Episode 53

Ethereum ETFs

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of the Untangling Web 3 podcast, we dive into the recent approval of Ethereum ETFs by the SEC, a pivotal development that promises to reshape the landscape of institutional crypto investments.

Join us as we dissect the implications of this approval, explore the background of the decision, and analyze its potential impact on the broader Web3 ecosystem.

Key highlights

1. Background and Significance: We kick off by explaining what ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) are and their importance in the financial market. We highlight the differences between spot ETFs and futures ETFs, setting the stage for understanding the recent Ethereum ETF approval.

2. Regulatory Landscape: Delving into the ongoing regulatory battles, we discuss the SEC's evolving stance on cryptocurrencies, the implications of defining digital assets as securities versus commodities, and the introduction of the Financial Innovation and Technology for the 21st Century (FIT21) bill.

3. Market Reactions and Future Outlook: We explore the market's response to the Ethereum ETF approval, including the significant price surge and the subsequent speculation around other cryptocurrencies like Solana and XRP. We also touch on the potential for future regulatory developments and their impact on the Web3 space.

This episode underscores the dynamic and rapidly evolving nature of the crypto landscape. The SEC's approval of Ethereum ETFs marks a crucial step towards greater institutional adoption and regulatory clarity.

As we navigate this new era, it's clear that the intersection of regulation, technology, and market forces will continue to shape the future of Web3. Stay tuned as we keep you updated on these developments and more.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

Matthew Sigel head of digital asset research at vanex described this as one of the biggest regulatory 180s in SEC history and obviously ethereum price spiked by 25% effectively overnight on the back of this there's this fit 21 bill which I think is a really funny name actually stands for financial Innovation and technology for the 21st century so they're basically saying in order to classify one of these digital assets as a commodity it needs to meet a kind of certain threshold for decentralization do you think this will change the view on ethereum the default right now I say ethereum is probably more likely a security do you think this will move the needle of and push into a commodity area or do you think this doesn't change anything I think what will be interesting is there'll be a real push to create better incentives for miners so that more people go into that space right now I think that's what we're going to see from networks is how do we incentivize miners to come into this

network so we can Define it as more welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today is going to be a quickfire Punchy recent news event which is the ethereum ETF approvals by the SEC um this is quite important back in January we spoke about the Bitcoin ETF approval and how Monumental that was for the crypto space but the web3 space at large especially in terms of institutional adoption and now the ethereum ETFs have been approved as well so yeah this episode we're going to unpack what it means and what happened you some of the chaos that actually went around this how you doing jack yeah not too bad thanks Al it's nice to uh start the new era right year two of podcast with some good news for the industry I guess and what didn't exactly take a crystal ball I don't think but after the Bitcoin approvals that we previewed and reacted to in January a lot of speculation was then well ethereum is going to follow suit quite soon I've

even seen today people saying salana is up next so it seems like the Bitcoin ETFs have had this knock on effect so yeah it's interesting I think there are a few different points of difference to discuss with the ethereum one and obviously as you said that the the background to it is a little bit different uh this time because of the sec's views but yeah I think this is going to be a interesting kind of quick fire one yeah let's go into some of the background so just for people that aren't aware an ETF is this Exchange traded fund it's basically a way for investors to get access to lots of different funds be it's stocks bonds blah blah blah very popular um amongst investors because they allow you to diversify your portfolio they give you access to liquidity and it's lower cost typically than say going with mutual funds and all this kind of stuff so anyway ETFs very boring Financial tools to invest in lots of stocks yeah maybe just also worth reminding

ourselves there are two types of ETFs typically so you get spot ETFs which is what we're talking about with the ethereum approvals and also the Bitcoin won in January so spot ETFs give you exposure to the spot price so basically the current trading price of the underlying asset whereas Futures ETFs they give you exposure to Futures contracts that speculate on future price and the Futures ETFs have been around for a little while now for Bitcoin and ethereum I think and these new spot ETFs is the ones that everyone was clamoring after that we're now getting in 2024 yeah exactly so some of the background if you're not aware of the effectively we've been having this ongoing battle from you know the crypto I guess Market you say we well yeah I guess I invest in it so I'm part of it we have been having this ongoing battle with the crypto community and the SEC which is like the regulatory body for financial tools and financial mechanisms in the US and you some of the

things around this were they were initially say a year or two ago trying to Define Bitcoin and ethereum as Securities and there was this whole palava about you know what is a security and what is a commodity and is Bitcoin are Bitcoin in ethereum security or Commodities the reason this matters is because if it's defined as a security if they are defined the Securities then there's a lot stricter regulation about how they can be used how the tax all this kind of all this kind of stuff and the SEC came out quite big early on and said we need really strict regulation around Bitcoin ethereum and all these things reasons like Market manipulation they thought a lot of these things were Ponzi schemes and they were quite unregulated there wasn't proper kind of of kyc going into it surveillance wasn't possible you know all that stuff around these are used to fund terrorist organizations and just used for money laundering and dur drugs and yeah the other main thing I think was they wanted to

protect investors because of this they thought you don't want big players like Black Rock going into Bitcoin then all of a sudden there's a rug pull and bitcoin price goes to zero and people lose billions right yeah it kind of underscores the getting these ETFs over the line has a lot of regulatory concerned you mentioned the kind of surveillance share ing agreements and this is something that was a big aspect in the Bitcoin ETF so I think in the end they had to have surveillance sharing agreements which is essentially for the providers of these funds to share information on the activity of them to other entities right so I think there's an agreement for the some of the Bitcoin ETFs with the NASDAQ exchange right and that's intended to to help avoid Market manipulation as you said yeah and it's just very interesting as you said this whole backdrop of is Bitcoin is ethereum uh commodity or is it a security and yeah it's kind of been more or less settled now right for Bitcoin

it's being treated as a commodity but ethereum is the one that's had this big cloud looming over it for many years and the question is basically does it satisfy the ho test right which is how you determ something's a security or not so I think that's involves from my memory it's something like it involves an investment of money with the expectation of profit in a common Enterprise and the profits that you get from that would be derived from a third party or a promoter so essentially on the surface lots of those things I mean most crypto looks like it probably falls under that bracket so that's why there's been a lot of nervousness I think around it for ethereum I think even the hery test is kind of vague it's not as black and white as yes know with those things right but I think yeah you talked about Bitcoin it's kind of been decided now that it's not a security but there was a lot of kind of issues and commotion around this like

early on in 2021 there was Bitcoin Futures ETF so you didn't hold the asset these big funds didn't hold the asset they speculated on the price of Bitcoin Futures contracts rather than holding the asset and this was the kind of the the set stage for a while until there was lawsuits bought in by grayscale and other people trying to actually get actual spot ETFs to hold the asset itself and the courts ruled they were like yeah actually there's no reason why you can't do this the kind of the arguments you've given don't make sense and the SEC had to kind of backtrack a lot and then back in January 202 before everything could approved the floodgates opened and Bitcoin became institutionally adopted in a lot of ways and yeah that was the state of play up until recently but like Jack said this wasn't the case for ethereum there was still a lot of speculation as to whether ethereum was a commodity like Bitcoin was being defined now or was it more of a security

and there was a lot of applications going in despite that and I think up until recently so we're in May 2024 now I saw that Bloomsburg prediction that the ethereum ETFs were going to be approved Pro was around 25% then literally overnight it skyrocketed to 75% and everyone was like what the hell has happened and we had a lot of SEC chaos because of it and now we're in the stage where things have been approved I mean if there's one thing you can say about the sec's handling of all the stuff is that there's been mixed messaging I think to say the least right over time and yeah so this news that there are these kind of two different filing types right they have to make you have to have a what's called a 19 B4 form that gets approved and that kind of is the basic allows an issuer to go and list an ETF and be a custodian Etc and set things up um and then you have the S1 form approval which

is what you need for the ETF to actually go live and be traded so it was news that these 19B for files uh they were asking them to go and update them on an accelerated basis basically you know with with hindsight it looks like they were saying you want to get these approved as fast as possible so can you go and can you go and sort things out so yeah that happened we saw this big boost in in in the odds and the bookmakers and interestingly there was a lots of kind of onchain betting which is quite funny I think well not funny actually kind of interesting to see where the speculation is happening now you know beyond just speculation on the price of these assets but then there was lots of onchain betting markets that then suddenly started changing their odds quite drastically on on their being in ethereum ETF approval yeah Matthew Sigel who's L of digital asset research vanex described this as one of the biggest regulatory 180s in SEC history just

to kind of highlight how abrupt this was out of nowhere and obviously ethereum price spiked by 25% effectively overnight on the back of this and like Jack said this this approval we've got so far is kind of like the high level approval that we agreed that ethereum can be listed in this way in these ETFs and then there's a bit of devil in the detail around this se1 approval stuff which is like how actually does it work like I se there's a lot of things around can you stake through these ETFs and they saying okay no stakings prohibited for XY reasons but yes there is more work that needs to go on before these are fully approved and can be traded but they've high level agreed that this will happen basically and there's one other thing that I want to give in the backdrop to this so there's this fit 21 bill which I think is a really funny name actually stands for financial Innovation and technology for the 21st century which is not as

fun as fit 21 bill that gives a little backdrop to this yeah exactly and this was very interesting timing let's say with this was approved more or less kind of five or six days ago now so this bill was being proposed and going through the House of Representatives in the US it passed the vote last week and I think there's some interesting political machinations going on between the two sides of of Congress and of of of the the political landscape in America generally with the upcoming elections and and eventually this was approved and and it's significant because it's going to as you said provide significant regulatory clarity not only hopefully eventually for the assets themselves but also in the division of labor between the various organizations that are involved right so you have the SEC which You' think would be just handling Securities and the cftc the Commodities Futures uh trading commission which should be just handling the commodity side of things now the issue being which crypto go and which buckets right but I

think this is going to provide some clarity over okay which of these organizations are actually going to start targeting and looking at certain things it's also meant to be providing other things like more detailed Market structure for digital assets so what issuers what custody Provisions you have you spoke a lot about custody in recent episodes lots of those kind of considerations that people know about generally in the industry but then they're going to be put into some more legislative Clarity right and and proper guidelines I think being accompanied with that yeah exactly we're not going to go too much into this fit 21 bill but Jack gave like a really good high level it effectively is a bill that provided more regulatory Clarity consumer protections basically all the things you need for the us to move more heavily into a regulated crypto space I think one of the interesting things around this was Biden previously said I will veto this bill no matter what I will veto this bill probably because he didn't think there

was much Democratic support for it and then all of a sudden there's this kind of cross Party Support the Democrats come out and they vote in favor of this bill and he's now saying he won't veto it so it was really this strange turn overnight basically over the course of a week where there was positive support from Joe Biden Democrats legislators across the board and we're going to go into some of the reasons why because that all fits into why the ethereum ETFs were approved as well why there's been this change but like I said don't want to go too much into this fit21 bill I think one part that I do want to highlight which is quite interesting is around this decentralization test which you know about this Jack I thought this was one of the most interesting parts of the entire bill yeah definitely and I think this is kind of Builds on some of the noises that have been made by The Regulators people like H Pier right has been talking about

decentralization and defining it in more detail for a number of years now so they're basically saying in order to classify one of these digital assets as a commodity it needs to meet a kind of certain threshold for decentralization which you know as we talked about in our episode on decentralization it is a spectrum so it's nice to see that they're acknowledging it and I think it's something like no entity can have more than 20% control of the network is that right to be considered sufficiently decentralized I think it that's so powerful like it'd be interesting to work out why they came to that number like you say this shows a real understanding of what decentralized means like a lot of people were coming out and saying okay ethereum shouldn't be considered a commodity because you have potentially this controlling organization that have a majority share or closer majority share that can manipulate the price or change the course of it and all this kind of stuff and like you say like decentralization is such a

kind of powerful word in the crypto space where everyone's vying to say they're the most decentralized and when you look under the hood a lot of them aren't but it's really interesting that they've come out and actually defined what what decentralization is yeah and I 100% agree with your point there right the number is really interesting 20% like why 20% is that the number that they've chosen and I think it's actually it's very cautious on their part and I think it's quite smart so if you look at the theoretical side of decentralization people would say well in Bitcoin so long as no one has 51% of the network then it's fine it's decentralized I mean lot of people would disagree with that but that's a theoretical argument you can make in other Corners you might have I've seen 3% is quite often touted and there are other consensus mechanisms for other blockchains and other cryptos that have a a scientific threshold on decentralization under which it's secure which is more like 33% and then they've

gone one step further and said no let's say 20% is our limit which is you know significantly lower so I think they're hedging their bet well I say hedging their bets I think they're being cautious and saying we really don't want to have any significant control of any entity in a network for it to be decentralized which is a little bit interesting for the case of ethereum and they've said I think that ethereum does qualify under this potentially but if you I just had a quick look at ether scam right this morning and there's a block proposer called Beaver build that is sitting around 41% of Block's mind in the last 24 hours taking around 50% of the rewards of the network right and this isn't again it's not black and white at all because it's a block proposer which is just one part of the whole consensus mechanism and validation system in ethereum but it does does show that there are still entities with uh influence in certain elements that go above that 20%

threshold so I'm interested to see whether that will impact them going forward and yeah I do want to talk about this more because like you say this is these are Dynamic things like mining percentage could change potentially overnight like how can you keep changing between security and commodity but before we go into that should we talk about you know some of the reasons that people are speculating there was this drastic U-turn basically overnight I think they are quite interesting and it kind of reflects mostly like politics in America for obvious reasons so yeah one of the big reasons that this U-turn happened was around legal pressure like the SEC was like facing basically repeated legal cases against them to Second why aren't you filing these things what's the actual reasoning behind a lot of this stuff and I think they just didn't necessarily have the means to fight all these cases I looked at some of the numbers that were being thrown around to actually keep pushing like some of the sec's legal battles and

it was like in the hundreds of millions like really crazy crazy numbers to keep fighting this stuff yeah it's crazy the stakes that we're talking about now in these legal decisions and you know we spoke before about I don't know if maybe this is the ones you've looked at but with coinbase's position they're actively reaching out trying to talk to The Regulators there's all these different fronts on which the SEC and to a lesser extent probably the cftc are fighting or dealing with at the minute so just even not even from a cost perspective but just from a Manpower and brain power perspective it must be impossible to keep on top of if you're in one of those organizations right now yeah and I think that the other side of that is that there's a lot of money in crypto now so they have the money to actually fight these cases it's not something you necessarily want to go up against when there's trillion dollar businesses on the line potentially and these matter so much

more for the say the crypto players than they do for the SEC so they're going to put so much into this and I think that's a really interesting Dynamic the other big one is the politics obviously we've seen that there's been a kind of a transition from say I know both the Republican and the Democratic side for more crypto Pro stance right and this has come because we're in an election year like you maybe you've seen Donald Trump has come out very strong on crypto side saying you know I will protect your rights to custody of digital assets I'll protect your right to trade crypto and all this kind of stuff I think maybe it's in part because he's trying to generate a lot of revenue from his new nft collection to fight some of those legal battles he's got going on right now yeah there there's a myriad reasons why this could be the case I mean the last US presidential election in what 2020 I remember how notable it was that there was

basically one major candidate I think it was a Democratic candidate I forget his name now but he was campaigning on a very Pro crypto ticket right and he was probably the only one he was very kind of tech focused young kind of looking forward basically in in the industry and now that's much more common place right you've got lots more candidates on both sides of the Spectrum in US politics who are now looking at being pro crypto and maybe it's the impact of mem coins you know all jokes aside there have been a lot of meme coins bleeding into the political sphere this year do with the ma major candidates but also I think it's very clear that there's now a growing mandate for um for the general widespread use of crypto I think the is the mayor of Miami has basically been on a singular oneman mission to make it the state for the home for for crypto I know Texas has also has been working to bring lot of innovators in there so

there are lots of you know not just on the federal level in the US but there's lots of infighting to position within the us as the home for crypto now which is very interesting yeah it's quite exciting for the space on that Meme stuff I saw that Joe Biden for his campaign is hiring I think it's something like director of memes or something like that who's like their whole job is to like develop memes and put it on social media to get him going it's just crazy to see how politics is trying to keep up with modern day Tech culture and like social media specific yeah and on the politics point I think it is just worth a very brief mention of SED because you know now he's obviously I believe serving a jail term right we discussed before but one of the big things about the whole FTX and sound bankman freed dearle was that he it turned out I believe that he was uh heavy political donor right and potentially to both sides

because he was as we spoke about so deep into influencing regulation kind of a one-man lobbyist almost so it's very interesting to see that lots of people are still Pro crypto despite maybe having been tainted indirectly or directly by what happened with Sam so yeah that's just one thing I think is worth mentioning as we lead up to the election yeah I mean Donald Trump is accepting crypto donations on coinbase so he's like got his finger in all pies obviously and like you say it was I think it was a surprise that this fit 21 Bill there was a lot of democratic support cross Party Support so Joe Biden's recognized that he doesn't want to lose that sector society that now see Donald Trump as the pro crypto St so he's trying to go into that even if it maybe is against some of his principles I think the other big person we got to speak about here is Gary gendler obviously who is just a bit all over the place I think when it

comes to this stuff like I've seen a lot of people saying like he just thinks Donald Trump is going to get elected sees that Donald Trump is very heavy on the pro crypto side and doesn't want to get fired When Donald Trump comes in so he's changed his tune basically overnight but that's all speculation yeah speaking of memes the gift that keeps on giving I'm quite kind of sympathetic in a way with Gary GZA because he's had a he's had a tough job and he's the figure of a lot of derision now but yeah I think he has had a pretty strong 180 himself really people talk about the SEC and a lot of the time they're referring to Gary genda anyway so yeah this may well be a a move of pragmatism for the next political regime and it'll be very interesting to see where it's left at the end of this year right if there as you say if there is a turnover in Personnel at these organizations if there is a completely

new kind of philosophy instilled at them I I can't imagine that these organizations are prone to such sweeping change as you get in politics because then it would be complete chaos but it's pretty chaotic anyway so maybe it will who knows yeah and the last two kind of like external Dynamics I want to talk about really quickly is we have this sab1 121 Bill and this was effectively a bill that required Banks to hold customers digital assets on their balance sheets which was a bit burdensome for banks they kind of limited say people's ability to do that and there been a resolution to overturn that to make it much easier for banks to allow consumers to hold digital assets that's one piece that I want to talk about that's also fed into this kind of positive crypto Outlook being pushed in kind of the legislative space and the other one is this anti- cbdc bill which I think is really interesting like for whatever reason America is really I've seen it like noticed it a

lot on social media like Americans are really worried about cbdcs generally they think it's a a way for say the Federal Reserve to dominate the kind of their financial instruments especially one on line they think it's a threat to privacy they think governments are going to increase control and I don't know if it feeds into this kind of like American idea of freedom Liberty you know privacy all this kind of stuff but people are really coming out against that and there's actually been an anti- cbdc bill that's been passed in the house which feeds into this whole kind of crypto play as well if you want the efficiency of crypto and this decentralized ability to interact peer top and you don't want to do with the cbdc well that obviously feeds quite positively into the Bitcoins the ethereums of the world yeah you're right this is a really interesting one and I agree with your analysis that it probably is that a case of cbdcs I think are going to be a hard sell to

a lot of the American public given the the American dream the idea of complete freedom in the market and and people wanting to have more autonomy over their money and things like that and even though we've discussed there are million different ways to implement cbdcs and there are a million different properties you get out of those choices I think the perception is still so great especially in places like America that this is the way for the state to get into your wallet basically and to have controls and following the the covid kind of parachute payments and the inflation that we've seen the money printing you know that's another meme printer go bur that's one of the big big memes we've seen over the last few years I think that's probably fed into this but as you said this does I think this does position the US to be much more Pro crypto native because the demand is there overall for digital money and if they're not going down the CBC route that means they necessarily

have to be a little bit more Pro actual blockchain infrastructure right the real stuff that we talk about all the time so yeah I think this could end up being a positive thing even though maybe they're throwing out the baby with the bath water a little bit on on cbdcs God we've not heard that phrase in a long time I'm glad it's made a return yeah I think like we talked about this early on in say normal legislators and say government Representatives misunderstanding of the crypto space and thinking I can turn off Bitcoin I can turn off ethereum it's like no you really can only turn off the access to bitcoin and ethereum if you really want to and it's nice to see that they've slowly started to understand that that pushing this away through legislation to other countries is just going to lead to a lack of innovation and a lack of revenue for their own country and Trump is obviously pushing that agenda saying we want business here we want the the crypto

natives to be here building because that's what America's about and it seems like Joe Biden's now had to do a uturn to make sure he's not you know lacking in that space basically yeah I think yeah this is one that we definitely will check in on in a few months if not towards the end of the year because it will be very different to see what the noises are coming out of The Regulators in a post 2024 election world in the US but yeah not to make this too much of a political cast right so I think that's well covered by other shows but maybe if we just finally end the show and return to what do we actually think the impact of these ETF approvals are for ethereum then so I we've covered the fact that you know this will provide additional regulatory oversight potentially and this is a signal of increased adoption which we can get into but the big I think the big question I have and that I'm a little bit

uncertain on is do you think this will change the view on ethereum because let's say the default right now I think is to to say ethereum is probably more likely a security if you go on what has been said by Gary gendler in the SEC do you think this will move the needle and push into a commodity area or do you think this doesn't change anything so I think that's the big question that comes from this I think that based on that speculation as to what decentralization is and therefore what is a security and what is a commodity I think networks will really be looking to decentralize and I think the big push just purely for like tax reasons the burden reasons whatever it is and I think what will be interesting is there'll be a real push to create better incentives for miners so that more people go into that space right now I think that's what we're going to see from networks is how do we incentivize miners to come into this network

so we can Define it as more decentralized and it's that's what I think will the the angle will be from a a technical and a kind of strategic perspective for these networks going forward yeah I I think that's a pretty kind of strong conclusion to draw and I'd agree with that I think the reason I asked partly is because I've seen a lot of Talking Heads saying well this this signals ethereum going down the same path as Bitcoin and this is it's definitely going to become a commodity not a security and I find that a bit of a strange one to jump to because all we're saying really is that they're going to allow these ethereum ETFs these spot ETFs which are themselves Securities right so if you have a share in an ETF that is a security so we're talking about the approval of a security that's linked ultimately to ethereum maybe you could contort it to think well actually this is getting people used to the idea of ethereum as a security so

I just wanted to point out that I think a lot of people are maybe getting ahead of themselves when they think this is gonna completely flip how people view ethereum but yeah that's my two cense no that makes sense I don't think this is that impactful a thing for say the actual details the technical aspects of ethereum or you know the I don't think the taxation stuff matters tooo much I think what it is just a nod towards this is the space to push towards and I we said that we prioritize utility over speculation and I think more people will be looking at and putting money into this space What are the daps that I can start to build and I think that's the most exciting thing is we' kind of said that Bitcoin in its implementation right now isn't known for supporting this kind of absolute Utopia of daps right because of maybe the misconception there's a lot of is an inability to smart Contracting and for whatever reason ethereum is that place like

it is the world computer that has the best ecosystem for building decentralized application I think the exciting thing is now the money that's going to come to that space I imagine there will be a boom in investment looking for how can I improve the technology to support other people coming into that space and even though this isn't that Monumental a thing like you say I think in five to 10 years people will never be looking into the Horizon okay in five to 10 years it will be a Monumental thing and this is the path going towards that yeah I I agree and if if you think of ethereum as having more utility than uh BTC for example then until now it was harder to access any potential price upside that comes from that for the general retail consumer right and I think this is good because it evens the playing field out between a BTC and an ethereum and it says well if the utility narrative around ethereum is valid and if it continues then

people can get price exposure to that and ethereum isn't limited by the lack of Market access that it had compared with Bitcoin right having its ETF approvals in January so in just terms of it direct impact I think it's good that at least we have those two on a level footing now that they can compete on in in The Wider Market I think and I think like we talk about blockchains and like cryptocurrencies that enable blockchains and all this kind of stuff and there's a lot of value to be derived from that transparency data all this kind of stuff but the fundamental thing that I think we've been missing that is the in my mind the USP of all stuff is the idea to embed data and value into one exchange for example and the point right now is we don't do that because not many people or the General market doesn't want to transact in ethereum like you have Micro payments that was one of the primary goals in my mind of Bitcoin but

that doesn't work there's a lot of reasons why that doesn't work but it fundamentally also doesn't work because people don't want to transact in Bitcoin you give me Bitcoin for some micro or micro incentive I can't use it down the markets like I just hold it in my coinbase wallet and maybe trade it out after a week or something like that but I think the idea that we can start to use cryptocurrencies for everyday payments in supermarkets is actual real you know currency and real kind of cash that really excites me and that's the kind of I think that's when we're going to see the real value ad of all these cryptocurrencies when we can actually use them for everyday payments and embed all the other functionality we've talked about with like data mutability transparency peer-to-peer all this kind of stuff yeah you've actually maybe had a thought there that these new financial instruments that we're getting that give people price exposure maybe will end up segregating the speculation to these regulated financial instruments and

then the people who are wanting to build wanting to do this exciting stuff try micro payments build applications on ethereum whatever it might be they'll be the ones who are actually self- custody and handling these things themselves and there are pros and cons to both but I think it's nice to now you before price exposure and utility were all in the same bucket basically but now with these instruments you can segregate it a little bit so you can I could put some money away in my retirement account this has exposure to one of these ETFs and then I can also have some in my wallet to go and play you know some web three game with right which is cool I like that it means we have more options at the end of the day yeah so just to summarize that the high level benefits are increased institutional interest which is good for you know financing a lot of these real utility projects Market reaction obviously ethereum went up 25% basically overnight which is always

nice and better regulatory in the space basically and you know and interesting kind of as soon as this happened like within a day I was seeing articles everywhere about okay Solano and xrp are the next to be approved everyone byy bye bye right now and I think they went not maybe as much as ethereum did just people were like you know in a year's time these will be approved and there's every all the value is already been locked up into ethereum these announcements were already assumed in was it really like was only like a day ago that everyone saying it wasn't going to happen yeah it's crazy how quickly people jump onto it I think it's a bit like listings on exchanges this what that kind of used to be it was like oh well I would get this crypto because if that's been listed then this might be listed and now we're talking about something with much higher regulatory burden on it right to get a listed an ETF I think it could be

a number of years away for some of these especially for the newer chains or the ones you know you mentioning salana as a potential candidate well that has significant downtime quite frequently right so that has it whole other set of challenges maybe that won't meet the requirement of a commodity right why is my commodity down right like gold doesn't go down that kind of thing so I think there are different questions to ask and another implication we didn't quite touch on yet is the fact that we now have you know this instrument for an ETF both for a proof of work or the biggest proof of work blockchain and the biggest proof of stake blockchain right so now again they're both on a level footing in terms of Market access potentially but how will this change in terms of the narrative maybe over the next few years um will this impact the staking Paradigm you have on ethereum which you don't really have on proof of work and you know will these big financial institutions

who are locking up assets and again when you think of someone like a black rock right they had to buy a load of Bitcoin to support their ETF if they then you know a Vanguard goes and buys a bunch of ethereum to support their ethereum ETF then they can do something more with that they can go and stake that right and how does that play into their obligations as as a custodian I'm not quite sure but it'll be interesting to know I think this is one of the most interesting points like you have proof of work where effectively the miners who they run the network at the end of the day they have massive heavy bits of kit that are very expensive to run that people don't really want to be involved with unless they absolutely have to be in that as their entire business portfolio they run the network so Black Rock coming in and buying whatever it is 100 million of Bitcoin or holding 100 million of Bitcoin for their consumers doesn't really

affect that too much obviously you can say they have indirect sway if they start saying come on can you do this thing then they'll listen because they have a lot of the activity on the network it's very different with a proof of State Network the network is effectively dominated or run by the amount of stake you put in which is the amount of ethereum you hold and yeah there's some mining equipment you need but it's insignificant to the amount of steak you need so if you then have a black rock that now owns say 15% of the network for example has 15% of the stake and they're like actually you know what I can just spend 100 Grand by a mining rig and I can be a dominant player in this space it really feeds into that kind of we talked about decentralization early on what is decentralized but if you all of a sudden have these ETFs that make up say 40% of the network there's might be a real centralization there of all

this stuff and I think that's GNA be really interesting to see how that plays out with the proof of State Network yeah that' be really ironic if one of the ethereum ETF custodians ends up accumulating so much ethereum and they think why don't I stake it as a validator and then there's some changes with other validators and all of a sudden one of these crosses that 20% threshold and brings it out of a commodity into a security domain that be interesting right that would be one One impact of of of of all this approval down the line that they maybe weren't foreseeing what would they do what they would probably do is split it up into two entities and then start saying okay we've got 15% here 15% there and then you're like okay so how do we really Define decentralization because these are separate legal entities but there's a connection there where they have similar motives and I think that's going to be really interesting to see how they start to Define decentralization I've

seen like a lot of these networks have a thousand mining nodes and stuff like that and when you they all have different names and you look under the it's all run by you know two companies you're like that's not decentralized like it's technically may be decentralized but like philosophically and politically whatever it is that's not decentralized really interesting to see how they start to regulate this across the crypto networks yeah and I haven't actually read the detail of the fit bill yet but I I definitely intend to I'd be interested to know how concrete the definition of the entities they're talking about right one entity having control because you have this question in Bitcoin with mining pools right now yeah we have you know potentially tens of thousands of people contributing hash power but really you have one controlling entity that's proposing the next block as we said in ethereum you have these block proposers these validators and can have a few other types in between if one of them has 40% like we mentioned

earlier does that tip them into having a controlling stake or controlling influence in the network or not so yeah I don't know are these decentralization terms in the bill even fit for purpose yet I don't know but definitely one for me to read up on and maybe come back to you with a hot take next time yeah but I think overall this news is exciting like the SEC had basically signed off that these ETFs can go ahead that looks good for the market obviously number goes up but you can't actually trade it until these S1 filings get approved and I'm quite interested maybe more interested to see what they look like because that's where the devil and the detail is I've seen already they're saying that you won't be able to stake with these ETFs there'll be lots of kind of prohibitions on them and they'll be quite Limited in the first iteration yeah let's wait to see if and when they get approved and what it actually looks like for people yeah we said

with the Bitcoin ETFs there was this interesting kind of clause in there about them being able to Define what they think Bitcoin is and ethereum also has this history of forking right we have ethereum classic and normal ethereum so how will that play in how will they cater for potential future upgrades and future Forks of ethereum that we can't foresee now that will be as you say the devil will be in the detail but yeah I think that kind of more or less wraps up our reaction to this news again significant but lots of lots of regulatory Clarity pending hopefully will come very soon so yeah with that we'll just say thank you for listening wherever you may be and join us next time to entangle a little more web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time

to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes