Episode 114
Bitcoin's Institutional Rise
About this episode
In this episode, we dive deep into the evolving relationship between Bitcoin, blockchain, and financial institutions. Once a symbol of rebellion against the banking system, Bitcoin is now embraced by institutions and governments alike—raising big questions.
Are they legitimizing crypto or diluting its original purpose?
As BlackRock, PayPal, and governments tokenize assets, we explore whether this new wave of adoption is saving Web3 or reshaping it altogether.
Key highlights
- The Institutional Era of Bitcoin and Crypto Finance. there has been a massive influx of institutions into the Bitcoin space. With over 10% of Bitcoin’s total supply now held by institutions, ETFs, and governments, and public companies like MicroStrategy owning over half a million BTC, the duo reflects on how this shift has transformed Bitcoin from a peer-to-peer payment network into a mainstream financial asset. The approval of ETFs, growing regulatory clarity, and widespread adoption by traditional financial firms all underscore this new financial paradigm.
- Benefits and Trade-Offs of Institutional Involvement. Institutional adoption brings with it pros like regulatory clarity, increased financial stability, and global legitimacy. It’s driving up prices, enabling better user protections, and opening new enterprise use cases beyond just finance—like digital identity and supply chain management. However, it also raises concerns about centralization, custodial dominance, and potential protocol-level influence.
- Cultural Shifts and the Future of Innovation. Many innovators have either exited the space or moved on to more flexible ecosystems like Ethereum. While Bitcoin thrives as “digital gold,” innovation now happens largely outside the BTC base layer. So does Web3's real future lies in alternative chains and what does rise of custodians like Coinbase and PayPal means for user control and digital self-sovereignty?
The institutionalization of Bitcoin is undeniably reshaping the crypto landscape. What began as a decentralized experiment is now a critical part of the financial system.
While some of the original dreams of Web3 may be fading, this mainstream adoption could be the key to realizing its broader potential—from stable payment rails to real-world blockchain use cases.
Whether you're a purist or pragmatist, one thing is clear: the future of Bitcoin and blockchain will be built by institutions, innovators, and communities—together.
This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here: https://vebetterdao.org/
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio.
Welcome to the Untangling Web 3 podcast. So, Bitcoin was born out of distrust in banks. Web 3 promised a new internet owned by users, not platforms. But here we are in 2025. Black Rockck holds billions in Bitcoin. PayPal has its own stable coin and governments are tokenizing bonds on private blockchains. So, what happened? In this episode, we're asking the big question. Are big institutions saving web 3 or killing the dream it was built on? Big questions, Jack. Yes, very good questions. I think uh you know for a lot of the the Bitcoin maxis out there, the last couple of years has been interesting because Bitcoin has never been so popular and never been so mainstream.
Um but at the same time, maybe the way it's going mainstream has challenged some of uh some of the things they might hold dear, right, to to the original vision of Bitcoin and things like that. So yeah, I think it's been a very interesting couple of years. Quite, you know, 2024 is probably the year of the financial institutions and, you know, big corporates at large taking Bitcoin to a greater extent and, you know, other cryptos to a lesser extent taking them much more seriously and 2025 is just seeing that continue.
So yeah, I think it's a good time to review uh what's happened and why. Yeah, and it's hard to say whether that was always inevitable, whether that had to happen. Like with the shifting of power, obviously the parties in power were going to resist that or try and get a piece of that. It's kind of in a lot of ways always going to happen. But let's jump into it. Let's set the tone nice and early. We're saying that institutions have come. So, let me shoot out some numbers at you just to justify that institutions are there.
Right now, over 2.2 2 million BTC, that is 10% of the total supply is now held by institutions, ETFs, and governments. And as we often know, there's only ever going to be a limited amount of Bitcoin made. So 10%, that's 10% of the total supply is only ever going to go up unless the institutions decide to sell it themselves. So that's an interesting one. We also look at, you know, Bitcoin right now is at an absolute all-time high and price tends to mean demand. And obviously there's a lot of demand coming from retailers but particularly in institutions of that you know 10% total supply.
We've got a over 80 public companies now following what is defined as the Bitcoin standard collectively owning 3.4% of the supply. You know Micro Strategy alone holds over half a million BTC. So these are some huge numbers that really do justify that institutions are already in Bitcoin in the web 3 space. >> Yeah. Yeah, and I think uh th those are big numbers, right? And maybe the kind of numbers you'd expect of an asset that is, you know, maturing in its life cycle. You know, the idea of it being on treasuries and balance sheets of large companies would make sense, right?
In terms of an asset mix that where they're trying to hedge against inflation, against other market movements from, you know, the whole pool of stock, shares, commodities that you could have on your balance sheets. So, I think that makes a lot of sense. We've obviously also seen with the the ETF inflows from the last couple of years, you know, since the Bitcoin spot ETF and Ethereum spot ETFs were approved kind of last year and the year before. Um, that's obviously a kind of a step between I guess the consumer and the institutions as well because the reason that you know those products being used as we discussed previously on the show is ultimately to give end users exposure to things like Bitcoin through their retirement savings accounts and their pension funds and things like that.
So I think it's been you know although mostly heavy on the institutions starting to step in there is also this kind of this new mode of getting involved for the end user as well because previously your only way of getting exposure to bitcoin was you know spinning up a coinbase account or if you were if you were sat techsavvy enough uh mining it yourself or you know get acquiring some directly you know onchain essentially which is not not so easy to do. Yeah, and I think that's part of it as well is like obviously the pioneers in this space were technically aware of the characteristics of Bitcoin and the advantages that Bitcoin had.
And because they were technically aware, they could get involved on them on theirelves, right? They could get involved by themselves to handle private keys, generate private keys, do the transfers before these, you know, super kind of modern UX systems, the wallets that we know, love and use today were widely adopted. I think another thing that I just want to mention is this trend for institutional adoption and interest is only growing. So if we look at say institutional investors over 83% of them have a plan to increase their crypto allocations in 2025 41% already hold spot crypto and 96% believe in the long-term value proposition of Bitcoin and crypto.
So institutional adoption is here. It's only going to grow. So that 10% supply is almost certainly going to go up. But how did this all happen? Like we've given I think one of was our second episode actually went into the origin story of Bitcoin. I know Jack absolutely loves this story, but we're not going to go too hard into the entire history. I think just setting some of the scene will be quite useful just to see where it started, what the community looked like then and how it's kind of evolved over the years to where we are now, which I imagine for a lot of the early adopters would have been quite unpredictable to think of people like Black Rockck and governments coming into the space in 2025.
I imagine they wouldn't have thought that possible or even something they wanted to aim for back when this was invented in 2008. >> Yeah. And uh you know that is casting our minds back a long time if even not to 2008 but to two years ago when we first kind of covered the origin story of Bitcoin on the show that we we were very you know much less gray at the time I think. Um but yeah I think the reason it's important to do that is everything we've just said about institutional adoption is kind of couched in the idea that Bitcoin is being treated as an asset class.
I already mentioned that terminology and phrasing before. Um whereas you know back in 2008 asset class wasn't necessarily the pitch of Bitcoin right so if you look back to when the the original white paper was released you know there's there's all these kind of um these these theories that get mapped on to how it was created and more specifically why it was created because it was launched you know in immediately following the 2008 financial crisis. It had the famous kind of cryptic message or maybe to some people very much not cryptic message in the in the genesis block about the chancellor bailing out the banks for a second time.
So for a lot of people Bitcoin has always been this kind of anti-bank idea, this anti- you know financial institution idea. But I think also if you look at the the white paper in and of itself and you don't look at, you know, some of that mythology around Bitcoin, it was very much pitching itself clearly as a payment system, right? It was electronic uh peer-to-peer cash was the original idea. And this is something that had been, you know, as we've covered before, people have been trying to come up with electronic money, e- money, digital cash, whatever you want to call it, just an electronic form of uh a monetary instrument that can be used for, you know, the the same things we use fiat currency for, for for payments, for store value, for medium of exchange, etc.
Um, so yeah, that for me, I don't know if you have an opinion on this, Alec. Mine has always been that I take the starting point of Bitcoin as this is a new way of doing money for payments. Basically, it's more more on the cash system side of it uh than anything else. Um, because also there was a lot of thinking around uh you know the internet at this point 2008 had been around functionally for 10 15 years, right? And there was never really a native currency for the internet.
So I think that was its kind of niche originally or the proposition was this should this should be the currency of the internet right but I don't know if you have a different take on that. No, that that's it my take as well like when we look at say I mean Satoshi's obviously held up as a semi deity figure in so many kind of circles and it was obvious that he was trying to replace the monetary system but in a digital capacity and what I mean by that is like mostly around I imagine retail users like retail transfers high frequency like we're looking at the numbers of bitcoin now it it doesn't do that but I think a lot of the commentary of Satoshi early on he kind of did envision that there would be more transactions in the network should support more transactions and that's not to say that that should be what Bitcoin is doing right obviously systems evolve over time and one of the beauties of having a decentralized system like Bitcoin
is that the community decides and the nodes the validators are the ones that vote for upgrades they vote to go in a certain direction and you tend to assume that they are representative of the community but yeah I agree that it was obviously always intended as an electronic cash system that was the title of the white paper whether that should be the aim I don't know but there certainly not that now and I think that's one of the interesting things is it's come so far from that and I kind of want to talk about not only how the tech has changed from that but also how the community and the culture has changed so like I said it was invented the web was released in 2008 early on Jack mentioned it's around a peer-to-peer electronic cash system some of the features permissionless transfers double spend resistance decentralized trust importantly so it was around this premise of don't trust verify anyone being able to look at a transaction and prove prove that that transaction is valid.
That doesn't mean that like you can see everything. I know all of Jack's weird and wonderful transactions and what he's buying, but I can he can prove that to me should he need to. So, the sending party and receiving party can both prove that a transaction is valid and that it's on chain. But the early culture of the community was very cipher funk, right? This some new music you've been listening to, I like. >> Yeah, cipher funk. I do love funk music. Was very cipher punk.
Sorry. So it was around privacy, self- sovereignty, a lot of things around cryptographic freedom and censorship resistance. You know, there's a lot of talk in say the web 3 community about people being shut off from the monetary systems. And we're going to touch on a little bit about that later, which I think is really interesting to see these same conversations happening in the web 3 and especially amongst crypto communities because of the institutional adoption. But this was really at the heart of the early community of Bitcoin in the early 2010s, right?
They were all about self-s sovereignty, not being dependent on these big intermediaries a lot around like personal freedoms and liberties. Yeah. I think uh and it's interesting if you you know it doesn't really matter in my view what you want to ascribe to Satoshi's thinking behind Bitcoin and what it was supposed to be. Um it's still a fact that the community it was initially released to right it was uh it was released on the cryptography or cipher punk uh kind of mailing list right and it's it's circulated around those communities so people who are quite uh you know anti-state anti- uh banking system all those kind of you know high high privacy focused individuals looking to find potentially a money that circumvented uh nation states circumvented the banking system um that was the early culture of Bitcoin that's the early culture of people who who picked it up like you know look no further than Silk Road right that was one of the very first and earliest use cases and adoptions of Bitcoin was used
on this kind of legal online marketplace. Um so if you look at what how things have changed over time actually the technology of Bitcoin has been incredibly stagnant and that is you know potentially one of the one of the strengths of it as a system. It's been battle tested over that. How long is it now? Like 17 years. God, that's making me feel really old. But it's it's been battle tested over a very long time. It hasn't changed a huge amount. Obviously, there's been there's been big changes in implementation from a kind of philosophical perspective, you could say.
But in terms of the bare nuts and bolts of how it works, not a huge amount has changed. It's retained crucially the same proof of work mechanism for securing that consensus and having the double spend uh prevention and things like that. So, you know, that's somewhat something has that is different to say an Ethereum which has changed its consensus mechanism to prove a stake. But it's crucially that community has changed drastically because no longer is it this small pool of kind of potentially anti-stake cipher punks that are that are developing and and um you know being proponents of Bitcoin.
as soon as it has you know I say as soon as maybe not as soon as it took a very very long time for it to gain kind of mainstream traction but now you know from like let's say 2015 1617 onwards as soon as it started hitting the mainstream the first few times with the big price spikes it's now been opening up that that pool to a much wider set of people who have I think you know pretty much solidified its status as a digital asset and and something to use as a store of value the whole digital gold narrative has kind of taken over from then and the cyber punks whether they like it or not I mean some of them love that um but the people who wanted to use it for online payments for all sorts of things they are kind of a little bit more stuck now I think >> yeah and I guess they love it because number go up right they got in early they probably were mining a
lot of the Bitcoin and they were at an all-time high and I've seen lots of say early Bitcoin adopters who are still working to innovate and have maybe moved from Bitcoin itself to say more innovative projects saying that a lot of the early big innovators have left web 3 generally because they made a crap ton money and you know they can just go live on an island now happily and get out of the system and maybe that's because they saw what was going to happen when the big institutions got in there and they wouldn't be able to compete anymore.
I think another thing we have to think about is that the early network would could be maintained from you could be a validator with a laptop, right? That is not possible anymore. Like the hash power involved in Bitcoin is crazy. Like you need entire hash farms, you need entire institutions. These are heavily regulated companies and they are the ones that determine and vote on how things are upgraded or if things are not upgraded as are often seen with Bitcoin. So yeah, I think it is interesting to see how the community's changed and you know it's kind of necessitated that but like you say a big point there is it has stagnated things haven't changed and that might be part of the angle.
Gold doesn't change so you don't really want digital gold necessarily to change but in 2008 the demands of the network were very light touch right there was no demand for transactions. There was no demand for throughput but now we're in a very different scenario where blocks are constantly being filled. Maybe there is demand and a need to expand, but they decided not to because digital gold does not need that. >> Yeah. And I think you you've touched on a really important point that I want to, you know, make sure we expand out here is that Bitcoin is not being institutionalized now for the first time.
I would very much argue that it's been institutionalized for a very very long time. The two main sets of institutions being the miners or nodes and then uh crypto exchanges as well. Right? So these are two classes of companies, businesses that have sprung up over the last decade. You know, as early as I'm sure 2015 16, you had the first kind of fully uh legitimate corporate entities that were doing these massive mining operations that you're talking about, right? So for a long time, the number of actual block producers on Bitcoin has been very small in any given time.
Right? is there's only a handful of say like 8 to 12 or something that are actually producing the blocks in any kind of short given time period. So in a in a way those are the institutions that have institutionalized bitcoin for a very very long time. The crypto exchanges are kind of the other side of that where they were not so much about institutions at the network level and maintaining the blockchain. But then they were the ones providing the bridge for people to uh you know actually buy, hold, sell, transfer these assets, right?
So your your wallets to to a lesser extent because a lot of those have been open source. Um but then the exchanges which have kind of become the deacto wallets for most people, right? Like a lot of people just custody their assets uh like Bitcoin now with the exchanges. So these have been around for a very very long time. Um the dream of a kind of highly highly decentralized uh Bitcoin I think has not been around for a long time in practicality. And then what we're talking about now in 2024 25 is this next wave of institutions and how they institutionalize say access to Bitcoin or the Bitcoin supply and and and things like that.
So kind of almost like second order institutionalization. I don't know if that uh makes sense Alec but I'm just kind of I'm just falling. That's what I'm thinking. It it does make sense when like I I think when I think about like the institutionalization of Bitcoin for me it's about the ability for it's a you can think about it from the network capacity like okay are validators and network administrators for bit bitcoin distributed and decentralized enough that if say eight of them go down or most of them go down the network can still run if a bomb goes off in a certain location like the US can Bitcoin still carry on technically and then the other side is the power dynamics So right now when I think of the problems of institutionalization of Bitcoin, it's the pressure that big institutions say single entities like a black rockck for example or a US government could apply to Bitcoin network more generally all the validators involved to actually make changes that don't necessarily suit the network but
suit the you know the higher up institutions themselves. That's kind of I think that the two angles but what you said there makes a lot of sense to me. I realize we've been talking 17 minutes and we actually haven't touched on like the the pros and cons and I think it's probably time that we jumped into it. Should we start with the pros because there definitely are a lot of pros to this. Obviously the the big one is number go up, right? A lot of people that invested early on and are in Bitcoin specifically.
It's mostly an investment piece for returns rather than using Bitcoin for daily life. I would say that quite generally. Maybe I'm speaking a bit too broadly there. Another one I think which is a bit more important is and I know you love this Jack is regulation regulatory clarity like this is demanded by institutions investors like the idea of say the validators the miners the people involved in the network kind of operating to a higher standard like not being nefarious being operating with clean money potentially maybe being transparent with the business operations like Coinbase is a great example of an exchange where they have to say prove their liquidity prove that the people they're hiring are operating the right way.
They're not doing anything nefarious. I think that's obviously a great thing to bring to Bitcoin and crypto as a whole is these big organizations that are accountable and are accountable to a higher standard by say governments, institutions, and retail users. >> Yeah, I 100%. I think for me it comes back to you know in the lifetime of Bitcoin it could have failed and died at a number of different periods and points in time, right? it could have failed as a project many many times over over the last 17 years.
Um and part of that process of you know it still being a living breathing thing right now is to convince the institutions that it should be taken seriously. It could in theory have been regulated out of existence. Um, I'm glad it hasn't been because I think, you know, that would have been potentially an overstep and I, you know, especially given you're seeing how much value lots of the institutions now see in Bitcoin, I think this was the, you know, the right move, but it's it's important to acknowledge that could have happened.
Um, and kind of the broader point for me is I I don't think Bitcoin could ever have existed if it wasn't willing well, it couldn't have existed in 2025 if it wasn't willing to play ball with the existing world essentially, right? if it was going to be this complete, you know, separate entity that tried to, you know, run run itself by its own rules, you know, to an extent in in in the technology way, it kind of does that. And you're seeing now institutions try and almost mimic some of the ways that Bitcoin works in in things that they're now doing in establishing, you know, private networks and things like that or even um kind of permissioned consorcia of these blockchain adjacent uh networks and structures.
Um, but yeah, my point being I don't think there was ever a scenario where Bitcoin would be here in 2025, let alone 2050 if it wasn't going to be, you know, playing playing alongside existing infrastructure. And, you know, nor nor should it ever have tried, I think, because that's part of the core, you know, that value proposition that we talked about of Bitcoin originally, a huge part of that is the word permissionless, right? It means there are there are no there are no um >> there are no restrictions on who can participate and that's one of the bedrocks of Bitcoin in my opinion maybe one of the biggest for you know the whole value proposition and that obviously then includes institutions you can't then say exclude a set of people whether they're corporate or you know individuals from participating so I think you know they're always going to be involved in some way and and I'm quite glad that they now are basically >> today's episode is sponsored by the Vchain Foundation.
Now, we often talk about how emerging technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and Vchain is at the forefront of this green movement with initiatives like Vet Dow. Let's take a closer look. Imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets. These verified records build a massive collective impact benefiting people through their own actions. Sound a bit complex, but Vchain made it fun. Explore our apps at vb better.com. Vchain's goal is to power a new era of sustainable solutions. So, if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for small sustainable actions every day, go check out vb better.com to find out more.
And now back to the show. >> Yeah, that makes sense. I think that's probably one of the reasons why I think this is always inevitable. Like as soon as a traditional finance company took note of say Bitcoin, they were always going to invest very heavily and because traditional finance has all the money or they would have had all the money at the time, then they can invest heavily and take over the network as we're seeing in a lot of ways like not take over in a bad way but like start to influence and maybe take ownership of a lot of large parts of the network.
I think on the regulation point as well like there are good like a lot of people are kind of anti-regulation. I think there are there are good points to that as well. Like a lot of crypto is obviously not like maybe more than traditional finance but it's more detectable and definitely more in the media is used for illicit funds can be used for you know terrorism and all these types of things. So it's quite good that we are seeing say networks crack down like a good example is tether.
Tether's frozen 2.9 billion in illicit funds cooperating with like over 275 law enforcement agencies. Yeah, we've obviously had like loads of examples from, you know, years and years ago at this point. I remember there being a case in around 201920 where you get these big crossjurisdictional task forces that work together to and have closed down you crime rings doing you know really heinous crimes the kind of thing you can't really even say on on YouTube without uh you know having to bleep it out so I won't bother but really terrible crimes these rings doing them and they you know making the false assumption that they could use Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies to you know fund that and skirt around it and and essentially That's a that's a really good case where the institutions both the kind of traditional ones the kind of law makers and regulators and in law enforce have worked together with the kind of new breed of in cryptospecific institutions like your exchanges because those are the kind of choke points you
can use to stop the flow of funds right especially you know when you have things like stable coins as well as you mentioned tether I think I think it's a really good thing because again you you in order to play ball with the existing world and to not be regulated out of existence you need to make sure that you know people are cooperating to stop crime ultimately or at least to make the best effort to stop crime. There's no way you're you're going to stop all crime uh crypto or otherwise, right?
Um and again on the regulation point, I think I that's very important all that kind of side of things you mentioned. But crypto has been of such a wild west for so long now and it's just kind of for me that that phase is just starting to end or at least I thought it was until certain kind of recent events around uh certain meme tokens and things like that. But there's been numerous cases right where things have collapsed, end users have lost out. There's been plenty of scams going on in the space and I think the regul the regulation catching up now and helping you know provide legitimate protections for users that are pretty much getting to on par with the existing financial world is is only a good thing really.
>> Yeah, I agree with that. Especially when you think about say some of the new characteristics that are brought up with blockchain technology and bit Bitcoin specifically is like the immutability. Once something happens, it's very very difficult to then make it unhapp. You send a transaction from A to B. If that's the wrong person, there's no real recourse for B to send that money back. But when we start to bring institutions, maybe some people will be opposed to the idea of KYC and maybe a Coinbase KYCing their users.
But if I all of a sudden know who B is and I can prove that that transaction should have happened, Coinbase can apply pressure to say B to send that money back to A and that is only a good thing in most cases like 99% of cases. I think another big good a big strong reason for having this institutional adoption is use cases like enterprise use cases on boarding like there are so many use cases that are enabled through institutional adoption of crypto and bitcoin like most enterprises if we think of them as institutions wouldn't touch this stuff unless there was clear regulatory involvement if there wasn't like black rocks and micro strategy all pushing into this space like you think of one of the most like widely used example of blockchain for a given use case is a supply chain, right?
Supply chain, supply chain, supply chain that involves many countries cross jurisdiction, you know, from farmers in the field to institutions and enterprises with 100,000 plus people. That is not possible when you have this kind of like edge case Bitcoin being passed from person to person. You need be institution enterprises hardware across every aspect of that supply chain for it to work. And there are so many different use cases that blockchain can be applied to. Whether that is crypto specifically, but also digital identity. We're talking about AI a lot, healthcare, like blockchain is so much bigger than just Bitcoin.
And without institutional adoption of these things, there's so many use cases that would never have been even talked about or discussed, but we are starting to see them be addressed with blockchain. It's still very early doors. They're not widely spread right now, but in the next 5 to 10 years, because of this regulatory clarity, because of institutions moving into the space, I'm hoping we'll see use cases outside of finance that can be solved using blockchain technology. >> Yeah, I I think that's really important because yeah, when you said use cases, I was getting ready for you to to load into the almost the financial sector use cases, which maybe we can cover after, but you're 100% right.
Like when we talk about Bitcoin, we should not limit ourselves to just the financial instrument side. You can you can use Bitcoin in so many interesting ways as a settlement layer for data essentially, right? As as you were describing with that supply chain, IoT there are hundred and hundreds of use cases. Um, one of my favorite ones or you know examples of of where this this point is being proven is when I think some some researchers from Microsoft were looking at how do we build a really good digital identity system.
Uh they I think it was called the side tree protocol. they originally went for and eventually became a W3C approved standard or vetted standard. Um they they were using Bitcoin as a settlement layer for your digital identifiers there, your DIDs. So it was a natural choice for them. I think the proof of work aspect of Bitcoin was also playing a role there, right? And that's something you shouldn't forget, I think, is that that that that the fact that Bitcoin still uses proof of work makes it arguably the gold standard for data settlement, right?
Because it's so much harder to rewrite records. Um but yeah but that's that's not to say anything of the myriad financial specific use cases that a lot of the institutions we're talking about are now themselves talking about. So you know improving on remittances for example payment versus delivery just cutting you know minor pain points out of the existing financial services uh world there are so many sources of inefficiency you know not least the fact that these things don't operate 24/7 whereas Bitcoin is is offering a new method to do things in a you know a 247 365 uh fashion.
So I think that's some of the stuff that I've seen a lot of the institutions actually talking about which to me is is is financial innovation that wouldn't have happened without Bitcoin as well. >> I think even on that point you can't decouple even like the data aspect of Bitcoin or whatever crypto you're using from the financial aspect as well. It's the very fact that we have these kind of financial incentives built into Bitcoin for miners, validators to maintain the network that makes it such a great way to store data and to have these DIDs that you know otherwise could be lost.
Like what's the incentive if a country goes down to store that did? There is no but if a validator goes down, there's 10 other validators that are willing to jump into that network to maintain the entire history, maintain that because there's a financial incentive that eventually a transaction might be generated and they'll get a fee as a result of that. So yeah, there's a lot of there's a lot of good pros for Bitcoin. I think one of the obvious ones like we said is institutional Bitcoin means all-time highs number goes up.
It also I think like another side of that is less volatility. Now this is one of the reasons why a lot of institutions enterprises haven't gone into Bitcoin is because historically it has been so volatile and that has been you know on the one side because there's very little liquidity. So, you know, big moves, you know, small moves, sorry, make big influences on the entire market. But it's also the type of users like retail users maybe are a bit more short-sighted, looking for snipes, short-term gains, all this kind of stuff.
But retail, sorry, institutional investors think much longer term. So, it's the 5 to 10 year play. They're not going to pull out just because someone said, "Oh, Bitcoin is going to go to zero tomorrow." They tend to have big research teams. They make decisions quite lethargically, but they are long-term decisions. So again, institutional adoption, less volatility probably means more institutional >> Yeah. And I think one one thing that is worth pointing out that I often forget is in terms of market cap, I've just double checked now, but Bitcoin is currently sitting sixth in terms of all assets on Earth by market cap.
Right? So only above it are Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, and gold. And gold is kind of way out in front. But now Bitcoin is bigger as an asset class than both Alphabet, the company, and silver, right? So these are these are huge you know entities commodities and the volatility of Bitcoin now looks much more like a big stock or share than you know what it used to like a small cap investment years and years ago which could go crazy like Bitcoin is still moving plenty but it's much more in line with the kind of volatility you would normally expect to see in the financial markets.
Um and yeah that's that's that purely as a result I'm sure of the um the market cap growth it's had in the last few years and the stability you're talking about. everywhere. Jack's got one of those graphs that you see all the investors have open with like 20 screens, number goes up, arrows >> Yeah, analysis every day. >> We've talked about a lot of the positives. Let's go into some of the negatives because there are some and I think, you know, it's not just the the cipher funks, joking, cyber cipher punks that are talking about this.
I do agree with a lot of this stuff. One of the obvious ones is the centralization of supply and control. Like we said around 10% of the current Bitcoin supply is now held by big institutions. And what does that mean? Like it it obviously means like influence in a lot of ways. Like if you have say a government with a large it's like the same with companies, right? When someone owns like a large share of a company, they have an influence in that company's direction. I think of it in a lot of ways in the same as Bitcoin.
If you have at the end of the day it's the validators who determine what happens on the network what the upgrades are but they are beholden to the users and the holders of Bitcoin like they don't want to see people pull out of their network and go to a competitor which is like it's a real possibility in a lot of ways. So if say someone owns 10% of the entire network and they say jump, like these validators may not jump, but they're going to take note of what the command is, right?
And I think that influence isn't necessarily a good thing. Like I would prefer if the influence was held by many different parties probably than a few individuals. It's like what's the phrase? It's like a good dictator will do more than democracy, but a bad dictator will ruin everything. So it's like you don't have these corrective mechanisms when you only have a few centralized controlling parties, which is a bit of a concern. Yeah, this is an interesting one because I I think I have a slightly differing view but not completely.
Um I don't like I don't have an innate problem with centralization of cryptocurrencies holding in particular because I think this is just a function of capitalism. Every asset class is pretty heavily centralized. It's not necessarily worse in that way. And actually what you mentioned there about you know the the separation between miners and holders of the asset is is something that Bitcoin has over potentially you know other asset classes um you traditional assets uh which which does mean the power to make decisions can reside a bit further away from those people who hold them right maybe not true of all cryptocurrencies um so I I think that's a really good thing in in favor of Bitcoin but crucially I think Bitcoin is in a unique position amongst the whole set of crypto assets on this point because I agree with you for 99% of assets it's a big problem who controls most of the supply because you know especially when you talk about institutions they can effectively become the kingmakers I think of what gets
adopted what become the household names or or the major kind of adopted assets I think bitcoin has such a specific unique story and has set its stall out so uniquely as the OG uh digital gold now and that's that narrative is so strong amongst the public not just the institutions that I think there there will be no king maker of whether or not Bitcoin succeeds I think it's already reached that threshold of kind of snowballing um but I agree for other asset classes or other cryptocurrencies then which institutions choose to you know use it adopt it custody it that's going to have a huge and probably outsized impact on which ones survive which may may also be a good thing because you want the good ones to survive you want the ones the risk and compliance Yeah, you want competition and you want the best of the best to survive for whatever criteria that is.
But yeah, I understand the concern as >> Yeah, I'm thinking about this separation of validators and say asset owners. Is that unique? Like if I think of someone that owns gold, do they influence how gold is mined? Probably not. Maybe they do indirectly. I think that is there something unique about say the black rocks of the world and their control over say what should happen on the network? like is there an influence there where Black Rockck which doesn't have any doesn't necessarily have much of a clue about how Bitcoin works and there's no guarantee they have technical understanding of the impacts of say a network upgrade should they have that influence there and I'm unsure how I feel about it for some reason it feels weird but you are right that that is just all systems that capitalism kind of tends towards centralization I I guess like maybe the promise of Bitcoin and web 3 was that that would be stopped like there wouldn't be that that would empower individuals and reduce the likelihood of
centralization, but maybe that's just always going to happen. >> Yeah, and I also think so. Yeah, it's a very this is a very nuanced point and I think there are ways to argue both ways and it I definitely concede that. Um I'm just thinking in terms of the the worry being I think the worry would be okay how much decision-making power will the asset holders have in how the system changes and operates in the future. And I don't have a huge worry that the financial institutions will want to change Bitcoin too much because it it does what it says on the tin from the perspective of most institutions.
It works as a good asset class. Um there's high demand for it. You can do interesting things with it. And I don't think an asset that is in the top uh five or six now of market cap you expect to change on like a fundamental level. So I don't think there's going to be too much positioning for that. Um but yeah, it's it's still an interesting question like maybe something big did need to change in the future then you know how do those holders get involved especially if they're not currently contributing to anything to do with the infrastructure of the network or the mining like how do they become you know go from zero to one to make those decisions in the future like that would be interesting to see >> I guess like yeah to be like give a more specific example we look at tether and tether is obviously like this web 2.5 solution it's run by a very centralized private entity so they are very different in that sense but we talked
about say some of the illicit funds that have been frozen like this is happening more and more as they become say more institutionalized and regulated. Could you imagine a world in which say I don't know a government pressures Bitcoin miners say they have 65% of the total hash power in their country and as we said these hash farms are becoming more and more regulated because they are huge institute huge enterprises now with a large investment that can't just move around the world say similar to Ethereum proof ofstake networks could you imagine a world in which a government puts pressure on those miners those validators to say not allow certain >> yeah I I I I think I can.
Um, and I think I think the one of my, you know, this is a very very difficult question to answer. I think it's one of the big political answer for Bitcoin. Yeah. No, I I think I think it is a great question. Give me 10 minutes about the answer. >> Yeah. Well, you know, I wish I had some notes. Um, it is one of the hardest questions to solve because Yeah, you're right. As soon as you allow things like freezing at the the protocol base level of Bitcoin, then you know a you have a jurisdictional problem because Bitcoin is global.
How do you enforce that on some and not others? And how do you also enforce that without kind of causing your nodes in your own country for example to become non-competitive uh or or you know cease to be used essentially. Um my my gut feeling is that the threshold for protocol level things will be incredibly high and that seiz forfeiture and seizure and that kind of thing freezing of assets at like the Bitcoin level. You know, we've already got a lot of evidence of it happening.
So much has been seized in criminal cases. I don't know the exact numbers. I'm pretty sure it's in the tens if not hundreds of millions at this point. Um UK actually I think is leading in the stats. people think that the US government holds the most, but I believe it's the UK has seized the most. Um I think I saw someone speaking about that recently. Um but yeah, so I think a lot of it can be done at a second order, second layer um thing and I don't necessarily think there'll be huge appetite to enforce that at the base layer in the future, but if it ever needed to be, yeah, it's hard.
I think on that kind of the second layer like another thing we're seeing with this kind of I guess is another rise is custodial dominance is that 80% of new crypto users in 2025 are coming into the space via custodial services your coin bases your PayPals your Robin Hoods mainly because like they know how to interact with users they've got all the money they've got all of the user base already and they're just offering these additional services to their user base that's very keen they've got the super streamlined UX all of that abstraction of you know managing private keys that most people don't want to touch and self- custody is declining making you know I guess the system a bit more vulnerable to those off-chain controls you talked about the freezes and the seizures and on the one hand you could say well that was an early promise of this technology was the fact that we didn't need to rely on central entities and we did have like you know cash as we do now
that was one of the I guess the main promises of this but like you said the the other side of that the flip side of that is that means that if there there is someone doing criminal activity and you can prove it then you know a second layer company can get involved freeze your assets and you should do go to jail on that money is returned and that is obviously a good thing and you know I'm very glad that a lot of custodians are doing that >> yeah and um I I agree it's it is a difficult choice to be made between whether you're going to custody them with an institution or not um I think again crucially for me there's nothing being enforced either way and I don't think ever it will be enforced either way.
Maybe that's a place where the centralization of the asset could cause an issue because if all the asset is residing in the hands of very few, then how do you get on boarded to self- custody to start with? Well, you have to go and get it from one of those. But, you know, most of the big exchanges will still let you offboard and self- custody if you want. Like Coinbase are pretty good at letting you self- custody. Obviously, you're taking on more risk as an individual, but that's kind of that's always going to be there, I think, is how much uh how much you willing to where's the bigger risk for you.
Is it institutional risk or is it individual personal security risk? Um but yeah, I don't think there'll ever be one of those options available. I think it'll always be both the way things are going. And to me, you know, I a lot of the pro for me the biggest issue and I say issue, you know, very very cautiously, but my only kind of downside that I really care about with the institutional institutionalization of of crypto generally is that it signals a little bit of a death of the exciting the old guard of of Bitcoin and crypto.
Um, I think ultimately, you know, Bitcoin may have been even more valuable as a digital gold that, you know, also functioned as a payment system, but I don't think it's ever going to recover to to be that now. And all the payment side of things will probably be subsumed by second layers. And it'd be great. It's great that we will have the payment side attached to Bitcoin, but I think it would have been strictly better if it could have all been done at the base layer.
And I just I think this what we're seeing in the last couple of years signifies the death of that dream. But maybe it was always maybe it was always too much to dream of. And you know I'm just hope wishful thinking there. >> Yeah, I think that you are right in that because we now have this narrative of safe digital gold that institutions clearly favor. That is what's going to happen. Like it's kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy. But the innovation won't happen on Bitcoin. We're seeing the innovation happen elsewhere.
And although all the market cap is going towards Bitcoin, actually I think Ethereum versus Bitcoin is actually the highest it's ever been in like the last couple of weeks. Um, which is great to hear because there's a lot more innovation happening on those kind of like altcoins and Ethereum versus Bitcoin. Um, it is sad in a lot of ways and like I say, I think I've read a lot of things about the early innovators of Bitcoin either completely leaving the web three web3 space because they felt disenfranchised and you know the vision's gone obviously they've made a huge amount of money so they don't need to work anymore or move into these completely separated projects and trying to innovate there because they don't have that big institutional pressure to not touch something that ain't broken.
I think overall I am very maybe I haven't seemed it but I am very pro institutional adoption of Bitcoin. I think they are a player. I think they're accelerating the retail users and general usage of this because they've got the money, because people trust the brands. my mom isn't going to touch Bitcoin anytime soon, but if her bank says, you know, this is a great investment, we'll do it on your behalf, then she's much more likely to go into that space and not get all the characteristics like the complete self-custodial aspects, but get some of the characteristics like the fact that, you know, as an asset, it is going to acrue value because there's only a limited supply like she isn't going to be absolutely ruined by constant printing of fear and all these kind of hyperinflation things we see with the traditional financial system.
Um, and also a big thing is custodians do protect users in a way that self-custodial uh, wallets do not. And you know, this happened to me recently. I know Jack, you know this, but I'll talk a little bit about it hopefully in next week's episode when things can go really wrong and people can lose assets and you do feel completely powerless. And these custodians because of regulation or because of you know their kind of sympathy for users or whatever it is they really do add a lot of value for users protecting them helping them supporting them all this kind of stuff and yeah I'll talk a little bit more about it next week but overall I think it is a good thing institutions move into the space but I want retail to also exist and not to be like 99.9% is owned by institutions and the 0.1 is owned by you know normal people like you and me.
Yeah, and I I also think just to you know, you know, my position, I think it's pretty clear I'm very I'm very pro-institutional adoption. Um I think there will be an equilibrium reached anyway between how much of this is, you know, fully institutionalized and how much of it is retail focused, self-custody, etc. because the value proposition of Bitcoin is strictly less if you go too far one way or the other. I think um I've always thought of Bitcoin as you know it's a credible viable alternative to traditional money, traditional assets.
Now um yeah, I I I hope we do see improvements in the in the use of, you know, Bitcoin for payments. Uh how they do that, you know, I'm not sure. But ultimately, if you're willing to to sacrifice enough of of of your wealth in fees at the end of the day, if you're desperate to use Bitcoin, it probably will always be usable to in some degree. So like you know you will always have the option to transact on chain if you're willing to pay enough or wait long enough.
Um it's just obviously not going to be practical for the kind of things we hoped it might be. But yeah that's where the innovations happening elsewhere. And I think it'd be interesting to see how many of those those other chains where we are seeing that kind of you know the microp payment style innovation used for small transactions the actual money of the internet dayto-day. Um it be interesting to see if if you know if we get two or three of them survive and work in the future that will also be because of institutional backing.
I think if they do survive. So yeah it be interesting to just see if we if we do get any and if so which they are. So the dream isn't dead but maybe it's just happening elsewhere other than BTC. Um yeah I guess thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed our little episode on institutional adoption and what it means for web 3. And join us next time to untangle a little more of web
Topics: Blockchain & Crypto