Episode 76
Technology Mental Health with Dr. Annie Zimmerman
About this episode
In this episode of Untangling Web3, we're joined by Dr. Annie Zimmerman, a distinguished psychotherapist, to blend technology with mental health discussions.
This episode explores how digital environments impact our psychological well-being and what the future holds for mental health in an increasingly digital world.
Key highlights
- Impact of Technology on Mental Health. Dr. Zimmerman sheds light on how pervasive technology use is reshaping our mental landscapes, particularly emphasizing the rise of mental health issues correlated with digital media consumption.
- Digital Interventions in Therapy. The conversation navigates through the potential and pitfalls of integrating technology in therapeutic practices, discussing innovative approaches like virtual reality (VR) in exposure therapy and digital platforms that facilitate remote mental health support.
- Technological Dependency. A critical discussion on our growing dependency on digital devices, highlighting the dual-edged nature of technology as both a tool for connectivity and a potential catalyst for isolation.
The episode contemplates the ethical dimensions of integrating technology with human-centric services like mental health. Dr. Zimmerman advocates for a balanced approach where technology aids human connection without displacing the genuine human elements essential for meaningful interpersonal interactions.
Our conversation together sheds light on the intersection of technology and mental health and prompts a deeper consideration of how we engage with technology daily.
Learn more about Your Pocket Therapist here: - Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/your_pocket_therapist - TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@your_pocket_therapist
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast today we'll be introducing my friend and social media influencer Dr Annie Zimmerman so Annie is a psychotherapist writer academic and influencer she started her lifechanging insights from the therapy room on Tik Tok and Instagram as your pocket therapist back in 2021 I have a lot of friends who actually know about this I didn't know about it until a year ago but it's everywhere basically since then she's built a community of hundreds of thousands of followers all across the world and today we've got Annie on the show to discuss technology and mental health and yeah it's a bit different we'll be talking about the implications of Technology on mental health and what technology needs to be like in the future to actually address some of the concerns and maybe even improve on a current mental health situation so without further Ado introducing Annie to the show let's kick this off thanks I'm happy to be here yeah I'm so excited to finally have you on I think that you
know we started off as a pure Tech podcast and more and more we're kind of having to go into the realm of like where technology kind of makes a difference in different fields different disciplines you know normal people's lives and when I asked you to come on this your first reaction was like no I don't do web three and technology and all this kind of stuff but that's exactly what we want because you've got so much experience in so many different ways I think it's going to be so fascinating to have your insights on this stuff thank you yeah I think therapy and mental health is a very like technophobic profession even though I am a Instagram influencer and I also work on Zoom it's like it's full of dinosaurs and like mostly middle-aged women so it's not like super updated as other fields are so it's going to be interesting to talk about like yeah how technology is impacted and where where the future's going with it and you're at such like a unique
kind of Junction of so many things like you say you're like the the social media influencer that's the big whole like Tech area there and also you kind of we talk going to talk about how Technologies impacting Society in a negative way and what you're seeing in like your day-to-day practice but there's also the option like is technology going to help us and I think that's kind of maybe one of the more hopeful exciting areas but we'll get on to that a bit later hopefully and kick off yeah and Annie just before we get into that I think this is good because we're probably both layman in each other's area here right so you're you're the you're the mental health professional and you have this huge experience and we know a little bit about web 3 but I think you know today is where the the East will meet West on these two so this is this is going to be really interesting for me as well you know I feel like lots of us
are much more aware of mental health as a topic than than virtually ever before it's spoken about a lot I think you know from my perspective at least the situation has improved from where it was maybe 10 15 20 years ago with this increased awareness with more access potentially but could you just give us a very brief kind of introduction to the field of mental health so what does it actually mean to you mental health and what are the trends you've been seeing towards the mental health of society in general at the minute yeah I guess it's a really broad term mental health but my understanding is it's like your relationship to yourself how you're feeling in yourself I mean it can impact physical health too it can feel Mental Health Health can feel really physical but it's generally how you're feeling psychologically your sense of identity your sense of purpose all of these things as well as you know symptoms that we might have like anxiety depression addiction diagnosis these kind of things and
in terms of where yeah Trends in mental health at the moment in the same way that there are Trends in technology there's also Trends in mental health problems so in in the 60s for example or even earlier in the in the 20s when Freud came about mental health issues presented really differently so women would have hysteria and would have all of this kind of like hysterical symptoms and people would have a lot of physical problems where like that they would they would stop being able to feel their limbs or they would suddenly go blind out of nowhere and actually we see Trends in mental health so I think a few years ago it was more anxiety and depression as being really really common which still a lot of people suffer with but but now it's kind of moving into ADHD and autism as being things that people are suddenly kind of resonating with and much more and seeing themselves in that I guess ADHD is something really interesting to talk about in terms of Technology
because there's such a link and I don't think technology is a great thing for people with ADHD who are trying to focus and motivate and things like that so that's a big area I think I think more generally just in terms of what Society is struggling with I think loneliness is is an epidemic not just in old people which is where it's traditionally talked about but I think actually in young people people more and more you hear all these stats about 16 year olds and 15 year olds and they're they're not getting involved with each other they're not connecting and why is that what's what's going wrong when we're supposed to be kind of more socially connected than ever I'm glad you brought this up like this is like what the kind of the promise was early on with like the boom of social media Giants right it was connection it's convenience being out to sit in your room and speak to someone across the side other side of the world near instantly and for
free most of the time and like when you think about that initially you're like wow that's going to bring people together we're going to understand each other more be more peaceful be more happy connected but it's the opposite right like we're seeing more and more we feel more isolated more tribal more extreme and like you say a lot of this is because of the social media Giants potentially I think a stat that I saw was that 32% of teenagers feel worse about their bodies after using social media like Instagram and like you brought it up there like the kind of the negative consequences for a BHD and all this kind of stuff so yeah let's jump into the technology bit like what do you think like at a high level the role of technology in these you know Trends yeah I mean social media is like the obvious thing and we should definitely talk about the the pros and cons of that but I think it starts even earlier now babies with iPads kids playing
video games instead of playing and being creative of not leaving the house you see those maps of where kids used to go in the 80s 90s early 2000s and in the 80s they were walking around the streets in the 90s they were going at least to the end of the road now they're not even leaving the front room like moving around into the garden you know because technology is so addictive and compulsive and you know you see babies with phones like it's some weird Instinct like they just want to look at the phone like more than they even want to look at you know like a human's eyes so it seems to like override some social Instinct that makes us want to be more on screens than with people and then you don't develop the skills you don't develop the bonds you don't develop you know everything that comes with being in like a community and it can then feel harder to connect with people and even scarier and you know like then it's it's
going out of your comfort zone just to say hello to someone in the street and I think that is a scary place to be because if you don't have Community as a human you don't feel safe you like that's is it's very like primitive that if you feel like belonging to a group then you're more likely to survive because then you hunt together and you you know share berries and all of that so if you're on the outside of a group it's an existential threat and it's terrifying and your body's pumped with cortisol and that's when you get loads of mental health problems so I think lack of connection is is at the root of like so many issues and that's when you start seeing addictions and anxiety and then when you grow up so that's just as a child then you grow up then you get on social media and then that's supposed to feel connecting and it's supposed to be about relationships and yet you feel more alone and less connected and more
terrible about yourself yeah I'm I'm glad you talked about like the addiction level of social media because like it's something that I think is becoming more and more understood as a problem but it wasn't early like in the early conception of it and I listen to a really interesting podcast I'll try and Link it after this about like what we're going to do a detailed episode on this about how AI actually impacted social media so they basically like set up these social media apps and they like okay we want to get people our whole kind of business model is to get people to use social media to be as engaged and as on the app as possible so they set up these kind of AI God algorithms to say optimized to make sure people are constantly clicking constantly engaging and what the AI apps kind of did by testing out on millions of humans what's the most addictive content they basically found that greed and fear are two of the the most addictive things so
the content that they push to people to kids to whatever just triggers those two buttons so they just that's why so much of the content is so addictive because it really triggers those kind of like Bas survival instincts of those two things I want something and I'm scared of something and that is kind of why it's so polarizing so many like negative consequences outside of the addiction also makes you more scared makes you question you know your neighbor makes you more racist whatever it is like it's it's such a problems for society this stuff that's really horrible isn't it that the the worse it is the more we want to be on it like why do we it's so so counterintuitive like why why it's so adjective when it's so painful I I was also thinking that I heard a theory about why it's so addictive especially Tik Tok and the like video real apps is because it works on the same way as a slot machine so the reward is inconsistent so on a
slot machine you lose lose lose and then win and then you your dopam Meine spikes and then you're like oh maybe I'll win again but there's no pattern and because it's random you're more likely to not guess the pattern and so you stay longer because your brain's trying to work out the pattern of when you when you get the reward and it's the same with Tik Tok that it's like not that good video not that good video oh that one I like Spike My dopamine but because it's so Random it keeps you on the app for like half an hour longer than all the other apps like they attention is amazing because they're they're like manipulating you in this way it's so horrible it's like you feel so powerless you know yeah that's that's really fascinating I actually hadn't heard of that one before but it's almost like hacking the uh the gamblers fallacy kind of you know putting investing more time and then you find a golden nugget and then you start investing more
and more time in the rubbish content that's really interesting one they definitely hadn't thought of before another aspect of you know the rise of social media because you you mentioned the search for Community one interesting term that I I've kind of seen popping up in the last couple of years is also around parasocial relationships and my understanding is this is kind of when you have a content creator or somebody online maybe a vlogger you know the rise of YouTube was very much partly through vloggers and people feeling like they have a genuine almost like a friendship with these people do you do you think that's been a kind of healthy development do you think that's something that can cause harm or you think that kind of thing is is a net good in how people ascribe value to people when they watching content creators online yeah that's a really interesting question I mean I definitely like from personal experience I watch some like YouTubers and you in a way okay so you're at home you
got an hour to spare you put a YouTube video on of someone doing a daily Vlog or whatever and talking at you and you feel like you're connecting you feel like a friend is talking to you but ultimately you're not showing any of yourself so it's like a really one-way relationship but in a way it's kind of like celebrity culture like you get completely obsessed by people's lives and they show you more and more and like you want to know at the same time they can be quite comfort and maybe that's more nourishing than watching like a cartoon or something because it is a real human and you might learn from them and connect with them and see yourself in them and like in a way it can be connective it's just that person doesn't know that you exist I guess it's yeah it's really easy to crit criticize social media as being antisocial but there are actually lots of positive elements like there there are amazing community online that people can access and talk
to and you can have connection even if it's not face to face with the person but it's at what cost what does that take away from your actual human experiences yeah I I think I I definitely agree with you it's it's one of those things where you're right is way too easy to be critical and I think people do I I have been guilty of this in the past as well being too kind of default critical of it I think the like most things right in life these these things are quite good in at least small doses and as you say that these things can be a comfort I know I've I've kind of felt this experience of a Paras social relationship with creators online because maybe I use you know one to listen to in the background and it's kind of nice then again we've had these things with the radio as well right like feeling like you might have a almost parasocial relationship with a radio presenter that you really like so I
think it's not necessarily new but one of the things we've seen with technology is just the barrier to entry or the the variety of possible entry points for this experience is now massively increased so yeah I think it's an interesting area and while we're talking about Trends I think one of the other big trends we've seen specifically kind of related to mental health is obviously the rise of kind of digital forms of uh therapy right so you have your your better healths for example they've they've seen huge increases do you have a take on that and the kind of the new online digital delivery mechanism for therapeutic help when it comes to mental health I have yeah I have lots of thoughts of it on it to varying degrees I think better help is kind of I guess like uber for therapists in a way um so you're still finding a real human it's just giving a platform to do that and so if if if the end result gets you to a human then
I'm ready for it I think therapy is like you know when you do those those quizzes that's like How likely is your job to be replaced by AI or a robot Wonder we're going to come this therapy is like the the like lowest percentile like even though there are now ai therapists um but that's questionable like for me therapy is about humo human in interaction and there's like no replacement for that I guess people use text therapists make and like almost like a kind of like online chat assistant or whatever but it's a therapist chat GPT even is giving therapy advice and things like that I was really anti- it because what works about therapy is you're being witnessed by another human and you're being held by another human and you bear your soul to them and you tell them like all of the most terrible things about you or that happened to you and you cry and you get angry and you admit things and another human says that's okay like I'm still going
to sit with you and you're acceptable and then you learn to accept yourself and a any sort of Technology just doesn't have that same gravitas and that same experience but something that's really changed my mind on it recently is is maybe still using technology as a tool to help alongside therapy because my friend Matt he and I think this is the kind of people the kind of client group that this could work for he really struggles to have conversations with his girlfriend about his feelings but he is like well aware that he needs to and that that's really helpful for his relationship and he he absolutely hates being illogical so he's designed this kind of chat GPT code where he just uh speaks aloud free all of his thoughts and rants kind of CH GPD and it spits out the key points that he's struggling with and it turns them into um what we call I feel statements so instead of him saying to his girlfriend you didn't text me back and you're terrible it's
I feel her when I don't hear from you which is like known to be a better way of communicating because it's less attacking and it's just he's just owning his feelings and what he's I'm sure the code is like more um developed than that but when he has these conversations he brings the script from chat GPT and he tells he literally reads aloud from it because he's able it it it helps him to master his feeling so instead of having a really heated conversation that actually isn't that productive he really can take out the core of what he wants to say and that made me think actually there is a place for that for for these kind of technological developments in therapy and in mental health that can help be a tool that people can feel like empowered to speak or have difficult conversations and that they they kind of lean on it as a crotch and in the same way on social media you know therapy content is available to 247 my therapist is
only available to me once a week so let's say I have a fight with my partner and I don't know why they've said that or whatever I can go straight onto Google and start googling you know questions and answers and go on to Instagram and watch something that resonates and like it's it's something that's there for you all of the time so I think that's that's what a therapist can't do a therapist has boundaries and limitations and their own personal needs there's something to be said for something being available to to you 24/7 that can make you feel supported or give you something in the moment but that doesn't mean that it's the same as therapy and I don't think that means it can replace therapy but it's just another tool yeah I'm glad you brought this up early on because it's like such a kind of philosophical conversation around this stuff it's like what is it to be human do we need this kind of stuff when you talk about the obvious things yeah
it we shouldn't be talking to robots about our feelings there's something missing there and the other person should be able to empathize and then you kind of like you talked about some of the pros like it's so expensive sometimes difficult to get therapy like I think there's a stat which I'll pull out somewhere it's like 56% of American adults with mental illnesses don't receive treatment because of cost and like lack of therapist so it's like a lot of people that aren't getting this and then you talked about you know some of these apps just filling in the Gap a little bit like lowering the barrier to entry for say the more simple things just to say okay well these are your thoughts maybe turn them into this kind of stuff so I imagine like maybe it does fit quite well with this this triage idea like it's not going to solve all the problems but it solves maybe the easier ones like the filtering say the bottom 20% or something like that and then it
gives the people that really need it the opportunity to say actually speak to a human and you kind of get into the realm of like well then if it say you know we could create an Annie AI where someone could converse with Annie and they couldn't tell the difference like it's online obviously but it's exactly like you Annie and they didn't know the difference like what would be the difference to them in say chatting with that AI bot that they wouldn't get say chatting to you the responses were exactly the same do you think if the response was exactly the same yeah and do they know it's AI they think it's real it depends how how legitimate we want this business to be it's interesting because actually you know I find sometimes when I have sessions in person versus on Zoom I personally don't like working on Zoom because there's something about being in the room of someone that is like so much more palpable and connecting um but sometimes I have a session on
zoom and and the person will suddenly be able to cry or connect to something that they wouldn't have if I was sat with them and there's something almost free and I I actually found this over lockdown I was really reluctant to talk on Zoom but I did so and I was actually like because I was safe in my own room with no one actually there just my therapist on the screen I suddenly found it much more freeing and I was able to like really cry in front of her which is something that i' struggle to do so there's I actually imagine if you had an AI therapist and you knew it was an AI therapist you might tell them like everything you know people might take a year to to confess to me something really shameful for example whereas if you knew it was Ai and it wasn't a real person you might feel really empowered and really free to just be really vulnerable and really open and show everything that's a good point maybe
it's because the lack of judgment or bias or like I mean I wonder if Facebook could be storing all that data and you might be a bit less interested in it yeah and it might make you paranoid that you're yeah exactly exactly a question on this though is like do you think that we lose something in ourselves when we kind of rely too heavily on you know say the AI for example in that instance like you know the kind of the classic is you said that you're using social media all the time like I listen to podcasts like I find it really hard now to not be doing something like even if I'm walking down the street I find it hard to not be listening to a podcast or not I found the lack of stimulation quite concerning and worry that like you know the short-term gain of us being able to connect over the Internet or be constantly you have access to therapists online or chat gbt to listen to my problems it's good
in the short term in the long term do we like develop a Reliance that maybe isn't that healthy because of this yeah I I think it's one of the main complaints that some of my patients are struggling with at the moment is phone addiction it it's like everyone has been given the most addictive drug in their pocket and beforehand only a certain type of person in a certain like class and culture and everything would be able to access really addictive drugs now we all have one in our pocket and we have to fight that so even if you weren't that susceptible to addiction and you're kind of like a reasonably mentally healthy person you still have to fight your phone every single day you know every minute of the day which is quite it's quite a difficult thing to put on to people because then you feel like you're wrong for or you know they're broken or you're weak or something because because you end up spending most of your time on your phone but
actually it's like we can't win this battle unless we all get rid of our phones somehow yeah I I saw a really powerful vid video on this you know again this is always the Paradox of talking about it I was probably watching on my phone someone kind of spent 15 minutes just explaining you know actually people talk about social media being a problem actually it's the phone it's the device it's the everpresent screen that takes your attention for 100 different reasons and I think there's a lot of Truth to that and as you're saying the way it the way it's affected our reward systems is the really scary thing because it it seems like you know it's confined to the phone but then it starts bleeding out especially in my experience into the rest of my life I find it harder to concentrate sometimes and you know when you were talking about people starting from an early age right getting an iPad in front of them when they're just an infant that is the thing
that really scares me because we're only just starting to understand the impact of this on our reward systems then if you go and accelerate that you know Alec and I are young enough luckily to probably have only started experiencing this effect you know in our early teens I would say with the rise of smartphones but now people are starting that when they're three four years old you know how much worse is the impact going to be so I think that's one of the things that that really scares me about it I mean do you think there's is there anything we can do in your view to curb that effect right and the impact the downstream impacts we're seeing on our mental health generally because when I say impact on Mental Health as well I think it's similar to what you were alluding to earlier right you were saying people are resonating with this idea of ADHD I feel like a lot of people now say oh I've got a bit of ADHD I'm on the
Spectrum in in the ADHD sense because of this sense of you know not being able to concentrate for example so do you think there's anything that we can do maybe from a regulation perspective or even if it's just practical things you know to do with limiting our exposure to this reward hacking thing what are your views on all that yeah I wish I had it hacked myself I think there's I guess there's two things there's like yeah there's just discipline and setting rules for yourself you know like not taking your phone into the bedroom for example trying not to scroll just before you go to bed or like first thing when you wake up in the morning some sort of regulation for yourself around it just to feel like you're the master of it rather than it's master of you um but also on a deeper level like any addiction there's a reason for it and what is it that you're avoiding In Yourself by scrolling for hours often you might feel bored you might
feel lonely you might feel anxious and the phone is numbing you so if we can start to let in those feelings and sit with them and get more comfortable with those things then the need to numb it all with the with the scrolling hopefully goes at the same time I think like we because of technology and the advancers we just have so much time on our hands and it's it's not natural like we're supposed to be hunting and sleeping and surviving and that's like the point of our lives and now we just have so much time and we're living like doubly as long like what are we supposed to fill it with so there's something about purpose and meaning and like what drives your day if you have too much space in your day you're going to fill it with something so trying to find like healthy productive purposes for your time yeah and I guess like a lot of us are inherently lazy when you're trying to fill your time with something the first
thing there is your mobile phone you're like oh there's a whole world there I'm going to go to that like it's to Jack's point about you know watching videos about addiction phone addiction like there's been a boom recently of mobile apps that are all about locking down your phone which I find fascinating there's like a whole industry now which is like hundreds of millions of pounds and hundreds of million of downloads of people just downloading phone apps to lock your phone away so you can't use your phone like it's actually Bonkers so much so that I am trying to develop an app right now that does the exact same thing with because it's like I there using my phone constantly for no reason I know it's not good for me my attention span is shrinking I'm like I need an nap to lock this phone away really the answer probably is to just get rid of my phone or something like that but I I can't do it it's like the ring and Lord of
the Rings like I don't want to get rid of the precious like it's just even though I know it's bad for me but yeah I don't know what we do about it like it's it's really tricky I think we're seeing a lot more regulation come into play like I've seen in like some of the Nordic countries they're banning they just went up to 15 years old to use social media lots of schools are starting to ban phones in the school and all this kind of stuff but yeah I'm not really sure what it is one thing that we've started to see is you know a change to wearables so rather than having this phone that is so addictive takes all of your attention I've seen people say that you know there's meta just release these smart glasses which does a lot of your phone capabilities but you just wear the glasses and you talk to an AI assistant and I guess the theory is there you're less like holding something completely engaged and distracted by
something it's more kind of complimentary to your life or you're seeing the world and when you want to you can engage on top of that with these smart glasses that kind of have like an Alexa style thing in there to support I don't know if that's going to be the solution but it's like something they're talking about I guess yeah I guess one of the problems is like we we're so dependent on our phones to function like I think I have like a fantasy of just having like a brick phone again but actually I need maps and like my like my cards and just like everything that your phone is there for like maybe you could have two phones one for like scrolling in social media and like YouTube and all of that and then one for like like practical day-to-day functions and if there was a way to only allow certain apps on each then maybe then you don't have your scrolling phone with you the whole time but I don't know if that's
possible to separate out yeah I mean I can talk from experience I actually tried that exact strategy before so I had a had a really old phone that I would basically keep in the bedroom and use that from like 9:00 p.m. on with so I wouldn't be I'd try and not be distracted by all the the other apps on there and I'd just use it for you know maybe I was going to watch CU I often watch kind of long re form things before going to sleep or something so I would just try and separate the two and then the phone broke so I did it for a little bit and then and then I stopped because of that and yeah it's I agree this is this feels like a very unsolved problem right it's got it's gotten so bad I think you know I I personally take pride and when I do watch long form content I think this is good I'm watching a full movie I'm not going to look at my phone
because I find that interesting and I can watch it for 90 minutes without looking at my phone and I think that's great when actually what I'm doing is still being kind of lazy and not doing anything but the fact that I'm not scrolling and getting this constant dopamine hit cycle I I feel a bit a bit proud of it so it's it's kind of got to that level where I'm rewarding myself with that um I think we maybe we should talk a little bit about this this web three stuff now right because you know we are we are nominally a web 3 podcast and I'm interested maybe if we just get your um starting point so what do you know about web 3 right now because if not we can talk about it and we can kind of find a middle point but yeah have you heard of the term what what do you think about it if if anything I know that Alec really likes web 3 and that is all I know about
an his eyes just like dilay to be like it's a trap they've got me something about blockchain maybe Bitcoin that's that's as good a definition as I I've heard to be honest I mean why do you have a go there now like if you if you like it so much apparently why don't you try and just give the intro to to web 3 and we'll go from there I we've been doing this for a year and a half now and we've had like maybe 50 guests trying and Define it and what we found is pry tricky to Define and there's not very many good definitions I think that like this particularly applies because of your social media influencer kind of background so it's kind of like in the the Paradigm right now of social media you're in a lot of ways beholden to like say the Instagram the Tik Tok of the world and like you kind of have to do what they say right to kind of monetize or get engagement all this kind
of stuff and there's a data privacy angle there where they're The Gatekeepers to everything this web three Paradigm is kind of like an advancement of Technology right now where more kind of onus and ownership is pushed to the individual so you own your account you own your data you take take a percentage of the cut of the social media engagements you get you actually determine maybe how the social medias run like this is kind of like one of the fundamentals is if you're a participant and you want to say the main contributors to say Tik Tok like you are then you actually get a saying how Tik Tok is run and what the underlying fundamentals of Tik Tok are how they do Jack is that okay it's lovely I mean I think I think you have hit on the main thing that I would here right I think web web 3 so I would Define it as kind of it's this collection of Technologies including blockchain as you said and I think we you know
Alec and I Define it as including AI as well so all that stuff we mentioned before is also in the conversation and it's a collection of technologies that are basically trying to improve ownership improve the ability for people to to reap more rewards from what they provide to the World online basically so the more the more you do online as you know as a content creator this obviously will will hopefully resonate with you a little bit but to be able to to get more of what you deliver return to you in value right so instead of it being all kind of monetized behind your your back but also beyond the Mone ation ownership aspect I think another stream of it is in the thinking is in privacy and security as well so there are lots of Technologies about you know how do I how do I maintain better privacy online how do we reduce the risk of data breaches for example by changing how much data is stored where basically so I think there are
there are definitely things um that that apply from both those contexts to to the kind of mental health profession like you mentioned earlier the almost doing therapy online and delivering kind of these services online helps some people potentially because it's a bit more abstract it's like it's talking to a computer is not as scary as talking to someone in person maybe and I think that's where maybe some of the security things could help that I can imagine being able to do things in a more Anonymous fashion as well so not be even if you want to a little bit like I guess how the Samaritans might work where you have an anonymous service but yeah based on that description is there anything in there that's resonating does that all sound like that rubbish to you I'd be interested to know yeah L it's definitely about the algorithms on social media because as a Creator they are just the bane of my life they're they're completely closed and there's constant rumors and videos about oh they've
changed the algorithm and now uh you know Instagram is putting out one minute videos as opposed to 5-sec video so then everyone quickly changes how they make their content and then actually that's not true or maybe it is true or it's happened to me that you'll be growing and growing and growing and then suddenly something in the algorithm changes and suddenly your stuff just not being shown to new people so something about like having no control and it being dictated by this kind of like anonymous source so is is the idea of web three that this is going to change into this like new thing or it's changing already it's fascinating that because we've always talked about this academically about social media influencers thinking that that's a neat like a thing they want it's actually nice to know that it is something that is true and you don't want to be beholden to these like AI algorithms that black box that no one knows about but yeah that is like a fundamental premise it's like
the idea of kind of decentralized governance is one of the ways it's kind of also described like you have these things called Dows where it's like the entities that contribute the most to these platforms they're the ones that also help with the governance and like the governance is done in quite a transparent way so there's a project called Blue Sky which is kind of like a a new paradigm for social media where you know if you are on Blue Sky and you the Twitter or the Instagram equivalent and you're generating lots of content lots of traffic everyone's looking at you as a content creator all of a sudden you have a bigger stake in the network and you can kind of think of that as like a a percentage control of the network like a percentage in the company of blue sky so if they're like you know we're going to change the algorithm you get to vote on that potentially and be like oh no I don't want to change the algorithm or you
know I actually don't like that the algorithm prioritizes fear and greed I want an algorithm that prioritizes hope and happiness because that's what I think is good for the world and then you get to put your percentage vote towards that I think it's kind of a lot of it is kind of Airy fairy in a lot of ways but like there are there's good examples of dows working in practice right now where the community that is involved in the system is actually the one governing the system rather than this gatekeeper that is Instagram at the top of everything ruling them all so it's kind of like democracy in a way because at the moment it's a total dictatorship like there's just like a room of people who are deciding who we didn't vote on EX how the rules work um exactly that's a good way to describe it but it's like yeah it is kind of like democracy but I guess like yeah you're the one of the one of the Beauties are that you
get more involved because you kind of think of it as having accountability and ownership you feel more attached to it so it also makes you want to succeed more in that app yeah it's quite a beautiful thing so are you going to invest in Bitcoin now like I asked I'm investing in Bitcoin you is this because your your partner told you too I told him too ex I can't believe you just admitted live on a that you've given Financial advice I would never do anything like that yeah I think for me that that's always been one of the things that I was most excited about about the the lofty promise of web 3 and to be clear it is very much still a promise I think I don't think this stuff's been cracked at all especially on the the replacing the algorithms themselves I think you know we're we're a long way off that this everything is still dominated by the same kind of group of Silicon Valley Giants Etc but the ethos is there
right it is meant to be making these things more transparent or replacing them with this kind of with the people often talk about as decentralized right or democratized governance process so I think you you kind of hit the nail on the head there the other thing that I've seen a lot of people talking about in the last year especially with chat gbt coming out and obviously we've touched on this but I think there's a bit more to talk about here is on actually using AI in two different contexts so and you drew the distinction between these earlier the loneliness kind of epidemic we've got as well as the delivery of of mental health so maybe we stick with the loneliness one first I've seen a lot of people positing chat Bots as a solution to this epidemic right so basically saying whether it's for old people in a nursing home and giving them someone to talk to I mean old people have alexes now in there so we're kind of already starting that process of
having someone they can interact with but people want to take it a bit further and give them someone that they can just talk to maybe you know even if they know it's uh a robot underneath the hood it gives them something to hold on to so what do you what do you think about that as a prospect do you think that is the the magic bullet that people are thinking of or do you think there there's issues with that uh it feels very depressing and I can't say why I guess it's like I don't know I believe sometimes it like there's too much advancement there's too much technology like I just saw a bunch of like Hollywood stars are signing to try to not have a chat GPT version or like a darly version of the writer strike thing right they're worried that like because a lot of actors right now they only need like a bit of transcript and them saying a few things in a certain ways and they can just CGI their
entire career basically and never pay them again so it's a big Fear Factor for them exactly yeah it's like it's it's replacing human creativity and art and in the same way with the like the retirement home example it's like there's so many other solutions that don't have to be technology I saw a really lovely video of they put a care home and a kindergarten next to each other and the kids would all go and visit and developed really nice relationships with the old people it's like an intergenerational thing kids love old people old people love kids they it would light up their face you know they loved it that seems like a really connective human solution to a problem than you know you get lots of things in retirement homes where people are sent in to do kind of entertainment and exercise and things like that what if you just cut all of them and put a robot in in all of their rooms like it feels cold even if the robot is able to
provide some sort of connection I think there's just something like to your core that you know it's not real it's like paying for sex you know like yes you are having the sex but are you feeling loved and are you feeling connected and intimate like that it might feel good in the moment but part of you probably knows that it's not quite real I feel that way about robots replacing human connection like it might tick all of the boxes but it's like The Uncanny Valley you know like the closer it is to human the more creepy and weird it is and like yeah it doesn't sit right with me but I'm up for there being some sort of positive use of it in the therapy space yeah I think I think I'm I'm kind of in a similar position on this right it's I have the suspicion that there is practical value to be had from some of this and but the practical value is because it's a way of avoiding solving it by other
means right it's like the classic we have the resources to solve World poverty there's just not the incentives to do so and I feel like that's the same with lots of things you know the loneliness epidemic with the elderly if you take them as one sub subset for now for this example I feel like adding these chat based robots into the world is a way of practically kind of uh plugging the hole for a short period of time and helping while there isn't the the care they need or or the the resources or these other Creative Solutions but you know is it dangerous to then do it because it means you then keep avoiding the problem you keep U kicking the can down the road a little bit so yeah it's it's it does smack of quite a dystopian future for me yeah and then you've got the other side of it where people are kind of as as we mentioned almost wholesale saying we could replace therapy with AI chat Bots and all this
stuff which yeah to me sounds like a very bad way to go for the reasons you described earlier right yeah I think I I would jump in on this and just say like it seems like again we talked about a short-term solution but like it's quite it's kind of a reflection of failure on Humanity it's like he we can't fill this Gap we'll just plug in a tech solution to do it and in in my mind I'm like that's a failure of society and also on the other side it's kind of like a a bit disrespectful to what humanity is at its core because you're like oh actually a robot can do this as well and you're kind of like well what is it to be human if a robot can do all these things that kind of think as as quite core human abilities to feel to empathize to care like if if a robot can do that to the point where it actually adds a lot of value like well what is it
to be human anymore is there any distinction and I feel like that kind of It kind of May creates a bit of friction between you know what we think of as a purpose in life but it's really tricky like it's really gets really philosophical this stuff is like if it solves the problem why not do it yeah exactly but also it doesn't solve the problem it's like technological advancement is really useful in areas where we need growth so climate change throw all of the technology at that problem like great but getting things to be to act like humans like humans have already developed that we've already had our own evolutionary development to become like the empathetic social creatures that we are we don't need any help with that what we need help with is being freed to to use those skills ourselves not having something replace replace that for us and I think sometimes it's just like growth for growth sake like let just develop develop develop and then suddenly AI has taken over all
of creative spaces and like what who wanted that why are we doing that and I think there's no reflection it's just like growth growth growth growth growth this that was a perfect segue on something I wanted to ask you about so you talked about growth growth growth and like we can't just growth growth growth when we don't we have like limited resources right and a limited space and all this kind of stuff on the earth that's one of the problems of the sustainability crisis we're having right now we've seen some work and some people pose the idea idea that the metaverse and this virtual reality is kind of a solution to that and because you know now we've pushed this idea of capitalism and growth is absolutely required constantly for the economy and all this kind of stuff and Society to grow but rather than do it in the physical world we can start to do in the in the virtual world which has less potentially ecological impact on the world and this is something
I see a lot of people pushing towards have you ever thought about you obviously know about VR AR I think we've used VR together maybe but like have you ever thought about that in the kind of in your field like using it for therapy you talked about you know the screen being quite artificial and that creates a separation sometimes maybe with clients and therapists but you also get a bit of security by doing in your room imagine being able to like 3D see someone in this reconstructed world you're safe in your room but it also feels slightly more human what do you think about that yeah that that's that's really interesting I haven't thought about it but lots of ideas came into my mind as you were talking one would be like exposure therapies so there's there's an exposure therapy where whatever the person is iic of you might you know go to the zoo and like together look at a spider and then like feel the fear and process it and then hold the
spider and yeah exposure therapy and I guess with VR you could possibly use that as a way of coming against your fear and but knowing that actually it's not real and but it feels so real so you have all of the emotional triggers that's one another one that I thought of is there's a type of therapy which is called chair work which is where you put like somebody in your life in an imaginary chair in front of you and have the conversation that you wish you could have with them so whether this person is dead or alive or you have a relationship with them not you might you know finally have the conversation with your father that you never got to have for example and you say it to them and imagine that they're sitting in front of you however it's it's a bit it's never quite real because they're not actually in front of you and you're talking to an empty chair but it's really cathartic to kind of get all of those feelings
and thoughts out with VR you were saying like putting like an avatar of like someone's dead grandparents in the room like but with VR you could actually have a conversation with someone like and say it to them and then it might feel like you have you know yeah yeah I feel like we've covered three or four different uh Black Mirror episodes right all of these things n them I actually think are healthy but I'm just trying to think of creative uses for VR yeah so if we if we do kind of you know maybe not looking down Black Mirror but just to the Future in general you know we have all these different emersion Technologies with web 3 and and also the the various other fields that are advancing all the time what what do you think we need in the future landscape of technology to support mental health as a as a profession as a a goal for society is there anything you think that would be really great for us to achieve with
by technological means to kind of support that goal well I think as we've disc a circuit breaker or a cycle breaker for phone addiction or any sort of like scrolling addiction more than what already exists something that actually inhibits you from using your phone like your phone turns off completely or something just to to give people tools to really break the phone addiction um in terms of mental health I think there are there are tools that can be used places that can encourage reflection for example you could have a notification like how do you feel right now what's going on for you stop breathe really basic fundamentals of checking in with yourself and allowing space for feelings so that could be really helpful I guess my my real like answer to that question is less technology I think technology is terrible for our mental health like I really want to be on board with finding Solutions within technology but I think technology is the problem so it's like yeah switching it all off and talking
to people not neuralink other no Annie this is a technology podcast you're not meant to say that sorry I get you but it's kind of things like the point of technology has been very practical right how do I make things faster better cheaper all this kind of stuff just improve and I think the understanding and the and the focus of importance on Mental Health has only really existed maybe in the last like 10 years in my mind 20 years maybe in the general mindset like it that it's completely popularized and everyone knows the terminology everyone knows about mental health and all this kind of stuff so I think that there's kind of like a a lagard effect right now where we are going to see technology start to take that into account hopefully and we're definitely seeing it from like a governmental regulatory standpoint but even like Mental Health Services in the UK are nowhere near what the physical health services are and I hope there will be a change in focus it seems like
we're starting to see like the effects on children that are starting off with you know technology from like age two and three and I imagine there'll be more governmental regulation on this stuff and that'll affect both us societally but also the technology as well that it has to have certain limits has to have certain restrictions like phones now already allow you to track your usage which was a bit of a game changer well I never thought they'd do that because obviously there's no positive person who's been like oh I'm spending 10 hours a day on my phone great let's try and spend 11 tomorrow that's only had a negative effect and I think that has come from the regulatory standpoint so I am hopeful but we'll see what happens right at the end of the day a lot of the tech companies care about one thing and that's profit so it's It's tricky to know how it's all going to work together yeah I think no one stopped to think oh how is this actually
going to impact us on a psychological level it was all about exactly as you said convenience and making it faster and all of that and now we're seeing these consequences uh but it it almost feels like it's gotten too big that I can't imagine how it will change as fundamentally as it needs to I gonna say we we were so busy asking if it could be done we didn't ask if it should be done so yeah this is where we are now and then that bombshell no that is a good point to end to be fair I am hopeful I think overall technology has done much more for Humanity than it has you know detriment it and it is obviously saving so many lives overall but it's something that I think designers developers Builders have to be aware of is the psychological impact of the technology they're developing and I hope and think more and more we are going to see that but Annie thank you so much for joining us like I've learned so
much this has been such an enjoyable and insightful episode yeah we'll link your social accounts CU before I got off Instagram and Tik Tok and all those things I was following them all the time and I felt much better for it it's some of the hopeful content actually online some of the few hopeful contents online anyway um and yeah thank you for joining us wherever you may be and join us next time to entangle a little more of web 3
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto