Episode 42

Sustainability in Web3 with Antonio from @vechainofficial

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of Untangling Web3, Jack and Alec sit down with Antonio Senatore, CTO at @vechainofficial Foundation, to dive deep into the realm of sustainability within the Web3 ecosystem.

Antonio shares his extensive background in blockchain and IT, emphasizing the transformative power of blockchain in addressing global sustainability challenges.

Through a detailed discussion on the inception and evolution of VeChain, Antonio highlights the platform's commitment to leveraging blockchain technology for real-world sustainability solutions, from anti-counterfeiting and track-and-trace systems to digital identity and beyond.

This conversation also explores the critical role of decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) like VeBetterDAO in fostering community-driven sustainability initiatives, showcasing how Web3 technologies can create a more transparent, accountable, and sustainable digital world.

Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://chat.openai.com/g/g-P2iObFBNS-vebetterdao-pal

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

A sustainability challenge cannot be solved vertically. It has to bring everyone together. So, we need to create an ecosystem where everyone is together. What we're trying to do at V chain create an ecosystem where all sustainability apps and behavior are brought together into one ecosystem. Either you're walking or you're studying, you're learning because that's a sustainable behavior. You're getting better in anything you do. You're recycling. You're taking the It's your decision, by the way. And you are incentivized for that. And then you're like, hold on a minute.

Sustainability is good for me. Welcome to another episode of the Entangling Web3 podcast. Today, we're delighted to have Antonio Senatore on our podcast. Antonio serves as the CTO of the V chain Foundation, where he leads the technical direction team. His background is extensive with 20 years in blockchain and IT working for giants like Deloitte, Accenture, and Deutsche Bank. Our discussion today will focus on Antonio's efforts in promoting sustainability in the Web3 ecosystem and his work at V chain. Antonio, it's a pleasure to welcome you to the show.

Thank you, Alec. It's a pleasure being here. Thank you for having me. Hi, Antonio. Really nice to have you on the show. How are you doing today? Hi, Jake. Nice to meet you. I'm good. I'm good. Thanks. Very excited to be talking to you guys. Awesome. Yeah, really good to have you on. I think it's very important topic to to discuss around sustainability in Web3. It's often one of the the stumbling blocks that people have had around things like Bitcoin and its energy consumption. So, I'm really excited to get into what you're doing at V chain and how you're addressing that.

But before we do dive into all that, can you just give us a quick summary of your early career? There are some big names on your CV as as Alec said, Accenture, Deloitte, and and and the likes. Can you just tell us about what led you into Web3? Yeah, I'm good until I joined V chain, but as a background, I'm a computer engineer from from Milan, Politecnico di Milano. I'm not from Milan, but that's where I got my degree. I studied even high school as with a specialization in computer science.

So, I've been coding since I was probably 14 or something like that. So, I'm a technologist by heart, really. My first experience that was a bit of a startup up at then was Accenture in Italy. It was more into the technology footprint of Accenture rather than consulting. Was delivering, back in the days, large Java enterprise applications, which was the big thing. Server-side applications we used to call. It was the first time where we would see the web transforming itself into delivering application rather than hypertext only, which is relevant to blockchain, by the way, this stuff because blockchain is an evolution of the web.

And then moved to Ireland after many years there in Accenture and did a couple of startups where I learned a lot about, again, web services and lightweight applications. How do we deliver services on the web effectively? How do we construct services together for many years? Then I moved to Deloitte for many years in Deloitte. In Deloitte, I've been 11 years. It's been probably the largest place where I've been to. It's also the place where I've been the I was initially leading big data capabilities. Uh uh back in the day it was a name.

Was something big data. And it still is. It meant uh talking about 2010 until 2021, pretty much, when I left Deloitte. And what I was doing there was, you the beginning of data lakes or enterprise data pool that we know nowadays. This idea that you can manage large amount of data, take control of this large amount of data, serve this large amount of data almost in real time or in near real time to many apps and people and users and actually get getting insights, etc. And now I'm at V chain, but what led me to blockchain?

While I was in Deloitte, well, a couple of things. My first experience with blockchain was knowing about Bitcoin, of course, like many many of you. But Bitcoin was the first thing. And I didn't know about Bitcoin until 2011. I think it was the case of the of Assange, Julian Assange, when I heard he was being cut from the financial system, effectively. And he was paid in Bitcoin. And I was like, what what do you mean? What is it What is that? And I read about it.

I of course didn't understood it. I didn't understand the point, really, at the beginning. But what I understood was the sense of censorship resistance aspect of it. The fact that, okay, there's no way to stop this thing. So, he's really getting paid in Bitcoin. And if he pays his lawyers in Bitcoin and he has solved the problem, he can do And then someone can hand him cash and they, you know, he can do his shopping. He can do So, there's no way you can stop that.

So, that censorship resistance got me. And then while I was doing big data, and trust me, we were doing really large uh scale big data cluster, the Edward Snowden case came out. The Snowden files came out. Which was almost a crime against big data, if you know what I mean. And into those files, as Snowden kind of released some interesting big data architecture, which were very similar to things I had done in the past. So, I was seeing at at that point. And that posed to me the question of all right, what about data ownership?

What about abuse of data? And what about the self-sovereign data? And what about the self-sovereign individual? So, the two cases posed two questions for me. Self-sovereign individual, the the Assange case. Am I free financially, really, or am I not? The other case put the situation into my head of what are they doing with my data? Which then was exposed by Cambridge Analytica case in the UK, guys. You you probably know that. And many other cases. So, a self-sovereign individual should have financial freedom and freedom of privacy, should have access and property of of its data and be able to transact.

So, that I started questioning the the the whole model. And at the time in Deloitte, Deloitte was starting looking at crypto as a way to solve and blockchain solve multiple problems. And David Dalton, who was the head of financial services, I think, at the time in Ireland for Deloitte, he had the idea of opening the the blockchain lab in Dublin. And he asked me if I wanted to Deloitte because I've always been doing the cutting-edge tax technologies. So, he was thought about me and I said, "Oh, I can't believe it." Because I was actually looking into this this all other type of to solve other type of problems as next step, next evolution.

How do we bring big data under control? How do we give fair financial access to everyone? And that that's when I joined up the blockchain lab. It was 2016. So, I've been doing blockchain and Web3 since 2016, full-time. It's the only thing I've done, 8 years now. I love that, Antonio. That that's such a good character arc. I think that might be the first time I've heard someone directly say that Julian Assange was the first person to make them realize the benefits of having censorship resistance.

And then the Edward Snowden case also being like, "Okay, well, what's actually happening with my data? How are they using it? I want more transparency and ownership over that data." And this is something that I think is slowly coming into the mind of a lot of individuals, especially in the last like 5, 10 years because of the Cambridge Analytica scandal that you've talked about in the UK, specifically. What I find really interesting is your work at the big tech companies. People often say something that is maybe it's a misnomer that blockchain is a solution looking for a problem, right?

But you've worked in the big tech companies. You understand what real-world problems are right now. So, as a techie, you're a techie at heart, right? What problems in your mind does blockchain solve? In my mind, oh, there there's one the single one There there's a number of them, okay? But the single one is to me is is decentralization, which means The ability to transact with peers. And we talk about peer-to-peer network for a reason because it's peer between peers without a middleman, removing the So, your ability for people to own their digital asset, their digital portfolio, whatever that is, to own their value, and whatever that is, that could be currency, that could be identity, that could be a digital asset of any kind, an insurance, etc., whatever that is, and transact directly with whoever you want to transact.

Disintermediation and removing middlemen is kind of like a broad stroke, right? And you and I know what how that can be applied. But to say our listeners who aren't in the space, what are the best use cases you can imagine with that kind of principle in mind? Some of the best use cases that we have seen, I mean, of course, the Bitcoin one and the crypto currencies one is what's probably one of the best that's been done so far. But the entire realization of a new financial ecosystem is also a big one with all the DeFi stuff.

They've been important one. This is one of one of the best. To me, in general, is the whole tokenization aspect as well and digitalization. It's probably one of the best use cases for blockchain because you can now digitize anything knowing, and that's another aspect of the blockchain, knowing that you own the only copy. So, blockchain also solves the double spending mechanism. That's what Satoshi in the white paper was trying to do. And what that is Somebody would say, "Hey, okay, you don't double spend. I can use a third party." No, because you can double spend, you can finally solve the digitalization problem, which means there's no digital copy of any other thing.

So, whatever you own digitally, it is yours. And that opens then to million of use cases. In our case of VeChain, we play we talk about sustainability because at the same in the same way you want to make sure you have a financial privilege, I want to make sure you also have a sustainability privilege. Which means sustainability goes back to you, digitizing whatever needs to be capturing the value and digitizing that value, and the value goes back to you. So, digitalization it's immense because then allows and tokenization in general allows to assign value to things, whatever they are.

In our case, can be positive externalities in Even recycling a bottle, okay? Even things like that or taking a bus or walking to the coffee shop. That's a positive externality. It's yours. It's tracked. You then tokenize that. It becomes a token, whatever it is. And then it's And why I can't create other tokens? Because blockchain doesn't allow me to do that. Because we know what are the tokens that are being here. And why can't I steal the token of someone else? I copy that one because there's blockchain that helps you avoiding that.

And so, it opens to millions of use cases. So, to me it's really the financial part, the DeFi, the crypto has been an example of a bigger picture, which is tokenization and digitalization. In general. really interesting point because I was a bit surprised given that we're about to go on to sustainability and everything that VeChain's doing knowing their background and their mandate that the first use case you mentioned was cryptocurrency. And I want to get like your really quick take before we go into the sustainability stuff is what do you think about the crypto space generally?

Okay, I said this is the first use case because it's been the first use case use case that has been developed in blockchain. We know Bitcoin was the first one to come. And then DeFi followed over time. And then we realized hold on a minute, we can tokenize anything. And tokenization and and now sustainability. And that's where we That's where I think the greatest use case still lies. But in general, my take on the crypto space, it's an industry that is growing. It's an industry that is gaining institutional uh trust, and we are seeing with the ETF.

It it's an industry that like many uh innovating industry, it has gone through some tough time, has gone through the scammers, has gone through abuses. But that was the same for the web. Uh I'm old enough to have been in this space where to have seen the web from day one. I was in my I think it was something like close to my 20s. And you know, I was coding without the when I was 14. There was no web. And so, then the web arrived. And she's the web companies were were There was some of them you didn't know what they were doing.

And I saw a lot of similarity in the crypto space. But to me, the crypto space is now effectively institutionalized. There's no question anymore whether the crypto is here to stay or not. It's done. Bitcoin is Even the European Union has said several times that they will work alongside with the crypto space. And I think the ECB is trying to also say and I talked about ECB because I live in the European Union. But I think also in UK is happening the same is trying to say we can work together and offer other services in the digital space.

And then they talk about CBDC and other stuff that are still in the same space but are supported by us. So, they can be an alternative. And so, that everyone will work together. So, I think that my take on the crypto space now is everyone knows it exists. Everyone knows it's here. Now, it's about what the large institutions are going to try to do is we can offer these services to others that are not really web three savvy. But also, we can work alongside these services to offer similar services that are backed by large institutions.

And the two worlds will not collide. I think they will work together. Sure, I love that outlook. I I and I completely agree. I think we are moving to this phase where a lot of people are now understanding the value proposition of digital assets, digital identity, all anchored by public blockchains. And that is related to the crypto space, but they're kind of they're not they're not separable. They are going to work together, I think, in the future as well. You touched on this idea of sustainability there again.

And obviously, that's the main focus of this episode. So, I want to move there that's for all the good things that we can do with digital assets, the biggest gripe, in my opinion, that most people have with it at the minute is the energy consumption associated with something like Bitcoin. So, I know a year ago, I think it was ranking 27th country in all the world for energy consumption. I think it doubled over the last year, right? So, people have this issue. Greenpeace have tried to campaign against the use of Bitcoin and move to more sustainable technologies.

So, my question is how important do you think this question of sustainability of the underlying technology is to its growth, to the whole growth of the web three space? And do you think it's actually being taken seriously by the space right It depends what the web three application or use case you have at hand is trying to do, what the problem is trying to solve. A layer one blockchain or any web three blockchain application, the app that doesn't take into account sustainability, cannot be taken If you say I work in sustainability, okay, I'm a layer one.

And I'm building a platform for sustainability. Whatever it does, carbon credits, recycling, anything. Sustainability needs to be taken into Now, and you need to make sure your platform is sustainable, has a low carbon footprint, etc. That's what we did at VeChain, okay? Our first goal was we wanted to make it sustainable in many ways, not only in terms of energy footprint and you can guys go into the website, you will see what's our carbon footprint there. You can use VeChain stats to measure the carbon footprint of all the transactions of VeChain.

It's extremely low. It's It's the lowest probably out there. And we did that in in several ways. We have a very simple, you know, consensus mechanism, which is a proof of authority. It's a round robin type of mechanism. We got number of authority 100 authorities, 101 that are there, well-defined, and KYC within the ecosystem. We have a low gas consumption like really you can run transaction with a few millicents. And that's sustainability, which means accessibility to things. Because sustainability is not only environment. If you look at the 17 sustainable goals, it's health, it's labor, it's governance, it's fair business practices, it's many other things.

And the environment is big part. It's energy, environment, etc. They They're a big part. So, you need to take sustainability seriously. If you look at sustainability within your technology, even things like the way we deploy our public nodes, the nodes that everyone used to access, we look at the cloud provider, and then we look, okay, what is your sustainable solution for the the EC2 machines or for the storage or whatever it is. And we monitor that, okay, how can we get the lowest level possible? So, you need to do that.

Now, you raised the question of Bitcoin. Bitcoin does something else. Uh and it's a large peer-to-peer network, was built for payments. Now, they call it digital To me, it's a massive financial ecosystem. So, you need to compare Bitcoin with all the infrastructure of all the financial ecosystem, central bank, etc. brought together. And the carbon footprint of those, and then you can really measure it. But it's a different use case. And I think there is there's a lot of talk about the the sustainability of Bitcoin. I think the Bitcoin is are also aware of that.

And I think they're working towards that. I think there is somebody even talks about a green machine now. Like it's actually a green machine. Well, why is it a green machine? How can it be? Well, the energy I think there's a percentage half of the energy used is renewables now for That's not too bad. It's pushing for innovation, you know, okay, how can we energy that is sustainable and we can do good. Actually, we can still maintain the the Bitcoin network. So, in the end, it's what I'm trying to say that sustainability becomes a problem for everyone.

If you're a sustainability layer, sustainability platform, it's paramount. But also in other networks, it's becoming a a common topic. The Ethereum at the time the Ethereum moved to proof of stake, went into that direction to remove proof of work. Proof of stake is one of the thing that Ethereum said we're now more sustainable, which is good. Yeah, I think it's a really good point that you raised there. And you know, Bill Gates' book, How to Avoid a Climate Disaster, he really emphasizes the point that the goal of sustainability isn't to just stop development and say we're not going to use any more energy because that that's not good for humanity, right?

Development has saved far more lives than it has you know, cost us so far. So, his whole point is we should just make sure that all development and all projects that we move forward with now have sustainability in mind. Is the value worth the amount of energy we're using? And I think on the point of Bitcoin, I think if we, you know, originally considered Bitcoin in its original implementation as this electronic peer-to-peer cash system, right? The utility right now is maybe questionable. It seems that more and more that Bitcoin's being used as this kind of digital gold rather than digital dollars where it's actually not being used to exchange, it's just being used for speculation.

What I would say is some of the work that you're doing at VeChain, I think, is much more focused on the utility and the real world value to provide it. And you you've touched on it a bit there, but could you give us a little bit of information about VeChain's inception? What was the goal there? How did it start and what are you working on? I think we chain was started with the Sunny Lou was the at the time CIO Louis Vuitton with the idea he saw that as a good way to to start solving a number of real world problems.

Okay. So Sunny said okay, this could be used for instance for anti-counterfeiting. Could be used for tracking trees and the fair supply chain. These are also issues by the way. Many people say to the Vechain why you move from supply chain tracking trees to sustainability because it's the same thing guys. Literally is it's just sustainability is a wider thing. So Sunny idea was this one we can bring actually the blockchain layer one technology into real world problems and solve real world issues. And then he he set up Vechain I think 2015.

Uh usual VC type of stuff at the beginning beginning investments like I said earlier then in 2017 Sunny run an ICO and the Vechain team run an ICO and they went live in on the 30th of June Okay. And with the goal in mind valuable transactions. That was the thing. Anything that runs on Vechain needs to be a real transaction. They started with tracking trees you know packaging things product passport. You know which were NFTs we didn't know they were NFTs at the time. And then I was still in Deloitte but I had met Sunny in 2018 in in New York at Consensus and I said can we work together because I like it.

Now there were a couple of things to do. Sunny got the use cases so like product passport so on. In when you have a product passport then you can track because it's blockchain and then and it's a truth machine you can track the provenance you can track the materials you can have everything in the passport and give it kind of a sustainability footprint of that product already. Uh at the time we were looking more at anti-counterfeit because it was a huge Hundreds of billions that you know get burned it's a serious one.

But one thing you know this notice like the question is why we created Vechain and we didn't use anything else. There was just not enterprise ready. For a layer one to be used by enterprises there were too many problems. One is the fluctuation of the price. Let's say you're a CTO or a CIO you put a budget and my operation budget to run this anti-counterfeit platform let's say done by Walmart like we it's a use case that we have or H&M and others. Let's say it's $50,000 a year.

Okay. That's the cost operational cost of the platform. All of a sudden you go to your CIO or your CEO and you say well you know that token price has gone 10x so it's now 10x. And you laugh. Okay we're talking back in the days now everyone is going to solve this problem. So we created at the time a double token token mechanism to to avoid that. And there was another thing for instance by the way let's say you're a large enterprise I need to buy crypto to run this platform.

So I need the token the gas as we call it in in the web three space. So I need the cryptocurrency that underpins this blockchain to pay for gas fees. So to pay for computation. What is gas fees? What do you pay? You literally pay instructions you know. Every instruction that the blockchain machine does has a price in gas. That that's what we do. And that's the way it's priced by the way for everyone to know. And when you have a large institution you buy a digital asset there are there a lot of of concerns there not because they're they're bad by any chance but you need to put in balance sheet there is a financial position then there you have there is a security concern with what is the security?

Well you have to store safely this financial asset. You need to make sure it's integrated safely from wherever it is into the application that then calls the blockchain and passes the financial asset to the miners or to the authorities in our case. And this was a huge issues like you go to somewhere like large institutions that does you know logistics and then you say great. Now you need to buy 2 million in this crypto to to run the platform and then I like the how do I do that?

And I don't have the infrastructure to store that. We're talking about 2017 18 19. I don't even know how to store that. We didn't have many institutional wallet as a service provider institutional custody let me call it that way. The right term is institutional custody providers. There are many nowadays not enough but still there are there are a lot more. So how do I store all of this? So what we created at Vechain we said okay we can have a fee delegation system which is now becoming already known by other platforms than Ethereum has created the account abstraction where you basically you say okay I run the transaction and on the transaction I say between the authorities of Vechain one of them will pay for my transaction fee.

And then I will settle that transaction in fiat afterwards behind the scenes normally as a normal. That created massive because all of a sudden it was okay everyone can use this thing. All I need is an authority that pays for me and and there are several. And we even had projects at Vechain and an example is Vechain energy which say hey guys I'm here offering energy services so you can I can act as a delegation for you which is incredible. And then of course there was also a problem who runs this blockchain?

It's fully decentralized. Okay but where is the ledger going to be stored? I know the ledger is public everyone but we need to know who runs that. And and the and it needs to be fast as well. So we looked and we we decided okay let's create a bulk of authorities a system with 101 authorities and they're KYC'd the steering committee is elected by the community but then they review the authorities they approve and they say okay that the these are the authority members. There is a system that yes is is maintained by a number a closed number but still fairly large but the large enterprises could work.

Just really quickly there you know we're talking about proof of authority right now the consensus mechanism Yes. that governs Vechain. So one of the phrases I have heard to describe this is it's a governance model that balances centralized and decentralized. And decentralized yeah. Would you would you take that as would you think that's a fair comment? You yeah it's a fair comment. It's not fully decentralized we we say in the white paper it's not fully centralized it's it balances out the speed that you need to get the consensus fairly quickly versus the the fact that you want one centralized authority to to govern the whole ecosystem.

So it goes to 101 authorities. Each one of them has equal power to have the momentum to to to generate a block and to basically validate it. And then there's a mechanism of validation once the the the block is published it's round robin by the way and we have a token that we call finality token where we say after a few seconds that block is published we say hey by the way this is final now. And finality is something that by the way concerns a lot of organizations because anything that you do in the crypto space is actually probabilistic you know it's a longer mathematical discussion.

But is is this thing really final or It poses question even legally speaking. So we try to solve all these things because what what why we try to solve those because Sunny in particular he was working with business people and he knew all the challenges and he said let's try to create something that these guys can Over the years then Alec we we continued we developed tracking and tracing cases figitals so link between a physical object giving it a digital passport effectively. Digital twins some people called it.

And we had a product like ToolChain we still have multiple tagging solutions. And you can tag your shoes your whatever anything your shirt your phone books anything you want bottle of wines food there's now World of V which is a marketplace running on the chain there. I think there's a serious number of bottle of wines that tagged. You can go there and check the And that that kept going and kept growing. Then we did you know the idea of digital identity for businesses which were NFTs basically uh which we did in Deloitte in 2019.

We said yeah we created a digital the ISO certification which is effectively gives you the ability to operate in a certain area because you're certified. So it's a passport effectively for a business. We digitized that and I think that week April 2019 Vechain passed the number of transaction of Bitcoin for about a week that was me and Deloitte working with the Vechain pushing in these digital passports all And then at some point I spoke to Sunny in 2021 and he said why don't you join us as leader of SDG we are turning into sustainability.

I said tell me more what it is that you want to do. And I like what he had in mind which is the idea that web three tries to do it's give power to the people again. The web three is an evolution of web one two. We we get to web three. Of course if there's a web three there's been a web one and two. The web one is hypertext and chatting. Guys you're probably younger than me but that that was what we were doing. Web two is this one what we see now is content creation.

It's really you you are the web as a person as an individual because you throw stuff on the web. You you create the content. The data that is generated on the web to is insane. But who owns that? Is the problem. And web three goes back to say, "Okay, we solved that problem of ownership. Now let's go back to sustainability." Suddenly idea was "Hey, hold on a minute. Web three can be used for better. Web three can be used for sustainability because all we do is now change the narrative from okay, sustainability what it is.

It's a number of regulation, a number of fines, and a number of buy this so that you can say you're sustainable versus web three's it's you, the individual, your behavior, and because you are being sustainable, the money goes back to you. Mhm. So, sustainability becomes an incentive system. And I was like, "Hold on a minute. We do the sustainability what with the what the DeFi and others have done for the financial system? Give it back to everyone." Yes. And I said that and I that was October 2021.

Wow, that makes that makes a lot of sense. Yeah. I and there's so many little threads I want to pull on in the the tapestry you painted there, but I think how you finished there is a crucial one, right? Because you started by talking about the fact that sustainability is much more than just how much energy you're using. A lot of it is actually to do with the applications. You mentioned double spending at the start. I'm aware that in the carbon credits world, they kind of have a double spending problem of their own.

And how do you verify that carbon credits have been used in one place and not another? So, there are so many applications and you're touching on the behavioral aspects there as well. So, I've seen it for example in Scotland, there's a plastic bottle recycling scheme where they're offering these micro incentives of like 20 p to go and recycle bottles. And I think that I think there is a narrative shift now in this X to earn economy, right? These small shifts. Do you think that's where things are heading?

The problem, Jack, and yes, and that's where we we are doing at VeChain. We launched the VBet DAO last week in Amsterdam, I think the 28th of February in alpha mode. So, it's going to go fully live in a few weeks' time, but it is live effectively. We were just leveraging testnet to to to get to that level, to incentivize X to earn and to create application to be together. What is one problem you described there, Jack? Recycling bottles, you get an incentive. You get a token that you can then spend only where you get it.

A sustainability challenge cannot be solved vertically. It has to bring everyone together. So, we need to create an ecosystem where everyone is together because you touched on the carbon credit spending is spent there, is spent there. There's Could there be a double spending problem on carbon credit? Of course, there could be and there has been. Could there be fake carbon credit generation? Oh, yeah, there's been. By the way, check the new. What did I say at the beginning? Solving the double spending problem and trust at the beginning, knowing who is giving the carbon credit and where it is going.

So, I think where we are going here is to creating what we're trying to do at VeChain, create an ecosystem where all sustainability apps, let's call it like that, and be were are brought together into one ecosystem. Either you're walking or you are studying, you're learning because that's a sustainable You're getting better in anything you do. You're recycling. You're driving less. You're taking the It's your decision, by the way. And you are incentivized for that. And if we can get into this head of X to earn, can you then install a solar panel and sell your energy?

And get an app that does that. Can you do a million things? And then you're like, "Hold on a Sustainability is good for me because I'm getting incentivized. And there is a thing of gamification Yes, but maybe gamification has been here for 20 years. But there is an aspect of capturing the value of what you do. And then you get assigned that value because it's yours. Mhm. And it's only yours. And by the way, you own that value. You decide what to do with that value.

With the VBet DAO, that value that is generated, we try to capture it. We we incentivize the apps. I really like the how you've you've led on to this, but if you go on the VeChain website, you see this VBet DAO, the name of which I really love, by the way. I think it's great. But yeah, can you explain cuz we haven't really covered DAOs in much detail. Can you explain first at high level what they are and why VeChain is using the VBet DAO as the mechanism to achieve this X to earn kind of economy that you're talking about?

VBet DAO is a DAO. It's a decentralized autonomous organization. So, it's it's a web three application that runs on VeChain. So, it's a series of smart contracts. A DAO means that there is behind a community of voters that can decide on issues. What VBet DAO is focused on is on X to earn apps, application in the sustainability space that, you know, want to incentivize good behavior. Okay? And what the VBet DAO does is it has a double token mechanism. One is better and one is vote three.

Better is a token for better. It's the token that in the end people receive for their good It's literally the ultimate value generation of a sustainable behavior of a positive externality. You can swap that better token with another token which is called vote three. As a sustainable person, maybe that better token I want to use to vote on the VBet DAO. And what are you going to vote on? For now, what you're going to vote on is what what are the applications that you want into VBet DAO.

Mhm. You know, I don't like that application. That application, guys, is And then there's Discord. People are going to chat there. Application is not, you know, they didn't allocate the better well last time. I think that is not tracked properly. Let's keep them out. I'm going to vote the others. Um I like this one. There's going to be a quadratic voting and funding mechanism in place. It's not there yet, but we're talking about weeks, okay? So, as you know, the quadratic voting for for the audience here means it's kind of an economics mathematical issue.

Voting is never good is never right. I voting is always difficult. It's one of the most difficult things to in in life, but really hard to do. But a quadratic voting means allows you to put more votes into an issue that is in your heart because by having better, let's say you have a thousand better, you can vote to everything in one app, but they also make sure that you don't just don't kill all the others. So, it distributes in a fair way. It's like emotions but avoid manipulation.

It's like putting your heart into things, but not too much. Let's avoid manipulation as well because not everyone has a good So, in the end, it's a sustainability platform that tries to attract X to earn and to tell them uh by the way, if you're part of us and you generate value and it's visible, that value is going to come through a better token to you. We can allocate better tokens to you. And the ultimate utility of the tokens is several things. It's it's it's the value itself that you're generating, you can use to vote into the platform.

And in the future, then that's why we're building a launcher cuz it's it's about what the apps will be able to come up with to how to use the better token. You could have a loyalty points somewhere or you could use to offset carbon somewhere else. So, we are working on utility at the moment. The thing is utility is so big because this is the first time that I see a DAO that is so open. Cuz if you look at all the DAOs that we have so far, one thing that is always is in any DAO design that you see, there's always that thing.

Token goes out, stake, we generate more here, goes back into the trash. We have a bit of that, but the reality that when it goes out, our token, it goes very far. It goes into can go into thousands of sustainability apps. And they can come up with their own tokenomics, by the way, which could wrap a better maybe. They could do anything else. And then they use better internally to vote themselves for their own tokenomics. So, you're like, "Hold on a minute. Here we we are up to something good because it is the first time where someone unleashes a token within an ecosystem in such a way." It's very brave in my view, but that's the only way you can do it because sustainability is everyone's challenge.

It's multi-industry. If you don't do that, the other What is the other solution? Okay? Let's say I don't want to I think we need to make sure there's a utility. What you're going to do? You go vertical. You solve one problem. You say, "Okay, I want to solve the solve the problem of recycling." And when the plastic bottle is generated a token, then you can spend the token into the shop. Or you can redeem into an exchange. Good. Well done. Not good enough. Maybe that token you want to use to offset something or to buy energy on another platform or to charge your EV car or to do what or to get a bike with that token to to cycle to work.

And then you get even more tokens. Or you want to vote for another. You know, sustainability is about a collective impact. And then we are How many we are? 10 billions on the planet. If each one of us does very little, like how much we are going to achieve? So, I just That's why the the token design is so brave. I have to say that once we launched, the community was like, "Oh, this is big." You know, like it's very big. And there was a lot of positive reaction.

A lot of There was criticism as well to say, "Okay, the tokenomics is complex." But it's just part of the journey, to be honest with you. It's very exciting. Like, I looked this through some of the white paper, and you are right, it does seem very big, but we have to be big to solve big problems in a lot of ways, right? And I think the idea of I know we don't like maybe the term gamification is a bit outdated these days, but the idea of X to earn models in society, like you can imagine in the future governments incentivizing exercise or healthy eating or planting trees and all this kind of stuff.

Like you said, you don't just want to solve one problem, you want an entire ecosystem that's supported through this X to earn model. I love the idea of community voting, and there's such a problem right now with say reviews. Are they real? Are they authentic? And the idea of linking tokens, whatever you want to call them, to actual purchases, actual transactions, to be able to prove, you know, I did use the service, so this is a review that I'm allowed to say and that is genuine and authentic is so powerful.

And I love the idea of having this ecosystem that supports having tokens linked to actual usage of the service. This kind of worldview is mind-blowing. I love it. It's so exciting. So, Vechain went from early days product passport type stuff to Phygital's. Now you're talking about DAOs. What are some of the biggest issues in the future that you're excited to tackle at Vechain? The V Better DAO scale, first of all, is for me the thing. I'll be honest with you, Alec and Jack. This is the biggest thing I ever worked on.

And I've done big things in my life. When I was in doing big data, I've done data lakes for large government institutions that were very insane. But, here you can touch everyone. So, it's the biggest thing I ever done, and I have a sense of like it's a mission, It's a mission not only for the planet, it's a mission for everyone, because I think we need Just a minute, it's like privilege. Check on some on one's privilege. Do you have financial privilege? You got to have the sustainability privilege as well.

Needs to be yours. You know, and and and you need to get the benefits of being sustainable. So, my biggest six challenges how do we scale this? We know how this going to scale, but in front of Alec, if I ask you and Jack, guys, if I ask you now how many X to earn app you can come up to your mind. We do a workshop. You probably going to come up with a Just as a half an hour workshop with Sunny in Dublin, we came up with Cleanify and Maxhot ourselves.

Then we're speaking to tons of We went to a hackathon in in Boston last year. It was October at And the kids, the the students came up with I don't know many X to earn apps. One of them won, actually, and they were English guys from I don't want to be wrong from the Cambridge University, the Movelo guys. Go and check their website. And they won, but there were others that are applying for grants, that are just setting up. So, you could come up yourself with that a hundred of those.

Now, imagine if you do this type of workshops in any This multiplies, like it goes exponential. And then all of a sudden you get 20, 30, 40,000 apps that are So, I think the next year we'll be okay, but we will get into the tens, the hundreds, and then you know the exponential curve the way it does. And that's that's to me that's the biggest challenge as Vechain, and then being able to make sure the core protocol responds to that. Being able to make sure the core protocol, we are a layer one protocol, is interoperable with the Ethereum ecosystem is interoperable with all the other, because if you want to be open, then you have to be open also with apps that are running on Ethereum, apps that are running on Cardano.

Otherwise, you're not open. And so, that's my my second biggest challenge, that the core protocol is able to serve. And that I think where our research will go, probably one of the things where our research will go. Making sure the interoperability is there, scalability is there, and it becomes a big concept, but I'll be honest with you, Alec, the design itself of better is it pushes down to people and apps rather than than Apple. So, a lot of transaction will be on the edge, like really at phone level, at IoT level, etc.

And then probably we will see we which is sustainability, by the way. Transaction at the edge means that you're using the computate Computing at the edge means that you're using your computing power of the thing you have at hand. There's less traffic, there's less, and it's all more sustainable. These are my challenges. At the personal level, the challenge is also to make sure, as a CTO, my team follows me. My You know, it's I was asked We had our CTO event in in Belfast. We gathered three, four times a year, and one of the questions I got asked, what is the thing that keeps you awake at night?

It is making sure my team follows me, like my team believes in me. Because Web3 is a space where you know, I've been a leader of multiple in multiple organization and with tens of people tens of people. In Web3, you got I have to be honest, Alec and Jack, you got the top notch of the Some of the brightest minds are in this And they don't buy easily. Anything you say is a very scrutinized. They don't buy anything, which is the right thing. You say something and you they answer it's not making sense.

my biggest concern is like coaching Real Madrid. I always say that, you know, or coaching Manchester United, or coaching whatever team you prefer, guys. It has to be a top notch. Can you really coach these players? Can you teach them how to play football? No. But, maybe you can teach them how to play together, and you can show them a vision. And the goal is let's get this team of very talented people, which are very hard to work with because they're very smart, and they they just don't go If I say do X, why should I do X?

Do you Do you have a good explanation why you should? And and so, the my the other challenge is really to getting everyone within my team to to But, I think Sunny is doing a fantastic job, and he's there, you know, he has inspired everyone. There is a feeling of Vechain of that we are on a mission because we really see it. We know that the the journey is going to be bumpy because you're not trying to deliver an app. Here's the app. Don't work. So, I have Alpha Wallet.

It's not a wallet. V Rewards was fantastic. You have 600,000 users now. It's good. It's a great product. Works. It's a wallet. That's one thing. Well, a number of things. It's about tokens. Yeah. Here you're talking about building an ecosystem, democratic, quadratic funding and quadratic voting to attract all the sustainability apps in the world to incentivize the end user to basically become the underpinning layer for all sustainability efforts in the world for the next 20 years. It's it's a big and bold vision, as Alec said, and I can attest to your experiences even just working with Alec on this podcast.

It takes a lot to get an idea through him, you know, he has big plans in Web3. They're not easy to convince, so I can definitely attest to No, Jack. I agree. That's the nature of the beast there, right? Again, people are in this space to change the world fundamentally, as you've described with Vechain. It's the biggest thing you've ever worked on because of the potential impact of it, not necessarily the technical complexity, but Actually, Web3 should be the opposite, like, you tiny app and fat protocols, like it Let's do one thing quickly, an exercise.

Without blockchain, how long you think it's going to take you to create a digital token? With blockchain, we can do that. Probably, if you use VORJ, me and you, which is a Vechain product, may take five seconds. So, that How long it's going to create a currency, okay, even? Five seconds. Without blockchain, how long would that make Maybe a few years. You know, the technology is getting there, it's less less complex, but the problems you are trying to solve then are more complex, which is the thing that that you want to do.

Exactly. And I think, again, there are so many other strands in this episode that we didn't have time to cover, and I you know, I hope we have you on again in the future to go through them, cuz there are really you I think we've covered it really nicely, the whole sustainability story for now at least, and we'll maybe check in when when V Better DAO is fully fledged in the future. So, Antonio, we like to end every show by asking our guests two kind of standard questions, and we like to see, you know, compare people's answers and see how they change over time.

So, if you're ready, I'll ask you the first one, which is in one sentence only, what is Web3 to you? It's a force for better. Web3 is a force for better. That's what it is. It's a thing for better. Enjoy. But, that's that's the sentence. It's a force for better. I can elaborate on that. It's a thing to do better things. For us, is to drive sustainability, because sustainability only technology can solve a sustainability challenge, not the other way around. Not eliminating technology, but give better technology.

It's an ally to sustainability, Web3, for me. But, it does better everywhere. It does better can do better in the financial system, giving access to banking to the unbanked, can give access to financial instruments to others that were not available until today to everyone. It's a source for better in any way you see it. You can have ownership of your your identity, self-sovereign in terms of How many other good things I can say about Web3? And that that's You know why I say it's a source for better.

It's a force, sorry, for better. It's because it's a space that has been under criticism for a for a long time, and maybe for too long, for and I don't think it deserved that, but sometimes we did as as a and as as a group of in this industry. And lately there was a time, probably a year and a half ago after the FTX case, where people some very senior individuals in large organizations, banks, etc. were even saying, we need to pull the plug to the whole Web3 industry, ban Bitcoin, ban any Web3 effort, ban the technology.

Seriously, you ban a technology. A technology that it's not You know, it's not the technology, software. And there were even things that like and we should also make sure we don't hire anyone in the future that has ever worked in a Web3 company. And there's so much stress going around. I don't know if you ever saw that, guys. That really put me like we are trying to well in the world. We are trying to transform the world into a better space. So, let me tell you, the Web3 is a force for better.

Thank you. So, that's why we say Web3 for better. Yeah, and I think that's a beautiful way of summarizing the mission or the fact that it's a visionary and missionary industry that everyone feels kind of motivated that way. And if ChatGPT was to summarize this episode, I'm sure it would come out with something like Web3 is a force for better. So, I love that. By the way, ChatGPT also has a chatbot. So, you go there. If you want information about VbetterDAO, yeah, we just developed it.

We launched 2 days ago. So, Well, we'll link that in the episode show notes for sure. If anyone wants to go and find out more, that's great. So, yeah, the final question, Antonio, then is So, if you could pick anyone on the planet or from throughout history or they could even be fictional to sit down and discuss this force for better Web3 with, who would that be and why? There There were two people I was thinking about, to be honest. One is and probably everyone would tell you the same, but it's probably really Elon Musk, but just to because he talks about energy transition a lot and he has a point into many things and just to explain, I don't think he talks much about how Web3 can enable this energy transition, transition, which is one part of sustainability.

I think I would love to have a discussion with him about that. And of course, on the other end, Friedman, which was the the Nobel Prize laureate of uh for economy uh decades ago to explain that yes, there is a solution for financial freedom as well. These are the two people I would love to uh we managed to get to a solution to achieve financial freedom, which he described, by the way, already in the I think it was in the '80s, early '90s, where he imagined a digital currency back in the days.

So, the two of them, one one from the past who is no longer with us, that spoke about financial freedom, and the other one uh who is alive who talks about energy transition, which means energy freedom. Uh and and sustainability freedom for sustainability. And the two of them It's a really good answer. I'm surprised they're they're two nuances as well that we don't often get. We get a lot of repetition, but they're two nuances. I'm surprised no one's actually mentioned Elon Musk before. Because everyone talks about him, Alec, and I was very happy, but he is a driver around the around around energy transition.

He is a leader in this space and he needs to know more about Web3. But he knows, he has this knowledge there. He has his Bitcoins. Yeah, he definitely has an impact in the crypto industry. I think any tweet on any coin always I just move the way, which is funny. Um but Antonio, thank you so much. This has been an incredible episode. We've learned so much and I am so very excited to see what the impact and effects of VbetterDAO are going to be. Yeah, everyone try and check that out because that's going to be a very big and exciting project.

But Antonio, thank you for joining us and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we untangle a little more of Web3. Thank you, Alec and Jack, and thank you, everyone. Thanks for listening. Thanks for tuning in to another episode of Untangling Web3, produced by Emma Camilleri. Don't forget to send us your thoughts, questions, and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode. See you next time to untangle a little bit more of Web3.

The views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Business & Society

Related episodes

All episodes