Episode 35

The Philosophy of Web3 with Dr. Alex Cahana

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode, Alec and Jack are joined by Dr. Alex Cahana to discuss the philosophical side of Web3. Dr, Cahana, with over 25 years of experience in clinical practice and expertise in Web3 and blockchain, provides an in-depth analysis of integrating technology into healthcare.

He emphasizes the ethical considerations and personal aspects of datafication in healthcare, viewing data as an extension of the self. Dr. Cahana explores the societal impacts of AI and blockchain and advocates for decentralized models in technology and governance, such as DAOs and smart city initiatives.

His insights highlight the potential of these technologies in transforming healthcare and society, advocating for a citizen-driven approach in technology governance. This episode offers a comprehensive view of Dr. Cahana's perspective on the intersection of healthcare, technology, and societal change.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

but if you think about it differently especially now with all the sensors that are capturing what we're doing you understand that I am my actions and these actions are captured by data and so when third parties use it lose it or abuse it they take a piece of welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we're delighted to have Dr Alex Kahana with us Alex operates on the intersection of healthcare and web 3 he brings over 25 years in clinical practice 15 years in Medtech and six years in blockchain technology so this will be a very interesting episode Alex welcome to the show thank you so much gentlemen it's good to see you and good morning from New York City yeah hi Alex thanks for thanks for joining us on the show we've been wanting to get this organized for a while you know we had Heather on the podcast before and she obviously spoke very highly of you first things first Alex how are you today how's things with you excellent

it's the start of a new day and um looking forward of changing the world awesome that's very very very Noble aim I'm sure everyone will will be glad to hear that so Alex can you give us I know you've got a really storied history you've got so much experience in a number of different fields can you just give us a brief overview of your background and explain what led you to web 3 uh thank you it's a very polite way of saying that I'm old but that's that's good my moniker and medium I say I live the four lives in one which means not only that I am of age but also that I know the dirty little secrets of each life I would say that you know I'm a physician by training a pain physician which means that I've seen all the I want to say failures or lack of successes in the Health Care system and I've been fortunate to build almost half a dozen pain Cent around the world um so that

means not only do I speak uh multiple languages but I'm quite familiar with the global Health industry I've always been interested in technology integration in the clinical workflow and try to understand how can that improve the patient physici diad which led me to understanding systems thinking as a pain doctor I've been exposed to the opioid epidemic so this is the man-made greatest manufactured epidemic that we've created in modern medicine and so I've not only understood the federal alphabet suit but also understand how systems work and systems thinking to solve these problems and then in my recent now 10 years into the foray of web 3 since we can't say the b word anymore in the United States yeah it's been interesting it's been a journey and one has to be humble to just follow what the universe is telling you yeah I've had that story from a lot of people right web 3 has been around for kind of you know really 10 10 or so years now in various forms and as you say

it's it's moved on from just being a Bitcoin type thing and blockchain now it's a whole Suite of different Technologies right what was the Allure of the web 3 world to you having been a physician having worked in in the healthcare industry was there a specific kind of point of interest in web 3 where you thought oh that that's definitely the path I need to go down to build on my experience and solve those challenges you saw well I think uh it's a great question I think there are two things that really happened one is that it was thrusted upon us I'm from the generation of being analog where we' write medical records and with pen and a pencil on a piece of paper and we were convinced that's bad for patients and so we were sold this idea that by digitizing electronic health records or introducing technology in the clinical uh uh uh workflow then suddenly things will be great outcomes will be great I think that the motto was right patient right time

right treatment whatever and that couldn't be anything far from true that it distan us from our I want to say work of being a doctor we were less doctoring and more kind of engaging with the computer and all this culminated in the second part which is covid and it really proved that whatever this is it's not working and that our inability to trust each other this erosion of cooperation coordination it just was so self-evident that we just failed we failed on many different levels but mostly technology wasn't there for us so there had to be a real I want to say deep dive into thinking okay what needs to change try to understand what is a web 3 and I think that and we'll talk about it it has in it features that are supposed to make us more resilient I would say to Future challenges um such as covid-19 and when you talk about well when most people talk about web 3 one of the the follow-up terms tends to be data and how

we use data ownership of data all these kind of things and you talked about your specific background and the idea of digitizing health records and I saw on some of your blogs and some of the the interviews you've done that you use this term datafication could you explain what daic is yeah first of all it's not a term that I invented unfortunately because it's a really good term but I would say that it's different than digitalization uh like I said I lived through this era where we moved from analog to digital and that's fine it it created this world that we live in where we interface with a world that is not tangible the computer if you wish the web is kind of like that barrier between the physical and that digital and data is that currency if you wish and I use currency here not in the financial analog but in the way we use in electricity where it just moves from one place to another and we use this data to allow us

to do things in a way that is more I want to say sufficient convenient uh better outcomes again a promise of a a better life dentification specifically pertains to I want to say two two aspects uh one is to treat data as an extension of you and I think that people don't think of it that way they say Okay data is this thing that is out there that may be the Bedrock of knowledge or information knowledge wisdom in in that pyramid that we tend to talk about but if you think about it differently especially now with all the sensors that are capturing what we're doing you understand that that I am my actions and these actions are captured by data and so when third parties use it lose it or abuse it they take a piece of me so this is not some theoretical or cold acid that just lives out there in the universe but really it is a part of me and it represents to a large extent my dignity and so when

we talk about security or privacy in depth or privacy by Design Technologies we're actually talking about dignity preserving Technologies and I'm not sure that we always understand that importance or give that importance when we build things second part of that ification of course is data as an asset and this is pertaining to those most of the modern world still lives in a capitalistic or what we call a free market I say still because and I believe this even more so with the llms and the chatter gpts that have coming out that we will arrive to a moment that might be a post-m monetary world but until that happens I think that the data that we create has value and so there's this kind of like flow back going back to energy between the data producers and the data consumers someone who creates that knowledge and someone who wants that knowledge and right now the world that we live in is a world of data a I know something that you don't know so you're going

to want to talk to me and pay me buckets of gold to hear what I have to say but also data IL liquidity because I might say I don't want to tell you all the fun stuff I don't want to tell you the secret sauce unless you pay me so this whole approach uh of um adding a I want to say a a dimension to capitalism where before we're talking about dollars and now we can replace the word with data so it's this kind of new byproduct of a web that is more fital it's not that web that okay I'm here the digital is there and there's no interface we upload and download yeah it's better than web one when we just looked at it and I said why am I using it now we use immersive Technologies I'm in it I own parts of it or the hope is that I will own parts of it but it's clear that it's da ification is something that is part and parcel of the evolution or

the hybridization of the physical and the digital yeah wow that's a really incredible explanation one thing that stuck with me there is the idea of data being an extension of you and I think that's both something that's being enabled with the technological developments but it also seems like it's a philosophical kind of mental advancement that is happening in a lot of ways and I think that directly aligns with the web 3 Vision as well but how do you think that all these web 3 advancements are actually enabling this statification that you're talking about first of all to to your point it is philosophical in philosophy this is called the extended mind and all what it says is that my mind doesn't sit just in my head and so you know as a doctor for example if I have a patient with Alzheimer and I give them Post-its and they go through their home and they say okay open the door turn on the light da da da you know that's their extended mind you know

if I take away those Post-its they won't be able to function or if I lose my phone I will literally lose my mind because there's data in it there's information in it be with photos or notes or things that I've taken that are very difficult to retrieve otherwise so so you are right by announcing that it is a philosophical approach I think that um what is interesting about this uh movement into uh this datafication world or this web 3 world and acknowledging the figal is that we're starting to think about okay how do we work in a diad with machines or with artificial intelligence which is just boomed in the last 12 to 18 months there's not a day that goes by that we don't read you know some drama AI drama related between AI optimism or techno optimism or AI always say and I apologize for those in the audience who've heard that already I am not worried about artificial intelligence what I'm worried about is natural stupidity so I I think that there

are limitations to what AI can and will do it'll always be a diad with us not because I don't think that computation wise the power is endless but I also remind people that our ability to think about things is also end endless and so when people think about the end of knowledge there's two ways to look at it one is to say okay I'm learning about data and that data creates knowledge what's the end of it what's the point the point is to understand how the universe works and that's the end of knowledge that's what we've been doing all the time but then if you have a certain way of looking at the world you say the world is like this and doesn't matter to what uh imaginary friend you you believe in then you ignore other parts of reality and this is where we live right now where we're ignoring stuff and we become incurious and so when you ignore something you introduce ignorance and you become ignorant and that is the end as

terms of the Terminus the finish of knowledge and so AI will be only as good as we can understand it and I think that a lot of the AI dumer ismn to as children uh what we've seen in science fiction or what we've read or our thoughts about it and I think that it's again if we understand or or embrace the extended mind Theory then this can only make us better creatures this machine human diet and I don't want to go too far and saying okay I've been a pain doctor and a lot of it is understanding emotions and and behavior and psychology will there be psychologist of machines or or or people who are working with machines probably people say I hate my computer or I hate my AI assistant what will I do with it oh it's about time to finish this marriage and go to another version but then of course you might find two AIS you know anthromorphic AIS or robots sitting in your office and complaining about their pain and

so forth so I'm not trying to be glit but what I'm trying to say is that imagination is infinite and that is really the only thing that that limits us I'm glad we're going down the rabbit hole so early in this episode it feels like we've gone straight for the Deep conceptual stuff and it's super interesting that you call out AI so early right when we're talking at web 3 I think we tend to think about it as this convergence of lots of different Technologies like AI blockchain lots of privacy preserving Technologies as well which are obviously super relevant in in the healthcare space another kind of broad point on on web 3 and I've seen you mentioned this I think it was in your your UN General Assembly panel you mentioned actually web 2.75 right and me and Alex sometimes do talk about two web 2.5 as a bridge between the two so I was interested what do you mean by 2.75 are you saying we're a little bit further ahead or which parts

of web 3 is it blockchain AI which bits of it are getting closer to realizing this web 3 dream in your mind well obviously the 2.75 was just a hook and to create that uh that interest because I knew that You' some point ask me this question but it's really to your point the the progression of our immersion into that because if you think about it and then I'll talk a little bit about the loveh relationship between Ai and blockchain is that if you look at the number that we append after the word web okay saying that web would be that border or that boundary between the physical and the digital then basically that number only represents our proximity to it so web one we're just looking at it and I'm like why the hell am I looking at a computer that look exactly like the New York Times just read the New York Times and I love the ink that is left on my fingers and I love the smell of paper web what

we're doing now is yeah I can upload I can download I can say stuff sure it's not mine I'm making someone rich but it's surely not me and then web 3 thanks to uh uh this stack that you're talking about AI which is like accelerated intelligence if you and blockchain which I call the software to the social solution of trust so I can say that it's a trustworthy intelligence that I'm enhanced with for example privacy knowing that there are things that can be dignity preserving Technologies and it could be iot with sensor so it also talks to what I'm doing with machines and so forth a web 3 is that figal I'm in and out so one can imagine that web 4 with brain computer interfac is I'm in the internet I'm totally immersed I don't know if that's my thoughts I can think about something and it goes back to me so wow I am in the internet and then web five would be okay I am the internet allaha Matrix you know I'm

finally in piano Reeds so the point being is that uh I think that we are now uh immersing more and more into the world into the environment into if you wish the phenomenological world world around us and when I say phenomenological I mean that the world what it means to me and that's really what's important is that and especially for someone who worked so many years in pain is that there's this firsters voice that science has neglected for a couple centuries that if it can't be measured if it can't be observed if it can't be you know uh uh in an experiment it's not real and I beg to differ if I think about a pink elephant even if pink elephants don't exist it is something that I'm thinking about so how do you quantify it how do you represent it do I say you know put a prompt now in mid journey and suddenly I see it and then the world can see it and the world can understand my thoughts or is it

just signals that come in MRI and say oh I know what he's thinking about so so the point is that we're now able to go into what I would call the transparent brain to start to really understand our thoughts our our our private voices and not just this observing operational psychology of oh I'm looking at you and you Alec you look to me quite depressed and you're like why would you say that I'm a doctor and I can tell that the way you're frowning that's totally it's not now LoveHate relationship between Ai and blockchain is very interesting because when people ask me what is the killer app for blockchain I say it's AI finally because everybody loves AI but everybody also understands the power of it and so they say Okay I I I don't like this black box I don't like this oh you think that because it's exactly that point what does it mean that it thinks it went through some unknown database that looked at some type of bias and on its

way it's hallucinating and now it's telling me what I'm supposed to do doesn't make sense and so watch which is the single source of Truth which enforce es into transparency which is security censorship collusion resistant that really creates a very powerful stack of saying yeah I think I can deal with more fire more computational power and still remain human well there's a lot there that I want to unpack I think one of the terms that I've see that you've used a few times and is is becoming quite prominent in the space is the idea of these fals right the concept of Bridging the digital and physical world with the idea of creating more I know interactive user experiences right and I think something that I I read quite recently which really resonated well with me I think we've discussed on the podcast is the idea that the digital world right now in web one Web Two it's all about convenience right I will use it for the convenience of being able to speak to someone

or interact with someone around the world but that is to the detriment of immersive experiences and the emotional and empathetic experiences and I've seen it seems like you're saying this as well that as we're pushing towards this web 3 maybe even web four Paradigm that will start to have the convenience of digital but also the ability to communicate emotion to empathize and I imagine that must be very relevant to your work as a clinical practitioner because that's so much of it right The Human Experience but being able to do that with a convenience of digital must be a powerful thing for the future it is it is and I think that you know I've been very fortunate to work in the field of pain because pain is something that's not tangible and carries with it stigma and the saying we used to say is the only pain that's easy to treat is the pain of others you can look at someone that looks completely fine and they say I I can't live it's it's just

and you're in your head you're just making this up and I can do the other way around I can see someone's totally broken into pieces and I say how are you I say I'm fine so there's this thing called Phantom limping where you can lose an arm or a hand or a foot and you feel pain in a limb that doesn't exist now we can talk about about the biology of how that happens what are the changes or the scars that happen in the central nervous system that can cause that I think that's less interesting I think that what really is interesting is that in that sense the brain doesn't need a body to feel things you know if you just take my brain put it in a in a jar and connect it to a mouth I'll be very good complaining about stuff so I think that the figal kind of oliviat that I want to say dependence on the stuff on the material which has profound impact of how we behave with each

other about this materialism that we live in oh I have to have stuff because if I don't have stuff if I don't hold a stock certificate if I can't touch this house this is the chair oh I'm I'm I have a bag expensive bag or some shoes or sneakers and that's why it's so interesting when I was when I meet young serious Gamers I love that it's like game I always thought as a kid the game is fun this is serious gaming is really that they value the digital the imaginary the untangle the first voice what it means to me then the stuff that is around us and so I think that it will just make us better people because we are now transforming from a world of Commodities a world of stuff which is um mindset of scarcity and our whole economics is built on scarcity it's all built on Supply demand and the price pressures on that Supply demand and it creates all these perversions of on one hand you have I'm in

New York here so on one side of the street I have homeless people piling up on top of each other and on the other side of the street I have all these mansions and all these expensive buildings that are empty owned by Russian oligarchs or the ultra Rich from the UAE and China because were all tied into this these rules of materialism and so Ai and to that extent also allows us not only to do things better bigger chocolatier more convenient o I can make a little bit more profit but also AI pays attention to us what we say what we do and and is a mirror to who we are it can be a tool and say oh my god do I sound like that am I that biased do I those huge blind spots out there so if anything I find that all these technology developments that we're doing are giving us not only an opportunity to reflect on what the hell are we doing here but also an opportunity to improve ourselves

as a species in our relationship with our planet because as a doctor and I say this many times you can't seriously talk about mental health and physical health and Planet Health without talking about Financial Health which drives the way we interact with each other I mean your passion for this topic is infectious I think me and Jack have spoken about this as well as well you know the idea of capitalism consumerism constant more and more it's not sustainable in a lot of ways and the episode we did on the metaverse I've seen a lot of people and they're saying well the metaverse is a way for people to have constant increase in what they own and ownership and demand and supply and all this kind of stuff without necessarily affecting the environment producing Mass amounts of material and there's this whole idea of capitalism now moving into the metaverse and all this kind of stuff to to maintain that relationship and it's very easy to think far ahead in the future what does that future

look like where we're all in the metaverse there's AI everywhere AI is commerc and all this kind of stuff but the wealth of experience you have right now in the clinical sector what are the the problems you see right now in web 2 centralized Healthcare well before I answer that because you said something so important I want to just underline that so the audience will will will really appreciate what you said and I saw that when I was this year in the Amazon you know and I was just with indigenous tribes and and they helped me understand that consumption is destruction because when the hunter I was with this tribe that of course I didn't interact with them because they didn't want me to infect them because I'm the one that carries covid but I observe them and the hunter would bring exactly what the group needed they would bring too much it's not helpful it just rots it just ruins the planet it's like why why the hell would you do that and so

you understand that is the importance of responsible production and responsible consumption and respect the balance of ecosystem that you're creating and the word econ e omy By the way economica from Greek means maintain your house keep your house in order and if you have too much stuff you start to hoard and so all these multi-millionaires and multi-billionaires what are they they're just hoarders they're just hoarding colored paper money which right now is supposed to be the consensus of value that has pictures of kings queens slave owners and Co colonizers on it they're supposed to represent something and to your point Alec is to say no there are other ways to Value who we are as people that are non-monetary and so that's what's so interesting and to answer what are the applications of these to your question and I'll answer about Healthcare but in general if you look at AI okay what is AI gonna do what G AI doesn't do anything it's what we do as humans with AI that makes a difference so

imagine that I'm the boss of a small business business and let's say for the sake of conversation it costs me $100 to maintain it a year and I made $200 so with $100 I pay the wages and the leases and the amortization and whatnot and I made a profit of a 100 it's good now Jack comes to me and says Alex Dr Kahana I have this AI thing maingi and everything will cost 50 so what is capitalism different me to do what am I supposed to do according to capitalism so I can say it's only cost me $50 fire half the people and make 100 yeah but that's not what that's not Adam sonian capitalism that's not what's it says there that's a moral decision that I took as a as an owner because what I could have said was that's great news so what I'll do is that morning shifts will be human and afternoon shifts will be robots and still people will maintain their jobs and I'll make a hundred now why is

that important because in scenario one now I'm a worker that says oh AI is terrible it took my job and the other I'm like AI is amazing because now I can go home be with the family pursue my interest play the piano paint pictures code for example maybe come up with better ideas for my company maybe build a competitive company that will make it even better in field so yeah in that sense capitalism is aoral it doesn't care what we do moral Wise It's human beings that make that different yeah it's really that really resonates with me because it sounds I've heard this kind of idea espoused by people like Nal ravikant right talking about the kind of the Utopia we could be going towards with AI whereby the menial tasks are all being moved away from Human it so we don't have to spend our time doing that and instead we can focus on the more meaningful things right creative things spending time with people and lots of people lots of people are worried

on the other side of this going to take my job but then you have the whole Universal basic income argument so why why do we have the jobs in the first place it's just for sustenance so it's yeah it's I think it's really useful to know the kind of very broad brushstrokes vision for these Technologies right especially AI as you talked about and then there are also looking kind of to the nearer future I see so many areas right just even we're from the UK we use the NHS there are so many inefficiencies where the other aspects of web 3 as well not just AI but things like blockchain as well certification all these other auxiliary Technologies in web 3 that can Aid processes make things more efficient help us share data more easily right because whenever we have to change our GP sometimes the the data is is physical still and it goes and gets mailed across and it can take a long time one one of the things you mentioned earlier was about

the opioid crisis in particular as well and this is something I came across a number of years ago in thinking about this from a blockchain perspective right because my understanding was there were really pharmacies were really struggling with the lack of real-time data right people could effectively in some cases cross state lines and get overprescribed drugs by going from one state to the next or one Pharmacy didn't know that he'd been had this prescription fi at another so it seems obvious to me that there's a link here between Healthcare and da ification how we managed data more effectively how we process it in real time how you can use blockchain to safeguard it but I'm I'd be Keen to hear what do you think are the main kind of applications in healthc care is specifically for this kind of tech yeah no these are great remarks and implied from your question is really a very interesting comparison of saying the NHS which is a centralized model that's not going pretty well and and in the

US which is a totally combination of centralized and decentralized elements is not working also because of all the friction and capital leakage and intermediaries that are in it and so what gives and obviously we can talk about the use cases of it like to your point supply chain okay where are the ventilators where are the masks where are the sanitizing gel for my hands and I don't know what we can talk about certification how do I really know that I'm a doctor and not just saying that I'm a doctor because I look like one we can talk about clinical trial management decentralized and really decentralized not how it's called today which basically means remote and virtual I'm saying about how the data architecture is built in such a way that it's self- Sovereign and all all the things that we talk about transparency and trust and tokenization we can talk about electronic health records which is difficult to apply because we live in a technological oligarchy or oligopoly in the US there over 12200 electronic

health records but five are holding 80% of it so you know the the rest uh 1245 are competing on a sliver of of the marketplace and we can talk about how do we aggregate as individuals and Dows and what is decentralized science and all those things before we dive into each example and you can ask me questions about it I do want to point out that healthc care is not broken it is doing exact ly what it is designed to do but if I use blockchain par it's that it is designed to trade in death coins because if I get healthy then I don't have business every time I would treat a patient and there would be better my CFO would look at me or my administrator and say G it was just an opportunity of of of a $100,000 just went out the door because we could have done physical therapy and we could have done drugs and we could have done injections and we could have a whole whole bunch of stuff on

them doesn't matter they help why did you just give them the counseling the meditation the good food the Sleep hygiene the spiritual support now he's lost and that was a good pay customer not not a poor customer that we had to do chair so so it is doing what is it is designed like web to and that is to extract exploit and exclude so the question here is not so much what are the use cases in healthcare which I mentioned and we can talk about but it's really about what is value what is valuable and the problem is that anybody who did econ 101 or 102 understands that value is Q divided by C quality divided by cost the problem with that equation is twofold one is that quality is something very subjective what is a quality for one is not for the other so a patient wants a million dooll p pill that's quality but the NHS youal director says that's rubbish why would I want a million doll pill now I can't treat

a million people and when you put cost in denominator then what you're implying is that it's all about cost supression let's do more with less and you reduce that number so much that at the end you divide it by zero and then it's not only practically undoable it's also mathematically undefined so what is the equation of value what should equation of value then I would argue that the fact that you want to put in the denominator what you want to get is meaningless I want to get a lot of stuff I want to get a lot of money I want to get stuff for free I want to get uh h a whole bunch of things that will make me feel good sure why not if you live in a country that can provide that to you good for you question is what's on the numerator and that is what are you willing to give and that's the whole point of web 3 this responsibilization and say sure you want ownership but what are you

willing to give what is your engagement what is your contribution what are you contributing to the DA how are you adding quality to the metaverse how are you adding quality to the planet what is the network effect or the ripple effect of what you do that has value and so you're saying I'm talking to Alex and it's valuable because what he does makes people think and creates these new ideas and all that and it can be Quantified and it be computerized and could I could we could imagine uh you know having a a a computer vision on this and it's you know recording all the ooze and a of people who are listening to it and every time I say something great and all goes like this it's like oh wow he liked it okay good I got on my phone a couple of pings and I made a lot of money you can do that we have the technology so I think that the reason I am not just saying okay okay web 3

is good in order for supply chain value chain clinical trials credentialing Dows unions electronic it's because we heard that already and and it's not getting adopted and it's not getting adopted because the system doesn't want it to get adopted why doesn't the system get adopted because it lives in a commodity economics of scarcity instead of a digital economy of abundance well this is reminding a little bit of I think Bitcoin itself right to use the b word because the whole Paradigm Shift we talk about in web 3 is essentially realigning incentives right it's ironic because a lot of people think Bitcoin is valuable because it's scarce and I think it's actually much more than that I think it's more about the economic incentive model behind how it works right you're taking traditional Payment Systems where you have an incumbent who's extracting value from the system exactly how you describe the Health Care System right and web 2 and it's moving to a more competitive open system where people Pro are competing essentially to provide value

to people and an actual value that they see so I think there's a nice there's a nice parallel there between the philosophy of web through you know we've gone back to philosophy and I appreciate that because we can often we we har on about use cases quite a lot right but I think is important to to touch on the fundamental values of why we're talking about it I think and again the reason why I want to step back and ask the why because all the time ask about the what and the when and the how is because it stretches our mind a little bit it doesn't have to be like this it wasn't always like this and I I think that you know Bitcoin for that matter I think all what it offers is this public infrastructure of exchange of value that right now the only one that does it is cash and so yeah there's gold digital gold and store of value and all these secondaries in this but really what it created is

that I can give to to you X and you know that I am me and I know that I am you and there's very minimal Capital leakage in between and it's 247 and it's good for the unbanked and underbanked and for those who don't have a don't have voices and that are are are in existential conditions I was in Elon in El Salvador when buou launched and we can talk about was it wise to do a Bitcoin and or should have he done a stable coin or something else and blah blah blah nobody asks my opinion so who cares but that's not the point the point is that I saw in my eyes a community of farmers that before that had to go with four hours on a bus to the Capal to get to an ATM to fill duffle bags of paper money to go back and do their business and hope that on the way nobody's going to kill them and and instead you're saying wait a second this is 2023 or when

I was in 2021 this is like this is in insane and so why can't we do it with our mobile phones with our digital infrastructure and that's really what this is about it is about like a country like s El Salvador doesn't have to cough up6 billion dollar a year for fees to private bank for remittances I had to transfer a payment to Nairobi and it's like what on a $100 I had to pay $40 of fees so I don't care because I have enough but 80% of the world doesn't make 20 so that's really the problem the exploitation that the one uh billion people are consuming the amount of the rest of the seven forget that it's not okay it's simply not sustainable and so we have the imagination we have the ability we have everything necessary to make this more sustainable and it really pertains to at the end to ask these philosophical questions of why is health care not working why is there such polarization and to the point that we can't

sit and talk about stuff let alone collaborate this resonates very well with me I know it does with Jack as well like the reason we started this podcast is because we were talking about web 3 in the abstract in a lot of ways we're like hey data ownership and then I go to my mom or go to my friends and say web 3 is all about data ownership and they're like don't I own my data what does data ownership really mean and then you talk in the abstract again about the benefits what it means people can't see it you control it all this kind of stuff and my experience has been anyway with my friends and fam is they they don't really care that much about that in in the kind of the norm what they care about is when they actually say tangible things and it might misalign with some of the things you've said around okay if you own your data you can monetize that data you can see less ads you can

start to control your experience better and that resonates a lot more with people and that does fit into this idea of data for profit and commercialization all this kind of stuff which maybe misaligns with the end goal but in the near term I think that kind of St does push people in in little baby steps towards this Paradigm in the future where it's not necessarily always about consumerism and monetization But It's Tricky right you have to have these steps it's I've found my experience so far is when you're identifying the why I personally resonate with the big question stuff that we're talking about right now but then I think the general public in my experience is more about baby steps to get there and what that actually means tomorrow in Practical terms and I would want to know more about what the you've got a I looked at your CV you have a lot of different projects going going on right now it'd really be interesting for me to know what do you think the

big things are right now that you're working on to the end goal so so I to 100% agree with you on on incrementalism you know and and Evolution versus let's torch everything and Revolution I think that people especially if they are fatigued have uh very little capacity for these huge changes and when I say fatigued it doesn't have to be physical IAL fatigue it just could be being overwhelmed by the delusion of data cognitive overload I want to say that the there are many projects and I'm always careful because I work with so many people so I love everyone all your stuff is is is equally interesting I love chocolate and vanilla but what I would say it is the big projects that excite me the most because they contain in it room for all the other projects that I'm working on and I think that the two most interesting for me is one anything that pertains to Dows so on all the Dows that I'm working in understanding that web 3 is a social

engineering tool and I always say that when I go into the bookstore if I see a blockchain or AI uh book if I see it in in the technical sector I'm like okay if I see it in the financial sector I'm like oh but I want to see them in the philosophy social studies section then I know now we're on a good on a good run so anything that is pertains to social engineering the way we interact with each other differently that is not only more sustainable and more logical but also more kind it's more gentle it's more respectful and less harsh the project that I'm enjoying most is building smart cities I work in a very large cohort of amazing people called and we built smart cities around the world we actually were able to write the standards of smart cities for the i e if you want to become a Cesar City open the standard and just do all those steps I'm actually going to travel to vanatu in the Pacific island and

go to Satoshi Island which is a small island that where we're building this Utopia where experimenting this idea of how how can we social engineer engineer ourselves what does electronic bartering looks like what do uh different type of economic models how do we understand value and monies and currencies differently while at the same time respect nature and respect indigenous knowledge we have to try to figure out to do things differently uh because there's just too many planet scale challenges that we're dealing dealing with right now that feel so overwhelming that we just disengage that's that sense of isolationism that we see especially among High income countries and lowincome countries I don't like to use the word developed and developing because we're always developing towards something and I don't like to use first and third world because it has this postcolonial tinge to it I call them obese and lean economies and there are the obese eon economies are starting to understand this is not healthy and so yeah I could take OIC or whatnot and

take a pill or an injection and get artificially slim and create all kinds of shocks to the body but it's really about how do we reorganize ourselves into that human exchange and that's what I find the most interesting is that the resistance to blockchain to crypto the resistance to Ai and is because it changes the way we interact with each other it changes power and people don't like it don't like it for different reasons and there are two ways to deal with it one is to just complain about it and that I think is a very toxic way to to approach it and then there are ways to say Okay can how can we solve it now whether these are tiny baby steps of optimization could be I would like to see it in my lifetime so maybe I have a sense of more sense of urgency than you guys have but I think that um we really need to understand the why before we start to jump into the how and uh I believe

in our infinite capacity to imagine I believe in our infinite capacity to love I always say that life is simple there there just three things and that is love abundantly live gently and graciously leave things that weren't meant to be and we can easily move on and just imagine this better world I like that a lot I think one thing I was going to say you were talking about all the problems in the world and the systemic and the huge and so much of it is drawing up these arbitrary borders governing them in a certain way and having government versus government World versus World obese versus lean like you said and individuals probably don't care so much that people actually operating in those economies don't care and at first I was like okay how does this fit in with web 3 how does this fit in with blockchain all this kind of stuff but that is the technological progression right when the whole point of Bitcoin and blockchain now was to move away from these

isolated systems open up and not just the wishy washy be transparent and all this kind of stuff but it's all about being peer-to-peer to cut across these borders to cut across these unnecessary intermediaries that facilitating the bloat in a lot of ways and actually interact on a more individual to individual basis and I don't know whether it will come from the technology first or whether it'll come from the pH philosophical change first but I do think that this is where web 3 is going I hope that it's going to happen in our lifetime for sure yeah and the way it will look like in this revolution or paradigm shift to use to borrow Thomas kon's expression is we're going to create a new language there's a whole bunch of words that we haven't used before I'm not talking about Riz or things like that I'm saying that there's all these new concepts of for example we always talk about B2B and B to C and B Tob Toc the economy at the end is going

to be C to C to C to C economy that we are going to I'm the business T you know my soulbound token or I am the business of Alex because people want to work with me they don't want to work with whatever brick and mortar I work at and I could care less of what's happening and we can create this spontaneous emerging mini da or DAC or dap decentralized autonomous project Jack Alec and Alex are now on a mission doing a Dap on untangling the way so I think that what web 3 brings to us is that power of not a citizen Centric World which turned out to be know it sounded really nice oh I'm going to do it it's going to be user Centric patient Centric citizen Centric turned out to be paternalistic nonsense I decided for you what you'd like I decided for you how this should be and instead it's a citizen driven world that I drive it I take it to where I want and we together in a

peer-to-peer way or into a ctoc economy Define the future and create that Regional economic activity yeah I think that's a really that's a really powerful way to put it I think saying that the individuals in the system are the driver right the active participant in this that that's really making this happen and I'm glad you just said right at the end there peerto peer right because one way I often describe it as we're aiming for a peer-to-peer economy and I like that dovetailing with your definition C to C to C but it's not just it's every interaction between every pair of se's is the important thing now so yeah I I fully subscribe to that um Dr Katana it's been amazing to talk to you I've really enjoyed this episode to finish off we've just got a couple of short kind of quick fire questions we like to ask everyone on the show to see you know how opinions change or how they differ over time so I hope you'll I hope you'll uh you

know give us some really insightful ones here I'm sure you will so the first one we'd like to ask you can you distill into just one sentence what web 3 is to you I would that web 3 is the toolbox that allows me to live in this digital world wow that that was definitely the most brevity we've had and I loved it that was very powerful thank you H and the final question Alex is if you could choose anyone they can be with us today or from any time throughout history to sit down and talk about web 3 with who would you pick and why well you know obviously you can tell that I love philosophy and I love philosophers and there's this amazing philosopher called Emanuel Lenas he's a French philosopher he lived from 1900 to 1996 so he actually exemplifies the 20th century and his philosophical theme was our dependence on the other called it the phenomenology of the other that when I say I'm responsible it means like I'm the head honcho

I'm the boss I'm everything what it means is you're responseable you're able to respond to the other if you can't do that you're not responsible and re means the other so it's not about cognition it's about recognition it's not about flection in praying but it's reflection it's not about our legiance between us it's about religion it's the greater good and all that and so he really created a whole ethical concept or construct that goes around our dependence on the other that I am good only because you think that I am good doesn't mean anything that I think that I'm good and as such he was not enthused with all this technology he saw what that technology did of course culminating in World War II where science was recruited to destroy in the name of science I think he would be very interested he would be very surprised he would be very intrigued by this what is this web 3 technology that forces me to acknowledge the centricity of the other to find the if you

wish Divinity in everybody and that the Universe and nature and the spirits speak through the other and that is the fuel that fuels me every day because I just see the success of what we're doing through you I like that I think this has been a great opportunity me and Jack often talk philosophy and usually we have to dial it in but this has been an incredible opportunity to actually go through that and really dive into it it's been a lot of fun I'm definitely going to check out the work of Emanuel Lanas thanks for that recommendation thank you for joining us Alex like I said this has been an absolute pleasure and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we untangle a little more of web thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to

catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes