Episode 45

The Halvening

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this week's episode of the Untangling Web3 podcast, we dive deep into the heart of cryptocurrency's most talked-about phenomenon – the Bitcoin halving.

This episode unpacks the mysteries, implications, and the sheer excitement surrounding the imminent Bitcoin halving event. With ETF approvals settling down, the crypto world's eyes are now fixed on the halving – a topic that sounds almost mythical but holds significant sway over Bitcoin's future.

Join us as we explore what the Bitcoin halving really means for the crypto space and why it's capturing everyone's imagination.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

so we started out at 50 per block back in the day now that's hared three times already and we're about to approach the fourth time so that eventually there will be no new Bitcoin issued every block and we'll just have the circulating 21 million Supply there's more demand coming in more and more people talking about it and then all of a sudden you create this real reduction in Supply but more people kind of speculating and talking about the reduction in Supply and it creates this self-fulfilling hype cycle of three Bitcoins that's worth what over $200,000 so that's not insignificant per block so if you're a big Miner and you're mining 20 30 blocks a day that's a big D in your bottom line welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast we're recording this as of March 2024 so we're in the middle of a ball run it's absolute cryptomania Jack is sitting on his desert island which is kindly blurred out in the background but yeah now the ETF approvals have actually

all finished and that kind of little bit of hype has ended to an extent or actually we're still seeing the ramifications but the the initial hype has ended most people all they're talking about with regards to Bitcoin in the crypto space is the harving sounds very imposing sounds kind of foreshadowing maybe a bit evil but today we're going to be doing a little bit of a deep dive into what the Bitcoin harving actually is and what it could mean for the space this should be a really interesting one and hopefully we keep it nice and Punchy and as ever I'm joined by my glorious co-host Jack Davis to jump into this topic are you excited for this one mate very excited you need to find more adjectives for me because you're running out of G's now but yeah no it's interesting one this is I think this is the second big event we kind of marked out on our predictions for the year so as you said ETFs done and next on to the harving

as they say you know and we are going through this crazy manic period March Madness call it what you want where we've just seen all-time highs for Bitcoin and a few other bigger currencies so everyone's excited about the price at the minute and the havening event really that's coming up in well when this comes out it'll be just a few days time this is the the next big milestone on bitcoin's journey and we'll go into what it means but people predict this could have a big impact on on the price I'm not so sure but we'll get into all that in a bit a bit of controversy we've only just started yeah let's dive into it so Bitcoin obviously the term that everyone likes to use is this decentralized network so how we in a decentralized network where you have no individual entity actually running the show necessarily do you get the actual Bitcoins to the masses to the people well this is one of the interesting things around Bitcoin is actually token issuance giving

the Bitcoins to to people in the ecosystem is managed in a decentralized way and it's actually given to miners in response for managing the network validating transactions and mining blocks and when they do this the network itself actually or the system itself actually gives them newly minted Bitcoins for their work exactly so we've described this process before with the mining and the incentive for the miners is we call it the block reward and that's comprised of two things the mining subsidy which is what the harving relates to plus your transaction fees for whatever you're paying to use the network so this is part of the kind of Immaculate coin setion let's say of of Bitcoin and how you know we talk about the fixed supply of Bitcoin 21 million Bitcoin split into 100 million satosi each or something like that I always forget the number but essentially you have this 21 million Bitcoin let's say and how does that get issued how do we get to that fix Supply well it's through this block subsidy

mechanism that part of the block reward so we started out 50 per block back in the day now that's halved three times already and we're about to approach the fourth time and the idea of this Haring I the reason it's harving over time is so that eventually there will be no new Bitcoin issued there'll be no kind of fresh Bitcoins being issued every block and we'll just have the circulating 21 million Supply that's quite a long way off in the future but that's how we're getting there with these harving events yeah and it's quite an interesting one like kind of people that AR in the space when they ask me about Bitcoin one of the things they they tend to say say is you know who runs it who owns it who actually makes the Bitcoins and I think that's one of the interesting things about this is kind of hardcoded into the system right that when miners kind of act in this decentralized distributed way for the good of the network by actually mining

blocks they're rewarded automatically by hard code in the system actually generates these rewards for them that's how the the actual Bitcoins are propagated to the network yeah let's go into this like you say this Haring event is really interesting because there's only been a few of them so far and there's lots of hype and speculation about what they mean so the very first ever block that was awarded the rewards in the early days for actually mining a block you're actually getting 50 Bitcoins in return for mining a block that seems like a an unfathomable amount right now it's a difficult word to say um and every four years roughly this halves right yeah exactly so again when we talk about it being a subsidy it makes perfect sense that the the largest subsidy is earliest on in in its history we talked about bitcoin's history on the last episode as well and the the fact that it got through those early years the Wilderness years before it was widely adopted is because there was this

relatively large amount of Bitcoins on offer now they didn't have the price it has today so it was still kind of taking a gamble to be even mining it at that point but you had the largest and again because it's all predetermined because it's all hardcoded in you know it'll be 50 Bitcoins for the first four years and then 25 and then 12.5 in successive Haring after that people mining back in 2010 knew that they were getting the largest proportion of the supply that they could per block right and it is analogous I think to mining precious metals I think Satoshi talked about it being analogous to mining gold where you're putting in hard work hard effort to find these blocks in the same way you would to mine gold or precious metals and then your reward is is is is this Bitcoins that you get out of that yeah so the exact quote from satachi was the steady addition of constant amount of new coins is analogous to gold miners expending resources to add

gold to circulation in our case it is CPU time and electricity that is expended yeah it's a really interesting this one I think like one of the you say you're talking about likening this to Precious Metals having to put some work in to actually gain some value from that I think the interesting things right now is we're looking at is do does gold necessarily have a a finite amount like how much gold is the in the world it's difficult to say and I think one of the beautiful things about Bitcoin is it's predictable we know exactly how much will be gained year on year we know exactly when this harving will happen and we know exactly the amount of Maximum Supply so it's far more predictable I imagine that makes it a bit more certain for maybe investors and Retail adopters institutional adopters of that because of that yeah I I've seen people joke about gold but it's true I maybe it was Elon Musk even that I first saw saying this but if there

was an asteroid made of gold that landed on planet Earth then all of a sudden your supply of gold has had a massive jump and the price would be significantly affected whereas in in Bitcoin it's pretty much guaranteed that it's 21 million Bitcoins now there are other things that could affect that maybe we'll discuss that at the end but let's assume for now nothing changes the rules of the system basically state that 21 million Bitcoins were issued back in 2009 and they're just slowly being issued individually in these 50 and 25 12.5 and coming up in a few days time it'll just be 3 .125 Bitcoins left right so that's just being slowly issued out in these dribs and drabs to people and it's interesting because there's only around 10% of the supply left I think that's right and that's quite small in in comparison to the amount that's been lost by estimates I think that's the the rough calculation these days right yeah 20% of the total bit Bitcoin supply has been deemed to

be lost in it's probably I think some people estimate that's actually in the order of 30 to 35% if you look at the non-confirmed cases as and there's a really funny quote on this by satosi where he said lost coins only make everyone else's coins worth slightly more think of it as a donation to everyone like back in the early days when Bitcoin wasn't worth very much I imagine that held something but now it's like people losing hundreds of millions of pounds potentially and that's like quite devastating yeah well frequent listeners to the podcast will know Alex a charitable guy so he's already made his donation to the rder Bitcoin Network by losing some of his a few years ago but yeah this is all again I like to talk of it in terms of this subsidy because these harving events really focus the Mind back onto the evolution of Bitcoin from moving from this very nent industry which requires a subsidy to to exist to something which is providing real value is processing lots

of transactions for people is used for payments or other things so it's part of this overall transition to a transaction fee based model because we know for certain at some point I think it's in the year 2100 or something like that but you know before long there'll be very few Bitcoins being minted every or issued every new block so you'll have to be subsisting on the transaction fees right and we've seen transaction fees are an issue but eventually that will be all that the miners get so it's part of this longer term transitioning to how the the reward structure for miners is changing and that's also you know very much by design of satosi yeah I think that's one of the the other major points is this move eventually satosi kind of envisioned this move eventually to miners just being subsidized by the transaction fees but knowing early on that wasn't possible because there weren't many transaction fees actually going through um and they weren't worth that much right and I guess one of the

primary goals of Bitcoin still is to be able to move money fairly cheaply and that is not necessarily true right now and it'd be interesting to see what happens in this kind of future Paradigm right now miners aren't really I don't know they're not making that much compared to the actual block reward for mining on the actual transaction fees I'm not sure what the exact stat or comparisons between the two but doesn't feel I I think it's not that much it's not that comparable if the end goal is to be solely benefiting from the transaction fees themselves and nothing to do with the the reward that comes from the block it surely that means that it's going to be much more expensive to transact on bitcoin especially if we're limiting the potential block size of the number of transactions that can actually go through per block yeah I I think I've seen it creeping up over time the last couple of years the proportion of the total block reward that actually is made up by

the Fe has been inreasing as you'd expect as the subsidy decreases naturally that's changing it but there is more and more of it being allocated to fees anyway but that is mostly because people are paying very high fees to M transactions is not as you said it brings into this whole scalability debate that we discussed on the show last week you know how you fill your blocks well it depends on the maximum size so if you have large blocks then you could fill them with millions of transactions that are lowy or if you have the situation you have with Bitcoin currently you have these very small one megabyte blocks where you will have to have high fees to compensate for you know if miners want to maintain parity in their revenue then every time you have this step change and harving the subsidy then you'd need a corresponding step change increase in the average fee that you're acquiring now there's also an impact on decentralization of the system as well right and how sustainable the

system is overall because the less Revenue there is in the system again this is decreasing the revenue at least in the short term then the profitability of mining goes down maybe the smaller players have to you know exit the game they can't survive anymore and then you have fewer and fewer miners now that's not necessarily to say it's against how Bitcoin is meant to work but it's just a comment on to to lots of people that's an important feature is having more Miners and these harving events have the potential as we've seen in the past to centralize down to fewer entities okay got you yeah right so let's go to maybe some of the things that have happened in the past because as we say like a lot of the crypto space and the crypto narrative is dominated by speculation you know go up classic and the reason that I think this is getting so much attention right now is mostly because of the investment piece rather than the actual technology we're talking about you

know subsidies versus transaction fees and what's going to be how is the technology going to move forward in the future and how is it going to affect mining right now but I think most people are kind of interested in this harving because they think it's going to mean more scarcity more people coming in and therefore price goes up so what's happened in the past so like we said the first Haring was in 2012 this was actually after the days that satosi kind of had left the scene so he could Define this economic model he thought it would work he talked about it a little bit but then he actually disappeared before the first Haring came into play so I imagine there was a lot of anticipation about what was going to happen around it but like I said it was in 2012 following it actually went from Bitcoin was worth around $12 just before the harving and I think it was a year after it went to $1,000 now we can't say that they necessarily

are directly onetoone link there's a lot of external Market factors that are going into this but you know potentially there's some correlation there yeah and we've seen this pattern play out that normally after the harving again we've got three data points to go on right it's not many 2012 and then the following ones in 2016 2020 again we should also mention that spacing that four years apart is actually not based on time it's based on number of blocks produced so it's meant to be every 210,000 blocks so hopefully we've timed this episode correctly but if the Bitcoin hash rate SS in the week before then we'll be late to the party unfortunately and then maybe it happens earlier but as I said you have the same pattern in 2016 so I think the price was around $650 around that and then a year to 18 months later it peaked around 20,000 that was the all-time high in 2017 and then similarly again in 2020 when it the block reward decreased to 6.25 BTC then following

that it reached around 60,000 and we're only just hitting those levels again nearly four years later after after a lengthy bare Market let's say yeah and like I say we're kind of just comparing two variables right now here and is that an accurate way of doing it I don't know there's some kind of controversy around doing this was Bitcoin going to go up regardless of the harving hard to say but it's just interesting it's just one of the big Market factors that people seem to be talking about right now what's your take on why these price increases have happened because there is a theory that we can go into that some people have come up with but do you have an opinion on is this priced in is it a self-fulfilling prophecy in in many ways what do you think I think I kind of go with the classic Supply Demand right there's more demand coming in potentially nothing to do with the harving whatsoever just more and more people talking about it and then

all of a sudden you create this not artificial reduction in Supply real reduction in Supply but more people kind of speculating and talking about the reduction in Supply and it creates this self-fulfilling hype cycle that people like oh my God there's not much left if you're going to get in now like I've seen it play out in the last couple of months purely with the upcoming Haring people are like well if you don't lock in now you're never going to have a chance to buy Bitcoin and people definitely play on this narrative what's your take on it yeah my mine is similar in that I don't think so there is this argument and we're GNA get into they call it the stock to flow model it was made by this guy called Plan B not the musician but some kind of crypto analyst and the stock to flow model basically takes the stock which is the current Supply you have of the system and the flow so that's the change in Supply you get right

so that every time you mine a block that's a small change in Supply and that change is diminishing over time and it Compares what is the current Supply the stock to the the change in Supply and that model has been quite good at tracking at least or predicting the price changes broadly for the major Haring events we've had now it predicts around $100,000 BTC by April so we'll know but by the time this comes out if if we've gained that extra 30k that'll be interesting if it does happen but my take on it is not necessarily that there's any fundamental economic reason for this happening again not an economist but everyone knows the the supply change right so it's not like a supply shock it's not like a change that is coming out of nowhere and the economy is reacting to it it's completely baked in so my take is that this narrative now exists based on those three data points that the price will go up everyone anticipates and then it becomes a self-fulfilling

prophecy plus you have as you said the fact that the system is just becoming more popular so the overall demand regardless of whether this harving Sy thing was happening at all is increasing while the supply is just tending towards this fixed limit so yeah I don't think there's necessarily anything special in my book about the harving apart from social media and most people are telling you to buy Bitcoin right about now so it seems like a massive oversimplification right to just have two variables effectively defining what the price of something as complex as Bitcoin is going to be like that doesn't take into account what's going on social media what's going on institutionally what's going around globally War all these things I think anyone who thinks that they can you know work at anything economically or related to the economy tends to be wrong they're right for a certain amount of time then eventually they're wrong and there an exception that breaks the rule typically but yeah what we're seeing is bitcoin's always G up

kind of this is probably the best time to be in Bitcoin right now not Financial advice not Financial advice and one is it history is not a prediction of the future but yeah it doesn't always go up in the way you intend to it's certainly not been linear for anyone who's been in the space for more than the last three months yeah and that's why I mentioned the lag it is important to note that the effect of this might based on history might not be felt for another year to 18 months so it's it'd be interesting to look back on this in a year's time and see how right or wrong we were but because it gives us time to get away Jack you're like don't any we say in here we've got we've got 12 to 18 months to get away basically and move to Cayman Isles pretty much we we won't be held accountable by subscribers until then which is nice so less about the speculation let's talk about the miners because they're

the people that lose out in all of this like just at a high level initially it's mind-blowing to think you have this business model say you're somewhat profitable you get in what is it say 6.25 Bitcoins right now 6.25 Bitcoins right now for every time you mine a block and Mining is kind of irregular but you can I imagine you can predict it roughly over the course of years how much you're going to mine and then all of a sudden overnight the amount the Bitcoins you receive per block mind halves it doesn't matter if you can predict that or not and look into the future and know exactly when that's going to happen at the end of the day your Revenue potentially overnight halves That's not including the blockchain transaction fees and that's mindboggling like it must be an absolute I don't know nightmare for those kind of companies yeah and again at least they've had forewarning that this will happen but it doesn't change the impact when it does arrive and the fact that

they will overnight have to try and compensate this harving in the block subsidy that they'd otherwise be getting that's three Bitcoins that's worth what over 200 Grand at the minute $200,000 so that's not insignificant per block so if you're a big Miner and you're mining 20 30 blocks a day that's a big dent in your bottom line and as one of the effects of this is that you will see potentially a reduction in hash rate for Bitcoin because either the bigger miners will deploy a little bit less and they might have to scale down operations in the short term if they're especially if they're waiting for bitcoin price to increase if that's a 12-month lag they're not getting it replaced straight away so they might have to to pair down and the smaller operations we have seen in the past that they've closed down following harving so I saw there was a report by Galaxy digital that they estimate roughly 20% reduction may happen as a result of this harving in the BTC hash rate

immediately following this right which would be pretty significant wow that is fascinating I didn't imagine that would happen like I understood the the number of miners that could actually compete in this space would lessen but I didn't think there'd be for some reason actually I mean obviously that does correspond to a reduction in hash rate overall if there less competitors but like you said earlier this is potentially a big issue for a network that kind of in it way highlights itself as this decentralized network with know resistant to single points of failure and all this kind of stuff the idea of less and less miners be being able to compete in this space potentially leading to centralization potentially then being more susceptible to control by a few large entities is I imagine quite worrying in the space and like you say like another impact of this is because all of a sudden the revenue goes potentially significantly down they have to become more efficient and they have to look at better ways to manage energy

costs maybe more advanced Hardware one thing I've saw is that you actually get a lot of miners as a result of harving changing geographical location moving to areas that may be much cheaper using renewable energy sources which is definitely a boon moving to place is where there's Excess power available and turnning you know regions that aren't necessarily set up for it like the Western worlds maybe less economically developed countries and actually using them for their you know cheaper energy Supply yeah if I had to make one prediction about the impact of this harving it would probably be on the energy distribution how much of it is from Renewables because renewable energy there's a big upfront cost to having it but once you've got it it's kind of free in a sense to simplify but you get this free renewable source of energy so it makes so much sense for Bitcoin miners to go renewable and we've seen more and more of the the Bitcoin hash rate being replaced by renewable sources but that has been

partly mandated by a lot of the the Regulatory leanings and kind of murmurings from many different countries on how Bitcoin should be sourcing its energy now that impetus is going to be provided by effectively by the market by Bitcoin itself saying your margins are Getting Thinner you can't afford to keep producing energy you can't afford to keep hashing based on the same old model and partly not just the energy cost as well but the hardware because these as6 they go through them so quickly that on top of everything is a humongous cost they had to replace the mining Hardware so I've actually seen lots of really interesting projects around using renewable energy to cool the mining rigs as well right this is something I mean I actually went and saw one of these back in Cardiff someone's got a mining rig and it's in kind of was immersed in this coolant fluid but the the fluid itself isn't conductive so you can have these as6 and the as6 are just the machines that you're mining

from right these dumb computers that are Computing hashes over and over again and it's really bizarre to see them because they're submerged in this clear liquid you think why isn't this blowing up this shouldn't this should be working but it's cooling them down and because it's immersed it's much more efficient at doing that and you can use renewable energy to do that so I think there's so much Innovation actually going on right now you've seen the sustainable Bitcoin protocol they're doing lots of work on reducing the Reliance on fossil Fus of Bitcoin mining so I just think that is going to be a huge impact now that those margins are squeezed even more that's a little bit of insight into what you're doing on your weekends yeah so I think one of the next big things that we touched on already which is you absolutely fascinating is about network security like the miners right now they're receiving these you well quite big subsidies right of Bitcoins to actually mine blocks what's going to happen when

all of that runs out if the transaction fees per transaction they're actually going through aren't equivalent to what they're getting right now for the rewards for mining blocks could this lead to a security problem could we have like you say already you saying their estimates that the hash pair of Bitcoin will potentially Reduce by 20% as a result of this harving are there going to be any long-term consequences of this and in one of the quotes by satosi about this is in a few decades when the reward gets too small the transaction fee will become the main compensation for nod so he foresaw this he knew this was going to happen and he had this idea of a transition of the economic model from block reward two transaction fees but right now is there enough transactions actually going on to say Bitcoin to potentially use this make this sustainable in the future yeah I think my guess would be yes it's for at least the next harving cycle the next four years it can be

sustainable for the miners because there is enough demand to pay significant huge fees exorbitant fees to use the network is it sustainable for the end users I think potentially not right because every time this happens you are pricing out more and more at end users from actually accessing the chain and that doesn't just affect people who want to use L1 dayto day as we said in in the layer two episode you have things like lightning Network built on top of it but you don't always stay in the layer two you want to open and close channels to settle your bartab every so often so it's going to impact even those people who are using layer 2 especially you know we've got El Salvador now completely using layer 2 in the lightning Network it's going to impact them as well because now the cost of settling those transactions is going to be that much higher in the future so is it sustainable for users I think potentially not and what I've seen we talked about it

in a lot of detail in the the history of Bitcoin episode about the idea of scalability the idea of block sizes basically the number of transactions that a miner can process per given block and right now that is fixed that is limited and rather than the potentially the actual transaction fees going up to make up for this to sustain miners in the future when the the block subsidy goes down the BR reward goes down could they increase the number of transactions that goes through and make sure that the actual transaction fee goes down and this is something that I've actually seen started people starting to have a discussion about this again is do we need to increase the number of transactions to make sure that we can compete and can keep the transaction fees down to actually get the transaction throughput into the network to keep it healthy and sustainable yeah you're right I think the the harving always tend to be a reason to Resto the fire of the scalability debate do we go

small blocks or do we go Big Blocks and and change how the fees are paid basically and and who pays for the fees so I wouldn't be surprised if we see that as an effect if there are more I've seen talks already in splintering in in the BTC Community about that so yeah it's interesting and this kind of brings us on to the whole idea of e Bitcoin as an economic system right because it's this nice blend of cryptography Network science and also economics and this probably the one of the more interesting things so many people especially in the institutional space are even more more and more starting to treat Bitcoin as digital gold right so not necessarily cash but some kind of some hard asset people call it that is not so subject to inflation so people are starting to see it on their balance sheets now you see micro strategy buying even more Bitcoin big companies even with the ETFs are starting to appreciate the idea of Bitcoin as an asset but it

is playing into this wider digital gold narrative right and honestly I think the The Narrative of digital goal we both said in a ways problematic if you think of Bitcoin as its original intended you know pit-to-pit Cash System but it definitely helps with the salale sales pitch like when you're talking to these big Financial institutes these people who are kind of experts in economics but have no idea about cryptography have no idea about Bitcoin and the technology behind it and you try and talk about this decentralized network of people getting rewards from this hardcoded blah blah blah I imagine they just glaze over instantly but as soon as you make the comparison and and the story of dig gold you know people are mining gold from who knows where and then you ACW more and acrew more but there is a limited Supply at the end of the day I imagine it just makes those conversations so much easier and what I've seen online from like Black Rock CEO Larry think he was completely against

Bitcoin in the early days like his whole agenda has changed completely he's done a full U-turn the last you know four years three years even and now he's saying things along the lines of you know as governments are navigating the mounting debt burdens and there's inflation left right and Center we can't trust people to make the right decisions and central banks to make the right decisions about issuance he said he's starting to promote Bitcoin scarcity and this decentralized offering as a real value proposition as a real alternative to our current solutions for finance and it kind of blows my mind a little bit because he was saying the complete opposite five years ago and maybe it's just because they've got an investment and a stake in Bitcoin now but it is really interesting to see the big institutes and traditional kind of economic institutes really B jumping into this yeah and I think it's good to talk about the scarcity idea because for lots of people now that's where they believe and again all of

this is belief really it's depending on who you ask who can Define what value is but for a lot of people bitcoin's value is derived from its scarcity now I I don't necessarily agree with that but it goes back to this point of Bitcoin is fundamentally an economic experiment right it's experimental in nature so this idea of the issuance of a fixed Supply and in kind of these increments over time that that exponentially decrease no one's ever done this before people have done it since in in droves but no one's ever done it in the same way and to the same scale in terms of use and notoriety the Bitcoin has and this is all an experiment and the scarcity piece people talk about Bitcoin being deflationary right and and I think of that as deflationary with respect to a traditional fiat currency like a US dollar so that its value shouldn't decrease over time because you don't have printing you don't have additional printing of Bitcoin now okay at the minute this is why

I get to have AIT bit of a bug bear here you are printing Bitcoin every every block but the difference being this is within the wider framework of the the fixed Supply so beyond that fixed Supply you can't be you can't have it printed and and the market knows these parameters of the system it knows how many there will be it knows the issuance rate whereas in your traditional currency you can print stupid amounts of money I saw some ridiculous fact the other day I don't remember the exact percentage but some humongous chunk of the US dollar has been printed in the last year I think like over 50% I think it was which is mindboggling to me as a fact well it's isn't it like well I just saw the debt increases in the US by 1 trillion every 40 days and I can see that you know a lot of the kind of the Bitcoin Maxes are using this in the Twitter sphere to say well why the hell would you buy into

this I think one of the comparisons is that people think the amount of money they have is going up every year if you invest in the S&P and all these kind of traditional stocks and funds but if you look at your purchasing power related to that bigger number it actually doesn't go up that much and this is a real reason I saw the coinbase kind of one of the first ads that coinbase did and it was all about this problem with investment you work your whole life and you put money into the system and you can't buy the house that could be bought 50 years ago you can't buy the car that could be bought 20 years ago and I don't know how much I agree with this is not Financial advice as we always say but their angle was you invest in crypto assets because actually a lot of them do enable you to live that life that you were told you could live if you kind of performed in the you know the

prescribed way from the government and yeah it's a really interesting one I think another really interesting point is we talk about Bitcoin is hardcoded and everything all this scarcity this limited Supply this fix Supply is hardcoded but as we've talked about in the past you know the miners are actually running the hard code they're running Bitcoin itself so is this 21 million actually fixed question yeah we're getting controversial now I'm GL I'm glad you bring it up because yeah this is a genuine question and it's one that's been posed before again it was talked relatively seriously by some of the Bitcoin developers a number of years ago and I've seen it cropping up again is the idea of expanding the supply because of the reducing issuance of new Bitcoins over time and to say how is this economically stable well we're GNA have to print more and if you look at something like ethereum they don't have a fixed Supply right they've kind of abandoned this notion I'm not entirely sure if they ever did

have it to be honest but they have a complet a supply that's totally in flux now you have new ether minted all the time and have it burned by transaction fees you don't have that in Bitcoin you do supposedly have this hard-coded limit but what if the developers of the software decide to suddenly change it one day what if they convince the miners there is precedent for as we saw in last week's episode there is precedent for the developers in Bitcoin kind of forcing changes upon miners now we're in a very different situation to where we were years ago with lots of those changes things like sewit but there is a valid question there I think and and you have to permit some trust that 21 million limit will always be the limit and it won't be increased my prediction is if that ever happens if there is a serious discussion Around increaseing The Limited Supply I really do think Bitcoin would potentially like overnight I think the price would just completely plummet but not

Financial advice and I don't think they would do that because like they're making their entire money off the value of Bitcoin and they know the effects when everyone's talking about scarcity limited Supply that is probably one of the defining features right now of Bitcoin it's the one that most of the institutions are talking about anyway if they start to have a serious conversation about this they know that it would screw up their entire business I can't imagine miners buying into that now maybe in the early days when we were talking about like I say the cash system but now it's this digital gold scarcity is King at the end of the day I think and one thing that I would want to bring up on this as well because it just came up in a conversation with my mom the other day because she was like oh I'm hearing about crypto and I'm listening to the podcast and she's like well how many Bitcoins do you have you talk about all time and I'm like

well I have a third of a Bitcoin or something like that and she's like have a third of a Bitcoin like what the hell is a third of a Bitcoin like how does this if I had a third of a pound I wouldn't be talking about it on a podcast and I like well actually you know Bitcoin is divisible we need to I don't think we' actually said this before but it is divisible into smaller denominations of 100 million it's 100 million s per bitco yeah and we should just emphasize that point that there aren't just 21 million Bitcoins it's 21 million times 100 million satosi so there is enough divisibility to actually exchange it round yeah I'm glad you reminded me of the actual number because I was fishing around for it earlier but so so the base unit in the system is the satosi and there are 2.1 * 10^ the 15 of those okay that's a big number but there is a price at which you know that that satosi amount could

become quote unquote too high for practical use you can't divide it into smaller things anymore and that's one of the other reasons I've seen people mentioning about increasing the supply well if it ever got so big and so valuable then you would want more kind of smaller denominations to use it and that way effectively inflate the supply now yeah I agree with you I don't necessarily think we'll ever get to increasing the supply for the reasons you stated I think we've hit that level of institutional awareness and adoption and the narrative kind of people have taken up this narrative around the digital gold angle and where the values come from that would be an athma to everyone they they just think it wouldn't get through and if Bitcoin ever got so big and so valuable that we needed more units of it I think people are probably going to be pretty happy anyway so it's probably if it did happen it would probably be for reasons that nobody really cares about but yeah I'm glad

you mentioned that it's an point yeah and I think like we're coming to the end of the show now and in my mind the kind of the main points to take away from this is bitcoin's an experiment in a way it's like when we think about the the digital space and digital kind of interaction we never I personally never really think of it as being finite we've talked about the metaverse previously and how it kind of opens up this potentially Infinite Space for us to operate in for us to transact in to commit Commerce in and that is quite exciting for a lot of reasons but Bitcoin is not that and it is digital scarcity in a way it's like the kind of the digital gold scarcity and it's really interesting to see how we're nowhere near it like you said the kind of the final the final time that miners will receive rewards from the network for actually mining blocks is something like I don't know 20 2,150 so it's like in a 100

years or something like that so we are far away for it but it' be really interesting to see how it plays out and them because this is a complete experiment and it's interesting to see that satosi back in 2008 pre 2008 imagin this without really having the ability to microtune as it was going along and kind of set this plan out and now we're seeing how everything plays out yeah I it kind of reminds me of why I fell in love with Bitcoin a little bit right because it is this kind of big living breathing experiment at the end of the day it's it's got its own characteristics its own personality it has this harving cycle it has it had to grow up right it has to grow up even further from this subsid ized kind of infancy to it being a fully-fledged adult of the monetary world and it's I think it's the most interesting economic experiment there's ever been and we are we're lucky enough to be living to uh see it play

out and every four years these harving events are just some of the way markers I like using them as as a yard stick to see how well has Bitcoin done over the last harving cycle not just in terms of price but in terms of adoption technical changes how it's being used what it's being used for so I just think it's a very interesting time to take stock on the wider role of Bitcoin in general and it does highlight tension between as we've said between the use of Bitcoin as the digital gold asset as a as as an asset and as a speculative vehicle versus it being used as a as a currency for payments and how its initial use was so yeah it's an interesting time to take stock of is Bitcoin now giving up on that value proposition because the the more harving we have the more it kind of goes down the digital gold route but yeah it's just for me it's just a piece of interesting kind of history that we'll probably

be writing about one day and say we were there yeah I think that's a really good point I think it would be really under the utility versus speculation point that you just made as you said they're going for this digital gold narrative and eventually we're saying right now unless things change drastically they're going to have to move to a purely transaction fee model and as soon as you go down that route and as soon as miners have to make up you know a lot more money from a lot fewer transactions potential limited transactions at least the utility angle all of a sudden becomes much more expensive and therefore difficult to do so I think it's it is leading them down that route I think that is unfortunately to the detriment of Bitcoin but there'll be other people that will capitalize on that there'll be other blockchains potentially ethereum is really targeting towards the utility angle but there'll also be layer twos that build on that and if if we're Limited in the number of transactions

we can put in a block then and they cost a lot of money then all of a sudden you have Layer Two roll up side chains that can fit more transactions on top of that single transaction and divide the price between the more so it's not the end of utility potentially it's just maybe foreshadowing that a very poignant place to end Alex so yeah I think hopefully that has given everyone a good overview of what's actually happening in the next couple of days with the harving event it's also worth reminding ourselves that it's occurring across multiple blockchains not exactly at the same time so we've referring to the BTC Haring but there's a similar one for all the kind of chains coming off that so Bitcoin cash Bitcoin SV as as well so they will play out at various different times but yeah that kind of sums up what it is and the impact of it and I think yeah we should check back in in a year to see if our predictions were right

or if they were Way Off the Mark so I think that's a good place to end this one so yeah we'll sign off there and thanks at home for listening wherever you may be and join us next time to untangle a little more of web thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes