Episode 2

Blockchain

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

When you hear the term ‘blockchain’ you might assume we’re referring to ‘crypto’. But that’s not always the case. With so much news about crypto right now, Untangling Web3 cuts through the noise to demystify this emerging technology.

In this episode, Alec and Jack navigate the fascinating maze of blockchain technology, diving into the origins of Bitcoin and Ethereum, the development of this revolutionary technology, and sharing insights into the unique role of Hyperledger in the realm of private blockchains. Alec and Jack discuss how blockchain fits into the futuristic world of Web3, clarifying jargon with simple explanations.

Together, we discover how blockchain is transforming industries, from making micropayments in social media to ensuring transparency in supply chains. Tune in to learn about scalability, privacy and the impact of blockchain technology.

Got a question or topic suggestion? Send us an email at theuntanglingweb3podcast@gmail.com

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

thank you welcome to the untangling web3 podcast you'll go to hope to learn insights and the latest developments in the wild and wonderful world of web3 I'm Alec Burns and I'm Jack Davis tune in each week as we navigate and explore the rapidly emerging landscape of the web3 Technologies projects and ideas that are shaping the future of the internet we'll be talking to the best and brightest in the industry to keep uncovering insights so that hopefully we can all learn together on our journey to untangle web3 welcome to another episode of the untangling web3 podcast hey Jack how are you doing yeah very well thanks are you Alec yeah not too bad I think I'm still riding the high of last week's episode so I'm very excited for this yeah exactly you know most episodes most podcasts don't make it past episode one so uh this is uh this is exciting to be here to do the second yeah it was a big first episode as well I think we covered a lot and I

think we realized how much how many gaps we have in our knowledge and how big this is going to be yeah it's one of those you know it's a difficult balance between trying to cover something at high level and generically and give an overall picture but um you know that we introduced so many Concepts that we'll definitely need entire episodes on in the future so don't worry if you listen to the first one and we're thinking uh you know what are we talking about at some points because we will definitely expand on everything in the future I think yeah so we didn't actually realize it was going to be a thing but we obviously referenced my mom quite a bit in the last episode so I had to show at the episode and she loved it I mean she loves everything I do so I don't know she's a very fair kind of Judge of everything but one of her biggest questions was okay I kind of understand what web3 is what is blockchain what

is this blockchain that you keep talking about and I think that's quite an important thing and it's going to be the the core concept that we address in this week's episode so I think yeah this week we're going to focus on blockchain the history of blockchain some of the major use cases of blockchain and The Core Concepts of blockchain yeah that's uh that's the the next question logically right it's that we said these two things web3 and blockchain are inexorably linked to one another but we haven't really defined blockchain yet in any meaningful term so um why don't we start there what is the definition of blockchain maybe if you want to go first I'll let give us a give us a nice Layman's concise definition of blockchain for us this is becoming a habit where I go first every time well you've got time to work out your answer it's becoming clear who the Layman is by the way yeah so I I am well versed in trying to make things digestible and so

I my definition of blockchain would be it's effectively a digital record of transactions that are shared and maintained by you know multiple computers and this along with some you know kind of quite detailed mathematics and cryptography and make it very secure and very difficult to edit and that's kind of the core concept of blockchain yeah that that's that's the good way of uh describing it I think when we because we mentioned digital ledgers right so really a blockchain is just a digital version of something we have many examples of in the in in the real life in the historical world of these idea of ledgers so a ledger is just somewhere you're recording information transactional ledgers is a classic one you know your bookkeepers the books they're keeping are the ledgers themselves and blockchain is really just a digital version of that but it's there are kind of two aspects to what I think a blockchain is one is the the data structure itself so that's not necessarily the most interesting part actually the blockchain

is just this chain of blocks and each block is like a page in in my ledger so it's just an aggregation of say the last um month of transactions I've done or we've done collectively and that structure you know that's not in and of itself that interesting you can kind of recreate a blockchain like that in an Excel spreadsheet you know have one sheet for this month the next sheet for the next month and then they get linked um using this cryptography that Alec mentioned they're kind of more interesting aspect of blockchain that we're talking about and why this has become a buzzword is the fact that it's distributed so it's a distributed Ledger not just digital and that means it's shared and replicated amongst a a network of different computers so it's available people can make sure it's consistent and everyone's checking everything on on The Ledger yeah I do think we said concise but um no that was great that was um yeah super informative I think um maybe the next thing would

actually be to go into the history of blockchain obviously you say it's kind of coming to the the public Limelight in the last few years with all these kind of crypto scandals and Ponzi schemes and kind of speculative um speculative kind of money hikes maybe be good to go into some of the background about where blockchain originated and how it's evolved over the yeah sure I agree so what what popularized blockchain is the Advent of Bitcoin so Bitcoin uh the white paper came out in in 2008 and then the first um uh the actual Network itself started in January 2009 and that was the first kind of accepted or widely used and now it's widely used application of this blockchain structure and this idea of a database or Ledger that's maintained by an open group of our participants so Bitcoin is really the the thing that kicked everything off and started uh the conversation about blockchain and then a little bit further down the line that then evolves and becomes this whole blockchain industry that

we're now we're now talking about yeah I think one of the the interesting facts that I like about Bitcoin is obviously we have these blocks these blocks that are mined and something that I quite like is that there was this encrypted message in the Genesis block the first ever block of Bitcoin um and the encrypted message read it was at the Times a title said Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks and there was kind of like two points to that there was a reference to some of the early work of um blockchain technology that was actually before it was kind of a I guess move to computers where there were some projects around using newspapers to link to link events together and also around this kind of this alternative to peer-to-peer electronic cash system which maybe would uh improve the efficiencies of banks so I quite like that although I think you put your thought in it with your your Layman's description because you said the message was encrypted and actually it may

have been cryptic but it wasn't actually encrypted so the message itself and this is one of those those kind of things you still hear repeated a lot is people think these blockchains these distributed ledgers are are encrypted because we use this word crypto to talk about the assets sometimes but actually uh Bitcoin was an example of a blockchain where all the data is public and that's part of why they're so they're so powerful you can trace the movement of funds um you can you can see exactly what's going on there's no encryption of um an encryption by the way maybe we should just explain is when you you have a message so you might have a transaction that says uh Alec pays me for some some service and we can either encrypt that so no one can so no one can see so I'm gonna see there's a record on the blockchain but no one can see what's happened but on bitcoin actually the opposite is true you can always see there's a motion of

funds from one one party to another so that's one of the key distinctions of Bitcoin to some of the some of the other blockchains we see yeah and I guess we're definitely going to spend future episodes going into the difference between encryption and hashing and hashing obviously a core concept of blockchain generally so to correct it was a hashing it was a hash that was on the unchain right not an encrypted message nearly the message itself was still plain text so oh that's it if you go down exactly if you go and download block zero or go to a block Explorer um online and just search Bitcoin block zero this message was just inscribed directly in plain text in the block as a kind of time stamp of when it when it originated so some people think the idea of this was it was a newspaper headline as you said um Chancellor on the brink of second bailout the banks and the point being that it's like holding up a newspaper in a photo to

show that this this is happening on this date or this couldn't happen before this date so that kind of is a time a time stamp marker for the start of the Bitcoin blockchain okay well that yeah I mean that's a great analogy for maybe not trusting third parties all the time and sometimes so maybe it's worth then going on to you know what happened after that was we're talking about 2009 things developed and and grew into now we talk about many many thousands of blockchains that exist so what was the kind of next phase in the Evolution for you Alec yeah so I mean the next phase okay I guess most people are aware of ethereum second biggest uh blockchain by by market cap um and that was invented by a man called well mainly by a man called vitalik buterin in 2015.

it's actually really interesting why he got into uh blockchain do you know this Jack why vitalik got into blockchain I think I know part of it but yeah it reminds me because I can't remember exactly so he was um an avid World of Warcraft player um actually very good at it and spent a lot of time on it and one day his um his character got nerfed which for the non-games that means his character stats were were reduced quite dramatically and this basically like destroyed him I think he described it as like a horror of centralized systems and kind of this defined his character Arc and then all of a sudden he became um an avid admirer of blockchains and decentralized um decentralized networks and that's one of the primary reasons he moved towards um developing ethereum so if we um yeah if we think of Bitcoin as the first peer-to-peer electronic cashier system then ethereum hoped to be the first world computer and it's um sorry what what do you mean by Will computer

there well what does what kind of what's the concept there so it the idea effectively was to create a decentralized platform and with a focus on the creation and execution of smart contracts and and smart contracts quite really briefly will probably spend future episodes speaking in detail about smart contracts uh self-executing contracts that are written in in code effectively and we kind of talked about it a little bit in the last episode around in web 3 versus web 2 the trust changing and getting more visibility in in how things are done and smart contracts can actually play a key role in that even if there are some issues that arise from having like this kind of quite black and white uh or binary smart contracts kind of controlling how things are done yeah I think that's a nice description I would add that if you if you think of Bitcoin as being a blockchain where we're recording simple transactions in the same in the basic case between you know people like you and I then

and and the nodes the the entities let's say who are in this network who this distributed Network who have copies of the blockchain their role is to verify the new transactions check that you know this payment is valid and you're not trying to spend money uh you're not trying to send me money that you've already sent to our producer Emma you know in the background and one of us is going to lose out and in ethereum's case the the network of knows what they're doing is they're not just verifying events that are happening they're also collectively executing some code but essentially so you so the network is uh executing these more complex functions they're doing computation A Step Beyond Simple payments so is Emma getting paid for this I didn't realize we were getting paid for well I don't think we deserve to be paid just yet so Emma definitely does deserve to be paid um she just said Lolo wish so yeah I think so this this kind of rise in the smart contract

focus of ethereum meant there was lots of developers lots of applications being built on top of the ethereum network I think one of the biggest ones that some of us are aware of would be crypto kitties I Know Jack you're an avid player of crypto cases back in the day is basically a way of connecting these kind of um I guess these these token kitties that you could exchange and play games with um there was lots of upgrades along ethereum I think one of the most interesting ones which relates to this this smart contract was around this decentralized autonomous organization hack which I think was back in 2016 2017 Jack do you remember this yeah I wasn't I wasn't around in the industry per se at the time but it's it's one of those big events that everyone is kind of uh scarred with or remembers quite uh quite vividly so yeah yeah so it's a really really briefly um there was basically this decentralized investment pool that was built on top of ethereum and

they use Smart contracts to to govern it and effectively someone found a bug in these smart contracts and they managed to siphon off 50 million back in the day of ethereum off of this smart contract and this caused outrage in the community um and basically divided ethereum not down the middle but into two major camps one group who were like okay we can't allow this hack to go ahead we need to you know actually correct it and bring the coins back and the other group were like I mean this is blockchains and mutability we shouldn't be changing these things and there was this quite a philosophical debate and it caused a split or a focus we kind of call it in blockchains typically between the protocols where you had the ethereum that most people know the most widely used one that brought the money back into the fold and kind of reverse the hack and then ethereum classic which which maintained the kind of the hack but this is this shows some of the some

of the issues that actually exist with smart contract effects like because they're definitive and they're so black and white which doesn't always replicate what we see in the real world these hacks can happen especially when contracts are getting quite complicated yeah and you're going back to what 2016 uh 2017 there which is you know that seems like really the the early Frontier of of the blockchain industry so that there are there are lots of these kind of examples now of things going wrong and uh and the need for caution when when looking at and also you're bringing up uh the Dow hack and the kind of split in the network that happens that's that introduces this idea of why is why do we talk about this pluralism of blockchains why why don't we just have one or two and in its history it's been partly new blockchains starting up to be kind of application specific so for us for a certain use um you know trying to do distributed file storage as a kind of

utility token or something like that or you know companies just trying to to launch their own as a fundraising mechanism which is which is another and the Third Kind of Avenue then is is when you have one blockchain where many people agree on what should be happening and there's kind of a broad consensus on how it should work there's there's a there's a bifurcation in that group where maybe an event happens like the hack or maybe there's proposed changes that not everyone agrees with and then that's led to in part why we have quite so many blockchains now we have different camps and factions and that speaks to you know there's this underlying tribalism in a lot of blockchain um but I think we can maybe Park some of that discussion for another episode and maybe we can uh maybe we just round off the history by talking about the third the third element of blockchains or the Third Kind of category we see now which is these private blockchains right so you know where

did they come from yeah so the blockchains I think the kind of the core original principle of blockchain was to be public was to be you know anyone could see anyone could kind of contribute and potentially to to these blockchains and then there was a move maybe in later years to have private versions of blockchains um and these are the key kind of Technology there was um the focus was around Enterprise grade blockchain technology for for sectors that wanted more control they wanted things to be customizable what they saw in the market say you know Bitcoin ethereum maybe wasn't for them and they kind of wanted control and maybe even more efficiency which is something I guess we could speak about a bit later as opposed to maybe the trust and open openness that's provided with with public blockchains yeah and it's interesting that that I think ironically given that this private nature flies in the face of one of the early initial blockchains Bitcoin ethereum and others that they were trying to to achieve

with this with this this public nature and not having encrypted things and not being private and then things like hyperledger came around in I think 2016 is when hyperledger started launching these these kind of Enterprise grade private blockchains and actually that was what gained I would argue most Traction in in uh with companies so there was lots and lots of projects that that took this idea they could see the value in a shared distributed database that they could that they could you know use for specific Industries so I think shipping was one of the examples where you have lots of different parties involved with shipping there's lots of complexity and instead of having an open public network where everyone can verify processes they were they decided we can have a closed system here we can have a closed network of just the stakeholders that that this this um that this supply chain is relevant to and then they would they would maintain a blockchain together um and there are lots of there's lots of debate

about the value of that you know whether it even is a blockchain but it's good to acknowledge that now we have that third dimension to things that there's also private blockchains um that are not no not so not used quite so much now and people have kind of gone back to um to using public blockchains I mean arguably a bit like what happened with the internet we talked last week about web one Web Two web three and web one was um was initially very uh very distributed but we have the.com Bubble as well right when there were lots of intranets created and private internet and obviously that concept didn't didn't have the hot same value as a public internet and then eventually everyone went back to public internet so you know that kind of that's a similar thing we could be seeing in blockchain as well yeah and I think a lot of it comes from a misconception that public blockchain means that all data that is kind of referenced on the blockchain is visible

you know if I put if I use the blockchain anyway for for my application it means all the raw data that I'm using on the application goes in the blockchain everyone can see all of my personal identifying information everything about me you know my tax history my salary and that's not the case as we kind of go to into I think the future episodes you can just reference things on chain and it's really difficult to create a link between the actual raw data and what's being referenced on the blockchain um so yeah Jackie how does all of this relate to web3 that's a good question because yeah this is the untangling web3 podcast so maybe I would say that the initial ideas and principles that are inherent to blockchain this idea of of removing unnecessary third parties having more efficient more peer-to-peer direct interactions all of these are values that are common to blockchain essentially so um they kind of coexisted and grown up together this notion of web3 web3 kind of started to be

talked about a little bit after Bitcoin and the early blockchain so I think it's a natural I think it's a natural evolution of blockchain web3 is just generalizing that notion to lots of different Industries and aspects of the internet yeah I've seen some like nice diagrams it's a shame that we can only share audio on this where it's like the central circle is the crypto and then this the circle outside of that is blockchain and the circle outside of that is web through and it kind of shows like the order of magnitude and what you need to kind of um enable the other Technologies but yeah I completely agree I think um I mean blockchain is effectively the key technology in web3 and to be a bit more applied it enables decentralized and transparent ways to store and exchange information and this obviously has all the kind of the the effects of user control user centricity enabling peer-to-peer exchange without unnecessary third parties so yeah it's the key technology for for web 3.

yeah I think I would go as far as to say and also it's an important qualifier I think web3 could in theory be implemented without a blockchain that there could be a way of doing it using other instruments but blockchain appears to be by far the best platform the best tool the best infrastructure to deliver on those promises of web3 to solve the problems that we were talking about in the last episode so it they're not necessarily uh they don't necessarily have to go hand in hand uh in the future but they right now they definitely do they're definitely intrinsically married to each other I think yeah I don't know I think that's a nice place to take a break okay so so far we've talked about blockchain we've given a kind of definition together of what we think blockchain is and how it relates to web3 and also explored a little bit of the of the history of blockchain you know and the industry that it did it spawned so why don't we turn

to our our friend chat gbt and see how its definition lines up with ours Maybe oh it gets a bit creepy when you start referring to chat GPT as a friend um yeah so I've asked chat gbt to explain this to my mom because obviously she's the the only listener right now so chat GPT said hey mum blockchain is a decentralized digital record book The securely and transparency keeps tracks of transactions it stores information in Connected blocks across multiple computers making it difficult to tamper with primarily used for digital currencies like Bitcoin blockchain also has a range of other potential not bad not a bad definition yeah I think we've covered a few of those points right we mentioned about the the they calls it a digital record book which I think is what we're referring to as The Ledger um but yeah I think that's that's a nice easy way of understanding it yeah maybe we should go into some of these terms that have been kind of just just dropped in there like

a big one that we've obviously said many times and gets thrown around a lot in the space is yeah we've already been you know dropping it in ourselves I've noticed um because it's it so often spoken about the same breath as as Bitcoin and blockchain so maybe I can have a stab at explaining decentralization so a lot of people refer to this concept decentralization as there being many many parties involved in in this so these networks that maintain the digital Ledger itself um people would describe that that Network as decentralized if it has many many parties that are involved now in reality you know decentralization is a spectrum it goes from one to potentially Infinity right it's it's either one party which would you'd call a totally centralized system and that's what you have in existing a lot of existing web 2 architectures and systems and you at some point along that you have to pick what what your flavor of decentralization is and I I would say for something like Bitcoin it's essentially a

minimum number of parties you need for the network to maintain its properties to maintain its immutability to continue um to be safe from subversion right so that could be anywhere from you know three to maybe uh 15 or something and if you actually look historically there's only ever you know around four to six um of these these nodes these Bitcoin miners that are contributing blocks at any one time so there's not actually that many people not any entities involved and the degree of decentralization you might say is not necessarily that high but that that's also that's fine the system still works nonetheless so it it depends where you fall on that Spectrum but I think it's important to know that um for these systems to work it doesn't necessarily have to be that high yeah and that's something that I've seen a lot in the space that you think maybe that having a thousand different uh parties validating things is preferable to 100 and maybe that's not always the case it depends on how many

trusted parties you actually have any how many trusted and kind of non-related parties you have uh validating the network and I think something that I found a lot and with this word is kind of there's a lot of negative connotations with it you know when we think of a decentralized network it it's not always like some people related to a decentralization of power but it's more and more I think about a decentralized network is about a robust and efficient system uh which removes any single points of failure and and this kind of you know having multiple nodes that have the entire history of a network and could kind of ensure that they're operating to the same standard I think is is more the purpose of the decentralized aspect of and you you'll you'll get into uh a debate about trade-offs as well right so the more parties the more nodes you have involved then the the more redundancy there is the more irrelevant or unnecessary messages or or communication between these computers if you only

had three you know that that minimizes how much redundancy you'll have um but you also want to maximize for things like availability so making sure that that data will be available at some point in the network so if I only have three maybe I'm worried that if all three of those go down at the same time then I I can't access the data on The Ledger but if I have five or six then that's much less of an issue so it's a matter of trade-offs and a lot of these things are you know at the will of the markets essentially you have these these economic entities a lot of the miners in Bitcoin are very large companies um you know so I think at least a few of them are publicly traded as well or have been in the past so they there it depends on what the incentives are for them um and how how the network looks best from their perspective on depending on how many people they have you know they don't

necessarily want to connect to a hundred thousand different uh home users who who might not be contributing very much to them whereas just connecting to the other big players might be much more preferable yeah and I think um the next term that I think we should go into in or not term phrase is this peer-to-peer which obviously directly relates to decentralization and I think and a nice way to think of that is it's around direct exchange without unnecessary third parties I think it's quite important to emphasize the unnecessary I mean most interactions even in the web 3 Model there'll still be a point of trust to say you know you are who you say you are what you're saying is true and all this kind of stuff it's just the the removing of unnecessary third parties they'll always be trusted into media is required for a lot of interactions and I think like maybe a good way to compare this is to like cash I think a good example is when I give you you

know like a 20 pound note Jack I don't know what I'm giving you a 20 pound note for but that's a direct peer-to-peer interaction um and I think we don't really see that so much on the internet it usually goes through these kind of these centralized Gatekeepers that will kind of validate verify store and exchange the information between between you and I whereas maybe we'll see in the future hopefully more and more peer-to-peer data exchange that it replicates cash exchange where I can just pass you a piece of data directly between me and you without needing unnecessary intermediaries so are you who who are the and who are these intermediaries in the case of a cash payment then because when I hand over cash uh a corner shop then to me it looks just um I'm just paying uh the merchant right but maybe I'm using my uh my debit card instead to pay for something who are the intermediaries involved that uh maybe are necessary and things yeah exactly so in in a cache

model there's effectively Security on the note you expect there's been some due diligence that has created this note which means it's very difficult for me to create a counterfeit note so I think that kind of really directly relates to blockchain data that's stored on blockchain and potentially been verified using cryptographic proofs or something like this at pki which we'll definitely go into in future episodes um to prove that the data is authentic and that enables me to directly exchange that data with you where I say in the in the case of your debit card you do have the third party it's directly involved to validate that you can make that transaction and you know there's efficient efficiency trade off there so I think the cash versus money is an interesting kind of Paradigm that we will definitely talk about in future yeah and in both cases it's probably important to mention that there are inefficiencies that exist that the the kind of Bitcoin peer-to-peer model can improve on right so in the in the cash

case there's actually a quite High Cost of storing and processing cash and validating you know that it's uh that it's it's not counterfeit that's one of the problems and then when you go to digital payments like if I'm paying my credit card then you have this this whole um plethora of fees that come out of this right from your you acquire a bank your your um you're issuing Bank the banker which is your card the bank who accepts the payments on the upper half of the merchant there's fees for point of sale terminals there's all sorts of extra costs that might be hidden to us users sometimes but that will you know potentially increase the cost of the product you're buying so it's important to note that some of these can be addressed with uh with I want to move on to maybe I want to move on to maybe um another word that was used here which was digital currency in the definition because that that opens up a whole new can of worms

right like what what are your thoughts on calling something like Bitcoin or ethereum digital currency um I mean I know that well effectively Bitcoin is an electronic Well appear to pay electronic cash system right so you're going to have problems with it being called a digital currency yeah I think I think I don't personally like that that phrasing um so you know this would be a a negative point on chat GPT here is that currency implies that kind of sovereign state involved or some some some backing by a state where whereas obviously that's not the case for the kind of public permissionless blockchains that we talk about but it does capture the fact that it's meant to work like money so it's more like digital money than currency I would say and that's quite an important distinction to make and I wonder if you could start to involve some of the more um aspects of you know some cryptocurrencies in that when you kind of hear the term cryptocurrencies a lot of people tend to

think speculation rather than the utility that I guess a lot of well more and more we're seeing the focus shifting towards so another term that was used I believe in that definition was what it was actually difficult to tamper with I think the term that we've used in the previous episode and we'll probably use throughout will be immutability and I think immutability is one of the core aspects of blockchain and I mean that specifically relates to two things in my mind one it's the decentralized nature which we've spoken about you know computers holding multiple coffee copies of the same data so they can you know reach consensus and then that leads me nicely onto the second aspect which is consensus how do we actually um ensure that these different versions of the same data is is the same and how do we add an append when we have you know two three plus versions of the same data how do we make sure that as we're adding multiple transactions to that data set that everyone

has the same data and that gets increasingly complicated when we think about the number of transactions that can potentially come through these networks and you know again I think we'll talk about it more in later episodes but there are can different consensus algorithms there's different ways for these these computers in the network to achieve consensus uh I mean the one that Bitcoin proposed was a proof of work consensus where each node would do a large amount of work to actually kind of um validate transactions into the network to prove there was some amount of effort done in that network but more and more we're seeing say networks like ethereum shift from proof of work to proof of stake and this has been an upgrade that has taken a long time and still hasn't been like kind of fully adopted by everyone and you know that's not really battle tested so we're very interested to see what actually happens when this proof of stake in census mechanism is is adopted yeah I agree I think you've

you've kind of nailed nailed on the head there like this immutability aspect is essentially about how difficult it is to change records once they're in the ledger so we talked about what The Ledger is and how it's maintained by this network of nodes but not about you know why how easy would it be for this network to create two three four different alternate versions of that Network and the proof of work algorithm you mentioned that consensus mechanism is kind of the the OG mechanism that was used by by um by Bitcoin and also ethereum until recently when it adopted proof of stake which is a slightly different kind of less battle tested as you said um version so yeah that's the kind of I would say the final element you have the you have these different blockchains you have the fact that we also have private versus public and now you also have the the competing consensus mechanisms and which will actually bear bear the most fruit in the future which is really I think

this podcast has already been worth it just by the fact that you've said OG on here and it's recorded yeah it's a first every consensus for that was a mistake I think should we move on to I'll bring it back from that pause so that was rubbish um I'm just reading the use cases that we so yeah I think um maybe I can go first with a use case that touches on the problems we talked about last week which would be um social media so how can we improve social media with uh with blockchain well that would be to use this micropayments element so using blockchains like Bitcoin to do very small payments um so what why is this a compelling use case for me well it basically changes the incentive model of something like a Twitter or a Facebook so currently it's it's free to use it's free at the point of view so or maybe I should say free to interact so we can always view the data you can see the data

even if you haven't got an account logged in but to interact to post to follow to comment to be involved in the conversation it's completely free at the minute and I think that is the source of a lot of the problems like having trolls and Bot Farms where you it's there's no cost essentially associated with abusing the system so how you would solve this with with blockchain is to say well okay instead of it being free if you apply a certain cost to liking to commenting subscribing following and that basically means that it's much much harder much more costly to abuse that um and you can you might be still be able to see the data I know I don't know about you but I know a lot of people on Twitter who are just lurkers right so they're not actually posting necessarily all the time but it would it would it would increase the cost of of doing that and abusing that and I think not only you know stopping those kind of problems

but it would also give you a way to earn as a user so if I post something and it's a particularly a particularly funny meme or something then I might get hundreds of likes out of that which would then be a way I I earn money directly without having to become like we said an influencer who's then an Advertiser as well so I can directly earn from people who follow me I'd be interested to see what you're posting that would get hundreds of likes but I suppose that's TBD um yeah I actually uh to relate this back to our first episode I saw someone and compare the the kind of the the Twitter lurkers to read only like in kind of the first phase of the internet and where one so they're in read-only mode where they're not engaged in not really kind of contributing anything and how they move to a web 2 model so it's quite interesting I think one of my points around that would be why would I if you said

to me okay you know I use Twitter right now I don't really care about privacy too much maybe you know I do have some um some some Bots that are interacting with me and I don't really like that why would I move to a model in which I would pay to engage and interact with people where I'm not paying anything right now well I mean just for that fact so I I don't I wouldn't mind having a bot reply to my to my tweets and and comment on my tweets if they have to pay me you know 5p to do that or another interesting thing you could do is have a social media where you can scale that so for a given account say I've identified uh someone I don't like or or or a bottle account I could toggle that they have to pay me one pound or ten pounds or 100 pounds to comment on my on my tweets so you know I wouldn't mind uh being being trolled if that if I

was getting paid that much for it so I think I think there are lots of different ways you could take it but it offers a different Avenue right got you so this is a way for you to monetize my engagement with you on Twitter LinkedIn Facebook all these things you basically want to distance yourself from me or at least charge me to engage with you yeah basically you specifically so I think that's that's a great one obviously everything related to social media is always good because it's very tangible everyone um that's you know what is it 1.5 billion users of Facebook everyone kind of understands the value in having like an upgrade in social um my use case is probably slightly less tangible for a lot of people even though um it affects the entire world let's say so it's around Supply chains and I think it's really important because everything made that is more complex than like a stick needs some kind of Supply chains and I think that they're more complex than ever

the multi-border they're multi-company their multi-ecosystem you know multi everything basically and I think quite importantly consumers care more than ever as well there's kind of more and more insight into Supply chains and particular you know quite dodgy Supply chains and consumers care that the product they're buying you know has come from say you know a fair trade or they want to know who is actually involved in the in in the entire kind of in the entire kind of supply chain itself and I think one of the issues here is is the trust in data so imagine like a world where each actor in a supply chain for say the coffee that you have or the phone that you're buying has to submit some data to the blockchain and you know if we actually kind of combine this together we get traceability so I can actually once I buy my item even before I buy my item I can trust the data and the blockchain hasn't been tampered with and actually kind of understand in more

detail what the various stages were for the item that I'm about to buy uh and you know one of the the issues around this is garbage in garbage out which I think is something that is used in in the kind of the blockchain space quite heavily blockchain really just ensures that the kind of the data hasn't been edited or hasn't been kind of changed anyway so if I submit some data that isn't correct I mean that data's still not going to be correct blockchain's not really going to fix that but one of the aspects we can actually add to kind of um to kind of improve that is around identity and there's a lot of work going on around digital identity and as soon as you start to combine that with the data that's being submitted on chain we then get a degree of authenticity and probably even ability to to verify um that data as well so yeah for me Supply chains are a big one I think you could also streamline processes you

know all this kind of stuff and reduce fraud I mean we're talking a lot about emissions and how much emissions go into a supply chain ensuring that the compliance there's no like slave labor that's going to I think Supply chains on blockchain is going to be a massive kind of area for improvement over the coming but yeah this is I have a question on this then because I think this is where lots of the the private blockchains this is the use case they were targeting you know when hyperledger first came out so how yeah we talked about the the nature of of a public blockchain so can you use public blockchain to deal with that what if the information in the supply chain is sensitive you know is that is that is it compatible with that yeah I think so we talked earlier about hashing and I think that that's quite important you know if I say let's give an example I want to say that you know I am a farmer and I farm

you know 10 bananas or something like that and I want to put that at the blockchain there's obviously various ports exports that it needs to go through customs all these kind of things and various actors in that supply chain I don't necessarily need to put 10 bananas by Alec burns on the blockchain as like readable uh raw data I can put it through something called a hashing algorithm which basically kind of obfuscates it and obfuscates the fancy word for kind of muddles the data so that no one can understand what it is put that on the blockchain and then later on if someone wants to understand what that that muddled obfuscated data is I can provably say that my 10 bananas by Alec Burns relates to that data and was submit at that time and that's one of the beautiful things about hashing algorithms is that it's almost impossible well I would basically say right now it's computationally impossible to kind of replicate that raw data and relate it to a hash on chain um

and yeah like I say so the raw data doesn't need to go Unchained but there's a way of referencing it or fingerprinting it on chain and then exchanging the raw data off chain so I could then say if you're buying bananas Jack and you want to prove that I am the person that made those bananas I'd say okay this is the reference on chain doesn't mean anything to you now I'll give you the raw data that relates to that and you can probably say that that was the data that was put on chain effectively using the things so you're using you're using the the on-chain record to check against something else in the real exactly it's kind of a bit like you have a private portion of the public blockchain so it's a fair analogy yeah I'd say so and I think yeah we'll still need like mechanisms for exchanging the raw data but I think the blockchain kind of provides that indisputability aspect and I think this is quite important actually is that in

a lot of the applications we're seeing blockchain is really the USP anything to make it tangible to users there's still a lot of things that need to be built around it so when we're talking about the web 3 versus web 2 a lot of the functions okay all right all right you ready okay so I think that's two pretty solid use cases and we've been singing the Praises of blockchain the whole time so maybe it's worth quickly covering to finish off some of the the the concerns or the the the things you should uh think about when using a blockchain some of the the considerations you have to make so maybe we can go to you mentioned crypto kitties right earlier on I know that was that caused a lot of problems when it first happened right because it was so popular maybe you can talk us through what happened actually yes this is a major pain point and it kind of all revolves around scalability and I know that this is a particular pain

point for you jack because you were you know heavily involved in crypto kitties you're a big admirer of their work and I think like the the popularity of it of crypto kitties itself and there was about 1.5 million users active users at one stage one of which is obviously um and this resulted in a lot of transactions um on the ethereum lots of spikes in transactions and the fees were astronomical it was it really upped massively and the network basically couldn't keep up with the amount of demand and I think that saw some like news headlines it was like crypto kitties kills ethereum and there was lots of network there and just trying to keep up with the demand so yeah this is a big issue for for a lot of blockchains is the scalability aspect and you know there's kind of two mechanisms for softness one is like uh I guess layer one scaling Solutions and more and more we're seeing these kind of Layer Two scaling solutions that build on top of layer

ones by Bitcoin and ethereum can you can you describe them what the difference is yeah got you so blockchains quite generally I would describe as layer one so where the consensus is achieved it's basically the the kind of the the foundational uh data storage solution um and then layer twos are built on top of that so they you know a good example was you know if I kind of bundle my 10 crypto kitties together on a layer 2 Network and I just send one reference for all of those 10 kitties to the layer one solution there I have two layers that are effectively separated and it reduces the kind of I guess the the um on the layer one solution by creating this or offset in the data and the throughput onto the layer two got it got yeah that's it's an interesting problem so you're basically touching on the scalability aspect right which I think you know lots of people will talk about blockchains as not being scalable because you've had a lot of

examples in the past I mean that that crypto kitties event was the first thing that Drew the public eye on uh on on the lack of scalability of some blockchains um and it's becoming a bigger problem as as they become more popular more people want to use them there's more demand and then now those bottlenecks of how many transactions they can process um are coming are coming to light so yeah scalability is definitely one of the biggest sticking points and there's obviously lots of different things to different approaches to solving that which I think maybe we can expand on in an entire future episode because it is a big topic yeah and I think um one of the other considerations thing and you want to talk about is privacy yeah privacy definitely privacy so we touched on it already a little bit and you know right at the start of the episode we were talking about this this message inscribed in the Bitcoin block zero right which we said was in in plain text you

could just see it and I was saying you can see the motion of funds um moving between one party and another so that seems like a big privacy issue it can be depending on how you use the blockchain so it there are very there are lots of different ways you can use the blockchain and you can use it in a bad way like most Technologies most um you can you can use it poorly and you can use it in ways that will not preserve your privacy or you can build in identity systems as you were mentioning so in it again to go back to the Bitcoin example what you can actually see on the blockchain is that something called a public key and again we'll Define all these in the future but the public key is is something that uh Alec and I will both have so you'll have a public key I'll have a public key when he sends me Bitcoin he's essentially sending it from his public key to my public key and

that's what controls um uh what helps you control and authorize new transactions so on the blockchain we're not recording Alec and Jack our identities we're recording the public keys that the funds are moving between and what we can do is we can build quite complex privacy features on top so how do you know associating identity with one of those keys but doing it in a private way so that I can prove to Alec that this is my public key but um you know not necessarily revealing to the whole world that's my public key and that kind of brings you know we've seen a lot of examples of where particularly on ethereum actually so in ethereum they're not so much called public keys but you'll call them um so you'll see people saying oh give me some ethereum pay to my address which is for all intents and purposes like a public key and uh they'll just post that address and then from that point you can track exactly what happens to that address so um

you know you can see all the motion of funds in and out so once you've made that real world identity link then you know what's going to happen with that person in the future and a lot of people so the example I would give is that in the past couple of years with the nft craze that was going on you saw lots of influencers on social media who would start to promote certain projects certain nft tokens and they would often do it in a way that looked innocent they would be like I really like this nft this is a great project um you know have a check this out and what they wouldn't be saying is that they're actually taking payments uh to to promote these things and they weren't disclosing this so this is something you have to do when you're doing a paid promotion is you have to disclose it you might have seen that on YouTube or something when whenever someone advertises they say this includes paid promotion now lots of lots

of these influencers didn't include this disclosure but they were then caught out later so there's a really good Channel I would recommend if you don't watch Alec called crypto sorry called coffeezilla who kind of documents a lot of these happening right and if you've seen that but he basically exposed or shown people exposing these influences because they'll maybe post their address one time and then you can track the funds coming in to the to their address over time so then you can match it up you can work out they were they might have accepted a payment from the uh the owner of an nft project one hour before they started promoting it out of nowhere so you know you can you can you can sacrifice your privacy if you use it incorrectly I think is the main point but the good message is there's lots of different ways you can you can improve your privacy when you use blockchain yeah what was in the high profile cases it was some of the the celebrities that

were getting done for these nft schemes uh I think I think mm is saying Kim Kardashian was one of them um I I don't wanna I don't want to name any in particular but I I can remember there being some pretty high profile ones I think maybe um you know you can go basically go and watch coffee zilla's Channel and he'll he'll give you the whole Lowdown but there are some pretty big names out there you know some people who like to fight in a uh in amateur boxing matches and things like that let's say yeah that's an interesting one and um I think yeah important point that you raise there around you know pseudo anonymity rather than anonymity that you can potentially link these addresses to people I think this is something that I really do want to talk about in future episodes it's around like um you know Ponzi schemes and kind of assets that have been stolen and how governments and kind of law enforcement agencies can actually track these addresses and

how even though there's kind of the hackers have created these ways to obfuscate funds and assets by you know sending them between millions of transactions over the course of millions of transactions millions of addresses sorry um very quickly there are they're quite impressive ways of tracking assets through all of the all of these different addresses and then eventually when someone tries to redeem those assets by you know convert it to an exchange and back into to normal currency that they can use they then you know come down on them quite swiftly and there's a lot of interest in examples of this that I think we should go go into in future episodes yeah I mean maybe I would just uh finally close on one other concern is that blockchains are essentially giving users more options for how they you know we're talking about monetary instruments effectively so something that can be used like digital cash or a bit like money so how you handle that money what security measures you take as an individual is

also really important so how you know if you've ever downloaded a wallet you've been a wallet that lets you use a blockchain then you'll have been prompted no doubt uh write down a 12 word phrase as your security and that you know that scares a lot of people and it's important because your personal security of your funds is actually um there it can really go wrong you know there's the the famous case of someone from Newport so you know someone else from Wales not just me but um in the blockchain landscape but who who accidentally threw out a hard drive that um uh the the security passwords effectively so so the the keys behind his his wallet throughout the hard drive which contained seven and a half thousand uh Bitcoins on it so and I think he said an ongoing struggle to work with the the local authorities to try and get it back which is you know it's a good story but it's something you feel really sorry for him for and it's you

know it's it's a reminder to take care when you're using blockchains and again lots of this will be mitigate it over time because it's still it's a maturing industry the the tools to help with these things how you can recover funds how you can um ensure funds there are Insurance products now for blockchain wallets and things so it's getting better but it's also worth worth knowing that there are risks involved when you're getting involved for the first time yeah I find these things this story is so interesting when someone I think that that guy from Newport specifically he thinks it's in some kind of um some kind of land fill somewhere right and he's like hired multiple agencies like some of the people that try to find like um crashed airplanes and things like this to help him find this this hard disk in this landfill and offered them like 70 of the reward there was like another one where I think you had like five attempts to guess his um to guess his C

phrase which is like the the I guess like what Jack said the private keys for that and he's on like his last attempt and it's like if someone can help me solve this I'll give them 90 of all the all the monies that are on there the RN is the guy the guy in Newport is like he's I think he's put together a really interesting plan to salvage it that involves automatically searching through things using Ai and robots to sift through and look for what might be the hard drive and things um so yeah it's it's a great story but it's it's very sad at the same time all the buzzwords in one project robotics AI ml to find cryptocurrencies on hard disk yeah and I think um another interesting fact that M has just dropped into the chat that I think is a is quite a good one is that the first payment that Bitcoin was actually used for was for two pizzas and Jack can you guess how much that was paid for

those two pizzas back in 2010 two pizzas was it in America I think so let's say 30 or something like that 10 000 Bitcoins which at the time was worth around 41 so yeah you're you're guessing of Pizza prices is pretty on point and now that is worth some tens of millions of dollars so I have no idea if that pizza joint held on to those Bitcoins probably not um that's quite an interesting one isn't it yeah I just want to know what the toppings were to be worth that much you know gold foil or something I think it actually went down as the most expensive pizza that was ever you'd hope so you know I don't know what would beat that so uh I think we've covered a lot of things there we've discussed what blockchain is and uh we discussed the history of blockchain some of the different flavors you know private public some of the different aspects like the consensus mechanism proof of work proof of stake we covered a couple of

use cases which I think are really interesting and it's fair to say only a couple of uh we're only scratching the surface of the many applications there are of blockchain but we discussed two ones that are particularly compelling to us and we've also covered a couple of the the things to be wary of or the considerations for uh the industry itself so I think I know what you think Alec that seems like a good sensible place to wrap up for this yeah I'm hoping that it's explained um you know the concept of blockchains a lot of people especially my mom but I think as we did before man we've opened up um even more future episodes to explain a lot of the concepts that we've introduced and barely scratched the surface off so yeah here's to the next episode I guess thank you thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma camilleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to

follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes