Episode 25
CBDCs with John Velissarios (part 2)
About this episode
In this episode of Untangling Web3, Alec Burns and Jack Davies delve further into central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) with digital finance expert John Velasarios.
The conversation focuses on critical issues like privacy and government control regarding CBDCs. The Bank of England's approach to CBDCs, emphasizing privacy and aggregate data collection over individual tracking, is a key talking point. Concerns about potential government overreach, such as access restrictions or account freezes, are also discussed, highlighting how these actions could undermine public trust in CBDCs.
The episode then explores the design and operational aspects of CBDCs. John describes CBDCs as instruments enabling peer-to-peer transactions without central authority approval, differentiating them from digital coupons. While central banks centrally issue CBDCs, their transfer in the marketplace is decentralized. The hosts contrast this with cryptocurrencies, noting CBDCs' legal tender status and backing by national entities, unlike the speculative nature of many cryptocurrencies.
The discussion broadens to consider the future of CBDCs, their regulatory needs, and their intersection with emerging technologies like AI and blockchain. John speculates on the possible convergence of CBDCs and AI in web three, envisioning a future where they facilitate direct value exchanges on digital platforms.
The episode concludes with a contemplative note on what a conversation with Satoshi, the mysterious Bitcoin creator, might reveal about the wider ecosystem of web three, inviting listeners to stay engaged with the evolving narrative of digital currencies and technologies.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
I think what you need to do is program uh something around it but the actual money itself should not have uh should not be programmable at the end because if you could sit there and you can you know put limits on it or put some impose some restrictions on it it's no longer money it's a coupon it's a something that is that will convert to money at some point in time so these things again again not to get too philosophical about these topics but fundamentally cbdc uh is uh should always be in its purest form something that is unencumbered that doesn't have any restrictions it doesn't have any controls this is the second part of a two-part conversation with John vasaros on the topic of Central Bank digital yeah it's really interesting that I've seen like a lot of kind of concerns around privacy like you've mentioned there and it seems like the bank of England like you said really understood that and that was like one of the Paramount fundamental pillars of their proposal
for the Digital P was that you know privacy is super important to all of all the people in the country so that's one going to be one of the things that we designed Bas around and they I think they use the term around we won't collect be able to monitor any individual data but we'll monitor aggregate data that we need that's quite an important thing another concern that I've see and maybe this is a more Western thing is around control right like it's privacy and control two fundamental pillars of web 3 Technologies and there's a lot of people who up in arms about the idea of a cbdc in which you know the government can just all of a sudden say youve got 10 grand in the bank well that's cbdc would no longer going to give you access to that 10 grand what do you think to that what do you say to I think um this is a big challenge for you know for uh any Central Bank any government you know in
in in its ability to impose these kind of restrictions I mean whether it's a cbdc or whether it's freezing your bank account I mean I think at the end of the day the effect is the same right and uh I never thought I'd say you know I look at sort of what happened uh uh you know uh not that long ago with uh you know the um freezing of accounts from for people in Canada for the protests that were taking place in from the parliament right and I think that I I I never thought I would actually see that happen in my life I think you know in terms of people that are objecting something the government is doing and then all of a sudden you know they uh they have their funds Frozen their accounts Frozen and and and an inability to transact and to basically live a you know normal day-to-day life pay for daycare pay for groceries pay for whatever and get paid you know and all sorts of stuff so so
whether it's money in the bank or money in a cbdc I think it's you know if that happens we need a better government I think at the end of the day we don't need governments that do that kind of stuff to its people um you know uh I think it's it's a very uh it is a it is a big concern um but if that is uh the you know the the fact that if that does happen then we end up in a situation where you know people lose Faith people lose trust just like just like that is event that took place you know and it has a long lasting effect on societies and so on so not to get too philosophical on the topic I think at the end it becomes you know I think something that will have to play itself out I think with regards to uh how Society deals with governments that you know impose too much controls on their financial uh Financial situations and things like that um ability to
convert it I mean I think at the end you know I think uh many many cbdc projects um look at it look at sort of cbdc as a complement to cash not as a replacement cash so you know you always have the ability in theory I guess depending on where it gets rolled out you'll always have the ability to convert that into cash if you needed to uh or into something else but at the end you know it's a very it's a concern that you know we should all have and we should always think about how government the role the government plays in in our day-to-day lives um but that's a again a broader topic not necessarily one for just this podcast yeah exactly I think it's important to address right because you're seeing this word programmable I think programmable cbdc that's already become something that people they're starting to protest about on the streets and I think if there's one thing I've learned and you've Echo many times so far on today's show is
that it's all you know the word cbdc in itself is not the problem it's how you design it you can design one in a bad way that might program in lots of these kind of draconian measures or you could design them in a more transparent way or a more private way that doesn't you know there's a lot there's a lots of Spectra and lots of different properties you can right right and I think you you mentioned something which I think is important to point out you know we talk about programmability and cbdc and I think that I think anything that is programmable isn't necessarily A cbdc I think what you need to do is program uh something around it but the actual money itself should not have uh should not be programmable at the end because if you could sit there and you can you know put limits on it or put some impose some restrictions on it it's no longer money it's a coupon it's a something that is that will convert to money
at some point in time so these things again again not to get too philosophical about these topics but fundamentally CBBC uh is uh should always be in its purest form something that is unencumbered that doesn't have any restrictions it doesn't have any controls what you do with it is create a smart contract you put some stuff around it you you you put like a an agreement a legal agreement and so on uh but it should it should not be encumbered once you encumber it you do something with it that restricts its usage then all of a sudden it isn't cbdc it's a coupon it's a voucher it's something else but not that and I think U there's there's a lot of again a lot of discussions around that point as well that's a really reassuring point I think and will be peace of mind for lots of people but I I really like that actually the distinction there saying actually maybe not cbdc that's like a coupon system I like that because that's the main
thing people are worried about and I agree with you completely that at the kind of base level it should be like it should be like money it should be neutral so another another of thing you could say Central Bank liability yes exactly and I think when people talk about oh um this restrictive form this coupon system that you referred to people say that's not very web three right so the next thing I wanted to touch on is where does cbdc sit in the the whole kind of landscape of web 3 in general right is it a web 3 is does it sit within web 3 is it kind of overlapping is it outside of that because obviously some of the technology overlaps and we've talked about public blockchain but where where does it sit you yeah I mean I think um again you know you look at sort of you know web 3 and you look at sort of centralized versus decentralized sort of you know who issues it how do you use it and
so on I think you know I guess if I look at web three web3 is about sort of a a new way of of interacting with one another where I can transact with you directly I can exchange value I can exchange assets I can exchange things with you without needing to sort of deal with any other centralized party the interesting thing and I was thinking about this actually when I was you know in you know in thinking about this session um a central bank digital currency is there a cbdc is a central bank digital currency issued by a central bank so it's a centralized Authority by definition right at the end of the day that issues it but once it puts it out of the circulation it's just like the you know bank note has no control or shouldn't have control of how I spend it and how I use it it's my money at the end of the day so at that point it can go from person to person and payments can be
made um and in a in a in a sort of distributed way in a decentralized way in a way that isn't necessarily uh requires some Central Authority to approve the transaction that is being made and that again comes back to the design of the cbdc solutions it comes back to how it gets implemented and rolled out but the idea is that once I have my money and it's in digital format I can give it to you um Jack and give it to Al and so on um and I don't need to go through my bank in order to do that I can do it directly peer-to-peer I can even do it offline I can even do it you know without sort of um you know any type of limitation or control which is exactly the way I could do it with the bank note but I can now do it in a digital manner with you directly you know at the other end of of the line basically would it be fair to say that
it's the issuance that's centralized but then the transfer afterwards is kind of decentralized distributed correct yeah distributed I mean the decentralized nature of it is the fact that you know You' now distributed into the marketplace you know people are using it to transact with one another exactly what they do with you know money at the end but it but it also enables those exchanges to be done in a digital Manner and I think it plays to the strengths of web 3 even though you it's counterintuitive and thinking at pay it's a centralized Central Bank digital currency you know but in reality it's used in a very distributed way across a wider Marketplace and I think and that market doesn't have to be a physical one it could be a virtual one or a digital one and I think U it it creates more opportunities to use it in these that type of digital sort of uh digital a digital exchange of value exchange of assets exchange of of uh of services or whatever for money
and uh I think the important thing is that it's who is the backer of that the currency that has been issued is you know as opposed to a cryptocurrency or some stable coin or you know this is something that has U the backing of an entire country of a Nation um you know there a unit of account as a store of value it has uh you know that is something that is well understood in a Market in a geography and even internationally as well as opposed to something that may not have that as well I that was about to be my next follow-up comment is you've talked about having these different currencies kind of all working in in parallel that they're not just going cbdcs aren't going to replace cryptocurrencies they aren't going to replace stable coins you imagine there's a a market for all of them and I agree with that I think you know we need resilience and resilience means options right if everyone's using one cc what happens if that goes down
I really agree with that principle and you kind of said that one of the main differences there is issuance and who's backing something I mean most of our listeners you know the web 3 kind of listeners know about crypto right that's what brings most people to the space in your mind John is what are the main differences between crypto and CBC is it just the issuance and just the backing or is there more than that I think um I mean the fundamental one is the backing like who is the issuer who is the who do you go to uh basically to um you know to claim this value and the the issuer behind it right so and I think U that's a very important point because also from an accounting point of view I want to know that you know I'm being paid a certain amount of money for my salary or my payments and things like that and it's denominated in a certain currency and so on there's no fluctuation associated with it you
can argue a lot of things around that but but fundamentally it's the issuer that that that is behind it the technology as well right obviously is going to be is going to be different it's not the same same type of Technology at the end of the day but it's not the same same one uh there's an element of resilience behind it you know if you have outages you know and and the availability the Integrity of it and so on um acceptance of the currency you know I think at the end if it's a uh central banks are going through a tremendous amount of effort to make sure that the legal the legislations the laws the regulations and everything that go around sort of the issuance of cbdcs makes them legally valid to be used in all types of transactions right at the end of the day so everyone should be able to accept them you know from a merchant to a cab driver to a whatever right government or whatever so so the acceptance of
the of the currency itself um so even though it's digital in nature it should be accepted widely in the marketplace um as a form of payment right at the end of the day so that's not the case with the crypto because you know people you know speculate a lot with crypto they don't necessarily use it for transactions all the time um some people do some people don't some people accept it some won't you know so you end up with this there's a you Myriad of different um you know usage scenarios for crypto right and I think uh not to say that it that that there is a role in a place it and I think there's to your point out I think you you you mentioned and I I firmly believe that there's a rule for all the stuff at the end of the day from crypto to stable coins to so so to cbdcs and so on it's almost like a tapestry of different formats of money right at the end of the day
um and they serve different purposes they serve different different you know they do different things and they serve different purposes they're backed by different sort of uh backers behind it um and I think it's up to us to figure out what's the most appropriate for the things that we're trying to use it for yeah I I think so I I understood that early on with cbdc versus crypto and then someone said to me okay why would I choose um a stable coin over a cbdc the similar kind of PR principles you know centrally backed someone's actually kind of it holds responsibility there but surely I trust a central bank over a private company so what's the the argument there then between the two it's a very yeah and very good point I think uh I mean especially when you end up with commercial banks that are issuing these things um I think U the interesting Dimension is that a Commercial Bank may you know issue a stable coin that has a very broad Geographic reach
so take a very big bank for instance that has you know presence in single country or many countries around the world you now have the ability to move that money across this institution if you're a commercial entity if you're a big corporate or whatever you can move money from one jurisdiction to the next one to the next one instantaneously and make treasury payments and make all sorts of payroll payments and pay your suppliers and do all that kind of stuff and you're dealing with a Commercial Bank liability not a central bank liability right some commercial banks are very big um you know very very solid and D with the the credit rating and all that kind of stuff so they almost almost but not quite are as you know strong as a central bank digital currency uh because they're not a country they're not a sovereign but they have a geographic Dimension to them that is much that is more uh International or more uh geographically dispersed than one single Central Bank in one particular
country or jurisdiction so I think that dimension of it actually opens up a lot of opportunities and I think big players big commercial banks are looking at issuing or have been issuing their own and have been transacting you know allowing their customers to use their uh basically their tokenized balance sheet they take their balance sheet and they say we're going to issue you on based on our balance sheet a bunch of tokens and you can use these uh denominated in dollars and EUR denominated in a currency but you can use them to do all sorts of payments across our entire sort of network of of entities and I think that again it creates almost again that that tapestry right so it's it's it's it's a Commercial Bank liability uh tokenize Commercial Bank liability that is used across Geographic boundaries to serve commercial needs uh very different than crypto again very different than a cbdc different type of usage scenario for that so I saw that there was lots of fear and lots of say private
banks that were kind of resisting cbdcs right because what's the term they use disintermediation which I think is such a difficult word to say but that's the term that's used and I saw that there was a lot of resistance to the digital pound specifically and the the bank of England recognized this right they were like okay well we're going to ensure that the digital pound isn't interest bearing so you put it in the bank you don't get any money from that so that's one way to kind of limit the fear from private banks that everyone's going to move into this digital pound I's see you shaking your head the other one was they're going to put caps on it so you can only hold so much and did those two things address in your mind enough that private Banks can feel safe that not everyone's going to jump into digital pound as soon as it becomes available I think um I I think it it's sort of uh it's an interesting scenario it's an interesting
sort of uh concern that commercial banks have and I think the the reason for it is of course that that sort of the services that they're providing um you know for especially for just basically transaction banking um comes out you know there's a cost associated with it consumers bearing that cost as well as the banks as well that that are providing these services but they're not but it doesn't cbdc when issue doesn't do a lot of things that that a commercial bank will do it doesn't provide lending it doesn't provide the relationship man insurance doesn't provide any of the things that a Commercial Bank uh when when uh sort of offering services to clients uh does mortgages credit you know credit cards uh loans uh Insurance U the portfolio of services investment and all this other stuff so to think that everyone will sort of take all their money out of their bank and hold it in their cbdc wallet is a bit of a stretch I think I think at the end of the
day and and and if you even if you did it how long would you do it for would you would you take it out knowing that you can take it out and then would you can do it put it back the next day or something like that so usually that you know this it's it's it's sort of a it's a concern of course that people that the banks do have uh but they have it more in times of financial distress than they do in a normal day-to-day operation of things because again when you have a banking relationship it's more of a relationship you're doing things with your money it's not just it's not just you know using it in the form of just to make payments to hold in digital W so uh I think it's the it's the financial distress part of it when a bank is in financial distress and then everybody panics right well what causes the Panic the Panic is caused by the fact that you cannot take enough money out
of an ATM machine or out of a teller to cover the deposits right because of course there isn't enough money that's you know that's fractional Reserve Bank banking so of course you're going to have a problem uh when that happens uh and limiting sort of it on a cbdc is just going to further create the Panic the the way to solve that problem is actually to is to is to have back stop measures with a central bank the bank of England or other other Banks central banks that basically can digitally issue that money immediately to consumers in times of financial distress so if I have let's say 20,000 you know pounds in my account and all of a sudden I hear that that sort of this bank is under distress I I can't I can't get enough money out of an ATM machine right because everyone would be doing the same uh but if there was enough money in the ATM machine the digital ATM machine right I could get it all out and what
would I do with the next day I probably go back and put it back into the account so it's like as long as I can get it out right I think and feel that level of comfort so um the physical limitation of bank note of the bank note distribution cost causes the panic in many cases the ability for uh central banks to step in and digitally support the Commercial Bank is a is a way to actually address that and as acts as a back stop measure for for run on Banks and things like that so I'm not sure the limit the limit on the wallet actually will do anything uh apart from maybe even cause more distress I'm I'm really glad you mentioned kind of the failure cases and the worst case that can happen kind of when you have a run on the banks type scenario and the impact on consumers and the need to protect consumers because obviously that's also what the role of Regulation is right and it's not something we like
to shy away from on the show we very much Pro regulation and I I have no idea what regulation means in the context of cudc so can you just give us a a comment on that right so I'm kind of wondering do we have the existing regulatory tools to to handle a map to cbdc world or do we need completely new Frameworks to handle them what's the kind of situation with that it's a broad uh again very jurisdiction specific uh I think the uh understanding of of uh whether the existing Central Bank uh Charter or uh act in many cases covers the the distribution of money in digital format or not uh is can be as simple as a you know one statement in a in in a legislation or a very complex uh series of changes actually to the the legislation so it really depends jurisdiction by jurisdiction and has it requires proper legal analysis and stuff like that in order to be able to make these kind of changes as well um however
um I think that none of that is you know insurmountable at the end it's just you know different um it's how you look at um the the the charter of the central banks and how they've been able how they're able to actually issue a digital currency and the kind of Regulation that needs to go around that and I think um uh I mean we have a lot of stuff through you know electronic money you know electronic money regulation and other types of you know regulations that already exist today um this is an extension of many of that um I mean not to simplify it but you know there are a lot of things that we already know how to deal with a lot of these different things the the the challenge here is that central banks have never really had to look at digital money for the you know for for The Wider Market usage they've always looked at it from a bank note printing very physical very very Legacy very traditional way of dealing
with money and money Printing and that has things around velocity of money movement how you know Bank notes are put into circulation how they're distributed how they're recovered and things like that and and then we all of a sudden say okay well that that's great for very traditional paper based means you know you're not going into a digital format you know how do you deal with velocity of money movement there how do you deal with anti-money know anti-money laundering regulation there how do you deal with kyc stuff does it still apply do you enable visitors to transact in central bank money right well if you if you're a u if you're a tourist that steps off a plane and you try to go withdraw money from the bank machine and there's no Bank notes anymore because no one's using that well what are they going to do how do they going to make payments right and how do they so what do you deal with how do you deal with that kind of a scenario
and uh who is allowed to who should who should have access to this money is it is it citizens is it residents is it foreigners is it visitors is it you know that kind of stuff so those are the kind of things that you need to think about a lot from a central bank point of view and I think that that creates a interesting sort of set of uh of uh you know constraints parameters as well to to the regulation and the legislation that needs to be featured into that I think at the end also that if you can you can create a number of very um uh Advanced tools that you introduce into the market and all of a sudden you find that those can those could be things that compete with incumbents that are there um it comes back to the question of what is a bank at the end right so if I'm a payment service provider I mean take a look at you know all the different you know fintex and
the Neo banks that are popped up at the end of the day they're challenging many of the com ma major sort of commercial Banks now imagine enabling them with cbdc or even new ones new entrance into the market with cbdc type capabilities the concept of what is a bank changes actually if and is it a you know and and and you you know you now have new tools that you can use to sort of enable these kind of new entrance into the market I love that it's um it's taken us an hour and we've come full circle and the question we've got to is what is a bank it just shows how complicated this topic is sometimes right um yeah so regulation very in the weeds very uh kind of detail focused now to flip from that and go big picture you've obviously been in the space for a long time I think the stat that gets pulled out is 85% of central banks are considering cbdcs and have various projects at various stages what
does it look like to you what is the future kind of end goal of cbdcs and particularly how do you think it's going to relate and intersect with other emerging Technologies like to use all the buzzwords AI blockchain metaverse all this kind of stuff how does the future Utopia of CBC look like in John's world yeah I mean I think uh the success or failure I mean I think of all these implementations is how pervasive they become uh and how invisible they become right at the end of the day I I've been in sort of the Technology field for many years and I think we talked a lot about you know certain types of Technologies many years ago uh and it's and and and then all of a sudden we stop talking about it because it's it was absolutely everywhere right and I think um I think this is going to be one of those things I think we will at some point you know I don't know when it's going to be but it'll
be a point where this topic will no longer be uh on the main on podcasts and things like that it'll be it'll be a mainstream topic no one will you know no one will care that much about it anymore because it'll be everywhere right at the end and then we'll have other types of things to talk about right um and I um it's almost like a race um I think there's a few things I think on this topic that I find is intriguing one is the the geopolitical nature of it and what is money and what does it mean right for governments for economies for for um for for many countries around the world for every country around the world but for some it needs even more because they become the rest of the world is riant on them um so so I think that for uh I think the success of this uh of this topic is really how visible it becomes in in five years time or whatever right five 10 years time
whenever whenever that gets you know becomes much more mainstream and and deployed I I think um it's a almost like a the genie out of the bottle we've now we're now sort of seeing these implementations and these roll outs and there's a lot a lot um a lot of investment that's going into it because it's solving a certain set of problems that we can now solve that we've never been able to solve before and I think it's actually very interesting uh for for the Market governments central banks economies and so on um taking it back I think to sort of you know web3 AI you know all these different sort of uh um sort of new paradigms of of interacting and and dealing um and and exchanging ideas values Services products uh entertainment and all these different things this could be the the money that goes into this as well right so at the end of the day rather than dealing with tokens of whatever nature you dealing with the money directly and I and
I and I know that it's sort of um you know this is just another this is a medium of exchange of value at the end and you now have these digital platforms where you can interact with one another and ideally you need to also have a means of of exchanging this value in order to you know acquire Goods services and all these other and various sort of uh uh you know products and services and and and exchanges that you have with various people on these platforms so I think they will uh cbdcs will play a role in that in the future no doubt like other cryptocurrencies like other stable coins like other type of tokens or whatever it is that you're that you're exchanging in these in these environments um with regards to AI uh I'm I'm not sure yet actually about the AI and how cbdcs and AI sort of come together um but I know that it's um there is obviously convergence there at some point um I think that with metaverse with
sort of environments um you know these things are been designed in a way to sort of um converge with into one another and they will um how that will play out what it will look like I think is still unknown I think it's a a a little bit out bit out there but you know there you can imagine all sorts of different things that you can do with this uh when you start uh exploring the art of the possible well I I definitely resonated me talking about the kind of the end State being how invisible it all is right that being a success metric and we all have our Central Bank digital Plumbing as we often call it uh on this show I think that that will be the metric of of success John it's it's been a real pleasure to have you on the show i' I've learned so much just I've been pretty much just listening to you the whole time we have two very quick closing questions that we like to ask
each guest and see how answers compare over time uh and I think you've already answered the first one really nicely and sucing earlier but I'm going to ask you to do it again so you have a chance to revise if you want to I don't think you need to but I want to ask you first so in one sentence what is web 3 to you um it's it's really sort of an environment where you can exchange value directly between people um that's what it means to me I think when I think about this uh it it it isn't sort of a centralized platform it's a it's basically something that allows us to engage and interact with one another uh without the need of any other intermediary in the middle of it all and I think that's a new something that's possible now uh enabled by cbdc but also you know wider sort of uh The Wider sort of environment that web 3 enables as well sorry that's a bit longer than a sentence but I
think that get point no I 100% agree it's we never get one sentence I'll just I'll just tell you that for now um okay and and the final question I have here then just to close things off is so if you could pick one person they can be with us today or from any time throughout history to sit down and discuss web 3 with who would that be at why um I thought about this actually as well and and uh I think that you know given where we are uh given all the Innovations and the developments that we've been talking about U especially around the digital currency side of things and so on I think our uh someone like Satoshi would be a wonderful you know person that we would be able to talk to if we knew who he was right or she or whoever whoever that person is that I think um I think that would uh be very intriguing to understand whether that was ever part of the plan uh in the
long-term Vision in terms of the plan of introducing Bitcoin into the wider Market um and uh that person had a vision um and again it was a genie out of letting a genie out of a bottle at the end of the day and I think it would be very interesting to understand you know um what Vision they had of The Wider impact that they would have not only on the money side not only on the but in the terms of The Wider ecosystem that this would develop around that um it would be intriguing to have that conversation with them U whoever that is I think that's a good one I think that might be the fourth time we've heard that answer I did expect every single guest to say she but yeah it's it's the fourth one so the most popular answer so far and definitely a good one I mean thank you for joining us John this has been a really great episode and thank you to those listening wherever you may be and
join us next time as we untangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto