Episode 21

Digital Cash (part 1)

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In the latest episode of Untangling Web3, hosts Alec Burns and Jack Davies explore the concept of Digital Cash, one of the foundational ideas underpinning Web3.

This week, Alec and Jack journey through the evolution of money, setting the stage for a deep dive into digital cash and its significance in the modern age. Beginning with the roots of currency, the discussion traverses from the barter system, through the era of commodity money and metal coins, emphasizing the inherent challenges like scalability and trust. The dialogue underscores the pivotal roles of gold and bitcoin, contrasting their perceived value determinants.

Transitioning into the age of paper money, the hosts shed light on the adoption of commodity-backed paper currency, symbolizing vaulted gold, which addressed earlier limitations but inadvertently introduced new challenges like fraud and inflation. With the advent of the post-World War II era, the spotlight shifts to fiat currency, which, decoupled from tangible assets, hinges its value on confidence in economic stability, as centrally orchestrated by pivotal institutions like central banks.

Diving into the core topic of digital cash, Alec and Jack emphasize the contemporary tilt towards electronic money, acknowledging the dwindling prevalence of physical cash. Highlighting the drawbacks of current digital money systems, they champion the merits of privacy, ownership, and minimal intervention. The discourse reverently nods to early visionaries like David Chaum, paving the path to bitcoin's revolutionary establishment as the first successful centralized authority-independent digital cash system. Drawing links to Web3, the conversation magnifies the alignment of digital cash principles with values like privacy and security, celebrating features like smart contracts and programmability.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

so we said money can exist in you know commodity commodity backed or Fiat forms um but that money is is also electronic in a lot of cases and and the figure is staggering it's if you depending on where you check it's anywhere from 92% up to kind of 97% of all money supply globally is currently in an electronic form so in a bank account somewhere of some kind is not part of physical cash which is crazy damn it's just numbers right it's just numbers on a screen you're like what the hell that is so crazy just numbers on someone's computer somewhere that's magic internet money for sure um so this as you say is a scary scary thought and so when we say digital money we might as well say money because most of it is digital most of it is electronic welcome to another episode of the untangling web3 podcast hello Jack my co-host my friend how are you doing this fine Sunday afternoon yeah not too bad thanks Alec uh having a nice

weekend so far how about yourself yeah it's been a good weekend it's been busy and we're topping it all off you know the cherry on top is that we get to record Another fascinating episode of a topic that relates to web 3 yeah exactly and uh today we uh we're covering one that I think is is very highly related to a few we've done before and might seem like duplication at first glance we're talking about digital cash and we say that all the time when we talk about Bitcoin but actually I think there's a lot more to dig into that maybe we haven't touched on before including you know the history of that term and different systems so yeah why don't we uh why don't we kick off with some definitions first just to to lay the ground on what we think digital cach is so yeah go ahead Alec what do what do you think straight in um well I would say that cash is it's a legal medium of exchange right it's like

a kind of I say a constant maybe medium exchange that's traditionally issued and maintained by the government um a tangible good it's probably like when we talking before it's like allows Ecommerce basically to have standards that we can kind of procure different goods and kind of adhere to the same standards when we're procuring things um and I guess digital cach is just the exact same but in the digital world right yeah exactly it's a pretty simple one really I mean it does involve I think this topic needs we need to talk about the meaning of you know money itself and again neither of us really monetary Theory experts but you need a kind of basic grasp of these terms so for me you know if you think of money as all all the different forms with which you can pay for services uses IM medium Exchange store value Etc cash is the physical subset of money and then digital is simply the digital representation of physical so it's essentially trying to replicate the properties and

the functionality of normal cash physical cash in a digital realm essentially yeah which is it's kind of weird sounds a bit like a a bit of a contrast or a bit of a controversy to say okay well cash is the physical subset of money which is every kind of legal medium of con of consistent exchange and then digital cach is no longer the physical vers of that like why is that not money then and hopefully we kind of get into the the depths of the difference between money and cash and what digital cash kind of hopes to replicate cash but in in the digital world what the advantages and benefits of that are but you were right earlier on and saying that we have touched on some of this stuff before especially in the token episodes because I mean I guess cash is probably one of the most well-known tokens that people kind of have kind a tangible understanding of so there will be a tiny bit of duplication but I think it's really important

to get to grips with the history and the evolution of cash and money to really understand like because I mean you know history comes around in waves right in circles and it kind of the things that we're experiencing there the reasonings and justifications for digital cash uh are actually things that we've experienced before and there's actually kind of a precedent that's been set in the past and I think we're seeing that come be again so I think going into the history will be you know interesting for us definitely but also kind of set the tone for why we want need digital cash in the kind of in the current age yeah exactly so why don't we kick it off by going you know all the way back to the start as we do and we talk about money and I know we have before about okay the very earliest form of of exchange really was what we call the barter system so this is how you know hundreds thousands of years ago you would have

been trading goods and services directly for other goods and services so there wasn't a medium of exchange to mediate that exchange you would just directly you know give your um your your barrel of grain for or some a basket of apples or something right and and they refer to this I think as the they call it the double coincidence of want problem that you you come up to here because you need two people you know you need someone who wants the apples at the same time as someone who wants the the barrel of grain or something yeah so I'm going to call BS on this since we first did um our tokens episode and we talked about this bar system I've done some reading and actually the B system where we kind of think of it on like a societal or high civilization level didn't exist like the the problem that you just kind of defined makes it almost impossible to imagine like a bar Society remember we were talking about in episode three tokens

like hey how the hell can I as a chicken farmer convert my chickens into caros like it just doesn't work and actually the kind of the current understanding is that b systems didn't really exist that the kind of the stages of evolution of exchange were very much we had these these tribes of 150 Max that we kind of talked about before and they were kind of quite socialist in a way there was no like exchanging to an extent especially of like Commodities and like food and goods everyone contributed to a single tribe um and obviously when we expanded those tribes out to civilizations and all this kind of stuff it was no longer possible to contribute in that way and they said well as soon as that started to happen then we started to have the next stage which was commodity money like standards of mediums of exchange that actually facilitated the exchange so sorry to call you out nice and early but I thought that was quite an interesting twe on what we said

last time we talked about this keep me on my toes Al I mean this is the thing I think uh yeah I would I would I would definitely say I think the Bara system is is one of these things you learn about in school right as like the early days of of exchange and yeah I'm kind of not very I'm not familiar with the details of of medieval history and things like that but I what I can imagine from you're saying is like yeah it we what we call a Bara system is actually a thing where by people are are exchanging but because of this you know this this this this problem of you need you need The Coincidence of want then actually that's not in him practice that's never happening so you're just having people sharing things with each other in the expectation that things will be shared with them when they need it so it's kind of the barter the barter system is kind of a nice euphemism for actually what was a

fairly socialist situation yeah I think maybe that's the issue maybe it's that that people hate the term socialist they're like instead of calling it ISM everyone contributing to an overall game without the need to profit they're like we'll just call it B system that sound you slightly more capitalist and all this kind of stuff so maybe that was the reason but yeah baa system didn't exist on any kind of large scale at all it was more small tribes yeah in a socialist system contributing to the tribe overall because like we said very difficult for someone who specializes in chicken farming to assume they're going to get you know milk and cheese and all this kind of stuff so yeah that was the the first age socialism was the first age and then we moved away from that as these tribes expanded into kind of you know start to globalize start to expand into more Society level um well Society level populations and then we move to commodity money so this is the first type of

money that we're going to speak about commodity money so this is very much like Goods used as a medium exchange we can think of like useful Goods like the best examples probably be grain cattle spices things that actually have intrinsic value being used used as mediums of exchange yeah exactly and this is the the one kind of I think the as you're saying the motivation for this was effectively what we refer to as scale right especially in web 3 it was the fact that this this previous Society barter otherwise did not scale very well to large populations so you needed to have some kind of commodity or some kind of fixed medium of exchange that you could use to actually you know resolve the that that issue that you never have a coincidence of once you need a commodity that you can exchange at the point where you want something and then then the person buying that from you can can then use to buy something else later Etc so yeah it's interesting and um

you know you had all different types of of of mediums you'd use right like the Grain and cattle spices and things like that Metals uh as well came a little bit later than that um but yeah it's a super interesting period I think when when that started and it just shows the need for when you have large popular societies you have to have a uniform medium exchange to function really yeah and you've already got like one of the first words in that's going to come later scale was important another one was trust not trust necessarily in the underlying technology because it's just grain but trust that people would want this everyone at this time needs grain everyone maybe didn't necessarily need cattle all the time but they understood there was always going to be an intrinsic desire or want to have cattle so they trusted in the exchange of these um an interesting one for me was that um the ancient Romans actually used salt as a medium exchange because they always assumed that people

would would want salt and this actually where um the term salary comes from Salt salary yeah interesting factor to get in nice and early didn't know you're multilingual Alec that's a that's a new one yeah then you the next one that you were talking about was m coins and the link there is kind of obvious we said that like you know it's Commodities things that have in kind of intrinsic value that were useful to society and you know in the same way coins were just kind of an easier kind not easier I guess easier to transact form of this right because you know Metals gold Silvers even coppers early on kind of the early in the earlier versions this they had intrin value they could be used for you know jewelry weapons all this kind of stuff and I guess some people might be saying okay well you know if I'm a farmer does gold necessarily have intrinsic value to me I'm not going to be eating gold as like a um as an absolute

necessity I think it comes back to the trust you know that there's a kind of a need or desire for gold in society um and that's the reason that they could invest in these and they still have like tangible value and I've seen there's actually been a lot of people that say okay well gold doesn't actually have a tangible value like it's not since only been in like the last 200 years or something like that that we've started to use in specific like manufacturing processing engines and things like this it's actually a good it's actually quite a good point is that gold maybe doesn't have a super tangible value it's kind of the societal perception of value that we've placed on gold and then I've seen some people compare and contrast this with like Bitcoin and say well you know Bitcoin doesn't have a a tangible value like gold you kind of well gold we kind of put this pressure and this kind of emphasis on gold in society for 4,000 years so we know

there's always going to well maybe not always but there is going to be a societal want for gold and doesn't really exist in Bitcoin yet I'd say yeah exactly and I think the the other analogy with with gold backed money and using gold as a commodity for for monetary systems is this this idea of scarcity and you'll see people talking about that all the time in relation to bitcoin because it's difficult to mine more gold it it has a has a relatively fixed or lwi inflating Supply which is why I mean when people talk about money they talk about it having a very a few distinct characteristics so one of them being a medium of exchange one of them being a good store of value and one of them being a good unit of account and to achieve these three things scarcity is is is quite important to that because if you had a a very highly inflating or highly fluctuating supply of that of that metal and I think this is also why you

know you're saying there's a demand for gold in society but it's also not something that it's why it was kind of a sweet spot I think my understanding is that because it's it's not used industrially quite as much as other Commodities that keeps the supply more more fixed or there's not a demand in other places that it becomes s sensible as a as a choice of commodity to be used as money because you know that becomes the main thing and you know obviously there's demand from other sources like like your royalties and things but that combination of it being scarce and having some kind of utility in society but not one where you're building everything from it you know in the age you're not using gold for obvious reasons um to build everything so it would have been more difficult to use uh those different kind of metals as uh as Commodities and you and as you say you see this in uh this analogy with Bitcoin because you have an Associated cost and difficulty

with mining Bitcoin as well and also the fact that it has a fixed Supply so in that sense you could say Bitcoin does mirror gold in a way because it because it has a relatively fixed Supply um or Bitcoin has a fig Supply and gold has a relatively fixed or low inflating Supply um and there's a kind of physical or energetic cost to uh getting more of it to mining more of it right now the analogy breaks down a little bit once Bitcoin is issued but we we we'll deal with that later yeah so like I think people can kind of quite easily imagine the idea of metal coins acting like servicing exchange as a medium exchange kind of makes sense there's a lot a very easy relation to paper notes today that represent something there's a central Authority which issues the standardized coins and then within Society there's a kind of knowledge of what that coin represents and what that coin can can has the purchasing P probably the term for that coin so

people can get behind that and that was kind of the standard for you know 2,000 years when it was invented really in 600 BC by the lydians and all the way through to probably the 17th century um but you know there was actually some challenges to the use of it one it's pretty heavy you know you want to exchange a lot of metal coins to buy a house or something like that that's quite inconvenient you don't want to be lugging around these heavy metal coins all the time um another one was which is quite sounds like quite a weird one was the wearing problem like the idea of like exchanging coins constantly you actually get this um kind of this this wearing down of the coin and over time you actually lose value and weight of the coin which seems a bit mad to to me now but back in the day it was actually one of the main reasons that they actually moved to the next system that we're going to talk about and

the final problem they had was this thing called the replacement problem whereas like if I have you know 500 gold coins and I lose 500 gold coins because I'm taken everywhere and it's heavy and everyone knows I've got 500 gold coins they're gone forever same problem with cash right they're gone forever so the next era that kind of surpassed metal coins was commodity backed paper money so it was literally representing the physical gold for example that's in a vault somewhere by a bank with paper notes that represents ownership and you can exchange these much more easily much more convenient paper notes that represents ownership of gold to say held by a bank somewhere yeah exactly and it kind of this this solved a lot of problems in you you have the the Britain wood system that pegs the US dollar and that becomes kind of global standard to the the price of gold and one of the big challenges this also solves is divisibility because you know you need if you have a bar of

gold it's not very easy to to pay for something that costs much much less than a bar of gold this kind of links on to the idea of micro payments we've talked about a lot you know being able to do smaller and smaller payments if you're lugging around bars of gold whether you're wearing wearing them or not it's very hard to divide that for smaller payments for for kind of day-to-day transactions and that's also linked to the scarcity um you know there's a bit of a mismatch between the the value of what you want to exchange you know for day-to-day purchases and how it's in how it's stored up in in in physical uh gold stores so yeah when when you come to commodity back payer money in in in particular the gold standard and gold backed commodity money then you have this ability to issue notes uh physical cash against that that commodity basically in stored in reserve um and pegged to the price of of the the currency is issuing say US dollar

and yeah then it then it becomes much more much easier and also there's you know this will be related when we come back to you know evolving to digital cach but there are a lot of costs associated even even with modern uh physical cash but even more so with securing uh commodity money you know that's part of why you want to move to commodity back paper money because all of a sudden the security problem is much less if you're if you're having to just secure a few physical notes as opposed to the gold bar that you might use and can't divide so there's a few things there true like there are also some issues that kind of come into play around fraud though right like it's very hard for me to fraud a solid gold bar if I'm exchanging with you it's very easy for you to test on the spot but a paper note especially when this kind of came into into practice and say the 17th century like it's very easy to fraud

of paper note just saying this is from the bank Alec has one gold bar here it is that kind of thing so fraud was a big challenge that actually came about from commodity-backed paper money another big one was the idea of um printing money and inflation right so at at the start of this especially in the west it was around like the 17th century where they started to have like commodity-backed paper money it was very much like the paper money represented gold that you had in reserve so you couldn't overinflate you couldn't all of a sudden say you know I have more paperback money because I don't all of a sudden have lots more gold but it was around um I think it was after World War I and after like the the economic crisis a lot of people had lost gold to war and there been spent overspending and stuff like that but they still needed money in the economy to pay you know soldiers to pay for buildings to pay for projects so

all of a sudden you say saw that countries were starting to write paper notes uh commodity backed paper money allegedly that represented gold and Reserve that they didn't actually have and this is where we started to see the Advent in a way of the next stage which is Fiat um and Fiat you know it blows my mind like so to this day Fiat blows my mind so we have Commodities as money understood there's tangible benefit there then we have commodity back to paper money again it's underpinned it's just an easy way to represent something that still has tangible use and tangible benefits and practical and all this kind of stuff and then we come to the next era of money which is Fiat which is this idea of paper notes that are now not backed by anything and one of the main reasons that this happened was after World War II like I said a lot of countries were in debt and they no longer had the gold reserves to actually you know Matt be

able to invest in the economies there was like a whole problem with obviously the Great Depression and all this kind of stuff where countries needed to invest in the economy but they didn't have the gold in reserve to actually issue money to pay for development all this kind of stuff so all of a sudden the great minds of the world got together and said well why don't we just start to make up our own currency that doesn't have to be backed to anything and you always star to see the overlap potential with Bitcoin um and they started to use what was Fiat and yeah that's the whole system that we're working in now this kind of made up paper money and you know hate it or love it that's the system we're in right now yeah people call web3 Magic internet money but really uh Fiat money is like magic paper money or magic government money Monopoly money Monopoly money but yeah it's I think it's interesting as as you you kind of articulated really

nicely there's this change in the trust model really as you go from commodity money pure commodity money to uh commodity backed paper money and then to Fiat which is essentially government-backed paper money because you know going from commodity to to commodity backed you as you said you have the counterfeit problem becomes uh more prevalent because it's easy to verify that gold is gold it's not so easy to verify that this bank note is actually associated with some gold uh so you're trusting the issue of those notes you're trusting that they haven't been duplicated by the issuer etc etc and then you move from commodity back pay for money to government back pay for money or Fiat where you don't even have an asset in reserve necessarily to to verify against it's it's more based on to be honest as I understand it it's more based on confidence in the economy of that country right which is much harder to Define much harder to verify there's lots of of different factors you have to take in

to control that it's almost impossible to validate um you know how or why a currency should be at a certain price it just becomes this big free market problem um but yeah so we've kind of the modern state of money um prior to to kind of Bitcoin and web 3 based digital money is much more government trusted that's the kind of that's the commodity you're that if that's the commodity if there's if there is one that you're you're using now yeah exactly you H the nail in the head I think like we were at a stage of commodity backed paper money and the problem was the governments and central banks at the time which kind of existed in a way they didn't have the flexibility to invest in the economy and to push the economy have the tools their disposal to get them out the Great Depression so they came up with Fiat this imaginary Monopoly money effectively at the time that they had the flexibility they had complete control over how much was in

circulation like they could start to control you know inflation you know through interest rates and printing lots of money and all this kind of stuff and it gave them the tools to then control the economy but with that like a lot of critiques of the Fiat system said it gave them too much power and were now completely beholden to you know not a few individuals but a few entities that effectively had the responsibility of keeping currency stable with only you know one or two mechanisms at the disposal which is interest rates to get people who have money in their Bank to either say start saving because it will give you loads of money if you do save um or start spending and we won't give you much money if you do save and printing money and you know a lot of people are well a lot of critiques of the Fiat system would like a return to the gold standard because they kind of believe that this this control this this flexibility that um central

banks actually have is leading to more economic crises for example yeah and you can this is you know I think actually a few years ago when I had even less understanding of how money worked uh this idea of money printing leading to inflation definitely was not as pressing a concern in my mind because I hadn't lived through an example of that happening and being RI but then obviously went through covid and and we saw effectively money printing across the globe in particular in places like America you know just to to stimulate the economy you know you hear the phrase stimy checks in America and and that's also quite funny I think because that they were all issued in check based form you know not digitally very very notably to people um and yeah we're just seeing the effect of that now and you're seeing in the UK as well uh that lever as you said of the central banks using interest rates very clearly is the the the way to to control inflation that we're

experiencing so if you're trying to buy a house or get a mortgage in the UK right now it's pretty scary um so yeah that that kind of wraps up the journey all the way from B systems whether or not they existed to fear money I would want to one thing that I think we need to talk about is we've talked about central banks and I just want to introduce the concept of what a central bank is very briefly just so people are on board with it so most people's interaction daily with be with a Commercial Bank like you know Sant andere HSBC these are privately run banks that are service providers right they're for profit they give out loans they charge interest on loans they invest your money in places and they make profit right private entities so your bank account with santand that is private money held by Sant andere on your behalf okay then we have central banks these are kind of public private entities bit weird right and their whole mandate is

to regulate a country's currency so when we talked about introducing Fiat which was these kind of I don't know fake Monopoly money style things we have to regulate the trust in that currency so people can feel confident in exchanging it because it's no longer gold back so the emphasis and the importance of central banks when the fance systems came in was well became key it was really important it was critical to say um so they issue and regulate the currency um and they can also you know kind of do that with raising and lowering interest rates rates and printing money and have like Financial systems all but their whole mandate is financial stability of the currency that they run so like the bank of England is the the pounds kind of regulatory body to ensure stability for the pound and yeah every most countries oh well every um kind of currency will have some Central Bank that that does that yeah exactly and I'm glad you defined it so clearly because it's it's it's important

to know that there is literally an entity in most countries around the world now that have their own fiat currency in the central bank that effectively has humans making decisions about the effectively about the value of a a currency which is a huge move um away from the earlier forms of money which you know dependent on the scarcity of gold for example being dependent more on a an intrinsic property of the world right which you can't control exactly when you look like when you compare countries like so most people believe in the dollar because they're like okay this is a very highly regulated trusted system that's existed there's not much volatility in the economy all this kind of stuff but like you said humans are fallible you look at Zimbabwe and the currency they use that's an example of human intervention of the currency and human regulation of a currency that went very wrong so the trust in that system failed completely lots of people pulled money out hyperinflation the economies suffered massively because of

that and a lot of people there actually will use the dollar as a means of exchange because that is stable and trusted because you know the humans evils that do a much better job of regulating that currency so I'm really glad you brought the human element there exactly so I think that also you know is a good way to to move on to the thing we're actually meant to be talking about now we we've buildt it up is is digital cash and digital money as well and we'll talk about both of those because they are slightly slightly different but that is one of the motivations for moving to a digital cache because they can be implemented in a way that is more robust that is is not dependent on the whims of individuals necessarily so just to kind of briefly set the scene what is dig cash and and you how long has it been a thing so we said money can exist in you know commodity commodity backed or Fiat forms um but that

money is is also electronic in a lot of cases and and the figure is staggering it's if you depending on where you check it's anywhere from 92% up to kind of 97% of all money supply globally is currently in an electronic form so in a bank account somewhere of some kind is not part of physical cash which is crazy damn just numbers right it's just numbers on a screen you're like what the hell that is so crazy just numbers on someone's computer somewhere that's magic internet money for sure um so this as you say is a scary scary thought and so when we say digital money we might as well say money because most of it is digital most of it is electronic already and this is because you know we've moved to accessing and transferring funds electronically in general so you know we we still have physical cards but they are interacting when we tap them you know to get on the tube or pay at a coffee shop they are accessing electronic and

digital systems to transfer money that are transferring money between digital bank accounts where all the money is digitally residing so it's it's it's massively digital already in case anyone hav realized this which is something that I also I also wasn't aware of until a couple of years ago yeah and like you said I think like even the physical cards like they're dying out now like I have a digital card on my phone right now for the exact same reasons people prefer digital money that they want a digital card convenience right it's all about convenience at the end of the day and like it's really interesting like I think when people think of the money they own they don't really realize that it's private and I do want to kind of really emphasize the difference between private and public when we talk about like physical cash that is like issued by a government that is public money you own the cash and this is a very big web three concept right ownership it's very hard to

some for someone to take away that 20 pound note that I have in my back pocket that is real ownership right there when we talk about money as Jack just said like numbers in my bank account with santand that is private money santand is effectively looking after my money on my behalf if all of a sudden santand wants to say you're not allowed to touch this money anymore they can do that and they have done that like the example we gave was those there Lorry drivers in Canada right they were getting lots of sponsorship for their protests in Canada and all of a sudden the Canadian government were like okay I want you to switch off their bank accounts so they cannot access any of the funds that's been sent to them and that's an example of private money and the kind of what can happen when things go wrong and like a lot of people be like okay well you know I'm a law-abiding citizen I'm fine with that like if it stops terrorists

and all this kind of stuff that's fine with me but if you start to stop protesters that's a big infringement on freedoms right just because as you agree with the current government and their ability to do that with those people what if a government comes into power that all of a sudden you don't start to agree with their policies and you're one of those people that they consider a non-desirable and they cut off your money so that this ownership thing that we talk about in web 3 really does apply to money and it's one of the kind of the driving principles behind digital cash because that is you know ownership yeah exactly and it's ownership is such a key concept because when you think about something like physical cash it I think the term is a bearer instrument so essentially the bearer the person holding that note is is is deemed the owner of it right and can use it at the point of sale right as as we expect and a lot of the

money doesn't necessarily function like that because there's no way of of proving that there's ownership information stored in databases you have to verify against Banks and things like that and digital cach I think is very much trying to replicate that Bearer instrument aspect of cash which is crucial so if you can present the correct cryptographic information in the case of a digital cach system that's that's the equivalent of having physical ownership and there's lots of nuance about the term ownership um in in in in the crypto world and and you know various legal bodies around the world are trying to get to grips of this trying to Define what does ownership actually mean in the context of digital assets and digital cash but maybe we're getting ahead of ourselves a little bit I I think I want to very quickly touch on the history of digital cash itself because it does even though we've just said this is kind of the end point of the whole history of cash and money there is a little

bit of history of the term itself but yeah go on do we want to talk about some of the before we go into digital cash talk about some of the challenges that we see with digital money right now I kind of just briefly touched on the ownership one but like you know you're talking about 92% did you say of all money is digital which is in a lot of ways private um as part of that we we kind of there's a lot of Monopoly on private money especially say in the US for example there's like four card providers was it MasterCard Visa I can't remember the other two AMX and something else like it's very centralized and in a way monopolies in a lot of ways are bad it means they can charge whatever fee they want and have non-c competition all this kind of stuff like I said this is high fees very high fees middlemen involved in the checking between you know account One account two and all the steps in between so

right now it's very expensive even though it is digital it's all about and speed and all this kind of stuff digital money is very expensive there's lots of middlemen high fees lots of minimum payments for example not being able to spend on your AMX below that 150 and all this kind of stuff because the costs are too high so I just want to set the scene there that there is a lot of problems with digital money as we kind of think of it right now yeah exactly um I'm glad you mentioned that because yeah the this High fees and middle band is exactly what we talk about when we when we talk about Bitcoin and micro payments side of things the that this is the one of the things that you're you're trying to move away from a digital cache so not just replicating cash systems but also when when you're replicating cash systems in a digital context you don't want to introduce the same middlemen that cause the high fees in most digital money

that we interact with I think that's a really good point that you've made there so yeah I think with that said let's just recap very quickly you know how we've what this current state of digital cache is and how we've got here because it's actually quite interesting so again for for context why are we moving to digital cash in addition to what you said you know the use of physical cash is dying significantly so I I saw some really interesting figures uh for the UK in particular so there were apparently 23 million people in the UK which is a very significant portion of of of our small island they they finally didn't use any cash payments in 2021 and thinking back I could well have been one of those people you know in 21 I don't really recall having physical cash in my pocket much lately and there are predictions that you know it's going to go to kind of just six% of Global Payments being uh being noncash based in 10 years which is

it's tiny right that's crazy especially when like I mean I'm bias and it's a bit weird when I think I think of the west as being slightly more digitally Advanced and maybe less economically developed countries the idea of everyone being able to make a digital payment there as well is just crazy like less than 6% that wow that's that's mad and this is a a concern right for central banks is when we're talking about their priority being maintenance of fiscal policy and all this kind of stuff cash is a big part of that and when things get into the private money realm it's slightly well not I mean not just private money but also talk about crypto and all this kind of stuff kind of gets out of their control more and more and I assume they don't like that yeah exactly and and and that that private of the Privacy issue is is becoming huge huge when you have governments now thinking about things like cbdc which we'll come on to but people are

really worried about the Privacy implications of of moving to more and more digital money I mean ironically given what we've just said we should already be quite worried given how much is electronic but it's actually the Advent of these of of CBD season things where people are starting to think well are we going to eliminate physical cash entirely is the system going to move completely into this digital version where maybe in some countries privacy is not going to be uh particularly well preserved in these systems so it's a big topic right now so I understand the perspective of why we'd want digital cash from the user perspective right I I care about my privacy I don't want this private Banks seeing all my transactions and all this kind of stuff I like cash because it's peer-to-peer which is the word we love to use other phrase We love to use peer-to-peer and there's no that also means efficient in a way there's no middlemen but also I get the privacy and security and all this

kind of stuff because of that um and you know you could say the central bank has a responsibility to enable that because they kind of work on behalf of the citizens but the Central Bank also wants digital cash because they want to have some kind of control right still and we're saying that more if more currencies being pushed towards the private sector potentially cryptocurrencies which central banks are opposed to we'll kind of come on to a bit later that's kind of moving outside of their control there it makes it harder for them to regulate fiscal policy right so okay now I understand the motivations of why people want it and why central banks want it yeah exactly and I think yeah the motivations have never been higher than they are right now um so speaking of that you know we're talking about the conditions right now in the world in 2023 but actually people have been thinking about digital cash systems for a very very long time in kind of the 80s as early as

the the 80s and 90s really so one of the very first and very famous examples of a digital cach system was something called uh ecash or it was the company was called digicash by David Chow and he was a a really interesting Pioneer in in in the space of cryptography and digital cach systems and he developed this idea of what we call blind signatures where you know you allow the bank to sign uh messages to sign transactions without knowing exactly what is being transferred and this is kind of a halfway house between having a Central Central issued money but also allowing people to preserve privacy when they transfer it so it's really interesting but it never really completely overcame that barrier of okay you need a central issue with it's always online checking all transactions again back to that word scale scaled terribly and eventually digicash I think went went went bust because it was trying to run this system and and had kind of poor adoption then you also had some kind of early

and again there's there's all these cryptographers that kind of um this band of of of Brothers who were who were developing these systems uh that also inspired satosi Nakamoto but there was also way Die For example he had a protocol called B money which was looking at again looking at digital signatures and how you can use them to to authorize payments and all of these different people who were thinking about various different cryptographic techniques for money for in digital money this all inspired what we saw with Bitcoin and satosi Nakamoto in his white pap paper released in 2008 that that combined loads of these different things right it was heavily inspired by them has references two things like way dies B money in there uh but yeah really Bitcoin is so significant because it was the first system to put all the pieces together and create a digital Cash System that did not need an online Central authority to to validate all the transactions it didn't have this single point of failure risk for monetary

policy like you said we have with central banks and Fiat money and it also enables things like micro payments so it overcomes that that gold bullying fractionalization problem that we said the divisibility so we kind of did all these things at once and that's I think that's why we're in where we are now we're digital cash digital money is so heavily about blockchain and web 3 yeah I like that you kind of you mentioned micro parents as well like we kind of say that digital cash should represent the or replicate the properties of cash buin the digital space but we can really go one step further and actually you know add new characteristics and abilities that we didn't have with cash and we should be able to do that right in the digital space and I think when we go into a bit later when we go into the characteristics of digital cach at a high level we will mention some of the the kind of the reasons or the abilities that digital cach should

have or generally does have and why it's so important in the digital age so really quickly how does digital cache relate to web 3 we kind of touched on it a little bit Jack but in your mind what's the alignment there yeah I me for me it's very clear what I just said in Bitcoin being the very first really successful digital cash implementation that had all the properties that you'd want of a digital Cash System so no Central Point failure low fees to use it uh used all the cryptographic techniques at its disposable disposable at its disposal like digital signatures for examples it it really you know having robust digital cash for the internet and and you know at the time when it was when it came out we'd already gone into the world of paypals and and visas dominating online transactions so for me web 3 is is coming from the same place that Bitcoin was right and and digital cash is just effectively the money we'll use in web 3 and all the

principles around privacy so maintaining user privacy the ownership piece you meant and how you can you can you can have digital money digital cash act as a bearer instrument so you can present me with a Bitcoin transaction that's signed and valid and I can check that um and all I need to know is that that signature is valid I don't need to know who you are I just need to get the transaction in my hands it acts like a barer instrument in that sense and replicates physical cach but in a much more robust way so that they're intrinsically linked to me yeah I like that I like that you you're kind of saying there's a a principal alignment between web 3 and digital cachee it's all around kind of ownership and with ownership comes the Privacy preservation The increased security but there's also the underlying things around interoperability as well and I like that these kind of maybe disparate fields in a way have so much over overlap and alignment and they're kind of maybe

the success of web 3 is kind of completely dependent on the success of a digital cache engine like you say so much of web 3 is based on bitcoin right exactly and I would also say you know efficiency is key I think when when when we think about web three it's very much how can we make processes more efficient and how can we do things in a better way than we could do before and when we talked earlier about physical money and even commodity monies commodity B monies having a digital Cash System is much more efficient than having a physical Cash System you don't have the same cost associated with storage and securing physical assets um you can push things to the edges like we talk about in data sovereignty where people can actually self custody their own funds if they want to so so yeah it's it's highly efficient from a user perspective which is why I think it's it's a very much a web three uh it's a web three tool um yeah

for me and I think the big one that we kind of touch on sometimes is around the pro it's characteristics so kind of maybe getting into it a bit early but the smart contracts and the programability like the idea of being able to you know uh automatically give funds based on some fulfillment of a contract and that comes down to the efficiency stuff right um so uh should we go to chat GPT see if we've uh see if we've covered everything why not yeah let's just round it off with with chat GPT so uh you you go ahead Alec read us out what it thinks so chbt I've asked it to explain digital cach for me and a friend has said digital cach refers to electronic representations of currency used for online transactions in other forms of digital Commerce unlike physical currency digital cash exists only in a digital form making it well suited for online and electronic activities below are some examples that constitute digital cash so we have electronic money or e-money then

cryptocurrencies digital cach and then cbdcs so these are the three types okay that's a that's an interesting one so it's given us three different types apparently yeah and I we we didn't really mention cbdcs specifically as an example of of uh digital cach and we kind of only hinted to it being on the horizon but it very much is another and a whole new classification under this umbrella of digital cash so yeah I think there's actually there's a lot to cover in going through the different types of digital cash you know as you said digital currency uh cryptocurrencies where there's even more different types to talk about like stable coins back to to Fiat and their commodity backed algorithmic back there's so many different types and now cbdcs so I think that will be a really good topic for a second part of this episode and I think this is a sensible place for us to kind of close off we've covered the history um the extensive history of money and cash and now also

of digital cash and I think this is a good place to maybe pause and then we'll go into the details drill down there uh in the next episode so yeah with that we'll say thank you for listening wherever you may be and we'll join you next time to tangle a little more of web thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes