Episode 24

CBDCs with John Velissarios (part 1)

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this week's episode hosts Alec Burns and Jack Davies are joined by John Velissarios, a seasoned expert in digital finance, to unpack the potential of CBDCs (central bank digital currencies).

John reflects on his journey from software development to becoming a specialist in cryptography and information security. He outlines CBDCs as innovative central bank-issued money designed for everyday transactions and international payments.

John argues that CBDCs can fill critical voids in the current financial system, aiding those without bank accounts and streamlining social benefits delivery. He also notes their power to transform international payments by bypassing middlemen for quicker, direct transfers. The conversation delves into the technical and sovereignty issues surrounding CBDCs, the significance of their interoperability, and the unique advantages they bring to cross-border payments without requiring intermediaries.

The episode also addresses the risks and challenges of CBDCs, such as privacy and financial control, while considering how they might reshape global economic influence, citing China’s Belt and Road initiative. It concludes with insights into central bank strategies like those of the Bank of England, signaling a thoughtful approach to introducing CBDCs. As always, Alec and Jack aim to clarify these complex topics, leaving listeners better informed and eagerly anticipating more web three insights.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

there is a there's a gap in the market for a a different format of money that doesn't exist yet which is obviously the cbdc where cbdc comes in um that isn't a Commercial Bank liability isn't isn't something that I that I have to you know use my my credit card or my bank account or my debit card or my you know making a transfer from my account to your account because at the end of the day so we have to we have to interact with these other intermediaries uh in order to transfer money welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today we're delighted to have John vasaros a distinguished Authority in the digital Financial realm John has a 25-year tenure in it and financial services he also served as a managing director at a centure for digital assets custody and Central Bank digital currencies John has advised multiple governments spoke at some of the largest events in the world and has an extensive portfolio of Publications and patents welcome to the podcast

John thank you great to be here thank you very much yeah thanks for joining us John I'm really excited to have you on we wanted to tackle this topic of cbdc and Central Bank digital currencies for a long time now and it was one we were tensive about because we wanted to have an expert with us to to kind of guide us hold our hand through it because it's a there's a lot to talk about how are you today John the first and foremost though very good thank you very good awesome so let's kick things off I know you've got a very storied career and history as Alec indicated there but can you just give us a very brief background about your early career well early on I guess uh before I got into the whole uh cbdc topic uh I actually worked in uh software development uh many years ago uh so even before the 25 year sort of career in technology and financial services I actually worked in software development in the Aerospace

industry um where I was involved in a lot of mission critical systems um and working in the um again in Aerospace um and then and then decided to make a jump into sort of a career in Consulting uh where I started working for a big consulting firm um in London and uh moved over from Canada originally um and started working in the whole information security space and I have background in cryptography and Technology of course and software development um and I got I got involved in this whole whole Space of financial services through my cryptography and information security background awesome yeah I I detected a slight Canadian twinge there so I'm glad I was right um and and it sounds like you've got the kind of career that would suit you very well obviously to to working in cbdc world but was there anything in particular that led you into into this space into digital assets cbdc and now I guess what we're calling web 3 in in a broader sense was there what was

the pathway from what you were doing early on in your career to that to now yeah I mean I got involved in I guess in the whole uh crypto uh cryptography not necessarily crypto as a currency but cryptography space and information security and that that sort of brought me into the whole financial services payment space uh I spent quite a lot of time working with big Banks um Financial Market infrastructure players and and a variety of different sort of uh organizations that are heavily involved in financial services uh and doing a lot of information security work in that space so anything from crypto key management and all the way through to risk management around those systems and that's how I sort of got into it um and and then I I took a career break halfway through that time and I ended up joining a Bitcoin wallet company uh that was about um over a decade ago and um that sort of uh took a year off from from my Consulting life uh where I

was doing information security stuff beforehand and and took a role in in this Bitcoin wallet company and uh spent a year and a bit um sort of uh working with that organization to try to commercialize more of the offerings that they had and things like that I uh I came I went back to Accenture actually uh at that point um and uh I quickly realized um and I also had a one of our very first uh blockchain uh projects uh which was with a central bank and I uh ended up sort of spending another year delivering that project with a team and uh that that meant I was sort of uh I had a almost a break in my sort of information security career by sort of taking that year off working in this crypto uh wallet company uh you know another year working on a central bank project in the whole digital currency space and that was sort of a very natural sort of uh pivot point for me because at that point I

then never looked back I actually said this is this is what I want to do I want to look at I want to look at look at uh how we develop um digital currency digital assets uh even crypto custody as well and this whole topic and it was actually a very natural place for me because of my information security background and knowing how critical a lot of that stuff was um you know understanding cryptography understanding the mathematics behind it and also the the Practical security implications of of uh of handling a lot of these type of new Innovative Technologies and stuff like that and uh given also the the financial services background it was just a natural fit for me and I ended up spending the rest Ranger of my time working in Consulting in that space and then obviously at the beginning of this year I I'd left and started up my own thing as well so yeah it seems like a a fairly natural character Arc right you had the technical background working

in cryptography then you moved to financial services but then you also developed the consult skills the ability to actually communicate all the advantages these Technologies to you know ministers central banks these people's that making the decisions so I'm going to put you on the spot here uh rather than calling them Central Bank digital currencies we'll save a lot of time by calling them cbdcs what is a cbdc cbdc is basically a digital currency a third format of of uh central bank money I mean for those that you know obviously for for those that just to be very clear central banks sort of have two formats of money right there's Bank notes and circulation things that you and I probably use much less uh these days but in some places it's still very very uh you know actively used and uh and digital money held by central banks in a digital register um so there those are two forms but that the the latter uh is basically more tailored towards commercial Banks uh who hold their

reserves with the central bank and so it's digital in nature of course but it's not uh it's not meant for for consumers and and the general public to use so cbdcs actually converge um for lack of a better description is a there's a convergence of both of those it's a digital format of a central bank liability like a bank note but meant for wider uh wider use so uh there's retail users for it uh so you and I can use it to buy things with uh cbdc there's wholesale uses of it which is more um for commercial Banks other types of uh of large scale payments even commercial entities and so on and I I want to also maybe make an adjustment here because a lot of a lot of us sort of uh the common terminology in the last few years has been retail and wholesale but in reality um if you take a look at that it's really more of a general purpose uh digital currency because it doesn't doesn't even if you

put it into circulation for consumers to use there's nothing stopping a commercial Comm entity from using that as well there may be different limits there may be different um interfaces and things like that that you may you may have with regards to the usage of it but a general purpose cbdc uh is something that could be used across the board for both retail wholesale commercial applications and so on and I think it's it's important to sort of uh make this distinction now because we we sort of are guilty of having you know created maybe a too simplistic language around retail and wholesale but that's a that's maybe a top for another discussion that's really interesting because I I've read upon these things and I'd never considered that before I always thought in the mindset of you have retail cbdc which is for general public you digital cash like you said used for daily transactions then wholesale which is for big Financial institutes large interbank stuff not for the general public you're so right like what

is stopping uh someone using a retail cbdc if they're a commercial entity that is really interesting first big learning curve for me so that's a little bit on the what and the distinction there okay why do we need cbdc this is really interesting one with the hype around crypto and all this kind of stuff why do we need a cbdc I think um and this is also a a sort of a a timing thing I think if you take a look at the Innovation that's happened over the last uh couple of years uh blockchain uh technology uh if you take a look at web three if you take a look at sort of the digitization of money um you know online services and things like that there is a there's a gap in the market for a a different format of money that doesn't exist yet which is obviously the cbdc where cbdc comes in um that isn't a Commercial Bank liability isn't isn't something that I I have to you know use my my

credit card or my bank account or my debit card or my you know making a transfer from my account to your account because at the end of the day so we have to we have to interact with these other intermediaries uh in order to to transfer our money and and here a cbdc is a is a is something that I own it's basically my own it's like a bank note right and and I have the ability to transfer it to you in a digital manner uh and it's final and it's uh and it's something that then you can also give me sort of change if or or or Goods or or other types of things back uh as well digital digital goods and things like that and I think this is where we have a a a new sort of Paradigm of engaging with other that that wasn't possible before especially when you're dealing with payments over long distances payments across borders payments uh where people don't have a bank account perhaps and I think

this is also a very important uh Dimension that that is also looked at if you have if you take a look at um there's there are large segments of the population that are unbanked um and and depending on countries of course and so on and there's certain functionality that you can enable with the cbdc that allows people to transact with each other uh without even needing a bank account in order to do that or credit cards or anything like that you can just basically do it like you're sending an email I can send you money you're sending emails and it's it's a it's something that is final you you receive it um you do something with it you spend it you bank it you do whatever you you want to do with it um and I think it creates a new Ab a new ability for us to transact with one another that wasn't possible before and it the timing of it will be as a result of sort of the Technology Innovation which I

think is matured enough to the point now where you've seen a lot of cbdc projects sort of tip into from Pilot to production and so on you'll see more of those uh but it's addressing a need in the market and and um that that is unfilled and I think there's there are a number of very specific applications of cbdcs that I think are very um are very interesting um you could argue the retail case um whether you whether the retail consum consumers need that or not and there's a lot of discussions and debates about that and that is very jurisdiction specific um in highly banked highly technologically advanced or you know Western countries where everyone has a kajillion sort of bank accounts and you know credit cards and payment methods Apple pay Google pay and all these things it may not serve that much of a useful purpose for those individuals um whereas in other markets where you know they don't have a bank account at all for instance and they and the government wants

to distribute uh social aid social benefits to them in a very uh frictionless manner that doesn't require intermediaries to distribute money and of course with intermediaries comes cost comes friction comes uh other sort of uh challenges as well uh and I think that's a you know this is a definitely a more um inclusive way of Distributing social Aid to to sort of consumers that can use it for paying for goods and services and we've seen that in in several projects I can talk more about that as well but there are other applications of of cbdc that I think are probably even more powerful uh and I think this is where the Innovation will take us I think very quickly I think uh because it's a space where there's a tremendous amount of friction and cost um uh and and that's in sort of the crossborder side of things whether it's consumers you know sending money home uh remittance payments or whether it's or or whether it's you know medium-size payments or even large value payments

there is a a high degree of friction because of the number of intermediaries involved today um and if you may know of course that when you send money abroad you're not actually sending the money you're sending a message and some other bank at the other end is is basically debiting and crediting accounts and there's a whole bunch of uh you know uh sort of transactions that take place to to to sort of complete that that transaction but here if I send a cbdc from one person to another in another country they receive it instantly and it's theirs and they have it and they can spend it and I think it's a different type of uh it it changes the I guess the geography of money right at the end of the the way money is used across these different Geographic boundaries so I think there are retail cases where consumers are using it to transact in very um I guess in in very uh different ways than they're doing today with other forms of digital

payments uh or Bank notes or you know access to government money and things like that um and there are also sort of in those scenarios there are also some some uh extreme cases where you have distressed scenarios like times of of economic distress or times of uh National emergencies and so on uh you know what do you do how do you get money to people how can they pay for things how do they you know how how do they transact uh when they can't you know can't use their bank account for instance or you know or their credit card or whatever um so those are those are some of the you know things to consider as well U from a reachup point of view uh from a commercial payment point of view as well there's a high cost high high cost associated with payments and uh there's a lot of friction associated with that uh and also I think on the crossborder side where there's a tremendous amount of uh value in using sort of

a cbdc for uh dealing with crossb payments in a more efficient way and I thought it would be a simple answer you know why do we need cbdc when when you say like why do people need crypto they usually use the same Buzz words immutability you know I don't know uh double spends efficiency all this kind of stuff but what you're saying there is it's very complicated and it's very specific to the region right you're saying in the UK maybe inclusivity isn't the biggest problem we have like Good Financial setup Good Financial rails all this kind of stuff but say and in less developed countries inclusivity might be the primary driver behind it and in the UK maybe it's more about supporting some kind of public utility in the digital age like having public services and public money in in the metaverse for example so it's quite a complicated question right yeah it is a complicated and and and it's one that's not only been studied a lot it's one that's been debated a lot

and it is very jurisdiction specific and I can I can give you a couple of examples in you know very advanced economies um uh one of the things that they were looking for is and and where there's a high degree of digital payments already so there's a very very little usage of cash High degree of digital payments everyone has a plethora of of me methods of payment but what they were planning for what the central bank and the government was looking for was what happens when I can't pay for anything like the internet goes down and the electricity goes down what happens then how you know what what what does society do how long can you last is it a you know a day is it a week is it a month what happens then right so and um that's a very scary scenario it doesn't matter which country you're in it's a very scary scenario and um and I think these this is also you know an example I'll give an example of where

that that happened where a grocery chain in one of the Nordic countries went down and there and their payment system went down rather and they had uh a tremendous amount of difficulty because they were uh in in many different Villages and towns and cities across the country but they couldn't take any payment and nobody had any cash so they had a a store full of goods uh they had people that wanted to buy the goods but no way to pay for the goods right there's no so what what does one do like actually and that's just a practical like daily or day-to-day thing today but what happens if it was in a more distressed scenario than you know time of War or conflict or something like that a natural disaster you know then it becomes more difficult and and cbdc would be a much more effective mechanism for making for Distributing funds emergency funds to people and then they'll be able to use them over you know to make payments and things like that as

well yeah that's that's f fasinating because I think one of the examples that Springs to mind would be the the stimulus checks in America during during covid-19 you know and and obviously there were lots of fraud around around that and people claiming for them especially in the UK as well so I think there are these as you say these use cases even in the more developed economies where it's not just purely about payments and remittances that that can motivate this there's actually so many little threads I want to pull on from what you said already but one thing that really caught my eye is that you said about the technology maturity being there and when I think of cbdc you know this is untangling web 3 we tend to think of blockchain right as the technology infrastructure for cbdcs but so my question is is that what you're referring to when you say the technolog is matured does does cbdc require blockchain to work I'm I'm intrigued by that question it doesn't necessarily require it

to work and I think it's it's an important point to make because um you know we sort of we sort of veered into this because we we've said um that blockchain technology is the most uh effective tool to use in order to solve the set of problems but um I think there's a bit of a you know I think a maybe a misunderstanding there because there are a lot of ways that you could still Implement cbdcs even without blockchain technology itself there are mechanisms by which you can do this and and a couple of cases you know a couple of examples that we've had you know a cbdc implementation many years ago that didn't have uh blockchain technology with it had strong cryptography it had secure methods of communicating value from one sort of uh card to another or one person to another and stuff like that uh it didn't use blockchain technology in order to do that it is however um a blockchain is sort of a a very effective mechanism because of of

uh you know the solving for double spend problems and you know um you know the things that you described before um and uh at the end of the day um you know there are effective mechanisms by you know that that many of the implementations of cbdcs have been implemented in in blockchain technology but it doesn't necessarily need to be just to be very clear about that it is a function of what you know it is a function of what kind of capabilities you're looking for specifically in the implementation and again uh every single one of these projects or implementations or or you know uh jurisdictions is very different they're all trying to solve for slightly different set of problems and so for some of them you know it may not require blockchain at all for other ones it might might require because it's the most effective mechanism effective means of of implementing what they're for yeah I mean that it kind of links back to the why right and the why is very dependent on

the region and that will obviously affect the implementation and it really thing that I kind of picked up there was on the blockchain side is I imagine central banks that obviously they want sovereignty how does the whole sovereignty piece which is one of the considerations fit in with say the public blockchain agenda like I can't imagine say some sovereign states wanting to have a cbdc that's based on a public blockchain with you know Network administrators which are effectively miners based in other countries it's uh that is also very uh widely uh debated topic as well I think it's a very good one because I think um sovereignty the sovereignty play is a very important play um clearly because you're talking about a country you're talking about it's uh it's money at the end of the day and uh and that has tremendous amount of impact on uh Financial fiscal monetary policy and everything else and so be the ability to be in control of that I think is absolutely key for any any Sovereign uh

any Sovereign uh country that that's that's uh and the money that they issue to to their society um and I think that if you look at the various uh I guess projects and things like that it's very difficult to see how uh a public uh version of of uh of any Ledger that could be used for specifically for enabling a sovereign entity to be able to issue its money on top of that that sort of public Ledger having said all that um this is still you know there's still room to explore I think and I think this is there there's a there is potentially an overlap with regards to what role does what does what do public ledgers and assets and currencies and everything else that that's gets built around all these things interface with and interact with uh a sovereign cbdc that's implemented um so I wouldn't I wouldn't sort of uh you know I I wouldn't want to be the one saying this because at the end you know it's hard to predict

the future but it but we may at some point see something like that on the public Ledger um something Implement like that on the public Ledger uh because there's a lot of benefit for having it um uh sort of rolled out in such a way but I think at at present it's it's just too much of a of a leap for many central banks to be jumping into and saying we want to implement our CBBC on on a public Ledger um it's the same sort of debate you I guess you would you would have with regards to cloud computing and servers in a server room at the end of the day right so um many many organizations that are running critical National infrastructure will say we want all of the stuff in full control of it and so on but over time as you saw you know as we see sort of many of these uh different Cloud providers and the the resilience of their their networks and stuff like that um people have relaxed

a little bit more a lot more on on on that front and and and it's not impossible to see some sort of point in the future where cbcs may be implemented on public ledgers but for the moment it's a sovereign play it's a very strong uh story uh and and it's still very early days so I I think it they'll be very nervous to implement these on on public ledes it makes sense right that there's a big risk AV verion there but one thing I picked up on which is really interesting not thought about before is the idea of how cbdcs work in you know the whole world of digital assets that is obviously now going to be hitting the mainstream over the next five to 10 years and that really brings in to the the idea of interoperability not just between different currencies but also between other assets and I mean public blockchains probably do have an advantage there everyone can kind of link and Trust the data with having to be in a

permissioned way so I do assume that might be a sell down the road once they've kind of you know built on maybe a web 2.5 kind of version potentially or whatever we call it yeah digital lense I mean I think are at least from the wholesale and Commercial you know security settlement perspective this is also an area where cbdcs can play a very do play a very strong role uh because of the fact that if you had to have digital assets on on an exchange well how are you going to settle those assets at the end of the day you g to use some form of traditional payment rail well that's okay but you you're gonna basically rely on on settlement in a different medium and I think the reason why that's that's not um appropriate is because of the the nature of the type of transaction so I'm sell I'm giving you an asset and an exchange I want an immediate settlement for that asset uh in the form of digital money and I

can combine that in a transaction which is atomic uh either complete or fail uh I can automate that I can put smart contracts around that I can do various things with it that make uh these transactions um much more uh effective when you're using digital assets and digital cbdcs basically in order to do the settlement side of it not to say that you need to do immediate settlement because that's also another open uh point of debate it's just that when you do the settlement you actually want uh the the the money aspect of it to be sort of in in the same format so so that you can so that you can um complete that transaction in a more effective way um and I think this is where cbdcs come into the digital asset space build digital exchanges or digital financial markets um in a much more um uh in a much more effective uh than than if you had just just one of those Dimensions addressed it's great to have digital assets but how

do you settle them and you know use cbdcs is a very effective way through that I think I'm I'm trying to crystallize in my mind because there's a few different pieces that are coming together now but I'm still wondering on this interoperability piece that you mentioned and I'm sure one question our listeners will have is around okay we said one of the big benefits of this is kind of crossborder payments maybe for remittances or something my question is do you need a cbdc to be set up in both the origin country and the re receiving country so say I'm you know I'm from the UK but I want to go live and work in Europe despite brexit Let's ignore that for a second and say I go and live and work in Europe and I want to send funds back home do I need in the cbdc model to have the UK and the EU both using cbdc that talk to each other or is there is there a way this can work kind of

unilaterally in your mind uh less effectively yes you can uh but you're also then dealing with uh something that is instantaneous it's so let me let me sort of put it in a in in a slightly different way if I hand you a bank note and you hand me and I you right uh that's not right at the end of the so if I'm if I'm doing these kind of transfers I want something of equal uh in of equal value not only in terms of the unit of account in terms of the value in terms of the uh what you're giving me but also in the fact that it's immediate it's final it's you know there's no way to dispute it and things like that so I think um we see a tremendous amount of uh of interest on the whole crossborder side and the reason for it is uh traditionally we've been using um you very you know a network of correspondent Banks we've been using mechanisms like Swift to do the messaging back

and forth to say I want to transfer funds from you know here to there uh and correspondent Banks to sort of Route the money around and so on and not only that but but it's also been done in in in a very limited number of currencies or currency pairs so when you get exotic currencies right into the mix they usually triangulate through dollars or whatever and and the the the challenge is you then get a lot of friction associated with that transaction um and timing and delays and sometimes things get blocked and all these kind of things that happen as a result of that and what we where we see uh a lot of interest is the fact that if I have a cbdc in my country and you have a cbdc in your country and and we agree to transfer to one another this uh for in order to make this this Currency Change there's nobody else that's needed in the mix in the middle of that right so we just basically agree a

we agree a price um and we you know there maybe some Market data that we can we can use in order to do that we agree on price and exchange rate and and there is an immediate transfer value and this is where I send you the money only when you send me the money and because it's because it's uh a digital a cbdc um and its Atomic uh swap can happen in a very effective uh manner without uh risk associated with the counterparties in the middle of that so when we talk about you know why do this in the first place what we're trying to eliminate uh is really it's not necessarily the speed because things um can be you know quick these days faster payments is pretty instantaneous I mean it's not the speed dimmension of it um it it is the fact that you have counterparties in the middle of it and depending on the leg that you're transacting or the currency or the you know and and I think that's where it

becomes much more um of a challenge and where cbdcs uh especially when you have multiple countries um looking and implementing and creating an exchange around those then it becomes much more effective way of trans transfer value there are several projects that have happened um I think I just want to make a couple of points first one is um central bank money has traditionally never left the I guess the jurisdiction of the of the country in which issued it apart from Bank notes right so Bank notes Bank notes can move freely and sometimes they Capital controls but fundamentally they they they can move but digital central bank money has never been able to leave the sort of the jurisdiction that in which it's been issued and now with cbdcs you have the ability to do that there are a couple of projects the first you know first one of its kind is something I was involved in was called project Juro where you had uh the bank of France uh issue a digital Euro and it

was used in the security settlement in Switzerland and vice versa in that transaction and that was a liability of the central bank so it was the counterparty risk is zero um and you you can use it to to do the settlement of his Securities trade in another jurisdiction now fast forward that a little bit um projects like embridge uh also did the same thing and they used four different currencies from four different central banks and they allowed sort of 20 commercial Banks to move money across these four jurisdictions without ever touching the dollar right it was Central Bank of UAE it was the People's Bank of China it was um uh Bank of Thailand and Hong Kong monetary Authority so all these uh and and all these sort of transactions were happening it was a payment versus payment in their local currencies but they never left uh they they basically never touched any other currency in in that in that uh in the exchange that was taking place and the money moved from jurisdiction to

jurisdiction now if you fast forward that even further imagine a scenario where you have free flowing or flowing sort of Central Bank D across multiple geographies um in a more efficient way and you creating a very different type of U you know ecosystem basically on the back of that that is I mean that's really interesting and I'm glad we're kind of get into some project specifics I Know Jack wants to talk about the digital pound at some point or the proposal for the digital pound something that has kind of come to mind uh for me that I was reading an article about the um the digital Yuan and when you're talking about crossb settlements and then we were also talking about sovereignty earlier it was the digital un being used in Africa and obviously it creates it's a really efficient mechanism for a lot of people in Africa right now to actually use the Central Bank digital currency is based in China but this creates a sovereignty Dynamic right for African governments that now no

longer have you know Financial control over assets in in their regions what does that mean I mean you have this in in uh in many Mark in many countries around the world you have dollarization where the dollar is a predominant currency regardless of what is you know has been issued by the local C Bank you have euroization same sort of concept uh as well where the euro is used predominantly for for transactions rather than local currencies and so on and now I I guess through the digital run uh that you will end up with a you know U onization or mization of the of the of the market price and I think that'll end I mean this these will all play out right think at the end um and it become I guess it's the the function of the utility uh how you can use that that money in the local market and and I think the interesting thing is it's not far it's not a far-fetched sort of idea where you know you have

uh China has sort of invested a tremendous amount in building this belt and Road initiative across the world right from China all the way through to um Central Asia through to Middle East and Africa and Europe and other countries as well so there's a lot of uh there are a lot of jurisdictions that are um part of the belt and Road initiative and and infrastructure so ports and Roads and everything else that's that allows the flow of goods to go back and forth um between these different countries well if you have also major buyers like China who are buying these raw materials from all these different countries how would they pay for it right do they pay for it dollars do they pay for it in local currency do they pay for it in one um and at the end it's it's a you know it's not that far-fetched to think well if I can give you a digital current immediately uh and you can also spend it immediately so you can put it onto

your wallet you can you know link it with your alipay wallet and so on you as a consumer sitting in Africa can make payments uh based on things that you received and it may be more uh and it may be more stable than your local currency so of course you can accept it of course you can want to use it that's where governments begin to lose sort of the sovereignty uh I think and the ability to have more control over their monetary and fiscal policies um and I think that's where uh you know it'll it'll all play out and I think at the end it it means that you know those countries will have to do more to be uh provide you know a level of prudence in their economic Affairs otherwise you'll end up with you know these kind of dollarization you know euroization or onization of economies which you're see in many cases no easy answer to that so speaking of yeah yeah no as with a lot of these I think there's

you're doing a great job of of managing very not easy answers so thank you for for giving us all the detail so kind of as you mentioned sovereignty let's bring it back to the UK as Alex said I'm very interested in obviously the bank of England is currently in the process as most central banks um are in the world of of exploring what cbdc looks like so I I'm not actually completely up to date with what's happening there I'm sure you are maybe can can tell us a little bit about it because I know lots of people are talking about it kind of uh in general in the public there are definitely people who are talking about it from a conern of privacy potentially and worried about you know what the bank of England might be able to to monitor VI via what they build so maybe if you're if you're up to date with this much more than we are can you give us an overview of where the bank of England is and

kind of what what road map there might be in in the UK for for a cbdc sure I mean I think I want to touch upon the Privacy topic because I think it's a big topic on its own um and um again you know not an easy one but I think with one of the the challenges I think that we all have in discussing these topics is that people are concerned about and sometimes we're very rightfully concerned about you know things that that may happen right at the end it doesn't mean that it will happen it just means that it may happen with you end with when you end up with solutions that are uh rolled out U that have uh a very um that have things that of concern of for consumers um privacy is a very big topic um and in and in many markets it varies widely in terms of the degree of concern from the general public in some markets it's not a concern at all in other markets is absolutely

the most important thing and um and and I think it has a lot to do with trust and faith in government it all has a lot to do with perhaps the you know the um geopolitical the sort of uh context in which countries are operating in um degree of surveillance of government um things like that so I think it has a lot uh there's a lot to consider to unpack there to actually to look at privacy as a topic um but again the the thing is that that a lot of that can be completely controlled and implemented in Sol with solutions that that provide a high a very high degree of privacy for consumers as well so there are there are projects worked on them and are working on them as we speak where users can have a high degree of anonymity with regards to cons purchases that they make so just like buying things like with cash um either you can control how much information you share with a merchant you can control how

much um you you you sort of provide to them as a as a result of the transaction and only in extreme circumstances by uh if values are above a certain amount and and and a number of conditions are met then obviously things are disclosed uh to Regulators if need be right so things situations like that um but I think that that's also a a very important thing to sort of highlight for people to you know Express that concern and to make it a very important topic and then obviously it gets factored into the design and the building of the solutions so not all cbdc solutions are the same as you implement them so you can you know you can have high degree of privacy and anonymity it's more complicated but it's doable or or you know very much uh transparent solution where every transaction can be monitored and so on if the if the Central Bank end or regulator would you know deemed it necessary uh or deemed it desirable rather uh however consumers always

have the option to not use it at all I think so there's a there's a balance between you know you're you're you're providing something that you know people don't want to use and then all of a sudden people don't use it so you know then then it's an immediate feedback loop where you know people just stay away from from certain things so I think it's uh I I think it's a lot of things to consider the thing I think it's important is um you know not all solutions are the same there are a number of them that have um different types of uh privacy sort of B baked into the solutions uh as you roll them out and uh important points that they need to be sort of factored into the design and and of course important that consumers uh Express that concern to to sort of their um to into the into the central bank that that's actually impl there's a lot of consultation papers that are out there's a lot of consultations that

have been taking place uh with regards to sort of The Wider Market including the bank of England that has done a number of those things as well this was the first part of a two-parter on Central Bank digital currencies with John thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes