Episode 23
BlackRock's Bitcoin ETF
About this episode
In this episode, the focus is on BlackRock's anticipated Bitcoin ETF. Unlike other ETFs, BlackRock aims to own actual bitcoins. The hosts explain the benefits of an ETF, emphasizing its regulation and accessibility for both everyday and institutional investors. With BlackRock's entry, there's speculation about a possible surge in Bitcoin prices.
BlackRock's crypto venture might net around $14 billion in its inaugural year. Their alliance with Nasdaq aims for market transparency, and insiders hint at an imminent SEC approval. The firm's partnership with Coinbase showcases a blend of traditional finance with crypto. However, there are concerns. The crypto community is wary of technological progress being overshadowed by speculation and wealth concentration. An interesting note is BlackRock's potential influence in deciding the 'real' Bitcoin in case of a network split.
The episode wraps up by questioning whether Bitcoin might become the new gold standard, what all of this could mean for the future of the web3 space and teases more web3 discussions.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
one of the most interesting things about black Rock's proposed spot ETF is they're actually going to buy Bitcoin and own and store Bitcoin themselves securely in in vaults and then I mean if we kind of go back to a few episodes ago they are effectively going to act as the G gated trusted custodians of the Bitcoin and then offer out you know shares of those Bitcoins to all their institutional retail consumers whoever it may be and this is kind of like um maybe a web 2.5 type thing welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today's episode is a little bit different as we're going to be discussing some ongoing news in the web 3 world more specifically we're going to take a look at the hotly anticipated Black Rock Bitcoin ETF Jack this is everywhere right now I'm glad that we're doing this it's h like I say hotly anticipated what are your thoughts yeah I mean this is going to be a little bit different from usual where we we go
through the the nitty-gritty of the history of some topic and how it relates to web 3 and this is really you know us talking about something is actually happening right now and if you've been online in the last few weeks all you'll see is news about this Bitcoin ETF and really it's it's weird to call it news because nothing's actually happened yet but it it's like people are anticipating the news so what is it that people are anticipating it's it's that this this this Bitcoin ETF that has been fired by Black Rock one of the world's biggest ass Asset Management firms is about to be approved that's what the whispers are and it was filed back in June of this year but now it's approaching a point where people think it it might get approval finally so yeah that's why that's why we're here to talk about it because it has some real significant implications I think you know we'll get into the detail of whether they're good or bad but what either way this
is going to be huge for for Bitcoin and web through in general right yeah and like you said it nothing's actually happened yet right and like we're going to discuss some of the things that have kind of happened that are similar in the past like similar kind of examples of this stuff but one of the biggest things about this is it that it's Black Rock that's doing it and like you mentioned they are the world's largest asset management firm right they I think the assets they manage are around n to 10 trillion dollars so these are this is basically a country bigger than I think all countries in the world apart from two to three um so the fact that they're moving into this space I hate to use the term because it's proper crypto bro but it's making lots of people bullish on bitcoin right now right no don't don't use it don't say it Alec we ridicule the crypto Bros and it's just funny though right it's funny because we're so not there
but it's so funny to say it I'm bearish on the term bullish put it that way yeah like this this is big big news and um I think one of the the most important things is they're going for it in a different way so they're going for this thing that's a Bitcoin spot ETF which hasn't been approved yet and that's slightly different and like we're going to see it's slightly more linked to to bitcoin itself and they're actually going to hold Bitcoin itself which is it's a big move right it's very big yeah it's huge um and it's it's also it's it's important to note you know the timing of this is very interesting right because they've filed this uh this application Black Rock they' filed with the US SEC the Securities and Exchange Commission who at the same time are really going after a lot of a lot of crypto companies like like coinbase um you've got Ripple Ripple as well on the crosshairs so there's is a strange time to be filing maybe
they're thinking we're going to move first here while while we're in the bare Market um but yeah as you say black rock are so big that if anyone's going to be the the Black Swan it will be Black Rock right to do this so why don't we actually get into a little bit of what we talking about here because we're just chucking this term ETF around so what what is your understanding Alec because I've just had to look into this recently myself right as you've seen the term in the news what do you understand by this term ETF so my understanding I'm I'm not in this space like I'm not a big investment bro by any means so I think my understanding of funds generally is is they're kind of a way for I was going to say everyday people but they're way for almost anyone big Enterprises small Enterprises individuals to effectively buy into a collection or a basket of different stocks and assets so I have done some fund investment like small small
scale right um where you kind of you trust a fund that basically regulates and monitors loads of different stocks for example in in one kind of overall basket of all the things and I just say put a bit of money in there and that goes across and like one of the best bits about that you get a lot of diversification across lots of different stocks rather than directly investing in one stock is that about right yeah I think so and it's one of the ones you'd be familiar to even as a retail investor so again you have two different types of investors institutional who your big investment Banks and other commercial entities and then you have retail investors like you and I Alec who get our bags uh ruined every day on the market but really uh fund is something anyone can interact with in general and yeah the key being it's a basket of goods so the fund you would know most commonly is something like an S&P 500 fund which is Index Fund
so that indexes a whole market right that indexes the big public companies in uh in America and in the same way an ETF is an is an exchange traded fund so that's what it stands for and the exchang traded part just essentially means that it's a fund that is accessible to the masses and you can buy shares in this fund on the General stock exchange and that that's a key point Point actually because when you're buying a stock normally you think you're buying a share in a company but when you're buying into a fund you're buying a share in effectively the returns of that basket of stock so you're not buying a single asset okay so just to recap because this is not my area at all I imagine there's some listeners who are also struggling or hopefully also struggling it's not just me um so ETFs are exchange traded funds and they're effectively just a big basket of stocks and assets that are managed by someone in this instance will be managed by uh
Black Rock and they're accessible to retail and institutional investors on exchanges is that about right yeah exactly exactly that maybe we should have preface with this episode with everything here is not Financial advice we're not going to give any but definitely don't listen to us or anything like that exactly so the next step is then what is a spot ETF and this is something interesting because a spot ETF contains the underlying asset so this is the the big thing that's getting lots of people excited the underlying asset in this in this thing that we're going to talk about this black rock Bitcoin ETF spoilers is actually is Bitcoin itself so they're actually going to be owning Bitcoin itself and it directly tracks the real time price of that and this is very different from Futures ETFs which have been granted in the past where they don't actually own the underlying asset they own Futures contracts that speculate on future prices only and I have no idea what a future is so that kind of stuff
is complete jargon to me Jack exactly so I've done a little bit of looking into this myself and it's the terms I've come across before but now I've had to go and try and understand it bit better so yeah as you say there's two main types of exchange traded fund you have the spot ETF Futures ETF the spot ETF is much easier to understand as you said it's essentially a basket of assets as we said a fund basket of assets that contains assets where where you're interested in the underlying price the spot price so effectively think of it as what's the price on the spot if you were to ask me right now what's the price of Bitcoin that's how much I'm going to pay for it or another asset right you're thinking about it on the spot real time uh the fund we say it tracks the price directly okay so if the value of Bitcoin goes up then the value of the fund goes up end of story because that fund contains that
that underlying asset it contains Bitcoin in it so if bitcoin's price goes up the fund goes up Futures ETF as you said contains these things called Futures contracts so your fund does not contain assets or the underly assets it contains Futures contracts related to those underlying assets and those Futures contracts as the term kind of implies Futures what they are they're essentially an agreement between a buyer and a seller to buy or sell a given asset at a future date for a given price in a given quantity so it's essentially a contract that's like a bet on the price and of course that's links to the underlying asset because if the asset is going up in price then you know you're going to have better odds on it effective to use the gambling analogy but it's only linked to the underlying asset you don't actually have the assets themselves in your basket so it's a basket of these strange contracts maybe not so smart contracts or something um but yeah so that's the key difference
there I know it's a little bit abstract to understand but just think of it as a basket of uh you know you know almost Commodities versus a basket of papers about the Commodities okay that is I think when you described it as a bet that makes a lot more sense to me than these Futures contracts but a lot of it is just jarg right I missed the technology at this stage so the thing is why do people find ETFs useful not just Bitcoin ETFs that we're talking about now but like I mentioned earlier the big things around diversification diversity is the spice of life the fact that you're investing in these funds that have lots of different stocks it gives you that instant diversity I just invest in a fund I don't even know need to know what all the different assets are kind of trust that because they're spreading the BET across a lot of things then I'll probably be fine hopefully longterm my investment will go up that's one of the big things
right yeah exactly that's that's a big piece of it it's drisking because you're not just you're not just buying and stock picking they say stock picking when you go and buy a single asset is really bad way of of investing your money it's why you know another example of a fund that you put money into is a pension fund in your pension plan from work you're not picking a stock you're putting into a basket of assets so again that's the same reason you buy an ETF now the other reason and on a similar note here is that ETFs themselves are very accessible because they're exchange traded that means the institution like your pension fund so when you're putting your pension contributions into your pension provider they are then putting that money into funds right and if you have an ETF for some asset that means those Pension funds for example can put your assets into that they can buy you shares of that ETF and get you return so it becomes accessible to General investors
as well as these institutions that would invest on your behalf typically okay so I guess that also relates to the regulation site as well so we're saying that like going into ETFs you assume that because you're going with large regulated bodies that have probably done their due diligence on the stocks they're investing in you have a kind of a degree of certainty and probably much more comfortable in investing that so the regulation which is definitely going to become quite an important talking point a bit later on is another reason why people think that ETFs are useful mechanisms for investing yeah exactly and as we'll come on to you especially with these kind of emerging asset classes an ETF where as you said you have this kind of trusted big custodian like Black Rock uh to they're the ones custody the funds they're the ones taking the kind of ultimate risk in all this not you you as the end investor you're just buying a share of their their basket so yeah the fact that it's
regulated and it'll be done by a big provider is what gives people a lot of confidence to dip their toes into the market and you know other institutions that maybe are not so big and have the same risk appetite as Black Rock they'll be able to invest through that and gain some we call it price exposure right they want to be exposed to the upside as bitcoin price May in increase if it does and don't want to be exposed when it decreases but the fact that they can do this in a kind of indirect way is very useful to them yeah and is it correct to say that these these spot funds are more efficient than Futures funds because they're more directly linked to the actual say asset class and the live price and that kind of stuff yeah that's my understanding from what I've read is that because your futures funds are you're actually buying a share on the returns of these Futures then those contracts the price of those can be they can
lag they can drift there's also a cost associated with you know creating the contracts in the first place more so than there is sometimes in actually just buying the assets themselves um that would be at a spot ETF yeah and this is a big thing with Bitcoin specifically and you know cryptocurrencies generally because of the volatility right like if you say you're betting on something in a future that you know maybe you can update or get out of in a month's time like how much does the price of Bitcoin fluctuate per hour let alone per month like people want to get out as soon as possible right maybe that's not a good thing maybe it's a bad thing but I can understand why people are particularly excited about the idea of investing in these kind of the spot ETFs because like you say more efficient especially when it comes to volatility that you're going to see when investing in Bitcoin specifically yeah exactly that that I I 100% agree and I can't imagine how scary
it must be to to have a have some shares of a a Futures far right now in crypto um so one thing I think is definitely worth us covering here as well and I didn't realize this until kind of reading up a bit more about it this week is that everyone's calling this the Bitcoin ETF right because this is the the first filing of a of a spot ETF that looks like it might make it through past the SEC but it's not the first Bitcoin ETF because there are actually many Futures ETFs that exist it's just a spot ETF that hasn't been done so you know there a few examples there one called pro shares it's got the the ticker BTO there's also a pro shares short Futures fund and when when they say short this is when you're actually betting on the price to go down which is interesting so you'll creating contracts to sell it at a kind of assuming the price has gone lower in the future um so people might use
that hedge funds for example to hedge risks of of other assets going going up as well and I think that's quite interesting because that kind of highlights the point that that's one company pro shares facilitating the people that believe in the price going and facilitating the people that believe the price going down and I think this is particularly important because maybe it doesn't actually all of this stuff doesn't necessarily mean that black rock itself believes that bitcoin's going to go to the Moon all this kind of stuff it just believes that its investors want to invest be it positively negatively it's just facilitating that investment on behalf of its consumers right yeah exactly what's that quote about in times of War you know to own the means of production own the ammunition or whatever and don't take aside that's kind of feels like a lot of these yeah that's definitely not the quote I can't remember um it's you know they're offering this financial product to people whatever they whatever their interest right so that's
the idea so yeah given that we've had all these Futures ETFs existing we don't have a spot ETF and there have been a lot of examples of them uh being filed right but not actually being successful so far okay do we know the reasons like is it just lack of Regulation is it the technology itself them not thinking that Bitcoin safe enough to invest in or is it the way in which the kind of these investment facilitators are regulated themselves yeah I I I think this is one way everyone's opinion will differ I think for me part of it is potentially going too early whilst you have all this regulatory uncertainty like as we said the SEC going after various crypto exchanges at the minute already so it's it makes sense why they might have um rejected applications but you've even got examples where gray scale for example have had an appeal of a of a rejected application now and in court so they had an application rejected they've taken it to court and they've
had their appeal actually seen successfully so they might end up having an ETF approved as well and I I agree I think it's just a this combination of how much you trust the institution that's that's offering the ETF and where the regulatory status is I mean one example of a rejected one was the winlos brothers who who filed the winlos Bitcoin trust right so maybe maybe the SEC saw the saw the social network and didn't want to trust them with with an ETF I don't know because there of us twins are actually they're two of the the biggest owners of Bitcoin right I think generally whenever I see like the top 10 list I'm like like they are always top of the list I think so they are big Believers so I understand why there's an incentive for them to facilitate other consumers being out to invest in Bitcoin because like you say I mean maybe there's a bit of Market manipulation there or whatever it is but it's in their best interest to support
other people institutions especially investing in Bitcoin because of all the reasons we're about to talk about as to why it will benefit bitco coin potentially yeah exactly I think that's been the main cited reason right is the risk of Market manipulation which can be done if you have a big player who's in an Emerging Market who might have a lot of the supply and and changing things so yeah what do we know right now well we know the applications was filed in June there's a lot of noise now around the SEC potentially being ready to approve as soon as kind of January or q1 of 2024 and there was some news the other day right I can't remember when this was exactly but did see this about the the false report that happened yeah yeah I was on I was scrolling on Twitter at the time was it was it coindesk I think falsely tweeted that it got approved and the price of Bitcoin went up 10% and then they pulled it down 30 minutes
later yeah that's why they say sell the news right because perfect example isn't that that's a perfect example of Market manipulation like if you can you know just one person tweeting that thing if they have invested heavily in Bitcoin tweeted that thing within the half an hour sold their you know whatever Bitcoin they had and made a 10% profit and all that kind of stuff like the volatility and that exists in most shares right but the volatility of cryptocurrencies and Bitcoin specifically means it there is a degree of kind of it's a it's slightly different right it's a bit scarier and it shows you why the The Regulators would take so long in approving one right because when it's that easy to move the market we've seen the moves from Donald Trump and Elon Musk Tweets in the past right when the market honestly that fragile in terms of um price action then it makes sense that You' you'd be cautious so let's talk about how how does it actually work then one of these
Bitcoin ETFs because we we talked about spot ETFs generally so how does it work specifically for Bitcoin are there any are there any specifics to it that are interesting do you think so like I said earlier I think one of the most interesting things about black Rock's proposed spot ETF is they're actually going to buy Bitcoin and own and store Bitcoin themselves securely in in vaults as and then I mean if we kind of go back to a few episodes ago they are effectively going to act as the G gated trusted custodians of the Bitcoin and then offer out you know shares of those Bitcoins to all their institutional retail consumers whoever it may be and this is kind of like um a maybe a web 2.5 type thing that we could kind of go into a little bit is it for web 3 no it's not but if it's like drisking it enough for people then there's a bit of um there's some there yeah exactly and that is kind of the interesting aspect
here right is that you have to actually own the assets that's why the spot is very different to the Futures you have to own the Assets in this fund to provide that fund and all those all those issues you have as an individual trying to to to have exposure to crypto right before this you have to get an account on a crypto exchange or you have to know someone or you have to have mined when you were you know back in 2016 or something like that right or 2012 so effectively what you're getting here is a very drisk exposure to the Bitcoin price as a retailer or Institutional Investor but especially as a retail investor I think where no longer do you have to worry about all these things to do with wallets and keys and who's the custodian because again you have like one of the most trusted providers who will be heavily regulated who is custody it like normally the people worry about crypto exchanges because they say not your keys not your
coins right when it's black rock holding it and then the amount at stake for them at risk them you know misbehaving you know they're not going to go not going to go and do anything wrong if they intentionally right yeah and this I think like maybe principally I had an issue with this kind of thing you know it's very anti- web 3 kind of removes some of the the benefits that we've stated in previous episodes but that they're effectively play doing what a coinbase does and I don't really have too many problems with coinbase if it's helping facilitate people's use of these Technologies and it's it's kind of like a Gateway technology like if they're just slowly getting to terms with it as a kind of a way to drisk like some of the things we've talked about the difficulties in rotating Keys storing you know all these secret puzzles the kind of stuff then I am a proponent of it because I do think it will enable people then to eventually feel comfortable enough
to go to the full web 3 Paradigm that I hope that we're moving towards um but with one of the things that like I said that I also find interesting is they will hold these Bitcoins themselves and then issue shares to individuals on behalf of like actually based on these Bitcoins it's kind of like what do we call it the um asset backed currencies that we kind of talked about in previous episodes stable coin type stuff yeah yeah exactly and you know again again in this case you trust Black Rock to issue one to one more than you might do other stable coin issuers right so again this is where trust is working in our favor I think in in web three at the minute yeah so why do you think that people want a a bit Bitcoin ETF then well I think 99% of people who currently know about this bit Bitcoin ETF are Bitcoin holders and they want it because they know what it is potentially going to do to the price right
and and again this is this is not my analysis but what people are speculating is that as you said Black Rock will need to accumulate a large Reserve or Bitcoins is I think the number I've seen is around 100 million is is the size of this fund because they want it to be big enough to to serve a big enough number of institutional and Retail customers so they'll be buying a huge reserve of Bitcoin this creates demand and buying pressure increases the price you know to higher levels as basic economics would dictate so a lot of people are just expecting you know Black Rock doing this and having approved to see the price bike and as you said 10% on some false news of approval is uh is significant for for an asset that's already around the half a trillion Mark I think these days yeah like you say and like 100 million doesn't seem like that much you say I think the the Bitcoin mark market cap which I said I have a problem
with def you know using market cap as as a means of success for for cryptocurrency and Bitcoin um but yeah say it's around half a turn I think it's actually like 650 billion 100 million is kind of like a drop in the ocean compared to that some of the numbers that I saw analysts from like Bloomsburg and Mackenzie throwing around was um that they actually think that if it goes ahead even though it's 100 million right now the amount of money that actually bring in directly through that in the first year alone will be something like 14 billion and like that is it's a big that's a big number right that's a significant percentage of what what we just said especially when we think of like in terms of Trends and forecast and how that will kind of hopefully grow as more and more institutions kind of Base things on that um yeah it is going to be a big mover exactly and yeah 100 million is what it's kind of being projected as like
just the the foot in the door right like just to start this thing off you could imagine if this is sucessful how how big it's going to get right those those those bigger numbers I think will will definitely come so obviously we've talked about black roog being a big uh big player big you know basically the big the big daddy of Finance in the classic traditional Finance tradire world but you know what is that the only difference this time or is there anything else that you're aware of what why this they think this is going to be um likely to be approved why are we actually talking about this as opposed to all the the rejected applications so far yeah so one thing that I've a term that I've heard banded around this surveillance sharing agreement with NASDAQ I don't know much about it but I think it's to do with like transparency on how they operate and auditability and things like this yeah that I think that's basically the key here other than blackr
being this big player is that they have put in this filing as you said the surveillance sharing agreement and this basically means they're they're going to be sharing with NASDAQ and have an open channel on lots of the operations of the fund to avoid that market manipulation risk right there's debates around you know how how much is this really going to add compared to other crypto exchanges where lots of this you can track on the blockchain anyway to be honest I've seen that argued but this is the key difference between a lot of the old filings and has actually triggered lots of the old filings that were were in progress or rejected to be refiled with this new requirement and in the intention that it will kind of assuage this fear of Market manipulation and everything should go ahead as a normal ETF that's the kind of basic difference um the Black Rock could bring to the table now that's interesting Black Rock do not mess around do they I saw that um BL Bloomsburg
said that there was a 75% chance of approval I think it was in January or first quarter McKenzie said it's about 85% so it's highly likely this is going to happen and I think one thing that I think is my understanding is that black rock are going to use coinbase as a means of actually acquiring and transacting the Bitcoin as well which is quite interesting right yeah exactly I think you know part of the issue in the past is those uh institutions like coinbase haven't been seen as NE necessarily trusted enough in and of themselves but in combination with this surveillance sharing agreement is is is just enough to make them be able to use some of the other providers so I think that's definitely a positive move overall here right is that is showing cooperation between traditional Finance institutions and and the new kind of web three um distributed World Finance institutions that we've seen like coinbase so yeah and just to like emphasize some of the the kind of things we've been talking
about quite generally throughout is one of the main positive impacts of this is of Black Rock moving into the space and potentially you know facilitating the ownership of Bitcoin through you know institutions retailers whatever it is is it's institutional adoption it's a general kind of trend of Institutions wanting to move into that space and there's a lot of kind of secondary effects of that one is definitely the price stability that we've talked about you know more money moving to that space Not only more money but more money from very regulated players moving into that space who can't just you know pull out the carpet from Out Underneath investors they have to you know they're actually are public facing public listed they have to answer to the government and its consumers and all this kind of stuff so it's not just the amount of money that's coming in it's also where that money is coming from which is is quite an interesting thing and on the regulation point I think that this is really going to
start to put Bitcoin more and more under the regulatory Spotlight it's going to maybe in the short term it might put a lot of red tape around things it might affect some companies kind of having to keep up with the regulation that's definitely going to kind of be um emphasized and pushed even harder but long term I think like we've said in the past it's absolutely needed like Bitcoin cryptocurrencies the entire web 3 space needs regulation for governmental trust for institutional trust and for everyday users to actually be able to trust in the service themselves I think that's a massive impact that's going to come from this yeah exactly you you'd think that a move like this if the SEC are going to approve a spot ETF for Bitcoin then they would have to be this is the point it feels like the point to me where now there'll be complete regulatory Clarity quite soon down the line on the status of Bitcoin and many other crypto assets you know whether they're Securities or not
we've discussed before the coinbase the Ripple cases as well I think we'll get a lot of that Clarity coming soon some of the negative aspects of this I mean I I think there's probably few downsides that I'm personally worried about I've see a lot of talk about well you know this is just classic tradire trying to get their slice of the pie concentration of wealth going into the old hands as well etc etc I think the one that I'm slightly the one that I do buy a little bit more is the kind of there's a risk to your both your institutional and your retail investors at the kind of existential level again right if Bitcoin fails completely if if um if confidence goes in this system if there if there's a break in the security model for example somehow that we don't anticipate then at the system level then you have this contagion and we saw last year with FTX the last time all the big institutions bought into anything in web 3 the contagion
that spread when it all came down was was hideous right and we're seeing just now the trial happening the number of other big companies even traditional Finance who were exposed to that and the institutional investors that lost out was significant so that's my only real worry but again because it's Black Rock and because of the way they're approaching this I I I'm feeling a little bit less worried than I I think I would otherwise yeah you'd hope that you know with all that money on the line Black Rock would do its due diligence maybe more so than you and I I think yeah completely Echo what you said there the other thing that I kind of feel is a bit of a negative as I kind of maybe I'm just going on about it all the time is the utility versus crypto kind of thing you know me you and I we're not investment Bros like we're techies like we we develop applications we want to see this like the magn ude of and the
kind of the great expanse of projects and applications that we're constantly talking about all the benefits that this can bring from a technology standpoint being the things that get the Limelight and you know this ETF thing kind of focuses so much on the speculative aspects the number go up number go down which in my mind in a lot of ways kind of is to the detriment of all the crazy cool technology and applications that we're talking about week in and week out and I hope that it doesn't detract from it I hope it just means there's a lot more money being pumped into those incredible companies that we're constantly talking about but in the back of my mind I am always when someone talks about speculative tools like can how can I invest in Bitcoin I'm like ah but there's so much more than that web3 is so much more than just Bitcoin investment come on look at everything else that's out there so that's a negative for me yeah I feel I feel kind
of similar to be honest I mean I know I've seen Larry think the CEO of Black Rock he's been likening this to the gold ETF right so you know strengthening strengthening this narrative that Bitcoin is just digital gold which I don't like because it doesn't do enough of Justice into to all those applications of Bitcoin and web 3 that we talk about but at the same time I do kind of feel like it's a it's still a necessary step on that Journey um there's a couple of other little things at the end I just want to touch on here right some maybe slightly more wacky nuanced pieces here but some some things I've seen floating around so did you see this this hard for clause in the disclosure the ETF filing from Black Rock nope I did not what's that okay so this is really interesting I think if you're kind of getting your conspiratorial hat on for just a second okay so at one point they talk about hard Forks of Bitcoin and I'm
sure we'll have a full episode on this because it's a fascinating topic but essentially when you have disputes in the network you can have Forks occur so if you've ever heard of Bitcoin and Bitcoin cash then the reason for those two existing and it not just being one Bitcoin why do we have two is that there was a hard Fork right that's the the long and the short of it so this is the like the ethereum versus the ethereum classic talked about like episodes ago that was kind of thing yeah yeah be great if I remember that of but so yeah you can have this there's plenty of examples of it happening in in all sorts of blockchains there's a there's a clause in this in this ETF filing from Black Rock that says this so it's talking about the the provider the sponsor of this ETF it says it can use its discretion to determine which network should be considered the appropriate Network for the trust processes and that there's no guarantee that the
sponsor will choose the digital asset that is ultimately the most valuable Fork basically in the event of a fork right so they're basically saying that they're going to be judge jury and executioner over what Bitcoin is in the event of a hard Fork right and that they might not take the most valuable one and as we've seen in the past you know the difference in value between the two chains if you look at BTC and bch right now the difference is is is Chasm so that's really interesting I think I don't know what what they're thinking about there do you have any thoughts so they're going to be judged Judy and executioner I mean that is huge so I'm just yeah I think the thing that that you're saying there is imagine if they bring in all this money and eventually like the Black Rock ETF is like the primary kind of custodian of of Bitcoin in a way like they have imagine if they're like 60% of the entire Bitcoin holding kind of consumers
and Retail investors all going through them and then all of a sudden they're like you know what we actually don't like what the Network's doing right now we're going to Fork make our own network and all that money is going to come with us and this is now the new Bitcoin they call and a Bitcoin black rock or something like that um yeah that's quite scary and like this this Clause that you put in there actually says they can do that and the fact that it's like it's not they don't have to go with the most valuable Fork seems very counterintuitive to an investment fund right the whole point is around what's the most valuable how do I get the most Returns on my investments yeah and uh you know a lot of people are saying this is a kind of a big state scop or something to to take over Bitcoin I I actually think I think it's just a very smart Savvy thing to put in this in the filing because it means
if there is a for like we had in 2017 with Bitcoin Bitcoin cash it means that you know they can make whatever Choice makes sense for them and ultimately for all these institutional and Retail investors at the end of it I don't think they're going to be trying to to co-opt bitcoin necessarily but I think it's interesting and also there's there's kind of I've seen speculation around well what are they defining as Bitcoin now okay because they mentioned the historical forks and because we're talking about a fund remember we said a basket of goods but we've only been talking about Bitcoin and all we know is that necessarily again my understanding is that just means the fund has to include Bitcoin so it has to track the price of Bitcoin that doesn't necessarily mean that they can't be tracking the price of a basket of Bitcoins all these different Forks that exist so who know who's to say they're not they're not uh accumulating all these other chains that that exist as well wow and
on that tinf foil bombshell we're goinging to the close right that was a good one though this is a super interesting topic let's see where we're at in a couple of months time when the likelihood is this this ETF actually will be approved and all this potential liquidity is going to come in and bitcoin's going to be the new gold or whatever they're saying right now yeah exactly I'm sure we'll check up on this one in the New Year and I hope everyone didn't uh didn't get too bored by this format of us just talking about something that's happening in the news but uh yeah I'm sure there more of these to come in the future so yeah with that we'll say thank you for listening wherever you may be and join us next time to untangle more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caler don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us
on your favorite podcast to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto