Episode 5

Metaverse

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

Welcome to another exciting episode of Untangling Web3 with your hosts Alec and Jack! In this episode, they delve into the captivating realm of the metaverse.

Join them as they explore the concept, its historical roots, its relationship with Web3, key components, the current landscape, compelling use cases, challenges, and the future it holds. From the iconic novel "Snow Crash" to Second Life and Ready Player One, Alec and Jack highlight the evolution of the metaverse and its connection to Bitcoin and Meta (formerly Facebook).

Together we delve into how the metaverse relates to Web3 and how the metaverse serves as an interface or gateway to Web3, incorporating elements such as virtual reality (VR), augmented reality (AR), artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain technology, and social networking.

But the metaverse is not all games, it holds the potential to revolutionize services. The hosts envision a future where phones enable seamless access to the metaverse and how the metaverse can transform work and education, opening up new possibilities for collaboration and immersive learning.

Alec and Jack paint an exciting picture of what the future of the metaverse may look like - more immersive experiences through advancements in VR, AR, and extended reality (XR), the evolution of avatars to represent individuals more authentically, the growth of digital property/land ownership within the metaverse, and the continued development of value exchange systems.

Get ready to unlock the mysteries of the metaverse! Join us on Untangling Web3 as we navigate the vast possibilities and potential of this digital universe. Tune in and embark on an immersive journey into the metaverse.

Got a question or topic suggestion? Send us an email at theuntanglingweb3podcast@gmail.com

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

podcast you'll go to hope to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet so we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep uncovering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web3 welcome to another episode of the untangling web3 podcast hey Jack how are you doing very very well thanks Alec nice to see you again how's things in your world yeah things in my world are very good very great right now again always better for seeing your face but you know here's everything we're going with you how's your week been yeah very good um I think you know as we're recording this we're starting to get some nice summer weather at last what better way to spend an evening than in indoors recording

a podcast instead of being out there but no it's uh yeah I'm enjoyed I'm enjoying the summer kind of creeping in how about what have you been up to last week ah you know just prepping for this podcast you know this is a full-time job basically I'm joking don't say that no I mean this episode especially is I'd say a bit of a passion of mine so I don't think I actually needed much prep but I suppose we'll see maybe I should say that I shouldn't say that until we finish the episode yeah for sure I mean it does drive me that this one will be very much in in your wheelhouse um so I'm excited to hopefully learn quite a lot from you today you're putting all the pressure on me now I mean one thing I would say is last week we talked about you know micropayments and we weren't very use case specific and I kind of said you know it seems like the podcast and the episodes were doing it getting

much more tangible and kind of practical and now we're taking a step back and we're talking about the metaverse which is an extremely non-tangible and quite abstract kind of concept so this should be quite interesting yeah definitely I think we're uh from the sublime to the ridiculous you could say yeah I think it's very interesting one because it's both uh as we'll get into this this concept the metaverse is both tangible and intangible it can mean kind of many things to different people but it is quite hard to wrap your head around some of the concepts I think to start with so yeah hopefully we'll we'll be able to Grapple with those today yeah definitely I mean do you want to start with your definition of what you think the metaverse is sure um again so I I'm very much I think the Layman and this one uh this week but for me so metaverse describes this idea Virtual Worlds and virtual Realms and realities that may or may not be blended with our uh

you know visual perception of normal reality so again I'm already getting into a mess of terms but it's essentially a way of doing new things in in in in immersive environments so we'll have these terms augmented reality virtual reality and I think extended reality is another one XR where we're we're taking you know instead of just doing things in the real world there are these different gradations of uh interacting playing games learning Etc in environments that are supported by something digital I would say um and there's lots you can do with them but um yeah that's that's my kind of waffly my waffly answer maybe you can improve on that for me no that that's that's great I mean you included like a lot of new Concepts that we're going to expand on but yeah to keep it kind of short and concise I think of it as a fully interactive digital reality it emerges the physical and digital world and it's all about the intersect of those two and you kind of you talked

about AR VR and XR and like you say they're kind of a scale of how much real world you're experiencing how much digital world you're experiencing where VR is like full digital you know everything you're seeing in front of you is kind of projected in into your eye basically through like a a kind of a screen effectively whereas AR you're mostly experiencing the real world so some glasses or something like this and within that real world you're actually seeing there's projections of digital kind of Assets in that but we're going through in some very specific examples of that a bit later so what about it just before we move on so AR when you say when you say glasses I I immediately think of something like Google Glass is that the kind of thing we're talking about there where you kind of put something on and yeah exactly I think um some of the like the the kind of most popular examples of glasses that have this AR capacity right now are um the hololens

so these are extremely the basically kind of exactly what you just described these are extremely expensive bits of kit but they're so cool like I I was very fortunate to have a play around with them you kind of you know again ahead of ourselves talking about the hardware already but like Oculus headsets a heavy kind of um forget very hot you can't wear them for too long even like the newest versions but like the hololens they're incredible super lightweight super neat you can imagine wearing them day-to-day but I think we take a step back and before we start diving into the tech and the one other things I wanted to say about like the definition of of metaverse is we kind of the way we think of the internet right now is very 2D and I've seen a lot of people kind of um apply the term 3D internet and kind of like um this corresponds to a more immersive internet where we kind of see the digital world becoming more human I'm not just

kind of trying to push that in there because we said the you know web3 and web3 podcasts 3D you could say right oh nice let's coin that sound quickly has anyone use that before hopefully I don't know I'm gonna write that down please but like it's not just web 3 that kind of interacts all this and kind of comes into people are saying that it's also AI you know blockchain VR it's like the intersect of so many disciplines potentially but I think we're getting a bit ahead of ourselves and maybe we should again take a step back and talk about some of the history of where this uh this term metaverse and concept came sure I mean I I can I can give you the the brief history that I'm aware of um and you can probably fill in the gaps for me so you know I actually I initially I was like well metaverse seems to be this thing that uh Facebook or previously called Facebook and now rebranded it's a matter of obvious

reasons you know in 2021 they kind of popularized this so for me that was one of the first times I started hearing about this but I realized after doing some reading that it actually kind of dates back much longer than that right so I think a lot of people go back to this um this sci-fi novel by um Neil Stevenson called Snow Crash from 1992 I think and that was I think that's where you'd have this first description in in in a in an in fiction about what what metaverse is kind of like but I haven't read the book so I don't know if you if you have and you know more about how it's described there yeah I mean I'm a massive nerd so this was a bit of me definitely snow crashly it's unbelievable it's basically a book about you follow this character who's kind of lives in this dystopian world and they have this version of the metaverse but also it's kind of this character's interaction both the real world has kind

of gone a bit crazy and the virtual real world where most people tend to interact and he said this this Neil Stevenson he was a bit of a Visionary I guess like I've got a couple of quotes that kind of just highlight her like how forward thinking he was one of them's not super related to this but he said um there was like in this in this novel this snow crash he talked about robot dogs employed by defense contractors and you're kind of you're thinking about the the DARPA spot dogs that are now being employed by like military units these robotic dogs so that was what I hope Facebook aren't doing that as well right but like another cool one that he was one that he coined well he says that he didn't coin I think it was it was him and someone else independently coined the term um Avatar so it was obviously has become like super relevant right now and he described avatars as um their pieces of software that represent people in

in the digital space that was one of the first terms that the kind of the first times we actually saw that that term being used um and he says they're basically audio visual bodies that people use to communicate with each other in the I but the pennies only just dropped that's where Avatar comes from I had no idea that that was the AV of Avatar right audio visual wow exactly all right learning already thanks but yeah so that was one of the the first kind of um I guess data points of the metaverse very interesting would recommend anyone to read that book it's very cool and then I guess the next big data point which I imagine you've played Jack I think everyone's kind of played it a little bit it's Sims which can you do you know what SIM stands for uh I imagine it's simulation simulation yeah basically yeah it's like life simulator I think it was and that was made in 2000 but they sold six million copies of that that first

version of Sims and for Emma's just said I was the queen of Sims it was quite cool like I mean that was like groundbreaking kind of game like you get to build your own little worlds like have these non-player characters interacting it was um it was very very yeah that's I actually did never play Sims I was more of a uh a Minecraft kid but these kind of these worlds where you you have um you know the open worlds that you can build things and do things in that seems to have taken off a lot in in recent years right you know fortnite is now this huge craze and it's interesting to see just how long that concept's been around I didn't realize how long ago Sims was now you said 2000 or something that was uh that's a long time ago so yeah yeah this has clearly been around for a long time but you know Sims is you you know we're talking about 3D or immersive visual experiences so in my mind Sims

is still kind of primitive example of that right that's still just a 2d thing on the screen exactly and yeah exactly and I think like The Sims kind of um setup was kind of quite it's about the kind of game like still it was fairly limited and I think in the original versions you could like it was intended to build houses and build universes in the kind of well not universes but it kind of it felt quite a limited in in my experience anyway but then there was this you've heard of this one I guess then there was a second life you heard about this so I wouldn't even describe this as a game like the creators of Second Life they really are adamant that it's not a game because there's no objective this was like a whole this is in 2003 they set up this kind of Second Life vision which is around like kind of creating a virtual world so there was their main like I said the main point is there's no

objective to it it's just to experience like a virtual life basically and you know it was all about the career economy they kind of set up the infrastructure and expected people to kind of build their own worlds there's like multiple continents seeing people built their own cities it was really cool and I think one of the most groundbreaking parts of this is they had real economies in there like people actually had like real virtual jobs in there they had like this real um virtual currency in there that people could convert to Fiat and some people's like entire kind of actual income came from Second Life there were people that were acting as like teachers in there like I don't know just like filling their non-player characters they were making real money it's so cool to think of these like virtual economies what platform was this on because again this is one that I I don't know if I was just out playing sport you know in the real world too much but what was what

was what platform did you uh did you play Second Life on you're talking about like device or yeah what how did how did you use Second Life what was it this was still still PC like this was still PC back in the day so I didn't play like second life that much I think I I kind of played it quite a bit after I mean there's only like eight years old when it first came out so it wasn't that big into second life it wasn't signing a job back when it came out but I think after um well we'll talk about it in a sec after reading Ready Player one I was like oh my God what is this real is this possible can we do this now and then I played second life because of it I was like oh God we're so far away from this like Ready Player One Vision yeah so I'm glad you mentioned Ready Player one because that's all kind of captured the philosophy the ideas most vividly to

me this idea of kind of plugging in to a new virtual world uh where you can you know you can do anything right the possibilities are endless in there and and that's that kind of gets to the heart of it being digitally immersive instead of it just you know in in The Sims or Second Life Cases still it's some PC or game uh based thing when you add this idea of hardware and putting on a pair of goggles into the scenario that's when the immersion kind of takes off to the next level right yeah and I mean I love Ready Player one so much this is one of the reasons why I want to push this episode because I was talking about this with some friends there where you have to do an episode on like on the mayor verse basically but yeah so I read the book before the film came out and I was pretty much obsessed with it this is so cool and the the film did a great job like it

really kind of encapsulated what a lot of people kind of uh wish for in in the kind of the final version of The Meta versus if that you know is ever possible basically but one thing that I think was quite different between the the book and the film was that the Universe in the book was that well it was exactly that it was it was a universe it was kind of it talked more about the services the economies like the real world utility that I don't think the film kind of encapsulated like the film was more about right the gaming experience the tasks like that kind of stuff it was more like they say gamification having fun in there in a lot of ways whereas the book actually talked about this universe like people actually having Services their jobs their entire lives being based and there and I think that's something that you know we really need to speak about when we talk about the meta verses most people are still kind of thinking about

it as just a way to have a bit of gaming experience for example I don't blame them it is the get big gaming companies that are really pushing the agenda in this space and it kind of it makes a lot of sense it will be Gamers probably that the first adopters of these like you look at the Oculus headsets and all this kind of stuff that's VR friendly like there's games that they're kind of used on right now but more and more we're going to see the utility come into this yeah that's really interesting because like so far we've tried to describe the concept pretty much exclusively in terms of games but that that seems like the the next Frontier is the where the real utility is what you can do Beyond gay uh you know game type things I mean the one that would then spring to mind is something like the Matrix where people are living their entire lives plugged into this machine and that has its own quite scary connotations with it

right so I think I think that's also saying that people push back on when there's metaverse concept yeah I mean it's two sides of the same coin like there's a lot of resistance to this you kind of either think of it as a tech Paradise that brings people together maybe in the maybe what's kind of portrayed in Ready Player one to an extent even though like the actual kind of real physical world's a bit grim and sad in it or like a disadopian hell that pushes people apart um but yeah I think one of the other really interesting things that's race in Ready Player one is this idea of like um you know there's the creator of the Oasis this James Halliday and his kind of vision for what it should be versus these big corporations that were trying to like section it off and monetize it and this is another big question is you know head of businesses head of private developers fit into this this idea of like in an interoperable space anyone

can kind of access um yeah but I think one other thing that was shown in in that movie we talk about utility and not just being a game is you know the bits where he buys he buys items in the game and like tries them on while he's in the virtual space they get delivered to his real world like we're seeing these kind of use cases already yeah exactly but I think I think you're kind of hitting on a really interesting point there as well about the businesses and and how the harder businesses and large organizations adopt and grow the metaverse because that's you know as we kind of started and we're back now to the to 2021 and and the present day where Facebook have kind of pivoted to this being their their main play for for their whole the whole business operation to trying to make the metaverse a reality and all these things we've been talking about um so I mean one thing I would I would ask at this question at

this at this point of view is where obviously a web 3 podcast and what what exactly is the relationship with web3 here because it so far it sounds like something that would be quite independent of it but I'm sure there's there are some links to draw yeah and I mean the metaverse is in kind of in my mind right now is effectively the gateway to web3 is how I I kind of Envision it when we think of like the metaverse being focused on the principle of like user experience and getting users into a space web 3 is kind of like the foundational protocol I guess that allows that space to kind of function at the at the lower levels um you know when we're thinking about some of the main principles of web 3 that we discussed in the first episode it was all about user centricity and when you think about user-centricity and user Focus the 3D internet will make everything more immersive so it's just going to add value to the kind of

the user experience and I think that's why metaverse and web 3 are kind of so intrinsically linked yeah that's interesting I think I think I broadly agree you know in my mind the metaverse is something that can exist completely separately from this web 3 economy that we've been talking about so far in the podcast but it's something that is has a big overlap with it and a growing overlap where I see web3 as being the kind of technological rails of of uh how you you know how you get that utility in metaverse so without web3 the metaverse might just be this uh this this kind of narrower focused uh thing where you might have you know uh metaverses for gaming but with web 3 and the technology stack you know enabling micropayments enabling ownership of digital property that's where I can certainly envisage metaverse becoming this much bigger thing that provides all this utility and can be you know used in lots of different applications Beyond just gaming in my mind yeah definitely I mean

that makes a lot of sense like I mean we're going to talk about all the individual components that contribute to to the metaverse and there are so many a lot of people are kind of just catching up with the hardware right now because that's I mean how a lot of people will access the metaverse but there's so many individual components that you said that you have to work out on you have to work out ownership we're talking about Services they can kind of be embedded in the metaverse how people can have jobs how people can create content and all of this relates to web3 and like you said before it's not necessarily not necessary for the metavers to be based on web3 but right now web 3 does fit the bill in the best way it seems for sure for sure um I think we've had a good stab there at you know defining ourselves should we uh as you as always turn to chat GPT and see what its definition is and see if

we missed anything out yeah I think you know chat TBT is your friend so I think maybe you should have a go given the definition from chat gbt yeah I'll let uh it helped me out this week in particular so okay here's how chat GPT explains uh the concept metaverse so the term metaverse refers to a concept that describes a virtual universe or Collective virtual shared space it is often depicted as a fully immersive interactive and expansive digital world that can be accessed by users through various devices such as virtual reality VR headsets augmented reality AR glasses computers and mobile devices so yeah I think we've mentioned a lot of those aspects first there's anything we missed out there no no I think yeah we'll go into more detail on on the hardware after the break I mean this is something that I've kind of worked on in the past and particularly interested in and like I said I think this is the thing that's really taken off in the past few years is that

you know the software to an extent has been there for a while but the hardware is really catching up now and becoming like commercially viable of people to own in kind of like quite you know simple terms and use quite simply and I think that's the thing that's kind of the big enabling factor for this this metaverse hype that's taken off right now yeah I think that's definitely the biggest Gap in my knowledge is the whole Hardware side of things and how how you need that to make it as I say this properly immersive experience um I just kind of finish off this uh this little excerpt from chat gbt because there is a little bit more so also says in the metaverse users can engage with digital environments objects and other users in real time creating a sense of presence and interactivity it goes beyond traditional 2D interfaces and aims to provide a more immersive and interconnected experience the metaverse typically incorporates elements such as virtual reality augmented reality artificial intelligence blockchain technology and

social networking so I think that that there is is quite a good insight into just how many different concepts are actually being kind of overlapping with the metaverse right that we've only you know we've only talked a little bit about web3 and the blockchain aspect but also mentioning artificial intelligence there is a whole other a whole other ball game to be talking about yeah I mean it's like how many buzzwords can you get into one sentence so I touch your teeth just ticking them all off so it's interesting like um obviously chatty fatigue is kicking off right now it's enabling people to kind of have you know real-time kind of I guess conversations and you should use chatty PT to kind of um I guess take the best information from the internet like you were talking to an expert in the field I think that's it's really intuitive how it does that and how that relates to the metaverses I've seen gaming companies actually forget which gaming company was the demoed this recently but you

know non-player characters in games they have these kind of set responses that you can go through like five responses or something like that and then they're out of they have this loopback where you can only go through those five responses at any one time um well this this gaming company is now pushing AI basically in into that that kind of MPC field so you can ask them anything and they can respond in almost any way but they're also doing so audio cues like they're trying to push like physical cues and all this kind of stuff so you can have like real-time kind of responses and kind of custom bespoke responses from NPCs and games was just crazy like this is going to be so immersive and so cool yeah that's really exciting stuff I can see how chat gbt with a really improve some of those those uh quite dry and alternative responses you normally get from non-player characters yeah we've talked so far about the metaverse quite generally we gave our definitions and went

into some of the very interesting history about the metaverse and actually discovered the world that it's quite an old concept and then you gave us the chat GPT definition and now we're going to expand on some of the concepts that chat gbt introduced so I think one of the the kind of like I said before one of the most important aspects of metaverse especially in recent years like the fields that are growing extremely quickly that have kind of enabled like real adoption and a lot of excitement around the space is the hardware really it's um like I said it's developing really really quickly like when we're looking at like the VR space I mean I think most people will be aware of like what a VR headset is Oculus have kind of um have kind of pushed the Forefront of VR headsets so quite quite vehemently and so Facebook actually took over Oculus back in 2014 so they kind of set their intent to jump into this space you know quite a while ago before

this whole this whole minute so I've I've never you know I've never owned one of these Oculus or any VR device so I I'm it sounds like you probably have used one right so what what was it like when you use one what's the experience of these things so right now it's quite clunky there are these like giant headsets they're like helmets effectively it's quite heavy helmets that go around your head and then give you like a full 360 visual kind of cues you know like a basically like a cinema screen attached around your attached around the front of your head so you can't see anything outside um I mean the kind of the the more Nifty ones these days are a bit more lightweight and you can also kind of you can also see outside of them so you can like say switch off the the display and actually you have cameras to see the real world if you need to because they are can't get quite clunky and dangerous um and then the

Oculus ones they have these these handles that you can put your hands on that kind of like trigger guns so you can know where your hands are relative to where you're looking so you can obviously interact with the environment it's not really enough to just see what's going on you want to interact and then they have this kind of like inbuilt tracking system so when you move you tilt you twist like you would in real life your visual your vision changes your hands move place so it really allows you to quite basically interact with the environment yeah so I'm thinking I'm in my head I'm thinking like the kind of thing you might find in a really really good arcade where you know you've got a big screen in front of you you've got uh physical prompts you've got you know maybe your seat is moving but it's it's fully immersive because you're you've got the headset on and you and that's all you can see right you can't see any of the the physical

world anymore yeah it's it's very similar to that I think one of the things that is missing right now is that is the movement aspect and I think it's probably more a practical thing as well as like a technological thing is that you can't have people that are playing this game in the room running around and hitting walls I've seen videos like everywhere of people like getting scared in these like horror games and just like jump into one side and hit the wall and things like that smashing the TV by accident that kind of thing yeah exactly so like it's crazy because right now if you actually use one of these VR headset on these oculuses the graphics are quite poor compared to like you know top spec televisions or gaming PCs and all this but even though the graphics are really poor it feels so much more real and immersive just because it's 3D and moves with you like I mean I got my mom to play this horror game on quite a basic

Oculus and she was terrified like really terrified like I have like a sometimes a fear of heights and they put you on this like Gangplank on like top of them like at the Empire State Building and you know it's completely fake but there's a part of you that really gets immersive and you're like this is genuine scary yeah I can I can see that I can imagine I I have seen people playing the horror games before and thinking that's not for me that'll be that'd be pretty crazy but you know there are other things where you know just like you know the experience of being in space and looking out and seeing you know just just the the the expanse would be really kind of fascinating to do but yeah it's not something I've ever done but I can see so many applications of it and if correct me if I'm wrong but this kind of VR approach with the headset as you said Facebook or meta have uh you know they acquired Oculus and

I think that kind of forms the basis of their main metaverse product which is the kind of it's called Horizon worlds right so they're going for this very much completely immersive you're only seeing the virtual world and you're you know I've seen people going into it it's almost like Sims from first person perspective right you're walking around these kind of funky Graphics talking to people but instead of it being the the weird made-up flaggle noogle language you have in Sims it's it's real people talking to you right is you just pretend that you hadn't played Sims when really you you clearly have yeah exactly that and and I think like you know at the end of the day we've evolved to have three division over like hundreds of millions of years it's very intuitive it's what feels natural to us I think that's what makes it so immersive even though the graphics right now so are quite poor compared to what we're seeing in like TVs in real life and all this stuff it's the

fact that it's 3D and moves with you that makes it so kind of immersive and makes you quite addicted to these these platforms and I think also aside from meta really pushing into this space do you know who the biggest um seller of watches by unit is in the world right now uh no idea it's apple and apple I'm moving into the VR headset space they're releasing their VR headset this year and I think this is one of going to be one of the most exciting Hardware releases related to the metaverse like apple do not move heavily into a space unless they're 100 sure they're going to get Mass adoption and I mean this is basically kind of a bet on the metaverse and quite a strong birth it's got a lot of people excited um yeah if anyone's gonna get it right you think it'll be it'll be apple um maybe that's quite a nice segue into you know I wanted to talk we've done kind of virtual reality VR now maybe we can

talk about augmented reality because I think actually it sounds a bit scary or or weirder or less uh or more abstract but actually I think augmented reality is the one that most people will actually have experienced thanks to things like Pokemon go so I'm glad you brought this one up yeah and and again why the apple is a good segue is because this is a this is an example of a metaverse that you can experience through your your mobile phone by downloading an app like Pokemon go so my understanding of augmented reality is very much that we're taking the the real world and augmenting it with some digital assets digital elements that you put in there so in the case of you know Pokemon go it's people can can now go around looking at real locations which now have you know digital items these Pokemon available there to catch right that that's kind of the augmented aspect yeah exactly like the the principle behind augmented is you kind of you're capturing data from The Real

World so you just have a camera like on your phone and then you're superimposing like digital assets into that real world to make it look like that that digital asset exists in the real world so most people understand you're walking around a park and then all of a sudden I put my phone out I see the park on my camera but there's a Pokemon in the place of you know on the grass or something like that there's like a lot of complicated kind of um software that goes into that like reconstructing what the the real world looks like and ensuring that the digital asset that Pokemon is interacting with the the real world in the way it should be so it's on the ground for example or it doesn't like you know move through a tree and all this kind of stuff and I think a really cool example I saw of this when I when I was using the hololens a few years ago in this um This research lab was that they they

were using it for surgeons so they had like surgeons that were plugged into these these AR glasses and their plan was to have like operations where you could see you know the incision points or you could have like a little feed saying what the heart rate is and you know where you're at in the kind of in the surgery and all this kind of stuff I was like oh my God like this is such a cool use case like there's so many applications this kind of stuff it's not just games like this is going to have like real world impact yeah and I think I think that's really that's really interesting right because you're you're starting to touch on the the kind of scale um the sliding scale of different types of metaverse you can get when you use different types of Hardware so for virtual reality you really do need um that you just kind of glasses based right now hardware for augmented reality you could experience it through your mobile phone and pointing

your camera at a physical location or it could also be uh you know some kind of glasses based thing for Like a Surgeon where it's augmenting them so the AR I always think of Might the example for that kind of application is like a Iron Man right so the heads-up display that he has when he's inside the the suit you know that's that's hardware that's augmenting his his um his his actual field of view to give him you know all the things he needs to to stop the bad guys in in Iron yeah exactly and I did feel like I remember when I put those glasses on and I mean there's so there's so much like so many elements we could speak about when it comes to Hardware like the haptic suits how you kind of feel things like physically in the real world like on your body and all this kind of stuff um but like they're so hard to get like temperature and pressure on like I saw there's a lot of research

around mechanical gloves that manually apply pressure there's even like a lot of research around like water that flows over the haptic suit so you could get temperature and pressure and running pads and how you actually move around but I think maybe we'll need an entire episode just on the hardware that could be related to the metaverse so we could before we move on before I get too excited yeah well why don't we what maybe that's a good place to start moving on to the web 3 components right so the bits that aren't to do with the hardware but the you know when we said that web 3 being a technological underpinning of of um some examples of the metaverse so I think this is where you know things like avatars come in as an example of a kind of digital property that you can own and you can you can use to interact in these worlds so they represent you they might represent your identity depending on how advanced they are and all of that

can be done kind of I in my opinion most robustly with with the tools of web3 with the technology the security the transparency you get from web3 that's kind of the best way of implementing things like avatars digital property like um owning a plot of a land in our in our virtual Sims worlds that that's better supported by blockchain than just the gaming system right yeah so so a cool fact that I like about the term Avatar is it's um it's actually it actually means descent in Sanskrit and it refers to the way that deities descending to the mortal world and I think that's quite cool to think of us like kind of um you know transcending in a way from like the physical to the digital world and like you say like identity is so important in both metaverse and web3 and it's going to be you know one of the key ways that the two areas kind of intersect like how do you represent who someone is like in the physical world to

the digital world and it's not just who you are in a lot of ways it's a it's customizable it's like who you want to be I think a lot of people like that kind of ability to express themselves as such like Express who you who you want to be it's also like representing psychology and like physical actions I think a big part of the metaverse is like the whole point of it is going to be more immersive it's going to be more real like I said more human and as part of that it's going to be more emotional like one thing you don't get in like interaction right now and say Sims and stuff like guys you know you don't actually know how someone feels when they're reacting to something how they're responding but I think with all these kind of the the advancements in Hardware we're going to get like you know real-time kind of reaction it's going to affect people it's going to make the experience more emotional and that sounds quite wishy-washy

right now but that has a lot of applications that are real world Services if you're kind of you know I'll talk about it a bit later when we come to use cases but there's a lot of services that require the kind of the human interaction level and digital experience is obviously very convenient but it's less human and there's certain Services where if we have that can kind of gain that human element like I'm talking about but also have the convenience of doing it digitally there's a whole area that's going to kind of just improve like yeah I mean sorry I'm just happy to have it on record that you feel like a god going into a virtual world when you when you put on your glasses that is a that's an interesting insight into your that's what you took from that I know on a serious no I I completely agree in the sense that yeah the realism element of this because you know we're quite a long way off the having truly realistic experiences

in in the metaverse but I think they they will come as things improve and yeah I I personally could see that being incredibly useful for things like you know education for example you see in in in in the pandemic when when all all teaching essentially went virtual and what you get is these screens of of blacked out uh spaces on the on the zoom call right people don't want to show their faces because they don't have to and that kind of you can't then read facial expressions you can't have any uh you know a real engagement with students with your other classmates that a lot of people lost out on whereas if you could have these realistic avatars that actually do you know um track your facial expressions represent you then that I think I see that removing the barrier you know what you don't have even if you're uncomfortable showing your face you can still have a much more meaningful engagement with someone um in a metaverse world than you could have just in

this 2D let's call it web 2 world of zoom and Microsoft teams and things like that yeah no exactly and I think in them in Ready Player one you see that that kind of um there's that scene where it says suppress emotions or something like that and then jumps back in and starts displaying them I think yeah there's a lot of applications a lot of benefits that come from that and I mean the next thing that we should also talk about we've kind of I think you mentioned Minecraft and second life like one of the big aspects of this was digital property and and ownership and like these platforms were very good at allowing communities to kind of to build out their own content and create social engagement kind of you know self um self-perpetuating social engagement within the community by letting people build their own content own their own content and then effectively monetize that content by selling it on and all this kind of stuff and I said that we've had like we

had a long discussion about web3 and how it enables ownership and it's like an effective way for peer-to-peer engagement and there's obviously a lot of overlap there between what web3 will enable and how that will directly kind of incentivize usage of the metaverse through digital property and ownership yeah and when I think of um you know being in the metaverse and it's all well and good talking to some someone random that has an avatar um you know within the name tag on it but when it comes to actually doing business with them or you know more more colloquially just uh interacting with them exchanging you know some in-game or in World tokens for an in-world asset you you want better systems to mediate that exchange and and it's a way of being able to trust the other person on the other end of that Avatar you know without without having uh without having full understanding of who they are without actually knowing their identity even in some cases and just having this sort of proxy

for their identity using the tools of web3 is something that you could do to make sure that you can be more comfortable with within getting with having these actual value exchange interactions um with other people you know that's that's all where I see it being really powerful and on that digital land aspect right I think that's that's something that the businesses will be really interested in like I know we've already had a large companies dipping their toes into the metaverse we had um we had a fashion week I don't know if it was Paris fashion week or one of the big ones actually you know did a version of that in metaverse in decentraland I think it was maybe they've done it twice now actually and that's all well and well and good as like a single kind of Showcase Event but actually you know businesses are always looking for for better ways to engage their customers and if the value proposition of metaverse is better engagement then I can see how big companies will

want to use this new digital real estate as the their entry point for new customers so you know if you can buy items as you said in world that are purely digital that's great but you might buy physical items in world where you have a better experience you know and um you know we've talked about Apple already like instead of going to the physical Apple Store and trying on or playing with a new product you can get the experience good enough then you can see how you could do that entirely virtually I know you can already kind of do a version of that but you know not in a purely immersive way but if you could try before you buy without having to go to the store that's going to make people more likely to buy from these companies I think that's a really big proposition for them yeah people are pushing heavily into the kind of um like the development of space out there no Snoop Dogg's done like quite a few different like

concerts there and got like thousands of people in there I saw that there was a use case of someone that made like a a wedding venue so it's the first official wedding that happened in may verse like a couple of years ago and they tied the knot they got like an official kind of um Pastor or vicar there basically I mean one of the issues they had was that there was um there was server scaling issues so they couldn't support all the all the wedding guests so for some people uh the bride was invisible for some people that she was wearing a hoodie for other people she was wearing a dress and it's like quite funny to imagine those kind of issues happening but yeah it is interesting to see that people are building kind of what we think of like physical spaces into digital spaces and there's a lot of competition for this yeah I've also you know in terms of advertising I've seen companies just buying up digital land doing literally digital land

grabs right just because it is a way of advertising the more of the digital land you own the more people are going to see it and I think it was maybe Atari in one of these games um maybe it was roadblocks and they because in that game you're buying blocks of land and they bought all these patches of land together and then just uh basically made it read as the road as the Atari logo so it's just it's pure advertising there um so you could think yeah it's gonna it offers loads of different ways to actually get to your own customers right but this is one of the things I find difficult obviously people like buy land just to hold land and know that because there's only a limited amount of land the value is almost kind of almost certainly going to go up I wonder how that applies to the digital space as well because to an extent it is extremely scalable and there's maybe not the same limitations on that so there's no

guarantee that the value will go up and actually saw like a really interesting um and very interesting talk about the kind of the links between the metaverse and capitalism so obviously that capitalism is built on the principle of a constant growth and it's quite you know we're finding maybe there's difficulties in supporting that physically in the real world the constant growth implies constant production implies kind of lots of materials you know all the problems we have for maybe with plastics being constantly produced being produced sorry and he described The Meta versus a potential solution as this where you don't need to necessarily have constant growth in the physical world you could assume constant growth in the digital world where you know the constant economic growth and commitments to sustain their economic growth and jobs in in the digital space space without some of the consequences of having to you know Mass manufacture and continually mass-produce you saw this as a potential solution to the environmental crisis and I thought there was a really interesting idea

yeah that is really and you can see apparent out there with you know something like Bitcoin and other blockchains where you have this idea of digital scarcity baked in right so you know we you're wanting constant growth with some kind of uh scarce resource that you can almost measure that against and acquire so yeah I think I think that's another reason why these web3 ideas are so closely I wonder if we should maybe just kind of as we come towards the end of the podcast maybe we should talk about some any specific use cases because we've discussed a lot of use cases throughout the episode today I think we've scattered them in you know with some some interesting ones but is there anything like that you've seen or have thought about that would be particularly exciting way of using the metaversal or what it could be good for I think the the exciting things are kind of they've been talked about a lot I kind of I'm maybe more interested in the more boring aspects

the things that are going to Garner interest quite quickly because they're already a part of life and not nothing that's kind of too revolutionary but just kind of offsetting something that we do day to day now in the digital world and make it more immersive in in the metaverse potentially so that like I kind of touched on it a bit earlier like a lot of people use the digital world because it's more convenient but the the downside of that is there's less Human Experience so I think like a good example certain services like you know physical and mental health examinations that I think would kind of gain a lot from being in the digital world obviously the convenience people don't have to leave the home to have these examinations but adding the aspect of a more human interaction actually kind of seeing you know being able to be empathetic in there see the emotions in there I think you're going to get a lot from that like imagine having like I mean right now I

use a digital outfit a lot of my kind of Health examinations call Babylons on the phone and you've got to talk to like your GP um like on the phone but yeah you do Miss like the human element when you do that like I can I really can't imagine like a not too distant future where we'll engage in those kind of services those Human Services in the metaverse rather than kind of across my phone yeah I mean that's a really good example right because I can see that even not just in terms of improving the experience for the end user like the patient but also helping the outcomes so if if you have vegan these hyper realistic future versions of the metaverse where you could ask a patient you know touch the part where it hurts and then you can see physically how they react then it might it might give better cues to the to the physician on what's going on so yeah I can see that being a really powerful one yeah I

mean what about you jack what do your kind of uh use cases that you're thinking of right now well I mentioned education already uh very briefly and I think that's that's quite an exciting one and I think it's also it's one of those that is being pushed already you know if if metaverse is a tool for engagement then one of the most important things to to help people engage with is education and young people so you know if you can imagine learning about animals or or the planets through one of these these headsets where you can actually get up close and see it and zoom in and like see the scale of things you know yeah and visualizing the scale of the planets or or the different animals and seeing um you know a classic example would be kind of exploding having exploded version of the anatomy of of an animal right that that would make me much more engaged to learn about it instead of and also much easier to learn because when you

see 2D diagrams of these things when you're in school it's almost intractable to understand what's going on is this line pointing to this what labels go into what part whereas if you can explore it in the kind of 3D virtual environment that would be much more useful exactly I love that I mean you know we've developed over hundreds of millions of years to kind of learn through Visual cues and 3D visual cues and right now it's not too Interactive education system is not very interactive like learning from textbooks doesn't work it certainly didn't work for me and much more of a practical learner I see these kind of um these examples as like kind of education where you're involved and actually fully immersed as being like so successful and so important I think it's quite like the gaming industry is taking off so well because it's addictive like people love these kind of like this visual stimulation yeah and actually just as a final thought on use cases right just kind of it's related to

work and education but if you're not sold on the idea of these virtual immersions then the one that really got me was if you just think about putting on a pair of glasses and that would transform your single laptop screen into three or four monitors that you can see and you know interact with then you can basically have a much more powerful office setup anywhere you are right if you're working in there or in a coffee shop you know it's just a case of what you could visually see and you don't actually need physical monitors so that one that's one of the first ones that made me think yeah that's a that's a huge benefit like a tangible benefit that I could get from using one of these things you're all about work productivity right yeah yeah exactly always I'm always thinking about work I like so so um why don't we talk about some of the challenges obviously there's a lot of um that has kind of been been displayed about the mayor verse

but I think it's worth discussing some of the challenges I think one of the the biggest ones for me right now is interoperability so we have this kind of this term metaverse that kind of implies like a singular a singular version of of the metaverse I guess that everyone's kind of involved in but right now we're seeing lots of individual developers we're getting kind of some of the issues that we saw maybe in like that when we talked about web one to web 2 to web 3 about these walled Gardens appearing where individual developers or companies are developing their own individual metaverse I don't even know how you describe the plural or is it meta verses like it just sounds really nice it's the many verse right that's what we have right now right then and he's got he's got another one but yeah so this is going to be an issue like we can't have lots of it's going to be really hard to have lots of different versions of the metaverse like people

want a kind of a seamless um a kind of transition from place to place they don't have to go from kind of different different models of the metaverse and like it's not just about the meta versus when we think of them as like a collective as like an environment it's also about the objects we have like we were talking about ownership and in that nft episode um and how you kind of you take ownership from place to place now you guarantee that like imagine if you owned an object Like You Know Jack you owned a cup in in one version of the metaverse say it's Facebook's version of the metaverse and you really want to move that cup to uh no Apple's version of the metaverse like it's really difficult right now for for apple and meta to understand that that object is is a cup in both realities maybe you know Apple thinks it's a rock and it's like quite a silly example but when there's a place to like you know kind of

your avatar your profile like all the items you've collected did of your entire life like it's quite important to people and they said dropped abilities is like a really pressing matter right now people are really trying to develop standards anything like in the kind of the AI and the VR space there are standards that are emerging from like well I think Disney actually in Pixar push these standards but we really need to see like standardization across the board to kind of solve this interoperability problem so we don't get these these walled Gardens that are one of the issues right now with web 2.

yeah I agree I think that's also where you know web3 comes in and where that's one of the most important aspects of how web3 fits into this metaverse idea is by baiting things on a blockchain by having digital assets that are themselves interoperable then we have a common shared currency that can at least go between these different worlds if we if we want to think of the meta versus a collection of Worlds that that is also um quite probable end State I think I don't necessarily think it'll be one universal world but it will be this one was the universe of Worlds and yeah having a currency that can be used between them makes sense having common essentially common records common databases that are shared by these worlds which the blockchain can provide is also is super important but I agree that's we're quite a long way off from having that idealized version of it right now right now it is very much a bunch of Walled Gardens because I think you know the early

metaverse implementations that we've seen you know take as we said Facebook's Horizon worlds as an example I'm pretty sure that's not exactly web3 based we're seeing lots of methods built out as just web 2 products but you know increasingly I think the transition will be to two more um to more web 3 type things which will enable that interoperability so yeah that's a big one for me as well um the other one I I worry about as a challenge for the metaverse is is definitely this you know we talk so much about Hardware so that presents an obvious barrier to I mean I haven't I haven't been motivated enough to Shell out the money to buy an Oculus yet so I haven't you know I haven't really experienced that side of things I can imagine um other things you know Google Glass was effectively shelled for one reason or another you know probably because you couldn't get people to part money for that for that kind of thing so I I see that being a

big barrier to adoption but you know with all the with all the with that with how technology progresses you think that will decrease over over the future right yeah exactly Moore's Law I mean it's developing like an exponential an exponential rate right now but right yeah it's not like at the level where it's as convenient as a mobile device but you know I mean mobile devices are kind of conceived off like 50 60 years ago only in the last like 10 to 15 years they've become like Mass adoption so it does take time but it's happening quite quickly and I think yeah related to the the accessibility and the kind of the high barrier to entry right now for the hardware right now in kind of these these metaverse projects I guess it's like the start of a slow um there's not many people in there it's a bit awkward but I think we are going to see in the next 10 to 15 years it's going to hit that critical mass where there's enough

people that it becomes extremely you know fun and immersive but the question is right now how do we get the people in and I think it's been an issue around like it's been very Tech Centric and all the people that are in a very kind of tech heavy in the tech space and I think we are seeing a more kind of a switch to a more user-centric approach to this space like the concept of bringing people together and then this is this is one of the big pushes that is gonna and has to happen over the next five to ten years yeah exactly I mean in the metaverse you have a similar problem that's being faced in web 3 is what will be the killer application it could even be that the metaverse as a concept is the killer application of web3 that makes it take off but it's hard to know what will um what will be the most practical application that you know delivers value to users that people people actually recognize you

know the one the only one that's truly taken off that I can see is Pokemon go that was literally yeah worldwide phenomenon I have actually played it you know of all these things but um you say that but you know how many active users there are of metaverse right now I've met verse projects yeah I don't know I would imagine if you include all these different examples maybe quite High actually yeah it's 400 million active monthly uses of metaverse based projects I mean one of the interesting Parts is that 51 of them are 13 and below so it just goes to show that this is something that kids are growing up with and you know 400 million users it's just going to grow like these kids in 10 years time are going to be the people that are designing the technology developing the software and leading by example yeah that's a really good point I mean do you know what what's the biggest contributor to that that number is it is it a fortnight or

is it something else I I think it might be fortnite I I'm not 100 sure but yeah it's like a an equal contribution in like Fortnight um and kind of all the examples that we talked about earlier and I think that's interesting right to it maybe as a point to end on because fortnite is something that I would probably personally describe as starring as a game that has been moving to more and of a metaverse over time you've been able to do more and more things in it the element of in-game currency in-game assets has only grown we've had big Brands go in there like the one I always think of as um the Star Wars episode nine I think it was and they and they they actually plot critical details only in fortnite which was mind-boggling to me right that was an insane thing so it's becoming this this beer moth really that is much more metaverse than it was when it started out and I think it's only a kind of small hop

away from becoming a web 3 based metaverse that would potentially deliver a lot of a lot more value and a lot more um of that interoperability that we talked about yeah I mean gaming is definitely indeed in this space but I mean it's exciting to see I'm a gamer so I get it and I think a lot of other Gamers do get it it's all about user experience and they kind of user experience and The Gamers tend to have like you know the income to kind of Splash on these these big um these big Hardware pieces so they get it and I think you know that's a good place to end so I think we've covered the metaverse quite neatly I think I could have spoken for another couple of hours on this stuff maybe we'll do a future episode expanding on some of the topics that we introduced but yeah it's a good episode so thank you for listening thank you thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by

Emma camilleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web3 thank you the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes