Episode 51
Crypto Custody
About this episode
In this episode of the Untangling Web 3 podcast, we tackle one of the most pressing questions in the world of cryptocurrency: how should you custody your assets to keep them secure?
The phrase "not your keys, not your coins" highlights the perceived risks of storing digital assets on centralized exchanges. In this episode, we delve into the various custody options available to crypto users and provide insights on what to consider when choosing the best method for safeguarding your assets.
Highlights from the episode
- Custodial Services. We explore the fully custodial model where a third party manages and secures your digital assets. This method is analogous to traditional banking, offering ease of use but also central points of failure. We discuss the pros and cons of using major exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken, and highlight the potential risks of technical issues, hacks, and regulatory challenges.
- Non-Custodial and Self-Custody Solutions. Moving on to non-custodial options, we explain how wallets allow users to maintain control over their private keys. This includes software wallets like MetaMask and hardware wallets like Ledger and Trezor. We emphasize the importance of securely backing up seed phrases and the potential pitfalls of managing your own security.
- Innovative Security Techniques. We touch on advanced cryptographic techniques such as multi-signature and threshold cryptography, which enhance security by distributing control across multiple parties. These methods strike a balance between security and convenience and are increasingly used by institutional custodians like BitGo and Fireblocks.
This episode underscores the importance of understanding your options for crypto custody. While custodial services offer convenience and user-friendly experiences, they come with significant risks. Non-custodial and self-custody solutions provide greater control and security but require careful management of private keys and seed phrases.
As the crypto market evolves, it is crucial to stay informed about best practices for securing your assets. Remember to do thorough research, consider insurance options, and stay vigilant about potential security threats. Join us next time as we continue to untangle the complexities of Web 3 and help you navigate the ever-changing landscape of cryptocurrency.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
the idea of having these intermediaries that effectively do everything on your behalf is philosophically an issue and I think also maybe technically an issue as well, right? One of the earliest Bitcoin miners who was involved very very early, he basically threw away one of the old hard drives he had which he thinks now contained private keys to some of those early block rewards that he mined. So, he thinks he's lost around 8,000 BTC. That's worth around 400 million today as we record this. This is the kind of thing that can happen if you go down the pure physical self-custody route, okay?
You are responsible and even someone as experienced and knowledgeable it can still happen to them. It can happen to the best of us, right? Welcome to another episode of the Entangling Web3 Podcast. Now, you may have heard the phrase not your keys, not your coins before which refers to the perceived risks of storing your digital assets on centralized This gets to the heart of one of the biggest questions for everyday users of crypto which is how should I custody my assets to keep them secure? So, today we'll be taking a look at the different custody options available to crypto users and what you should consider when choosing one of them.
Of course, as ever I'm joined by my co-host Alec to discuss this topic. How are you today, my Yeah, I'm very good. This is the question that's in the news and everyone's lips right now. All anyone is talking about is how do I store my keys, right? And how do I store my crypto? No, I'm joking but with the recent boom in the crypto market right now, it is a hot topic. There are people that are coming into space, a lot of newbies. Actually, I've been asked quite a lot in the last like couple of weeks is even by one of my friends who's like 60 plus and this is like said, I've heard about this Bitcoin thing.
Is it really a good way to invest? Like you were there, Jack, as well. I was just like, okay. Yeah, it's probably the time to maybe get involved in this stuff but it is a question that a lot of people are asking and I I it's really important to understand the different ways that we can actually store our keys and store our cryptocurrency, right? Yeah, it is a very important topic. I likewise have had the same experience for many years, people wanting to get some exposure to Bitcoin or other cryptos, and you might tell them, "Okay, well, there's this wallet to use." And then a year or two later they say, "Oh, you know that that crypto I bought, I can't seem to access it anymore." And then they can they run into this exact problem that you sometimes get when you hold your own keys.
So, yeah, why don't we just start off I think it's worth just summarizing, okay? At a glance, what are we talking about? So, in general, we as users of crypto, we have three options broadly when it comes to securing our assets. So, firstly, you can use a custodial service. So, you know, that's a third party being fully responsible for storage and security management of your digital assets. Then you have what's called non-custodial services. That's when you still have a third party involved, but they actually allow you to maintain full control of your keys, the the private keys that control your funds.
And then you have self-custody, which is kind of a third option. It's very similar to non-custodial because it is non-custodial, but self-custody is when you're completely fully independent, and it typically is more physical where your non-custodial services are digital. So, yeah, that's the three kind of broad options. Unless you've heard of any other ways of holding your crypto recently. No, I think they're the the main three. I think I have experienced all three of them and probably experienced the pitfalls of all three of them as well, but it probably makes sense to go into each of them in a bit more detail just so people understand what their options are, what the pros are, what the cons are, and hopefully enable them to make an educated decision on what's best for them if they start to move into this Yeah, exactly.
So, why don't we start with the first one then, the fully custodial option. So, as we said, this is when you are effectively giving over the control of your assets to a third party. You're letting them safeguard them, the private keys that control spending the funds on the blockchain itself or even on a layer two as we've talked about recently. Those keys effectively sit with that third party, Yeah, and I think one of the best analogies for this is like a bank, right? I think most people who aren't Jack Davis storing their cash under their mattresses tend to store all of their physical and digital cash with a third party, their bank, their Santander, the HSBCs of the world, right?
And there's pros to this. The reason we do this is because we trust them. We trust they have the right security measures in place. We trust they have our interests at heart. We trust they're not going to mess around. And also, who wants to store their cash under the bed? It tends to just be the tinfoil hat people of the world who think doomsday is coming any minute and then we can't trust the government. But I think most people understand the benefits of custodians when it comes to cash, and it applies in the exact same way with crypto as well.
Yeah, I think you're getting at the whole customer experience there as well, right? The customer experience of using custodial service providers, whether that be typically a crypto exchange, for example. We'll get onto other types in a minute, but the experience of managing crypto assets via a third-party custodian is by far and away superior just in terms of how easy it is. It's much easier to get the assets in the first place, to off-board typically when things are going well. So, yeah, for most people, that will be their first point of contact with the the crypto world, and that makes sense.
As you said, it's analogous to what we have in in the traditional world. So, yeah, it's no surprise to me how much they get used. And I feel like we're flogging a dead horse here a little bit in that whenever we talk about the problem of Web3, it's always the user experience, right? You go onto the apps, and we're going to get onto it a little bit. There's loads of issues with non-custodial stuff. I don't want to jump the gun, but I already am, on seed phrase and all this kind of stuff.
But when you're looking at Coinbase of the world and downloading the app and getting involved, it's the exact same as interacting with, you know, a normal kind of stock exchange or something like this. And I think the custodial model is, as we kind of have said before, a more web 2.5 because you're managing web three assets in a way these cryptocurrencies and NFTs and all this kind of stuff, but you're doing it in a web two way. So, whenever someone who's not web three native or doesn't have that guy that I was speaking to us the other day, the 60-plus-year-old who was asking about this, the first thing I said was go to Coinbase.
That's a bit of you. Like, they'll do all the hard stuff. You'll just be able to interact with the environment, but you won't have any of the burdens of all the web three stuff that we're still trying to figure out. So, yeah, I think it is necessary. We're going to talk about some of the shortfalls of this stuff, obviously, but I do think it's a necessary intermediary right now as people start to get familiar with this Yeah, 100% and we've seen, you know, things like Revolut is a good example of a not a traditional bank, but a challenger bank, much more modern, digital first.
They were offering crypto products as well, an ability to buy and sell via that. Or you used to have your Robinhood app as well. So, yeah, there's very low friction for people to get involved in in holding it. Now, how does it actually work, this idea of fully custodial services? So, essentially, they have to do the security somewhere and you really have to think carefully about which provider you use because you need to be confident that they're using the right security measures. But, typically, what they'll do is they'll use what's called cold storage.
So, those private keys that you never really see as a user in a custodial environment, they will still take those very, very seriously. They'll hold them in these cold storage environments. And what that means is essentially, they're not exposed to the internet for most of the time. They're they're in secure air-gapped from the internet typically until the point where they need to sign a transaction with them, move funds around. But again, you never see any of how that's managed on on on the user end as as a customer of one of these services, but you kind of trust that it's happening in the back end.
Yeah, and I think this is something I didn't know that we were going to come on to it this early, but it does make sense. So, we have these terms like cold wallets and hot wallets, right? And you touched on what a cold wallet is there. It's usually managed offline for enhanced security against hacking, but a bit less convenient for for frequent access, right? So, you tend to prefer these cold storage solutions or cold wallet solutions as you just mentioned there for long-term storage and large holdings, you know, the holders of the world, the people who don't actually intend to use Bitcoin every day.
They tend to just, you know, look at what's happening a year down the line and see how much money they've made. And then you have hot wallets, which are on the contrary, the opposite, interconnected there. They're for easy access, transactions every day, but much more vulnerable to online threats and scams, right? And people that actually want to use cryptocurrency for the intended original use case, if we think about Bitcoin being this peer-to-peer electronic cash system, then that's a hot wallet. You want to actually be exchanging things every day, doing micro payments and all the wonderful and weird things that Jack and I are always saying early in about.
So, yeah, there's a big distinction there that we need to probably clarify as we go through because that will keep coming up. Yeah, it's a good point. And you Yeah, just generally I think of cold storage or cold wallet as offline and hot wallet as online, right? So, obviously, if something's online, you are exposed to different kinds of risks because there are access points to that through the internet protocols that we know about. So, one of the things that I'd also like to to mention here is there's there's distinctions within distinctions.
There's different types of custodial services as well, right? There's the kind of the black and white way of thinking of it where whenever I want to use Coinbase, Coinbase will effectively access my key and they'll do the transaction for me. So, it's effectively they're the full service provider. They do everything whenever I want them to. But there's actually kind of these things in between as well when we start to think about it, multi-signature, threshold signature, multi-party computation stuff. And this is a little bit in between a custodial and a non-custodial arrangement, I'd say.
We will definitely do full episodes going into these cuz these are really interesting topics around the space. But just at like quite a high level, they're they're cryptographic techniques to enhance security by splitting up, say, signing tools to multiple parties. So, whenever I want to say send one Bitcoin from me to Jack, instead of me having the whole of that key, I can actually say I'll have a part of that key, maybe Coinbase will have a part of that key, and my mom will have a part of that key as well.
And you know, on the one hand that makes it more secure because you have to compromise my key, Coinbase's key, and potentially even my mom's key to do any transaction. But maybe the the that which is good good on the security perspective. The downside of that could be that all three parties need to agree every time. So, you might not be able to do that, you know, 20 times per second and things like this. But I mean, do you You know, you're interested in these topics as well.
Is there stuff you'd want to add there on the the threshold signature, the multi-party stuff? Yeah, I think it's really interesting and it's becoming very very commonplace now to use this multi-signatures or uh threshold cryptography. So, multi-signatures is is the easiest to grasp, as you were saying. And there's an analogy with if you've ever worked in a corporate environment, in the finance department maybe, for any big financial decision you make, payroll happening, or end of month bills being paid by a company, you'll typically have a kind of double, triple, quadruple stamping going on from different people in the company.
Your CFO, your CEO will both have to agree before the transaction goes ahead. So, multi-signature is just like that. So, for a given transaction, you need multiple people to sign. And then the threshold cryptography basically is a bit more magic and takes that a step further where things are even more secure in the MPC environment or this threshold environment where the keys don't actually exist. So, these private keys that we say are in hot or cold storage, this is taking it one step further where they kind of never exist and take our word for it.
This is magic, it's mathematics, but it's real. And it's really interesting. So, lots of the bigger providers are experimenting and using these techniques now. Yeah, we definitely I'm glad you just described it as magic because we definitely need a whole episode to go into some of the the detail of that. But for now, we'll just say it is magic. These are very cool. There's lots of people that are exploring these. And there's so many more applications that threshold signatures and multi-party computation could be used for than just managing crypto and crypto wallets.
But, yeah, it's very secure, very interesting, but there are some downsides to it as well. So, yeah, most kind of exchanges that are actually doing this kind of custodial arrangement, the big ones that everyone's probably familiar with, the Coinbase of the world. I mean, that's the provider I use just because I've always thought of them as the most regulatory friendly. Like, they've been working with the US for a long time. I think they're probably the least likely to go under. That's always been my understanding of Coinbase anyway.
You've got the Krakens of the world. I mean, I used Kraken for a I used Kraken for a little while, and I know they they do custodial arrangements, right? But, I think they also do non-custodial arrangements as well. I think you have the option for both. And the reason I know that is because I actually had a Kraken non-custodial wallet, which I talked about previously, and I lost coins on that. But, maybe we'll talk about that a bit later in the next Yeah, exactly. And it's true that most of the centralized exchanges that do implement the custodial model are actually offering their customers the option to go non-custodial as well.
So, it's not just black and white. If you name a given provider, typically most are trying to offer both options. You also have other examples of dedicated custodians. So, there's crypto exchanges are more for your end consumers, like you or I just trying to buy, hold, sell, whatever your your crypto assets. Then you have the dedicated custodians like a BitGo for example or a Fireblocks, who really have become very huge recently, actually. They're much more focused on institutions. So, if a if a big company, as we talked about in the recent episode of on adoption, if they want to start adding these assets to their balance sheet, they don't necessarily want to worry about all the security implications themselves, they'll use one of these dedicated custodians like a BitGo to do that for them.
And they're the ones actually, like your BitGos, Fireblocks, who are doing a lot of this interesting threshold MPC stuff. Then finally, not necessarily a custodian, but I think it's worth mentioning given what we're seeing at the minute, ETFs as well. So, we talked about the fact that that's a way of getting price exposure to things like Bitcoin now, but you never actually hold the assets. And in that case, you don't actually own the asset necessarily. You own a share in this fund, but it's a similar idea.
And in that case, the funds themselves are there the ones who are doing custody of the underlying assets themselves. Yeah, I mean, I see it like all these ETFs like they're kind of they split the Web3 and the crypto and definitely the maybe the Bitcoin maxi community to an extent where half the people were saying, "This is great. Institutional adoption, boom. Look everything all the money's going to flow in and everything's rocketing like it is now." And then the other half was like, "Well, no. This is really anti-Web3." Like the term that I think we've already touched on that we say often here as kind of something that's popular not necessarily that we agree with it, but it's something's very popular in the space is not your keys, not your coins.
It kind of goes against the principles of Web3, which is all about individual ownership empowerment. You know, we've talked about data sovereignty and all this kind of stuff. And the idea of having these intermediaries to effectively do everything on your behalf is philosophically an issue. And I think also maybe technically an issue as well. Like we've seen some of the how it can go wrongs very like very recently. FTX. Like a lot of people used in FTX. That was the poster boy, right? Kind of just spoke about Coinbase being like one of the golden boys.
But FTX was actually probably as much if not more so as Coinbase. And so many so much money was lost there. So many normal people, not just the big investors, but you know, retail investors like you or I, they lost a lot of money as well. And now they're still trying to work out if they can get it back. Yeah, this phrase not your keys, not your coins. I've always had a problem with it because I don't like how what implications it has in terms of property rights.
I don't agree with the phrase in terms of if you don't have the keys, you don't own the property. I disagree with that. But in a very practical sense, it is true. As you said, things like FTX. If we go back even further to many years ago, one of the first big exchange collapses, Quadriga, that collapsed the exchange was basically being run off one guy's laptop and ended up losing 200 million in customer funds. The guy disappeared, right? So, this is the kind of thing and even when you don't have malicious actors, we've just seen very recently with with Bitcoin hitting all-time highs, Coinbase had issues at that time because of the surge in demand and that led to I think around 100 billion being wiped off the crypto market purely because of the lack of service.
So, it's not just that the the providers themselves might be malicious in any way. This it's purely the fact that technical issues can arise and that can affect you as a user. Yeah, and one thing I want to say is I am so surprised you didn't give the example for countering not your keys, not your coins. Jack loves talking about this. This is his favorite story. It was like, "Well, if I am a car owner and someone takes the keys to my car or takes the keys to my house, it doesn't mean they own it." But, you've actually avoided that for once because we've probably got other things to talk about.
Yeah, the Coinbase one's really interesting cuz I was part of the issues. I look at my Coinbase account maybe every day, something like this. And the error that was coming through because of all this activity was that a lot of people's wallets were reporting zero. So, I looked at my Coinbase account, it was non-zero at 8:00 p.m. I look at it 9:00 p.m., it's zero. I'm like, "Oh my god, have I been hacked? Has Coinbase done an FTX and disappeared?" I was literally like on the phone to my girlfriend being like, "We're screwed.
Sorry, I've got no money left." Which is so ridiculous. Yeah, not financial advice. Do not do what Alex does and pour all your money into crypto, but yeah, it it it it's true. These things can happen. And yeah, I won't go into the whole property rights thing. That is a whole other issue, but I think it's totally fair to think of it as not your keys, not your coins from purely practical means. As you say with FTX, you know, people have lost money, they probably won't get it back.
There are other issues as well in the centralized exchange world and kind of with this custodial model. I don't think it's KYC is an issue, but some people see it as an issue and the fact that you have to do KYC checking sometimes, actually the bigger issue is that there can be big data breaches. These are huge kind of targets, these exchanges and and other providers are big targets for hackers, right? So, there's been huge data breaches. In 2023, there was one exchange where a million customers' personal data was leaked, right?
Because they know how many how many customers they have, and maybe the security provisions aren't as good for the customer data as they are for the private key. So, that's another issue people have with tying that their ownership to one of these exchanges. Yeah, and I I take your point about KYC. Like, I am also, you know, pro-KYC. I think as we kind of move into the real world, and we need to start actually, you know, be able to do retail purchases, then you should have some KYC over a certain amount because there there is some money laundering.
Like, I know it's always Bitcoin and crypto is always thrown into that. Everything's drugs and money laundering, and really when you look at the data, that's not true. It's really like cash and things like that that are far worse for it. But, one of the things that I I particularly take issue with on on this kind of stuff is the idea of censorship. I think that's a big thing. Like, right now we're in the UK, where we don't really have much censorship right now, but you look at other countries, you know, it happens.
Everyone likes to give the example of the Canadian truckers, you know, their accounts were frozen, and that's a real example of how custodial arrangements really can go wrong. And a more interesting one that this plays into rather than domestic censorship is our idea of like international censorship. Because obviously, you know, cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, it's this global asset, cross-borders. That's one of the most powerful and beautiful things about the whole thing. And you have Coinbase, which is also a multi-international company across the world. Their headquarters are in the US, right?
And it's all of a sudden, if the US says, "Actually, we don't like that country over there. You better freeze all those accounts, Coinbase, or else we're going to start to screw you over because your headquarters is based here, and your employees are based here, and you pay tax here." Well, this becomes an issue no longer have this idea of this decentralized, distributed network with no single point point of failure. If everyone's going through Coinbase, and the US government can all of a sudden put the pressure onto Coinbase to start to restrict certain accounts.
I'm not saying that's going to happen, and you know, in some cases, that is a good thing, right? If we can stop terrorism and things like that, that's great. I just think it's something to be aware of when we think about this idea of everyone using Coinbase and these custodians as the only way to exchange Yeah, I completely agree. And ultimately, it comes down to the fact that as soon as you put full trust in a third party like this, then you're also putting your faith in how they sit in the regulatory environment where they are, whatever jurisdiction they operate in.
And that's always going to be an unknown that can change over time. So, yeah, it's definitely an important consideration. So, moving on then, what can we do if you don't want to be in that situation? If you want to sacrifice a bit of user experience, add in a bit of friction potentially, but to have more control. So, that's where the non-custodial arrangements take place, right? That's the alternative. So, what does that mean? Well, typically, this is wallets or kind of other software like a Chrome plugin, for example, that basically lets you take full control of your private key.
So, then you as a user, Alec, maybe you cannot cannot be trusted to to look after your own private keys. And what he's alluding to here is I had this, which I've talked about previously for those people that are consistent across our episodes and up-to-date. I had a Kraken wallet. I had 500 pound worth of Bitcoin in there, I think, which I mean, one of those people that's like, "Oh my god, that's like in 10 years time." That was like a billion pounds worth of Bitcoin that's lost on this Kraken wallet.
But I think right now it would have been like 2K or something like that. And yeah, didn't take the I know it's annoying. Didn't take the seed phrase. Um should we go into this as well? We should go into this. But effectively, you know, you have these wallets and they're still run by third-party providers, right? It's not like you create your own wallet on your phone. Like you still have um a service provider that creates the wallet. But the point is the software's run on your device and you're less beholden to the actual company.
Everything can kind of be managed on your own device. And one of the most important things of this is when you create your wallet for the security purposes, you effectively create this seed phrase. And the seed phrase is it's a a big number, right? It's a number between 128 and 256 bits or something like this. It's a huge huge number. And they convert this to a mnemonic because no one's going to be able to write down this number and not make a mistake. So, a mnemonic is like basically the word equivalent of that big number, right?
And there's pretty good standards for how we do this. And it's like weird numbers like, you know, Bible, tree, goat, and things like that in like the sequence, right? I remember the first time I saw it, I was like, "What the hell is this? Is it like a quiz or something like that?" But the point of these mnemonics is going to represent that really big random number that represents like everything that kind of controls your wallet and the and the keys in there. And the mnemonic is more human-readable.
And we use like very well-known standards for doing this, the BIP standards, which is the Bitcoin Improvement Protocol standards, right, Jack? And effectively, this seed phrase represent is like a it's a cryptographic key. It's the root of all the cryptographic keys in your wallet effectively. And from this seed phrase, using this thing called a hierarchical deterministic wallet, you can produce an infinite number of keys from that seed phrase. It's like Jack nodding along like, "Yes, I like you've got this. You can do this." Come on, you're nearly there through the technical stuff.
I know, it's getting Finally getting it. So, yeah, your wallet will derive all your private keys and obviously effectively the public keys related to that in a repeatable and consistent way. There's kind of like a defined way of how it will do these things once it's got the seed phrase. Meaning that the same seed phrase will always generate the same set of keys in the same order. Okay, so that's quite important. So, if I if I lose my phone and lose my wallet on my phone, for example, if I have that seed phrase, I can go to realistically probably any wallet that uses these standards, which is almost every wallet anyway, and I can put that seed phrase into the wallet, and the software within the wallet can derive all the private keys and all the transactions by scanning the public keys that are related to those private keys on blockchain to see all the funds linked to that wallet and all the transaction history.
And I think that's it, right? They get that Yeah, I hope everyone's still with us, but yeah, that was a technical deep dive. I was actually very well explained, I think. It's not easy cuz there's so many things going on. But yeah, so I often think of a wallet as it's basically a collection of private keys, which are these kind of long 256-bit typically numbers. So, 256 ones and zeros in a line, that's a random number that you use. It's your one true dream, isn't it, Yeah, these days at least, anyway.
But as you alluded to, your entire wallet, because of the standards that have emerged around how you manage wallets, your entire wallet is completely derived from a single 256-bit And that is what this mnemonic seed phrase is. So, you map this 256 bits to a bunch of words, right? So, the first four bits or something will map to Bible, and the next four will map to go. And I won't reveal Alex's entire And ruin this episode. But yeah, there And there's this standard dictionary, right? So, if this is the number in the first four bits, then this is the word.
That's how it works. And yeah, from that 256-bit number, you can then regenerate all of the keys for all of your assets. And that's very portable in that sense, right? You can take your seed phrase from one wallet to the next, which is another nice thing about the non-custodial arrangement, is that you're not locked into a single platform. You can very easily switch between them. And a wallet then, think of your MetaMask for example, or even like a Coinbase wallet for their non-custodial option or an Exodus, these are all just interfaces where you can input this private key, and it will show you then, as you said, all these assets that you manage based on those private keys.
So, that's what we're talking about with non-custodial. Now, we've talked mostly about software wallets so far. As I said, the MetaMasks of the world, things that are very easy to use. You also have the kind of more tinfoil hat experience of this. You also have the cold wallets, which are hardware typically hardware wallets. So, probably the most famous of these you have the Ledger Nano S I think it is the actual product and no sponsorship but you have that one. You also have the Trezor. So, these are actually physical devices and they are digital but they're physical kind of devices.
Think of your physical key that helps you log on to online banking sometimes. I know a lot of people have those and they help people become more confident using online banking. But these are physical devices that effectively store your private key securely and away from the internet for most of their lifetime unless you want to go on and make a Yeah, I mean if you see someone with these hardware wallets you know they're serious about this. They're probably a Bitcoin maxi and they're probably laughing at me.
They've got a lot of money. It's some serious business. I'm not at that stage yet. I'm still using Coinbase and losing seed phrases all over the place. But yeah, some of the problems and just considerations around these non-custodial arrangements, obviously you have to write down these seed phrases and store them somewhere. Otherwise, if you lose your phone like I did, you lose everything associated with that wallet which is a big issue. I think one of the crazy stats that I've seen around this is a lot of people have lost these seed phrases, right?
And I think it's somewhere around 13% of the entire Bitcoin supply has been lost to this kind of issue, to people losing their seed phrases. I don't even know how much money that is right now but it's a hell of a lot. Yeah, I feel like every single person who has some crypto will know at least one other person who's lost their crypto by forgetting their seed phrase. So, you know, in this in this case that's that's my Alec. The other aspect of this which is interesting is because okay, we're not no longer are we custodying our keys with a third party but there is an element of trust typically with another third party, whoever is that third party that's created the wallet whether it be software or hardware.
And a good example of this is a hack that happened with Ledger actually recently. So, there was a kind of complex phishing attack launched on an employee at Ledger, and that basically led to the code of one of their products that connected the Ledger, you know, as I say, the hot is cold normally, but it can connect out if you choose to to other services. They compromise that code, and that resulted in it again, not huge, but it's still significant. It was around half a million in customer funds lost from that.
But, it that I like this story because it proves you can't just trust it because you have the keys and you think it's safe. You are still sacrificing a little bit of trust in the hardware or the software, especially if the wallet isn't open source software, for example, then you can't fully verify how secure how securely it's storing your assets. Yeah, I think one of the things that we want to touch on here as well is we're talking about these kind of what do you call them?
The crown jewel type situations. You have a Coinbase database that has everyone's potentially everyone's data, everyone's keys in one place. And yeah, there's going to be a hell of a lot of security on that. What's the phrase they use? It's like a mountain vault setup where it's so heavily security that there's no way of Yeah, well, there are the I think there are these like Swiss mountains, right? Where they store Bitcoin keys, and they're in like safety deposit boxes in mountains with It's like Fort Knox, basically, right?
You know, the so that's the kind of thing you're do that. Exactly. So, we're talking about this Fort Knox setup probably for Coinbase. But, the point is it is crown jewels. There's a lot of people, maybe hackers from international states, shadow states, and all this kind of stuff looking at those keys and being like, "Wow, there is billions in there. If I just get through that Fort Knox style security, then I've got all access to all these keys." In the self-custodial arrangement, obviously, you're managing your own keys.
So, your security is much less. It's only the biometric sign-in of your device or your seed phrase that's maybe in a locker somewhere or something like this. But, the actual assets there is much lower. And if you get compromised, it doesn't mean anyone else gets compromised. So, we have this kind of security arrangement where because funds are distributed across many people, we're a much smaller target. So, it's actually probably it's probably a benefit to the actual security arrangement because of that because people working for the KGB or whatever it is aren't going to be hacking my device.
I hope not anyway. Probably now they know about me. Yeah, I was going to say after this episode maybe they will be. But that's a probably a pro-security thing for the self-custodial Yeah, and I think it's important just to make a quick distinction. Right now, we're talking about self-custody, which is really a subset of non-custodial. Except, I think non-custodial things that we talked about before, your hardware software wallets, they tend to be digital in some sense. Your self-custody arrangement tends to be purely physical, right? So, how does this normally work?
Well, people basically there's a few different options. So, some people consider the hardware wallets as pure self-custody, but for the reasons we've just explained, maybe that's not quite true. The actual OG, let's say, self-custody tends to be things like paper wallets. So, you literally write down your seed phrase on a piece of paper, and then you hide that under the mattress, okay? Or you put that in a safety deposit box. That is quite commonplace actually, I believe. If you see someone that does this, run away.
Run far away. Yeah, or or you know, find the seed But um so, either they'll be on a paper wallet. I've seen a good technique talked about being to put it on an old phone that you're not using anymore that's not connected to the internet. Again, you have a risk there that the phone won't work when you go and turn it on. So, not necessarily recommended. Some people also use these brain wallets. Now, I think these are highly unrecommended, but this is where people literally memorize the seed phrase or try and, you know, build a story around it or something.
So, it it sounds funny, but it's true. This does happen. But yeah, this the pure self-custody model is taking it that much further where you basically have zero third-party arrangement involved. The idea of this brain wallet is ridiculous. I can't I can't even remember birthdays sometimes. I'm not remembering 18 words, Golden. It's always Golden Bible, I think. But yeah, like Jack says, the issues here are probably the lowest level of user experience, right? This is for people that don't want to use this very often. There's no third party that's trying to help them to get into their wallet ever.
So, it is basic as hell, but probably the most secure and the least dependent on anyone if anything's going to happen." And like when we think about the hot and cold wallet stuff, this is I guess it's probably the most cold of any cold wallet, right? They're not going to be someone that is They're looking They're putting the Bitcoin away and they're going to look at it in 100 years' time or something like that, probably. There's a lot of problems that can come about because of this and I think Jack's got some stories that he wants to tell us about the consequences of using this kind of setup.
Yeah, well, I mean, there's a very famous story and as a a fellow Welshman, I feel like I should tell this one. So, again, you may well have heard of this one, but there's a guy called James Howells. So, he was was a Welsh IT worker from Newport and is basically one of the earliest Bitcoin miners. He was involved very, very Mined some of the earliest blocks in in Bitcoin ever. Now, in 2013, as the story goes, he basically threw away, accidentally, one of the old hard drives he had, you know, as you do over time, which he thinks now contained private keys to some of those early block rewards that he mined.
So, you know, literally, mining rewards coming directly from blocks, now effectively lost. So, he thinks he's lost around 8,000 BTC. That's worth around 400 million today as we record this just after the all-time highs. So, it's a lot of money. Now, currently, that that hard drive he believes is sat in a landfill site in Newport that's owned by Newport Council, but he's putting together this huge project. He's got private backing to do this. There's a whole the kind of documentary on it as well, where he's petitioning the council, "I want to go and dig up this landfill.
I want to use like IoT and robots to scan through the soil to find the hard drive." I I honestly this is the case. And he wants to donate 25% of the proceeds back to the local community if they let him do this, but at the minute, it's not happening. But, the whole point is this is the kind of thing that can happen if you go down the pure physical self-custody route, okay? You are responsible. And even someone as experienced and knowledgeable as James, who was, you know, there on the ground mining Bitcoin in like 2011, 2012, potentially, it can still happen to them.
It can happen to the best of us, Yeah, I'd love to get James on because this is such an incredible story. I think the kind of the attempt to recover is probably as interesting as the fact that he lost it in the first place, right? I think some of the things that I saw that he was trying to get to is this highly specialized team, like robot dogs, artificial intelligence-powered machines specifically for identifying hard drives. There's so much tech going into this. He wanted 24-hour CCTV across the entire patrol.
And all So, to make sure there's no unauthorized searches cuz obviously as he gets closer and closer, people will be thinking, "All I've got to do is take this hard drive from this landfill and I've got 400 million pound, potentially." But, I saw that the council wouldn't approve it because there's obviously ecological and legal concerns about him digging through people's stuff, right? Yeah, exactly. So, as you say, it's a great story. And I think the whole the take-home message here is that the more self-custodial you go, cuz again, this is really a spectrum from pure custodial to to fully self-custodial is a big spectrum of options in between.
But, the more you take responsibility for your own assets, the bigger the risks that you are obviously incurring upon yourself, right? Another issue with the whole self-custody thing, as you alluded to earlier, it's not really necessarily in the interest of cryptocurrency in general, right? Because the more self-custodial you go, the less likely you are to actually use it. If your stuff is If your coins are stored on this paper wallet, you're not going to dig that out and use it every day. So, it it goes back to this hodling mentality, right?
Just holding the assets, hoping it will moon, coming back in 20 years. And it's not for this utility usage of payments for for data, for anything. It's not really on that. So, I think it's not necessarily great for crypto in general. But, yeah, you You see why people do it as well. Yeah, it makes sense. We've always said that we're proponents of utility and we want to see them like these cryptocurrencies potentially replacing fiat to an extent because of this there's so many benefits to it.
And we've kind of seen the CBDCs go down that route where these CBDCs, whether you're pro or against them, like what we've seen so far from the projects and pilots that are out there is they won't be interest bearing. So they're not going to be you're not going to be able to use these things as investment and huddle assets, right? In a lot of the cases, especially in the UK. And the the pound digital pound scenario, sorry. But they are focused quite heavily on either retail or wholesale.
So actual utility coming from this. It's a shame because that should have been that should have been what crypto was is doing and hopefully will do. But yeah, you are right. I understand why they're doing it, right? At the end of the day, most people want to make money and it seems like huddling these kind of cryptocurrencies and assets is a way of making money. But yeah, I hope they also eventually get used for the peer-to-peer cash system that we're planning. So, let's do a little bit of a review.
Like we we always say this isn't financial advice. We're techies and we've been around this and I've made a lot of mistakes. So you want to learn from some of the mistakes I've made. If you are going to do this kind of stuff, we've talked at a really high level about what each of the the scenarios and options are. Custodial, we said they're very web two, easy to use, single points of failure in a lot of ways. But like we say, they're they're good for people that are moving into this space for the first time.
But really do your research on the exchange. Look at the breaches, look at how heavily regulated they are, make sure they've got guarantees and all this kind of stuff. But do your research before just going to any old exchange because you don't want to end up like those poor people that invested in FTX and had assets stored in FTX, right? Because they lost a lot of money. Yeah, exactly. And and again, just be aware of the risks, I think. This is more security advice. Even with an FTX, which lots of people told you was a great place to use and was perfectly safe, ended up being really bad place to put your assets.
So you know, you always have to assume the worst potentially when you're using these things and just be aware of the risks associated. You can also check for any guarantees they might provide. I'm aware of some exchanges beginning to offer things like insurance products. So, there is a company called Coin Cover who provides this insurance product to exchanges. So, they will insure assets up to a certain amount. I think maybe you have to opt in pay slightly more. But, if you're really worried about these risks, then taking out an insurance policy is also a really good idea.
You can also look out for exchanges in the custodial model that are using some of those multi-party techniques, right? Where you have more checks and balances on how the assets are used. So, that's definitely something to look out for. In the non-custodial or self-custody world, again, the headline is about securely back up backing up your seed phrases. So, don't just put it in your iPhone notes or something as I know lots of people have done. Don't stick it in an email or something. Be much more careful about where you back these things up.
Again, typically it might well be more secure if you back it up on something physical. You can also use a password manager. That kind of thing is very commonplace now. Yeah, learn from my failures. And I think like we talked about the UX traditionally being quite poor on these solutions, but it's getting better. And I think if we look to the kind of the future of this space, like I've seen a lot of work going on and projects going on right now around the idea of removing these mnemonics, removing these seed phrases, and linking that that that kind of core key, that core number that we talked about originally to biometrics.
As we all know, it's so easy to get onto your phone by just scanning your fingerprint. And a lot of people attest to that being a very high security standard, right? So, why not have a way to link our fingerprint to our wallets instead? And assuming that won't go wrong, right? Um that would be the best case scenario of a high UX. And also, you get the the kind of the non-custodial approach as well. But, a big assumption. It It It It obviously there are other issues you might introduce there, but I think again, it's going to be up to everyone's individual preference, right?
Some people would more than happy to use biometrics like as we do with banking. People use biometrics to confirm their banking transactions. Uh you're completely right. In the future, people will do the same thing with their their backup phrases for their crypto. So, yeah, I think looking to the future, you know, I don't know if there's necessarily that much happening right now in this world in terms of changes apart from what you said, right? Trying to remove seed phrases, that's probably the biggest trend I've seen and there's lots of clever people working on that, but I guess more broadly you also have a lot more scrutiny now on the centralized exchanges given what's happened with FTX and then Binance.
So, I think in the future you're they're likely to become more trustworthy because they know there's more regulatory action coming their way if they do have a big failing, right? So, that's a good thing. And I also think the way that the lawmakers are are starting to apply I mean, in the UK in particular classifying crypto assets as property in a legal sense is a really good step forward because again, they're clarifying the other side of that not your keys, not your coins argument and that will hopefully drive exchanges to have more obligations to to reimburse people that lose money when things go wrong, I think.
Yeah, there's going to be a lot of people moving into this space and importantly a lot of kind of like you say, regulatory certainty coming in with big institutions coming in as well. And that's exciting. I think the exchanges are going to come more and more under the thumb. Regulators are starting to catch up as you've said and that is a good boon for everyone that wants to use some of these kind of more custodial approaches. And like you say, it's beautiful that a lot of the the non-custodial approaches have been kind of focusing more and more on the UX and trying to just be a web 2 platform as much as possible with all the web 3 underpinnings.
So, that that is quite exciting. But I guess yeah, the main message is do your research, stay safe out there and write those seed phrases down somewhere and don't lose them. Don't follow Alex's example, that's our main message today. Do what I say, not what I do. And yeah, this has been a good episode then and I guess thank you to listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we untangle a little more of web 3. Thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling Web 3 produced by Emma Camilleri.
Don't forget to send us your thoughts, questions, and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode. See you next time to untangle a little bit more of Web 3. The views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto