Episode 68

Bitcoin Mining with Kurt Wuckert Jr.

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

Join us in this episode of Untangling Web3 to explore the intricate world of Bitcoin mining with expert Kurt Wuckert Jr.

This episode delves into the critical aspects of Proof of Work, providing a detailed examination of its mechanics, sustainability, and future trajectory in the blockchain ecosystem.

Key Highlights

  • Deep Dive into Proof of Work. Kurt explains the technicalities of the Proof of Work process, emphasizing its role in validating transactions and maintaining the security and integrity of the Bitcoin blockchain.
  • Economic Impacts of Mining. The discussion expands on the financial aspects of mining, including the cost of electricity and hardware, and how these factors influence the profitability and geographic distribution of mining operations.
  • Environmental Concerns and Solutions. Kurt addresses the environmental concerns associated with Bitcoin mining, particularly focusing on energy consumption. He discusses the industry's efforts to move towards more sustainable practices, including the adoption of renewable energy sources within mining operations.
  • Regulatory Landscape and Future Outlook. Insights into how changing regulations across the globe could impact Bitcoin mining. Kurt also speculates on future developments in the mining technology and how it could evolve to become more energy-efficient and less centralized.

This episode offers a comprehensive look at Bitcoin mining through the lens of an expert, enhancing understanding of its complexities and the balance between technological advancement and environmental responsibility.

Kurt's insights provide valuable perspectives on the sustainability and future of Bitcoin mining, preparing us all for the challenges and innovations shaping this crucial area of the cryptocurrency sector.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of the entangling web 3 podcast today we're delighted to welcome back a friend of the podcast Kurt wer Jr now last time in episode 44 Kurt outlined the history of Bitcoin and we sidelined his other side hustle as a Bitcoin minor so today we've asked Kurt to wear his other hat as a minor and ask him about the economics of Bitcoin mining how it all works and where it's going to go in the future so Kurt without further Ado it's a pleasure to welcome you back to the show hey how you guys doing yeah not too bad and and I mean we we tried to get too much into the last episode and you can talk and it's s so interesting we didn't want to stop you and it just we kind of went down the rabbit hole of Bitcoin its history and it was so fascinating so we had to split you into a two-parter and today we're going to get into the world of Bitcoin mining which should be

extremely interesting and exciting to dive into yeah no I I honestly it's one of the one of my favorite appearances in the last year or so uh because most people don't want to take the time to kind of get all the way into it and so you get that surface level conversation of a few things and it's like well that's a curiosity but uh when you when you really take the time it really starts to be like wow that's there's there's a lot there so no I really had a lot of fun and I'm really glad to be back yeah I mean as style is when someone is as passionate and kind of knowledgeable as you are we just let you go and just don't try to get too involved but yeah today we're going to be talking about Bitcoin mining so let's just kick it off explain to me and Jack like we're 5 years old what is bitcoin mining what does it actually mean uh well here's another start to a two-hour question

um in the beginning M yeah there there you go um mining so mining is is simple but it's not easy right and and I think it's really important to uh to break it down into what's actually happening um in a very basic sense we are just competitive accountants and so when somebody broadcasts a transaction to the Bitcoin Network they they sit in a sort of limbo and people use a term called the mempool but it's actually not a monolithic uh unconfirm transaction set it is each individual computer on the network has its own unconfirmed transaction set and generally on well connected computers you should expect that to be near 100% the same on on every computer but when you have lots and lots of transactions it's less likely that they are going to be the same data set so what we are doing is that individually each computer that is quote unquote mining we're competing to reconcile transactions better faster cheaper than the other computers that are trying to do the same thing and if

we are so lucky to be the ones that do two things both confirm that all the transactions in our proposed block are valid Bitcoin transactions they haven't broken some fundamental rule of Bitcoin and if we have a efficient proof of work and we find a valid hash first then we get to propose the next block to the blockchain and so there's a lot going into each of those steps but that's the most basic thing is we're basically digital accountants in a NeverEnding competitive race to be the the next computer to add a reconciled block to the blockchain now I I don't know if you want to ask follow-up questions on each of those things or if you just want me to talk for another like 10 minutes on years old and you I'm five years old and you the accountant I got it the analogy there was perfect then you started talking about hashing cryptography all this kind of stuff and blocks I think we will get there but before we get there let's take

a step back why do people you know become miners what's the point of being a minor what do you need to do um I think most people become miners because they think it's going to be the easy way to get Bitcoins and if if it was 2009 that would be the case uh really up until like 20 2011 that would have been the case like okay download this software give some of my compute for my laptop or my gaming computer and cool I I get I get 50 Bitcoins every 10 minutes or you know in all likelihood there were less than a dozen miners in the whole world and so you'd get a few blocks a day at 50 Bitcoins each and they didn't they weren't worth anything but they it was cool basically um that still persists I still get people reach out to me like hey so I got this uh I got a pretty hot laptop can I mine Bitcoin with it and um you know I have to say like well

you know you've got about a a 10 billionth of a of a chance here uh given your given your difficulty but um so I think a lot of people they see that is the easy way to get Bitcoins and then pretty quickly they realize that is maybe the hardest way to get Bitcoins today and so then you get this whole other economy of things that's been built around you know Cloud mining or pooled mining or or some kind of other uh hosted thing but really mining for the most part is is kind of a big boys game today like if you're not sitting on like family office level money at the very minimum you probably shouldn't be in the mining game um now that's it really depends what you're mining so in Bitcoin BTC that that really is truly the case if you look at who's actually mining it is some of the biggest companies in the world at this point is companies that have between two and 10 billion dollar uh company valuations stuff

are competing for blocks on bitcoin BTC but uh but there are smaller variations there's lots and lots of other little blockchains that you can actually mine on your laptop and and that kind of thing but um you also have the opportunity to do hosted mining Solutions there's a few companies that have popped up over the years I think the oldest one is still in operation uh Genesis mining based out of uh I think they're Dutch and they have their infrastructure is in Iceland if I recall but um you know so they offer yeah buy an Asic will host it and you know when it when it fails you just have to trust us that it failed and you know sorry you're you're lost and that kind of thing it's a little bit of a weird business model uh but there's also companies like um Compass Mining and watm and some of these other companies that offer your sort of retail clientele but even even when I say retail now like they have five Asic minimums

and at five grand a piece we're still talking about $25,000 minimums which is more money than your typical hey I work a 9 to5 job I'm a regional manager at Target or something like those kind of guys don't typically have 25 Grand to kind of pitch at should I be a Bitcoin minor so even that is starting to really get away from your typical middle class citizen um but yeah I think people think it's going to be the easy way but but like I said all all that to say it's not that easy anymore uh and and it's becoming more and more difficult over time yeah I think that that's really highlighted by the start of your answer you're saying about home computers people mining in 2009 on their personal laptops and then you're talking about CL Cloud mining right which is a completely different ball game you also mentioned as6 right which are these dedicated bits of Hardware to do the hashing so just to kind of summarize then as it is today if

you're if you're a Bitcoin miner and we'll stay with Bitcoin and maybe we'll get into the differences of proof of work and proof of State mining later but if you're a proof of work mining Miner mining something like Bitcoin BTC then what what components are involved there because previously everything was happening on this laptop so it was doing all those things you mentioned about the the mle the transactions and validating and then you also bring in the hashing so is it the case that all these things are now split out into dedicated functions and how does that work with the various different types of miners you have right because you mentioned Cloud mining people might also have heard of mining pools and I know you're running a mining pool CT that we can get into later but what does it actually look like you know as a minor what does it look like to be one that what kind of setup do you need so unfortunately a lot of companies keep this information close to

the vest uh like it'd be nice to to know like hey how does ant pool work what what does their infrastructure actually look like and by and large we don't know um I can speak from my experience where essentially what we do is we're running uh what is monolithic node infrastructure so it's a Bitcoin node uh is basically doing this giant bucket of validating transactions and it's listening to the peer-to-peer Network it's receiving uh incoming and outgoing uh transaction data uh and whatever other data is is over over this network trying to figure out what it's supposed to do it's trying to stay in consensus it's it's checking all all the stuff that that a Bitcoin node should do and then there's this one aspect of mining that has been specialized out and broken out and that is the hashing now hashing is um it's funny because this is the part where capitalism has really taken over in Bitcoin and I think that eventually all of these other node functions will also be broken out

and specialized as well but uh hashing broke out I think it was 201 12 or 13 basically that the Chinese uh created Asic so this is a a very specific it does one thing it just looks for shotu 56 hashes very very efficiently and it is extremely inefficient at every other possible thing and so what it does it's going through a table of hashes and it's doing a guess and check it is simply saying is it this hash yes or no and if the answer is yes it proposes it to the network and says hey I found the valid hash did I find it first uh and if the answer is no it just checks the next one in in line so uh in in Computing you might call this a Brute Force tool so it is just guess and check that is literally all it's doing now uh the reasons it does that are economic it's a game theory thing um and there's been probably a million hours of podcasts and books written about

why proof of work and you know is it is it the greatest idea that you know was ever invented or is it extremely wasteful bad for the environment you know whatever else but uh we can get more into those specific details soon but but that's the really interesting thing that what we saw the incentives of Bitcoin do with What's called the block subsidy uh these are the quote unquote free Bitcoins that are given to people that uh successfully build blocks on the Chain uh you get this block subsidy it was 50 at the the beginning of Bitcoin it cuts in half every 210,000 blocks roughly four years uh today we're in the three and an eighth era of of Bitcoin and so every block if you successfully mine that block you get three and one8 Bitcoins per block and that's your incentive to mine or it's 99.9% of your incentive to mine uh there's also those ply little transaction fees that uh create that added um incentive but but what's actually going on is you

can run your Bitcoin node that is doing most of the the computational work on bitcoin itself and that actually really can run on a laptop in most situations mostly you just want to have a pretty good internet connection if you're proposing blocks quickly but um that that can be a very basic computer you could run that out of your home if you have gigabit in uh ethernet and you're in a first world country and you can buy a you know the kind of computer that you buy Modern at Best Buy you could sufficiently run a pool and build blocks off of that computer but your hashing operation is worldclass data center um in some cases in warehouses that you cannot see from one end to the other and you need to take a golf cart across the uh across the building and then and just a tremendous amount of uh electrical and networking equipment uh these are massive industrial uh buildings so uh there's a huge dichotomy in the yeah in what we see with

hey there's an incentive to do this particular ularly well uh and then you see what comes of that and then in BTC specifically it's like we're going to remove that incentive to scale this thing we're g to try to we're gonna we're gonna keep this small and like wouldn't you know it you could actually run it on a on an HP laptop so that's that's what that looks like in a very basic sense there's a a lot of little details that go into you know well why would you do it one way versus another and and again some of that is proprietary your big pools are not telling you what their stack looks like because it's part of their competitive advantage against the other big Global pools that makes sense and I think um you kind of you've touched on a few different topics there that I'd like to jump into in more detail so one is the idea of I think someone explained like Bitcoin or one of the main benefits of Bitcoin to

me a really kind of layman terms as you know previously we had trust in entities everything online was around trust in entities people stamping us knowing the brands all this kind of stuff and one of the things that Bitcoin did was really remove that trust in entities and removed it to a trust in hash or compute and then you let you say because of that there's been an absolute kind of battle to see who can provide the most hash the most compute to be the most trusted and the person that's getting the most transactions on bitcoin but then like you say it's kind of hard to get into that space because they're dominated by these big players that are like billion dollar companies right now um so then like we look at Alternatives that are out there like a big movement in the last few years has been this idea of moving away from proof of work in some on some networks and moving towards proof of stake and you know take ethereum for example

they have tens of thousands of what they call validators no no longer miners because miners isn't maybe the sexy word anymore like what's your take on that how does that differ what does that mean for the networks do you think it's like a feasible thing to push forward what are the advantages disadvantages so it like a lot of things the the actual issue is more philosophical than it is technical you get a lot of people that want to turn everything into a technical conversation and say well you know the math says and and it's not really that kind of thing uh so the actual problem that proof of work solves goes goes back way before Bitcoin about about 20 years before Bitcoin uh it's kind of the problem with uh spam uh spam email uh Just Junk basically what is junk data um for for people who don't know there's something like 10 trillion emails a day are sent around the internet like it's an absurd amount of of stuff but over 90% of it

is garbage it's stuff that you you not only won't read but you don't want to read and you don't want to SI through and so there were a few people that worked on this issue starting in the 90s you had Mo neor and Cynthia dwar uh who who wrote I think the first proof of work white paper they're both computer scientists basically talked about um how do we create some kind of an opportunity cost for people to send an email and essentially make it that your mailbox will not receive an email unless there is a sufficient amount of proof of work making it that it's very easy it is essentially free to send an email or an important email to somebody that you know but it becomes very impractical IAL for monetary reasons uh to to spam people so it sucks to send 10,000 emails and so you you knock that back uh heavily and uh you know make it that it's only for Roi now you also have the same kind of thing essentially

uh Adam back wrote uh 99% the same white paper about seven years later uh the hash cash white paper which he gets uh an incredible amount of credit for inventing even though he literally didn't invent the concept uh and then the first practical application of this was actually written by Hal finny uh who we know worked with Satoshi Nakamoto in Bitcoin looks like the first week of Bitcoin launching hfny um definitely was involved there's been uh some Theory and speculation that maybe he is Satoshi Nakamoto and or maybe worked with Satoshi before Bitcoin was launched and whatever so we don't really know uh how died a number of years ago um we we don't know uh Hal's whole history but but Hal wrote row I think he called the his white paper um that that solved this problem but but had a a practical implementation of software as well um although it never was released uh commercially or anything like that but he at least showed like hey no here's how this actually could and

should work but um sorry again for the history lesson but I love it what they were solving for there is basically there there's this problem in computer science with uh with trusting entities when you can't shake their hand physically right so this is they call it the Byzantine generals problem the way it's explained is okay so you have uh Invaders from banum the the old Constantine uh the the Christian Empire of Eastern Rome uh if you're trying to surround a city how how do you communicate without like a phone or or whatever so back then you'd have to send riders or birds or something but how do you know that the information you've received was not intercepted or tampered with in some way uh during that journey and the answer is you don't and so it's the same as the email issue so how do I make it that I only get the email that I want to get and so you make it that you only will receive information if it has sufficient proof

of work so if somebody is willing to do this absurd thing it's like the secret handshake a little bit so it's like you know you and you and I are are speaking on opposite sides of the Atlantic Ocean right now and we trust that our internet connection is secure we're not being monitored by the NSA even though we probably are and then you know some of these other things here but but what if we had you know a secret like we you know we we do some special winking and blinking here so we know that like okay now I'm actually telling you the truth right now and that's our secret code that we have shared previously that has not been said over a communication Channel and therefore when we see the secret signal okay this is trustworthy information and I should presume everything that happened before it was a lie and so people have come to worship this concept of proof of work and and that that has made it super distorted as to what

it is actually uh doing and what it's for um a conclusion that I came to a couple years ago just thinking about it was that the Byzantine generals think about what a Byzantine General is so these are guys that would have come up in the ranks in the Byzantine Army these are guys that would have fought and bled together uh and frankly they' become generals because a they trust each other and B they're really good at fighting wars together and so they have survived long enough and accumulated enough experience to be generals now and they don't have a trust problem they have a trust in Communications problem and so if they could communicate directly if they were standing in a room together they would not struggle to trust each other's opinions and that kind of thing they they can't trust the rider in between or or the note hasn't been tampered with and so what we're trying to solve in Bitcoin is how can I trust that this is a valid transaction that it isn't

malicious in some way that it hasn't broken the rules that it's uh like wasn't built in some way to uh either destroy the network or trick me into accepting an invalid payment and you know there's a bunch of other things that it it solves here but ultimately proof of work is it's a it's an opportunity cost it is that wink or that handshake or that that thing that takes the place of hey we actually trust each and we have Rapport it replaces all of that makes it that going from okay I probably shouldn't trust this thing and it makes it that somewhere approaching 99.9999% I probably should trust this transaction that's really all that it's doing there makes sense now the the problem is that because Bitcoin is competitive uh that that competitive difficulty makes it that the consumption to create that piece of trust that piece of proof of work has become extremely expensive and that starts to introduce a new trust problem in that okay if only a billionaire or a Consortium of

Corporations and Millionaires and financial Titans can participate in this trust why should I trust them at this point right and so so you do have a little bit of an economic problem here with uh you know you're creating this new level of centralization you know I I don't trust Larry and Jamie Diamond and the kind of people that have invested into things like Foundry pool or ant pool so so you start to have a new trust problem that that has been created here uh and then you also have this massive consumption issue which uh you know consumption of electricity is unfortunately a very divisive political issue and so you you get the your sort of environmentalist contingent saying like Okay why why would we be spending all this money on creating this trust isn't there a more energy efficient way to create trust and and so they've created proof of stake now what proof of stake does is instead of burning a ton of energy to convey a trustworthy message it is simply you should

trust my message based on how much of the asset that I hold and it's much more easy from an energy consumption level but that also has its own trust issues because just because you're rich doesn't mean we should trust you it's actually the same problem we have with uh with with trusting a giant pool is like well which which cabal of Bankers own this pool right and it's the same thing it's which cabal of Bankers own ethereum validators and so we actually did solve this problem with Bitcoin Bitcoin solved a problem but it but it created a spillover effect of new problems that we need to solve and and yeah those Solutions probably aren't uh technological um and I I think I said it 20 minutes ago but most probably are social um and and so if if we can simplify a problem and solution and make it that people can understand okay what is the trust model um and and what is my risk model because again we're just trying to be better than

previous things it doesn't have to be perfect I think this is actually why we have 20,000 blockchains that all do very slight variations of what the other one does because well that blockchain isn't perfect and damn it I'm going to build a perfect one and and that's really a big problem like we need to be okay with a you know maybe 25x Improvement on what existed 10 years ago because we've approached 99 point you know 99999 out to like six decimal places like we're that close to perfect and damn it that's okay uh but that's it's not really okay for uh your typical neurode Divergent computer science uh type who wants to say like no if I just come up with better math and better software and better what like I I can make this an actual perfect system and sorry yeah and it's led to that exact situation that you explained ra thousands of different blockchains and there are hundreds of different consensus protocols because proof of work is would be broadly described as

a consensus protocol it's how does that group of Byzantine generals reach consensus on you know which which thought to attack or something but in this case it's which block to add to the blockchain and then proof of stake was kind of inspired but then said oh we need to change things because of the energy cons or whatnot and then there are you know hundreds more now but you know just going back to your description of proof of work I really really liked how you described it because I think that makes it more tangible and for anyone who hasn't heard of this email proof of work problem right the fact that there was there were these little proof of work challenges associated with emails to stop spam that basic idea of having to essentially having what people call a costly signal right you have to put some level of cost into sending that spam email or that email to prove that you that there is some cost because if there's no cost associated with it then

you can just Spam there's there's zero cost to replicate there's zero cost to do this millions and billions of times if you don't think this is a problem then look at you know the proliferation of bots and fake accounts on Twitter that's because it's effectively free to use right that's the kind of analogy and then one thing we should touch on about again sticking with proof of work and what H what what the innovation of Bitcoin really is we touched on it last time but I think personally it's very much around the difficulty adjustment algorithm right so that little problem that you're adding to the email that little challenge that is a very low difficulty challenge right because you don't want to stop all emails there might be some useful ones and you're not going to you're not going to get one of these special devices and compute these things every time to send an email so the difficulty of passing that challenge is very low but in Bitcoin the difficulty of passing the challenge

I.E of creating a valid block is dynamic so it's not fixed and that's that that is essentially if I'm right the reason that we have these big mining operations now right is because the difficulty of adding new blocks is always changing and it's based on that competition element that you said right so it's that combination of making it adjustable and then also having people compete to add these blocks right that that then introduces a block difficulty that has gradually increased over time and is always changing is that is that roughly the reason why you think these are happened correct yeah so so Satoshi Nakamoto is brilliant in setting a few variables that are always targeted uh one of them is the 10-minute block so if if you add a lot of hash power quickly that block time will speed up but when it speeds up the network is designed to raise the difficulty of building blocks such that it achieves an average of 10 minutes at any difficulty so even if you added all of

the compute in the world to pick coin uh there would be some time where blocks would be fast but but the difficulty would would change and it would slow that block time back to 10 minutes so it's always trying to achieve that 10-minute window um now that does a few things it it makes it that you know even if you had some you know Quantum breakthrough that kind of thing everybody's always ah Quantum Computing is gonna break Bitcoin and it's like no not really that's just that's not how that works but um it's it's designed to make it that immediately or or very very quickly the network heals from any situation it also can heal from you know hey we've had a global internet outage or or whatever else which is something we actually just experienced with this crowd strike hack um or or whatever it was some kind of some kind of high level cyber incident and yeah so I mean let's say half the hash power in the world is kicked offline for

some reason well all of a sudden blocks will be slow for a little while but but then difficulty we will adjust down sufficiently such that your block time comes back to a 10 so um so Toshi Nakamoto uh gave us a very smooth predictable uh function here that that you can always assume that it's roughly 10 minutes between blocks except under extreme circumstances but those extreme circumstances basically can't be permanent um they they they will adjust it is self-healing and then ultimately that's that's part of the the Brilliance but then there's also the fact that uh you also have this constant arms race which we're kind of seeing the The Fallout on um asex have gotten exponentially more efficient over time um but one of the one of the weird things that has happened is that difficulty has heavily outpaced profitability for a very long time it's we are uh mining right now at about a seven-year low in profitability because miners are able to make money doing all kinds of other things because they

are consuming so much energy that they've created this proximity to the energy sector that allows them to make big deals with very big energy companies which is an old money industry they're very tightly integrated into lots of other things so uh one of the ways is just simply like carbon offset credits or things like curtailment agreements like when you're the biggest consumer of electricity uh in a County uh the the power company May pay you not to consume electricity during times of high pressure on the grid and so uh so there's lots of weird ways to make money which means even if Bitcoin is telling you that you should be lowering the difficulty that you should be turning your minors off if you've got these other things going on in other aspects of your business it actually encourages you to keep raising the difficulty because you're making money on all this other stuff there's a whole other conversation to be had about like public traded mining companies that are also you know having incredible amount

of stock valuation uh or or Venture Capital that kind of thing like hey I need to hit these hash power targets just to get a new check from seoa next quarter and that kind of thing it's like okay that that that does throw the balance of bitcoin's Economics off quite a bit but um we're we're we're gonna see what happens there I think there is a there is some kind of an inflection point coming but it's it's a little bit unprecedented um there's two points that I want to like kind of dial in on there that kind of relate to a question I have so you've mentioned that you know Bitcoin is this what near perfect at least an improvement of a significant Improvement on what we had before but one of the spillover effects is the idea of you know the hashing power constantly upping and that requires a lot of energy so there's this growing sect of society saying that you know we shouldn't be using all this energy for something that maybe

doesn't have as much value as other things so kind of I kind of put myself in the position of it's not that we shouldn't be using energy like that's ridiculous that we obviously have to continue developing it's just that everything should have a cost benefit analysis where it's like okay how much energy we using how much benefit does that create and you know you could argue how beneficial is Bitcoin right now with hash par using and that's a whole separate argument the other thing that you talked about is profitability people using all this energy all this hash power and it not being as profitable being an absolute low right now so the kind of the combination of those two points is can we use the hash power this hash power that's just thrown to you know randomly compute these numbers for something useful I know I've seen some things out there but what have you seen around using the hash power currently that just outputs a hash you know using a random nons is there

anything that we could use that for in a more useful manner you this was proposed and and I've heard rumors of other sort of like home compute problems and that kind of thing that the problem is is that shot 256 hashing isn't really valuable for any other reason so it's it's good for cryptographically securing something but but but you can't turn it into like hey what if we use the extra compute for protein folding or like it just it doesn't it's not good for that so there's not really there's not really a spillover benefit to the actual compute um but but there is that value again in the electricity consumption like another one is like trapped gas for example so when you've got like oil exploration you have fracking which is Big political issue in the US I don't know if it's as much in in the EU or in the UK but um over here there's large swaths of this country that have oil companies that just they'll show up in an area and

they'll just start injecting just an incredible amount of like water down into the Shale and see if oil bubbles up and like it impacts the water table it impacts all kinds of things ecologically and then one of the spillover things that occurs is like oh if you do actually discover a pocket of natural gas for example now you have to vented which means you put in a big uh chimney basically that goes a few hundred feet into the ground and then I don't know 100 feet into the air or whatever and then you light it on fire and then it just sit burps gas into the atmosphere for 15 years 50 years like it it depends how big your gas bubble is that you've discovered now that's just a spillover cost of hey we need oil and oil is is what the economy runs on and so you just kind of have to have that and what Bitcoin mining has allowed you to do is say well that's just energy that's being pushed out into

the atmosphere for no reason it's not close to anybody because by its nature we're in some rural place where there you know there's not a large demand for energy within proximity but what you can do is you can put like a mining pod out there you can convert that gas uh using you know a generator essentially that turns a turbine creates electricity and you have a mining pod out in rural wherever you know Pennsylvania or Alberta Canada or somewhere in Texas um and now you're taking what would have just been pure cost uh both ecologically and just monetary it's just you know Exxon Mobile or whatever like I don't know we're just gonna burn a billion dollars worth of fuel and send it into the atmosphere for for whatever and and now there's opportunity to turn that into money like now that can be a profit Center in your business so that is that's a way that you can sort of repurpose Bitcoin as a way to take energy that would otherwise just be wasted

uh both ecological and monetary cost and turn it into hey uh we're now at least digesting that that fuel one more time we're releasing a uh perhaps less toxic gas as exhaust and we're turning into a potential profit Center in our business so yeah that is a way that you get an added spillover benefit from from hashing but uh as for the compute itself shot to 56 really is not good for uh doing almost anything else other than Ju Just Simply making a hash and so if you can find another way to make hashes as valuable or more valuable than Bitcoin hashes well power to you but but I don't know what those things are I hope that was a pun that you put all power to you in there pal but you know we'll skip over that one yeah I've heard I've heard the arguments on both sides right so as you put there using creative energy sources that would otherwise be wasted or cause a just a net negative and you know even

things like Surplus power in the grid right that might not be used and it's hard to store if you just collocate a minor somewhere at least you can earn some money from that for local government or something so I've heard that and I'm more convinced by that side of the argument than the other side potentially which says can we use the wasted energy of Bitcoin or other Pro work mining for things right because partly because most of that wasted energy is from heat right so it's very inefficient the as6 themselves get very hot you can kind of recycle some of that heat but it's not the most efficient way to do it you're not going to capture a huge amount of value listen C we've we we've had an hour and a half at least with you now and we have still failed to talk about you so I'm I'm determined we're going to do it okay so let's move on to Guerilla pool now okay so we mentioned before you you run your own

mining pool gorilla pool what does the pool mean in gorilla pool like what what is because we've heard this term mining pools what does that actually mean in practice how does it differ from solo mining setup in your eyes so so yeah when you when you have ashing and hashing becomes competitive now I'm I'm not a trust fund kid and I never worked at JP Morgan or Goldman Sachs and so I you know I I just never had that much money to to get into mining but when I got into mining uh in 20 I think it was 13 that I actually started to mine it was right at the cusp where you maybe could have solo mined profitably but by the time I got my stuff set up I had missed that boat and difficulty had run away from me and it that was kind of the beginning right there that 2013 to 14 Euro when Bitcoin difficulty made it that a typical person could not practically profitably mine uh Bitcoin anymore and so

the next level uh sort of cooperation tool was created at that point in in saying that okay I'm not big enough myself but if five of us got together and we were able to pull our hashing power together maybe we could solve these puzzles uh actually don't ever let me use the word puzzle because you're not solving a cryptographic puzzle uh when when you mind the old the oldest Trope in the book you it is no it is it is old and it's wrong like it is completely fous but um yeah no so if if we can uh Brute Force this hashtable together as a group we can share it relative to uh your contributions if I'm 10% of the pool when we find a block I get 10% of of the reward and so that that is in a very basic sense what a pool does uh gorilla pool is a bsv exclusive mining pool uh bsv I you know not all of your audience will know what it is but it's a a

a a derivation of of Bitcoin or or a fork is is the more typical colloquialism um and and basically it is a competing variant of Bitcoin and it is also too difficult to solo mine unless you're quite wealthy and so uh I I created this pool with a couple of my friends in the space uh simply because we wanted to have like a community Le uh pool in Bitcoin uh that was not super corporate I am not like a IBM suit and tie kind of guy I I wanted to have a a basically a meme pool and so that's what we uh what we created and and basically anyone can can point their Asic or they can rent hash power anywhere they want or they can build their own industrial size hashing location and they can point it at gorilla pool we have an open API that allows you to just contribute hash power in fact we have a mystery hasher that shows up with about 80 petahash uh which is something like four or

five million dollars worth of equipment and just points it at the pool essentially every night for the last six weeks and which makes me think he's in the Eastern hemisphere somewhere because he's trying to Hash on US during his daytime uh but yeah they they come mine with us but it's it's an open pool anybody can mine with us and when we find blocks you get rewarded your contribution relative to the total size of the pool and uh very basic sense that's that's gorilla Fool's mining operation that makes sense I guess you kind of said earlier that these kind of when you have these solo miners these big operations they keep every the CL cards close to their chest and we don't really know how they're set up and so I guess it's all about the technology and the efficiency and all this kind of stuff so what's the USP from like a pooling standpoint is it is your USP compared with other pools that you have like light touch your low friction anyone can

join and also what do you mean when you say you know they can point hash you what's the actual role that the pool plays with that hash so so yeah we run Bitcoin node infrastructure so we're doing like validation of transactions we're collecting unconfirmed transactions into our mem pool then we're providing uh extra infrastructure to allow commercial like application Builders and stuff to uh to connect and and use us as an infrastructure partner uh and and for that you know we build blocks as part of part of our operation and so what we're offering that nobody else in bsv is offering is is I'm pretty sure we're the only public pool right now um tall tall is uh the largest mining operation they're a I think canadian-based Corporation but they have hashing operations all over the world themselves uh and then there's a few other po like mining Dutch uh is is another which is their name would apply they are Dutch Miners and then um uh there's there's a couple others that sort of

pop in and pop out and mine on bsv but we offer a a open public pool so anybody like you don't have to give me your information in order to mine bsv with us uh you can simply just use our IP address and and and a simple string that we publish uh publicly and and you can mine with us now when I say hashing separately or you can have your own hashing operation it's literally just us sharing our uh our block candidate and then also our table of hashes so we have a table that the Bitcoin Network gives us uh in order to look for what I like to call the magic number but it's it's literally just a a hash with a sufficient amount of leading zeros so 000000000000 then a cryptographic string of random numbers and letters uh and if we collectively find that hash together we we build the block and so you you can be anybody you can be a guy with a 10-year-old Asic that contributes almost nothing or you

could literally be you know Jihan woo I think is the CEO of bit deer which I think is based in Tennessee today um you know one of the one of the biggest hashing operations in the country like you can point at gorilla pool it would take you two minutes to to switch your hashing operations over you'd be you know the biggest we gorilla pool would be 99% of hash power if we got all a bit deer's hash but um that would be uh uh that would be a thing that could conceivably happen for anybody with shot 256 infrastructure so that's what is typically mining BTC bch and bsv it's all the same infra uh and a number of pools and hashing operations will sort of Arbitrage their hash power to chains depending on uh profitability this is kind of a way to skirt the difficulty adjustment like hey I'm not so profitable to mine BTC so maybe I'll mine bch right now and then if you know the price of bsv spikes sudden and none

of the other ones do like all of a sudden you'll see that Arbitrage immediately sort of move over bu profitably over here and then drives the profitability back down and then it spreads back out evenly there's this constant EB and flow of uh like profitability Discovery occurring among those chains yeah it's one of the fascinating artifacts of there being multiple chains and also how the whole design of Bitcoin is it's actually very lightweight that connection between the hashing part and everything else you mentioned right you said at the start the hashing part is the one that's grown and specialized but to connect the two is actually incredibly light way I definitely recommend anyone who is interested in learning more about just exactly how they can communicate because it's you literally just pass a tiny bit of data between those two systems one of them could be your your your nice MacBook and another could be this massive data center Cloud mining infrastructure and they only need this small bit of information to to coordinate so

it's pretty fascinating to me one one other thing I think is worth mentioning about gorilla pool specifically actually from what I've seen is you're somewhat of a Pioneer in in mining Services because I've seen you tapping into data services right so you said that mining is quite unprofitable right now and it seems to me you've started looking at what I think is a very untapped Revenue source which is miners are procuring this data set you're building the blockchain you're adding blocks it's an incredibly valuable data set because it's immutable and you get all these benefits of the blockchain why aren't people charging for access to certain uh data on the Chain why are they not charging for certain indexing services and you know then I saw gorilla pool and that's exactly one of the things you guys are offering right with jungle bus so can you talk us through that that data services aspect because I think very few people do acknowledge this and I think it's really interesting yeah so one one of the

things uh it's funny you you'll get your typical Bitcoin Advocate talking about how bitcoin's the hardest money in the world because it has this Havoc every four years and so they're getting more scarce which is actually uh both rhetorically and mathematically incorrect terminology and um so they're becoming more rare uh but they are also uh your coins are disinflationary so you also get people say bitcoin's deflationary it's not Bitcoin is distributed by inflation uh but that rate of inflation goes down every four years and so you get people that are like well yeah then the price has to go up because demand is perpetual and the asset is is increasingly scarce and it's like I don't know how many people out there with a lot of money are unaware that Bitcoin that there's only ever going to be 21 million Bitcoins so I am not one who believes that at our current like two or three trillion dollar market cap that there's just another 20 trillion dollar out there that's going to push Bitcoin to

a million a coin just because so what I think Satoshi actually intended with his design of the system is that the havening is like a it's like a guillotine hanging over your head that that chops down by half every four years and the only way to pull your head out of that Guillotine is to find ways to monetize Bitcoin that aren't the subsidy that that block reward that we get every every 10 minutes and that cuts in half every four years and so I am an extreme minority on that position uh I am the the the maybe the most bullish guy on the technology and the least bullish on its like per Perpetual uh like yeah yeah bro it just gets more valuable because there's there's just more people that want it and the asset is is finite um now that's an aspect of bitcoin's value like I don't disagree that that is one of the ingredients but the actual valuable thing the thing that Bitcoin is valuable because of is the data like Bitcoin

is a data money um Andreas senopoulos used to call it the internet of money and he wrote a whole book about hey it's valuable because of all these things about data and money that when you integrate them they become more valuable so I've I've said uh a number of times in public that data is it's the most valuable asset in the world today and it's the most valued asset in the world today at the same time so no other asset gets more valuable as more of it's created but data is that because the data becomes more profound and it becomes more uh more sophisticated and it it just continues to add resolution to our lives as you get more data and so that means there's an incredible opportunity for the Mone ation of data and if you have a tool that allows you to monetize every bite of data in a way that is exponentially more efficient than any other tool can monetize every bit and bite of data well then you're sitting on what

I think is the absolute goldest of the golden goose eggs and there's like 12 people on Earth that agree with me on it at this point which I think puts me ahead of the curve I'm either completely insane or I am like Christopher Columbus level uh you know ex Explorer here and so you know like history will will judge ultimately but um so so all that is set up to say that nobody is monetizing the data on the blockchain almost at all there there's a couple of small exceptions but people are still in this nent phase of hey you know like you can trade like uh what was it Joe Joe Bowden coin uh dropped really hard on salana after it was announced that Joe is not going to be running and then the the Kamala coin you know exploded up in value and that's like 90% of what's going on in the crypto economy uh and then in in the BTC space like hey Donald Trump is Gonna Come speak at uh at uh

you know Bitcoin 2024 in Nashville and so we're all bullish and except for Max Kaiser who wants everybody to know that he hates Donald Trump and NAA bu is is the king of the universe uh you know coming soon but but you know that's all that's going on it's just this weird sort of social uh social posturing and trading but but the actual Golden Goose is is that data so me and and and just a couple of buddies it it was literally me a guy named Luke Rowen o uh and and Michael Boyd who goes by root he's our he's our our CTO over at gorilla pool and said hey you know we talk about data being valuable but what are we actually doing about it how can we help people extract that value and utilize that value in the real economy because I don't want to be the guy that just sat and theorized about it in in a library Hall forever like that's fun but it's not ultimately uh you know the coolest

way to go about it so we so we conceptualized what would it look like if we were to serve that data in a way that is lightweight trustworthy validated and and can ultimately allow people to reduce the friction of deploying a blockchain based Data Business and so we created a tool called jungle bus which is essentially just a filtering an indexing tool um that operates adjacent to our Bitcoin node which takes in unsorted monolithic data that is timestamped but is ultimately like here's a JPEG and here's somebody's mortgage payment and here's some other you know like it's everything is it's just chaos it is a chaos funnel and at the bottom of that funnel jungle bus sorts things by by listening to Hey what are 20 or 30 things that people are using typically that we can filter out by and say okay this is uh this is stable coin or this is just a simple payment or this is some kind of nft or or or whatever else um and then allow people to

subscribe to just the data they want and then we serve it in like an ISP model so I see us as like a budding um I don't want to say AOL or xinity or you know some of these companies that are very disliked in the world but they are providing a valuable service in that you know I'm communicating with you right now over an Xfinity rail uh that's coming like that's what provides my internet service out to the to the universe and so I want us to be that I want it to be um hey I'm gonna start a business it's going to be a blockchain business and I need to choose my web 3 ISP and hey the only one in the universe is Gorilla pool and they have this jungle bus product that packs it up for me in a way that I can understand and easily deploy in my business I mean there's so much value to that like I think it's so obvious and I think it kind of what I've

been seeing the headlines a lot recently in major kind of news articles around Ai and obviously everyone's talkinging about AI but the lack of quality data in Ai and more and more models are trying to use less and less high quality data and I think not only is this going to be an obvious thing for people for entities but training AI models going forward is going to need this high quality authenticated data and being attach value to the exchange of data which is something I think is severely underutilized in blockchains generally it's going to be a whole economy I think you're definitely you know you and your 11 disciples whatever it is are going to be ahead of the curve and stuff and I think that's definitely a huge opportunity going forward yeah I I certainly hope so I I I think AI among all of its other benefits I I think that one of the big things that AI has taught a lot of normal people is that data is valuable and also that

that that bad data gives you uh really bad outputs very quickly and so uh you know we're kind of back at the uh Cynthia dwar or Hal finny or Adam backck problem like Hey how do I how do I filter out this 95% trash and actually only give my AI model the cream that it should be working with so that we're efficient and um that that's the next big problem to solve I think there's a huge role for blockchain to play there um and that's that's really what we're hoping to do with our uh our tooling and our our stack is is we're about two years ahead of anybody else that I'm aware of in using blockchain uh as a data filter and then all of that data filtering methodology so that we can serve it to either a very simple you know webbased business or directly to you know some kind of llm uh you know learning uh module or or something so we are in internally training some uh Bitcoin thinking Bots uh

using this tool right now um so that we have a little bit of data to to share with uh you know who whoever comes to us first to say hey we heard you're doing this uh so we have a little bit of some proof of concept we are using it internally we have a bot Yeah in our Discord group that's called uh VV and what VV does is basically answer questions technical questions about Bitcoin uh and it can be a you know as complex as you know H how to build very unorthodox Bitcoin transaction types or it can be as simple as like hey what day did the Bitcoin white paper come out and you know th those kind of things can be answered uh very effectively by VV or or at least will be able to because we are currently training VV uh on on the information we're feeding that's that's very cool I think you say AI has so I see everyone posting about the overlap of AI and web 3 and blockchain

and bitco coin that is a new use case application and I think people are just repeating themselves but to know you're actually doing it rather than just talking about it is it's exciting um so to go back 10 15 minutes I think you were talking you said something along the lines of you know the Larry Finks and the Jamie Dions of the world who are kind of coming into this space and investing in uls but they're playing like a kind of um a more obvious and transparent role in exchanges right like we're getting big regulated exchanges that are kind of more and more do ating the Bitcoin landscape whereas it was previously all about the miners the miners controlled you know I guess most of the Bitcoins all this kind of stuff they dominated the landscape it seems like more attention and focus and weight is being pushed now to exchanges what do you think about that from a kind of you know philosophy standpoint about what Bitcoin is intended to do and what role

they're having on that so it's it's interesting I'm I'm very publicly critical of uh guys like Larry Frink uh in fact I think I've tweeted his name probably half a dozen times in just the last week um I think he's a a villain in this story but ultimately I I I don't think that it's purposeful on on his behalf though so I don't I don't think he is actually like receiving orders from a predatory alien species or something but but I think that the the Practical outcomes of his behavior uh and just the way that black rock works and and all these things I I I think are a net negative for uh you know actual competitive capitalism and and World freedom in general and so you know while I can respect his his Acumen as a businessman I think that the sum total of guys like Larry thinkink having uh you know their thumb on the scale is a net bad and here's the reason why when you when you become that large and

and it's funny because I I make a lot of criticisms and I call a lot of people Communists and uh taken out of context I think that my next couple of statements here could uh could come back to haunt me a little bit but but ultimately when you when you become so large we saw this with uh Bear Sterns and some of these companies in 2008 Standard and pors was afraid to downgrade the credit worthiness of of a few of these big Wall Street Banks because we're golfing next weekend if I downgrade their credit I might be the one that actually puts them out of business because all of a sudden their their uh you know debt to income ratio flips and it like I'm the one putting them into bankruptcy because their books work at this credit rating and they don't work at this one and we're all kind of trusting each other to uh just make sure this all works but but ultimately it's standard andor's job to give an accurate accreditation to

to these companies because that's that's how the company works and Bear Sterns was being incredibly irresponsible with their with their company with their Investments and so uh you know we've lived through the frankly we're still living through the Fallout of of a lot of what happened there but um you get the same kind of thing with black rock where everybody wants black Rock's money everybody wants to have their business everybody wants to be the guy to say hey man I don't know we just took a check from Black Rock or or you know like we're a new vendor to them or something like we want proximity to that money because they're like a I don't even know 10 or 15 trillion dollar asset management company I me they basically own everything they're like the third largest uh property holder in the whole world and they own they own a sizable chunk of essentially every business in the world that matters and so to to be close to Black Rock is to be close to everything

that matters in a capitalist society and so the real question is is you know what what do we do like that that is definitely too much power uh even if everyone's you know good then you know it's it's still it's still problematic because what if he becomes B what if Larry think has a heart attack like what if like like there's all these things that like you know does the whole world collapse based on the sneeze of some of some businessman and so there there's a real problem there now we have a similar problem in the space i' I've uh talked at length about uh Barry silbert being a very similar sort of figure in the blockchain space because digital currency group Barry silber's the CEO and and at least he was he may have actually left in recent recent times because he became a controversial figure but um they basically seed every major startup in the blockchain Eon this your coinbase Kraken bitgo fire blocks lightning Labs blockstream like you know all these companies

if if you name like the hundred most important companies uh in the en entire blockchain economy digital currency group is probably invested in 95 of them and and not just a little bit like they're heavily like we were their angel investor we were seed level or or actually we acted as an incubator to this company for you know the first couple of years or whatever and so you kind of have this problem of yeah it looks like Kraken and coinbase are two competing entities but in reality the CEOs of both companies went to high school together and they're both part of a bigger portfolio and they all golf together and they all ultimately uh Hey guys uh we're we're broke can you front us some money for the week and we'll we'll we'll pay it back under the table everything's going to be fine so it's a little bit like that relationship between be Sterns and standard and pors in 2008 where yeah yeah nobody's actually doing their job nobody's actually competing and the only

people who know that this is working are the like 10 or 15 people that are kind of running the entire economy over there now you would think that a regulator would be the solution to this because Reg ators are also supposed to do their jobs but as we've seen um you know the New York attorney general's office a few years ago slapped IEX uh tether corporation on the wrist for like $15 million because they proved that they were fraudulently running their company that their books weren't real like all these things that like would probably put someone like me in prison but uh but in in tether's case was like oh well pay a $15 million fine which is you know one hour is worth of profit for a company like and so you get that kind of thing or you have Gary gendler who has come under Fire as like the worst SEC chairman that's ever existed or whatever because he's kind of picking winners and losers but it looks like maybe everyone was in

his pocket like maybe Ripple was paying him under the table maybe the ethereum foundation was paying him under the table maybe you know maybe all these entities are actually just paying Gary gendler to help choose winners and losers and that's its own whole massive bag of uh problems I I can see you want to comment here yeah it's hard like I I've had this conversation as well around like what is capitalism and what is capitalism meant to be and I've kind of got into an argument with friend and say you know one of the benefits of capitalism is you work hard and you make you you're efficient and you create productivity you create benefit to society and you're rewarded Capital it's like kind of in this neoc capitalism there where it's like you just hold assets those assets don't really maybe add to civilization Society and my friend was like no that is literally the definition of capitalism it's about how much Capital can you attain I'm like okay well we need to change capitalism

then the way and make sure that it's always productive and you don't just have these laggards at the top who just own things and don't actually contribute to productivity Society all this kind of stuff and it's really tricky because then you say it starts to go okay well how do we regulate how do we become more heavy touch all these kind of things and it's yeah this is a Tech podcast not a political podcast but it always borders on this stuff and you know what the kind of the question I actually want to follow on from with that which is also kind bit philosophical political all this kind of stuff is a lot of these people the Larry thinks of the world have changed their tune because they're now saying there is a set limit on bitcoin 21 million that is never going to change set in stone but you know it's a line of code is is that is that 21 million limit as set in stone as everyone seems to think no hard

stop boom just it's it's one line of code it's one line of code and a social contract that isn't written anywhere and so so it's it's just like anything else like should should the the block size is is the block size limit permanent is is is a digital signature or the way that digital signatures are validated in Bitcoin like what is a Bitcoin I mean that's that's the most fundamental question that needs to be answered right well Satoshi Nakamoto is very clear it's an unbroken chain of digital signatures back to either the time it was mined or the Genesis block and if you have that unbroken chain of digital signatures that's I mean this is based in 253 years of of computer science and a few hundred years of contract law in the Western Hemisphere like yep here's a contract here's the signature for when this property was transferred from this guy to this guy to this guy to this guy for 500 years and now this person owns this land because we have an

unbroken chain of signatures on contracts and so Bitcoin was only able to maintain that concept from two 2009 until sometime in 2017 when they replaced the digital signature with a hash IOU that a digital signature exists that's sitting in another Merkel tree and I've already said so much that any normal person is like I'm out I don't I don't know what that means and so this is the this is the beauty of it to the the technocrat is that bitcoin's whatever I decid it is because there's like 10 people on Earth who can actually argue with me about it in a sophistic at manner but all of those people work for the same venture capitalist that I do and so we're in a really good spot to redefine Bitcoin to whatever is really valuable to us at the time and so uh no that 21 million number if if the fundamental definition of a Bitcoin is is Up For Debate and and can very trivially be changed by uh what was ultimately a pretty short

and fast social engineering campaign in the history of Bitcoin then anything's up for grabs that that 21 Million number is as set in stone as you know a Jello mold sitting in a in a window in in Barcelona I love it this is really interesting though and I'm really glad we're doing this in an episode about mining because you said it's one line of code that needs changing to a new number but the other thing that I think also would need to happen that that line of code ISS changing and then you need all the miners on the network to agree to update right so sure if we have 10 major miners in BTC then they could in theory upgrade now I've heard the argument and I'd love to get your take on this as a minor I've heard the argument that well this couldn't possibly happen because we it's not just these 10 miners who contribute hash power we also have like thousands of people running the validator side of the mining or the

validator side of the node software at home they can detect the change but also I've heard an argument that is is more compelling than that at least that because of mining pools that's not an issue because if any of the miners do that then you start pointing your hash to other ones that don't what do you think of that argument as a protection against that kind of failure right that the Min has just changed the code you think it's valid we we've actually seen the exact opposite so so you have you have this developer class that issue software now for whatever reason our culture worships software Engineers the way that that people for 10,000 years worshiped priests and it's this I'm I'm connected directly to God or the gods or you know nature that is our God or whatever and the things that I say like I'm gonna tear the heart out of a virgin now and you're all gonna thank me for it and like that's that's most of human history and for whatever

reason we've decided that those priests are now people that can write code and the reason is is we still worship the same talismans that we've always worshiped for for you know 20 or 50 or 100 thousand years as a species it's it's power we worship power now power manifests itself as money in our society mostly um or or this this conglomeration of of money and and physical like military might or whatever whatever it means we also have a similar Concept in government or the law uh both things that also don't actually exist but because we all pretend they do they're the most dangerous thing and so it's it's imagine imagine if if Santa Claus still had like crompus was was this other thing like if you're bad you're actually gonna die on Christmas right so um I don't want to get too weird about it but these are things people should understand about human nature is is that because we don't understand the average person doesn't understand how software Works where it comes from why

does a computer enforce these things B that are conjured up by this wizard who sits at a laptop with a neck beard and like so there's this there's this like this Majesty that occurs in the the ignorance of of what's happening there and we see the same thing in the minor economy like there's this this threat of oh man if miners decided to collude we'd be like that's the real danger so we need to hold them in check instead of like we can't trust the Byzantine generals which is who they are we need to therefore have this whole mesh network of Byzantine soldiers that are this secondary uh this is like the Deep State conversation that everybody's everybody's sure there's a deep State and it's definitely the other guy in charge of it right and and you're definitely the good guy because uh you know because right because we watch a lot of movies but what's happening is that you have these node operators that say well because we're this class we're all the same

we're this Collective of likeminded trustworthy people because we run these little nodes at home and I'm validating everything I'm actually keeping people in check it's the same concept as like your union truck driver or something like yeah I work for a big powerful company but ultimately if all of us decide we're just not driving our trucks we're actually the ones in Char and maybe they are like that's there's a there's a balance there there's a negotiation that needs to occur for everything to kind of keep flowing and the problem is is that you can only Flex that might for a certain amount of time everybody's got like this amount of breath they can hold before everybody just needs to like take a step back and say okay I'm tapping out or you're tapping out who's it gonna be and so so there's this there's this antagonism between your node operators that say I I won't run uh a version of this software and obviously you can see based on the version of the software that

most people are running that's a sort of vote that's our Union Collective uh that this is the version of Bitcoin that we're running now here's the problem is that's a very cheap signal while proof of work is an extremely expensive signal the other side is a signal because I mean you only need a very small connection and all these other things now it's funny because Satoshi Nakamoto actually warns us about this in the Bitcoin white paper saying like if consensus is essentially a proof of IP address if your IP address is simply signaling this is the version of Bitcoin that I'm running that's that's an attack this is called a civil attack in computer science it is a easy to spin up cheap but potentially and and maybe maybe it should be assumed to be a mili I assume it's a malicious signal because of how cheap it is to to run so imagine Larry thinkink again he wants to change Bitcoin fundamentally he's like you know what let's let's make it a 100 million

coins what do I gotta do to get people and Moss to agree that it should be 100 million well I already pay all the influencers I already buy proxy own all the media I buy proxy own a lot of the exchange es probably a lot of the mining pools what would the cost be to to get those developers to to start to advocate for this idea and then build a piece of software that that runs that code like that and then also let's put 50,000 end points in AWS that are signaling we want 100 million Bitcoin I mean that's a few million dollars to invest in something that's that's something prohibitively expensive for me to try to pay to social engineer on bitcoin but for somebody like Larry thinkink that's a that's a rounding error in the you know the the asymmetric part of the portfolio right and so for for them it's like yeah Le let's do that let's let's just make that happen I have argued at length that that's actually what happened

in 2017 uh to to push over like the the segregated witness change and some of these other more controversial changes in Bitcoin that occurred in in that era uh because they voted with their nodes and sorry there was no identity on most of those nodes that voted with their software to activate that change and so I have to assume that some percentage and probably a sizable percentage of those were just the same interested parties creating a false signal and saying we all vote for this change and the wi is a nebulous black box that nobody will ever see inside maybe it was guy probably not one guy but it I I think it was a very small collusive Collective of people saying we're running this version of the software and this version of the software is Bitcoin uh and then we also have a lot of actual history of of mining pools so we have like ant pool in China and Via BTC and some of these other people saying look we really didn't want

the segwit upgrade But ultimately we don't have an independent group of developers we're just going to trust what Bitcoin core tells us to trust we're going to run the reference client when they tell us to update we're going to update because we're not experts and the the Wizard priests that make the Bitcoin core software we're just going to trust them we don't want to start a splinter group or a revolution and they kind of did with Bitcoin cash uh which was supported by antpool and some of these other things like they kind of did a two chain experiment to to sort of see how this would play out but uh that was about the worst way to have a revolution and uh you know ultimately we've seen that doesn't work very well for anybody and um that that's that's kind of where we're at I think it's important to have these conversations because there's so many people that like you say aren't necessarily kind of completely familiar with the space and they take these things

for granted and like you say the Larry f of the world saying 21 million they can never be more it's an absolute hard set and you're right to say that's not true it is a line of code and obviously we're saying right now that there's so many reasons why someone wouldn't change that right it's like one of the assumed pillar that if someone were to change that it would [ __ ] the price overnight like have so many ramifications it's very unlikely that most the miners would sign up that but you know it could happen right it is possible so it's not an absolute set in stone pillar you know and we so we come we're coming to the closing sections this has been epic as we knew it would be usually we ask in one sentence what is web 3 to you but because we've got you know the Bitcoin historian on last time we asked what is bitcoin to you what I want to ask for the first question is and in one sentence which

I know it might be tricky for you Kurt is what do you think the future of Bitcoin is uh I'm I'm going to I'm going to quote Satoshi Nakamoto so uh I'm gonna paraphrase Satoshi Nakamoto uh he was he was asked what Bitcoin will will look like uh I think in 10 years or something like that 20 years I I don't remember the time frame but but he said uh basically there will be millions of transactions or there will be zero and it's it's a binary outcome for coin either everybody uses it because it creates an incredible amount of value because you used it or people will cease to use it because it doesn't do what they thought it was going to do right now everybody thinks it's going to make them Rich because they did nothing with it and that's got a whole host of problems with it in in my opinion but um if we don't make that pivot and if we don't figure out how to make make our our jobs 10x

more profitable or or or whatever if if we don't find a way to 10x our lives with Bitcoin it it will go away so it's it's either I think to to I'm I'm gonna sort of resay what I said the last time it's bitcoin's either going to be integrated with everything or it's going to be integrated with nothing it's going to cease to be uh or or it will be or it will be everything so it's it's it's or nothing that's powerful I like that um and the second question so we asked you last time to choose anyone Dead Alive to sit down and discuss Bitcoin with you chose John Calvin right the French Theologian just to make it a bit more relevant and you know real time for our audience if you could choose anyone alive today who who would it be apart from us obviously you're not allowed to say us that's fine yeah this is this is my dream come true to be H show um you know it's it's it's hard

to say because I've I've actually had some interesting sitd Downs with with a lot of people uh who are powerful and influential I wonder I wonder what it would be like to sit and talk to someone like uh an Elon Musk or somebody and you know I I think there are a lot of people like that who would sort of be easy to say like ah if I had an hour with him I'd I'd fix everything you know you know that that kind of thing and I actually think that's that's really kind of nonsense I I think it's funny I've even talked to like uh with Peter Schiff and like you know got got him to see the light on a couple of things but like what was the fruit of any of that right just just like still just goes back on Twitter the next day to talk about how Bitcoins for idiots you know I don't know I think I'd rather talk to a large group of like small business owners or or

people that have other influence on much more regular people because I I think your your high level influencer types or your power you know like you know like King Charles probably like you know we'd have an engaging conversation and then it would just be like any other engaging conversation he had with anybody that week you know and so so I it I I would spread it out I would try to democratize my my thing a little bit and say you know what I'd love to talk to like a hundred people in a room that all run like1 Million companies because I think there would be a lot more fruit there uh for people that are hungry uh hungry enough to still grow something cool and not so uh so beyond at all that they just uh can write it off as just one more thing to discuss in a week nice I love that answer this the first time we've had more than one person I think explicitly named but I feel like that also

might be one of the more feasible ones we could fingers cross arrange for you one day if we if we get big enough maybe we can make that that dinner table happen but again thank you so much C it's been a it's been a huge pleasure for both of us to have back on the show I'm sure it won't be the last time and I'm very pleased that we got to talk a bit more about you today and and your story what you're doing with Gorilla pool So yeah thank you so much for being on and to our audience wherever you may be join us next time to entangle a little more web three thanks for tuning in into another episode of untangling web 3 don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own

and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes