Episode 88

Crypto ETFs with Johnny Garcia

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

This week's episode of Untangling Web3, features Johnny Garcia, who brings extensive experience from VeChain Foundation and Bitwise Asset Management, focusing on the intersection of ETFs, cryptocurrencies, and the broader financial landscape influenced by blockchain technology.

Key highlights

  • Development of Crypto ETFs. The inception and evolution of cryptocurrency ETFs are explored, highlighting how regulatory milestones have facilitated the inclusion of Bitcoin and Ethereum in mainstream investment portfolios.
  • Convergence of DeFi and TradFi. The blending of decentralized and traditional finance is reshaping investment strategies and asset management, leveraging blockchain enhancements.
  • Impact of Regulatory Changes on Crypto Investments. Recent and ongoing regulatory developments affect the appeal and structure of crypto ETFs, impacting both institutional and retail investors.
  • Technological Innovations in Blockchain for Finance. Technological advancements within blockchain are enhancing the functionality and appeal of ETFs, reinforcing their importance in the financial ecosystem.

Johnny's insights illuminate the transformative role of blockchain and crypto ETFs in modernizing financial markets, underscoring the importance of regulatory clarity and technological innovation in fostering growth and stability in this dynamic sector.

This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/

00:00:00 - Introduction 00:00:03 - Guest Introduction: Johnny Garcia 00:00:50 - Understanding ETFs 00:01:26 - History of ETFs 00:02:46 - Difference Between ETFs, ETPs, and ETNs 00:07:35 - Benefits of ETFs 00:08:45 - Crypto and ETFs 00:09:06 - Regulations and Taxation 00:11:07 - Simplicity and Accessibility of ETFs 00:11:45 - Investing in ETFs through Retirement Plans 00:15:30 - Looking Back: Bitcoin Spot ETF Approval 00:15:44 - Performance of iShares BlackRock ETF 00:19:05 - Impact of Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs 00:20:04 - Understanding the Popularity of Bitcoin Over Ethereum 00:21:55 - Impact of Regulatory Changes on Crypto 00:27:01 - Potential of Bitcoin as a Strategic Reserve 00:30:01 - Discussion on Meme Coins and Their Value 00:31:50 - Value Proposition of Asset Management 00:33:03 - Business Model of Asset Management 00:33:18 - Offering Exposure to Meme Coins 00:33:52 - Consistency and Trust in Asset Management 00:39:42 - Role at VeChain 00:43:12 - Changing Mindset in Crypto Investment 00:44:14 - Reaction to VeChain's Story 00:47:38 - Current Projects and Challenges 00:49:33 - Future of Real World Assets and Meme Coins 00:51:30 - Role of Financial Institutions and Blockchain Networks 00:56:26 - The Future of ETFs and ETPs 00:58:20 - Intersection of Traditional Capital Markets and Crypto Markets 01:01:00 - Closing Remarks

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of the untangling web3 podcast today we have a very special guest Johnny Garcia joining us on the show Johnny leads the vchain foundation's institutional adoption strategy prior to joining the foundation he was director of ETF and ETP Capital markets at bitwise Asset Management where he played a key role in bringing the firm's Bitcoin ethereum ETFs to Market bit of a non-traditional background his career not only spans traditional Asset Management roles but he also served as an officer in the United States Army so let's dive straight into it Johnny welcome to the show awesome thanks sha it's wonderful here very glad to have you on here like we did a whole episode a while back on trafi Defi and the tldr was Trad fight is so complex and so difficult to kind of understand what the hell's going on so many acronyms so many terms and that's why we got you on Johnny because you understand this space you've come from this space and now you moved into the crypto world and

yeah let's just jump into it what the hell is an ETF uh well long form it is an exchange fund um but yeah know how do we how do we imbue a little bit of fun into this because quite honestly I I'll be honest like I'm I'm a little I'm a little over uh the typical sort of boring approach towards how we discuss Financial products but I also understand that you know you have to give the usual disclaimers that none of this is uh Financial advice it's all sort of you know based off pred based off my own personal experience um but yeah ETFs and why are they a big deal so uh let's see it all started out there the October 1987 crash okay wow history lesson to start with yeah yeah a little a little bit of History lesson here um the uh the the the oh my goodness was the Monday or Friday doesn't matter was an October October 1987 crash uh where in essence there were a number of folks that

were sitting at this desk that wondered hey this would be a really interesting way of quickly transferring risk why is that well we have these various vehicles that pull together a bunch of individuals assets and they're all exposed to um you know you name it stocks bonds fixed fixed income instruments and the like um and a number of folks would love to be able to adequately price these things out in a way intraday most importantly particularly assets that aren't necessarily that have like in of day um what we refer to as net asset value pricing right so if you think about traditional pulled funds like a mutual fund here in the US um what happens is you don't really get a price on that until the end of the day um so some brainiacs at a desk at a train at a trading desk had come up with this tool where hey what if we were able to price something out intraday something that traditionally you don't have a market for um and therein lies

uh the birth uh the birthplace the Genesis the Genesis block if you will of ETFs uh now what is an ETF and how does it like actually pertain to what uh to today's topic it's interesting like I I always like to offer up like a bit of beyond the history I actually don't really talk about the 1987 October uh Friday crash um often uh but I really want to like provide a little bit of uh this may be pedantic uh but there are differences with ETFs versus etps versus etn so exchange traded products tends to be the sort of umbrella term which basically describes a product that can trade on an exchange AKA you can get a price between nine and four at least here in in the U 930 and 4 when the markets are open um or when the markets are open in other uh in say local in local local markets for instance um but the assets underneath change depending on the actual uh nomenclature so an ETF tends to be tends

to wrap um the majority of the assets that are wrapped in an ETF tend to be uh stocks and bonds right and they trade in this fashion what we refer to in the industry as in kind basically saying I have a set of constituents that make up the S&P 500 right so I have the pro slice of the S&P stocks I want to give it to you Alec and you are an issuer you give me shares that are a representation of that what's beautiful about that is one uh I'm getting a price in the form of an ETF right you're getting you're getting the you're getting the constituent shares that that constitute the uh S&P 500 I'm getting exposure to that but what's also beautiful about inine is the is a tax treatment right so here in America we're particularly focused on tax etps are different and they they're they're regulated differently the market structure underneath in terms of how we exchange assets for ETF shares um is different and that here in the US

in particular um but even in the in the EU with etn and etcs and other etps the mechanism is different in terms of the exchange versus the cash mechanism right so I give you cash you then give me the shares you then go out and buy the Bitcoin or buy the ethereum um therefore now I have shares that represent exposure to the Bitcoin or ethereum and the like um okay I get you yeah so there's so much yeah yeah and and and everyone's fallen asleep and Chang like so my understanding because like I'm not from this space at all and neither is Jack and when we went into this is that the point of an ETF was that it makes it slightly more accessible for people to jump into a space it's like rather than owning say one asset you kind of have a bundle of different assets and it makes it say more appealing to an individual to jump into that ET is that like a massive oversimplification or is that the case no

it is the case yeah I mean if you think about the number of assets uh it's it's geographically uh dependent right I mean I think you you really have to take into consideration um that the lines of demarcation as it relates to how folks manage or gain access to various type of asset classes is very different um once you cross over into uh into another jurisdiction right here in the US for instance there's north of some $60 trillion dollar in assets that are managed by professionals what does that mean okay there's some financial adviser who is managing assets on behalf of an in client you jack Alec myself um it's really easy when I've been buying and selling ETFs and by the way I've got a whole Tech stack that shows me all my positioning it shows me my risk that I'm exposed to I can now just turn that over into a report and pass it along to an in client and say hey this is why you underperformed a particular market overperformed so

forth so on um it's it's so it's a it's a massive unlock because now if you're a financial adviser and you've been worried about whether or not my business is now being put at risk because I have clients asking me for Bitcoin exposure and I have no view I have no view I have no way in which I can go and easily just start allocating to a particular market right like otherwise I have to manage a bunch of individual's wallets I've got to figure out how do I put that into my risk engine ETFs make it simple it's like oh okay cool um we now have a house view that we're okay with all getting 1 to 5% to bitcoin I can now just go and buy an ETF and now Jack you've got exposure to bitcoin right um that that it is it is it makes it tremendously simple it's in a way that's you know folks like me have already traditionally been talking you start talking about hard code wallets uh hot code

wallets hard forks and consensus like people are like okay look you know what I'm done okay um so it is it is a massive unlock for a very important uh and growing segment uh of the market in terms of you know traditional asset management and financial services I get you like I think my kind of how I would relate it to myself is I can't trade on say stock classic stocks and shares I can't buy stocks from say the US market but if I ow a sudden jump into a fund that's International and registered in the UK they can give me exposure to say the US top 10 whatever stocks and I just invest in them I don't have to worry about the legislation all the regulations all that kind of stuff so it's similar kind of thing you're saying that it's simpl for the big players to get exposed to assets without having to worry about regulations legislations all this kind of stuff they just give the money pass it over and say yeah

we like Bitcoin jump into this for me and handle all that all that nonsense and if I make money if you make money sorry I make money that that make sense yeah totally totally yeah yeah yeah I I mean absolutely it's again I just go back to like it's it's a really massive unlock much like buying the S&P 500 buying a buying a basket of stocks was a massive unlock right I get now you and I I all put our money in together into one fund that makes it much more easier for us versus me going out and buying 500 stocks that make up the S500 right it just becomes um just cost prohibitive economically prohibitive um but it's also easier for this management class right so is crypto special in any way like is it the same as everything else like I know there's been a lot of uncertainty about people you know jumping into investing in crypto and all this kind of stuff does it is it like unique in that sense that

they kind of these ETFs are kind more valuable Maybe for the crypto Market as a whole because there's so much uncertainty about the classification or what it means for taxes and all this kind of stuff yeah I mean you you hit you hit a really you hit a really core um part of the argument right which I think in part so above and beyond making it easier and accessible for um for folks to gain access so individuals like you and myself who perhaps don't want to be incredibly native we just want access to the exposure we don't we don't intend on participating in an ecosystem right I'm not going to buy and stake eth and I'm not and vote and do I'm not going to do that I just want access to the price um so there's that but then there's also this component of how should I be treating this from a tax component is it a security is a commodity that leads to very two different tax as well as regulatory regimes yeah

um and what is unique so far at least about what's been approved here um in so much as we have etps that wrap or give you exposure to bitcoin so they're physically backed by Bitcoin um or give you exposure to ethereum we don't have anything else here uh in the US um in the form of exchange traded we have other forms um private placements uh and and the like um so what what what is what is what's the sort of important part to highlight here um either you're a commodity or your security so the ETF the exchange traded part the ETP part that's managed by our our local regul um regulatory body which is the Securities and Exchange Commission the mar the uh underlying Market Park the ethereum or the Bitcoin park is in essence because it's filed as an ETP which you know it's 33 Act form and you know uh 33 act Securities Law and all that Jaz um now makes it uh regulated by the cftc so our Commodities Futures and trade

um shap um regulatory body uh very to um regulatory regimes very to different uh tax regimes um so that's that's the important that's the important sort of Distinction here yeah that's really interesting I think we we've actually covered so much ground even in that opening introduction so thank you so much but I think I just want to highlight a couple of things I think you know the the the ease of use and simplicity of just getting price exposure I think is is the thing that people were so excited about and I think the analogy for people who aren't so well versed in this is probably especially in the UK I guess would be like an index fund right its way of getting broad exposure to a market or to to some kind of stocks and shares um but in a very simple way so people who don't want to stock pick people who don't know how to invest they'll Chuck it in an index fund on Vanguard or something like that right so I think

I think it makes that kind of process easier um another thing I feel like I remember correct me if I'm wrong is it also allows people the ETFs now is it right that they allow people to invest in the US via their uh we call them pension schemes but your retirement plan right your 401k is that right I feel like I remember hearing that you can invest into ETFs that way is that is that right it it so it's platform dependent um I I will say uh there's also sort of sort of Industry structural things that kind of get in the way um namely in the form of um administrative costs uh recordkeeping and I mean the the industry is incredibly comple honestly we could probably we could we could we could spend I mean there's entire lectures uh dedicated if not like full on phds dedicated to just oh my God yeah well I'm I'm just I'm just going off the strength of you know some news articles I remember seeing that were like

people can invest in Bitcoin in their 401K now and that was what what kind I was I was remembering um yeah yeah it is platform dependent so if you're if you're at Fidelity for instance right and Fidelity has been very uh very forward um and I guess yeah I mean I'd use the word like Progressive and as it relates to uh offering up exposure to uh cryp to to to the crypto or digital asset economy um namely in the form of one they participate actively right they have their own Bitcoin ETF um they also have uh you know the 401 qu 401k or you know the the uh um our former retirement um funds where they they've made purchasing Bitcoin available as well um I I will say you know even even so even thinking about Pension funds right or retirement income um uh DC plans um that's managed also by another another regulatory body right okay uh nightmare orisa yeah so I mean it's it's it's it's it's very it's you know again it

it Le it leads itself or lends itself to a very different set of considerations um which is why you know ETFs are are are they're ubiquitous uh they're everywhere right it's they're they're they're a really interesting sort of techn technological innovation if you will um as it relates to like getting in and getting out of exposure um from the perspective of professional managers right managing risk as well right so um it's not just a matter of like oh I want to gain exposure to price go up I also want to be able to manage you know um the potential risk of price go down right so yeah um and ETFs allow that and you can also repackage them in different jurisdictions so we have usit and things like that out that that now make them compatible to UK or other EU specific jurisdictions right um but yes um it it's I would say that that's probably that's probably going to be a longer uh a longer com that's probably longer in the tooth or later

in in in terms of sort of the the life cycle of the evolution of etps and getting into we don't even they're not even they're not ubiquitous in in Pinchin here to say the least so so the idea of having like a Bitcoin ETF also being available in 401ks with the exception of very few ones like uh um fideli I I I just my my my personal View is that's probably uh that's low that's lower on the priority rungs for most 401K providers yeah makes sense and I guess maybe the the the most important thing to take away from that is that we are even having that conversation because if you look back two three four years the idea that the big financial institutions would be you know getting to grips with Bitcoin and crypto in such a an involved way now and actively you know offering any products at all seems a little bit uh bizarre now looking back on some of the rhetoric we saw in the past so if we if we

cast our mind back to I guess basically one year ago now right when the Bitcoin spot ETF got approved I think it was last January because we were covering it around Christmas time everyone was speculating you know which dat is it going to be announced and these approvals coming through um I recall you know the ey shares the Black Rock one I think was something like the most successful ETF launch in history I remember reading that somewhere how is you know one year on how have they actually performed what impact have they had and what can we actually learn from what we've seen in the last yet um so yeah I was going to say it was the most successful launch it was also the most successful in terms of garnering assets for the first year it's been it's been quite historic um yeah I mean and and and I would say I me as a category so uh generally speaking if you think about like a a category of of assets that have launched

they were pretty unique right so first and foremost January 11th and and this is I know intimately well because I was uh at bit bitwise Asset Management um um and this was you know this was two years in two years in two years in uh into joining when I had expected for a spot Bitcoin ETF to be um well hopefully be available in the US and then here we we found ourselves two years later um so we were a part of the mix this is this is quite historic in so much as there were some 10 ETFs all providing virtually I mean no all providing the exact same access to an underlying Market all lined up and launched on the same day um and and and I will say you know accredit to uh this is probably gonna probably fall in death years but a credit to the SEC and so much as they wanted to prevent uh what could ostensibly look like giving any advantage to one particular issuer by allowing an issuer to

launch um an ETF or or or a or product uh in advance of others so they gave folks they said hey look all the folks who have said they're uh in launching this particular type of financial product you need to be ready by X day and we're going to go live on y day um and so that's why you saw this sort of bursting at the seams of ETFs all offering the same exact exposure to the same exact asset um on the same exact day um and so it was so that alone was quite historic um but yes I mean in terms of garnering assets uh I mean both in both both obviously form of uh in the form of price performance as well as ass growth um it's been an incredibly successful launch and I think in part look it's obviously a representation of the builtup demand for this particular uh for exposure to this asset um I think there was also candidly a lot of uh transfers so some folks who had been

and I I want to say this like with a caveat but you know it's not in in my in my view this is not creating additional like buyers this is not a this was this this is an Essence a uh a a a movement from one particular wallet to another wallet uh in right so there were a number of folks who were also likely um now that there's Clarity around hey what is the regulatory regime and the tax regime under which I'm going to live I no longer need to hold it in uh in sort of its native form I can now hold it in this ETP form um but it was quite it's it's it's undeniably the most successful um ETF launch uh both by asset Gathering both by number of products on on on listed on the same day in performance and ethereum's right behind it um so John I was gonna ask you about this like so I I I don't know what if it was just like speculation or just random

news outlets or what but one of the comparisons I saw was that the Bitcoin ETFs have been hugely successful I saw like numbers of like 120 billion or close to of total assets locked up in these um and then there was some people I don't if it was like the initial stall or something like that were saying that the sto that story wasn't true or that Trend wasn't true necessarily for the ethereum ETFs is that is that your opinion as well or are you saying they're both like equally successful yeah no they're not equally successful I mean Bitcoin blew ethereum out of the water um okay but relative to uh if we're benchmarking against the broader share of ETFs that have launched uh ethereum is very successful I mean tens of billions sure it's not hundreds of billions um almost a trillion or so in assets I think uh now on bitcoin ETFs but I mean ethereum was also quite quite popular um yeah there there really are I mean there there's there's no other

candidly is it like you come from this world so can you understand or can you explain and give us some insight into why that is like why is Bitcoin so maybe why is Bitcoin more well understood compared with ethereum yeah I think it's had the benefit of uh duration in terms of it just being top of mine headlines how many times I mean bitcoin's died a thousand deaths um right the the what seems to be sort of like the staying montra proverbial saying now around folks you like you think about like the CNBC or uh Bloomberg or um various sort of media Outlet headlines um like this must be it for Bitcoin uh so I think I think I think there's there's there's that narrative um it's also been one of the best performing assets um and it's it's not this probably doesn't take a ton of guessing nor a ton of it doesn't take a quantitative uh engineering or mathematical degree to to understand this but humans have a tendency to uh Chase returns

and so naturally folks are thinking oh wow this is an asset that's increased you know thousands of percent uh what I'm sure I'll Port 10 and think that that's going to happen in the future uh so look I just think that there was just a lot of fomo uh and there was a lot of missing out that I think folks now have a have a have an opportunity to get in now candidly and more recent years Circa like uh or sorry not even years months um the trailing call it you know three to four to six months there's also been the the news and narrative around a softening here in the US that I think has also you know added an additional sort of buoyancy if you will to uh demand to the demand side uh for Bitcoin ethereum and and other and other alt coins as well um and that's namely around uh a softening of sort of the the the regulatory regime under which uh many crypto projects and um and financial supporters

right namely in the form of uh Venture capitalists and other folks who have explored very various different uh ways of getting exposure have had to endure uh in the past not just four years but in the past decade um of building businesses in and around uh crypto and digital assets and so I think that's been you know the election here the change of administration the change of guard has certainly been a bell weather moment as well and it's like I guess so on that point is there two rough buckets to what the current Administration in the US means for this space one is around say softer regulation maybe softer on taxes I've seen a lot of the time for these assets and the gains that are associated with the assets I guess that's the one bucket so people feel more certain going to the space and more comfortable going to the space and then the other one is it around the the Strategic Reserve potentially and like all this potential talk about you know America

putting some of the their current strategic Reserve into Bitcoin all this kind of stuff and the demand that could be created from that yeah um uh you know look I I think I'm a bit mixed on this um I I do I do think that uh well sorry let me take let me take my personal view out of it for a second and then I'll just and and then I can on the back in alline uh and bring that into bring that into the view um yes I I think canly any sort of clarity would be great I I don't think anyone's looking for um any preferred well naturally we all know how these things sort of work out of course folks are looking for things that would be preferential to existing ways of doing business but I think most importantly any Clarity namely in the form of hey I'm not going to be debanked or hey I'm not going to end up with a Wells notice at my front door when I go to

pick up my Amazon package I'm not sure if that's actually how you receive it when you get when you get a when you get a well yeah U but no I think the just the general fear of we're doing something uh that is quite Innovative that has the potential to be um really transformative and yet we don't really know whether or not I could potentially um be doing all this work putting in all this energy putting all this financial Capital um and so sort of Sweat Equity only to uh effectively you know be in a law be be be in litigation or or legal battles with the SEC right like I I think for the most part people are like hey we would love to get to the other side of that um and so you know what that looks like uh time will tell I mean I think we've seen sort of a barrage of um various early days in the form of executive orders and things of that nature that have that have

alluded to one first and foremost setting up task force not only uh within the ex cutive Branch but then also well not only within the White House excuse me but then also in um various cabinets so the cftc the SEC have also um have basically given an indication that hey we're also looking at this and taking a very different approach than um enforcement uh I've already forgotten what the general term enforcement by regulation by enforcement excuse me yeah yeah um so that that that is that that is at least you know it's it's a tea leaf uh we'll see what you know that what what's going to Bear out in terms of true efforts there but it's definitely that should be that should bode well for um for the broader Market in so much as look you you should feel comfortable that unless you're absolutely just grifting like we're not well not even that sorry grifting is legal unless you're doing fraudulent illegal activities um you you're you're probably going to be okay um you

know more clarity would be would be great again we see that extending up in different even here right we're Federal systems our states also have their own like you've see sandboxes being set up in places like Wyoming for folks to go and set up um Dows or explore experiment with various different types of uh of of tech technology today's episode is sponsored by the vchain foundation now we often talk about how emerging Technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and vchain is at the Forefront of this green movement with initiative like be better Dow let's take a closer look imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets these verified records build a massive Collective impact benefiting people through their own actions sound a bit complex but vchain made it fun explore our apps at v better.com v Chain's goal is to power a new era of Sustainable Solutions so if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day go

check out vb.com to find out more and now back to the show on the Strategic Reserve H I mean I I feel I feel like yeah cryp cryp crypto twitters uh it gives it gives and it takes right it gives and it takes um yeah look my my uh my personal view uh is I think I think it's it's it's if it is if it happens it's hard for us to say that that would not put demand pressure demand side pressure on uh the price of Bitcoin where where or sorry I should say demand side pressure for Bitcoin where the price goes I mean that usually just becomes um an imbalance problem right there's more selling it doesn't it doesn't really um but I think generally speaking most folks are saying oh well you know what there's a fixed supply of Bitcoin this we know will then effectively uh be a sort of reoccurring cyclical buide action that's happening now from if the US goes then there's going to be sort of follow on effects

where others are then going to go um and so therefore we now know uh that it's going to be I think the I think the therefore we now know that there's going to be consistent buying sorry I think it's a little bit over soow to think that that somehow makes it um mainstream right a lot of risks that are just not being uh considered here namely um I don't know the efficacy of the US dollar um n namely uh you know um yeah again whe whether whether or not I mean I ideally right like how do we say that we we also we want the US dollar to continue to be the Strategic reserve of choice uh but multaneously say um we're looking to happen a we're looking to set up a strategic Reserve denoted in Bitcoin I think there's various different ways in which governments can can get exposure right um it's a different thing you say hey you know what I'm looking at it from the perspective of its investment characteristics it's risk

return characteristics right and maybe you do uh you do that in the form of like a sovereign wealth fund or you do that in other form it's another thing to say um uh I'm looking for this to be I'm looking to set up a strategic Reserve that's just my like my sort of personal View and and it seems a little bit contradictory to the US dollar also being the reserve currency uh of the world but maybe maybe maybe I'm a little a little shallow on that one no I think I think it's actually a refreshingly um kind of measured take on the whole thing right if you if you just go and listen to Michael sailor and go on crypto Twitter as you mentioned you get you get a different picture I think but that that's that's valid and also I guess you you can also factor in the fact that you've got uh tether you know big supposedly US dollar denominated maybe there's some bet about helping to keep that running as the main

stable coin there's there's all sorts of things to play in but you know there's nothing I want to speculate there speculate there about at the minute um I actually want to maybe shift the conversation onto this idea of utility that we've touched on once or twice um because when we talk about the ETFs and the the idea being just to get price exposure right spot ETFs get spot price exposure to these underlying assets like Bitcoin um that seems to be quite a long way from the original Vision or the original thinking behind Bitcoin right as a peer-to-peer cashes being use of payments Etc people are now just you know they just want those returns right you said chasing returns is this this kind of inbuilt thing we have as as a species and we seem to be in my opinion we seem to be getting further and further away from that utility idea in a lot of the crypto space not least in this whole meme coin phenomenon right so you know the word meme

itself is funny right because you sing no no no it's it's that's kind of the reaction I was hoping for I should mute myself now yeah well because you know you say the word meme itself refers to people just imitating other people in behaviors and that's what we're kind of seeing on the whole price side of things as well right is people are just seeing people are making returns this highly performing asset people just buying in and buying in and they becoming the self-fulfilling meme but what is happening with these meme coins themselves we've seen the you know the various ones launched over the last few weeks with the new Administration I've even seen you know to tie ETFs back to this I've seen as of yesterday I think there's now mem coin tf's being filed as well so crazy things happening what what's your take on all of that like should we be scared is there any value in any of this at all I guess my take is crazier things have happened I

I I suppose I'm just I'm just having a tough time looking for uh like like coming up with an example off the top of my off the top of my head I think it is maybe maybe we should take a step back uh and just uh think uh a little bit more deeply about what what exactly is it that this particular segment and what I mean is capital allocators or asset all Asset Management what what what do they what's their what's their value proposition um you know and what is what is ultimately their business model and in essence it's giving access to streams of returns um to investors that otherwise or to a client that otherwise would not have that access or is too busy doing their own job you're a plumber you are a lawyer you you don't want to spend time thinking about how you want to uh deploy your money but you do want your money to work for you want it to be deployed in a way that's efficient that gives

you return right so you have idle cash instead of putting it in a savings account where it's charging where it's giving you um 0 one% uh which is still which is still a thing here in certain savs accounts here at certain US Banks um yeah you can put it somewhere else hopefully generate a return because you don't need that cash um or you don't need that Capital at that point in time so like that's what so the business model for them is they collect a fee for providing that service um that service could be simple like indexing we talked about that it could be simple like offering spot price exposure to uh to bitcoin eth um now uh Doge which uh you're right Jack I mean I've recently seen a filing um from my my last employers and others uh around offering exposure to uh meme coins or pric offering exposure to prices on on Meme coins um and so uh I think generally speaking the way they see this is if there's a market

if there's an opportunity for for for um if if there's demand and I can cover the cost of managing and running a fund um then why would I uh not offer it I tend to think that you should probably have you know something that's consistent with whatever your philosophy is uh it's anchored to your brand it's anchored to I mean because ultimately these things are still built on trust um right these Enterprises and these institutions are still built on trust and also like being consistent with what they're offering I mean credit to another former employer Vanguard right um I know they catch a lot of flack for not offering I mean I having I mean I had I have a brokage account at Vanguard and I remember going to purchase a product that I had just launched at my when I was at uh bitwise and I couldn't purchase it because they don't allow it some folks say oh it's incredibly paternalistic some folks say oh you're missing out on a on a Tong but

they're they're the second largest asset manager in the world I think they're doing okay um and and and it's consistent with what they've said before which is hey look we don't offer cart blanch exposure to anything um we believe that what we're doing is is is in the best interest of our clients and so um do I get scared I guess was the other part of your question yeah I yeah here's here's I I I take comfort and I know this may not this may come off right I take comfort in so much as it is managed um you know this is this is the antithetical I think this is this is certainly antithetical to to the space it's it's it's coming from professional managers who are ultimately will be held liable if and if if and when something goes wrong right and you you you take on those protections when you deci to opt out and or to opt out of going native and instead buying an ETF right you take out the risk

of hard Forks of losing your um you know losing you losing your keys um of you know you you you you remove that as a part of your equation and instead you opt into something that's protected um it's insured uh and and uh and you you you can you can sleep uh maybe perhaps a little bit easier at night I'm not sure if you sleep easier at night candidly buying buying buying Dosh but yeah uh this is where I go it's a free world it's it's a free world yeah I think it comes it's reminded me of that whole debate you know you get around Health as well and like the the libertarian or the the kind of less governmental approach of saying well people are free should be free to do what they want don't overregulation the benefits of the ETFs themselves and and these products as an industry is yeah you'd probably much rather than buy the meme coin straight up you'd rather buy it as part of a regulated rapper by a

pretty trusted institution I think that makes a lot of sense I think I I would be more comfortable as you say I just probably wouldn't be that comfortable overall um and speaking of trust you know we've spoken a lot about your some of your previous employees right you you've mentioned a few of them but your current role is at vchain as you mentioned at the start and I'm conscious we haven't spoken about it because I'm sure that is also involved in kind of driving institutional adoption of uh crypto in and the industry in general so can you talk a bit more about your role and and the role of I guess trust in these institutions as well if that if that plays into I'd be very interested to hear yeah no I'm I'm I'm certainly happy to go that um go in that direction I I will I I was gonna say I will I will deviate just here for a second and say I I mean my view here and and i' I feel

like I've um I don't know I've spent the last certainly the last week two weeks um doing a lot of internal investigation as to what and how I think of memes um and um I think there's a so there's the component of like I look I I have a deep appreciation for incredibly technical uh technical folks um and like the positive spit on this is to the extent that I know that there were a lot of Engineers that canly had the equivalent of a uh an exciting dream let's call it um off of the fact that there was there was I mean if we think about all of this happening on chain as it relates to Trump and milania it's it's quite incredible um that things just didn't kind of um I I do however go back to what does this mean for the broader industry and I think this is one of the points maybe Jack that you're trying to you're alluding to as it relates to now perhaps a bit of what potentially

could be signaling a validation in the form of putting it in to regulated um I I do I do draw some concern on that um namely in the form of does this uh how will this be received by mass by the masses them yes exactly exactly I mean because we I I still have to remember like we are we are Fringe we are very small um we're nowhere near masses uh if I think about you know the conversations I have with family members and um either they've been burned or something's happened before and like does this what does this do um in terms of you know the impression that we leave as to whether or not uh the industry is filled with serious people or are the serious people effectively just put into a corner U so I do I do think there's something to be said about that I probably haven't given too much thought uh beyond the occasional night sweats um thinking about sort of Market liquidity and it being pulled from all

various different places but um anyways uh now back to the I sorry I said I was I thought it was gonna be a quick caveat it wasn't um I love those yeah so my my my time IV changed so yeah I I hit up our institutional growth in capital markets efforts which I I I really try to uh which is just a I guess it's a fancy somewhat fancy way um of trying to say I engage directly with professional Capital allocators uh and directly with um Market or professional Market participants namely Traders um yeah large trading shops um and why do I think it's important or because what's pretty unique about this technology is that like there's there's always a market for like the tokens are a requirement um right um and there's a there's a market for these things 247 and it's important that at any point in time at anywhere in the world uh you're able to get a price for something I think that's really really it's something that um has always

been spoken about but it's actually it's it's it's live and it's true we're experimenting and experiencing it today uh and so I'm often talking with folks on hey how can we improve um effectively what we refer to as you know the liquidity the ability for at any point in time someone who's looking to purchase or sell um any one of the uh Native tokens that are live on on vchain Thor um that they're able to do that and they're able to do that in a way that doesn't feel as if they're uh getting a price getting a bad price or getting bad execution so I mean that's that's the Capital Market side on the institutional growth side it's really sharing the narrative and story about hey these are the things that the foundation's working um these are sort of the developments in in in activities that are taking place here's why we think you know our approach to um to application and growth is unique and interesting um and here's potentially how you can get

involved and so sharing the various ways or exploring various ways oftentimes it comes from them and I think that's that's really important is like understanding that if you know getting their Buy in and getting them to also be a participant and client um um in the in in sort of the in the growth uh is is really important uh and perhaps most important is oftentimes uh their feedback their thoughts on how they explore it how they think um their potential use cases that could exist in the network that we support um would be something that's inviting to them so that's how I spend my time um I I I'll pause because I feel like I was a little I was a little all over the place there no it's interesting that it answered a lot of questions I think like the space is definitely changing and maybe the ETS have led that like a lot of the early crypto stuff was very much individuals retail probably why the nft craze when so big probably why

the meme coin craze is happening right now is that it's not about the underlying technology the fundamentals like what problem are you solving it's very much like can you make a QuickBook do you think other people are going to believe in you know Trump coin or Melania coin whatever it's going to be and you don't really think that that's going to have real world you know utility you don't think that's going to be used to for remittances across the world right like you think is this going to go up and can I get out before it goes down on me or something like that you know what I mean so it's like I think but I think that has changed that mindset has changed with institutions you must be aware of this as well like you're now speaking to professionals who have research teams who are like okay how does this you know differ from the other assets and I think that's something that BTC did quite well the story was fairly obvious and simple

it's like this is you know this is gold this is the digital gold like whatever you want to call it and they're like oh that makes sense you know secure store of value not going to change much like you know bomb proof all this kind of stuff and I think that's why a lot of people said that maybe the ethereum ETF didn't go as well still super successful like you said but not as well maybe as Bitcoins because the narrative is a bit more confused it's a bit more oh actually this is deeply technical with the settlement layer for the internet and okay what does that mean how does that compare to what I understand with traditional markets it's a bit different right that's quite Hard Sell and then you see there's loads of other crypto coins now that are trying to get their own ETFs trying to get more institutional adoption how has the response been to say to vchain story V Chain's an OG in this space like been around for a long

time well-known Brands like what's been the kind of the reaction to the story of vchain yeah it's been it's been largely positive um and and look I I want to couch that with with some direct feedback like I I'll s uh here I go with the caveats again Alec the point that you just brought up was is is is brilliant I know it's something that I missed earlier but you're you're you're absolutely right I think for the most part um if the industry could have they would have maybe preferred a bit of distance in the availability of eth ETFs versus Bitcoin ETFs more than the six or seeven see we launched in January July so six uh I right yeah six months um uh uh be between them so that way there could have been a much better opportunity to arm and educate the market around what exactly theum is which I think it's still also depending on which forums you're in it's still TBD um so uh but Bitcoin had it had a track

record of over a decade of of narrative both spinning but then also you know the last half decade or so um solidifying around sort of the the gold the digital gold narrative and that helped in terms of adoption um I think it also just helped in the form of there were more folks coming online more folks buying Bitcoin the price certainly helped uh the return certainly helped going back to that sort of animal nature in us um and uh and and very clearly there was just more conversations and it was very easy narrative candidly for folks who have traditionally like if you think about distribution and you think about how folks are and particularly in this industry selling products to to to to in clients or investors um the the simpler the story the better right indexing bu the market boom yeah done right get your share get your share of corporate earnings boom done right I mean the the most Innovative you know uh form of of you know Collective socialism like you like

it's a very it's a very easy sale and then it's just a matter of like oh well how much is it for me to how much can I how much can I get access um a broad basket of global stocks oh you're cheaper great um got it uh there's more but still that's generally it um ethereum's not that uh B Chain's not that um and so I think generally speaking though the feedback has been surprisingly quite quite constructive uh namely the moment that I go into a conversation and I have um and I say oh you know I'm see I'm I'm a red vchain now that inevitably the first question goes wow so you you really went down Market or the first comment is like wow you really went down Market um you're all in I said yes and then the second one's like yeah I know vchain I have a little bit you all were rwa before rwa was even a thing right and like that is that's for me it's it's always been

um you know really positive Omen because uh canly speaking that was one of the things that really attracted me to the foundation is it just felt like there was obvious there's a builtup track record of really integral in in um developments to and Evolutions to uh this entire industry in the form of there's a very clear narrative there's a very clear Market opportunity it was going after it uh and it was having success um and so like and it was something that it resonated with me um it was clear for me to understand um and so like that that whenever I get that response it resonates now the following question is the more difficult the follow sorry the third comment right there's a wow you really went down Market um to uh yeah rwa before Rd was a thing and the third one's always so what are you all doing now yeah okay um and that's and that's the more difficult uh question right uh I mean because as as as as as you know

Alec I mean there's there's a lot of there are a lot of things that we're doing um and I think this is in part one of the uh one of the potential not drawbacks but it's a hurdle for the industry which is it is a general purpose technology and trying to like it effectively what they're saying is like what what how are you solving for the problem that I have now and from the perspective of an Institutional desk it's how are you all like tell me how you all are growing show me the evidence for that growth um show me how that's driving value to like how are you all attracting new users and driving value to the network um and lastly how are you going to help me generate like what I what I pass on is a stream of returns right so like again trying to understand exactly the client and who it is that you're engaging I think it's incredibly important and you partnering with them to figure out oh okay got

it it's like you're your focus is I offer up a stream of returns how is that different from the other things that I'm doing um so that when packaged together it's Unique it's a it's a great value value or sales proposition that I can then make to my in clients um and so that's that's that's that's in essence how you know that's the feedback that I've been given and that's sort of the good bad and the uh uh not not ugly but the good better and different in terms of how it's been how it's been how it's been received so far by by by the market that makes sense and I think you are right though whenever you look at I mean RW at real world assets that is kind of the the buzzword that was like digital gold crypto five years ago now it's all about real world assets and I think that that narrative makes a lot of sense when there are like say you know projects that are basing their entire kind

of market cap transaction volume all this kind of stuff on mem coins I think that that's fad I think that's people trying to you know make quick money as we spoken about which is you know it's natural makes sense but long term I think there'll be enough people burned that that will start to be unappealing and people will no longer go down that route but the real world asset stuff like it's something that black rocker constantly talking about JP Morgan are constantly talking about all these big asset managers they understand the value of getting say traditional assets on chain purely for the same reasons that they understand the value of having say the digital gold equivalent it it's represent in ownership is having something that's uptime you know 247 consistent you can get price action around the world crossboard all this kind of stuff so that that narrative I think is going to be the new narrative in a lot of ways I think it's a a kind of a perfect marment of blockchain Technology

but deployed on kind of on top of existing infrastructure and it's hard to know whether the the the kind of the peer-to-peer electronic cache system that was the previous narrative will die out and if it'll be more about D say and I think that kind of comes from the tech in a lot of ways like say we've seen that BTC can't handle the transactions volume that you know it needs to do to hit the Visa Mastercard equivalent but it could handle the selling of you know contracts homes Deeds whatever you want and I think that that that kind of the narrative there makes sense and it's exciting that vchain has been in the space that space for so long and it's well entrenched into it has actually been doing these things and I think as institutions well hopefully you'll see this as well assigned to understand that's the new application they understand that you know something like vchain is something they want to be involved in yeah I I I agree I agree it's been

interesting because I felt like the the um you're you're right with the last three or four years and still I even even today I would it depends on who you're talking to I think folks still think that there's a lot of wind in the uh wi in the wings um remaining or or wi in the sales I think that's how it goes wi in the sales remaining uh around defi right that was it was you know the big defi summer and then folks continue to keep talking about there's still a defi surgence and candidly speaking from from from my particular angle I it it it is pretty unique to have such things as autonomous settlement to not obviously 100% eliminate counterparty risk but to reduce it um to you know some some some fraction of a decimal uh is is these are these are really critical um these are really critical things that are that that are a part of Opex and operational cost for uh for existing Financial Services firms and so like it's

really interesting to think about that particular application as a use case for uh continued uh growth and adoption particularly from from FIS or financial institutions and you see that happening like you mentioned you mentioned J JPM you also see it happening at your Franklin templetons um of the of the world who have their own ecosystem that they've been that they've been incorporating and also have folded into accepted pra practices namely you know covered covered um by existing um requirements and so like it's it is it is happening it's just kind of in the in the background and again it may not be a part of the sort of original or uh ethos um but it just goes to show you that when you have a general purpose technology like folks and continue to borrow from it however they they see fit much like much like AI it's like I I guarantee you all of us are using it in some different form yeah um right uh and so I think I think that part is

is is really is really interesting the other item that I would just add just like on the last the last bit here is um the rwa thing has been interesting because it's really namely So within within within within this space it's it's been interesting hearing that the the following there been two two common bits of feedback one um this industry has largely been an industry of narratives if we continues to be an industry of narratives it will not exist in like I don't know two three half a decade um and the second item is on the r rwa side uh or defi side depending on it feels like there there's there's a bit of a mix here right as we start to continue to tokenize say Financial assets and things of that nature then you're going to continue to see build out of things like collateral which is really important for um financial institutions who are in the business of Shifting and managing risk right I mean I mentioned like streams of returns the opposite

of that same coin is risk right you don't get returns without some level of risk again going back to I get a penny on the $10,000 or whatever that I put into my savings account um for the bank to then go out and do what banks do uh which is wanted out um and make four plus percent on anyways it's another note but um but they're they're in the business of of of managing risk uh and being as capital efficient as you possibly can and so that seems to be one of the areas where I know a lot of folks are really exploring and so improving the quality of of of of your network of your of the things that um uh improving the quality of the network is ultimately really really important in terms of being able to be perceived as a safeguarded asset that you then could use in collateral or use in other mechanisms where folks are going to continue to evolve and experiment so that's one of the things I just

wanted to uh to highlight no I'm really I'm really glad you brought that up actually riskk is is quite close to my heart and I think it's it sounds boring for a lot of people probably but it's so important to the Machinery behind you know financial services and and ultimately by extension the machinery and lots of things in our lives right lot that we don't directly see but is is so crucial to how the world works and I think it is I find it very exciting that now you have all these institutions who are finally taking these things very seriously taking the risk side of it very seriously and also you know blockchains and and major networks like yourselves are taking those steps to to meet the demands as well I think that's it's it's a exciting place to be in um speaking of you know where we are now I just want to close on looking to the Future then so you know are we going to see a vchain ETF in the future

what what does that hold and maybe you know more speculative beyond that or more more looking further into the future maybe what do you think people should be thinking about going forward in this space as it relates to um you know maybe not just financial institutions but you know your take on on the whole space in general what do you think we should be thinking about yeah um so I'll tread lightly um that way I don't get any knocks at um my door um no but I I think I think so I'll just I maybe I'll back out and say generally speaking I think we're going to see more and more ETFs etps um I just think that it's it's a very low it's a very low barrier of Entry it's very low cost um to uh effectively stand up so uh yeah um I I think we're going to see more etps we're going to see more ETFs they won't just be here in the US they're going to be again it's it's an

instrument that is um it is ubiquitous um so you're going to see it in in multiple jurisdictions uh and it's going to continue I mean what I mean we see it revolving across a number of Industries it's going to continue to figure out ways in which they can wrap some like insert asset here create ETP on top find her find her you know provide finder toll fee uh right or collector's fee um you I again I I do believe that look it's it's it is a massive unlock for a number of folks who want to be able to offer this uh to in clients because for some clients it's going to be their first exposure ever to crypto right will be through an ETF and so um it it is it is it's worth taking taking that perspective as well so there's going to be a continued sort of proliferation in ETFs and it's going to continue to uh it's going to continue to eat the eat the fund management world if you will um

so I I that that's certainly a prediction that I see so you will see more we certainly see it in the form of filings um I I I I suspect that we'll probably see more that are are going to continue to uh proliferate the space um what should we look forward to um here's here's another sort of like prediction that I have which is I'm not entirely sure what it looks like but the sort of of traditional Capital markets and crypto markets um sort of merging and what do I mean by that like there's this thing that we tend to refer to as like Market structure uh right and I think oftentimes it's it's it's sort of lossing us within within the industry uh in so much as we we talk about it very often but every but in essence where where there's a market there's likely a structure U whether not it's th evolves naturally or it evolves unnaturally in the form of um you know regulations things of that nature and so I

do I do suspect um you have ETFs we have tokenized assets I I I don't know what that looks like in the future I don't I don't see tokenized assets you know out sprinting ETFs in terms of just glum up or uh you know absorbing or sucking up all the assets in the world um right but I I do think that uh there is going to be some merge um and interaction between the two and we're going to continue to see more and more and by virtue of that we're going to continue to see more and more own chain economy more and more decentralization um and a sort of uh like where centralization is much more efficient scales of economy is much more um you know economically like Fe like feasible that's going to continue to exist but I think alongside you're going to see you know this this this this sort of intersection of the two uh taking place again I don't I don't know what exactly that looks like some people suspect that

it's tokenization um you know tokenization of uh um I I I I'm I'm I'm probably less less optimistic on that particular view but uh but but you will you will see I mean seeing folks going effectively so we've seen stuff like spaxs right and other ways in which you can potentially go um make yourself available and have price um have a have a tradable price available for you on a particular like on a registered exchange well I mean like you can effectively do that now with with crypto we've talked about memes but you know but there but there are but there are potentially going to be uh and I know there's views and arguments out there for why memes could be something else but um I think there's also going to be opportunities where you could potentially experience those particular type of liquid um events without uh and providing liquidity and price transparency without um having to go the route of say you know the existing sort of reg route um yeah I think that's

a really interesting note to end on actually because you know it is about the intersection right and I think it's it's going to be fascinating to see these two worlds not Collide this kind of a slow entanglement and marriage of them right the traditional financial institutions and this wild west of crypto that it feels like it's been a Marque year we've just seen for them uh you know getting together and how that plays out you know whether the crypto Bros end up hating everything because it's it's all the values captured through these ETFs and products it's going to be it's going to be crypto Twitter is goingon to be interesting for the foreseeable so that's one prediction I would I think will definitely come true but John it's it's been an absolute pleasure Johnny speaking to you thank you so much for your time and uh I hope you've enjoyed being on the show it's been great to have you oh this has been great this has been great I've been this has been longer

do and I've been I've been waiting for it so I really appreciate you all inviting me on and this has been I listen to you all um pretty religious so I sincerely appreciate the invitation it's been an honor thanks shcking pleasure all our thank you Johnny and to everyone listening at home thank you for joining us and you can see us next week to entangle a little more web 3

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes