Episode 70
DAOs with Sunny Lu
About this episode
In this week's episode of Untangling Web3, we're joined by Sunny Lu, co-founder and CEO of @vechainofficial. Sunny brings a wealth of knowledge from his former role as CIO of Louis Vuitton China and over a decade in technology.
VeChain, under Sunny's leadership, is redefining global supply chains and leveraging blockchain for sustainability initiatives like VeBetterDAO, which rewards sustainable actions.
Key Highlights
- DAOs and Decentralization. Sunny introduces us to the concept of Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs), explaining them as a new structure for collaboration and decision-making across diverse parties, aiming to achieve common goals efficiently.
- VeBetterDAO. The discussion dives deep into how VeChain uses blockchain to enhance supply chain transparency and efficiency, illustrating the practical applications of such technologies in enterprise settings.
- Challenges of DAOs. While DAOs promise a decentralized way of operating, they come with challenges such as ensuring widespread and knowledgeable participation in decision-making processes.
Sunny's insights highlight the transformative potential of DAOs in business and beyond, advocating for a shift towards decentralized structures to tackle global challenges collaboratively.
This episode not only illuminates the path forward for integrating blockchain into traditional businesses but also underscores the importance of community-driven decision making in fostering sustainable and innovative ecosystems.
Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
Welcome to the Untangling Web 3 podcast. Today, we're thrilled to welcome Sunny Lu, the visionary co-founder and CEO of VeChain. With a background as the former CIO of Louis Vuitton China and over 15 years of tech expertise, Sunny is pioneering the use of blockchain for enterprise solutions and sustainability. Under his leadership, VeChain is transforming global supply chains and driving cutting-edge initiatives like Vebetdao, which incentivizes sustainable actions through blockchain technology. Today, we'll be speaking to Sunny about DAOs or decentralized autonomous organizations. Sunny, it's a pleasure to welcome you to the show.
Yeah, very glad to be here. Um, you know, we could have we can have a lot of the fun things to talk about a DAO and a blockchain and crypto, sustainability, anything. So, yeah. I think yeah, the the problem's going to be keeping it dialed. Uh, when I first met you, it was a few months ago now, and I remember we started speaking about the crypto space and how it's changed, and we ended up speaking for hours because you've been such a big player in the ecosystem for so long.
You've got so many stories and so many insights about what it used to be like, most of which we we wouldn't have time if we had like 12 hours to record this. But, you know, let's go into some of it. Could you tell us a little bit about how you got into crypto and, you know, how VeChain came about all those years ago? Oh, yeah. Um, very long time story, actually. actually, last year was my 10-years anniversary. So, this year is already 11th year to be in the crypto space.
And I was I remember that I was working Louis Vuitton, and also I was a game and I played World of Warcraft uh most of the time. And um, you know, I don't I don't really like the environment like um the regime of World of World of Warcraft China. So, I was trying to play with my friends in West Coast, um you know, in the European region, the West West Coast region, East Coast region of US. And um I tried to catch up with my with my friends and um I tried to buy some coins, right?
But I do I didn't have a dollars and so somebody offered me like, "Okay, you you can use the Bitcoin." Um it was like $1 each um back in 2012. And I was like, "What a Is it a scam or So start to uh and you know, study about the Bitcoin and um and later on I did I did actually get scammed actually. Um I was buy the Bitcoins through the through the Tor browser. Um and the guy never sent me the Bitcoin, but I lost about $100 or something.
I tried to buy 100 Bitcoin. Um but later on um you know, um get to know more Bitcoin and get to know about uh Bitcoin talk and start to meet lots of people. And by the way, because I was uh working Louis Vuitton, I got um you know, quite a good opportunity to travel around. So every time I travel to a different city, I always try to find a Bitcoin meetup, crypto meetup at the time and get to know more about Bitcoin and everything else. So that's that's how basically how I get started.
So that's that seems like you and Vitalik have that in common cuz he started getting to the decentralized nature of crypto because his World of Warcraft player got nerfed, right? But yours was about the transaction. I'm not a warlock player. Let's put this I'm more like a assassin or more like a knight, that kind of thing. Um but uh yeah, and also in 2015 um I well, firstly I made a first bucket money uh through the Bitcoin mining. And um I feel like, well, it's the right time I should uh start to do something on my own.
And also I was um I was managing the a global project in Louis Vuitton. It's called track and trace. So I'm thinking about, "Okay, what about if we use a blockchain to replace the traditional database? So we should do something more um more even more interesting. So, that's that's how Vechain started. Actually, you know, I'm engineer, I'm a technical guy, and um I choose the name pretty like a direct meaning with a direct meaning. So, Vechain stands for verification blockchain. So, we try to use the you know, uh blockchain to verify the global project like a track and trace inside the Louis Vuitton, and that's that's how Vechain started.
That's that's super interesting as a as a way in. And obviously, having been a more or less a an OG of the crypto and Bitcoin space, right? 11 years is quite a long tenure in the space for anyone. That makes you kind of one of the the gurus, the oldest living gurus in the space in my mind. And yeah, it's interesting that you had that way in with Louis Vuitton and the kind of one of the traditional applications of blockchain in the kind of supply chain track and check track and trace world.
But now you've moved on to something that's kind of when when we spoke to Antonio Santoro, your CTO, a couple of months ago, you know, he he espoused this really big grand vision that really inspired us for Vechain. I think it's really exciting. And I think today I I really really like to dig deeper in one of those aspects, which is the DAO aspect. So, you know, we've mentioned V better DAO, and I'm sure we'll get into the specifics of that a little bit more later, but for our audience, could you just give us a brief overview like what's the the explain like I'm five version of uh what is a DAO, okay?
What is it? How does it differ from a traditional organizational structure, and why do why should we care about Yeah, well, that's actually very quite a tough challenge, right? When we think about a DAO, it's not that easy to But I will try. Um so, firstly, DAO represents decentralized autonomous organization, you know, in a direct Um it's um I would say it's a new way to organize the different parties to, let's say, make a decision and work out towards the same goal, uh those type of things.
And if we try to use a very simple language, it's just, you know, you you kind of you kind of use a vote voting power to decide anything within this organization for the best uh interest of efficiency and the smart decisions and eventually to achieve the goal. So, yeah, well, still, I don't think the 5-year-old could understand But it's like uh within your family, if you try to go to um a movie with your kids, with your uh spouses, and then that's vote. What kind of movie we should uh go for it?
Is that family animation? Is it or like a Marvel movies? So, that's basically a typical DAO use case. Yeah, that's that is a really good description, I think. And, you know, uh some very clever 5-year-olds, I'm sure, would just about be able to grasp what you're saying. Cuz, again, you're talking about it in an abstract term, right? It's about decision-making. How do you come to consensus on on something as a group, which is part of the core of what blockchain is all about, right? Consensus mechanisms.
How do we How do we agree on the state of a blockchain? Well, DAOs are kind of more general in a sense. How do you agree on on making decisions? And, you know, we've had a few very famous examples. So, the first one I was aware of was the, you know, the Ethereum the DAO that you know, famously raised 150 million pounds and then got hacked. That's, you know, maybe a little bit less successful, but and then you have recent things like the Constitution DAO, right?
Which very nearly bought a copy of the Constitution. So, I think they're definitely gaining in popularity. Moving away from the abstract, what does it actually mean on a technical level? Like, what are the underpinnings from a technical perspective of what all these DAOs actually are then? Well, actually, there are many technical elements, um you know, in terms of the DAO, um or to to make the DAO working. Um number one, for sure, is a smart contract, right? Um smart contract is um um a typical technical terms on the blockchain.
I don't think we need to explain what a smart contract is. But I was Smart contract is a backbone of a DAO. Um basically smart contract will automate um processes like governance, voting, funding, even the rewards distribution. So once the smart contract deploy on a blockchain and then it's kind of um the smart contract will execute um predefined rules. All of the predefined rules without any human interventions. Um and for sure the blockchain is um the infrastructure to support a smart contract um to you know the to guarantee the the transparency in um you know the publicity.
So all of the let's say the the technical features on the of the blockchain is kind of guarantee the smart contract and also uh the other And also uh decentralized voting um is one of the key elements also. Going to make sure the voting is not cannot be manipulated, cannot be centralized, decided by only a small group of people. But we do need like the decentralized voting mechanism to make sure everyone got a chip in, everyone got to say something, everyone can have a power to to decide something.
And also make sure the decision can be decided by the majority um of the entire community. And also the governance token um acting as um carrier of those voting mechanism. How do you guarantee the voting mechanism is decentralized? You going to use a governance token inside of the DAO to make sure people using the token to make the voting um to be to be done. Well, actually there are many other things like a treasury management, the general tokenomics. Oh, a very important thing is about oracles.
Um because DAO um is let's say running um on the virtual world, right? Running on the blockchain. you got to have a oracle to be able to connect with the real world. Either you get the real world input to be as the source, as a reference, as like all of the information you need to make your decision. Or as a result you need to have a result to be or decision to be executed in the real world. So basically a oracle is acting a very important element also in the DAO to be make sure to be connecting with you know between the virtual world to the real world.
So yeah, there there are many other things. We can talk about Yeah, I know. But you definitely touched on the core components in my mind. Like the one is smart contracts. And if you don't know what a smart contract is, we've got a whole episode kind of explaining the fundamentals of smart contracts. But when you're talking about multiple people interacting all around the world and everyone sometimes having like equal vote, you need some way to govern that, some way to manage that. And that's one of the beauties of you know of DAOs is that they use smart contracts.
So everyone knows what the terms are, how things will operate in advance. You kind of touched on that transparency. And the second component if we're talking about an MVP of a DAO in my mind which you also touched on is the tokens, the things that actually people use to actually participate in the network. And this is where the whole crypto world kind of comes in. People that are all familiar with crypto understand that you're basically using them and being rewarded with these tokens to actually participate in in the DAO.
And then if that's the MVP stuff in my mind, then you go in a bit bigger and broader when you think about oracles. This is how we start to like you say go into the real world, actually make our decisions actionable and do something outside of blockchain. And we actually haven't explained what oracles are in detail, but we will do an episode on that at some point. But it's effectively how we get information from the real world onto a blockchain and sometimes action, you know action DAO information or blockchain information into the real world.
So, Sunny, you touched on like some of the benefits that you talked about transparency being a major benefit, seeing all the transactions and decisions being recorded on blockchain so anyone can audit it. But, are there any other kind of primary benefits you see with DAOs when compared compared with like conventional business models? Well, I would say there are many benefits, but the the biggest the one or my favorable one is actually I do believe the power of You know, um no one is perfect. No one is a superman, right?
No one is like a god can be able to know everything or decide everything without any kind of uh let's say um um mistakes or So, I would say it's really the power of decentralization could make the best of decision on many other things. Um especially in terms of the organization, you know, uh the current company structure or company or corporation structure has been existing like a 500 years or 600 years, something like that. And sure, there are many other uh whatever from the management process or or uh you know, information system kind of um make the efficiency or productivity um much much more advanced comparing like 500 years ago or 600 years ago.
But, also we see the a typical challenge, you know, the the corporate structure becomes more and more um reaching to some kind of bottleneck stage, mhm, right? Um first they you got to have like especially when your business becomes like super big and we're not talking about only five people or 10 people, we're talking about 10,000 people or 20,000 people. And it's very difficult to let's say to have to listen to everyone's opinion, everyone's advices, or everyone's suggestion, good or bad. Um so eventually kind of using the hierarchy structure in the normal corporation style and eventually the fundamental decision or the ultimate decision decide by the board, only like five or six people.
Let's put this way. And those are people actually quite um disconnected with the frontier line, with the like ground work. So how do they do, right? We we all know like Elon Musk who likes to uh goes through the the the manufacturing side, it goes through the basics launch station, talking to the people directly. Because that that information is very uh let's say essential critical to some of the decision-making. While in a normal corporate structure, um it's it's really difficult to uh to reach over there.
So um how to make a decision um you know, in a more effective way or way? I would say that's that's that's um number one benefit of the launching the Yeah, you've touched on some really like big things there. Like the primary benefit being decentralization. Like one, it's enabling everyone to kind of like well, the decentralization bit is removing these bottlenecks, right? Meaning it can be 24/7, single points of failure. That's the buzzword when it comes to this stuff. And then the other one we were talking about was transparency.
And I guess this kind of touches on what you were kind of saying and it being a game and having a game in background, the idea of like community involvement. And when you're part of something and you're voting on something, you want to make it like the best thing it can be and you really like give your heart and soul to something and that thing grows and becomes better because of it. I think that's a like you said, there's a really powerful benefit of these DAOs.
So we've touched on a lot of the good things. You've been doing this first hand now. What are some of the challenges or drawbacks like typically associated with DAOs? Yeah, well, that's also um let's say very obvious. Um for example, the efficiency. Um you know, if you try to get the idea from 5,000 people or 10,000 people, you know, it could it could have take ages to go through all of the debates and try to think about overall, but also not everyone has for example, not everyone is expert in some of the territory.
I'll give an example, one of the common model or use case of the DAO right now is about a cross funding or investment, right? But not everyone is expert in terms of the venture capital or in terms of even even think about it like a treasury allocation. Let's say we wanted to go for some marketing events, but not everyone is marketing expert, right? Not everyone understands, you know, is the token 2049 is a good event or consensus is better event. Nobody are able to like they're let's say limited people with that kind of knowledge, with that kind of expertise are able to make the best decision.
So, I think the typical challenge is how do we get to the right people with the right expertise to make the right decision in the right territory. So, maybe like NFT with a reputation system could do the work. So, instead of giving like equally the voting power to everyone, but some of experts may have you know, better or way weighted voting power to guarantee the success of the decision-making process. So, yeah, that's that's I would say that the most headache in my mind when we when we think about some of the decision-making process.
Yeah, it's one of those old adages, isn't it? That you have an existing problem, you solve it and then that creates a whole new set of problems, but it is true and I just want to touch on the fact that you know, you mentioned how large some of the organizations are in the world, you know, places like I think Walmart is the one of the largest private companies in the world. They have over 2 million employees. Like, I don't understand how how you can govern these things properly and how they are.
And yeah, it's a great idea moving to this DAO model where you flatten that hierarchy, you have kind of equal levels of participation based on your your stake involved, but then that introduces the again these these new sets of challenges that you mentioned. So, maybe just to to crystallize this idea then, can we talk about how how do these DAOs actually function uh you know, from from from a practical perspective? So, let's say we have a DAO, we have a bunch of participants. They all have a different amount of the governance tokens, so they have different voting weight, etc.
What does that decision-making process actually look like? Say someone has a great idea, how do you go from that to this idea actually being executed in Yeah, well, um firstly, it's just it's let's go back uh go back a little bit like a human nature. You know, one very interesting thing I discovered, especially when I traveling around uh especially in Europe, you know, whatever is a big city like a Brussels or the smaller city um very small like even a small town with only like a few thousands of people, um you can find out most of the uh towns or cities have a unique uh configurations as the infrastructure, which is kind of like a Right?
Actually, the plaza usually have a uh signature building is is a fountain or is a big church um as a as a symbol. Well, but usually every place has a place according to the plaza. And I was I was wondering like, "What is it for, right?" It's actually for a town hall meeting. Like, gathering everyone together, try somebody going to make a proposal to say, "Oh, I want to change like this or I want to change like that or I discovered this problem, maybe we should look for a solution." So, that's basically the I would say the primitive like a doll.
So, doll needs to have a place like a town hall even virtually, right? It could be a Telegram group, it could be a Reddit thread, it could be a different kind of formats. Or actually the the first doll, I would say it's Bitcoin talk. The old BBS, right? I I knew I knew you like the young fellows don't even familiar with the concept what is a BBS. Um but that's kind of the town hall for everybody can say something. And then, you know, some organizer or like even even naturally it would be like a leader find out there was some let's say a hot topic or clearly it's obvious challenge of course, you know, impacting the entire community or even entire the project, then somebody will jumped out.
It It could be It could be anybody. But somebody could jump out like, "Okay, let's make a proposal. Let's address that issue or let's try to you know solve some issue some problems and then make a proposal and let the people to debate on that." So, usually try to you know make more efficient, make more reasonable. There is also we call the heat check process. Right? You see like is it just you or is it really represent the majority of the community? And after you pass the heat check then you could be formalized as the proposal.
So, usually who wrote this proposal, who you know, raised up the proposal should take a little bit more actual work. Try to put every information into that. It could be a theoretical reference, it could be Um, know, reference from the outside of the project, like who has done the similar things, what is the bad or cons and pros analysis, or what is the feedback or or voice situation in the community, so they can gather together, put it into one single article. You know, usually pretty lengthy, and you know, let people to to read through all of that.
So, it's also kind of like a summarize the situation, because usually when you kind of debating with others or discussing from one topic to another, maybe take a few days or even just a few hours, it could be deviated to some, you know, unknown places, right? So, this kind of proposal is also acting as a summary to gather all of the information just to for the convenience of any kind of readers or voters in the future. And then, start to vote about it. You know, people use the governance token to make your decision, to cast your votes.
So, there are there are different type let's say mechanism for the voting. You could be just based on like a POS, like as based on how many tokens you have, you can decide you can you can the the tokens you have kind of represent the power your voting. Or we can use a quadratic voting, you know, like to giving more balance about the people's votes, and also the treasury or the assets you have. Try to avoid the capitalism issue, right? But for sure, it will lead to another another situation like a civil attack, those type of things.
But yeah, that's a voting process, and once the decision the result can comes out, either it's get approved or either get rejected, and you know, Um, passed to the execution of team like uh usually is a technical team to make it that kind of the changes and then implement to uh to everyone. So, that's a typical process from the town hall that kind of format discussion to a heat check to a proposal and to the voting and to the decision and to the Yeah, I that's I that's a really good job of summarizing the whole process and I'm glad you took it back to, you know, early civilization as well as early Bitcoin civilization because I do I definitely feel like there's a connection between how things like Bitcoin and Ethereum work and what you're describing with DAOs because as you said, you had the Bitcoin talk forum, you have the the BIP process, Bitcoin improvement process, and you have the same thing in Ethereum where you have this community proposal, people attack it and
and improve it until it's it's ready for kind of implementation in the wider world. And to me, it sounds like DAOs are a generalization of that that that world from where in Bitcoin, you have proposals, maybe miners vote on it with the hash power. Ethereum, people vote it validators vote on it with their stake. Now, you're opening that up so you don't have to be a blockchain miner or a blockchain validator to do that. You can do it for anything, right? You just need to have this this thing to participate.
Is Is that roughly how you see it as well? Yeah, well, that's uh we we have to show the respect to Ethereum because Ethereum kind of make um um you know, smart contract viable, smart contract doable, right? And a smart contract comparing to Bitcoin, um Bitcoin is like a purely ledger system while smart contract is more much more complicated, right? You can make the activity also immutable on the blockchain. That's what the smart contract do. Even still, uh you know, reminds me that's also a typical challenge to DAO or to that kind of decentralized voting mechanism.
Um, smart contract is still not strong You know, you only can have a very simple logic um into the smart contract to be coded, to be executed, predefined rules. And then what about the the predefined rules could be really complicated, right? Even when we think about the movie, like the whole family goes to a movie, um, is a is a horror movie, is a, you you know, Asian movie, is a, action movie, adventure, scientific fiction or not or it's a, you know, drama or not drama.
So, it it could be a lot of the different rules, right? So, it's also one of the typical challenge, um, but still we should salute to the Ethereum and and EVM and smart contract, um, because that kind of make, let's say, more complicated decision process or complicated pro- proposal can be executed and carry on in on the blockchain by the smart contract. So, yeah, that's you know, that's why we said smart contract is the backbone of the DAO. I'm glad you like brought that up. It's such a big thing that we talked about when we were outlining what a smart contract is and what kind of effects it can have on society because there's some people that would say be proponents of, you know, smart contract, you're going to codify the world and everything will be transparent.
And you're like, but there's so much gray zone in everything like you just said, there's so many different types of movie. Not everything can be codified. Like a big thing would be like when you put in these proposals forward, you don't know like the unknown unknown, right? You have to you want to if someone has delivered the thing that they proposed because there's so many different things that can come up. I imagine that's one of the trickier things when you're talking about DAOs. If something does get voted on, how say a year down the line do you prove that say someone executed it to the way that was voted on?
What if things change, you know? Like a big thing we had in the UK with Brexit and half the people voted for Brexit and I imagine that most of those people aren't happy with how it was executed, but it's too late now, we can't bring it back. Um, but to get practical, uh, you know, you're actually running the experiment now. You're running a version a DAO basically. We've had Antonio on previously talking about V-DAO, but can you give us, you know, now we know what DAOs are and it's been well explained, what is V-DAO?
What is the grand vision and aim of V-DAO? Well, V-DAO is um a typical decentralized the marketplace um for um a specific um type of decentralized application. We call it um to let's say motivate or incentivize individual users to do the right action or better action to make the right contribution eventually as a collective way to sustainability rollouts. Simply say about a V-DAO. Um and the reason we choose DAO because honestly you know, we think about the fundamental issues we want to do address inside especially inside of the sustainability.
Firstly, sustainability is the biggest the consensus of the humankind, right? So, everyone knows like that's the right thing to do. That's something we have to do. Otherwise, it maybe not us, but our kids, our next generations going to suffer whatever from the environmental change or the the chaotic social organization, whatever. Um so, we know sustainability is the right thing to do. But, we also can see it's quite a decentralized challenge, right? So, it's it's it it needs to count on everyone's um commitment, everyone's delivery. So, give an example, if you save one tons of CO2 in California, which has no no difference than somebody save one tons of CO2 in uh Philippines or in uh Vietnam.
So, basically it's the same same thing, same impact, same result to the um to the to our earth. So, it's a typical decentralized a challenge which requires, I would say, decentralized solution. So, generally speaking, web three, blockchain, smart contract, and even including the DAO, a typical decentralized autonomous organization, is a perfect answer to address that type of the challenge. So, that's why we wanted to use a DAO to um to, you know, carry on this type of um activities coming from the individual users, coming from everyone, whatever is normal people or Nobel Prize winner or a big corporation or a you know, NGO as association, organization.
Um everybody can do something and could could do different type of the roles in this ecosystem and eventually all work together a collective and accumulative results as the sustainability implementations. So, that's that's let's say simply to say, that's a Vechain DAO. So, we wanted to, let's say, use that DAO as the format to allocate the tokenomics or to allocate the token allocation. It's kind of like a treasury, right? The funds you wanted to allocate to the right people, to the right application, right project. But who going to make the decision?
Is it me or is it Vechain Foundation per Um you know, we we we wanted to try the way like let everyone to make a decision. Let everyone to decide, you know, who is who should be the right decision? You know, you may not be the expert in kind of the developer uh or technology realization or choose what type of the protocol, but you could be the user. Everybody can be the user, right? Everybody can use a mug shot to drink a coffee, use a cleaning fight to you know, pick up the littering, clean up your corner, or use a EV app to try charge your EV cars.
So, everyone can be the user, then let every user, based on your experience, based on your um your journey with that application, and then make a decision who's your favorable application. Right? And so, we design a certain type of the rules inside of the V better DAO to make the user like the direct user who use those X to earn application can make a voting power. Can make a decision like, okay, what is the next a batch of token allocation could it go? Should it go to Cleanfy?
Should it go to Coveneer? Should go to um you know, NFPC or Bio? Actually, different people has a different uh choices. So, eventually, as a whole, you know, that's the power of decentralization. That's a representative representation of the power of decentralization. And worked out pretty fine so far. And I'm a pretty exciting about the progress so far. Yeah, I just want to double click on what you said there, Sunny, because I completely agree. The sustainability problem is such a cross-border and decentralized issue. Like this the people that are being hit the hardest are the people with the fewest funds to actually like do anything about it, right?
It's people places in less economically developed countries around the world who don't really necessarily have the available funds to address those issues. And we and maybe the richer Western societies who are causing a lot of the problems do have the funds. And because we don't see the impact necessarily directly at us, we're actually not doing much about it. So, I completely agree with like the reasoning why you've gone for this approach. Um and I love the definition that V better DAO is effectively a treasury to support and back these X to earn apps.
And we haven't actually touched on the idea of X to earn apps. But it's such an interesting concept. Like Jack and I have, you know, previously talked about micro incentives and how, you know, one of the main purposes, or in my mind anyway, of crypto was because it's this efficient payment system, you can actually have these micro-incentives, which could lead to, you know, micro-rewards for small actions. So, you you you kind of you talked about a lot of different applications. Could you double-click and just really explain one of your favorite applications, for example, and how this X-to-earn app works in that use case?
Well, um, you know, I I try as as um as the leader of the WeGene Foundation and also the V-Pet at all, um, I try to not be like kind of bias for any kind of application. I love them all. I honestly say I love them all. Seriously, um, because let's say by design, I think not only our own engineers, but also those developers and builders from the community, they're really genius. You when we picture this idea roughly, and they're able to deliver with those different type of application.
But, following like our um time of lives, our daily lives, from the beginning, you can wake up and drink a coffee, you can choose use a recycled mug or use a paper cup or disposable cup. Or, when you drive to your work, you can take a EV or not a fossil car. Or, you know, um when you walk um in the in your lunch break, you can find out, um you know, what kind of a you can pick up the littering from the street and clean up a beach just at your convenience.
Um even like when you finish your work, you go to a supermarket, buy your groceries, you can choose different type of products, right? Is that a sustainable one or not sustainable one? Or, um you can choose um, you know, a recycled bag or try to not so you not using a plastic ones, generating the plastic waste or plastic pollutions. And even before you go to sleep, you can, you you listen a little bit like audio books, um to save some trees as well. So, honestly, all of the different type of action, I just I just love them all.
And them all. Yeah, and I think the the the most important thing for all of the application, it's like very convenient, very friendly to use for um any users. So, basically, you don't need to I I always say thanks to um all of the we call emerging technology progress, including the AI, including the IoT. It kind of make the feasibility so much um there. Like, you can just simply to to use application, take a few steps, boom, you finish your work, and you record your work.
And sure, there will be more functionalities or features kind of expecting from the users right now, but starting from simple, starting from easy way, and then you can get things started. And sure, different user, you know, they have a different uh again, back a little bit to the voting power, you know, um different user have a different preferences. For example, when I travel to Tokyo, I find the Japanese user are really into the cleaning vibe. Because like a clean up the neighborhood um is kind of mean to be in the DNA.
For example, you cannot find the any kind of uh um public bin or trash bin uh in the street of Tokyo or most of the places in in Japan. Because they they they have a a routine like they carry on their garbage, and they they can put in the right categories, you know, um for the garbage clear collectors. Um or uh you know, right now for for Korean people, um that's one thing I just learned from the Korean Blockchain Week, they actually really like the NFBC, like the you know, using the book club things.
Because they kind of feel like I don't need to go out to do anything. I'm just at my home, and you know, I listen my uh audio book and I can earn rewards. They just love them, right? So, yeah, different places, different people, they have a different things. Even though somebody is start to complain, it's also the Korean user, they're complaining They they like coffee. However, Mugshot use the Google Map, right? As a background mapping service, which Google Map is not working pretty well in Korea.
They use their own maps. So, it kind of giving a challenge to Mugshot like, okay, you might you might have a a specific version for Korean users to make sure they can have, you know, more coffee shop allocate locations. So, that's actually I would have considered as the power of decentralization. So, user are able to say something to the builders, to the developers and then the user would drive the needs using the needs leverage eventually the delivery of those Mhm. You talk about when you talk about this last more natural structure, it also means that you get direct interaction with your potential user base using these Dows, which makes so much sense.
So, on that Mugshot one, I don't Can you explain to me how that actually works? Cuz what's, you know, what does coffee drinking got to do with sustainability? What's the X there and what's the earn there? Could you give us like a a work through of how that works? Yeah, well, firstly, from the user journey is pretty simple. Um you take a coffee and if you choose to use a recycle mug other than the paper cup or plastic cup and you take a photo, boom, you get a rewards right away.
And also for sure, they also have a different options like if you at a coffee shop, you can choose a different option, different button inside of the to say, oh, I can I can choose like based on my geographical location and I can choose oh I'm in this coffee shop, I'm in this Starbucks, I'm in that Costa or I'm in that Caffe Nero, whatever. And then I can take a photo of my coffee along with my receipts. You get get the better allocation in terms of the rewards.
Or there's another one they call Super Shot campaign, which you know, in some of the week some of the time period of time you can go to a specific coffee brand. For example, you go to eating coffee and you get even more rewards as as like a marketing campaign for the for that coffee shop. So we call it a super shots. So in terms of user journey, it's it's pretty easy. And by the way, recently Map Share also adopted a third-party social log on. So you can log on with your Apple accounts or you can log on with your Google accounts.
So it kind of opened the door to even non-crypto user. You don't necessarily to own the wallet, but you can use a little bit of custodian service and social log on and you can start to use that right away. Actually, some of my friends and families, they they're not crypto user, but they start to start to use that because of this. My mom actually loved that. You know, my mom is a 70-years-old Chinese lady, doesn't speak English, but uh think the last trip he visited in Milan with me and start to grow a happy like a cappuccino.
He likes to drink cappuccino, so I told her like, "Okay, use the Map Share and you can earn some rewards." And he really enjoyed that. That's that's super exciting. I think, you know, you touched on the the importance of getting the UX right and and user journey and I completely agree. We talk about all the time, but I'm I'm honestly really enamored by the whole approach that you're taking with these X2O naps and I the way I see it is very much around micro actions, that being micro incentivized, right?
And I think that's an idea that has been around for a long time, but web 3 is now really making it mainstream. So, if you know, one example, well, we've got a couple examples in the UK I'll show. We we had the uh plastic bag charge introduced, you know, however long ago, 10 15 years or something like that. And the the impact of that, so you know, every it's only a small change. It's like if it was 5 or 10 p. But I looked up that and it it's reduced it by something like 7.5 billion plastic bag sales per year, right?
Or you know, something like 98% of the actual total. So, it's actually huge, but back in that those times, that was a penalty, right? It wasn't an incentive. And now we're seeing these incentive schemes and you know, we've got one coming in Scotland for uh plastic recycling for bottles where they're giving you back 20 p on what you paid for for the drink, right? So, these things are now becoming a lot more mainstream. So, yeah, I think I think the future's very bright for those apps and I hope they uh I hope they do take Just mentioned about the very two, let's say, key points about um why we wanted you know, design and build the V-Label app as as the new way to incentivize people to do the right thing.
Um one is, for example, actually many other traditional corporations, they have we they call it a campaign. Like, you know, with a certain period of time, they organize a campaign like, "Okay, don't use the plastic bags or don't use uh paper cups. And if you use a recycle ones, we want to reward you." Actually, there's a similar campaigns in the in the traditional world. But usually, they run it in a period of time. Why? Because try to verify the actions, you know, it's quite difficult. It It difficult.
Um so, they wanted to limit to only to one location or uh one period of time and you know, use extra force to organize the campaign and try to grow the habit. However, this type of thing it should be on a daily basis. You shouldn't just do like for this week or for that months. No, you should do it every day, right? It's a huge amount of, let's say, collective and accumulated value um coming from your daily actions. And Web3 just make it a possible. You know, use IoT to digitalize your activity and they use the smart contract to verify your actions and also smart contract to guarantee your rewards.
And then, boom, you can be done like on a daily basis. You could be reaching out reach to everyone. Not necessary, oh, you have to be in London, you have to be in Paris, you are able to participating that type of things. It can be decentralized way. So, that's that's um uh number one, you know, um when we think about how to design the V better app. And the other thing is about a penalty. You know, penalty is always showing the negative thing, right? It's like uh you know, um kind of make the every user become like a bad boys.
They're like, okay, you do bad things, so I want to punish you. It's not really a right, I would say it's not right a gamification to grow user that kind of behavior, that kind of habits. And then, we all know that a positive education is is much more effective, right? So, instead of punishing anyone, we say, okay, we incentivize you um to do something positive thing. Not only, you know, financially. Financially is you get a token rewards, but also you get this kind of accomplishments or you are part of the big movement.
Um one functionality I give idea to Mark Shaw, actually, is every time when you finish the drinking of coffee with Mugshot, you should see a tree map saying like how much percentage you are saving one tree along with maybe 10,000 people, 20,000 people, you know, across the whole world. It gives the user accomplishment like, "Okay, I'm really doing something meaningful and something valuable, right? And I'm doing the good things for the whole world, not only just for me or for my for my family." That kind of thing.
So, this kind of positive thinking or positive behavior change can really make the user grow that kind of habit. And it eventually will drive the business demands or business leverage to those enterprise. Those enterprise should, you know, start to produce more recycled products or to lower the cost of the recycled products, and, you know, able to, you know, make the sustainability implementation more inclusive, not exclusive. Right now, if you think about sustainability, most of the user were like, "Yeah, it's a good thing, but I too expensive.
I cannot afford that." So, we want to really change that kind of thing from a fundamental root cause root point that kind of And first when you're talking about that Mugshot feature there and the idea to show people what their contribution is, the word that comes to mind there I imagine often is gamification. But it seemed more and more the way you're describing it, it's actually deeper than that. And it's more about like combining with community and showing like the overall effect that many people can make.
And at the end of the day we are such tribal community-based creatures. So, I think we've kind of seen there's been so many failures when it comes to sustainability because we have these single points of failure at the top or centralized, you know, governments that are too laggards to actually make the decisions. So, I think like a big thing that I imagine you're seeing is this network effect where you get more and more people talking about this like your your mom drinking the coffee and then then who does she talk to?
And like, you kind of get this spiraling effect of more people. And even just having the conversations a lot to be like, "Oh, actually, you know, coffee cups are bad for the environment." And most people from an education standpoint probably don't know that. Like, I didn't know that before this call. And you go into Actually, you know, if you see the result, it's really really impressive. I mean, think about like how many paper cups has been used around the world every year. 16 billion paper cups.
And they're coming from the 6.5 million trees. So, that means if you cut half of consumption of the paper cups used every week and keep doing that every year, you are part of the big group people saving small and 3 million trees every year. So, think about the value of the 3 million trees. Right? And and then another direction that I I really glad Alec you brought this up. Um another direction is we also wanted to make the building X2E application so much easy. Like, very easy.
I give I give Antonio a OKR target or goals is within 2 weeks. It doesn't matter if you are a developer or what kind of the developer or you you may not be just a developer. You may just a normal user. If you want to build anything like X2E feeding your life, feeding your neighborhood, your people know to know, um you know, you can you should use only less than 2 weeks. You are able to deliver X2E applications. And then you can build something and it running like that to serve the people around you, serve the people you know, or territory you are familiar with.
Even you could be have multiple different mock shots or multiple different Clinify NFPC. Why not? You know, it's it's the power of Yeah. I like that. Like, it shouldn't just be that you say developers who are solving these problems. Like, anyone can have a problem. I love the idea of like reducing the friction and obviously a big thing like obviously blockchain comes into that, the idea of decentralization, empowering individuals. But AI is more and more coming into that fold as well where, you know, the goals of so many companies now is to basically remove the need potentially for developers, not entirely, but to reduce the need for developers.
So any, you know, Joe off the street can be like, "I want to build an app. This is what I want to build. Go build it for me. I can run it." That's really powerful. And kind of on that, you've touched on emerging technology and like the future and all this kind of stuff, but what are you most excited for for the future of V-shaped DAO? Like are there any big things in your mind that you want to incorporate, that you want to leverage, build on, upgrade to?
I think it's what I'm so far really exciting is about the user You know, from right now, like we just a little bit more than a month after the main net launch, 2 months. Literally, 2 months after the main net launch. And we already see like so many users coming from so different so many different countries, different cities. Actually, we just, you know, did a little bit analysis. The first 2 months, like from July 1st to the first week of August, like 4-5 And we can see 90,000 weekly active users who would participating the Who are voting every week, you know, which which application should get how many allocations.
And most important thing, interesting part is those are people coming from 3,000 cities from 137 different countries. So basically, if you look at the the world map, it's kind of like everywhere. You got the people everywhere into that, despite the languages, the cultures, the geographical location, or even the behavior, it doesn't matter. Everybody is looking, you know, coming into that place and start to like that. And also another thing is, you know, when we talk to people in person and everybody love this idea. Whatever is a big corporation or you know, huge institutional investors.
Give an example, in the hive we have someone from Franklin Templeton, right? Come over to make a very impressive speech. Basically, it's kind of like a from the institutional institutional investor what they try to do with with the sustainability implementations or sustainability challenges, which is 100% aligned what we're doing in Viverse. So, when we when we talk to them in person, they really like it. They really like, oh, that's that's a really, you know, something we should do, right? We have looking for as a viable application creating the real value in the crypto space other than just speculation trading.
So, the other, let's say, I will consider as a challenge is how we can make more people to understand that. How we can make people more people to know about this and start to be part of the user, be part of the builders, even part of the promoters. So, I I still quite to be persistent in our goal. I believe Viverse going to be like 1 billion users that kind of platform someday. And, you know, for sure we're just going to start with the first a half million first you know, two 10 million user, 100 million user and eventually reach to 1 billion user.
But, I would say this narrative is just the same for everyone in the world. Again, despite your language, despite your culture, geographical location, you can be part of the user, part of the builder, part of the promoter. And eventually, I I really exciting about how big you know, this platform could be and how much value we can really create. More than just a 3 million trees every year, you know, I'm really exciting about that. Yeah, that's a really nice visionary place to end the episode, I think.
And I'm really uh seeing where Antonio is getting it from with his big grand vision when he when he spoke to us because I I I completely agree. You're very well placed to take advantage and and improve and help this groundswell that we're seeing of people actually taking sustainability seriously, right? Like you know, political parties are much bigger that are single issue on on this topic now. I think it we're in that phase now where there's so many people that care about it. It's an 8 billion person problem.
So, why can't you have a billion users of this kind of thing? I think that's a perfectly perfectly reasonable thing. get 15% of the people, right? Not much. Exactly. Exactly. It's it's it's you're aiming low, some people would say, but no, we'll see we'll see where it goes in the future. So, Sunny, it's it's been uh such a pleasure to talk to you and I've I've really learned a lot today. Um as I said, we're coming to the end, but we always like to to end this show with a couple of uh common questions that we we ask everybody and we we like to compare what answers we get.
So, I'll ask you the first one if you're ready. So, in one sentence, let's say we're talking to that 5-year-old again, that very intelligent 5-year-old. They understand doubts. We want to take a step back. How would you explain to them in just one sentence what is Web3 to Oh, um that's a tough one, actually, to a 5-year-old. I would say Web3 is just another advanced version of internet. Um now, especially those young people, kids, you know, like my daughter, um play the internet every day. They kind of enjoy the internet even without knowing how it works and everything.
So, I just tell them, you know, the Web3 is just a a next level of the internet and you're going to you're going to see lots of the changes coming from that even without knowing that. So, yeah, that's uh still a very tough one. Very tough Whenever anyone asks me, you know, when I go and and and see friends and they ask me what you do, I always struggle with with explaining it. So, I think maybe I'll just use that one in the future. That's much simpler.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And then the final question then is So, let's say you're having a kind of dream dinner party and you could pick anyone on the planet. They could be from throughout history or even a fictional character to sit down at this party and discuss Web3 with, then who would you pick and why? Oh, another tough one. Um I would I would say Steve Jobs. Um because uh Steve Steve Jobs is a one to inspire me a lot. Um all of his stories um you know, even back and forth um to Apple and you know, insist his vision, create the best product for the for the whole world.
Um it's very let's say um well, I don't know what kind of the word could describe the guy. I think most of people get it. Um but um I really wanted to let's say um try to pick his brain about like um you know, he he's a one to create a lot of the amazing things in the internet arrows. And if we got a chance, you know, I really wanted to let's see how he could do in the Web3 world. And how he could understand the crypto, understand the blockchain, the Web3 mentality, the DAO, and see how he can bring you know, create something similar like Apple, like iPhone, iPod into the Web3 world.
And actually, that's kind of my goal. Um you know, I believe um we better doubt could be acting as like Apple Store, right? And we should have um more more actual applications which uh support the sustainability and eventually um make the big big platform. The only thing we want to do differently with Apple is we're not going to charge you every application like 30%. I'm surprised that's the first time we've heard Steve Jobs on the podcast. That's a great answer. I think crypto and blockchain has been missing that kind of person, the UX user-centric Yeah.
You know, the the first impression, the first idea actually I was thinking about Elon Musk, but then I think about, "Wow, he's already into Dogecoin." That's fine, you know. We move on. He knows about crypto, I'm sure. It would be an interesting one to have a conversation with. Um yeah, thank you, Sunny. This has been a really epic episode. I've learned so much. For anyone who's listening, we'll link VbetterDAO. If you've got an idea for an extra one, and if you've got an idea for sustainability app, you should go there.
Maybe you can pitch it. Maybe it can get funded and, you know, launch on VbetterDAO in the future. I'm trying to work out how we can have some kind of podcast to earn app, Jack. Let's see if we can get that someday. But no, thank you so much for joining us, Sunny. And thank you to those listening wherever you may be. Join us next time to untangle a little more of Thanks for tuning in to another episode of Untangling Web3. Don't forget to send us your thoughts, questions, and comments on social media.
And be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode. See you next time to untangle a little bit more of Web3. The views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto