Episode 66

The Impact of Quantum Computing

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this week's episode of Untangling Web3, we continue our exploration of quantum computing, diving deeper into its practical applications and potential impacts on various industries.

In this episode, we focus on how quantum computing is not just a futuristic concept but a rapidly advancing field poised to revolutionize technology and computing power as we know it.

Key highlights

  • Quantum Computing in Drug Discovery. Quantum computing offers immense potential in the field of drug discovery by enabling precise molecular simulations and testing at an unprecedented scale. Traditional computers struggle with the complexities of modeling molecular interactions, a task that quantum computers can handle efficiently due to their ability to process multiple states simultaneously. This advancement can significantly reduce the time and cost required to develop new drugs, potentially bringing life-saving treatments to market much faster.
  • Cryptography and Security Risks. One of the most discussed aspects of quantum computing is its impact on cryptography. Quantum computers have the potential to break widely used encryption methods like RSA and elliptic curve cryptography, posing a threat to current security systems. However, they also offer new methods for securing data through quantum-resistant algorithms and quantum key distribution. The episode highlights the dual-edged nature of quantum computing in cybersecurity—posing challenges to existing protocols while also providing new tools for enhancing data protection.
  • Optimization and Artificial Intelligence. Quantum computing's ability to handle complex optimization problems makes it a powerful tool for industries such as logistics, finance, and artificial intelligence. By processing vast amounts of data and evaluating numerous variables simultaneously, quantum computers can optimize routes, supply chains, and investment strategies far more effectively than classical computers. Moreover, they have the potential to accelerate the training and development of AI models, leading to more advanced and efficient machine learning applications.

Quantum computing stands at the forefront of technological innovation, promising to transform various aspects of our digital and physical worlds. From enhancing drug development and disrupting current encryption standards to optimizing complex systems and advancing AI, the potential applications of quantum computing are vast and far-reaching.

As this technology continues to evolve, it will be crucial to understand both its capabilities and the new challenges it brings. Thank you for joining us in this episode, and stay tuned as we continue to explore the dynamic world of Web3 and cutting-edge technologies.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of entangling web 3 now this is the second part of our two-parter on Quantum Computing so in the previous episode we gave the 101 introduction to what Quantum Computing is so we talked about all sorts of weird and wonderful things in quantum physics and today we're going to go into a bit more of a deep dive in what the actual applications and impacts of this right Alec yeah so if um you did make it through that verbal diarrhea that was quantum 101 now I hope it wasn't that bad we what we covered was roughly the high level of what Quantum Computing actually does some like the key characteristics so a quick summary if you don't understand any of the terms that I'm using now do recommend going through to that episode and that will kind of form the basis of what we're going to talk about today which is what Quantum Computing actually means for the world and what applications it has and if it's even possible so one of the

key characteristics was super position and this at a high level allows cubits to exist in multiple States simultaneously and this means that quantum computers can process many possibilities at the same time and this increases computational power for very specific tasks okay so that's the first thing and the second big thing is entanglement and this links cubits in such a way that one state of a cubit instantly influences the state of another regardless of the distance and this on the one hand facilitates more powerful quantum computers Quantum algorithms but also enables some kind of like secure communication and that's basically the backbone of quantum computers do recommend listening to that that first episode Quantum 101 to understand that in a bit more detail and today we'll be talking about what this actually means and how we make this practical in the real world yeah exactly and and obviously last time we also talk touched on the difficulties in in making these quantum computers right and some of the the techniques we have with the super super

conducting quantum computers so now we've you know we've covered how you make a quantum computer it makes sense to actually discuss we make a quantum computer what would we actually use them for so yeah let's go through some of the the big major use cases so the one of the first ones that comes to mind and is talked about a lot is for things like drug Discovery right so when you're when your big pharmaceutical company or something or or a medical research company trying to create new uh therapeutic drugs or even just do research for things like cancer treatment drugs and things like that then you have to do these very heavy molecular simulations right you have to model these molecules you have to see how they interact with what other you have to do very very complex things that classical computers really just are not very good at handling it takes a long time is very expensive and computationally inefficient to use classical computers for this so this is one of those areas that

people are very excited about for Quant Computing because with all this increased parallelism with all this increased computational power the ability to try many many different uh combinations of different states all at the same time to see which drugs might work best and things that's one of the Avenues they think think is going to be really good for drug Discovery and development in the future right yeah so um I think I saw some estimates from you know the big Consultants of the world that basically said by 2030 they reckon they can save around 1.3 billion on the molecular simulation and and testing in the kind of the way that you just describe using quantum computers and you talked about the simulation these are obviously very complex things so being able to simulate many states in a more efficient way at the same time is obviously good so that's you know a powerful application of of quantum computer but also the testing as well being out to test how they interact over time you know what

the longevity of these things are I know that like the average time right now for Dr to bring a drug to Market from conception is like 10 to 15 years so a really long time and they estimate that using quantum computers they can half that and a lot of that is basically being able to rapidly test lots of different scenarios kind of simultaneously whereas like classical computers take a long time to model say you know a 100 atom molecule it might take hours might take years sorry um whereas quantum computer can obviously do that same mapping in and test in in hours theoretically anyway yeah and obviously this is a a really good thing for the drug companies in particular you know whether or not you you think that that in itself is a good thing but it's a big business that and it's you know the amount of money that gets put towards these research processes and trials is huge right it's billi it's a it's a trillion dollar industry I'm sure so any

way you can save things in the billion that's going to be very helpful but it's i' I've also seen people talking about how it's very good for the state of clinical testing and trials as well because being able to do all these uh much faster rapid computer simulated testing means that we can rule out certain drugs much faster without needing to go to kind of animal or human trials and things like that so from an ethical perspective that's also quite a good uh quite a big benefit of this use of quantum Computing I think yeah Healthcare is universal that's why we kind of always start with it when it comes to Applications because everyone gets it and you know being able to lower I mean lower the cost is obviously good across the world so another one that's somewhat Universal even if people don't know it is cryptography and that's one of the things that we see talked about and discussed when it comes to Quantum a lot of the time is are these cryptographic

algorithms Quantum resistant that's the buzz word and basically to say why we say this that is kind of um applied horizontally across the world is that a lot of secure communication a lot of the systems you're using are based on um you know basic cryptography algorithms that have been around for like you know 20 years basically RSA is one of the fundamental ones and one of the Highlight high level kind of you scary things around Quantum Computing is that it's going to be able to break these algorithms these cryptographic algorithms that so many applications and so many security mechanisms are based on and this is a big scary thing like I think I saw some of the estimates of um you know some of the RSA algorithms that we have right now would take thousands of years for a classical computer to break maybe not a super computer but a classical computer and they can be broken potentially in minutes with these proposed quantum computers that will be ready by like 2030 this is a

big scary thing yeah exactly and this is one of the implications of you know when we covered the history of quantum Computing we spoke about how in the early 90s there were these theoretical algorithms devised to say well if you could have a quantum computer based on these Quantum States and cubits then you could in theory uh solve some of these problems and one of the big ones was the one we mentioned Peter Shaw's algorithm Shaw's algorithm in 1994 and this is the one that actually is this is the one that RSA cryptography is vulnerable to so that algorithm allows you to we won't get into all the maths of it but essentially allows you to recover the private key of the RSA crypto system and I I actually when I was researching this I presumed RSA wasn't used very much anymore because it's so old and we have more advanced crypto systems in use now um but it's actually one of the the most widely used um uh public key crypto systems still in

use today so it's used for everything from you know your your uh uh internet connections right now your when you see the little TSL SSL connections things that are very standard and commonplace lots of the time RSA is still used for exchanging Keys when you're securely connecting to a website so this is quite worrying that that can be broken by Quantum right and then it's not just RSA that's vulnerable also things like elliptic elliptic curve cryptography which is what's used and is the Bedrock for your private keys in Bitcoin um so yeah it's it's a bit worrying that both of those systems are vulnerable especially in the web 3 world right when when you can maybe have your private Keys exposed in that way I mean yeah it's one of those things if if it ain't broke don't fix it so you got a lot of these Legacy systems that have been using RSA which has been around for like what 30 40 years or something like that um but now we're getting to the

stage where it could be breakable and I think like some of the estimates on if you could actually commercially and practically break RSA like a global scale it's like obviously trillions of dollars like this is the backbone of the internet in so many ways um yeah this is scary so one of the big things we've seen is around the idea of these Quantum resistant cryptographic algorithms I mean even like just simply you can like compound what's one of the basic most basic Bitcoin transactions to pay to public key hash right even just adding a degree of hashing to your cryptographic signature what might make it more secure so like you said there that we can use you RSA because of the factorization problem it could be done much more efficiently on a quantum computer can be potentially broken in minutes rather than thousands of years but it don't have the same problem with hashing algorithms um so I think it's like for the hashing space for sh 256 this is we get into the mathematics

a little bit here right is the the search space like two to the 256 obviously and a quantum computer right now can only do that in a factor of two more efficiently basically so it's still a huge space so even just adding a simple hashing algorithm onto a cryptographic algorithm could solve some of these problems but that's a bit boring I imagine talk about now yeah I mean it is is an important distinction to make that a lot of people say well Quantum Computing is going to break things like Bitcoin and it's it's it's right that you distinguish between the elliptic curve cryptography and the algorithms behind that and things like hashing because part of the security of Bitcoin and and similar things especially proof of work blockchains is on the hashing process we talk about how miners are hashing all the time and yeah as far as we know right now hashing isn't vulnerable to any Quantum algorithm so no one's come up with a theoretical algorithm that will you know make hashes vulnerable

because that would really uh you know mess up the security model of Bitcoin you wouldn't know what was the correct state of Bitcoin anymore but it's those it's those key pairs that are potentially vulnerable so yeah I think we're going to have to see this shift to Quantum resistant schemes or Quantum secure crypto schemes and at some point all the major blockchains if they haven't already got them uh you know especially the Legacy kind of older chains like Bitcoin ethereum are all going to move to these Quantum secure algorithms and you know just to highlight how new a thing this is so nist the the standards agency in America that is responsible for just basically deciding via competitions which is the most secure algorithm they've actually only just as of kind of a couple of weeks ago published their short list for uh Quantum resistant cryptography scheme so this is still not finalized which one is going to be the nist approved one um but yeah once it is I imagine we'll see a lot

of people transitioning over their blockchains do that yeah it's quite exciting and I think one of the things that I've seen around this as well and I'm sure we want to talk a bit more more is the idea of actually using Quantum key distribution as well so this is a way for secure communication we talked about um entanglement properties a little bit in the quantum 101 being able to kind of link two cuits so that they can communicate with one under and if you you know move one in a certain direction or move another in a certain direction the state will change and that creat a way to communicate right across distances so if we could then you know actually deploy that same principle to a secure Communication channel um with you know potentially private Keys similar to Diffy Helman style and someone were to ease drop in the middle we can actually detect because of what we said earlier that it's we don't really want any interference between those two cubits as soon as

there is interference that that that connection breaks down and this could create a secure Communication channel as well so there are awes some opportunities there related to Security in the cryptographic um insecurity yeah you're saying it's not all bad right Quantum isn't just here to blockchains yeah it's good to know that we can we can use these the same properties not just to attack blockchains but also to improve security and things and you know there's some high-profile names already uh putting this in production so I think there was a a partnership between ey and tashiba they launched one of these Quantum key distribution qkd networks back in 2022 so that's been live for a number of years now to improve the security of you know these cryptographic keys that are the Bedrock and underpinning of lots of our secure systems today so that's that's a positive thing okay so to move on to the next one we've got optimization problems super General let's talk about maybe something that's also General is Supply chains we've done

a whole episode on Supply chains and how kind of wide ranging and impactful they are in society they're you know worth trillions across the board super vulnerable all this kind of stuff and similar to the molecular stuff for drug Discovery we have lots of variables and it kind of the problem scales quite significantly when you think about how do I get my van from A to B and we get 100 vans from A to B and then a thousand different destinations like the problem is huge and vast so being able to optimize say something like Supply chains using something like Quantum which obviously a more efficient way of doing it could save hundreds of billions a year across the world globally make things but also make things more efficient so one of the projects I saw around this was I think it was Volkswagen successfully used a quantum computer to reduce realtime traffic in Beijing and save like five to 10% of like gas consumption by doing that so these are actually things that are

happening now using quantum computers and are actually making a real difference yeah it's uh it's it's very impressive and obviously like if you're going to talk about optimization problems it's a general class of things right could be many many different things it could apply to financial markets you know trying to optimize the Returns on your portfolio or something but you know in the logistics industry this so complex and we saw all the issues around covid when things break down it's good to know there are applications of quantum Computing here and that's again taking advantage of the superposition properties that we mentioned last week so being able to you know run many different trials simultaneously and find the out the the best answer the optimized answer very very quickly using that supersition property so that's good and yeah I've seen there's there's lots of people starting to make moves in this area you've got um I think there's a company in Latin America called Quantum South they're applying this with the International Airlines group to the

whole uh management of flight and things like that so workload efficiency gains that they're targeting there and they're very they're very uh they're very optimistic about how this could help them reduce kind of efficiencies that intentional world put optimistic optimization I heard it I heard it when I said it I know um try and get two buzzword in one and talk about artificial intelligence combined with Quantum Computing comining with blockchain and crypto and everything else yeah why not I mean artificial intelligence is your favorite thing to talk about right because you you live you live in the AI world now you use it for all your work I presume so yeah let's let's jump into that I think like obviously one of the big things is around the obvious ones around training the models like it takes a vast amount of computational power and time to train these models like you often try and parallelize it you have you know hundreds of hours weeks if not months sometimes training these models just on one data

set trying to optimize the output so again this is an optimization problem being able to do that with a quantum computer is an easy win like right now we're seeing that I've seen that more well you know we had this boom of AI companies everywhere just basically trying to say We'll become profitable in five years time and then they start to realize that as they're scaling up they have to scale up their backend servers to kind of do all this AI computation it's getting more and more well it is expensive right now we' assess we hope that the hardware does eventually bring the cost down but right now it's becoming infeasible for a lot of these companies to do this and we're kind of getting this centralization a lot ways of the AI offerings because it's so computationally difficult to to basically optim AI algorithms yeah and I think from my perspective it's it's hard to know precisely how they're going to use the quantum algorithms for me at least because um you know the

how the AI models work and are trained are somewhat opaque already like they're they're a little bit behind closed doors we know some details we don't know everything especially about the data sets they're using but it is probably the the area that is the biggest wing of Big Data at the minute right it's they are the biggest data centers these models have billions to trillions of parameters involved in them so they're incredibly complex um machine learning techniques being used and in theory yeah the kind of parallel parallelization properties we talked about last episode on Quantum are some of the things I think that can Target here and again you've got the big names who are working on this you've got people like IBM their Quantum team is you know developing their own Quantum machine learn learning algorithm so I presume it's possible it must be possible even if I don't quite understand how and you know they at least their early research is showing that this should significantly reduce the time required to do things

like training the AI models on those initial data sets and things like that to help you know improve predictions we get from them and I think like one of the things here that I'm kind of torn between whether I think it is going to be easy to do or difficult to do is that when you think of like the quantum algorithms right now that we've talked about they're very specific like it's very much we it's a mathematical problem in a lot of ways like you're talking about the factorization of ours say very simple in a way I guess to model like input output what the success criteria is but when we talk about AI it's a bit more generic like it's a bit more ambigu ambiguous so it's harder to maybe simplify it down but then maybe not so much at the end of the day it's all binary it's all math running through even if we think that the output is very generic and ambiguous maybe it's not so much so we'll see how

that plays out yeah and you know we talk about Shaw's algorithm I think you will start to see more and more algorithms be created for these specific problems so things like machine learning like IBM's working on and you could say okay now we have an algorithm that that can be used with a quantum computer to attack this problem and I think that's probably one of the big areas of research you have on the side of building the quantum computers and how to do it practically and also on what algorithms can we use now that we we weren't able to to think up with uh with classical Computing um so yeah on that note then why don't we talk about some of the actual kind of societal impact of all this right we talked about some of the ways you can use quantum computers the problems you can solve but what's it actually going to mean for society so we've already said I mean naturally this is going to touch virtually every industry much like AI

it's a very general um potential solution to lots of different problems we talked about logistics Finance Health Care all these things already so we know it's going to have a massive impact I guess we just don't know quite where it will have the most impact yet right yeah I think like one that I can think of off the bat which is kind of happening with AI in in some ways right now and we've kind of touched on it a little bit is the people that can run these quantum computers are only going to be governments and super huge entities right and this in my mind is going to create a centralization of power to an extent like you know if your classical computer or classical Computing system and servers and all this kind of stuff can no longer compete with the say the one super computer or quantum computer that's working in America like it's just going to be able to optimize problems in seconds that would take you years and then just outperform everyone

so do worry it's going to lead to a centralization of power in in in some ways but you know maybe we can get around that using blockchain or something like this WOW wishful thinking blockchain you know the uh the the solution looking for a problem um yeah I think that's something maybe I mean it was implied when we last spoke about Quantum but because of the Practical difficulties in creating these Quantum systems that you build the computers from I I it seems very very very unlikely that we will ever even with you know M law and things factored into all this that we'll ever have practical commercial kind of retail end user quantum computers they'll probably always be in the Googles the apples the ibms of the world in these massive data centers carefully managed and things like that and we'll all just be probably accessing them from cloud services so that there are some cloud services that exist already I think that you can you can um you know make requests too so like

to to Google's one of Google's prototype in beta machines I think one of their computers you can interact with it by sending requests but at the at the end of the day they're still hosting the whole thing they're mediating the response so you know when we talked about AI just now and saying well there's a centralization problem there will Quantum Compu Computing help it if it's just in these massive same group of Silicon Valley companies who hold the quantum computers yeah I don't know so much that is one of the big risks I think um and we got we've as we said so yeah on that idea of like democratization of quantum like you kind of you democratize access to ibms you know say okay it'll take you 10 years to train your algorithm um I'll charge you 20 million and it'll take me five seconds to do it on my Quantum here's the you know API to do that and I guess that makes sense when it's a non-competitor but it's like kind of

the similar to the Amazon style where as soon as they can undercut someone on their platform they will like they're only going to allow that for non-competitors to to do that right um but yeah let's see I think um let's to move on to the next one H obviously there's going to be a job market shift because of this there's going to be more Jack davises of the world playing with their Johnson Johnson's throwing electrons through insulators taking weeks and millions of pounds worth of helium that's going to be I saw they said it might create um over 200,000 new jobs I think by like 20 35 something like this so it's a big business yeah so everyone who lost their job from AI can then just become quantum computer programmer right so no um yeah I it's going to be interesting like because obviously it will be an extremely specialized field but for those in it I think that will be that will be one of the new like top tier uh jobs to

be in right to be in the development of these Quantum algorithms to be people who can configure the computers the it's going to create a lots of jobs in manufacturing as well right because of all the materials needed to create them and and and as this space race Contin there'll be more and more money put into it like the US government has already invested well over a billion into uh into Quantum initiatives as I understand it so yeah the job market as as with all of these new emerging technologies will definitely have some kind of impact um but you know will it replace all the air jobs who knows like that's that's the open question yeah that the the um what's it called the US investing what 1.2 billion into what's it called the national Quantum initiative act um I guess that's kind of there's a double-edged sword there one is it to be world leaders pushing the boundary of quantum blah BL blah all this kind of stuff but I imagine also it's going

to be a lot of Consultants coming in and being like hey these are all the vulnerabilities you have in your system you need to update all this or potential foreign enemy state is going to hack you with their Quantum Tech so I imagine there's going to be a lot of updating Legacy systems to make sure that the their current systems are safe and secure as well yeah it's a it's a bit reminds me of the millennium bug right and the fact that there was a whole worldwide surge to update our Legacy system so that you know planes didn't fall out of the sky on the first day of the the New Millennium and you know that is going to be a genuine risk if these quantum computers can support more and more cubits can break things like RSA ECC because you know every system that uses that will need to do that managed upgrade and even though with nist rolling out its new algorithms it will you know people are not too worried about it

happening but there's still a huge amount of work to do to transition the Legacy systems over that will will cost a lot in the short term but you know it's just one of those necessary things now yeah I think like overall on like the the job market economic disruption piece it kind of doesn't seem too fundamental a shift I I guess we can kind of think of it as just like an an improvement in Computing P which has been happening anyway right it's not like it's going to completely overhaul the whole job sector it's probably just going to make you know certain sectors where it's applied more productive have better outputs that kind of stuff and there be more people moving from Legacy style hardware to supporting this Quantum style hardware so it doesn't really worry me as much as say things like AI where it's kind of like there's a jump from the capabilities of what can be done and the understanding of what can be done basically over the course of a year

which is revolutionary yeah exactly and and the AI you know explosion there's a lot more of the Unknown about that I feel than with Quantum where you you have you need to come up with the algorithms to break certain things or improve certain things it seems a little bit more um step by step whereas AI is kind of this beast that's growing and growing with more data and you know getting out of control um and yeah speaking of AI then so because you know we want to sit situate this in the world of web 3 as well and we have always treated web3 is a broad Church of different emerging Technologies I think Quantum Computing is probably the first technology that is is fairly orthogonal to to most of web 3 in general like it's not necessarily directly overlapping but it's kind of growing in the corner and we've already spoken about okay all the blockchains are going to have to think about this at least whether that's the you know I think deoe estimated

25% of existing blockchains are going to have to uh make upgrades because they have vulnerabilities and you know if something ever happens and someone comes up with an algorithm that breaks hash functions that's a whole different problem but aside from just updating the crypto systems for the key Pairs and things what what what do you think are the big impacts for the rest of web 3 right like opportunities or risks that come with it I think like the we kind of touched on it a bit earlier so I'll just briefly mention it again the idea of potentially democratizing access and tokenizing Quantum Resources like it's going to be a big Fear Factor say having five companies or states around the world that have access to these quantum computers that are so much more powerful than everything else in the market um so all of a sudden people they might want to democratize that they might want to allow anyone to have access to that for a certain price and then say I will pay for

you know x amount of time or x amount of compute PA to solve this problem you know being able to do that with a kind of a peer-to-peer decentralized Network might be the most efficient way to do that to represent ownership represent access um that's one thing I could think of yeah I think that's the main one for me as well right like the tokenization of access to the resources being able to use things like microp payments again in the same way we describe for AI like for very small simple tasks that are massively sped up by Quantum Computing in the same way as you can get those with AI and we are starting to see Ai and people talking about AI agents empowered with the crypto wallets like we've been talking about um I think the whole tokenization and microp payments model for Quantum Computing will be maybe in five 10 years when the quantum computers are big enough that they can support you know hundreds of millions of users concurrently requesting things and

then you want those um those requests to be you know a very small payment attach you don't want to pay uh 1010 every time you call it you want to pay a penny or something like that so I think that is probably the main area I I kind of struggle to think of what the other overlaps will be right now I because because the idea in blockchain of lots of people wanting blockchains to be heavily decentralized and being able to run those nodes and things at home or be part of the network and to add Quantum Computing into that infrastructure as as as blockchains most blockchains you know like BTC they are not compatible with the idea of Quant Computing being these big heavy resource in intensive things that you can't run at home so I think you know some blockchains may end up being run by quantum computers who knows but I I don't necessarily see that in the near to midterm future for me yeah I'm kind of thinking of it like uh

seon's eye right now there's going to be five seon's eyes and wherever they put their focus that thing is going to change radically and because there's only five and they're going to be you know massive companies in big States like they're going to focus on maybe the big topics at hand whatever it is sustainability development optimizing Logistics that kind of boring traditional Web Two stuff right I don't see their focus being blockchain the cryptos of the world for the next 10 15 years but you said that that could change quite quickly like if all of a sudden they could commercialize it much faster and parallelize the development of this stuff then it might change and and I think yeah one of the the crazy things you kind of we have to get our head around is that it's not just say a Bitcoin system of the world today could say we're going to change uh you know key paare system or cryptographic signing system from today they have to back dat everything right they have

to back dat all the network all of these whales that haven't touched their keys for like 20 years even maybe even Satoshi wallet whatever it is like that has to be backdated as well and that's a huge huge task it's a huge huge problem maybe not so much for btcs because there's not you know what what hundreds of billions of transactions but for some of the networks that have really high throughput you have to change that stuff yeah you're right that I think the migration problem for blockchains is probably much worse than in the web 2 world in that respect because you have to get some kind of you have to communicate this new thing to everyone you have to say we need to migrate keys and things you need lots of onchain transactions to do that as well to move funds from one to another potentially and again I don't know exactly how people are planning to transition I think that I haven't seen many kind of active um plans to transition things like

ethereum yeah I might be wrong on that um but yeah one thing you just maybe think of as well is all these keys that people have lost over the years right we talked about the guy in in Newport in South Wales who's lost his hard drive maybe there'll be a service in that in the future for ethical hacking of old wallets but then there'll be a whole bunch of other issues around that about proving that you did own it and stuff like that so yeah I think that that is Bonkers yeah and that is absolutely crazy to think of that guy who's got like 200 million Bitcoins lying around some Quantum service being out I'll find your keys for you here you go just give me half that is mad and like you're saying like blockchain data is notoriously very unstructured and very index like very good for verification but very difficult to actually search through so this is going to be a huge huge task to actually like you know make this tabula make

this easy to read through and like notoriously people that are using crypto want anonymity don't necessarily want to be communicated with and like the idea of them being potentially docked by having to inter like talk to an exchange and update everything like there's so many problems with this kind of stuff it's actually quite scary to think about what the implications are going to be you're right I'm actually a bit more worried now that we we've kind of spoken about it and reasoned it out than I was that was half an hour ago um yeah and I your 5 in Bitcoin will be safe don't worry if that um yeah maybe there's a final thought on the web 3 stuff as well I think it'll also depend on what you know moods can change in the philosophical interpretation of blockchain as well so I just mentioned that it's incompatible this Quantum Computing idea of big heavy systems working with heavy decentralized ation where you want everything being run by the edges but maybe in the future

we know Bitcoin and things like that are run by a small number of players in effect anyway so what if they do start saying well actually we can do this much more efficiently with Quantum Computing we can validate transactions more efficiently we can offer data services you can put data on chain more easily and more inexpensively so maybe eventually there will be a shift in the narratives around things like Bitcoin but I think that's still also a long way off yeah like really quickly on that point like optim izing Supply chains optimizing you know uh traffic all this kind of stuff can apply to networks in the exact same way to being able to optimize transaction propagation all this kind of stuff so that kind of boring but it can optimize you know Bitcoin ethereum all these kind of things another interesting point there's probably a highlight is like you kind of said that this stuff still doesn't solve the hashing problem necessarily this Quantum doesn't get around the hashing so maybe Bitcoin ethereums of

the world might certainly have much more value maybe even more from like the proof of work perspective where these quantum computers still won't be able to get around the proof of work to say okay well what is what is the one of the merits of Bitcoin it's the fact that it time stamps based on this enormous amount of work so you know what the series of events happened in this chronological order right and that's quite a powerful thing when we think of like traditional Web Two style Legacy systems you kind of you get these basically the record of events is done by a notary or a signature like a trusted entity based on RSA the time stamp doesn't necessarily come into it you kind of trust their time stamp so if could break into that get the key using Quantum and then change the entire course of history and just you know time stamp it with whatever I want it suddenly becomes difficult to work out what the order of events are but Bitcoin still

has this kind of this way of defining what the order of events are based on this enormous amount of work that goes into it so maybe there will be a place for proof of work style blockchains in the future once they can get around this kind of you know ecdsa problem we talked about yeah exactly I think it's it's to summarize it's kind of Bitcoin has this unique value proposition in my mind and proof of work in general has a unique value proposition over other consens algorithms potentially the way where it has this property that it's very difficult to forge the history and it's good that as of now Quantum Computing doesn't seem like it's going to change that so it's it's basically saying proof of work blockchains haven't lost this yet if someone comes out with an algorithm that breaks that that might be something that you know Bitcoin and prw blockchains have to lose right that would kind of potentially almost level the playing field between U Bitcoin and other blockchains then because

well you can say well if if if it's easy to create an alternate history of Bitcoin using these quantum computers then it almost loses the benefit of proof of work and that whole argument about why we need proof of work might end up you know having fewer legs to stand on in the future but yeah it's it's an interesting thought and hopefully hopefully doesn't come to pass hopefully no one comes up with that algorithm but yeah we'll see the question is How likely is it we're saying that there are some quantum computers that exist right now um we've talked about some examples of how they've been used already but are these things going to become commercial are they going to become like part of our day-to-day lives yeah I think as we said not part of our day-to-day lives in in terms of us running them but I think there has been so much progress and you know you take a year off from looking at these things and the number of cubits which is

the basically the main metric that people are interested about how many cubits can you have in a qu computer and how long can you keep them in these entangled States for right without them collapsing and decohering as you mentioned so you know some of the records and you can see the growth here so in 2019 when we mentioned Google said it first achieved Quantum Supremacy so it can beat a classical computer at a given task you know at that time the record was 54 cubits that Google had and then as of December 2023 IBM got to 1,121 cubits and just for context you need something like 2 and a half th000 cubits to break elliptic curve cryptography for the kind of key lengths that we currently use so it's gone from 54 to 1,121 and currently the record is around you know just just slightly more than that it's just under 1,200 cubits so it's increasing all the time I don't know if it's plateauing or anything but it's it seems like for these big

companies that are going to be running the the quantum computers it's getting more practical all the time who knows how far off we are from them you know being large scale commercial that we can all access through apis and things but it does seem like the March is onward in these things and one of the interesting things about this is that because it's probabalistic because like it's not definitive in a way like actually one of the reasons you want to scale and have lots of QQ bits is for error correction so you might have if you only have like a system of 50 and say you know 40 of them point one way and 10 of them point a different way like the the more you scale SC this up the more you know likely is the probability gets to the right value right so we're talking about I've seen like numbers thr around that when you actually need um systems in the order of millions of cubits to create quite importantly reliable large scale

Quantum Computing um which is the key is that it's reliability a lot of these things are still very error prone and they won't always optimize to the right value um and like the amount of money that's actually going into this I've seen like it's like 25 billion a year globally is going into Quantum R&D which is an R&D budget is just astronomical yeah and that's funny because like when I've seen predictions you obviously these predictions are always crazy and can be very inaccurate but the industry size was something like only 1.6 billion in 2022 estimated and then they thought it'll be around 50 billion by 2035 and already those kind of budgets you're mentioning were already hitting the 25 billion spend per year so yeah it's crazy and the one thing I would say to caveat you know okay we're increasing the number of cubits but as you said how long are they being kept in this state how long are they being kept you know in a coherent State um and usable as Quant

computers because that's the bit we don't necessarily know are they getting a thousand cubits together for half a second well that's not that useful are they getting them together and keeping them there for days or weeks at a time which is much more useful so yeah that's it's those two different things you've got to you've got to measure it's back to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle the more you know about One the less you know about the other so and just to end with some probabilities I saw a study that said 50 % of quantum computer experts believe that it might be possible in 10 to 15 years probabilties within probabilties within might yeah well I mean I was going to end with the joke that we've probably got shring as viewer right now you know Shing is listener we both have one and don't have one until we put this episode out so yeah it's it's nice that we're in that state where we could have one but I'm doubtful and on that bombshell well I

hope you enjoyed this practical appc or somewhat practical applications of quantum Computing we basically covered what it might mean for the world when these things get deployed at scale yeah I hope you learned something um and thank you for listening wherever you may be and join us next time to entangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of tangling web 3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes