Episode 121
Stablecoins CBDCs w/ Keir Finlow-Bates
About this episode
In this episode of Untangling Web3, blockchain researcher and educator Keir Finlow-Bates returns to unpack one of the most critical debates in modern finance—the rise of stablecoins and central bank digital currencies (CBDCs).
As digital assets evolve from niche tools for traders into core infrastructure for global payments, this conversation explores how blockchain-based money systems are reshaping the way value moves, who controls it, and what the next era of programmable finance might look like.
Key highlights
- Why Stablecoins Have Become the Bridge Between Finance and Blockchain. Stablecoins solve two critical problems—volatility and interoperability. They provide a stable medium of exchange that allows individuals and institutions to engage with blockchain networks without the price risk of native tokens like Bitcoin or Ether. At the same time, they act as a universal liquidity layer connecting decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols, exchanges, and traditional financial systems.
- Comparing Stablecoins and CBDCs. Architecture and Control: While both stablecoins and CBDCs represent fiat on the blockchain, their architectures differ fundamentally. Stablecoins like USDC or USDT are issued by private entities that hold reserves—often in treasury bonds or cash equivalents—and provide blockchain tokens on a 1:1 basis. They rely on smart contracts with mint, burn, and freeze functions that grant issuers limited control. CBDCs, in contrast, would be issued directly by central banks.
- Monetary Philosophy - What Money Really Represents. Fiat currencies are no longer backed by commodities or assets but by government decree and collective belief. Representing fiat digitally on blockchain networks forces society to confront this abstraction. Stablecoins expose the philosophical foundations of money—its value is not intrinsic but agreed upon. By contrast, Bitcoin introduces verifiable scarcity as a digital property, creating a new category of value rooted in cryptographic and computational certainty rather than institutional trust.
Stablecoins represent the convergence of traditional finance and blockchain technology, providing the infrastructure for global, programmable money. CBDCs, meanwhile, embody a competing vision—state-issued digital assets designed for control and policy enforcement rather than decentralization.
Between these two poles lies the defining question for the next decade of monetary innovation: will the future of money be open, programmable, and user-controlled—or centralized, monitored, and conditional?
This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
Money is changing. Stable coins have exploded to over 250 billion in circulation, pairing DeFi and crossber payments. While governments are racing to roll out CBDC's like the digital euro. For some, this is the future of programmable frictionless money. For others, it's a battleground of regulation, control, and innovation. To help us untangle it all, we're joined by the legendary blockchain Gandalf, Kia Finloates, making his second appearance on the show. Here is one of the sharpest voices in the space, known for cutting through hype, and explaining complex blockchain concepts with clarity.
Today, we'll dive into CBDC's versus stable coins, the EU versus the US, and the future of money in your wallet, and what it actually might look like. K, welcome to Untangling Web 3. And welcome back. How are you doing today? >> I'm fine, thanks. Very good. >> Yeah. Well, we had you on about I think it was like a year and a half ago. We were talking about smart contracts. And then afterwards you basically said, "Oh, I want to talk about stable coins. I want to talk about CBDC's." And it's been basically 18 months since that and now we finally get to talk about the topic that you're so interested in.
>> Right. Yeah. Well, I mean, I'm looking forward to it because it's a fascinating topic and it ties in an awful lot of interesting stuff. >> Yeah. Well, since that time, like I say, so much has happened like crypto is kind of now a dominant was a dominant market at the time, but it seems like there's real institutional adoption. Obviously governments now seriously getting into the space. So with that in mind, what is the problem that say stable coins are trying to solve versus say something like crypto?
>> Right. So um uh to start with firstly they're actually surprisingly old. I think the first one uh was launched in 2014 or 2013 something like that. So they've been around for over a decade. And the initial problem they were looking to solve was for people who were trading crypto and wanted a way to sit out of the market and then get back in without having to sell their crypto and then transfer the dollar or euro amount to a bank account and then back into the exchange again.
So the idea there and this is how they were first used is that you have a stable coin like USDT or something and when you sell your Bitcoin or Ether or your whatever meme token um you convert it to USDT and then a month or two later or a day later you can then sell your USDT back for crypto um and you've sat out what you think might be a uh a bare market. Um, so that was the original idea and they chugged along like that for a long time.
What we're seeing now is that they're being used as a way of having conventional currencies in the crypto markets because crypto markets have become a lot lot bigger since then and people are using them for payments. Um, and people are using them for holding and moving uh, national currency assets uh, in a in a blockchainy way. I guess that's the the simple way of describing it now. Yeah, it's interesting because it seems like it's, as you said, it's evolved from stable coins essentially being a tool for people to stay within the crypto sphere without having to, you know, fully use it, but while preserving the value at a given level, you know, maybe there's a bare market going on they don't want to be exposed to.
And now it feels like it's there's kind of an an inflow the other direction where you have kind of nation states and you know big corporations saying actually what we want to inject some of our financial system into crypto via the same the same kind of mechanism but for quite a different reason and you know from kind of even just if if you've been on the sidelines in the last year in in the cryptos world it'll be hard to ignore just how much adoption and noise there's been at least I want to say noise more than adoption because obviously you get a lot of press releases um before these things happen.
So, what do you think has kind of driven the the pace of things happening in the last year? There's been so many announcements, so many people saying, you know, stable coins are the killer app now of crypto all of a sudden, which to to you and I might seem strange because they've been around chugging along for so long. So, what what do you think's actually changed to cause that shift in the narrative? >> Um well, there's a whole bunch of things. Um firstly the well if I think back to like 2017 2018 even I used to go to bed at night and wake up in the middle of the night with a nightmare of finding out that Bitcoin was worth nothing that Ethereum had shut down and that it was all just a a pipe dream that uh was now over.
Um, now it's really clear that blockchain is relevant and it's here to stay and it is a new financial innovation that is not just for a bunch of crypto punk nerds. It's going to impact the world and the the large financial institutions have woken up to it or maybe they woke up to it 5 years ago um and now they're actually saying it. I mean, I'm thinking here, for example, JP Morgan, who seven years ago were saying that uh this is all nonsense. Um it's now clear that actually while they were saying it was nonsense, they were working away on what if it wasn't.
Um and they've changed their story. So, it's now got legitimacy. There are huge financial institutions and governments who are saying this stuff is real, it's relevant, it's useful. Um, and then you face the problem, well, how do you interface uh things like the US dollar being a reserve currency of the world with something like Bitcoin or Ethereum? Um, and the answer is you need to have a bridge. You need to be able to say, well, we have assets on the blockchain, but they represent conventional financial assets.
And that's where stable coins step in. And uh for ordinary people and indeed even for institutions, they solve the problem of blockchain tokens are seen as being very volatile. Some of them are, some of them aren't. Um we're used to currencies kind of chugging along, especially the big ones, not really changing very much in value in purchasing power on a day-to-day basis. It's just over years and decades that they their value erodess away. And people are familiar with that. So it brings the familiar financial monetary system onto the blockchain and that means that a lot more people who might have been skeptical now think well actually I could do something with that.
Um it's quite interesting to have a dollar that is programmable that can be held by a piece of software rather than a human being or an institution things like that. So uh suddenly the doors open up. Um and then the other thing is that the conventional financial system has done a rather poor job at >> We have things like international bank account numbers but the US doesn't use them. We have all sorts of payment systems and you get the network effect where if you want to transfer money from country A to country B um you may be using a very different route from transferring money from country A to country C for example.
Um whereas blockchain despite this proliferation of chains and different consensus protocols and transaction formats and even say smart contract coding languages is actually relatively homogeneous in terms of how you go about interfacing with it compared to the conventional banking system which is fragmented um often undocumented often inaccessible to the average person. So, um I think these things all tie into this. Um and finance is becoming well, not more important, but more visible. It's no longer a bunch of gray-haired guys in dark blue suits uh in expensive offices in some sector of London that nobody else visits.
It's it's become something that more and more people can participate in, set up companies to do stuff. um you don't need as much permission um or connections to an old boys club to be able to engage in financial activity on a big scale rather than the kind of dayto-day I'm going to go and buy some bread with a 5 note. >> So I think these things all tie into >> One of the things that I want to jump on there is that you mentioned the idea of the value of fiat and traditional currencies eroding away over years and and decades.
And when people think of volatility, they tend to think short-term volatility, but the long-term volatility of something like fiat is obviously like you compare the purchasing power of the dollar and the pound and the euro over 20, 30 years and it's obviously going down relative to things like Bitcoin for example. So stables give us say some of the benefits of crypto, but the main pro is against the volatility versus say something like crypto. Do you see stables as a stock gap? Do you think that we will need them in the ultimate end goal of a world with crypto or do you think there'll always be a place for them?
Um, well, you're asking me to predict the future, and that's that's always hard. What's the old statement? I I hate making predictions, especially ones about the future. Um, so uh um I mean, I have some kind of ideas and visions of where this may go. I do think that stable coins are forming an intermediary system. I mean I and I believe that we're going through one of the most turbulent financial changes that um humanity has seen. You know there've been a number of kind of shifts in how human beings deal with the world financially over the years.
um from uh using SK uh rare metals as money to having paper representations of those rare metals to detaching the paper from the rare metals and saying it now stands on its own. That's why we use the uh word fiat. You know, it's by decree that they have value. Um and now we have um things that have value without a government or an organization saying we are the ones backing this. They have value because we have tanks or because um we've got a mandate from um some people in in power.
Um so this kind of stable coin thing is where the two meet where crypto and conventional finance meet and it provides a bridge and I think it's going stable coins will last for quite some time and I think a more and more of our monetary processes will move onto blockchains just because they're actually despite people complaining about block times uh surprisingly fast compared to conventional finance. um they are much more convenient in that they are easier to automate. You know, you're not facing some um open banking API that changes every 3 months and where the documentation is incredibly hard to find and you have an immensely long KYC process before you can do something as simple as move money from one of your own bank accounts to another.
Um a competent developer today with a bit of blockchain knowledge can do that in five minutes. Um, so the stable coins form the meshing between these two. They make crypto more valid. They make conventional more flexible and more usable. Um, as for the long term, yes, I I think that um currencies, national currencies going onto open public uh blockchains through um the form of stable coins is the start of the end of them to be honest because at some point people who are using stable coins or maybe some um government uh fiat currency will go, "Hey, I understand this.
it's actually easier than I thought it would be. Now I'm going to dabble in some of these other things I hear about. Um, and then eventually it kind of cascades and you end up with more and more people using things like Bitcoin and Ether and um, other blockchain and blockchain tokens uh, for transacting and then eventually fiat currencies will become less and less relevant. >> Today's episode is sponsored by the Bchain Foundation. Now, we often talk about how emerging technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and Vchain is at the forefront of this green movement with initiatives like Veta Dao.
Let's take a closer look. >> Imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets. These verified records build a massive collective impact benefiting people through their own actions. Sound a bit complex, but Vchain made it fun. Explore our apps at vb Vchain's goal is to power a new era of sustainable solutions. So, if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day, go check out vb better.com to find out more. And now back to the show.
Well, I think to your point, I I love the the bridge analogy. I think it makes sense because when I think about you know crypto assets in the kind of whole spectrum now that we have you kind of can think of the issuance of the asset and the operations of the asset as slightly separate and if you think think of a cryp typical crypto asset like a bitcoin or an ethereum potentially you have both of those are being kind of done in a decentralized distributed way then you have the stable coins where the issuance is kind of still centralized to a third party but the operations is somewhat decentralized by the nature of you know how they're being transacted and then you know to go to a third path that is potential then if we have both of those things being done in a centralized manner essentially um we have something that looks a bit like a a CBDC I think and you said there are one of many potential futures I want to get
your maybe your not your strong arm for what CBDC's are meant to be and represent but I think if you could just define them as a se as as a separate category um and you know define them in terms of how they they differ potentially from stable coins and I think it'd be good to start that discussion on you know the v the various merits of each >> right so if we look at stable coins you have a company like tether or circle and they're now fortunately under some regulation in that they're required to prove that they have backing assets they're not allowed to pay yields on stable coins and we should revisit that because it's an interesting one um and they have to guarantee that they will redeem these blockchain tokens for real dollars, real in quotes, as real as money is.
Um, when requested to under the terms and conditions, I think, for example, Tether is only required to redeem uh USDT for dollars if it's an amount of more than $100,000, for example. But the fact is that you should be able to get your money out. Um, but what Tether is doing here is it's receiving dollars from you and me. Um, and it's putting them into treasury bonds or other investments. Um, so it's kind of it's only supposed to issue USDT tokens in a one-to-one match with conventional dollars that they have received.
And as a result, you can say, well, the USDT or USDC is backed by these assets sitting in these financial instruments. And the idea is that they're meant to be, you know, blue chip financial instruments, things like treasury bonds, which have um about as close to guaranteed payouts as you can get. Um they're not allowed to go and shove it all into some startup that uh one of the uh Tether executives or circle executives happen to stumble across. So um if you now look at a CBDC, well that's a central bank digital currency.
If if a central bank were to take the approach of issuing their some amount of the currency that they're responsible for on a blockchain like Ethereum as an ERC20 token, suddenly the question of backing becomes very different. They're the one institution that um doesn't have to back their digital token because they can just create the money to do so. So that makes him very different from a bank or a a stable coin issuer. Um and and it's kind of odd when you think about it that they could just, you know, it starts to illustrate the fact that this money is being created out of thin air because what does it mean for the European Central Bank to back an ERC20 representation of a euro?
Um and then we move on to well what are central banks looking at doing and um what I see over if we pick say two of the most important ones the uh Federal Reserve in the US and uh the ECP under Christine Lagard in uh Europe uh I'm not seeing much in the way of pronouncements from the US um the Fed that they're kind of letting it be private that it's uh private companies that are issuing digital versions and just running business as usual um the way they have for decades in the US.
The European approach is very different. They've been talking about having a digital euro for years. Um it's always in kind of a we're investigating. We haven't made any firm decisions. And yet when you look back over it, it looks like they've been traveling down a railroad running straight towards one particular goal. Um, and I think the ECB is rather concerned about the way that um, all this blockchain and crypto stuff has progressed. Um, because well there could be a number of reasons. I think it's a lot to do with control.
You know, Europe's very centrally planned compared to say the US. Um, and they see stable coins and things like that as a threat. Uh so when you look at what um they are proposing with the digital euro, it's not we're going to mint um ERC20 tokens on Ethereum at all. Um there's not even really any talk about blockchain. It's it's likely to be a database um in uh some servers operated by the European Central Bank. Um, yeah, a very very different beast. And really to me, it looks almost like they're going to be offering banking services um with the digital euro.
And then to mllify the banks, they're saying, "Ah, but people will only be allowed to hold a couple of thousand euros worth of these things, which in my mind makes them completely pointless." But I I'm on record as being quite skeptical about the European Central Bank's approach both from technical terms um from the promises they're making like how it's going to be able uh it's going to be possible to transact them offline. They keep saying they they know how to do this but they never tell us how and all the leading cryptographers out there who've been working on this problem for decades don't know how.
So maybe they have a secret genius in a basement somewhere who they're going to announce. Um and um yeah, the the all these limits on them, it it just uh and and this constant uh we're thinking about it, we're not going to do it. Um, and of course lots and lots of uh videos that quite frankly look like propaganda to me coming out always with young female interns walking enthusiastically in front of EU buildings talking how wonderful this is going to be and how everybody's going to be able to use it and how not to worry.
That kind of stuff makes me worry. >> So it's the main concern for you that the backing is no longer independent. It's the the backing you say you can just create money out of nowhere without having to peg it to anything. In the same way that a lot of people speculated say five years ago USDT was in a similar boat and potentially they weren't declaring their assets and didn't have a onetoone peg. Is that the main concern then between a CBDC versus say a USDT that's now regulated?
>> No, because um national currencies issued by central banks are not backed by anything. Um well if you ask uh Christine Lagard he will tell you emphatically that the euro is backed by the European Central Bank and then you ask well what does that mean and you don't get an answer it's backed by a a bunch of bureaucrats in a building somewhere. Um, I mean the it it it's a bit of a strange sort of Alice and Wonderland world when you start digging into how our money systems work and we have all these weird mechanisms in place where um central banks and um wholesale banks and retail banks are selling each other financial instruments to create the money.
It's kind of like they're both I borrow off you and you borrow off me. So we have have nothing between us and you lend me a note saying I owe you £100 and I give you a note saying I lend you £100. Now in a sort of a world where conservation rules apply like conservation of energy and mass and stuff like that um there should be a total of zero but in the financial world that means we now have 200 right >> um you see the same in economics where I pay you £30 to do a job you pay Jack30 and he pays me30 we're all square but from the government's point of view we now have 90 pounds worth of economic activity and this is brilliant and we can post it as part of our GDP me.
Um, right. So, they're kind of financial systems do create stuff out of nothing. And in a sense, they have to, right? Because we have the real world with things like land and commodities and people doing work and timber growing in the form of trees and all, you know, stuff's being created. If we're going to have a virtual representation of it, which is what money is, um, and of things like people's capacity to work and the value of ideas that people have, um, that has to come out of somewhere.
And the answer is it has to come out of nowhere. Um, you can try to tie it to these things, but that gets very difficult because you're trying to value things with something that has no um, inherent value. I mean you don't want your money to have uh value because um then you see the problem that you have with some for example gold where gold is used as a store of value it's also got industrial uses. It's very annoying to the industry that gold is used as a store of value because it means that this wonderful corrosion proof electric conductor is 100 times more expensive in dollars than it needs to be.
Um, >> yeah. Well, I think this is such an interesting obviously we're getting into the philosophy of money all of a sudden, which I think is unavoidable, uh, when we're talking about, you know, stable coins and CBDC's. >> Um, and yeah, I I hadn't quite thought of things how in the sense that you put it there, which is interesting because it's almost like >> when we decide to try and put fiat currency into the the blockchain world, then it forces you to ask some uncomfortable questions about the nature of it, right?
because you know you're lifting the you're saying I'm trying to virtually represent something. What is it that I'm virtually trying to represent? And that's when it all becomes a little bit more more difficult. Um I'm interested as you were speaking I was thinking well how does this all compare then to something like you know a Bitcoin or an Ethereum where there's been a debate for many many years from the the other side from the kind of old financial world and the fiat currency issuing side where's the intrinsic value of Bitcoin and Ethereum.
So, how how do you think the three of those things stack up? So, the actual kind of native cryptocurrencies, stable coins, and then CBDC's and, you know, issued fiat currency on on blockchain in terms of a value standpoint. >> Well, I have to warn you, you just used a triggering phrase to me there. The intrinsic value of Bitcoin inherent value, I think. >> Sorry. Sorry. >> It's It's okay. We won't talk about it. There are plenty of videos um that I produce that are available on my YouTube site where I talk about um the uh intrinsic value of things and how um academics and central banks misuse it to mislead us.
Um but anyway, so you're talking about where did where does the value of these three things come from, right? And >> yeah, and also in a sense, if we're just trying to use any of these in a currency like way, then how do you think we should be thinking of them in terms of their uh inherent or day-to-day value? Let's say, let's use an easier word. >> Okay. So, the first thing you have when you want to measure the value of something, you need to have a unit of measurement for that.
And of course, this is the funny thing is that we use fiat currencies. So, people talk about, hey, Bitcoin is now worth $125,000, right? Um, and it's a very narrow and quite peculiar way of valuing things. Uh, right. What was the Oscar Wild quote? Um, a cynic is someone who knows the price of everything and the value of >> I mean, you have this issue. We we see it in society. The >> uh people looking after their elderly parents is immensely valuable to society, but we don't put a dollar value on it.
um people working in the banking industry get paid massive salaries. Do they are they proportional to the value of the service that these bankers provide or are we just giving them that money because they happen to be very close to where the money is created. Um and in general when you happen to be near the wellspring of something um you get more of it. So, um, back to the value of Bitcoin. Um, I think it's starting to become clear that the main value of Bitcoin is this hard limit on how many there can be.
It is truly the only scarce thing in the universe. And it's you can go and look at the code and see that as long as uh humanity continues to act on mass the way they do in terms of running Bitcoin nodes and not making changes to it, it'll continue that way. And it's um there's a lot of friction and resistance if you were to try and change it. There'd be an awful lot of people, some of whom hold very strong opinions, that you would have to convince to change it.
Mhm. >> Um and this idea of um absolute digital scarcity is is a really really powerful one. I mean I think somebody I saw the other day was giving the example of gold is valuable because it's scarce but as it becomes more valuable we look for more techniques to extract more of it. Um so the sea is full of gold. It's not economically viable to try and filter out gold um atoms from the sea. But if the price of gold went high enough, at some point it would become worthwhile to work on how to get their gold out.
Um, if an solid gold asteroid uh were to crash onto Earth, um, ignoring the fact that it might, you know, destroy 95% of life on the planet, um, it would immediately devalue gold. And we have no guarantee that that won't happen. And we have no guarantee that uh we're not going to wake up tomorrow and find that they've found a massive gold reserve in Siberia um where they equal to the amount of gold that is currently in Fort Knox, which would immensely uh deflate the value of gold.
With Bitcoin, we know that this much comes along every 10 minutes and it'll continue to um reduce in how much is produced over time and eventually it's going to cap out at just under 21 million of these. Plus, people are losing them all the time. So, having something that is truly scarce makes it very useful for um uh a store of value. I I don't know if you've read um uh the Douglas Adams Hitchhiker's trilogy, but I think at the end of um uh the third book, there's this group called the >> and they decide to use leaves on trees as money.
And of course there's an immense problem in that they're so common that the value of money their money is um vastly deflated by all the forests and their solution is to burn down all the forests right um and I think that illustrates the problem you have with money is that it needs to be there needs to be enough of it that you can do sensible transactions you don't want to be transacting with minuscule flakes of gold um but there can't be too much of it because then you're carrying wheelbarrows of it around.
So, um, so that's the Bitcoin side of things and I think I went on a little bit too long there, so sorry about that. >> Okay. And know, can I ask a question on that? Because people I've seen a lot of people say it's absolute scarcity, like this is never going to change, but and you even started with that and then kind of caveed it a little bit to say, well, there's people with very strong opinions that would not want to change it. How absolute is that?
Like I'm not saying it's very likely that you know the scarcity the upper limit could change but I see more and more people posting as Bitcoin becomes more centralized there's potentially more external influence to maybe change that upper limit not in the next 10 20 years but what about 50 years is it possible that that absolute scarcity we're all so comfortable with is an absolute um well you can do it tomorrow you can release a fork of the Bitcoin blockchain where you say as of today um we're going back to issuing 50 Bitcoin a block, right?
And that would bump the amount up immensely. Um, and it would be a fork and then it's up to all the miners to decide if they want to jump on it or not. Um, and in fact, forks of Bitcoin have happened on numerous occasions. The most well-known ones are Bitcoin Cash, Roger Ve, and Bitcoin Satoshi Vision by Craig Wright, who is no longer to say that he's Satoshi. So, uh, um, there goes that vision. But uh then then you have the question who jumps on which bandwagon and uh if you look at the dollar prices of Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV um they show that it's not the mainstream one.
If you look at the number of nodes that are being run for it whereas it's Bitcoin core that has the lion share of the support. So if there were a proposal that was enacted on to make a bitcoin fork where the amount of bitcoin was increased the the total cap was increased uh some groups might decide that they would follow that. Um others might stick with the original one. So in that sense the the answer I guess is yes and no. Um and my feeling is at the moment that it's one of these kind of core things about Bitcoin that um the majority people don't want to change.
So I think there wouldn't be much traction for a >> um I mean what would the purpose be? Um why why would you want to increase the amount? And the answer is somebody must be thinking that they can make money out of this, right? >> Um and then the question is who is it? Now if it's all the miners then they might well do that, right? we say um and of course they're the ones getting the block reward but on the other hand they may also look at it and say well yeah I'll get more Bitcoin but the value of it will be less and the confidence in Bitcoin may drop so actually thinking about it rationally it's not a good idea to jump on this new chain because it's going to give me more bitcoins that are worth far less and my dollar value of these things as a result is reduced so I'll stick with the traditional 21 million in cap.
Thank you very much. >> Yeah, it's interesting. I think I think I've seen it mooted in the past, not for quite a while actually, but I saw it muted I think in the context of just the number system not, you know, having enough space to capture enough value. I think that was the the argument, right? And I think at that point you you're doing pretty well and you don't have to worry so much. And also to your point, I think at that point if it's if it's more like a it's it's like making the system quantum secure, right?
if it if it needs to, you know, if you need to add decimal places to make sure it can literally be the the main use of currency used across the whole world, then it's not going to undermine confidence necessarily to implement that change, but I think we're a long long way off that yet. >> Um, and I I think so just just to couch it again, so what what do you think would be the optimal kind of end state for these three categories? Um I think I can guess for one of them but in terms at least in a world where we have you know native currencies and then oh sorry native assets like bitcoin and ethereum for example and then you have your stable coins and let's include CBDCs as kind of a comparative example.
So how do you think ideally the world would be using them in 20 years time? >> Right. I mean I think firstly my opinion is that the mechanisms behind them and the backing required um may well differ. But if a central bank were to issue its currency on a blockchain as an ERC20s token, then from our perspective, they wouldn't differ much from stable coins, >> Um, and central banks would become the sort of the leading stable coin issuers in that respect. So, I think you can in this because we're not looking in detail at stable coins versus CBDC's.
If you step back and look at crypto versus stable coins and CBDC's ignoring the irrelevance of the EU releasing its own database backed system and not having any to do with blockchain, which is I think fairly likely, um, blockchain stable coins and blockchain CBDC's are pretty much the same from the end users point of view. Um, and so then we're stuck with stable coins, representations of jurisdictional currencies versus um, crypto. Um, and the thing is that stable coins include centralized controls. If you look at the smart contract for Tether or Circle or uh PayPal USD, they all contain a freeze um option so that uh a particular account can no longer move uh coins around.
Some of them contain the ability to then burn the coins that are in a frozen account. Um and there's this mint function, so it's all in the hands of the entity controlling that smart contract. Um, and for all of us that's really the same as everyday life, right? I don't have any control over how many pounds pound notes the Bank of England prints um or what kind of bond sales go on to inject more money into the economy or what kind of fractional reserve holdings are required this month um to multiply uh the money supply.
Um and similarly I don't have control over tethers freezing, unfreezing, minting, burning of USDT. When you move to crypto, it becomes different. Yes, there are restrictions and rules, but they feel more like um like physical laws like gravity, right? Bitcoin has these rules. They're baked in there. We all have to play by them. There are no special players who get a a hall pass for Bitcoin. you, me and the governor of the Bank of England are all beholden to the same rules. Um, and it's on a censorship resistance system.
So, um, with a bank account or with, uh, USDT or whatever, I can be censored. The bank can say, "You can no longer have your funds. We're investigating you for money laundering." Or tell say, "We've had a request from the FBI to freeze this account. Sorry, you can't move those USDT." Um, with Bitcoin, they can't stop me. Well, unless they lock me in a jail cell with no access to the internet. Um, and this is where I think it's going to get interesting because I do have the sense that we're moving into more and more authoritarian times with more and more surveillance and restrictions.
Um, I'm not living in the UK at the moment, so I have a bit of a skewed view of it as to how it's reported abroad. Um, but there's lots of what to me now look like rather odd things rather going on in terms of how policing is handled and um what people can and cannot say under what circumstances and I'm not going to go into the politics of that but um >> yeah but it feels like there are more and more restrictions and governments have more and more capacity to put cameras up to request information about our finances to um hold data on us And that's worrying.
And now we have this um second financial system that they can't control. So it's quite possible that it's those restrictions that start moving people over. Um so that's the second step, right? The first step is onto the blockchain because stable coins are there and it's just like digital banking. And then when people are familiar with that um moving on to freer financial systems where those controls are not so much in place and this has upsides and downsides. I mean um there there are good reasons for having legislation and know your customer and um uh counterterrorism funding um regulation because most of us don't want people laundering money.
Um but it's there hovering in the background when you look at the idea of um money that can't be censored. Yeah, I think um it's you again we're getting into very we're approaching very difficult questions, right, which is speaks to the you know the not just the impact that you know cryptocurrencies have had the fact that we are having this conversation but also how difficult they are to answer and I think >> I I I I broadly agree with you. Think it seems to me you have the class of financial instruments that we're going to see the stable coins ushering in issued by you know financial institutions or or governments they they're a horse for a course okay and they have you know these protections baked in which make complete sense and they solve a set of problems either for the institutions themselves or the customers that you we will be able to access new products um via them but then the kind of native crypto side like a Bitcoin or Ethereum is solving a
very orthogonal different problem set, right? And and and that's more for the very extreme cases, which I think, you know, I think we should definitely have you back on in the future, Kia, to get into the weeds of some of those, but maybe we need a bit more a bit more preparation and and, you know, see what happens in the world before then. >> Um, but yeah, Kia, it's been a it's been a real pleasure to have you on. I think, yeah, we could talk about this stuff for days, but maybe we should we should do another session another time.
Yeah, thank you so much for joining us. >> Okay. Well, thank you for the opportunity and uh let's make sure it's not 18 months in the future. >> Yeah, exactly. Well, because I mean honestly at the at the current rate, who knows what where we'll be by then. On that note, we'll say thank you for listening and you can join us next time to untangle a little more web
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto