Episode 81

Data Tokenization with Nikhil Varma

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this week's episode of Untangling Web3, we're joined by Nikhil Varma, Associate Professor at Ramapo College and Technology Lead for the Algorand Foundation in India.

Nikhil helps us dive into the intricate world of data tokenization, sharing his deep knowledge on transforming abstract data into tangible, tradable assets within the blockchain ecosystem.

Key highlights

  • Understanding Data Tokenization. data tokenization is the process of converting data into digital assets that can be managed and exchanged on blockchain platforms. This includes anything from carbon credits to personal health data, highlighting the vast applications of this technology.
  • Economic and Functional Benefits. tokenized data can enhance efficiency, transparency, and security in transactions. Nikhil illustrates how smart contracts and tokenization can automate exchanges, protect intellectual property, and create new economic opportunities by providing liquidity to otherwise static data assets.
  • Real-World Applications and Challenges. healthcare data tokenization is poised to revolutionize personal data control and privacy, along with the potential of using tokenized data in diverse sectors like environmental credits and personal identification.

Nikhil Varma’s insights reveal the transformative potential of data tokenization in shaping a more secure and efficient digital economy.

This episode not only enlightens on the technical aspects but also underscores the critical need for a supportive regulatory framework to foster widespread adoption and implementation of these technologies.

This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today I'm delighted to welcome back to the show nickel vmer to discuss data tokenization nikil is an associate professor at rampo College in New Jersey and Technology lead for the alaran foundation India nikil also serves as the chair of the blockchain work group at the center of excellence at the digital Economist where he leads initiatives at the Forefront of blockchain technology and digital economics let's talk about all things data tokenization nikil welcome back to the show it's nice to be back Jack yeah it's exciting to have you back last time we had you on to discuss Supply chains and when people talk about blockchain like the main use case I think they use outside of crypto is Supply chains and that was a fascinating episode I learned a lot it one of our most popular episodes so we thought we have to get you back and today we're talking about data tokenization so I I'm really excited for this one I think we're going to

learn a lot I hope I'm able to provide good insights today yeah I'm sure you will Dr V I mean why don't we start you know with a basic definition because this term data tokenization it's something that I think has become more popular in the last couple of years maybe and at first glance you know it might not be clear exactly what we're talking about so when people hear tokenization a bunch of things come to mind most of it to do with crypto speculation and you know nfts for example and nfts we have data associated with them right typically if it's a if it's an image type nft you have like a JPEG famously associated with that but I think data tokenization means something quite different right so what what is your definition of that sure so before I I get into Data tokenization just kind of briefly what exactly tokenizing tokenization is and what tokenization serves the idea of tokenizing something and especially in the context of blockchain is to be able to provide

it a digital identity to be able to kind of play with it to be able to manage things right and then there are other things like you know you have a something which is a fungible tokenization or a non-fungible or a unique tokenization now once it becomes a tokenized asset in the blockchain we could do different kinds of business processes and and and in that same ve when we have data okay now what exactly is data going to be serving here right is data uh something which is going to eventually lead to something yeah and generally the data tokenization term that I have used is in the context of data which is going to be used used to develop something like a carbon credit so if if I have some kind of a mechanism to be able to trace data streams which result in generating carbon credits then that data stream that I am getting on a regular basis and securing in the blockchain I can tokenize it and I can preserve it as an

asset so that's essentially what data tokenization is in the context of what I'm talking about okay got it yeah that makes sense so just to kind of slow things down a little bit then so we understand the basic idea of tokenization in general then you mentioned things like carbon credit so is the idea here to take things that aren't currently in a tokenized form that are more or less abstract right like something like a carbon credit or I'm sure you have other examples and then to give it the properties of tokens such that they can be uh traded and transferred or am I missing anything there is that the kind of Cor principle we're getting at that's exactly the the principle behind tokenization so tokenization gives it uh an identity the structure right uh and and then it becomes that mechanism that is the mechanism with which you are able to that you can share with someone that you can you know hold with someone as an asset and then kind of have some kind

of a financial transaction around it I'll give you another example maybe the carbon credit is a bit abstract assume that I have my Healthcare data yeah now my Healthcare data is something that I can share with a research medical research institution and a Medical resch Institution would provide me some incentives for there yeah now this has been done for quite some time and then then what is The X Factor that blockchain brings in what is the Delta that blockchain will bring in is I tokenize my data now yeah now I tokenize my data and that tokenized data that I have I will only give access to certain people who have signed some kind of an economic arrangement with me for that data economic or could be any other Arrangement right so maybe I'm just lending my data to a Innovation right and if that Innovation happens maybe there would be a fractional ownership in that Innovation that that's I could possibly have you know just to kind of show The Connect out the far-reaching effect

of tokenization because if you just kind of sharing data we will not be able to get all these different functionalities that we talking about right so efficiency uh financial transaction having a complete visibility of the impact all these things can happen with data tokenization okay that's that's useful to know because when most people talk about tokenization right now they think of value exchange they think of either let's say the cryptocurrencies of the world or this big buzzword right now real world assets and getting all assets on chain right and when I think of something that's tangible and real like a building I can very easily understand if I tokenize that I can split that up I can represent ownership and everything comes down to ownership but what you're saying there is I also want to have assign some value to you know the data like my Healthcare data for example and also represent ownership and access rights to that data what's the value for the end user in that example you gave say I have

Healthcare data I tokenize it I can control access sure but I could do that with an Excel file as well what's the value and tokenize it on a blockchain for example tokenize ation gives it you know it becomes more efficient it's much more easier to share right it it can be integrated to different kinds of systems right if I'm an architect I've designed a house design yeah yeah I can share my design with a password protected design with someone yeah but how can I protect it right how can I protect it and how can I actually be incentivized or paid when it is used right so essentially it's you know a smart contract wrapped around this whole token uh can actually go and do business for me like you know I'm I'm suppose I'm a 3D artist I tokenize my data and I say yeah you can print my artwork into any 3D printer of the world as long as you pay me right and that that the smart contract has the ability to unlock

it when the payment happens and that gets integrated to a 3D printer you get me so data tokenization through blockchain protects your asset also brings in efficiency also and the the economic Mobility that kind of is caused because of the tokenization is far outreaching than any web to system in my opinion I get that so that actually makes a lot of sense so it's not the data itself that's necessarily changing from the web two to web 3 Model that you're talking about it's all the utility around it so the example you gave there is like I can I think uniqueness is quite an important thing right I can prove that this data hasn't been tampered with for example so I like the healthcare example because I think it's it's so Universal to everyone around the world they always understand like the value of having accurate and up-to-date Healthcare data but it's also very private and you don't want anyone to be able to access it so imagine like we have a problem with the NHS

I talk about it all the time here in the UK where data isn't very sharable and it's very personal I want it for myself so what I'm imagining in this model you're talking about is I could potentially have my health care data on my mobile device you know personal to me there's a reference to it on the blockchain or something like this that's been signed off by a medical professional to know that it is been verified it has been verified and then I can share it on whatever basis I want in like a peer-to-peer interaction and they can reference that on the blockchain is that that's one of the utilities I guess that's quite a cool cool thing to think about in this model yeah yeah yeah and there is one more aspect so this is a very transactional approach that we are seeing now the other aspect that you know which I've kind of written one of my uh papers is uh talking about this data you know it's like these immovable Assets in

liquid assets that we have right this data can sometimes be an illiquid asset and that's where the example of carbon credit comes into play right now the data which is kind of a streaming data suppose I am going to generate carbon credit from a biodigestor yeah and and and I have the amount of gas that is being consumed uh or is being produced by the biodigestor through a meter yeah and that data is being stored in some kind of a system which the data is hashed into blockchain to be able to preserve is its Integrity now this data actually to you and me means nothing because I will probably tokenize it into a carbon Credit in six months fine but while it is sitting there what if I could tokenize it I could assign a future value to it and then send it out to a D5 protocol for liquidity and trade you see this creates a complete completely different Avenue right I mean in the past people used to have like you know I

have a fixed asset I have land okay I'm going to be able to put my land on a reverse mortgage and I'll get some liquid for it yeah essentially following the same kind of a logic here that I am going to tokenize this data so this data cannot be turned into a carbon grid unless until you DET tokenize it okay and that token now becomes a liquid and with which I will be able to trade in D5 protocols so that's interesting another another angle to tokenization of data yeah I think that's a really interesting point that I want to touch on so I'm I'm not sure I've fully grasped that last point about the the kind of future value but I think before we get to that I want to build up a couple of other points here as well so from what you've said so far and from some other things I've heard one of the main incentives or reasons to tokenize data in this way so let's you know maybe we go back

to the healthcare example there's a clear incentive for you know this the transactional model that you were talking about right so example I've heard people talk a lot about is uh things like smart watches right or or fitness trackers where you are a source of data yourself your watches tracking things like heartbeat steps all that kind of stuff and there's an incentive to share this for a reward with someone like a an insurance provider or a medical research company who wants to use that data for you know their research purposes for example so I understand that the transactional element there what is there any deeper reason than that for say us as end users to want to tokenized data or am I missing something is that is it purely in that kind of before we get on to the kind of the future value and maybe get into almost like derivative type stuff is that is that the core reason why someone would want to tokenize data that they own yes I mean that is

definitely one of the reason but let's kind of let me kind of give you some more aspects of that data okay now once you tokenize the data you giving it an identity right so it could be one or the other right I'm sharing my data I get say 225 for that yeah end of story that data goes into a database they clean it up they take my name off and then whatever and then they do some kind of a research with it okay now picture this I have a token right I share my token with you with which you are going to do some kind of a research suppose you are doing an AI model training with that data set right what we could do is something that is called a sensitivity analysis so using and I have actually this is a PhD research work that we looking at currently is what is the impact that this data is going to have on that AI engine okay now not every data item would have an

equal impact on the AI engines learning ability okay now suppose I give a data set which actually made a big Delta on the AI engine okay we are using uh different kinds of models to be able to study that okay then that data set should have a different value as compared to the other data sets you get me if I give you data you give me €25 for that but my data was actually content rich and actually help progress science okay why do I have to get $25 225 for that I mean I'm thinking from a pure capitalistic mindset right so I am giving you data which is of high value I should get 500 for that but you know you and I cannot make that determination let the machine make that determination and since my data is tokenized I am pretty sure that the subjectivity aspect is gone uh the impact as aspect will be measured and the identity aspect will be carried forward through multiple streams you get me in fact Suppose there

is some kind of a data contribution where actually my piece of work work is helping something happen I'm always saying my piece but anybody else's piece I'm just using my myself as an example here I could get a a bigger share in the pie as compared to uh uh somebody else and that bigger share in the pie creates this whole Avenue of less bias in data which means now uh you as a person would create collect data from a convenience example because people who don't know you will not give you data because they'll be like okay I don't know this person why would I share my data but now if I'm a tokenized data set and I know that it is not a subjective aspect it's not a known aspect but the system is going to give me uh a fair price for my data set I would go in uh go into that as a Marketplace so essentially you have the ability to create a more open more decentralized Marketplace when you are tokenizing

your data through a Blain BAS system that makes sense I think it kind of links back to the art example you gave earlier on as well the idea of like ownership and payb as it kind of gets push you know I create a piece of art I tokenize it and then I in program I program into the token that if it gets sold later on down the line any increase in profit I get 10% of that as well and that's a big thing that people do with nfts to ensure that they you know they have their work at the start and if it you know it turns out to be Millions down the line then they get a part of that the idea of doing that with data is quite powerful especially with this kind of AI Revolution that's happening where you know it's all based on the quality of the data and you know lesser and lesser people want to share the data and it's becoming illegal with gdpr compliance to have website crawlers

and whatnot just pulling data from everywhere so more and more we want you know fewer higher quality data than just Spam data everywhere but how do you incentivize people to actually share that data it's obviously monetization but people don't trust AI companies right they don't trust where the data is going how it's being used but my question is is it actually easy because you know we're talking about onchain data and all this kind of stuff but as soon as it goes to an AI model that's offchain is that is it easy to kind of ensure that link is maintained and there's traceability when it goes into the AI model yeah I mean as a matter of to answer this question straight line answer is absolutely at this point of time it is not possible right okay but we'll have to build systems like that right one of the other arguments that is happening in the AI world is this whole idea of data coming in from all kinds of sources whether it is you know

whether it was actually authentically authentically sourced or you know it was just a data scrapping solution which pulled all that information out now if an AI engine is able to demonstrate that all the data that they used to train themselves were actually cized data that they procured from sources and they did have access to it that gives it more credibility right so we could have you know multiple kinds of AI engines evolving over a here time many organizations have stopped have actually a corporate policy now you cannot use an open AI system in in the organization because that actually starts hindering with the customers privacy but there are many professors many scholars many researchers who have started training their own AI engines in their own space right uh and and I mean of course that also kind of mandates you to be able to make sure that the data that you're training it with is actually a data that you're allowed to train it with there's no way to check that uh but I feel

that there will be a time when we will have to tokenize data that could be uh the data that would be used for to train the AI should come in from a tokenized data source rather than just a data source yeah it's I think that the whole question of AI training it's it's very much an open question and and one as you said it's kind of very much unsolved right now and that whole piece about a lot of companies saying you can't really use these llms because we're going to start disclosing our corporate data or sensitive corporate data um and I've seen a lot of people also talking about the idea of local llms which I think will be another interesting model but it's still not quite this ideal hybrid that you're talking about I think where you can have these almost public growing large models which provide the most value they have the most data they are the most performant of these AI models but you also get these guarantees of the authenticity of

which data is being used to tr train it and and managing it a private way but as you said I think a lot of that is definitely not a solved problem today's episode is sponsored by the vchain foundation now we often talk about how emerging Technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and vchain is at the Forefront of this green movement with initiatives like V better da let's take a closer look imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets these verified records build a massive Collective impact benefiting people through their own actions sound a bit complex but vchain made it fun explore our apps at v better.com v Chain's goal is to power a new era of Sustainable Solutions so if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day go check out vb.com to find out more and now back to the show I want to come back to just the general idea of tokenizing data and I think

this I I see why when we've moved on to thinking about this now right because everyone has said for a long time data the new oil right it's one of the the greatest Commodities but I've seen you interestingly you haven't called it oil you've actually said you know things like environmental data they're actually more like Fine Wines right um and that's because of the uniqueness of things so could you could you elaborate on that point what is there that's unique and interesting about that kind of data that that we can tokenize sure with my love for fine wine of course I had to kind of connect a few dots there so one of the things that actually came to my mind was uh you know what exactly constitutes a fine wine right how is wine actually fine so depends on uh what is the kind of grape that was used to cultivate it how was the grape stored right uh what was the process of making that wine whether the casts were clean whether they

were you know they were transparent if you know that this is a good brand so of course there is a bit of a centralization when we talk about fine wine so it's kind of an antithesis of what I trying to talk about here decentralization but the motivation was that you know you have to have a fine grape to make a fine wine yeah same thing to be able to make a fine data right to be able to make data because when I talk about environmental data environmental data is coming in from all places right when you look at an ESG report it's everything almost half of it is self-reported when you look at a carbon credit it's computed it's not even reported it's it's bizar when you look at how people get carbon credits they just go there they do an audit and they say okay yeah you know what we're going to give you 25,000 carbon credits how did we get that or we just computed that or we just did a small section

of you know small population subset of the population and based on that we are going to be just extrapolating and giving you the carbon credits now the the whole purpose of this carbon credit gets defeated when you look at all these different process that are being formed right which means it we are going to get a very cheap wine over there the carbon credit that we get is AB absolutely like the wine that you get in your corner store like a $5 wine a 5 pound wine yeah uh I mean yes you might want to drink it when you're out for a picnic but when you are actually in a serious uh meal and and having a business discussion you might want to have the nice wine but where do you get the nice wine from right so my concept is to be able to get the nice wine we have to get the nice grave which means to be able to get the nice environmental carbon credit we have to get the nice data

to be able to get the nice data you have to make sure that the data comes in non-biased iot sensors and these non-biased iot sensors would get you the nice grape that you can preserve and protect in a blockchain and when you preserve and protect in a blockchain then that grape that's where the future value aspect was coming in that grape which would give me a nice Vine in the future becomes an asset because now I can extrapolate and say hey I'm going to get a very nice wine out of this grape are you willing to underwrite this I'm going to tokenize this and get some liquidity on that's the whole construct that I mean Jack Jack's favorite wine is cheap he refuses to spend more than like5 pound on a bottle of wine so it's gone over his head but I appreciate the find of things um so yeah we've been talking about tokenized data and how to make data more valuable and you have good data and bad data and you know one

of the classic kind of um sayings around blockchain is garbage in garbage out right that kind of thing and I'm surprised it's taking so long to talk about iot because we you know previously when you were on the show we talked about Supply chains and blockchain and web 3 and iot was a big part of that you know just in time delivery iot devices all this kind of stuff and when we talk about quality of data the blockchain itself doesn't necessarily it might understanding is the blockchain itself doesn't necessarily guarantee quality data it just guarantees that the data hasn't changed for example and you know in the example we're talking about earlier when talking about Healthcare data well you probably want your Healthcare data signed off by a doctor but you don't want want that to be in the public domain shared across blockchain so we have all these very intelligent ways to do that where you can obfuscate the data hash it confuse it all these kind of terms for that and then sign

across that and then just prove that that data relates to it but how does the iot part fit into this Paradigm of you know quality data maintained through blockchain so I feel it's not only iot I think iot Ai and blockchain their interplay is what is going to get us the high quality right so okay essentially iot is my source so you know actually there's one thing that I I mean when we talking about uh trust which blockchain is getting us is you know how is my trust going to be scalable right so it's it could be let's start from like a step-by-step approach yeah it could be oh I know Alec Alec is a really nice guy Alec is going to go and do the readings for me yeah and he signs off with those readings and then that we put that reading into a database Oh by this by the way this reading was collected by Alex yeah now I know Alex so essentially I say thumbs up to the data that you

put in because you want to give me really nice data but the person who works along with me doesn't know Alec and I'll have to go and explain to him hey Alec is a nice guy maybe he trusts me so that Trust might go away but might be transferred but imagine trying to scale this uph yeah it's going to be a problem right so I have to have something else so I will probably take a picture of Alec taking that data right and then use that picture as as a measure say hey this is Alec and you know this is geofence and whatever and this picture has the latitude longitude over there so that would be my next level yeah now again this is not a very scalable thing when it comes to this might be a good idea when it comes to something which is of high value but Alec doesn't come in for cheap right he's he's an expensive resource so if I have to scale this up if I have to make

sure that this TR is scalable yet inexpensive I have to do Innovations in iot it's as simple as that and I mean then again the question would be how do we trust the iot right whether the iot is functioning the way it short function we can do triangulation of data we can use artificial intelligence so just a simple few things that people have done in the past with iot and this is just solar data so with solar you are able to compute the amount of uh carbon footprint that you're reducing yeah but then you could triangulate that with the amount of time sun was uh you know that place had sun over the year and see hey this day it was raining here how did you get solar data so that ways you could make sure that the technology is there so iot AI blockchain all these three would actually increase the value of the grape that we are talking about that's a really good comparison I never thought about having like different data sources

that kind of enrich the data set but also contrast to make sure it's kind of like you're operating like in a blockchain kind of mindset of decentralized and everyone's working together but also independently against one another so in that example to simplify you've got multiple data sets that are all being collected by independent iot devices they're all being pulled together and you're having this kind of AI algorithm in between that's assessing the data and applying some kind of reasoning to be like oh yeah this iot cannot have been producing this many carbon credits because it was dark at this time and the blockchain angle again is just to log that data create a unique identifier just prove what's happened and then create a degree of liquidity to you know change that around that's so true that's true okay that's a really interesting example I was trying to think about how this relates to say autonomous vehicles where you have the intelligence data being collected but when they crash what happens there like do we trust

the Tesla vehicle to say you know this is the reason they crashed and update the entire system like the this is like a kind of pressing issue I guess in the states where you are right now where people you know the data suggests that Tesla are far better at you know not having crashes and being safe and all this kind of stuff but there's a real trust Paradigm people can't get over that barrier not trusting that you know all the Teslas don't get binned because one Tesla had a car crash yeah and you know what I mean definitely I I understand your analogy when you talk about uh autonomous vehicles but you know the scale of trust also has to be normalized by the impact on your life right I I mean I I don't I think you know if I have a scale of of trust I won't kind of trust an autonomous uh artificial intelligent tool to be able to do my kidney stone surgery let's put it that way right I mean

as much as it sounds fancy and maybe we'll see it in our lifetimes uh but you know you will be a bit for it yeah uh you still want a person driving the tool suppose it goes Rogue on you yeah but you know when it comes comes time to things which have impact which does matter to us but not something which is going to impact on is going to kill us then maybe the technology is something that we would accept in many ways yeah uh I have I've seen people talking about autopilot mode in Tesla and saying oh it's so cool it's like okay are you going to drive autopilot all the time no no no only when I'm in long drives uh okay what is the difference there oh because it's a clear day some people have all kinds of information yeah whether right or wrong who knows oh when it's nice bright and it's not raining that's the best day to go autopilot I said okay fine you know what that's your way

of looking at things that they think that is the day when you know autopilot works best they must have read things that when it rains it's difficult for the autopilot to detect the lines on the road but autopilot can go wrong anytime right uh uh and so as autonomous vehicle can go wrong anytime and it can kill people right but carbon credit it's not going to kill people right and iot so I I feel that normalization needs to be done before we start kind of scaling the trust to something which is going to be of high impact to us in my opinion this is like really interesting because like yeah I guess autonomous vehicles and I know this is not what we got you here to talk about but now we're talking about it I'm quite interested to get your opinion on it because like if you look at say the data it says it's much safer on average than the average person but then every individual is like no no no I am the

exception to the rule I personally am far safer than any autonomous vehicle what is your like attitude to this do you think that like they are safe do you think it's the future is it inevitable but also do you trust in the data themselves and it's kind of the relation here is about trus in data right it is and I I mean if you ask me I'm always an early adopter to things so I might I might not be the right person to kind of give an opinion on this but I'll give my personal opinion I I I'm a big uh supporter of autonomous transportation for multitude of reasons because you know I'm designing optimal autonomous transportations where we could have shared transportation for a community and would reduce our carbon footprint right so I definitely believe in that piece I definitely believe that that's going to happen I believe that that's happening I mean there are so many solutions which are out there which are quite safe uh better than and as humans uh

we we don't know when we'll make a mistake right from an AI system there could be unique permutation combination mathematically yes there could be a combination that you know it might not be able to respond or there might be uh a weird kind of a response uh to something but that happens with humans as well so I mean it's just if it's just the machine uh why are we going to be like you know why do we have a bias right why do we think people are better than machine but yeah I mean I did mention that yes I would love to have a doctor at the other end doing a surgery for me yeah uh but uh I mean on on introspection doctor can also make a mistake we always hear about surgeons making a mistake and people end of suffering because of that mistake but then you can go and hold that doctor but over here you don't have an AI engine to hold accountable accountable to right whom are you going to

talk to so these are some and as as we evolve and as you know this gets more and more embedded in our in our day-to-day life I think maybe you'll start accepting everything yeah it's like it gets into the realm of like philosophy at the end of the day it's like we want someone to be accountable and like maybe we can't necessarily empathize and fully trust in something we don't understand I get my doctor I know there you know 40 years old they've done this many many times and if they screwed up they wouldn't be a doctor whereas an AI even if it's necessarily safer we don't really understand like how it goes wrong and you say okay this AI has made two million mistakes but it's far safer than a human but you're still like well it's made two million mistakes am I one of those mistakes um yeah it's a tricky one but I think it's something that we are seeing being addressed more and more and the conversation is coming up as

like you know Tesla's recently announced all their new humanoid robots and all their new autonomous vehicles without drivers without taxi drivers even seats and steering wheels and this conversation is coming up more and more where it's safer but people have a problem with deploying them and using them personally I've actually used some of them and I think they're incredible but yeah there's still like a bit of weirdness the first time you jump in a car without a driver yeah it's just because you know I was in a in a Summit last week and then somebody talked about the the problem that the mechanics are going to have right uh with electric cars because there's no longer an engine right so this whole Paradigm has shifted the transportation the idea was that you're going to look for a like engine which has a piston and you know you have to do oil change what about oil change with electric cars right so I mean the things that we grew up with when they change it takes

some time for people to kind of adapt but technology for people a technology is only for things things that we have seen in our lifetime come in right like you know like cell phone was introduced after we were born after I was born at least uh so it's a technology for me but it's not a technology for my kids right for them it's just a form commodity or something exactly so artificial intelligence is also going to be something like that when you have kids who are one year old start talking to AI engines and they have their own personal AI buddies or whatever then they will probably take this like okay what's the problem here right I the human race also evolve when it's they say it's you know when it's uh suitably Advanced it appears like magic right you don't have to worry anymore um I like I'm interested that you know Alec just used the word commod commodity one of the themes I'm picking out here and and stop me if I'm wrong

but I think when we're talking about data tokenization I'm seeing kind of two different buckets so one being on the personal individual human being side of things and and tokenizing your personal data and on the other is kind of everything else it's more like the industrial supply chain iot type data and AI can feed into both of those buckets right you can use them to train AI for different purposes now I I'm interested in getting out of the abstract the pure abstract where do you see the most promise for these things because I know on the human kind of personal data side uh people like Tim berners Lee obviously have been working on how you manage that better I'm not necessarily sure from a tokenization perspective but with his kind of company and and product solid they're trying to do that and I know you know you've mentioned in the past things like algorand as being something like a digital seller for your data but I men where are you seeing the actual on the

ground progress towards everything you've been talking about so far and and how far do you think we've got to go to actually you know get these into into the hands of real users and and people yeah see when it comes to analytics data is way I mean out there right you know I'm if you talk about the web two world of data and analytics but when it comes to the web 3 aspect as of now uh I think identity as a data is something that we still grappling with we have not actually crack that very well right and how can that identity as a data transformal Li simple things right you want to go to a club when you are 20 uh how many I don't know in 21 years old right I think it's 18 yeah 18 okay in Quebec it was 17 17 18 21 okay 18 okay now you want to go to a club you're 21 years old uh 18 years old rather you have to show them your ID yeah

the person at the front desk has a glass where he can take he or she can take a picture of your ID yeah now your ID can easily be duplicated we all know how IDs are being duplicated how uh you know you you can just change a picture and print an ID and 17 olds are getting into clubs yeah what if I have an identity system where I just give you a token that you are 18 plus right I'm not showing any personal information to anyone over here I'm just giving you a simple example right we figured that out yet do we have that yet right in fact all developed countries if you remember the time dur Co we had to carry our covid vaccination cards on ush why did we have to carry those vaccination cards if those if we had received two tokens or one token that we've been vaccinated that was good enough no but how could we issue that in a web2 system right but if it was a web3 system

through which it was issued right so as of now when it comes to talking about data and talk about about how things are going on I think identity is a a working process for me and that is where most of the things once that gets grounded then most of the things would start kind of wrapping around really fast okay and and also applications around identity like you know I do some kind of a social service my my kids do do some kind of service yeah they have some service hours they go from their school community service here and there they go to the beach they clean the beach they get a certificate right who's verified that there a person person in the beach can be my drinking buddy and I say hey I need like 10 certificates for my kid the person I'm not saying I'm going to do that but suppose yeah there is no verification of anything of that sort yeah I feel that kind of data that quality of information is going

to start coming in more and more when we go more decentralized centralized systems are are prone to manipulation centralized systems as much as we have grown up with centralized systems we all know centralized systems have one person who can make that change for you can add the data decentralized systems are much more trustworthy but we don't have the mechanisms to be able to put them into play yeah and that's what I think is the key piece over here how can we scale the trust what are the mechanisms that we have to be able to collect data in a decentralized manner and scale it and scale it to a level where it is going to start impacting Our Lives start giving us high quality wine in in the context of that's the end goal for using it get high quality wine instead of the low quality wine that we are getting as of now or maybe you know we think we are drinking wine but it is just some some kind of a red colored water

yeah why is this taking so long though I feel like we've been people have been talking about like the decentralized identity solution ution for like honestly 10 years now what's the big hold up with this kind of stuff do you think the biggest hold up for this is that once you have issuers you have to have verifiers also okay so we can we can go and I mean I was talking to somebody yesterday who was talking about yes you made a great solution with decentralized identity but who's going to accept that and that's a very valid point right I create an identity for financial inclusion for a person right if I go to a bank and say hey I have a whole identity for this person their whole identity journey is there will you accept that they're like I don't have the mechanism to be able to study that I still need a print out where everything needs to be attested and submitted to me right so if we have an identity we have to

have a consumer right I'll give you one simple example of identity and consumer maybe that's not in the web three Paradigm but it is a system which was built which is an Adar system in India okay if you look at the adhar system in India it's magical okay it just tells you that if I tell you that I'm nikil Verma you can put me in front of a small machine and say this person is saying is nikil Verma is he nikil Verma and it'll give you a yes or a no answer nothing more yeah so you see now verification which is the key one know your customer kyc become super easy back in those days it took so much time for me to just tell them I am who I am yeah now it takes them they just need an interface my fingerprint and off you go right so we have to have those kind of mechanisms put into play and this is you know I was looking at defusion models this has to come

in from two places one places where technology we are looking at bringing in efficiencies bringing in more inclusion other by policy right both directions then this convergence happens we will start getting to see things yeah that's a that's a really good point I think to for us to you know close a show out with because we've been talking again a lot in the abstract and I think I like that you highlighted that yet last use case around K as not being necessarily you know in the web 3 Paradigm completely it's something this this whole thing we're talking about with data tokenization does really transcend web 3 and as you outlined there's lots of good good reasons for going towards this model and the incentives you know to improve incentives for both companies and individuals I think there's lots of good things we can do there but there's also lots of things that need to happen in order to realize that Vision right it's very much still at the conceptual experimental stage although we are seeing

some green roots in in web 3 I think leading this but it's it's it's one to keep an eye on for the future I think it's going to take a long time to get there but yeah thank you so much nille for giving us such a really good introduction to this topic and I'm sure we'll have you on again in the future to to go into more details potentially be thank you for your time and to those listening wherever you may be join us next time to entangle a little more web

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes