Episode 73

DePIN with Alex Pawlowski

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode of Untangling Web3, we're joined by Alex Pawlowski, an expert in Decentralized Physical Infrastructure Networks (DePIN), to unravel how DePIN is revolutionizing traditional infrastructure systems through blockchain technology, enhancing both efficiency and public accessibility.

Key highlights

  • Understanding DePIN. Alex defines DePIN as the integration of physical infrastructure with decentralized governance, which includes everything from transport systems to energy grids. By leveraging blockchain, these systems promise greater efficiency and public engagement.
  • The Role of Blockchain. Detailed discussion on how blockchain technology underpins the decentralized aspect of DePIN, ensuring transparent and secure transactions within physical infrastructure networks.
  • Real-World Applications. Exploration of practical implementations of DePIN, such as smart grids and decentralized energy production, where individuals not only consume but also produce and distribute resources.

DePIN is set to have a significant impact in pushing forward the transition to renewable energy sources and reducing dependency on centralized power structures.

In this episode, Alex highlights the importance of community involvement and the potential of blockchain to democratize access to essential services, paving the way for a more connected and sustainable future in the physical world through Web3 innovations.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we are thrilled to be joined by Alex palowski a seasoned product strategist with deep expertise in blockchain and web 3 applications today we will be discussing deep in or decentralized physical infrastructure networks quite a marful uh fortunately Alex has been helping companies across real estate food and Manufacturing rethink and revolutionize their process using this technology so without further Ado welcome to the show Alex thanks for having me guys how are you doing today I'm good I'm good it's kind of cold outside but um it's warm in here I'm good to go what about you yeah I'm all good I'm super excited to have you on we've been trying to get this episode done for a while it's a topic that we've not talked about but it is quite an important topic I'm seeing you know this deep in term used more and more thank God as an acronym because it's quite a mouthful so I'm super excited to get an expert on the topic

to come in and actually tell us what it actually means absolutely me deep in is one of these new buzzword that's been around and it's a huge thing I guess um but we'll see you know pick up expectations um as with every technology every new trend U we'll we'll see over time how this unfolds yeah exactly I mean what good is the new technology if we don't have a new acronym for it as well right so yeah why don't why don't we we start off there then by you know just going straight into the 101 of what this term means so deep in decentralized physical infrastructure networks What on earth does that term mean right could you just give us a really basic example maybe and explain how that differs from traditional kind of networks that we have right so we can break it apart I guess so um we have the uh physical side of it and we have the governance side of it because you think of decentralization most people are really puzzled

with what it really means and I think of it as a as a spectrum right so centralization decentralization are spectrums and in my opinion you can really attain one of both it's more like okay how are you positioned right and then you have with these physical networks physical networks of things could be widgets appliances physical things infrastructure and if you look at dpin you have sometimes it's called the decentralization of infrastructure and then public infrastructure so I would look at it as um if you look at an economy we have the three components transport communication energy and then everything that falls under the category could be a radio tower could be Streets Could Be roads could be really anything that you can also digitize because it makes it really worthwhile interesting to look at but then uh Grit right physical grits to uh distribute and generate energy would be interesting um and then the governance side of that and if we now expand um into the decentralized side um it's really about the access for

the public to be closer to that subject so if you say um you're not only a consumer but also a producer in the future um you have a um solar panel on your roof you can now also produce and every excess energy can be sold to other people people or in redistributed and um it's particular interesting because um the government has an interest in that because they struggle with this transition to Renewables if we look at the energy sector and uh you have control energy so there's a surplus and a shortage because it doesn't shine all day and there's rain you can not really foresee what the weather's going to be next week so the government has an interest in the future because we have more people and do you know higher demand in energy and now with new technologies there's a higher demand anyway so uh there must be U you know an interest from the government side in the future to to have these additional points of of success if you will so

not one point of failure as in the past so you have one company to fail and if it fails you know you have a blackout or brown out instead you have different little power generators or radio towers the same applies to the Telo sector I guess yeah I like that I mean the kind of the governance side is it's complicated right we we're going to spend a lot of time probably talking about Dows and how to manage things and how to govern things and how to get consensus and all this kind of stuff but purely like the example you gave there on power like we're in the UK it's probably one of the most cost intensive places in the world to build any big bit of infrastructure any big project like you try and build yeah you try and build a solar panel Farm you try and build I don't know wind farms whatever it is there's a million people that don't want to do it right not in my backyard or nimes as they're

called they don't want these big wind farms in their back Garden but we need to hit Net Zero and more and more we're seeing that these projects need to happen no matter what and I think that's a really good example already that kind of highlights the need for this kind of stuff is if I want to put a solar panel on my roof or in my garden that might be great for me but then what if I have excess the idea that I can then contribute to like a larger hole and say sell it to other people around the country or even start to do like Peak load balancing and all this kind of stuff that's really powerful just that one example already makes sense why this kind of stuff needs to happen yeah yeah and it's um so there's this need you know you have you have always I look always at the supply and demand side um and it's a particular interesting because if we look from the web 3 perspective everything that

happened so far most of it was digital right so of course you have you have data warehouses you have the compute but it gets really interesting when people get drawn uh in because they live in the physical world and they have much more of a relationship also from a you know necessity side okay okay I'm much more interested in real world things because I follow the news I follow you know what happens out in the world and um I can't in the future maybe I can't uh I don't have to blame the government anymore because the power fails I blame the government and now I can actually uh cut out the intermediaries or have a much more closer uh relationship to what happens and then if I invest or provide my energy I'm actually you know from a purpose side I'm I'm closer to the narrative right so when win yeah I mean I really like the the ethos that you're kind of espousing with it I I want to stay on the idea of

you know deep in as a concept because I think already you know you're mentioning web 3 but the kind of what you talked about initially was much more I guess high level conceptual than that so is deep in is it both a concept to do with how we you know democratized governance of existing physical infrastructure and physical infrastructure Network um is it that as well as being a kind of tech Suite that involves other things like maybe web 3 that we'll get into or do they coexist are they kind of one and the same in your mind um as far as I'm concerned I mean there prent projects like helium projects like render um so helium is for wireless network networks um render is for um you know providing access to compute because we will face we already face a shortage of that because AI eats up a lot of um data and also energy and the file con is another one so um storage space uh just to mention three notable projects um so

so web 3 is of course older than deepin deepin just popped up because we have these parallel developments in iot and Industry 4.0 5.0 and this convergence now happens simultaneously so you have ai plus iot you have um uh you know Quantum all these other things and the question really is how they intersect and uh how people can access them so is it just something uh industry professionals large corporations can can do and use and with web 3 you have the democratization because it happen simultaneously on the side and web 3 as you know is basically the internet of value so I love to look at it as the Europe system on the internet to account for things that happen so who did what when and then essentially as the smallest common denominator the the wallet the person that's represented by a digital ID or a wallet and what that person can basically do um and how they can carry back and forth uh their information and their well value how they can gain from

that yeah that makes sense I think I see it in the same way is in that like as you said deep in has emerged much more recently than web 3 as a concept and it seems kind of in my mind at least almost web 3 native right web 3 is the tools and we'll get into kind of more of the detail but those are the tools that people are using to realize the ground Vision the thesis behind deepin which is as you said you know decentralizing these networks making them more robust potentially making people uh incentivized to participate in them um you mentioned filecoin there I think that's a really interesting example because actually that's been around for a long long time a lot longer I think than uh than the term deepin probably has so maybe for for our listeners could you just break down what file coin is as an example of one of these kind of deep in Concepts in action for us so maybe maybe first thing first I'm not I'm

not endorsed or affiliated with fcoin so sure I'm not so I'm I'm a consultant so I didn't introduce myself I'm a consultant I advise big corporations smes and startups how they can make more or anything of decentralized technology and embed that stuff into their business but speaking of filecoin it's it's really um providing access uh to file storage file storage to store things information um and uh it goes both ways so um it's the same with um convence mechanisms if you're if you're a minor for those that don't know right you have this world of consensus mechanisms where you have to uh ensure you ensure the Integrity of a transaction in the blockchain web3 world and in the old world in the old realm there was this P called proof of work where people would mine they would have a Data Center and uh as a as another a token appreciation a reward they would get you know um an incentive a monetary token incentive and now it's more the staking side and this is

basically the same with a file coin but with a different consensus mechanism and with file storage so um it's interesting because if we think of usual assets um we only think about physical things and everything that you you'll find in your in your balance sheet right but the intangibles are particularly interesting in the future if we look look at things as um attention right if we look at the brave project the brave browser if you heard about that and everything that really goes along the lines of what else can an asset be so storage is also one but of course we never thought about storage as an asset because you know there's enough of that used to be that could change in the future that could change in the future as with compute because again my um training data um at some point in 26 I read about that 26 27 28 we would run out of training data and this could very well happen um also with the with the shortage in in materials

driven by this new shift of a multipolar world very interesting I'm glad you brought up um Brave like we so we actually had someone on the show from Brave the topic was web 2.5 and kind of bridging you know what is now the current web with what could be the future of the internet and I kind of see this is somewhat to do with that like you're kind of linking traditional Technologies traditional infrastructures with some of the components of web 3 to kind of create this Middle Ground of the two um so we kind of touched on like some of the issues that you know deepin is trying to address but you know why is it such a game changer because you really highlight some of the fundamental problems that we're seeing right now with traditional infrastructure that this is really trying to revolutionize well the I think the most interesting thing is um that we can finally access um all the physical devices and coordinate them so if you think of cars you know

the shift to renewable cards but especially autonomous driven cars uh robots once they enter the workforce um especially um in lower level tasks dangerous tasks there's this 4ds uh dull dangerous dirty and deer I think that's the 4ds um it's it's quite interesting to look at um how because there's so much resource outside and not in the hands of companies and authorities because everybody owns something but how can that actually help to serve a higher cause right so the energy transition is one as such example there's always this Narrative of people or by people when they say okay what is it that I small person can do uh to improve the the the state of the status quo um so I think that whatever it is that you can contribute and it's the same with right hailing right or right sharing if you can just have resources that sit idle not in your garage but at home um or in your attic right if you if you own stuff and you're not aware what your

what you own but you can actually plug it into the system that can for somehow work for you for some benefit and um but it's the same that already works with computes so there already projects out there like go mining um where you can actually earn rewards by providing your idle uh compute so if you your laptop runs all day 247 or just for the day eight hours and you use it effectively for five hours you can you know just you know let it turn on the application earn rewards and give away the compute for three hours so that's something that you can already effectively do and then research projects or other applications on a higher level on higher magnitude can tap into that and uh utilize it and so so it's basically you can you can it's particularly interesting because you can tap into a lot of tiny points of resource instead of just one company owning everything and that's the decentralization side so one makes sense that's the access part so people have

access they get aay on a lower level and then the other thing is the um the governance right so I think I think I think that's a very particularly interesting yeah I like that I think like you kind of democratizing and distributing access to kind of create lots of little points that can all contribute to a hole is always a good thing not even not just for the community buying stuff to make people feel a part of something but also when we start to talk about the tenant of blockchain this kind of overlaps that a lot right you're REM we have a big problem with monopolies in the UK over water transport all these kind of things so if you start to have other options built up of lots of individuals then you start to get an increased resilience right if one of those small individuals goes down that's actually fine have a million other individuals that can contribute it and yeah the other thing is yeah reducing the Reliance of monopolies which hopefully creates

a more competitive and eventually cheaper market and we're talking a lot about blockchain here so in my mind I'm kind of seeing this as two general overarching areas you've got the blockchain stuff which kind of handles the the value exchange for some service and then the idea of governance tokens and all this kind of stuff and the way you actually democratize stuff and then you've got the hardware side the physical assets which is kind of you talked about iot to manage it but there's probably something that's a bit further down the line which is like the know the actual water source or whatever is there any like more granularity there or those two kind of high level areas about right well we would have to look at a particular value change and break it down really I mean there's so much well let me start the other side because we're speaking on from a very idealistic point of view um there's a lot that you can digitize but there's I mean your toaster doesn't need

Wi-Fi I think we can agree your toaster yeah maybe one day doesn't yeah it doesn't need Wi-Fi so um there there's a lot of stuff there's there's still a lot of friction that will result from this but what it does is basically it creates a larger Network an ecosystem of of of things that can coordinate and cooperate together and um as I said before some of these challenges that we Face uh there's no other way than just looking at the entire um landscape the entire as I said the ecosystem of of value because back in the old days you know in the in the in the old world you had a couple companies that would create value by you know chopping down wood for and then they would just burn the wood and you know create energy and use that energy to power uh I don't know um your chimney or your your furnace your car and now it's it's a whole different level where we uh are more aware of what's happening in the

world and we can you know uh uh um control the system maneuver the system in in in these ways but I would I would say it's it it really requires to look particularly into the value chain of energy or transport or um um or any other industry to to Really uh uh look at what what makes sense what doesn't and I wouldn't be also too idealistic about um decentralizing as I said before this word very magical but I would instead search for the uh largest common in nominator interoperability is also such a thing that you can combine because the government will never allow to decentralize everything right so we're not living in an anarch capitalistic state or anarchistic system that's not going to happen so the state has an interest because uh it's deals with power it has to do with power uh existence or or you know those kind of things power interests and geopolitical interests so um but what it can do is it can create like a second resource or it can

prevent this single source of failure I think governments and institutions are very aware of that that's a really interesting point you bring up there so like you say a lot of this deep in stuff is I imagine applied to like fundamental infrastructure like water electricity things that governments have you know they have have to keep intact right and if all of a sudden I'm saying I'm putting this on a public blockchain right and say a large percentage of say the UK's Now power supply is based on let's say something like ethereum right all of a sudden the UK government's going well this is very much out of my control but I don't know who these actors are who are controlling this that could be I'm not saying it could be because actually really difficult to do but it could be overthrown by like a foreign agent whatever with lots of money is this something that like is being aled about in the deepen infrastructure does it limit the applications of this stuff like you say

if the governments are so heavily involved in this it does intersect with Smart City initiatives you know smart Dubai is one such example I mean I heard this in conversation um and some jurisdictions and governments are not well Democratic so it's um not that difficult to imagine what that means but um I think there's still um a lot of room in between um in in Smart City initiatives there's a lot of open data if you're were concept so that information that is captured directly or indirectly um and then provide it to the to the public for for uh secondary use so um like City Furniture For example or um C lighting or um uh you know that that kind of information information weather information pressure temperature sensoring and then so so that's completely I think in between in line with what a government wants improving the uh level of quality well-being I think that's that that really plays in the hands of a government but when it comes to anything that would undermine the the

legitimacy of a government that wouldn't be it wouldn't be very interesting I guess it wouldn't be yeah yeah it's a really interesting aspect of deeping right because I think maybe more so than lots of other Technologies you have in in and around the web 3 space right now I feel like deepin has its its physical let's say challenges or the technology challenges right which are being addressed with various things but it is it's inherently complex because as you saying you've got everything from the actual kind of blockchainbased networks that help monitoring and distributing rewards and things like that in the system you you need to connect that with the iot world and smart cities to get the data in maybe oracles too so there's a lots of technical challenges but to me I almost think what you're highlighting there is probably the bigger one right is how do you how do you get these things off the ground bootstrapped get them adopted because as you say the interests of the people who own most of

these networks currently aren't necessarily uh aligned with the people who want to you know us basically the people who want to build these kind of secondary networks as you describe them so you know what kind of what kind of ways do you think these networks can achieve success like what kind of strategies could people employ for these these new ways of doing deep in networks that can help them kind of gain that Network effect and kind of Go Global thanks for mentioning LK effects that's uh I think the most misunderstood concept out there when it not only it's it's within within blockchain outside blockchain when we think of ecosystems um so we start from we have apps when we have uh platforms and then platform economy is well understood but then ecosystems of platforms and everything Beyond is is very difficult to grasp and uh um derive value from so with network effects the way I look at it and I wrote an article about this I would compare to a city and the incentive

for an individual institution or any other entity to settle in that City so you and I if we if we moved to the UK or if I moved to the UK for me it was you know a no-brainer because I studied I had this spot where I studied in in London then I worked in London but there was then the question okay where do I settle next do I even settle anywhere for you the question is do you uh just leave another place because electricity cost is cheaper somewhere else probably not you you have different other opportunities you can just switch to provider but then if um the the uh the quality of life is better air quality everything uh etc etc living costs and then you know infrastructure etc etc uh and then your salary your wage has an increase there's an increase to that um I think um it's it's the same here so Network effects derive when people gather so volume uh of people in one place and um enough things to

do for enough people in other words if you project it to a platform and then um they interact in a way that it benefits the most of these people so if you have a Public Square in a city and people move to London because oh wow there's Big Ben a lot of history a lot of British culture and then also your job and then there's you know your I don't know your belief your religion then there's a lot of pubs and there's you know University and then all these other uh historic things and Friends of course you know your family so that builds Network effects because it gives people no more reasons to interact and if we project and if we now transfer that to the it's no no different um so uh creating the conditions um and requirements that a lot of people flock in and then they can derive maximum value from it so in the network effect fashion more people know and interact with more people and then the um value that

uh is is generated increases that makes sense I think like that's what was one of my first like kind of hesitations with this stuff you're talking about you know selling solar panel solar power everywhere or Uber and all this kind of stuff that kind of democratize access to these things but you know if you got one person with a a car who's doing Uber that that's not a successful app right so the big thing he here is buying and the question is how do you get buying both on the actual kind of consumer side but also on the producer side right and I think like it's kind of a lot of the appeal here has to be more than just it's a d right you see it everywhere it's a d oh cool everyone gets to vote on things like blah blah blah doesn't always mean anything that you always need a bit more than that to justify the blockchain angle in my mind like I think a really cool application here we're talking about

energy and reselling energy I'm like okay why is a blockchain good for reselling energy yeah it democratizes stuff but you could probably just do that in a Web Two fashion a cool thing here in my mind would be okay green energy carbon credits all this kind of stuff we've seen that there's been a whole host of issues with carbon credits sold around the world that aren't authentic that are duplicated triplicated all these kind of things like they've been made many many times over and none of it's actually from the source and authentic a big thing here is you know put it all on the public blockchain sure there's some trickiness with you need iot that's also verified you need someone to be signing off to say this is the only authenticated bit there but then you do get a way to actually easily sell stuff once you've got that proof authentication in a database that's open that anyone can check and verify so in my mind that's a really good application of this stuff green

energy and carbon credits in a deep in fashion do you have any like you know you've been Consulting in this space for a while you've got lots of different news cases are there any like real killer applications that you can think of that really marry this idea of like the hardware and the iot side plus the blockchain the governance side to really make like a true deep in system that works uh um I would say it's not even in Europe it's not even in Europe um it's it's waste disposal um some of these really critic I would point to Southeast Asia I was involved with something and it has to do with um getting rid of all the plastic from the ocean and from the environment and um yeah um I think I think this really points also to the big application fields or why why we even need decentralization for anything decentralization's potential really folds if you have a high degree of complexity that you can tackle um with the centralized system or just

one because coordination completely fails so there's no possible and then emergency emergency so if the system uh breaks down or if you look at uh a particular disaster relief right disaster relief for disaster management now in the US this this hurricane speak big storm and then setting something in place that can mobilize all the resources so everything's you know the whole system broke down you have no infrastructure you have no communication internet no nothing's available and now you need to help people and mobilize resources so how do you do that and um but that's just one example one example was involved was the was the TR trash and garbage removal um aspect Al can you can you explain that one like I don't I I'm trying to work out how that actually works as a solution like I don't get it right now yeah so so in Europe we're very used to a lot of Standards there's not even the question to not have a standard or a system for something so um like if

you return your plastic here in the Netherlands or in Germany you you're incentiv for that you get like you pay a premium of 25 cents per plastic bottle and then you throw it into the vending machine if you upon upon um return and then you receive the the coupon then you can redeem the money get it back and um it works in in a very similar way but you have The Ledger and your ID in between and um you have also all these to um get incentivized non-financially or financially so I think nonanal stuff is very interesting because you get more insights into what happens how the um garbage is removed what happens with the plastic because that's a concern to people um and then you can have a say uh in what to do with the plastic how to further develop system um make decisions uh and then also get a reward get a get a discount for public transport for a long time there was I forget if it was uh Indonesia I

can't remember but um you could pay with plastic you could literally your plastic and buy a bus ticket with plastic like in a bag it's insane but um it works in similar ways so you have again in that particular example I was in M with it was a high degree in complexity a lot of mess so crash and then building a system where a lot of people can be actually back cleaners to the system where they can bring you know they they pick up they pick the the trash because paying a lot of people would you know take forever and the government doesn't have the money so instead you turn the people into servants in a way but incentivize them for good behavior and this this is also a way i i i two years ago I was involved in a in a Civic project that you funded and I coined the term um stimulation by participation I called it that because I discovered I'm not even a scientist but we wrote this book and

we worked on this model city called faap City so Global local production Global collaboration um and I I figured out that if you um give people access and all the necessary means you can build a platform where people can actually work for you but only as long as you put a strict purpose at the core of the platform if you say it's for profit then people will not do anything they will just in web two fashion come in they will get what they need for instance an insurance log out again and eventually we'll come back but probably not we have three it's different because we have all these NGO and for purpose uh projects and if people are very aware and know exactly what they're working towards you can break it down you can say okay you only have uh two hours per day you have um the resarch you have a car fine you have a bike you know you can also do something for against climate change on a on a very low

level but um and it's the same with the trash so um everybody can bring as much trash uh and and turn it into uh or or turn it in um as as possible one hour per day time or or 10 hours so it doesn't make a difference really yeah I do I completely agree with that kind of um the concept that at the end of the day like we are quite tribal as humans right and like the tribe that's formed bigger civilizations is like stories and like things that connect us and values and all this kind of stuff you can you can sell a story in a value people really will buy into that and be part of that and capitalism is kind of one story but less and less people kind of you know driven that yeah don't get me wrong I'm I'm I'm also a capitalist but I try to improve capitalism Beyond it very primitive uh roots and I would love to see something like it um so I'm a realist really

I really look at the system okay what can we effectively do with what we have and where we are at the moment right so it's exactly what you said it's um that's the point and honestly yeah I'm a capitalist too I believe that like money what makes the world go around the way but like when you see these startups and like the kind of the real startups where it's like two or three people they're not always they're typically not driven by money right they're driven by a mission like something that they think is their like from God calling and they're the people that really changed the world and you know a lot of it is also capitalism somewhere else but like I think sometimes it is the story but back oh we're getting really off topic here we're talking about on The Ledger and this this project to do with rubbish like I actually kind of really do get that as well especially when you're in say southeast Asia where I imagine the real kind

of value ad of blockchain Technology there is kind of twofold in my mind one is that okay a lot of the people a lot of the things that are being that are contributing to the trash in the ocean are from Western countries they the Coca-Cola bottles the the Pepsi Max bottles the Cris packets and more and more we're seeing that these companies are being regulated and held accountable for actually producing this stuff and not having no not actually doing anything about the waste that it's creating I imagine one thing we could start to do is if you have like unique identifiers for the trash can or whatever not trash can sorry the the Coke can and say okay well this is now ended up in Indonesia and it's been recycled and you can start to monetize the Recycled Coke can and Link it back through you know a blockchain to say okay this has been recycl it's monetized back by the original creator and producer of that that's one reason we might need to have

this public Ledger that can go you know cross Globe cross Enterprise the immutability the immutability of the accounting so as I said before a lot of people are disillusioned because they heard the term decentralization they as we are as humans we always go to the max right to do the most extreme oh decentralization it's all going to be unrelated you can't touch it but it will work wonders right um it's not what it is it's as I said in the beginning it's it's a spectrum it's it's a spectrum and part of it are decentralized part of it are less decentralized because you can never take out the people and the and the ways people can mingle or interfere with the system like these 50 1% attacks and then all the problems that you mentioned beginning with with with Dows right so user engagement is a problem power distribution is not a problem incentives are another problem and I think um we didn't really touch the incentives because I think I I dropped off there a

little with the with the network effects but in particularly non Financial incentives are interesting so if I for instance again the example with southeast Asia if I collect one kilo of or one pound of plastic on Monday uh or every week for a month I can get 10% off if I buy a bus ticket for another month right so these these kind of interesting um non-financial incentives where people say you know what it's actually very useful I could do that every month every day and uh also have a benefit if I if I continue doing so so again this stimulation by participation thing you don't you're not forced to do something you stimulate you stimulated because you have incentive and this is also something that puts off people because they think ah gamification gamification it's manipulation you can't do that with right and I get that a lot I get it a lot and I think okay then what's What's it gonna be like what else like there's there's nothing else you can't really make

it I mean natural I mean this is too much of a big problem the big the problems too large there's no natural solution to this right yeah we create this problem in unnatural way because you know we we developed over Millennia and millions of years and our impact on the world has um exceeded what we can actually afford to do right so we can destroy the system of the words other Primal animals I know I'm diverting a little but we can actually we're the first creatures that can actually destroy their habitat and their ecosystem for good and I think it's interesting you say you know people criticize gamification but no one's forcing you to play the game at least not now anyway right it's it's and I think gamification has huge merits like there's a lot of research behind the the power of it and and the the way it can you know yeah compel real real change but also um you were mentioning that it's not about punitive action it's about stimulation right it's

about positive incentivization we spoke about this with with sunny as well recently on the show I think it's really powerful and you know it's something that we're seeing more and more like the the scheme you mentioned with recycling I think is a perfect example one of my favorite use cases we have a similar thing coming in in in Scotland and the UK I always mentioned this one where you're doing exactly the same deposit and reward scheme right it's going to happen I don't think it's using deep in in like the web three way but hopefully hopefully it will at some point um and another thing I think is really really interesting as a use case of deepin is actually it's kind of around data sharing and especially in in industrial situations so I actually had uh the kind of the fortune to speak to to a friend who is working in the kind of supply chain sector in kind of procurement and they really enlightened me like blew me away with the lack of information

that's shared between people you know who should be working together right that they're in a trade with they should be explaining and I'm talking about things like scheduling so if you're a producer of a raw material they are going to be selling every month to to some uh some some Downstream contractor or something you know they need a raw material but they won't tell them until it's almost too late to do it and you have this just in time manufacturing cycle if they could just be broadcasting their their their um expected intake and usage a bit ahead of time then this could be done so much more efficiently you don't have to you know have a Lor's going and doing a single delivery and going back empty that kind of thing right it's really really wasteful so that's one of my favorite use cases thank thanks for saying that I I I totally you inspired me to to to say the following I um what what the blockchain really does and that's interesting is it

um it makes you more aware of transaction effects it makes Mak you more aware of consequences because as you know the transaction can only happen if the information level the Symmetry is complete so the information symmetry as you said so in the real world human behavior is I mean intentionally not intentionally sometimes a little manipulative or you just wait things out you defer the process because you know you want to I don't know have the upper hand but also you forget and and you have all these deficiencies human deficiencies but then with blockchain it's the case is you you have a complete state of information because um you have these contracts they can only trigger if you meet these requirements and the effect on uh transactions effects transaction effect is Al also very interesting because you have search cost negotiation costs all these relationships between people and the question is how this will long term I find this really fascinating how this will change or can you know benefit Society if we are more aware

of what we're doing and would we rather not do something I mean this can also go the other way this can also have detrimental effects because what about um entrepreneurial risk risk-taking this is very irrational too this is something I find very interesting yeah speaking of things that you know we find interesting you I see you on LinkedIn a lot that's how actually this conversation came about and a lot of the time you're talking about AI so we we have to have a question on you know what could be the impact of integrating AI you know broad stroke AI with deep in like how do you think this might shake the future I would say generally speaking all the uh deficiencies that would also be interesting to observe without uh decentralization like making things more efficient adjusting uh adjusting uh deficient systems making up for human deficiencies like error control or issue handling um and then all the analytics stuff um that's very interesting and then what we're now uh looking at is the autonomous

agent um uh Frontier where these systems like for the audience like a programmable Bots that can basically break beyond the proprietary system and I and I teach this at University because most people say oh well this is just you know a more efficient intelligent Alexa well it's not because it can go beyond Amazon you you can provide it with access to your keychain and can say okay like your assistant make a call on Monday at 8: am. in the morning schedule me an appointment at my hairdresser and then take the credentials from my banking account and then wire money a wire $88,000 to account B and then you can all do all these things and they can themselves trigger new or other systems that are more proficient at what they do so this is something I think is very interesting because we have now these systems that interact without the interference of people and of course they can you know replace they can augment people this is very interesting sometimes they can even interact because

the speed and the frequency is too high like an iot if you have a system that that triggers a database and you have these thousands of data pieces of information that go back and forth and there's of course no person in between you need a smart contract or something to account for who's responsible if something fails or ensuring it doesn't fail like if Bosch or simmens have these uh these these these waves and networks of of sensors I mean there has to be something in between that yeah I think I think that whole conversation about almost like AI agents right being able to go out and do task for you is super super interesting and now that you've even got uh these High Fidelity voices that you can model you can have them go and do all your kind of talking as well at some point um what really scared me the other day is seeing don't if you've seen this one there's uh something now that where you can create a podcast based on

a document have you seen this one LL notebook I think the Google whatever I spend a lot of time just putting my info in there and getting like the satisfaction of it telling me the things I've done in a nicer way yeah I mean it really depressed me when I did ex I was like well this is they're doing a better job than we are in the podcast and they're not even real but um yeah think to be quite fair with the with the developments in AI I mean this this doesn't nor relate dpin and um a blockchain I think um a lot of people I think a lot of people are afraid but I think I think the answer is somewhere in the middle I mean we have these natural bottlenecks and of course you have uh billions of dollars that flow into investment to uh ramp up uh data data warehouses and train find training data but eventually we will we will run out of that because we have of course regulations that

really um you know put a bumper in front of you know this this endless hunger for these train models and um and then um we also have uh again the same example as with the toaster the Wi-Fi toaster um people don't want everything to include to include Ai and I think I read about this it was a apple or another tech company they're developing a new device to make usability uh or accessing AI easier so they don't find thesei researchers in companies they don't find that the laptop or the smart glass not sure about the smartass class but the smartphone it's not the end game for AI it's going to be either like ubiquitous somewhere integrated in the walls when everything is you know a computer or there going to be another device that people will wear or H or hold in their pocket and you know access the AI so um and then the other thing is um I mean I see it in my my everyday work um I have very well uh

automated way and augmented at least 40% nearly 50% of my workload and I can do more it's not that I really miss that stuff because it's really daunting stuff it's um I can search faster I can evaluate faster I can generate content but I teach this that's what I teach my student I tell okay you need to be careful you really need to check the result and then see it more as a because AI is about asking the question it's about context exactly and you draw the window and within the window you ask the questions and if you can't ask the questions you you basically it's it's useless right so still need to be an engine enger and and undergo this education Engineering in order to know what it means to build a fundament or you know build a roof or uh be knowledgeable about Statics and all these other research Fields yeah it's uh it's very true that you know it's going to put Power in the hands of those who can ask the

right questions and speaking of asking the right questions Alex so thank you so much for you know your time today and giving us this crash course into deep in which is one of these you know topics that I think a lot of will be new to a lot of people but you know whether or not they've heard the term so thank you for that um and just to finish then so on these questions that we like to ask um we have two kind of standard ones that we ask everyone so if you're ready I'll fire the first one at you okay sure so in one sentence in just one sentence because we've had plenty of people be liberal with this one before um what is web 3 to you the internet of value very nice I like that I I think it's the old ones are the gold ones right like that's one of the I think how Ripple used to describe it so yeah I like that too that's true and one word would

be more difficult but I can't do that like web free one word that's so hard yeah it becomes more cringe the fewer words so it's okay um awesome and then the final question then Alex so if you could choose anyone on the planet now from throughout history or maybe it's even someone fictional that you'd like to talk to and you get sit down with them over dinner and talk about web 3 who would that be for you and why it we want of you guys ni let's do it each nice but yeah Alex it's been an absolute pleasure having you on the show I'm glad we finally got to have this happen um thank you for joining us and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time to untangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast

provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes