Episode 78
BlueSky
About this episode
Welcome to the latest episode of the Untangling Web 3 podcast! Today, we're exploring BlueSky, the emerging decentralized social media platform that aims to challenge Twitter (now X) by offering more user control and transparency.
Born from the vision of Jack Dorsey, BlueSky promises a fresh take on social networking, rooted in decentralization and user empowerment. As X grapples with controversies and shifting user sentiment, BlueSky steps in as an alternative that brings innovation back to the forefront of social media.
Key Highlights
- Why Users Are Leaving X (Twitter). we look at the underlying reasons why millions are turning away from X, touching on the growing dissatisfaction with algorithm-driven content that amplifies divisive and sensational material, fostering a less pleasant user experience. These trends have pushed many users to seek platforms that provide a more controlled and positive social space, setting the stage for BlueSky’s rise.
- BlueSky’s Decentralized Foundation. BlueSky stands out due to its use of the Authenticated Transfer Protocol (ATP), which offers a more transparent and flexible user experience. Unlike centralized models like X and Meta's Threads, ATP allows users to manage their data, move seamlessly between servers, and customize their social media algorithms. This decentralized infrastructure empowers users to tailor their feeds and content moderation, giving them more say in how they interact with social media.
- Custom Algorithms and User Empowerment. One of BlueSky's most compelling features is its focus on user customization. Listeners will learn how BlueSky enables people to choose or create custom algorithms to curate their content, moving beyond the opaque, engagement-driven algorithms of centralized platforms. We discuss how this opens doors for a more personal, less contentious user experience where individuals have true autonomy over what appears in their feeds.
As social media evolves, BlueSky presents an exciting and innovative shift toward user-centric design and decentralization. By offering more control, transparency, and data portability, it challenges the status quo set by platforms like Twitter (X).
While questions remain about monetization and scalability, BlueSky’s early traction and vision suggest it could become a strong contender in the decentralized social media space.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
welcome to the untangling web 3 podcast today we're exploring Blue Sky the decentralized social media competitor to X that seems to be grabbing all the headlines so there's a lot of chaos X paid features polarizing figures and a flood of controversies and with that millions of people are looking to alternates blue sky is stepping in and with fresh ideas usually control and a bit of a focus on decentralization today we're going to unpack what the buzz is all about and if Blue Sky really is the next big thing so let's jump into it so Jack what do you know about blue sky yeah well this is something very very interesting and we've kind of talked about some of the concepts on this right in the past a lot of times but now it's hitting a flash point where lots of people are leaving Twitter and droves and actually now they're joining this blue sky and you know when it comes to you know when when even play people like the Bristol Clifton suspension bridge Twitter
account are now leaving Twitter right you know there's something wrong and yeah as you said there's lots of problems with Twitter we can get into that and what I know about blue sky is it's very different web 3 like approach it's not really pushing the web 3 angle but it's taking this kind of protocol heavy open model to social media so yeah super interesting why don't we let's dig into the details yeah I do think it's important to talk about some of the background because that is one of the motivations as to why Blue Sky kind of pitched the way that it has um you mentioned there's a lot of people leaving and you know let's talk about why they're leaving like we're both on X we've been on you know Twitter SLX for a while um it's changed a lot I think in in my opinion like just the high level intro is it just seems a lot more Angry recently like I'm looking at my feeds and if they're a reflection of the
things that I'm into then I'm a much more angry and hateful person than I would like to admit and we've kind of talked about the fact that this is maybe across the board on social media where you know you have these these algorithms these you know machine learning algorithms where you just say Okay optimize engagement get people to be as addicted to the screen as possible and what those algorithms realize is that people really do care about hate and greed they're the things that get attention so that's the content that has been prioritized to our feeds and that's why a lot of you know X right now seems quite angry and maybe it's one of the motivators for Blue Sky potentially yeah for sure I think the opaqueness of the algorithms that drive social media is one of the big problems we've all been having and it's kind of you know we we're a bit like the Frog that's been boiled very slowly on this right because it wasn't always like that back in the
start of Twitter and even Facebook it was this kind of big linear feed of posts right your Facebook wall or your Twitter feed they were kind of just what are people saying it wasn't necessarily this Doom scrolling endless timeline of stuff that the algorithm thinks you need to look at and as you said you know we spoke about this with Annie as well in the mental health episode the stuff being pushed is the stuff that that triggers the animal hate fight or flight response in you a lot of the time so yeah that's one of the big ones is is a that we are being pushed this kind of content and B we don't know that much about you know the algorithms behind it that are doing this right and then coupling that with what's actually happened to Twitter specifically or that the platform formerly known as Twitter X what's happened with that since elot musk took it over and the move towards a kind of you know Free Speech model and then again not
not a problem with free speech whatsoever I think it's a good thing but it's kind of opened the floodgates for more of the more divisive kind of content to be pushed toward towards top of our feeds and the certain you know public figures being back allowed back on there after being banned for violating terms of service and things like that that's also put a lot of people off Twitter generally right yeah like I I kind of agree with you there that a lot of people are kind of upset that say the Donald Trumps and the Andrew takes of the worlder back on there I personally think that is fine like you should have you know freedom of speech but it's the fact that their content because it's divisive because it's quite click baity is the thing that's always at the top of the feed and you know that's just personal choice I think that's one of the problems that's been highlighted here is we don't have personal choice over what the feed is actually prioritizing
and that's a big reason why I'm getting a bit you know dissatisfied with xes I just want to see nice puppies and kittens all day not hate speech and like things about migration all this kind of stuff like that is not what I want to look at when I'm doom scrolling for eight hours a day let me tell you um but there's other things as well I think that you know everyone's kind of hailing Elon Musk is this great uh businessman who's com in and cut like what is it 75% of the workforce or something like that but that you know there has been some issues with that I know a few small businesses that used to plug into twitch and use the data and things like that and they're saying it's difficult to get in contact with anyone these days actually difficult to use like the services maybe have been a bit more restrictive and limited lately but yeah I think overall there's definitely a reason why blue sky is getting a lot of
the headlines right now yeah and actually that's a good point you raised about people you know not just the lurkers which is like 90% of people who are just angry about or annoyed about what they're being presented with but then how you get engagement on the platform has very much changed for the same reasons the other side of that coin as you said a lot of people businesses individuals are constantly having to second guess what this algorithm is going to push and has you know when you work it out then you tend to push things that might be worse things that don't represent uh you know the real you behind it so it's made people a little more a little bit more disingenuous it's made it you know a place where people now click farm and clickbait you know we taught you that word Alec right back at the start of the show people will put things out there knowing this is the kind of thing that the argi is pushing and is it changes
behavior on both sides and I think it's dissatisfied a lot of people on both sides um and you add into that you know what's happened with monetizing Twitter and having this tiered system of a premium being able to use different features at different price levels it's all just become a bit of a a zombie of what it used to be in my opinion so yeah what is Blue Sky then so what's what is the the counter offer that that blue sky has made because obviously this is something that's come from we go into the history right it's come from Jack dorsy originally who is also you know the original founder or co-founder of Twitter so from right back in the Inception of Twitter he had a vision for it it's now no longer that Vision really uh so why did he start Blue Sky yeah so my understanding was he started this while he was still the CEO of Twitter and it was just a research project he wanted to look into the concept of
decentralized social networking and explore like how that could affect you know user control of the data and the content distribution so D Jack dorsy is obviously a big advocate of Bitcoin has been for for a while so it's kind of like a match made in heaven where he understood the value of decentralized finance of Bitcoin and all this kind of stuff and he was also working you know at the Forefront of Twitter and he just kind of married those two ideas and that is well I guess the one liner of Blue Sky it's this decentralized social networking platform and you know I think it's been off the ground theyve been you been involved from 2021 I think but it know to end of 2024 when we're recording this they hit 50 million users that's kind of like a drop in the ocean compared to like the face books of the world which have billions even twitters which is close to a billion but I think that was mostly because they were in this kind of
stealth mode where it was an invite only type of thing where they were just inviting journalists creators Tech enthusiasts just to see what they thought of the platform and you know kind of I guess go from there and now it's started to hit the headlines and you we kind of getting to that stage where it seems like maybe they're hitting Mass adoption or starting to you know getting the outlets everywhere and people are starting to take interest in him yeah exactly you you can't under estimate I think the power of Jack dorsey's DNA running through Blue Sky even though as you said you know he's not been involved directly or not been CEO directly since 2021 you know now it's run by someone called Jay gra she's been running the show since then but it's clearly got his DNA running through it it's got the DNA of early Twitter right what you know when you and I probably first started using it uh in the kind of early 2000s kind of early 2010s it's got
that feel to it right it's very much a Twitter to clone so it's not necessarily feature complete with Twitter it hasn't got all the bells and whistles that you have on Twitter and you know for that reason people might like it also it's a bit it's a bit simpler it brings back that Simplicity but yeah it's also worth mentioning that in the background whilst blue sky has been kind of in stealth mode and development it was I think invite only until around February this year or something like that or definitely this year and now it's no longer invite only it's kind of in full public release mode but in that time you also had the rise of something called madon which is a very similar idea it's this protocol based decentralized social media framework but that didn't have necessarily the the brand behind this that the Jack dorsy brings and the whole Twitter story that he brings right so that I think has only ever peaked at around two two and a half million daily
active users and now it sits around you just under a million and as you said at the minute blue sky as we say this is getting one million new users per day right it's hit about 18 million actually I think just today I saw so yeah it's it's growth is is huge but it's definitely not the first example we've seen of this kind of social media yeah yeah so I obviously in preparation for this jumped on there signed up it was easy and as soon as you're on there it just feels like Twitter like it really does feel like early days Twitter but a bit more kind of I guess cutesy is probably the way I describe it like you know being a to select your feeds a bit more customizable but I suppose the fact is that you know my Twitter account now is deep like S6 seven years or something like that so when I go on there I'm just completely absorbed in everything that's going on in the world whereas this one's
like you know it's a new game you kind of working out where everything is and maybe it doesn't have any of the the previous biases of Twitter so maybe that's a nice thing yeah let's go into some of the tech I think we it's worth starting on the tech side and then we'll go into what that actually means for users because you mentioned masted on there and you know Blue Sky Maston similar kind of angle and they both run on this underlying Tech which is called the authenticated transfer protocol at protocol and the whole point of this is kind of like I guess the piping that connects whatever you want to do on top when we talk about you the the goal of this protocol is design to give users more control and you know make networks work together it's kind of like the Bitcoin I guess of this interoperability layer that we talk about when we want to think about users and what they can do on social media networks so when we think
about you know X or threads you basically have one single company that controls everything it's very Web Two model whereas blue sky and masteron as well they let users shape their own social media experience and they can move you know their data their accounts whatever they want from potential social media networks to another one to another server for example because of this underlying transfer protocol that they're both based on yeah I think that is the key thing to get your head around right and if there's anything you know if you're interested in the technology side of blue sky and how this is all working then the key thing to take away is the fact that we are talking about a protocol underneath so the two key differences one as you mentioned you're going from a single company uh kind of client server model so you have a big company behind it as you said that's serving everything out to us users and it's kind of this big central point of failure but also point of
coordination of everything and then you also have the idea that the data because of that model is very much locked in to the platform so if you wanted to take what you've done you know Twitter and threads very very similar um platforms but you can't exactly Port your whole history profile everything you've ever done your posts from Twitter to threads because they're run by two different companies right X and and Facebook or meta yeah you have to keep up with all these name changes um but that's another key thing this dis portability so the the main concept to get head around is that now this is the social media model where you have protocols open protocols the standards and the specifications are all public and documented so you can understand how it works if you want to you can Implement your own kind of server for this which we'll get into as well and then Blue Sky itself is actually it's just one app built on top of the protocol and that is just the
first of many that we'll see in the future right so this the protocol will kind of stay the same or very static like the internet is and then we'll have these apps built on top of it where you can move the data between them so it's not like it's disconnecting the protocol of how the thing works from the actual social media app like blue sky which is like a single View into the data that's being kind of passed around and and the users that are using this network yeah I think I'm glad you made that distinction there like effectively it's Federated right so users can interact across different servers and still stay connected so that can work internally where you know we have different versions of people running Blue Sky say I don't know European server that runs Blue Sky in a certain way they have gdpr compliance and all this kind of stuff and then American version which is more light touch you could opt into either one of those kind of I guess
rules and reg ations and stuff but still communicate with one another so that's like you know got selections within Blue Sky of exactly how you want to run your day-to-day app but then like you said there you could imagine this going much bigger imagine if threads or meta or something like this plugged in to the ATP protocol then I could start to you know connect across these different Blue Sky apps with me threads and then you know move my account across move my followers across you know send one tweet out and it connects to both so it's like interoperability on the internal which is good because we've got more flexibility we can choose what we want in the day-to-day but also then interoperability on the the external side where we can start to have our accounts working across everything I hate the fact that I have like six different social media accounts each with a different password if I want to do one post across everything it's have to sign into every single one and
do one post for each of them it's it's Bonkers yeah this is definitely in my mind like a future proof way of doing this yeah and it's it's kind of similar you know to a lot of Gamers out there might be familiar with this model where they're playing a game but the experience they're getting is being given to you from a server of your choice right so you can be on a server I I haven't actually played one of these any of these big kind of um multiplayer open world games but you can pick which serve you're in and then you'll be playing with different people or in a different landscape or you know that kind of thing so it's it has been around in gaming for actually quite a while and I would also highlight there's some interesting aspects to how it all works under the hood right so we can just run through a couple so firstly is this personal data server so what as I mentioned the data isn't locked into Blue
Sky it's part of the protocol and part of that protocol is each individual user when they sign up you basically get a handle that's linked to a domain right and currently that domain when by by default when you go to Blue Sky will be a Blue Sky Run domain but you can choose uh your own so connect it to a a domain like a website domain that you own yourself and under that domain then you get this personal data repository and this is similar to again we've talked about Tim burners Lee and his solid uh inrupt project where he's kind of letting people put data in their own little pods um but all the stuff you do on Blue Sky then is structured into funnny enough a Merkel tree right so you can see also a bit of the Bitcoin DNA in here but everything you do is all the post you create all the kind all the content you add is structured into this tree thing that this Merkel tree structure that you can
and you're doing like a PhD in this stuff sorry I don't I don't want to go into all the detail but it's it's just it's very effic tree structure that is all underpinned by your domain so all links back to your your handon domain and there are also some interesting stuff about how the identity works but yeah maybe I I'll stop there before I lose anyone yeah I think we've lost 99% of the people that were listening so should we go into what this actually means in terms of like user features I think one of the big like I say everything is based the foundation of this is this at protocol and that effectively means choice and flexibility where you can take your data and then start to choose the parameters of which you want to operate on that so one of the biggest things which I think is super powerful is the idea of these custom algorithms so right now saying I don't know the the Twitter X's of the world they're quite opaque
and how the algorithm you know prioritizes viral or controversial content to maximize engagement I don't really necessarily want to see that stuff what I want to see is you know cap pictures only or they have this thing it's like my bangers where it like just displays users most popular posts it sounds quite silly but that's the kind of stuff that you know people actually enjoy it doesn't you know polarize people and get you it's not super controversial so a big thing here is that blue sky lets users pick or create their own algorithm for fees so they can you know basically offer unprecedented control over whatever content you want to see and curate I mean that's already a big a big value ad that you don't get on on X right people just choosing the kind of algorithm that they're being exposed to and again just to belabor the point this is blue Sky's Choice as a view into this data that's pinning it so someone else could build a blue sky competitor in a
month's time that gives you a better choice of algorithms or you can have competition on these algorithms that are offered by different views so that's going to be really interesting as well who can design the best algorithms a bit like you have in the AI world people trying to design the best AI models I think that's something we're going to see as well so yeah the custom experience and the customization you know some people will like to over customize they'll like to get into the weeds some people will just want a simple version right like having a simple linear feed of just stuff that's coming in for a small list of Curative followers and they're not getting on their timeline the Doom Scroll of random stuff and sponsored ads that they're currently getting on X so I think that that's a huge Improvement for most people already yeah definitely and then the question kind of fits in so I say I want to see you know real news only who decides what is real news
like that's tricky like the algorithm will prioritize real news but it won't know what exactly is real news when there's things being created everywhere so that brings me on to the second point which is the idea of these labelers so these are like thirdparty tools and they might even be users sometimes that effectively tag content or accounts to categorize for that moderation it's kind of tricky like to do this kind of stuff right when we think about how Twitter exists now let's take a step back when we think about news outlets you know from the past like 50 to 100 years we have these big centralized entities the Guardians the telegraphs of the world that would put out content and you kind of knew they were accountable they verified it if something was lied or some kind of you know misinformation came out they would be held accountable for that and one of the the things that's happened with social media is that anyone can create that content so the accountability the misinformation angle is
much harder to kind of regulate what this in my mind is kind of doing is taking a step in the direction of going back towards that point of centralization where you start to have say single points that people trust like a telegram of the world that is on Blue Sky and then I can opt for I just want real news that comes from telegram for example and I think this takes a step in that direction having these points that basically categorize and label content out there so that that can then be fed into people's custom configurations for their feeds yeah yeah it's almost like delegating trust again a kind of term that is a web three term it's all kind of sprinkled through but you can delegate this job of deciding you know what kind of stuff should be labeled as certain types of content to entities that you put some trust in and that's again it's it's this nice it's another way in which this is decentralized not just the data Network kind of
layer but at the at the content layer this is decentralization because then you can pick a bunch of different people you don't have to you don't have to centralize that trust in one you can pick the balanced set of entities to label right so you're not going to be uh putting yourself into a silo because that's something you could do easily by accident but you also have the choice to make sure you're not going to be uh just getting content labeled by certain types of people certain types of entities you can have both sides of the political divide for example in any given country so that that's another really interesting there I think on this as well it's kind of like I wouldn't say that twist is not doing this or X is not doing this right now because they kind of have the community notes section which is meant to kind of do this ad hoc like after the fact but I don't really know how Community notes is run like I like say
this model it might actually end up feeding things and making them worse like two different labelers could look at the exact same content in a completely different way one could say it's real and one could say it's not real but it's down to me then to choose which label I respect say if one is this verified party that I know is authenticated like Telegraph for an example and another one is Dave from down the road in his basement or something like that like that one might say that this vaccine's real the other one might say it's an absolute you know hoax and then you choose from from that point like who you respect and who you want to go with and who's actually labeling the content that comes into your feed so think quite an important distinction there yeah 100% I think um it's definitely not going to be a perfect system def you know ever probably and it will have teething problems and it will take time to itate but for me the the
big difference here is the fact that the iteration is something that you're going to be going on that Journey with with the platform you're going to be able to choose and okay this isn't working my feed's not quite how I want it I know I can change certain things about it right so it gives you empowers you as a user to actually make some of those changes I think that's that's a very interesting new aspect of this um we've already mentioned one of the other kind of big features which is these uh handles based on domains which is also really interesting because it implies kind of stronger level of ownership to these domains and because you know if you own a domain you have to pay for that uh separately to Blue Sky or separately to the app protocol you have to have you know your domain bought on a Marketplace or it's registered with a registar and not everyone will be comfortable with doing that but I think we will see a growing adoption
of that behavior people trying to own their own domain because this kind of thing will become much more important with social media like blue sky so yeah I I I think this is really interesting and and again gives you the similar level of personalization but an increased level of ownership over domains that you don't have or over handles that you don't actually have with X right now yeah I think the the kind of at first I was like I don't really see the point in this like this is just me setting up a new handle that just works for blue sky but I think when you take a step back and think about okay what's the landscape going to look like in 20 years time or something like that this handle that you're using here can be used for other applications as well and the point here is you know for a lot of people this handle will be their first you know step into this space the idea of having your own handle your
domain and all this kind of stuff but in 20 years Time Imagine imagine just having one domain that is then linked to all my accounts to my payment services to my you know my tax services everything everything can be linked to one single identity and it starts to get into the realm of like web 3 identity and all this kind of stuff we' talked about previously and yeah I think this is quite powerful yeah just on that I think you know I don't want to go into all the weeds and the details right now but it is worth noting exactly that that the the way identity works in the app protocol and therefore by how it's used in Blue Sky as well is it actually does have a digital identity system under the hood right so it is using a did system that like we've discussed I think if you want to go into Deep dive on the technology there you can see episode 15 and 16 where we kind of talked about digital density
and the finer points of how that works but essentially as you were saying you are getting a did document and and a persistent digital identity assigned to you when you sign up for this and that's going to be linked to The Domain you have but one of the interesting things about digital identities and did documents is that they are inherently extensible so you can always add as you said new protocols new applications in the future it's one of these things where your digital identity is going to grow in the future and as you as you add more services to it as more as more platforms adopt this standard and again this is it has the DNA of Bitcoin and Jack dorsy running through it because uh I had a quick look and the only the only cryptographic keys that supporting right now are the same elliptic curve keys that you use in Bitcoin right and I think there's a there's a clear reason for that but these keys are very important right because these are
the kind of things that let you sign so I also didn't mention in the in the data repository everything is signed by one of your keys in your document and you can rotate the keys you can use it to recover your account if you lose one of your keys you can recover it which is also one of the problems that had with masteron right if basically masteron uh if your server went down you kind have lost everything which also put a lot of people off that yeah you stop talking about keys and signing you're getting really nerdy and Bitcoin right now sorry yeah this don't worry this stuff is important when it comes down to trust and who you are as an individual to have my entire like online transactional history no it's my account is actually quite important when I start on a new account like say I want to transact for a, pounds everyone's like well I don't trust you I don't know you then you can prove that you are verified on
this other platform for example but it's not all going to be viewable to everyone like there's still like an access control where you can say it's private unless I want to reveal it to someone to prove that something's happened but we won't Deep dive into that too much because the identity episode's kind of touched on um another big feature which they kind of discuss is the idea of you know you can choose how the feed is actually displayed again I didn't think this was a big thing like how things are actually displayed on my Twitter feed but there actually is when you kind of dive deep into it like right now how post to displayed on your feed is kind of out of your control to a to a great degree like there's a lot of algorithmic interference in this stuff where something from two days ago again is very click ba might come on your feed first and they just had another level of control there where you can say I just want oldest
to newest newest to oldest the most liked the most responded say just from people that I care about all that kind of stuff so again it's less unknown less black box and more much more transparent and flexible and I guess yeah customizable to whatever your preferences are yeah I I think it's it's easy to underestimate how important that kind of feature is because again that's part of the original flavor of Twitter was having a single kind of timeline of posts coming in and knowing when it happened and now when you're Doom rolling it's like you're just getting information thrown at you in a non-chronological order and it's just that's part of the the the whole nasty experience we have with with with social media now it's just the endless when did this happen don't know it's just now presented in front of you so right you click on like one video of a puppy and then you're like a 100 videos of puppies down you're like how the hell did this happen this shouldn't be
my timeline right now yeah it's pretty horrible and it's easy to get trapped into it so I think this is this is good for a lot of those mental health kind of related topics that we discussed recently as well but yeah it's not it's not hard to see how it's going to how it's going to appeal to more users there is other things as well I've seen the founders talking about how they're committed to making sure that none of the data being put into this platform is going to be used for uh training AI for example which is something that you know other other platforms may not necessarily committed to probably using in the background and again because blue sky is one view into this you've also going to have other competitors coming out there will maybe have stronger guarantees maybe have different authentication mechanisms different kind of differential privacy solutions that let you make things more private so they definitely can't even be uh publicly scraped to train by other people right because on
Blue Sky anything's public okay someone can scrape it still and train something with it but um at a base level they're kind of committing not to do that which is good and I think like the overall benefits of this are quite obvious like much more transparency much more control I know exactly why the feed looks like this why I'm getting this in front of me and I can control that but you know we've kind of talked about the tech underpinning this but one of the most exciting things about this is as we've said like I've downloaded this and played with it is how engaging it is how playful it is how it feels like you know a modern social media experience where a lot of these you know decentralized applications we're playing around with they don't feel like that they're so Tech heavy you have to download keys and Jack's playing with his keys all the time whereas this is just like signing up to a new social media experience and it is as intuitive
fun as any other social media experience which I think is one of the best things because you're going to get web two users that don't necessarily have the whole Mandate of has to be web 3 in their mind they use it and then all of a sudden they've got all these additional features and they like oh that's cool I didn't know that was a thing so yeah I can see this really taking off yeah 100% I think this has the potential to be the uh the chat gbt moment for web 3 right because they're not as you said they're not pushing it as a web 3 thing but all the things we talk about in web 3 all of that is baked in at the core and it doesn't have you know anything to do with monetization and tokens and stuff like that but that kind of stuff can be laid in as well for those that want it which I think is is going to be interesting to see how that works but comparing
it again to something like masteron that struggled to G gain a bigger user base because it was a little bit too techy it exposed too much of the inner workings to you like picking a server whereas Blue Sky they kind of make you let you default go to one of their main ones that you know you can choose to uh pick another one later if you want to IM migrate to which I think is way of doing it so yeah they're clearly they're clearly doing everything right from a user acquisition perspective right now and even that server selection thing like the way I've seen they doing it is like you know what's your focus is it you want to go down the tech route or is it you want to go down the politics route and that's how they kind of are trying to configure the servers like there will be like the advanced options where you can choose a fig a server that's you know located here and has this rule set or something
like that but for most people it just be the intuitive what are your preferences do you want to select This Server over here yes I do and again I think they've really got that we want to limit the friction or reduce the friction as much as possible in their head because you know Jack dorsy has been around this space for so long but it's not all perfect there are some like minor concerns like I think and things they could do better like right now it's not really clear what the funding model is for them like they they're growing quite quickly we don't really know how they're going to monetize this stuff like you said they're not going to sell the data to AI it doesn't seem like there's a premium service that people can pay for and I guess one of the fears is they're going to go down the x route where they start to have these tiered subscriptions and more features available able for premium users or they're going to start pumping ads
everywhere which obviously limit the user experience it's hard to know these things I guess from past you know experience what we've seen from social media Giants is they're free for a while then they get the people addicted and hooked and then all of a sudden they start throwing ads and over stimulating everyone's bu um that's one of the things I have and the other thing is you know it's based on this decentralized network we've talked about how complicated it is under the hood managing the data important in the data will it scale always a question when we have to think about decentralized networks they're beautiful for so many reasons but do they scale will they scale well that's a big question as well yeah they kind of go hand inand like how you going to monetize this whole thing and also how you going to scale it um and there's already questions kind of related to that you could say how decentralized is this if we're all just signing up and going straight to the
blue controlled server then is this not just repeating the problems of the past and obviously we still have the option to and you know one point we didn't mention is there are like kind of other um they call proxy servers in between the kind of main Blue Sky one and individual people hosting there and they're going to be very computational intensive to run and I kind of envisaged we'll also see big companies running their own servers uh on behalf of large user groups and things like that so that there's going to be this this Dynamic level of decentralization that they're going to have to deal with and but again I don't think I don't think a lot of people are actually coming to to Blue Sky for that they're coming for the user experience they coming for the the actual product right which is what they're part of what they're getting so right but yeah at some point that might come to ahead and how they scale this is going to be tough and and
kind of on that point as well they've got to compete the whole time right with all the existing social media networks now we've got you know probably seven or eight that are properly competing with each other at this point and we always talking about Network effects you need a critical mass I don't know if we've hit that yet with blue sky that's why we're recording this today maybe we're just on the cusp of that hockey stick but they're always going to be competing and will people stay with the platform eventually right will they will the user experience be good enough to keep them there once they've got there so that's going to be another challenge for them yeah I think on that point about Enterprises running their own servers I could see like nation states running their own service we've seen like the whole hooa with Brazil trying to close down Twitter and obviously China cracking down and all you know social media from the west and all this kind of stuff but imagine like
if a nation state starts to run their own server and say okay citizens you're only allowed to use this if you use our controlled server and it's not ideal from like a censorship perspective but like it it is something that I could quite easily see happening I think the overall thing on this is options are good you know we talk about distribution having multiple options I think this is definitely a very powerful option that everyone should go and have a look at like I'm on it now and I'm going try start using it and hopefully in like a couple of months or feedback and be like this is the best thing ever the only thing I thought that they would plug into it was some kind of concept of you know crypto payments and all this kind of stuff but I saw that Jack dorsy despite like it's actually coming you know getting 15 million in a series a from blockchain Capital he actually said he doesn't want to hyperf financialized the social experience so
it doesn't look like they're going to put crypto into it anytime soon but let's see yeah I think the operative word there is soon right I think if uh if if the adoption of crypto and web 3 carries on the way it's going then eventually we'll see it but yeah it's it's not smart I don't think in the short term but yeah it's definitely one we will keep tabs on I mean as we can find you can find Alec and I on there now you can find the entangling web podcast on there so make sure you follow us on Blue Sky to make sure you're getting every episode and yeah thank you for listening wherever you may be and you can join us next time on Tangle a little more web three
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto