Episode 7

Data Sovereignty

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

Join hosts Alec and Jack on the Untangling Web3 podcast as they explore the captivating concept of data sovereignty and ownership. In this episode, they delve into the importance of data sovereignty in the evolving landscape of Web3.

Together, we explore the definitions of data sovereignty and trace its evolution throughout history, highlighting the shift from local data storage to centralized entities during the Internet era, along with the rise of data brokers and the impact of social media platforms on data sharing.

Where do data sovereignty and Web3 intersect? Web3 technologies aim to address data privacy and security concerns. Alec and Jack discuss the emergence of new distributed data models and technologies that enable individuals to have greater control over their data.

We look at real-world examples of data sovereignty in practice are explored, including Apple's app tracking changes and their impact on companies like Facebook. The hosts also touch on the potential applications of data sovereignty in the healthcare industry and raise questions about the incentives for large companies to embrace data sovereignty and transition to decentralized data models.

Tune in to this episode of Untangling Web3 to gain insights into the importance of data sovereignty in the Web3 era. Discover the historical evolution of data storage, the impact of data breaches, and the transformative potential of Web3 technologies in empowering individuals to reclaim ownership and control over their data.

Got a question or topic suggestion? Send us an email at theuntanglingweb3podcast@gmail.com

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

thank you welcome to the untangling web3 podcast you'll go to hope to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep uncovering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web3 welcome to another episode of the untangling web3 podcast hey Alec how are you doing mate I'm good I'm good the big question is how are you doing yeah I'm not too bad I'm I'm recovering slightly if you can't I'm if you can't tell from my voice um so I went to Glastonbury last week which was uh amazing but I've clearly been belting out Elton John's Classics too too loudly so I'm struggling what about you were you watching it from home I watched some of it

I was really envious that you know you got tickets and I did not so I was kind of sad just stewing at home thinking about you watching Elton John but I mean we were meant to record this episode two three days ago but Jack's voice said it's so husky I don't think anyone would have enjoyed that yeah now we thought we'd save everyone at home the the despair of listening to me I mean you couldn't have heard me so but yeah um no it's it's nice to be back recording another episode and I think today in particular is is one of the the really interesting um what even more so than some of the other ones you've done but for me personally so today we are going to be talking about data sovereignty right as a term which is I think it's a bit of a loaded term because it means a lot of different things to different people um and I think it's one that's hard to pin down sometimes yeah and I think

when you suggested this topic I was a bit like oh you know compared to the metaverse compared to nfts web 3 blockchain all these kind of like sexy exciting words the idea of like data sovereignty which in my mind is just data ownership doesn't sound that sexy it doesn't sound that people listen to but then you kind of I mean we haven't mentioned it a lot so like we did just have to talk about it to kind of Define what it is because it's such an ambiguous term that's so pivotal and like in web 3 but then you kind of like look into the history of it and some of the kind of the big news stories that have come out and it is quite interesting like there actually is quite a lot of interesting Dynamics to this term data sovereignty or data ownership yeah definitely I think um I mean it shows that we've touched on the concepts that we might we might mention today in lots of the other episodes but just not

under the term uh data sovereignty and yeah you're right I think it can feel sometimes like it's something that's come out of thin air in the last few years but actually the things that have led us here and and some of the problems with data sovereignty and what people are trying to solve on web3 these are things that have been brewing for you know 20 30 40 years so um yeah why don't we get into it why don't we go for our normal starting point and try and Define This this term so uh I'll let you go first Alec because I think you've got a nice short one today yeah so your voice is still recovering so I think you're going to try and limit how much you talk today maybe um but yeah so I guess data sovereignty first of all in my mind when you said that I didn't even know what the term meant so I kind of think of data sovereignty as data ownership like how you own the data and

I think the definition for for both of those sovereignty and ownership is quite simply that the legal rights and control over data over the data so it kind of in that includes you know the responsibility for data privacy security you know in compliance like relevant relevant laws and all that and I think in quite simple terms if you you know you own the data you have the right to control and use it and you know others need to come to you for for permission to use it and I think that that's probably how I would Define that anything you want to add there Jack no I think I think that that's that's a good definition I think um I agree data sovereignty is about um data ownership um the problem that for me is you know then you say what does ownership mean because um I think it's it's potentially a legally gray area and what ownership means exactly um but if you see if you think about it in terms of privacy and control

I think that that is more tangible to me so ownership being uh essentially having control over uh who has my data how how it gets shared with with the parties um whether or not I am in control of permissioning access to people so if I mean I am I the individual that's consenting to sharing some data with a company a website um another person or is it a third party is it a social media company that's me that's making that decision for me and I think that's kind of at the heart of the the whole concept yeah anything you said in one of the previous episodes you're like what does it mean like don't I own my own data and I think a lot of people will be asking that question like don't they own their own data and I think hopefully as we kind of go through this episode you'll start to realize what it really means to own your data and understand that in a lot of the applications and use cases that

you're probably experiencing day to day now you don't own your data and I think the most important thing for me that I hope to get for this episode is why it's important that you do own your own data and why there's such a push in this kind of web 3 agenda or Vision to to move towards that kind of apparent time I yeah I think yeah it's kind of a it's a practical thing right it's like do I in practice own my data because that's what I care about do I in practice um you know have what looks like sovereignty what looks like me having the decisions to make uh or make make my own decisions about about data um but you know as we said so this is something that's been been brewing as a problem for a long time maybe we just recap the history of data in the internet so you know in the very very early days or even even before the internet was widely I think uh from what I've

read most you know data wasn't widely transferred or shared around it was something that was very much localized in in you know individually you'd store your data it might not even be digital right um you go back like I'm thinking like if you go back to here we usually start these things like prehistorically how you like local store things you know if we go back to Ugg uh you know a distant or depending on who you ask maybe not too distant caveman relative of Jack I mean his brain is the biggest state of storage going you know and it's very easy to understand you know what ownership is there if it's in his head he owns it but eventually it gets quite smart and things go from his brain to symbols on clay tablets instead okay well that's an importable data what happens then who owns the portable data and I guess ownership in that context is your physical ownership if you have it in your position if you have it in your hands or

some like stored somewhere that that you own only you can access that that is ownership but I think what you're alluding to is as we move to towards like you know the digital age it's not as simple because you don't have that physical possession aspect yeah exactly 100 I think um that's the key right is that with the internet age came digitalization um so there wasn't much of a question about ownership because you just have paper documents in your in in your uh your filing cabinet or in in the company you'd have it you know in your internal um and then with the digital Age and and you know hitting the 1990s and kind of a much widespread use of the internet this is where the model moved from okay everything is stored in-house or you know in my bedroom and for my personal files to you know the Advent of things like cloud storage so that was you know what what really took off or started taking off in the early 90s I know

that cloud storage didn't exactly become widespread initially but by the time of you know AWS being launched in 2006 that was a very common concept is to push your data to someone else to store that so that was kind of for me that's one of the starting points of this whole problem is that we moved from data being you know distributed in a sense it's with each individual owner to it being stored in these large Central entities like your Amazons and your your kind of big cloud providers yeah and I think that that physical ownership that we kind of you'd think of in like say you know pre-internet again like physical forms like paper documents photographs you physically own it and The Possession equals the ownership and I don't think maybe in the early digital age it was it was too difficult to comprehend if you own the hard drive the computer the data is stored locally there it still fits within that remit of possession and when you get to the bit about cloud

computing I only realized like a couple of years ago what cloud computing was it's kind of obvious when you say it it's just like someone else's computer right it's like it's just like yeah someone else has their computer locally and you're just accessing it I always kind of thought as these distributed like things happening in in the internet but no it's as simple as that and I think as you're saying like you know data began to be digitized and stored on these servers let's just start on someone someone else's computer right yeah but I think it's interesting because you know when I go back I mean 2006 I was only like 10 years old but I do I still remember this idea of cloud um what you know hearing about the cloud and it was always couched in kind of uh people were very wary of it and that was you know coming from a place I think of of what we now would call data sovereignty you're thinking well how am I in control

of data if it's in the cloud and I think it's similar to what's happened with blockchain you know because uh for the for the longest time people would look at blockchain as uh you know oh that's a distributed uh database I'm not going to put my stuff on that it's you know if it's distributed if it's zero or in all these different locations around the world if it's transparent um but now we're kind of hitting that maturity curve where you know people got much more comfortable with the cloud and now people are getting more comfortable with with blockchain the difference being that I think my blockchain people are trying to to solve the data sovereignty aspect of it whereas Cloud was one of the first things that was maybe pushing us to the problems yeah I mean that's a good point and I think like this this kind of some of these these trust issues um will kind of maybe emphasized by like you know the.com Boom the fact that there was these like companies

that were working on this kind of server model of of harvesting data and then they often said like data is the new oil I think that's a term that people tend to use and like the sheer amount that they were collecting and storing and that users you know didn't actually know was like incredible and I think at the time no one could probably have understood how much data they were going to have and like no one kind of you know it's always one of those things that regulation is always behind the technology if you don't know how these things are going to evolve and I know we're going to talk about regulation a bit later but no one really knew how to control this right yeah and uh that's that's a really good point I mean there was a big uh Gold Rush or oil rush because yeah you know people would say data is the new oil and um another another phrase I like to think of is um you know data is a

commodity is um and this is not my quote this is from uh shout out to weijang for this one I think but it's kind of powering the um if if electricity was powering the um Revolution a mechanical Evolution then Revolution then uh data was powering now the analytical Revolution so the power to analyze complex systems and and break things down and gives that was that was clearly seen as um being hugely valuable and you know people also took advantage of it so I think this is where the idea of things that data Brokers came into play I think in the early early 2000s um I don't know how much do you know about data Brokers is that is that something you've come across I was just about to say I don't know what data Brokers are so I would like you to ah okay okay please cool yeah no no definitely um I mean I I actually first heard the term from there's a really really funny uh and scary video from John Oliver on

his uh on his show he talks for about 25 minutes about this idea of uh data Brokers and he quotes someone else who calls them uh which I like as a definition he says data Brokers are the middlemen of surveillance capitalism so essentially these are these are companies which will collect and aggregate data on individuals from many many different um and then sell those that that data on uh in larger data sets that profile individuals so you know examples that we the the example of a data broker that you would be familiar with is something like a credit checking agency so when you apply for a loan you know they they're a data broker in that they they aggregate data from here from sources and then sell that to whatever the the uh the bank is that you're applying for a loan but then there are all these other kinds of um slightly slightly murkier examples of data Brokers which may or may not be kind of in the in the dark markets um collecting

data from the internet and profiling individuals and I think like yeah when you think of it on an individual basis like I'm like okay how much does Facebook actually know about me and then think okay well if you can start to aggregate what Facebook knows about me what Instagram knows about me what you know Tick Tock all these apps that I don't use knows about me that is it's quite a lot of data isn't it and I think that's quite scary that people have the power to be like a central point to collect all these different data sources align them and be like well this is out like this is all the things you like know that how many dog videos that I'm liking every day that would be scary it would not want that information to get out yeah well that I mean you brought it on to kind of the next phase of it all as well I think by mentioning social media because they have kind of I think inadvertently become almost

like a data broker themselves not necessarily they're selling it but they're essentially a broker to advertisers because they have all this user information and they can use that to profile the users on the platform so you know everyone is familiar now with um receiving adverts for something you feel like you talked about 10 minutes ago with a friend right you um you read the book chaos monkeys I know I haven't um oh man it's incredible it's about the guy who was kind of like the the product manager and maybe not Pioneer but to an extent Pioneer of Facebook's kind of uh advertising for for Revenue model um and it was like ah you've got to read it would recommend to anyone but like one of the main aspects about the the data aggregation and how like Facebook was kind of this firewall where they didn't want to you you know you know how cookies work like it's it's quite interesting the cookies that you accept and say you know when I go on a page

I'm gonna use it well for every web page you actually don't just contact that web page when you go and like say Facebook and you're using all the buttons and everything like that there's actually like you know I don't know tens if not hundreds of different companies that are actually contributing to that that web page and each of them has like a cookie based system effectively so all of them can access the data like every button engagement everything you do each of the companies can aggregate the data it's not just Facebook that gets access to these days there's loads of companies that access to data whenever you use like an app or a web page and his the book is like I say is absolutely fascinating it's about how Facebook kind of moved used the kind of the buttons that they put into the general internet and kind of broke down the firewalls and started to aggregate like vast amounts of data to better inform the advertising models it's really interesting Jack I would recommend

it's quite related to this stuff okay yeah you know I'll have to I mean my attention span short right so I've my recommendation for you I'm sure you've seen it but do you remember the Black Mirror episode where um yes where they they basically they were the police were trying to track down uh criminal I think you've driven a car away or something it's a long time ago um and the kind of moral of the story was the social media company which was you know a very very thinly veiled version of Facebook um because of the data profiling they they were you know so so much further ahead of um of of tracking this and the police were because they had so much more information vastly more because they're they're getting it from all these different sources on the internet um and I watched it and I thought you know this this feels very much like it's probably true right if you if you asked a social media company to track someone down they'd probably

do it more quickly than the police would now yeah so I thought you were going to reference the um the the other episode where it's like everyone has that that social kind of media score where for every action you get like a positive or A negative and like it's like the aggregate of all these different kind of apps and interfaces to to overview like who you are are as a person and I thought that's what you're going to reference but yeah I do remember that episode and yeah that's quite scary isn't it yeah oh I think that yeah you're kind of touching on like the one of the really scary end states which I think people are very very worried about is the um the kind of social credit score system when that when that data gets linked to your your finances um and that's you know I think that's something we'll cover in a future episode as well because it's you know it's it's whole it's this whole um other topic but um you

know we said we said we'd also talk about regulation so kind of after we've had the rise of the social media platforms I mean I think gdpr is the next the next Landmark stop on on the trip right yeah what does gdpr even stand for like I know what it is but one second it's done for uh I think I had to Google it as well just to check um all these acronyms we have in web3 as um so it's it stands for General data protection regulation um and it was it was in enacted in the EU in I think 2018.

um and I I don't again I don't know the full context but I think in part this was in response to things like the Cambridge analytica Scandal the growing prevalence of these data Brokers um yeah and also the social media Giants so yeah I mean that that to me was like the first real pushback and you think 2018 is a long time after these things started happening like 25 years yeah it's always the first real pushback it's always the way like regulation always plays catch-up with technology like it you never know like what the I mean you see sitting there with Regulators only now starting to trying to get a hold of like crypto and all this kind of stuff like they're always so far behind but it's just a way you can never predict how a technology is going to evolve and you know I kind of I do have some well I say quite a lot of experience with gdpr like a you know a working product and software and like all the

first question is always like where's the data stored like are we gdpr compliant like you know it's quite a scary thing our companies who are building in kind of software are always worried about gdpr compliance because you know there's so many lines out there like it's yeah it's quite interesting so I guess the whole premise of gdpr like a higher level is to declare that individuals that they own their personal data right and they have the right to know how it's used how it's stored and how it's shared I guess that's it at a high level right yeah I'm when you sorry when you said uh the first question we always asked I was gonna say well maybe that should have been what does gdpr stand for yeah and nobody did not what it stands for acronym acronym just make you sound like you know what you're talking about right yeah yeah it's a TBA so you mentioned it's about personal data so what kind of thing do you know what qualifies as personal data

what does that refer to are you going to say well I it's another acronym you just get trying to be funny you get PIR in there so I think personal data is like personal identifying information right so it's things like my address Alec burns my age my date of birth something that's unique to me probably not so much along the lines of um I don't know I was gonna say location but it is I'm trying to think I feel like everything in a way can be tracked it can be like directly kind of um worked out from your back to your identity right like everything can be aggregated to your identities I'm trying to think what doesn't qualify as pii yeah I I when I was doing some research for this as well I I noticed that I think the definition involves saying something like that can be used to directly or indirectly identify someone so what can be you you know anything in theory could be used to indirectly identify someone and something I

hadn't appreciated until I was working on a project a few years ago um was the idea of um some some data that might be innocuous and might seem well okay you can't link that to me in the right context could be you know so even even something that's quite um uh innocent could end up being something that can link back to you if it's in the wrong so you know if they can put uh two things together I mean maybe a classic example would be like a a cash payment in a store you'd think that's how can you link that payment amount back to me but if there's a if there's a CCTV camera then it becomes something that you can yeah yeah so I know a good example is so Jack every single day at 12 midday will go by a ham sandwich from m s every single day and you're like you know an individual purchase like that it doesn't add up like it but when you say every single day I know

he's purchasing you can start to associate you know the fact that I know exactly 12 p.m he will be spending exactly the price of a ham sandwich maybe I can start to link those transactions and Link it back to your that is a very good and sad indictment as an example of me so thank you for bringing that up it's actually it's chicken but you know oh I'm sorry mate I thought I'd do um yeah one of the points here is that like it's so broad like you've given kind of a vague term of what pii is and we've just said it's really hard for information to to not be related to pii especially the gdpr compliance if it's directly and indirectly and I think this is why companies are so scared I'm not scared but like kind of um on form when it comes to gdpr now because they're so worried that they're violating it because it's such broad reaching right and I guess what we're going to say is there are lots of

violations I think I saw a stat there's like 33 of global consumers have experienced a gdpr data breach and that that's just the ones that we know about like my question would be like how the hell do they monitor this like how do they how do you yeah exactly um and I I guess the take-home message there for me personally is that the the idea of data sovereignty is much broader than you might think so I think sometimes you might think of it as okay just this is control over the the directly identifiable data that is really sensitive but it actually applies to all these other things that are um and not just about identifying you but just you know in general what what things you might want to uh to have to have control over like your personal files and things and yeah as you said like the can I come on to like the idea of the a number of breaches that have happened of of companies I mean there's that I'm sure

they don't want to store this data in some cases if you're not a data broker and you're not profiting from it if you're just a company if you're just a company with customers trying to do business um the fact that you currently have to store so much data and you have these kind of Crown Jewel data sets they call them that you know if compromised will will cause your customers major harm I don't think they people want to companies don't want to store that and you've had so many examples like I've got a couple of the big ones the kind of famous ones I mean the Yahoo one from 2013 and 14.

in consecutive years and the second one I think this is there was a billion user accounts affected in some way like personal information password information is unbelievable the scale who's using Yahoo in 2013 like I I think they deserve it yeah I mean I don't know there must have I mean maybe maybe the other six billion would do anything else that's crazy they're one billion users my God that's that's unbelievable yeah and then you know so that that's I guess there's two separate things there so one is the um the companies who just have to store your data for doing business that are a massive Target and you know just by you being a customer you then become at risk right the other one is then the more uh intentionally nefarious use of your data which is kind of what we've talked about already but I do want to bring it back to the Cambridge analytica idea because this gets to the heart of consent because you know people's data was taken from Facebook and

I know it's like in some sense a public forum that people are using but um people didn't consent to it being used in that way I'm sure I mean I imagine it wasn't part of the terms of service that your data can be used to try and potentially influence elections and that was that's the event that put it in everyone's in the Forefront everyone's mind yeah it's crazy and like and my thing with with a lot of these is like how do they find out about these things it's not obvious to me how Facebook is using my data for example and I guess it's things like audits which you know sometimes can come from governments you're saying we have to audit this company the publicly listed all these kind of things which happens I imagine it's fairly regularly where it's all about process where they have to show they have a functioning process that properly protects the data properly you um collects consent on how they're using the data and all these kind of things

um I guess like one of the things that one of the big finds that I was quite aware of where that you know the process wasn't in place for this was meta where meta was fine I think it was one one point two billion something like that or one billion 1.2 billion and that was purely for transferring personal data from the EU to the US without adequate data protections which is just it's an unbelievable amount isn't it yeah yeah and and that that's that is is shocking um but it also highlights the difficulty of doing things in the internet where you have to deal with different jurisdictions much like in web 3 and blockchain yeah where it's a global system so if data's being transferred all the time between different countries different legal jurisdictions then you have to account for all these different things I mean that maybe is a nice segue to to the web 3 um current stated play right where so having seen everything that's happened in web 2 having seen all

you know the wires of social media um all that the data breaches of large companies then you know we've had gdpr but then web3 is kind of uh from the non-regulatory side from the the tech world is trying to solve some of these problems from the ground up so I mean for you what are the what are the Hallmarks of what's happening in in web 3 right now for in data sovereignty I think yeah you're seeing like a lot of these companies that are kind of trying to push well they say if they they if they don't have a benefit in owning the data you know obviously Facebook and people that push advertising there's a benefit to them in having like being the single point for all the data to be collected and stored and analyzed but I say these companies that don't necessarily have that as part of their business model it's a liability for them and I guess one of the big things that you're seeing in these web3 companies is data's more

and more frequently being pushed to the user where the user is responsible for their own data I think we're seeing more and more that data is being stored on devices and backed up in devices that are owned by the user for example like imagine rather than all my you know images and photos for Facebook being stored on the Facebook servers they're stored locally on my mobile device and when I use the the you know the web 3 equivalent of Facebook I just you know access those images and like those images are pulled directly from my phone so I guess this this is one of the one of the the ways in which web threes get getting around this right is they're pushing more and more to the user and the responsibilities on the user yeah exactly and I think um a good tangible example of this I'm sure we've mentioned this one uh briefly in a previous episode I think I couldn't remember the name back then but um so Tim berners-lee our friend who

we mentioned is kind of the founding father of the internet and the World Wide Web so you know we mentioned his dissatisfaction with the way the web's gone all these problems with data sovereignty I mean he's been talking about this the idea of um I think called open data and the ability for people to own their data properly to control permissioning to different companies he's been talking about it since the early 2000s um and He is building this this company and a product called solid where it's kind of exactly that principle where your data as an individual gets stored in one of these called solid pods um so you are you are individually you have you you have physical physical control but you have um let's say digital physical control of uh of your data in a certain place and then whenever you you need to access a service log into something you're permissioning access to that service for a given period of time we're given access rights maybe just certain bits of the information

not not everything so he's kind of um he's he's pushing that forward now and that I would class that as a a very much a web 3 initiative um yeah anything yeah so like to get back to the well to stay on course with the web 3 stuff I guess one of the main motivations of that the web 3 paradigm shift is to address the privacy and security issues that we're seeing in in web 2 like all these gdpr kind of um lawsuits and breaches that that are happening but like my big problem not problem with this but I think some of the resistance to this is like we've just said you're pushing a lot of the responsibility onto users to manage you know their own data have it on their own data and that's inconvenient like there's this whole kind of I guess contrast between um privacy and security that web 3 promises and that kind of contending with the convenience and the user experience like do I want to actually be responsible for

all my data you know sometimes it's convenient if I forget my password if I mess up on my end that Facebook is kind of liable and they have you know lots of people working in the background to make sure that I have the best experience to keep me on the platform you know do I actually want to be responsible for that do I understand what that actually means that's a lot of liability being pushed to me which is good for the companies maybe but is it good for me yeah 100 agree I think um it's it's something where web3 so how we how we talk about blockchain previously as a kind of credible alternative for payments and you know doing micropayments where you get more autonomy and managing your funds managing your own keys and things like that it gives you the option to do that but it doesn't it doesn't prohibit you from also having third-party custody if you want it having Insurance having you know adding but yeah you know not getting rid

of all the middle men just giving people the option to if they want and I think the same is true with the data sovereignty aspect I mean I think you said as well in a previous episode like uh people might well be happy to give away that data if they're getting you know remunerated for it if they're getting paid to do it it might just be cut people might just be angry that they're not consenting and they might be you know not really care too much especially if there's a small incentive for them to to share data with companies um and when you start adding in incentives then it becomes something where companies will actually compete you know I think I think that's the difference in that model I mean that doesn't sound like me I don't think I said that joke you are right like I say most people even after this episode probably still won't care maybe someone care too much about the ownership we care about the you know the private insecurity

concerns because of the convenience aspect until you start to make things tangible until you start to say well you know Facebook makes one penny per every megabyte of data there on you why don't you make that one penny instead you know if company starts like have this kind of the shared monetization model with the users like that empowers the users and there's like a lot of benefit that can be had to that and I think you know one more thing they want to say on this um is about you know we've talked about the Privacy versus convenience of Shifting the data ownership from the large corporations to the individuals I think another benefit around this is also the security aspect if you know you have one Facebook that has the data for five billion people or whatever it is now whatever crazy number of Facebook users there are right now I mean although they're going to have you know very heavy security protocols to protect that data that's a big large attack surface there right

there's a lot of reason that people would want to invest a lot of time to break down those those kind of firewalls and get into that Facebook repo they've got five billion people's worth of data that's a a lot of longer but if you know you start to shift this to the individuals I've got one person's worth of data on my on my phone with the not similar security at all but like a high degree of security maybe that off puts some like offset some of the the security concerns because it's all about attack surface right like my data individually is not worth that much is it worth the time of someone trying to hack into my phone maybe not yeah exactly I think I think that is maybe the key in how you distinguish what web 2 does for data sovereignty compared to web3 in web 2 you very much have this client server model where you as a user are a client you request data from a server which sits in a large

company has massive data sets that are that these Crown Jewel data sets that are very valuable to attackers and attackers have a few large source of data to exploit you know they're highly highly incentivized to attack it to put resources into attacking it whereas as you say in web 3 moving that moving the data out to the client and keeping data client-side means that now they have to attack everyone in the world and it becomes much much less much much less uh profitable to do that it also reduces your risk as an individual as well so yeah and I will just say on the kind of the the privacy and security versus convenience and user experience like I've messed up on this uh you know I had a a crypto wallet and it was I should have known like it was um non-custodial Arrangements I had the keys on my end and it was I think I had like 500 pounds 600 pounds a lot of money you know and it was in my crypto

wallet I just didn't think about it for a long time like a year or two years and you know you don't have to worry about it too much on my phone looks fine they have to think about these things and then I updated my phone and I changed my phone and put everything across and then wiped the old phone then the apps tried to sign in I was like oh my God the keys were my previous phone that's been wiped I was like oh crap like I I got the benefits of the security and the ownership and all the sovereignty and stuff and then when it came to like the responsibility there was for me to realize that I was responsible for the keys and I had to move them across and all this kind of stuff and even me who's like aware of the space and I know what a non-custodial wallet is I know how this stuff works but still I messed up and I lost that money and that is just completely

inaccessible contact with the company they couldn't do anything obviously because it's on my end the thought point of this but there are genuine concerns around this like some people want the convenience user experience to know the big company will look after them and they'd have to worry about these things and that really was like eye-opening for me I was like okay web3 there are definitely some issues as well like I there are people including me sometimes who aren't willing to lose the convenience and the ease of use for the benefits of ownership and privacy definitely and I think there's also an element here of it's you know it's convenience versus security and if you haven't been burned by a bad incident then you don't know what it's like you don't you're comparing convenience against inconvenience and there's no there's no other there's no other upside there's that obvious until it happens to um but I think you know that's also a function of of it being early and these these still being quite freshly uh

talked about problems they've only been in the public Consciousness for quite a short amount of time and I think maybe as a final example of um you know this this is this isn't even necessarily web3 but just that people becoming more conscious of online security is the uptake in VPN use you know like four or four or five years ago I wouldn't have known what a VPN was and no one sure things um yeah maybe my friends wouldn't um but the point is now it's they're so widely spread like I think you watch you watch any YouTuber there's probably like a one in three chance that they'll be advertising a VPN subscription and they've gone to the roof after things like Cambridge analytica where people are people are just more conscious about online security than they ever were I think and people being able to track you know things like your IP address so um yeah I think we've we've talked about an awful lot I think that's our longest first section on the podcast

so maybe maybe it's a good chance to to go over okay welcome back so in the first half of this episode on day sovereignty and ownership we talked about you know the evolution why data ownership is so has become so important especially like in web 2 companies um taking vast amounts of data sometimes without user consent and using it in ways that you know maybe weren't um the the invention of gdpr to protect customers and consumers and you know some of the breaches and and the effects of this and how this all fits in to the web 3 idea of kind of you know increase increasing data ownership amongst consumers and impairing consumers we with the the data sovereignty um so yeah let's let's kick it off with uh we definition from chat GPT so chat TPT Jack's friend defines data sovereignty is the concept that information is subject to the laws and governance structures within the nation it is collected in essence it's about the control and management of data this includes where data

is stored how it is handled who has access to it and under what conditions it can be accessed or deleted well that was a very formal voice I gave yeah well I mean it sounded like uh you're reading some some legal document to be honest that definition felt like it could have been straight out of the gdpr legislation right it was very much focused on that well you know like some people have like uh they have phone voices I think I have a chatty PT reading out voice I wish I had any voice today to be honest so yeah what do you think of that definition I think we've kind of covered a lot of that stuff right yeah I think I think we have covered I think it um it does seem kind of limited to the uh the legal aspect that I'm looking at you know as you said at the start like being located in a nation like uh sovereignty being something that is um quite tied to the country in which

a data some data is collected or used which is uh which is interesting I don't think it necessarily captures too much of the web 3 aspect but I mean it's a pretty good definition right yeah I think so too I think it's kind of quite simple I think it's yeah it's a bit more complicated than that but we're trying to keep this this fairly high level I think yeah maybe now it would be interesting to go into some of the terms that are related to data sovereignty like we hear there's a lot of things there's a lot of aspects um I think one of the things that we've kind of talked about with them with data sovereignty is interoperability and I kind of want to kick off this one because we talk about it so much right we've talked about it I think in almost every episode so far is probably as as um to talk about as like data ownership is as well and I think in my mind this is the the ability

of different systems and applications to work together and exchange data you know in in ways that um maintain user control and ownerships it's all about that portability you know if I you gave an example of Tim Burns in his project there's another example I was quite interested in is Jack Dorsey you know Big Guy created Twitter um now moving to this other project called Blue Sky which is kind of like a social media base layer that he wants to push which is kind of in line with the web 3 model and his whole thing was that you know you pushed the kind of the data ownership to the users and that enables the users to take their data from application to application so you imagine you have this layer underneath that kind of references and stores the the user data and they can just choose to move that data you know my Facebook profile all the information associated with my Facebook profile my pictures my status all that stuff all of a sudden I want

to use something else instead of Facebook I don't have to reinvent the wheel I just have that that kind of layer beneath that takes all the data to my Instagram profile and I have one you know way to kind of Port from place to place and I think that's an incredible project and it's very exciting what he's doing right now yeah I am also a big fan of that I think uh I think is is moving in the right direction and um it's kind of tackling this idea that we mentioned previously of uh platform lock-in so once you know the stickiness of a particular platform or social media um site where it comes so hard to take your history with you everything you've done your reputation with you and interoperability is definitely a big part of that because if if the data that you know creates your reputation you know your reputation being essentially the history of all the data you've you've created or consumed on a platform then being able to take that with

you to a new platform and take the reputation with you take that identity with you that's all a case of interoperability I mean the other a similar example I don't know how similar it is technically but have you heard of I feel like you've mentioned in the pub before maybe which is you know typical um so it's like a Federated social media um where again all the data is meant to be interoperable with different implementations so you could spin up different um front ends to serve the same data and the other interesting thing is it's doing something like you were saying with pushing data out to the the end point so when I say Federated IT basically means that instead of having a Twitter or Facebook running the site from uh their their Central database um uh data centers instead you have you have individuals spinning up their own servers and having kind of micro servers around the world where you know you and I could support a certain bit of the bandwidth on this

site maybe for local data I I think there's a fascinating concept that will come in the future people will will store data for people other people they'd know in like a community system um which is where I think Mastodon and things like that going now you're getting ahead of yourself I think now you're getting very ahead of yourself you think in 10 20 years ahead of the future you heard it here first as you copyright that I think um yeah one of the things you know we're talking about is interoperability inside it's like how I move my data from place a to place B and like how I mean that's all about shared standards and you know all that all that kind of stuff I think a big question around this this portability stuff that we're talking about is you know why would I as Facebook who have in a way a monopoly on this data want you to have the ability to leave why would I want interoperability if I have you know 70

of the population working on my platform why would all of a sudden relinquish that control by saying yeah you can take your profile and all your stuff to you know Instagram I know Instagram is part of meta but to a different social media competitive social media platform like it's a difficult one yeah 100 I think um there is there probably is very little incentive right now because of what we said as well people people are aware of of the problems with um data aggregation and and it being sold but it's not stopping people really from using Twitter and Facebook um and other platforms so there's no incentive that they're not serving a big enough market demand probably by by changing the model it's it's still relatively Fringe I would say in in global terms this what we're talking about but I do I do feel like in the future we will move to a place where um platforms will try and compete in different ways and offering better privacy offering um a better relationship with

its users will be something that people will be willing to um to either move platform for or um yeah or start you know on differently I think that better privacy stuff is like it's still quite wishy-washy like I don't even I don't really care about that much but if a platform comes along and they say you know we'll give you money if you use that alternative to Facebook I'd be like yeah that makes so I think um one of the other things I know you and talk about is around hashing and encryption I mean that's super related to the stuff right yeah and I think it's worth in this episode just defining some of these terms because we have dropped them in before and I think you know it's worth saying what we mean by that so when we talk about web 3 privacy uh hashing is one of the first tools that is used to preserve privacy so if the blockchain is a public Ledger then any data you put on that is going

to be by definition visible so if you want to take advantage of the the proof of work put it being put into a blockchain uh the immutability of the data because it's an advantage to put the data there it can't be changed you can prove it hasn't changed it has all these applications and data logging it has applications in you know proving things about yourself in the context of data ownership so what hashing does essentially is it takes data it could be very large it condenses it into a very small uh very very small fingerprint of that data which is unique to to the input so we call them hashing functions you basically take some input data you run it through the hashing function and you get this fingerprint and people can put that fingerprint on the blockchain as a way of proving that some data hasn't changed without exposing the data publicly so that's why it's kind of one of these key privacy tools that we use in blockchain and web3 yeah so I

think a good example of what it's all want to do this is you know I have a certificate say you know I'm a University degree from whatever and the day I get that University degree I want to put that on the blockchain to prove you know on this day I receive my University degree and you know if my company says you get a pay rise from the day that you can prove your University degrees on there I have that date logged on the blockchain but I don't want to say yeah Alec Burns has an aerospace engineering degree from this University on this day so everyone in the world can see it you know I might get torn apart by you know people like you jack who don't appreciate aerospace engineering so I want to you know I want to cover that up I don't want people see that raw data so you would put it through a hashing algorithm like you were just explaining where the actual stuff on the blockchain doesn't mean anything to

anyone apart from say me who I know who knows what the kind of the the kind of the pre-data before the hashing algorithm was and anyone that I permission that to so I can then say look this this gobbledygoop effectively that's on chain at this date if I show you that you know my certificate directly relates to that information you know that information can't have changed with submit on that date and now you know what that actually information actually means yeah and I think this is this is really crucial because I think hashing is almost hashing something and putting on the blockchain is very similar to a definition I've heard of privacy so what I've heard people say that privacy is essentially um being able to prove something when it needs to be proved or being able to reveal something when it needs to be revealed but not before or you know when you're asked so in the case of auditing you know it's not the case that you're if you're being audited as a

company you're not publishing the data all the time you just reveal it to the auditor at the time and that's exactly the same concept as hashing data and putting on the blockchain in your case right you're you're preparing that degree certificate in in a way that you can prove yeah later down the line but you don't want to put you don't want to you don't want to reveal it in advance essentially okay I think in in software we call this like a backdoor type thing right that's a term that's kind of used but yeah exactly that so Jack what's the difference between hashing and yeah well this is reminded me of our our first episode same you better get the definition right now yeah I know probably erroneously said the first Bitcoin block header an encrypted message in it so hashing is a this way of of um fingerprinting data but you need the actual data to go back and connect it to the hash you need to run it through the algorithm again to

prove um that it corresponds to the hash on chain encryption is where you take some data and you apply what's called a an encryption key and you run that through an encryption algorithm so you take the data the key you feed that into an encryption algorithm and now the other side you get something called a ciphertext or an encrypted data packet the interesting thing about an encrypted data packet is unlike a hash it's not one way where you can only go from data to the hash encryption lets you go back from the encrypted data to the raw data so if you have possession of the key you can take the encrypted data apply the the key to it with the decryption function which is the kind of inverse of the encryption function for for kind of a simple way of thinking about it and that allows you to read the data again so that's another way that you can you can achieve privacy on the blockchain if you want to use it for data and

get that tamper-proof benefit is I'll take my data I'll encrypt it I'll put the ciphertext the encrypted data on chain so again no one can read what that data is it will be gobbledygook to anyone else unless they have the private key um to to the cryptographic key to decrypt that data again in the future got you I'm surprised you use the term gobbledygoop if that's silly as soon as I said it but I'm glad she did so I like it so what are some of the differences between you know instances where you prefer hashing versus encryption because they say I know you know ones one way either there was two-way so there must be like use cases that are very specific to each of them yeah I mean so I I think it's a little bit philosophical when you think about encryption because we use encrypted data all the time like it is the standard for all online Communications you when you get that little padlock sign uh at the top of your browser

um you may not notice it all the time but you definitely notice it when you go to like online banking or something because it says you've got a secure connection and that secure connection is being secured because the packets you're exchanging from your computer and the server at the bank are encrypted um and we we basically we are very confident that the encryption algorithms are robust so that means that if you if I give you the encrypted data packet but I don't give you the key then it's practically infeasible you know without without uh ungodly amounts of power um to to decrypt that and find out what the raw data is and the encryption schemes that we use they've been tested they've been developed by places like uh nist in America so they're kind of um the standards agency in America for cryptography and these are subject to huge testing uh huge battle testing so that the standard we use is called AES uh AES now Advanced encryption standard and we trust that we trust

that online Communications yeah yeah I had to drop another one in but we try and help FML okay there we go yeah no I get it I get it and I think like a good example were you talking earlier to link it back about you know some companies they don't want to store the raw data they don't want to be liable so imagine like I'm going to communicate with you but I want to communicate in a web 2 kind of model where we go through a central server like you I say you know hello Jack how you doing all this kind of stuff our usual kind of boring conversation if I have to go through that Central server say the Facebook equivalent they might have to store the raw data saying hello Jack how are you doing like and then pass it on to you there's pii there they say they know that Alec is sending a message to someone called Jack and the message contains Jack and hashing wouldn't really get around that by

me sending a hash to you because you need to have that original message for it to mean anything right whereas like encryption if you have if you and I for some reason we talk a lot which which we don't inside this podcast have an encryption and decryption key I could encrypt my message and say hello Jack how are you doing encrypt it it means nothing it's Gobbledy group I send it through the Facebook equivalent the central server they have no idea what that message means there's potentially no identifying pii identifying information in there now they pass on the encrypted message to Jack without any liability on their end and then Jack gets this gobbledygoop and he gets the D he has the decryption key already he uses that and he gets hey Jack how are you and he gets very happy that made his day and there's no liability in everyone's everyone's good yeah yeah and I think to kind of summarize the difference would be with encrypted data you have more functionality because if

I can see the encrypted data I can decrypt it if someone gives me the key so if I put an encrypted data packet on the blockchain then I could give you the key and you can decrypt it whereas if I put the hash on the blockchain I'd have to give you the raw data and that might be very large so one reason you might do that is for efficiency reasons it might be more efficient for me to transmit you a single cryptographic key which is very very small and then ask you to go and download the data yourself and decrypt it rather than me sending you the whole you know gigabyte or two gigabyte file or something um but yeah in my mind both hashing and encryption they both rely on certain assumptions about the security and what the ones we use currently are incredibly secure although one thing to bear in mind is for buck for both cases really um standards change over time so AES the encryption standard we use is not the

one we've always used we used to use one called Des um uh if the d stands for now but the idea being eventually we won't use AES anymore we'll use a more advanced crypto encryption standard um when we when we have fully flash if we ever have fully fledged things like Quantum Computing we'll need a Quantum resistant oh yeah encryption scheme so if you put data on the blockchain using today's scheme it probably will be fine for the next well don't quote me on this but 15 20 years at least but at some point the standards will move on and then it might become more more high risk so if we if we go 15 years and on this podcast and Quantum Computing is broken broken it I'm going to come back to you and then get back to this episode um so I think maybe we've spoken quite a long time already today which is I don't know how it's gone so quickly for the potentially a dry topic but I was going to

ask are there do you have any examples of people achieving or trying to achieve data sovereignty and ownership in practice like any examples of it happening um that the the a particularly interesting View I think like I love that I love social media like I think as in I love using social media as an example of how how important web3 is and I think we've talked about a fair bit so I don't want to spend too long on it but essentially you know web 2 social media platforms like Facebook they have control over your data if you you know if you decide to delete your account you lose access to all your photos photos messages all that kind of stuff and I think I want to imagine projects like Jack dorsey's Blue Sky project where he's thinking about the the web 3 based social media platforms where in this model you own your data not the platform so when you know you post a photo or a status update that data is stored in a

way that you control I think in in the blue skies it was basically in a distributed file storage system which you know we can talk about another time so you get to see you get to see who sees your data who sees that photo and under what conditions and if a company wants to use that you know use your data for advertising or kind of sell to other people and they would have to get your permission to use it and potentially even pay you and if you decide to leave that platform you can take that data with you and move it to a different platform that's part of the Blue Sky model and I think you know the shift in data ownership it's gonna well it is inevitably gonna lead to more privacy and better control over personal data and you know you're no longer the product but but instead you know being sold to these advertisers you become like an active participant in in how your data is used and who profits from from

that data and that mean for me that's one of the best examples of of how this can be applied what about you jack what were you thinking well before I say mine I think I'm kind of interested because this stuff is being built now um you know it's in various stages but I'm kind of curious what what do you think would tip you over into making the jump right would it be would it be something like um a platform with no advertising that you can achieve like with this or because I was also thinking for me I think it would be you'd have to have it tied to some bigger identity system where it's not just it's not just uh one social media platform I can use and move between but maybe I can link my social media with my other credentials and my national identity and all that is potentially further away but I'm curious what would be like the the biggest driver for you to to move over I think like I like

the idea of monetization I think if I could be incentivized for for using it that would be a big thing for me but man I'm I'm a sheep I think I think it's all about Network Theory uh and you know as soon as there's enough people who are on there using it I would just jump ship like I don't think I use social media that much right now but it is mostly talk to friends like I think I'm quite light touch in that sense but I think as soon as that happens you had a few friends who are using it I would just jump then basically which is not ideal because someone's going to be the first mover right yeah okay cool I mean so the main message is just be a sheep always be a cheaper it's true that is true I mean it especially with social media I think it's uh yeah Network effects that's that's going to be uh the slow March of adoption but you know I'm sure we'll get there

at some point so what about you if you've got any favorite real world applications for so I mean I have I have an example of um seeing this move to data sovereignty and it's not I don't think it's really a web three example but I think it's a very powerful one so do you remember when Apple I think in 2021 it was when they introduced their new um privacy tracking policy do you remember this no are you an Apple user uh I am not I'm Samsung user ah okay okay so you're you remember the work in Tech so you're you're like the guys who are using Yahoo in 2013.

I dare you sir okay let me fill you in um because yeah that explains you would definitely have noticed this I think if uh if you're an Apple user so they they introduced this this um policy on their apps where whenever you download an app or whenever there's an update I think as well the app has to ask you whether it can track you so it literally pops up and it says um you know do you allow this app to track you so how often do you think I I say yes you know very very infrequently and in addition to that you know that's kind of actively stopping tracking and that it now also tells you in the App Store exactly what data is collected by each app so you know and the kind of the bit what happened here is that this completely changed things for Facebook so this is 2021.

it kind of started destroying their advertising model because of this whole data broker aspect this data aggregation aspect they were really relying on the cross-site tracking the tracking you through different apps and things yeah so as soon as people started saying no their advertising model their quality went straight down and people there was there was a prediction I saw that it was going to cost them something like 12 billion in Revenue oh my God you know what happens six nine months later in 2021 is Facebook fully pivot to the metaverse you know they're kind of changing their business model so it was that powerful Apple making this one change um so yeah I think that's that for me that's the biggest thing that's happened in data private in sovereignty in a long that is so interesting a couple of it in here but that see now I am adamant you need to read chaos monkeys because it's about the decision they start to go like cross-platform advertising and selling like user kind of data to

other other people outside of the Facebook it's crazy like it really is you need to read it it's so incredible that's yeah that's an exciting one I will do we'll let that's uh that's a good recommendation to uh to end on maybe so yeah I think uh I think I think I've said all I want to say about data sovereignty for one day there's plenty more for a future episode I think yeah definitely and I think yeah some of the main things for me about like concerns and considerations about data sovereignty we've talked a lot about you know the additional responsibility of the ux versus convenience do people want these things and I think a big thing that we just touched on to end with was how do companies fit into this what are the new economic models for companies like Facebook in in this kind of in this new world where they don't have complete ownership of users data I think that's a big topic and I think we could spend a whole another

episode speaking about that I think yeah that's a good place to end thank you for listening thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma camilleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes