Episode 22
Digital Cash (part 2)
About this episode
In this week's edition of Untangling Web3, hosts Alec Burns and Jack Davies dive into the world of digital cash, breaking down its complexities and history. They explain the difference between cash and money, pointing out key features like privacy and direct transactions. The chat then introduces listeners to different forms of digital money: from electronic cash, which doesn't quite capture the essence of physical cash, to cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, which has its own set of challenges.
The conversation turns to Bitcoin's transaction methods and how security measures vary depending on the size of the transaction. They also touch on why some big companies and governments are hesitant to fully embrace Bitcoin. The discussion then shifts to stablecoins, digital currencies like Tether and Luna that are tied to stable assets, explaining how they work and their potential risks.
The highlight of the episode is the introduction to Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs). They discuss how most countries are considering using these digital forms of their national currencies and the advantages they offer, like helping more people access banking services and easier money management. They also cover ongoing projects in countries like South Korea and the UK.
But it's not all praise for digital cash. Alec and Jack also bring up concerns about digital money systems, such as potential technical issues, government control, and worries about privacy. They mention interesting developments like companies making physical notes linked to CBDCs, emphasizing the significance of the shift from physical to digital money. The episode wraps up by looking at how digital cash could change global money transfers and payments and the benefits CBDCs offer to central banks. The pair stress the importance of explaining complex topics like these clearly and look forward to the next episode.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
I I'm trying to imagine a world in the future in which I whip out my Visa card and I can all of a sudden pay with Bitcoin or whatever the the cryptocurrency is in the future like the it's like not just interoperability between systems it's the idea of interoperability between traditional Finance systems of the web two World um like electronic money as we've defined them and the next generation of cash systems and I F I can't POS like comprehend right now the idea of using a card a Visa card for Bitcoin welcome to this second part of a two-parter on digital cash so last time we discussed a brief history of cash we went through the evolution of commodity based cach uh commodity backed paper cache and then finally the weird and wonderful world that we're in right now which is Fiat cach um we defined the difference between cash and money primarily money is any medium of exchange and cash is a specific subset of that which is physical money and you know there's
a lot of things that assumes like you know full ownership I really hold the cash in my possession which enables me to interact peer-to-peer and that makes it more private and all this kind of stuff and maybe more secure and certain instances um then we went to talk about digital cach and the evolution of cash to digital cach and how this aligns with web 3 and similarly with what I just mentioned about the properties of cash there's lots of things there around privacy ownership peer-to-peer all this kind of stuff and then we ended as we typically do with a nice chat GPT summary which um gave us four example types of digital cash electronic money cryptocurrencies stable coins and then C bdcs which is Central Bank digital currencies is that about summarized the last episode Jack yeah I think so I think it's it's a good kind of place to pick back up as well because obviously we've got these four different types of of digital cach so yeah maybe we can dig into those
uh and start with one which I think is a little bit of a faux par on gpt's part uh calling out electronic money or e- money as a type of digital cach because I think we probably agree this is not actually a great example of digital cash so you know we said last time electronic money e- money is basically all the money we already have and interact with in our day-to-day what we use you know with our bank accounts it's all linked to our credit cards it's all a form of money that's digital but it's not really cash it doesn't have the same properties as of cash the same peer-to-peer private aspects that we we come to expect or we defined for for cash last time right yeah I think when most people think of how they interact digitally in the world or even physically sometimes when I use my credit cards it's all associated with bank accounts or you know maybe debt in my in my bank accounts and that's basically digital money these
numbers that are controlled by banks on on your behalf maybe in a way and that's money rather than cash and I think one of the stats that you pulled out last time which is really interesting is that over 92% of all money right now currently exists in this electronic money form which is this is crazy right and you know all of most of this especially in the UK is run and owned by private Banks and maybe this is like a slight concern especially when we come to like maybe some of the benefits of digital cash and cash generally is that you know these private Banks kind of know about every transaction you're doing know a lot about you and is this too much information like is the convenience worth the amount of information that they are getting right now yeah exactly and the fact that so much of our money is this is this e-money digital money form that we have right now bank account based you know just numbers moving on on spreadsheets that's
actually probably one of the key motivations to develop proper versions of digital cash right so so we can retake this private notion of of cash we can have money that we can spend in a private manner in a peer-to-peer way um in a low cost way so maybe that that kind of moves us on to okay what are what are the real examples of digital cash what are the real types and the the the first one of those that chat gbt calls out is cryptocurrency which is interesting because I think that's the one that encapsulates things like digicash right so we talked about David Cham last time and maybe I'll give a very brief explanation of what that is now given that we're digging into it so digicash is actually a company that that David Chan founded in 1989 and shortly after released something called ecash so that was the kind of product of of digicash um as a company and ecash is this is this new model for digital cash remember we're talking early
90s at this point so this is uh probably one of the early examples of a cryptocurrency in in the terms that we defined in a previous episode so how this works basically is that you have a central issuer in this case digicash was the issuer of these these digital cash notes effectively so you would withdraw these from your your your bank your dig digicash compliant Bank as a user and then when you go to spend it you also then kind of need um these coins to be signed by that Central entity as well or at least checked by the central entity so this was kind of a first pass of doing a digital cache and it used this quite cool cryptography called Blind signatures so that that's one of the things that kind of maintains user privacy the bank signs these transactions not knowing who the participating parties are so your identity isn't actually linked in a similar way to bitcoin but uh actually it doesn't really achieve a lot of what we know about
cryptocurrencies today because it's not exactly peer-to-peer you're still involving this Bank in the process I don't think anyone but you would ever Define cryptography as cool but I what that noted down cool cryptography yeah you're you're right like that mean my when I think of digital cash like it should as closely represent the properties of cash as it can right and maybe then extend and go a bit further and like the the basic properties of cash really come down to ownership the fact that I physically own it in my possession and I'm no one I'm not reliant on anyone to then use it means that I get a complete peer-to-peer interaction there's no unnecessary intermediaries when I go down to the shop and I give them a 20 pound note like the bank of England doesn't know that I've just given that 20 note and obviously there's there's limits to this if I'm buying like a 500,000 you know car or house with that kind of money there's checks and all this kind stuff but
for basic everyday interactions like that it is fully peer-to-peer because I own it and that makes it private and what you're describing there it seems like the digicash project solved the Privacy issue to an extent where they didn't know exactly what the kind of the transaction was but it didn't fully solve the peer-to-peer aspect and they were required you know an intermediary was required for every interaction in the loop is that correct yeah exactly and and it comes back to this we've mentioned a couple of times before but this double spending problem or how do you prevent double spending right because when we talk about physical cash double spending is very easy you have Bank notes they're physical you can you know look at them in under under a UV light or whatever check the serial number for example you know that it's an authentic note that is is going to be accepted as legal tender in the digital world you may well have some some cryptographic information that says this is valid but how
do you know that's not been spent on Amazon and uh you know on Apple at the same time right right for two different transactions so yeah really digicash and and the ecash project itself it solved the double spending problem but only using this kind of non-optimal solution involving a central bank so it didn't solve it in a particularly satisfactory way that leads us on quite nicely to you know what was the first really compelling solution of that problem which was Bitcoin right yeah I think when you were just talking that about checking bank notes as imagine you like 10-year-old Jack at Christmas getting like1 pound checking each of the bank notes under UV light being like you sure this is real yeah yeah every time I get a birthday card I'm like have you actually given me some money here um yeah so that kind of yeah moves us on to bitcoin which I think you can easily describe it as the first really compet sorry you can describe it as the really first compelling
solution to the double spending problem that didn't require a central third party so for every time you're you're you're making a transaction to check if this is double have Bitcoin sold this instead of having a central bank as as the Checker you have this distributed network of nodes who are who are maintaining this distributed shared Ledger right so instead of one party we go to many parties competing to do that and that's I think that is is the describes the modern state of play with digital cash yeah and when we were kind of given the history earlier it was basically from like say the 1940s 1950s onwards like the central banks came completely critical to the infrastructure of of of currency right and I suppose Bitcoin was quite revolutionary in a way where it kind of offset this this idea of one Central agency that controls you know every intermediary or is the intermediary for every kind of online transaction and and remove the need for that in quite a powerful way so yeah Bitcoin
drastically changed this model uh to I guess like in a way maybe a distribute a decentralized ledger for transaction execution and record keeping right and this kind of made the whole money currency cash whatever we call it outside of the control of sovereign monetary authorities which is quite a revolutionary concept exactly and and you know Bitcoin is a lot of things to a lot of people but fundamentally if you look back at the original white paper on what it actually said the title you know called Bitcoin a peer-to-peer electronic cash system so electronic cash digital cash whatever you want to call it the same thing it was really trying to solve that problem of robust electronic cach and you know what we got from that was this much more peer-to-peer model of doing things where where you don't you you can transact privately offline online with other parties and you don't need that third party for for settlement and it has a very uh has a has a similar privacy model to digit cach in
the sense that there's no identity linked to these transactions natively right but um but but it achieved that double spend prevention in a very very different way and I think like you're right on the surface um when we're talking about real ownership real peer-to-peer privacy all this kind of stuff there in the fundamentals of cash Bitcoin does enable that but when we think about like the depth of it like when I give you 20 pound note you know there's instant settlement there like there's no transaction fee you know there's kind of like transaction fees in the background you know we all pay taxes to you know the bank of England to make sure I can actually have cash in my pocket but there's no actual transaction fee in the loop right there and when we think about Bitcoin right now it's that doesn't happen like there's no instant settlement takes a while to go through but the transaction fees associated with it are astronomical and this really go goes against the principles of the white
paper right if it's meant to be this peer-to-peer electronic cash system there shouldn't be these crazy transaction fees that associated with it yeah exactly that and Settlements a really interesting point to mention actually because in our you know in digicash or the the e-money world settlement is being done it's kind of in a binary sense it's either you have this contact with the banks and they say whether this transaction will settle or not and you have you know sometimes you have real time grow settlement they call it so you're settling things in real time and in other cases you defer that and and you clear it later but in Bitcoin if you've ever been on a Bitcoin exchange or crypto exchange you you might have seen this notion of confirmations so it'll say okay well you make a transaction you buy some crypto you swap it you change it whatever and it'll say you know need six confirmations or X confirmations whatever this is kind of applying a notion of of time based settlement to
saying effectively if you say you need six confirmations you need this transaction to appear six blocks deep yeah in the blockchain but actually this is conveying the fact that it's not a binary model anymore there's a complete spectrum of security so in a sense your transaction is never settled on on the blockchain but it's it's all a case of how much risk you're willing to accept it's incredibly likely to have been settled in a sense yeah I was going to say there's an increased likelihood the more blocks and the more confirmations that have happened right and I think that I guess the how that applies is that if you're like trying you know I'm paying for coffee it's one pound worth a Bitcoin or something like that that I might be happy with a small number of confirmations but if I'm say paying 500 Grand on a house then I probably want the security of like you know many confirmations and proper Network propagation before I say okay now I feel comfortable that it's gone
through and I will give you the house that kind of thing right yeah exactly that and there are also lots of different ways you can go about mitigating that risk um you know not to get too technical but in Bitcoin there's this idea of simplified payment verification SPV whereby you're meant to actually once you have a transaction I would I should if I'm paying you Alec for something I would give you the transaction and you'd be responsible for submitting it to the network and you can then apply whatever additional Security checks you need that might be uh I I send it to one node and I'm happy if they say this is valid I'll put this in my block could send it to all of the nodes and ask for them all to talk to you it's up to you to decide your own level of risk and what what what checks you need on that and as you say for a cup of coffee uh you're not going to need too much of that
if you're buying a car you're going to probably take some more severe measures yeah I mean you've grown so much I was so worried then you were going to go off on like a 2hour tangent technicalities of that we will definitely save that for another episode but yeah Jack's 22nd summary on that was perfect right I I've learned I've learned from all the the hate mail I've got over the last the last few episodes about going too deep so we thought about like there's a funny joke in there um we were worried before about like you us both going off attention to the idea of bringing in a buzzer to be like you need to stop there the explanation is not good but rather than going up a tangent back to it um so the idea of like big Bitcoin being this peer-to-peer electronic cash system and we've talked about some of the issues right now around like inst settlements transaction fees all this kind of stuff like the adoption is not there is it
like and there's also issues around stability like people not trusting in it because of the volatility and like a lack of trust and I guess adoption by big corporations by governments especially like when I think of electronic or digital cash systems you need government adoption right that kind of trust really does have to be propagated in a lot of ways from governments even if it's not them not being directly involved but them just saying yeah this is a safe currency for you to use and right that now that is not there exactly and you're almost talking about the properties of money again there right so I think I would say like Bitcoin and blockchain work perfectly well as digital cash right now they have done since you know 2009 more or less but do they work well as digital money right because digital cash should be a subset of money as you said uh and not not so much right because of because of what you say the volatility is meant to be one of
the properties of money was a good unit of account should be a store of value as well so for it to grow from being just purely cash to money that you can use it needs you know institutional adoption it needs to be widely used so that the price will stabilize at some point where you know I I remember an example a number of years ago when I first started um and and and there was there was a brewery that was accepting Bitcoin payments for a day as kind of a test case and between them giving you the giving you the the between them giving you the bill and you paying the bill the price had changed enough that then you they had to issue in you a new bill so it did really didn't work very well practically and I think we're still in that in that that phase to a certain degree there's a lot that needs to happen for this to become not just digital cash but also a functional digital money oh
that is a perfect tangent it's almost like you knew what you were doing there because the next of the four the third is stable coins right and stable coins is a weird one it's effectively a cryptocurrency that is pegged to a stable asset so in the same way before we were talking about um you know commodity backed notes as in what we were doing when we had gold backat reserves for the dollar and all this kind of stuff it's kind of a similar s situation but we're having cryptocurrency style but pegged to stable assets and that asset that it's pegged to could be Fiat like the dollar the pound could be Commodities like gold silver could even be other cryptocurrencies okay which is an interesting one and there's Al this idea of an algorithmic one that kind of caps it to some function related to something else there there's a lot of ways and the whole premise of this is to make the asset more stable right so this like some of the things that
Jack was saying there about the price of Bitcoin changing over the course of seconds that's a big issue like when you actually want to use it in any kind of practical sense so the idea of stable coins quite roughly is to remove that by pegging it to something that is more stable exactly and so stable coins really are they use the same technology the same infrastructure let's say as Bitcoin blockchain so they achieve the digital cash properties via very similar mechanisms but you are kind of reintroducing your third party here in most cases you said you know if uh you have it pegged to a stable asset and that could be at Fiat Commodities or other cryptocurrencies for example and that pegging is done by a third party it's done by the issuer company so tether is probably the most famous example of uh a stable coin usdt and they are supposedly back one to one and whether or not they are is a whole other question um that people are people are wondering about
but you know putting that aside you're reintroducing this third party and any risk associated with them to actually have the Reserves oneto one with the with the stable coins in circulation the algorithmic one that you mentioned is interesting because actually that is trying to overcome that issue and trying to to say well okay we don't want to reintroduce this third party for obvious reasons we want it to function more like digital cast just with that stable price the problem there is that you know the economics of the situation aren't necessarily robust we've seen multiple huge catastrophic failures of Al coins that you know they work for a while but then when things go south they really go south so you know Luna um was was the example last year which which many people will have heard about because that affected lots of lots of other uh currencies that were kind of using lunar as a liquidity vehicle so yeah it's definitely not a solved problem so let's let's go into an example like we're talking
about stable coins and all this kind of stuff like you mentioned Luna there so let's go into the terror example Tera is probably the overarching brand of it and Terra is a blockchain platform that basically hosts two digital coins so you have us which is the stable coin which is designed to always be worth $1 and then you have Luna which can change and price so effectively if we have this us which is meant to be$ one dollar but it isn't worth $1 then people can make a small profit by trading us with Luna in a way that L nudges us back towards the $1 Mark and that's effectively how the stable coins work there and this this usually works well say usually it did work pretty well for a while and it it but it might so things might start to go wrong if like big Financial players uh try to manipulate this and make the most of it and it can cause like big Market crashes or you know if governments tried to
enforce new rules and you have this like single rule if you always want to get this to the right price then this can have big consequences and that did happen in May 2019 Jack do you want to provide a bit more info on this well yeah as you said there was a there was a significant issue effectively you know a bank run on on on this on this on this stable coin platform but you know you had a big withdrawal from one trading platform that caused a lot of concerns about uh you know you know what what the liquidity would look like that's backing the stability of us and this kind of loss on confidence as you see with bank runs led to a real spiral in Us's value and there essentially wasn't enough enough of a market for Arbitrage because that's what we call this kind of um this this secondary asset that's not pegged that's not stable but is keeping the stable coin stable the whole reason is as you say there there's
a market for Arbitrage people see an opportunity to buy and sell at different prices um provide essentially what they do is when they buy the um the Luna they then provide liquidity for this big pool they call it liquidity pools and this a lot of the stability of the stable coin is linked to the size and confidence in that liquidity pool of the of the volatile asset and yeah essentially in in May 2019 this spiral began that pretty much couldn't be uh couldn't be recovered from there were further drops in value subsequently to this a huge decrease in also Luna's value when the Luna's value went off off a cliff they both because again they're inter Interlink with one another there was no recovery point and there was a huge contagion because people have been using this this Luna and and and also Tera Luna the stable coin for liquidity in other things they've been you know I mean you have this whole defi World which we will cover in a future episode but one
thing in defi is they call composability so you can link things together and that's great when things are going well but when something goes wrong then there's almost a chain reaction of problems that you see yeah they're not so stable coins um so yeah like I said the main thing around stable coins is they're typically issued and backed by private entities um and that moves us nicely to the fourth and final of the four that we were given by Chachi PT which see which is many ways probably I guess one of the hottest topics right now is Central Bank digital currencies they're kind of similar to maybe we can maybe relate them quite closely to stable coins but instead of is I mean there are some differences but instead of issuance by a private company we now have issuance by a central bank so this is effectively getting as close to cash as possible and representing say representing say the pound as closely as possible uh in a digital form so in the same way
that the bank of England will you know print and manage uh all the pounds all the coins and all the notes you have it's effectively them issuing and regulating that same currency but in a digital form um and yeah I guess one of the most interesting things around this is that doesn't necessarily have to be blockchain or crypto C based right exactly so you know cbdc is effectively kind of moving some of that money from e-money so this electronic version of Fiat money that we deal with every day in our bank accounts and moving that to other infrastructure that operates a bit more like cash so trying to move the physical cash that we have in in society to to a digital form and that doesn't need to be yeah there's no real technological barrier to to how you achieve that you could just achieve that using a fully propri system that a government wants to roll out in conjunction with its Central Bank to issue this uh with its own proprietary software that only
works in one company in one country so yeah it doesn't need a blockchain to do this however because of blockchain being the main infrastructure for most digital cash and compelling digital cash and all the stable coins that have come uh since uh 2009 it is often and typically I think also should be seen as the best infrastructure for Central Bank ual currency and we can go into why a little bit later but it's just important to know as you said it's not it's not necessary yeah I mean and governments are worried about crypto and stable coins like you know they they have an obligation to their citizens to provide you know stable safe monetary options for them to interact so when they see people like losing lots of money on crypto maybe stable coins taking a lot of their user base away they want to provide trusted options for people and maybe even have the ability to control those options to an extent you know for fiscal monetary policy and all this kind of stuff
so this is like a big kind of um this is being very emphasized by central banks right now I think the stat is over 85% of countries are considering some form of cbdc right now so there's no fully implemented CB cbdc out there right now there's a lot of countries that are in the latter stages of prototypes and and big test like I think one of the best ones is in South Korea right now but there's lots I mean the bank of England's working on it the you know the America's working on every country is effectively working on this and some of them are getting quite Advanced and I think the bank of England said that they would probably have some cbdc solution in five to 10 years time being rolled out and apart from those kind of concerns about what's happening generally in in the kind of financial world and people moving outside their ecosystem potentially and that being a fear there's a lot of benefits to having you know digital cash that they
can jump on the back off like there's lots of reports and it could how it could help like Financial inclusion how they could have programmability which is a very controversial topic that we'll come on to a bit later but there's a lot of things that would add a lot of value to central banks issuing this yeah yeah exactly there are a lot of advantages not just to I mean there's there's definitely an element of jumping on the bandwagon right you said 85% of countries at least now considering it and part of that is obviously due to not you know the fomo from from governments and central banks not wanting to miss out on this but I think there's a general consensus that there are a lot of benefits to this you know like things like implementing fiscal policy um we saw in covid um this this the stimy checks as as they referred to so all the all the stimulus packages sent out to citizens in the US were actually based on checks sent at
the post right which is obviously a nonideal situation there's all all sorts of problems that you can have arising from that the security problems you know I get my post going to the wrong place sometimes so I don't want my check to go somewhere else that kind of thing but so so having digital version of that and and you can kind of think of cbdc as a little bit like just a a stable coin a Fiat backed stable coin issued by a more trusted entity because the trusted entity is your is your Central Bank in this case but yeah there are lots of different Financial inclusion is a big one you know you can use this to give give easier access to um to people in society to use government services for example uh to to receive stimulus to receive benefits and things it also helps governments as well so you can think of things like if you're using a central bank digital currency for payments then you could think about taxation at source as
well so rather than reconciling tax at a later time you can also use this property which we talk about in Bitcoin of kind of splitting payments um natively on the blockchain you could be taxing kind of a small micro payment tax um every time you make a payment so that's really interesting and could basically as we say increase efficiencies for how central banks manage the supply of money yeah and I think cbdc is a fascinating topic because there's so many examples of obviously huge governments and huge central banks rolling it out or trying to roll it out around the world and effectively trying monitoring how different countries are potentially adopting it and different countries are rolling air is fascinating and I think we are well we are definitely going to have an entire episode on cbdc hopefully from an industry expert um but yeah like I say it's really interesting to see how different countries have very different ideas of what an ideal cbdc looks like so in the Bank of England the report they
rolled out the primary concern and it's typical of Europe typical of the UK is privacy it's all about user privacy users can't have their data being tracked you know for every transaction I do in the way that it's kind of done in in the private banking electronic money you know through send HSBC all these right now but when you look at China's uh adoption it's far they don't do not care so much about privacy it's actually in fact privacy is not really a concern to them whatsoever yeah it's all for them it's all about scalability technology all this kind of stuff so it's really fascinating to see how we have these kind of dials for certain characteristics around like security privacy and how different countries will basically turn those dials left and right depending on the needs of their implementation yeah exactly so I think it probably is a good time to talk about you know what are the the characteristics characteristics of digital cach and specifically good implementations to digital cach and and how
we can avoid them uh you know in bad implementation so let's start with kind of I think probably the one of the most important is security right because we said digital cash should all be all be about ownership of an asset and you know cash we said is a bearer instrument it should be something which you can just present at a a at a counter to your Merchant and and they should know it's valid and you own this so achieving that security for digital cash actually is fairly it's fairly simple this is why all the stable coins are being built on the same blockchain infrastructure why cbdc is also using potentially going to be using the same infrastructure is because all of that has been solved quite neatly with the the cryptography side of Bitcoin and blockchain so you know you have you have public private key pirs for signing transactions you have script for enforcing conditions on transactions so this can only be spent by a certain person or a certain key or after
a certain time those kind of conditions so the security element is actually as as as important as it is I think it's probably arguably the most well solved right in in digital cach it it you you're completely right like we do need an episode private public Keir zero knowledge proofs all this kind of stuff because it's like the bread and butter of what enables all this technology to really succeed um it's really interesting though that so much of the kind of of the web 3 world generally uh actually is typically deploying these like web 2.5 options where people don't want you know the responsibility of owning their own Keys owning their own like you know I guess digital versions of money on their mobile device because how many times do you lose your phone how many times you forget your password all this kind of stuff there's a lot of issues around that I do completely agree that the end goal should be this like non I mean this this self- custodial arrang where I
own all the stuff but even like coinbase the most popular kind of crypto Exchange in the world right now that is a custodial Arrangement where they run your keys for you it's interesting a lot of people even though this should be the goal and move into this much easier userfriendly web 2.5 option where someone is running the keys on their behalf yeah that's a really important I've probably just jumped in there thinking from a like technical perspective that's what we call system level security right so the the actual security of the digital cache system itself is very well solved the user side so how do how do you ensure user security and how do you custody your own keys and things successfully is definitely not very well solved so the technology exists but the user experience uh side of this is really pretty poor still as you said and lots of people are still opting for uh uh for self U sorry for exchange custodi funds um and until yeah I again not an unsolvable
problem it's more an education and improving the Tooling in the future but yeah really important to to to distinguish the two types of security I think and this is really important for central banks as well like how do they roll this out are they going to play a coinbase role where they you know own all the keys for everyone in the UK If we take the bank of England for example and then maintain you know the security maintain the user friendliness if I lose my phone they can make sure I don't lose any of the money that was on on my phone or do they go you know full full privacy mode which is what they're saying they're pushing towards where they don't know anything about anyone ever and nothing goes through them in a way and users have the responsibility of managing their own keys and if they lose their funds well you know who cares that's that's on you that's the responsibility you've taken it's a really interesting one to see how different
kind of deployments of this are playing this out so the the next big one for me is privacy we've said it many times privacy I think everything comes down to ownership and peer-to-peer but effectively in the same way I have cash in my device if I pay Jack 20 pound for whatever um no one really apart from me and Jack should know that occurred and the difference between you know I saw this this this quot the difference between secrecy and privacy is privacy I want to just maintain um privacy between me and Jack and secrecies I don't want anyone to know about it privacy is I only want the person relevant to know about it and secrecies I don't want anyone to know about it and I think in this instance when we have a peer-to-peer interaction it's just the only person that this transaction relates to is myself and Jack and the whole world doesn't know that I we need to know that I sent Jack 20 pound and I think you know Bitcoin
has solved this in a way like they enable peer-to-peer interaction you know throughout the network um but there there's an interesting thing here about identity and how identity comes into the whole idea of privacy yeah exactly and as you say in Bitcoin the Privacy model is quite simple and you know we talk about the transp Arcy of Bitcoins so saying you can see the transactions they're all public but you can't necessarily see identity you can only really there's only visible identity in Bitcoin if you want it to be that way because natively you're just seeing these private public key pairs interacting digital signatures no one can determine who created the signatures who owns the keys for example they're what we call firewalled off from from Bitcoin so what that means is you can Implement Identity On Top you could have certified keys where you're given a key by some one and this is again how how cbdc could be implemented in some cases where you're assigned a key to use for your for your cbdc
money that is linked to kind of standard public key infrastructure you can also very privately link keys so that you know maybe I don't want everyone to know that this is my key or maybe I don't even want the central bank to know this is my key but they have some way of checking later on if if we need to check something or if there's a kyc um a payment where you need kyc involved but yeah basically Bitcoin solve the the double the double spending problem without sacrificing privacy this is where kind of ecash does fall down a bit because yes it does have a good level of privacy um in most cases because of this thing called Blind signatures we mentioned so the bank doesn't know the transactions it's signing so the identity of the of the um the users uh when they're transacting is is is filed off except it couldn't quite solve this for offline payments actually so if you're doing offline payments and you don't want to have a bank a
a direct connection with the bank while you're making the payment then actually this involves some kind of additional identity and they will basically be able to reveal your identity or determine your identity if you try and double spend so it's kind of very uh it's it's not great as a solution it's kind of a stop Gap yeah um you have there and this is an interesting one like the idea of identity I'm glad you mentioned like kyc which is know your customer um AML anti-money laundering checks like if you ever go to open a bank account you obviously have to give your passport in they do loads of backround checks to make sure you know you are who you say you are you don't have any outstanding debt you're not a criminal all this kind of stuff and then they monitor all your transactions based on that but cash is slightly different right like I can own as much cash as I want through whatever methods and not anyone like no one's the wiser for
it and know if I spend 20 pound in the shop then no one knows about it I don't have to tell anyone about it don't have to prove my identity depending on what I'm purchasing when purchasing alcohol obviously there's checks there but if I say all of a sudden I try and buy like a a 50 Grand car and I pull up with a 50 Grand bag um in cash in notes then there's obviously going to be some questions asked there's gon to be some checks there so I think it's an interesting one for identi is a very interesting one for cbdc and how they're going to implement it is going to be very interesting I what I've seen generally is the idea of like tiered access so you don't need very many identity checks whatsoever to spend below like5 pound and daily on something like that if you're spending above 10 grand then you have to have a serious like kyc check yeah exactly and that just mirrors that you know as you said
kyc works in the real world and interestingly with cash you can think of the kyc check S I was going to pay I think it's in a region of2 200s or something is is is the limit for a cash payment I'm not don't quote me on it but the actual money side is still kind of separate right because you're still paying with some physical money and you do the kyc check on your identity but they're two different parts of the transaction and you can mirror that again in Bitcoin you can separate how you do the kyc check from the the actual onchain payment itself which is I think just worth clarifying as well you don't need to build it in at the at the system level again to bitcoin yeah and I think the next big characteristic that we want to talk about is resilience right I think earlier when you're talking about cbdcs not necessarily having to be based on blockchain um well there's a reason that blockchain exists and there's a reason people
find blockchain favorable it's this idea of decentralization right the fact that we are Distributing these data sets across different nodes and that means that if one node goes down that the other two or however many nodes there are in the network can pick it up and make sure the network is carrying on and being healthy and I think this is something that cbdc you know it needs to have resilience it needs to have uptime and if we all of a sudden start to have cbdc that replicates you know maybe monetary systems or something like this where it's very centralized then might be an issue there with resilience yeah exactly I I think we've we've kind of hared on this plenty in on the podcast but that that's the key with with doing using Bitcoin is is digital cash is that the resiliency comes from making it a comp a competition between no to maintain service to you as a user you know Bitcoin has had effectively 100% uptime for uh how like 14 years now
which is insane right you've basically been able to use it without outage for 14 years because you always have multiple participants willing to accept your transaction whereas if you have a bank or or payment services provider go down then you then you'll run into problems and then you don't want that with a privately issued digital money basically or digital cash so yeah I think it's it's pretty clear why there's a big value proposition for using blockchain as the underlying piece for digital cash yeah I think um the next big one is around interoperability and this is an interesting one because I I'm trying to imagine a world in the future in which I whip out my Visa card and I can all of a sudden pay with Bitcoin or whatever the the cryptocurrency is in the future like the it's like not just interoperability between systems it's the idea of interoperability between traditional Finance systems of the web two World um like electronic money as we've defined them and the next generation of cash systems
and I F I can't POS like comprehend right now the idea of using a card a Visa card for yeah I have to say this is almost definitely the biggest challenge I think um for using digital cach in general um beyond the kind of volatility aspect but even for things like stable coins just being inoperable with physical terminals because I think the online piece is actually a little bit easier where you you can you can quickly update software in a website that's taking payments you can add an additional payment option online as you'll see you know you'll see people saying pay with crypto and actually in the ear days you you it wasn't that uncommon to see a pay with Bitcoin option because you you could do that um relatively easily it's almost interfacing with the the physical world your brick and mortar payment providers which is such a huge challenge because there's a huge sunk cost into the terminals that they're already using to accept your payments and you are seeing an uptake of
um of of new devices uh square is an example you know seen the new Square terminals which is a clever way because you can have applications on those terminals for accepting different uh different types of payment including cryptocurrency um but yeah it's it's still not a a particularly easy challenge to solve yeah and that's what I was going to say like when you're thinking of it on the web and I'm paying for something it's very easy to imagine someone offering a service and if I'm paying for Fiat they will just provide a little add-on where they can monetize the idea of converting that to bitcoin you behind the scenes and I don't see anything that makes sense but like I say physical world it's so different like Visa Mastercard aex all these kind of chip terminal um relevant companies they have a complete Monopoly on this system why would they want to enable someone to start to put Bitcoin in there or whatever cryptocurrency or whatever digital Cash System in there and like say there's
a massive sunk cost it would cost so much for them to change the hardware of the devices will start to support it and there's no real incentive for them to do that no it's definitely the stickiest part of the existing payments world to overcome um 100% agree and there are lots of companies actually offering what you said in the general online payments space whe you have people effectively being liquidity providers or exchange providers for crypto to fat fat to crypto online payments as well and you know talking of inability we also probably have to mention blockchain to blockchain or digital cash to digital cash inability because that is also a big challenge um we have seen some advances in this like you've got this no I hate the layers if you ever talk about layers in in in crypto I absolutely hate don't get started don't get started they change every right so traditionally you'd think of Bitcoin as like a layer one thing and then something built on top of that like te tether
would be a layer two thing right which is just using Bitcoin as a as a base layer now they're talking about layer zero which is is confounding in my head but this is for things like CH interoperability between the actual layer one chains themselves so you have things like polka dot you have Bridges being built um between different chains to make make it easier to exchange cash between different chains which is important but again there's a huge ux and adoption challenge for that as well but no one wants to see that no one wants to know like what the hell like what's going on behind the scenes that should be all like fundamental protocol that's fixed for life and the plumbing I don't give a crap about TCP and IP and what's going on beneath the surface like I just want to use it and I want the SE most seamless user experience possible and it's worth mentioning as well you know back to the security issue the the layer zero inability thing is where
you're seeing the biggest security challenges actually for this bridging that's where a lot of the the recent hacks um in the ethereum world and polka dot world are happening is these Bridges because you have these kind of almost semi centralized entities involved it's a real it's a real mindfield so let's not get into it but you know ites you convinced me though we'll do a Bridges episode you have convinced me we'll do a Bridges episode we'll push it to another day so you don't get too worked up right now nice good good idea so speaking of getting worked up um come on to the kind of final property or characteristic which is this programmability that we mentioned and this is this is a really controversial one and I think is the one that people are most worried about when they they hear about cbdc right yeah this is so when I first heard about the this concept I was like oh my God that's so cool like they can well let's explain what it is
like programmability related to digital cache like you can effectively um Implement smart contracts behind the scenes that can be used to do anything from you know automatically executing something on a predefined criteria like holding money in escrow and then when someone does the job it automatically gets sent someone all this kind of stuff but it can go so much further where you could say in say I know cbdc sell I can start to directly incentivize people to use their digital pounds at certain shops for example like spend it on certain foods I think a good example that I heard was like you can say okay uh people on benefits or something like this or if there's Universal income like deployed around the country you can say okay you're only allowed to spend this 100 pound a month on food or something like that I was like okay cool that's like a really interesting implementation and then you're like oh wow this is actually quite a scary slippery slope that could lead to complete governmental control
right where they can say you can only spend your money in a certain way and this has got a lot of people in kind of very concerned and in uproar right now yeah exactly and I think it is a valid concern right it's this is where people worry about moving away from physical cash to digital cash and cbdc taking us to this dystopian surveillance State type idea where programmability becomes something that can be used against you you know the example I've seen and I think this has happened uh already in a digital cash system in the in the world somewhere is pro saying you need to spend this money by a given time right which is really scary right saying this will become invalid if you don't spend it by next month and obviously you can see why you might want to do that as a government to stimulate spending and maybe it's great for for reducing or or modifying inflation but as a as an individual user as a as a as a member
of society that is really scary that your money could come become worthless overnight because it's sitting in your wallet yeah like I think I saw this as well where obviously we have interest rates right now you hold your your your money in a bank account and the number determines whether how much you save and they kind of use this in a way to say if there's lots of interest you obviously are more inclined to save your money in the bank account because you get a lot more money back and it's worth saving it and if they reduce the interest rates you're more likely to spend it but then obviously what you've just implied there another version of that is this thing called like disinterest or something like that where it depreciates over time so like the longer you hold in your bank account you have like a minus 5% every month or something like this and obviously stimulates you to spending the economy but like imagine how it rages that would be You' worked your
whole life to save like 20 grand in your bank account you better to buy a house or something like this put the deposit down in the house then all of a sudden the the government comes to like nah we're going to start taking that every month if unless you spend it ASAP it's crazy yeah again this just proves the point right all new technology can be used for good or for ill and when people say cbdc you have to take it with a pinch of salt right just cbdc is not good in and of itself it has to be implemented well in a way that preserves all these properties that we that we've just mentioned I mean I I know this is we we kind of wanted to cover the challenges and concerns around digital cach I think we've actually covered quite a lot of them already right just talking about the properties so you know we talked about security and privacy and needing to make sure that the user level security is there the
regul regulatory challenges on you know how you implement identity well ensure KY is still um possible then one interesting one I definitely think we should maybe highlight now is is the any technology barriers right because the biggest one I think I can see is scale because you to the high fees right why why that's a problem yeah yeah I think um it in scale means many things to many people like I say the one thing would be transaction fees like it costs an absolute bomb to send anything on ethereum and even Bitcoin to a certain extent but then also like the transaction throughput right now on bitcoin is like seven transactions a second or something like this I think that what Visa's processing worldwide is in the hundreds of thousands a second if not the millions a second I mean ethereum doesn't do much better it's like 30 a second so like these networks right now don't scale properly or they're not scaling in the way that they should and I think this is you
know if you want something I think the bank of England said that any cbdc solution that they have has to have a minimum throughput stable throughput of 30,000 transactions a second so there's just no way you can base it on these kind of implementations right now yeah exactly and we're talking about you know the lack of scalability of some of basically the leading most popular blockchains and cryptocurrencies and they're really not suitable in any meaning way to to to root most digital currencies on right now right so even if the governments do decide on a perfectly good model with all these properties preserved if they can't implement it on a blockchain that's scalable enough then it's a noo anyway um and I think that is also we're racking them up today but I think that's another episode for the future where we should go deep into the scalability challenge itself and what it means because I think you know there is good news I think there are ways to to overcome this challenge um and
that blockchain can be used to support you know National level cbdcs but current state of players is not very attractive for them right now yeah definitely and we also in terms of challenges we talked about you know adoption and primarily one of the the barriers to adoption is around the integration with traditional Financial systems like you know chip and pin terminals things like that like I can't see that changing anytime soon like in in a real kind of wide widespread way because you know Visa Mas they have Monopoly on these systems um and the other thing is should digital cash replace cash completely it's a big question like there's a lot of questions around inclusivity like there's just there's always going to be people that are left out when you move to like the digital world because just people that don't have smartphones aren't digitally Savvy and obviously it's the the right or the kind of government is supposed to make sure that these people kind of do come with us on that journey and
they have access to digital like education and also digital devices but there's always going to be maybe at least for the next 50 Years anyway a small group of society that do not want to use a smartphone to transact right and we shouldn't take that away from them like we shouldn't push digital cash as a means to replace cash digital cash should be an option for people that don't necessarily want to use digital money in the kind of the way that we're using it right now which is private money and this kind of stuff yeah exactly and I think the inclusivity part is is a real that's the main right reason for saying maybe we don't go straight to uh replacing physical cash I mean I will say again cryptography is is cool because you know what you can do uh with cryptography in a physical setting you know we're already used to using your bank cards um you can embed cryptographic information into physical into very low powerered physical things including Bank notes right
so there are companies actually looking into this I think I want to say one of them is called duel where they are issuing notes now so physical cash notes that are linked to Central Bank digital currency and they can be linked and when you when you spend them they're using the cryptography embedded within within the note itself so it is super cool technology but um this this this doesn't this should be not taken lightly this transition from Pure physical especially with those concerns about programmable cbdc right in if you're if you're in a country where there's a move to this more Draconian form of CBC then you should be a little bit worried I think about you know going completely away from physical cash yeah so lots of concerns like so many opportunities but there are some concerns and it it's not that governments aren't thinking about let them like in almost all the documents that I've read on they they understand these like the Digital P was very hot on inclusivity and making sure
people aren't Left Behind it's just an alternative option for people that want it um but yeah will be interesting to see how different implementations of digital cach and cbdc specifically maybe are rolled out and how they work and if they work and who adopts them and who doesn't adopt them and so Jack what is your take on the future of digital cash well let's assume that we know we get good implementations happening and we the the scalability challenges is solved well enough to use them I think the biggest use case I see for digital cash and the one that has the biggest immedate impact globally is for you know remittances right so making payments cross border for people working in different countries to to where their families are potentially because this is there's a huge I don't want to say market for this but there's a huge demand for for doing this globally there are lots of overseas workers across the world and currently so so this is is measured typically for what's the cost
of remittance for a $200 payment and on average it's around 6.2% which is again it's high even as it is right but that's twice that's over twice the un's sustainable development goal of 3% right so we're in a really it's a big challenge that there's a lot of um there's a lot of impetus to solve there's a lot of demand to solve this Challenge and I think digital cash and cbdcs are the best tool again if you have a scalable version of this to reduce those cost cost right down to to fractions of of the actual um the payment amount itself because that that's just untenable if you're losing 6% of your money to to just pure fees then that's just it's it's really unfair I think yeah I like that one that's a powerful one like the remittance economy is huge like it that makes a lot of sense I think um for me like we we've talked about in the entire episode but it's micro payments like the microp pams obviously well in
a lot of ways are dependent on the success of digital cash but there's going to be so many any use cases and new business models and new economies that are realized when we can start to send fractions of pennies or fractions of dollars whatever it is like the idea of payment streaming the idea of you know micro payments micro incentives being out especially from like a governmental level we talked about this before like if we start to have a cbdc that's implemented in the UK imagine if the government could start to micro incentivize like actions that are good for say people in the UK like it could be you know you give you put a bottle all through the you scan the QR code put it into this recycling plant you get a penny fraction of a penny you go for a run obviously that's a really great way to stay healthy that's going to reduce the burden on the NHS you get a penny or you get a 10p or something like this you
get a penny per mile say something like this like the idea and it's kind of it could go down the Draconian route where you start to say okay well they start to really get involved in how we act societally and is this going to go down a slippery slope where they start to De incentivize certain activities potentially but the idea of like incentivizing positive kind of out put and positive actions by citizens in a micro incentive way I find really powerful I really like the idea of that happening yeah 100% agree and basically I think what you're describing there is all use cases we normally talk about with micro payments just being applied to effectively legal tender if you use it for a CBC then this is something that immediately has much better adoption is much easier to you to to do these interesting use cases of micro payments so I'm fully on board with that I think the other thing kind of just the final one for me is like on the the cbdc
um fiscal policy side and actually managing the money of a state I think there are huge benefits because there's very as you can imagine with physical cash one of the downsides of the Privacy you give users is that then the central bank has very poor visibility of how money is used so moving to a cbdc digital cash model you should in theory be able to be able to track the use of money track how money is flowing in the economy much better and be able to analyze get real time insights that you can't get with physical cash and again as long as you you should be able to do that in a way that doesn't compromise privacy of users but then gives all this extra data information for analytics to your central banks which I think is a very important tool they will have in the future it's an interesting one because when we were talking about you know what is um what is what's the thing gdpr what's data that's related to gdpr and
how can personal identifying information right pii and it's like everything everything personal identifying information in a way but I do say your point that if we I think what the term the bank of England used on this is that if we aggregate data aggregate data is fine to analyze if we look at it on the course of like you know 10 million people these are the rough things over the course of like a month or something like that it's really difficult if not impossible to go into the the the minutia of that to be like Alec keeps buying coffee every day at 10: a.m.
like that kind of thing so yeah I think aggregate data I'm fine with the analysis of that as long it's quite as long as it's like the system is designed in such a way there's no way to actually kind of you know go to the back door and work out how that data's actually gone has been spent by me for example yeah I I and I I where I'm coming from there is I I fully think it's possible to have a version of cbdc that looks very much like Bitcoin whereas if you look at the Bitcoin blockchain right now you can see the flow of money you can see the velocity of money the transactions you know various statistics that you you can perform on that data but I can't tell anything about the identity of the users and I think that is the form if you have a cbdc that mirrors the Bitcoin privacy model then you will get a lot of those benefits I think fine fine I'll let you do it I
trust you you can do it well yeah it's easy to say isn't it if I'm not the one implementing it but awesome okay well I think yeah we've covered a lot there I think uh you know two episodes in digital cash is probably enough uh for one season of the show let's say so um yeah and and we've got lots more to to cover now much more homework to do for future episodes so with that we'll say yeah thank you for listening wherever you may and we'll join you next time to entangle a little bit more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of entangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto