Episode 19
Decentralization
About this episode
In this episode of Untangling Web3, Alec Burns and Jack Davies navigate through the intricate world of decentralization within Web3 technologies, explaining its pivotal role in crafting systems without a single point of failure and distinguishing it from mere distribution.
The hosts probe into the mechanics of blockchain networks, spotlighting how miners exert control and influence changes, while also debunking prevalent myths that equate decentralization with anti-government stances. Instead, they champion the viewpoint that entities managing decentralized networks should be accountable and transparent in their operations.
The duo also explores the evolution of Bitcoin mining from an individualistic activity to an arena dominated by corporate entities and influential mining pools, emphasizing that decentralization reconfigures trust from intermediaries to the technology itself. Despite the aggregation of hash power, the control over transactions and block templates remains concentrated with the coordinating entity of mining pools. They praise Bitcoin's inherent competitive and resilient nature, against centralized systems like Visa and Mastercard.
Navigating through consensus mechanisms, Alec and Jack scrutinize the competition involved in both Proof of Stake (PoS) and Proof of Work (PoW) systems. The hosts argue the necessity of adept regulations for companies navigating the decentralized tech space, referencing the SEC’s definition which highlights the absence of control by any singular or cohesive group. The discussion concludes with reflections on open protocols, indispensable for Web3 development, thereby ensuring transparency and avoiding the centralized dominion observed in Web2 platforms.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
where there was this accidental chain split because there was a network upgrade there was an incompatibility between the old version of the software the new version and people didn't like that and they said well let's just roll it back and they did you know so Bitcoin we say this immutable decentralized Ledger was rolled back and and completely reverse the state of The welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast hello Jack how you doing this fine evening yeah very well thanks Alec I noticed we're uh we're both in our our Jedi and Padawan outfits tonight you know in the spirit of Ahsoka airing at the minute H yeah how are you doing yeah I'm good it's obviously winternet it's getting cold so we started wearing hoodies rather than paying the bills um it's more like Jedi and Sith I think you're looking a bit evil to be honest you should have said hello there at the start and that would have been much funnier such a terrible terrible reference but I love it
um yeah so today's episode is an interesting one I can see Jack smiling he's super excited to talk about this one today we're talking about another controversial decentralization yeah this is a a really I think it's really interesting actually and it is a bit controversial because again lots of different opinions on it um but that's why I'm glad we're covering it I think uh I think we'll we'll be able to tease out a bit of a definition and and explain the various viewpoints on it so um yeah I mean I maybe I should go first this time because I always put you on the spot aleec and then try and explain what decentralization is um so for me it it's quite simple actually if if something is decentralized then you normally use the the term to describe a system so like something like Bitcoin or blockchain is a system it has rules and participants in it and decentralization is the quality of a system that it doesn't have a central point of failure and to
me that's pretty much the the the main definition you should use for for this term yeah I think it's nice nice and concise and simple and you're telling me that decentralization isn't about anarchism and you know anti- Elite and anti-government all this kind of stuff I feel like that's what you're alluding to but no I'm being factious um Jack's right decentralization I think is kind of misused in a a lot of this space and they think the word the word really is more of a in my mind anyway the way I use it is from the technical kind of perspective and if we're thinking about decentralization applies to blockchains or you know cryptocurrencies with the last episode we did how it applies to that it's all about Distributing The Ledger The Ledger which is you know we can describe it as that Excel sheet that stores all the transactions having multiple copies of that Excel sheet or that ledger at different points and you know different people different entities different nodes PCS whatever you want
to call them and that effectively means resilience right so if when Jack talks about single point of failure if I just have one version of my Excel sheet and all of a sudden my computer goes down and gets wiped that Excel Sheet's gone forever but if I have 10 versions of that Excel sheet all with the exact same copy all live all working together to make sure they're running the exact same Excel sheet and one of them goes down well that's fine I've got nine backups so there's no single point of failure and that's what Jack is trying to talk or get across when he says single point of failure right jack yeah exactly um and I think it's really interesting that you use the word distributed there as well because this is there's a very fine distinction between decentralization and distrib distribution or something that's decentralized versus just distributed because um I think we tend to use the word decentralized in the context of kind of open permissionless systems like blockchains where you have
people can come and come and leave and it's it's an open protocol um and decentralization because there are different flavors of decentralization actually as well we'll come on to but um really the meaningful sense is kind of decentralization of power so who has the power to to update the blockchain for example who has power to to change the system and this if something is distributed it's more tends to mean in in the flavor of it's like a distribution of resources um having backup to the local copies and Bitcoin does a bit of this both but you can have a distributed system that is centralized from a powered perspective you know like if you think of something like Facebook or Twitter or Amazon they they are operating massive distributed systems because they have servers and and and uh data centers across the world which are kind of keeping local backups and things so so you know decentralization for me is much is much more apt in a in an open blockchain type context got you so
like my understanding of the white paper which is obviously the Bitcoin white paper is that actually doesn't use the term decentralization right but it does use the term distributed is that correct I think so yeah it's an interesting observation don't pretend like you don't know it word for word like pretend you think so it's on his wall somewhere I think yeah yeah well you know I have to be Co about these things but yeah I do know pretty well it talks about the word honest much more than it talks about um anything like decentralization and and actually that's an interesting point is that a lot of people when they talk about Bitcoin and and similar blockchain systems they I I've often heard people say the whole point of Bitcoin is decentralization they say it's the the end right and and and and or this they might sometimes just say it's the means to the end as well but they say that's the core point of it and I have always thought of decentralization as more
of an emergent property so Bitcoin has this design that enables you know peer-to-peer electronic cash and as a result of how it's designed it is it is always decentralized in in the power sense it's not like oh it must be decentralized and that's the end goal no it's the end goal is digital cash and as a result of doing that properly it it ends up having to be decentralized well this is something actually do want to talk about in more detail so you're saying that Bitcoin has to be decentralized you know I think when you talk about the the kind of the power and Power in say a blockchain network or a Bitcoin or any of cryptocurrencies we tend to talk about power people think that you know power is decentralized and all the people are contributing to the network if you own a Bitcoin then you are part of the parody dnamic that runs the Bitcoin Network right and then what was that thing about um Raspberry Pi is you can mine the Raspberry
Pi and you can contribute to the network but this is this isn't true is my understanding it's that it's actually the miners who control the network right they are effectively the people in power and when everyone says if you've got any Bitcoin or you're running a rasb p and you're contributing to the the BTC Network that's not in fact true it's the miners and it's far more centralized than people think if you've got 10,000 you know nodes on BTC or whatever it is really all the mining power that's actually the the network administrators who are contributing to that ledger we can think about the miners as being the people that actually own the Excel files and are appending to the Excel files to update The Ledger and contribute to the Ledger using proof of work they're actually the people with the per so it's far less decentralized than people tend to think yeah exactly and this is this is where that kind of main controversy comes in is people will sometimes Define decentralization of a
blockchain as the number of people who are uh effectively using the node software who are running software that interacts with the blockchain essentially and can validate the blockchain but really and and the opposite view that I subscribe to is that as you said the only people that really matter in terms of the upkeep of Bitcoin upkeep of The Ledger are the miners the ones who are expending energy proofer work that they're kind of putting uh they've got skin in the game for the maintenance of The Ledger under the rules so some people will say you know the the metric that is important for decentralization is the number of people who run node software whereas I I think it's very much it's just the number of nodes that are actually creating blocks who are exerting proof of work and one of the arguments because I really can't buy the the first argument about you know the people just running the node software and people will say oh well we're still involved we're still we're still important
to the system even if I run this software on a raspber pi a really low powerered kind of device uh that's not that's not doing proof of work they'll say it's still important because I can validate the blockchain I can check that everything's correct and then the question I always have is okay okay well if something isn't correct what can you do about it right yeah because if you're not producing blocks you can't affect the system and that's why decentralization only really applies to the node Network the miners themselves because they can actually enact change if there something goes wrong yeah just imagine this like guy living in his basement with a Raspberry Pi thinking that he's contributing to the mining of like Bitcoin and then going to one of these like mining Farms that's worth like however many billions and say look no no actually this transaction wasn't valid can you please update that they like no way I mean the whole question is though and actually this brings me on to the next
point is that when people think this is another kind of misunderstanding I think is when people think decentralized and this kind of applies to Dows as well it's like they T tend to think of like anti-government and outside the Realms of Regulation and this is not true like especially with say maybe proof of work systems and maybe other systems similar where you have quite public facing entities like to be a big actual contributing minor to BTC you've got to have a huge mining setup right and to have a setup that's that big you have to also have like be probably quite a public facing easy identifiable body and with that kind of thing like you should also be held to like legal account right and I think there's a lot this misunderstanding decentralized means that no one's held accountable it's distributed amongst all the people but if we're saying these miners are big entities that are actually running the show it's far more centralized than we think then these miners should be held to account
and it doesn't seem like they are right now in a lot of spaces yeah I I agree um it's a difficult one because yeah a lot of them are corporate entities and I I know at least a few Miners and Mining pools have been you know like uh publicly traded companies so they have also fiduciary duties to their their shareholders and things so yeah I think that's something that will mature actually a lot in the future is what of the obligations on uh these entities the nodes which are act actively maintaining the network who are trade blocks and and who are contributing to the meaningful definition of decentralization that that is is useful I mean this this kind of we've got Emma pus in the chat with a really interesting FAQ that often gets leveled I think is like can blockchain actually exist without decentralization I mean what do you think about that do you have a do you have do you have a take on it I think well there are well alleged blockchains
that do exist that aren't decentralized like I could quite easily have three separate computers that are either all in my house they're all separate Miners and say I've got a decentralized network but even if those you know three computers are you know 10 times the compu or th say a million times the computer P we've got some serious hash power if they're all controlled by an entity like me then if we're saying decentralization is all about the power Dynamic and I am the power Dynamic and I run all those minors then it's not properly decentralized right and then even if like those computers who are mining are in different countries but they're still owned by me that this is not deenal I've seen there's been like a lot of Publications do looking into how decentralized are a lot of these top cryptocurrency networks and all this kind of stuff and they've got a thousand proper miners you H but these thousand miners are all run by the same company or you know subsidiaries of this
company it seems like yeah I think people would describe them as decentralized quite easily but it's the par Dynamic actually it doesn't really make sense if it's not separate individual entities without maybe shared goals that don't work together and interact right yeah exactly um and I I'm aware of the kind of reports you're mentioning like there was an interesting study published I think it was actually commissioned by the Pentagon in in the US um and and they they did this report into what is you know how decentralized is Bitcoin in practice and they kind of found that it's maybe not so decentralized but I think we'll come back to that point after um you you you mentioned there kind of mining pools and things as well and that's another dimension to this so one of the you know we've talked about miners as as kind of these individuals like corporate entities so far uh and obviously to take it all the way back to the beginning of Bitcoin it wouldn't actually have been like that
it was in the beginning people in their in their bedrooms being able to mine because the hash rate was so low um and it's the difficulty of mining has increased exponentially over time but now yeah it's corporate entities but you do have this what one kind of subcategory of miners which are called mining pools right and these are entities that uh they they effectively aggregate hash power from many different sources so that's how you as an individual might be involved in Bitcoin mining is you might contribute your your hashing power your electricity power to one of these mining pools but again you're still not uh contributing the the the power in the system because uh the political power or the rule making power um or rule enforcing power I should say in the system because effectively the the the coordinator the the corporate entity that's kind of making most of the money here will be defining okay what transactions go in that block which transactions are valid and just giving uh a block template that
they say is valid to yeah to these hashing entities and say just hash on that you don't care what's in that block let me worry about that um but yeah but the point on that would be like if I contribute and then all of a sudden I don't like what this part is doing that controls you know mining pool I can pull out right so isn't that like voting with my feet in a way and say okay well I'm going to move to a different mining pool because I don't agree with this this this transaction you just mind I'm not saying that happens but that is an right yeah and that is that is a subtlety right it's true if you are if you are pointing your hash rate at one provider then you can you can move it to another but that it is true that you never are an active decision maker you know you could go to a different one that is in a kind of collusion or cartel with with the
one you were with previously and uh and you still can't make the rules unless you're kind of independently um mining blocks so yeah it's uh it's a difficult one there are a lot of subtleties involved in in in decentralization and I think one of the other things that we kind of touched on earlier about the anti-government agenda which I think is kind of inherent with this term like when people think of decentralization they think of like big the biggest Central authorities which you know in a lot of ways a governments and all this kind of stuff and I think that they kind of see crypto currencies and all the ter all the things around decentralization as a means to remove trusted intermediaries and I I think that is completely it's impossible in my mind still like sure we can interact in a peer-to-peer fashion for very small transactions because there's not much skin in the game and all this kind of stuff and maybe I just need you to give me an address and all
this kind of stuff but for like a lot of interactions we have we're always going to need a trusted intermediary to facilitate that like if I don't know you are Jack Davis and you've been given this you know passport by the UK um by the UK government or you've got this bank account that I can send money to and all this kind of stuff it's really difficult for us to interact and the only way to facilitate that kind of peer-to-peer interaction especially like we go talking about larger transactions and more important day-to-day usage we do need some kind of intermediate or certificate authority to initiate that trust I think one of the things that I want to emphasize around decentralization is it's not a complete removal of all intermediaries and definitely not of all trusted parties it's a kind of a push from the complete Reliance of those trusted intermediaries in every single step to an initial trusted step and then we push the trust from them to the technology itself they propagate the trust
initially and give us the tools to trust one another but then we push our interactions and The Trusted interactions onto the technology itself yeah I kind of would go I I really like the way you described that and I kind of go one further you know I do know the white paper quite well and it and it talks about removing unnecessary intermediaries right so it's not saying that third parties and intermediaries aren't important I think it's actually much more the nature of those third parties and the ones that we don't want are the kind of um the rent seeking you would say third parties that basically capture the market like your um your MasterCards visas because essentially if you compare uh Visa Mastercard as a payments system or payments Network and then you compare that with something like Bitcoin you've essentially got a network in something like Visa which is a central point of failure and it's it's non-competitive so once you're once you're using that there's no competition they're just taking a fee on
your on your transaction and kind of a percentage fee um and in Bitcoin what you have is you never actually submit to a single provider so when you're paying you know a card payment you're kind of choosing a provider MasterCard Visa worldpay or whatever you're picking your provider and you're saying you have my transaction and they say great and uh and and because you're our customer we'll charge you whatever we want and that's fine what you're doing in Bitcoin is you're submitting it to a network of potential providers so you don't actually pick your provider up front and that's the key is that there's always it's always competitive so all the nodes all the miners are constantly competing for your for your for your fee that you're offering basically so that's why that's why it's um it's more robust than it and and why decentralization kind of matters is because it's it's it's basically it's an the decentralization is an emergent property of Bitcoin because it's competitive in my opinion so because um they're always
competing for for your for your fees then you're going to have different parties and this brings us on to another interesting point so on the competition this is makes sense to me for proof of work does this also apply for proof of stake which is the new kind of consensus mechanism when we talk about consensus mechanism consensus mechanisms we did have a an episode on blockchain we touched on it lightly but it's effectively if we have these say three different miners who all own their own Excel file which is The Ledger um the thing with you know blockchains typically is you can't remove any of the previous kind of um the previous fields or um or P things basically in in the Excel file you can only append so the trick is if I have three different Excel files and three different locations run by three different people how do we achieve consensus when we append new entries to those Excel files and there's different ways of doing that the leading one which was demonstrated
by Bitcoin was proof of work kind of met reference there by Jack competition to basically get there by increasing you know the amount of work we do to basically choose this random number but there's this new consensus mechanism which is kind of taking a lot of headlines right now which is a bit less which is is less energy efficient which is called proof of stake does that still add the aspect you're talking about or have the aspect you're talking about with competition yeah that's a really really good question and I I think yes it still has that competitive nature because in both proof of work and proof of stake essentially you have um each each each block is is going to be mined by someone who's kind of selected at random let's say but it's not like a a uniform distribution like you you basically Buy more lottery tickets um and the more lottery tickets you have the more like likely you are to mine the block and in proof of work the the lottery
tickets you're buying are correspond to your your hashing power the amount of energy you're expending the amount the amount of machines you've got to Hash in proof of stake it the number of tickets you have corresponds to how much money you've put down in the system how much money You' you've Stak that's where the term comes from and so the comp the competitive element is there but what I think is the fundamental difference is that in proof of work it kind of acts as a A deanonymization or a way of identifying who the participants are so you know that there is an essential point of failure because you know okay there are three or four big corporate entities you know some of them all registered companies as I said one of them could be a publicly listed company and the reason for that is it's very hard to hide if you have a massive mining operation I mean the size of these things is huge that there's one in um uh in El or being
powered by geothermal energy from a volcano they're huge operations whereas in proof of stake it's much easier to hide wealth because it's just money it's an account-based system so you know you you have multiple different addresses with money associated with them that are doing most of the the voting on on on new blocks but how do we know they're not all controlled by the same person or some conglomerate you know and maybe that is a central point of failure that we it's not as easy to tell that there isn't one basically yeah and when we're saying that one of the issues right now with like this whole decentralization Dows and all this kind of stuff is that a lot of these organizations that are effectively running these huge businesses that a lot of people are dependent on um they're not kind they don't seem like they're properly regulated they don't seem like they come under the same laws that you and I come under Jack and I I hope that it seems like governments are
starting to catch up with this and you know starting to actually push through you know legislation onto these companies to say no no you are if you're operating in our country you are beholden to our laws and like you say if it's a very publicly visible company with mining operations for example that it's much easier to put get them under the thumb basically and start to regulate these people properly and make sure we don't have all these Ponzi schemes and miners dropping off the face of the Earth and loads of money being stolen and all this kind of stuff yeah exactly and uh that's a nice segue that you mentioning regulation because uh in 2022 there there was quite a nice definition I think of of decentralization introduced by the SEC the Securities and Exchange Commission in America and this this kind of backs up the defition I think we both subscribe to so I'll read it out for you so this was from commissioner of the SEC Hester Pierce in 2020 so they said
decentralization essentially means it's not controlled and is not reasonably likely to be controlled or unilaterally Changed by any single person group of persons or entities under common control so I think that's that's a really nice concise way of saying and it captures that point about you know is it reasonably likely to be controlled by a single entity or group and that's why you know proof of stake I think it's it's harder to say it's unlikely to be controlled by some person and I think this whole idea of like control and controlling protocols kind of reminds me a lot of like um you know going back more high level the web one to web two to web three like you know early days of web one it was all open source we saw lots of like individual small startups just spinning out companies as left right and Center things were advancing very quickly and then web 2 these centralized parties all of a sudden start to dominate you know the Google the the Microsoft whatever it
was and they started to develop like their own internal protocols private protocols potentially um and they got all the users coming on so all of a sudden it was quite difficult for people to say develop on these protocols not difficult but they had to go through the companies right and there's this whole thing that I've seen with like Central companies when they have like good developers or good um good projects built on top of them they then they bring them in because obviously they want the users that come from that and then they turn into comp s and they'll start to try and like replicate their product and actually make it better or they'll change the protocol and go in a different direction and there's a lot of uncertainty that comes with that and I think one of the things that I see from web 3 and if we think of like say Bitcoin becoming the plumbing of the next Internet it's like I've seen that in a lot of places I think one of
the things that we need to see in web 3 is open protocols fixed open protocols that anyone can build on in a transparent way and I know that dent calization doesn't necessarily mean that but I think it's something that we do need to see yeah 100% I mean it's it's really good to you know make the call the comparison out between web two and web 3 because yeah all the the central companies have centralized control of the internet in a way right we we go to a single company like Google for access to information we go to a single uh company for our posting photos on Instagram and stuff and you see when this goes wrong like I remember when Facebook went down and Twitter goes down you know everyone goes crazy and that's why there's this big push to to web 3 based social media models where it's kind of this Federated idea you don't have one company in control it's a protocol based social media so that different people can provide the data
and there's not one company that's centralizing control of of of um access to that data basically so yeah it's a good comparison to make yeah and you see like it must be hard like what was the whole Twitter thing there's loads of companies that were built on feeds directly from Twitter and taking data from Twitter and then Twitter all of a sudden just changed their entire protocol and it was like hundreds of Millions worth of like companies would were not companies and value of companies were lost because all of a sudden they couldn't work on Twitter anymore it's like their entire business model is that is gone same with Amazon like people build it's a bit slightly different comparison where people will develop a product on Amazon Amazon will take it make it way cheaper put it to the top of the search list and then just steal it and it's there it's like it's it's hard must be hard for developers it must like stifle innovation to have to go through these quite closed
barriers that are controlled by single Central entities and I'm hoping that this whole decentralization agenda even though it's not directly that it helps that with the especially on the protocol level yeah you're you're right it's a it's like really can really disrupt the business models of people who use these uh you use web to kind of um business models because you know if Facebook changed their advertising algorithm as has happened many many times then this can affect everyone that's using it in a really you know detrimental way um I feel like I want to talk a bit about you know we've alluded to the maybe the lack of decentralization in Bitcoin but I want I want to go into some specifics about you know how decentralized are these blockchains in practice because there are some interesting uh there are some interesting historical things that we've seen right and even if you just go looking today I had a quick I had a quick look on the kind of the mining distribution in Bitcoin so classic
morning read right yeah I get it before I do anything else in the morning I've got to check check the binding stats so as of today two miners in in BTC control more than 50% of the of the hash rate so are the decision makers on more than 50% of blocks and if you go to just seven miners that's 95% right and the this this this comes back to something we didn't mention is decentralization is a spectrum right right so we said it's no it means no central point of failure so that means anything basically more than um two or three basically it can be three nodes in the system that means there's no single point of failure it could be a thousand nodes and it's a spectrum people will say how decentralized is it based on where where along that Spectrum you fall and what what are the benefits of okay so if' you've got three completely separate entities that are all mining right we'll say that there's it's a very small chance that
all three of them can go down or two other three of them can collude right so that for all intents and purposes they are separate three separate minors is there any benefit in having five miners now what is the benefit of having like an increasing decentralization after the point at which we say it's decentralized enough that we don't think there's a single point of failure yeah it's it's an age-old question I definitely I don't have the answer to this I think um I think it's something that will will kind of naturally be borne out you know what what what are people comfortable with um will determine confidence in the system and therefore how many nodes there are I mean I especially as Bitcoin scales I think your nodes are just going to get bigger and bigger they'll move from Big corporate entities to you know unicorn size corporate entities and maybe I think in the future there'll be government entities will be will be binding I mean maybe in the future is just governments when
it gets that big um so I think there's definitely an advantage to not necessarily just purely the number of nodes um up to a certain point but where they're located what legal jurisdictions they're in I can definitely see it being a good thing to have one or two in each continent of the world for example because then it's it's very hard to imagine a scenario where all of them all of them are compromised at once yeah and this becomes so hard when we're talking about like Dows and them operating outside of like legal systems the fact is like Bitcoin ethereum they are Global Systems but they're run by miners in certain jurisdictions imagine if you know I'm in subsaharan Africa and all of a sudden Bitcoins like the people that run Bitcoin say all the minors are in America I don't think they are in America think they're a bit more distributed than that um they all of a sudden say okay you're not allowed to have this transaction because we don't agree with the
merchant that you're sending to or something like this like how is that going to work like how do we have like Global regulation for mining systems that are in certain jurisdictions yeah again you give me all the tough questions now um my view on it is kind of that you know you know have this concept of net neutrality and um service providers like isps being kind of not held responsible for the traffic that goes through them necessarily because they're not The Originators I think I think a similar model can apply in Bitcoin because you could say well the nodes because nodes aren't looking at your transactions and saying oh who's sending to who here because again it's not always it's very hard to tell in most cases or data transactions they're not saying I don't like this application I'm not going to mine their transactions they they're just purely looking at how profitable is it to mine this transaction so yeah I think some kind of similar neutrality policy could could apply to them but
beyond that it's difficult you're right it's the exchanges that do that typically right it's the exchanges that come under the Kos for because they know where money's actually being transferred it's like it's not Anonymous with them because they do KC on your identities and a lot of the AML that happens and when people's accounts get Frozen it goes through exchanges but the same questions kind of apply like coinbase is obviously a global operator with people all over the world using it but it's based well partially based in the US and a lot of like the freezing account freezing all this kind of stuff is pushed on them by The Regulators in the US and it's a tricky one for kind of international systems to kind of be regulated in certain jurisdictions for globe yeah and and and if Bitcoin is that successful or any blockchain is that successful that is you know getting massive um maybe even nation state actors as as nodes it's kind of your interest to to keep the the barrier to
doing that low not from a hash power sense but from a legal one you you want to limit the number of failure cases for why you might not be able to do something as a know why you might not be able to continue operations um and just as as a example of you know how how why you need multiple jurisdictions is because a huge amount of the mining was previously in China and then they had this ban that kind of just completely destroyed it I can't even remember if if they lifted the band I think they might have but for a number of years it was another thing we should touch on about decentralization is that it's not a static thing it changes over time and there's no more obvious way to think about that than you know think about the origin of Bitcoin you would have had just one guy it was a centralized system for all intents and purposes for the first however long you know on on day dot you had effectively
one minor and for various periods from from 2009 to 201 12 who knows if it was just one minor at various times in that you know so people are happy Bitcoin survived despite being heavily heavily centralized in the past and now we've kind of hit this kind of maybe a happy medium of say three to 10 nodes that are typically mining everything yeah I mean this kind of reminds me of the ethereum Dow hack like the giant F that we talked about in in the blockchain episode like that's that was a very centralized decision right I think a lot of people I'm not sure whether I agree or not a lot of people say that it was vitalik's friends who are people that supported him that lost a lot of this money so it was in his best interest to you know make sure that the money was returned to them and because he had like a good control over the miners at that stage he was able to take most of ethereum's network in
the direction he wanted which was actually to take the money back right yeah do you do you remember the details of that one about why that happened because it I think it'd be good to just recap very very briefly yeah so my understanding is there was this this de this decentralized um autonomous organization that had a fund and they had a smart contract that was basically getting lots of money onto the ethereum network and some guy in the smart contract found a hack where he could basically take all the money it was like what was it like 60 million or it 60 Milli 100 million I think I think it's worth like billion yeah yeah and obviously at the time they're like well half a lot of the developers in the community were like well you shouldn't have you know you shouldn't have maned handled the the the smart contract in the first place and this is immutability manifest like you've lost the money because of a mistake you made and now it's been transferred
to this address that we can all see and well screw you but obviously the the fund itself was an example for falic about all how all these things could be used what the future looked like and I think he had some friends that were actually involved in the Dow fund as well that what some of the conspiracies were so he was like no no I am going to make sure all the miners will return the funds which is basically for them just on The Ledger they can just say input over here push that input over here and we can manually get around all this stuff and this split the community I think italic took like 80% of the network with him which was ethereum as we know it today and then the 20% who were like no this is not the principles of blockchain this is not how it's meant to work we're meant to stick with the mutability they fored off and went to ethereum Classic and carried on um that's my understanding yeah
I think I think that t with my memory as well and you know yeah as you said this led to a big change between ethereum and ethereum classic and only only one of them really survived but it it goes back to that definition of commission Piers right in this was a case clearly of some kind of effectively a cartel of um developers and miners who decided amongst themselves we want to change we want to roll back right they call these roll backs and in Bitcoin people this is really you know this is H this goes against all the sacred decentralization properties of Bitcoin to roll something back as a unanimous decision but even in Bitcoin we've got historical precedent for this right so in in 2013 there was a very similar situation where there was this accidental chain split because there was a network upgrade there was an incompatibility between the old version of the software the new version and people didn't like that and they said well let's just roll it back and they
did you know so Bitcoin we said it's IM mutable decentralized Ledger was rolled back and and completely reversed the state of The Ledger and you know people go okay well that was that was 2013 you know that was in the old was just a few people but as recently as 2019 so you know when I was actually working in the space uh you may may not recall this one but there was a there was a hack of binance right so basically the biggest Exchange in the world right now they were hacked for $40 million and they essentially started exploring the option of of rolling back the bit the Bitcoin blockchain so so the CEO Chang Pang Xiao started talking about this on Twitter and everyone lost their minds and they didn't do it in the end but it shows you that there is there is a little bit of a a weakness to this decentralization when you when you start thinking about you know which actors like the exchanges are well funded while motivated to
try and influence the system yeah well I think they're known as a bit of a pirate exchange right but it just goes to show that you know miners they do control the network we talk about decentralized but they are effectively the network administrators they can with sufficient power if they have like over what a 50% of the mining power they can do whatever they want in the Network and they should be held accountable for the things they do right um but yeah so we've talked a little bit about what decentralization is should we talk about whether it's good or bad talk about some of the positives and the negatives of the term generally and maybe the specifics within that sure so I think maybe I can start with saying I think overall it's a good thing because fundamentally as I said it's I think it's an emergent property of how Bitcoin works so it's good because it you know it's just a it's a result of a functioning blockchain a functioning digital cach system so
if you have a blockchain that's decentralized it's it's probably operating correctly right and uh and again it's it's it's it's a better trust model um for for implementing a distributed non- fiat-based currency or or money I think yeah I think well when I think my definition from the network side which you said is distribution rather than and decentralization but I suppose they kind of apply it in both scenarios is resilience like the fact that we get such great Network resilience from Bitcoin in a way because it's distributed across multiple computers but in another way because it's D decentralized across different entities in different places as well means there's never been a network failure to my mind of Bitcoin which is impressive right for however long it's been going there's never been a network failure I think that's obviously a massive positive um one of the other things is like we talked about earlier is the opening things up I think it's not inherent in decentralized networks as a whole but it's part of the conversation
of having these fix protocols that aren't controlled by you know single Central entities with their own agendas um means that people can comfortably develop on it know that things aren't going to change to radically because the network administrators their incentive is to just maintain the network is to get the Tok because they get tokens they're rewarded with tokens for actually maintain the network right so what they want is people to be happy with the network people to be coming to the network to use those tokens and to up the value of those tokens so I think the separation of the motivations is quite important and I think that enables the open protocols and the web three Vision that we're talking about right yeah I and I agree I think it's for me it's not so much the the decentralization itself right I don't think it's the end it's the things that cause it to be decentralized that are really good so you know the incentive mechanism as you said the fact that it's open permissionless
so anyone can join and compete you know you could always have a new player join the network and compete and the fact that is always competitive is a very very good thing you know because miners who offer a poor service who don't you know processes many transactions who are slower they get punished directly you know because you know they they call it um like a red queen game like you're always running one of these infinite games um you running on the treadmill forever only the fit is survive and you have to maintain it's not like you can just like youve see with the Mastercard or VISA you work hard to gain a position of superiority in the market but then once you get there you have this kind of closed uh network with with sticky customers whereas you don't have that in Bitcoin you always have to keep working which is I think a fundamentally very good thing what about the bad what what do you think is a bad consequence of decentralization I think
some of the things aren't with decentralization itself like my thing is around like people's understanding of decentralization it's like it's not like bitcoin's not going to take down governments like we're not going to never need need Central entities or trusted certificate authorities and all this sudden there' been no regulation and Anarchy and all this kind of stuff like that annoys me about the space to be honest I think we're always going to need that like in the best case scenario Bitcoin will work alongside governments right and will actually enable governments like there needs to be an identity solution that is you know built in or works with Bitcoin to actually take it to its full potential and I think people need to understand that the decentralized systems still need to operate within the law and that that is complex I think that's another bad side is that Bitcoin and ethereum and all the biggest you know kind of decentralized networks in the world they're they're well they're Global they're all over the world but they
need to be regulated and I think we really do need to see a global effort to regulate them consistently across the board otherwise all the miners you know will just move to one place where there's no laws but people will still be able to use it right and that that kind of is is a a disadvantage of of the the system I'd say yeah and you know where do you sit on regulation right now like do you think that um do you think that miners should be directly regulated or do you think it's kind of the systems the coins themselves need regulation or is it a combination of both I think it is a combination of both I think I have stronger opinions on the miners I think miners do need to be regulated and one of the reasons I think it's positive for them to be regulated I think if you know if the US government gives a network or a minor the seal of approval and says you know what we've actually done
our due diligence here and Bitcoin miners said they're going to comply you US citizens start using Bitcoin like that's going to be a boon for them right loads of people are going to jump on the network and feel confident and comfortable interacting um that that's the one thing I think will help adoption but we also need to make sure that they do comply with laws like we can't have these like I think in two ways one it will get rid of all these pirate networks and these Ponzi schemes and these cryptos that spin out of nowhere if you suddenly have have a cev approval to say these are the safe ones these are not the safe ones I think that is going to be a big boom for the industry once regulation starts to catch up with the technology and both coins and miners are regulated what do you think about regulation Jack it's a big topic yeah and also I think I agree with everything you said I think also an aspect that is
not being discussed whatsoever and definitely needs to be for all the utility applications the data applications we talked about is what what obligations the miners have about the data on the blockchain itself because you know we've had cases in the past of illegal data being stored on the blockchain and who's responsible should it be redacted um the right to privacy and gdpr you know um right to be forgotten if some if some data is leaked on the blockchain and then there's an a super injunction to get rid of it uh then you know how do you do that and I think it's all it's not like a technical problem it's more there's not clear there's not regulatory Clarity on what the role of nodes is there but I think that will come um and yeah I think I just regulation as we always say is is inevitable um just the final thought for me on kind of the negatives I think you've alluded to it already with the Dows but I think decentralization is often
used as a by word for kind of a lack of accountability actually so people think well decentralized is just we're all in this together we're in a herd mentality therefore when when you don't have someone accountable no one is right which is very much not the case I don't think um and you know I often think about this with smart contracts on ethereum and people uh who create um defi decentralized Finance can't believe we haven't brought up that term maybe another time I think def is a whole episode in itself yeah but decentralized Finance sure it might be decentralized in how it operates um you know you put the contract on the blockchain and then anyone can use it open permissions whatever but somebody has to write the contract in the first place right and should they be responsible for how that works and if they if they attract people to use it and then there's a security flaw as we've seen time and time again with these hacks who's responsible and how responsible should
they be especially if it's it's been created by you know multiple different people and open source developers and things and people often just shrug it off I think at the minute while regulation is catching up and say well it's decentralized therefore no one's responsible by I don't think you can operate like that yeah no I completely agree someone I think like a lot of the laws we have do apply it's just kind of retrofitting them and the education needs to be there for people to understand that someone is always accountable for something someone's the one that pushes the button someone's the one that signs the contract um so on that note what do you think the future looks like for decentralization yeah I think um I I think the main question about it for me again if we regulation aside and all all those points is is what you mentioned earlier like what is the optimal level on this spectrum of calization uh I think it's really really interesting to see where that goes so
I think the most interesting thing will happen in the future beyond the regulatory Clarity and what happens there is just seeing you know where Bitcoin and other blockchains land what is the what is the golden number um so maybe not not the most exciting point but uh I think it'll be interesting to watch what about you I think for me it's around I think like we said in decentralized network there's a tendency to have more transparency more open protocols and I hope that's the case I hope that we start to see you know lots of communities building on you know well well decentralized networks like Bitcoin for example as a protocol layer that would really excite me and I think the other thing is the education side like you said people need to understand that decentralized doesn't mean you're outside the law and you have to be held accountable and I'm hoping regulation catches up I'm hoping that legal enforcement catches up just because it's going to mean that these systems are adopted by the
biggest players in the world once the regular ation catches up we're going to see lots of people real world applications being built on top of them and that really excites me yeah 100% And I think you know the SEC and the Pentagon taking a stance on decentralization is is really is really positive I think that's a great thing moving us forward okay so I think that is a probably a good place to end we've covered lots of ground there on decentralization and you know for what can be a controversial topic I think it was uh it was pretty it was pretty good actually maybe we didn't have too much to disagree on uh certainly less so than maybe on the crypto episode but um yeah with that said Thank you at home for listening wherever you may be and we'll see you next time to entangle a little more of 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and
comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto