Episode 44
The History of Bitcoin with Kurt Wuckert Jr
About this episode
00:00:00 - Intro: Meeting Kurt Wuckert Jr. 00:04:26 - Early Career & Discovering Bitcoin 00:07:39 - Involvement in Bitcoin Mining & Community 00:14:47 - Origins and Inspirations Behind Bitcoin 00:19:42 - Satoshi's Departure & The Early Bitcoin Community 00:24:27 - The Scaling Debate: Small Block vs. Big Block 00:32:58 - Forks and Fractures: BTC, BCH, and BSV 00:37:23 - Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV: Philosophies and Differences 00:41:22 - Future Directions and Uses of Bitcoin 00:45:43 - The Importance of Community and Vision in Bitcoin's Evolution 00:50:00 - Final Thoughts and Conclusion
In this episode of Untangling Web3, Jack and Alec are joined by Kurt Wuckert Jr., a seasoned Bitcoin enthusiast and Chief Bitcoin Historian at CoinGeek.
Kurt delves into Bitcoin's rich history, from its inception in 2008 to its evolution and the various ideological splits within the community. He discusses the early days of Bitcoin, the pivotal moments that led to the creation of Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV, and the ongoing debates about scalability, governance, and the original vision of Satoshi Nakamoto.
This episode not only provides a deep dive into Bitcoin's past and present but also explores the implications for its future in the broader context of Web3 and digital sovereignty.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
for hard money it needs to have consistency over time like gold becomes valuable because you discover it wow it doesn't rust does it still not rust like 50 years later wow this coin is still not Rusty in the drawer that's pretty interesting property now after 5,000 years of that we can guarantee it's going to do its damn job and and that's great so that's why gold has that value now Bitcoin it's got to prove that same thing to itself it's not going to break because of this it's not going to break because of that and actually Bitcoin has broken two major times in the history of Bitcoin welcome to another episode of the entangling web 3 podcast today we're delighted to be joined on the show by Kurt wer Jr Kurt is a true veteran of Bitcoin from hble Beginnings as nearly adopter to founding his own Mining Company gorilla pool not only that but Kurt has been documenting the twisting tailor of the blockchain as chief Bitcoin historian at coingeek so today we've invited
Kurt on the show to share his deep knowledge of the space and explore the full history of Bitcoin in its entirety from its emergence in 2008 to how it's changed since its Inception and where it might be going in the future Kurt it's a huge pleasure to welcome you to the show hey uh happy to be here guys it's a pleasure I've been enjoying your show did a little bit of catching up as soon as you invited me on uh gosh a month and a half ago now so uh good stuff yeah thanks for being here Kur I mean me and Jack have known for a while while that we wanted to get you on the show because you've got such incredible insights you've been in the space for so long and Jack touched on a little bit of that background which is yeah even the title Chief Bitcoin historian that's something I've never heard of before it sounds absolutely fascinating but before we get there could you tell us a little bit about your
early career pre- Bitcoin maybe pre web 3 all this kind of stuff how did you what were you doing in the early days before you got into this space so I'm kind of a maybe even toxic serial entrepreneur as a little kid I I come from Chicago which is a very kind of in fact it's some people call it Hustler City so you get this oh cool I'll buy something low I'll sell it high if I can make a buck this and there so I mean even as a little kid I was cutting Lawns and I'd hit garage sales and try to flip stuff that I'd find and I always had a very um very keen eye for quality and and that kind of thing so uh and then my best friend growing up his father did that fulltime that was all he ever did was he'd have a circuit hit resale shops and he'd buy like designer clothes that maybe they'd be selling for three bucks and so he got into e-commerce really early
he had an ebay account like day one and was selling things that you'd buy for under $5 at a Chicago resale shop and he'd turn around sometimes sell things for two three $500 and we hung out constantly so I would be on these trips with his dad and all this other stuff so I was always super into that and then my parents were also entrepreneurs they owned a printing company which is another very Chicago thing there's a whole neighborhood called Printers Row and it's just like this sort of broad shoulders industrial manufacturing old school thing my dad was fourth generation in the printing industry so we just had like all of this get up early work hard work till you die and freeze on the way because that's how the weather is and so so I just kind of had this like work really hard but also be really smart you know be be shrewd as kind of my my background but I was also like while everybody in my family is kind of like
tough guy I was an intellectual so I always want I read a lot of books I was really into computers young and just kind of got into that so I ended up owning my own printing company in my early 20s we were doing marketing like uh rock and roll kind of stuff I I played guitar I was in bands and that kind of thing so I got into like doing t-shirts and Banners and promotional flyers and that kind of thing and that literally snowballed into a career that I did for over a decade and then also would rebuild computers on the side so I I used to mod old Max so the G3 Max you could open them right up they would just unfold and then you could buy all these parts for super cheap and you could just you could throw in a G4 chip you could throw in new hard drive like I could literally spend 20 minutes turning a G3 computer that I would buy for two or 300 bucks and then
add maybe two or three hundred bucks worth of stuff and I turn around and sell it for $1,000 to the pre-press people that worked at other printing companies that I knew so if they needed like a really hot computer I I would just build them out and so got into that so when I discovered Bitcoin and I discovered Bitcoin because I was also super into like politics I would do political activism on the weekends and I was a imagine your interaction like the career adviser being like I have no idea what where to put you what camp do you fit in I'm not sure pretty much well that's a thing I was always kind of on like a little bit in detention but I was also the Honor Society president and so I was just a little bit this like annoyance but not in a way that anybody wanted me to leave they're just like Kurt we need to apply you and we think you'd be really good at this and I was always just
kind of like yeah but I want to do this other thing so I was a volunteer on two Ron Paul presidential campaigns it was 2008 and 2012 in 2012 I met some people we went to like an End the Fed rally there's I think it's daily Plaza in Chicago and there was a big End the Fed rally and it was coming up like a week later and a buddy of mine who I knew casually said hey can you print me some posters and can I pay you in Bitcoin and I didn't know what Bitcoin was at the time and he told me it was like video game money and I remember asking him what video game because I wasn't really a gamer and he's like not a video game money but every video game like it could go across video games was essentially this was my first pitch on bitcoin and I was just like yeah I guess like that's fine I love that one line of definition gaming money that's ridiculous yeah and I
I don't know if he knew anything more about it honestly like he just kind of pitched it as this thing and it was a pretty small job because it was just a few posters for a rally so I was like yeah whatever I'll do this thing for 150 bucks worth of bitcoin and but in 2012 that was like two two or three Bitcoins so pretty serious half them I have the original one so I made a point once I realized that Bitcoin mattered in like 2013 and I started buying other Bitcoin I made a point of segregating my first coin and keeping so I have one unsplit untouched 2012 Bitcoin and the rest of them honestly I spent most of the other ones is I just I always thought of it as money first it's it's some kind of a tool and so like not all of I didn't spend every Bitcoin every time I got it I'm not like a spendaholic or anything but I never really treated it like this is you know
the longer I hold the Richer I'll be I just never had that attitude about about Bitcoins so your friend comes in he gives you he basically gives you this computer game money and you're like what the hell is this and then is it like instant hit from there you do all the reading you're into it or what happens from there no I actually I didn't even really think much of it I thought it was cool like it was a novel idea but I didn't really jump in it uh it was sometime in the next 6 months my brother who also did a lot of similar things to me got a job offer to do internet marketing for a relatively big YouTube channel at the time it was called Adam what was it called Adam versus the man I think is what it was called his name is Adam Kash and he would do these essentially stunts where he would figure out like the dumbest law in every jurisdiction and he would go break it like
really ceremoniously and try to get himself arrested and it is outrageous no he's a mad man and he's only gotten crazier so back you know 2013 his show was a spectacle but now he has just become like this absurd spectacle but he was a I think Iraq war veteran he was a marine so I mean he had his own PTSD and some other stuff he was very like anti-government and so that's kind of what inspired the channel but he offered my brother this job and he said but I got to pay you in either Bitcoin or in I think it was steam dollars if I it was something it was one of the things on the steam platform they had like three tokens so I don't remember which one it was but that was the second time I heard it and I really liked Adam so I was like okay I guess I better look into this and so I went down the rabbit hole probably mid 2013 and I had a bunch of computers
because I used to build and flip computers was like maybe I could mine and then it just I've literally never stopped tinkering with Bitcoin since then yeah that makes a lot of sense I've also seen you talk about the fact that you wrote an economics paper when you you were an undergraduate maybe and maybe some of the tokenization concepts clicked umis yeah I think you're you're a proper veteran right and you know I don't use those words lightly because you've been through pretty much every evolution of Bitcoin as long as people widely have even known about it maybe even a little earlier in 2012 so if we go a little bit further back then 31st of October 2008 that's when the Bitcoin white paper's released that's what you could call the origin of Bitcoin but I want us to go because we're doing the full history I want us to go even a step further back and you've already mentioned things like anti-fed anti-state potentially anti-government type things and I think a lot of people
rightly or wrongly might think that is partly where the origin of Bitcoin comes from but where in your view do The Inspirations for Bitcoin come from and also from the technology side because I in my opinion Bitcoin is comprised of lots of existing Technologies and it's just a really clever way of putting them together but what's your view on how it all came together in October 31st 2008 honestly this could be a whole univers City lecture series because you could take this you could take this back to the the Roman Republic and talk about money and monetary distribution fiat currency and and there's there's lots of get us started please let's not go there we stop it's I'll be very brief but if we look at the way that money has evolved and actually money and communication because Bitcoin is both of those things both money and communication have evolved alongside like this human Revolution or human evolution this tendency toward Freedom you know we've gone from holding off saber-tooth tigers and hunting Mammoth and
then you know okay now we've got a society and then turns the cities and then now we're Agricultural and Industrial and all these other things but in the vacuum of power of state power like post Roman Empire when the empire fell lots of little families became very powerful in all these little regions so we had like I didn't even know a few hundred or maybe may even a few thousand city states across Europe and lots of them especially in Italy started their own sort of banking Empires that honestly some of them still exist to this day so the the major one kind of medich exactly yeah the deidi family kind of established a lot of the premises that we think of that are just banking Basics today but they invented them and very quickly they became the richest people in basically the history of the world outside of you know kings and queens but honestly they had more money and therefore they had more power that kind of inspired a backlash pretty quickly because you
had the Roman Church that also was like o we need to make sure they don't get too powerful and so we had lots of power struggles about the control of money including the things that we talk about today with like inflation or shaving gold off your coins or making sure okay is this actual gold or is it is there 20% more electrum than there should be in the metal and there so there's lots of stuff where people came to realize that control of the money is control of power and then the other thing that you can control for power is information which is also the banks and the church and the state and all these things is all in in not ancient Europe but Medieval Europe where we see the uh you know the proliferation of the printing press in the 1500s right around the same time as the Protestant Reformation there's another huge it was a backlash against the the Roman Church and a backlash against the control of the state because all of
a sudden went from okay I basically have to go to church on Sunday to get any news about anything to hey they now they print stuff in my language I don't have to read Latin I can basically read first German and then you know all the other things outside of Germany so the world kept getting a little bit smaller people kept being able to communicate on increasingly larger distances which turned into both Communications and economics and a broader scale and so it's backlash after backlash that leads us to now you know 1973 you've got the Federal Reserve policy getting off completely off the gold standard and establishment of the Petro dollar and Nixon establishing this very weird relationship with China and the way that's impacted World economics since and there's lots of things but in the 1970s there there became a very powerful movement of basically libertarian response to this bizarre Global federalism where you know it's kind of trying to establish a very powerful Thum that people live in again and we still live
there like this thing that was established in the 1970s with the Petro dollar and the way that you know we have these Banks and pseudo banking institutions that just control the flow of money and really it's just dollars oil and Military might that that essentially control everything and we had the cipher Punk movement really was a big backlash to that and those guys have been trying to create all kinds of things but first the internet like encrypted communication and then it pushed its way into digital cash as soon as they figured out how to communicate over channels they wanted to figure out how can we do business over an encrypted Channel how can we do business in a way that's private Andor separate from the state or the banks and and whatever else and so there's you know then there's 30 almost 30 years of history of that trial and error there's probably 50 cryptocurrencies that precede Bitcoin and failed for various reasons and then Satoshi Nakamoto very confidently showed up and says hey I
solved the double spend problem and we don't have a a mint and we don't have a single head you can cut off and like I might have just fixed money and yeah 15 years later there's a whole heck of a lot of people that think he was right so for sure yeah I think that's a really concise summary I don't know how you could do much better than that to be honest but yeah I think it's it's interesting that you had so many precursors to bitcoin really right that whole Cipher Punk movement there was building digital cash systems or trying and failing to build digital cash also the kind of cryptography movement basically you know that was becoming much more prevalent developing things like hash functions digital signatures All The Primitives that are now in Bitcoin all were existing you know a little bit before and I think one thing we have to note about preceding Bitcoin given that you're from the printing business is that the longest blockchain has existed in print right since
like the '90s I think right in the New York times3 or four I think yeah stornetta and habber have been publishing a hash in the New York Times Sunday edition for 30 I don't even know 33 34 some some some crazy amount of time that you can just exactly oh reference the hash and and say okay we're good yeah so that's one of the first things I often say to people it's like you know Bitcoin didn't invent blockchain right blockchain was around a long time before that so that kind of I guess that sums up prior to bitcoin then at the instant of its release there's just a couple of things I think we should comment on and get your opinion on so there are some strange or interesting features about the so for starters you have the fact that it's this pseudonymous creator doesn't show a kind of real world identity to it and it's published the white paper under this pseudonym you also have this kind of cryptic message in the Genesis block
and a few months later in 2009 I think it the chanc on the brink of the second bail out of the bank so this is coming just in the kind of peak crisis time following the 2008 banking crisis so these are the two of the things people tend to site about the launch of Bitcoin so how do you inter those two facts what is your view on why those two things were done so there's a lot of intrigue there I think there's I'm a big fan of Japanese culture myself so I think using a Japanese pseudonym if you understand Japanese culture like they are a culture of extreme honor like my son has a Japanese name I'm a black belt in Jiu-Jitsu I'm wearing a grand SEO watch like I'm like I'm very into Japanese stuff but the reason for that is it's they just have this incredible amount of discipline and trustworthiness if you ever wanted to go to a city where you could walk around as a 100 pound woman wearing a million
dollars worth of jewelry and stuff that was easy to rip off of you like your chances of getting mugged in any city of Japan are practically zero and it's because nobody will do that like everybody waits at every stoplight nobody jaywalks nobody litters like it's just it is this and this is a country that has tens of millions of people in major cities like it is extremely congested but it's orderly it's quiet it is respectful everybody's well dressed everybody's well kept etc etc and so I think issuing a money under a pseudonym that is Japanese it sort of imbus a little bit of a hey guys this is not going to be frivolous like it is going to be it is going to be very well planned and very well exed and I think to anybody that sort of can take a step back and think about why a Japanese pseudonym because it's clearly Satoshi was a speaking the queen's English like the way he types and that kind of thing so there was somebody
that had a respect for Japanese culture and then if you understand economic history uh to tomaga Nakamoto is like the Japanese Adam Smith as well so if you want to get into like libertarian capitalism politics again if you understand that character that immediately also imbus okay this is sort of a at least libertarian bent like big on property rights big on sound money like just on principle there's those two things now with the Genesis block and the headline I lots and lots of people I guarantee you could find a hundred influencers explaining why well you know the the chancellor bailed out the b like that was the worst thing in world history that ever happened and maybe it's true I actually would tend to agree that uh you know the bailouts stuff that happened in that era we're still living in the the consequences of that and it is generally not good but I actually think it's a lot simpler than that I think it's a simple Tim stamp I think it's much like uh
habber and stornetta who are referenced in the white paper here's the newspaper headline here's the hash this is I'm letting you know this is not pre-ind if this is actually a sound money here's how you prove it and so I think it's simpler than that circumstantially it's great I mean if you believe in fate or destiny or Providence there's that too and that's also very cool but just very practically it lets you know Satoshi Nakamoto wasn't sitting there doing a pre-mine for two weeks or two months like you know 99% of every other uh currency that was ever issued after and like oh okay the the founders got the founders tax he's sitting on 15% of the supply or whatever else no no I think part of me kind of does want it to not be coincidence that it was intentional and he was just sitting on it knew it was about to happen and boom he just like deploys it on the day because of that I think I think there could be I
mean because it wasn't not obvious that we were heading for in in that era I mean the news every day for weeks was is standard and pores actually going to downgrade the three of the largest banks in the world you know so there was that sort of like oh man is this it are we gonna have a banking collapse so it's I don't think it was purely circumstantial but I also think it's relevant that the white paper came out on October 31st 2008 and the Genesis block happened on January was it 3rd I think thir yeah of 2009 um so that amount of time it's like a 60-day from announcement to Creation which has some legal precedent in the issuance of assets and stuff as well this is what I was going to follow up so we have the paper being published in 2008 you got were familiar with the space in 2012 but really into the space 2013 what does Bitcoin look like in that infancy period that time what was actually happening what
was going on could gives a bit more detail on that sure unfortunately it was pretty deep into sort of the sophomore generation of Bitcoin I really did miss the the early days which my my disappointment with having missed it is why I've become sort of a historian because I'm like I was so close to being involved in this this thing in the Cradle because when I got involved it was like $100 a coin it wasn't real exciting but within 3 months of me really getting into it all of a sudden it was you'd see like articles on your web brows you'd open up like bitcoin's the word of the year you know just like oh man okay like I only got to be cool for three months before it turned into a mainstream thing uh and then the price blew up and then it was huge and then Mount gox collapsed and then it was ah bitcoin's dead it's all over and so I was pretty wild uh like first year and a half being
involved in any of it but the culture at the time really was defined by a lot of very deep thinkers and there was a lot of Discord them at at the time too I like comment personally all the time how toxic Bitcoin is but it was it was toxic back then too it just was the you know 95% fewer people involved but I remember watching videos with Roger ver was a big one who was producing a ton of content and doing you know seemed like every day of his life just traveling the planet and trying to get people to accept Bitcoin as a form of payment and all that kind of stuff found that really inspiring and then Andre Antonopoulos actually was another just really fertile thinker on bitcoin and sort of a macro and a microeconomic just view on all the things that it could do and should do and the way he just came at it with it will do and and he just was this just this fire brand that I really
loved at the time there's that famous photo of him isn't there where he I think is giving a lecture to this completely empty lecture theater there's like two people in it right and I don't know what year it was in but it's crazy to think about it that he was there giving all these Al for all this information on what was to come and no one was listening at the time yeah no he was on it unfortunately he's become kind of a disappointment in many ways early days it wasn't just people going around like promoting Bitcoin right there was actually saying there was discourse there was people talking about how Bitcoin should be improved implemented could you give us a a bit of detail on that as well so there were two major camps there was the sort of academic Andor tech people so you had the people who were computer scientists there was a lot of your average person had at least some experience in C++ or cryptography like they were very very skilled
but very Niche and very like the IQ level was very high in in in the community and then the other half were essentially all libertarian political activists it was everybody I knew in Bitcoin was either a hard line the states collapsing and that's a good thing because you're you're your own Sovereign Nation like that kind of person of which I'm I'm frankly one but and then the other half were all these computer science or just really he macroeconomic thinkers and so that was the Melting Pot so the discourse was incredible if you liked to go out for drinks and spend six hours debating macro econ compai Game Theory you know and all these other things I used to go to the meetups in Chicago there was a Bitcoin Meetup was relatively small when I would go and it just was it was exactly that you'd show up it'd be scheduled for two hours but it'd be like all right it's 2: a.m.
I really got to go like that kind of thing but it just was so engaging so there was a a very high threshold of just that the culture to to show up I imagine it be like you know going into any heady place at a special time I I I like to picture like two years before the American Revolution when the people who became our founding fathers were actually just like meet me at the coffee shop we're going to do some cool stuff you know and they were nobody yet but five years from them they were Veterans of this whole thing you know so just like that was the culture um a question a lot people ask Kurt is is was satosi involved in this early discourse when did you know that individual slowly start to move away from the space it's something I get asked a lot but by that time he was gone Satoshi was very active from 2008 to 2010 and then there was this massive decrease in his involvement from 2010
to 2012 I think the very last thing he said as Satoshi Nakamoto was an email and actually the last thing ever posted was a little bit later but it probably wasn't him because it didn't sound like him and it was from an account that we later found out had been compromised of him criticizing Bitcoin XT I think is the last actual thing that a Satoshi account posted and then there was also I'm not Dorian Nakamoto and there's some other stuff that's all post him like we know he had been compromised at that point but he disappeared completely in 2012 with him basically telling Gavin and Dron the new lead developer Bitcoin core and him saying saying hey man don't talk about me as a shadowy figure stop talking about crime money and that kind of thing and honestly just make this about that like go praise your devs they've done a lot of really cool things and kind of encouraging like hey Bitcoin still needs a lot of work like we we don't need all
these political problems and that kind of stuff so Satoshi um was very metered especially early like early Satoshi like I picture it as very sort of uh Sermon on the Mount Jesus Christ kind of like every word that's coming out of his mouth is wow okay that's profound and then two minutes later like okay that whole bit was really profound too and then and just really consistently but you can see as time went on he got an irritation with the developer community and and kind of the early people because it was a very weird group of people those first two years it was it was a lot less like macroeconomic and academic types and it was a lot more sort of dark web gray hat black hat just the that culture at that time like you had to be deep into the sort of cyber security cryptography communities and those are always like the kind of guys that like yeah I write Bank software during the day I do an occasional stint for the CIA
and I also Rob people like a lot of those types on on those sorts of forums and Satoshi seem to really dislike them so I I think that fed his irritation and I think that's why he essentially dipped out after not too long yeah and I think one of the things I remember seeing correct if I'm wrong is around he was quite worried about the association with things like the Silk Road and things like the dark markets he didn't want there to be an easy kind of regulatory capture or other kind of lawful capture of the system before it had grown up because again during the early years because of how the block subsidy works right and there were very few transactions happening on the chain at the time the system really had to survive those early years on the subsidy and it was small enough probably that it could have died it could have that the whole experiment could have failed and thankfully it hasn't and one of the things I think so you
mentioned Bitcoin XT which is a really nice segue onto what what comes next really because Bitcoin XT I think is a one of the the the competing software clients for Bitcoin I think Mike Hearn actually was the guy behind it right correct so yeah and this was this heralded well not not Bitcoin XT in particular but this idea of protocol forking and changing the protocol this became more popular kind of after satosi left the scene and wasn't really guiding things and that kind of brings us to you know we have some relatively stable years and then fast forward to what 201617 and then you get mired in what we now called the Great scaling debate of Bitcoin so can you explain a bit about how that debate arose and what actually it was all about what were the two sides on that debate so I I always try to pinpoint when this actually started because some people would be like yeah it was when Bitcoin XT got proposed or it's actually day one so October
31st 2008 Satoshi put out the white paper and the very first comment is from a a gentleman named James Donald which is a pseudonym of a guy I was saying dark web nastiness he ended up like he's got a whole blog like advocating for all these other you know like your typical dark malines but he's a computer science guy and explains to Satoshi Nakamoto well here's why this doesn't scale because everyone would need to run a node and we have to have all these other like so it's the sort of small blocker ethos was established as the very first response to bitcoin coming out and it's an amazing exchange because you can watch Satoshi on day one of the announcement of Bitcoin go back and forth with this James Donald character where he's explaining Bitcoin scalability and it never reaches a scaling ceiling and it does all these other things and James Donald being like nah like I basically I think you're dumb here's why you're wrong and the points that he's making are the
points today that you would hear Adam back or Gregory Maxwell or any of your influencers on the BTC side today making those statements which were the antagonistic statements as the first criticism of Bitcoin to Satoshi now Satoshi built his allies as well you mentioned Mike Hearn briefly who was another guy who got into Bitcoin very early uh Gavin and Dre and these are all guys that were in the first three or four months spotted Bitcoin saw why it was interesting and ingratiated themselves to Satoshi Nakamoto and wanted to participate in testing this experiment thoroughly now the argument came about because Satoshi added the block size limit this was not original to bitcoin there was a practical block size limit of about 32 megabytes based on just limitations in the implementation but there was no hardcoded 1 Megabyte block size limit but uh I believe it was hfy actually that realized that there was a uh a a Dos attack Vector due to that and due to basically how weak and poorly connected your nodes were
because it was at the time maybe a couple dozen people running it on a side computer or a laptop and yeah you can dos something like that off the network pretty easily just our listeners might not know what the impact of block sizes relative to bitcoin so just before we go into you know block size the block size Li can you explain what the impact of that on bitcoin how it affects Bitcoin and like the network and all this kind of stuff sure so Bitcoin has a has a settlement period of 10 minutes so every 10 minutes everything that is that has been authorized but not settled is then reconciled by one computer on the network they're be competitively reconciled by everybody but one computer is the one that actually builds the block when that's accepted you build the blockchain moving forward now how much data can you reconcile in 10 minutes well that's a computer science question that's a well how much CPU do you have how much RAM do you have how fast
is your internet connection and at the time time if it was well Bitcoin is 12 laptops and and three Dell computers that are poorly connected and may overheat at any time and and all these other things the answer is well you can't really do that much work in a 10-minute period because some of these people they're just going to turn their computer off at at the end of the night and if we don't have people around the globe that are doing it assuming everybody's in America sometime between 10 p.m.
and 2: am. Bitcoin goes off every day you know like that's that doesn't work and Satoshi basically had to make a very practical decision for a very young Network in the cradle and say okay we're going to limit the amount of transactions that can be reconciled in a 10-minute period so that some malicious actor can't show up and say Here's a billion transactions and everybody's laptop crashes and Bitcoin goes down so that's the the very B it's a bandwidth limitation but it's a very reasonable bandwidth limitation for a very young Network it's Alpha level technology but Satoshi understands for a hard money to be valued it needs to have consistency over time like gold becomes valuable because you discover it wow it doesn't rust does it still not rust like 50 years later wow this coin is still not Rusty in the drawer that's pretty interesting property now after 5,000 years of that we can guarantee all right I can use gold on the space shuttle and it's going to do its damn job and
and that's great so that's why gold has that value now Bitcoin it's got to prove that same thing to itself it's not going to break because of this it's not going to break because of that and actually Bitcoin has has broken two major times in the history of Bitcoin but we'll get into that a little later so because of that it was basically let's throttle this way back we'll keep it throttled back while we figure out what other Edge case problems might exist technologically here and then actually Satoshi explained and here's how we can make this grow he he gave a very basic like two lines of code we'll pick a like a flag day we'll change what we're going to do we'll all just decide to raise that block size limit as the network matures so as it grows we'll grow with it it's like if we keep having kids we'll buy a bigger house you know so that's what year was that in the original one megabyte limit do you remember I believe
it was 2010 yeah I don't remember precisely yeah I always I that's roughly in my head when it is but again even based on this kind of temporary limitation just by extrapolating things like Moos law Right double the capacity every two years is you'd expect to be able to increase that size over time so why didn't we why didn't we see that happen in Bitcoin so it's interesting in the absence of Satoshi the guy that was put in charge was Gavin andreon now Gavin super nice guy he's a little I don't know I don't know what the term is for it he kind of has this like mental and emotional softness to him where like under pressure you see him just collapse into himself but not in that he looks scared he just kind of I don't know he just has a very benign attitude that essentially allowed him to be bulldozed so he was like I I think a good criticism would be it's sort of like Jimmy Carter being in charge of the
United States when Iran was threatening nuclear war you know he just was like he's this guy from the country and just was kind of like well maybe we can work it out what the nation actually needed at the time was Ronald Reagan which is why after four years of Carter Reagan won the largest Landslide victory in the history of American politics and it it just was people realized like o shoot we should have had somebody tougher in charge this was a tough time bad time to have a weak man at the helm and Gavin was that weak man essentially and so as the power vacuum of Satoshi had gone away there was also a pretty quick influx of new new developers and and new sort of advocacy type so you had guys like Vladimir vand Deron showed up pretty early you had Gregory Maxwell and a pile of others like another dozen or so people that showed up with tons of street cred they were highlevel programmers guys that had inventions and patents under their
belt and these kind of things and explaining why okay if we were to do all these other things like let's move the Merkel tree over here let's do you know and it was very difficult to argue with them because they were in some cases phds and like oh well yes I work at the computer lab at MIT so let me handle it and you're a little bit like I guess and so in in that power vacuum they came to Value the block size limit as a religious Talisman that okay if we keep the bandwidth small forever then we can just have nodes everywhere on Earth we can make this network completely Unstoppable if everybody is running a full copy at home and it's a little bit like how you can put a cheap Android smartphone in the hands of like six billion people right now but you can't expect them to all get 5G Wireless like that's a whole other problem but if you keep bandwidth low everyone can have a phone and so that's
kind of the logic there for the small block ethos and basically Gavin was not good at at advocating for why Bitcoin was meant to scale and do all these other things now Mike Hearn was quite a bit better at it which is why Mike Hearn was bullied mercilessly but Mike was a very I believe he worked at Google before and during the whole Bitcoin era has whole stint in Bitcoin he's a guy who has patents under his belt as well but he was a very commercial minded person and for him he looked at it and was like dude I work in scaling databases and doing all this stuff at Google like this actually isn't that hard if you if you don't think we can deal with more than six megabytes an hour you shouldn't have control of anything but the fact that he was so uh Brash the other direction led to this new group really bullying him and they completely bullied him out of the project by uh 2016 he wrote a now Infamous
breakup letter with the Bitcoin core developers where uh he calls out Gregory Maxwell by name but basically says like you're the worst people I have ever had to deal with in any context bitcoin's a failure it's your fault it's a failure I'm out essentially and Mike was a classy guy he was not the kind of guy to lose as cool and he lost his cool because they literally pushed him mercilessly like Mike was bullied more than anybody for that era but it's because he was such an effective advocate for Bitcoin at scale big block Bitcoin like legally compliant Bitcoin like integrating Bitcoin into our banks and governments and institutions and tokens and all like he was like this fractal Bitcoin thinker and everybody was like no it's decentralization first and we were going to focus on getting as many nodes out into the universe and that's it that's our Focus until further notice that's the only thing that matters and yeah so that that kind of proceeded what became the Civil War that those are
the opening blows of the Civil War basically got you and then so could you tell us a little bit I mean you kind of you used the you named the two camps right now in this Civil War the small blockers and the big blockers and how did it resolve itself me and Jack have hinted at you know the different Forks the different camps and what happened but could you give us your insight into that event basically um I mean it's it's unresolved it's as unresolved as the differences between the Catholic and Protestant churches right look at we now have over 500 years years of of all these people saying no we're the real followers of Christ and they both make really compelling arguments based on provenance and like that obviously really committed so it's much the same thing so by 2017 there was a proposed agreement called the Hong Kong agreement where it was kind of like okay we'll do a 2 megabyte block size limit raise we we'll all kind of agree to this
very broad yeah I was just going to say who's agreeing here this is the miners of Bitcoin it's a mix so it is it's commercial entities so it was even companies like coinbase so it was a lot of uh exchanges wallets then your developer group so like your block stream and and other people like that and your miners so it was a pretty broad brush stroke of representing like the people that actually work in Bitcoin not your Fanboys but the actual people whose careers are they're here and so uh they sort of came up with the broad brush strokes and those were essentially we will add uh segregated witness protocol which is a way to basically simplify signatures down to a hash of signatures add a new Merkel tree that gets referenced in different ways that enters as a soft fork and whatever else and then we will also like if you'll allow us to do that then we will allow you to get your doubling of the block size we'll get to 2 megabytes
as the block size limit which decent compromise uh that was solidified a little later in the year in 2017 What's called the New York agreement where it actually was like a constitution the whole thing was sort of brokered by digital currency Group which was the largest Venture Capital uh I think they're called themselves an incubator or an accelerator in the space and kind of had a a controlling stake and a lot of the companies that were involved in the negotiations anyway so uh Barry silbert was kind of a big ring leader in getting the New York agreement signed and it was signed by basically everybody that mattered if you look at the signers it's like oh wow they signed the new York agreement too that's fascinating and then it was like okay we're doing this uh August 2017 we're going to get segwit 2x that's Bitcoin and we're all gonna we're all going to move forward and then about two months before that was going to happen all of a sudden this massive counter marketing
campaign the no2x campaign burst out of nowhere I tend to think that it was a coordinated piece of subterfuge but it's you know that this is where I turn into Alex Jones if I talk about it too much but it really did kind of come out of nowhere and the people who just a few months earlier were very happy to sign the New York agreement are now yeah we were fooled it's been like nobody's thinking about the this is an attack on bitcoin like it turned into this whole thing now everybody's wearing like military regalia people are getting docked there's people getting swatted at their homes it was it got really bad wow with two months notice you had the big blocker saying oh my God God all the big money is clearly on the no2x side how do we form a coalition to maintain the real Bitcoin because we do not want to have segwit forked into the protocol if there's no compromise like that was already a very sharp pill for us to
swallow and so we need to Pivot really hard so uh Roger ver basically raised money from bitmain to create what became Bitcoin cash so they created an 8 megabyte BL size limit Bitcoin variant called Bitcoin ABC which stands for adaptable block size cap I think hired a French developer from Facebook to put it together a gentleman by the name of amori s and uh created this client and said I guess we're going to have an old school hash War and the market will decide who's the real Bitcoin the one that looks exactly like Bitcoin and followed this whole road map that Satoshi gave us for raising the block size limit or this one with all this new fangled signature hashing technology and all this other stuff that is backed by the jerks who like got rid of all of satoshi's friends so it was from a personal marketing standpoint circumstantially all of my old school Bitcoin friends were very like Bitcoin cash man this is where it's going like these new fangled tech people like
it's all Silicon Valley it's weird New York money and then it's like Gregory Maxwell and and his cohorts who bullied out all my favorite Bitcoin developers and so then it split so there just there was this split and then there's this very weird pivot on okay the price went up over here now coinbase went down and now it comes back on and they've flipped each other again and now kraken's down and the price flipped there and then 10 billion dollar in tether showed up over here now btc's it just was like this weird I don't know 48 hour period like right at the fork where nobody can figure what the price of either asset was hash power was going back and forth because if you're a minor that just has bills to pay you're like which which one do I mind because like my bill is due in two weeks and so it just it was really really crazy for a couple of days and then all of a sudden everything just kind of turned
back on all your influencers all your exchanges everybody's like all right this one gets the BTC ticker the price is way higher hash power is higher that's the real Bitcoin that's how we decide it's over and the Bitcoin Cashers who had in in my opinion their fatal mistake was adding replay protection from the get-go which means that they can't reorg each other Bitcoin game theoretically you can reorg Bitcoin you can rewrite the blockchain if you have enough hash power and if everybody agrees that the valid chain is the one that's been Rewritten that's Bitcoin but what the Bitcoin cash chain did is say okay we're just going to predetermine that these chains cannot reorg each other so they're going to not ever compete for consensus against each other we're just going to try to compete in the marketplace and let the let the investors decide based on price and then hash power will follow price and we like whoever gets the most hash power at the end of the week is the real Bitcoin well
that was always something they were going to lose and so yeah it was I don't know it was like prec conceding defeat it's like going to battleing me like all right we're going to tie our left hands behind our back because we're honorable you know what I'm out yeah I think guess that's why you say it's unresolved right probably down to this decision because leading up the only idea of consensus have been what people call Nakamoto consensus right so the longest chain win and people were saying we will fight for the best version of Bitcoin based on that principle and then you have the replay protection added in and all of a sudden it's a fight for the brand of Bitcoin based on which of these two now effectively incompatible chains wins right so that's kind of how I viewed it and yeah it was always destined to this unresolved thing and and it still isn't to this day because of that now I always remember this Fork not because it was around but because
my very first day ever working in the blockchain space happened to be the oneyear anniversary of the fork so it's all anyone was talking about and I was like I didn't know anything about it and I was like what's happening here and I didn't have enough time to even learn about that because before you knew it that Bitcoin cash chain was going into a second kind of War a second protocol War y right but this time it was different so you've got in my opinion you have a kind of relative stability after that 2017 fork BTC that kind of just carries on with its 2 megabyte or 4 megabyte effective limit now right but basically one megabyte in reality so you have it going ahead nothing really changes then you have Bitcoin cash continues this lower hash power chain and then there's an infighting in that camp again so this kind of camp that you say you were in at the time that splits again but it was over not to do with block size
necessarily there was some dispute on that but it was over like minutia it was like oh which op codes which bits of code are we going to put into the chain what arbitrary changes are we going to do we're going to change I think it was called the topological transaction ordering rule like we're going to change the way we order transactions it was bizarre that people were trying to change these kind of things and the other Camp within Bitcoin cash was kind of saying we don't want to set precedent for arbitrary change that's my understanding so what was your take on that second split because it happened literally what a year later somehow yeah 13 months almost to the day so um yeah it it really was um I think also malicious I think it was a a subterfuge based thing and a lot of it I think is carryover from the original the BTC bch split in that it was social first there's this whole social engineering aspect of if Bitcoin is important it's
important to control it and the way to control it is not through the technology or attacking the system because Bitcoin really is antifragile it's attacking the people that pull the levers around Bitcoin that's the weak link and so uh I I remember the day that I realized there was a problem was amori s again he wrote a paper about the need for pre- consensus and I remember reading it because he goes into to explain the way that Avalanche consensus works and it's a it's a pretty novel idea it's unlike Nakamoto consensus in a lot of ways but what he was doing is basically saying that there should be a second layer above Bitcoin that miners are essentially subscribed to that are pre-building your backlog of blocks and so you kind of know not what the next block is going to be but maybe what the next three to five or you know some other amount of blocks are going to be because they are following this prec consensus algorithm which really changes the competitive nature
of what nodes are doing now to your originalists which was roughly half the community it was folks like me who are like hey man we really didn't want to to create as you said like arbitrary change bitcoin's not supposed to be a science experiment we're trying to build provenance and stability and we've got this guy out here talking about like a major both technological and economic change to the network well the people who essentially were the conservatives on bitcoin the response is fundamentally no like we we already we don't have the original Bitcoin here we should be working our way back to Restoration of Bitcoin before we start adding bells and whistles maybe we need a bell or a whistle but at the very least can we restore this to original before we start adding or subtracting there was also you mentioned the transaction ordering they for whatever reason decided that it would be more scalable to pre-order all transactions in their numerological sequence so I believe they called it canonical transaction ordering is what
they called versus like first is first which is you know the first scene rule in Bitcoin is like another major precedent in how and why Bitcoin works it's funny because it's also they've come to admit the people from Bitcoin unlimited which were Advocates of seor have admitted that not only is it not more scalable it's actually less scalable because it's more arbitrary calculation that needs to happen before other work is done so those were the two major ones it was this prec consensus concept and this transaction ordering concept that in my opinion really were just put out in order to off the conservative types like me who wanted to get back to bitcoin first I I just think there was this I don't know the way concern trolling isn't it like saying oh this is this really matters to me when actually it probably doesn't at the end of the day yeah I I don't think it did at all because as soon as the split happened all of those ideas basically went away all
the contentious stuff they're just like shelv it so it was like wait what were we fighting over and and I really think it was like it's if you have somebody in New York City and the way they think of people from West Virginia or something and if too many people from West Virginia move to the city it's like you know what let's just argue about something that will them off and make them leave and I think that's I think that's really what it was what did happen then Kurt with that then if like nothing if saying those things that they wanted and requesting were kind of grinding your gears a little bit didn't happen what happened when the split did happen very little uh in fact they pivoted pretty quickly to the next big change was going to be schnor signatures on the Bitcoin cash chain uh which is just another uh way to do uh signing and aggregate transaction signatures and I I don't even know what else has happened since in the last
two years there's been no real progress they added some kind of adaptable block size that if there's volume it will make some other calculation to decide how big the block size limit should be and whatever but but development on bitcoin cash has been very small and they literally have blocks that have five transaction in them that happen this is like months at a time there's very little use and kind of is what it is and then on the other side the ones that wanted to restore the original Bitcoin uh about H what would it be it' be about 18 months after the split between Bitcoin cash and Bitcoin SV Satoshi Vision we we basically did we got to about 98% of restoring Bitcoin meaning all of the original op codes except for I think two or three restoring a block size limit that is determined by node policy instead of by consensus Rule and other stuff like that like getting rid of this concept of a standard transaction so every blockchain has like a standard
transaction format where everything has to be in a specific order and do things in a very specific way or it's rejected as an invalid transaction but Bitcoin SV loosened those rules back up to the way they were in the original Bitcoin which allows you to do much more novel things in okay well let's do this and this and this and that allows it to Launch more complex computations on chain and all this other stuff so it it really was a let's loosen up all the kind of frivolous stuff and then let's add back all the original stuff and then let's experiment with that and that occurred in uh early 2020 and now it's been about four years of R&D and working on trying to prove out stuff that goes back all the way to 20089 like Satoshi Nakamoto saying you know Bitcoin could do X and nobody ever tested it so those kind of things have been being done and basically just competing in the marketplace but now it really is a BTC is still
small block nobody rocked the boat kind of Bitcoin uh you have Bitcoin cash which is pretty small community that that has its own values and has the second largest market cap and and all of that then you have bsv which is trying to break computer science records every quarter but also has the lowest market cap and people saying like yeah it's just a really irresponsible experiment in Bitcoin like the things they're doing are the things that were turned off for reasons of safety and and those kind of things and so we get uh criticisms for being bizarrely puritanical originalists who don't heed any warnings from all the brilliant people who fixed Bitcoin over the the previous 10 years or whatever so again amazing summary of some very complex history and you obviously you haven't gone into all of it there because it would take hours and hours and hours but I think I can summarized by saying where we are today is you have these three competing I like to call them prongs I don't
like to call them Forks because you know that's not what a fork looks like they're three different prongs of the fork right and this basically now three-way competition still in the longterm for um depending on your time Horizon for effectively the brand of Bitcoin to be the original Bitcoin or the mainstream version of Bitcoin and you have BTC or what's widely known as Bitcoin by you know virtually everyone that kind of hasn't changed in ethos it's still there small blocks keep it small everyone can run it on a Raspberry Pi type model then you have Bitcoin SV on the other end of the spectrum so like the most recently created prong of this Fork that is going turn the Taps on release the limits we'll just see what's possible and then you have Bitcoin cash in my opinion somewhere in the middle of it right it's neither here or there it hasn't gone as far as bsv but it's gone further than BTC so it's kind of in between one thing I think I've seen
you say before on another maybe on your show it was you said Bitcoin will become what we use it for and I think this is such an interesting way of describing it because not only is it about how you scale Bitcoin the reason for these three prongs emerging right it's also the the uses because the use cases on BTC are very different to the use cases on bch and bsv do you think that phrase describes how we've got to this position as well and also what do you think we will use Bitcoin for going forward will that help to resolve this question of the three chains in the future so it's actually one of my oldest adages as soon as I started doing Bitcoin media I I was encouraging people to at least use some in Commerce use it as money a little bit because if it's only used as an investment or it's only used as a trading pair or these things it'll end up being regulated by governments as this asset and it'll
be taxed the way that it is taxed today and it turns out I was right that regulations come in and now it's a piece of property and now you have short and long-term property taxes anytime you make a transaction and all this other nonsense which like it's an electronic cash system that's the title of the Bitcoin white paper it was designed to optimize payments as its first thing and then Satoshi then explain some of the other basic novel things that you could do once you've gotten past this okay once you understand that it's money now you could also make tokens with it or you could use it to do this thing with a vending machine he made a couple of of very simple comments about you could drop it in you could use it in an adult website for a little extra privacy like these kind of things so yeah I I think it was very clear what Bitcoin was for but just like a lot of things if everybody says nope I'm not going
to do it that way and 99% of people treat it like this other thing now it is regulated and taxed and used and now you know now most are are sitting in Black Rock's desk drawer on a ledger Nano and traded as uh synthetic assets as an ETF as if the world needed another financial asset to to to let people screw around with because they wear suits to work and so it's just very very weird pivot but but at the same time bsv as the most maligned blockchain in existence and frankly one of the most malign pieces of technology in the last 20 years we we've been doing the exact opposite it's it's been a lot more of let's try it just to try it and this is from both the kind of people that are filing patents and and working on kind of high Lev heady computer science problems or the entrepreneurs who show up and are just like I don't know man here's how I'm going to write this jpeg do a chain
and I I think we could bootstrap DNS on top of tokens and make a Unstoppable internet and I don't know I built an encrypted Communications app so there's a lot of very out of the neighborhood type people that uh you know are making their own little insular economies based on on very novel uses of the technology lots of very cool little proofs of concept have come out of that actually and frankly if people value this is a big if because I think most people don't value anything but if we can get people to Value sound money privacy digital asset owner like digital identity ownership in a world where you know Jack dorsy and Mark Zuckerberg are two of the richest people in the world and they're selling your data every day those kind of things like Bitcoin solves those problems but it's not going to solve those problems unless people begin to demand that those problems be solved and so a major criticism of Bitcoin that I recall from 10 or 12 years ago when
I got involved was yeah bitcoin's a solution looking for a problem to fix and I think it was it was true because it it was always kind of a niche thing like yeah sure angry internet Libertarians feel like there's a problem with the economy but I'm fine right but then it's keeps extrapolating out now we're the bitcoin's bitcoiners who are now 15 years later saying okay what's the next problem we can attempt to solve that people don't really care about but but there's gold there and my response to those people is like you know Henry Ford famously said that if he would have asked everybody what problem they wanted solved they would have asked for a faster horse and he's right because that's the beauty of real entrepreneurship and real Visionary leadership is saying look I could make a ton of money selling really great horse saddles and carriages and all these other things but I'm going to take the 20year path the longer harder Road the you know got to build all this industrial
nonsense and all it but I think I'm right and if I'm right I'm going to I'm going to change not only my own fortune but I'm going to change the way the whole world functions and he was right and so we have a lot of examples of that and that's that's what I think bsv is here for it is to not only optimize hard money sound money fix some of the problems of the issuance and distribution of hard assets and move us back toward a hard asset-based economy but also and this might even be more important given the way that the world has changed over the last 20 or 30 years is giving back digital sovereignty like ownership of your digital identity the ability to log into things without having to broadcast to the world that you're the one who logged into it that's a huge aspect of of privacy that we really need to maintain because it's either we win this revolution or it's guys like Mark Zuckerberg end up becoming more powerful than
our own governments and Banks because he controls everything he has everyone's data and not only that like we went from the internet being this kind of distributed thing to now the whole internet runs on Amazon and so guys like Jeff Bezos can be like hey look the entire US Government just uses AWS for everything and therefore I'm actually in charge here and if guys like that end up just getting all the power and all your data and all your everything that that becomes the kind of phase shift like we saw during the collapse of the Roman Empire and then all of a sudden the dedis are the most powerful people like exactly the same kind of thing so imagine the US government thinks it's in charge until maybe a half dozen guys who actually control all these levers of power say you know what if we all teamed up what could they even leverage against us and so this is crucial we need to make this concept of ownership of digital identity and digital sovereignty
is is the spearhead that we need to be driving into the future here and if we it's 500 years of Darkness like I don't want to be too cryptic here but that's really what's at stake the way I see it that I mean I couldn't agree more that's a really powerful way to come to the end of the show there like I think so many people come maybe to this podcast in the space generally for Bitcoin as a speculative asset digital gold how do I make money and not gain any utility from it and the ETF you've mentioned there although like in some ways it's good institutional adoption come into space and maybe that means more projects potentially get funding and more utility and all these real world problems actually being solved which is great but they lose sight in a lot of ways of actually solving real world problems because they think it's just for making money at the end of day number go up and it's so much more than that I think
you are right and we tried to do that on this podcast is focus on what utility can actually be derived from cryptocurrencies blockchains everything in you know the web three space and I think it's so important for you know people like us to actually focus on that and get that marketing Spiel across that there is so much more than just number go up but like I say this has been such a great episode we're coming to the final part of the show now and we usually we ask the question what on line question but I actually want to double it because we've got the chief Bitcoin historian here so I'm gonna ask two questions the first one is in one sentence what is bitcoin to you and then I would also like to hear in one sentence what is web three to you they're the same thing they they're everything bit Bitcoin is a very focused thing for most people it's like you said it's the I don't know I bought some Bitcoin it's on
my coin something account and I'll sell it someday and buy a nicer car right and that's not what it is for me bit Bitcoin should be used on everything in everything it should integr like Bitcoin should work like a virus that doesn't have a vaccine and doesn't have immunity because everything that it touches becomes more integrally connected it becomes more valuable it allows us to add a monetary value to every single bit and bite of information on the internet and we already know so data is two things it is the most valuable commodity in the world and it's the most undervalued commodity in the world right now that there's never been an asset like data in that it is the most valuable and the most undervalued it has so much upside and so using Bitcoin if you can virally integrate Bitcoin into every bit of data and then monetize all of it and figure out who owns every bit in the universe it's everything it is literally going to the atomic level of everything that
has value and allowing it to be traded like enter Economic Opportunity of everything thanks to bitcoin that's what Bitcoin is to me so is the one word answer say in all caps no love that and that resonates with what Jack and I say often is that Bitcoin and blockchain is meant to be the tcpip protocol of exchange right peer-to-peer exchange importantly and this internet of value is one of the terms we've heard banded around but yeah I love that answer um the second one is this would be a really good one actually the chief Bitcoin St got so much to choose from so many people but if you could choose anyone alive dead or fictional so sit down and discuss Bitcoin or web 3 with who would it be why oh man that's hard I think it'd be really interesting to talk to like your old school your Austrian Economist types maybe even pre- Austrian like I could say like I feel like an easy one would be like ludic Von misus or or somebody
like that the guys that sort of understood hard money and created the backlash to Fiat banking in the first place but I I may even go a little weirder in that the data problem so I've me I've made a bunch of religious analogies I'm I am myself a Protestant Christian and I look at the way that culture has moved Visa people having access to more data and more information and so I'm very specifically a big fan of a of a reformer named John Calvin now the Calvinists got kicked out of Europe some of the most brutally kicked out of Europe people in fact the French slaughtered them there was the whole Hugo Massacre and all these other things that happened and part of it was the fact that they were so interested in just spreading the information it was just like everyone should have the Bible in their own language like they they married that principle and they just spent so much time translating and printing and distributing and it was causing so much chaos
for the powers that be that it ended up like I said getting them slaughtered in France most of them ended up moving to the United States to just get the hell out of Europe because they were in big trouble there but the the funny thing is ultimately they won what we think of as like the American Industrial Revolution and here we call it the Protestant work ethic I don't know if that's a a term that gets used on the other side of the pond but there's this notion among Americans where where you would say it's this Midwest Protestant work ethics it's the kind of person that would be like I left New York I walked for A Thousand Miles and I built Minneapolis with my friends you know and you look at the construction and you look at all these things be like wait whole city was built in 20 years a 100 years ago because it's beautiful and it literally a few dozen or a few hundred families that all were essentially Dutch calvinist
or French calvinist or German calvinist that just left Europe and said you know what we're going to build all of this and it's where I'm from so Chicago is another place that was built by that same ethic and so sharing this with somebody like John Calvin For Whom the denomination is named after and saying like hey we have a tool that allows data to be unconfiscatable indestructible infinitely distributable like all these like somebody like him would be like Oh I'm all in let's make this work and uh I I see us as a little bit the inheritors of that ethic and taking the next thing forward it's I want to give ownership of data and the permanence of data to everybody because if we can just get all the information out there we can stop arguing about what's true what's false who's lying and all like it just becomes the data and we can start to solve higher level problems and so that that would be my that would be my answer John Calvin I
would love to be at that dinner party that sounds amazing and I have to say C two of the longest single sentence answers we've ever had on the show but also I expected nothing less from a guy who podcasts at least once a week but two of my favorite answers as well for sure especially on on the Bitcoin and web 3 that is bang on what how I think of it I always have said web 3 to me is like a an extrapolation of Bitcoin it's what happens when you take the ethos of Bitcoin and apply it to the internet and all these other big problems you have so yeah I I love how you you sum that up we'll definitely be we'll be clipping that one up so C I feel like you're taking one for the team today it's been such a great episode and we haven't talked about you at all so I'm going to hold you to this we're going to have you back on very soon I'm sure when we
can talk more about gorilla pool what you're doing your perspective as a minor rather than just as a historian as we've had today but I think you've done a great job of taking us through from precursors and pre- origin of Bitcoin right the way to this Visionary future so thank you so much Kurt for joining us today and all that remains to say is to everyone listening at home thank you for listening wherever you may be and join us next time to entangle a little more of web thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto