Episode 87
Tech and Misinformation
About this episode
In this week's episode of Untangling Web3, we delve into the intersection of AI, misinformation, Web3, and social media—exploring how advanced technologies are reshaping the way we consume information and engage with politics.
From the promises of democratized information to the challenges of AI-driven algorithms, this conversation unpacks the evolving role of technology in our everyday lives and its implications for the future of truth and trust.
Key highlights
- The Evolution of Social Media and Algorithms. We discuss how social media transitioned from its early days of playful interaction to becoming the primary source of news and political discourse. Algorithms have optimized platforms to maximize engagement, often amplifying fear, hate, and greed, which studies show are the emotions most likely to keep users hooked. The unintended consequences of these algorithms have fundamentally altered how societies process and act on information.
- AI and Misinformation. The episode highlights how generative AI and advanced algorithms exacerbate the spread of misinformation. With AI’s ability to create convincing deepfakes and emotionally charged content, distinguishing between fact and fiction has become more challenging than ever. We touch on studies that show false political news spreads six times faster than factual content, creating an urgent need for better digital literacy and AI accountability.
- The Role of Web3 and Digital Identity. Blockchain technology and decentralized platforms like BlueSky offer potential solutions to the challenges of misinformation. Features such as transparent algorithms, user-controlled feeds, and cryptographic proof of identity are promising tools to counter the chaos of traditional social media. These innovations could restore trust in digital interactions while enabling more equitable control over online content.
The intersection of tech, AI, and social media presents both incredible opportunities and pressing challenges. While algorithms and AI have enhanced connectivity, they’ve also amplified misinformation and polarized discourse.
By integrating Web3 principles and fostering digital literacy, we can create a more transparent and equitable digital landscape. As these technologies evolve, staying informed and skeptical will be key. Thank you for joining us, and tune in next time as we continue untangling the complexities of Web3 and its role in shaping our digital future!
This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we're going to be talking about two of my favorite topics AI the obvious one but also politics and maybe have the two things overlap Jack how you doing today very well thank you it's nice that we're you know back recording in the studio in the New Year again thanks to Voss shout out to Voss for uh setting us up and the great team here for sorting us out the studio making us look very professional maybe more so than we deserve but yeah nice way to kick off 2025 back in the studio how are you how was your Christmas and New Year it was good I'm about 3 kilg heavier and the camera adds about 10 kogg so I'm a whopping 120 kgs right now it's a lot but yeah it's good I'm ready to be back um ready to start talking absolute nonsense again and maybe kicking off the show by you know going into how important politics is how important technology is for
politics and all this kind of stuff I said it's two of my favorite topics I do genuinely believe that or do that is generally true because you know politics influences absolutely everything it's how a kind of lives are run how money spent the access to facilities we have I think it's probably one of the most important things in people's lives day to-day I think a lot of people don't actually appreciate that around the world um and I also think that technology is playing such a huge role in you know politics typically through information maybe misinformation through voting basically I think it's technology has enabled you know well we live in a democracy but democracies to flourish and yeah I'm really excited to kind of go into that and then eventually talk about one of the you know most Cutting Edge technologies that we have today which is AI and how it's influencing all these things yeah 100% I think um I'm in a similar boat I I love technology obviously it's no surprise to anyone
um and I I am a follower of politics and I I when I was younger you know we're getting on a bit now ale right we're we're getting on the wrinkles are showing 4k camera we've realized how I'll be looking on these cameras um and I was definitely more politically active and interested um you know when I was in university for example um and I've kind of partly this kind of ties the two together actually because one of the big technological things that's changed in our lifetimes is our exposure to information generally and as we'll get on to the history but because we have so much exposure to social media information being bombarded dayto day that's actually the reason I've become more politically disengaged I was kind of i' I've stopped following every development that's going on in politics and I try and just get it a little bit more secondhand from a couple of let's say trusted sources or friends and family that kind of thing rather than having the constant notification so it's
an interesting way in for me because actually my experience of politics has already changed in the last few years from from technology yeah I mean you're right like I find a political discourse online depressing a lot of the time it's so polarizing it's not just in politics it's across like almost everything you can have an opinion on social media makes it polarizing um I've read read something recently you know I'm going to talk about this guy I think maybe multiple times but a lot of this this episode has actually been inspired in a lot of ways by a man called yuel Noah Harari he you probably know him he's the person that authored sapiens which is an incredible book and more recently Nexus which basically goes into the importance of information networks and you kind of see the relation of that to to politics and yeah a lot of this is inspired by him but yeah let's just go go into it like I said we live in a Dem Ry right you know both
new Flash new Flash yeah in the UK we live in democracy crazy um and yvo kind of describes the setup for democracies he's like he kind of um distills in a really nice way he's like a democracy is a conversation it's about multiple parties just having a conversation and agreeing to some outcome you know many different outcomes in a lot of cases very different to dictatorship orth authoritarian regime is one person basically pushing everything to other people and saying this is the decision I'm going to do it you action this whereas democracy is many people trying to come to some kind of consensus here we go got a web already and he was like well back in early days back in the early days it was very easy to do five people conversation's easy with a 100 people very easy with a small village easy you can have this conversation but when we start to go past the scale of say nation states like Athens ancient G or kind of ath Sparta all these kind
of nation states within ancient Greece say two to 3 thousand years ago it actually becomes quite difficult to have that conversation how do you propagate information quickly enough accurately enough between nation states across how do you scale it how do you scale it exactly scalability question comes in and how do you make sure that there's no problems in that scaling the kind of the coms that's going across and he basically says to have democracies at the size we have now say you know the UK the us all these kind of things you need technology like the printing press for example to disseminate information efficiently effectively at scale and in a trustworthy way yeah exactly the printing press is a good one to bring in here because when you think typically of how democracies change right with elections and things like that then the amount of money that goes into campaigns advertising for different uh different parties different leaders of parties Etc um you see that the medium by which that advertising happens has obviously changed
to keep Pace with technology so yeah you literally had the the printing press doing this stuff you had radio television um and now obviously in in in modern day we have kind of hinting towards the social media type stuff as well which we'll come on to but yeah and it's interesting that technology has become not only part of the the method of changing and involving democracies because again you need technology to help scale things right that's why we're involving it that's why we're able to have democracies operate on such a large scale and you know I don't know what you think I'm I I subscribe to the is it the Winston Church opinion of like it's the Democracy doesn't work but it's the best we've got type thing right it's the best of the options available there's always going to be flaws in everything right and I think something that operates in this scale and is as impactful as we've already said politics is for people's everyday lives there's always going to be people that
are may be left behind or disadvantaged in certain ways especially when you're trying to manage 70 million people with a group of 200 300 people at the center of it um but yeah like we said like healthy democracies need communication to build ensus and you know previously say predating the internet and social media companies specifically we had newspapers radio television station so it was kind of like a few centralized parties in a way controlled the narrative with big influences into each of them exactly exactly so on the one hand that means there is this kind of this central point of accountability you'd had ways to kind of I guess hold them accountable to vet them potentially to regulate them maybe so you had like say the telegraph or these New York Times or whatever it is um but also you say then because there's a few of these entities and they're kind of The Gatekeepers in a way maybe they were politically biased maybe they were influenc like we can talk about many different newspapers
in the UK for example that are left wi rightwing all this kind of stuff but yeah I think there's pros which are obviously there's a degree of accountability there because they're corporations they're organizations they have shareholders blah blah blah but on the other hand it's probably maybe in a way easier to influence because there are only five big big newspapers in the UK for example and they obviously have their bias everyone has their bias um and then you know social media kind of completely Chang the game yeah and it's interesting because if you look at the kind of original promise and purpose of social media it was framed around the language of politics it was about democratization of freedom of speech essentially right and being able to democrati democratization of communication with one another with connection um with sharing information that kind of thing so yeah when was your first experience social media because I I think it must have been it must have been Facebook or maybe even something like MSN Messenger or something
like that right and but that was again within our within our lifetimes these platforms and again that's a word I want to highlight right we've moved from the corporation to the platform as being one of the major players in uh in in political discourse but yeah if you go back to the the start it was just this fun cutesy I'm G to you know I would have been probably well I don't don't want to say anything that'll say I violated terms of service but I probably was about 12 or 13 when I was using when I was first using social media and it was just very fun you chat with your mates at school maybe some family and friends and things or if you want if you wanted to add them and then you had all kind of mini games like habo hotel or what was the Farmville right that kind of thing it was a nice place to be okay and it was fun ultimately and that's definitely I don't think anyone described social
media as that in 2025 yeah well I I had bio and Myspace back in the early days where it was super simple right it was like I think I got in like 2008 or something like that but it was kind of go to this idea the web one Web Two model you're posting stuff there's not much interaction I think the reason it was so cutesy is because the people that were using it were kids right they were like late teenagers or early kind of 20s I mean in our case maybe younger than that as well so they were doing it to play games to have fun to talk to friends like there was no kind of hidden agenda there but as these people started to you kids grew up basically and started to understand the value of social media and connection all this kind of stuff and maybe became more political as part of that and you know the numbers obviously skyrocketed to five billion you know social media users um in 2023 all of
a sudden there was kind of more agenda there there was actually you know even companies decided to say well actually you know we can start to influence these people this is actually a voting power all this kind of stuff so maybe that's why it became a bit of a well a free-for-all and less kind of cutesy funsy there are a lot of Pros though let's like let's not undermine the massive amount of advantages social media has created like you get more sides to every story it does really democratize anyone can be a newslet if they want to so you get more sides to every argument every kind of all the discourse also faster I saw a thing on X recently where it was like comparison of say X versus traditional news media Outlets obviously a traditional news media outlet has to be has to be you know printed all this kind of stuff so it takes a while to go through the process it's kind of more centralized right whereas I on my camera can
film something and put it up instantly so the time to actually get these these news these events online and into the kind of the sphere of influence is very short so it's much faster yeah and I think that highlights the key point and transition from again the corporation to the platform as the source of of news for people in general because again news and politics are pretty much interchangeable as well right politics follows news news follows politics blah in a circle um the way yeah as you said corporations typically heav heavily regulated you know in the UK you have something like ofcom for for regulating kind of TV and things like that um and the transition to platform has basically made as you said everyone the an individual news outlet and it's then the platform that may or may not have to be regulated not necessarily the individual right who's a contributor but there doesn't seem to be a huge I mean I'm not aware of the obligations of me and no again no one's
intentionally acting necess some people okay sure journalists use it people want to uh you know highlight things that are happening um but they're not necessarily considering themselves as as journalists they're just individuals they're they're observers right of the world they see but it can become news very quickly um yeah you're right the speed and and that's what we've seen I think probably happened around around kind of 20145 and onwards from there is that it transitioned from the first Port of Call being the traditional news media Outlets to social media and now I if I want to find something out as bad as it is I will go straight to X or something right yeah and then I'll go down the the rabbit hole of you know a bunch of tweets I didn't want to see but I will I will have seen what's actually happening and I think like to kind of bring that back to what was happening before it's because we had these news articles like the telegraph whatever it is and they
were a bit more vetted a bit more kind of institutional in a way um and you have this accountability that they're regulating all this kind of stuff people trusted them right you see news you see an article you trust it you think there's a degree of vetting you think the information there is probably real and all this kind of stuff um I actually have an anecdotal thing to say here I am sure I've noticed a huge uptick in the number of spelling mistakes on BBC sport in the last few years right and I think that's purely because they have the pressure put things out faster because I I you know used to read BBC Sport and I think this is very well written very well vetted now it's like speed is is the most important thing and so I see mistakes in there like on a daily basis which I never thought let's not pretend that this was like a kind of a holy grail of you know information like there was always bias there
all these kind of news outlets whatever they are printing presses had bias everyone has bias everything's ever created has some form of bias the main thing was about facts and is it real if say they give a stat that isn't true for example then there would be a degree of recourse that someone could say well you said this is true correct it blah blah blah and they would have to do that like ofcom would make sure they were regulated way was it perfect no but far better than say what we have now where you still have the bias probably much more bias I guess but also there's no easy kind of means or regulated means to actually hold things accountable like facts accountable like studies accountable this kind of stuff well I think it's important to mention the word fact as well right because there's an old adage um the the LI is halfway around the world before the truth's got trousers on it's so true because the truth is it has more I don't
want to use a Bitcoin analogy but it's kind of like there's a proof of work to it you have to authenticate and verify information before you put it out there um if you want to tell a lie you haven't got to do any of that work it's like it's like a civil attack on on information right so it's it's it's almost a feature of Truth Versus untruth that it travels faster and then I guess that leads us on to what's happened with the algorithms right well on that point like I saw there's a study by MIT in 2022 that basically emphasizes that point they found that false political news spread six times faster than factual news onx largely due to algorithmic amplification and now we're going to start to talk about the role of AIS and all this kind of stuff like we said that you know news outlets all this all this had they had bias and they're producing things and you know imagine if we had social media where everything's sequential you follow
a 100 people I jack posts at 10:00 a.m. someone else post at 10:30 a.m. and it's just sequentially posted on my feed but that's not how it works like we I've kind of touched on this a few times we actually have algorithms in the background that are optimizing people's feeds suggesting feeds all this kind of stuff and their whole goal is to basically maximize engagement maximize say Jack or eyes Jack or eyes Jack or my time on the app so I the whole kind of goal for this AI algorithm say on a social media platform is to ensure that we spend the most amount of time on that platform as possible and they don't really necessarily know exactly how they do it the inner mechanics of this it's basically go look at all the hundreds of millions of people that are using this treat them as guinea pigs AB test on everything work out what kind of information or what kind of things they want on their feed that will maximize their time on that
platform right and what we kind of found out to kind of I guess cut it short and give like the final result is that AI algorithms discovered that the gold mine of human emotions the human attention were three-fold fear hate and greed and it's not like people enjoy you know experiencing those emotions but it makes you stay on the platform it g gains your attention yeah I just not realized as you were saying that that two of those horrible emotions are included in like the the coin market cap index the fear and greed Index right for how the market is looking yeah it's um it's it's something that once you hear that finding right that observation about fear hate and greed being the main drivers of Engagement as soon as you hear it you think of course it's obvious it makes complete sense but you know it is something that 10 years ago we might not have known about ourselves except you know people have now worked it out and it's being and I saw
a really really interesting video around um Andrew Tate okay it's not one of his videos and I'm kind of I'm going to repeat this very sin um about to you know talk about now by by saying this but I think it's interesting so they're basically saying that what people like take do is real trolling and trolling I I was I was literally yesterday years old when I found out that trolling isn't to do with cave trolls it's to do with a me of method of fishing right so yeah it's it's it's basically the method where you put bait out on the back of a of a troller I think okay and you you you let the fish kind of Follow You Follow The Bait to a certain location so that's where trolling actually comes from and this is the mechanism they're using again we'll we we'll link the video in the description maybe but um the idea that people are putting things out their like tap that are deliberately incendiary that that is baiting people
to engage to that makes sense the troll link to clickbait okay yeah and and the bait is not to engage positively it's to engage and this it's trying to get people who disagree with him to voice that disagreement as vly as possible to share it to make reaction videos so I know again I'm talking about him now but just in the kind of meta context that people now farm for those precise emotions and it is created you know Andrew Tate has become one of the most well-known people on the planet and and that's and that's why because people have kind of fallen for that trap and I I don't we're not like going to go into psychology and all this kind of stuff but I kind of guess it's it goes to our base human instinct right it's like that's what you says in in in sapiens right he talks about this like we're not this why we have there's so much problems with like anxiety and depression all this kind of stuff at the
end of the day we are just programmed to survive we're not programmed to be happy so the things that charge us the most are the things that kind of could end that survival the idea of like fear and hate and all this kind of it's all very strongly linked to our core characteristics and on that point around you know emotionally charged content and all this kind of stuff there was another study that showed that you know emotionally charged language particularly fear and and outrage and all this kind of stuff it's 70% more likely to be shared than neutral content so yeah it's probably the reason that you know there's so much crazy things online because you know one thing is we have these AI algorithms that are amplifying it because you know they don't look at it as a problem for Humanity all they want to do is optimize the amount of time spent on there and then there's the whole thing around filtering should we filter this content freedom of speech versus you know
AI algorithms and what's positive to humanity and this is a whole kind of I guess this is a whole Hot Topic Hot Potato that is constantly being talked about and I guess we're going to talk a little bit about now yeah and and just while we touch on algorithms because again we want to dis dis disentangle algorithms from now ai and also those internal kind of instinctive impulses we have as humans so what's actually happening under the hood of social media platforms is obviously they have these algorithms that determine how the platform works right it's not people manually working out that's why we have the infinite scrolling timelines now is they've worked out how to populate that timeline yeah in a way that's going to keep us on there for longer the algorithms you basically have um you have ranking algorithms like the most famous one being Google's page rank um but there kind other modifications of that and different platforms use different ones but that's what basically how you rank content on the platform
and then you have recommender algorithms which basically pick a user so say you know Twitter's looking at me or X is looking at me and saying what does this guy want to see or really what is this guy God no um what what is this what is going to keep this guy on the platform longer right and those are the kind of algorithms that are involved now you have I just mentioned Tate is hacking those algorithms by you knowing potentially how they work and knowing the the psychological side that goes into them so how how things be ranked well if they're ranked by engagement what gets the most engagement has to be that thing then you also have those recommender systems that are talking you know directly to me and saying what do I want that might be taking information from many many different sources right this is where we talked about the whole data Brokers this is the you know is is Siri listening to me in the background all the time why am
I getting advertised Adidas shoes because I mentioned Adidas to my friend right it's that kind of stuff so there's there's lots of different inputs that can go to these algorithms as well um and this is all before the Advent of proper the scary kind of uh Advent of AI in this context as well today's episode is sponsored by the vchain foundation now we often talk about how emerging Technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and vchain is at the Forefront of this green movement with initiatives like V better let's take a closer look imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets these verified records build a massive Collective impact benefiting people through their own actions sound a bit complex but vchain made it fun explore our apps at v better.com v Chain's goal is to a new era of Sustainable Solutions so if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day go check out v.com to find out more
and now back to the show I think that the like not the the problem but the kind of the issues that people are starting to highlight is one like the user attention like what is negative content and again all of this is so subjective what is negative content what's good what's bad so we're not going to give an opinion on on that stuff but some people are now saying that one of the problems is that a lot of negative content is being promoted on these things because not because of the freedom of speech stuff like if you just say everyone has absolute right to say whatever they want in the platform but purely because of the algorithm that Jack just spoke about being highlighted being pushed to the Forefront because it is Click baiting because it's kind of touching on those fear receptors that's the one part the other part is the lack of transparency like you kind of said there that maybe the Andrew Tates of the world have worked out what is the
thing that's going to the top of the feed but we don't actually know right and I think some of the times I guess they have data but I guess even the corporations that are running these things don't necessarily know they've gone on and said you maximize engagement put the posts that will make Jack stay on the algorithm stay on the platform for as long as possible and they have so many data points it's really hard for them to work out why something is being recommended they can probably work it out through data and show some things but really it's very hard to keep up with and they're the two big problems lack of transparency and what is actually being promoted may be negative yeah I agree that that's a really interesting aspect to this is is the fact that you maybe the platforms don't even know maybe now ai is starting to do some of the recommendation algorithm itself right or is starting to inform how the algorithms are built even we don't quite know
I mean I know X when it was taken over they kind of Open Source some aspects of the um of their algorithms right they they did they did expose some of the logic but not all of it these are not open source by any means because these algorithms are both built upon and contribute to what is arguably the largest source of value for these companies which is their data sets right their data sets of that not just the content itself but also the user Behavior and the interactions between people right so those they're not going to expose how they're using those data sets they're not going to expose you know they might even if they expose some of the algorithm they're not going to give us that raw data that's secret source with Tik Tok like that had like I think maybe the best algorithm for getting people absolutely fixated I remember seeing like without going to the numbers it like took the most amount of data of any app I remember someone saying they
went into it and saw that Tik Tok was taking so much data from across all your different apps all your different mobile devices and again I don't know whether This is BS or not but that was one of the reasons why they think that Tik Tok has been removed because it was taking too much data and had too much information that was being exported to the company um but with all that data it made it extremely sticky it made it extremely addictive for you users so like we said we have these algorithms that working on say working like we're stting to humanize them even in our language we have these algorithms that have been set up by say the social media Giants of the world and they act as The Gatekeepers they're effectively determining what is seen what is heard what is prioritizes they're the king makers of the digital age like we said the reason this overlaps with politics so much is because information and good in well information is basically what enables democracies
to kind of work successfully flourish like it's a convers and if we have bad information or untrue information being propagated whatever then democracies can't necessarily succeed like I said another kind of way to think about this is you know back in the olden times we didn't know where our food was coming from so we're kind of genetically programmed to just eat as much food as we want whenever we can and we'll be fine right all of a sudden we have a lot of junk food coming into the world lots of high fats all this kind of stuff so that genetic programming if we kind of like dive into it will mean that we get obese we eat too much junk food and that's bad it's kind of the same with information we don't need all this junky information constantly being spammed to kill our serotonin and all this kind of stuff what we need is good healthy information and this is kind of where we get into the realm of what is the role of
a social media company in monitoring managing and maybe even preventing information from getting through like should they be just an open source anyone can say whatever they want or should they start to filter things and we've seen say Facebook used AI to downrank what they considered covid-19 misinformation we have Community notes on X for example these are all solutions that have been implemented to try and reduce the amount of misinformation yeah and I think when we're talking about politics specifically I think most people would point back to you know a very significant event involving the UK and Europe in 2016 where you know the cambage analytica Scandal came out and everyone found out okay that that I think that we don't know if that's the first instance of this happening but it was the the time that everyone realized okay political information is now social media is now being used as a primary way to influence elections which is not necessarily a statement about malicious intent that's just could be for advertising right but people
were using it seriously to win elections one way or the other but it was also the time that people realized that okay and you can abuse this power and you can abuse these systems yeah very very heavily to influence unduly elections Beyond those so we said the regulations on the media yeah well obviously you also have regulations on political parties in terms of donation campaign spending and that kind of thing and that maybe these were being subverted as well via social media and targeting and and things like that so I think that you know that's 2016 that was that's a long time ago now right it's a shockingly long time ago actually doesn't feel that long um that that's one of the first times people thought okay these are these are big issues just purely with social media and for me when you're talking about free and its impact on things like elections I I don't have a fully formed opinion yet on how I don't again it's a very difficult problem to solve but
my my opinion is that when platforms use algorithms to decide what's on the feed that's when it ceases to be a forum for Pure kind of free speech right and it becomes more like a product right they they're they're producing this feed as a product for you because free speech in my mind mind almost makes sense in a public form you're free to go outside and say what you want more or less that's there a whole another discussion but and we did have Forums on the internet we do have Forums on the internet which are kind of unmoderated to a large degree but you know less and less and we've moved from that Forum model where Free Speech has a direct analogy and just saying something into the open air yeah to this platform model where everything is being said but through this this filter of a product filter of a platform and then the question is right what are their responsibilities um I I personally you know I'm a I'm I'm a big believer
in free speech but equally am a strong proponent that I don't think plat I think that perfectly fine for platforms to have terms of service and to potentially censor things on their own terms because they're not necessarily there to provide a public forum and that's the distinct I don't think I think too many social media platforms have been trying to have their cake and eat it by pretending they're public forum but without actually uh operating as one yeah and I guess this kind of like tricky it's like what is their responsibility at the end of the day these are private companies right they are products like we should always think of them in my mind as products like who say who is say a government to say you need to meet the standards in this in what a lot of ways is a private network of your users right is it a public forum is it a basic human right and that's kind of the conversation we're starting to move towards is actually a lot
of people are starting to consider these as basic human rights and all of a sudden then they're held to a higher degree of accountability than it would if it was a private product and private operation and you're no longer just accountable to your shareholders you're also accountable to governments and things like this and that kind of distinguish well that that the kind of the line is quite gray on what are their responsibilities right and like you say they've been having their cake and eating it saying you know there's been a transition over the last like few years to say okay we've banned lots of what we consider undesirables or governments undesirables but I don't agree with that I actually don't think people should have been banned I think they saying everyone has a right to freedom of speech I think the problem isn't around you know do people have the right to freedom of speech it's this problem with Filter like you say what's being prioritized like it's not freedom of speech if saying someone
who's saying one thing gets you know times one views and someone is saying another thing is getting times 10 views ex it's like saying you're free to speak in this empty room over here versus you're free to speak to this Hall full of people exactly so if we agree on that then the question becomes how do we filter because it's clear there needs to be some filter and like blue sky has kind of started to get around this with having like well one option is to have just sequential feeds or whatever I just follow 10 people and the only things I see is those 10 people now obviously there's going to be an effect there on user engagement like it doesn't trigger those hate receptors or whatever but is that a better way to do it like unsure I think the how to filter I think we agree that the filter needs to be more transparent adapted but the filter is much more ambiguous and subjective and difficult to kind of get ahead own there's
no way some regulator is going to come in and be like these are the standards do this like that just doesn't make sense yeah and I think one thing I wanted to pick up there particularly is you're mentioning um one that actually it was going to be about the the kind of global nature of all of these social media platforms and how you comply with a million different rule sets in a million different country right it blows my mind that people like mattera people like Google are even able to comply with you know gdpr in the in in Europe at the same time as they are you know different data regulation different countries they they have to have they again this is where technology kind of comes to to the aid and to save the day for uh politics and information in general because they have found ways to you know create these incredible centralized but distributed systems that serve different views of the content to people in different countries that PR in theory I
Haven invested it myself but in theory uh obey and and um abide by the local jurisdiction laws right because people take it very Ser if you're a big company if you're a publicly traded tech company um in Silicon Valley or something you're you're definit you've definitely got a big compliance team who's working on making sure that you are obeying these rules and for me it blows a mind that it even happens right that they're even able to solve these problems and it is all with these incredible distributed systems and database technology that you know goes a little bit above my head sometimes um but yeah I just wanted to pick pick up on that point because we're just talking about another it's very similar to data privacy it's just about freedom of speech law it's a different type of law it's a different type of Regulation that is jurisdiction specific that is the problem is it's much it's much less clear right I think and how in how these platforms should be treated and every
everyone's starting to get an opin now lots of countries are starting to say well X should be a forum or X should be a private platform with terms of service that can or cannot be violated and therefore you know kicked off the pl that kind of thing so but everyone's disagreeing with it and how they respond yeah is is different yeah and I think like I don't want to go too much into this because it kind of gets into the whole realm of like conspiracy theories and all this kind of stuff but it's I think a big thing is like we saying we know that social media filters and what's being put to the top of someone's feed has a big impact on what they see which is their opinion which then affects how they vote and what happens in the country right and then all of a sudden you start to have saying foreign actors that will influence potentially those feeds to get to gain over say political opponents whatever and this has been
something that SED to be highlighted by you know actual studies I think Microsoft did a massive one about the number of bots that some countries were using to say manipulate elections and all of a sudden then you say Okay so how do we start to control these or whatever and should they control these are they private companies what whatever whatever but yeah I guess the question is what do we do like It's Tricky it really is tricky and I think this it kind of gets into the realm of like having accountable AI to you know readable ai ai that is understandable and on the one hand one thing I think that should be offered is this something that's been pushed by Blue Sky for example is the idea of algorithmic choice you go in as a user and you can select say what kind of content you want how things are prioritized what kind of feeds you have rather than the system we have right now which is just a bit of a black box
and it's kind of default and it will just prioritize the things that keep you glued to the screen for as long as possible yeah I think um it it it's a nice kind of initial step um the problem for me is that okay also unless you get big adoption of these kind of blue sky like social networks yeah then we haven't solved the problem but also the what the major social media platforms do currently and those algorithms again we we said at the start they provide a really good experience right it's an experience that we seem to want to have and to enjoy and is incredibly quick and gets us all the information very quickly as well as all the memes and everything um it does it very well and if you look at something like blue sky right now the alternative is is relatively primitive right so it's it's it's not going to replicate necessarily that experience right away it might do in the future but also you need literacy about things like llms
or algorithms themselves and no one's going to be able to pass them like most people who use blue sky will not be able to pass and understand what the algorithm they even choose is doing they can understand the high level description but they can't verify themselves right and there's that that separation of trust but we have that in the banking system right when we use when we use mobile internet banking right there's always going to be that and I don't have an issue with that um one thing I just wanted to mention while we're talking about AI though is I it just crossed my mind as we were preparing for this episode that again everything we've just said more or less in the last half an hour has been could have been just directed at social media platforms and algorithms which are not necessarily AI now we've got really really good generative Ai and we've got great models behind them and you know it's not just going to be LMS in the future there's going
to be extrapolations of this you know from AI agents to things that are not just about you know generating uh content but you know purely decision-making engines um I'm interested in think wondering if we have these platforms currently experimenting with them maybe they're building AI into you know they're asking an AI to write the next algorithm right if they have them doing that and they're giving them all the data sets are these AI algorithms just going to spit out things that are like optimized versions that have learned from the very worst traits of what's been happening right so if they if if you take an AI now and it looks at Twitter or looks at X and you say write me a really performant algorithm to recommend content and and retain people better it's probably going to take those things that jual Noah Harari has identified about them maybe identify sweet spots for them and make it that much worse so I'm wondering if like it's gonna it's gonna kind of be a a negative
feedback loop of of of of um of those primitive right the wor fees the wor and helps us do that that was something that cross my mind I hadn't thought about before I'm quite worried about well is it's interesting I know the term that's being used constantly as AI agents and what role would they play and all this kind of stuff and there's a black mirror episode kind of related to this the idea of this um cartoon character style person getting elected and a lot of the stuff there is promoting fear greed like these negative emotions we said they kind of like stimulating humans and like you say if an AI agent it's not too crazy to think of in 50 to 100 years time the idea of an AI agent being potentially a political figure that is based on all this information knows that the things that humans are currently responding to based on social media are negative fear hate all this kind of stuff and what kind of world do we live in
where that is the foremost driver of political discourse the scary world I guess and then it's kind of like I've seen this often touted as like a the re the thing to do AI obviously has got a lot of scary things a lot of good things what we need to make sure is the good guy have the best AI and then he brings into question what is good what is bad like it you don't really know um I'm not really sure what the answer is to be honest is scary like as AI agents are built on more and more data publicly available data that will be social media data and like we're saying right now the things that are prioritized on social media feeds which makes up probably the 90% of things on there are based on those negative receptors that we've talked about already yeah I think you know I I guess we're looking now what is the path forward right how do we operate in this new regime where we have big social
media platforms that are being operated in a more kind of wild west way than ever before potentially we have algorithms that have been building and learning how to control what we see for years and how to put us in silos or show us what we need to for years or dominate certain discourses in politics and things and now we have ever improving AI right so what's the path forward and yeah I like you I do not have a good answer I think it's really refreshing actually to sometimes just not have a strong opinion thing and in a world where chat gbt can give you an answer for any question you've got then you may as well just you know that's that's what you can do as a human what is to is human said to just be like you know as as they do and even like the quality of the misinformation like the you know talked about like deep fakes and completely changing like our ability to verify what is real what is not
real like that is I mean it's had an effect already and it's going to continue to have an effect I think that maybe getting back to some kind of like trusted route of things like I don't I think there is like an Optimum in between the previous idea of like centralized news outlets and all this kind of stuff and verified content and what we have now is anyone can say anything I think there is kind of a middle ground where but a lot of this comes down to education right you T teach people what AI can do teach people how social media algorithms work like again that comes as transparency we need to know how they work we more kind of transparency in how they work and then teach people the pros and cons of these so hopefully people can actually understand what is what the good is what the bad is and come to their own decision in a healthier manner than what we've got now um and I start to see this there's
a lot of initiatives in obviously it's always Scandinavia I think it's in Finland where 15 years rather than right now our kind of education system is breaking down being like AI is going to revolutionize everything destroy education system blah blah blah what they're doing is teaching people the pros and cons how you can use it what some of the downsides are and trying to help them come to a middle ground where it's like actually I need to be able to verify content because it's so easy to spin up whatever I want and it might not always be true yeah I I 100% agree a lot of this is beyond obviously regulation and arming the good guys with the good AI whatever that means as you said um yeah education is huge and I don't think it's I I I 100% agree with you in educating on llms digital literacy all this stuff is huge but I think one of the most important things you can do now is just to focus on educ around just
critical thinking skills right I I've always thought one of the most valuable things I've ever been taught or one of the most valuable coures I've ever had was like my my my school history classes right like gcca level that's true because one of the big components is like these Source papers and you have to critically analyze okay what was a situation in Germany in 1940 but they give you primary sources secondary resources ter resources you learn about how to come to a conclusion based on the fact that there are many different opinions many different agendas at play in in telling a story and I think everyone should know those everyone should just be made aware of uh the fact that a story can be spun up for you based on any number of of competing interest right and and that's all you really need to know just be skeptical I think just that if that's my takeover message to the audience right is just always approach things with maximum skepticism and have a high bar
for being convinced by them 100% I think everything's a data point at the end of the day and some should have more waiting than others but don't let social media or AI dictate those waiting for you you've got to come up with your own waiting and take them as data points basically yeah I guess it's not all doom and gloom I think I am very optimistic for the future if the good AAS but yeah I think like I say politics in my mind is one of the most important subjects or one of the most important Realms that everyone should be interested in and I think social media and Ai and the AI algorithms that control social media is also an absolute huge topic and I think the overlap of these two things is extremely kind of important and weighted and people should be aware of what's going on underneath the surface and maybe V everything they read and don't trust anything even what we say don't trust what we say or better yet just switch
it all off once in a while that's my advice digital detox um but yeah this has been a fun episode I guess we'll talk about this a lot more because this is a constantly fluxing and evolving subject thank you for listening wherever you may be and join us next time to entangle a little more of web 3
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto