Episode 4
Micropayments
About this episode
Join hosts Alec and Jack on an exciting episode of Untangling Web3 as they explore the world of micro-payments and their transformative impact in the realm of Web3.
Discover the origins of micro-payments, their fascinating history, and the challenges they face within traditional payment systems. Delving into history, our hosts trace the roots of micro-payments from Web1 to the groundbreaking introduction of the "payment required" status code (402). They uncover how traditional payment systems often hinder micro-payments due to fees and unnecessary intermediaries. It's time for a change!
Enter Web3, where Alec and Jack reveal the immense potential of micro-payments. Thanks to peer-to-peer transactions through blockchain technology, Web3 offers an ideal environment for micro-payments to thrive, unlocking new economic models and opportunities.
Exploring the opportunities within Web3, Jack focuses on micro-incentives, where gamification takes centre stage. Micro-payments can motivate positive behaviours, such as health improvement or recycling plastic bottles. Alec explores payment streaming, envisioning real-time payments for energy consumption and pay-per-minute media streaming.
Got a question or topic suggestion? Send us an email at theuntanglingweb3podcast@gmail.com
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast your go-to Hub to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web 3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web 3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep uncovering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast hey Alec how are you doing mate yeah I'm good all the better for seeing your face and hearing voice yeah this is uh this is fast becoming my favorite part of the week so yeah nice to be back for another one yeah I know it's it's exciting talk about these things and I think that the last episode was very interesting you know talking about tokenization nfts it's it's much more tangible than some maybe like the
web 3 and blockchain it's more practical and I think it's more interesting to talk about with the use case and I think the episodes we're going for now we probably going to reflect that too yeah for sure I think it's uh it's it's a nice way to start talking more about use cases instead of just the intangibles of web 3 um but it's a it's a big old topic so I think we've only scratch the surface there and we'll have to to revisit tokens plenty of times in the future um so I guess yeah we we've covered kind of the some of the basics the background on web 3 blockchain and now tokens um and one of the things we haven't really touched on is kind of this idea of monetization you hear lots of that uh in the token world as well right we kind of we didn't really go too deep into into the the financial and monetary aspects last week well that was one of the things that I took from last
last week's episode is we could tokenize one of our episodes one of our podcast episodes and potentially try to monetize it and then when I kind of mentioned this to my mom she was like well I wouldn't pay very much for it and I was like well maybe there's a mechanism for that maybe we could use micro payments which is the topic we're going to be talking about today to actually facilitate the purchase of one of the one of our episodes very nice nice segue onto today's topic Al Supernatural casual I know so um so yeah microp payments we're gonna be talking about today and trying to discuss kind of what they are because that's one of these these core uh areas in web 3 it's something you'll hear a lot of people talking about so you know as ever should we let's try and Define this term first before we go any further so what does Micro payments mean to you Alec so micro payments to me is being the ability to send a
very small amount like you know less than 10p or less than a penny to someone um for a very cheap fee basically for a very cheap transaction yeah exactly I think um you know it's something we encounter a little bit in in in real life but it's I wouldn't call them micro payments necessarily like I think one one of the things what's the smallest thing you've ever paid for I think I mentioned Penny Suites in the first episode on web 3 which was a little bit of an outdated reference but you know you're not used to going into a store and spending less than a few pounds right because normally they won't take a card payment for that so micro payments is really um includes those things that you can't those values those values are so small that you can't pay for them in brick and mortar shops but then it also will Encompass a huge range of even smaller payments that are you know maybe sub Penny or Subs scent maybe tenth or 100th
of a scent per per transaction and we're going to kind of explore today what what's what what might you be wanting to pay for of that uh in that amount no exactly I think um that we talk about small payments like being able to send a penny 5p you know what was it Fredo used to cost 5p back in the day you know they're up to a pound or something crazy like this but it you can't imagine why you'd want to pay for very small Goods with you know with change or or cash typically and I could say transfer really two or three p to you on your monzo or your bank account but I couldn't do that with a card like what can you actually pay for What's the the minimum amount a card I think that's the difference between say a microtransaction like you were saying before which is sometimes less than a penny in a small transaction which is probably like five pennies to to a pent potentially and I think yeah
one of the most interesting things that we're going to touch on today is what would you want to pay for that costs less than a penny like when I first kind of came across this topic I didn't understand why you would ever want to send know fractions of pennies to people but yeah I think the idea of micro payments is actually quite revolutionary and it's going to be a whole paradigm shift and there's going to be whole business models that derived specifically from that concept which we couldn't even imagine you know five to 10 years ago yeah exactly and I think it's worth maybe if we just quickly go back into the history of payments uh on the internet to kind of see how how we've arrived at the current state and why this micro payment Paradigm is a new thing so one of the one of the kind of references I really like is um in the early development of of web one so the early earlier stage of the internet where it was
just kind of this idea of sharing data and information widely with when they were building the kind of core protocols um for doing this information sharing you you know we're aware of this this thing called the hypex transfer protocol HTTP you might see it when you type in an address um in your search bar uh or on Google and one of the things that that protocol includes is these things called status code so if you've been to a website and there's not something there you might get a a 500 for a server error or something on the on the web page and of the status codes was actually uh I think it's 402 and the the message was called payment required and this was kind of put there in the early days of web one right because they were envisaging that you might you might visit a website and have to pay a small amount of money say 10 10 cents or some other small microp payment to access the data instead of how we
we typically now have it everything's free always behind some kind of bigger pay wall that requires your credit card you know yeah and I think so yeah just when Jack talks about HTTP I mean that's effectively the the kind of the rules of what the protocol for transferring and and interacting with you know sending data across the web basically what enables interoperability across the web so when he says that there there was this 402 kind of code or protocol in that it means that they had this in mind they thought this was going to be a mechanism that people would want to add embed payments small payments for for data exchange um but I I would ask why didn't that happen like it seems like you know it's something which talking about right now they obviously thought about it when they were developing um developing the web Why didn't it happen exactly that's the big question right what if the early developers were thinking about it why didn't we you know start paying for websites
like that in a small kind of granular way so I think the the main answer is that there wasn't a a payment system that could could do that that could facilitate small transactions so the the developers of the internet thought you know I'm sure we'll get a payment system that can do this and and never really materialized so then you know that leads us to the question why didn't one of these Payment Systems materialize and I think that's all down to um the costs of the incumbent payment systems and and the cost of running a payment system in general so you know when you go and make a a bank a debit card payment in a in a store for example there are a number of different fees associated with that transaction now as the consumer you won't necessarily see those fees you just get the the price on the terminal you tap your card and off you go but the um the merchant actually has to deal with a lot of these and there's
a I think there's typically three fees involved so that there's a fee involved with the the bank that issues the debit card you're using there's a fee involved with the um the terminal that the Merchant's using the the point of sale terminal that you tap your card at there's a fee for using one of those which are actually very high and then there's also a payment processing fee that you get that goes to you know a Visa or a MasterCard for for settling that payment essentially making sure that it goes through and that there's this communication between the two Banks and all the parties involved there are taking you know they have to be paid for for doing that service so they they're taking costs away um at three different points and those c those costs Stack Up basically so that you know below a certain point it it wouldn't be there would be no Revenue in it for them to offer payments below I mean I think the limit is pretty low right now
you can't do anything below 50p or something would be completely infeasible yeah so like you said there's a lot of intermediaries that are involved in you know just me submitting a transaction or trying to purchase something with a card in quite what I see is quite a simple payment but there's a lot of intermediaries involved in actually getting that payment to the the Merchant's Bank account effectively so we have this like flat fee plus a percentage which doesn't scale so when you know if you say I'm buying something for 50p then with all the fees that're included if they did support this the actual purchase might cost 80P and you know that just doesn't make sense if I know an item's worth 50p and I'm being charged 80P or the merchants someone's being charged 80P that markup doesn't make sense and I think to to make this tangible this is the the reason that a lot of places you don't accept AMX for example you know because the fees on AMX are so high that
it actually puts a lot of pressure on the merchant to sell you know at a higher price basically it's why small businesses don't typically support people like up institutions like AMX and it stops the sales of small products yeah and if you ever walked into a shop that has you know this minimum card spent that's the same effect and it's it's important to know that it's not just you know digital payments like when you're you're using your bank money that's kind of a form of digital money but um it's not free to to handle cash either when you make a cash payment there are there are also costs on the merchant for for handling your cash and and and processing it that you know again you don't see as the customer but the the merchant incurs which would you know if we wanted to pay a penny for something in a shop that that would also uh make that more difficult and then when you look at the internet right no one's buying your penny
Suite there's probably more than one reason why we don't wear penny suits anymore yeah so how does that how does that then map through the internet right because we're talking about web payments so how how do we get from the world of the the cost of um brick M payments to to the web well I think um what one other point that kind of relates to the question there which I think was another inhibitor it wasn't ju in my mind it wasn't just about the fact that institutions made it prohibitively expensive to to do micro payments because of the unnecessary intermediaries I think there was also like a mental aspect to the consumers and the users you know if I offer two solutions one where you pay for exchange on the internet using micro payments and another that's free and you have some you know ad-based internet which I think is what you were just alluding to Jack if to me like the initial upfront cost of potentially having to pay for all engagements seems
like the worst option of the two and I think that was maybe maybe shortsightedness because they didn't see that advertising would become such a big part of the social media you know Facebook classically didn't have have advertisements at first it got the user engagement and you see okay I'm getting a free service an incredible free service I get involved it gets very sticky and then all of a sudden the advertising comes in and I think that's the mechanisms you're thinking about because we don't have this kind of inbuilt micro payments for for data Exchange in the internet because of the reasons we just stated internet bases or internet companies had to move towards a more ad-based internet yeah exactly and I think maybe just to disentangle a couple of Concepts here so I think you're you're kind of touching on the larger point that we can kind of delve into now but it's also worth remembering like you know what Payment Systems have existed for the internet itself I think one of the earliest dominating
ones would be something like PayPal right so some of the earliest uh transactions I ever did on the internet were with PayPal they you basically had companies like PayPal um you know we also have stripe now but but making it easier for people to accept payments on the internet and they have a very similar business model if not even um more expensive with even higher fees so the same problem that exists in the real world became a problem of the internet and that combines with exactly what you were saying there right it combines with what was the actual business model on the internet which is this uh this Advertising based subscription based um monetizing your clicks essentially you're monetizing your attention model that came about on the internet so you you have these two things you have the fact that there's one there's no real payment system that is low fee and then to the internet decided Well we don't really care about that anyway we're going to we're going to make our money using
something a very different model which is what we're all kind of accustomed to now in web to yeah definitely so without the ability the ability for to charge users seamlessly in small increments I guess like the big media players they needed scale where you know you either had a an audience or a user base that was loyal enough to subscribe and pay regularly or more and more the user base is big enough for for advertisers to care and them to make money from the actual advertising that was on there and to relate this back to a point now I've learned what clickbait is I imagine this is one of the one of the reasons that clickbait is so prolific is because it's all about traffic and not substance and this is like one of the things I think people you know we talk about social media a lot but I think this is one of the things that people are starting to wake up to you know that the classic line that we keep repeating
I think everyone repeat is if you're not paying for something you're the product people are sign to wake up to the fact that you know they are paying with their time with the content that they're kind of they're looking into with clickbait all these kind of things and maybe there are alternatives that are coming out you know social media Alternatives where I do pay a little bit but I get a better service because of that yeah exactly I think uh you know if we if we were want to to ever monetize this podcast we would end up feeling the same the same forces of the the internet business model you know we would have to be competing with the or or using the algorithm right that everyone is subject to so I always find it funny when you see a lot of people talking about you know being a digital Nomad and working for themselves not working for a boss so they start an online Media Company you know they're producing content on Tik Tok
or YouTube or something um but for me they've in a lot of cases they actually replace a nine-to-five boss with the big opaque algorithmic boss in the sky and you know if they don't they don't do what makes the algorithm happy then they they really struggle so it's kind of a scary situation to be in I think that um so much of of monetizing things online is now based on these big players and their algorithms that we don't necessarily know how they work either yeah well you can't see this but Jack is head to toe in branding but little did that the branders know that it's actually not there's no audio that's sorry no visuals that are being released right now yeah you are right um I mean yeah content creators who build followers and you know they actually do add value they're completely reliant on social media Outreach and because of like these lack of financial tools for you know for consumers to directly incentivize the the content creators they have to rely on
either Revenue sharing with the platform itself you know with Facebook or they have to rely on advertising or brand merchandising in in the content they create so yeah I think the idea of direct payments in this nature which we're going to talk about a bit later is going to create like it's going to definitely affect influencers and like content creators exactly so I think maybe just to summarize that that thought on you know what's the state of play in web 2 we kind of have an internet now where you know we never saw a microp payment system evolve and in its place we have kind of two dominant modes of monetizing things one is things that are free at the point of view so that look free but you know you're actually paying um with your attention your time through advertising and things and then the second business model is this subscription based one where you know you might get some things for free they might sometimes you call it a premium model you might
get some content for free or some some service for free and then the platforms have to to monetize um by Subs you know making you subscribe to something like we've talked about online newspapers which do that they might give you three free articles but then you have to add and enter A1 pound a month subscription or something so that's kind of the state of play of web two um so where does web 3 come in then what's the relationship of micro payments in web 3 how how are we looking to solve these problems so I I mean it's I think so okay if we're saying that web 3 is based on the principles of Bitcoin and blockchain in a model in which interaction is more peer-to-peer and we don't need these unnecessary intermediaries we can have these cheap micro payments or these cheap transactions um which allows us to know for example directly monetize data ownership if I own my data and someone wants to access it I can monetize their access to my data
for example I think like we're going to assign value to data exchange and there's going to be a lot more transparency in the operations of you know value exchange whereas right now I don't know how people use my data for example I don't know how Facebook's using my data you know the Cambridge analytica Scandal and all this kind of stuff I think in the web 3 model in which social media platforms based and it actually monetized through direct engagement you see where that monetization comes from there's going to be a lot more transparency a lot more trust in the process but also a lot better dis distribution of of the value to the end consumers as well and I think there's all the stuff around you know improved kind of solutions I think we're g gonna go into a bit later about like Bots and spam and how we can kind of make these kind of these um issues redundant in in a web 3 Model where we're kind of associating associating value to actual
data exchange as well yeah that that's my high level kind of understanding of how it's going to affect how web 3 is going to affect microp payments or vice versa yeah I think I I completely fully agree with that you know um I would say Bitcoin is essentially what presented uh the first practical way to do micro payments by incentivizing a competitive Network to process payments instead of it being like a large gatekeeping Network that's more rent seeking let's say so you know web 3 being partially if not you know almost entirely based on the industry that started with Bitcoin uh taking that microp payments idea into into the mainstream is a huge part of that I like what you what you're talking about there with um monetizing data because you know it that's kind of wrapping up some of the other problems we've been talking about into this right it's not just there's one problem that we can't do micro payments to pay for you know looking at a website that's one issue um
that we might want to solve uh on the on on on the internet but since those early days when they had the the status code you know they also didn't envisage that we'd be essentially giving up our data for free to use the internet um and we also want to to monetize that and that's where they kind of go hand inand micro payments are small in nature you know micro and so is data so are the so are these incremental pieces of data that you're giving um every time you you you you make you take an action you click something you you watch a watch a video or something these are all small kind of granular actions and how do you value them well you need a small you need a payment system that can do to make small enough valuations right it needs to be able to micro payments are the only thing that could apply Financial value to uh an item of data essentially an action or recording of something recording an action
you've done so it's for me it's kind of funny that we've come full circle in that micro payments that were envisaged right at the beginning are now being reintroduced to solve some of the downstream problems that web 2 brought along with it yeah and I wonder if one of like the the the limiters on this is that you know a lot of people say well it's actually not that cheap to transact on you know Bitcoin and ethereum and all these things and there you know congestion and the lack of scaling issues that we've seen you the fact there's more transactions per limited space means that the transactions fee are actually getting higher and you know these these kind of these these blockchains that are underneath supporting in these models they need scaling to kind of facilitate this as the adoption and the user base increases yeah yeah exactly um it's kind of a there's there's some level of hypocrisy right in the claim of web 3 to do micro payments but in practice many blockchains
are that expensive that you know they they've uh become what they seek to disrupt in that the cost of using them is is so high in many cases but I think when we talk about micro payments in web 3 we're talking about um this model that you know in in some cases is is being proven um and and so long as you can scale a blockchain then all these these use cases and possibilities are possible um and that's kind of why we want want to focus on those they become what they seek to disrupt was that like a a direct reference to Star Wars I like that no I'm thinking it's it's is it is it is it Batman you live long enough to see yourself become the enemy or something like that there there is a quote I thought it was obiwan when it says you became the very thing that you s sought to destroy the Sith anyway I think we're going to tangent a little bit so maybe that's a good point
to call a break okay so we've had a stab at talking about micro payments in general and what we we think they are and how they relate to the the different phases of growth of the internet um so I think at this point we normally turn to uh I won't I won't call it our friend this week because Alec thinks that's weird but we'll we'll turn to chat gbt to compare our definition and see if it can tease out any other things we we missed I think chat gbt is your friend and I my tool maybe but yeah so chat GPT describes micro payments uh as for small Financial transactions typically online that usually involve amounts less than a dollar these types of transactions are common in various internet services okay nice I think we kind of we we Define that pretty well I think we actually Define them as as much less than a dollar but um yeah I would know if i' Define um you know 50p as a microtransaction maybe but this
has been pedantic the second part of the definition is microp payments provide a way for digital service providers to earn money without having to charge a large amount all at once it's like going to a store and buying one apple instead of a whole bag I like that that's quite that's quite an easy to understand example and I think it's going to become much more tangible for people once we start to go into some of the use cases of micro payments yeah definitely I think I really like that as well that that second part because it's kind of it's hinting at this idea of um efficiency or economic efficiency that I you know it's something I have a big problem with personally in with the subscription model is that you end up paying a big chunk of of money every month for something that you may or may not be using you know I've had subscriptions where i' I've not turned on the service at all but I've still paid 10 pounds and that's for
me that's like that's an inefficiency in in in in in my money but you know we all have these of subscriptions it's it's great for the platform sometimes but I bet you tell your girlfriend that you're just paying for the subscriptions you're not actually using them no no not not like that but um I'm just messing with you um yeah so why don't we go into some of these actual models that we keep internet do you want to kick us off yeah sure I think um so I think there are two kind of key areas of opportunity we have with micro payments um that you know are slightly different applications of them so one of them is is is on micro incentives and the other is then I think payment streaming so I'm just going to focus on micro incentives first and and um you know another term you may have heard for this is gamification and I think lots of us are becoming quite familiar with the idea of gamification through things like um
education and health um so I know you know things like dualingo for example are really a really good example of of how you gamify learning a language so you you know you have small tasks to complete you get small rewards when when you when you um you know you do some uh some vocab testing or something to learn a language and then in health you also have um I know Vitality is quite a well-known health program where you know you're doing some small activities filling in uh Health Report doing 10,000 steps a day you get a small reward for that that can build up over time to get a free coffee or something so gamification is is a really interesting thing and it's there's a lot of research showing that it's effective at incentivizing Behavior so I think taking that to the next level is basically what microp payments can do is instead of in those examples you know dualingo there's no real Financial incentive it's just a it's a it's a psychology thing and
in the Vitality example um you you might be earning a coffee at the end of a week or a month but you're not getting these small these small incremental payments you kind of have to redeem it all in one go so micro payments essentially let you be directly incentivized for everything you do and this is good for the user because obviously they can get paid for something to do something but it's also good for companies if they want to incentivize you know it their their customers to do something to Pro to provide a little piece of data to F fill in a survey you know how many times have you had a survey someone asked you to fill in a survey and you've kind of G ah I can't be I can't be bothered with that if you can get paid five P to do it I think you would right so that's kind of an exciting one I think yeah I mean Emma asked if I knew what the term gamification was um and
I do I am a gamer so I understand it I've been very hooked on certain games I mean you know it's when they threshold they're like you know earn two more points and you get this Milestone and I've been playing the game for like 10 hours and I can't really like see straight anymore but I still push for those two extra two extra points just to level up like completely get this like the gaming industry so into this and I think other Industries are now catching up and being like how can we apply the kind of the tools and the mechanisms of the gaming industry to to real world life because I mean in a way they've kind of proven that it's quite addictive and it's sticky and people people love this kind of stuff don't they exactly and I think that to give a kind of concrete example of of how powerful this is is in something like Recycling and I know this is actually happening in other countries already there are places that
are much further ahead than of the UK than this but there is a I may have mentioned this already in that previous episode but there's this there's a a plastic bottle return scheme that's being implemented in Scotland if it hasn't already started and I think the idea is that as a as a consumer plastic bottles that you get in in a shop for your your Coca-Cola or your your kind of um your Fanta bottle or whatever it is you can get 20p back off the the cost price of that item when you set take it to a recycling center which is a very clear incentive um for someone to recycle and it's a positive action it can help towards the kind of Net Zero goals of the UK I I think Emma said in the chat Malta is a good example of this you know where they've been ahead of of the curve on that and it's a nice example I use the Scotland one because it's 20p so it falls in this micro payment
range that we're talking about and and it just shows um there's so many places that you could apply that logic um and I I particularly like it for this kind of B tooc angle business to customer where you could have um you know a big company that wants to engage its customers better instead of just sending out these these impersonal emails that are just informative you know maybe a company is trying to educate its customers on uh on environmental issues instead of just sending out an email that that gives them information maybe I incentivize them to to to to perform a little test or take a quiz to prove that I have actually educated them instead of it just being you know uh in informative I'm actually proving the impact that that we've got so I don't know if there's any other examples of that kind of incentive scheme that that interest you Alec but that one that I I find interesting yeah I really like the the recycling one that you spoke about you
can imagine like not just the like governments incentivizing that scheme but also you know if I can scan a QR code of a Coca-Cola ball or something like that then it's Coca-Cola itself that gives me the money for that because they can prove you know they can offset their carbon footprint prove that they're more ethical and you know what we say was micro incentives of 20p in this country I mean that's not necessarily micro for someone in I don't know sub Sahara in Africa so like this has this is scalable to other countries as well I know there's in certain countries where there are lots of plastic bottles these are actual kind of like full-time jobs for people so there's like real money to be had from these schemes it's not just like a little side hustle which we probably see in the UK like real kind of economies can't grow from this in terms of like other angles that I think we can look at I am a big time reviewer like I love
reviewing services like on Google absolutely everything I just love going to a restaurant I knew there were people out there that do this I'm glad we found one I am the person like people appreciate it so I I because I'm so into it I don't even know like how much people appreciate it it's like people so 70% of consumers prefer um user reviews or consumer reviews to marketing and advertising people love that kind of stuff and people need at least four reviews before they trust in the product of a company and my point is like how do you know when one when reviews are authentic how do you know when reviews are authentic like it's a big big question like you see so many kind of spams online especially on Amazon and things like that and I think related to the the last episode imagine being able to tokenize a purchase to prove that you know you paid for that Cola bottle you actually you know do own that Cola bottle tangibly and then you
can link the ability to review that that Cola bottle because of your purchase so that's that's the one element but to relate to gamification how do you incentivized honest consumers to review you know I mean one way would be micro incentive you don't want to like have to give a over5 pound out for review but five or 10 P just to leave a quick review like I think a lot of people would be inclined to do that and it's the same with like loyalty programs you can link this to loyalty whereas say in coffee shops you it's more economical for them to offer a free coffee on on the eighth coffee that you purchase you could incentivize people directly by giving small amounts like give them five 10p per purchase back and they can reuse that in store potentially yeah 100% um I think yeah the applications for this are kind of endless and there are so many ways that microp payments can be integrated to kind of what you're talking about in reviews like
I think of something like uh Q&A services like qu online you there's a model to there to be had where you can have Micro payments just for answering but then you have subsequent payments micro payments for the reflect the quality of your answer so normally you have you you have like 10 answers given to a given to a particular question and then people come in and up up or down vote them they'll rank them and yeah if you have a micro payment I know but not everyone necessarily spends all their time Googling the answers to their problems like you are some people you know might might not rely on the internet so they're up voting your answers every time yeah and again you know that's that that's incentivizing the right kind of behavior I think is crucial that's why I kind of say uh micro payments for micro incentives you're trying to change or incentivize a type of behavior like recycling is one example and then quality of information is is is the other we're
talking about here um so yeah I think I think I think uh reviews surveys uh online questionnaire kind of things is is a really good example even to like oh I was gonna say even to link it back to the social media that we were we were talking about earlier like there's such a problem with bots on Twitter and you know fake accounts and and spam accounts and all this kind of stuff I mean we also talked about the fact that it's really difficult for influencers to be directly incentivized they have to add Brands and advertisers and all this kind of stuff like if imagine if you could you know direct I think we used this in the previous example directly engaging and directly sending microp payments to people that would also kill off the entire kind of Bot scape that exists on Twitter if they can you know Bots are really easy to spin up and make a quick bot account that then spams people and is quite aggressive and you know is to
the detriment of the platform but if we start charging micro pay payments per Engagement online you get rid of all these Bots don't you like they're no longer become economical and you could apply this to emails as well like you know how many spam emails do you get imagine if it cost like a small micro payment to send an email it would just remove the ability for spam accounts to just send out millions of emails to accounts they've never like never even recognize I never even heard of yeah for sure I think um this is a super interesting point right you touched on I just want to mention before I kind of talk about email the the social media one is is really powerful and it comes from I think an asymmetry of cost that you have so just by going from a free to a it costs something model completely changes um it introduces a huge asymmetry to be a bad actor so even if the cost you know it's nonzero but it doesn't
have to be high it could be tiny it could be a tenth of a p to to um to post but it then becomes so expensive to subvert to spin up a million accounts and it's the asymmetry between behaving um in a socially uh good way let's say and then behaving as a bad actor trying to subvert so I think it's kind of this whole new paradigm and the email example I love and I'm so glad you mentioned it because I completely forgot about this but do you know are you aware of the the proof of work C aspect of email aleec is that is it something you come across no I'm not but I'm sure you're better enlighten me cool so this is this is such a nice link to web 3 I think actually so proof of work before I I carry on is um we may have touched on it I'm sure in previous episodes but it's this idea that you need to expend energy to do some work um to prove
that you've you've kind of made some some you you you you've sunk some cost into something right and it's the kind of the Bedrock of how Bitcoin works and how many other blockchains work so proof of work is this thing that essentially commits you to to to a cost to do something now proof of work has been massively popularized by Bitcoin but it was actually used earlier than that for email so emails and I they might even still do it I'm not entirely sure but at some point at least in the past so every email you would send would have this this small proof of work attached to stop spamming and it's the same idea of asymmetric cost it would be very expensive to do this proof of work for millions of emails to spam a lot of people but for the average email it doesn't cost much so is that happening now I don't understand how has this not been implemented I get spam all the time it's so tiresome yeah I I so
I I think it's um it was definitely implemented in some places I don't think it's used widely and it never really caught on because it wasn't it wasn't trying to be too prohibitive I think email when it came about the idea was um making it as open as possible but it's just interesting that the idea has existed of trying to stop spam by adding a cost right that's the key idea and now micro payments are people are looking at social media as a way of doing this and you know as a concrete example we've seen I think in the last few weeks Elon Musk so Elon Musk has also Gone full circle right from founding PayPal as one of these first payment systems and the internet that stop micro payments he is now proposing that they allow that for news Publishers on Twitter so you can pay a small amount to read an article on Twitter which is kind of really fascinating to me yeah we we tried to get him on as a guest
today but I think he's a bit busy and annoyingly may maybe next episode we'll get him on yeah hopefully the um the other aspect you know we've talked about micro incentives gameification so the other one that I want to speak about I think you touched on it a bit earlier Jack is payment streaming which I find very exciting this is where I really see you know business model kind of flipping and you know much more kind of it's really focus on the consumer and benefits to the consumer so really quickly so you know we're very used to the concept of paying subscriptions you know paying on a yearly basis for you know your Spotify bu your Netflix Amazon Prime whatever it is but most people even though they have the option to pay yearly um they they tend to pay monthly even if over the course of that year that costs a bit more and you know the reason for this is It's better consumer cash flow no one really wants to pay a 100
pound up front for the year when they can pay you know1 pound every month because of cash flow so it means I have more money per month and I can better manage my money but also like you said earlier I think you guarantee that you pay for what you use if I pay for a year up front and I don't like service after two months then I can just stop I can I still have to pay for the remaining 10 months but if I pay on a monthly basis the most I'll ever lose is a month worth of payment if I decide to stop using it so that's the second benefit but the final benefit of breaking you know large subscription payments down to smaller payments is you guarantee that there's consistent content quality if all of a sudden the the streaming service becomes poor again I'm going to cancel my subscription so there's potentially more pressure on them to keep outputting good quality content and this is like a a really common concept everyone
understands it people tend to want to pay monthly over yearly I think it's like 70% I say I think I know 70% of consumers prefer to pay monthly over annual subscriptions and 90% of consumers around the world have at least one rolling subscription service so this is a very common common concept but why do we limit it to monthly would be my question wouldn't you prefer to pay for a service you know on a daily basis or an hourly basis or even like a buy second basis Jack well and this is to be honest I mean I'm going to call this an open question right so one of the things I I know there's this research out there that talks about like what's the maximum number of subscriptions a US household will is willing to have and it's quite low it's something like four or five um and part of that is obviously to do with the cost of having many subscriptions partly part of it might also be due to the um the mental
energy of managing subscriptions and I'm actually I'm kind of holding out judgment on whether people will f for for for all applications if people will prefer the idea of paying monthly because it's kind of a way of bundling up lots of small interactions into an easy to manage cost that takes less mental energy um will people will people be able to get around the hurdle of saying no I'm going to pay for exactly what I use but it means I have I can see payments going out all the time and I don't know actually if that will be something that people latch on to or maybe people will prefer the subscription model for that reason but um I guess that's a problem of user experience right and how you design the solutions yeah I I think for me so that the concept of this is like I said breaking rather than you know paying on a yearly basis or a monthly basis breaking even to even smaller increments that are paid more regularly so like
you know rather than paying monthly for your entire next Netflix subscription you pay per episode that you watch or rather than paying the example you gave I think in one of the First episodes was rather than paying for a newspaper up front you you know you pay this 10 pound for the whole newspaper not knowing how good the new newspaper's going to be you pay per page that you read you pay like 10 P per page that you read um you can even apply this to gyms swimming pools all these kind of things pay per second that you're actually there and I think yeah I I don't think that this model is going to necessarily replace like existing subscription models and because like for the reason you mentioned Some people prefer convenience even if it means they might potentially lose out on quality or have like worse cash flow management purely because of the convenience but I think there will be an alternative especially for people that you know are kind of more economically strapped
like you want to break these payments down to smaller models like if someone said to me okay I'll offer a Netflix equivalent where you pay daily and I'm tight that month yeah why wouldn't I opt for that kind of solution I only use Netflix you know well I actually use Netflix a lot of the time but if I only use Netflix on weekends maybe I only want to start my subscription on a Friday night and finish it on a Sunday morning and just binge an entire series for the weekend and then stop my subscription again yeah I'd say Netflix is probably the one subscription where I do get my money's worth and probably more um but I think you you've kind of hit the nail on the head there because it's not again and a lot of people will throw the baby out with a bath water with web 3 and go we're going to replace everything but no it's about I think micro payments are essentially just a credible alternative to the subscription based
model and people will love the payment streaming flavor of micr payments probably if if the cost is is important enough to them people who want the convenience will will probably opt for the subscription model and carry on but you know you only have to think of something like energy Energy payments I think that is is exactly the kind of thing where you know we kind of have a pseudo uh micro payment model with these smart meters where you can track um how much you're you're using you kind of you you you you have a micro monitoring system but you're not actually paying in increments you're still just paying at the end of a month um but I think energy is is a good example of where you literally do you really do want to pay for only what you use and you don't want to pay for anything more or less so that that's that that maps to micro payments and payment streaming perfectly I think I think a good example that I've experienced in
my past is like paying for shoters or paying for therapists like physical therapists like all this kind of stuff they have really high high expenses you know it's like it's 80 pound per hour1 pound per hour you pay up front there's no like guarantee of quality like imagine I would be so much more there's so much less risk involved if I was to pay per minute if I was to say okay pay one pound per minute that I'm actually in there like I guarantee straight away that there's there's lower risk because they I'm going to ensure they're going to be insured quality from their side and I'd be so much more willing to opt into services like that if they exist yeah yeah and it it just kind of lowers the barrier to entry to accessing Services right I think that's kind of the the Crux what you're saying is I don't need I don't want I don't need to pay a 50 60 70 pound upfront fee to do something I can just pick
up the phone because you know this you could you could conceive of um I've seen web 3 applications where you can pay per second of someone's time and people can list their their rates maybe their 10 p a second maybe they're 5 pound a second second if there if there are any L musk maybe even more um but it gives you a way of having some kind of level of access to work out what you need and there are so many you might have a conversation where your problem gets resolved instantly and and and and you don't want to you know you don't want to have to pay this big chunk of cost um for something and then you might have other examples where you do need to pay longer so it's again just a more efficient way of allocating resources but it also lowers the bar to people accessing the resources in the first place I think which is is really useful for yeah and like it it might not be suitable for everyone
like I said you said before that some people will up for convenience paying monthly some people might you know use more than the mean they might be the kind of the top one percentage of Netflix users like you so maybe a pay per episode subscription wouldn't work because you'd be you know watching it 18 hours a day every day and you probably price yourself out so it's not for everyone yeah exactly I I think there plenty of caveat as with everything um but I think broadly you know we're quite optimistic about both these these propositions of microp payments yeah I'm so excited especially for Content like media even like access to facilities I find this like to be such an exciting kind of prospect I'm really looking forward to seeing what businesses will start to deploy it yeah for sure it's it's it's like it's very much the space of possibilities opening up we don't know what will be what you can do with this right we're just listing things that we think we're actually
listing a lot of existing businesses and business models that could be altered using micr payments but we kind of are ignoring all the possible new business models that we don't even know of and the new companies and and use cases that we we can't even conceive of right now that will be made possible by micro payments so I think you know that that's also what excites me is the unknown here may maybe to uh to finish today I think another Hot Topic right is is AI artificial intelligence in the news with things like chat don't say yeah I mean we've been we've been you know for for a number of episodes talking to our friend chat GPT but um we haven't talked about the significance necessarily and I think everyone's talking about these large language models and and chat Bots and things but I think it's worth as considering how micro payments could impact them and how they they might be related because I personally think it's a huge it's a huge um potential marriage
of the two things but you know I wanted to know do you have any opinions on that so are you talking about like what the the economic usage so right now is like he's talking about how I pay per usage of chat gbt we talking about how the data actually Exchange in in the back end well I think I think both right I think web 3 and AI have lots of different overlap like I think yeah the most obvious use case is just micropayments for usage of of them because um I don't know if you've seen a few weeks ago the mid Journey service so the one that gener generates these photo realistic images based on text prompts you can describe what you want and it'll it'll spit out an amazing image which again really scary but they had a free trial and it was so inundated with use that they had to stop the free trial and you have to go straight to subscription now and it got me thinking you know if you
just had micro payments available to to to to you know you pay 10p 50p I mean people will pay a lot of money for these pictures before mid Journey you probably pay hundreds of pounds to an agency to do these things for you so you you could you could be charging 50p a pound for every use of the of the of the mid Journey service instead of forcing people to jump straight into an expense subscription so I think you know just funding the AI models themselves is a great use case of micro payments well you tell me now I mean I'm one of those suckers that signed up to the chat GPT subscription but even then they they give you like a number of uses so it's like so obvious like you get 25 uses a day or something like that for for Cat gbt 4 so yeah directly aligns with the amount that I'm paying like I suppose the problem is that over the month that I pay for 25 uses a day like
it does break down effectively to fractions of a penny per usage and there's not the economic models to support it right now or they don't think there is anyway but we're kind of uncovered this episode that there are the economic models to support it so that effectively wraps up the episode we've talked about micro payments what we think they are you know how we've kind of come full circle from the early Inception of micro payments and now actually get to a state where we can start to deploy them and use them in in real businesses we've gone through two main kind of applications micro incentives and payment streaming and we went through a lot of applications and use cases where these can be applied so yeah I think micro payments is an extremely extremely exciting topic and the kind of the use cases and possibilities are endless So yeah thank you for thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions
and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Business & Society