Episode 31

2023: The Web3 Review

Watch on YouTube

About this episode

In this year-end review episode, the hosts recap the major themes and events of 2023 in the web3 space. They kick off by discussing the significant impact of AI, notably Chat GPT, and its role as a game-changing application in making AI practical and understandable for users. The hosts emphasize the synergy between AI and blockchain technologies, particularly in tackling issues like data sovereignty and privacy.

The conversation then shifts to the financial landscape, highlighting the recent banking collapses, including the fall of Silicon Valley Bank and its ties to crypto assets. This has sparked a growing interest in distributed cash systems and decentralized alternatives to state-controlled money. The hosts also discuss the challenges facing traditional financial systems, evidenced by layoffs and a shift towards AI in the web3 industry. They note the growing pains of web3, including regulatory actions and fines, particularly in Western countries, and acknowledge Ethereum's transition to proof of stake as a crucial development addressing environmental concerns.

In the latter part of the episode, the hosts delve into various topics within web3 and crypto. They contrast proof of work and proof of stake in cryptocurrencies, mention the rising institutional interest exemplified by Blackrock's ETF approval, and explore the tokenization of real-world assets. Despite hypocritical statements from traditional finance figures, they note a secret investment in the crypto space.

The concept of the metaverse, especially with Apple's entry with the Apple Vision Pro headset, is discussed, suggesting a shift in focus towards utility-focused projects and NFTs. The hosts conclude by reflecting on their podcast journey, thanking listeners for their support, and promising more exciting content in 2024, with a festive wish for a happy Christmas.

00:00 The metaverse and its impact on Web3 in 2023. 02:05 Chat GPT as AI's impact on Web3 05:43 AI and blockchain's role in data ownership and transparency 07:28 Traditional Finance banking collapses and its impact on web3 11:05 Web 3 and traditional finance need to work together for robust systems. 12:50 Web3 and crypto companies experienced significant layoffs due to market conditions and the shift towards AI. 16:23 Regulatory uncertainty impacting compliance in Web3 companies 17:54 Web3 businesses facing uncertainty and changing regulations 20:57 Shifting trust paradigm from authority to energy or stake in the Proof of Work vs Proof of Stake debate. 22:21 Greenpeace called for Bitcoin to change its codebase to reduce energy usage 25:40 Spot ETFs and institutional advertising signal web3's growing maturity. 27:13 Institutional adoption of digital assets is increasing. 30:28 The decline of the metaverse in 2023 32:12 The metaverse is a promising concept but may still need time to truly take off. 35:17 Apple's pause on smartwatches and shift to spatial computing 36:51 Utility moving to the forefront in crypto, shakeout of bad actors

Transcript

Auto-generated from the episode audio.

in 2023 I think we have to mention is the metaverse right so we've had a few episodes on the metaverse just to kind of recap we had in 2021 the name change Facebook to meta then from there you get about hundred billion dollars I've seen is the figure spent on R&D right and there was this yeah there was this division of of meta Creator called reality Labs well they reported a loss of around 24 billion across 2021 2022 and yeah 2023 barely gets a mention welcome to another episode of the untangling web 3 podcast it's getting to the end of the year now and this episode will be a nice hopefully short and Punchy review of 20123 and what we've seen so far how are you doing today my little elf Jack yeah being very merry thanks your little helper today but um yes we've got we've got our Christmas jumpers on it's that time of year I think it's good to uh to look back on on the year we've had in 2023 right

there's been a lot going on lots of uh lots of big events but also kind of General themes right that we we've kind of uh teased out I think in today's episode so hopefully we'll see what the bigger picture is for for web three and then next week we'll we'll maybe do some crystal ball gazing and see what we think is coming next year yeah I think the the crystal ball will be quite interesting just so we can obviously this is our first year we've only been around for seven months at this stage but as we kind of get this continuation we can see how close our predictions are to the reviews at the end of the year we're in a golden era right now where we can't be held accountable for any of our predictions um but yeah should we kick it off then this has been a super spicy year and my number one for the year I think it's a term that's on a lot of people's tongues right now is AI

obviously at the start of the Year well it was actually the end of 2022 we saw chat G com about right and AI has been around for a long time like a lot of people have been working in the space But as we've talked about in great detail now Chad GPT was the killer application of AI for a lot of people it made AI understandable it made it uh kind of real and practical and tangible for people to just jump on on the interface throw some queries at it and see the pair of AI and I think this is one of the most impactful things for web 3 in mind yeah exactly and it's probably worth you know mentioning our distinction the way we see web 3 right is that I think we see AI as a big part of the larger web 3 space right it's it's a it's a technology that sits next to and in in conjunction with all the other kind of blockchain smart contract tokenization aspects of web 3 and

traditionally I especially before this year I think they were seen as very separate Industries but you know what what we've seen with the rise of chat GPT is yeah it's had its killer up everyone's now taking it seriously people have seen okay this is there is real kind of consumer utility to be had with AI and and that explosion of chat GPT and actually we've seen that take a lot of a lot of focus and attention away from the rest of web 3 right let's let's call it the rest of web 3 because some people would say you know everyone's moved on from web 3 to AI now but actually I think it's just the focus has shifted a lot right yeah I mean like you say we saw I think it was I think chat gbt went live in November 2022 and by febr 2023 they had 100 million active users you know this year at the end of this year 33% of companies are starting to use AI in their everyday business practices

like this is big and yeah I completely agree we kind of see it under the general umbrella term of web 3 but it it probably is has been to the detriment of say some of the more traditional web three topics like blockchain and digital identity and all these kind of things um I think yeah one thing that I mean I know that you agree with as well is that the use of AI is not to the detriment of these topics though I think as we see more and more people using AI as you see some of the issues that are starting to come about about you know chat GPT being trained by scraping the internet where does data belong where does data sovereignty lie all this kind of stuff I think it's actually going to be an absolute Game Changer and opportunity for blockchain for digital identity you know for zero knowledge proofs I think AI is going to bring people into you know the general web three space they can understand the benefits but

there's going to be a lot of issues that come about because of that I think that's going to take everyone in the journey to a lot of the topics already talked about where data sovereignty is probably at the core of that yeah 100% I mean it's completely put into context this whole conversation around you know data security and privacy because now there's a there's there's a real thing out there with chat GPT and all its competitors you know we've seen so many competitors come out this year from other companies you've got grock now from Twitter you've got Bard from Google they're springing up every day right but it's it's really stoked this conversation around okay what's our sovereignty over data in this context because you know chat GPT effectively being you know trained on the internet data without anyone's consent really um and now okay cool we're using it for something it's great but our question is now how do we use this in an ethical way going forward how do we make sure the

data sets used to train them are managed uh you know with security and privacy in mind so I think it's if anything you know in the short term and and at the start of the Year definitely it felt like okay all the VC money is moving away from the traditional other kind of areas of web 3 all the heads have been turned now to AI but actually I think it's shifting back and people are starting to realize Ai and blockchain specifically and other web 3 Technologies they're kind of a match made in heaven they will have to work in concert going forward basically right and during our data ownership um episode where we talked about this in detail we said that most people don't probably care about data ownership in like the full sense of the term but I think because of AI that conversation is happening more and more readily and it's also happening from regulatory standpoint as well like the EU AI act actually came out and they talked about you know what

are the limits what are companies allowed to do they said you know you're not allowed to do internet scraping for certain very personal types of data like pictures of yourselves emotional things related to healthc care and all this kind of stuff and they also said systems for AI which you know typically considered the black box I have no idea how chat PT trains their models that kind of issue well they has to be more transparent and I think these are a lot of opportunities for you know blockchain we talked about Providence you know next year and the year after I think we're going to really see a boom of all these deep fakes and I think it's going to cause an absolute hell for the upcoming presidential election and I think that's going to be Paramount there's going to need to be Providence there's going to need to be public provability of of the source of some of these materials and I think it's a real opportunity for blockchain know the web three topics so

yeah it's a huge one AI is an absolute number one for me yeah I think it they definitely deserve to be first on this list right because it's if we' recorded this episode this time last year it would have also been the only thing anyone was talking about and it's proven to be you know the hype was real not the pace of change hasn't stopped it's accelerated so yeah I think it is deservedly kind of first on our list um and again I don't think the the list apart from this is necessarily in order but um but that one probably probably is so I think the second theme or the big kind of Suite of events we've seen this year was actually not so much in the web 3 space but it's something highly related to it right so we saw this this kind of wave of of banking collapses in traditional Finance so you know I think the number was five banks in the end actually collapsed to the highest number since we've seen

since 2017 right and everyone's now thinking you know this is slightly mirroring the 2008 financial crash you've got interest rates on the rise all this stuff right so people are saying history is repeating in the traditional Finance world and that's obviously spurring a conversation again on the motivation and need for uh distributed cash systems money that is separated from State right so I think that is also something that's that's helped to bring web3 back into the conversation from where it was maybe this time last year when everyone was saying okay well web3 is dying AI is the the main thing yeah I think it was really interesting to see this earlier on in the year where there was these they weren't just small Banks like it was Silicon Valley Bank was the biggest right that's a very wellknown Bank in America assets of like 200 billion or something like that quite establish 40 years old all this kind of stuff um and for them to collapse because of bank run and I think one of

the things that we have to mention here obviously the relation to web 3 is they were um I guess one of the more friendly crypto Banks right they actually had their um kind of involvement in a lot of crypto projects they they were investing in a lot of crypto projects directly or or indirectly and initially when this Bank Run happened that we've talked about in detail previously a lot of people saying it's because they were exposed to crypto assets and that was the reason it's all crypto's faults not there nothing wrong with traditional Financial systems and that was what I I understood and we saw you know a dip in the stock market obviously bit a larger dip in crypto assets because of this and then very quickly crypto recovered and a lot of people were using them as safe havens because it turned out that actually it it wasn't really because of their exposure to crypto specifically it's because there wasn't there wasn't good regulation there wasn't good transparency it was actually issues with

you know traditional Financial systems and then actually crypto became the Safe Haven post that it was a really interesting this kind of set the tone the early narrative was very anti- crypto and then actually was a proof that you know traditional Finance sometimes can make mistakes in the same way that decentralized Finance it can as well yeah and I think this is almost kind of adding more fuel to the fire of what we saw throughout covid right and then a couple of years leading up to now is all the money printing that's going on the D destabilization of various different Fiat currencies in the world that you know do do provide more evidence and backing for okay justification we need U proper services in web 3 we need functioning scalable blockchains that can handle user demand for whole countries and things that they can they can have safe havens for their assets but you know at the same time with this traditional banking kind of collapse in various places we saw that element of contagion

right the same as you say the same contagion we saw in D5 with the collapse of terraluna last year and also FTX you know some of the contagion with all the other companies associated with that also impacted web 3 this year with with the Silicon Valley Bank collapse right as you said it was they were the ones who were providing a lot of banking services to these companies they couldn't get it elsewhere and then they had this you know in particular the one of the indirect effects was you saw with usdc right so they held lots of those reserves for for the stable coin usdc issuer Circle held lots of their reserves with svb and there was a temporary D pegging from the US dollar right so this wasn't like with Luna or or you could have with other algorithmic stable coins where there was a dep pegging because of the web three elements it was actually a d Peggy because of trauma and problems happening in in the traditional Finance world but you know

what's your take in it overall because for me I think um although significant this this doesn't really change too much for me I think there's enough momentum behind web 3 now there's enough momentum in the narratives we know there's a need for for these these alternative asset types right um yeah so I think it's it's significant to show that the same problems that were there in 2008 right when when Bitcoin was born are still there today so we haven't solved them the traditional way so I think it does show us that there isn't there's still a need let's say for traditional money uh money we talked about it in the FTX and binance and I think the thing was that all systems are fallible to humans right and a lot of this is human a human problem at the end of the day and I think yeah one of the one of the actual kind of narratives I saw coming out of this stuff was around people being anti- Fiat the idea of being able

to hold you know fractional reserves is evil and this is what happens when you actually have that system I think yeah you're right like it's um I don't think it was necessarily anti- web 3 and anti cryptocurrency it just showed there's vulnerabilities in everything and the more transparent one can be the better and maybe that does lend itself slightly to web 3 and that would be my take on it maybe just to kind of compliment that as well right it does show that there is still this need for web 3 and web two to play ball with one another for traditional finance and defi to play ball right because they are interconnected and in an ideal end State you will have this big mixing and crossover between traditional finance and web 3 based Finance so I think it shows that there there's need for more robust systems to actually handle that I think going forward definitely and like we always say there's always a need for regulatory oversight being in web two and web three

like that is essential and that kind of leads me to the next one which is around web 3 growing pains and really the institutional regulation and fines that have come in in the space we've had an entire episode I think last week on this and there's a few different areas that we could talk about on this one the early one was actually probably all negative right it was around the web 3 and crypto layoffs like early 2023 there was in q1 there was like 20% layoffs across the board for huge huge companies like coinbase crypto.com consensus Bitcoin Swiss chain analysis they were laying off one fifth of their Workforce across the board and there was a couple of reasons this one of it was partly because there was a bare Market you know less money coming in people you know being a bit more reluctant to invest all this kind of stuff less enthusiasm less optimism so people have to cut especially considering there've been a lot of growth in the previous year so everyone

was expecting that that that would continue and they need to prepare for that and have have the the kind of the staff base to do that so that was bad across the board um the other thing was to do with AI like we said I mean a lot of the hype that was going into crypto blockchain decentralization all this kind of stuff was then shifting to Ai and you saw like a lot of these companies that were deines from web 3 or more traditional web three topics that say like blockchain and crypto um were then pushing into Ai and that like got so much attention right I think one of the the Mad things that I saw as IBM this huge huge company said that any we're going to freeze hiring any jobs that that are related or could even potentially be related to AI were going to freeze until we understand if AI can actually do those jobs and that was 25,000 jobs that was related to like it just blew my mind how

quickly companies were jumping on the fact that AI could do you know a lot of jobs probably more efficiently more cheaply than people and they woke up to that fact very quickly it feels like a bit a perfect storm right what we had especially earlier in the year is that coming out of 2022 not only had you had this prolonged bare Market entering it second or third year I lose count at this point and all the Fallout from FTX and everything that happened all the contagion with the stable coins um all the stuff that happened in 2022 that was pretty cataclysmic for web 3 and then all of a sudden comes along this new poster boy for Tech in AI right so you have these two things you know hand over the Baton to for all the VCS and all the money it's going to obviously go straight to to the AI project so yeah we saw all these layoffs that was that was particularly kind of harrowing at the start of the year I

think I think there is a bit of a recovery now but it was quite quite um Stark that the change in narrative across the year and then you know going later into the year we have I guess all a lot of those problems in web 3 coming to maturity with all the legal and Regulatory action action right as we spoke about in the last episode The the SEC rulings about whether or not bit think things like Bitcoin and ethereum our Securities Commodities exchange tokens all these things have been kind of slowly moving towards resolution I think even though we don't have full clarity some of the interactions the SEC have had with coinbase and and and with xrp and things like that have answered some of those questions and has angered a lot of people in some cases right I think cardano was one of the examples of this happening with with the Securities regulations so that's been a big theme this year of actual regulatory teeth starting to take take hold in the market

which is not helpful for a lot of the the classical web 3 companies which were trying to take advantage of the LAX environment before not necessarily a bad thing but something significant yeah it's hard I think like like you say it's not necessarily a bad thing because as we always said regulation is good I think my issue with the whole SEC debacle early on was that it it wasn't clear for a lot of people and like this kind of stuff's important like how assets taxed and regulated is very important I remember like seeing Gary gendler um in in court trying to Define things and CH it seemed like he changed a lot and it wasn't like the regulation wasn't clear and now he's come out blaming web 3 companies for not complying and say okay well you're not been complying we're going to punish you and they' well they've been there like well we've been trying to comply but we haven't had regulatory certainty to actually move with it and you've kind of you've been

regulating through enforcement after something has happened rather than you know creating the standards in advance and then expecting people to match those standards which is an issue and I think it's very difficult for web 3 companies like coinbase obviously spent a lot of time working with the SEC to understand how they could comply and they got publicly listed to a great expense to them I think it was FDX actually had the most interactions with the SEC and look how that went like it didn't really end up very well for them right I mean that's one of the other big things we've talked in great detail about um FDX and obviously they're gone there that was a huge issue um we talked about the criminal case and and that that concluded in December but the class action still ongoing but like you say I think a lot of this stuff including the binance stuff as well there's a silver lining there we say regulation's good regulatory certainty is good it provides users and businesses more trust

and in the end of the day that leads to more adoption I think that's really needed and we're going to see institutional adoption I hope this is an early early kind of um Crystal Ball but I think we are going to see a lot of institutional adoption coming forward yeah definitely I agree with that with that silver line and it's also worth mentioning you know these growing pains are probably being most starkly felt you know in the Western World America and the UK in particular and the EU to an extent right because that's where a lot of the the it's become more hostile towards crypto and web 3 in the last couple of years UK is a very difficult place to to have a web three business in the US you have all this uncertainty if you're even you know as big as coinbase and you still don't know then then that's a worrying sign but lots of places in the world taken different you know blockchain and web three is global it's distributed in

nature as as we always say so there are actually many other jurisdictions which are taking different parts and I think that's it kind of speaks to the one of the beautiful things I web through right is that it can move anywhere it can move to where the environment is most uh most appealing for them but yeah I think it's it's it's something to keep tabs on next year right let's see how those environments Chang going into 2020 for and and you said it really well last time I think it's one of the episodes I can't remember which one it was like one of the things is around the rapid growth right it's actually the change that's happened the the kind of the rate of change that's happened it's the fact that these companies have grown so very quickly out of nowhere like FTX was just 200 people and they were managing tens of billions worth of assets I think that's some of the growing pains as well is that there's just been so much demand

and these companies have been trying to match that and cutting Corners to do that and I think well this is speculation as well we're probably going to see that with a lot of the AI stuff that's coming as well because these companies are getting so much investment so quickly and let's see if the regulatory certainty is there and in place to actually make sure they do it safely yeah that's a great point you know what if the regulatory Hammer comes down on AI next year right and then everything moves back to web 3 that's definitely a possibility so I think the fourth thing I wanted to talk about in terms of you know what have we seen this year one of the big events that we've seen not just a theme but an event was ethereum moving to proof of stake right this was a huge huge shift for the the second largest blockchain and arguably the most popular in terms of building applications on top right so this was it was a number of

years in in in development at some stages it like it might not happen but you know it got over the line in September 2023 so to recap ethereum changed its entire consensus algorithm and this is huge I know some chains may have done this but on a much smaller scale for much smaller blockchains but ethereum one of the leading blockchains managed to change from proof of work so expending a lot of energy to produce blocks and maintain the blockchain to prove your stake so basically cuts down kind of almost something like 99% of the the direct electricity consumption and by extension the emissions associated with running the blockchain overnight right that switch just happened and this kind of plays into this wider theme of the conversation around the environmental impacts of blockchain and web 3 right this has been quite a hot topic for a number of years and it's become much more under the spotlight in 2023 with this proof of State merge for ethereum yeah this was going on for a long time

right they called it the merge and it was kind of like looming over people for a long time and I think one of the issues was that you know proof of work even though it does have uh a big energy consumption and that's the cost right there it had been battle tested it had been you know being used in Bitcoin since 2008 no real hacks no real flaws people trusted in that whereas proof of stake completely untested in a way and I think that's gonna be really interesting to see if there are any issues that come about I think a good friend of mine explained it to me quite recently is that you know we have trusted systems right now we trust an authority and they'll stamp of approval over things and that's quite a centralized traditional system the idea of proof work was that you trust in the hash you trust in the amount of energy being used in the network and that's what you trust and you're Shifting the trust Paradigm and proof

of stake then goes in a different direction you're now trusting stake you're now trusting someone's assets and that's you know moving away from the energy and there's some downsides to that obviously we have the upsides that it's going to save energy and all this kind of stuff canare Pro work but some of the downsides are it can be self perpetuating to people with assets and you know there's no incentive for other people to get involved it's quite difficult for other people to get involved and will it create these kind of I don't know dragons sitting on top of a pile of gold at the end of the day and it's difficult to know what will happen with that yeah um I think it'll warrant a full episode to explore this right because it's such a super interesting topic that the differences and Arguments for against proof of work and proof of stake but that's the big one right is the is the fact that there is no real energy consumption required for proof of stake

and you say it's not battle tested but some people would say well it's been battle tested in the traditional Finance world for many many years right it kind of mirrors what we have there which is an interesting take but on this kind of environmental question you've also seen I think bandwagoning on this and ethereum effectively uh accepting for one reason or another to go down this path did you see the attack by Green piece on bitcoin this year that kind of jumping on this proof of stake Hy were you aware of this Al no not no what is it so I can't it happened sometime kind of early earlier this year but Greenpeace basically started coming out publicly and saying Bitcoin needs to change its codebase to stop using so much energy right because it was saying you know in 2022 62% of the energy maintaining Bitcoin was not from renewable resources I think I think that was the figure that they quoted so they actually came out and they they pinpointed all of the

uh big Financial Services players right black Brock Fidelity JP Morgan all these big players we talk about on the institutional adoption side and they said you guys are all helping to further Bitcoin you're you're promoting its use in the future but we need you to acknowledge the impact of Bitcoin mining we need you to acknowledge that it's energy intensive that lots of that energy currently is coming from non-renewable sources and they basically came out and said you need to go and check change the code which I think is a a thinly veiled you know expression of you need to adopt proof of stake right which is really interesting you have a massive play like that coming in now yeah it's a difficult one like I've WR um what's his name Bill Gates book on environmental impact and how to live a sustainable future and his his take is you know we can't stop development we can't say we're no longer going to use energy to improve the quality of living because I mean there's a

few reasons one as we develop obviously the world the living standards improveed there's Le less economically developed countries around the world that you know have to develop and have to consume more energy it's just ensuring that the amount of energy we use for certain tasks is worth the utility that's created and I kind kind of get it right now Bitcoin the way it's being used is just a store of value all of that energy is being used for you know just holding gold effectively and it's kind of moved away from the utility that would have been you know the electronic cash system that it was set up to be and I think yeah it is it's a valid point a lot if this energy is been used just to store value then you know what's the point but if it's being used for real utility like an electronic cash system like all the many applications that can be built on blockchain that we've talked about that have real value then that's something that actually need

to discuss it you can't just be okay any energy is any energy usage is always bad like I think that's the wrong stance but it's always good to you know think about the environment and consider sustainability in the conversation and I think one of the interesting things is like you see like by market cap which we've talked about previously Mark caps is a very weird way to evaluate cryptocurrencies um I think only maybe of the top 30 or 20 three of them use proof will work now I think it's BTC Litecoin and then Doge after that which just shows the quality the rest are all using proof of stake or proof of authority and all these new consensus algorithms that they coming out and a bit untested yeah it's not making the most compelling argument for using proof of work when it's just those kind of chains at the minute right yeah exactly um but on the Green Piece you know coming in and trying to go to these big companies and saying you know

Force Bitcoin to actually start to consider more environmentally friendly consensus mechanism the number five that I want to talk about and we've talked about this in great detail and already mentioned it in this episode is is the institutional interest that is picking back up in the web 3 space obviously everyone should know now about the Black Rock ETF this is a huge boost to to web 3 and crypto generally I think one of the the news articles that we talked about previously was around the coindesk falce flag where they said it had been approved and this ETF you know instantly led to a 10% rise in the in the kind of the market cap and price of BTC and there's lots of other spot ETFs that are coming off the back of this right now they have that uncertainty one of the things that I've been seen all over social media as like actual advertisements talking about Satoshi and Bitcoin and the big players now trying to already assume that their ETFs are going to

go through trying to get people to use their ETFs and it's really funny seeing like traditional kind of uh Banks and traditional kind of Institutions come in and try and advertise crypto because they do it really well and it's actually got me trying thinking about investing in as well yeah and I I think that's like there there seems to be a swaye of maturity now coming for all the actors who still remain web three after the the kind of ShakeOut of the last year or so is that a lot of them are are have seemed to have grown up a bit and are now appealing to the traditional Finance much more than the your just your crypto consumers I don't know if you saw the coinbase advert that came out recently really really amazing compelling oh you know it's it's such such a kind of heartstrings pull about the value proposition of yeah it great um is the new it's the new uh John Lewis Christmas ad right yeah well the point was like you

can work your ass off and still not be able to compete in the world and still not be able to buy a house but you know being able to allow anyone to invest in these Solutions is is good and accessibility is important and yeah it really tugged on the the heartstrings it made me want well I do use coinbase now after that but it was a good one yeah very effective so they you know they are targeting these proper institutional adopters we' talked at length about the ETF and people are talking about it now like it's a foregone conclusion right people are predicting the day exactly on which it'll be approved in in January which is interesting but I think it's it's fair to assume that there is more acceptance coming of these digital assets as a new asset class that people want there's enough demand now even despite um what's happened in the last couple of years with all the all the all the crashes and the ftxs of the world people still fundamentally

are clamoring for these alternative assets and these companies are going to provide those services for people and one of the interesting themes that's come out of this is um tokenization right that was a super hot term and topic you know the last number of years much more popular in say 2019 2020 and that's when your big Banks and and investment firms are talking about tokenizing assets that that kind of died away over the last few years but now has seen a real Resurgence with a new name so now they're calling it real world assets they're saying how do we rwa you'll see that term everywhere right so it's definitely something that's come out of 2023 and this increased pickup of institutional adoption is um tokenizing real world assets as as we talked about in the the tradire episode there's a big demand to make very illiquid assets um you know things like Company ownership things like real estate things like Collectibles that are traditionally quite a liquid the private markets right that's the the big

the big area right private markets which are hard to gain access to actually you can make these assets very liquid Now using web 3 tools so they're calling it rwas if you see it in the next year that's what they're referring to um but yeah there's clearly people not only accepting Bitcoin and its compatriots as like an asset class but also the technology and tools on top to tokenize things that was a bit of literation but they're really seeing the opportunity there and advantage of that yeah and I want to give a couple of shout outs to people on this one obviously Larry fin the CEO of Black Rock he was one of the uh the biggest crypto haters and Bitcoin haters like what two three years ago and all of a sudden he's it's like it's his new thing right he's obsessed with it it's all he ever tweets about so he's been converted um I mean one of the one of the other people I want to share to is Jamie dimon he's

on he's the JP Morgan CEO and he's coming out hard against crypto and BTC specifically right now and he's saying you know if if you Congress could and they could take up a Bitcoin he should shut it down it's just for drug dealers and they won't comply and all this kind of stuff I think he's a bit hypocritical because you know JP Morgan's paid 40 billion in fines for AML money laundering and actually not complying with regulations I there's a bit of a hypocrisy there but also there's another level of hypocrisy where they've increased their crypto and blockchain team from 100 to 300 in 2023 so it's like they're saying one thing say don't invest in this thing it's bad but really it seems like they're just trying to bring the price down so they can invest and make a quick book on it and they'll be ready in next by by next year to start to move into this space quite heavily yeah you can certainly see the the motivation for doing that right

if you can if you can you know tell people to look one way and then you actually run the other there definitely a reason for that um the sixth and final Trend or maybe not not a trend in this case the absence of a trend in 2023 I think we have to mention is the metaverse right so we've had a few episodes on the metaverse it was a super Hot Topic in 2021 less so in 2022 in 2023 it barely gets a mention or if it does it's being spoken about in the context of uh the failings of of Facebook or meta and Mark Zuckerberg right so just to kind of recap we had in 2021 the name change Facebook to meta then from there you get about hundred billion dollars I've seen is the figure spent on R&D right and there was this yeah there was this division of of meta created called reality Labs well they reported a loss of around 24 billion across 2021 2022 yeah crazy and uh and that led

to you know their own set of layoffs right so about 10% of their Workforce was laid off in in late 20122 in in Facebook and yeah 2023 barely gets a mention so now thinking kind of mid this year Mark Zuckerberg quite sheepishly talking about what Facebook are up to and they're basically saying their single biggest investment now is in AI generative AI how they use that right so they they seem to have there seem to been a slow quiet death of the metaverse as a concept as as far as Facebook was pushing it right yeah I mean I remember those early advertisements of like Mark Zuckerberg talking to his friends in the conference room absolutely cringing but it was kind of it was quite promising to see this kind of stuff right like I had always talked about the metaverse in in great detail and I'd always thought there was a great value proposition of the meterse like we talked about you know the digital age is all about convenience but this convenience to be

able to talk on a screen or on a phone across the world comes to the detriment of you know the emotional the physical world and the metaverse one of the goals of that is to bring the emotional world the empathetic world into the convenience of the digital world combine those things I think there's a lot of utility a lot of value that can be have from that outside of you know some of the hype stuff around being able to sit in a conference room and like talk to your friends with your avatar and all this kind of stuff I think the metaverse is going to be a thing I do believe in it I think that right now is probably slightly too soon for companies to be put in a hundred billion dollars of R&D into I don't know if the world's necessarily ready and I think they've seen okay actually AI has a lot of value right now and it's probably a much easier sell and the lower hanging fruit of the two so

I think metaverse it will come back in like the five to 10 year kind of range I think the Hardware's got to keep up and start to you know pick up the pace and become more accessible and on that we obviously saw Apple move quite well into the space a big step for them with the uh Apple Vision Pro the headset that came out in June um three and a half K so not very accessible very few people they're going to use it but you know it looks incredible I've seen some of the Run throughs and some of the people using it and what everyone's saying is it's going to replace laptops it's going to replace monitors you're going to be able to work from wherever on the go and it's so intuitive I'm really excited for this kind of technology to be more accessible to be more affordable and to see more people using it I really want to use it I really want to use it yeah yeah I I think um I

agree with what you're saying right I think probably the the Outlook I have now is the vision of the metaverse as Mark Zuckerberg was selling it a couple of years ago is dead in the short term at least and I agree as the hardware improves over time we probably will end up getting closer to that again in the future when there's more demand but there are going to be stepping stones to that and I think what Apple's doing is is a very shrewd way of getting us on that path again but you know if you see the way they're marketing it and the way everyone was waiting for their entrance right they were saying if anyone's going to get this right it'll be apple and you see it's it's clear that they're not using the same terminology of metaverse of extended reality mixed reality I mean in practice what they what the product is doing with the Vision Pro is very much lots of stuff we talked about with Robert Rice earli this year right

and I think they will come but they're talking about uh the idea of spatial Computing or spatial operating system right and they're very much focused on the use cases and the value that you can get from the technology they're not talking about the technology first which makes a lot of sense and the Apple Vision Pro launch right that was the first time I thought oh okay I me I'm an apple Fanboy but that was the first time I thought I could watch on right now yeah that was the first time I thought I could I could probably buy a thing right because when I when I saw them showcasing uh extending your laptop virtually right your screens and having more real estate wherever you are if you're in a coffee shop I thought wow that I can actually see the value in doing that right that's the stepping stone version of metaverse I think that people can accept so I think I think it's positive news that the hype around the old version has kind

of died down for now and that we're going to see some potential adoption with apple but yeah we'll see how that pans out next year yeah I think one more thing on this is I saw that Apple are no longer going to what they're saying right now they're putting a pause on all smart watches right um which is obviously going to really screw up my Christmas present to you jack but so that's one thing I thought everyone was saying okay it's because they're moving purely into this spatial Computing space but I don't know if that's true they say it's to do with patent infringement or something like this so it' be interesting to see if they start to dial back on the wearables if they're promoting purely on the spatial Computing or what yeah it will be interesting when Apple move into a space they tend to do it very well right and very large um yeah on these Brands I think one thing that I would like to say is that this year we've

seen because of all the things you've mentioned but institutional adoption um the bare Market we have seen attending attending from the crypto hype that you know I hate towards more utility and projects with utility I think the purge that kind of happened early on with the bare market and all this kind of you know all the people that are just there for the buzzword moving from web 3 and blockchain to AI Focus projects has meant that we do have some really really strong projects left that are focused on utility and real value for their customers like we've seen a lot of big Brands start to move into you know the nft space but not just nft for the sake of nft board apes and all this kind of stuff but nfts for real utility we've seen like Reddit Nike Starbucks all starting to utilize well real utility nfts to increase brand awareness to generate Revenue like you know fals loyalty points all these things I think it's getting really excited that we're moving away from

all the BS that we've previously seen in the space and more and more to actual Brands deriving real value from this yeah I think a lot of that side of crypto moving to utility is probably going to feature heavily in our predictions episodes so spoiler aler but you know it's it's true that has been one of the big themes is the shake out of the Bad actors and and moving away from a lot of the hype you know the the insane interest rates and defi actually not being so good or realistic and seeing okay where can we get that's you know same with real world assets right that's where the utility lies for for lots of traditional Finance so yeah I think that that goes kind of definitely in my kind of let's say honorable mentions we've had the big six themes from the year I think a couple of other very quickly small events we have to mention so worldcoin was launched this year again um that came out of V this year again

a project from the man Sam Sam Alman himself about scanning your iris and getting crypto tokens for that crazy business um again we'll probably have to cover that in an episode but worth mentioning that that also happened and another honor mention I wanted to say about is the fact that there's been a bit of a Renaissance of layer one and scaling on layer one right on scaling on layer one blockchains we we've seen a lot of demand and Hyper and layer to for a number of years but actually there's been a number of new chains like Aptos and sui coming out to try and really SOL scalability at layer one you've also had salana which went through its trials and tribulations over the last few years after saying it was going to be the ethereum killer much more scalable and a cheap and it's found its Market again right it's grown and grown the transaction numbers are going through the roof now so there has been increased and renewed demand for scalable layer one so

I think that's that's definitely a positive i' taken away from this year yeah that's really exciting we're going to have to do a whole episode know side chains layer ones Layer Two to really go into that and deep dive it and see how they continue to grow over over the coming year and I think one last mention probably the biggest thing in web 3 that happened in 2023 was that untangling web 3 was founded six seven months ago now um yeah been incredible we've covered I think 30 episodes up until this point it says 30 weeks of constant content I feel like I have learned an awful lot I feel like I hope that some of the listeners not just my mom have learned something as well but it has been an incredible seven months yeah likewise I I feel like we've fulfilled the goal at least of us learning something this year so right whether or not we've still got listeners I think it's been a really good fun ride right so far for

both of us we've learned so much and not just about podcasting but about web 3 in general so yeah the biggest event to happen in 2023 to finish is obviously unang web 3 launching and there'll be much more where all this came from in 2024 so stick around keep listening but with that from M and I it's happy Christmas from us at untangling web 3 and join us next time in the New Year to untangle a little more of web 3 thanks for tuning in to another episode of untangling web 3 produced by Emma caleri don't forget to send us your thoughts questions and comments on social media and be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast provider to catch the next episode see you next time to untangle a little bit more of web 3 the views we express here are our own and do not reflect the views of our

Topics: Blockchain & Crypto · Business & Society

Related episodes

All episodes