Episode 26

Digital Ownership Access Controls with Sean Griffin

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of Untangling Web3, hosts Alec Burns and Jack Davies engage with Sean Griffin, co-founder of Object Layer, to dissect the intersection of blockchain technology and data ownership.

Sean, with a background in policy advising for the Canadian government, shares his journey towards blockchain, driven by a desire for more control over digital files. He explains how blockchain enhances individual control through peer-to-peer interactions and delves into the world of NFTs (non-fungible tokens). They explore NFTs' utility beyond collectibles and gaming assets, discussing their broader potential in data or media content ownership.

The conversation shifts to focus on utility NFTs and their practical applications. These NFTs go beyond just being digital art; they can signify ownership rights or grant access to specific services. Sean gives an intriguing example of how owning a complete Nike shoe NFT collection could potentially yield unique benefits from Nike.

The discussion also touches on how different blockchain networks provide varied attributes and the possibilities of interconnecting these databases through bridging technologies. Emphasizing the utility aspect, Sean prefers referring to digital assets as "objects" rather than "tokens," citing examples where NFTs secure sensitive documents in collaborative projects, enhancing control over access and preventing unauthorized copying.

Further delving into decentralization, the episode highlights its role in facilitating direct peer-to-peer data transfer, with applications in secure communication like video chats and phone calls. Sean illustrates how blockchain can revolutionize document sharing among multiple parties, ensuring consistency and accountability, with applications ranging from trade secrets to general data security. Object Layer, likened to a safety deposit box for data, aims to provide customizable data security solutions across various domains, allowing enterprises to store their 'lockbox' either on-premises or in the cloud while maintaining secure access.

In addition, Sean discusses the broader implications of this technology in areas like health records management and online privacy, stressing the importance of secure, accessible record-keeping in the Web Three era. Despite some resistance to the NFT terminology, Sean envisions media as the first industry to widely adopt these technologies, although enterprise adoption might be slower. Media and entertainment executives show interest in the concept's potential, recognizing the need for familiarization through major endorsements. The episode concludes with a forward-looking perspective, envisioning an internet where assets and information of varying credibility coexist, accessible through AI-integrated, permission-based personal data stores, revolutionizing interaction and privacy controls.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

when I moved to the UK a number of years ago the one that I've always joked with people like I had a movie where you know it's a big Labowski and the DVD is sitting on my shelf and then the Apple version of it got stuck in Canada effectively like I can't access it from over here and that to me was the beginning of it and so then when I began working in blockchain in the UK that was the thing that resonated once I understood this idea of control and that it gives us a way of controlling data in a peer-to-peer welcome to another episode of the untangling web3 podcast today we're delighted to be joined by Sean Griffin co-founder of object lirer a company revolutionizing data ownership and secure sharing across the internet with a rich background from policy advising with top secret clearance for the Canadian government to Leading comms for blockchain R&D Giants sha brings a wealth of experience in guaranteeing secure and accessible data management in the digital realm welcome to

the show Sean hey Alec and Jack nice to be here hey Sean yeah we're really happy to have you here how are you doing today I'm good I've been excited to talk to you guys all day actually looking forward to this oh that's lovely we've been excited to have you on for a long time so I'm sure this will be a a great conversation so um Sean I know I know we have known each other for a little while actually uh in the space but can you just give us a very quick intro summary to your background professionally your early career because I think there's as Alec alluded to there's some interesting things in there that we'd like to hear about yeah so I mean I was fortunate I began my career with the government of Canada in a bit of an advisory role so always working in head of agency so in the UK the equivalent would be the uh permanent secretary's office so in that way you really become about moving information around

so you're really an advisor to a very senior person and helping data move around effec l in a very manual way or an analog way and one of my jobs involved the International Development agency where I was really the conduit for every memo around Project funding anything over about 100K on a total portfolio of about $2 and a half billion dollars a year that was deployed all of those memos came through me as that included you know full things that were going to Cabinet versus things that were just SM requiring a little bit of authority and all of that went through me and so it really ingrained this concept of okay managing access to this information is important and in that analog world we'd even have you know faes come from Afghanistan where you'd have to sign out like I got to see this for this amount of time and so all of these things that now I see happening in the digital world I'm like wow that's a way back to right when I

started when we would were actually you know with file folders and papers and stuff where people would come to your office and be like Sean could you sign out this fact well what do we call that in the space don't we call that single point of failure you were the original single point of failure for the canadi government basically yeah I mean again it was all coming through my office and and I was there to help the the deputy Minister basically triage all of this to help them say hey these meet all of the things that you've asked me to review is I think it's a pretty simple file for you to look at versus hey there's a more complex thing before it goes to the minister and so you are right like a very single point failure but it also gave me a tremendous view of what it meant almost like an air traffic controller what do what's required for a system to make sure the right people have signed off that the right

documentation is there uh you know there was one example where after I left a file that sat on my desk for a while became news in Canada and various people were hauled in front of parliament to explain like what had happened with this file and why certain decisions were made and I can remember like what was documented where because it was really you know it was potenti at the time let alone when it made it you know years later out out into public and you could see very clearly and so when I came eventually into working in blockchain I was already aware of things like what are timestamping and why did it matter but more from an analog world not from the idea of like hey let's automate some of it got you so that that you you kind of alluded to it there what led you from this single point of failure in the Canadian government to the world of web 3 and blockchain you know to be honest I come at it as

a fan so maybe different than other people who came at it from looking at the technology and wanting to solve problems in terms of building a business I actually came at it as a fan so the thing that irritated me with not owning my digital file the way I physical files um I've talked to lots of people at this I have a large media collection whether it's DVDs CDs vinyl records I like collecting that stuff I I enjoy having it I enjoy having access to it and it really irritates me that I don't digitally have that same ability I'm always tied to a platform there's always an intermediary that determines my access or can revoke that even though it cost me the same and when I moved to the UK a number of years ago the one that I've always joked with people like I had a movie where you know it's a big Labowski and the DVD is sitting sitting on my shelf and then the Apple version of it got stuck in Canada

effectively like I can't access it from over here and that to me was the beginning of it and so then when I began working in blockchain in the UK that was the thing that resonated once I understood this idea of control and that it gives us a way of controlling data in a peer-to-peer way where we all think peer-to-peer is the enemy that's where we fall down that's where naps are happen but actually being like wait a second if we structure it properly and the architecture is good period fear could give us individual control and that to me is what got me really excited and to be honest that idea hit me probably firmly um another guy that both of us know Andy me and I had a conversation and that's where it really came from for me and that led me down a whole rabbit hole that a couple years in the making right now of me really being like that's very cool as a fan I could have the thing that I want

and in a way that's really been a bit of you know that you say what brought me into it was the idea that nobody talks about the fan in a way they talk about the distributor they talk about the content creator but the fan actually plays an important role in all this that's just like your opinion man sorry I had to you m I had I had to get that in there um no that's really interesting and I think from a lot of people we talked to actually when you expect people maybe have just got a professional background in blockchain and web 3 actually there's always a personal story behind it and and people discovering on their own what the real problems are that that this is solving and I think yeah the data only ship aspect is something we've talked a lot about in other episodes and I think it's so interesting and I know that you're tackling this with with your company object layer in in a slightly different way but I want

to first get your take on the concept of nfts and tokenization right because I think this will feed into how we talk about object layer but you know what I know you have a a slightly different take to the mainstream one it let's say so what is that yeah so again I think tokens are it's easy tokens are just a digital representation of something and it tends to tie to to a database somewhere and that can be privately so I I think one of the things when we talk about nft is people act as if it's a totally new thing the element of it that is new is that it's a public database that you're drawing from but tokens exist in all modern software right like that's how you get access to and from Services Apple has their own versions it's just in a closed system and so I think for me at least the understanding that tokens are not new that inter interoperable tokens and moving them around is not knew that we know

this but what is happening with NFP is is now we're actually saying hey wait a second if we use public ledgers public databases we can interact directly with more confidence and in a way what it gives us is the security that Apple can exert over the entire Apple ecosystem which is actually stunning when you think about the security that they deploy to say that movie can only be accessed by these accounts like it it Rock Solid it's really good and they often use similar type of Technologies and so for me the nft really being that but now brought to a public place where all of a sudden all of us can rely on it it begins to take actually that security that exists elsewhere and I really think of it as a security protocol it brings it to all of us so instead of us having to be apple to have this we can each have it for whatever we want to own or whatever we want to control that yeah I like that I

mean that that's incredible I think it's I am a big fan like I understand the Collectibles I'm a gamer so I've always understood understood nfts I think the of nfts were collectors right collections kind of it seems like an innate human quality we love collecting and that we have these collections but it seems like at asset layer you're sorry object lay you're doing one more you are moving further and not just having an nft as a representation of ownership it actually gives you utility which me and Jack are a big proponent of and we'd like to talk a bit more about what how can nfts provide utility so I think that that's you they always have utility it's just how thoughtful are people in delivering what that is so even if we take for Apes which lots of people will mign if it's it's a JPEG out in the cloud we can all have a copy of it like who cares but you could layer utility after the fact and you could say hey anybody

that owns Five for Apes is allowed into this party and you you've already deployed utility on top of something so really what it is is what do these tie to and I always think of in the real world what do they tie to maybe it's a digital good but if we if we start thinking about the utility is why do I care about this the token is a technology that gives me certain attributes and as I said I think that attribute is the moving ownership around and being able to validate who has that and then the utility is for people like me and other businesses to say hey how can I give somebody unique utility how can I give them what they actually want and you know we started this with me being excited around media so that's what I want to help people with is say hey actually the utility for me is owning your data and data is always in a form of some type of content or media and so Let's help

you own that so that you can move it and that's the utility you want other people look at things and I think Alec you're right that gaming and collectibles is an easy one because it quickly moves you into a space with people that were used to collecting things in games they were used to you know you get the award you get all of this you get your XP and that moves with you so it made sense that that's where it started and and you know you had asked before the the show about utility nfts and what I think is interesting there is it's really just showing that the Market's maturing in a way so I don't want to malign anyone I actually think it's a natural thing is you prove can we do the bait you know like Network tokens so whether it's ethereum or BTC that's proving that tokens can move around and can secure the network and then it's a provisioning system and now people are beginning to say wait a second maybe

we could do more interesting things with that so I don't want to suggest that it's nonsense but in a way it's a marketing term that created say hey these are utility nfts but there's always a utility to them that layered or after I think the better you articulate what that frontend utility is the better the adoption will be so if I say hey buy this in one day it might be worth something unlikely anyone cares about that right but if I say hey today this ties to the following concrete deliverable and service for you people like oh that has utility or it doesn't and I can and I can actually then it becomes a market people just priced it accordingly yeah I I and I think we may be guilty of this right because sometimes we I I definitely tend to talk about utility nfts it's basically nft that is doing something more than just a JPEG ownership but even those do as you say they they can confer some utility because they allow you

to make a claim right that I bought this directly from the the original artist like the guy who bought Jack dorsey's first tweet on Twitter okay it's it's lost 99% of his value but he can still make the claim that he legitimately bought that from the originator right yeah and I think maybe if we even on the collectible level we think you lots of Collectibles decrease in value like if we think of hockey cards you know I'm Canadian so I'll talk about hockey cards most of them decrease to zero and they're they're just garbage cardboard but every now and then one of them has Extra Value because it actually was given value by something that happened subsequently right so oh that player became famous or whatever and I think if we think of tokens in the same way that many of them will be discardable and you would burn them and there there's nothing there and some of them will have residual things because people will collect them so if we of the like you

know Nike put out those $50 shoes right like the JP shoes or whatever they're probably not worth anything anytime soon but my guess is at some point in the distant future if somebody owns the entire Nike shoe collection people might find that interesting right again because it could be that Nike might say if you're the guy who owns all of this we give you a free pair of shoes every like whatever it isik could make that decision after the fact and that's also novel too right I think that that's a bit where maybe when looking at them and saying hey it doesn't have value we're missing that there's actually future things that people could do with them because what you're saying is you're registering ownership of effectively an entry on the blockchain right you're like you're saying hey this is a a representation of this transaction or whatever this cell in gives you access to that's pretty powerful too and I and I think again the utility nft is one way of people beginning to

explore what could it possibly be that we're getting access to yeah you're completely right I feel a bit guilty now for coming after these people that are just doing nfts of board Apes I think it's like me and Jack come at it from the technology standpoint right and it's like it's kind of difficult it aligns with the whole crypto debate and what is crypto and crypto Bros all this stuff it's like the metrics for success for crypto and nfts are quite related it's all about speculation it's all about what's the value does the number go up does the number go down and I've always I've always thought of cryptocurrencies blockchain nfts as like piping and trying to really really provide utility and benefits for application all the people on top it's always been for me the problem is the metrics that define success right now aren't right and you are completely right like ownership is utility and I think it's not a binary definition of nfts versus utility nfts it's just how much utility do

you get from this nft that's the question we should be asking yeah and I think you you kind of alluded to a couple interesting things there but again it is a process of people getting to understand like you know it took me a lot a long time and a lot of thought and a lot of research to understand why is it so powerful that I could own a discret entry in a public Ledger and that's I think what the space is realizing is people are beginning to move through that concept of originally it was hey it's just speculative value and now people are really think wait a second I could use these to transact a whole number of things and then we get into a thing that you know we talked about in sort of the Preamble around you know different chains offer different attributes and you might decide that one is better than the other and I know certain people think hey it's it's going to come down to one or two main chains

but there's no reason we couldn't have a plethora of them and then it becomes the bridging technology to move your record from one chain to another and that's really from one database to another and when we think of that I actually think it starts to look to help people that aren't experienced understand it that starts to maybe look like single signon like if all of a sudden my record can move from Apple to Google to this that's a single sign on type feature and I don't know that people talk about it that way but that to me is when we start thinking of these databases working together what we're talking about is true control I can control my data and move it the way that I could move again uh a vinyl record from Canada to the UK and I can move it to Japan I can move and I can always play it that's what we're also really talking about with control and I think sometimes that's been missed in the discussion that a

lot of this is working through how those mechanisms control will work and you're not going to start that with you know the greatest thing ever you're going to start it with a really modest proof of concept like can these things move around and can we actually secure a network and I when I think of Bitcoin or ethereum you know the last decade has really been about proving that you could secure these things and it can work right and now we're getting into interesting things and many of the CTO I've talked to they get it they're in Enterprise or they're removed from the but they get it they understand those attributes they're just waiting for it to be mature enough to work and I think that's another bit you know it's just that we should be honest with it's a totally novel way of doing stuff and the internet developed without that and not to do that and now some people are coming along being like hey wait a second we almost have a whole new

way of doing this it's going to take a lot of time because people are going to expect to see a mature piece of software something that delivers everything and it's just not there yet because it's being built exactly I think that's really interesting right because at the start you were talking about you know okay we've always had token and tokenization and now we're just doing it in a slightly more efficient manner where you get different properties and and attributes and even applied to your your kind of basic jpeg type nfts the the fact that they are on a public blockchain of some kind and you get the long-term record of ownership not just you know while you're while you might own it but you might want to prove you owned it well after you well after you've sold it on in the future right there's so many use cases for that um one thing I wanted to touch on while we while we're kind of in the Quagmire of uh of terminology so I know

you kind of prefer the term object in general and and can you talk a little bit around that and why why that's your phrase of choice I mean it specifically has to do with the way that we've looked at building the software but to me it was this idea of the first time I understood it I was trying to work through what is a key and what does it give you and I kept getting lost in the different formats of data and and the different ways people would talk about it and all of a sudden we're like hey ID is different than media which is different this an object allows me to remove that complexity it it allows you to to basically Elevate to a very simple level which is in the physical world if I talk to you about objects you're not confused at all you might be like what object are you meaning and then we could talk about an a point at it and so for me talking about objects removes the

complexity of tokens and we start talking up again to ask get right into utility and if we're talking about objects then I'm talking to you about what's the object you care about what's the thing that you care about and let's define it and secure it with this technology so that we can move access around so object is in one way is for me to basically remove out the complexity of all of the formats and I think that to me is also part when we look at what this solves is so many solutions and networks appc applications they're built to run on their own and so they don't work because someone's built a thing to be like hey this is a really secure way to do chat so here's a secure chat and then somebody over here is like hey I found a really secure way to do DRM on movies right so then the rights are managed on the and you're like but wait a second what if we just realize that all data is

is at its source a binary object and then build from there and that's it's almost completely inverting where you're looking from um and that's where I you know sometimes struggled explaining to people because really technical people will be like that's not true and I I understand them but I also don't agree with them because I was like right if you get lost in the engineering complexity it's easy to to really pay attention to these but if you begin looking at it from what's it giving me object to me helps that it makes it easier to talk to people about it so they're not thinking about a token they're thinking about what is it that I'm trying to control what is the thing that I care about and what do I want to move so um with that we kind of talked a little bit about your record collection that was a good example of like how an nft could work are there other real tangible and this podcast is all about tangible examples right I

always thought you were there very good at giving everyday Layman tangible examples of things no pressure but other like use cases you can think of for nfts that people you know in their everyday lives will understand that really solve real world problems yeah let me I'll give you one that we're working with um somebody right now on so that it's an Enterprise they help run capital projects so building large kind of real world venues you know and and here you have groups investing hundreds of millions of dollars into something and they're thinking I want to share this information between organizations so again let's just take a very simple one a PDF I want to share this PDF of this kind of commercially sensitive information with four people and we're all in different organization that immediately poses the problem because if I email it I have no record as soon as I've emailed it it blasts every everywhere right if I give you access to my G drive I have some controls but again if you

remove it from G drive one way or the other I have none what tokens and nfps allow is allows me to say hey I'm gonna create four access credentials to that PDF now we're not worried about the file being replicated because the access points can't be replicated so all of a sudden in a way you create back to the very beginning of where I started my career like you create the thing that moves around like somebody signing it and it's moving around the office so in a way what you're actually creating is with documents you're saying actually do I want to restrict the number of these that exist and there's lots of I think economic and philosophical like rabbit hole you can run into that because it's a fascinating thought but the core I think that's a great one in Enterprise data you start to say hey we want to share stuff but it's confidential and if we move physical paper around we have confidence that people won't be copying it or we know what's

happened to it we should be able to apply that to data and I think that to me is a really tangible one where with that group they don't care about nfts and in fact actually when they find it's nft they're almost off-put by it but the concept of of what it's helping them with is what they're interested in right because once you say hey this is an NFP they're like what the I don't I don't I don't want to be a part of that but when you say this is a way for you to have security over your data and you control it you decide who sees it how they see it and under what independent of a platform and I think that's the the other bit with tokens that really that independence from a platform often people talk about decentralization and lots of really great terms but what it really just means is I can move it directly between people and that's that's really fascinating because again another real world example chats or video

chats like we're streaming on this and we have to be on the same platform but actually my phone can phone a rotary phone the same way it can phone the latest iPhone the way it can phone you know an old satellite phone of some kind right and so if we begin thinking about connecting that way so you remove some of the security concerns it actually results in I think more efficient software because the software is really just trying to handle specific forms of data so when I said object allows me to think in a certain way about it but then it allows developers and programmers to build data handlers for specific types of objects right but you're not having to embed security and you're not in people into specific software or specific ways of looking at stuff yeah that's I really like the document one I mean one you from Full Circle you solved the problems you have seven years ago which I like but also like it's so tangible I get it and even

I imagine like the idea of four separate parties all accessing this single document using like blockchain technology you obviously have a degree I can measure the consistency of the terms within that say document between all four parties which must be very important in a lot of ways yeah and and so one and natural expansion of that is you know I know actually Jack I saw your uh a ton of patents in the last few years I saw you recently on Twitter somebody claiming they sh but patents is a great example right on top of patenting ideas we also have Trade Secrets where we don't want anyone to know that where it's a patent you're making a public claim but Trade Secrets come with requirements around do you gate access how many people have access are you able to prove that you didn't do this and that's a great example of a PDF or a document where we' say hey this is a trade secret this is the key to X algorithm that drives our business

and only three people are supposed to have access to it and we need to track it we need to know that you can get really complicated and we can nerd out deep on how you could daisy chain a whole bunch of credentials to be like I need to be on this type of device from this IP address with this credential for before I could open it but just at a basic level I think we could all understand that would be really powerful if we could say actually I definitively know that only three people have ever accessed this they're tied to these accounts and we were able to secure those accounts with the same thing it gives you a really a really good way of being able to I want to enforce that that was a trade secret and somebody breached it I can prove I did my due diligence I did what I was supposed to do to protect my my information and my confidential information I think that's the other bit is the audit

record becomes instantaneous and really interesting from an element of we can just quickly check that yeah there's a there's so many things there to dig into right I think I completely agree with you when you're talking about things like Trade Secrets and audit they're things where you want to make reliable robust attestation that you can prove down the line you don't want to prove it at the minute you might be in 10 years you reveal what happened but it's going to be something that you still need the infrastructure to attest to that that fact um I'm really interested so I think we've heard some of the components of how I think object layer works here can you describe a little bit more like in Practical terms how how does how does it work and what are you actually building because when when people you know talk about web 3 products they sometimes go oh are you just going to be a man of the middle again or are you doing things in a kind of

web three way so the way yeah what we've done is basically built at a very simple level for people to understand safety deposit boxes for data so if you think of if I go to a bank and I have a safety deposit box I can put any object in there and it doesn't matter but there's two keys on a safety deposit box there's the one that you hold and there's the one that the bank holds and to get into your safety deposit box both of those have to go so the way that we built the solution is to say hey we should have the same type of containers for data no limits on size no limits on what can be held in that again an object so then we get very literal in terms of in programming you can Define objects but then let's put basically two Factor authentication at that level you need a token an nft which says I'm a registered owner or this account or this wallet address is a registered owner

and then associated with that is an encryption key and that encryption key gets you into the Container so you need both of them so again if I hack in and I get just the encryption key somehow it doesn't let me in because I need the record and the record is the hard thing because it's secured by this public network that would take Mass amounts of money you know to compromise and it would be very public that it was happening so at the core that's what we've built I think is to think of safety deposit boxes I love think about it yeah yeah and then with it with it with a pretty simple decryption viewer you can just integrate it into anything and I think one of the the bit you know I've been working on this um at business for for a year and really it's helping people understand that blockchain addresses and and connecting with blockchain is not terribly difficult it sounds daunting but actually you can integrate wallets and all of this into

any web browser they could be plugins or they could be Standalone apps and so the the limitations there not much basically anything that can have a web browser can connect to the blockchain and be able to validate records and then be able to decrypt them and so when you ask you know are we just trying to be another man in the middle no what we're hoping to do is be equivalent of your locksmith being like hey I'll let you put a lock on whatever you think is important and we'll give you a bunch of templates and a bunch of ways to do that it's infinitely customizable but at the core let's give you some templates so that could be messaging it could be publishing media it could be storage like a storage Vault would be a more advanced way of really looking at how do we do that and that's that's what we could maybe dig into but giving people that and then saying to them once you have that you know I think where

we'd love to go is have the point of the decryption View viewer be an open-source tool and say to everybody hey once it's been created with this mechanism you'll always be able to open it kind of like the PDF you're always going to be able to view a PDF at no point a PDF viewer is going to disappear because it's out there for everyone to build and in the early years you needed you know a license or some type of software that let you create them or edit them now it's a bit more open and I think that would be similar to what we're trying to build with object ler say hey we built a really clever way it's not quite a file format it's not I'm not sure how to talk about it the protocol is not but basically it's a way for you to secure stuff move it around confidently and then always be able to open it so I don't necessarily like the idea of always you know lots of people like

taking a cut on all future royalties trying to do this I actually think for our business we should go to people in a very oldfashioned way of like hey you need to put a lock on something here's your lock now you want to pay you know do you want to do you want the software on a white label basis so that you can run your entire thing on it you want some apis but at the core let us help you lock down your stuff and then you do whatever you want you also Define who has access how they have access that's totally up to you I don't want anything to do with that I just want to help you lock it down so that you can then exert some level of control I understand that was going to be my question so in this like lockbox analogy can Enterprises have their lock boox wherever they want they can store it you know on Prem in the cloud wherever they want and you just provide the

locking software effectively that just sits on top it can either be run by them it can be run by you as a service is that completely configurable yeah I think you you've got it right it just sort of sits there if you think there's the data layer and then there's applications and there's a user on top we're just sitting between the data and the application and we're saying okay let's enforce some rights on what the application can do and by extension what the user can access and see and do and we sit there we've built a reference implementation to be honest because when I started this I was like this is amazing we just need to do this and we'll be off to the racist and everyone will think we're Geniuses and like no more work done but not true because again back to that bit about the networks and some stuff being immature we weren't able to get it working properly so we built the reference implementation with a multi-chain wallet with credentialing with

publishing messaging and we're sort of going through the beta testing process there to say to people here's a reference it's a reference implementation if you want to do your own thing we can find a way to support you but at the core what we're helping you is really exert that control and then you do whatever you want with it and I think Enterprises they could look at it and say we want to gate everything this way I think when we really get into what storage can look like for this it becomes fascinating to me because there's two main attributes that might not be obvious everyone one is this completely inverts a bunch of things I no longer care about transmission of my file my file is an encrypted container I don't care actually from an availability standpoint it's like back again you guys are a bit younger but back to Napster I want it Seated on every node every computer everything everywhere because then my availability is perfect I can always access it at lightning

speed but the the access point is discreet that's the thing I care about and that's the thing that's secure and so in in a way in vers everyone's worried about like I don't like my files moving around so then when we look at Enterprise storage people could say actually I'm going to build a really nice Vault that has this two Factor authentication for every version of a file and let the wallet and the credentialing system deal with the complexity of that but I as a user I now have a vault that only has a single way in if you come in from a from just loog you know hacking into the the the store or whatever every one of these is double encrypted and therefore man if you don't have any identifiers on it I might you the joke I was make is I might spend a whole bunch of money and it's like Jack's birthday card that I cped it's not commercially confidential and I'm like man that was a waste of millions of

dollars and so in that way actually we start to deal with ransomware and and this is a bit that I I've begun talking to people about and it's I I got to work through it a little bit but what if you were ransomware in perw because you no longer care about people accessing your store and taking stuff from you you're like it exists everywhere I it's on every Network everywhere it can be file exist because I have confidence that the access point is discreet and that you can't break in that makes a whole bunch of programming and network decisions a lot easier for people right because they don't have to be so worried about every one of us having our own security protocol and mechanisms and and you know mass number of people trying to protect your data we're like actually we're letting the public network do that which is a is a different difficult thing I think for people to wrap their head around that the public networ is going to secure my individual

rights yeah I don't know that many people get to that conclusion easily this aligns with so much of what we've been talking about I mean you imagine if me gdpr is the current buzzword right like company shouldn't be owning user data all this kind of stuff so there's been huge amounts of push from you know web 3 companies to push it to self- soving models where I own my data on my device so there's no issues with gdpr and this kind of setup makes so much sense I don't want this data moving around from point A to point B I want to keep it here and just manage access to that data on my terms which is it's very sexy web three cell right like the perfect example of how this would be used is health records I've got my health records on my mobile device I want my doctor to check it at that moment to say you do you have this disease or do you not have this disease I don't want that

doctor having it 10 years down the line I want them to have a single instance of that data when I give access to it yeah so I think also the other bit is you watch of times when we talk about it it's like that it's like I don't want that person to have access past you know what what I think they should but there's another more Insidious one which is I personally want access to those records I moved here from Canada and I still don't have my dental record the guys in Canada are like no we're not going to send them we need a whole bunch of paperwork and I'm like but wait a second I'm never returning to you there's zero chance ever in my life that you are cleaning my teeth ever again so like it's not a competitive thing it's not like I'm I live down the street and I've gone to your like competitor it's like I live across the planet I'm I'm never getting my my my teeth cleaned with

you again can you just give me my records like there's you have no value in having the x-rays of my teeth from 10 years ago like like what are you doing with that you're just wasting storage space But even that I can't get that from them so I think it's actually when people realize it's both ends it's the backend security but it's also the frontend accessibility for users and that's when I I'm really talking about this as a fan I think also that is just the user like I'm not like you guys you know technically aware of everything that's going on I can't do a bunch of that that's not where I came from from I came from I would just like to have my records have confidence that they're my records and be able to move them that would be fascinating to me yeah and and again the health records is such an easy one because it touches everybody right people are like wouldn't it be great if I could have that or I

have a paranoia that somebody's consuming that and doing stuff which you know I think that also you know we'll talk about it it feeds through a little of the web 3 there is this speling almost like there's a paranoia like who's who's got your record like who's doing this but it's big and there was this story I don't know if you guys saw um recently wired put out something around that Google was behind the scen like you would type in whatever and they would actually swap that into basically a term that would search for an Advertiser like they were kind of doing a they were they were editing the query behind that was the story wired puts it out there you read the headline I read the story and then like four days later wired it's like oh we don't know that b met our editorial standard like we we're taking this story down but for me the damage is already happened I'm always like Google's already screwing with my records yeah and so actually

in a way I think what would be good for everyone in web 3 is to talk about it's not necessarily this paranoia but actually there is a reason why we have miscommunication because these things exist they happen and there's no record so now wir has taken down the story it doesn't actually it just tells you like we made an error but so nobody can conf IR what the error actually was down the line and there's no responsibility that editors and a journalists put out stuff that may or may not be true and when I think of me as a reader I only came at it because I was looking back I like wanted to look into something I read in the article and I they've taking it down oh yeah but but you know what otherwise I would be walking around telling everybody about did you know that Google's doing following to you I where did you read that I be wired and like well that's a credible Source like Sean's a well read guy

like you rather wired and then actually we'd go and we'd make there's no record of that Sean where did you create that and then I'm the source and so I also thing when we have the web 3 discussion around that and and the recordkeeping it is the can I let somebody see something but then if I made something and let people see it is there a record that I did that exactly yeah it kind of creates a chill I think is the word is the worry that some have it will create a chill for how online um interactions happen I think that's just people who don't understand HD wallets to be honest MH you can easily firewall your identity uh and you can easily hide behind stuff but there will be a record and you know when we talk about object cayer one of the things we have to be careful with is while I just want to give you the ability to lock stuff I have to be careful who we give that to

If we're honest because a lot of the web three stuff and and I think we've seen it with the way the crypto space developed it's actually great for people who are doing things outside the law right like you know one of the best one of the best crypto backed uh websites is a drug dealer like I've seen it in the UK and it's truly amazing the way they take in what what you and I would be like wow that's the greatest like web free store I've ever seen and to sell drugs you're like like wow they they like did they work with me really understand what they're doing but again I think that's one thing we have to be careful with is figuring out who has access to these tools and how they do it because it's giving a power that hasn't currently existed right that idea of being secure direct peer-to-peer but then also free from anybody knowing what you're doing exactly it it creates a you know just a balancing act that I

think do have definitely so we we'll edit that bit out Sean just so no one thinks that you are actually backing organized crime with what you're doing um yeah there's a couple of things that I picked up on right because again loads of that is resonating with what what we think about web 3 as well I think what's so powerful only just kind of clicked in my head about what you're doing you said you're inverting the model right so you're not having to share data every time it resides in one place but you you're also articulating it's residing in the right place it's it's residing with the actual owner and that applies to the healthcare data CA Healthcare data use case to corporate data it shouldn't be leaving premises where owned by that owner and you should just be provisioning access say it makes perfect sense my question is because when I put my tech brain on I then start thinking oh cryptography Keys all this stuff and I start thinking of all the ways

this could go wrong right so I'm wondering for object layer is the kind of USP this whole paradigm shift because I think it's it's something quite new I don't see many people doing that or is it kind of in the way you're implementing it to safeguard against some of those kind of potential I to be honest I think it is the the concept RIT large is is the novel unique thing the fact that we're looking at completely inverting stuff to be what does it mean to be in control so I can give you a couple examples we talk about that I think uh cookies is a great example I go to a website and somebody drops something on me and it follows me around now let's think about that in the real world if you went into a store and they dropped a bug on you that would be like catastrophic that they would go out of business because you'd be like they're foll me around the planet this is crazy and you would sue

them for a bunch of stuff but digitally it's okay and so one thing that we've thought about is well with these you could begin those cookies could be again have utilities so let's say I'm a fashion brand I could say hey guys here I'm giving it to you for free here is this the the fall winter um runway show here's the video you can see it but now I know that you like it I can communicate with you and so now again there's an interesting way that you've been verdict you've been forced to compete for their attention but now you have a direct way and as a user I could just no longer connect to that address and you can't bother me or I could burn the token and I would not be on your distribution list anymore there's a number of ways to deal with it so I think what we're really saying is the unique bit is if you can guard at an object level and again I'm not a security expert that's

not where I came into this but I've done a lot of research on that now and the concept of object-based access controls is pretty novel in terms of people have talked about it they've said it would be great but there isn't an implementation where people have used it writ large across everything and with object layer we're being like actually with a clever design we might be able to do this on the internet level where the internet is based on objects which it is by the way that browsers render things and all of this wouldn't that be fascinating if every one of those objects that we care about we're not going to care about everything and I think that's the other thing that gets lost in the in the talk about tokenization of everything is not everything will have value right like my logo doesn't have value I don't need to tokenize the logo I actually want it ripping around and everyone touching in it and all of this my white paper maybe I do want

that because I want to know who's consumed it and the other bit when we talk about this is that on that control level and when we're thinking about how this could work imagine if now I get Jack to your point of permissioning I'm the artist I'm the musician and I permission my Master Copy to Spotify I now will pull I'll know all of the calls I'll know how often it was called I'll know all of this and then it's the discussion between the artist and Spotify like does Spotify obscure their entire membership and they don't give you any audience details and Spotify uses that in ter that their unique position that they're helping people in whatever way or maybe they say hey actually Taylor Swift you know you do a whole bunch we we'd love to sell you data on all of your uh listeners on our platform so in that way I'm not a web three type who thinks that the existing platforms die I actually think they just have to compete differently they

have to compete for what they actually offer not for just a broad Network effect so you mentioned that right now you're at at the beta you're talking to Enterprises um and the conversations you have sound interestes in you said you mentioned that the they're waiting for maturity in the space you mentioned there's a bit of a resistance to the term which I completely get what do you think it's going to take to get Global adoption of objects you know it's tough so I I came into this believing and I still do that media is the first thing to fall because it's easier I think that when I look at it I I it sort of bifurcates into Enterprise use cases where it's really about data security and trying to stop rent somewhere and you know unauthorized access there I would say if we were to look at the the two markets that were media the enter Enterprises are the ones who are most immediately interested but then they have all the inertia and all of

the needs that require it to be more advanced and so there you're like ah they have the most acute Demand right now but they also have the highest you know kind of barriers to entry whereas on media um I was in LA a while ago when we were talking to some really senior Executives in in media entertainment and they it was amazing we kind of stopped them in their tracks when we talked about you know object Protections in way of doing and they were like wait a second we have to really think about that and then there was like the metaverse and web 3 team in the room and they were like you're going to need someone big to do this they're like some the F they're like it will kind of languish they're like but if you can convince a big name to do this then all of the sudden people will quickly see it's not so foreign to them right like it feels foreign when I talk to you it feels foreign but

what if we weren't hard with nftp we like that's just an album you just opened your album and then in the background you understand that you could move it from any platform you want and you can move it wherever you want and so in a way it's like I think people need a big shiny well-polished example of how it could work and then they'll say like oh it's not scary it's not new actually it will it will look like an album on Spotify it will just have different attributes underlying it and I said I still think many people will interact with it on a level of going to Spotify or a platform like that but we'll be happy to the back end is artists won't need to audit their streams they won't need to audit their royalties they'll know they'll have confidence so I think that it would be interesting because the people who stand to benefit are kind of everybody in their own way but it might not be revolutionary at any one moment

for an individual so I do when we talk about adoption I really think it needs to be what's that use case where somebody just feels excited about it and then it happens in a polished enough way and that's one thing that the network struggle with like we've looked at a number of different blockchains and you know we're we a multi-chain operator we support multiple ones and all of them offer different attributes and so at any point you're like oh this is really good for media distribution this is terrible for storage Vault man okay this one's really good for storage Vault I don't think it's very good for media distribution so that's where I think it's also everybody you know back to the the conversation about utility uh tokens like as people understand what you could possibly do with these things the investment makes sense I think what we've seen is a lot of investment geared toward jpegs and network tokens like I still even when you hear me talk about object controls like we've talked

to some possible investors and they'll be well when are you going to launch your token uh I guess I guess I guess you missed the last 45 minutes of what we were talking about probably never with us right and but again the way people have made money is this and so what it will take is also those people realizing like wait a second someone doing something more interesting there there's another application here and and then we'll get kind of like I said I think there'll be another Rush people looking at wow this is really interesting from what can I do with these attributes now that the networks work yeah you never get those people who are looking to invest you never get them asking when you're launching your access token right because I thought that was funny because I that was one I was like well if you mean by a token will we have a shareholder registry where we'll have you know protected information and like a data room that I'll share with you

quarterly results yeah totally we'll have that you'll have that token and that will be part of being sh exactly oh you meant a publicly traded one the price goes up probably not going to happen you you meant a mem coin you meant a meme yeah Sean listen I I think you probably have I'm gonna go out a limb but I think you probably got the most open-minded take on web 3 of any guests we've had so far because you've talked about you know using the blockchain as data storage layer as token layer uh you're talking about multi-chain it seems like you're just completely fully bought into web 3 in a really open way my My worry is that we always think about regulation as well as an afterthought right and I I wonder is there a price that you'll pay and have you how much have you thought about this because you've now got lots of things to consider right the aspects of putting data on chain how you store it securely and then also

any any other legal obligations around tokens and now multi-chain right how how are you thinking about regulation in general I mean I don't think it will be a shock to anyone that i' probably a little different on that I think regulation is is inevitable which I just accepted that it's going to come but also it comes in an amazing way like I did work on a token recovery project and to me it's really fascinating because what if now we blend the best of the physical world of things being discreet but now we also have the computer type layer of where I can actually follow things and we have a great audit Trail wouldn't it be great if my passport goes missing and we can immediately either revoke it and kill it or we can recover it so I think when we look at it there's going to be Tools around like we have it with object layer where you can revoke that connection between the two keys and that effectively kills the ability to open

it so if we were to put a passport in there the government could you know kill kill it revoke that access and all a sudden the thing is is junk nobody can access it or there could be a recovery mechanism those all go to me to be there will be regulation around this there will be like hey what are we going to do because now we have better tools we can track stuff again that's I think kyc becomes kind of important like who is doing what and we don't want to have public identifiers of it but do we want to have somebody sitting behind who can ultimately follow that trail and it would be a forensic Trail I'm not somebody who believes will all be open but the idea that it's going to be a free-for-all and regulation won't apply I think is people who are setting themselves up for a very poor outcome I think it's inevitable it will happen you can't have a perfect timestamp Ledger and assume that Regulators are going to

not eventually kind of get like oh that's really good audit Trail if we apply the right governance and the right sort of things to it we could really benefit from that while people can also maintain their privacy in the right implementation It's the Best of Both Worlds in the wrong implementation it's like the worst of both actually we think a lot it I mean that's a position that me and Jack both share as well you know you always need a trust framework it has to come from somewhere right um I think so throughout this episode you've spoken very tangibly about the benefits of object L made it really practical and understandable for everyday users even people that aren't in the space now I want you to flip that I don't want you to think about Utopia in the future like go far off as wild as you want what do you imagine like are some of the the crazy future use cases you could see with object layer or more more generally for tokenized assets

that are just so far removed right now so the one that I think is amazing is AI and and again I'll take a bit of it I'll take I'll make a market in AI differently than everyone else imagine now we go back to the creators now I can permission my data into that model and we'll know are you pulling my data is that sampling so if we think of music again right like the ability to sus out have you sampled my music in that track is amazing like people are write down to like a couple chords to be like that was from this song like you own royalty well now what We Begin permissioning that so Bots can interact over permission data and when I think of that that opens up a bunch of fun things like right now I have to bother you like hey Jack and I like do you guys know anybody who's doing the following but what if we all have Bots and like you've a you've agreed that certain parts

of your personal data store and database can be shared with me I can just ping out to people who shared that with me so I think what begins happening is you get automated Behavior around around really complicated things and it becomes very simple as a user like chat GTV is proving it I just type in a thing and it starts having a conversation with me but what if we could all control our contributions and maybe I'm somebody who is really successful or I just don't like contributing generally and I I hoard it all and I'm willing to pay all of the fees to access all the subscriptions and do everything and I'm just a ghost nobody knows I exist I never leave a data trail anywhere it costs me a fortune to to consume anything or there would be people who are like I give away all my data all the time and it cost me nothing I roam around freely that will look an awful lot like today right like today you can generally

have all these free services and what it means is that other people track you and get to do stuff with your data and so when I think of that far out all of a sudden you're GNA have that whole Spectrum run by the same system and so when I think about it for me it's the concept of the internet becoming an actual Library the internet is the actual Library you go to to check out a book and when I create it for my own part I might release one copy of that book like you know you have the Once Upon a Time it shall end like the only version of that wuang album exists it's one it's in a box I think it's interesting that the last time it was sold they created an NFP to track the ownership record so again people are starting to understand like what the power of recordkeeping is but that to me if I think really far out wouldn't it be amazing if the internet turned into the actual

media library and there's going to be beside it the thing powered by Ai and junk and you could find anything and everything there and we'll all just be like that's just create that's the that's like you know I don't know what that is it's just the world subconscious it's everything is available there you want to go see it tra and over here we have stuff that has an an owner that you know is attributed and that we know who it is and we know where it came from that's really powerful because now all a sudden the same system when you talk about really projecting forward the same system is both you used for my own personal exploration in terms of pure fantasy world as well as concrete this is actually what I want to do and that would be really amazing right I can go on I can know immediately is that junk or is it you know does it have Providence and at any moment I might want junk or I might want Providence

but at least I will know so then I can go and have a lot of fun in whatever way I want to have fun yeah I love that way of thinking about it because you again you for me you're rooting it in the fact that all of this is still infrastructure in a sense but it's once that's laid down you can do such crazy far-fetched things with it like you you bringing the AI piece into it I really hadn't thought about in this way but I'm now thinking of like an actor who will you know create um little Snippets of voice recording of certain moods they're in and they'll give some to one director so they can create one kind of character and they'll give some to another director and create a market for there's so many things you could do there um that that just completely new yeah I think that's totally new and a new way of people saying like I I read a funny thing about how um you know Universal Music

is looking to put like James Brown back to work and basically they're like we've got all the James Brown stuff we're GNA feed it into AI programs but also what we're seeing is an interesting one is there's been a bit of a rollover and a softening in the market for music um IP so you've seen actually a whole bunch of the private Equity firms that bought libraries from you know well you know well- selling established artists they're starting to sell those and they're selling them at a discount to where they sold them a couple years ago and I think what that that shows is the market understands without some form of gating data becomes increasingly less valuable like basic there's like almost a decay of value like the moment I put it out there it just starts decaying immediately if I don't put it out it still holds some value but if I throw it out there and then it gets thrown into chat gbt or mid Journey or something everybody's got it there's no

value there I think people are getting on they they see that and that's the worry that the screenwriters and the actors and all these people had they're like you're going to completely devalue everything I do yeah with with one you know one one one program devalued it all well this is a nice segue onto the kind of the closing questions right because maybe you'll bring someone back from the dead for for one of my questions but sure it's been a great episode and I we we always end in the same way we like to ask our guests two specific questions and we want to check compare answers over time and see see the Spectrum out there so the first question is as concisely as possible and in one sentence what is web3 to you web 3 is control it's it's an element of individual control nice perfect I love it um and then onto onto the the Reviving The Dead potentially so if you could choose anyone throughout history or Alive with us today that

you can bring back with AI or just go and meet in a coffee shop to talk about web 3 with who would that be and why so I mean the business part of me is like Taylor Swift because I think she all of the like you know like what I mean like she's said all the things but nobody has shown her how to actually do what she's been talking about for years but realistically I wrote an article recently and there was an artist called Clifford still I find him fascinating so he got really irritated by the Art Market he didn't like the way it worked and so he rained all of his Creations for like I think it was like 60 years or something and then on his death he he said I'll leave these to a city that builds a permanent facility for them and so to see basically I think it's 93 or 94% of his total output over his entire life is now in a museum in in Denver I think talking

to an artist like that about control and about what it meant and why he wanted to exert control in those ways would be a fascinating thing to say like you got irritated by the market you think it's important for people to Value art you think it's important for people to travel to see yard and put effort in to consume it what if you now could leverage Digital World in a different way what would you think about that because I think of him as like almost off on a way way far extreme of I don't share anything it's analog it's discreet it's over here and he cares about control so talking to him with the way I think about this would be a fascinating one for me of like okay so what if you could exert that control but it wouldn't be quite so difficult for everybody what what would you say about I think that's the conversation to me which would be a one to hear that's a great answer I really like that I'm

going to have to check out that museum um yeah thank you for joining us SE this has been a really incredible episode and thank you to listening at home wherever you may be and join us next time as we entangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes