Episode 83

2024: The Web3 Review

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

Merry Christmas one and all! Join us for our annual festive review of the year in Web3, looking back at our favourite guests, clips, and highlights from 2024.

This episode is sponsored by the VeChain foundation. Learn more about VeBetterDAO here:

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast and I think we need to start by saying Merry Christmas this episode is going out on the 25th of December so Merry Christmas to you all and what is a better present than listening to me and Jack speak about some of our highlights from the year yeah Merry Christmas Alec Merry Christmas to everyone listening at home um this just just reminder me of last year our Christmas episode where I just could not I we had drinks at the time right we had drinks and we would I mean we had to be fair we hadn't drunk them at this point um and I just couldn't coordinate myself to like say Merry Christmas have a sip and then like smile I just couldn't do it I still don't think you can and we're not going to test it out now I don't think we have the time but today we're gonna be talking about some of our favorite moments from the year and it's the first full

year we've actually had the second Christmas but the First full year so we have 52 episodes of content to choose from we've had some incredible guests we've done some incredibly trick key topics as well but there's lots of things to choose from and I think I am quite excited just to go through some of the best moments from you as well yeah me too I'm super excited we've had such a great year we've had some awesome guests on and we're going to highlight some of the best ones today um before we start though we should definitely just have a quick shout out to Voss for making this possible right we're in we're in the studio with IRL you know just for folks at home this is not the first time we mean Al like been in a room together um but it is the first time we record the podcast in the same room together so yeah is super exciting and thanks to V boss for making it happen and I think it's the perfect

time to do this because we're reflecting on the year and we're kind of looking at how the episodes the quality the topics have kind of well I would say improved over the course of the year and this is the cherry on top to now be in person recording in a podcast Suite we're going to do this more regularly hopefully have more events in person potentially in the future as well yeah it's an extremely exciting way to end the year and now should we dive into some of our favorite moments from the year yeah let's get into it we've had so many incredible guests so many incredible episodes covered and topics covered and also so many incredible events across the year like to look back a year ago when we were kind of in you know crypto winter style lots of things AI was just picking up to where we are now it is Monumental shift in both technology politics Everything Has Changed substantially and I think it's an incredible time to be you know a

technology podcast talking about these things but yeah should we kick it off yeah why not I mean I have picked so we obviously we've both picked three of our favorite guest clips of the year and we've also as tradition picked the clip of each other which you know we're not entirely short of each other's Clips so that'll be fun to to work out but yeah let's start with our favorite guests so for my first one I have gone for a clip of Jeff garic so this is uh from episode 72 unifying Bitcoin and ethereum and Jeff is you know if you don't know him then you should know him he is a proper proper OG of the Bitcoin world right he was one of the the very earliest developers of Bitcoin post satosi and Gavin andreon so he has been in the world of Bitcoin for so long and this clip is really interesting because he's talking about the the issue and the concept of scalability how we how we get enough transactions on bitcoin

other blockchains and I think it's it's super interesting that we actually got to hear this from someone who's been there from the start so yeah let's take a look at this one the way blockchain networks work today is the network fees increase it's called congestion pricing and some of us might literally have congestion pricing on our highways today uh blockchains have congestion pricing as well and it's fundamentally an auction for Block space which is finite and limited resource and when the road is busy when the blockchain is busy those fees go up and when the road is not busy when the blockchain is not busy those fees go down but fundamentally you can't put all the cars in the world on one road you can't put all the coffees on a single blockchain no matter how much Starbucks would love to blockchain that would uh lead to a a suboptimal user experience but again the root of the crypto tree Bitcoin incredibly secure ethereum the queen of crypto uh Grand Central Station for digital assets

the way uh this all comes together is that you build a road connecting the two these are called layer 2 blockchains or L2 and your additional Road like uh and I'll bring in another analogy like the champagne waterfall that you see at hotels and wedding receptions the the blockchain at the top that is that layer one blockchain and traffic spills over into that next layer of champagne glasses that next layer of secondary blockchains yeah and as that traffic increas es those secondary blockchains can handle more of that load and fundamentally it's all again connected back to bitcoin and ethereum the king and queen of crypto yeah so Jeff was a great guest obviously like you say one of the people at the core of early Bitcoin development he knows this space like no one else does effectively it was an absolute privilege to have him on the podcast and he's talking there at a very high level about twos and about say some of the kind of the key characteristics of Bitcoin and ethereum and

trying to marry them in his current project which is around with Hemi Labs um and yeah he he does it really well right he makes it fairly understandable because these are really complex and tricky things to get your head around and it would take us a week to probably kind of jump into the actual technical detail but yeah that's a great clip I'm glad you shows that one that that is partly why I chose a right is because he is like a a very technical guy like he's he's a proper kind of open- source Dev background but to be able to have that kind of skill set and then still explain things like that in such a a clear and concise way and using that analogy of the kind of the highways that that connects everything together is is super interesting and yeah again we had to mention Jeff I think because it was such a such a great guest so yeah that's my first pick what's yours so my guest is Kia Fino Bates

um a lot of people will know him maybe as blockchain gandal he is prolific on LinkedIn and some times on other I think he's on Twitter and all these kind of things as well he's just such an interesting and thoughtful guy I think I actually first saw him on LinkedIn and similar to your reasoning for Jeff he's extremely technical I would say like his expertise are on the technical side and when you get someone who's that Technical and insightful and intelligent who can also explain things very concisely and in a digestible way like Kieran I think it's a perfect perfect basically podcast guest and in this episode he's talking about blockchain Basics he's talking about smart contracts and how they can be applied to things like gaming and specifically the importance that blockchain has for things like digital ownership in kind of an open world and yeah let me run the clip to me the obvious one has always been the gaming industry right um I mean we we've gone through this strange evolution of

ownership in the you when I was young I had my record collection on buying and then on CD I had my book collection and paper um and I had movies on DVD VHS before that and I owned them I I had a box and uh as long as I looked after them I knew that I had them for the rest of my life and then we got to the point where um it became easy to duplicate CDs and copy mp3s and stuff like that so um so we used to own our stuff and not only that we could lend it to our friends and we could give it to our uh um kids right then uh streaming came along and solved the problem that uh these media companies had and that they could uh uh rather than trying to solve things with DRM which didn't work they they could uh they could lease us the movie so even if you go and buy a movie on Amazon Prime right it's you don't own it the

way that you owned it when you bought it on a DVD because when you die you don't get to pass it on to your kids right plus you don't know what um they they I haven't read the 27 Pages or whatever that terms and conditions but I imagine that it actually says there's no guarantee that you will be able to see your movie that you bought at some point in the future because it's just too big a promise to make right and they have the responsibility to make sure the server's running whereas when they gave you a DVD the responsibility was yours to make sure it didn't get scratched or lost or burnt in the house fire right so um and I I think that blockchain may allow us to return back to that sort of golden age where you actually bought stuff and then you genuinely owned it in the sense that it was yours to keep forever more or pass on to somebody else and I presume that'll come with extra costs they'll

keep you know streaming cheaper than actually buying it but you'll have a real representation of it in digital form on a blockchain and and then I mentioned gaming and the reason I mentioned that is because my kids um are obsessed with amassing digital assets on fortnite on Roblox on braw stars and things like that um and they think that a a Pokemon that they only own on Pokemon go on their phone they they give that the same Credence they give a Pokémon card right so I'm I'm next to me the card is certainly more valuable than the representation on the phone but they they live in a world that they have a different view of the digital that I do for them the digital is much more real than it is for me I imagine if they watch The Matrix they'll just go yeah and right um so uh they're not going to have the kind of uh mind-blowing experience I had when I watched it once I got over there wanting that phone the

went click um you know so uh so and I think there you may end up in a situation where they want to own their game assets and know that they really own them that if the game eventually shuts down they still have the assets that they they obtained and to me clearly the blockchain is the way to do that right now we're not relying on a company continuing to run the servers now we have decentralized data storage decentralized um blockchain and other people ensure that it keeps surviving so um so so that to me has always been the first use case but uh the game industry didn't like it so they did a PR Hatchet job on blockchain to start with and they got the gamers thinking that this was going to be bad for them um how genuinely owning your gaming assets could be bad for you as a gamer I don't know but uh it worked until now maybe the tide is starting to shift yeah it's a it's a really great clip

I think you've chosen there um partly because as you said you know Kia gets to the heart of the value proposition of blockchain so neatly In that clip right so it's a challenge I often have and I'm sure you've had as well where people ask you know why why do we really need blockchain why do we need this web three stuff and a lot of the time it's easy to reach for the whole oh well you know digital gold or digital money digital cash like something on the monetary side of things and sure for some people that might hold sway but it it's not it's not great in from a storytelling perspective it doesn't kind of tug at the heartstrings where you know Kier instead there is getting at this this wider idea of digital property and I think that is that is actually a really interesting line to go down and it's one that kind of I think resonates with a lot more people right this idea that you know do we really own

the things we buy people who you know I have a big library on on Apple right films and TV shows I've bought um and it's interesting when you dig deeper into to how how much of an actual kind of ownership of those things that confers on you there's been various stories about people you know things being removed from libraries or people not being able to transfer them down to uh other members of their family and that kind of stuff so I think yeah that that's that's a nice way of getting to why we really should care about web 3 for you digital assets and and and property yeah I think it's a tricky one like I think we've seen like you say that institutional adoption in this year particularly Has Come For Bitcoin right and a lot of people are convinced that this is because the narrative makes sense it's a simple story you can sell it very easy to the suits and ties in Wall Street that this is digital gold and they're like

ah that makes perfect sense to me I don't need to understand technology necessarily but that story makes sense where I think ethereum has actually struggled a lot and we're not you know those price indicators where we just talk about the price of ethereum and whatnot but it hasn't been rocketing to the same extent as Bitcoin has right and I think a large part of that is because the narrative is a bit more complex to explain when you're talking about this application settlement layer what the hell does that mean to you know your average Joe on the street but like you say that clip there by Kier really goes into it quite well like he explains it in simple terms that it gives ownership a degree of programmability that we don't have right now and when you're talking about ownership you're talking about a ledger you want it to be open you want it to be transparent you want anyone to be able to participate in that and that's really where the power of public Ledger

comes from the power of distributed ler technology comes from Bitcoin ethereum particularly yeah I think the key word there for me is definitely the whole you know programmability is good but I I think the transparency is is huge and we this episode was talking about smart contracts right um and I think it's for me that's something that I always like most about smart contracts is we know that we can't express everything we need to in smart contracts necessarily but what is there is transparent you know exactly how it should work and how it will work what the rules are of the smart contract even if it can't cater for every yeah scenario right and there some of the limitations we have with them I love the fact that you can analyze them you have Smart contract Auditors that kind of tell you exactly what they should do how it should work and what it's what its weaknesses are so yeah I think it's nice and I think that that point you made there about your

kind of your the key characteristic there for you is transparency that relates to the the Bitcoin sell point right whereas the programmability relates more to the ethereum cell Point like it's all well and good having this simple Ledger that anyone can access is immutable and all these kind of things but to take it to the next level which is ethereum has tried to do and is doing all these many blockchains that are evm and all this kind of stuff what they are trying to do versus Bitcoin is to have this level of intelligent intelligence sorry that goes a bit further which I think is quite exciting and I think will reap the benefits in a couple of years time when we see all the applications that are coming on kind of going mainstream but right now that narrative is still quite hard to sell to the big institutional investors clearly but enough on that clip what is your second clip yeah well speaking of kind of narratives that are forming around web 3 I think

what an interlude J yeah we've ued our game with studio and with the the lovely Segways now um yeah is the narrative around digital identity I think is one that has been growing for you know a number of years now when I first heard of it three or four years ago I think it was much more of a niche subject I know that Microsoft were doing something but it was kind of a very Fringe project and now digital identity is at the Forefront of a lot of conversations around things like real world assets that you said around government identities uh you know we we also know of countries that are now starting to issue kind of blockchain based digital identity systems as well so this it's happened a lot in the last few years and this clip is from Sandy Carter right and she's from obviously Unstoppable domains which is part of this kind of digital identity ecosystem so let's take a look at what she had to say about it tokenization just means that

the asset is online on the internet on blockchain um you might have your driver's license your birth certificate your membership in the Chamber of Commerce your last concert ticket may be digitized so you can hold that as well and that will give you as a person some pH phenomenal benefits I'll just give you two real quick a friend of mine was born in Venezuela she's living here in the US now she lost her birth certificate she's got no family left in Venezuela and she needs her birth certificate so she reached out to the hospital the hospital burned down so how dides she get her birth certificate like what does she do and so we were chatting and she goes if I had digitized it if I had it inside of my domain or my digital identity then I would always have it it would always be with me and then another example I was down in Brazil and I had an accident and I needed to go to the emergency room I went to the

emergency room they wanted to operate right away but they couldn't because they didn't have my medical records and so then I in this horrible state had to call to get hospitals to transfer records down it took 72 hours to get the information down now imagine if I had all that information with me in my digital identity and I could have just shared it I could have gone into immediately these are really valuable use cases for digital identity and using that domain to represent that for a person and a company right like today that digital identity ibm.com amazon.com that is their identity having the same thing for individuals I think is a very concept well Sandy is a legend as anyone who's just seen that clip can probably gather would recommend you listen to the full episode because I learned a lot in that dishal identity is one of my favorite topics I think it's completely married to blockchain web 3 everything we do in the digital age basically I think when we have this infrastructure

layout at the bottom it's all about data immutability the quality of data guaranteeing that and then everything above that you want to attach to an individual so identity is so important for that okay to that clip there's two things I want to take from it one is Sandy explains things so well just saying like taking an asset is something online when you think about nft or tokenization taking an asset online she's so good at selling things and making it easy to understand but the other point when she's like okay she lost her friend lost her birthday certificate well people would say well okay well you just need to store things on your phone you have them on your phone or you have them physically but it's not enough really because the point is it's permanence you want to reference it somehow on a legend like if I have a certificate and in the hospital that printed that certificate burns down there's no way to verify the certificate I have in my possession actually corresp responds

to you know some kind of certificate authority to the hospital in the first instance so you want to have something that is immutable that is long lasting is resilient will be there in perpetuity and you need something like a blockchain to reference that that certificate I have in my possession actually has been signed off and timestamped at a certain point in time by a certain individual so yeah that is such a great use case it's been very well highlighted and explained by Sandy there yeah that you pretty much hit the nail in the head for like why I like this clip so much you beyond how how good she has explaining things is the that digital permanence aspect I think is something that can be overlooked with you know when you're talking about blockchains and so historically digital stuff you might think of as more vulnerable like more risky could be wiped easily or hard drive and stop working Than Physical records but I think that's one of the things that web through brings us

blockchains and you know specifically for me proof a work blockchains as well they are s so good compared to the old digital world for permanence of a record so I think yeah for me that's important point that she highlighted so yeah we're halfway through our favorite guest picks of the year so yeah why don't me take a quick break and we'll be back shortly today's episode is sponsored by the vchain foundation now we often talk about how emerging Technologies like blockchain have the potential to revolutionize sustainability and vchain is at the Forefront of this green movement with initiatives like V better let's take a closer look imagine tracking small actions like recycling at low cost making them valuable assets these verified records build a massive Collective impact that benefiting people through their own actions sound a bit complex but vchain made it fun explore our apps at v better.com v Chain's goal is to power a new era of Sustainable Solutions so if you've got an app idea or just want to earn rewards for

small sustainable actions every day go check out vet.com to find out more and now back to the show so let's get straight back to it Alec what's your second guest clip of the year so I'm actually combining two guests into one we've got Heather flry and Alex Kahana we've had them both on the podcast previously we bought them together for an episode all around self Sovereign AI combining two of my favorite topics self- Sovereign identity and the principles of self- sovereign identity and obviously AI let's take a look at the clip but unethical AI is a step backward is a principle then we're saying okay we live now in a data World in a digital world and we live in datafication so to speak all our actions are translated into Data and so what about this automatic harvesting and collection of our data all the time I am talking out to you and there's someone in the background that is collecting everything and taking it and using it and abusing it and losing it to

your point that we said from the last conversation that's ethical AI so what automatically we accept this idea without a conversation there will be automatic harvesting of all the data that is out there that afterwards will commoditized and what then the commoditization of everything is there we're going to sell everything on the SBT or nft or nontransferable nft or whatnot and so why is that important it's important because then what is my Approach do I collect everything and I do maximization of data like open AI does or for example I do minimization of data like Heather does because she's very concentrated on keeping the respect of human beings and the Dignity of human beings so that's what's important is that we already are down that road of deciding things without reflecting on the Deep issues that are simply just going by I'll be transparent um that this is work that my organization and our partners are uh seeking to advance as rapidly as possible what we're working on is not necessarily systems that would directly

prevent or change um any use of AI in the Enterprise and governance government space and we think we can influence that to the positive in many ways and intend to but the one thing that we're certain we can do and that must happen very quickly is we must introduce the capability for self- Sovereign Ai and and to be clear that is not a different kind of AI technology that is not what it is it is instead an operating Model A governance model an economic and financial structure that allows individual human beings including when they wish to become collectives as families or communities or Affinity groups uh that allows individual human beings to interact with technological parody with the endless thousands of AI eyes that will be influencing seeking to serve and influence them from across the private sector and the public sector many of those AI seeking to influence them may be compromised they may have intentions that are inconsistent with the aims and goals and interests of individuals or perhaps they are nominally aligned

like a ven diagram for example a healthc care provider wants to see their patient well and the patient wants to be well so in there there is an alignment but it is a vend diagram it is not a perfect alignment it is an alignment but not a perfect alignment of interests so self Sovereign AI requires First Data sovereignty and data sovereignty requires identity sovereignty so when you're talking about bringing that about that also means you need a system boundary and a compliance boundary placed around individual human beings such that from a technology perspective a person looks like an Enterprise from an IT perspective then this means now let's say you have this what we will have are the first self- Sovereign digital twins we will be having conversations with mirror images of ourselves that need to be completely private our approach is called the epitome and I can't even imagine the conversation between Dr Kahana and his epitome like that is going to be epic I just I want toate that was a powerful one

uh I know it was a long clip but there's so much packed into it and I think you know I was just making notes as that was going and I want to just you know try and touch on a few of the big points I think that are raised because yeah if if you're new to the podcast maybe that's not the episode to start with even though it's one of the best episodes I think there's some really high level Concepts coming in there um you know lots to pass so some of the things I noted right let's let's talk about Alex first he was focusing a lot on this idea of the automatic harvesting of data right he mentioned that phrase and I think that's something that has been very much kind of top of everyone's mind regarding ethical AI right he was saying ethical AI how are we accepting this notion of you know being ethical if it's you know the classic example being chat gbt and its training right um I think it

was year where the CTO or now previous CTO of open a open AI was interviewed remember this well she was interviewed and and asked live right is this trained on my Facebook data and kind of just ignored the question viws and it was very awkward right and that's that's been the central kind of worry of a lot of people about this unethical use of AI so far and that term means lots of other things but that's one thing I think I'm glad he was framing in that way um he also mentioned you know in terms of how we commoditize Ai and also just use use the data responsibly in the future he mentioned this idea of minimization so minimization of data I think that's really interesting because for me that's a very concrete bridge between Ai and web 3 yeah and you know lots of people just go AI web 3 you know match made in heaven but picking out specific reasons why it's it's good it's a good match is there right because web

3 is where a lot of the Privacy preserving Tech is zero knowledge proofs all been kind of developed within the realm of web 3 and that's where you get you know we've talked about selective disclosure before how we can use things in a minute minimalistic sense I think that's at the heart of web 3 so I really like that um well yeah just jump in on that one it it's so true I think people often try and force blockchain and zero knowledge proof and all this stuff into AI but like you say concrete example AI the point is I want data I want good data and most people what's the example we give for most dig we're combining so many different things here most people give the digital identity example like I go to a club and do I need to show them my entire history or my entire license passport whatever it is no all they need to know is that I'm above 18 and like you say it's a perfect example where the

thing we care about there really is ownership and data sovereignty and that is kind of like the fundamental pillar of what a lot of web 3 is and what a lot of kind of blockchain privacy prever preserving identity systems are about and yeah it's a great example they're combining that with what AI needs to do in the future to kind of be successful and most importantly probably serve Humanity in the best way yeah I I think 100% agree with you I think it's it's such an important topic and I I like the way he framed it and I think you know this is this is going to be a key feature I'm sure we releas saw episode next week on the future that's still going to be part of the theme so yeah uh hugely insightful from Alex in that episode and then to get onto what Heather was talking about she was very much focused on this idea of self- sovereign AI right which is super interesting topic and to be honest you know

this came out what five six seven months ago seven months ago now and at the time a lot of this was kind of wow like this is futuristic stuff I'm not quite getting everything here I need to listen to this a few times to take in what she's saying but I actually think my big takeaway is a lot of what she's saying in this clip now makes a lot more sense in the context of the last few months with this boom of AI agents right yeah yeah all I see at the minute is people talking about AI agents AI agents AI agents right so AI models imbued with additional functionalities right text to action this whole this whole thing that people are talking about so I I just that's my big takeaway is how much more crystallized this is uh three six seven months later down the line right now this makes perfect sense and when they were talking about having your own kind of AI doppelganger right your epitome going out there doing things

for you having your traits and stuff we we saw very early signs of that early in the year but now this is becoming like a very fast reality so yeah very very uh forward thinking it's a tiny bit tangental but I would recommend anyone who has free time over Christmas to watch this Netflix series called Pantheon and they talk about this concept of uploaded intelligence it is so juicy so great and the point here is the idea of uploading your intelligence to your personal device and getting all this functionality out of it and like you say this is not so far removed from reality right now and the point that Heather is making here is would I want to upload all of my personality my kind of the information my device my history all this very deep personal stuff to a cloud that's run by open AI almost certainly not but the idea that they will train models to a certain standard based on all the information that's out there and then you will give

that model a bit more information host it on your personal device is very real and it's probably going to be something we see in the not too distant future and I am ready for it I think I'm really excited for it but yeah that's a great one um shall we come to your next clip yeah so my third and final clip is from Cynthia uh now she has you know we had a couple of episodes this year about the general concept of web three and tourism and in this one and I really like the way she describes this new concept of the interconnected trip so yeah let's let's see how she describes it what exactly do you mean by interconnected trips yeah so I think that's the ideal that we in the travel industry have been working towards and trying to accomplish and the interconnected trip I think means something slightly different to different people in the industry the way that I see it is that it basically is like this endtoend um experience that's

personalized for you so regardless of how you start your journey if you're searching for flights or a hotel or even an experience that you want to book it doesn't really matter where you're coming in but it's going to remember like no matter where you start it will have your travel preferences or your booking preferences built into that so the idea is that you have all of the data for all of your trips that you've booked so if you're let's say if you travel somewhere by yourself maybe you have certain preferences when you're a Solo Traveler versus if you're traveling with your family or a partner or for work you might have again different preferences and so you almost have like these profiles that you can switch on and off and when you go to book anything it's going to remember those preferences and automatically filter and only surface things are super relevant for you and I think this is where AI comes in because AI is really really good at obviously looking for a lot

of data and being able to make those recommendations and I think where the web three aspect comes in is web 3 is amazing at storing a lot of interoperable data and that's one of the challenges that we've had on delivering in this interconnected trip is that every company is very siloed right that's sort of a Feature Feature or bug of web to and um I think they like to keep it that way where they have their own data they're not not sharing with anybody else if they're ever sharing their API it's permission to access and so it's basically impossible to deliver on this idea of an interconnected trip just because every company operates on its own and so Airbnb is not going to be sharing data with xedia xedia is not going to be sharing data with um you know Uber and so you as a consumer can never have that endtoend trip that's connected with all of your preferences for that very reason but web 3 one of the things that we talk about

a lot is this idea of interoperable data where if anybody is has data within one ecosystem now that data can be interoperable it uses the same data standards but also more importantly you as a consumer can choose who you want to share that data with so if you were like hey I really want this endtoend experience you can say I'm going to share it with Uber I'm going to share with Airbnb I'm going to share it with d travel I'm going to share it with Expedia and then everybody has access to your data to really be able to build that like custom profile but then you can revoke it at any time I like that I loved having C through on the podcast she was so enthusiastic her kind of story about how why she got into the tourism industry generally to bring people together the idea of experience other people's cultures I think was really moving and I think that's a kind of there's a real philosophical alignment of what web 3 and blockchain

and all these kind of Technologies are for and it's about empowering the individual peer-to-peer connections all this kind of stuff that clip in particular again is a perfect marment of AI plus web 3 plus digital identity you know AI obviously for analyzing all the vast amount of data creating personal kind of recommendations and preferences and then when we go to the more blockchain traditional web 3 stuff the concept of privacy preservation sovereignty over your data and then selective disclosure of what you want to send with the travel agency is kind of obvious the interoperability piece is a bit less obvious I didn't know there was such a problem with kind of traditional travel agency that they were kind of monopolizing the data and not sharing the apis and exposing things that is quite cool I mean I think that again aligns with a lot of the concepts of blockchain and Bitcoin removing these unnecessary intermediate intermediaries these monopolies and opening that system up in a permissionless way so yeah it's kind of so many different

topics all combined into like a two-minute clip so that that a really great recommendation she was a great guest yeah and and that's part of why I chose that one you know apart from Cynthia being brilliant and a wonderful speaker it was the topic right tourism and we also had Sam from Min pass on right I'm sure they're pretty sure they're good buddies as well but tourism for me was like one of the standout topics of the year in terms of seeing okay there are actually so many ways in which web 3 is related to it and has kind of these these links to it I had no idea right so it's for me it's stood out as one of the most promising applications this year um but yeah so that's my that's all my my picks done right so Alec why don't you round us off with your your third and final we had probably one of our most energetic guests on the show this year I think you might know who I'm talking

about we had the famous Aragon moland dijes um self-proclaimed future historian I think we kind of worked out what that term meant during the episode he's also known as Mr metaverse he talks about all things AI metaverse web 3 crazy he was an epic guest like he was so incredibly enthusiastic it was hard to find one clip to show from that entire episode I think there's about 50 and if I could choose him multiple times I proba would but here's the clip the final invention I think it's important to stress that I don't necessarily mean that we will not create any new technologies after AI in fact I think we're going to create many but I don't think we will be creating them as being Homo sapiens I think AI is going to launch us into new level of reality and civilization that we cannot possibly comprehend and so going forth Humanity will no longer be inventing things in and off ourselves right if you if we look at for example penicillin penicillin was well

okay technically wasn't invented it was empirically discovered maybe this is not the best example combustion engine let's take the combustion engine was a Belgian man who invented the combustion engine great invention we're using it every day he didn't put it in a car straight away that was Carl Ben who invented the car and then guess Carl Benz was told you know a horror horrid Contraption Henry Ford was forced to invent the conveyor belt so that he could mass-produce the malty that's how that went down all of these things all of these men invented things of course they used knowledge that they then got from people that came before them right Carl Benz build on the work of Jean shf and then hry Ford build on the work of Carl Ben we all stand on the shoulders of giants but up until this point mankind has been the sole Creator and inventor of our technology right and in that sense we invented these things we created them we came up with the ways of building them

and doing that that time is already over man's best and strongest technology today is no longer created just by men right up until a few years ago it was still Engineers with a computer basically some jacked up calculator on steroids but now that the game has changed right the game has changed now we're talking to an intelligence other than our own that is informing our decisions and our ideas and our creativity on every single test we can run at this point gbt 40 scores higher creativity marks than humans it's scoring an IQ of 125 to 130 on most standard tests and I guarantee you that at open AI right now there's they're not working like oh we have this team of humans and we're thinking about the next Ai No they're using the best version they have of gbd4 or something else to help them develop the next product and that AI might not be buil putting itself together yet it might not be reproducing its own species in that sense but it is helping

them build Nvidia has in inside the company they basically build an AI that holds all the knowledge of the company going back two three decades so they created basically an AI that represents their company and all its knowledge and everybody can talk to it that means that no Nvidia engineer going forward will ever be the sole inventor of something because they will always have created it in collaboration with this Ai and that is y AI is the final invention of humanity wow what a way to close off that clip I I absolutely love it I think yeah I mean first and foremost arag Gordon's enthusiasm his way of speaking is absolutely infectious I will also never forget the fact that he took a delivery during this this recording and just walked to the edge of the room opened the door didn't break stri just kept talking it was amazing but yeah that that clip is a really really good pick I think because it gets you inside his mind and the way he's thinking and

I think it's it's a good way to be thinking about these things right this idea that we we we may reached the end of purely man-made things right and now everything is going to be partly co-invented or co-created with AI I think is there there's there's a ring of truth to it right I think the fact that everyone is using Ai and things already especially in Creative topics or Creative Media like we had a recent episode on the biggest names in the game are doing it the smallest name into the game and do it you know everyone has to do it we have to use it as well to keep up with content generation right so this is just a thing that's here to stay now um and I think that's you know it's something we all have to think about is from a philosophical perspective what does it mean to create things in a world where we have ai um the other thing I I really liked about that clip right you know he

he reinforces a different version of digital permanence that we were talking about earlier because his idea when he talks about uh preserving company knowledge through AI I think it's brilliant because that's something you have in companies you have people drift you have employee churn you lose that knowledge well AI is now here to be the kind of the best knowledge base has ever been so yeah that's something for me is something that I hadn't thought about it before and I I came away from that episode just mind blown I like that the the company permanence thing because it's so true like get kind of the example we give can give for uh autonomous vehicles is someone has an accident they're removed from the road but we as like a a potential hive mind don't necessarily learn from that because that individual struck and then no one else gains that knowledge but when an autonomous vehicle a Tesla of the world has an accident obviously that car is not necessarily taken off the road but the

entire fleet will improve because of that and I think that kind of relates to what you're saying um the other thing that I really like from that clip and from what you're saying here is It's Kind it's difficult to know what it means for Humanity like are we kind of thought AI say two three years ago when everyone playing around with chaty te was it's going to do the menial tasks it's going to do the laborious tasks the kind of the dumb tasks traditionally You' think of but more and more it diving into the realm of the really high functioning task it's doing The Cutting Edge research it's assembling the molecules to create new substances to create whatever and I think on the one hand from a civilization progression standpoint that's obviously very advantageous we're going to move at a much faster rate on the other hand like you say you get into philosophy and we're not going to do it here don't have enough time is what does it Humanity what's it have place

in it are we still pushing the envelope or are we just pressing the button and saying go does it make us lazy does it make us lazy do we end up like the w-e kind of people that are in space doing nothing just pressing buttons and being you know pushed around but yeah I I don't know I think it depends on the individual right and I know for for me I'm definitely Outsourcing a lot of the tasks I don't like and hopefully that means that I have more time for the tasks I do like but we'll see yeah the irony of doing our first IRL podcast while saying we're Outsourcing everything it's very funny awesome so that's our that's our picks right of guests um as is tradition shall we do our favorite clips of each other now yeah I think are you going to go first I'm always a bit worried about the clips you're going to choose because Jack does mostly editing so he has all the out cuts and issues and double

takes so I have all the stuff that he forgets about so yeah let's uh no let's go with you so I have picked a kind of a quick succession of clips from episode 65 where we did our kind of 101 on uh quantum physics and Quantum in general as it relates to you know Quantum Computing so yeah let's take a look in early 1900s where we were at was we knew that atoms existed and to a degree we knew that electrons existed but we didn't really know why elements behave differently we didn't really know too much about electrons namely because you know we could didn't have them the tools to actually measure them properly I'd say so you had this big man named Max plank I know he's a bit of a hero of yours Jack and he noticed had some observations around melting Steels and melting iron and melting your Metals basically and as you would add temperature you would get these these discolorations these changes but unlike most of this classical kind of

physics we talk about where we have this Continuum occurring you would have these discrete steps occurred that he couldn't actually work out as to why so you know I heated my iron I don't know why I'm heating iron I'm a forger blacksmith in medal ages or something like this and it changes color it changes to yellow and I keep heating it and it's still yellow and then there's a discrete jump as they get to a certain threshold of temperature that it goes to Orange and it stays at that threshold for a while then eventually it goes to Blue and we basically had these discrete steps these discrete quantities and you know that's kind of where it came about like that's why Max plank came up with the term quantum because of these discrete quantities of basically energy being taken by these atoms it's just crazy that the ameran names like we've only been talking for less than a couple of minutes and the amount of names we're bringing into this they like the big names

of physics and science they kind of the names that a house told names in many places but yeah Max plank kind of challenged classical physics introduced the concept of like plank constant anyone who's done any physics any stage knows about this and he laid the groundwork for quantum mechanics and basically started the boom of science around subatomic particles and kind of after that you know Jack just name dropped him a bit early there two camps kind of emerged for the study around subatomic particles that are kind of relevant to this one was Neil's bour and the other was Schrodinger the famous Schrodinger and yeah there were kind of two camps that were opposed in some ways initially they kind of was a bit of slandering toss between them because they viewed the subatomic World in a different way but in the end it kind of the two ways basically describe the same system but just from a different Viewpoint I mean if I was at the time I would agreed with bore because that's the

only thing that would have made sense to my simple mind is the idea of having these fixed particles as soon as we start to get to this like wave like kind of probabilistic location so we don't know exactly where they are there's like a probability they're going to be somewhere maybe a probability they're going to be somewhere else like it kind of just blows the mind a little bit I think a way to simplify this is that the kind of the classical deterministic science is very much like outcomes are 2 plus 2 always equals four and when we start to get to this wave particle duality where know Shing as kind of viewpoint that electrons behaved as waves and they were in probabilistic location so there's 20% chance it could be here 40% chance it could be here imagine if your maths now changes to 2 plus two has a 10 10% chance of equaling five all of a sudden it becomes quite impractical when we think on the big scale but it's very useful

when we start to think on the smaller scale and you know this kind of viewpoint really led to groundbreaking research in how we actually understood sub subatomic particles wow what a clip I just realized how quickly I talk I need to slow down but also God damn we look so tanned there it's so nice um I really enjoyed that episode I really enjoyed doing the research for it because it's such an interesting topic like very acade well has been traditionally very academic and is kind of becoming more practical you're seeing people constantly talk about the impacts of quantum especially in the crypto world but why did you choose that well there's a couple of reasons here firstly you're covering one of my favorite stories in all of science what how excited you were when talking exactly exactly the whole you know buildup to the quantum revolution in physics generally is one of my favorite things I think I'm pretty sure my personal statement was based on that story when I was when I was you

17 um but you know that aside I I think you did such a great job here of explaining that story and the most important parts of you know what this new model of physics actually meant at the time because my instinct is to go into the details and I'm pretty sure we had to kind of have a couple of goes at recording this episode it was definitely one of our toughest ones because of the subject matter and I think you just did such a good job here of distilling down okay what do people actually care about and then then I would come in and do that okay but if if the Nerds are in the room want to hear then then here's what I think but yeah I think you just did a really good job of keeping this one on on track thanks I I remember the first take of this and after 20 minutes I think we both just paused I'm like this is too much even for us but yeah I it

was fun it was very fun to record I think one of our most popular episodes actually maybe because Quantum is a bit of a buzz word but I think yeah this was probably the one of the most dialed episodes we've done and probably because it's quite a recent one as well but thanks I appreciate that you ready for yours put me out of misery I wonder if you know which one this is going to be you have a suspicion so this is from our episode on zero knowledge proofs one of your favorite topics um I can see how excited you are when you're actually doing the explanation of this again this is another one that took multiple Cuts famously and maybe we'll do show some of the outakes afterwards but here's the clip essentially think you've got two friends say me and Alec and one of us is color blind so in this scenario I'll be the prover and Alec will be the verifier so Alec is my color blind friend for this example the

verif fire so let's say I've got two balls one of them is colored red one of them is colored green I've got two balls you should get those checked out I've got one red ball one green ball and my statement that I want to prove is that these two balls are different colors because you Alec you can't tell that CU you're color blind right so to you the balls look exactly the same to me they're different colors so how do I prove the statement to you that these are actually different colors in practice what I can do is I can ask you to hold them and put them behind your back so I give you to the two balls you put them behind your back and then you can decide to switch them so again you're the verifier you're going to switch or not switch those balls you're going to show them back to me and then I'm going to tell you if you've switched them or not okay so because I can see the

color difference I should be able to correctly identify if you switch them or not and you'll know if you switch them or not because you've done the physical movement of switching them okay that's a very simple kind of challenge response I you challenge me to identify if it's changed and then I respond to tell you it has or hasn't now I could get this right with probability a half okay so how do we make sure you're convinced by this statement is then you would repeat that many many times so switching or not switching and then I'll be able to guess right every single time and the probability of me doing that just by random chance is vanishingly small if you do many many of these challenge response back and forth so at high level that's how it works and you can be convinced even though you're color blind that these are actually different color ah my old enemy that clip I actually we just laughed as we were watching that I didn't remember we left

that much of the blooper in I think that's a blooper of a blooper I don't think we meant to leave that it's a truncated blooper because we released the full clip on social media we'll leave a link in the comments if you want to see the absolute Parx isms of laughter that we were in after that blue perception it still ended up in there I don't think either of us realized that took so long to record the idea of youing got two col balls it's such a shame that the it's the canonical example of how to explain zero knowledge and it just happens to involve two big balls so yeah that was that was a fun one to record what what I I don't I'm not gonna ask why you picked that one it's just comedy Val it actually goes it's not just comedy value I think zero knowledge proof is such a tricky thing to explain especially on a podcast I I think you did it so well and this is a famous example

it is what most people use but I still think it's very tricky to get across and you did and you so brave to talk about your balls on air but it was a good example I think it really does explain how zero knowledge works at a high level and this a deeply technical thing so I was very impressed even though I was smirking throughout the entire clip trying to hold it together and you like you said just you disassociated you managed to get through it but it also is one of my all-time favorite moments of life I think it was so funny I think we ended up like blooping out like 20 minutes of us just laughing about this but we kept some in as well so yeah we'll definitely show that blueprint again at the end of this because it is really worth a watch okay well if if everyone wants that as their their Christmas present then they can have it but yeah no thank you I think I think yeah I think

you're right it's um that was it's funny that our best clips of the year have come from the two most challenging topics I think right it shows that we we put a lot of effort into to getting these ones right we need to push ourselves more often maybe and stop talking about ai ai is too easy um yeah so with that bombshell I guess that's the end of our first ever episode IRL it's the end of another year of untangling web 3 another calendar year so yeah join us next week where we'll be talking about our predictions for 2025 and to everyone at home I guess Merry Christmas yeah and join us next time to entangle a little more of web 3

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Business & Society

Related episodes

All episodes