Episode 30

Binance FTX

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this episode, the hosts delve into the recent upheavals in the Web3 finance sector, with a particular focus on the dramatic developments around FTX. They analyze the significant impact these events have had on the broader crypto industry, noting the increasingly blurred lines between web2 and web3 realms.

A central topic of discussion is the controversy engulfing Binance, particularly its insufficient customer verification processes and alleged involvement in transactions linked to terrorist organizations. The situation escalates as Binance's founder, CZ (Changpeng Zhao), faces hefty fines and steps down as CEO, yet remains a key figure in the company.

The narrative then shifts to the challenges faced by two major cryptocurrency exchanges, Binance and FTX. The hosts detail the Binance hack, leading to the controversial decision to roll back transactions in coordination with miners. They also scrutinize the scandal involving FTX and its sister company, Alameda Research, which resulted in a significant loss of funds, a liquidity crisis, and panic among investors. The episode further covers ongoing class action lawsuits against both exchanges, highlighting accusations of misrepresentation and misuse of customer funds, and the involvement of FTX's celebrity endorsers in these legal entanglements.

In the final segment, the hosts dissect the criminal case against FTX and Alameda, revealing alarming financial practices that led to substantial losses. They emphasize the importance of individual responsibility over technology flaws and argue for the necessity of regulatory measures in the crypto space. While acknowledging the market’s volatility and complexities, the hosts suggest that proper regulation could bring more certainty and attract institutional players.

Despite some concerns about potential overregulation, the increasing government interest in understanding and regulating cryptocurrencies is seen as a positive step, hinting at a maturing and more stable future for the Web3 industry.

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

CZ as you said offered to well said he was going to buy out FTX and looked like the Savior and then a few days later retracted the offer and one explanation is that he had a closer look did he they said they did due diligence and maybe a lot of the funds that were supposedly just IL liquid so it would take time to sell them and get the money back but fundamentally the money was there they were actually insolvent rather than a liquid so they the assets just didn't exist because of this relationship with alamida they basically just siphoned all this money away to alamida they they didn't actually have it so but yeah it's hard to know how much of it was just CZ doing a power play there who knows but um yeah he he really played a big role in the downfall welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast today is another short quickfire around on recent events in web 3 specifically around what's been happening with binance and

FDX some of the lawsuits that have come out some of the finds I know Jack's got a lot of strong opinions how you doing today Jack yeah yeah all good excited to get my my teeth into this one people are probably surprised that we haven't talked about these topics in too much detail yet so yeah let's let's unleash ourselves on them today I think people will also be surprised that we're wearing the exact same outfit we're slowly becoming one person I think our voices are quite similar maybe we need to differentiate a little bit we're Gemini today the other exchange but we won't touch on them but uh we were playing that role we're the wi today yeah so I think this is a really important one I know that like there's been a lot of events and a lot of these events have been talked about for actually quite a while now but it's really come into a culmination especially as we're constantly going on about institutional adoption Web Two versus web 3 like

how right how important regulation is coming into this space and in my mind a lot of these recent events they've been hugely impactful to the crypto industry right generally but web 3 um more broadly and I think it's really interesting to see what in my mind are growing pains as web 3 and web two kind of the overlap and the ven diagram slowly starts to increase and I think this is a really interesting time to actually start to explore those things yeah yeah I think um this we might have a difference of opinion on this one today because you know I I see a lot of what's happened recently more as just a classic human Lings right just you can't trust people I don't see it so much as like a technological difference or or or because I don't I don't see it as coming from the philosophies of web 3 and web two I see it very much as you know history repeating itself and not learning from the failures we've had before web

3 before we had these crypto companies but yeah we we'll get into the details maybe I'm wrong but um you know I'm I'm too cynical on this one no that is interesting I do agree there's always era at the core of these but I think maybe a lot of people have put more faith into these projects because they think you know are they blockchain based are they transparent are there web three so there must be everything must be regulated everything must be trustworthy there's no they're all decentralized there's no way one person can screw up all these things and I think maybe there's a lower barrier to trust because of those reasons but like we're going to see the systems were as flawed as they are in web two companies didn't allows individuals to manipulate the systems I think that's probably the angle that I come come at it from but yeah I take your point yeah no that's that's fair enough and maybe I'm being too too harsh on it I think um because

the ones we're going to focus on right are binance and FTX as you said and really they are they are just companies providing a service to web 3 right but they leverage a lot of the same terminology a lot of the same ethos around decentralization you know all the stuff we hear in blockchain I think I agree with you that's where people might think okay this is a all the stuff we say as well about a fairer or Equitable peer-to-peer way of doing things and then you get these companies who insert themselves in the middle to offer a service and as we said recently in our our Trad fine defi episodes your your exchanges are offering a service if run correctly but they are at the end of the day just companies with fallible people clearly in the middle so yeah I think there's maybe a blurring of lines between what the actual companies are and what the things they proposedly stand for you know yeah so speaking of those fallible people let's kick off

we're going to start with binance so binance was founded in 2017 by Shang panga I think most people probably know him as CZ he's quite a big uh figure in the space right and you know binance very quickly like a lot of these projects um became huge very fast and I think one of the the big things about binance is that offered a really diverse portfolio lots and lots of different assets had a very easy to use user experience user interface all these kind of things and they quick quickly became the the largest Exchange in in the world especially by trade volume so they're very big on high frequency many trades and things like this yeah exactly I mean I actually remember probably around 2018 2019 first coming across binance before it was a huge thing I remember thinking actually this is uh this doesn't look that impressive right now it didn't have a great app when I first looked at it but it as you're right it quickly became you know the most widely

used crypto exchange a lot of that is to do as you say basically being come one come all right getting all the tokens on there it built its own blockchain binance smart chain and has its own token B&B it's own cryptocurrency so it basically you know they they've kind of said yes to everything right they said yes and let's just do this and that they've offered all sorts of different products staking services like we talked about in the defi episode um they've I think lots of people saw them as a very forward thinking right for the cryp crypto people I know you know things like lightning Network in Bitcoin which we've not covered too much but they have been trying to adopt that as well so people saw them as as kind of a crypto first exchange right they weren't the enemy they people did not see them like a traditional Financial player coming in to take a slice of the pie they looked much more like uh like like a new player who was

trying to serve customers who are in web 3 in crypto right and I think a stat that was kind of Staggering for me is that in terms of like the daily volum volume of transactions they're obviously the largest in the world but the actual degree to which they are the largest is they offer three times they actually create three times more transactions per day than the next three exchanges combined which is like it's quite staggering right and 90% of their total revenue comes from transaction fees associated with this and I think this is probably going to relate you know the actual kind of um USP of binance actually relates to probably part of the not the downfall but some of the fines they've been facing is because they have so so many users so many cryptos so much going on they have like no friction whatsoever and that's part of one of I think it's one of their principles right they don't want Alpha frictions to anything getting on there so in that way they

had very weak know your customer policies very weak anti-money laundering policies and this is where we actually start this is some of the reasons why we actually started to see a lot of fines coming out specifically in the US yeah exactly I think if I would describe you know as we said before crypto as being like the Wild West CZ was probably the sheriff right or maybe not maybe not the maybe the the the um the corrupted Sheriff maybe so he you know binance had yeah had a very open stance and basically saw this Gap in the Regulatory and certainty the fact that the SEC and doj Etc weren't moving too quickly to classify certain tokens like ethereum of Securities for example and other other tokens not being too clear kind of not making the first move on regulation and really you know they were given maybe not an inch they were maybe given a mile and they took 100 miles right they just they took that as the green light to go and expand

start you know playing by their own rules effectively I mean one of the things so obviously we're talking about this now day of recording in light of the the big penalties you've just seen right so CZ and binance agreed to this this I this four billion doar penalty right who that is so much money just in the US as well that is crazy yeah I saw a video of him being grilled on on American News Channel saying you know if you had to pay a two billion fine right now could you back it up and he didn't seem too convinced then so that's doubling the fine right it's it's it's crazy but you know some of the things that they kind of were were alleged in in this suit against I think this is the doj suit and there actually other ones that still unsettled but one of the things alleged is that kind of they weren't operating in the US they weren't supposedly allowed to operate in the US because because they didn't really

have an entity there so they weren't supposedly being supposed to be able to serve us customers and then the allegations were kind of that they were doing this underhanded thing because they had been serving us customers from the beginning from the early days that was a big percentage of their market share like I think 20 to 30% I saw was how much of their market share was us-based and then they were doing all sorts of weird things like ringing people up supposedly and getting them to kind of create new accounts but not under the US Banner it was very strange what was happening but um yeah you know very unnerving stuff so yeah I think that was part of it it was a large part of this fight was for them basically allowing the business and transactions and trading of unregistered crypto derivatives specifically in the US and I think that was like three billion of the total fine another really interesting one was the the type of characters they actually had trading on there

so there was um there was links for actually like organizations like Al-Qaeda Isis Hamas were all using um binance as a means to actually transact and this is you know people actually went away I think it's coind Des or something like that actually found and Link this back to binance and the reason they were able to do this obviously an international organization these these terrible terrorist organizations the reason they were able to do this is because binance really didn't want to have any friction to use a signup so they didn't have you know know your customer you didn't have to put your identity to actually start trading these you didn't have to do a likeness testt so it was really easy for these organizations to transfer money internationally around the globe biscate it and then actually use it for criminal transactions so that was another big part of the fine I think one of the interesting things around this that I saw was that I think it was CZ specifically as well as well as

like a lot of the top tier at binance were made aware of this made aware of these Terror terrorist organizations doing this kind of Nefarious activities using binance there's emails being sent to them and they were like completely ignored it they're like don't worry this is just like this is part of the part of the parcel and I think that's partly one of the reasons why CZ was directly finded him himself um you know he resigned as the the CEO of binance due to these anti-money anti-money laundering failures that he you know actually saw and did nothing about but one of the interesting things is he's still like a major stakeholder in the company so despite him stepping down as like the public appearance of oh I'll no longer be part of binance he's going to be really influential regardless right yeah exactly and the AML stuff is is particularly interesting I mean again in some of the allegations I saw it looked like they were doing things where by even when they had knowledge

not not just being passive and say and they had knowledge that customers might have been you know taking money into and out of the dark web and things like that I think Hydra is the name that we'll probably get our podcast shut down by someone we mention it but like even when they had knowledge one of the allegations showed an email or something telling that customer they had to shut the account down but you could just go and make another one right they can't know it's like that Meme of the guy you know at the football ground just doing the pat down check and not actually touching that is a niche reference Jesus Christ I I really hope someone gets that but yeah you're right and CZ is still he's a huge player right he's very well known in the web 3 world I we'll come on to this role in what happened with FTX as well but he was seen as kind of one of these very Pro crypto people people have rallied around

him um one thing I will say as well is that I find it ironic they've kind of seemed to have had their cake eaten it as well in terms of Regulation and law because as we mentioned on a previous episode there was a there was a hack at one point on binance I think and they were talking about you know coordinating with Bitcoin miners or ethereum miners I forget which one to roll back the blockchain right because they wanted to get their funds back so they're happy to cooperate with people and kind of play the victim when it suits them but but actually they're really just you know they're just doing whatever they needed to make the money at the end of the day yeah I mean completely right so yeah to just to summarize what actually happened it was moving forward I mean binance is somewhat unaffected they're still the biggest Exchange in the world like the CEO has stepped down they're saying they're going to take steps to be more regulatory compliant um

they've like made some changes across the board but binance is almost certainly going to be okay they're going to continue to operate maybe they'll be slightly more hesitant how they Opera in the US specifically but globally operations are continuing as usual right so the next big one we have which I think is maybe even more famous than the binance one is FDX I'm sure everyone's heard of the FDX Scandal you know closure but FTX similarly to binance was an exchange founded in 2019 by the infamous Sam bankman freed SBF you might know of him um and actually quite similar to binance like their whole USP was that they had one of the largest market offerings largest crypto variations of all the exchanges I think they were the the leading in terms of the the number of offerings they had um and binance was second so it was FTX then bance that was what their main USP is they had even lower friction to actually getting registered on the exchange and yeah it's absolutely fascinating Scandal

this one yeah well and you say you know they had um this kind of uh similar USP as well when you're talking about how how frictionless and everything was but actually one of the big they were kind of the good the the good face of the good face of crypto exchanges because are arguably their biggest USP for the financial institutions we have today and The Regulators was that s bankman freed SBF was incredibly pro- regulation right and part of what as we'll see with the downfall that came was because he was actually poking fun at at CZ about cooperating with with Washington DC and because one of the times that s SPF became much more famous I mean he had this perception of a of a of a genius kind of billionaire but also Phil philanthropic as well right that he was you know supposedly didn't spend his money on on nice things he wanted to give away he had this supposed effective altruism they called it he was trying to make money so he

could improve the world um so people really liked him and he was very pro- regulation he would go to uh depositions and things or hearings with us legislators and he would sit down with him and explain with him and he was the poster boy for responsible crypto for a long time right yeah I mean they I think he was referred to as the JP Morgan of crypto before he became this controversial figure Amin the the crisis but yeah so like one of the shocking things for me was how quickly FDX went from nothing to this huge huge organization like we say they were established in 2019 and by early 2022 they were 32 billion um they had 24% of the entire Market crypto market share by 2022 and they were trading volumes of around three trillion it's like huge huge amounts um and like I say sam bman freed obviously had a lot of involvement with sushi swap so he had a foundation in this area which obviously made FTX like quite a kind of

um a desirable application and an efficient application as well yeah exactly I think that's where the JP Morgan thing came around right because he basically helped bail out this this project with sushi swap that was migrating from Unis swap to Sushi swap the guy doing it originally kind of abandoned what was happening and then he stepped in and then from that moment he was seen as this kind of philanthropic Guru who was trying to do the best for for the markets and then yeah FTX I I remember that happening actually the sushi swap event and then the next thing I knew I started seeing his face everywhere with the FTX and you know he was he was just lapped up by institutional investors by the big Venture Capital players in the world seoa capital I think was one of the big investors in FTX and then you start seeing FTX at the Super Bowl and with all these celebrity endorsements you know now there's a class action suit against them but at the time it

looked you know all all all smell like roses from everything he did like he couldn't do anything wrong at the time which was it's crazy to think where we were a few years ago to to where it's ended up yeah I think one of the the crazy things about this is everything was going smoothly there was no kind of indication that things were going wrong and then coindesk released this article on in no on November 2nd 2022 about this alamida research and the the link between the two how much do you know about this Jack yeah I I know a fair bit about it but I mean go on if you've uh if you've looked into it more recently maybe you go ahead and summarize it for us so my understanding is that um FDX had a token a coin that they were using and they were putting investment through right it was called the FDT token or something like this um and effectively that say one of the big uh applications or reasons that

people will come into FTX was that they had this um this actual you could invest money and they would they had a market predictor and that actually that would be used for you to actually get Returns on this right and that was one of the big reasons that people come into this and aot lot of this went through the ftt token right and alamida which was a separate organization which was set up by S bankman freeze was actually using the funds that were associated with these ftt tokens that people were investing in and siphoning off and investing in other areas is that is that correct yeah pretty much I think like so if you wind Back to Before FTX was even a thing I believe alamida research existed before and yeah was set up by S bankman freed basically a a trading firm or a hedge fund I think trading crypto I mean they how they Rose to prominence is funny because they basically had this um this big Arbitrage opportunity where they noticed one

Bitcoin exchange maybe it was in Japan I think was trading Bitcoin way below above market price so they would they would go and buy it all up there and then sell it on the rest of the market made a huge profit and that's how they became kind of noteworthy and then a few years later FTX is established and Alam media research continues you know basically as a client of FTX itself so they are supposedly and this is what s bankman fre set they were just like a customer of FTX using the derivatives trading on there all the while alamia was being run by by San bankman Freed's girlfriend at the time right Carolyn Ellison so there's clearly a bit of a conflict of interest there and a lot of this you know as as was pointed out in the coindesk report it basically alleged that there was this kind of co-mingling of funds potentially or basically alamaa research was being allowed to dip into the pockets of FTX and the customer funds there to fund

its trading activities which seemed to be going pretty badly at the time so that's how this all kicked off really yeah and it's saw that there might have been like an overinflation of numbers where numbers were being misrepresented on one side and compar with the other side to you know self-inflate and all this kind of stuff but the point was that this coindesk article effectively exposed this strong relationship between Alam res Arch the dependency on this ft token and them effectively dipping into ftxs Pockets to fund all their investment opportunities and this like triggered this massive platform downfall yeah exactly and not just the fact that they were linked right but also I think it was to do with the balance sheet of FTX because they supposedly had billions in assets but you know I'm glad we've talked about tradire recently because the big word is liquidity right they had a lot of uh assets locked up in very illiquid assets and I think it was five billion of their balance sheet was supposedly in

their own ft token and that's the pool of funds that alamia was basically degenerately gambling on by looks of thing so yeah it's crazy yeah I mean I think one of the the fascinating things was that the platform effectively experienced a bank run right and within 72 hours six billion was drawn out and this like obviously created uh reducing all resources to a critically low point I think one of the things that I read was at one point FDX just had one bit coin remaining in their reserves after all this run which is absolutely crazy and then to link it back to what we were talking about earlier um where there's a bit of like political Discord between um binance CEO at the time CZ well he actually impacted the Collapse by initially offering an acquisition saying you know FTX is experienced a bank run there's a liquidity crisis maybe we can come in binance and buy them out support them and then there was some political kind of uh wasn't there some things on

Twitter of them disagreeing online and then um CZ with Dre the offer and um sold all of binance's Holdings of the ftt tokens um and actually kind of perpetuated this this Bank Run even further so this is where it gets really interesting I think when when CZ comes into the picture and it goes back as I was saying earlier to this difference between FTX and and binance you know FTX being looking like the poster boy for regulation and binance being a little bit more Wild West more than a little bit more um and there's this famous tweet where sank freed basically calls out CZ implying you know is he allowed on us soil like how can he how can he go and help The Regulators in America you know basically calling into question his his legitimacy um from a from a legal standpoint and from there kind of this big Feud apart from the fact that they were the number one and the two Exchange in the world this Feud grew and grew and it

looks like it's hard to tell exactly what happened with the order operations because CZ as you said offered to well said he was going to buy out FTX look like the Savior and then a few days later retracted the offer and one explanation is that he had a closer look did he they said they did due diligence and maybe a lot of the funds that were supposedly just El liquid so it would take time to sell them and get the money back but fundamentally the money was there they were actually insolvent rather than a liquid so the assets just didn't exist because of this relationship with alamida they basically just siphoned all this money away to alamida and they they didn't actually have it so but yeah it's hard to know how much of it was just just Cy doing a power play there who knows but um yeah he he he really played a big role in the downfall the Divas of crypto right so where we're at now is effectively there's a class

action lawsuit which accuses FDX and interestingly its celebrity endorsers of false representation deception effectively this is a Ponzi scheme and you lied to us I don't know what's going to happen with all the celebrity endorsers well that would be quite interesting because there was a lot of them and these are really high-profile celebrity endorsers um and the lawsuit ly alleges there was a misuse of customer funds and improper inter entity transfers FTX eg it was being used by the cister company without their knowledge and I think yeah everyone's probably seen the photos and videos of Sam bankman freed being arrested for personally wire frauding and money laundering um I mean there was loads of things coming out about him you know in the dying days maybe of fex when there was this this this kind of bank run sending money to his mom and dad and like all the kind of misappropriation of funds there as well yeah and you know as you said there's this class action that's kind of pending and lots of

other big players have been added I think maybe the F1 body and also baseball I think it was Major League Baseball added to this class action because they were involved you know one of the big MLB stadiums uh was the FTX arena for a short period of time and that kind of thing and some of the evidence that came out I don't know if how closely you watched it Alec but some of the evidence is really shocking from the from the SBF specific the criminal case that's just concluded and and obviously he's uh he's now been indicted but like for example they had um I think the CTO was testifying and showing the code in court that there's literally a function basically or parameter that let alamida have a negative balance right so they could have a negative account balance they were like the only looks like they were the only customer customer of FTX that could have a negative balance and then they could just withdraw add INF an item basically and that's how

this big this big hole was burned I mean I think the number is something like 9 billion was the hole left between their actual assets and the liabilities it's just it's sickening because obviously people are just going to lose a lot of money from this yeah I mean and like you say it's probably the action of individuals rather than the technology itself like there's no difference between it being a web 3 company or web two company it's individuals being able to misappropriate These funds and acting in in you know the various ways yeah exactly and that's why I I agree there is a relationship with regulation here right because it's showing that there is regulatory teeth to this and you know things like the class action things like the fact that the binance and CZ lawsuit is coming from you know people like the doj I think is the main uh belligerent in this this first one that they paid the fine for it shows that there is teeth now and we're seeing by the

day more and more cases come up and and settlements being made and things like that but to my mind it's more the fact that individuals in the ecosystem have just been taking advantage of a seem lack environment for a number of years right and I I hate personally I hate when people say crypto is unregulated because as we've said lots of them are being classified as Securities for which there's a ton of Regulation and they're all falling a foul of that now right it's just when when do these things get applied in my mind um yeah that that's my that's how I view it I mean yeah you look at like I mean there's Web Two company finds all the time like for various reasons be it gdpr be it like the 2008 financial crash like lot of companies has have been fined and individuals specifically have been fined for misappropriating funds it's maybe there's something around web3 specifically because of the rapid growth that they're experiencing like some companies have gone from startup to

huge multi- International 100 billion dollar companies in the course of years like I think FTX towards the end even though it was like worth 32 billion had like 200 employees or something like that and there's no way that you can keep up purely with like the Regulatory Compliance standards with 200 employees let alone an entire company and I think you are right I think there's a lot of people that are just waiting to nayay because there's so much volatility around crypto and because they're adverse to it I don't know what it is but yeah I think it's people at the end of the day not the space itself that's the problem yeah but I do I do I think you hit the nail on the head there with like the fundamental difference here to the traditional world and traditional Finance where you have other you know violations and things like that in the past is the growth factor and how fast the prices can grow and go it's going to spiral in crypto the fact

that it was perceived like a lucrative investment by so many people in the social media age and that it is it is still a wild west of tokens you can still spin up a new one every day um I think that's the difference right there lack of understanding doesn't necessarily make the tech any different in the long run or doesn't mean it will come under a different regulatory jurisdiction in the long run but in the short term more people are getting affected right more people are buying into the various narrative whether or not they're right whether or not they're correct you know um and they're they're the ones that ultimately are losing out just because it's been such a high growth fomo industry right people don't want to miss out on the next the next pump and that's how we keep seeing this over and over again I think the next pump like he such a Chad um yeah I mean what does this all mean though like for me these things mean certainty probably

in the market it's good to show The Regulators assigned to get to grips and understand that these companies do come under you know regulatory kind of observation and the regulatory umbrella it's good to show that you know the US has teeth potentially so that you know companies comply and at the end of the day more compliance means more certainty for investors for consumers and that will probably lead to more adoption right there's so many big institutional players that just want that regulatory certainty before they go into these spaces so I personally see a lot of these fines these class actions as good things because it means that companies will push more and more to compliance which will lead to adoption hopefully I mean we actually had Gracie Chen on here recently from bit get another exchange and what she said was actually a lot of this turbulence means that they're not going to Target the US for example because of the uncertainty because of these class actions they want to wait for the you know

the dices to fall before they start to push into those spaces which is quite interesting yeah I I fundamentally just totally agree with you right like it's is a good thing that we're we're going through all this pain as an industry to weed out the Bad actors you know and and people losing a lot of money in the process but it's good that there is coming to a resolution it will presumably deter people in the future from going down a similar path and it will also make people more wary of again because that's why I keep coming back to people have been wary of the technology and then they find a couple of people to invest in that they believe in and it's no you need to be very diligent about who you're investing in as well uh in this space my my only kind of worry I think the only caveat I would say to it being a good thing is that you could have a kind of overcorrection from here from a regulatory

point where things crack down so much that it that it suffocates a lot of the good actors who have been you know throughout this whole period and we've just you know been going through this crypto winter have been suffering just from the market perceptions anyway regardless of FTX and CZ um you know one example I would have is like what happens if ethereum does get classified as a security tomorrow right because sure some people who were around founding ethereum will will be punished for that presumably but the confidence in the systems will plummet the prices will probably drop and the the retail holders will again be be damaged by that kind of action so that's the only thing that worries me is that overcorrection could still end up hurting a lot of a lot of retail investors yeah I mean I I completely take that point and I think one of the interesting things is you expect I expected all of these fines all of these issues with you know the crypto exchanges to actually

lead to a dip in the market and you know it's early December it's December 5th right now and everything's rocketing which is interesting and I think maybe people more and more the the more finds we experience the more regulatory impact we see on the market the more people want to invest because the more they see that governments are starting to read into this understand it get to grips with it and potentially lead to more adoption and I think that's quite exciting yeah I was just goingon to add to that very quickly yeah I I agree there's like the there there will probably be a perception maybe that's what we're seeing in the market of this all being priced in and actually now that the Regulators are showing teeth the market is more confident right because that you have these these the guardian angels you normally have protecting consumers in traditional markets are actually they are still there because until recently you it's not been clear that they are to help people out so yeah I

just to Echo your thoughts I think um I think it's a very good thing overall what's happening now yeah and I'm sure importantly we'll see a lot more of this going forward and we'll have more episodes to cover them um but on that note thank you to those listening wherever you may be and join us next time as we entangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto

Related episodes

All episodes