Episode 96

How DAOs Work with Daniel Liebau

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of Untangling Web3, Daniel Liebau, founder of Lightbulb Capital and co-author of a leading academic book on DAOs, explores how decentralized autonomous organizations are redefining governance, collaboration, and organizational design.

Drawing on research and real-world examples, this episode examines the opportunities and risks associated with DAOs as scalable, decentralized alternatives to traditional organizational structures.

Key highlights

  • Defining a DAO and Its Core Mechanics. A decentralized autonomous organization is an on-chain entity that coordinates individuals around a shared objective using blockchain-based governance systems. Participation is typically open to anyone holding the DAO's native governance token, which confers the right to vote on proposals. Unlike traditional companies, DAOs rely on distributed consensus rather than centralized leadership, and participation structures are often non-hierarchical.
  • Use Cases Where DAOs Provide Strategic Value. DAOs are especially well-suited to non-profit, community-driven, or public-good initiatives. Examples include grant distribution collectives, award programs, open-source development communities, and sustainability-focused initiatives. These use cases benefit from shared governance, global participation, and token-based incentives that align diverse stakeholders without relying on central entities.
  • Risks and Governance Challenges. The permissionless and decentralized nature of DAOs introduces unique challenges. Accountability risks arise when it is unclear who is responsible for decisions or outcomes. Financial risk increases when DAO treasuries are overly concentrated in their native tokens, making them vulnerable to market volatility. Governance risks include voter apathy, low participation rates, and poorly structured voting mechanisms that fail to align expertise with influence.

DAOs offer a fundamentally new model for coordination, one that replaces rigid hierarchies with collective governance, transparency, and programmable incentives. While risks around accountability, governance, and financial stability remain, DAO design continues to evolve in ways that make these organizations more resilient and scalable.

As regulatory frameworks mature and infrastructure improves, DAOs have the potential to become core components of both decentralized ecosystems and traditional institutions seeking to embrace openness and adaptability.

Learn more about Daniel's work here: https://www.danielliebau.org/

This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/

00:00:00 – Intro: Daniel Liebau 00:06:56 – DAOs: The basics 00:12:24 – Why create a DAO? 00:16:53 – The Impact of DAOs 00:21:14 – Finance & Future 00:27:21 – Regulation & Privacy 00:31:49 – What are the Risks? 00:36:53 – The Future of DAOS

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

Welcome to the Untangling Web 3 podcast. So, as you've probably heard, Dows are reshaping governance, enabling decentralized decision-m without traditional hierarchies. Today, we're sitting down with Dan Lebo to explore their impact. So, Dan is the founder of Light Ball Capital and former CIO of the Modular Blockchain Fund. He's an affiliate faculty member at Singapore Management University, teaching blockchain and DeFi and lectures in ESEX Masters in Finance program. His research on blockchain and financial markets has been published by Springer and MIT Press. He's also an associate editor and chief of world scientific annual review of fintech and is completing a PhD in finance at the Resmus University.

God, he's got a lot on. So Dan, without further ado, welcome to the show and we're very excited to have you on. Thank you very much. I'm looking forward to this conversation. We've been trying for a while. So good that we got together today. Yeah, we met in Hive like a year ago or something like this, Dan. And someone was like, "Anle, you have to get this guy on the show. He's really good. He knows lots about Dows." And I was like, "Yeah, it's taken this long to get you on, but it's finally happening." So, I think it's perfect timing.

So, obviously today the big topic is Dows. Now, it's something that we've talked about kind of loosely on the show before here and there. Um, but I don't think we've given it the full justice of a deep dive. So, I'm really glad we've got you Dan, a bit of an expert in this field. So, why don't we kick it off there with a kind of 101 explainer. What actually are Dows, decentralized autonomous organizations and why should we actually be caring about them? Because a lot of people will hear the terminal and think what on earth does that mean?

But yeah, how how would you describe them? Yeah, I mean there are a whole bunch of different definition that fly around in different academic papers. But uh if I had to summarize what they all sort of say is that it is a a new form of organization that um helps people with the same objective to pursue their goals. Um they're all blockchain based. So they record their decisions on blockchain and often they have a a governance module where some members of the community can put forward proposals and then everyone else who has a governance token and a and a voting right that comes with it can vote on these proposals to to say yay or nay.

Okay. Does that make sense? Simple. Wow. That was like a explain it like I'm five. I like it. So like how does this differ to traditional setups like especially when we're thinking like you know early days tribal you know everyone just having a conversation and that seems kind of you know decentralized in a way potentially how does it compare to what we're experiencing say in the modern times as well. M I mean the the probably the most important um comparison is the one with the private limited company, right?

Because that's the the sort of one way that we tend to organize for economic activity at least. And um it's quite interesting. So in Dow um technically speaking, anyone can join, right? Whereas in a um in a in a company, you you have to buy shares and then your name's going to be recorded on the share register and so on. Um companies usually also sell shares that come with a cash flow, right? Right. So if you own a a stock, then you are entitled to get some sort of dividend payment or or something like that.

Um that's not necessarily the case in the DAO context. So in the DAO context basically um and I'm making some um generalizations here so forgive me if it's not true for all Dows in the world but but often um if you buy a governance token you're buying a a voting right so to participate in that in that governance um ecosystem. Yeah that makes sense. I think that's that's the yeah that that's a sort of most um prevalent and and most important difference I would say. Yeah, I think that that tallies with kind of my understanding as well and what I've seen from them is, you know, yeah, very much typically um you're you're holding a token to participate in the decision-m around whatever this organization is.

Look, I think the one I always come back to as an example just because it's kind of illustrative is a constitution DA, right? You had this this Dow where people were trying to kind of pull funds together in order to buy the Constitution, right? And that's something that you can't do by traditional means, right? How do you coordinate something like that? How do you raise those kind of funds for a very specific purpose? Um, and owning the kind of governance token was part of that. So, yeah, that makes a lot of sense.

Um, can you maybe just in an abstract sense before we kind of dive into the technical details at all, um, why why would people want to decentralize an organization? Because it sounds like something very futuristic and strange. Um and you think like okay a company is something that is fairly kind of mentally tangible right you can understand what it looks like you have a hierarchy imposed on it that makes sense how does that actually translate and why would you want to translate an organizational structure into a decentralized model with this voting mechanism yeah that's that's a great great question and I think I want to answer by by saying that um we shouldn't necess necessarily transfer all sorts of for-profit company type entities into Dows.

So, while I have spent quite a significant amount of my last two years on investigating Dows, I'm not the kind of person that will tell you that we have to Dowo everything. Okay? But um there are some specific use cases where perhaps it makes more sense to organize yourself as a DAO than as a company. And I think that is especially the case in the context of perhaps not forprofit uh type of scenarios. So I'm not saying that's the that's the only thing but um I was just having lunch with a dear friend of mine today.

He runs an award uh ceremony and he wants to expand this award that has to do with financial literacy beyond its current size. So he's like Daniel should I create a company or a media company or should it be a DAO or should it be what? So, so there's kind of an interesting use case, right? Because you have a whole bunch of different type of actors that contribute to this award seminar. You know, you have the judges, you have the people who sponsor the awards, then you have the people who submit their proposals to uh be to get an award across all the different categories, right?

You can easily imagine how you can uh develop a nice token economy where all of these participants basically uh take place in that market and um purchase the tokens for certain reasons and get paid in tokens for certain reasons and then also can um participate in developing and implementing the strategy as they put up proposals and and vote on the different proposals that are out there. Okay. And we it's another like big advantage in my mind and this probably relates to the more the crypto aspect u the cris crypto aspect and that is around like the community engagement the fact that you're saying that in a private company you have to buy shares it's in a private way you typically have to get approval there's different say share classes and rights to vote and whatnot and it's very I guess blackboxy in a way whereas one of the big sales of Dows and crypto projects is that realistically you know the rules There's a degree of transparency.

That's the onchain element you're talking about. But also almost anyone can participate if they've got money. Obviously, that's kind of the private angle is I can buy almost any crypto asset and be involved in that crypto project and then potentially vote using the underlying assets and that you're saying there's not really a degree of profitability. I guess the profitability is the number go up on the cryp underlying crypto asset. Is that something that's quite unique with Dows? Would you say that anyone can get involved? I mean it is but it's also a bit of a problem.

So in the in the book that we that I put together with Sandy oh my my dear co-author um we talk about this set of idiosyncratic risks that exist in the DAO context and then one of the risks is what we call the DAO accountability risk and that risk basically describes this uh situation where you're not really able to identify clearly who's responsible for the Dows and the members actions, right? So, so as as good as it sounds that anyone can join, um you also run into trouble if you perhaps want to open a bank account or if you want to interface with the financial services industry overall.

So, um it's it's not only good, yeah, it's good that everyone can play, but it also brings some idiosyncratic risks which in the case of a of a private limited company, you don't even have because you can just look at the share register and you know who who the ultimate beneficial owners are. and so on. No. Yeah. And like the kind of this point about anyone can participate as well. It maybe creates other issues along the lines of okay if these people are voting on say consensus upgrades.

How many people that own Bitcoin understand how to like what a consensus upgrade means or whether we should go one way or another way? And it starts to bring around the problem of specializations versus generalizations. Like should they be voting on deeply technical things that we've seen in a lot of democracies around the world actually the power of the people doesn't always isn't always the right decision for the people. Is this another problem scientist see? I mean I think it depends a little bit. um you you can define constraints around what decisions are um up for for a vote or not and you can also implement for example different thresholds right you could say okay if there's something that is mission critical for example a consensus upgrade then maybe uh the majority vote uh comes in a very different sort of a comes at a different threshold than if you just say okay I need a simple majority right um that that's kind of one thing.

I mean people have gone um different path to uh retain certain levels of control that is also good and bad by the way because you want to call yourself decentralized autonomous organization and then you're very concentrated in terms of voting power is also not so good but I think um yeah is a is a two-edged sword as well. Yeah, I I would be um quite careful to um manage especially these technical upgrades because we can also talk about the different types of proposals that people usually uh put forward, right?

So there's there's basically two types. There are these technical changes which can be quite critical to the operating of the protocol and then you have these other ones that are basically asking for money in in its very simplistic form, right? And it's like okay the DAO has a treasury and has some money and then I I I believe that with my proposal I can create something that contributes to the ecosystem and is is a net net benefit to the ecosystem. So I need a bunch of money and then I I put forward my proposal and ask for it.

So these are obviously less system systematically critical. Um but you also want guardrails there right because you don't want somebody to just uh drain your treasury for example. And there's there's also new research by I think some some folks from ETH that are looking at DAO attacks and all the different permutations of what bad actors are trying to do to get hold of these treasury assets right so that's also something that we have to continue to watch and to bring it back to like the different you know the analogy of the different shareholders in a private limited company what different rights are is it typically that um so the kind of the distribution or the separation I'd imagine in most say blockchain networks would you have validators or miners as one kind of you know citizen class and then token holders as the other and in that technical upgrade I guess is is it mostly validators and miners that would have the weight and the vote on you know how we should upgrade certain consensus

mechanism issues and whatnot and then the typical token holders who vote say on the allocation of treasury or where the money should go is that the kind of what we tend to see or it depends I mean um not not all Dows are the same but um often uh the DAO is the overarching decision making vehicle across the entire ecosystem. So um it's not like the technical matters can only be decided by um maybe the validators. Yeah. But um I I do want to highlight that there's a kind of one little distinction in some ecosystems at least in the in the prominent ones on Ethereum for example where you can delegate your vote.

So, so if you bought a bunch of UNI token for example and um you know you you just believe that UNI is the greatest platform of all times and you want to participate in the sort of capital gain over the next 5 years but you really don't understand how an AMM works and whether the fee switch should be turned off or on and and so you feel like you know I I can't really contribute much here. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to try and do a little bit of research to figure out who I can delegate my voting power to.

And then there are folks that are, you know, have lots of delegations from other people. So I choose the one that I feel can represent my point of view best and then I delegate my votes to them and then they will basically use my voting power to believe what um to to implement or to act on what what they believe is the best. Yeah. for each proposal. That's really interesting because it very much sounds like a form of kind of representative democracy. Then when you're delegating the power to do something to someone you've elected, but in this case, you're very much electing them with your money, right?

You're putting your tokens where your beliefs are, where where you who in in the other actors who you think will make the best decisions. So that's really interesting because it's taking what we what most of us know of in kind of most representative democracies to a kind of slightly different place for this context. Um, I also you mentioned there uh unis swap which I think is I'm I'm glad you brought that up because it shows there's quite a diverse range of uh different reasons why you might create a dow.

So obviously unis swap you have that for the operations of the automated market maker. Um we had things like the dowo as well for ethereum which had the hack associated with it that everyone's kind of familiar with. Constitution dow that we mentioned. Um, and then you also have, you know, as as as Alex said, blockchains being underpinned in some sense by Dows themselves, right? So things like the internet computer protocol there making decisions on the network level, right? So we've got a whole bunch of different things there.

Um, I wonder could you maybe pick a kind of a typical use case for a Dow. So what you know, one that you might see spring up today or tomorrow and take us through the kind of life cycle. So what does it actually look like? Who sets one up? how do they set one up? How do people get involved? That kind of things. So, I think that would really help to make things more tangible. Yeah. I mean, you've you've mentioned a whole bunch of them already.

And um in in our book again, we have a whole chapter on the different types of Dows because it it is actually a little bit complicated to make sense of what the purposes of all of these different dows are. And you mentioned there are protocol Dows then. Um I I think at the moment probably the biggest group of Dows are the ones that operate DeFi platforms at least the most prominent ones right and then of course unis swap is the kind of uh very big one in the room and if you ask me you know why why do these guys set up Dows and don't run it all as a company this is probably to do with the fact that the ethos of creating blockchainbased platforms is that we're creating something that is more akin to a public good rather than to some profit-making company.

Right? So I think when unis swap was set up probably the idea was to say okay this this AMM functionality is so fundamental to a lot of the crypto activity that's happening today. You know swapping one token for the next. you kind of need to have that and and we want to build it in a way that it's not run centrally by some platform that governs the rules but we want it to be run by the by the community. So I think that's how often these these projects start where they say okay we we really need to uh have community based decision- making because we believe that what we've created is a public good.

the this idea of public good, right, goes back to Elena Ostramm, who won the Nobel Prize in economics a long time ago. Um, but interestingly, she only looked at very um small communities that governed a local public good. You know, think about fish in the sea or or water um under under the ground and so on. So it's a kind of a open question whether the concept of governing a public good through the community works on such a global level. Um because of course blockchains you know don't know any jurisdiction.

They don't know any any borders um and they operate 24/7. So um that is actually an interesting research question that um maybe something to to look at in the future. You're 100% right. I think that is I I really find this topic of public goods and what they mean interesting because obviously people often describe blockchains a certain type of new public good where you have you know the mining network or the staking network that's securing them. Um I think another example that we didn't mention actually is our sponsor on the show Vet Dow.

Obviously they are um kind of working on how to allocate funds towards various sustainability uh initiatives and kind of doing using using that public good aspect but on a more local or small scale level distributed across lots of different use cases and uh I think that's really an interesting way of of describing actually what what Veta data do. So I'm glad you mentioned that. Um, so yeah, okay, let's let's say someone has, you know, and and maybe even it's worth mentioning where does someone go to find out what Dows exist, right?

They don't go on company's house in the UK to search up company names or they don't, you know, where where would people discover one and then let's say I find a Dow that particularly resonates with me. What does the process look like for actually getting involved, right? Because you have to presumably acquire some of the the governance tokens. How does one normally go about that? Yeah. So, I mean, there are a bunch of platforms that list Dows almost similar to what we perhaps know from the world of cryptocurrencies.

You know, the there's an equivalent to coin market cap, I would say. Um there's there's one called Deep Dow, for example, where lots and lots of different Dows are listed. Um, and you can, you know, see the size of the treasury and you can see how many proposals they put forward and some other statistics. So that's perhaps a good uh starting point, but I think this is not really how it works, right? Like people don't wake up and say, I want to be a member of a DAO today, you know, that that's that's really not how it works.

So people care about some cause and then eventually they search for ways to get involved in that cause. And again, veta is a good example, right? Maybe some people are really uh excited about uh sustainability and they have a specific idea but they don't know yet how to bootstrap and implement this idea and and I think that's when they go to be better down and and in the book we also have the the afterward that is actually written by Sunny. So he also draws a little bit of a picture on where this is all going in the future and and of course if you've if you met Sunonny you know that he's quite a visionary guy and he thinks very big.

So, so it's also interesting to see how some of the people today already um see see Dows play a much bigger role in the future. Yeah, I think that's quite a nice um bridge to the next topic. It you know, you said that a lot of these things start as public goods um rather than money-making schemes necessarily, but one of the things that VBA does obviously is kind of combine those two things. It's you can do a public good but also monetize that and like the link there is sustainability you know to kind of exist in our current paradigm of capitalism or whatever you should be able to make money and profit from these things that's the primary motivator for a lot of people beyond just you know doing something nice and you you know you wrote a book you've already mentioned it very briefly but I'll just say that book is called decentralized autonomous organizations there we go how finance can blockchainbased dares but this kind of like this is a nice kind of

bridge to what we were just talking about is you Finance is obviously for profit. So why should the finance industry be interested in Dows? Like what's their role there? Yeah. So it's interesting um Sandy's and my hunch was that as Dows get bigger and bigger treasuries eventually some smart banker will wake up one morning and say how do I get these guys as a client? Because anyone who has money is a potential client, right? So um there was a bit of a a hunch and we started writing the book with that in mind.

Right? If that happened one day those are big enough for traditional financial institutions to care then maybe we we can add um to the table with our book where we describes the the risks and and what you have to think about if you want to do business with a doubt. And halfway through, I kid you not, um, two bigger Dows started doing exactly that, right? So, if you remember, make a DAO put out an RFP for a billion dollar worth of money to be managed by a traditional financial institution, and I think Securitize and and Black Rockck basically got it.

Uh, some other some other asset managers including Singapore based Open Eden, I think, also got a chunk of that. Um, so that was one. And then I think Arbitum was in a similar situation, right? They said, "Oh, our concentration in our DAO treasury portfolio is quite high and maybe we should do something about that." Because this this idea of sustainability, right, is not only about drinking out of a mark. It's also about making sure that you have some sort of longevity in your ecosystem. So um it's an interesting topic because I started looking at these different DAO treasury compositions on deep DAO and then I realized that some of them they have 99.9% in their own token right I remember one point in time it probably changed by now but it's one point in time where I looked at optimism and optimism's biggest position of course is OP tokens and then its second largest position is was either USDC or Ethereum, but it doesn't matter.

Why? Because that second largest position was only $600 worth and the biggest position was something like $6 billion, right? So basically, they don't have anything else. So sure enough, 6 days later after I pondered on this, the market crashed and I think they lost $1.2 billion, right, in their market cap, which teaches you a few things. And number one, whatever that market cap number is is a nonsense, right? Um, but number two, if you are if you're worried about your longevity of your organization, decentralized organization in this case, you you want to make sure that you can survive bad times, right?

And that is that is quite important for those who are in charge of um managing the finances of of a DAO. Today's episode is sponsored by the Vchain Foundation. Now, we often talk about how emerging technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and Vchain is at the forefront of this green movement with initiatives like Vet Dow. Let's take a closer look. Imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets. These verified records build a massive collective impact benefiting people through their own actions.

Sound a bit complex, but Vchain made it fun. Explore our apps at vb better.com. Vchain's goal is to power a new era of sustainable solutions. So, if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day, go check out vb better.com to find out more. And now back to the show. And this is this kind of brings us back to our earlier topic like just because you're involved in a in a crypto token doesn't mean you necessarily know how to run a a DeFi system or understand financial risk and whatnot and the idea of specialization versus generalization.

So is the kind of the take-home message that a lot of these Dows when they grow to a certain size they really should start to have a diversified portfolio to not you know I don't want to sound bor too boring but is that the point that they should be interacting with specialists who can help help them manage their portfolio to ensure they have this longevity and security. It's a very tricky topic, right? Because sometimes if you speak to the hardcore Dgents, they will say, "No, no, no.

It should be like that. You should have 99% of your own token because if you don't then," and you know, if it all blows up, then we just go and do something else. But ah man, when I hear these comments, I really struggle, you And I think if you if you've accepted any sort of money from anyone, you have a bit of a fiduciary duty whether you can be identified or not, right? It's just a moral thing that you try very hard to make sure that this thing can survive for a while.

Um so so I do think there is some valid reason diversification. Now it's difficult, right? Because imagine you're the treasurer of unis swap and then of course with platforms like nansen and all and into the blog and all these other data database companies right the community will know if if you as a dial treasurer start selling your own token they will know and then you know there's going to be a Twitter storm right because everyone's like okay these guys lost confidence in their own project and you can see it in in Ethereum right now right if the Ethereum Foundation sells Ether that's not very good for the Ethereum ecosystem.

Whereas I always as a bystander I think they're damn smart. The price is not very very low right now. Take some money off the table. You make this thing a lot more resilient in the long term. Right? So that is something that perhaps everyone needs to think about a little bit. Um very large companies that we I mean just drawing to the world of traditional finance, right? large companies sell their stock to raise capital to make sure that they can build their new projects and and that's perfectly fine.

So I think I would see a parallel here to the world of of Dows and and cryptocurrencies as well. Yeah, that's really interesting. And and you're also kind of speaking to I think as the industry scales up and matures that the the sheer amount of money involved in these Dows and these projects overall will likely only increase and you'll have kind of more professionalized ones as well. Maybe ones where people are quite willing to identify themselves with Dows. you know, we've had that those cases in the past and not kind of operating on a fully anonymous or pseudonmous um kind of version of these dows, but actually being quite public and open about who is involved in the future as well.

Um I'm curious then you mentioned this this potential marriage between the world of traditional finance and Dows, right? How they interact. What do you think that looks like in the future ideally? So, how do we get the the big kind of financial players to interact with Dows or to use Dows maybe to create Dows in the future? Um, how what does what does that look like in an ideal sense? Because I'm sure some people will be worried about um, you know, what the implications are for the kind of cryptonative community, right?

Or for the blockchains and Dows themselves. Yeah. How how would you see that Wow, there's a lot in your question. So let me try to go bit by bit. No, no, no. But I'm just saying there's there's a lot in there. So um I mean right now let's start with traditional finance, right? Traditional runs on a on a sort of basic assumption that you know who you're dealing with, right? So it's is a very stark contrast to the world of blockchains where you know you you don't directly know who you're dealing with necessarily.

maybe you can infer and you can have all sorts of data science but you effectively there's no onetoone match between my wallet and and my name right so that presents a little bit of an issue and there arguably is also the biggest legal issue for any traditional institution to do anything with the DAO which is why one of the interviews that we have in the book with my lawyer friend Hagen Brook is also very interesting because he talks a lot about how the structuring has been done in several cases to facilitate this collaboration.

But I feel like at the moment we are perhaps more in a stage where these things are uh quick fixes, you know, they're not they're not so clean. So I think um for DA to succeed further, there also needs to be regulatory change. And this is something I'm particularly excited about because you you can strike a nice middle ground where on the one side you don't have to um send a copy of your password uh passport to somebody um and on the other side you you also sort of protect the ecosystem from rogue actors and so on right so that that is something that I'm I believe that is uh required and the good news is that many regulators.

I mean, I think the Singapore regulator is is probably leading the charge here. They are investigating, you know, how how do zero knowledge proofs work? How how can we make sure that these concepts can be used um so that uh public blockchains can also be an option to conduct financial services activities, right? That that would be a biggie for anything that is organized as a DA And that's really interesting because you were talking about kind of you know when when there's movements on chain say a foundation starts to liquidate assets or move it to a different asset class then there's a lot of panic and people are okay loss of confidence and everything comes down to confidence and that's one thing that I guess the blockchain provides is a degree of transparency so you have confidence in the activity that is on chain whether that's good or bad but the fact that you can see is quite important the more information a lot of times the better but there's a lot of things that are

happening offchain as well right we're kind of talking about say different asset classes. Um do you think that more and more we should try and put so the thing you just said there was around account the more information that is currently offchain that we put onchain is probably better for say anonymity confidence in the system confidence in the individuals that we're interacting with. Do you think more and more we'll start to see say traditional finance go more onchain putting more of the information on chain more of their activity on chain and do you think that Dows are doing that right now as well because I know that we're kind of talking earlier about a lot of the information that Dows actually have and all their assets are offchain so you need to kind of watch what they're saying and what they're doing kind of think about everything that's hidden underneath as well yeah so um I think it's already happening you know the adoption of blockchain in tradition traditional finance is happening.

But this transparency that you mentioned in my mind is a bug. It's not a feature. And I'm sometimes, you know, people look at me funny when I say that, but you think about it. If you can trace all transaction level data of a company, right, basically there's no room for anyone to interpret what that actually means. And there's always an immediate reaction. Um, I don't know whether that level of transparency is so good. Equally, with all of the machine learning capabilities that we have, it's very easy to figure out who has really large Bitcoin wallets, right?

And and who controls them. And then it's only a matter of time before other people just break into somebody's house and abduct the kid and say, "Hey, we know that this wallet is yours and we want it. You know, you we want all that money in there." So I think the the privacy aspect of this will become more and more important which is why I'm quite excited about those blockchains that also think about how to make transactions more private. And as a matter of fact we have many laws around the world.

In Europe we have GDPR. In Singapore we have PDPA that protect personal data. And so what we have to kind of marry is currently all of the requirements that financial services regulators have on the one side that of course concerned with terrorist financing and moneyaundering and so on. But that's not all right and that that's already a small amount of the of the overall transaction. So what's what's more important is how do we preserve the privacy because pres privacy in my mind is like a human right is not necessarily something that uh you can use to autocategorize somebody into the the bad actor compartment right so that that will be uh an interesting few years ahead where some of this regulation will have to evolve as well yeah I think this is really important for highlighting something we said earlier right is that now we're not just talking about voting, we're talking about voting and money, right?

It's a it's a kind of very it's kind of a very new way of combining those two things. And we know how important anonymity and privacy is when it comes to voting, especially kind of when we go to the ballot box ourselves, but in all other sorts of contexts as well. And there's all sorts of discussion around digital voting and the merits and demerits of that. But when you add in money to the mix, then the importance of that privacy is is kind of tenfold, if not more, right?

or something like that because um then yeah, as you said, you can become a target with a with a with a with a measurable incentive um to to target you if you're involved in a DA potentially, that kind of thing. So yeah, I think that's that's definitely one of the the kind of key risks I think people need to be aware of. Um what would you say are the other if any risks that people need should know and and and how we can mitigate them for Dows?

Because we mentioned something like the Dow hack, right? That was probably the if if anyone knows of a of a vulnerability then that's the one they'll have probably heard of the Ethereum D hack. But yeah, what would what do you think people should be thinking of in in general from a a kind of risks perspective on Dows? I mean I mean if you're if you're financial institution and you deal with a DAO there are bunch of idiosyncratic risks that we also outline in the book right apart from that accountability risk that we spoke about earlier there's also what we call DAO community risk you know what happens if the community suddenly abandons the the project right and then you maybe you build a product or a service that you're offering or you you want to participate in that ecosystem and and it basically is is an empty shell, right?

That is that is one risk. Um there is this what we call DAO financial risk which we touched upon a little bit when we talked about treasury management and the longevity of these portfolios. So I think that is another very serious topic. um you do have the governance risk as well, right? And basically governance risk is eventually the governance of the DA becomes dysfunctional in some shape or form whether it's through an external attack or whether internal players do do some funny business. So that that is also something to consider.

Um there are some operational risks as well, right? So, anything that has to do with uh people always bears uh the risk that somebody does something wrong. And I what's very much underappreciated today is that you also have a technology risk associated to this. And if I if we can spend maybe one or two minutes on it, but in my mind, not not all smart contract platforms are the same. They come with different characteristics. And if you choose as a DAO to build on a particular platform, you want to make sure that many characteristics um are conducive to what you're trying to do with the DAO.

Right? So for example, if you build an automated market maker, you anticipate lots and lots of transactions for the people who use your platform. You cannot have a model where you can't predict the gas price, you know, because you how are you going to build some sort of viable long-term model where you don't know what your operating cost is? That's that doesn't work. Um, I mean, there's a whole bunch of there's a there's a whole chapter on this actually in the book, but I'll say two more examples, right?

The first one that I wanted to bring up stability. Some smart contract platforms on a regular basis stop working. So if you offer a critical service to your users and then suddenly your system stops working for 8 hours, I think that is that is probably not very conducive to what you're trying to do, right? Um I think there are there are some others, but one one thing that we briefly spoke about is also privacy. So I I do think that that is uh a technological characteristic that will become more and more important and often as a DAO you're dependent on what your smart contract platform has to offer on that on that side.

I guess um on the the the risks involved, you mentioned like there's lots of operational risks, lots of people can make, you know, bad decisions and whatnot, but isn't that quite a powerful um kind of incentive to maybe be part of a dare because there's more people there's more this data points that there's more likelihood that there will be corrective measures to say address those especially when there's competition where whereas if we compare with like I say an individual that you know kind of does the whole thing themselves and they make all the decisions if they go psychopath and just go down that one road and it seems like it's going crazy but they have the entire power to say yes no and they keep going down that route then is that like a potential kind of um mitigating factor the de is there are a lot of people all kind of collectively making decisions as more likely to correct that path if something goes wrong.

Yeah, it can be. And if you look into again I use unis swap because I looked into it a little bit more. um they have this time lock functionality right where if a proposal is approved I think there's a 24 or 48 hour period where the smart contract can reviewed can be reviewed once more just to make sure that there are no vulnerabilities right so people buy into these guard rails to protect the ecosystem from these operational risks and that is something that is is very good I think yeah I think that that's quite fascinating it's the same with like validator is as well, right?

You have to lock your stake in for two four weeks. So if you do some kind of negative malicious behavior, there is an inbuilt kind of technology to ensure that you know you go down with the ship a little bit to disincentivize that. So like we've talked a little bit about how we think, you know, how you think Dows are evolving. It seems like they're going to kind of align more with traditional finance in a way, you know, more risk management kind of that kind of stuff, but also the traditional finance is going to align more with Dows and maybe go more on chain, be a bit more transparent.

How do you see Dows evolving like in the long term, say 10 years plus? Do you think they're going to be like part of our day-to-day? Do you think they're going to affect us like in the kind of the normal real world sense as well? It's interesting. So I don't think that as we said in the beginning that everything has to become a DAO but I already do see some large corporations to re you know they're investigating how to restructure part of their organization as a DA.

So I I do have one dear friend who is part of a very large insurance company and they think about how to organize their sales agents, right? and then they said, "Oh, maybe we should we should organize them as a DA." So these things are also happening inside of corporations, which I think is is very exciting. Um, so that is something that maybe we we can see more of. Um, I want to be a little bit careful because uh I don't have a a crystal ball.

I don't know what's going to happen. I mean, if I if I think about what I thought is going to happen 10 years ago, you know, wow, that was very different from what what eventually happened. And there's lots of things we couldn't predict. But I think uh for now is it's probably important to see the potential and also realize that um there have been some successes where people have started whole ecosystems and they're run by a DAO and the decision-m sort of works. Um of course nothing is perfect.

Um you could also argue you know there's all sorts of centralization tendencies and so on. I also believe that you have to be fair to these uh DAO founders and that only over time they can reach their decentralization goal. It's not like you can have that from day one, right? That is probably also not not very realistic. Yeah, I think that's uh it's good to highlight the need to be pragmatic when you're building these Dows, right? And understanding things won't always be perfect. These are kind of ideals to strive for 100%.

Um, I think that's a good view of the future. I I would be curious to know is there is there one single kind of gets you out of bed use case project idea in the DAO space that you know you think if I see this in the next 5 to 10 years then I'll be really happy. I think we've achieved something. Is there one kind of that that stands out to you in that regard? So many things could be organized as a Um I mean because I'm also a little bit in the education camp, right?

I'm also thinking about okay, how can we use these systems to incentivize people to learn about topics that are perhaps really important? So I give one example that I I'm a little bit passionate about. I think there are many human beings on the planet that are not financially very literate and because of that they take decisions that become a bit of a problem for them further down the line but then many people also are not interested in finance right it's it's not like I mean I wake up every morning and I think finance is great but I know that many people find it boring and not interesting but for them it's also important to learn about finance otherwise they make all these these mistakes.

So what if there was a DAO based uh educational um organization that could incentivize people to learn the basics of finance so that they can avoid these topics, right? That I think would be very very exciting and if if that if that ever existed, I would be very excited about it. Yeah. Yeah. That's a really lovely one. I think there's a kind of beautiful almost irony in the the aiming for a future where you know the crypto and web 3 space that is so derided for you know potentially uh being damaging financially to people um because of the lack of financial literacy right because because it's difficult to know um you know how to to use your money wisely and and prepare for things like retirement.

I think it'll be great to see web 3 actually come up with a solution to incentivize how do we how do we get that education because you know we're in the UK it's not in a good state I think financial literacy and financial education it's not something you really um or when me and Alec were in school it's not something that you really learn and hence you know how we're we're two crypto djens now but no absolutely not thank you Dan it's uh it's been a real pleasure talking to you thank you so much um obviously we we'll we'll link you out and make sure everyone can uh can follow you and and find you more but I think LinkedIn's the place to to catch you, right?

Yeah. Perfect. Thanks for having me. It was really interesting conversation. Thank you. No, pleasure is all ours, Dan. Thank you very much. And thank you for listening. You can join us next week to untangle a little more web

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes