security tokens

to fall out of the sky that are apparently on the right protocol rails and a lot of these guys did private chains and everything we talk about in this podcast is generally is not possible on a private blockchain everything I'm talking about today is on public blockchains and so there was no market because they needed market makers with licenses who'd gone to the regular Market making security tokens you know what how do we go so and here's the fee structure you know and and so people were like well tokenizing private assets kind of looks and feels like publicly traded assets and you know in when that when we work L on NASDAQ that's great right $100 million of fees but there's all this money around and when a new world in a new industry there's all this money is not around so structure is out of whack that's interesting so you had you had like the crypto wild west but there there was no one really willing to try and solve the whole problem for

security tokens offerings right well people working on it but it was like in 2018 you know we we had the broker and we were trying to build the token issuance and then trying to work out you know what's legal what's not all that how's it going to work and then you started getting more infrastructure so then Along Came the security token exchanges um but their model is challenged then you started having more security token issuance companies that had a broken dealer license C could then start to actually legally launch them and raise Capital so that started going on in 2021 22 and then now you know around the world there's there's a lot more players that have spent you know so the industry is only four or five years old but in the last couple of years a lot of people have worked out some kind of Licensing which makes it a lot better for everyone and so with that in mind that was that's and that's why now the key reasons why we're having

this discussion now and everyone's getting excited uh because number one is that there's all this infrastructure there that has taken years to come together like four years ago no custodian in the world security tokens now I could name like 10 right and and I'm sure there's more that I don't know about so that was the first main reason the second main reason was because this is all my thoughts as well but it's because like last year the defi meltdown and with all the blowups in decentral finance and nowhere to get yield right so there's billions of dollars of stable coins because a lot of the crypto guys don't want to go into the banking system the Fiat system um so that's why there's hundreds of billions of dollars of stable coins and they're only earning their money so then along at the beginning of this year they became the first tokenized treasury bills tokenized money market instruments that were paying like 5% interest so then this was the greatest yield in crypto so all these

crypto guys started buying real world asset tokens which is token IST bills security tokens so so you've had both the trfy guys that were always going to come but you've also had the crypto guys who actually are buying them and now saying oh these don't suck anymore oh this is actually a real use case oh we can make money and hey we should this is great let's do more stuff so that's kind of why it's finally happening and it couldn't have come sooner because it's been like four years of pain waiting for everyone to kind of get Point Julian I was gonna say so what is the role that investor X plays in this entire Journey then right now what's the problem that you think that you're solving yeah so so if you think about uh just what I just said so token issurance leaves a lot of problems on the table security token exchange leaves a lot of problems on the table even security token broker only leaves problems on the table so we

said all right let's get all the licenses let's Stitch it all together let's throw away um you know here's the 50 fee structures whilst we do all these things because there is a justification advising structuring listing issuing trading because I mean there's a justification on these fees but the world you know these tradire guys are pretty hopeless like you know you need to simplify stuff for them it's not really going to get it so we we stitched it all together and we said what people really want and we've got thousand discussions and we got a lot of people in our Network people want a low cost they want to co-brand a section they want to be in they don't want any technical integration they don't most of them don't care how the technology Works they don't want any new licenses and they want to be able to issue shade and do everything in liquidity all in one place and then I just topped it off by saying and it's a low monthly subscription fee and

all the batteries are included so we give the lowest possible price the most flexibility the least amount of work and that's what investor X does and then I ex swap provides the market making pools which no one else has yet but people are starting to finally understand that the amm model is is going to be the dominant for I believe this but you know now DBS JP Morgan they're all writing papers on it about the potential for it even though we built one it's like this this is going to be the dominating Market making model for security tokens because most security tokens are going to be private Market assets that don't belong in an exchange anyway so if you can can let anyone start their own liquidity pool we just did it one last week we did a someone someone had a $50,000 share of a secondary like a fintech company and we started a $10,000 liquidity pull on I well now how much liquidity is there how the end but the point is that

like when have you ever been able to create liquidity for a secondary token and an ability for people to buy and sell it for a dollar it's it's amazing um we need more capital and partners and all the fun stuff to grow but yeah so that's how we position ourselves in in the ecosystem the other thing I I want to say is that um you know years ago one of the reasons it took us a very long time to get some of our licenses we have like six now is because from day one we were super pro public protocols because that's where all the assets are issued and a lot of other groups in the real world assets space a lot of the groups you might have just heard of this year don't have any licenses and they better go get them or something's going to go down but anyway I'm supportive of all the crazy Innovation and new platforms but for the guys that do have licenses that means they started years ago most

of them went and built on their own private blockchain um because most of them were trafi guys and most of them and they know it's easy to get a license because you just say to the regulator you how's all your Tech work and it's like oh it's fine I can just delete it and whatever you want me to say I'll say it right versus I'm going to issue these assets on these public protocol and how them what happens with protocol po you know a gas fees supporting terrorism and you know all this ridiculous but anyway we kept pushing on that and you know Big Ups to Singapore government that's why I'm still here I it's a great place but like we went to them and said no public protocols like it's not about private change there's no different it's 5% better than the old version like all the assets are on public chains and all the Innovation there all the developers are there all the brains trust is there all the products are there and

we're just getting started on the products like in not in 2018 when we started in this particular Focus there were no nfts there were hardly any Dows I say hardly any I it was like one or two but it wasn't like a thing um there there wasn't any Market amm models and you know which blockchains Pro a blockchain high level it's proving that as a technology stat we're just going to keep rolling out new things it's going to be which is exciting and it's great but again you can't do any of that if you're just sitting on your own little private CH even all the stable coins right like all the stable coins are on public protocols well the ones that matter right so that was key because public all the stuff we're talking about all this value proposition that we're here today is that's why you know that's very much the web 3 DNA of the whole you know the whole Space yeah that's how that's how we believe in it um and you

know and many people say well don't like this isn't going to work this is the wrong way no one's going to issue an asset on it and it's just finally that's not sure think Franklin Templeton CEO they're like 1.5 trillion dollar finance company and even for people that hate trfi for whatever reasons um the CEO was like public chains are going to dominate that that the they're going to overtake no's going to care about private change basic and I was just like Yay you know five years to get that pation um so yeah so anyways but that's important because I think that um you know that that's where you should be looking to try things out to to get started like you start in the right space at least uh and take it from there that's super interesting that you say that right because I I think this is one of those those those things that some there's a group of people who've been touting this you know like we should be going public you

know a lot of case proof of work as well blockchains and there a lot of detractors for a lot of different reasons about public blockchain being the infrastructure that we need but I think sounds like you agree with what we think is that that is kind of the that has the highest value proposition that that has the fundamentals that you need to make any of this worthwhile right to have peer-to-peer exchange immutable data that you can do all this this cool stuff on so yeah it's really refreshing to hear you say that I don't know if there did you have any take on that dichotomy and how and where we are now with it like where do you think continue in the future yeah so if you if you I can't recall exactly because there's so many things going on I think it's ey or one of those big consultancies just did a I've seen a few actually every year it's the same it's like surveys on tradire institutions basically who's using public and who

would you use public and who's using private and it's just a a steep kind of up curve for the adoption of public Tres and look there's a world for private chains because there's a world of banks that aren't going to do anything and they talk a big game and they don't want to leave anyone I'm not going to name names but uh one of the biggest investment banks in the world I went and pitched our whole concept and ideas years ago and they went this is amazing and I said Wow Let's Get there's no way in the world we're ever doing any of this we're not letting our customers out we want them stuck in deals we want to take them for their fees I mean he he was joking he was saying it in a jokingly way but he was he was also ha yeah that's what we do and I was like wow um okay so anyway I never started all this stuff to compete with banks or do anything Banks you know

if banks can use us and we can help them great but like this this there's two worlds going on there's there's ABC Bank doing their own private chain talking into all the conferences about how they love blockchain and all we going to do stuff and they're just a bank doing their own private you know it's just the bank we all know how they operate then's a whole new world like what we're doing new assets um startups the crypto exchanges the the grab financials there's a whole new world like that's actually what you're seeing right now which is not surprising at all is banks are all adopting crypto and banks are now and they always have and there's a renewed push to screw crypto companies over by kicking kicking them out of the bank so they don't have bank accounts and bang the bank pops out and they're doing all the same services and sell on crypto and all that kind of stuff so that's probably good overall price action number of buyers all that kind

of stuff and that's fine but that's the world right it's like it's the banking system and then it's everyone out and um yeah that's the it's almost like the war that goes on and it's kind of fun and it's not really like a friendly competition at all it's like allout War but you know at the end of the day we're not full crypto and we love crypto I swap even has its own token um and we're right in mdal so we got to kind of play nice with everyone um but you know at the end of the day I think that um you know banks will help the real world asset industry and eventually um once they're busy tokenizing and boring Bank assets they'll get demand and they'll start looking for all the exciting Alternatives and all these other stuffs that that is being worked on uh out there and even if they don't come doesn't even matter like there's there's being built without them and all all brain and all the finance people they're

all moving to they have been for a long time I mean you guys are doing the same thing I'm doing the same thing this is where the action is this is where the whole financial world's being kind of redesigned exactly it's quite exciting to see the momentum growing as well so just to recap to confirm my understanding when we talk about tokenization it's all about you know representing ownership of an asset in a very efficient way and that's effectively what invest X is doing they're providing the tools for people to represent which are you know quite complicated objects highly regulated Assets in an efficient way in a cost- effective way and then the other part of that if we can do that represent that ownership in a very effective way the next bit is the exchange how can we actually exchange that ownership in the most efficient way and you know we think about Securities and bonds and all this kind of thing it's quite heavily regulated it's very manual I imagine it's quite laborious

and that's where ex swap comes in right you're trying to automate and make the process of actually exchanging those assets as efficient as possible and when you say automated market makers you're actually you like smart contracts is probably how that's probably the buzzword I'd probably use try and like recreate and reduce the number of steps involved by just automating processes based on like you know predefined values is that correct yeah well the simplest way to explain the difference between an amm an automated Market maker versus a traditional Market maker is to start with a traditional Market maker and that's where you you know open up a binance exchange and you're buying BTC usdc or whatever it is and it's definitely not usdc but it's BTC usdt and you see all the different prices right all the bids and all the offers and there's market makers in there buying and selling and and making the making the market that's the market making and they can be big and small and and whatever they can use their

own money outside money some of them have license some of them don't um that was the original Global understanding of what an exchange is and how market makers work and it's the same for Apple stocks on NASDAQ right same thing looks assets change different players same thing the automated Market maker was an algorithmically driven development where there wasn't all these different bids and prices it just it just priced an asset based off Smart contracts and and how many of those assets exist within a pool so when you start a pool there's different versions I trying to keep it simple you bring your token a and token B that have equivalent value on day one and then it starts trading and that moves up and down and then you have Market forces but when you go to buy and sell just I want to buy token a it just immediately calculates what the price is that second for you and there's not like other prices it's take it or leave it and the difference as well

is that the automated Market making solution is crowdsourced Market making it's not it doesn't have to be a company or one person anyone who has those tokens who's legally hard to hold them can join the pool so that's another key difference you don't you don't have crowdsource Market making from a traditional Market maker yeah that was and that was part of the Innovation as well because if you think about it and why Unis swap became so successful because first of all these big Market maker guys in the big exchanges they don't want to deal with all the small stuff right they only want big stuff so it leaves the biggest side of the market because there's a lot more small guys and big guys with no help and so when Unis swap said to everyone you guys can start a liquidity pool yourselves and it's small and then once you do that go and tell everyone else who bought your tokens or that you're trying to sell them to yeah there's some liquidity here it's

small whatever get involved put your tokens in we can buy and so we create that market so they've given so much to the the market um like some of the now uh I don't know the exact ones but some of the biggest pairings I don't know ethereum and usdt whatever they're deeper pools on Unis swap than they are on binance and coinbase yeah so you know because there's also a side of the crypto Market that's so anti centralized anything there's a side of that that refuses to especially after the FTX to barkle and all these exchanges stealing everyone's money they'd rather have the amm model for buying and selling which you know there times where you might get a better price on a centralized exchange for whatever reasons they'd rather do they'd rather stay in in in decentralized land and all the other key point at least on the crypto side of uni swap was you were you you never gave your coins to anyone that was a big that was a big part of

it yeah one slightly different because um smart contracts alone can't legally customize a security token there's got to be a licensed player so we slightly we don't it's a slight change behind there yeah that that's great that was great description actually because I think automated market makers amm are quite hard to describe actually if you not have a bit of background in this and I think that was a really nice way of doing it I think it's also very web three in the sense that as you said it's a crowdfunded thing and it's very permissionless like anyone can come and join this pool of funds and the larger the pool essentially the more stable that price should be right so similar to how yeah it's similar to how Bitcoin Works anyone can join as a minor anyone can pull their resources to help the network and secure the network and then the bigger it gets the more secure in theory it should get as well so yeah it makes sense that the Innovation came out

of the Bitcoin blockchain era that's a um and that's that's one of the reasons I love IO I think it's kind of a killer application for the space but also it's crypto born right that that's where the Innovation came from and that that's why all these maximalists kind of missed the point because like some of the best things that happen in the space whether you're a blockchain protocol maximalist Bitcoin maximalist whatever you're doing some of the best stuff that happens is when there's a bit of this and a bit of that and this way of doing things and that's exactly what hybrid yeah I mean even in defi decentralized Finance like up until lending borrowing staking capabilities in crypto um well when that came a couple of years ago the activity and the volume and the price went Galactic what is lending borrowing staking they're banking services right even if you don't like to hear that that's what they are it's just like it's you know it's financial services but then look we brought that

to crypto and bang that that that did a great thing so yeah now we're go with this one at least we're going we're going back in the other way and it's hilarious because you can say to people like you know at the beginning I saw every token because at the beginning there weren't that many I used to defeat all the security tokens because you know there weren't that many they weren't very good actually most of them were terrible but I used to come along the one part of the story wasn't that but the real part of the story was every single issuer I'd say 90% still today and we probably have 10 to 20 discussions a day um oh this sounds great I'll do it if you guarantee liquidity it's like what does that mean they're like well sounds great like so you know guarante me liquidity I'm like all appears a little unfortunate news for you there's no magical Market maker that doesn't know you sitting up in the sky dying to make your

asset that we've never we don't even know what it is and therefore we'll guarantee anything at all however that's what we used to say and then just leave it there the next part is however we now have a system where you can be the market maker which of course if they're not super crypto native they could have crossed their eyes and have a bit of a brain fart and say like what we've got this system where you can start first liquidity pool because no one else is going to do it there's another side of this like there's no one else is ever going to do it so if you want to do it you do it and then they go oh how's this work and then some some of them start to really go wow okay this is really interesting and you know away we go try and get them started and set up and get them out there that's again an really good point I think one of the things that I find quite

refreshing is what I assume are your views on the regulation of digital assets which probably weren't the views of people in the space maybe 10 years ago could you just give a bit more may flesh to the bones on what you think the role of Regulation is and should be going forward for digital asset so if I separate between crypto and real world asset tokens the crypto is evolving but getting more clear in different jurisdictions around the world there's a lot of stuff I completely disagree with but I'm not writing those rules and there's a way to play that's what that's how I look at it so and if you're a company in crypto go somewhere that treats you the best and that's as good as it's going to get right unfortunately for American friends they're getting plumbling they got to leave and go somewhere else where they can run Innovation and business and and even like Singapore's become like definitely number one Hub in in Asia for blockchain and so many discussions I had

to talken to for9 two weeks ago was like wow it's pumping here like it's great in Asia we also don't have like the US dollar to protect and we're not like complicated in the EU it's all these members and everyone you know too many cooks in kitchen all that stuff so on the digital asset and the crypto side it's getting more clear and you know it is what it is like there's ways to do it and some people retail only some are accredited only whatever the rules are so that's good and that's progressing and you know UAE is trying to now become the latest and greatest and and Hong Kong's turned on the tap after being years of like we're not doing anything on the real world asset side the security token side every country has their own securi regulations what's interesting about security tokens is and as I said before you don't need new regulations now there should be updates and there should be upgrades and there's two ways to think about this as

well most people are in a tokenized security world where there's a piece of paper we're tokenizing a share that piece of paper might be a Singapore fund vehicle so you know it's a digital representation and then and there's there's things going on there so that's what a lot of the world real world asset tokens are today security tokens are today um and that'll go on forever I think and then there's the other side that's in parallel we have this um let's call it paperless based security tokens which essentially are things like Dows like a dow is the very first security tokens because there's no paper um The Challenge there has been no government in the world considers ethereum to be a country so you know a lot of DS have to back into companies otherwise they start getting called to Legal Securities and all this kind of stuff but look but so my point is that on the real world asset side there's already enough rules in place there's ways to do things so it's

a really matter of like you got to go old school and get licenses or find licensed partners and that's been our position since day one and how I think about it's it's evolved over time I used to be a bit more you know everyone should will want to take their security tokens and put them in their own Ledges and all the fun stuff stuff and that's going to be possible the the important part about that is and then what do you do with it and the answer is nothing and and security tokens are not like Bitcoin right you can't just come and steal someone's security token and then sell it somewhere else because it's not just it's not private key based it's like attached to an asset based and the asset needs to know who the owner is and the owner needed to register because that's how the world works with Equity so if I steal your St it's like me stealing your piece of paper and it doesn't work that's the simple version so

you don't have that problem okay maybe the banks are coming and stealing people's cash but no one's really thinking the banks are coming and stealing your shares of your realate yet you know um but so that's not really a problem that the world's thinking is coming today but but I think that if you think through what I was said at the beginning which I believe in you know the real value of tokenizing here is lending borrowing staking plugging into an amm Distributing on a different platform da da da da da well I don't want to deal with that on my ledger just like that's why people buy crypto on on binance because they don't want to deal with anything and they want all the services there and they just want to click around and hopefully you don't get your money stolen and it's the same for interactive brokers right like what's the point of taking my Apple stocks off interactive brokers like there is no point as I don't even own them there right no

most people don't even know don't even own your stocks it looks nice you got a little you know this how many dollars I have each day and it says that many stocks I don't even really own them but anyway the point is that I trust the system enough and interactive brokers enough that I can leave them there and Loan and margin and take it out and send my money back to whichever bank and that's how I think security tokens are going to work so although technically you can do things like send them peer to-peer and all these kind of things I just don't think people let's think about the one of the best statements I heard the other day was like what it was a discussion around uxui for web 3 web 2.5 web 2 which is a big discussion point you know how does the whole thing work when you're using it and it was like we don't use those terms in our company we just say what do humans want what do humans

do and build that and so what do humans do with secur what do humans do with crypto there's a very small percentage of people that live on dexes most people live on centr Exchange even after FTX like stole everyone's money that you know go to coin gecko or or coin market cap and you look at like the trading volume on the centralized exchanges and it's just where it's super dominant force of nature people still leave all their coins on exchanges so that's what I think is is interesting about security tokens and even now we've learned that from our own platform we started off it's metam mask only everyone own your own like deal with it take care of it and then people like sounds great man I'm not you know I'm not doing I don't want to touch any of this stuff he I was like what that's from individuals to Banks to everyone you do it for I don't want to touch it and you know just just you know here's some money I

got friends send me money like like there's a pain our system here it's like digital Banks just send me money I'm like why' you send me all this money they're like can you buy that thing from me and I send it back no I'm not dealing with it like what that's not how it works that's not the system but the point is that that's how I think a lot of the marketplace will be in terms of where's the volume of users and just giving people what they want and you know of course self- custody is possible and all that but I think that there's a lot more scalability if you if you mirror more of what people are used to from a uxui perspective yeah yeah I really like that point and I think me and Jack came to that realization maybe like six or seven episodes ago we were so deep in the tech and so deep in like the theory of web 3 you were like look at all these cool things you

know full impowerment full peer-to-peer exchange all this kind of your privacy security stuff and you realize most people don't care they care about the user experience like it's the same with chat GPT the reason that's taken off now and that's the buzzle is because of the user experience like the underline Tech maybe isn't that great compare with competitors and I think that's something that all products in web 3 and all companies based around the principles three need to realize is that the fundamentals to a lot of people actually don't matter that much they care about their day-to-day benefits and user experience I'm really glad you made that point yeah we we've had to I'm not going to name platform or product but we've actually had had a discussion recently I like I know we built the best possible version of this let's just say version not uxui just like are we using blockchain there's no banks there's no paper this is just amazing but because people have to do this this and this and bridge

that and go to that second Pro layer protocol to do the d da no like let them buy it with visa and that's like No And I was like all right then they won't buy it right let them do a bank transfer no we can't have that I'm like okay they won't buy it so we've even on one little project we were doing it was painful because it's it is the best version of itself but it's ahead of its time it's got to come back and and do some baby steps which sucks but is what it is you know and then still have that there still have the great version for the super DG and the guys that know what a bridge is and the guys that know how to do XYZ and then for everybody else which is like nearly everyone can we just build something that they're used to clicking or in a payment method that they understand otherwise you know we're not going to it's not going to grow that fast so

everyone agreed but yeah it's interesting about that and if you think about why we and again we've proven this in crypto which is a good analogy because crypto you know the DNA of crypto was like a new world of money and we own it and no one else can take it off me and it's self custody all right so why is everyone's training on centralized crypto exchanges oh because it's easy I don't know how to use the decks I don't want to deal with the metamask I was like so the value propositions there but 99% of people went n you know ux so we got to build like that in this space and even the hardcore web 3 platforms I think need to build more like that otherwise they just assume that everyone knows what they know and most of those most of that knowledge for those Founders at least or those product teams is a couple of years in the weeds and losing coins and all the fun stuff right um and that's why

they know most other people don't have three years to work this stuff out right yeah and that's why web 2.5 is so important because you kind of the techies think they know what the end goal is but users are used to a certain way of thinking a certain user experience and need to take them on that Journey where you're making those little steps I think that's something that you're doing investor X obviously yeah and a lot of the big VCS won't say this out loud but that's exactly what they've been doing and they've been doing it for a long time yeah they'll always promote the and they are investing in web 3 and all kind of stuff but like you know there's already been the guys that have been deepest in the space investing for many many years have also been in many projects already that were ahead of their time from a uxui they ahead of their time from ad adoption um and and therefore there's much more business and you know there's also

in the last bull run right like oh we're going to do a metaverse it's going to have 75 million people and it's going to be the next Facebook in there and it was just like no that didn't happen and like sounds great but then again like what are you talking about from a uxui that's other than people clicking the Facebook button on their browser and staying in web too sure you lost a few people from there I mean even Zuckerberg got excited by the idea and everyone was laughing at him still but I mean that'll evolve but that was just another kind of point in case related to trying to make sure we don't get over the skis on the on boarding side you think about metamask is one of the reasons ethereum still dominates it's because of metamask and and all the onramps and the rails like most of the other protocols that so we've integrated with five public protocols and we're about to integrate with another four and three of those protocols which

I won't name today there's nothing happening because because their wallets are so complicated that our CTO couldn't work it out for an hour it's like so what's going on people lose the woods for the trees with this thing sometimes I think you can really over complicate things and you can lose sight of the actual problem you were trying to solve for your customers in the first place so yeah and and speaking of which so you said you said about you know some of what you're doing being ahead of its time what do you think the future does hold for tokenization in general are there any kind of major use cases that you think will be most exciting and then yeah what are you guys what is in the future for investor X yeah I got asked this this week actually like which assets which areas are pumping the most and where's the excitement and of course there a bit of talk about carbon credits and whatnot well we're asset agnostic and Industry agnostic because for

me a tokenize share is a share of anything so what you're seeing now is evidence that all different types of companies and industries are trying stuff right there's carbon credit tokens there's uranium tokens There's real estate there's private startups there's all kinds of stuff and so I don't think about any industry going to be bigger or better than any other industry uh because eventually I think that governments will stop issuing pieces of paper and the only way you can set up a company will be on a distributed Ledger and then everything will be a security token right but so until we get to that point everything's everyone's having a crack and everything's having a go what I think is more important is for people to think about what I think is more exting and interesting is all those other value propositions that I've mentioned about what you can do with a tokenized security and an st if you can because then there's the multi-dimensional value and it doesn't have it could be any you know

it could be real estate so I think the the most exciting place to build and what I get up after you know these crazy long days all the time is like that's that's where the magic is you know to me it was very obvious that we toiz ships because we've been digitizing everything you know the move from analog to digital has been going for a long time and email and paper on that stuff so it was just made a whole lot of sense so that was that was the easy part to consider and then now it was like that's a given so if that's a given which is now starting com fruition how do you start building these other things and I even tried to get into the lending borrowing staking of security tokens like a year and a half ago contacted all the big D5 platforms said oh we we've got stos and licenses and like we can't do stos no that's that's what we have you've got risk management and Tech of course

they all had zero risk management um and and when they did blow up a lot of people were saying well okay the blow Up's terrible but what it proved was this huge use case so if we stop just lending tokens for other tokens and state yield farming with token for token on the same token and use real assets behind it that's a massive use case and that's what I was thinking I was like yeah this is again that Ico let's make it seos that lending bar in crypto let's do that in um STL land that amm model for crypto let's do that like let's do that with the real assets and so that's where um that's that's the exciting kind of I guess cyclical where where it's kind of all going but I think I think the most exciting part is building those new rails right that's just blue ocean territory like no one it's just new structures that come up with a brand new VC tokenized VC fund that that operates differently and has

distributions and dividends and and it's that's the magic I think that's where I think the excitement is going to be moving forward yeah I totally see that I can see you know building the infrastructure for this hyper tokenized world is definitely it's a huge opportunity so juliia it's been such a great episode I've really enjoyed having you on we've got two closing questions we like to ask all our guests at the end because we like to see how the responses change and Vary over time so um if you're happy we're GNA just just throw these at you very quickly sure so firstly in one sentence what is web 3 to I would say that a web 3 to me is the use of technology to develop communities that exchange value that require that is run and and uh you know organized and run by that Community with no third party in charge and and how these people exchange value and communicate and It's All Digital it's all blockchain that that's how I kind of see

it there a long sentence but that's what I think no that was that was one of the shorter ones actually and I think it's the first time someone's mentioned called out explicitly community in the answer which is really interesting because I think that is people don't understand how much of a Community Technology is sometimes so yeah that was that was a great answer and my second question then is so if you could pick anybody throughout history so that means they can be alive with us today or they can be you know from any time in the past that you can sit down with and discuss web three with then who would you pick and why um I would I'd probably pick confucious because I studied a lot of philosophy and I still listen to call it readings or scriptures whatever people that podcast this stuff Alan wats he's one of my favorite guys so I I'd probably sit down with him and find out like what he thinks about the world that's that's probably my

choice that's a good answer I'm a big fan of confusious too so yeah thank you for joining us Julian and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we untangle a little more of web thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes