Episode 115

Losing All Your Bitcoin...?

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode, Alec shares a harrowing story of Bitcoin loss, digital vulnerability, and eventual recovery.

After his phone was stolen during a night out, Alec discovered that his Coinbase account had been compromised—resulting in the theft of his entire Bitcoin holdings.

This candid conversation explores what went wrong, how crypto thefts are becoming more sophisticated, and what lessons can be drawn to protect yourself in the age of digital finance.

Key highlights

  • How the Theft Happened and the Shocking Aftermath. Alec recounts the moment his phone was snatched in London and how, within minutes, the thieves accessed his Coinbase app and drained his Bitcoin. Despite biometric protections and multi-factor authentication, the attackers managed to bypass security and execute transactions. Alec describes the emotional toll, the helplessness of watching the funds move in real time, and the feeling of transparency without control as he tracked the Bitcoin theft on-chain.
  • The Role of Custodians and Coinbase’s Response. The episode highlights a surprising silver lining: Coinbase investigated the incident thoroughly and refunded the stolen funds after six weeks. Alec praises the company’s approach, transparency, and user support—contrasting it with other platforms where victims often receive no compensation. This part of the conversation reignites the debate between self-custody and trusted custodians, underscoring the importance of platforms that provide recourse in the event of security failures.
  • Crypto Security, Recovery Challenges, and Broader Implications. Jack and Alec delve into how the immaturity of police investigations, social engineering, and growing AI-enabled attacks complicate crypto security. They explore how blockchain’s immutability—one of its greatest strengths—can also work against victims. They also reflect on the limitations of traditional law enforcement when it comes to investigating digital theft, and how Alec's experience may push more crypto holders toward regulated platforms, especially those that can offer a chance at recovery.

This episode is a powerful reminder that Bitcoin and blockchain may be secure technologies, but the people using them remain vulnerable.

Alec's experience offers a cautionary tale and a call for better security practices, awareness, and institutional protections. Whether you store your tokens on-chain or with a custodian, being proactive about your security is non-negotiable.

And sometimes, as Alec learned, choosing the right platform—like Coinbase—can make all the difference between loss and recovery.

This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

Welcome to the Untangling Web 3 podcast. So, we like to think of crypto as secure, immutable, trustless. But what happens when that immutability works against you? We see in the news all the time big thefts, big hacks, big scams. But today, I'll be talking about my own story as well as the wider picture and what's happening in crypto when it comes to crypto hacks and crypto scams and crypto thefts. It's a big one and probably quite a personal one. Jack, back in the studio. It's been a few months.

How you doing? Yeah, very well. It's nice to be back. This studio's clearly been revamped heavily. We're looking probably worse than ever because the the lighting's better. Um, but yeah, I'm excited we're talking about this because this is I'm I'm sad to say we've got personal experience in this one. But, um, yeah, it's it's it's good to to probably people to know that things can go wrong no matter how techsavvy you are and how much you know, you profess to talk about these things and know about these things.

The same exploits can affect anyone basically, right? at that core the same things can affect you whether you're like an individual user or even when we talk about like networks themselves being vulnerable to attacks these things happen to the biggest best known networks right so yeah there's lots to cover I think it's an important kind of public service announcement uh episode for us today >> public service announcement let's set the stage then so I think most people know that there are a lot of hacks and scams and Ponzi schemes and all this kind of stuff in crypto >> but we're in 2025 now surely the ecosystem has evolved to maybe, you know, get rid of some of these things or filter some of them out.

But no, it's 2025 and in the first half already 2.5 billion has been lost in crypto to hacks and scams. Already surpassing 2024's full year hacks and scams. This is big. Like obviously the big leading, you know, case in that was the 1.5 billion that was stolen in bybit in early 2025. This the single largest theft in crypto history. But that being said, 24% of all crypto stolen this year came from individual wallets and exchanges which is it's huge. So it's not just affecting the big companies where they have like a buy bit style um exploit.

It's also affecting lots of individuals too. And I guess the argument you could make for you know the numbers getting bigger is obviously we're at an all-time high in a bull market and all this stuff. know maybe the actual number of bitcoins being stolen is the same but the value of those bitcoins in US real dollar terms is higher but this stuff isn't going away like it seems like they're becoming more prolific there's more hacks that we're seeing in the news and more people suffering yeah I I'm interested at that statistic right about how many are being stolen from individual wallets because firstly you've always got this tension between you know self custodying so we we had a previous episode about custody we talked about you know the options for full self custody where you take control of your own bitcoins or you know crypto whatever it's going to be you put it in your own wallets you don't let anyone touch it right and there there are in theory plenty of safe ways to

do that um ranging everywhere from your software wallets to writing down your seed phrase and putting it under your mattress type >> but so there's always that tension between how you know security principles and whether you want to keep it on and off exchanges that probably contributes to this figure being so high is I think lots of people have you know maybe trusting exchanges just less and less over time. Um, which is kind of strange even though like some of them are getting much more mature in theory.

Like I think there is a general distrust of institutions in some senses. >> Do you think that the institution people using institutions less that is meaning that more people are getting hacked? >> Well, I think I think there's always been a there's been a continuing push as you know I'll say Bitcoin as a short hand, right? But as Bitcoin and other crypto has become much more mainstream, I think people are saying, "Right, okay, now we're reaching this this point at which it's kind of starting to get to traditional finance levels." And that's the point at which, you know, people will cite the the banking crisis again and say, "We don't want all this like like we talked about in institutions episode.

the people who are worried about the centralization risks and everything of all this money being in uh you know the traditional banking system and finance sector >> they then have been pushing for a long time to like take your crypto off exchanges. So there is a big movement in that and I do wonder if that contributes to it or the other thing I was going to mention was how much is this to do with the sophistication of like social engineering attacks in the age of AI.

Right? Did you see the Sam Alman the other day was basically saying all of the the means we have today for verifying like humanness >> on you know your your banking apps like whether it's voice recognition all this stuff it's basically not cut out anymore right so I think that I wonder if that because we don't know what's causing these uh these loss of funds in in the individual cases right or do we >> um I've seen some of the ones are around like you think you're on a website that is hosted by say a buy bit or something like their hosted website and you're exchanging and doing stuff with the wallet and you're sending it somewhere that was not intentional.

You're basically giving away your Cphrase and this kind of stuff. I think the AI stuff is interesting and we've done a whole I think we did a whole episode on what some of the negative implications of AI going forward will be and spam attacks and all this kind of stuff are an obvious one. there's a massive avenue there for, you know, self-s sovereign identity and biometrics and yeah, your um what's the project? World coin style eye scans and all this futuristic sci-fi stuff to get around this.

But yeah, it's it's an interesting one because I think on the one hand, like you say, there the cryptosavvy native people as more centralization and more kind of I guess money is being pumped into centralized exchanges and institutions and whatnot are trying to resist that and go more self-custodial. But on the other hand, you have all the normies, the web two users, the institutions who aren't cryptosavvy who are obviously going to go through those mechanisms like the big >> And I think yeah, it's it's an interesting point because my specific story, I was using like a a very regulated centralized custodian um and it happened to me, but I think it can happen to anyone.

I think one of the big things here is it doesn't matter >> how much security you have unless you have like your seed phrases split across six different geographic locations where you need all six parts to do anything. So basically it's unusable for most the the time. There's always a way to get that password whether it's under your bed and someone comes in with like a gun or a wrench. And we're seeing like we're seeing lots of stories. I don't know if you were following this, but there was like that example in Paris where there was those armed thugs that took this crypto millionaire's daughter and threatened him like dead and tried to kidnap his daughter and luckily he got away from it.

But we're seeing more and more stories about industry leaders, big Kos basically people with I guess a bit of a kind of a public persona that are in the crypto space being threatened in certain countries and yeah, >> you don't expect it to happen in like the modern world, but obviously it does. Yeah, it's not it's not surprising that I think people become the individ the kind of the source of the target, right, of the attacks. >> Um it's I guess it's not social engineering. It's it's a kind of different more violent type of attack on the system.

But so I guess we can put it into two categories. You have the the crypto that is lost by human error, right? And and the one I the one I think of here is kind of funny is did you see there was some there are a lot of bitcoins that are supposedly Satoshi era bitcoins that moved recently. >> So that you know the all these coins that Satoshi or early miners mined. we're not sure, you know, which belongs to who or whether they're all Satoshi, but basically there's this whole chunk of them that that could be.

And then a big dormant whale wallet full of these bitcoins moved and they moved it all in one transaction, right? And I saw people online basically saying, "Wow, like you know, even if this is Satoshi or one of the OG's, the earliest miners, that is that is ballsy to do it in one transaction, they said they said they didn't even use a test transaction, >> right? So I think it's it's it's it speaks to the fact that no matter how confident you are in just the the user error side of things, I'll always use a test transaction.

Just send a penny, send a pound or something before you move, you know, the big numbers like the£10 or the£100, right? >> Yeah. Which is something we have in Tradfine now. Like even when >> you're sending someone to an account number or sort code, you'd be like, "Oh, well, is is this real?" But they've obviously improved that UX by associating with the name and they'll check the accounts to be like, "Oh yeah, this account number does match this sort code. This matches the name." kind of stuff which is such a game changer on UX.

I imagine we are going to get to that stage in crypto where we start to have maybe these like indexes where you can maybe see like the account name associated with that. But I guess the one of the problems not problems but I guess one of the characteristics of a lot of crypto is that people are pseudonmous in a lot of ways and maybe they won't want to give any revealing information about that account. So maybe that wouldn't work. Um yeah I think one of the big things here one of the differences between tradfi and defi in this space is the immutability and you know once a transaction happens the transaction doesn't go back like it's not like traditional banking where you know money sent from Santandere to Barclays this KYC at every point and effectively like when I'm moving Santandere money I'm asking them permission to move their money when really it's my money so they can track it they can trace it takes days so they can hold it and stop it if

something goes wrong >> with crypto it's very different. Like it can be sent to an address in the middle of nowhere and no one can stop that once a transaction's on chain. Like there's no way to reverse that. And that is one of the beauties of the network, but it's also on the flip side can lead to some of the issues with hacks, thefts, and all this stuff. >> Yeah. And and this is interesting also again talking about like you know this can affect anyone from users to exchanges.

Some of the only times in history that there has it's even been mooted that the the blockchain should be rolled back have been exchange hacks, right? So I guess exchange hack and and and the Dow hack as well, right? So the Dow hack was kind of in its own entity and you know that that's a whole other story. But the more interesting one I think is >> uh I think it was Binance they had a big hack that was the whole funds are safu kind of stuff right when he was saying yeah funds are safe in our in our fund.

Um, but basically that at that point, I'm pretty sure I'm recalling this correctly. This is just off the top of my head, but >> he was saying, you know, publicly, we're considering, you know, how do we roll back bitcoin? How do we roll back? I think it was Bitcoin or was it Ethereum? >> Uh, it was one of the big two and they were saying like, how do we roll back the chain to undo this loss of funds from the hack, right? And that was met with huge derision in the community.

Everyone was like, you obviously can't do this. This is terrible. And also what precedent does that set if you know just one of the exchanges can force a roll back even though objectively it probably would have done a net good. It would have restored all the funds of these users that have been lost. Um but it's it's that conflict with the principles of the blockchain that you said. And if you're not a big exchange, you've got no hope in hell. That's kind of the bottom line for us us mortals.

>> That's that's the tricky thing is like subjectively you're like this is a good thing. Like if say there is a big theft and you can stop it and roll it back, you should. But then it's like okay where does that line stop? Either you've got to be completely objective and you say we never roll back ever and once a transaction is on chain like it's on chain it's in immutable like but if all of a sudden you have big players that can influence the network future by saying okay this has affected us personally we're going to roll it back it really does change the dynamics of the entire ecosystem and one of the three core characteristics of blockchain technology in so many ways and obviously the best example is Ethereum versus Ethereum classic and that split there and how it divided the community but in that case most of the network was on board with rolling it back, which yeah, I think is fascinating.

Yeah, it's a it's an interesting one for sure. Um, should we talk about the >> Yeah, let let's get into the, you know, the real the real meat of this because I want to know cuz so for context, you know, a few weeks ago or a few months ago now, >> three months ago, time goes quickly. >> Time goes. Yeah. >> Yeah. I get a mysterious message from Alex saying, you know, funds are not safu. Basically, he says, you know, I've had an issue, you know, bear with me.

Um, so I don't know the full details of of what happened here. >> Oh, wow. This is a tell all for you as >> This is a tell. Yeah. I'm I'm I'm just looking forward to listening to the >> Excited. I remember when I told you actually. Let's go into the story first. So, basically what happened was it was three months ago. I was on a night out with some friends. Like we it was in London, central London, and we I was in like smoking at the time.

Don't smoke, but I was just chilling out there. And I was on my phone as you are on a night out just messaging my partner I think at the time. and someone just comes along out of nowhere and snatches my phone and disappears. Like there was a group of them and they completely disappeared. >> And you know that's all she wrote. Like couldn't find it. Was stressed out was like what the hell? Um what do I do now? >> And you'd be hardressed to find someone in in London who hasn't heard of someone that happened to someone they know, right?

I've had that multiple people. >> I've seen it happen in London. Like it's a shame, but like it is a reality, especially on like you have people that go past on scooters. That's the classic example. And you know, obviously face fixed to phone. you're just staring the snatch phone. I think one of the problems are that >> we are so like reliant on UX that right now if you biometrically sign in it's open for a certain amount of time, right? And you can access all the apps and all this kind of stuff.

This happened to me. I was like, damn. Okay. Can't find it. Need to get back. Police obviously tried to call the police. Didn't get through immediately. Tried to get back to my house. I was like, I need to get my laptop. Locked the phone down. um went back and by the time I'd gotten home, it was like 30 minutes later, 20 minutes later, something like that. Reasonable time, I went on my laptop and saw emails coming through from Coinbase being like, "Ah, >> transaction sent." Like, crap, how the hell have they got into my Coinbase?

Like, I've got 2FA, I've got biometrics. Like, it shouldn't be possible to get into that. Yeah. >> Without like having some kind of like verification, right? >> Um and then I was like, "Guys, try to full call Co Coinbase. It took a while to get through." as it does. They're obviously a busy service like everyone's trying to use them. So by the time like I got through another transaction was sent through. It was like okay that's basically all my bitcoin gone and I was like that was a lot of money.

Like I had saved that over the course like four or five years hadn't touched it. >> And then a couple of minutes later it was like ah suspicious activity detected. We're going to lock down your account. I was like okay well you know >> and that's another email you're getting. >> That's the third email. So two emails. >> attempt to move my Kadano moved to it's like this is at night time as well. an account I hadn't touched in a long time um transaction submitted then half an hour later um it was Bitcoin being moved similar way and then like a minute later suspicious activity detected we're going to lock down your account so like by then obviously all of it happened got through to Coinbase phone operator and it's like oh yeah these transaction gone through um locking down your account now and money was gone and >> there's nothing you can do in that situation I sat there like I know how this works I know how this plays out like I don't

think I've done anything wrong here like I've got all the security set up on there and somehow they've managed to transfer almost all my savings at my crypto account. >> Yeah. So maybe just for for people who haven't used, you know, crypto wallets on their phone before, what are those security measures that were in place and you thought protecting it? What what what steps are there normally if you're going to go and send funds somewhere? >> So usually like right now when I use the app, um it is every time you're trying to send a transaction or get onto the Coinbase account specifically, you biometrically sign in.

So it doesn't matter if I'm biometrically signed into my phone to go on Coinbase, I have to resign in with a biometrics. So if like I unlock my phone now, they pass it to you. You can't get into my Coinbase account because you don't have a biometric, you don't have a password. And then when I send transactions, there's a further degree of verification typically 2FA. But like 2FA when you this is an interesting thing I've seen now in security settings, which didn't happen when I first downloaded Coinbase and set it all up was that 2FA linked to the same device obviously isn't that powerful, right?

Yeah, cuz I'm on your phone. Message through. I'm on your >> I always wonder this. It's like, you know, or prove you're signing into your Google account like prove you're holding the phone and it's like, well, it's the same phone. >> Exactly. But now with like so I've seen they've changed it recently where they have like pass keys and authenticator separate to the device and then that enforces you have another degree of biometric signing to get into that pass key or to get into that device.

So for however it happened, I still don't know, they managed to get through that because I was on my phone, wasn't on Coinbase, hadn't touched that app for like four days. Yeah. >> And they got through and sent all the money out without having to verify anything. That's interesting. So I'm just trying to get inside the mind of this. Do you do you feel like this is someone who was intending to to drain a crypto wallet when they grabbed your phone or >> or was it opportunistic?

Have they just stolen a phone? And because it seems really How long What was the time span between you losing the phone and that first email saying, you know, someone's sending your funds out? >> I think it was like maybe 20 minutes, like 15 minutes or something like that. >> That sounds pretty premeditated, right? >> It sounded quick. Like it sounded really quick. And I think like and we'll talk a little bit about it um later on, but when you look at the transactions on chain, which again is another like beautiful and terrifying thing, being able to trace the transactions and know exactly where it's gone.

>> Transparent theft. >> It's horrible. Like it's it's because you're just watching the screen being like, where's it gone to? And like I'm in the space, I know to trace these things. So I'm looking at it being like transaction sent transaction sense gone through mixers, gone through exchanges. >> it didn't seem like it was completely like a novice in the space. it seemed like they had some experience with this stuff. Whether it's targeted, impossible to say, right? Like I can't tell whether it was targeted or not.

>> But like I say, I think one of the things we are seeing in the space is more and more people are being if you've got a profile I guess in the space will know you're in crypto, you are a target. >> Today's episode is sponsored by the Vchain Foundation. Now, we often talk about how emerging technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and Vchain is at the forefront of this green movement with initiatives like Vet Dao. Let's take a closer look. Imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets.

These verified records build a massive collective impact benefiting people through their own actions. Sound a bit complex, but Vchain made it fun. Explore our apps at vb better.com. Vchain's goal is to power a new era of sustainable solutions. So, if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day, go check out vetero.com to find out >> And now back to the show. >> This is what I was going to ask. Right. So, I was just I was trying to establish.

Do you think it was premeditated for wallet theft or you know trying basically attacking you your phone getting your phone to get your crypto or was it getting your phone and then opportunist opportunistically getting your crypto because if it is premeditated that they were going to drain your crypto wallet and then my mind does go to well maybe you have been targeted right because you yeah you have an online presence people know you into crypto because of the podcast because of your job you know whatever it is um which is quite a scary thought to think you know if if And then that's it sounds kind of sophisticated enough that they could go past the they knew it was going to be facing them on Coinbase.

>> They seem to have got around it somehow which is also kind of a little bit spooky. Yeah. >> Um we can conjecture about how that is. But yeah, to me like my my assumption would be maybe they have >> targeted me in that case. >> Well, I mean if they're targeting people at our level like like the bottom of the runs like imagine the people that are above us which is everyone. >> Yeah. Hard to say. Like it's all speculative, right? I think based on the things I've seen on chain, it seemed like it was I imagine that right now we have like what in the UK I think it's about 15 to 20% of people own some form of crypto >> and you know it's hard to it's easy to track phones.

There's not that much money in phone theft. It's easy to track banks and stuff like that because everything's KYC so it's easy to trace that stuff. I imagine what they do is they see an opportunity they get the phone and the first thing they do is have you got a crypto app? because that's the best way to get money out right now. So basically it's probably more a function well could be a function of the thief being a millennial or a >> gener exactly but then so I guess what happened next was I'm there like just working out okay all my money's gone this is awful like this is the one of the lowest points of my life and you get in I got in touch with Coinbase they were like you know really they were they were great like they actually were great um they were like we're looking into this they took it really seriously I was like guys I don't know how this happened like I've got all the recommended security on

like how have they managed to steal it without me confirming anything like locally on the device >> and yeah, six weeks of hell basically like trying to pull my life together, went home for a little bit, took pause from podcast and everything. Um, and yeah, they came through like I honestly have so much respect for Coinbase. They six weeks later we've done a full internal like investigation and they've refunded me. Like they not they refunded the whole amount. Like I understand we see a lot of like negativity around institutions and custodians not taking responsibility for this, but all props to Coinbase.

They looked into it and they're refunding me absolutely all of it. And I will always be a loyal user to Coinbase. Like I think even you said it, most people are moving away from the big exchanges and the big custodians, the big institutions because these things target them specifically and because it's more secure to go on your own. I actually disagree. Like I do think 99% of the time for 99% of use cases, it's better to be with someone like Coinbase because they do have those systems in place.

They have the recommended security. They do have biometrics. They detect suspicious activity. It just didn't pick it up this time. And I think they accepted blame because of that because most of the time they do pick it up. And it made me feel so much more confident in a solution like Coinbase because they were like, "Yeah, we're at full here. Here's your refund." >> Yeah. It's really good to hear that because I think Coinbase has always been in my my mind one of the, you know, the best shiny examples.

You know, forget the IPO and everything. Just they're a very cryptonative company, right? Like if you look at Brian Armstrong and some of the the people they've got working for them, like these people actually do care about Bitcoin and they have for a very very long time. Um, so they're big proponents of crypto and web 3 and you'd hope that they'd be you know on the side of the customers and not just you know uh being like a faceless corporate in this scenario which is good and you know they're doing so much info stuff they're building base they're like they're a proper they want to see crypto succeed more than anyone right pretty much but I do wonder if if you have been a different exchange with the same setup same scenario I can imagine you would have not got a positive response >> 100% I think like Coinbase of all the exchanges and customs I could think of is like the most regulatory friendly and they've got like one of the most active user

bases by far. I think they're the best of both worlds in so many ways where they are very cryptosavvy like you go on the platform they've got so many incredible features like staking like lots of coins supported lots of cool features web3 wallets all this stuff but then also the regulatory stuff of this is the recommended security we do have you know KYC stuff we do do AML stuff we do detect suspicious activity I think >> one of the one of the things I've been thinking of is okay what would have happened if they'd have taken my hardware wallet or my device or something like this and come in and threaten me like would I have given it over and like crypto is not worth your life at the end of the day and if that is like a real threat that's true that I if you're Sasha Nakamoto maybe it is but like if it's a real threat and you genuinely believe in it you are probably going to hand over those keys >>

but then something like Coinbase to have that okay actually you know this is a weird transaction going out at 4:00 a.m. in the middle of the night from a wallet you never touch. We think it's suspicious. We're going to lock down your account. Like it takes it out your hands to a degree and they're not going to go and then threaten like the director of Coinbase and like give us the money. So I think there's a lot of a lot of reason and justification for the existence of custodians and regulated exchanges and Coinbase.

>> Yeah, I think and this is I think it's a really good story that you've had. you know, is not a nice experience to go through, but it's good to highlight the that very real risk you have with going full self-custody, right? And >> uh, you know, not that it is in your case, but say someone has gone full self-custody. They're keeping everything on hardware wallets or under their mattress or on their phone, right? Like an old phone or something. >> If you that can be all well and good, right?

And you can be more than safe and secure and you don't have any third party counterparty risk or anything like this. But if you have any slip up with your OPSSE in your life generally that can flip on its head. So you can do everything right on the Bitcoin side. Yeah. But if some other part of your you know identity and your personal data is leaked and again we know that's not always up to you. Most of the time it's not like the rules are getting more and more strict about how much data we're being forced to hand over in all aspects of using the internet.

>> And we're seeing more and more data breaches. I mean Coinbase had another data breach itself right this year. >> Yeah. cost him like $400 million. I mean, I don't know if that >> I think they they paid the users back, didn't they? Pay users. What was the I saw it was the Brian Armstrong one was like they wanted a hundred million the hackers and he was like, "We're not going to pay them, but we'll pay 100 million for anyone that can help us identify them." Which I thought was pretty cool.

And then they also paid a lot of the users back. So again, like having these big cryptosavvy exchanges, custodians that are regulated and trying to operate in the more traditional fight, more trady space is powerful. I think it's really valuable for users. Yeah, it's a it's a sad story. Like the six weeks were awful, but then to get it back and like actually kind of come out of it with like a lot of learnings was really powerful. Um yeah, weird one. >> Yeah. Well, I hope it never happens to you again, Alec, cuz uh it sounds pretty >> I remember I told you you gave the most awkward reaction.

You were like, we're on camera and you're like, oh yeah, what's what's been going on? And I was like, yeah, yeah, I had all my crypto stuff. And you did that awkward face that most British people do when they don't interact. You were like, >> well, to be honest, I was worried it was something even worse, right? I was, you know, it was it was very unlike Alec to to to, you know, cancel meeting up or anything and like I was I was like, what? This must be bad.

>> So when I found out it was just a couple of um yeah, weird one, I think like on the other point around new avenues for attacks as well. Another one that I saw that kind of made me think about this whole story about self-custodial keys and cphrase and all this kind of stuff. I saw one on cursor recently like I use cursor all the time and vibe coding is obviously everywhere and there was this like understanding what you're deploying and people understanding less and less about what they're deploying because you're getting more nontechnical people going into coding and just using cursor and doing oneclick one sentence deployments of apps and dabs and all this kind of stuff and the example was this blockchain developer was very experienced in the space um was deploying a cursor DAP and didn't know all the dependencies one the dependencies were from was from an external server that they didn't know anything about and effectively you saw this one and it mirrored their um it mirrored their laptop and

got their seed phrase which is held locally on the laptop and took 500k in Ethereum like the attack vectors are getting smarter and smarter and I think as users are understanding less and less of what they're doing because of things like cursor and because of things like chat GPT the attack vectors will become >> well that's interesting like that is a great example of you could argue the attack the attackers are getting smarter and smarter as >> humans are getting dumber and >> dumber and dumber right and they're just relying on on non-technical I mean that that is a really interesting case of you know um someone who you think could be techsavvy or maybe is getting like the Dunning Krueger effect right they they're thinking they can go and dabble in crypto and do all this stuff and then they've just gone and exposed their private keys yeah it's it's a really bizarre one um and in terms of not just the attacks being more sophisticated, but a lot of the complexity around crypto

in many ways is increasing in in terms of like so I guess you have you have systemic risks that affect people, right? And whether you can, you know, have your fund you can lose your funds like things like the Ronin Bridge attack a few years ago and AXI and everything. >> So you have these kind of network level exploits which are becoming more and more common as you get more and more layers of blockchain stacked on top and you have more and more security stuff on top on top.

Um, arguably the user side of it has probably got a lot better. Like in theory, the security side has got better. It's more on that opsac side, I think, and more on the, you know, data um, data leaks, data brokers, all this stuff. It's so much easier to impersonate or or find out the minimum number viable information you need to mount one of these attacks. Like, I don't know if you've ever seen those YouTube channels where they try and like trap the scammers from like call center scams and stuff, right?

Like it's crazy the lengths they go to to do this and like they'll they'll stay on a case for days and days and days to do it. So yeah, I'm I'm a little bit How How do you feel about now you've been through this experience? Are you confident in using crypto in future or are you going to be more careful? >> Um I'll definitely be more careful with my phone. Like that's a big thing is >> Yeah. Yeah. Like I've been working on my grip strength and I'm just going to unlock my phone like not go out.

my lanyard and stuff. >> Yeah, exactly. Like not go outside. Um, no, I think it it definitely made me more confident in Coinbase, like as an app, like going through their security, speaking to their like their kind of user support and whatnot, I was very impressed with everything and it really did help me. Um, I think I I think anyone that's involved in the crypto space, anyone with a public profile should be more aware. Like the amount of people that I spoke to after and told the story and they were some of the guests that are coming on next week as well, Owen for example, you used to speak to them.

I told them how it happened. They're like, "Oh, I didn't even know like I used that as well. I had 2FA with the exact same device. Like actually that's not very secure." And you tell people and they're like, "Oh yeah, I've got the exact same setup that could have happened to anyone." And but then you go on to like say I'm looking into my apps now and saying how can I improve the security of my phone? They've got like anti- theft security like say it moves really quickly like out of nowhere just lock your phone straight away.

So I think devices are getting much smarter. I think it's just one of the things with crypto we have to be aware of is that the fantastic capabilities that we like to kind of tout as like world changing like immutability have downsides in that that immutability can work against you if you're not careful. And I think the people in the space so far have been very cryptosavvy >> and that's changing. Um like I say 20% of people in the UK, 25% of people in the US right now have crypto in some form.

They don't understand necessarily what seed phrase is or how immutability can impact them. They are relying on custodians and exchanges to basically handle all the risk for them and they just press a button. And I think it's when you're working with a a regulated exchange that is fine. That's completely fine. when you're working with a less regulated exchange like Binance or something like this, like a lot of the hacks that we've seen and say money that's gone missing goes through Binance. Like that is an example of some an exchange you have to be careful with, for example.

>> Um overall, yeah, I'm still 100% in crypto. Like I love it, >> but it it's mad how your life could kind of change the flip of a coin. Well, um I was going to say it for me it's like it's I have always been not down the full self- sovereignty route and the full self-custody route. I think >> yeah for some of the reasons you said you know the personal risks are higher um and you know the personal error risks and error rate is much higher but also like I just I have always had enough trust in certain you know companies like Coinbase like Coinbase I've used for like nearly a decade now probably >> I've never had of an inkling that I trust them less than say my bank.

>> Yeah. and what you've gone through is sounds very similar to, you know, the process that would happen if you got tricked into sending money, you know, via your your current bank and the current financial system. Like there you FCA FCA protections for losses against things. You you probably have plenty of banks that will refund you in the same scenario, right? Because they they have reserves set aside for these things because at the end of the day, they want to keep you as a customer. >> Yeah.

They care about that user experience and they care about protecting users and like it it was surprising to see that >> a company like Coinbase would act like a like a bank basically like a traditional bank and that is refreshing. >> Yeah. Which is ironic because it's kind of coming full circle. Yeah. It's like >> uh it's almost like some version of the weak times create. It's like good you know good good decentralized money creates weak >> Yeah. I know. I think I know. >> You know what I'm saying?

But I'm basically saying like now we're like, "Oh, actually the banks can help us sometimes." And if there's a place for it exchange, >> there's I know like, you know, crypto is often tempted as removing all intermediaries and trusted parties and all this kind of stuff, but it's not. There's a place for them. There's always going to be a need for them and a place for them. Yeah, I think those funds are still out there as well. Like that's one of the mad things about this transparency is that you can see those funds still.

They can see what's happened, the transactions and all this kind of stuff. And it's frustrating in a >> That is an interesting point. Right. So you're just to clarify, you're saying you were refunded like the cash equivalent in Bitcoin or >> Yeah, I was I was refunded the Bitcoin equivalent of the Bitcoin, but not the exact Bitcoin. They're out there stolen. Yeah, exactly. Like that kind of stuff at a dormant address and like still working with Metropolitan Police on this stuff. That's been another eye opener is interacting with, you know, a kind of traditional police force in these cases and seeing what their understanding is of this stuff.

So far it's been three months understanding is you know non-existent basically like I've sent obviously have an understanding of the space I've sent them you know all the kind of information transactions where they are all this stuff and progress has been almost negligible like you look at the transactions on chain and they're interacting with exchanges like they're inter so there is like some way to trace this stuff but the police having been they're the only ones that can actually do it you know subpoena people all this kind of stuff find out information you know corroborate all the different like banks that are involved in transactions, but they've not done anything.

>> You're not you're not a high enough net worth individual to to take it right because a lot of the time it will be it's in I imagine it'll be take I the only times I've seen these kind of seizure and forfeiture things is when you have like a court case around what's happened or you have you know a larger criminal kind of crime ring that we kind of spoke about last week where you've got often crossjurisdictional collaboration between different law enforcement agencies and things. So, yeah, I can imagine maybe yours you're going to be unlucky with your if you if you wanted to double your money and get it all back.

>> When I told them when I told the the police the number that was involved, like let's be honest, it was 40K, right? It's 40 USD equivalent. They were like, "Wow, it's a big amount of money. We're definitely going to work really hard on this." And it's been 3 months and like there's been no deliverables. I get that this stuff is complex and maybe they're not like understanding the space, but >> 15 to 20% of the UK population owns this stuff right now. It should be treated in the same light as we treat like traditional cash theft.

But it's actually simpler in a lot of ways in my mind to actually trace this stuff because there's so much transparency there because we know all the interactions, everything's on chain. >> I just don't think they're taking it seriously. And I can understand after all this happened, I can understand why so many people move to places like Dubai because you're like >> in Dubai this wouldn't have happened, right? There would have cracked down. There's no crime out there, no tax, all this kind of stuff. I'm kind of thinking >> what aspect wouldn't have happened?

And you mean the actual physical >> there would have been theft like obviously theft in big metropolitan European cities is high compared to places like Dubai. There's lots of reasons for that like bigger population all this kind of stuff >> but yeah I can understand why someone in crypto would move out there and this kind of added to that that feeling in a lot of ways. >> So are you going to be jumping ship >> I thought about it like it's kind of like I'm paying taxes like lots of income tax.

You're paying capital gains tax on crypto nowadays. like what does that go into? Like the government and the police haven't protected me in this sense. So it's like yeah maybe I'm still like a bit negative on that front but maybe we'll move to Dubai. Who knows? >> Wow. Okay. So let let maybe just to bring it back one second as we as we kind of close this up to where you are now. Have you still been tracing these these funds? Like do you do you check them every day?

>> Of course I'm looking at it. Like most of them are at a dormant address and I'm just looking at it. >> Dormant as in so what's it been doing? >> Nothing. So, it's like freshly made address a few a few interactions before it into there and sat >> And it's like, let's see what happens when it moves. >> Well, maybe they've forgotten their private key. >> Oh, man. Yeah, that would be there's no there's no real winner on their side. >> Yeah, exactly. That's that's my hope, but let's see.

>> Yeah. Awesome. Well, I think it's a good cautionary tale. I think you know it's a good way of opening the conversation up to the risks that there are in in in self custody as well as you know third party custody right and and the fact that you always have to be very careful and you know I mentioned the FCA protections and things like that >> it is important to note that there is not parity yet like what happened to you is it's an exception in the case that not everyone's going to get robbed every day and it's also an exception in the case that not every exchange is going to be refunding you and they're not going to do it every time right So it is kind of an exception in both in both um directions here.

But um that won't be the happy story for most people probably or a lot of people >> a lot of people will not have their crypto stolen. They'll lose it by other means. There'll be things that they really can't recover and especially if it's you know lower amounts I can imagine. Um a lot of people will just lose it through apathy, right? They'll lose they'll lose their money and they'll be like well I presume I can't get that. I know people who've done that. they've sent money to the wrong address and they're like, "Well, that's just gone." >> But yeah, I think it is a cautionary tale.

I think a lot of friends I spoke to after this checked their accounts, worked out what exchanges and custodians they were working with and are just now hyper aware that this can happen to everyone. Like I've read a lot of stories, seen the numbers involved to happen to for it to happen to me personally was obviously eye opening. But yeah, I think big custodians have a place to play in this space and Coinbase did a really good thing and the right thing and I'll be a loyal customer with them forever now like you are as well.

Yeah, and I appreciate it. But I think that's everything that I wanted to say on this stuff. Be careful out there crypto investors and thank you for listening to Untangling Web 3. Join us next time to untangle a little more of Untangling Web 3. >> That is what we do. >> Really? Yes, there's a

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes